SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Psychology Explains
Common Mistakes in
Mortgage Refinancing
Primary Residential Mortgage, Inc.
Mortgage refinancing is one of the leading avenues for households to relieve themselves
of housing loan debt, interest rates, and monthly payments. It is also one of the most
viable options for people looking to buy an investment property or start a business.
In the U.S., fixed rate mortgage debt is still the dominant form of residential financial
obligation, but refinancing provides ways to lighten the financial load during adverse
economic conditions.
Common Mistakes in Refinancing and the Psychology Behind Them
Economists from the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago and Georgia State University
conducted a study in 2015 that focused on the reason behind mortgage refinancing
mistakes.
Their study found that borrowers usually choose an interest rate from options provided by
lenders during a particular period. Since interest rates regularly change, 50 percent of
borrowers choose the wrong rate while 17% wait too long for other options, hence
delaying their payment.
The study found that the more experienced borrowers commit fewer mistakes than the
new borrowers. Upon learning from previous refinancing experiences, competent
borrowers make sure to refinance at rates closer to optimal. They also have less waiting
time after mortgage rates reach their trigger rates.
Another study from the Federal Bank Reserve of Chicago and University of Chicago
pointed to factors brought by the Great Recession. During this time, many households
took advantage of extracting equities during the housing bubble burst. It resulted in
severe declines in home prices that left people with little or no equity in their homes.
The Great Recession also contributed to many job losses that made a lot of homeowners
unable to refinance and underwrite new mortgages in the absence of a regular source of
income. When a primary channel for accommodative financial services like refinancing
gets blocked, there are fewer stimuli for people to buy homes and file for loans, despite
low-interest rates.
Borrowers' Behaviors Towards Mortgage and Housing
The above studies concluded that borrowers have different attitudes in refinancing their
mortgage. Less-experienced borrowers either choose the most viable option among the
available ones or wait too long until interest rates meet their budget. Experienced
borrowers, on the other hand, know when the right time is to refinance and immediately
know which option is optimal.
The housing bubble burst caused by the Great Recession has also significantly affected
people access to a mortgage. Those who were left jobless lost access to low-interest
programs while others ended up with little to no equity in their homes due to acts of
impulse.
Sources:
http://primeresnw.com/
https://pubsonline.informs.org/doi/abs/10.1287/mnsc.2015.2272
https://ideas.repec.org/a/fip/fedhle/00042.html
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1364661316300997

More Related Content

What's hot

mortgage Rates's location
mortgage Rates's locationmortgage Rates's location
mortgage Rates's location
wilsondxunydbytc
 
Student loan basics
Student loan basicsStudent loan basics
Student loan basics
Student Loan
 
Principal Reduction Powerpoint Presentation
Principal Reduction Powerpoint PresentationPrincipal Reduction Powerpoint Presentation
Principal Reduction Powerpoint Presentation
NickRadz
 
One loan for all loans debt consolidation loan
One loan for all loans  debt consolidation loanOne loan for all loans  debt consolidation loan
One loan for all loans debt consolidation loan
Anisha Sachit
 
People Involved in the Mortgage Process
People Involved in the Mortgage ProcessPeople Involved in the Mortgage Process
People Involved in the Mortgage Process
New American Funding - Direct Mortgage Lenders
 
Synergy Debt Group - Canadian Debt News - Vol 3
Synergy Debt Group - Canadian Debt News - Vol 3Synergy Debt Group - Canadian Debt News - Vol 3
Synergy Debt Group - Canadian Debt News - Vol 3
Synergy Debt Group
 
New America Parent Plus Loan Panel
New America Parent Plus Loan PanelNew America Parent Plus Loan Panel
New America Parent Plus Loan Panel
LendKey
 
Payday loans no credit check
Payday loans no credit checkPayday loans no credit check
Payday loans no credit check
shantanu pramanik
 
Adjustable Rate Mortgage Modification Strategy - Revised June 2017
Adjustable Rate Mortgage Modification Strategy - Revised June 2017Adjustable Rate Mortgage Modification Strategy - Revised June 2017
Adjustable Rate Mortgage Modification Strategy - Revised June 2017
Marc Gilmore
 
