SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Root Cause Analysis (RCA)
                &
Failure Modes and Effects Analysis
            (FMEA)
      Tom Johns, PharmD, BCPS
    Shands at the University of Florida
“Healthy” Root Cause Analysis
   A Structured (Reactive) Response to Medication
    Errors
   Multidisciplinary team including individuals
    involved in the error
       Importance of medical staff involvement
   Structured (semi) process - what happened, why
    did it happen (causes/contributing factors); what
    can be done to prevent it from happening again
   Everyone needs to play well in sandbox together:
    no finger pointing, no accusations, no passing
    judgment
Medication
Error
Analysis
www.ismp.org
A Framework for a Root Cause Analysis and
Action Plan In Response to a Sentinel Event
www.jointcommission.org
Amphotericin RCA
   What happened?

       24 y/o male in MICU s/p peripheral stem cell transplant.
        Wt = 68kg
       Problem list: respiratory failure being mechanically
        ventilated, fungal pneumonia (mucormycosis v aspergillus),
        acute renal failure, CMV colitis, diabetes
       BMT clinical pharmacist recommends ABLC 340 mg IV daily
        – recommended to BMT team. Pharmacist is not sure how it
        was communicated to MICU team.
Amphotericin RCA
   What happened?

       Medical team discusses on rounds and decides to initiate
        amphotericin therapy
       Another physician on rounds shows the prescribing intern
        information sheet for prescribing amphotericin
       Physician completes handwriting order




       Other team members provided “second” check of new intern
        work
Amphotericin RCA
   What happened?

       Order faxed to Pharmacy satellite for processing

       “Pharmacist in training” discussed with
        experienced pharmacist because orders needed
        approval from ID; Pharmacist has conversation
        with ID physician to discuss antifungal drug as the
        patient was on posaconazole – no discussion of
        doses.
Amphotericin RCA
   What happened?
       Pharmacist enters order into Pharmacy Computer System –
        Pharmacist unaware of BMT pharmacist recommendation.
        States she was preoccupied with working with ID and taking
        care of other patients at the same time. She did not double
        check the dose.
       IV label is printed in sterile products area for compounding
        by pharmacy technician. Nine vials of amphotericin (50
        mg/vial) used to compound infusion.
       Compounded product is checked by sterile products
        pharmacist and delivered to the satellite pharmacy for
        delivery to nursing unit
       Amphotericin is administered by the nurse
Amphotericin RCA
 What     happened?

    Error discovered by BMT pharmacist the following
     day (only one dose given)
    HD initiated (attending felt that amphotericin was a
     contributing factor to worsening renal failure)
    Family and risk management notified of the error
    Patient expired – unrelated to amphotericin error
Why did it happen?
Amphotericin RCA
   Why did it happen? (causes and contributing factors)
       Knowledge

            Physician was not familiar with amphotericin
             dosing
              • “I’ve only been a doctor for 6 weeks”

            MICU team was not familiar with amphotericin
             formulations and dosing
Amphotericin RCA
   Why did it happen? (causes and contributing factors)
       Communication

           Rounds in MICU are busy and contain
            distractions with multiple individuals
            communicating at the same time

           Prescribing physician was transcribing another
            physician’s verbal order

           Complicated culture of physician training versus
            allowing consultants to prescribe directly
Amphotericin RCA
   Why did it happen? (causes and contributing factors)
       No standardized, required method for writing
        amphotericin
Amphotericin RCA
   Why did it happen? (causes and contributing factors)
     Look-alike/sound-alike medication
           Amphotericin, amphotericin B, amphotericin B
            deoxycholate, ABLC, Abelcet, amphotericin B lipid
            complex, Ambisome
           Different dosing (lipid formulations commonly prescribed at
            5mg/kg; traditional amphotericin 0.5-1mg/kg)
           Very common LA/SA error reported in literature
           TJC requirement to develop LA/SA like
           Dispense message in pharmacy computer system
            contains label “Caution – Look-alike/Sound-alike
            Medication”. Also appear on MAR and storage containers
            in pharmacy.
           Use of medication name abbreviations (ABLC) – not
            recommended (ISMP)
Amphotericin RCA
   Why did it happen? (causes and contributing factors)
       Distractions in Pharmacy by pharmacist
        training and need for ID pre-approval of
        medication

       Pharmacy computer system did not produce
        clinical alert for the overdose
Amphotericin RCA
   Why did it happen? (causes and contributing
    factors)
        Compounding pharmacist did not
         recognized the overdose or the excessive
         number of vials needed to prepare the
         infusion

