SlideShare a Scribd company logo
EAWOP, May 2009
Santiago de Compostela/Spain
contact details: Christian Bosau phone: +49 221 470-4120
Herbert-Lewin-Str. 2 mail: christian.bosau@uni-koeln.de
50931 Cologne/Germany web: http://wisopsy.uni-koeln.de
Measures:
Organizational image: measured by 17 items that were developed according to
the literature on organizational image, loading on 4 factors (a) standing of the
organization in the market, b) production quality, c) organizational climate,
d) general attractiveness and sympathy)
Employer image: measured by 3 items, e.g. “I could imagine to work for that
organization”
Product image: measured by cognitive items (e.g. “I know the products of this
organization”) and affective items (e.g. “I think, the products of the organization are
of high quality”).
Sample & Method:
Scenario-based experiments with repeated measurements (with-in-subject):
a) pre-test: 2 (before & after) x 2 (brand & no-brand organizations) ANOVA with
270 students from the university of Cologne
b) 2 (before & after) x 3 (recruitment database & rejection & invitation to job
interview) ANOVA with 452 students from the university of Cologne
The scenario described that applicants sent their application to an organization,
which took some effort, and after that received an invitation to a job interview, a
rejection or the opportunity to join the recruitment database, respectively.
Results of the main study:
References:
Cable, D.M., & Turban, D.B. (2001). Establishing the dimensions, sources and value of job seekers’ employer knowledge during recruitment. In G.R. Ferris (Ed.), Research in personnel and
human resources management (pp. 115-163). New York: Elsevier Science.
Chambers, B.A. (2002). Applicant reactions and their consequences: review, advice, and recommendations for future research. International Journal of Management Reviews, 4(4), 317-333.
Gilliland, S.W., Groth, M., Baker IV, R.C., Dew, A.F., Polly, L.M., & Langdon, J.C. (2001). Improving applicants’ reactions to rejection letters: An application of fairness theory. Personnel
Psychology, 54, 669-703.
Hausknecht, J.P., Day, D.V., & Thomas, S.C. (2004). Applicant reactions to selection procedures: An updated model and meta-analysis. Personnel Psychology, 57, 639-683.
Ryan, A.M., & Ployhart, R.E. (2000). Applicants’ perception of selection procedures and decisions: A critical review and agenda for the future. Journal of Management, 26(3), 565-606.
Smither, J.W., Reilly, R.R., Millsap, R.E., Pearlman, K., & Stoffey, R.W. (1993). Applicant reactions to selection procedures. Personnel Psychology, 46, 49-76.
Results:
generally: responses in the recruitment process influence how applicants think about the organization. The organizational image, the employer image as well as
the product image is changed after applicants get a response from the organization to their application.
specifically: different responses are responsible for different changes in the images. Invitations to a job interview (i.e. reaching the next step in the recruitment
process) have a positive/neutral effect on the images whereas rejection letters and invitations for putting the CV in the recruitment database have a negative effect.
interestingly: the product image, that was not supposed to be influenced by recruitment processes, is devalued as well. Thus, the way of dealing with applicants
also influences whether those people become future customers or not.
MOST IMPORTANT: invitations for joining the recruitment database are almost as bad as rejection letters. If applicants get the opportunity to join the recruitment
database they devalue the three images in the same way as if they receive a rejection. Therefore, from the applicant’s perspective a recruitment database invitation almost
feels like a rejection, since applicants are looking for a job and not for a membership in a recruitment database.
Theoretical Background:
In competitive labor markets characterized by a ‘war of talent’ organizations try to attract the best talents, often using so-called ‘recruitment databases’ in order to not loose
any good talent. Thus, organizations try to avoid sending out any rejection notices but instead try to keep the applicants’ CVs in a recruitment database to use them for
staffing of future open posts. Instead of a rejection letter applicants receive an invitation (also called ice-letter) to put their CV in the ‘recruitment database’. The applicants
are told that this will be the first step in entering the organization and getting a job.
However, what do applicants think about this recruitment practice? Will the image of the organization actually raise – as organizations often expect – since applicants are
not rejected anymore? The consequences of such a recruitment strategy were not fully explored yet, neither in the research nor in the professional area.
Scholars have suggested that it is very important to look at reactions of applicants (Hausknecht, Day, & Thomas, 2004). Organizations with a good reputation and a good
image are supposed to be able to attract better applicants (Cable & Turban, 2001). If applicants perceive the selection procedure to be not acceptable, however, several
important aspects might be negatively influenced (Chambers, 2002): besides their behavioral intentions, their actual behavior, their test-performance in the selection
procedure, their later job-performance, most importantly their overall organizational impressions could change. Applicants get those impressions about an organization
when they experience its recruitment and selection practices (Smither, Reilly, Millsap, Pearlman, & Stoffey, 1993). Whether applicants are rejected or accepted clearly
influences their perceptions of the organization (Ryan & Ployhart, 2000). Therefore, the question that has to be answered is, whether using recruitment databases is
perceived from the applicants as being accepted or rejected, since this in turn influences the perceived images of the organization.
However, it can be assumed that recruitment databases will not have a very positive effect on the applicants’ impressions since applicants are normally looking for a job
and not for a ‘membership’ in a recruitment database.
Exploring recruitment databases from the applicantExploring recruitment databases from the applicant’’s perspectives perspective
ChristianChristian Bosau, NicoleBosau, Nicole MoiserMoiser--BeekBeek & Henrik& Henrik WichelmannWichelmann
University of Cologne, GermanyUniversity of Cologne, Germany

More Related Content

Similar to Exploring recruitment databases from the applicant's perspective - Poster Congress EAWOP Santiago de Compostela 2009

