Opiates in Chronic
Non-malignant Pain
    Jonathan Ploudré, MD
Name ‘em
Fentanyl
 Tramadol
                              Oxycodone
 Hydromorphone
                             Oxymorphone
                 Morphine
Meperidine
                       Methadone
       Codeine
                       (Prophxyphene)
  Hydrocodone
Group ‘em
Fentanyl
 Tramadol
                              Oxycodone
 Hydromorphone
                             Oxymorphone
                 Morphine
Meperidine
                       Methadone
       Codeine
                       (Prophxyphene)
  Hydrocodone
Strong          Weak         Weak/Re-uptake

   Fentanyl       Codeine          Tramadol
Hydromorphone   Hydrocodone
  Meperidine    (Prophxyphene)
  Morphine

  Methadone

Oxymorphone
 Oxycodone
Strong          Weak         Weak/Re-uptake

   Fentanyl       Codeine          Tramadol
Hydromorphone   Hydrocodone
  Meperidine    (Prophxyphene)
  Morphine

  Methadone

Oxymorphone
 Oxycodone
Time ‘em
Fentanyl
 Tramadol
                              Oxycodone
 Hydromorphone
                             Oxymorphone
                 Morphine
Meperidine
                       Methadone
       Codeine
                       (Prophxyphene)
  Hydrocodone
< 3 hours     4-6 hours    > 6 hours

 Fentanyl    Hydromorphone   Fentanyl
Meperidine    Hydrocodone   Methadone
                Morphine     Morphine
               Oxycodone    Oxycodone
              Oxymorphone Oxymorphone
                 Codeine     Tramadol
             (Prophxyphene)
                Tramadol
< 3 hours     4-6 hours    > 6 hours

 Fentanyl    Hydromorphone   Fentanyl
Meperidine    Hydrocodone   Methadone
                Morphine     Morphine
               Oxycodone    Oxycodone
              Oxymorphone Oxymorphone
                 Codeine     Tramadol
             (Prophxyphene)
                Tramadol
Controversies
• Different Physician Styles of Prescribing
• Pain is 100% subjective
• Risks of Abuse and Overdose
• Risks of Under-treatment
• Marijuana
• And on and on......
NEJM: Nov 2010
NEJM: Nov 2010
WA Law is
National News. This
   starts in 3m




  More than
   MVAs




                NEJM: Nov 2010
Starting Out

• Is this chronic?
• Is this patient high-risk?
• Has workup been done?
Screening Risk




  Painknowledge.org
Opioids: Details
•   No evidence based approach for individualizing for
    a patient.
•   Expert opinion prefer long-acting, scheduled
    dosing over short-acting prn dosing.
•   Expert opinion avoid high # counts.
•   VA Study 2011: Scheduled vs PRN are equal risk
    for accidental overdose
•   VA Study 2011: High Daily Dose, higher risk of
    overdose.
Provider Variation
• Residency 2005:Variation of experienced
  prescribers (3rd years, faculty) ranged from
  3% of total prescriptions to 25%.
• “Default” practices for acute pain vary
  widely.
• “Default” practices for acute/chronic pain
  vary from guidelines, too.
Opioids: WA referral
        levels
• Morphine: 120mg daily
• Methadone: 40mg daily
• Oxycodone: 80mg daily
• Hydrocodone: 120mg daily
• Hydromorphone: 30mg daily
• Oxymorphone: 40mg daily
The 5 A’s

• Analgesia
• ADLs (Function)
• Adverse Reactions
• Aberrant Behaviors
• Assessment
Analgesia
• Your average pain over the past week?
• Your worst pain over the past week?
• What percentage of pain has been relieved
  over the past week?
• Is the pain relief enough to make a real
  difference?
ADLs (Function)
 Surprisingly
 Reproducible
Validated across                                    8-10/10
     culture
                                     6-7/10         General
                                                   Activities
                      5/10        Relationships   Relationships
                                    Walking         Walking
    3-4/10            Work           Work            Work
                      Sleep          Sleep           Sleep
  Enjoyment         Enjoyment      Enjoyment       Enjoyment
 Overall Mood      Overall Mood   Overall Mood    Overall Mood
Adverse Reactions
• Nausea/Vomiting
• Constipation
• Itching
• Mental Cloudiness
• Sweating
• Fatigue
• Drowsiness
Adverse Reactions
• Nausea/Vomiting
• Constipation      “The hand that writes the prescription
                 should write for something for constipation.”