Retail Banking
Retail BankingRetail Banking
Retail Banking
Sushmita Audichya
 
FAQ
FAQFAQ
Reverse mortgage to financial planners & advisors
Reverse mortgage to financial planners & advisorsReverse mortgage to financial planners & advisors
Reverse mortgage to financial planners & advisors
Michael Pinter
 
Kandy Wong_Chinese banks step up lending in the US - FT
Kandy Wong_Chinese banks step up lending in the US - FTKandy Wong_Chinese banks step up lending in the US - FT
Kandy Wong_Chinese banks step up lending in the US - FT
Kandy Wong
 
Credit Scores - How Much Do They Matter with A Mortgage
Credit Scores - How Much Do They Matter with A MortgageCredit Scores - How Much Do They Matter with A Mortgage
Credit Scores - How Much Do They Matter with A Mortgage
Buzz Marketing Pros
 
Credit Scores – How Much do They Matter with a Mortgage?
Credit Scores – How Much do They Matter with a Mortgage?Credit Scores – How Much do They Matter with a Mortgage?
Credit Scores – How Much do They Matter with a Mortgage?
Buzz Marketing Pros
 
Debits consolidation
Debits consolidationDebits consolidation
Debits consolidation
Amrita Agarwal
 
5 Things You Need to Be Pre-Approved for a Mortgage Loan - New American Funding
5 Things You Need to Be Pre-Approved for a Mortgage Loan - New American Funding5 Things You Need to Be Pre-Approved for a Mortgage Loan - New American Funding
5 Things You Need to Be Pre-Approved for a Mortgage Loan - New American Funding
New American Funding - Direct Mortgage Lenders
 
Quick Short Term Loans
Quick Short Term LoansQuick Short Term Loans
Quick Short Term Loans
quick short term loans
 
FAQ
FAQFAQ
Get the Right Loan for You
Get the Right Loan for YouGet the Right Loan for You
Get the Right Loan for You
Five Star Capital
 

What's hot (20)

mortgage Rates's location
mortgage Rates's locationmortgage Rates's location
mortgage Rates's location
 
Student loan basics
Student loan basicsStudent loan basics
Student loan basics
 
Principal Reduction Powerpoint Presentation
Principal Reduction Powerpoint PresentationPrincipal Reduction Powerpoint Presentation
Principal Reduction Powerpoint Presentation
 
One loan for all loans debt consolidation loan
One loan for all loans  debt consolidation loanOne loan for all loans  debt consolidation loan
One loan for all loans debt consolidation loan
 
People Involved in the Mortgage Process
People Involved in the Mortgage ProcessPeople Involved in the Mortgage Process
People Involved in the Mortgage Process
 
Synergy Debt Group - Canadian Debt News - Vol 3
Synergy Debt Group - Canadian Debt News - Vol 3Synergy Debt Group - Canadian Debt News - Vol 3
Synergy Debt Group - Canadian Debt News - Vol 3
 
New America Parent Plus Loan Panel
New America Parent Plus Loan PanelNew America Parent Plus Loan Panel
New America Parent Plus Loan Panel
 
Payday loans no credit check
Payday loans no credit checkPayday loans no credit check
Payday loans no credit check
 
Adjustable Rate Mortgage Modification Strategy - Revised June 2017
Adjustable Rate Mortgage Modification Strategy - Revised June 2017Adjustable Rate Mortgage Modification Strategy - Revised June 2017
Adjustable Rate Mortgage Modification Strategy - Revised June 2017
 
Retail Banking
Retail BankingRetail Banking
Retail Banking
 
FAQ
FAQFAQ
FAQ
 
Reverse mortgage to financial planners & advisors
Reverse mortgage to financial planners & advisorsReverse mortgage to financial planners & advisors
Reverse mortgage to financial planners & advisors
 
Kandy Wong_Chinese banks step up lending in the US - FT
Kandy Wong_Chinese banks step up lending in the US - FTKandy Wong_Chinese banks step up lending in the US - FT
Kandy Wong_Chinese banks step up lending in the US - FT
 
Credit Scores - How Much Do They Matter with A Mortgage
Credit Scores - How Much Do They Matter with A MortgageCredit Scores - How Much Do They Matter with A Mortgage
Credit Scores - How Much Do They Matter with A Mortgage
 
Credit Scores – How Much do They Matter with a Mortgage?
Credit Scores – How Much do They Matter with a Mortgage?Credit Scores – How Much do They Matter with a Mortgage?
Credit Scores – How Much do They Matter with a Mortgage?
 