A Neat Sampling Strategy Based On Purposive Sampling Essay
A Neat Sampling Strategy Based On Purposive Sampling EssayA Neat Sampling Strategy Based On Purposive Sampling Essay
A Neat Sampling Strategy Based On Purposive Sampling Essay
Tammy Majors
 
The impact of Recruitment and Selection process on candidates' intention to a...
The impact of Recruitment and Selection process on candidates' intention to a...The impact of Recruitment and Selection process on candidates' intention to a...
The impact of Recruitment and Selection process on candidates' intention to a...
Target Research
 
Gks recruitment and selection
Gks  recruitment and selectionGks  recruitment and selection
Gks recruitment and selection
FMS UDAIPUR
 
Staffing and Recruitment
Staffing and Recruitment Staffing and Recruitment
Staffing and Recruitment
Vikram Dahiya
 
Employee Testing and SelectionOnce you build upon your app
Employee Testing and SelectionOnce you build upon your appEmployee Testing and SelectionOnce you build upon your app
Employee Testing and SelectionOnce you build upon your app
TanaMaeskm
 
Three Basic Job Evaluation Methods
Three Basic Job Evaluation MethodsThree Basic Job Evaluation Methods
Three Basic Job Evaluation Methods
Ashley Lovato
 
Pre Assessment Quantitative And Qualitative Data Essay
Pre Assessment Quantitative And Qualitative Data EssayPre Assessment Quantitative And Qualitative Data Essay
Pre Assessment Quantitative And Qualitative Data Essay
Tiffany Sandoval
 
RESEARCH PROPOSAL MBA-HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT1. Project (re.docx
RESEARCH PROPOSAL MBA-HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT1. Project (re.docxRESEARCH PROPOSAL MBA-HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT1. Project (re.docx
RESEARCH PROPOSAL MBA-HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT1. Project (re.docx
ronak56
 
Organizational BehaviorEighteenth EditionChapter 17Human R.docx
Organizational BehaviorEighteenth EditionChapter 17Human R.docxOrganizational BehaviorEighteenth EditionChapter 17Human R.docx
Organizational BehaviorEighteenth EditionChapter 17Human R.docx
vannagoforth
 
Running Head Dissertation of Service Quality Improvement .docx
Running Head Dissertation of Service Quality Improvement       .docxRunning Head Dissertation of Service Quality Improvement       .docx
Running Head Dissertation of Service Quality Improvement .docx
charisellington63520
 
Research process
Research processResearch process
Research process
snehasawant
 
Managing human resources (psych)
Managing human resources (psych)Managing human resources (psych)
Managing human resources (psych)
University of East Anglia/CCN
 
Research methodology ppt babasab
Research methodology ppt babasab Research methodology ppt babasab
Research methodology ppt babasab
Babasab Patil
 
Job Simulation- Whitepaper from Hiring Simulation Assessments
Job Simulation- Whitepaper from Hiring Simulation AssessmentsJob Simulation- Whitepaper from Hiring Simulation Assessments
Job Simulation- Whitepaper from Hiring Simulation Assessments
Hire Results
 
PPT Staffing decission
PPT Staffing decissionPPT Staffing decission
PPT Staffing decission
ErrienMaulidia
 
RSTD
RSTDRSTD
RSTD
ckrishnan
 
Raise your likeability factor white paper
Raise your likeability factor white paperRaise your likeability factor white paper
Raise your likeability factor white paper
Donn LeVie Jr. STRATEGIES
 
Sample Qualitative Research Proposal Background of the Study.docx
Sample Qualitative Research Proposal Background of the Study.docxSample Qualitative Research Proposal Background of the Study.docx
Sample Qualitative Research Proposal Background of the Study.docx
anhlodge
 
Methods Of Program Evaluation. Evaluation Research Is Offered
Methods Of Program Evaluation. Evaluation Research Is OfferedMethods Of Program Evaluation. Evaluation Research Is Offered
Methods Of Program Evaluation. Evaluation Research Is Offered
Jennifer Wood
 
Discussion 2 Predictor Effectiveness in Criterion Measure Estimat.docx
Discussion 2 Predictor Effectiveness in Criterion Measure Estimat.docxDiscussion 2 Predictor Effectiveness in Criterion Measure Estimat.docx
Discussion 2 Predictor Effectiveness in Criterion Measure Estimat.docx
elinoraudley582231
 

Similar to Exploring recruitment databases from the applicant's perspective - Poster Congress EAWOP Santiago de Compostela 2009 (20)

A Neat Sampling Strategy Based On Purposive Sampling Essay
A Neat Sampling Strategy Based On Purposive Sampling EssayA Neat Sampling Strategy Based On Purposive Sampling Essay
A Neat Sampling Strategy Based On Purposive Sampling Essay
 
The impact of Recruitment and Selection process on candidates' intention to a...
The impact of Recruitment and Selection process on candidates' intention to a...The impact of Recruitment and Selection process on candidates' intention to a...
The impact of Recruitment and Selection process on candidates' intention to a...
 