        Nurse did not perform dose check prior to
         administration
RANK ORDER OF ERROR REDUCTION STRATEGIES

            Forcing functions and constraints

     Automation, computerization, bar code scanning

             Standardization and protocols

     Time out, checklists and double check systems

                   Rules and policies

            Visual warnings (auxiliary labels)

                 Education/information

              Be more careful, be vigilant
Amphotericin RCA
   What can be done to prevent futures errors?
       Removal of conventional amphotericin B from
        Formulary
            Is there a clinical need to use this product?
       Fix “bug” in Pharmacy computer system
       Develop standardized pre-printed amphotericin B
        order set
       Seek P&T Committee approval to require use of
        standardized form when prescribing amphotericin
       Implement CPOE with functional clinical alerts
       Education
Failure
Modes
and
Effects
Analysis
(FMEA)
Failure
Mode
and
Effects
Analysis
(FMEA)
Rca%2 c+medication+safety+committees
Rca%2 c+medication+safety+committees
Rca%2 c+medication+safety+committees
Rca%2 c+medication+safety+committees

More Related Content

Similar to Rca%2 c+medication+safety+committees

Medication error presentation
Medication error presentationMedication error presentation
Medication error presentation
Beenish Arain
 
medicationerrorpresentation-150621162934-lva1-app6892 (1).pdf
medicationerrorpresentation-150621162934-lva1-app6892 (1).pdfmedicationerrorpresentation-150621162934-lva1-app6892 (1).pdf
medicationerrorpresentation-150621162934-lva1-app6892 (1).pdf
EsterCintyaRomiannaS
 
Medication error presentation
Medication error presentationMedication error presentation
Medication error presentation
Beenish Arain
 
chapter2.pptx hospital pharmacy rules of phamacy
chapter2.pptx hospital pharmacy  rules of phamacychapter2.pptx hospital pharmacy  rules of phamacy
chapter2.pptx hospital pharmacy rules of phamacy
balajeechari
 
Drug and therapeutic committee
Drug and therapeutic committee Drug and therapeutic committee
Drug and therapeutic committee
Jisa Anna M
 
P. PRASANNA
P. PRASANNAP. PRASANNA
P. PRASANNA
Ramesh Ganpisetti
 
Pharmacy news 2014
Pharmacy news 2014Pharmacy news 2014
Pharmacy news 2014
munaoqal
 
AN OVERVIEW ON PHARMACO THERAPEUTIC COMMITTEE - M.L.SUSHMITHA
AN OVERVIEW ON PHARMACO THERAPEUTIC COMMITTEE - M.L.SUSHMITHAAN OVERVIEW ON PHARMACO THERAPEUTIC COMMITTEE - M.L.SUSHMITHA
AN OVERVIEW ON PHARMACO THERAPEUTIC COMMITTEE - M.L.SUSHMITHA
lakshmisushmitha2
 
Pharmacy and therapeutic committee
Pharmacy and therapeutic committeePharmacy and therapeutic committee
Pharmacy and therapeutic committee
DrSiddharthSingh5
 
Lior - Improving Medication Safety in Radiology
Lior - Improving Medication Safety in RadiologyLior - Improving Medication Safety in Radiology
Lior - Improving Medication Safety in Radiology
Lior Molvin
 
Medication error- In Multidisciplinary Hospital
Medication error- In Multidisciplinary HospitalMedication error- In Multidisciplinary Hospital
Medication error- In Multidisciplinary Hospital
anamsohail29
 
PTC.pptx
PTC.pptxPTC.pptx
PTC.pptx
Archana Chavhan
 
Pharmacovigilance
PharmacovigilancePharmacovigilance
Pharmacovigilance
Dr Rahul Saini
 
Harm through medication error
Harm through medication errorHarm through medication error
Harm through medication error
Diana Rangaves, PharmD, CEO
 
Medication Error a pharmacist perspective 2-23-01
Medication Error a  pharmacist perspective 2-23-01Medication Error a  pharmacist perspective 2-23-01
Medication Error a pharmacist perspective 2-23-01
Charles Sharkey
 
Records and reports
Records  and  reportsRecords  and  reports
Records and reports
Ashok Kumar Singh
 
Pharmacy & Therapeutics Committee.ppt
Pharmacy & Therapeutics Committee.pptPharmacy & Therapeutics Committee.ppt
Pharmacy & Therapeutics Committee.ppt
Ravinandan A P
 