Debits consolidation
Debits consolidationDebits consolidation
Debits consolidation
 
5 Things You Need to Be Pre-Approved for a Mortgage Loan - New American Funding
5 Things You Need to Be Pre-Approved for a Mortgage Loan - New American Funding5 Things You Need to Be Pre-Approved for a Mortgage Loan - New American Funding
5 Things You Need to Be Pre-Approved for a Mortgage Loan - New American Funding
 
Quick Short Term Loans
Quick Short Term LoansQuick Short Term Loans
Quick Short Term Loans
 
FAQ
FAQFAQ
FAQ
 
Get the Right Loan for You
Get the Right Loan for YouGet the Right Loan for You
Get the Right Loan for You
 

Similar to Psychology Explains Common Mistakes in Mortgage Refinancing

The surprising savings from mortgage refinancing
The surprising savings from mortgage refinancingThe surprising savings from mortgage refinancing
The surprising savings from mortgage refinancing
reversemortgagelenders763
 
home process
home process home process
home process
1234sawai
 
Homeloans
HomeloansHomeloans
Homeloans
Dharmik
 
Complete Payday Advance Borrower Guide
Complete Payday Advance Borrower GuideComplete Payday Advance Borrower Guide
Complete Payday Advance Borrower Guide
mushyfan9226
 
Whole Payday Loan Borrower Guide
Whole Payday Loan Borrower GuideWhole Payday Loan Borrower Guide
Whole Payday Loan Borrower Guide
cervantesdoeroyriry
 
Homeloans
HomeloansHomeloans
Homeloans
saurabh goel
 
Decoding U.S. Mortgage Rates: Factors and Trends
Decoding U.S. Mortgage Rates: Factors and TrendsDecoding U.S. Mortgage Rates: Factors and Trends
Decoding U.S. Mortgage Rates: Factors and Trends
Danon Real Estate
 
Does less regulation equal more loan defaults
Does less regulation equal more loan defaultsDoes less regulation equal more loan defaults
Does less regulation equal more loan defaults
usmajormovers
 
The New Face of LMI Lending
The New Face of LMI Lending The New Face of LMI Lending
The New Face of LMI Lending
Dwight Crawford, CMC
 
Buying a Home? Know Hard Costs Going In
Buying a Home?  Know Hard Costs Going InBuying a Home?  Know Hard Costs Going In
Buying a Home? Know Hard Costs Going In
Dean Graziosi
 
Payday Lending in TEXAS-Brief
Payday Lending in TEXAS-BriefPayday Lending in TEXAS-Brief
Payday Lending in TEXAS-Brief
Rama Gerig
 
Financial freedom through reverse mortgage
Financial freedom through reverse mortgageFinancial freedom through reverse mortgage
Financial freedom through reverse mortgage
Projects Kart
 
Investors Who Do a Few Mortgages on the Side
Investors Who Do a Few Mortgages on the SideInvestors Who Do a Few Mortgages on the Side
Investors Who Do a Few Mortgages on the Side
William E. Nassour
 
Financial Freedom through Reverse Mortgage
Financial Freedom through Reverse MortgageFinancial Freedom through Reverse Mortgage
Financial Freedom through Reverse Mortgage
Projects Kart
 
What Is a Hard Money Loan How a Hard Money Loan Works
What Is a Hard Money Loan How a Hard Money Loan WorksWhat Is a Hard Money Loan How a Hard Money Loan Works
What Is a Hard Money Loan How a Hard Money Loan Works
All California Lending
 
Credit crunch
Credit crunch  Credit crunch
Credit crunch
Rotaract Club of IoBM
 
PPT on 2008. US SUB PRIME CRISIS-2.pptx
PPT on 2008.  US SUB PRIME CRISIS-2.pptxPPT on 2008.  US SUB PRIME CRISIS-2.pptx
PPT on 2008. US SUB PRIME CRISIS-2.pptx
kthegreatks
 
Reverse Mortgage Product Basics 3 24 2010
Reverse Mortgage Product Basics 3 24 2010Reverse Mortgage Product Basics 3 24 2010
Reverse Mortgage Product Basics 3 24 2010
fstadler
 
