ABSTRACT : The study of the social influence on the scientific praxis is an important branch of social
sciences. This branch, however, has focused mostly on large scale phenomena or otherwise individual ethics. In
this work we propose a way to approach this topic from individual psychological constructs using the
cognitiveframe of personal epistemology. In particular, we show that the insertion of psychological variables to
account for the self-control over personal epistemology is a useful tool facing the modern tendencies of the
scientific work. The pertinence of this approach for a complete analysis of the science agents is discussed in
several perspectives. We recall that, even when socio-scientific dynamics is not reducible to its constituents, it is
precisely within the individuals that many important clues can be found to understend complex collective
behaviors.
KEYWORDS : Personal epistemology, interdisciplinary research, cognitive processes, social sciences
Назаренко Д.М., Співпраця з батьками як шлях формування творчої ос...Наталья Качковская
У посібнику висвітлено теоретичні і практичні аспекти роботи з
сім’єю керівника гуртка позашкільного навчального закладу.
Акцентовано увагу на форми роботи з батьками, що сприяють розвитку
творчої особистості дитини, формуванню національно-патріотичних
цінностей вихованців гуртка.
Матеріали посібника адресовані керівникам гуртків позашкільних
навчальних закладів, класним керівникам, вчителям початкової школи
для організації взаємодії з батьками школярів.
Sujay the Sociology of Science FINAL FINAL FINAL - Copy (2).pdfSujay Rao Mandavilli
This document discusses the sociology of science and its potential to promote social change through better communication of science. It defines science as a systematic process of investigation using observation, experimentation and theory building. The sociology of science can help developing countries by analyzing differences between their scientific development and that of developed countries. For sociology of science to achieve this potential, it must become a distinct interdisciplinary field that incorporates diverse cultural perspectives.
OBJECTIVITY IN SOCIAL SCIENCE RESEARCH Ruby Med Plus
Objectivity is considered as an ideal for scientific inquiry, as a good reason for valuing scientific knowledge, and as the foundation of the authority of science in society. It expresses the thought that the claims, methods and results of science are not, or should not be influenced by particular perspectives, value commitments, community bias or personal interests, to name a few significant factors. Scientific objectivity is a feature of scientific claims, methods and results.
This document provides an overview of research methodology in social sciences. It discusses what research is, the purposes of research including developing new knowledge and solving problems. It outlines different research designs including defining problems, formulating hypotheses, collecting and analyzing data. It also discusses the objectives of social research as discovering new facts and understanding human behavior. The document covers quantitative and qualitative research methods, as well as sources of data collection for social research like interviews, observations, and documents. It provides examples of the process of social research.
Sujay Certainty Uncertainty principle FINAL FINAL FINAL FINAL FINAL (2).pdfSujay Rao Mandavilli
This paper proposes a "certainty-uncertainty principle" for evaluating hypotheses in the social sciences. It discusses theories of uncertainty from physics, like Heisenberg's uncertainty principle and Gödel's incompleteness theorems, but notes its approach is different. The principle has two main postulates: 1) Researchers should consciously search for uncertainties in hypotheses, similar to searching for exceptions. 2) Certainties must be evaluated against uncertainties in hypotheses, with the net effect considered. This approach should be used along with the prior "sociological ninety-ten rule" about finding exceptions over space and time. The goal is to improve social science research quality and lead to better hypothesis formulation.
Назаренко Д.М., Співпраця з батьками як шлях формування творчої ос...Наталья Качковская
У посібнику висвітлено теоретичні і практичні аспекти роботи з
сім’єю керівника гуртка позашкільного навчального закладу.
Акцентовано увагу на форми роботи з батьками, що сприяють розвитку
творчої особистості дитини, формуванню національно-патріотичних
цінностей вихованців гуртка.
Матеріали посібника адресовані керівникам гуртків позашкільних
навчальних закладів, класним керівникам, вчителям початкової школи
для організації взаємодії з батьками школярів.
Sujay the Sociology of Science FINAL FINAL FINAL - Copy (2).pdfSujay Rao Mandavilli
This document discusses the sociology of science and its potential to promote social change through better communication of science. It defines science as a systematic process of investigation using observation, experimentation and theory building. The sociology of science can help developing countries by analyzing differences between their scientific development and that of developed countries. For sociology of science to achieve this potential, it must become a distinct interdisciplinary field that incorporates diverse cultural perspectives.
OBJECTIVITY IN SOCIAL SCIENCE RESEARCH Ruby Med Plus
Objectivity is considered as an ideal for scientific inquiry, as a good reason for valuing scientific knowledge, and as the foundation of the authority of science in society. It expresses the thought that the claims, methods and results of science are not, or should not be influenced by particular perspectives, value commitments, community bias or personal interests, to name a few significant factors. Scientific objectivity is a feature of scientific claims, methods and results.
This document provides an overview of research methodology in social sciences. It discusses what research is, the purposes of research including developing new knowledge and solving problems. It outlines different research designs including defining problems, formulating hypotheses, collecting and analyzing data. It also discusses the objectives of social research as discovering new facts and understanding human behavior. The document covers quantitative and qualitative research methods, as well as sources of data collection for social research like interviews, observations, and documents. It provides examples of the process of social research.
Sujay Certainty Uncertainty principle FINAL FINAL FINAL FINAL FINAL (2).pdfSujay Rao Mandavilli
This paper proposes a "certainty-uncertainty principle" for evaluating hypotheses in the social sciences. It discusses theories of uncertainty from physics, like Heisenberg's uncertainty principle and Gödel's incompleteness theorems, but notes its approach is different. The principle has two main postulates: 1) Researchers should consciously search for uncertainties in hypotheses, similar to searching for exceptions. 2) Certainties must be evaluated against uncertainties in hypotheses, with the net effect considered. This approach should be used along with the prior "sociological ninety-ten rule" about finding exceptions over space and time. The goal is to improve social science research quality and lead to better hypothesis formulation.
Sujay Certainty Uncertainty principle FINAL FINAL FINAL FINAL FINAL.pdfSujay Rao Mandavilli
This document discusses guidelines for formulating hypotheses in the social sciences that consider both certainty and uncertainty. It proposes weighing certainty and uncertainty when evaluating hypotheses to make science more objective and multi-polar. The document reviews theories of uncertainty from physics and mathematics and discusses how concepts like fuzzy logic, paradoxes, and cross-cultural research can be applied to social sciences. The goal is to make scientific research more inclusive of diverse contexts and needs of societies to better serve social progress.
Development of Social Sciences in Dissertations of Immanuel Wallerstein - Imp...RemigiuszRosicki
This paper presents an analysis of the social science development concept of Immanuel Wallerstein. In general terms we can say that the development of social sciences was based on a process of emancipation of individual subjects of research and validation of research methods.
I. Wallerstein drew attention to the process of emancipation of individual disciplines, therefore
we can talk about the separation of philosophy, followed by social sciences and, negatively evaluated by I. Wallerstein, applied social sciences. With the constitution of individual disciplines
we dealt with the process of polarising methodological positions, which can be roughly described as the concept of two cultures. The text describes the following issues: (1) the directions
of emancipation of scientific disciplines, (2) the processes of emancipation of scientific disciplines, (3) the dynamics of changes in social sciences, (4) the effects of changes occurring in sciences. In addition to the main assumptions of I. Wallerstein on science, the text attempts to confront these assumptions with the achievements of T. S. Kuhn, R. K. Merton and C. W. Mills. The aim of the article is to point out the implications for the “theory of international relations” deriving from the general trends in the development of social sciences. This issue has come down to only selected issues of: microscopisation, idealisation, metaphorical use, deformation, transcendentalisation, fictionalisation and fetishisation of notions in the “theory of international relations”.
Sujay Academic freedom versus social responsibility for researchers FINAL FIN...Sujay Rao Mandavilli
This document discusses the concepts of academic freedom and social responsibility. It explores tensions between the two, noting that while academic freedom is important for open inquiry, it cannot override social responsibilities and must be balanced. The document provides historical context for the development of academic freedom as a concept. It notes the need for strengthened codes of conduct and ethics for scholars to emphasize their duties to society. While academic freedom allows important work, unrestricted freedom could undermine integrity and produce harmful results. Overall responsibility to science and society must be considered alongside freedom of research and teaching.
THE SELF CRITICISM OF SCIENCE - ALEXIS KARPOUZOSalexis karpouzos
The neoteric human being is now being cut off from the order of nature and establishes itself as the rationally re- flecting and acting subject which is now posited against the object of its cognitive and practical activity. Civiliza- tion is constituted as the product of human activity, as an artifact and technical construct. iWth this development, human civilization is transformed to a ‘quasi nature’, aim- ing to correct and replace nature, and man assumes the nature of a technical existence. By ‘technical existence’ we mean the prevalence of a one-dimensional image of the human person as the producer of rational hypotheses and interpretations and the downgrading and degrada- tion of the non-rational element of human existence, i.e. the radical imagination as a creative capacity, which forms the a priori condition and prerequisite for social activity. This constitutive element of the modern world (man, as the producer of rational hypotheses) and its ar- ticulation with the ideology of techno-scientific progress and the evolution of the machine that transforms the methods and theories of natural sciences, arming these with new tools and constantly renovating their research and experimental capabilities, finally led to the replace- ment of religious and metaphysical dogmas by the blind faith to the dogma of technical and scientific progress.
Sociology aims to study society using scientific methods like those used in natural sciences. However, whether sociology can truly be considered a science is debated. Society consists of humans and human behavior/ideas, which are more difficult to study objectively and empirically compared to natural phenomena. Positivism approaches sociology as an objective, empirical science, while interpretivism argues human behavior has meaningful context beyond just observation and measurement. Ultimately, what constitutes valid knowledge and scientific truth depends on one's philosophical views about reality and the nature of human behavior.
This document summarizes the major philosophical perspectives in education. It discusses idealism, realism, naturalism, pragmatism, progressivism, existentialism, essentialism, perennialism, social reconstructionism, and critical theory. It provides an overview of each perspective, including a discussion of Plato's idealism and the influence of the Sophists. The purpose is to help readers classify, analyze, and apply these perspectives to examine their own philosophies of leadership and teaching.
This document discusses the epistemology and methodology of Islamic economics. It begins by defining epistemology as the theory of knowledge that examines the origin, structure, and validity of scientific knowledge. It then discusses the relationship between epistemology and empirical science, noting that epistemology provides a philosophical framework for the scientific method while empirical science involves applying that method to discover realities. The document also introduces naturalistic epistemology, which emphasizes applying methods and theories from empirical sciences to the study of knowledge. It concludes by explaining how epistemology impacts empirical science by encouraging critical thinking, reflecting on assumptions and methods, and providing a logical foundation for the scientific method.
