SlideShare a Scribd company logo
SENSE OF COMMUNITY BELONGING AND HEALTH IN CANADA:
                            A REGIONAL ANALYSIS

                                        Peter Kitchen
                            School of Geography & Earth Sciences
                                     McMaster University
                                 Hamilton, Ontario, Canada
                                    kitchen@mcmaster.ca

                                       Allison Williams
                            School of Geography & Earth Sciences
                                     McMaster University
                                 Hamilton, Ontario, Canada

                                     James Chowhan
                                 DeGroote School of Business
                                    McMaster University
                                  Hamilton, Ontario, Canada


                                           Abstract

This article investigates the association between sense of community belonging and health
among settlements of different size and across the urban to rural continuum and in Canada.
Using data from the recent 2007/08 Canadian Community Health Survey (CCHS), the objective
is to identify the major health, social and geographic determinants of sense of community
belonging and to consider policy options aimed at improving sense of belonging among certain
segments of the population. The research found a significant and consistent association
between sense of belonging and health, particularly mental health, even when controlling for
geography and socio-economic status. At the same time, sense of community belonging
improved progressively across the urban to rural continuum with remarkably high levels of
belonging evident in the outer most regions of Canada. Despite the health deficit that exists in
rural and small-town Canada, the paper postulates that these communities are able to
overcome health challenges to create conditions conducive to a positive sense of belonging.
Overall, sense of belonging was also found to be highest among seniors, people residing in
single-detached homes and among couples with children and was lowest among youth,
residents of high-rise apartments and among single-parents. Finally, in the context of
addressing deficiencies in sense of belonging, the paper examines several recent policy
developments aimed at improving mental health services in Canada.

More Related Content

More from Canadian Rural Research Network / Réseau canadien de recherche rurale

Prism 016- canadian expert in regional rural development
Prism  016- canadian expert in regional rural developmentPrism  016- canadian expert in regional rural development
Prism 016- canadian expert in regional rural development
Canadian Rural Research Network / Réseau canadien de recherche rurale
 
Cs5 p14 hanavan policy role in socio-agricultural transition
Cs5 p14 hanavan   policy role in socio-agricultural transitionCs5 p14 hanavan   policy role in socio-agricultural transition
Cs5 p14 hanavan policy role in socio-agricultural transition
Canadian Rural Research Network / Réseau canadien de recherche rurale
 
Cs4 p12 alasia bollman agri_rural
Cs4 p12 alasia bollman agri_ruralCs4 p12 alasia bollman agri_rural
Cs8 p24 fast public attitudes towards new ret e ont highlands
Cs8 p24 fast public attitudes towards new ret e ont highlandsCs8 p24 fast public attitudes towards new ret e ont highlands
Cs8 p24 fast public attitudes towards new ret e ont highlands
Canadian Rural Research Network / Réseau canadien de recherche rurale
 
Cs5 p15 cameron co-ops and the emerging markets
Cs5 p15 cameron   co-ops and the emerging marketsCs5 p15 cameron   co-ops and the emerging markets
Cs5 p15 cameron co-ops and the emerging markets
Canadian Rural Research Network / Réseau canadien de recherche rurale
 
Cs5 p13 kennedy building rural health
Cs5 p13 kennedy building rural healthCs5 p13 kennedy building rural health
Cs8 p22 bullock fn mun collaboration_rrw 2011
Cs8 p22 bullock fn mun collaboration_rrw 2011Cs8 p22 bullock fn mun collaboration_rrw 2011
Cs8 p22 bullock fn mun collaboration_rrw 2011
Canadian Rural Research Network / Réseau canadien de recherche rurale
 
Cs7 p21 rogers campus in the country
Cs7 p21 rogers campus in the countryCs7 p21 rogers campus in the country
Cs7 p20 johnson using the geoweb
Cs7 p20 johnson using the geowebCs7 p20 johnson using the geoweb
Cs7 p19 nelson understanding traditional food behaviour
Cs7 p19 nelson understanding traditional food behaviourCs7 p19 nelson understanding traditional food behaviour
Cs7 p19 nelson understanding traditional food behaviour
Canadian Rural Research Network / Réseau canadien de recherche rurale
 