Cdl conference finance presentation v.final
Cdl conference finance presentation v.finalCdl conference finance presentation v.final
Cdl conference finance presentation v.final
SUNY Empire State College
 
This Month in Real Estate- July 09
This Month in Real Estate- July 09This Month in Real Estate- July 09
This Month in Real Estate- July 09
Keller Williams Realty Professionals
 

Similar to Psychology Explains Common Mistakes in Mortgage Refinancing (20)

The surprising savings from mortgage refinancing
The surprising savings from mortgage refinancingThe surprising savings from mortgage refinancing
The surprising savings from mortgage refinancing
 
home process
home process home process
home process
 
Homeloans
HomeloansHomeloans
Homeloans
 
Complete Payday Advance Borrower Guide
Complete Payday Advance Borrower GuideComplete Payday Advance Borrower Guide
Complete Payday Advance Borrower Guide
 
Whole Payday Loan Borrower Guide
Whole Payday Loan Borrower GuideWhole Payday Loan Borrower Guide
Whole Payday Loan Borrower Guide
 
Homeloans
HomeloansHomeloans
Homeloans
 
Decoding U.S. Mortgage Rates: Factors and Trends
Decoding U.S. Mortgage Rates: Factors and TrendsDecoding U.S. Mortgage Rates: Factors and Trends
Decoding U.S. Mortgage Rates: Factors and Trends
 
Does less regulation equal more loan defaults
Does less regulation equal more loan defaultsDoes less regulation equal more loan defaults
Does less regulation equal more loan defaults
 
The New Face of LMI Lending
The New Face of LMI Lending The New Face of LMI Lending
The New Face of LMI Lending
 
Buying a Home? Know Hard Costs Going In
Buying a Home?  Know Hard Costs Going InBuying a Home?  Know Hard Costs Going In
Buying a Home? Know Hard Costs Going In
 
Payday Lending in TEXAS-Brief
Payday Lending in TEXAS-BriefPayday Lending in TEXAS-Brief
Payday Lending in TEXAS-Brief
 
Financial freedom through reverse mortgage
Financial freedom through reverse mortgageFinancial freedom through reverse mortgage
Financial freedom through reverse mortgage
 
Investors Who Do a Few Mortgages on the Side
Investors Who Do a Few Mortgages on the SideInvestors Who Do a Few Mortgages on the Side
Investors Who Do a Few Mortgages on the Side
 
Financial Freedom through Reverse Mortgage
Financial Freedom through Reverse MortgageFinancial Freedom through Reverse Mortgage
Financial Freedom through Reverse Mortgage
 
What Is a Hard Money Loan How a Hard Money Loan Works
What Is a Hard Money Loan How a Hard Money Loan WorksWhat Is a Hard Money Loan How a Hard Money Loan Works
What Is a Hard Money Loan How a Hard Money Loan Works
 
Credit crunch
Credit crunch  Credit crunch
Credit crunch
 
PPT on 2008. US SUB PRIME CRISIS-2.pptx
PPT on 2008.  US SUB PRIME CRISIS-2.pptxPPT on 2008.  US SUB PRIME CRISIS-2.pptx
PPT on 2008. US SUB PRIME CRISIS-2.pptx
 
Reverse Mortgage Product Basics 3 24 2010
Reverse Mortgage Product Basics 3 24 2010Reverse Mortgage Product Basics 3 24 2010
Reverse Mortgage Product Basics 3 24 2010
 
Cdl conference finance presentation v.final
Cdl conference finance presentation v.finalCdl conference finance presentation v.final
Cdl conference finance presentation v.final
 
This Month in Real Estate- July 09
This Month in Real Estate- July 09This Month in Real Estate- July 09
This Month in Real Estate- July 09
 

Recently uploaded

SVN Live 6.17.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
SVN Live 6.17.24 Weekly Property BroadcastSVN Live 6.17.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
SVN Live 6.17.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
SVN International Corp.
 