This document discusses guidelines for formulating hypotheses in the social sciences based on the concepts of certainty and uncertainty. It proposes a "Certainty-uncertainty principle" that evaluates hypotheses by weighing certainties against uncertainties. The paper discusses existing theories on uncertainty from physics, like the uncertainty principle in quantum mechanics. It also discusses Gödel's incompleteness theorem in mathematics and Tarski's undefinability theorem. The paper aims to make identifying and evaluating uncertainties as important as certainties in hypotheses. This approach hopes to make social science research more objective, reliable and applicable across diverse cultural contexts by incorporating varied perspectives from around the world.
Scientism, or the unity of scientific method. The positivist
methodology does not see any difference between the
natural and the social sciences. The adoption however, of
the unity of the scientific method is accepted in tandem
with the notion of the predominant role of the natural
sciences, in which the social sciences see their model.
The outcome is what we call scientism, that is the view
that only the natural sciences can produce the semantic
interpretation of knowledge.
This document provides an overview and analysis of Alexis Karpouzos's book "The self-criticism of science". It discusses some of the key arguments and criticisms addressed against positivism in the contemporary philosophy of science, including criticisms of scientism, empiricism, and the idea that science can provide value-neutral or objective knowledge. It also summarizes some of the alternative perspectives proposed, such as phenomenology and conventionalism.
This document discusses the relationship between science and philosophy. It provides definitions of science as the study of natural phenomena through observation and experimentation with the goal of discovering general truths and laws. Philosophy is defined as the study of knowledge, reality, and ethics through reflection rather than empirical discovery. The philosophy of science examines the methods and justification of scientific claims.
The relationship between science and philosophy is examined in three ways: they can deal with different subject matters, philosophy can be an extension of science by evaluating scientific concepts and theories, or philosophy can describe realities independent of science. While science studies empirical facts, philosophy clarifies scientific language and theories. Both fields influence each other as science is not purely objective and philosophy reflects on scientific findings.
The contemporary philosophy of science & the problem of the scientific consciousness.
...The understanding of scientific knowledge requires reflective thinking. The reflective thinking could restore the communication between subject and object, between social sciences and natural sciences. Only then, communication between facts and values can achieved. In other words, communication between reason and myth, science and art, knowledge and wisdom, empirical research and the existential question for the meaning of life.
...the problem of scientific consciousness (liability) requires the transformation of the structures of the same knowledge. The sovereignty of uncontrolled scientism-positivism leads to brutalization and the reaction to it, leads to metaphysical obscurantism and madness. The researcher should be aware of the complex and reciprocal relationships between the scientific, technical, social and political worlds...
This document discusses using methods from physics to approach social planning and the social sciences. It notes that while physics relies on observation and experimentation to develop laws, the social sciences involve human observation and participation that complicate establishing general patterns. While some efforts have been made to apply physics results to society, success has been limited. The document argues that observation methods from physics could still benefit social sciences and planning by establishing basic data through improved interview techniques that select respondents based on relevant parameters rather than aiming for random representation.
Sujay Inductive, nomothetic approaches and grounded theory FINAL FINAL FINAL ...Sujay Rao Mandavilli
This document discusses inductive and deductive approaches to theory building in social sciences research. It recommends using both nomothetic (law-building) and idiographic (case-specific) approaches, as well as grounded theory which generates theories from real-world data. The document aims to promote more inclusive globalized approaches to increase the quality and impact of social sciences research. It relates this topic to the author's previous work on responsibilities of researchers and principles like exceptionism, uncertainty, and cross-cultural research design.
Sujay Inductive, nomothetic approaches and grounded theory FINAL FINAL FINAL ...Sujay Rao Mandavilli
This paper evaluates both inductive and deductive methods with respect to theory building particularly
in the social sciences. The former is an approach for drawing conclusions by proceeding from the specific
to the general, while as per the latter, a hypothesis is usually developed and subsequently tested based
on further evidence. This paper also evaluates nomothetic approaches in opposition to idiographic or
stand-alone approaches with respect to theorization or theory-formulation as well, and recommends
that a combination of the two be used. It also discusses the application of grounded theory in social
sciences research besides other approaches to theorization as well. While choosing a appropriate
research method is the prerogative of the researcher, based on the research question involved, the
researcher’s personal inclinations, besides time and cost considerations, this paper hopes to generate
awareness of more globalized and inclusive approaches to scientific endeavour. This is as such, our fifth
paper on the philosophy of science, and extends our earlier work which primarily focused on the
importance of the social duties of every researcher and scholar, the principle of exceptionism or the
sociological ninety ten rule, the certainty uncertainty principle, and the importance of cross-cultural
research design. This paper is also therefore the logical culmination of all our earlier endeavours, and
forms an integral part of our “Globalization of science” movement, with particular emphasis on the
social sciences.
1) The document discusses the theoretical approaches to social pedagogy in Denmark from the 1970s-1980s. Two main schools of thought emerged: a Marxist approach focused on group dynamics, and a North American pragmatic approach focused on everyday experiences.
2) In the late 1980s-1990s, approaches drew from German critical theory and focused more on communication and emotional exchange. However, empirical research was still lacking.
3) The document argues for a third theoretical approach drawing from French philosophers like Bourdieu that examines social pedagogy as a social occurrence rather than just an experience. It emphasizes analyzing power relations and how dominated groups accept their position in society.
This document discusses the relationship between academic freedom and social responsibility for researchers and scholars. It argues that while academic freedom is important for open inquiry, it cannot override social responsibility and must emphasize a scholar's duties to science, society, and education. Ethics and codes of conduct around these issues are currently inadequate and need to be strengthened, consolidated, and enforced through university mandates. Moving forward, emphasizing social responsibilities should extend across all fields of social science and become a major movement in the 21st century.
The Influence of Green Tax Implementation and Social Responsibility Programs ...AJHSSR Journal
ABSTRACT : The issue of climate change related to carbon emissions has become an alarming global
phenomenon. The manufacturing sector contributes significantly to global greenhouse gas emissions. Therefore,
efforts to mitigate climate change through the implementation of green taxes and Social Responsibility
Programsare important for manufacturing industry. This research aims to analyze the effect of implementing
green tax and Social Responsibility Programs on environmentally sustainable development in manufacturing
industry. A quantitative approach is used with the research object of manufacturing industry listed on the
Indonesia Stock Exchange in 2020-2022. Analyzed using Partial Least Square (PLS) method. The research
results show that the implementation of green tax has a significant effect on environmentally sustainable
development, while Social Responsibility Programsdo not have a significant effect. These findings indicate that
green tax policies are effective in encouraging companies to switch to more environmentally friendly business
practices, but Social Responsibility Programshave not been fully integrated with environmental sustainability
efforts. This research contributes to the literature related to fiscal policy instruments and corporate social
responsibility practices in supporting environmentally sound sustainable development in the manufacturing
sector.
KEYWORDS: Green tax; Social responsibility; Environmentally sustainable development; Manufacturing
industry
Creating Immersive Language Learning Environments for Young LearnersAJHSSR Journal
ABSTRACT: Creating immersive language learning environments for young learners in English as a Foreign
Language (EFL) contexts has been a topic of considerable interest and debate among educators. Despite
numerous constraints such as time, curriculum, and stakeholder expectations, it is feasible to develop effective
immersive environments. This paper explores the concept of immersion language learning, tracing its historical
development and highlighting its benefits, particularly for young learners. It discusses the distinctions between
total, partial, and dual-immersion programs, emphasizing the critical role of using the target language as the
medium of instruction. Furthermore, it examines the cognitive and academic advantages documented in seminal
immersion programs like Saint-Lambert and Coral Way. By synthesizing research and offering practical
strategies for EFL settings, this paper underscores the importance of teacher commitment, the selection of
appropriate materials, and the adoption of Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL) principles.
Ultimately, the findings affirm that immersive environments significantly enhance language proficiency,
cognitive flexibility, and academic achievement, advocating for their broader implementation in EFL
classrooms.
KEYWORDS : CLIL, EFL, immersion, young learners
More Related Content
Similar to On the role of personal epistemology in the study of Science, Technology and Society
Sujay Certainty Uncertainty principle FINAL FINAL FINAL FINAL FINAL.pdfSujay Rao Mandavilli
This document discusses guidelines for formulating hypotheses in the social sciences that consider both certainty and uncertainty. It proposes weighing certainty and uncertainty when evaluating hypotheses to make science more objective and multi-polar. The document reviews theories of uncertainty from physics and mathematics and discusses how concepts like fuzzy logic, paradoxes, and cross-cultural research can be applied to social sciences. The goal is to make scientific research more inclusive of diverse contexts and needs of societies to better serve social progress.
Development of Social Sciences in Dissertations of Immanuel Wallerstein - Imp...RemigiuszRosicki
This paper presents an analysis of the social science development concept of Immanuel Wallerstein. In general terms we can say that the development of social sciences was based on a process of emancipation of individual subjects of research and validation of research methods.
I. Wallerstein drew attention to the process of emancipation of individual disciplines, therefore
we can talk about the separation of philosophy, followed by social sciences and, negatively evaluated by I. Wallerstein, applied social sciences. With the constitution of individual disciplines
we dealt with the process of polarising methodological positions, which can be roughly described as the concept of two cultures. The text describes the following issues: (1) the directions
of emancipation of scientific disciplines, (2) the processes of emancipation of scientific disciplines, (3) the dynamics of changes in social sciences, (4) the effects of changes occurring in sciences. In addition to the main assumptions of I. Wallerstein on science, the text attempts to confront these assumptions with the achievements of T. S. Kuhn, R. K. Merton and C. W. Mills. The aim of the article is to point out the implications for the “theory of international relations” deriving from the general trends in the development of social sciences. This issue has come down to only selected issues of: microscopisation, idealisation, metaphorical use, deformation, transcendentalisation, fictionalisation and fetishisation of notions in the “theory of international relations”.
Sujay Academic freedom versus social responsibility for researchers FINAL FIN...Sujay Rao Mandavilli
This document discusses the concepts of academic freedom and social responsibility. It explores tensions between the two, noting that while academic freedom is important for open inquiry, it cannot override social responsibilities and must be balanced. The document provides historical context for the development of academic freedom as a concept. It notes the need for strengthened codes of conduct and ethics for scholars to emphasize their duties to society. While academic freedom allows important work, unrestricted freedom could undermine integrity and produce harmful results. Overall responsibility to science and society must be considered alongside freedom of research and teaching.
