SlideShare a Scribd company logo
‘Russification’ of ‘Soft Power’:
Transformation of a Concept
Yelena Osipova
School of International Service
American University, Washington, DC
Soft Power
- Joseph S. Nye, Jr. (1990)
- Appeal & attraction  shape preferences
- Resources:
- Culture and attractiveness
- Political values
- Perceived legitimacy of policies
Critique: Hegemony?
 Gramsci: reproduction of a given social order
 Ideational as well as material means
 “Universal ideology”
 “Historic bloc”: an articulate network of social
institutions that reinforces hegemony
 Not entirely coercion-free
American Soft Power?
 Parallels: soft power & hegemony (Zahran & Ramos, 2010)
 American global hegemony?
 Global popularity:
• “de-Westernization”
Russia: The Context
 Prominence in mid-2000s
• Putin’s 2nd term:
more assertive FP
• “Color Revolutions”
• NATO expansion
 Geopolitical lens
Reinterpretation
 Sovereignty & “sovereign democracy” (Surkov)
• Resist American meddling
• Basis for Russian soft power: no strings attached
 “Color revolutions” as America’s “historic bloc”
 Response: enhance Russia’s own soft power
Recontextualization
Nye’s framework:
 Culture & attractiveness:
• Rich heritage, multiculturalism, Russian language, &
conservative “moral pole”
 Attractiveness of political values:
• Diversity, tolerance, & inclusiveness
 Legitimacy of policies:
• Respect of sovereignty; holding US accountable
Tools & Mechanisms
 Many borrowed from others & the past
 Foundational:
• Russian language
• Humanitarian cooperation
 “Compatriots abroad”
Example: Ukraine/Crimea
 #Euromaidan seen as Western intervention
 Threat to Russian interests
 Large Russian/Russian-speaking population
 Vast network of cultural/social diasporan orgs.
 Activated to promote Russian interests
 Crimea: success case
Conclusion
“For Russia, soft power doesn’t have to mean being a softy.”
Pavel Koshkin & Ksenia Smertina, Russia Direct, March 17, 2014

More Related Content

What's hot

Odyssey of a_fellow_traveler-jb_mathews-1938-283pgs-soc-com
Odyssey of a_fellow_traveler-jb_mathews-1938-283pgs-soc-comOdyssey of a_fellow_traveler-jb_mathews-1938-283pgs-soc-com
Odyssey of a_fellow_traveler-jb_mathews-1938-283pgs-soc-com
RareBooksnRecords
 
The Automatization of Music
The Automatization of MusicThe Automatization of Music
The Automatization of Music
Menas Yang
 
The Russian Opposition - Julia Pettengill, Henry Jackson Society report
The Russian Opposition - Julia Pettengill, Henry Jackson Society reportThe Russian Opposition - Julia Pettengill, Henry Jackson Society report
The Russian Opposition - Julia Pettengill, Henry Jackson Society report
Ilya Ponomarev
 
Gender tropes
Gender tropesGender tropes
Gender tropes
NicolasBlovsky1
 
SPA Conference 2012 E. Duda-Mikulin
SPA Conference 2012 E. Duda-MikulinSPA Conference 2012 E. Duda-Mikulin
SPA Conference 2012 E. Duda-Mikulin
the University of Salford
 
Feminism
FeminismFeminism
Feminism
Jenny Walsh
 
A2 Feminism and the Media
A2 Feminism and the MediaA2 Feminism and the Media
A2 Feminism and the Media
KBucket
 
Dissertation FINAL
Dissertation FINALDissertation FINAL
Dissertation FINAL
Megan Leigh
 
249136674 events-in-the-crimea-in-the-polish-national-newspapers-and-periodic...
249136674 events-in-the-crimea-in-the-polish-national-newspapers-and-periodic...249136674 events-in-the-crimea-in-the-polish-national-newspapers-and-periodic...
249136674 events-in-the-crimea-in-the-polish-national-newspapers-and-periodic...
Medioznawca_com
 
Concepts and various theoretical frameworks of feminism and mass media
Concepts and various theoretical frameworks of feminism and mass mediaConcepts and various theoretical frameworks of feminism and mass media
Concepts and various theoretical frameworks of feminism and mass media
Zarmeen Durrani
 