BEST FARMLAND FOR SALE | FARM PLOTS NEAR BANGALORE | KANAKAPURA | CHICKKABALP...
BEST FARMLAND FOR SALE | FARM PLOTS NEAR BANGALORE | KANAKAPURA | CHICKKABALP...BEST FARMLAND FOR SALE | FARM PLOTS NEAR BANGALORE | KANAKAPURA | CHICKKABALP...
BEST FARMLAND FOR SALE | FARM PLOTS NEAR BANGALORE | KANAKAPURA | CHICKKABALP...
knox groups real estate
 
Living in an UBER World - June '24 Sales Meeting
Living in an UBER World - June '24 Sales MeetingLiving in an UBER World - June '24 Sales Meeting
Living in an UBER World - June '24 Sales Meeting
Tom Blefko
 
Anilesh Ahuja Pioneering a Paradigm Shift in Real Estate Success.pptx
Anilesh Ahuja Pioneering a Paradigm Shift in Real Estate Success.pptxAnilesh Ahuja Pioneering a Paradigm Shift in Real Estate Success.pptx
Anilesh Ahuja Pioneering a Paradigm Shift in Real Estate Success.pptx
neilahuja668
 
Deed 3754 S Honeysuckle Mesa AZ 85212 owner Shawn Freeman - Pamela Brown Nota...
Deed 3754 S Honeysuckle Mesa AZ 85212 owner Shawn Freeman - Pamela Brown Nota...Deed 3754 S Honeysuckle Mesa AZ 85212 owner Shawn Freeman - Pamela Brown Nota...
Deed 3754 S Honeysuckle Mesa AZ 85212 owner Shawn Freeman - Pamela Brown Nota...
olgashriki
 
Kumar Codename Fireworks at Hadapsar Link Road, Pune - PDF.pdf
Kumar Codename Fireworks at Hadapsar Link Road, Pune - PDF.pdfKumar Codename Fireworks at Hadapsar Link Road, Pune - PDF.pdf
Kumar Codename Fireworks at Hadapsar Link Road, Pune - PDF.pdf
monikasharma630
 
AVRUPA KONUTLARI ESENTEPE - ENGLISH - Listing Turkey
AVRUPA KONUTLARI ESENTEPE - ENGLISH - Listing TurkeyAVRUPA KONUTLARI ESENTEPE - ENGLISH - Listing Turkey
AVRUPA KONUTLARI ESENTEPE - ENGLISH - Listing Turkey
Listing Turkey
 
原版制作(Greenwich毕业证书)格林威治大学毕业证PDF成绩单一模一样
原版制作(Greenwich毕业证书)格林威治大学毕业证PDF成绩单一模一样原版制作(Greenwich毕业证书)格林威治大学毕业证PDF成绩单一模一样
原版制作(Greenwich毕业证书)格林威治大学毕业证PDF成绩单一模一样
a7xjm8n4
 
Stark Builders: Where Quality Meets Craftsmanship!
Stark Builders: Where Quality Meets Craftsmanship!Stark Builders: Where Quality Meets Craftsmanship!
Stark Builders: Where Quality Meets Craftsmanship!
shuilykhatunnil
 

Recently uploaded (9)

SVN Live 6.17.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
SVN Live 6.17.24 Weekly Property BroadcastSVN Live 6.17.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
SVN Live 6.17.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
 
BEST FARMLAND FOR SALE | FARM PLOTS NEAR BANGALORE | KANAKAPURA | CHICKKABALP...
BEST FARMLAND FOR SALE | FARM PLOTS NEAR BANGALORE | KANAKAPURA | CHICKKABALP...BEST FARMLAND FOR SALE | FARM PLOTS NEAR BANGALORE | KANAKAPURA | CHICKKABALP...
BEST FARMLAND FOR SALE | FARM PLOTS NEAR BANGALORE | KANAKAPURA | CHICKKABALP...
 
Living in an UBER World - June '24 Sales Meeting
Living in an UBER World - June '24 Sales MeetingLiving in an UBER World - June '24 Sales Meeting
Living in an UBER World - June '24 Sales Meeting
 
Anilesh Ahuja Pioneering a Paradigm Shift in Real Estate Success.pptx
Anilesh Ahuja Pioneering a Paradigm Shift in Real Estate Success.pptxAnilesh Ahuja Pioneering a Paradigm Shift in Real Estate Success.pptx
Anilesh Ahuja Pioneering a Paradigm Shift in Real Estate Success.pptx
 
Deed 3754 S Honeysuckle Mesa AZ 85212 owner Shawn Freeman - Pamela Brown Nota...
Deed 3754 S Honeysuckle Mesa AZ 85212 owner Shawn Freeman - Pamela Brown Nota...Deed 3754 S Honeysuckle Mesa AZ 85212 owner Shawn Freeman - Pamela Brown Nota...
Deed 3754 S Honeysuckle Mesa AZ 85212 owner Shawn Freeman - Pamela Brown Nota...
 
