 Introduce new project at PSHMC
 Discuss ethnography and field site projects
 Review and discuss assignment 3
– Significant socio-economic barriers



– Lowest level of socio-economic barriers
USDA Food Desert Locator




http://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/food-desert-locator/go-to-the-locator.aspx
   How do we work with community
    organizations to improve access to healthy
    foods and education/information?
   An empirical research
    method for learning
    about cultural
    phenomena and
    discovering the nature
    of peoples
Learning the culture of the group
                                 under study before deriving
                                 explanations of their
                                 attitudes/behavior




Physical geography and climate
 Historical research
 Active field notes
 Participant observation
 Interviews
 Questionnaires
 Geography/topography
 Build a rich history of your site
 Develop relationships & trust
 Identify key informants
 Take rigorous notes & cross-check
  with informants
    › Quote your informants
 Understand your biases and assumptions
 Keep an open mind
Assignment 3




Final assignment
   Give voice to an underserved population
   Contextualize your observations
   Identify themes and patterns that can inform
    effective intervention strategies
   Determine variables for future research and
    develop a testable hypothesis
   Propose more culturally-sensitive plans for
    project implementation
   Identify key questions about existing programs
    and policies
 You are not a consultant, you are a learner
 We are not expecting you to ‘save’ the
  organization or its clients
 Think long-term about your involvement
  with the organization
 There will be many opportunities for
  leadership/action in medical school

Questions or concerns?      dgeorge1@hmc.psu.edu
                            C1747 – Diversity Office
 Goals:
  › Eliminate preventable disease, disability, injury,
    and premature death
  › Achieve health equity, eliminate disparities, and
    improve the health of all groups
  › Create social and physical environments that
    promote good health for all.
 Goals (cont.)
  › Promote healthy development and healthy
    behaviors across every stage of life.
 Objectives
  › 37 focus areas
 Models serve as frames from which to
  build; Provide structure & organization
  for the planning process
 Many different models, common
  elements, but different labels.




    A Generalized Model for Program Planning
                      26
    Biology/
    Genetics
    Behaviors
    Social
     Environment
    Physical
     Environment
    Policies and
     Interventions
    Access to
     Quality Health
     Care/ Services




                      27
   Assessments
                                              Summary (III)
                • Social
                                               • Justify need for an
                • Environmental                  intervention/program
The way         • Behavioral                   • Identify possible solutions
  it is…          What are the behaviors         (interventions) to health
Describe          that impact health             problem
      I           problem?                    Next Paper: The
                                               Program/Intervention
                • Risk and Protective
Analyzing         Factors Associated                      I
targeted          with/Influence                         II
behavior          Behaviors
    II                                                   III
                                                                  28
?




29
30
   Radiation Exposure      Infectious Agents
   Workplace Hazards       Auto/Road Design
   Home Hazards            Speed Limits
   Contaminants            Medical Care Access
   Media                   Product Design (e.g., handgun)
   Political Systems       Noise
   Migration               War/Civil Conflict
   Global Warming          Deforestation
   Recreational space      Adequate Surveillance Systems




                                                    31
   Geography         Discrimination
   Age               Residence
   Race              Literacy
   Education         Isolation
   Crime             Family Composition
   Income            Faith/Spirituality
   Unemployment      Culture
   Roles             Gender




                                            32
   Access to care
   Quality of care
   Access to interventions
   Representativeness in
    policy development
   Equity and justice




                              33
Hi! I’m the
Literature!

              34
35
 Behavior = What people do or don’t do
 Factors = influence behavior


An analysis of the determining (predisposing
[facilitate or hinder person’s motivation to change,
e.g., knowledge, attitudes, beliefs, etc.], enabling
[barriers or vehicles created by society or system,
e.g., access to hl, resources, rules, etc.], and
reinforcing [feedbacks & rewards by peers, relatives,
employers, etc.]) factors that influence the chosen
behavior and health problem.
37
 Awareness and Knowledge
 Beliefs, Values, and Attitudes
 Perceptions of Susceptibility,
  Seriousness, Benefits, & Cost
 Personal Histories
 Behavioral Intentions
 Existing Skills



                                   38
39
   Health Care Environment.
    › Facilities, clinics, providers, etc.
    › Cost, distance, transportation, hours, etc.
   Other Environmental Conditions.
    › Availability of fast food, cigarettes, billboard,
      alcohol , sports, laws, etc.
   Skills – ability to perform task.