Queer Theory
Queer TheoryQueer Theory
Queer Theory
N Jones
 
Presentation feminism
Presentation feminismPresentation feminism
Causes and Concequences of Colour Revolutions in the Post-Soviet Countries
Causes and Concequences of Colour Revolutions in the Post-Soviet CountriesCauses and Concequences of Colour Revolutions in the Post-Soviet Countries
Causes and Concequences of Colour Revolutions in the Post-Soviet Countries
Mikhail / Mykhailo Minakov
 
When comrade stalin sends us to the battle
When comrade stalin sends us to the battleWhen comrade stalin sends us to the battle
When comrade stalin sends us to the battle
Persoonlijke studie teksten
 
Cultural criticism slides 2020
Cultural criticism slides 2020Cultural criticism slides 2020
Cultural criticism slides 2020
Deidre Pike
 
Week 11 Race and Prejudice
Week 11 Race and PrejudiceWeek 11 Race and Prejudice
Week 11 Race and Prejudice
Brenna Hassinger-Das
 
Ronald Summa _Non-CE Certificate
Ronald Summa _Non-CE CertificateRonald Summa _Non-CE Certificate
Ronald Summa _Non-CE Certificate
Ronald Summa
 
03 text krastev_06 oct
03 text krastev_06 oct03 text krastev_06 oct
03 text krastev_06 oct
jhenri5
 
My perestroika
My perestroikaMy perestroika
My perestroika
sjmajidi
 
Michael brown Ferguson/ Social Action
Michael brown Ferguson/ Social Action Michael brown Ferguson/ Social Action
Michael brown Ferguson/ Social Action
myrycale1
 

What's hot (20)

Odyssey of a_fellow_traveler-jb_mathews-1938-283pgs-soc-com
Odyssey of a_fellow_traveler-jb_mathews-1938-283pgs-soc-comOdyssey of a_fellow_traveler-jb_mathews-1938-283pgs-soc-com
Odyssey of a_fellow_traveler-jb_mathews-1938-283pgs-soc-com
 
The Automatization of Music
The Automatization of MusicThe Automatization of Music
The Automatization of Music
 
The Russian Opposition - Julia Pettengill, Henry Jackson Society report
The Russian Opposition - Julia Pettengill, Henry Jackson Society reportThe Russian Opposition - Julia Pettengill, Henry Jackson Society report
The Russian Opposition - Julia Pettengill, Henry Jackson Society report
 
Gender tropes
Gender tropesGender tropes
Gender tropes
 
SPA Conference 2012 E. Duda-Mikulin
SPA Conference 2012 E. Duda-MikulinSPA Conference 2012 E. Duda-Mikulin
SPA Conference 2012 E. Duda-Mikulin
 
Feminism
FeminismFeminism
Feminism
 
A2 Feminism and the Media
A2 Feminism and the MediaA2 Feminism and the Media
A2 Feminism and the Media
 
Dissertation FINAL
Dissertation FINALDissertation FINAL
Dissertation FINAL
 
249136674 events-in-the-crimea-in-the-polish-national-newspapers-and-periodic...
249136674 events-in-the-crimea-in-the-polish-national-newspapers-and-periodic...249136674 events-in-the-crimea-in-the-polish-national-newspapers-and-periodic...
249136674 events-in-the-crimea-in-the-polish-national-newspapers-and-periodic...
 
Concepts and various theoretical frameworks of feminism and mass media
Concepts and various theoretical frameworks of feminism and mass mediaConcepts and various theoretical frameworks of feminism and mass media
Concepts and various theoretical frameworks of feminism and mass media
 
Queer Theory
Queer TheoryQueer Theory
Queer Theory
 
Presentation feminism
Presentation feminismPresentation feminism
Presentation feminism
 
Causes and Concequences of Colour Revolutions in the Post-Soviet Countries
Causes and Concequences of Colour Revolutions in the Post-Soviet CountriesCauses and Concequences of Colour Revolutions in the Post-Soviet Countries
Causes and Concequences of Colour Revolutions in the Post-Soviet Countries
 
When comrade stalin sends us to the battle
When comrade stalin sends us to the battleWhen comrade stalin sends us to the battle
When comrade stalin sends us to the battle
 
Cultural criticism slides 2020
Cultural criticism slides 2020Cultural criticism slides 2020
Cultural criticism slides 2020
 
Week 11 Race and Prejudice
Week 11 Race and PrejudiceWeek 11 Race and Prejudice
Week 11 Race and Prejudice
 