Gks recruitment and selection
Gks  recruitment and selectionGks  recruitment and selection
Gks recruitment and selection
 
Staffing and Recruitment
Staffing and Recruitment Staffing and Recruitment
Staffing and Recruitment
 
Employee Testing and SelectionOnce you build upon your app
Employee Testing and SelectionOnce you build upon your appEmployee Testing and SelectionOnce you build upon your app
Employee Testing and SelectionOnce you build upon your app
 
Three Basic Job Evaluation Methods
Three Basic Job Evaluation MethodsThree Basic Job Evaluation Methods
Three Basic Job Evaluation Methods
 
Pre Assessment Quantitative And Qualitative Data Essay
Pre Assessment Quantitative And Qualitative Data EssayPre Assessment Quantitative And Qualitative Data Essay
Pre Assessment Quantitative And Qualitative Data Essay
 
RESEARCH PROPOSAL MBA-HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT1. Project (re.docx
RESEARCH PROPOSAL MBA-HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT1. Project (re.docxRESEARCH PROPOSAL MBA-HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT1. Project (re.docx
RESEARCH PROPOSAL MBA-HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT1. Project (re.docx
 
Organizational BehaviorEighteenth EditionChapter 17Human R.docx
Organizational BehaviorEighteenth EditionChapter 17Human R.docxOrganizational BehaviorEighteenth EditionChapter 17Human R.docx
Organizational BehaviorEighteenth EditionChapter 17Human R.docx
 
Running Head Dissertation of Service Quality Improvement .docx
Running Head Dissertation of Service Quality Improvement       .docxRunning Head Dissertation of Service Quality Improvement       .docx
Running Head Dissertation of Service Quality Improvement .docx
 
Research process
Research processResearch process
Research process
 
Managing human resources (psych)
Managing human resources (psych)Managing human resources (psych)
Managing human resources (psych)
 
Research methodology ppt babasab
Research methodology ppt babasab Research methodology ppt babasab
Research methodology ppt babasab
 
Job Simulation- Whitepaper from Hiring Simulation Assessments
Job Simulation- Whitepaper from Hiring Simulation AssessmentsJob Simulation- Whitepaper from Hiring Simulation Assessments
Job Simulation- Whitepaper from Hiring Simulation Assessments
 
PPT Staffing decission
PPT Staffing decissionPPT Staffing decission
PPT Staffing decission
 
RSTD
RSTDRSTD
RSTD
 
Raise your likeability factor white paper
Raise your likeability factor white paperRaise your likeability factor white paper
Raise your likeability factor white paper
 
Sample Qualitative Research Proposal Background of the Study.docx
Sample Qualitative Research Proposal Background of the Study.docxSample Qualitative Research Proposal Background of the Study.docx
Sample Qualitative Research Proposal Background of the Study.docx
 
Methods Of Program Evaluation. Evaluation Research Is Offered
Methods Of Program Evaluation. Evaluation Research Is OfferedMethods Of Program Evaluation. Evaluation Research Is Offered
Methods Of Program Evaluation. Evaluation Research Is Offered
 
Discussion 2 Predictor Effectiveness in Criterion Measure Estimat.docx
Discussion 2 Predictor Effectiveness in Criterion Measure Estimat.docxDiscussion 2 Predictor Effectiveness in Criterion Measure Estimat.docx
Discussion 2 Predictor Effectiveness in Criterion Measure Estimat.docx
 

More from Christian Bosau

Personalauswahl in Zeiten von Big Data: Möglichkeiten zur Erhöhung der Akzept...
Personalauswahl in Zeiten von Big Data: Möglichkeiten zur Erhöhung der Akzept...Personalauswahl in Zeiten von Big Data: Möglichkeiten zur Erhöhung der Akzept...
Personalauswahl in Zeiten von Big Data: Möglichkeiten zur Erhöhung der Akzept...
Christian Bosau
 
If I can virtually touch it, I'll buy it - Vortrag GOR19.pdf
If I can virtually touch it, I'll buy it - Vortrag GOR19.pdfIf I can virtually touch it, I'll buy it - Vortrag GOR19.pdf
If I can virtually touch it, I'll buy it - Vortrag GOR19.pdf
Christian Bosau
 
Personal ratings or social proof - Vortrag GOR 2019.pdf
Personal ratings or social proof  - Vortrag GOR 2019.pdfPersonal ratings or social proof  - Vortrag GOR 2019.pdf
Personal ratings or social proof - Vortrag GOR 2019.pdf
Christian Bosau
 
Akzeptanz von Sprachanalyse im Bewerbungsprozess - Vortrag AOWI-Tagung 2023.pdf
Akzeptanz von Sprachanalyse im Bewerbungsprozess -  Vortrag AOWI-Tagung 2023.pdfAkzeptanz von Sprachanalyse im Bewerbungsprozess -  Vortrag AOWI-Tagung 2023.pdf
Akzeptanz von Sprachanalyse im Bewerbungsprozess - Vortrag AOWI-Tagung 2023.pdf
Christian Bosau
 
"Fomotiker" und ihr starkes soziales Bedürfnis - Vortrag GWPs 2018
"Fomotiker" und ihr starkes soziales Bedürfnis - Vortrag GWPs 2018"Fomotiker" und ihr starkes soziales Bedürfnis - Vortrag GWPs 2018
"Fomotiker" und ihr starkes soziales Bedürfnis - Vortrag GWPs 2018
Christian Bosau
 
"Phubbing" - only caused by "Fear of Missing Out"? - Presentation Media Psych...
"Phubbing" - only caused by "Fear of Missing Out"? - Presentation Media Psych..."Phubbing" - only caused by "Fear of Missing Out"? - Presentation Media Psych...
"Phubbing" - only caused by "Fear of Missing Out"? - Presentation Media Psych...
Christian Bosau
 
Explaining the FoMO-phenomenon - Presentation at GOR 2017
Explaining the FoMO-phenomenon - Presentation at GOR 2017Explaining the FoMO-phenomenon - Presentation at GOR 2017
Explaining the FoMO-phenomenon - Presentation at GOR 2017
Christian Bosau
 