J. SUBRAHMANYAM
J. SUBRAHMANYAMJ. SUBRAHMANYAM
J. SUBRAHMANYAM
Ramesh Ganpisetti
 
Informatics Primer
Informatics PrimerInformatics Primer
Informatics Primer
rxinformatica
 
Pharmacy and therapeutic committee(PTC)
Pharmacy and therapeutic committee(PTC)Pharmacy and therapeutic committee(PTC)
Pharmacy and therapeutic committee(PTC)
faysalahmed35
 

Similar to Rca%2 c+medication+safety+committees (20)

Medication error presentation
Medication error presentationMedication error presentation
Medication error presentation
 
medicationerrorpresentation-150621162934-lva1-app6892 (1).pdf
medicationerrorpresentation-150621162934-lva1-app6892 (1).pdfmedicationerrorpresentation-150621162934-lva1-app6892 (1).pdf
medicationerrorpresentation-150621162934-lva1-app6892 (1).pdf
 
Medication error presentation
Medication error presentationMedication error presentation
Medication error presentation
 
chapter2.pptx hospital pharmacy rules of phamacy
chapter2.pptx hospital pharmacy  rules of phamacychapter2.pptx hospital pharmacy  rules of phamacy
chapter2.pptx hospital pharmacy rules of phamacy
 
Drug and therapeutic committee
Drug and therapeutic committee Drug and therapeutic committee
Drug and therapeutic committee
 
P. PRASANNA
P. PRASANNAP. PRASANNA
P. PRASANNA
 
Pharmacy news 2014
Pharmacy news 2014Pharmacy news 2014
Pharmacy news 2014
 
AN OVERVIEW ON PHARMACO THERAPEUTIC COMMITTEE - M.L.SUSHMITHA
AN OVERVIEW ON PHARMACO THERAPEUTIC COMMITTEE - M.L.SUSHMITHAAN OVERVIEW ON PHARMACO THERAPEUTIC COMMITTEE - M.L.SUSHMITHA
AN OVERVIEW ON PHARMACO THERAPEUTIC COMMITTEE - M.L.SUSHMITHA
 
Pharmacy and therapeutic committee
Pharmacy and therapeutic committeePharmacy and therapeutic committee
Pharmacy and therapeutic committee
 
Lior - Improving Medication Safety in Radiology
Lior - Improving Medication Safety in RadiologyLior - Improving Medication Safety in Radiology
Lior - Improving Medication Safety in Radiology
 
Medication error- In Multidisciplinary Hospital
Medication error- In Multidisciplinary HospitalMedication error- In Multidisciplinary Hospital
Medication error- In Multidisciplinary Hospital
 
PTC.pptx
PTC.pptxPTC.pptx
PTC.pptx
 
Pharmacovigilance
PharmacovigilancePharmacovigilance
Pharmacovigilance
 
Harm through medication error
Harm through medication errorHarm through medication error
Harm through medication error
 
Medication Error a pharmacist perspective 2-23-01
Medication Error a  pharmacist perspective 2-23-01Medication Error a  pharmacist perspective 2-23-01
Medication Error a pharmacist perspective 2-23-01
 
Records and reports
Records  and  reportsRecords  and  reports
Records and reports
 
Pharmacy & Therapeutics Committee.ppt
Pharmacy & Therapeutics Committee.pptPharmacy & Therapeutics Committee.ppt
Pharmacy & Therapeutics Committee.ppt
 
J. SUBRAHMANYAM
J. SUBRAHMANYAMJ. SUBRAHMANYAM
J. SUBRAHMANYAM
 
Informatics Primer
Informatics PrimerInformatics Primer
Informatics Primer
 
Pharmacy and therapeutic committee(PTC)
Pharmacy and therapeutic committee(PTC)Pharmacy and therapeutic committee(PTC)
Pharmacy and therapeutic committee(PTC)
 

