SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Q and A: Not Dead Yet of Georgia 404-687-8890National NDY: www.notdeadyet.org© Eleanor Smith, 2012
What is Not Dead Yet of GA about?We’re about protecting disabled and older people from assisted suicide, lethal
medical neglect, involuntary withdrawal of life-sustaining medical care, encouragement to die, and “compassionate”
murder.
Why are you so adamant about your mission?
Because our lives and the lives of our disabled friends and loved ones are in danger. There’s a crucial
differencebetween the freedom to end one’s own life, which cannot be denied, and the freedom to have others end
one’s life, which endangers the lives of an identified group of people less valued by society.
When you’re a member of a group officially offered help to die, and a group designated not to receive medical
help given to others,it’seasy to start believing you don’t deserve to live.And it’s realistic to fear you will not receive life-
protecting medical help in an emergency room, hospital or nursing home. We proclaim that there is life after
disability,at any age—and that people with disabilities need encouragement to live, not die.
We seek equal access to suicide prevention, equal access to medical care, and consequencesfor murdering one’s
disabled child or spouse equal tomurdering peoplewho do not have disabilities.
Suppose someone is in the last stages of a terminal illness and then has a heart attack. Are you saying they should be
shocked back to life through aggressive, possibly painful measures?We ourselves would probably direct not to be
resuscitated in that circumstance. Any person can refuse surgery, dialysis, antibiotics, or other medical interventions.
But we’re aware that sometimes conditions mislabeled ‘last stages’ are far from last, and sometimes conditions
mislabeled ‘terminal’ are merely incurable, like many of our own conditions. And we know that people who develop
disabilities but are NOT terminally ill often feel suicidal because of negativecultural messages and inadequate financial
support; they need explicit positive messages and tangible assistance.
But what about people whose disability puts them in a position where they can’t kill themselves, like a quadriplegic
or a person with severe dementia?Isn’t it cruel not to help them die?The larger question too often ignored is, what can
and must be done to value people, including those with disabilities, and help them value themselves? Nevertheless,
people intent on killing themselves must take responsibility for their own suicide; otherwise, they endanger other
people with disabilities by adding to the attitudes, practices and even laws that devalue their lives. In fact, there are
several ways a quadriplegic could kill him- or herself, and the person with dementia may not want to die. Further,
people who believe they don’t want to live under certain circumstances must give clear, documented advance directives
about the medical treatments they do and do not want, although people who initially believe they would not want to
live with a disability often find that they do want to live.
Besides not permitting disabled or older people to be killed, what can people do to protect lives? Recognize that
quality of life is not fixed -– it varies depending on the presence or absence of help, love, respect, pain management and
money. Support high quality of life by advocating for policiesproviding the help disabled people need tosurvive
andthrive, in their individual ways. Actively challenge media pieces that imply ‘better dead than disabled’ or call for no
jail time when a distraught person kills a disabled family member. And support policies that promote a high quality of
life for non-disabled people---so that no one needs to envy or resent a good quality of life for disabled or older people.
Are you a politically right-wing organization? No, Not Dead Yet has participants from many political persuasions. We
ask people on the left, and organizations like the ACLU, who often frame death-dealing practices against people with
disabilities as simple ‘choice’, to take into account the impact of social oppression on people’s ‘choices’. We ask people
on the right, many of whom share our opposition to assisted suicide and euthanasia, to advocate strongly for the
supports we need to sustain our lives: access to full health care and funding for the personal assistance many of us need
to maintain our independence to live in our communities.

More Related Content

What's hot

Bystander Awareness
Bystander AwarenessBystander Awareness
Bystander Awareness
mikewilhelm
 
Is It Worth It -- Hazing 101
Is It Worth It -- Hazing 101Is It Worth It -- Hazing 101
Is It Worth It -- Hazing 101
a_powell
 
What is Abuse?
What is Abuse? What is Abuse?
What is Abuse?
FHCCommunity
 
Domestic Violence
Domestic ViolenceDomestic Violence
Domestic Violence
Nivert Zaki
 
Speak out power point (1)
Speak out power point (1)Speak out power point (1)
Speak out power point (1)
CLPankow
 
Women violence and abuse
Women violence and abuseWomen violence and abuse
Women violence and abuse
Emi Melo
 
In My Shoes - beyondblue Insights Community
In My Shoes - beyondblue Insights Community In My Shoes - beyondblue Insights Community
In My Shoes - beyondblue Insights Community
Latitude Insights
 