FoMO (Fear of Missing Out) und die exzessive Smartphone-Nutzung - Tatsächlich...
FoMO (Fear of Missing Out) und die exzessive Smartphone-Nutzung - Tatsächlich...FoMO (Fear of Missing Out) und die exzessive Smartphone-Nutzung - Tatsächlich...
FoMO (Fear of Missing Out) und die exzessive Smartphone-Nutzung - Tatsächlich...
Christian Bosau
 
Die Nutzung von Smartphones in Partnerschaften - Vortrag DGPs 2016
Die Nutzung von Smartphones in Partnerschaften - Vortrag DGPs 2016Die Nutzung von Smartphones in Partnerschaften - Vortrag DGPs 2016
Die Nutzung von Smartphones in Partnerschaften - Vortrag DGPs 2016
Christian Bosau
 
The two sides of social media friendship - Presentation at GOR 2016
The two sides of social media friendship - Presentation at GOR 2016The two sides of social media friendship - Presentation at GOR 2016
The two sides of social media friendship - Presentation at GOR 2016
Christian Bosau
 
Kann Facebook-Nutzung glücklich machen? - Vortrag GWPs 2016
Kann Facebook-Nutzung glücklich machen? - Vortrag GWPs 2016Kann Facebook-Nutzung glücklich machen? - Vortrag GWPs 2016
Kann Facebook-Nutzung glücklich machen? - Vortrag GWPs 2016
Christian Bosau
 
How to explain phubbing - Presentation Media Psychology Conference 2015
How to explain phubbing - Presentation Media Psychology Conference 2015How to explain phubbing - Presentation Media Psychology Conference 2015
How to explain phubbing - Presentation Media Psychology Conference 2015
Christian Bosau
 
"Who is affected by FoMO (Fear of Missing Out)? - presentation ecpa 2015
"Who is affected by FoMO (Fear of Missing Out)? - presentation ecpa 2015"Who is affected by FoMO (Fear of Missing Out)? - presentation ecpa 2015
"Who is affected by FoMO (Fear of Missing Out)? - presentation ecpa 2015
Christian Bosau
 
"not hired, not bought" - presentation eawop 2015
"not hired, not bought" - presentation eawop 2015"not hired, not bought" - presentation eawop 2015
"not hired, not bought" - presentation eawop 2015
Christian Bosau
 
Phubbing because of FoMO? - presentation GOR 2015
Phubbing because of FoMO? - presentation GOR 2015Phubbing because of FoMO? - presentation GOR 2015
Phubbing because of FoMO? - presentation GOR 2015
Christian Bosau
 
Social ratings as the new currency of marketeers? - Presentation GOR 2015
Social ratings as the new currency of marketeers? - Presentation GOR 2015Social ratings as the new currency of marketeers? - Presentation GOR 2015
Social ratings as the new currency of marketeers? - Presentation GOR 2015
Christian Bosau
 
FoMO (Fear of Missing Out) beeinträchtigt Studienerfolg – Warum man in einer...
FoMO (Fear of Missing Out) beeinträchtigt Studienerfolg – Warum man in einer...FoMO (Fear of Missing Out) beeinträchtigt Studienerfolg – Warum man in einer...
FoMO (Fear of Missing Out) beeinträchtigt Studienerfolg – Warum man in einer...
Christian Bosau
 
„Ich darf nichts verpassen“ - „Fear of Missing Out (FoMO)“ als Prädiktor fü...
„Ich darf nichts verpassen“ - „Fear of Missing Out (FoMO)“ als Prädiktor fü...„Ich darf nichts verpassen“ - „Fear of Missing Out (FoMO)“ als Prädiktor fü...
„Ich darf nichts verpassen“ - „Fear of Missing Out (FoMO)“ als Prädiktor fü...
Christian Bosau
 
FoMO (Fear of Missing Out) - Kann die Angst, etwas zu verpassen, erklären, wa...
FoMO (Fear of Missing Out) - Kann die Angst, etwas zu verpassen, erklären, wa...FoMO (Fear of Missing Out) - Kann die Angst, etwas zu verpassen, erklären, wa...
FoMO (Fear of Missing Out) - Kann die Angst, etwas zu verpassen, erklären, wa...
Christian Bosau
 
Interessanter Job oder lieber ein gutes Gehalt? - Eine interkulturelle Studie...
Interessanter Job oder lieber ein gutes Gehalt? - Eine interkulturelle Studie...Interessanter Job oder lieber ein gutes Gehalt? - Eine interkulturelle Studie...
Interessanter Job oder lieber ein gutes Gehalt? - Eine interkulturelle Studie...
Christian Bosau
 

More from Christian Bosau (20)

Personalauswahl in Zeiten von Big Data: Möglichkeiten zur Erhöhung der Akzept...
Personalauswahl in Zeiten von Big Data: Möglichkeiten zur Erhöhung der Akzept...Personalauswahl in Zeiten von Big Data: Möglichkeiten zur Erhöhung der Akzept...
Personalauswahl in Zeiten von Big Data: Möglichkeiten zur Erhöhung der Akzept...
 