THE SELF CRITICISM OF SCIENCE - ALEXIS KARPOUZOSalexis karpouzos
The neoteric human being is now being cut off from the order of nature and establishes itself as the rationally re- flecting and acting subject which is now posited against the object of its cognitive and practical activity. Civiliza- tion is constituted as the product of human activity, as an artifact and technical construct. iWth this development, human civilization is transformed to a ‘quasi nature’, aim- ing to correct and replace nature, and man assumes the nature of a technical existence. By ‘technical existence’ we mean the prevalence of a one-dimensional image of the human person as the producer of rational hypotheses and interpretations and the downgrading and degrada- tion of the non-rational element of human existence, i.e. the radical imagination as a creative capacity, which forms the a priori condition and prerequisite for social activity. This constitutive element of the modern world (man, as the producer of rational hypotheses) and its ar- ticulation with the ideology of techno-scientific progress and the evolution of the machine that transforms the methods and theories of natural sciences, arming these with new tools and constantly renovating their research and experimental capabilities, finally led to the replace- ment of religious and metaphysical dogmas by the blind faith to the dogma of technical and scientific progress.
Sociology aims to study society using scientific methods like those used in natural sciences. However, whether sociology can truly be considered a science is debated. Society consists of humans and human behavior/ideas, which are more difficult to study objectively and empirically compared to natural phenomena. Positivism approaches sociology as an objective, empirical science, while interpretivism argues human behavior has meaningful context beyond just observation and measurement. Ultimately, what constitutes valid knowledge and scientific truth depends on one's philosophical views about reality and the nature of human behavior.
This document summarizes the major philosophical perspectives in education. It discusses idealism, realism, naturalism, pragmatism, progressivism, existentialism, essentialism, perennialism, social reconstructionism, and critical theory. It provides an overview of each perspective, including a discussion of Plato's idealism and the influence of the Sophists. The purpose is to help readers classify, analyze, and apply these perspectives to examine their own philosophies of leadership and teaching.
This document discusses the epistemology and methodology of Islamic economics. It begins by defining epistemology as the theory of knowledge that examines the origin, structure, and validity of scientific knowledge. It then discusses the relationship between epistemology and empirical science, noting that epistemology provides a philosophical framework for the scientific method while empirical science involves applying that method to discover realities. The document also introduces naturalistic epistemology, which emphasizes applying methods and theories from empirical sciences to the study of knowledge. It concludes by explaining how epistemology impacts empirical science by encouraging critical thinking, reflecting on assumptions and methods, and providing a logical foundation for the scientific method.
This document discusses guidelines for formulating hypotheses in the social sciences based on the concepts of certainty and uncertainty. It proposes a "Certainty-uncertainty principle" that evaluates hypotheses by weighing certainties against uncertainties. The paper discusses existing theories on uncertainty from physics, like the uncertainty principle in quantum mechanics. It also discusses Gödel's incompleteness theorem in mathematics and Tarski's undefinability theorem. The paper aims to make identifying and evaluating uncertainties as important as certainties in hypotheses. This approach hopes to make social science research more objective, reliable and applicable across diverse cultural contexts by incorporating varied perspectives from around the world.
Scientism, or the unity of scientific method. The positivist
methodology does not see any difference between the
natural and the social sciences. The adoption however, of
the unity of the scientific method is accepted in tandem
with the notion of the predominant role of the natural
sciences, in which the social sciences see their model.
The outcome is what we call scientism, that is the view
that only the natural sciences can produce the semantic
interpretation of knowledge.
This document provides an overview and analysis of Alexis Karpouzos's book "The self-criticism of science". It discusses some of the key arguments and criticisms addressed against positivism in the contemporary philosophy of science, including criticisms of scientism, empiricism, and the idea that science can provide value-neutral or objective knowledge. It also summarizes some of the alternative perspectives proposed, such as phenomenology and conventionalism.
This document discusses the relationship between science and philosophy. It provides definitions of science as the study of natural phenomena through observation and experimentation with the goal of discovering general truths and laws. Philosophy is defined as the study of knowledge, reality, and ethics through reflection rather than empirical discovery. The philosophy of science examines the methods and justification of scientific claims.
The relationship between science and philosophy is examined in three ways: they can deal with different subject matters, philosophy can be an extension of science by evaluating scientific concepts and theories, or philosophy can describe realities independent of science. While science studies empirical facts, philosophy clarifies scientific language and theories. Both fields influence each other as science is not purely objective and philosophy reflects on scientific findings.
The contemporary philosophy of science & the problem of the scientific consciousness.
...The understanding of scientific knowledge requires reflective thinking. The reflective thinking could restore the communication between subject and object, between social sciences and natural sciences. Only then, communication between facts and values can achieved. In other words, communication between reason and myth, science and art, knowledge and wisdom, empirical research and the existential question for the meaning of life.
...the problem of scientific consciousness (liability) requires the transformation of the structures of the same knowledge. The sovereignty of uncontrolled scientism-positivism leads to brutalization and the reaction to it, leads to metaphysical obscurantism and madness. The researcher should be aware of the complex and reciprocal relationships between the scientific, technical, social and political worlds...
This document discusses using methods from physics to approach social planning and the social sciences. It notes that while physics relies on observation and experimentation to develop laws, the social sciences involve human observation and participation that complicate establishing general patterns. While some efforts have been made to apply physics results to society, success has been limited. The document argues that observation methods from physics could still benefit social sciences and planning by establishing basic data through improved interview techniques that select respondents based on relevant parameters rather than aiming for random representation.
Sujay Inductive, nomothetic approaches and grounded theory FINAL FINAL FINAL ...Sujay Rao Mandavilli
This document discusses inductive and deductive approaches to theory building in social sciences research. It recommends using both nomothetic (law-building) and idiographic (case-specific) approaches, as well as grounded theory which generates theories from real-world data. The document aims to promote more inclusive globalized approaches to increase the quality and impact of social sciences research. It relates this topic to the author's previous work on responsibilities of researchers and principles like exceptionism, uncertainty, and cross-cultural research design.
Sujay Inductive, nomothetic approaches and grounded theory FINAL FINAL FINAL ...Sujay Rao Mandavilli
This paper evaluates both inductive and deductive methods with respect to theory building particularly
in the social sciences. The former is an approach for drawing conclusions by proceeding from the specific
to the general, while as per the latter, a hypothesis is usually developed and subsequently tested based
on further evidence. This paper also evaluates nomothetic approaches in opposition to idiographic or
stand-alone approaches with respect to theorization or theory-formulation as well, and recommends
that a combination of the two be used. It also discusses the application of grounded theory in social
sciences research besides other approaches to theorization as well. While choosing a appropriate
research method is the prerogative of the researcher, based on the research question involved, the
researcher’s personal inclinations, besides time and cost considerations, this paper hopes to generate
awareness of more globalized and inclusive approaches to scientific endeavour. This is as such, our fifth
paper on the philosophy of science, and extends our earlier work which primarily focused on the
importance of the social duties of every researcher and scholar, the principle of exceptionism or the
sociological ninety ten rule, the certainty uncertainty principle, and the importance of cross-cultural
research design. This paper is also therefore the logical culmination of all our earlier endeavours, and
forms an integral part of our “Globalization of science” movement, with particular emphasis on the
social sciences.
1) The document discusses the theoretical approaches to social pedagogy in Denmark from the 1970s-1980s. Two main schools of thought emerged: a Marxist approach focused on group dynamics, and a North American pragmatic approach focused on everyday experiences.
2) In the late 1980s-1990s, approaches drew from German critical theory and focused more on communication and emotional exchange. However, empirical research was still lacking.
3) The document argues for a third theoretical approach drawing from French philosophers like Bourdieu that examines social pedagogy as a social occurrence rather than just an experience. It emphasizes analyzing power relations and how dominated groups accept their position in society.
This document discusses the relationship between academic freedom and social responsibility for researchers and scholars. It argues that while academic freedom is important for open inquiry, it cannot override social responsibility and must emphasize a scholar's duties to science, society, and education. Ethics and codes of conduct around these issues are currently inadequate and need to be strengthened, consolidated, and enforced through university mandates. Moving forward, emphasizing social responsibilities should extend across all fields of social science and become a major movement in the 21st century.
The Influence of Green Tax Implementation and Social Responsibility Programs ...AJHSSR Journal
ABSTRACT : The issue of climate change related to carbon emissions has become an alarming global
phenomenon. The manufacturing sector contributes significantly to global greenhouse gas emissions. Therefore,
efforts to mitigate climate change through the implementation of green taxes and Social Responsibility
Programsare important for manufacturing industry. This research aims to analyze the effect of implementing
green tax and Social Responsibility Programs on environmentally sustainable development in manufacturing
industry. A quantitative approach is used with the research object of manufacturing industry listed on the
Indonesia Stock Exchange in 2020-2022. Analyzed using Partial Least Square (PLS) method. The research
results show that the implementation of green tax has a significant effect on environmentally sustainable
development, while Social Responsibility Programsdo not have a significant effect. These findings indicate that
green tax policies are effective in encouraging companies to switch to more environmentally friendly business
practices, but Social Responsibility Programshave not been fully integrated with environmental sustainability
efforts. This research contributes to the literature related to fiscal policy instruments and corporate social
responsibility practices in supporting environmentally sound sustainable development in the manufacturing
sector.
KEYWORDS: Green tax; Social responsibility; Environmentally sustainable development; Manufacturing
industry
Creating Immersive Language Learning Environments for Young LearnersAJHSSR Journal
ABSTRACT: Creating immersive language learning environments for young learners in English as a Foreign
Language (EFL) contexts has been a topic of considerable interest and debate among educators. Despite
numerous constraints such as time, curriculum, and stakeholder expectations, it is feasible to develop effective
immersive environments. This paper explores the concept of immersion language learning, tracing its historical
development and highlighting its benefits, particularly for young learners. It discusses the distinctions between
total, partial, and dual-immersion programs, emphasizing the critical role of using the target language as the
medium of instruction. Furthermore, it examines the cognitive and academic advantages documented in seminal
immersion programs like Saint-Lambert and Coral Way. By synthesizing research and offering practical
strategies for EFL settings, this paper underscores the importance of teacher commitment, the selection of
appropriate materials, and the adoption of Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL) principles.