Role of media
 Role of media Role of media
Role of media
Binita Sharma
 
What Is Elder Abuse and How to Prevent It?
What Is Elder Abuse and How to Prevent It?What Is Elder Abuse and How to Prevent It?
What Is Elder Abuse and How to Prevent It?
Lanzone Morgan
 
Suicide Prevention
Suicide PreventionSuicide Prevention
Suicide Prevention
finman84
 
If I am the Last Resort, Where do I Turn for Help?
If I am the Last Resort, Where do I Turn for Help?If I am the Last Resort, Where do I Turn for Help?
If I am the Last Resort, Where do I Turn for Help?
citinfo
 
Careif compassion & care series 3
Careif compassion & care series 3Careif compassion & care series 3
Careif compassion & care series 3
MrBiswas
 
CIT: Responding to Mulitcultural Incidents
CIT: Responding to Mulitcultural Incidents CIT: Responding to Mulitcultural Incidents
CIT: Responding to Mulitcultural Incidents
citinfo
 
Internship Paper
Internship PaperInternship Paper
Internship Paper
Michelle Chenevert
 
Dv,sa,dfsa
Dv,sa,dfsaDv,sa,dfsa
Dv,sa,dfsa
Karoline Khamis
 
Words, Stories and Noises - BMER Women and Domestic Violence by Marai Larasi
Words, Stories and Noises - BMER Women and Domestic Violence by Marai LarasiWords, Stories and Noises - BMER Women and Domestic Violence by Marai Larasi
Words, Stories and Noises - BMER Women and Domestic Violence by Marai Larasi
British Sociological Association
 
Chapter 8
Chapter 8Chapter 8
Chapter 8
Meli2245
 
DateRapeResearchPaper1
DateRapeResearchPaper1DateRapeResearchPaper1
DateRapeResearchPaper1
Destiney Guthrie
 
Teen and Domestic Violence
Teen and Domestic ViolenceTeen and Domestic Violence
Teen and Domestic Violence
miguelpim
 
Discrimination erdem (1)
Discrimination erdem (1)Discrimination erdem (1)
Discrimination erdem (1)
KTDM
 

What's hot (20)

Bystander Awareness
Bystander AwarenessBystander Awareness
Bystander Awareness
 
Is It Worth It -- Hazing 101
Is It Worth It -- Hazing 101Is It Worth It -- Hazing 101
Is It Worth It -- Hazing 101
 
What is Abuse?
What is Abuse? What is Abuse?
What is Abuse?
 
Domestic Violence
Domestic ViolenceDomestic Violence
Domestic Violence
 
Speak out power point (1)
Speak out power point (1)Speak out power point (1)
Speak out power point (1)
 
Women violence and abuse
Women violence and abuseWomen violence and abuse
Women violence and abuse
 
In My Shoes - beyondblue Insights Community
In My Shoes - beyondblue Insights Community In My Shoes - beyondblue Insights Community
In My Shoes - beyondblue Insights Community
 
Role of media
 Role of media Role of media
Role of media
 
What Is Elder Abuse and How to Prevent It?
What Is Elder Abuse and How to Prevent It?What Is Elder Abuse and How to Prevent It?
What Is Elder Abuse and How to Prevent It?
 
Suicide Prevention
Suicide PreventionSuicide Prevention
Suicide Prevention
 
If I am the Last Resort, Where do I Turn for Help?
If I am the Last Resort, Where do I Turn for Help?If I am the Last Resort, Where do I Turn for Help?
If I am the Last Resort, Where do I Turn for Help?
 
Careif compassion & care series 3
Careif compassion & care series 3Careif compassion & care series 3
Careif compassion & care series 3
 
CIT: Responding to Mulitcultural Incidents
CIT: Responding to Mulitcultural Incidents CIT: Responding to Mulitcultural Incidents
CIT: Responding to Mulitcultural Incidents
 
Internship Paper
Internship PaperInternship Paper
Internship Paper
 
Dv,sa,dfsa
Dv,sa,dfsaDv,sa,dfsa
Dv,sa,dfsa
 
Words, Stories and Noises - BMER Women and Domestic Violence by Marai Larasi
Words, Stories and Noises - BMER Women and Domestic Violence by Marai LarasiWords, Stories and Noises - BMER Women and Domestic Violence by Marai Larasi
Words, Stories and Noises - BMER Women and Domestic Violence by Marai Larasi
 