If I can virtually touch it, I'll buy it - Vortrag GOR19.pdf
If I can virtually touch it, I'll buy it - Vortrag GOR19.pdfIf I can virtually touch it, I'll buy it - Vortrag GOR19.pdf
If I can virtually touch it, I'll buy it - Vortrag GOR19.pdf
 
Personal ratings or social proof - Vortrag GOR 2019.pdf
Personal ratings or social proof  - Vortrag GOR 2019.pdfPersonal ratings or social proof  - Vortrag GOR 2019.pdf
Personal ratings or social proof - Vortrag GOR 2019.pdf
 
Akzeptanz von Sprachanalyse im Bewerbungsprozess - Vortrag AOWI-Tagung 2023.pdf
Akzeptanz von Sprachanalyse im Bewerbungsprozess -  Vortrag AOWI-Tagung 2023.pdfAkzeptanz von Sprachanalyse im Bewerbungsprozess -  Vortrag AOWI-Tagung 2023.pdf
Akzeptanz von Sprachanalyse im Bewerbungsprozess - Vortrag AOWI-Tagung 2023.pdf
 
"Fomotiker" und ihr starkes soziales Bedürfnis - Vortrag GWPs 2018
"Fomotiker" und ihr starkes soziales Bedürfnis - Vortrag GWPs 2018"Fomotiker" und ihr starkes soziales Bedürfnis - Vortrag GWPs 2018
"Fomotiker" und ihr starkes soziales Bedürfnis - Vortrag GWPs 2018
 
"Phubbing" - only caused by "Fear of Missing Out"? - Presentation Media Psych...
"Phubbing" - only caused by "Fear of Missing Out"? - Presentation Media Psych..."Phubbing" - only caused by "Fear of Missing Out"? - Presentation Media Psych...
"Phubbing" - only caused by "Fear of Missing Out"? - Presentation Media Psych...
 
Explaining the FoMO-phenomenon - Presentation at GOR 2017
Explaining the FoMO-phenomenon - Presentation at GOR 2017Explaining the FoMO-phenomenon - Presentation at GOR 2017
Explaining the FoMO-phenomenon - Presentation at GOR 2017
 
FoMO (Fear of Missing Out) und die exzessive Smartphone-Nutzung - Tatsächlich...
FoMO (Fear of Missing Out) und die exzessive Smartphone-Nutzung - Tatsächlich...FoMO (Fear of Missing Out) und die exzessive Smartphone-Nutzung - Tatsächlich...
FoMO (Fear of Missing Out) und die exzessive Smartphone-Nutzung - Tatsächlich...
 
Die Nutzung von Smartphones in Partnerschaften - Vortrag DGPs 2016
Die Nutzung von Smartphones in Partnerschaften - Vortrag DGPs 2016Die Nutzung von Smartphones in Partnerschaften - Vortrag DGPs 2016
Die Nutzung von Smartphones in Partnerschaften - Vortrag DGPs 2016
 
The two sides of social media friendship - Presentation at GOR 2016
The two sides of social media friendship - Presentation at GOR 2016The two sides of social media friendship - Presentation at GOR 2016
The two sides of social media friendship - Presentation at GOR 2016
 
Kann Facebook-Nutzung glücklich machen? - Vortrag GWPs 2016
Kann Facebook-Nutzung glücklich machen? - Vortrag GWPs 2016Kann Facebook-Nutzung glücklich machen? - Vortrag GWPs 2016
Kann Facebook-Nutzung glücklich machen? - Vortrag GWPs 2016
 
How to explain phubbing - Presentation Media Psychology Conference 2015
How to explain phubbing - Presentation Media Psychology Conference 2015How to explain phubbing - Presentation Media Psychology Conference 2015
How to explain phubbing - Presentation Media Psychology Conference 2015
 
"Who is affected by FoMO (Fear of Missing Out)? - presentation ecpa 2015
"Who is affected by FoMO (Fear of Missing Out)? - presentation ecpa 2015"Who is affected by FoMO (Fear of Missing Out)? - presentation ecpa 2015
"Who is affected by FoMO (Fear of Missing Out)? - presentation ecpa 2015
 
"not hired, not bought" - presentation eawop 2015
"not hired, not bought" - presentation eawop 2015"not hired, not bought" - presentation eawop 2015
"not hired, not bought" - presentation eawop 2015
 
Phubbing because of FoMO? - presentation GOR 2015
Phubbing because of FoMO? - presentation GOR 2015Phubbing because of FoMO? - presentation GOR 2015
Phubbing because of FoMO? - presentation GOR 2015
 
Social ratings as the new currency of marketeers? - Presentation GOR 2015
Social ratings as the new currency of marketeers? - Presentation GOR 2015Social ratings as the new currency of marketeers? - Presentation GOR 2015
Social ratings as the new currency of marketeers? - Presentation GOR 2015
 
FoMO (Fear of Missing Out) beeinträchtigt Studienerfolg – Warum man in einer...
FoMO (Fear of Missing Out) beeinträchtigt Studienerfolg – Warum man in einer...FoMO (Fear of Missing Out) beeinträchtigt Studienerfolg – Warum man in einer...
FoMO (Fear of Missing Out) beeinträchtigt Studienerfolg – Warum man in einer...
 
„Ich darf nichts verpassen“ - „Fear of Missing Out (FoMO)“ als Prädiktor fü...
„Ich darf nichts verpassen“ - „Fear of Missing Out (FoMO)“ als Prädiktor fü...„Ich darf nichts verpassen“ - „Fear of Missing Out (FoMO)“ als Prädiktor fü...
„Ich darf nichts verpassen“ - „Fear of Missing Out (FoMO)“ als Prädiktor fü...
 
FoMO (Fear of Missing Out) - Kann die Angst, etwas zu verpassen, erklären, wa...
FoMO (Fear of Missing Out) - Kann die Angst, etwas zu verpassen, erklären, wa...FoMO (Fear of Missing Out) - Kann die Angst, etwas zu verpassen, erklären, wa...
FoMO (Fear of Missing Out) - Kann die Angst, etwas zu verpassen, erklären, wa...
 