Ultimately, the findings affirm that immersive environments significantly enhance language proficiency,
cognitive flexibility, and academic achievement, advocating for their broader implementation in EFL
classrooms.
KEYWORDS : CLIL, EFL, immersion, young learners
Study of Road Patterns and Space Formation in Settlement Areas on the Edge of...AJHSSR Journal
ABSTRACT: This research aims to find developments in road patterns from 2008 to 2024 and explain the
influence of road patterns on the formation of settlements on the edge of Lake Laut Tawar. This research uses a
quantitative descriptive approach and diachronic reading analysis techniques. This research uses overlapping
maps (superimpose), surveys, and interviews. The results of this research are to find factors that influence the
formation of settlements on the edge of Lake Laut Tawar, including the flat topographic conditions. Demographics
continue to increase in the population of the study location. The social culture at the study location is that the
residents who live on the edges of Lake Laut Tawar are residents who have family relationships. Distribution of
space designations that change function from agricultural land to residential land. Land values vary on the edges
of Lake Laut Tawar according to their zones.
KEYWORDS : Road Pattern, Lake Edge, Laut Tawar Lake
HAPIS AT KATANUNGAN, PANGUNGULILA NG MGA NAIWAN: SIPAT-SURI SA MAIKLING KUWEN...AJHSSR Journal
ABSTRAK: Ang pagpapatiwakal o sariling pagtapos ng buhay ay isang malubhang dilema na madalas na
kinahaharap ng isang taong nakararanas ng malalim na hirap at kalungkutan. Ang isa sa mga dahilan ng
pagpapatiwakal ay ang pagtingin dito bilang isang paraan ng pagtakas mula sa mga suliranin at hamon ng buhay.
Ang pagsusuri sa maikling kuwentong "Bahay sa Dilim" ni Alfredo Enriquez ay isang uri ng kwalitatibong
pananaliksik na gumamit ng pagsusuring pangnilalaman upang maabot ang layunin nito na tukuyin at
maipaliwanag ang mga isyu ng dilema at desisyon sa pagpapatiwakal, pagmamahal sa pamilya, at pangungulila
at pagsisisi. Sa paggamit ng mga teoryang pampanitikan tulad ng eksistensyalismo at romantisismo bilang mga
gabay, ninais ng mga mananaliksik na magbigay-liwanag at solusyon sa mga isyu ng pagpapatiwakal. Ito ay
magiging patnubay sa pagpapalawak ng kaalaman tungkol sa mga suliranin at karanasan ng mga pamilyang
Pilipino, pati na rin sa mga laban na hinaharap ng isang tao na nakararanas ng isang dilema. Sa dulo, hinahamon
ng pag-aaral na ito na gamitin pa ang iba't ibang uri ng panitikan na mas naglalarawan ng tunay na karanasan at
realidad ng buhay.
KEYWORDS : pagpapatiwakal, dilema, kalungkutan, buhay, pangungulila
Risk Tolerance as A Moderation of Financial Literacy and Lifestyle on Old Age...AJHSSR Journal
ABSTRACT:Old age financial planning must consider various factors, such as retirement age, estimated
monthly expenses in retirement, life expectancy, current and projected income until retirement which determines
the ability to save, assets and investments already owned, and the impact of inflation on future purchasing
power. Future, as well as the level of investment return. This research is causal associative research, this
research uses a quantitative approach. The population used in this research were employees within the Rectorate
of the University of Mataram, 67 Civil Servants. The saturated sampling method or total sampling is a sampling
technique in which all members of the population are used as samples. In this questionnaire, respondents'
answers were measured using a 6-point Likert scale: with ratings of 1 (strongly disagree), 2 (disagree), 3
(somewhat disagree), 4 (somewhat agree), 5 (agree), 6 (strongly agree). The Partial Least Square-Structural
Equation Model (PLS-SEM) with smart PLS 3.0 software was used to analyze the research data. The study's
findings indicate that financial literacy is found to have a positive and significant impact on old-age financial
planning among Rectorate employees at the University of Mataram. This indicates that as financial literacy
levels increase, so do activities relate to planning for retirement. Conversely, lifestyle does not exhibit a
significant influence on old-age financial planning for these employees. Furthermore, the interaction between
financial literacy and risk tolerance weakens the effect of financial literacy on retirement financial planning,
implying that higher risk tolerance diminishes the impact of financial literacy on planning for retirement.
However, risk tolerance does not moderate the influence of lifestyle on old-age financial planning, indicating
that the interaction between lifestyle and risk tolerance does not significantly affect retirement financial
planning for Rectorate employees at Mataram University.
KEYWORDS :Risk Tolerance, Financial Literacy, Lifestyle, Old Age Financial Planning
THE INFLUENCE OF APPLICATION FEATURES AND SECURITY THROUGH TRUST ON BRImo CUS...AJHSSR Journal
ABSTRACT : This research objective is to determine the influence of application features and security
through trust on BRImo customer loyalty in Banyuwangi. This research used the Explanatory Research type.
The population used in this research is all customers who use the BRImo application as of the end of December
2022 at the BRI Banyuwangi office, totaling 89,333 customers. The sampling technique in this research used a
multistage random sampling technique (multi stage sampling). In this study, the criteria used were customers
who happened to use the BRImo application and were financially registered, totaling 100 respondents. The data
analysis method used Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) with the SmaprtPLS application. The research
results showed that Application Features influence BRIMo Trust in Banyuwangi Regency. Security influenced
BRIMo's trust in Banyuwangi Regency. Application features influenced BRIMo customer loyalty in
Banyuwangi Regency. Security influenced BRIMo Customer Loyalty in Banyuwangi Regency. Trust influenced
BRIMo Customer Loyalty in Banyuwangi Regency. Trust mediated the influence of Application Features on
BRIMo Customer Loyalty in Banyuwangi Regency. Trust mediated the influence of Security on BRIMo
Customer Loyalty in Banyuwangi Regency.
KEYWORDS : Application feature, security, trust, loyalty
On Storytelling & Magic Realism in Rushdie’s Midnight’s Children, Shame, and ...AJHSSR Journal
ABSTRACT: Salman Rushdie’s novels are humorous books about serious times. His cosmopolitanism and
hybrid identity allowed him access to multiple cultures, religions, languages, dialects, and various modes of
writing. His style is often classified as magic realism, blending the imaginary with the real. He draws
inspiration from both English literature and Indian classical sources. Throughout his works, there is a lineage of
‘bastards of history’, a carnival of shameful characters scrolling all along his works. Rushdie intertwines fiction
with reality, incorporating intertextual references to Western literature in his texts, and frequently employing
mythology to explore history. This paper focuses on Rushdie’s three novels: Midnight’s Children, Shame, and
Haroun and the Sea of Stories, analyzing his postmodern storytelling techniques that aim to explore human
vices and follies while offering socio-political criticism.
KEYWORDS : Magic Realism, Rushdie, Satire, Storytelling, Transfictional Identities
CYBER SECURITY ENHANCEMENT IN NIGERIA. A CASE STUDY OF SIX STATES IN THE NORT...AJHSSR Journal
ABSTRACT: Security plays an important role in human life and endeavors. Securing information and
disseminating are critical challenges in the present day. This study aimed at identifying innovative technologies
that aid cybercrimes and can constitute threats to cybersecurity in North Central (Middle Belt) Nigeria covering
its six States and the FCT Abuja. A survey research design was adopted. The researchers employed the use of
Google form in administering the structured questionnaire. The instruments were faced validated by one expert
each from ICT and security. Cronbach Alpha reliability Coefficient was employed and achieved 0.83 level of
coefficient. The population of the study was 200, comprising 100 undergraduate students from computer science
and Computer/Robotics Education, 80 ICT instructors, technologists and lecturers in the University and
Technical Colleges in the Middle Belt Nigeria using innovative technologies for their daily jobs and 20 officers
of the crime agency such as: Independent Corrupt Practices Commission (ICPC) andEconomic and Financial
Crimes Commission (EFCC). Three research purposes and questions as well as the hypothesis guided the study
on Five (5) point Likert scale. Data collected were analyzed using mean and standard deviation for the three
research questions while three hypotheses were tested using t-test at 0.05 level of significance. Major findings
revealed that serious steps are needed to better secure the cybers against cybercrimes. Motivation, types, threats
and strategies for the prevention of cybercrimes were identified. The study recommends that government,
organizations and individuals should place emphasis on moral development, regular training of its employees,
regular update of software, use strong password, back up data and information, produce strong cybersecurity
policy, install antivirus soft and security surveillance (CCTV) in offices in order to safeguard its employees and
properties from being hacked and vandalized.
KEYWORDS: Cybersecurity, cybercrime, cyberattack, cybercriminal, computer virus, Virtual Private Networks
(VPN).
TACKLING ILLEGAL LOGGING: PROBLEMS AND CHALLENGESAJHSSR Journal
ABSTRACT: Illegal logging poses significant environmental, economic, and social challenges worldwide. This
research explores the problems associated with illegal logging in the present and future, shedding light on the
multifaceted nature of this issue and the accompanying challenges faced by governments, organizations, and
communities. The study employs a comprehensive literature review to analyze the current state of illegal
logging, its causes, and its consequences. It examines the environmental impact of deforestation, including
biodiversity loss, habitat degradation, and climate change. The researchers identify the challenges faced in
combating illegal logging in the present and anticipate future obstacles. It considers illegal logging networks'
complex and elusive nature, the limited enforcement capacity, and the need for international cooperation and
coordination. The study also examines the adoption and effectiveness of policies, regulations, and technological
advancements in curbing illegal logging practices in Davao City.
Keywords -Problems and Challenges, Cultural Disruptions, Anticipate future problems.
Towards Developing Students’ Soft Skills: The Case of ENSAM StudentsAJHSSR Journal
ABSTRACT: Building students’ soft skills has started to gain ground within the realm of higher education in
Morocco. However, the development of these skills requires a real-life context which simplifies their learning.
In this regard, the present study is mainly conducted to investigate the effect of the out-group collaborative
learning method on the development of students’ soft skills. Data for the study comes from 20 semester two
students at “Ecole Nationale Superieure d'Arts et Metiers” (ENSAM), Moulay Ismail University, Meknes, by
implementing a one-group pretest-posttest research design. The qualitative and quantitative findings confirm
that there is a statistically significant difference between the pretest and posttest results. Therefore, the adopted
treatment, the out-group collaborative learning method, has improved students’ communication, adaptability and
presentation delivery skills. The findings of this study can be useful for future studies and give language
teachers insights into the importance of using the out-group collaborative learning method in their teaching of
the soft skills.