Chapter 8
Chapter 8Chapter 8
Chapter 8
 
DateRapeResearchPaper1
DateRapeResearchPaper1DateRapeResearchPaper1
DateRapeResearchPaper1
 
Teen and Domestic Violence
Teen and Domestic ViolenceTeen and Domestic Violence
Teen and Domestic Violence
 
Discrimination erdem (1)
Discrimination erdem (1)Discrimination erdem (1)
Discrimination erdem (1)
 

Viewers also liked

Alumni Bocconi e Taranto Finanza Forum 2012
Alumni Bocconi e Taranto Finanza Forum 2012Alumni Bocconi e Taranto Finanza Forum 2012
Alumni Bocconi e Taranto Finanza Forum 2012Francesco Cometa
 
Math 01
Math 01Math 01
Math 01
Alis31
 
Programa 27 janeiro_aristides_de_sousa_mendes_new
Programa 27 janeiro_aristides_de_sousa_mendes_newPrograma 27 janeiro_aristides_de_sousa_mendes_new
Programa 27 janeiro_aristides_de_sousa_mendes_new
Biblioteca Escolar Cabeceiras Basto
 
Exposicion oral
Exposicion oralExposicion oral
Exposicion oral
sanz_alagonero8
 
Scribd
ScribdScribd
Scribd
Jessy Alexa
 
linkedin_centrillion
linkedin_centrillionlinkedin_centrillion
linkedin_centrillion
Shann Oliver
 
Aprendizaje colaborativo.gv
Aprendizaje colaborativo.gvAprendizaje colaborativo.gv
Aprendizaje colaborativo.gv
GinaVittore
 
Estudio comparativo educación de finlandia y ecuador
Estudio comparativo educación de finlandia y ecuadorEstudio comparativo educación de finlandia y ecuador
Estudio comparativo educación de finlandia y ecuador
Silvia Regalado Díaz
 
Web 2
Web 2Web 2
Una breve guida
Una breve guidaUna breve guida
Una breve guidaFaizal MH
 
Música
MúsicaMúsica
Música
guest410a847
 
CFC Russia IFA December 2014
CFC Russia IFA December 2014CFC Russia IFA December 2014
CFC Russia IFA December 2014
Roustam Vakhitov
 
Goldman sachs-global-metals-mining-presentation final-presentation-v001_m53f0w
Goldman sachs-global-metals-mining-presentation final-presentation-v001_m53f0wGoldman sachs-global-metals-mining-presentation final-presentation-v001_m53f0w
Goldman sachs-global-metals-mining-presentation final-presentation-v001_m53f0w
NewmontMining
 
Summer blogging responsibilities
Summer blogging responsibilitiesSummer blogging responsibilities
Summer blogging responsibilities
Jenn Kirk
 
Polymicrobial colonisation of the nasopharynx in UK children
Polymicrobial colonisation of the nasopharynx in UK childrenPolymicrobial colonisation of the nasopharynx in UK children
Polymicrobial colonisation of the nasopharynx in UK children
Rebeccagladstone
 
Come pubblicare un video tutorial su youtube
Come pubblicare un video tutorial su youtubeCome pubblicare un video tutorial su youtube
Come pubblicare un video tutorial su youtubeFederico Molinari
 
PresentacióN1
PresentacióN1PresentacióN1
PresentacióN1
hildabp
 
Bienvenidos2
Bienvenidos2Bienvenidos2
Bienvenidos2
Laura Pincay
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Alumni Bocconi e Taranto Finanza Forum 2012
Alumni Bocconi e Taranto Finanza Forum 2012Alumni Bocconi e Taranto Finanza Forum 2012
Alumni Bocconi e Taranto Finanza Forum 2012
 
Math 01
Math 01Math 01
Math 01
 
Programa 27 janeiro_aristides_de_sousa_mendes_new
Programa 27 janeiro_aristides_de_sousa_mendes_newPrograma 27 janeiro_aristides_de_sousa_mendes_new
Programa 27 janeiro_aristides_de_sousa_mendes_new
 
Exposicion oral
Exposicion oralExposicion oral
Exposicion oral
 
Scribd
ScribdScribd
Scribd
 
linkedin_centrillion
linkedin_centrillionlinkedin_centrillion
linkedin_centrillion
 
Aprendizaje colaborativo.gv
Aprendizaje colaborativo.gvAprendizaje colaborativo.gv
Aprendizaje colaborativo.gv
 