Interessanter Job oder lieber ein gutes Gehalt? - Eine interkulturelle Studie...
Interessanter Job oder lieber ein gutes Gehalt? - Eine interkulturelle Studie...Interessanter Job oder lieber ein gutes Gehalt? - Eine interkulturelle Studie...
Interessanter Job oder lieber ein gutes Gehalt? - Eine interkulturelle Studie...
 

Recently uploaded

Qatar Airways Kuwait Office.pdf.........
Qatar Airways Kuwait Office.pdf.........Qatar Airways Kuwait Office.pdf.........
Qatar Airways Kuwait Office.pdf.........
anissageorge9890
 
CLEARPATH SUBDIVISION AUCKLAND Optimize Your Land’s Potential
CLEARPATH SUBDIVISION AUCKLAND Optimize Your Land’s PotentialCLEARPATH SUBDIVISION AUCKLAND Optimize Your Land’s Potential
CLEARPATH SUBDIVISION AUCKLAND Optimize Your Land’s Potential
ROIX LIMITED
 
upGrad_Case_Study_by_Himanshu_Singh.pptx
upGrad_Case_Study_by_Himanshu_Singh.pptxupGrad_Case_Study_by_Himanshu_Singh.pptx
upGrad_Case_Study_by_Himanshu_Singh.pptx
himanshubclubofgsv
 
Steps to Register Company in Dubai Mainland.pptx
Steps to Register Company in Dubai Mainland.pptxSteps to Register Company in Dubai Mainland.pptx
Steps to Register Company in Dubai Mainland.pptx
blackswanbss
 
Virtual Paralegal Services: Your Remote Legal Assistant
Virtual Paralegal Services: Your Remote Legal AssistantVirtual Paralegal Services: Your Remote Legal Assistant
Virtual Paralegal Services: Your Remote Legal Assistant
Eternity Paralegal Services
 
From Dallas to Houston Exploring Texas.docx
From Dallas to Houston Exploring Texas.docxFrom Dallas to Houston Exploring Texas.docx
From Dallas to Houston Exploring Texas.docx
KeilyLexi
 
What's your strategy? Getting tactical about being strategic.
What's your strategy? Getting tactical about being strategic.What's your strategy? Getting tactical about being strategic.
What's your strategy? Getting tactical about being strategic.
Doug Hall
 
Solution manual for canadian income taxation 20222023 25th edition by william...
Solution manual for canadian income taxation 20222023 25th edition by william...Solution manual for canadian income taxation 20222023 25th edition by william...
Solution manual for canadian income taxation 20222023 25th edition by william...
stanslausnzuki569
 
Busty Girls Call Navi Mumbai 🎈🔥9920725232 🔥💋🎈 Provide Best And Top Girl Servi...
Busty Girls Call Navi Mumbai 🎈🔥9920725232 🔥💋🎈 Provide Best And Top Girl Servi...Busty Girls Call Navi Mumbai 🎈🔥9920725232 🔥💋🎈 Provide Best And Top Girl Servi...
Busty Girls Call Navi Mumbai 🎈🔥9920725232 🔥💋🎈 Provide Best And Top Girl Servi...
bellared2
 
Gym business MODEL .pdf .
Gym business MODEL .pdf                 .Gym business MODEL .pdf                 .
Gym business MODEL .pdf .
Divyanshu56740
 
Activated Carbon Manufacturing Plant Project Report.pdf
Activated Carbon Manufacturing Plant Project Report.pdfActivated Carbon Manufacturing Plant Project Report.pdf
Activated Carbon Manufacturing Plant Project Report.pdf
rudrap2099
 
Floating Pontoon | Premier marine solution
Floating Pontoon | Premier marine solutionFloating Pontoon | Premier marine solution
Floating Pontoon | Premier marine solution
PMSME
 
Movers near me in Dubai , Best Packers and Movers In Dubai
Movers near me in Dubai , Best Packers and Movers In DubaiMovers near me in Dubai , Best Packers and Movers In Dubai
Movers near me in Dubai , Best Packers and Movers In Dubai
imranmalik114455
 
IRDAI's Regulatory Sandbox - Transforming Insurance Sector in India
IRDAI's Regulatory Sandbox - Transforming Insurance Sector in IndiaIRDAI's Regulatory Sandbox - Transforming Insurance Sector in India
IRDAI's Regulatory Sandbox - Transforming Insurance Sector in India
Enterslice
 
Standard Operating Procedure for Digital Marketing
Standard Operating Procedure for Digital MarketingStandard Operating Procedure for Digital Marketing
Standard Operating Procedure for Digital Marketing
Dipendra Prasad Poudel
 
Honoring and Understanding the Significance of Guru Purnima
Honoring and Understanding the Significance of Guru PurnimaHonoring and Understanding the Significance of Guru Purnima
Honoring and Understanding the Significance of Guru Purnima
Exotic India
 
84th Marketing Club (OTC Marketing) Dr.Mahmoud Hamed 23rd Cairo.pdf
84th Marketing Club (OTC Marketing) Dr.Mahmoud Hamed 23rd Cairo.pdf84th Marketing Club (OTC Marketing) Dr.Mahmoud Hamed 23rd Cairo.pdf
84th Marketing Club (OTC Marketing) Dr.Mahmoud Hamed 23rd Cairo.pdf
ahmed614380
 
How to use lace front wig importance and
How to use lace front wig importance andHow to use lace front wig importance and
How to use lace front wig importance and
kaporej505
 
ShotOniPhone campaign by Vancy macwan.pptx
ShotOniPhone campaign by Vancy macwan.pptxShotOniPhone campaign by Vancy macwan.pptx
ShotOniPhone campaign by Vancy macwan.pptx
macwanvancy
 
EN_Chinese-Automotive-in-SEA-Vero-White-Paper_2023.pdf
EN_Chinese-Automotive-in-SEA-Vero-White-Paper_2023.pdfEN_Chinese-Automotive-in-SEA-Vero-White-Paper_2023.pdf
EN_Chinese-Automotive-in-SEA-Vero-White-Paper_2023.pdf
ivanparu86
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Qatar Airways Kuwait Office.pdf.........
Qatar Airways Kuwait Office.pdf.........Qatar Airways Kuwait Office.pdf.........
Qatar Airways Kuwait Office.pdf.........
 