KEYWORDS : collaborative learning, soft-skills, out-group collaborative learning method
STUDY ON THE DEVELOPMENT STRATEGY OF HUZHOU TOURISMAJHSSR Journal
ABSTRACT: Huzhou has rich tourism resources, as early as a considerable development since the reform and
opening up, especially in recent years, Huzhou tourism has ushered in a new period of development
opportunities. At present, Huzhou tourism has become one of the most characteristic tourist cities on the East
China tourism line. With the development of Huzhou City, the tourism industry has been further improved, and
the tourism degree of the whole city has further increased the transformation and upgrading of the tourism
industry. However, the development of tourism in Huzhou City still lags far behind the tourism development of
major cities in East China. This round of research mainly analyzes the current development of tourism in
Huzhou City, on the basis of analyzing the specific situation, pointed out that the current development of
Huzhou tourism problems, and then analyzes these problems one by one, and put forward some specific
solutions, so as to promote the further rapid development of tourism in Huzhou City.
KEYWORDS:Huzhou; Travel; Development
Enhancing Losari Beach Exploration: Augmented Reality for Immersive Visualiza...AJHSSR Journal
ABSTRACT: South Sulawesi, commonly known as Makassar, boasts rich cultural heritage and customs,
making it a prominent destination for tourism. Among its attractions, Losari beach stands out as a focal point for
visitors seeking to explore the city's natural beauty and cultural offerings. In this context, leveraging modern
technology such as augmented reality presents an innovative approach to showcasing Losari beach to potential
tourists. This research endeavors to introduce tourism assets in a more visually captivating manner through the
use of augmented reality. Utilizing software tools like Unity and Adobe Illustrator, the study focuses on creating
an immersive experience where tourists can interact with virtual representations of Losari beach. By simply
pointing their mobile phone cameras at designated markers or using barcode scanners, tourists can access
augmented reality features embedded within the application. The findings of this research aim to provide
valuable information, particularly for foreign tourists, about Losari beach, positioning it as a compelling
destination within South Sulawesi's diverse array of tourist attractions. Through this technological innovation,
the study seeks to enhance the visibility and appeal of Makassar city's tourism offerings on a global scale.
KEYWORDS: Visualizing, Losari Beach, Augmented Reality
DEVELOPMENT STATUS AND COUNTERMEASURES OF TMALL DURING THE COVID-19 EPIDEMICAJHSSR Journal
ABSTRACT:China's e-commerce enterprises have developed rapidly, among which Tmall has become one of
the largest retail shopping websites in China.But in the past year, the Covid-19 epidemic has brought a huge
impact to Chinese e-commerce enterprises, and Tmall is no exception.Therefore, the development status of
Tmall in the new crown epidemic situation was analyzed, and the viewpoint was put forward :Tmall1 stabilized
the situation in the face of the epidemic situation and made a very correct countermeasures.The influence of this
epidemic on Tmall was deeply analyzed, and the conclusion was made: the new crown epidemic is both a
challenge and an opportunity forTmall.
KEYWORDS:Tmall; COVID - 19 outbreak ; The electronic commerce
Factors affecting undergraduate students’ motivation at a university in Tra VinhAJHSSR Journal
ABSTRACT: Motivation plays an important role in foreign language learning process. This study aimed to
investigate student’s motivation patterns towards English language learning at a University in Tra Vinh, and factors
affecting their motivation change toward English language learning of non-English-major students in the semester.
The researcher used semi-structured interview at the first phase of choosing the participants and writing reflection
through the instrument called “My English Learning Motivation History” adapted from Sawyer (2007) to collect
qualitative data within 15 weeks. The participants consisted of nine first year non-English-major students who learning
General English at pre-intermediate level. They were chosen and divided into three groups of three members each
(high motivation group; average motivation group; and low motivation group). The results of the present study
identified six visual motivation patterns of three groups of students with different motivation fluctuation, through the
use of cluster analysis. The study also indicated a diversity of factors affecting students’ motivation involving internal
factors as influencing factors (cognitive, psychology, and emotion) and external factors as social factors (instructor,
peers, family, and learning environment) during English language learning in a period of 15 weeks. The findings of
the study helped teacher understand relationship of motivation change and its influential factors. Furthermore, the
findings also inspired next research about motivation development in learning English process.
KEY WORDS: language learning motivation, motivation change, motivation patterns, influential factors, students’
motivation.
The Impact of Work Stress and Digital Literacy on Employee Performance at PT ...AJHSSR Journal
ABSTRACT :This research aims to analyze the correlation between employee work stress and digital literacy
with employee performance at PT Telkom Akses Area Cirebon, both concurrently and partially. Employing a
quantitative approach, the study's objectives are descriptive and causal, adopting a positivist paradigm with a
deductive approach to theory development and a survey research strategy. Findings reveal that work stress
negatively and significantly impacts employee performance, while digital literacy positively and significantly
affects it. Simultaneously, work stress and digital literacy have a positive and significant influence on employee
performance. It is anticipated that company management will devise workload management strategies to
alleviate work stress and assess the implementation of more efficient digital technology to enhance employee
performance.
KEYWORDS -digital literacy, employee performance,job stress, multiple regression analysis, workload
management
The Settlement of Construction Disputes Through Dispute Councils From the Per...AJHSSR Journal
ABSTRACT:This research differs from the practice of business activity in the construction services industry,
which may lead to construction disputes. The settlement of construction disputes is a consensus based on the
basic principle of debate. If the discussions between the parties do not reach an agreement, the parties may take
measures to resolve the dispute through the dispute council. Because the standard governing the disputes
committee was not fully regulated, they did not comply with the principle of legal certainty. Therefore, further
research was needed to establish a theoretical basis for regulating the disputes committee in settling construction
disputes. This research is a standard legal research using a legal regulatory, conceptual, and comparative
approach. The research results show that the ideal concept of resolving construction disputes through a dispute
council based on the value of legal certainty is to establish that the position of the dispute council is a special
court that has the authority to resolve construction disputes under construction services agreements. To realize
the position of the Court of Disputation as a special court, it must be based on the creation of philosophical
values, the creationof legislative regulations, and the creation of the institutional structure of the Court of
Disputation.
KEYWORDS-Construction Disputes, Dispute Council, Special Court
VALUES OF ORAL LITERATURE IN THE SOCIETY: A STUDY OF FOLKTALES OFOGBA IN RIVE...AJHSSR Journal
ABSTRACT : Oral literature is a creative work of art that portends high merit and has the creative use of
imagination in preliterate societies. It adopts the genres of literature: drama, prose and poetry in the oral milieu,
using performance as its hallmark. It thrives on the use of oral data because of its orality. This paper focuses on
the moral values or oral literature in the society using Ogba as a spring board. The study was carried out in
communities ofOgba. The population of the study consists of ten towns and village, in Ogba. The theoretical
framework used is Dell Hyme’s ethno-poetics because the works of oral literature relate to the society. This
paper concludes that oral literature serves to against all odds; communicate ideas, emotions, beliefs and
appreciation of life. The folktales in Ogba for instance, serve similar purpose through their
rendition/performance. Through the stories, the younger generation in Ogba society is familiarised with the
customs, traditions, and rituals prevalent in the society. This paper therefore recommends the use of oral
literature in all its genres to inculcate moral values and lessons to the teenagers and youths. Against this
background, Ogba (African) themselves must cease to regard oral literature as primitive and fetish.
KEYWORDS: Values, Oral Literature, Society, Ogba, Folktales
Pormalistikong Pagdalumat sa mga Tula ni Ron CanimoAJHSSR Journal
ABSTRACT: Nilayon ng pag-aaral na ito na masuri ang dalawampung (20) tula ni Ron Canimo gamit ang
pormalistikong dulog batay sa mga sumusunod na elemento: (a) Sukat at Tugma, (b) Talinghaga at
Simbolismo, (c) Imahen, (d) Tema, at (e) Diksiyon. Layunin din nitong mataya ang antas ng pagtanggap ng
ginawang pagsusuri gamit ang nabuong instrumento sa pagtataya nito. Sinunod dito ang Input-Process-Output
na balangkas ng pag-aaral at ginamitan ng kwantitatib-deskriptib-ebalwatib na pamamaraan. Sa pamamagitan
ng talatanungang ibinatay sa ginamit ni Morales (2014) na naimodipika ayon sa kahingian ng kasalukuyang
pag-aaral, tatlong (3) gurong eksperto ang nagsilbing tagataya dito na siyang tumiyak sa kahusayan ng nabuong
pagsusuri ng mananaliksik. Gamit ang Content Analysis, natuklasan na makabagong pamamaraan ang istilo na
ginamit ni Ron Canimo sa pagsulat ng mga tula. Lahat ng kanyang mga tula ay walang sinusunod na sukat at
tugma, may iba‟t ibang tayutay at simbolismong ginamit, magkaibang pandama ang pinagana dahil sa mga
imahe at paglalarawang ginawa, iba‟t ibang uri ng pag-ibig ang tinalakay at gumamit ng pormal, impormal o
kumbersasyonal na wika at makabagong istilo sa pagsulat ng tula. Gamit ang mean at standard deviation,
lumabas na “Mataas” ang antas ng pagtanggap sa kabuuan ng mga gurong eksperto na tumaya sa nabuong
pagsusuri. Lumabas din na “Mataas” ang antas ng kanilang pagtanggap sa nabuong pagsusuri batay sa mga
sumusunod na elemento: (a) Sukat at Tugma, (b) Talinghaga at Simbolismo, (c) Imahen, (d) Tema, at (e)
Diksiyon. Mula sa natayang pagsusuri at kinalabasan ng antas ng pagtanggap dito, naitala ang mga paksa sa
Junior High School Filipino na maaaring lapatan at gamitan ng nabuong pagsusuri.
KEYWORDS: Kumbensyunal, Pagdalumat, Pormalistiko, Ron Canimo, Tula
SCHOOL CULTURE ADAPTATION AMONG INDIGENOUS PEOPLES COLLEGE STUDENTS AT A PRIV...AJHSSR Journal
ABSTRACT: This qualitative study investigates the adaption experiences of indigenous college students at the
University of Mindanao, Matina-main campus. Eight major themes emerged, including difficulties with language
proficiency, online learning, classroom interaction, examination systems, grading procedures, school regulations,
resource accessibility, coping mechanisms, and future goals. Implications include the requirement for targeted
language proficiency and technology use support, an understanding of adaption processes, interventions to
improve resource accessibility, and equitable public administration policies. The study underlines the importance
of adaptation in various educational contexts, as well as the role of educators and legislators in creating inclusive
learning environments.