Cs6 p17 williams evidence-based prog planning for rural econ dev
Cs6 p17 williams   evidence-based prog planning for rural econ devCs6 p17 williams   evidence-based prog planning for rural econ dev
Cs6 p17 williams evidence-based prog planning for rural econ dev
Canadian Rural Research Network / Réseau canadien de recherche rurale
 
Cs6 p18 ryser youth policy
Cs6 p18 ryser youth policyCs6 p18 ryser youth policy
Cs6 p16 walsh using mobility to gain stability
Cs6 p16 walsh   using mobility to gain stabilityCs6 p16 walsh   using mobility to gain stability
Cs6 p16 walsh using mobility to gain stability
Canadian Rural Research Network / Réseau canadien de recherche rurale
 
Cs8 p23 murphy non forest timber products
Cs8 p23 murphy non forest timber productsCs8 p23 murphy non forest timber products
Cs3 p8 dyck listenning to the voices of rural mb
Cs3 p8 dyck listenning to the voices of rural mbCs3 p8 dyck listenning to the voices of rural mb
Cs3 p8 dyck listenning to the voices of rural mb
Canadian Rural Research Network / Réseau canadien de recherche rurale
 
Cs3 p7 malone setting the socio historial context for prof ethics
Cs3 p7 malone setting the socio historial context for prof ethicsCs3 p7 malone setting the socio historial context for prof ethics
Cs3 p7 malone setting the socio historial context for prof ethics
Canadian Rural Research Network / Réseau canadien de recherche rurale
 
Cs4 p10 reed now for the bad news
Cs4 p10 reed now for the bad newsCs4 p10 reed now for the bad news
Cs2 p6 conteh managing canada's rural regions in a knowledge based economy
Cs2 p6 conteh managing canada's rural regions in a knowledge based economyCs2 p6 conteh managing canada's rural regions in a knowledge based economy
Cs2 p6 conteh managing canada's rural regions in a knowledge based economy
Canadian Rural Research Network / Réseau canadien de recherche rurale
 
Cs3 p9 fisher towards an understanding of social
Cs3 p9 fisher towards an understanding of socialCs3 p9 fisher towards an understanding of social
Cs3 p9 fisher towards an understanding of social
Canadian Rural Research Network / Réseau canadien de recherche rurale
 

More from Canadian Rural Research Network / Réseau canadien de recherche rurale (20)

Prism 016- canadian expert in regional rural development
Prism  016- canadian expert in regional rural developmentPrism  016- canadian expert in regional rural development
Prism 016- canadian expert in regional rural development
 
Cs5 p14 hanavan policy role in socio-agricultural transition
Cs5 p14 hanavan   policy role in socio-agricultural transitionCs5 p14 hanavan   policy role in socio-agricultural transition
Cs5 p14 hanavan policy role in socio-agricultural transition
 
Cs4 p12 alasia bollman agri_rural
Cs4 p12 alasia bollman agri_ruralCs4 p12 alasia bollman agri_rural
Cs4 p12 alasia bollman agri_rural
 
Cs4 p11 olfert triage at the periphery
Cs4 p11 olfert triage at the peripheryCs4 p11 olfert triage at the periphery
Cs4 p11 olfert triage at the periphery
 
Cs8 p24 fast public attitudes towards new ret e ont highlands
Cs8 p24 fast public attitudes towards new ret e ont highlandsCs8 p24 fast public attitudes towards new ret e ont highlands
Cs8 p24 fast public attitudes towards new ret e ont highlands
 
Cs5 p15 cameron co-ops and the emerging markets
Cs5 p15 cameron   co-ops and the emerging marketsCs5 p15 cameron   co-ops and the emerging markets
Cs5 p15 cameron co-ops and the emerging markets
 
Cs5 p13 kennedy building rural health
Cs5 p13 kennedy building rural healthCs5 p13 kennedy building rural health
Cs5 p13 kennedy building rural health
 
Cs8 p22 bullock fn mun collaboration_rrw 2011
Cs8 p22 bullock fn mun collaboration_rrw 2011Cs8 p22 bullock fn mun collaboration_rrw 2011
Cs8 p22 bullock fn mun collaboration_rrw 2011
 