CLEARPATH SUBDIVISION AUCKLAND Optimize Your Land’s Potential
CLEARPATH SUBDIVISION AUCKLAND Optimize Your Land’s PotentialCLEARPATH SUBDIVISION AUCKLAND Optimize Your Land’s Potential
CLEARPATH SUBDIVISION AUCKLAND Optimize Your Land’s Potential
 
upGrad_Case_Study_by_Himanshu_Singh.pptx
upGrad_Case_Study_by_Himanshu_Singh.pptxupGrad_Case_Study_by_Himanshu_Singh.pptx
upGrad_Case_Study_by_Himanshu_Singh.pptx
 
Steps to Register Company in Dubai Mainland.pptx
Steps to Register Company in Dubai Mainland.pptxSteps to Register Company in Dubai Mainland.pptx
Steps to Register Company in Dubai Mainland.pptx
 
Virtual Paralegal Services: Your Remote Legal Assistant
Virtual Paralegal Services: Your Remote Legal AssistantVirtual Paralegal Services: Your Remote Legal Assistant
Virtual Paralegal Services: Your Remote Legal Assistant
 
From Dallas to Houston Exploring Texas.docx
From Dallas to Houston Exploring Texas.docxFrom Dallas to Houston Exploring Texas.docx
From Dallas to Houston Exploring Texas.docx
 
What's your strategy? Getting tactical about being strategic.
What's your strategy? Getting tactical about being strategic.What's your strategy? Getting tactical about being strategic.
What's your strategy? Getting tactical about being strategic.
 
Solution manual for canadian income taxation 20222023 25th edition by william...
Solution manual for canadian income taxation 20222023 25th edition by william...Solution manual for canadian income taxation 20222023 25th edition by william...
Solution manual for canadian income taxation 20222023 25th edition by william...
 
Busty Girls Call Navi Mumbai 🎈🔥9920725232 🔥💋🎈 Provide Best And Top Girl Servi...
Busty Girls Call Navi Mumbai 🎈🔥9920725232 🔥💋🎈 Provide Best And Top Girl Servi...Busty Girls Call Navi Mumbai 🎈🔥9920725232 🔥💋🎈 Provide Best And Top Girl Servi...
Busty Girls Call Navi Mumbai 🎈🔥9920725232 🔥💋🎈 Provide Best And Top Girl Servi...
 
Gym business MODEL .pdf .
Gym business MODEL .pdf                 .Gym business MODEL .pdf                 .
Gym business MODEL .pdf .
 
Activated Carbon Manufacturing Plant Project Report.pdf
Activated Carbon Manufacturing Plant Project Report.pdfActivated Carbon Manufacturing Plant Project Report.pdf
Activated Carbon Manufacturing Plant Project Report.pdf
 
Floating Pontoon | Premier marine solution
Floating Pontoon | Premier marine solutionFloating Pontoon | Premier marine solution
Floating Pontoon | Premier marine solution
 
Movers near me in Dubai , Best Packers and Movers In Dubai
Movers near me in Dubai , Best Packers and Movers In DubaiMovers near me in Dubai , Best Packers and Movers In Dubai
Movers near me in Dubai , Best Packers and Movers In Dubai
 
IRDAI's Regulatory Sandbox - Transforming Insurance Sector in India
IRDAI's Regulatory Sandbox - Transforming Insurance Sector in IndiaIRDAI's Regulatory Sandbox - Transforming Insurance Sector in India
IRDAI's Regulatory Sandbox - Transforming Insurance Sector in India
 
Standard Operating Procedure for Digital Marketing
Standard Operating Procedure for Digital MarketingStandard Operating Procedure for Digital Marketing
Standard Operating Procedure for Digital Marketing
 
Honoring and Understanding the Significance of Guru Purnima
Honoring and Understanding the Significance of Guru PurnimaHonoring and Understanding the Significance of Guru Purnima
Honoring and Understanding the Significance of Guru Purnima
 
84th Marketing Club (OTC Marketing) Dr.Mahmoud Hamed 23rd Cairo.pdf
84th Marketing Club (OTC Marketing) Dr.Mahmoud Hamed 23rd Cairo.pdf84th Marketing Club (OTC Marketing) Dr.Mahmoud Hamed 23rd Cairo.pdf
84th Marketing Club (OTC Marketing) Dr.Mahmoud Hamed 23rd Cairo.pdf
 
How to use lace front wig importance and
How to use lace front wig importance andHow to use lace front wig importance and
How to use lace front wig importance and
 
ShotOniPhone campaign by Vancy macwan.pptx
ShotOniPhone campaign by Vancy macwan.pptxShotOniPhone campaign by Vancy macwan.pptx
ShotOniPhone campaign by Vancy macwan.pptx
 
EN_Chinese-Automotive-in-SEA-Vero-White-Paper_2023.pdf
EN_Chinese-Automotive-in-SEA-Vero-White-Paper_2023.pdfEN_Chinese-Automotive-in-SEA-Vero-White-Paper_2023.pdf
EN_Chinese-Automotive-in-SEA-Vero-White-Paper_2023.pdf
 