Rca%2 c+medication+safety+committees

  • 1. Root Cause Analysis (RCA) & Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (FMEA) Tom Johns, PharmD, BCPS Shands at the University of Florida
  • 2. “Healthy” Root Cause Analysis  A Structured (Reactive) Response to Medication Errors  Multidisciplinary team including individuals involved in the error  Importance of medical staff involvement  Structured (semi) process - what happened, why did it happen (causes/contributing factors); what can be done to prevent it from happening again  Everyone needs to play well in sandbox together: no finger pointing, no accusations, no passing judgment
  • 4.
  • 5. A Framework for a Root Cause Analysis and Action Plan In Response to a Sentinel Event www.jointcommission.org
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8. Amphotericin RCA  What happened?  24 y/o male in MICU s/p peripheral stem cell transplant. Wt = 68kg  Problem list: respiratory failure being mechanically ventilated, fungal pneumonia (mucormycosis v aspergillus), acute renal failure, CMV colitis, diabetes  BMT clinical pharmacist recommends ABLC 340 mg IV daily – recommended to BMT team. Pharmacist is not sure how it was communicated to MICU team.
  • 9. Amphotericin RCA  What happened?  Medical team discusses on rounds and decides to initiate amphotericin therapy  Another physician on rounds shows the prescribing intern information sheet for prescribing amphotericin  Physician completes handwriting order  Other team members provided “second” check of new intern work
  • 10. Amphotericin RCA  What happened?  Order faxed to Pharmacy satellite for processing  “Pharmacist in training” discussed with experienced pharmacist because orders needed approval from ID; Pharmacist has conversation with ID physician to discuss antifungal drug as the patient was on posaconazole – no discussion of doses.
  • 11. Amphotericin RCA  What happened?  Pharmacist enters order into Pharmacy Computer System – Pharmacist unaware of BMT pharmacist recommendation. States she was preoccupied with working with ID and taking care of other patients at the same time. She did not double check the dose.  IV label is printed in sterile products area for compounding by pharmacy technician. Nine vials of amphotericin (50 mg/vial) used to compound infusion.  Compounded product is checked by sterile products pharmacist and delivered to the satellite pharmacy for delivery to nursing unit  Amphotericin is administered by the nurse
  • 12. Amphotericin RCA  What happened?  Error discovered by BMT pharmacist the following day (only one dose given)  HD initiated (attending felt that amphotericin was a contributing factor to worsening renal failure)  Family and risk management notified of the error  Patient expired – unrelated to amphotericin error
  • 13. Why did it happen?
  • 14. Amphotericin RCA  Why did it happen? (causes and contributing factors)  Knowledge  Physician was not familiar with amphotericin dosing • “I’ve only been a doctor for 6 weeks”  MICU team was not familiar with amphotericin formulations and dosing
  • 15. Amphotericin RCA  Why did it happen? (causes and contributing factors)  Communication  Rounds in MICU are busy and contain distractions with multiple individuals communicating at the same time  Prescribing physician was transcribing another physician’s verbal order  Complicated culture of physician training versus allowing consultants to prescribe directly
  • 16. Amphotericin RCA  Why did it happen? (causes and contributing factors)  No standardized, required method for writing amphotericin
  • 17. Amphotericin RCA  Why did it happen? (causes and contributing factors)  Look-alike/sound-alike medication  Amphotericin, amphotericin B, amphotericin B deoxycholate, ABLC, Abelcet, amphotericin B lipid complex, Ambisome  Different dosing (lipid formulations commonly prescribed at 5mg/kg; traditional amphotericin 0.5-1mg/kg)  Very common LA/SA error reported in literature  TJC requirement to develop LA/SA like  Dispense message in pharmacy computer system contains label “Caution – Look-alike/Sound-alike Medication”. Also appear on MAR and storage containers in pharmacy.  Use of medication name abbreviations (ABLC) – not recommended (ISMP)
  • 18. Amphotericin RCA  Why did it happen? (causes and contributing factors)  Distractions in Pharmacy by pharmacist training and need for ID pre-approval of medication  Pharmacy computer system did not produce clinical alert for the overdose
  • 19.
  • 20.
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 23. Amphotericin RCA  Why did it happen? (causes and contributing factors)  Compounding pharmacist did not recognized the overdose or the excessive number of vials needed to prepare the infusion  Nurse did not perform dose check prior to administration
  • 24. RANK ORDER OF ERROR REDUCTION STRATEGIES Forcing functions and constraints Automation, computerization, bar code scanning Standardization and protocols Time out, checklists and double check systems Rules and policies Visual warnings (auxiliary labels) Education/information Be more careful, be vigilant
  • 25. Amphotericin RCA  What can be done to prevent futures errors?  Removal of conventional amphotericin B from Formulary  Is there a clinical need to use this product?  Fix “bug” in Pharmacy computer system  Develop standardized pre-printed amphotericin B order set  Seek P&T Committee approval to require use of standardized form when prescribing amphotericin  Implement CPOE with functional clinical alerts  Education
  • 26.