Estudio comparativo educación de finlandia y ecuador
Estudio comparativo educación de finlandia y ecuadorEstudio comparativo educación de finlandia y ecuador
Estudio comparativo educación de finlandia y ecuador
 
Web 2
Web 2Web 2
Web 2
 
Una breve guida
Una breve guidaUna breve guida
Una breve guida
 
Música
MúsicaMúsica
Música
 
Triptico
TripticoTriptico
Triptico
 
1 analisi sveglia
1 analisi sveglia1 analisi sveglia
1 analisi sveglia
 
CFC Russia IFA December 2014
CFC Russia IFA December 2014CFC Russia IFA December 2014
CFC Russia IFA December 2014
 
Goldman sachs-global-metals-mining-presentation final-presentation-v001_m53f0w
Goldman sachs-global-metals-mining-presentation final-presentation-v001_m53f0wGoldman sachs-global-metals-mining-presentation final-presentation-v001_m53f0w
Goldman sachs-global-metals-mining-presentation final-presentation-v001_m53f0w
 
Summer blogging responsibilities
Summer blogging responsibilitiesSummer blogging responsibilities
Summer blogging responsibilities
 
Polymicrobial colonisation of the nasopharynx in UK children
Polymicrobial colonisation of the nasopharynx in UK childrenPolymicrobial colonisation of the nasopharynx in UK children
Polymicrobial colonisation of the nasopharynx in UK children
 
Come pubblicare un video tutorial su youtube
Come pubblicare un video tutorial su youtubeCome pubblicare un video tutorial su youtube
Come pubblicare un video tutorial su youtube
 
PresentacióN1
PresentacióN1PresentacióN1
PresentacióN1
 
Bienvenidos2
Bienvenidos2Bienvenidos2
Bienvenidos2
 

Similar to Q and a final ndy of ga 9 12

Research Paper DraftMy NameArgosy UniversityThesisPhys.docx
Research Paper DraftMy NameArgosy UniversityThesisPhys.docxResearch Paper DraftMy NameArgosy UniversityThesisPhys.docx
Research Paper DraftMy NameArgosy UniversityThesisPhys.docx
debishakespeare
 
Discrimination & Stigma
Discrimination & StigmaDiscrimination & Stigma
Discrimination & Stigma
Cindy Pivacic
 
Suicide myths symptoms
Suicide myths symptomsSuicide myths symptoms
Suicide myths symptoms
Hylton Upshon
 
Facts and myths about suicide
Facts and myths about suicideFacts and myths about suicide
Facts and myths about suicide
oskyinteractive
 
Self Harm Essay
Self Harm EssaySelf Harm Essay
Self Harm Essay
Papers Writing Service
 
Unit 6 Psychosocial Issues
Unit 6 Psychosocial IssuesUnit 6 Psychosocial Issues
Unit 6 Psychosocial Issues
Washington State Dental Association
 
trifold_PEAC
trifold_PEACtrifold_PEAC
trifold_PEAC
Catherine Adams
 
Stigma & discrimination final by dr. munawar
Stigma & discrimination final by dr. munawarStigma & discrimination final by dr. munawar
Stigma & discrimination final by dr. munawar
Dr Munawar Khan
 
Social Construction And Doctors And Patients
Social Construction And Doctors And PatientsSocial Construction And Doctors And Patients
Social Construction And Doctors And Patients
minnarory
 
Promoting a Culture of Abandonment Teresa R. Wagner Tere.docx
Promoting a Culture of Abandonment Teresa R. Wagner Tere.docxPromoting a Culture of Abandonment Teresa R. Wagner Tere.docx
Promoting a Culture of Abandonment Teresa R. Wagner Tere.docx
amrit47
 

Similar to Q and a final ndy of ga 9 12 (10)

Research Paper DraftMy NameArgosy UniversityThesisPhys.docx
Research Paper DraftMy NameArgosy UniversityThesisPhys.docxResearch Paper DraftMy NameArgosy UniversityThesisPhys.docx
Research Paper DraftMy NameArgosy UniversityThesisPhys.docx
 
Discrimination & Stigma
Discrimination & StigmaDiscrimination & Stigma
Discrimination & Stigma
 
Suicide myths symptoms
Suicide myths symptomsSuicide myths symptoms
Suicide myths symptoms
 
Facts and myths about suicide
Facts and myths about suicideFacts and myths about suicide
Facts and myths about suicide
 