                                                          40
 Social Support
 Family and Peer Influences
 Advise/Feedback from Providers
 Benefits of the Treatment/Action
 Social and Economical Benefits
 Adverse Consequences




                        41
 Theory - “a set of interrelated concepts,
  definitions, and propositions that present a
  systematic view of events or situations by
  specifying relations among variables in order to
  explain and predict the events of the situations”
  (Glanz, Lewis, & Rimer, 2002, p. 25)
 Concept - primary elements of theories or
  building blocks of theory (Glanz et al., 2002)
   “A theory based approach provides direction and
    justification for program activities and serves as
    the basis for processes that are to be
    incorporated into an intervention/program
    (Cowdery et al., 1995, p. 248)

   “Theories can provide answers to program
    developers’ questions regarding why people
    aren’t engaging in a desirable behavior of
    interest, how to go about changing their
    behaviors, and what factors to look at when
    evaluating a program’s focus” (van Ryn &
    Heaney, 1992, p. 326).
   Perceived Susceptibility – is he/she
    vulnerable to health problem?
   Perceived Seriousness – how serious is
    the the illness/problem?
   Perceived Benefits – anticipated value of
    the recommended action.
   Perceived Barriers – cost involved in
    taking a particular action.
   Motivation/Cues to Action & Self-efficacy.
   Stages of Changes
    ›   Precontemplation.
    ›   Contemplation.
    ›   Preparation.
    ›   Action.
    ›   Maintenance.
    ›   Termination.        *Relapse
   Decisional Balance – pros vs. cons.
 Attitudes – toward performing the behavior.
 Subjective Norm – influence of other people
  (i.e., parents, friends).
 Intentions – probability of performing.
 Behavior – the actual action.

Plenary 10 18-12 final

  • 1.
     Introduce newproject at PSHMC  Discuss ethnography and field site projects  Review and discuss assignment 3
  • 4.
    – Significant socio-economicbarriers – Lowest level of socio-economic barriers
  • 5.
    USDA Food DesertLocator http://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/food-desert-locator/go-to-the-locator.aspx
  • 6.
    How do we work with community organizations to improve access to healthy foods and education/information?
  • 13.
    An empirical research method for learning about cultural phenomena and discovering the nature of peoples
  • 14.
    Learning the cultureof the group under study before deriving explanations of their attitudes/behavior Physical geography and climate
  • 15.
     Historical research Active field notes  Participant observation  Interviews  Questionnaires  Geography/topography
  • 20.
     Build arich history of your site  Develop relationships & trust  Identify key informants  Take rigorous notes & cross-check with informants › Quote your informants  Understand your biases and assumptions  Keep an open mind
  • 21.
  • 23.
    Give voice to an underserved population  Contextualize your observations  Identify themes and patterns that can inform effective intervention strategies  Determine variables for future research and develop a testable hypothesis  Propose more culturally-sensitive plans for project implementation  Identify key questions about existing programs and policies
  • 24.
     You arenot a consultant, you are a learner  We are not expecting you to ‘save’ the organization or its clients  Think long-term about your involvement with the organization  There will be many opportunities for leadership/action in medical school Questions or concerns? dgeorge1@hmc.psu.edu C1747 – Diversity Office
  • 25.
     Goals: › Eliminate preventable disease, disability, injury, and premature death › Achieve health equity, eliminate disparities, and improve the health of all groups › Create social and physical environments that promote good health for all.  Goals (cont.) › Promote healthy development and healthy behaviors across every stage of life.  Objectives › 37 focus areas
  • 26.
     Models serveas frames from which to build; Provide structure & organization for the planning process  Many different models, common elements, but different labels. A Generalized Model for Program Planning 26
  • 27.
    Biology/ Genetics  Behaviors  Social Environment  Physical Environment  Policies and Interventions  Access to Quality Health Care/ Services 27
  • 28.
    Assessments  Summary (III) • Social • Justify need for an • Environmental intervention/program The way • Behavioral • Identify possible solutions it is… What are the behaviors (interventions) to health Describe that impact health problem I problem?  Next Paper: The Program/Intervention • Risk and Protective Analyzing Factors Associated I targeted with/Influence II behavior Behaviors II III 28
  • 29.
  • 30.
  • 31.
    Radiation Exposure  Infectious Agents  Workplace Hazards  Auto/Road Design  Home Hazards  Speed Limits  Contaminants  Medical Care Access  Media  Product Design (e.g., handgun)  Political Systems  Noise  Migration  War/Civil Conflict  Global Warming  Deforestation  Recreational space  Adequate Surveillance Systems 31
  • 32.
    Geography  Discrimination  Age  Residence  Race  Literacy  Education  Isolation  Crime  Family Composition  Income  Faith/Spirituality  Unemployment  Culture  Roles  Gender 32
  • 33.
    Access to care  Quality of care  Access to interventions  Representativeness in policy development  Equity and justice 33
  • 34.
  • 35.
  • 36.
     Behavior =What people do or don’t do  Factors = influence behavior An analysis of the determining (predisposing [facilitate or hinder person’s motivation to change, e.g., knowledge, attitudes, beliefs, etc.], enabling [barriers or vehicles created by society or system, e.g., access to hl, resources, rules, etc.], and reinforcing [feedbacks & rewards by peers, relatives, employers, etc.]) factors that influence the chosen behavior and health problem.
  • 37.
  • 38.
     Awareness andKnowledge  Beliefs, Values, and Attitudes  Perceptions of Susceptibility, Seriousness, Benefits, & Cost  Personal Histories  Behavioral Intentions  Existing Skills 38
  • 39.
  • 40.
    Health Care Environment. › Facilities, clinics, providers, etc. › Cost, distance, transportation, hours, etc.  Other Environmental Conditions. › Availability of fast food, cigarettes, billboard, alcohol , sports, laws, etc.  Skills – ability to perform task. 40
  • 41.
     Social Support Family and Peer Influences  Advise/Feedback from Providers  Benefits of the Treatment/Action  Social and Economical Benefits  Adverse Consequences 41
  • 42.
     Theory -“a set of interrelated concepts, definitions, and propositions that present a systematic view of events or situations by specifying relations among variables in order to explain and predict the events of the situations” (Glanz, Lewis, & Rimer, 2002, p. 25)  Concept - primary elements of theories or building blocks of theory (Glanz et al., 2002)
  • 43.
    “A theory based approach provides direction and justification for program activities and serves as the basis for processes that are to be incorporated into an intervention/program (Cowdery et al., 1995, p. 248)  “Theories can provide answers to program developers’ questions regarding why people aren’t engaging in a desirable behavior of interest, how to go about changing their behaviors, and what factors to look at when evaluating a program’s focus” (van Ryn & Heaney, 1992, p. 326).
  • 44.
    Perceived Susceptibility – is he/she vulnerable to health problem?  Perceived Seriousness – how serious is the the illness/problem?  Perceived Benefits – anticipated value of the recommended action.  Perceived Barriers – cost involved in taking a particular action.  Motivation/Cues to Action & Self-efficacy.
  • 45.
    Stages of Changes › Precontemplation. › Contemplation. › Preparation. › Action. › Maintenance. › Termination. *Relapse  Decisional Balance – pros vs. cons.
  • 46.
     Attitudes –toward performing the behavior.  Subjective Norm – influence of other people (i.e., parents, friends).  Intentions – probability of performing.  Behavior – the actual action.