Kumar Codename Fireworks at Hadapsar Link Road, Pune - PDF.pdf
Kumar Codename Fireworks at Hadapsar Link Road, Pune - PDF.pdfKumar Codename Fireworks at Hadapsar Link Road, Pune - PDF.pdf
Kumar Codename Fireworks at Hadapsar Link Road, Pune - PDF.pdf
 
AVRUPA KONUTLARI ESENTEPE - ENGLISH - Listing Turkey
AVRUPA KONUTLARI ESENTEPE - ENGLISH - Listing TurkeyAVRUPA KONUTLARI ESENTEPE - ENGLISH - Listing Turkey
AVRUPA KONUTLARI ESENTEPE - ENGLISH - Listing Turkey
 
原版制作(Greenwich毕业证书)格林威治大学毕业证PDF成绩单一模一样
原版制作(Greenwich毕业证书)格林威治大学毕业证PDF成绩单一模一样原版制作(Greenwich毕业证书)格林威治大学毕业证PDF成绩单一模一样
原版制作(Greenwich毕业证书)格林威治大学毕业证PDF成绩单一模一样
 
Stark Builders: Where Quality Meets Craftsmanship!
Stark Builders: Where Quality Meets Craftsmanship!Stark Builders: Where Quality Meets Craftsmanship!
Stark Builders: Where Quality Meets Craftsmanship!
 

Psychology Explains Common Mistakes in Mortgage Refinancing

  • 1. Psychology Explains Common Mistakes in Mortgage Refinancing Primary Residential Mortgage, Inc.
  • 2. Mortgage refinancing is one of the leading avenues for households to relieve themselves of housing loan debt, interest rates, and monthly payments. It is also one of the most viable options for people looking to buy an investment property or start a business. In the U.S., fixed rate mortgage debt is still the dominant form of residential financial obligation, but refinancing provides ways to lighten the financial load during adverse economic conditions. Common Mistakes in Refinancing and the Psychology Behind Them Economists from the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago and Georgia State University conducted a study in 2015 that focused on the reason behind mortgage refinancing mistakes. Their study found that borrowers usually choose an interest rate from options provided by lenders during a particular period. Since interest rates regularly change, 50 percent of borrowers choose the wrong rate while 17% wait too long for other options, hence delaying their payment.
  • 3. The study found that the more experienced borrowers commit fewer mistakes than the new borrowers. Upon learning from previous refinancing experiences, competent borrowers make sure to refinance at rates closer to optimal. They also have less waiting time after mortgage rates reach their trigger rates. Another study from the Federal Bank Reserve of Chicago and University of Chicago pointed to factors brought by the Great Recession. During this time, many households took advantage of extracting equities during the housing bubble burst. It resulted in severe declines in home prices that left people with little or no equity in their homes. The Great Recession also contributed to many job losses that made a lot of homeowners unable to refinance and underwrite new mortgages in the absence of a regular source of income. When a primary channel for accommodative financial services like refinancing gets blocked, there are fewer stimuli for people to buy homes and file for loans, despite low-interest rates.
  • 4. Borrowers' Behaviors Towards Mortgage and Housing The above studies concluded that borrowers have different attitudes in refinancing their mortgage. Less-experienced borrowers either choose the most viable option among the available ones or wait too long until interest rates meet their budget. Experienced borrowers, on the other hand, know when the right time is to refinance and immediately know which option is optimal. The housing bubble burst caused by the Great Recession has also significantly affected people access to a mortgage. Those who were left jobless lost access to low-interest programs while others ended up with little to no equity in their homes due to acts of impulse. Sources: http://primeresnw.com/ https://pubsonline.informs.org/doi/abs/10.1287/mnsc.2015.2272 https://ideas.repec.org/a/fip/fedhle/00042.html https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1364661316300997