Cs7 p21 rogers campus in the country
Cs7 p21 rogers campus in the countryCs7 p21 rogers campus in the country
Cs7 p21 rogers campus in the country
 
Cs7 p20 johnson using the geoweb
Cs7 p20 johnson using the geowebCs7 p20 johnson using the geoweb
Cs7 p20 johnson using the geoweb
 
Cs7 p19 nelson understanding traditional food behaviour
Cs7 p19 nelson understanding traditional food behaviourCs7 p19 nelson understanding traditional food behaviour
Cs7 p19 nelson understanding traditional food behaviour
 
Cs6 p17 williams evidence-based prog planning for rural econ dev
Cs6 p17 williams   evidence-based prog planning for rural econ devCs6 p17 williams   evidence-based prog planning for rural econ dev
Cs6 p17 williams evidence-based prog planning for rural econ dev
 
Cs6 p18 ryser youth policy
Cs6 p18 ryser youth policyCs6 p18 ryser youth policy
Cs6 p18 ryser youth policy
 
Cs6 p16 walsh using mobility to gain stability
Cs6 p16 walsh   using mobility to gain stabilityCs6 p16 walsh   using mobility to gain stability
Cs6 p16 walsh using mobility to gain stability
 
Cs8 p23 murphy non forest timber products
Cs8 p23 murphy non forest timber productsCs8 p23 murphy non forest timber products
Cs8 p23 murphy non forest timber products
 
Cs3 p8 dyck listenning to the voices of rural mb
Cs3 p8 dyck listenning to the voices of rural mbCs3 p8 dyck listenning to the voices of rural mb
Cs3 p8 dyck listenning to the voices of rural mb
 
Cs3 p7 malone setting the socio historial context for prof ethics
Cs3 p7 malone setting the socio historial context for prof ethicsCs3 p7 malone setting the socio historial context for prof ethics
Cs3 p7 malone setting the socio historial context for prof ethics
 
Cs4 p10 reed now for the bad news
Cs4 p10 reed now for the bad newsCs4 p10 reed now for the bad news
Cs4 p10 reed now for the bad news
 
Cs2 p6 conteh managing canada's rural regions in a knowledge based economy
Cs2 p6 conteh managing canada's rural regions in a knowledge based economyCs2 p6 conteh managing canada's rural regions in a knowledge based economy
Cs2 p6 conteh managing canada's rural regions in a knowledge based economy
 
Cs3 p9 fisher towards an understanding of social
Cs3 p9 fisher towards an understanding of socialCs3 p9 fisher towards an understanding of social
Cs3 p9 fisher towards an understanding of social
 

P3 abstract - kitchen p

  • 1. SENSE OF COMMUNITY BELONGING AND HEALTH IN CANADA: A REGIONAL ANALYSIS Peter Kitchen School of Geography & Earth Sciences McMaster University Hamilton, Ontario, Canada kitchen@mcmaster.ca Allison Williams School of Geography & Earth Sciences McMaster University Hamilton, Ontario, Canada James Chowhan DeGroote School of Business McMaster University Hamilton, Ontario, Canada Abstract This article investigates the association between sense of community belonging and health among settlements of different size and across the urban to rural continuum and in Canada. Using data from the recent 2007/08 Canadian Community Health Survey (CCHS), the objective is to identify the major health, social and geographic determinants of sense of community belonging and to consider policy options aimed at improving sense of belonging among certain segments of the population. The research found a significant and consistent association between sense of belonging and health, particularly mental health, even when controlling for geography and socio-economic status. At the same time, sense of community belonging improved progressively across the urban to rural continuum with remarkably high levels of belonging evident in the outer most regions of Canada. Despite the health deficit that exists in rural and small-town Canada, the paper postulates that these communities are able to overcome health challenges to create conditions conducive to a positive sense of belonging. Overall, sense of belonging was also found to be highest among seniors, people residing in single-detached homes and among couples with children and was lowest among youth, residents of high-rise apartments and among single-parents. Finally, in the context of addressing deficiencies in sense of belonging, the paper examines several recent policy developments aimed at improving mental health services in Canada.