KEYWORDS: indigenous college students, adaptation, educational challenges, coping strategies
The effect of Institutional Ownership, Sales Growth and Profitability on Tax ...AJHSSR Journal
ABSTRACT: This research aims to test, analyze and obtain empirical evidence about the influence of
institutional ownership, sales growth and profitability on tax avoidance. The object of this research is
manufacturing companies in the consumer goods industry sector listed on the Indonesia Stock Exchange (BEI)
in 2018-2022. This research used quantitative research methods and causal research design. The sampling
technique in this research used non-probability sampling with purposive sampling as the basis for determining
the sample so that a sample of 55 samples was obtained. The data used is secondary data obtained from the
official website of the Indonesia Stock Exchange (BEI) during the 2018-2022 period. The data analysis method
used was multiple linear regression analysis with several tests such as descriptive statistical tests, classical
assumption tests, and hypothesis testing using SPSS version 26 statistical software. The results showed that the
institutional ownership variable has no effect on tax avoidance, while the sales growth and profitability has a
negative and significant effect on tax avoidance.
KEYWORDS: Institutional Ownership, Sales Growth, Profitability, Tax Avoidance
Leveraging Generative AI to Drive Nonprofit InnovationTechSoup
In this webinar, participants learned how to utilize Generative AI to streamline operations and elevate member engagement. Amazon Web Service experts provided a customer specific use cases and dived into low/no-code tools that are quick and easy to deploy through Amazon Web Service (AWS.)
Elevate Your Nonprofit's Online Presence_ A Guide to Effective SEO Strategies...TechSoup
Whether you're new to SEO or looking to refine your existing strategies, this webinar will provide you with actionable insights and practical tips to elevate your nonprofit's online presence.
Temple of Asclepius in Thrace. Excavation resultsKrassimira Luka
The temple and the sanctuary around were dedicated to Asklepios Zmidrenus. This name has been known since 1875 when an inscription dedicated to him was discovered in Rome. The inscription is dated in 227 AD and was left by soldiers originating from the city of Philippopolis (modern Plovdiv).
Chapter wise All Notes of First year Basic Civil Engineering.pptxDenish Jangid
Chapter wise All Notes of First year Basic Civil Engineering
Syllabus
Chapter-1
Introduction to objective, scope and outcome the subject
Chapter 2
Introduction: Scope and Specialization of Civil Engineering, Role of civil Engineer in Society, Impact of infrastructural development on economy of country.
Chapter 3
Surveying: Object Principles & Types of Surveying; Site Plans, Plans & Maps; Scales & Unit of different Measurements.
Linear Measurements: Instruments used. Linear Measurement by Tape, Ranging out Survey Lines and overcoming Obstructions; Measurements on sloping ground; Tape corrections, conventional symbols. Angular Measurements: Instruments used; Introduction to Compass Surveying, Bearings and Longitude & Latitude of a Line, Introduction to total station.
Levelling: Instrument used Object of levelling, Methods of levelling in brief, and Contour maps.
Chapter 4
Buildings: Selection of site for Buildings, Layout of Building Plan, Types of buildings, Plinth area, carpet area, floor space index, Introduction to building byelaws, concept of sun light & ventilation. Components of Buildings & their functions, Basic concept of R.C.C., Introduction to types of foundation
Chapter 5
Transportation: Introduction to Transportation Engineering; Traffic and Road Safety: Types and Characteristics of Various Modes of Transportation; Various Road Traffic Signs, Causes of Accidents and Road Safety Measures.
Chapter 6
Environmental Engineering: Environmental Pollution, Environmental Acts and Regulations, Functional Concepts of Ecology, Basics of Species, Biodiversity, Ecosystem, Hydrological Cycle; Chemical Cycles: Carbon, Nitrogen & Phosphorus; Energy Flow in Ecosystems.
Water Pollution: Water Quality standards, Introduction to Treatment & Disposal of Waste Water. Reuse and Saving of Water, Rain Water Harvesting. Solid Waste Management: Classification of Solid Waste, Collection, Transportation and Disposal of Solid. Recycling of Solid Waste: Energy Recovery, Sanitary Landfill, On-Site Sanitation. Air & Noise Pollution: Primary and Secondary air pollutants, Harmful effects of Air Pollution, Control of Air Pollution. . Noise Pollution Harmful Effects of noise pollution, control of noise pollution, Global warming & Climate Change, Ozone depletion, Greenhouse effect
Text Books:
1. Palancharmy, Basic Civil Engineering, McGraw Hill publishers.
2. Satheesh Gopi, Basic Civil Engineering, Pearson Publishers.
3. Ketki Rangwala Dalal, Essentials of Civil Engineering, Charotar Publishing House.
4. BCP, Surveying volume 1
How Barcodes Can Be Leveraged Within Odoo 17Celine George
In this presentation, we will explore how barcodes can be leveraged within Odoo 17 to streamline our manufacturing processes. We will cover the configuration steps, how to utilize barcodes in different manufacturing scenarios, and the overall benefits of implementing this technology.
This presentation was provided by Rebecca Benner, Ph.D., of the American Society of Anesthesiologists, for the second session of NISO's 2024 Training Series "DEIA in the Scholarly Landscape." Session Two: 'Expanding Pathways to Publishing Careers,' was held June 13, 2024.
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH LỚP 9 CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2024-2025 - ...
On the role of personal epistemology in the study of Science, Technology and Society
1. American Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences Research (AJHSSR) 2019
A J H S S R J o u r n a l P a g e | 11
American Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences Research (AJHSSR)
e-ISSN : 2378-703X
Volume-3, Issue-7, pp-11-17
www.ajhssr.com
Research Paper Open Access
On the role of personal epistemology in the study of Science,
Technology and Society
Maybí Morell
Faculty of Psychology, University of Havana, San Lázaro y L, 10400 La Habana, Cuba
ABSTRACT : The study of the social influence on the scientific praxis is an important branch of social
sciences. This branch, however, has focused mostly on large scale phenomena or otherwise individual ethics. In
this work we propose a way to approach this topic from individual psychological constructs using the
cognitiveframe of personal epistemology. In particular, we show that the insertion of psychological variables to
account for the self-control over personal epistemology is a useful tool facing the modern tendencies of the
scientific work. The pertinence of this approach for a complete analysis of the science agents is discussed in
several perspectives. We recall that, even when socio-scientific dynamics is not reducible to its constituents, it is
precisely within the individuals that many important clues can be found to understend complex collective
behaviors.
KEYWORDS : Personal epistemology, interdisciplinary research, cognitive processes, social sciences
I. INTRODUCTION
The interplay between science and technology is mediated by individuals and its social structures,
which in turn are an expression of the specific context. As it is now extensively accepted [1], the processes of
production, diffusion and application of the scientific knowledge cannot be explained without taking into
account external variables such as economical motivations or political and military interests. With a particular
strength since the last century, these processes link science to all other forms of human activity. In the
following, with the aim of not to neglect the scientific objectivity in the discussion on the influence of social
interests and conventions, we adhere to a two-dimensional operationalization of science: Science as activity and
science as knowledge [2].
This classification is very useful for social researchers, even if its value is only theoretical and the
limits between knowledge and activity is sometimes quite hard to determine. Within this frame, it is assumed
that while science as knowledge is (and has to be) neutral, science as activity can be seen as an institution of the
society an thereforeconstantly permeated and influenced by societal paradigms and structures [3]. In this
approach the science as knowledge guarantees the cognitive value of theories and other expressions of
knowledge, on the basis of intellectual honesty, understood as a commitment with objectivity. While the social
environment is the place where contemporary scientific activity is performed, i.e. the science as activity, the
science as knowledge is developed to a great extent within the scientists and other science agents. Therefore, the
complete analysis of this topic has to include a complementary psychosocial study of the individuals.
In this work we start to build this path, by considering the epistemological beliefs system that
individuals develop during her life, understood in the broad sense of what it is known today as personal
epistemology. We argue that personal epistemology can be used as fundamental variable to unveil the puzzle of
how social and scientific traits are braided within the subjects.
1.1 Theoretical basis
Here we subscribe to the classification of knowledge made by Karl Popper [4] distinguishing between
the knowledge of common sense or ordinary, and the scientific knowledge. In Popper’s epistemological position
the scientific knowledge is considered as a development of ordinary knowledge. In this way science, philosophy
and rational thinking emerges from common sense, even if the latter can be completely false in many situations.
Unlike rationalists and empiricists, this approach do not intends to build a system with immovable grounds. The
common sense is a basic knowledge to start from, a foundational knowledge that is in the basis of any rational
discussion, but their beliefs can and must be questioned and criticized any time [5]. In this way there is a
2. American Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences Research (AJHSSR) 2019
A J H S S R J o u r n a l P a g e | 12
continuity between ordinary and scientific knowledge, being the latter a result of the systematic application of
rational critics on the former.
The psychological theories explaining the evolution of scientific concepts from childhood, establish
that these concepts emerge separated from the so-called spontaneous concepts. This split occurs only at the early
stage of the individuals life and are a result of the fact that its introduction comes from different social agents,
e.g. the school in the case of scientific concepts and the family in the case of spontaneous concepts [6].
However, a very singular interaction is established between these concepts, so that when the child reaches a
developed thinking that allows to operate with hypothesis as mental representations, the strong relationship
between both types of concepts makes them difficult to isolate. In that point the abstract and generalist nature of
the scientific concepts has developed the spontaneous concepts, and these in turn have been the foundational
basis for the scientific concepts to be particularized, applied and operationalized.
From the point of view of the contemporary cognitive psychology, the individual evolution toward a
scientific knowledge is mediated by a complex system of mental processes [7], including not only cognitive but
also affective processes that are connected to the social context and experienced differently for different
subjects. The current perspective is thus less rationalistic, considering the individuals as logically driven and
capable of solving complex problems but at the same time failing to overcome many cognitive biases and
emotional pitfalls that arise even in daily common tasks [8]. This is ultimately the result of its human nature and
its social and cultural interactions through which the conception of reality was shaped and developed.
It is thus comprehensible that the epistemological beliefs will be marked by an idiosyncratic vision of
the nature and the structure of knowledge, as a resemblance of the social, historical and cultural context. In turn,
this construct integrates to the psychological formation that shapes the personality, intervening in the regulation
of the behavior and influencing from inside both the individual practicing of science as activity and the
individual comprehension of science as knowledge.