Self Harm Essay
Self Harm EssaySelf Harm Essay
Self Harm Essay
 
Unit 6 Psychosocial Issues
Unit 6 Psychosocial IssuesUnit 6 Psychosocial Issues
Unit 6 Psychosocial Issues
 
trifold_PEAC
trifold_PEACtrifold_PEAC
trifold_PEAC
 
Stigma & discrimination final by dr. munawar
Stigma & discrimination final by dr. munawarStigma & discrimination final by dr. munawar
Stigma & discrimination final by dr. munawar
 
Social Construction And Doctors And Patients
Social Construction And Doctors And PatientsSocial Construction And Doctors And Patients
Social Construction And Doctors And Patients
 
Promoting a Culture of Abandonment Teresa R. Wagner Tere.docx
Promoting a Culture of Abandonment Teresa R. Wagner Tere.docxPromoting a Culture of Abandonment Teresa R. Wagner Tere.docx
Promoting a Culture of Abandonment Teresa R. Wagner Tere.docx
 

Q and a final ndy of ga 9 12

  • 1. Q and A: Not Dead Yet of Georgia 404-687-8890National NDY: www.notdeadyet.org© Eleanor Smith, 2012 What is Not Dead Yet of GA about?We’re about protecting disabled and older people from assisted suicide, lethal medical neglect, involuntary withdrawal of life-sustaining medical care, encouragement to die, and “compassionate” murder. Why are you so adamant about your mission? Because our lives and the lives of our disabled friends and loved ones are in danger. There’s a crucial differencebetween the freedom to end one’s own life, which cannot be denied, and the freedom to have others end one’s life, which endangers the lives of an identified group of people less valued by society. When you’re a member of a group officially offered help to die, and a group designated not to receive medical help given to others,it’seasy to start believing you don’t deserve to live.And it’s realistic to fear you will not receive life- protecting medical help in an emergency room, hospital or nursing home. We proclaim that there is life after disability,at any age—and that people with disabilities need encouragement to live, not die. We seek equal access to suicide prevention, equal access to medical care, and consequencesfor murdering one’s disabled child or spouse equal tomurdering peoplewho do not have disabilities. Suppose someone is in the last stages of a terminal illness and then has a heart attack. Are you saying they should be shocked back to life through aggressive, possibly painful measures?We ourselves would probably direct not to be resuscitated in that circumstance. Any person can refuse surgery, dialysis, antibiotics, or other medical interventions. But we’re aware that sometimes conditions mislabeled ‘last stages’ are far from last, and sometimes conditions mislabeled ‘terminal’ are merely incurable, like many of our own conditions. And we know that people who develop disabilities but are NOT terminally ill often feel suicidal because of negativecultural messages and inadequate financial support; they need explicit positive messages and tangible assistance. But what about people whose disability puts them in a position where they can’t kill themselves, like a quadriplegic or a person with severe dementia?Isn’t it cruel not to help them die?The larger question too often ignored is, what can and must be done to value people, including those with disabilities, and help them value themselves? Nevertheless, people intent on killing themselves must take responsibility for their own suicide; otherwise, they endanger other people with disabilities by adding to the attitudes, practices and even laws that devalue their lives. In fact, there are several ways a quadriplegic could kill him- or herself, and the person with dementia may not want to die. Further, people who believe they don’t want to live under certain circumstances must give clear, documented advance directives about the medical treatments they do and do not want, although people who initially believe they would not want to live with a disability often find that they do want to live. Besides not permitting disabled or older people to be killed, what can people do to protect lives? Recognize that quality of life is not fixed -– it varies depending on the presence or absence of help, love, respect, pain management and money. Support high quality of life by advocating for policiesproviding the help disabled people need tosurvive andthrive, in their individual ways. Actively challenge media pieces that imply ‘better dead than disabled’ or call for no jail time when a distraught person kills a disabled family member. And support policies that promote a high quality of life for non-disabled people---so that no one needs to envy or resent a good quality of life for disabled or older people. Are you a politically right-wing organization? No, Not Dead Yet has participants from many political persuasions. We ask people on the left, and organizations like the ACLU, who often frame death-dealing practices against people with disabilities as simple ‘choice’, to take into account the impact of social oppression on people’s ‘choices’. We ask people on the right, many of whom share our opposition to assisted suicide and euthanasia, to advocate strongly for the supports we need to sustain our lives: access to full health care and funding for the personal assistance many of us need to maintain our independence to live in our communities.