Exploring recruitment databases from the applicant's perspective - Poster Congress EAWOP Santiago de Compostela 2009

  • 1. EAWOP, May 2009 Santiago de Compostela/Spain contact details: Christian Bosau phone: +49 221 470-4120 Herbert-Lewin-Str. 2 mail: christian.bosau@uni-koeln.de 50931 Cologne/Germany web: http://wisopsy.uni-koeln.de Measures: Organizational image: measured by 17 items that were developed according to the literature on organizational image, loading on 4 factors (a) standing of the organization in the market, b) production quality, c) organizational climate, d) general attractiveness and sympathy) Employer image: measured by 3 items, e.g. “I could imagine to work for that organization” Product image: measured by cognitive items (e.g. “I know the products of this organization”) and affective items (e.g. “I think, the products of the organization are of high quality”). Sample & Method: Scenario-based experiments with repeated measurements (with-in-subject): a) pre-test: 2 (before & after) x 2 (brand & no-brand organizations) ANOVA with 270 students from the university of Cologne b) 2 (before & after) x 3 (recruitment database & rejection & invitation to job interview) ANOVA with 452 students from the university of Cologne The scenario described that applicants sent their application to an organization, which took some effort, and after that received an invitation to a job interview, a rejection or the opportunity to join the recruitment database, respectively. Results of the main study: References: Cable, D.M., & Turban, D.B. (2001). Establishing the dimensions, sources and value of job seekers’ employer knowledge during recruitment. In G.R. Ferris (Ed.), Research in personnel and human resources management (pp. 115-163). New York: Elsevier Science. Chambers, B.A. (2002). Applicant reactions and their consequences: review, advice, and recommendations for future research. International Journal of Management Reviews, 4(4), 317-333. Gilliland, S.W., Groth, M., Baker IV, R.C., Dew, A.F., Polly, L.M., & Langdon, J.C. (2001). Improving applicants’ reactions to rejection letters: An application of fairness theory. Personnel Psychology, 54, 669-703. Hausknecht, J.P., Day, D.V., & Thomas, S.C. (2004). Applicant reactions to selection procedures: An updated model and meta-analysis. Personnel Psychology, 57, 639-683. Ryan, A.M., & Ployhart, R.E. (2000). Applicants’ perception of selection procedures and decisions: A critical review and agenda for the future. Journal of Management, 26(3), 565-606. Smither, J.W., Reilly, R.R., Millsap, R.E., Pearlman, K., & Stoffey, R.W. (1993). Applicant reactions to selection procedures. Personnel Psychology, 46, 49-76. Results: generally: responses in the recruitment process influence how applicants think about the organization. The organizational image, the employer image as well as the product image is changed after applicants get a response from the organization to their application. specifically: different responses are responsible for different changes in the images. Invitations to a job interview (i.e. reaching the next step in the recruitment process) have a positive/neutral effect on the images whereas rejection letters and invitations for putting the CV in the recruitment database have a negative effect. interestingly: the product image, that was not supposed to be influenced by recruitment processes, is devalued as well. Thus, the way of dealing with applicants also influences whether those people become future customers or not. MOST IMPORTANT: invitations for joining the recruitment database are almost as bad as rejection letters. If applicants get the opportunity to join the recruitment database they devalue the three images in the same way as if they receive a rejection. Therefore, from the applicant’s perspective a recruitment database invitation almost feels like a rejection, since applicants are looking for a job and not for a membership in a recruitment database. Theoretical Background: In competitive labor markets characterized by a ‘war of talent’ organizations try to attract the best talents, often using so-called ‘recruitment databases’ in order to not loose any good talent. Thus, organizations try to avoid sending out any rejection notices but instead try to keep the applicants’ CVs in a recruitment database to use them for staffing of future open posts. Instead of a rejection letter applicants receive an invitation (also called ice-letter) to put their CV in the ‘recruitment database’. The applicants are told that this will be the first step in entering the organization and getting a job. However, what do applicants think about this recruitment practice? Will the image of the organization actually raise – as organizations often expect – since applicants are not rejected anymore? The consequences of such a recruitment strategy were not fully explored yet, neither in the research nor in the professional area. Scholars have suggested that it is very important to look at reactions of applicants (Hausknecht, Day, & Thomas, 2004). Organizations with a good reputation and a good image are supposed to be able to attract better applicants (Cable & Turban, 2001). If applicants perceive the selection procedure to be not acceptable, however, several important aspects might be negatively influenced (Chambers, 2002): besides their behavioral intentions, their actual behavior, their test-performance in the selection procedure, their later job-performance, most importantly their overall organizational impressions could change. Applicants get those impressions about an organization when they experience its recruitment and selection practices (Smither, Reilly, Millsap, Pearlman, & Stoffey, 1993). Whether applicants are rejected or accepted clearly influences their perceptions of the organization (Ryan & Ployhart, 2000). Therefore, the question that has to be answered is, whether using recruitment databases is perceived from the applicants as being accepted or rejected, since this in turn influences the perceived images of the organization. However, it can be assumed that recruitment databases will not have a very positive effect on the applicants’ impressions since applicants are normally looking for a job and not for a ‘membership’ in a recruitment database. Exploring recruitment databases from the applicantExploring recruitment databases from the applicant’’s perspectives perspective ChristianChristian Bosau, NicoleBosau, Nicole MoiserMoiser--BeekBeek & Henrik& Henrik WichelmannWichelmann University of Cologne, GermanyUniversity of Cologne, Germany