Ronald Summa _Non-CE Certificate
Ronald Summa _Non-CE CertificateRonald Summa _Non-CE Certificate
Ronald Summa _Non-CE Certificate
 
03 text krastev_06 oct
03 text krastev_06 oct03 text krastev_06 oct
03 text krastev_06 oct
 
My perestroika
My perestroikaMy perestroika
My perestroika
 
Michael brown Ferguson/ Social Action
Michael brown Ferguson/ Social Action Michael brown Ferguson/ Social Action
Michael brown Ferguson/ Social Action
 

Viewers also liked

China's Soft Power
China's Soft PowerChina's Soft Power
China's Soft Power
Hahn Ryu
 
Soft Power Presentation
Soft Power PresentationSoft Power Presentation
Soft Power Presentation
vadim003
 
Ch_16-section2
Ch_16-section2Ch_16-section2
Ch_16-section2
Cynthia Ryan
 
international relation China presention
international relation China presentioninternational relation China presention
international relation China presention
Ashwa Khan
 
Ethics ppt p&o
Ethics ppt p&oEthics ppt p&o
Ethics ppt p&o
Ashwa Khan
 
Soft Power Vs Hard Power
Soft Power Vs Hard PowerSoft Power Vs Hard Power
Soft Power Vs Hard Power
edvill666
 
hard v soft power
 hard v soft power hard v soft power
hard v soft power
Remas Mohamed
 
India and Cultural Diplomacy
India and Cultural DiplomacyIndia and Cultural Diplomacy
India and Cultural Diplomacy
Bhawna Gupta
 
Theories of International Relations
Theories of International RelationsTheories of International Relations
Theories of International Relations
Jeffrey Hart
 
Globalization of world economy ppt
Globalization of world economy pptGlobalization of world economy ppt
Globalization of world economy ppt
gunacharlotte
 
Power & politics in organizations
Power & politics in organizationsPower & politics in organizations
Power & politics in organizations
mdfaizan
 
Chapter 8 - Organizational Behavior: Power, Politics, Conflict, and Stress
Chapter 8 - Organizational Behavior: Power, Politics, Conflict, and StressChapter 8 - Organizational Behavior: Power, Politics, Conflict, and Stress
Chapter 8 - Organizational Behavior: Power, Politics, Conflict, and Stress
dpd
 

Viewers also liked (12)

China's Soft Power
China's Soft PowerChina's Soft Power
China's Soft Power
 
Soft Power Presentation
Soft Power PresentationSoft Power Presentation
Soft Power Presentation
 
Ch_16-section2
Ch_16-section2Ch_16-section2
Ch_16-section2
 
international relation China presention
international relation China presentioninternational relation China presention
international relation China presention
 
Ethics ppt p&o
Ethics ppt p&oEthics ppt p&o
Ethics ppt p&o
 
Soft Power Vs Hard Power
Soft Power Vs Hard PowerSoft Power Vs Hard Power
Soft Power Vs Hard Power
 
hard v soft power
 hard v soft power hard v soft power
hard v soft power
 
India and Cultural Diplomacy
India and Cultural DiplomacyIndia and Cultural Diplomacy
India and Cultural Diplomacy
 
Theories of International Relations
Theories of International RelationsTheories of International Relations
Theories of International Relations
 
Globalization of world economy ppt
Globalization of world economy pptGlobalization of world economy ppt
Globalization of world economy ppt
 
Power & politics in organizations
Power & politics in organizationsPower & politics in organizations
Power & politics in organizations
 
Chapter 8 - Organizational Behavior: Power, Politics, Conflict, and Stress
Chapter 8 - Organizational Behavior: Power, Politics, Conflict, and StressChapter 8 - Organizational Behavior: Power, Politics, Conflict, and Stress
Chapter 8 - Organizational Behavior: Power, Politics, Conflict, and Stress
 

Similar to Osipova - Russification of Soft Power

The Black Power Movement- A State of the Field
The Black Power Movement- A State of the FieldThe Black Power Movement- A State of the Field
The Black Power Movement- A State of the Field
RBG Communiversity
 
The Black Power Movement, A State of the Field. Joseph PE, 2009.
The Black Power Movement, A State of the Field. Joseph PE, 2009.The Black Power Movement, A State of the Field. Joseph PE, 2009.
The Black Power Movement, A State of the Field. Joseph PE, 2009.
RBG Communiversity
 