Editor's Notes

  • #2 1. Introduce new project at PSHMC (Relevance to your field site intervention and to you personally) 2. Discuss ethnography and field site projects (3. Review and discuss assignment 3 (Date change to next Weds, Oct 24th)
  • #4 The charge of the garden is to participate in community outreach in underserved areas in the community – help people stay healthy rather than just treating illness
  • #6 USDA food desert map – many of your field sites are located within these areas
  • #9 Mike – potentially drive into food deserts and deliver produce, health screenings, etc
  • #10 Pilot program – giving prescriptions to patients for produce at farmers markets, and then tracking blood pressure, weight, BMI, weight gain in pregnant women, etc . Will serve 100 families and six farmers markets during 2010 season with plans to expand. “Maine, Massachusetts tackle healthy eating.” The Nation’s Health. Oct 2010: 9.
  • #11 “Let thy food be thy medicine” – Hippocrates
  • #12 Just some ideas to consider given recent changes at PSHMC. Bridge to your field experience / most have been good, almost ¾ plan on visiting again. This is encouraging because, as you know, we don’t want you to see your role as being a consultant
  • #13 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2SoWNMNKNeM
  • #14 Your role is more of an ethnographer
  • #17 Med anthro – applying ethnographic principles and practices to medicine. Diseases are social with a biological aspect
  • #21 What’s interesting is that this list is equally applicable to your clinical practice
  • #24 As you go about this process, without the shackles of anatomy, you’ll understand the value of this approach
  • #25 If this isn’t inspiring or momentus that’s fine. This is a learning experience rooted in the community – for some it may be more but if not, it’s ok. Questions/concerns. Please feel free to email me or meet in my office