1.2 General Purpose
Two well defined directions can be drawn regarding the problem of establishing the complex interplay
between science, technology and society through the psychosocial study of the individual subject as central
element. The first one comprises the efforts that attempt to explore the individual as a conscious subject in its
scientific activity. To this field belong for instance the studies of ethics, focused in the cultural influence and
individual responsibility on the scientific praxis, as well as all other approaches to conceptualize and
operationalize individual footprints of the science agents in science and society. But there is a second direction.
That of the systematization of the ideas regarding the way in which the socio-historical context and the science
itself influence the individual. This influence affects the conformation and development of a mental
representation which is precisely the starting point to process the scientific information and deliver its
conclusions in the scientific activity.
The utility of the studies on personal epistemology in the frame of the research on science, technology
and society will be discussed in the following, contextualizing the influence of the social variables on the
individual epistemological structures. The necessity of a new cognitive construct to operationalize the changes
in the representation of the science as knowledge will be discussed as well.
II. THE BELIEFS SYSTEM
In its most simple formulation, the epistemological beliefs are the beliefs that an individual has
regarding the nature of knowledge. This simplicity, however, hides out a discussion extended over decades on
the correct conceptualization of the beliefs. Through these years the contribution of many researchers have built,
from different perspectives and approaches, the conception of what we understand today as system of
epistemological beliefs or personal epistemology.
The pioneer studies carried out by William Perry [9] focused on the effects that student’s
personological characteristics had on the multiple ways they interpreted the educative experiences. He found
certain behavioral patterns that allowed to identify the type of meaning students were likely to give to her own
experience. Moreover, it was shown that in the first years of university studies, perception and judging of
knowledge was less developed that in the last senior years. It was concluded that the epistemological and ethical
development is a qualitative reorganization of the formation of meanings through subsequent stages.
The epistemological development proposed by Perry was further studied by many authors. Some
outstanding researchers defined their own terminology to refer to similar concepts and states according to their
ways of modeling the process, e.g. the model of reflective judgment [10], epistemological reflexion [11] and
argumentative reasoning [12]. New insights were advanced through concepts like ways of knowing [13],
epistemological standards [14] and, eventually, epistemological beliefs [15]. The latter, while sometimes
associated to the original specific model introduced by Schommer [15, 16], has became the most widely
accepted terminology for the current scientific community. The concept of personal epistemology, on the other
3. American Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences Research (AJHSSR) 2019
A J H S S R J o u r n a l P a g e | 13
hand, is representative of a more integrated vision of the many theoretical and methodological approaches for
the same phenomenon, even if different authors use slightly different definitions.
For the purpose of this work the model studied by Schommer offers a suited theoretical frame for the
analysis of the problematic. The model is called system of epistemological beliefs, and it transformed the
comprehension of the personal epistemology construct in the early 90’s by focusing in a multidimensional
perspective. In this frame the personal epistemology is conceived as a system of multiple beliefs, more or less
independents, whose complexity makes it impossible to be described in a general way as a single dimension. In
order to determine the components of this system a type of instrument was designed to group main factors from
simples answers to questions about the nature of knowledge and learning encompassing many possible visions.
The processing of the answers, typically by means of main component factorial analysis, delineates the
individual characterization of the set of epistemological beliefs. Each belief is operationalized as a continuum
component, ranging from the less developed or naive extreme, to the other where beliefs are more developed or
sophisticated. The idea of the relative independence of the beliefs in the system is related to the asynchrony of
the development. It means that a single individual can have at the same time naive and sophisticated beliefs both
coexisting and shaping her personal epistemology. While in general dependent on the context, some particular
beliefs have been found to be widely common and frequently identified across different cultural and academic
environments. The original dimensions proposed in the Schommer’s model [15] are listed below.
Beliefs on the structure of knowledge: Simple and isolated knowledge vs complex and structured.
Beliefs on the certainty or stability of knowledge: Certain, absolute and immovable knowledge vs
tentative, contextual and improvable.
Beliefs on the determinants of knowledge formation: Innate learning vs acquired and socio-culturally
developed.
Beliefs on the velocity of knowledge acquisition: Fast, all-or-nothing learning vs slow and systematic.
Beliefs on the source of knowledge: Knowledge contained in authoritative authorities vs generated by
observation and reasoning.
Beyond the detailed description of the structure of the epistemological beliefs, the contribution of the
model includes an important characterization of the fundamentals of its development. Additionally, this has
motivated a sustained trend of more specific researches to clearly establish the influence of particular belief
dimensions on the learning process. These studies, mostly conducted in academic contexts, apply
methodological tools that are based on large samples and allow further generalization [17, 18, 19].
2.1 Sophistication and scientific conception of reality
The studies on personal epistemology are mostly conducted within the fields of cognitive and
educational psychology and use questionnaires and multidimensional analysis as well as interviews and other
qualitative instruments. In both type of approaches the epistemological beliefs are evaluated in a scale, ordinal
or not, ranging beliefs from naive to sophisticated. While dominant in the scientific literature, the basis of this
evaluation has received several critics [20] and motivated improvements in specific subfields [21]. Nevertheless,
it cannot be denied the fact that there are some preferential states of epistemological beliefs, that correspond to a
better, more mature comprehension of the nature of knowledge.
In general terms the sophistication is understood within a clear scientific perspective. The type of
epistemological positions that the studies in personal epistemology consider mature or sophisticated are those in
higher agreement with the scientific method [22]. Thus, for instance, the belief in authority as the source of
knowledge is less sophisticated than the belief in sources like observation and reasoning. This simplification is
ultimately justified by the fact that the epistemological sophistication defined in this way has consistently shown
high degrees of positive correlation with other meaningful variables such as study strategies, comprehension,
interpretation and problem solving ability.
2.2 Development of the epistemological beliefs
While the exact nature of the development of the beliefs is hard to precise, the more accepted scenario
is that personal epistemology starts to emerge since early in life. As the child interacts with different social
groups like family, friends and school, this system of beliefs become more and more specific. It is plausible that
in the subsequent stages of development the individual additionally form domain-general beliefs as the type of
problems she faces become broader in nature [23]. The evolution of the beliefs system continues through the
adult age, and involves a myriad of psycho-social variables. The role of education is shown to be instrumental.
Since the first studies on the development of beliefs along the educative process [9, 24], it has been
demonstrated that formation and change of the beliefs are highly influenced by the level of instruction. A large
number of works have focused in describing how this process takes place and which elements regulates it. Some
authors claim that important conceptual changes takes place in the years of university undergrad. Many studies
confirm this evolution in different cultural contexts.
4. American Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences Research (AJHSSR) 2019
A J H S S R J o u r n a l P a g e | 14
Regarding curricular or occasional interventions to intentionally boost the development of the
epistemological beliefs, a consensus has not been reached, as a clear and efficient method to achieve that goal
has been elusive until now. This is indeed a consequence of the multiplicity of factors that underlies the
formation of the beliefs, from idiosyncratic notions to emotions and vocationalpreferences, generating a strong
resistance to possible changes. In the opinion of Schommer, the more rooted epistemological beliefs shape the
perspective from which a mature person faces new unexplored fields of knowledge, and they could only change
as a consequence of traumatic experiences or extreme challenges [16].
The way in which epistemological beliefs could be changed with intervention is a current open
discussion in which the use of debate dialogs and design of intellectual challenges are the most outstanding
candidates. This direction points toward the self awareness, so that individuals can make a conscious reflexion
on their own epistemological beliefs. All these ideas are an important support to the proposal of this work and
will come back in section 3.1 when introducing a novel construct: the meta-epistemology.
III. PERSONAL EPISTEMOLOGY AND TRANSDISCIPLINARITY
The expertise is a concept usually defined by looking at a number of traits and characteristics that
distinguish between experts and novices in a domain of knowledge. It has been established that, in general
terms, the experts solve problems by using more directed strategies, have a broader and structured knowledge,
more motivation and deploy a better monitoring of their own development [25, 26, 27]. The influence of social
and personal factors in reaching the expertise in certain domains has been studied and established, showing how
family and social contexts can boost or hinder the efforts [28, 29].
This development, as we discussed before, should imply the concomitant formation of a personal
epistemology at a mental level. In this way it make sense to associate the expertise with a particular mental
structure, not only of knowledge and abilities but also sophistication in the comprehension of these knowledges
and abilities.
On the other hand, the domain-specific nature of these abilities developed with the expertise is a well-
studied and replicated fact. For example, the use of graphic representations in physics differentiate novices from
experts, unlike what happens in biology [30]. In medicine, the expert develops certain particular narrative
structures called illness scripts that are used to diagnose new cases [31]. In computational science the relevant
characteristics of the experts include a high flexibility to use different syntaxes [32].
Since the 19th century the cognitive dynamics of science and its social organization have converged to
the creation of an academic science composed of well-defined scientific disciplines. Each one of these
disciplines having a particular development regarding the production, diffusion and legitimation of the scientific
knowledge that became standard. Thus, the specific type of personal epistemology that the contemporary
academy foster is strongly linked to the specific features of each domain of specialization.
The domain-specificity of epistemological beliefs [33, 17, 34] refers to the specialization or the field of
application of certain group of beliefs. The relevant question in this topic is whether a particular belief is
domain-general in the sense that it is applied to all areas of knowledge, or domain-specific, that is, valid only for
certain well-defined areas. Let’s now slightly modify this question and, instead of thinking in the specificity of a
single belief, focus on the possible specificity of the whole personal epistemology.
As discussed before, each individual posses a set of epistemological beliefs forming a system that is
called personal epistemology. For a single individual, these beliefs change when applied to different domains of
knowledge, but always within her own personal scheme. However, it is expectable that individuals formed as
experts in certain areas of knowledge will have relatively close personal epistemology in comparison with
individuals that are experts in way different areas. Accepting the differentiation in the expression of this
psychological construct for persons with different professional specialization is thus reasonable. It is a result of
assuming that the individual epistemological beliefs tend to emulate the epistemological standards of the
disciplines in which the individuals are expert.
Disciplines differentiate from each other to a large extent due to a number of epistemological standards
like, e.g. the way of evaluate knowledge, the type of theoretical support that is considered strong, or the type of
role that is played by the evidence. What is considered as a good theory or a good evidence is very different in
psychology, chemistry or computational sciences; and, even if the scientific method is the mandatory schedule
for all scientific activity, its general formulation allows an extremely large freedom in the epistemological sense.