History G8323 Graduate Colloquium Syllabus 2015
History G8323 Graduate Colloquium Syllabus 2015History G8323 Graduate Colloquium Syllabus 2015
History G8323 Graduate Colloquium Syllabus 2015
DreaCofield
 
Alexander Bogomolov. RUSSIAN SOFT POWER IN UKRAINE: sources and effects
Alexander Bogomolov. RUSSIAN SOFT POWER IN UKRAINE: sources and effects Alexander Bogomolov. RUSSIAN SOFT POWER IN UKRAINE: sources and effects
Alexander Bogomolov. RUSSIAN SOFT POWER IN UKRAINE: sources and effects
sergeAmes
 
090310_chinesesoftpower__chap2
090310_chinesesoftpower__chap2090310_chinesesoftpower__chap2
090310_chinesesoftpower__chap2
Jen W
 
Art, society, politics - Russian soft power_Denis Maksimov_KU Leuven
Art, society, politics - Russian soft power_Denis Maksimov_KU LeuvenArt, society, politics - Russian soft power_Denis Maksimov_KU Leuven
Art, society, politics - Russian soft power_Denis Maksimov_KU Leuven
Denis Maksimov
 
Stalin russia and_the_crisis_in_socialism-max_eastman-1940-281pgs-pol
Stalin  russia and_the_crisis_in_socialism-max_eastman-1940-281pgs-polStalin  russia and_the_crisis_in_socialism-max_eastman-1940-281pgs-pol
Stalin russia and_the_crisis_in_socialism-max_eastman-1940-281pgs-pol
RareBooksnRecords
 
Research Paper On Russian Culture
Research Paper On Russian CultureResearch Paper On Russian Culture
Research Paper On Russian Culture
Kimberly Haynes
 
Russian Revolution
Russian RevolutionRussian Revolution
Russian Revolution
DMTLA_HUM
 
Politics, Power and Resistance
Politics, Power and Resistance Politics, Power and Resistance
Politics, Power and Resistance
vermeerliam
 
Terminology quiz
Terminology quizTerminology quiz
Terminology quiz
Andy Wallis
 
07 text elshtain_20 oct
07 text elshtain_20 oct07 text elshtain_20 oct
07 text elshtain_20 oct
jhenri5
 
Dependency Theory: A Critical Review
Dependency Theory: A Critical ReviewDependency Theory: A Critical Review
Dependency Theory: A Critical Review
Craig Collins, Ph.D.
 
A3120105.pdf
A3120105.pdfA3120105.pdf
Russia Revolution
Russia RevolutionRussia Revolution
Russia Revolution
DMTLA_HUM
 
International relations part 2
International relations part 2International relations part 2
International relations part 2
Amin Sadeghi
 
[Plenary 2] Dang Ngoc Sinh
[Plenary 2] Dang Ngoc Sinh[Plenary 2] Dang Ngoc Sinh
[Plenary 2] Dang Ngoc Sinh
englishonecfl
 
Neoconservatism
NeoconservatismNeoconservatism
Neoconservatism
Michael Peters
 
Neoconservatism
NeoconservatismNeoconservatism
Neoconservatism
mpt001
 
China and the West Final Paper
China and the West Final PaperChina and the West Final Paper
China and the West Final Paper
Caleb Chen
 

Similar to Osipova - Russification of Soft Power (20)

The Black Power Movement- A State of the Field
The Black Power Movement- A State of the FieldThe Black Power Movement- A State of the Field
The Black Power Movement- A State of the Field
 
The Black Power Movement, A State of the Field. Joseph PE, 2009.
The Black Power Movement, A State of the Field. Joseph PE, 2009.The Black Power Movement, A State of the Field. Joseph PE, 2009.
The Black Power Movement, A State of the Field. Joseph PE, 2009.
 