• Itching
• Mental Cloudiness
• Sweating
• Fatigue
• Drowsiness
Aberrant Behaviors



       ?
Spidey-Sense
Aberrant Behaviors
•   Purposeful Over-sedation
•   Negative mood change
•   Appears intoxicated
•   Increasingly unkempt or impaired
•   Involvement in car or other accidents
•   Requests for frequent early renewals
•   Increasing dose without authorization
•   Reports lost/stolen prescriptions
•   Prescriptions from other doctors
•   Changes route of administration
•   Uses medications in response to situational stressors
•   Insists on certain medications by name
•   Contact with street drug culture
•   Abusing alcohol or illicit drugs
•   Hoarding (Stockpiling) of medication
•   Arrested by police
•    Victim of abuse
Aberrance Prevalence
  60

  50

  40

  30

  20

  10
       0




                 2




                         4



                              5+
               1-




                       3-




  Passik 2005: Pain Clinic Population
Does a Utox Work?

              Previous No Previous
              Behaviors Behaviors
    Urine +     10         26

    Urine -     17         69


  Katz 2003: Pain Clinic Population
 (So not generalizable to lower risk
           populations.)
Assessment

• Benefits outweigh risks:Yes, No, Uncertain
 • Continue Same Dose
 • Titrate Dose
 • Change Medications
 • Discontinue/Taper
Discontinuation:
   in a tweet



      ?
Discontinuation:
    in a tweet
David Schumer, MD:
These are trust medications and I
don’t trust you. So I won’t prescribe
them anymore. I believe you have
pain but I don’t trust you.
Self Knowledge


• Philosophically: Where will you be on the
  spectrum of opiate prescribing norms?
“Interagency Guideline on Opioid Dosing”
Q &A



 ?