Consequently, each discipline performs the same method from its own epistemological platform, which has a
marked socio-historical influence and whose most important footprint is that of determine the type of scientific
questions that can be asked.
On the other hand, the science as activity has lately paid a special attention to multidisciplinary
projects. Particularly since the last decades of 20th
century, the intense development leaded by biotechnology
and nanoscience, and recently followed by artificial intelligence, has redirected a large fraction of the scientific
work to the conformation of teams with experts of very different areas, mostly within the applied research. This
is a tendency that is going to still growing in the future, while at the same time does not mean a threat for the
5. American Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences Research (AJHSSR) 2019
A J H S S R J o u r n a l P a g e | 15
vertical growth of the traditional disciplines. One of the main characteristics of the current times is precisely the
increment of different ways of horizontal integrations as a necessary tool to generate new knowledge and
technology [2]. Additionally, the science as knowledge has an own dynamics for the expansion of the limits of
the knowledge. In this evolution, the limits of two disciplines eventually meet and new domains of knowledge
emerge. The research in these new domains is called transdisciplinary and is not necessary linked to a need for
particular applications, but rather is usually conceived as basic research.
3.1 The challenge of a meta-epitemology
From the poit of view of the epistemology, both the multidisciplinary and the transdisciplinary research
have its own particular features. The multidisciplinary research attacks a problem from different disciplines, that
is, by means of the work of experts with different epistemological perspectives. In turn, the transdisciplinary
research develops in a rather new field of science which, even if located at the frontier of traditional disciplines,
generate problems of its own singular nature, shaping a particular epistemological standard.
The study of personal epistemology in experts can play a determinant role to understand the context of
the multidisciplinary activity. In this context the researchers must constantly recognize and, to some extent,
understand the several views on the problem, which are much more than different tools and terminology. It is
likely to think that a proper domain-specificity of the epistemological beliefs may be instrumental for the
required attitude toward the multidisciplinary research. In that case the researcher will be allowed to easily think
the problems across disciplines, beyond the elementary conjectures.
On the side of the transdisciplinary research, the scientist do not have to deal with different views of
the problem, but rather to develop a new view and consequently create a new domain for her personal
epistemology. Clearly the starting point will be the epistemological platforms of the nearest traditional
disciplines, but the new set of beliefs cannot be a direct interpolation of them since the new context involves
scientific problems and questions of a whole new nature. In such a situation, the capacity of develop a new
domain with a new set of beliefs will be an individual ability, forged indirectly through her live and her
scientific instruction.
We can thus define a new construct to study the individual monitoring of the evolution and expression
of the epistemological beliefs. This construct will be of metacognitive nature since its central core is the self-
regulation of the personal epistemology. We call it here metaepistemology, and it encompass all the conscious
and intentional activities oriented to modify the own set of epistemological beliefs in order to better suit the new
cognitive contexts.
The conceptualization and the study of the metaepistemology finds its utility and field not only as a
mental element that express a purely psychological characteristics. As we have seen, the concept of
metaepistemology emerges in a natural way in the study of the interplay between science, technology and
society. It is conceived as a variable that can offer valuable information on the versatility and reach of the
personal epistemological structures that allow an individual to perform contemporary scientific activity.
IV. CONCLUSIONS
The necessary knowledge and ability to undergo scientific research within the several scientific
disciplines are in a great extent the product of a complex social interaction. Consequently, it is useful to develop
studies of science, technology and society directed to the exploration of individual psychological variables. The
cognitive psychology, in particular, has profiled for many decades the interest in the concept of personal
epistemology. Here we have introduced this concept and discussed several features of it from a social
perspective focusing in the contemporary scientific activity.
In this context, the construct of metaepistemology, a new contribution, is presented as naturally
emerged from a psychological necessity in the description of the mental mechanisms involved in multi- and
transdisciplinary research. Its basic characteristics is the description of the capacity of monitoring and self-
regulating the process of organization of the own personal epistemology. In principle, a systematization of the
metaepistemology can help to understand the horizontal movement of scientists and research groups; why for
some scientists is more easy to engage in multidisciplinary projects while for others is a huge effort, and how
are new disciplines conceived from different niches and schools.
Moreover, taking advantage from the current practical strength of the cognitive psychology, it would
be possible to try to influence these elements at will, with e.g. curricular interventions. This perspective is of
particular importance since, beyond the great theoretical and methodological advances in the studies on science,
technology and society, the way to feedback this knowledge is by far the big absent in the literature. This work
can serve as an introduction, motivation and guide for a more systematic and detailed study of this important
topic of social sciences.
V. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
6. American Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences Research (AJHSSR) 2019
A J H S S R J o u r n a l P a g e | 16
The author acknowledges Prof. Roberto Corral for very interesting comments in the early stages of this work
and Dr. Rogelio Díaz-Méndez for a careful reading of the manuscript.
REFERENCES
[1] C. Valdés Menocal, Problemas sociales de la Ciencia y la Tecnología. Selección de lecturas (La
Habana: Editorial Félix Varela, 2004).
[2] J. Núñez Jover, La Ciencia y la Tecnología como procesos sociales (La Habana: Editorial Félix
Varela, 2007).
[3] E. Agazzi, El bien, el mal y la Ciencia (Madrid: Editorial Tecnos, 1996).
[4] K. R. Popper, The logic of scientific discovery (London: Hutchinson, 1959).
[5] E. Gonález de Luna, El concepto de sentido común en la epistemología de Karl Popper, Signos
Filosóficos, 6, 2004, 131-144.
[6] E. Subbotsky, Luria and Vygotsky, in A. Yasnitsky, R. Van der Veer and M. Ferrari (Eds.), The
Cambridge Handbook of Cultural Historical Psychology (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press ,
2014) 295-312.
[7] A. Peña-Ayala, Metacognition: Fundaments, applications and trends (Switzerland: Springer, 2015).
[8] D. Kahneman, Thinking fast and slow (New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2011).
[9] W. G. Perry, Forms of ethical and intellectual development in the college years: A scheme (New York:
Holt, Rinehart & Winston, 1970).
[10] P. M. King, and K. S. Kitchener, Developing reflective judgment: Understanding and promoting
intellectual growth and critical thinking in adolescents and adults (San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1994).
[11] M. B. Baxter Magolda, Knowing and reasoning in college: Gen-der-related patterns in students’
intellectual development (San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1992).
[12] D. Kuhn, The skills of argument, (Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press, 1991).
[13] M. F. Belenky, B. M. Clinchy, N. R. Goldberger,and J. M. Tarule, Women's ways of knowing: The
development of self, voice, and mind (New York: Basic Books, 1997).
[14] M. P. Ryan, Monitoring text comprehension: Individual differences in epistemological standards.
Journal of Educational Psychology, 76(2), 1984, 248-258.
[15] M. Schommer, Effects of beliefs about the nature of knowledge on comprehension, Journal of
Educational Psychology, 82, 1990, 498-504.
[16] M. Schommer-Aikins, An evolving theoretical framework of epistemological beliefs system, in B. K.
Hofer and P. R. Pintrich (Eds.), Personal Epistemology: The psychology of beliefs about knowledge
and knowing, (Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 2002) 103-118.
[17] B. K. Hofer, Dimensionality and disciplinary differences in personal epistemology, Contemporary
Educational Psychology, 25, 2000, 378-405.
[18] M. Schommer-Aikins, Explaining the epistemological belief system: Introducing the embedded
systemic model and coordinated research approach, Educational Psychologist, 39, 2004, 19-29.
[19] M. Morell and M. Manzano, Are Low-Achievement Classrooms Cognitively Unbalanced?,
International Journal of Education and Psycholgical Research, 8(1), 2019, 20-26.
[20] K. Holma and H. Hyytinen, The philosophy of personal epistemology, Theory and Research in
Education, 13(3), 2015, 334-350.
[21] W. K. Adams, K. K. Perkins, N. S. Podolefsky, M. Dubson, N. D. Finkelstein and C. E. Wieman, New
instrument for measuring student beliefs about physics and learning physics: The Colorado Learning
Attitudes about Science Survey, Physical Review Special Topics: Physics Educational Research 2,
2006, 010101.
[22] M. Bunge, La ciencia, su método y su filosofía (Buenos Aires: Ediciones Siglo XX, 1978).
[23] P. A. Alexander, Domain knowledge: evolving themes and emerging concerns, Educational
Psychologist, 27, 1992, 33-51.
[24] D. Kuhn, E. Amsel and M. O’Loughlin, The development of scientific thinking skills. (Orlando, FL:
Academic, 1988).
[25] P. A. Alexander, Can we get there from here?, Educational Researcher, 32, 2003m 3-4.
[26] R. H. Bruning, G. J. Schraw, M. N. Norby and R. R. Ronning, Cognitive psychology and instruction.
(Upper Saddle River, New Jersey: Pearson Prentice Hall, 2004).
[27] K. A. Ericsson, The influence of experience and deliberate practice on the development of superior
expert performance, in K. A. Ericsson, N. Charness, P. Feltovich and R. R. Hoffman (Eds.), Cambridge
handbook of expertise and expert performance, (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 2006)
685-706.
[28] B. S. Bloom, Developing talent in young people. (New York: Ballantine Books, 1985).
7. American Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences Research (AJHSSR) 2019
A J H S S R J o u r n a l P a g e | 17
[29] S. Abuhamdeh and M. Csikszentmihalyi, The artistic personality: A systems approach, in R. J.
Sternberg, E. L. Grigorenko and J. L. Singer (Eds.), Creativity: From potential to realization,
(Washington: American Psychological Association, 2004) 685-706.
[30] J. S. Boster and J. C. Johnson, Form or function: A comparison of expert and novice judgments of
similarity among fish, American Antropologist, 91, 1989, 866-889.
[31] H. G. Schmidt and P. A. Boshuizen, On acquiring expertise in medicine, Educational Psychology
Review, 5, 1993, 205-220.
[32] L. Mciver, The effect of programming language on errorrates of novice programmers, in Proceedings
of the twelfth annual meeting of the Psychology of Programming, (Italy: Interest Group Corigliano
Calabro, 2000).
[33] N. B. Songer and M. C. Linn, How do students’ views of science influence knowledge integration?,
Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 28(9), 1991, 761-784.
[34] P. R. Pintrich, Future challenges and directions for theory and research on personal epistemology, in B.
K. Hofer and P. R. Pintrich (Eds.), The psychology of beliefs about knowledge and knowing (NJ:
Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc, 2002).