History G8323 Graduate Colloquium Syllabus 2015
History G8323 Graduate Colloquium Syllabus 2015History G8323 Graduate Colloquium Syllabus 2015
History G8323 Graduate Colloquium Syllabus 2015
 
Alexander Bogomolov. RUSSIAN SOFT POWER IN UKRAINE: sources and effects
Alexander Bogomolov. RUSSIAN SOFT POWER IN UKRAINE: sources and effects Alexander Bogomolov. RUSSIAN SOFT POWER IN UKRAINE: sources and effects
Alexander Bogomolov. RUSSIAN SOFT POWER IN UKRAINE: sources and effects
 
090310_chinesesoftpower__chap2
090310_chinesesoftpower__chap2090310_chinesesoftpower__chap2
090310_chinesesoftpower__chap2
 
Art, society, politics - Russian soft power_Denis Maksimov_KU Leuven
Art, society, politics - Russian soft power_Denis Maksimov_KU LeuvenArt, society, politics - Russian soft power_Denis Maksimov_KU Leuven
Art, society, politics - Russian soft power_Denis Maksimov_KU Leuven
 
Stalin russia and_the_crisis_in_socialism-max_eastman-1940-281pgs-pol
Stalin  russia and_the_crisis_in_socialism-max_eastman-1940-281pgs-polStalin  russia and_the_crisis_in_socialism-max_eastman-1940-281pgs-pol
Stalin russia and_the_crisis_in_socialism-max_eastman-1940-281pgs-pol
 
Research Paper On Russian Culture
Research Paper On Russian CultureResearch Paper On Russian Culture
Research Paper On Russian Culture
 
Russian Revolution
Russian RevolutionRussian Revolution
Russian Revolution
 
Politics, Power and Resistance
Politics, Power and Resistance Politics, Power and Resistance
Politics, Power and Resistance
 
Terminology quiz
Terminology quizTerminology quiz
Terminology quiz
 
07 text elshtain_20 oct
07 text elshtain_20 oct07 text elshtain_20 oct
07 text elshtain_20 oct
 
Dependency Theory: A Critical Review
Dependency Theory: A Critical ReviewDependency Theory: A Critical Review
Dependency Theory: A Critical Review
 
A3120105.pdf
A3120105.pdfA3120105.pdf
A3120105.pdf
 
Russia Revolution
Russia RevolutionRussia Revolution
Russia Revolution
 
International relations part 2
International relations part 2International relations part 2
International relations part 2
 
[Plenary 2] Dang Ngoc Sinh
[Plenary 2] Dang Ngoc Sinh[Plenary 2] Dang Ngoc Sinh
[Plenary 2] Dang Ngoc Sinh
 
Neoconservatism
NeoconservatismNeoconservatism
Neoconservatism
 
Neoconservatism
NeoconservatismNeoconservatism
Neoconservatism
 
China and the West Final Paper
China and the West Final PaperChina and the West Final Paper
China and the West Final Paper
 

Osipova - Russification of Soft Power

  • 1. ‘Russification’ of ‘Soft Power’: Transformation of a Concept Yelena Osipova School of International Service American University, Washington, DC
  • 2. Soft Power - Joseph S. Nye, Jr. (1990) - Appeal & attraction  shape preferences - Resources: - Culture and attractiveness - Political values - Perceived legitimacy of policies
  • 3. Critique: Hegemony?  Gramsci: reproduction of a given social order  Ideational as well as material means  “Universal ideology”  “Historic bloc”: an articulate network of social institutions that reinforces hegemony  Not entirely coercion-free
  • 4. American Soft Power?  Parallels: soft power & hegemony (Zahran & Ramos, 2010)  American global hegemony?  Global popularity: • “de-Westernization”
  • 5. Russia: The Context  Prominence in mid-2000s • Putin’s 2nd term: more assertive FP • “Color Revolutions” • NATO expansion  Geopolitical lens
  • 6. Reinterpretation  Sovereignty & “sovereign democracy” (Surkov) • Resist American meddling • Basis for Russian soft power: no strings attached  “Color revolutions” as America’s “historic bloc”  Response: enhance Russia’s own soft power
  • 7. Recontextualization Nye’s framework:  Culture & attractiveness: • Rich heritage, multiculturalism, Russian language, & conservative “moral pole”  Attractiveness of political values: • Diversity, tolerance, & inclusiveness  Legitimacy of policies: • Respect of sovereignty; holding US accountable
  • 8. Tools & Mechanisms  Many borrowed from others & the past  Foundational: • Russian language • Humanitarian cooperation  “Compatriots abroad”
  • 9. Example: Ukraine/Crimea  #Euromaidan seen as Western intervention  Threat to Russian interests  Large Russian/Russian-speaking population  Vast network of cultural/social diasporan orgs.  Activated to promote Russian interests  Crimea: success case
  • 10. Conclusion “For Russia, soft power doesn’t have to mean being a softy.” Pavel Koshkin & Ksenia Smertina, Russia Direct, March 17, 2014