Opiate Prescription, Washington 2011

  • 1.
    Opiates in Chronic Non-malignantPain Jonathan Ploudré, MD
  • 2.
  • 3.
    Fentanyl Tramadol Oxycodone Hydromorphone Oxymorphone Morphine Meperidine Methadone Codeine (Prophxyphene) Hydrocodone
  • 4.
  • 5.
    Fentanyl Tramadol Oxycodone Hydromorphone Oxymorphone Morphine Meperidine Methadone Codeine (Prophxyphene) Hydrocodone
  • 6.
    Strong Weak Weak/Re-uptake Fentanyl Codeine Tramadol Hydromorphone Hydrocodone Meperidine (Prophxyphene) Morphine Methadone Oxymorphone Oxycodone
  • 7.
    Strong Weak Weak/Re-uptake Fentanyl Codeine Tramadol Hydromorphone Hydrocodone Meperidine (Prophxyphene) Morphine Methadone Oxymorphone Oxycodone
  • 8.
  • 9.
    Fentanyl Tramadol Oxycodone Hydromorphone Oxymorphone Morphine Meperidine Methadone Codeine (Prophxyphene) Hydrocodone
  • 10.
    < 3 hours 4-6 hours > 6 hours Fentanyl Hydromorphone Fentanyl Meperidine Hydrocodone Methadone Morphine Morphine Oxycodone Oxycodone Oxymorphone Oxymorphone Codeine Tramadol (Prophxyphene) Tramadol
  • 11.
    < 3 hours 4-6 hours > 6 hours Fentanyl Hydromorphone Fentanyl Meperidine Hydrocodone Methadone Morphine Morphine Oxycodone Oxycodone Oxymorphone Oxymorphone Codeine Tramadol (Prophxyphene) Tramadol
  • 13.
    Controversies • Different PhysicianStyles of Prescribing • Pain is 100% subjective • Risks of Abuse and Overdose • Risks of Under-treatment • Marijuana • And on and on......
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
    WA Law is NationalNews. This starts in 3m More than MVAs NEJM: Nov 2010
  • 17.
    Starting Out • Isthis chronic? • Is this patient high-risk? • Has workup been done?
  • 18.
    Screening Risk Painknowledge.org
  • 19.
    Opioids: Details • No evidence based approach for individualizing for a patient. • Expert opinion prefer long-acting, scheduled dosing over short-acting prn dosing. • Expert opinion avoid high # counts. • VA Study 2011: Scheduled vs PRN are equal risk for accidental overdose • VA Study 2011: High Daily Dose, higher risk of overdose.
  • 20.
    Provider Variation • Residency2005:Variation of experienced prescribers (3rd years, faculty) ranged from 3% of total prescriptions to 25%. • “Default” practices for acute pain vary widely. • “Default” practices for acute/chronic pain vary from guidelines, too.
  • 21.
    Opioids: WA referral levels • Morphine: 120mg daily • Methadone: 40mg daily • Oxycodone: 80mg daily • Hydrocodone: 120mg daily • Hydromorphone: 30mg daily • Oxymorphone: 40mg daily
  • 22.
    The 5 A’s •Analgesia • ADLs (Function) • Adverse Reactions • Aberrant Behaviors • Assessment
  • 23.
    Analgesia • Your averagepain over the past week? • Your worst pain over the past week? • What percentage of pain has been relieved over the past week? • Is the pain relief enough to make a real difference?
  • 24.
    ADLs (Function) Surprisingly Reproducible Validated across 8-10/10 culture 6-7/10 General Activities 5/10 Relationships Relationships Walking Walking 3-4/10 Work Work Work Sleep Sleep Sleep Enjoyment Enjoyment Enjoyment Enjoyment Overall Mood Overall Mood Overall Mood Overall Mood
  • 25.
    Adverse Reactions • Nausea/Vomiting •Constipation • Itching • Mental Cloudiness • Sweating • Fatigue • Drowsiness
  • 26.
    Adverse Reactions • Nausea/Vomiting •Constipation “The hand that writes the prescription should write for something for constipation.” • Itching • Mental Cloudiness • Sweating • Fatigue • Drowsiness
  • 27.
  • 28.
  • 29.
    Aberrant Behaviors • Purposeful Over-sedation • Negative mood change • Appears intoxicated • Increasingly unkempt or impaired • Involvement in car or other accidents • Requests for frequent early renewals • Increasing dose without authorization • Reports lost/stolen prescriptions • Prescriptions from other doctors • Changes route of administration • Uses medications in response to situational stressors • Insists on certain medications by name • Contact with street drug culture • Abusing alcohol or illicit drugs • Hoarding (Stockpiling) of medication • Arrested by police • Victim of abuse
  • 30.
    Aberrance Prevalence 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 2 4 5+ 1- 3- Passik 2005: Pain Clinic Population
  • 31.
    Does a UtoxWork? Previous No Previous Behaviors Behaviors Urine + 10 26 Urine - 17 69 Katz 2003: Pain Clinic Population (So not generalizable to lower risk populations.)
  • 32.
    Assessment • Benefits outweighrisks:Yes, No, Uncertain • Continue Same Dose • Titrate Dose • Change Medications • Discontinue/Taper
  • 33.
    Discontinuation: in a tweet ?
  • 34.
    Discontinuation: in a tweet David Schumer, MD: These are trust medications and I don’t trust you. So I won’t prescribe them anymore. I believe you have pain but I don’t trust you.
  • 35.
    Self Knowledge • Philosophically:Where will you be on the spectrum of opiate prescribing norms?
  • 36.
  • 37.