SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Tort is a civil wrong arising from an act or failure to act,
independently of any contract, for which an action for
personal injury or property damages may be brought
Definition of tort according to-
 Salmond:-
Tort is a civil wrong for which the remedy is a common law
action for unliquidated damages, and which is not
exclusively the breach of contract or the breach of trust or other
merely equitable obligation.
 Winfield:-
Tortuous liability arises from breach of duty primarily
fixed by law; this duty is towards persons generally
and its breach is redressible by an action for
unliquidated damages
The word tort is equivalent to-
WRONG in English
DELICT in Roman
JIMHA in Sanskrit
When we look at the journey of the word ‘tort’ from France to
India we find that it came from to India from
England. In 1605, England was conquered by Normandy (a
place in France) and French became the spoken language of
courts for many years. Thus, it happened
The word ‘tort’ is of French origin and has been derived from
the Latin word tortum which means to twist.
That many technical terms of English law are of
French origin. When Britishers ruled over India,
during the 18th century British courts were established
and use of British legal terms were common. Thus,
the word ‘tort’ was introduced in Indian legal system.
As per Salmond’s definition, the essentials of a tort are –
1- There must be a civil wrong,
2- The remedy for that wrong, is a common law action for
unliquidated damages,
3- and which is not exclusively the reach of a contract or the
breach of trust or other merely equitable obligation.
According to Dr. Winfield, the essentials of a tort are –
1- Tortuous liability arises from breach of duty primarily fixed by
law,
2- This duty is towards person generally,
3- Its breach is redressable by an action for unliquidated
damages.
It is a shock to the nerve and brain structures of the body
It is not a physical injury either by stick, bullet or sword but
merely by what has been seen or heard.
E.g., injury through agitation caused by a false alarm
or unlawful threats may result in a nervous breakdown or a
mental shock which may injure the plaintiff for his ordinary
activities.
It is a shock which arises from a reasonable fear to
immediate personal injury to oneself
For a case under nervous shock, the plaintiff has to prove
the following things: -
 Necessary chain of causation between
nervous shock and the death or injury of one or more parties
caused by the defendant's wrongful act;
 Plaintiff is required to prove shock
caused to him by seeing or hearing something. Physical
injury is not necessary;
 His proximity to the accident was sufficiently close in
time and space.
Thus, a man who came up on a scene of serious accident for
acting as a rescuer, when suffered a nervous shock, was
allowed to claim the damages
In Page v. Smith (1995 ) 2 All ER 736) (House of Lords
case), the plaintiff, though directly involved in the motor
accident remained physically unhurt but suffered a
psychiatric illness.
The House of Lords held the defendant liable for damages
and laid down the following important propositions: -
 in cases involving nervous shock, it is essential to
distinguish between the primary victims and secondary
victims;
in claims of secondary victims, the law insists on certain
control mechanisms, to limit the number of potential
claimants;
Thus, defendant will not be liable unless the psychiatric
injury/nervous shock is foreseeable in a person of normal
health.
The control mechanism has no place where the plaintiff is a
primary victim.
 in claims of secondary victims, it may be legitimate to
use hindsight/observation in order to be able to apply the
test of reasonable foreseeability;
 subject to the above, whether the defendant can
reasonably foresee that his conduct will expose the plaintiff
to the risk of personal physical injury or nervous shock?
If the answer is YES, then the duty of care is established,
even though physical injury does not in fact occur.
 the defendant who is under a duty of care to the plaintiff,
whether primary or secondary victim, is not liable for
damages for nervous shock unless the nervous shock
results in some recognized psychiatric illness.
The tortfeasor must take his victim as he finds him.
A mere bystander not in the vicinity of danger zone and
who suffers injury by nervous shock cannot recover
damages from the defendant.
YOU

More Related Content

What's hot

Ubi jus ibi remedium
Ubi jus ibi remediumUbi jus ibi remedium
Ubi jus ibi remedium
Rahul Gaur
 
Tort strict absolute liability
Tort  strict absolute liabilityTort  strict absolute liability
Tort strict absolute liability
Dr. Vikas Khakare
 
Torts against property by Architha Suresh
Torts against property by Architha SureshTorts against property by Architha Suresh
Torts against property by Architha Suresh
ARCHITHA SURESH
 
Judgment and decree
Judgment and decreeJudgment and decree
Judgment and decree
CS Bhuwan Taragi
 
custom as a source of law
custom as a source of lawcustom as a source of law
custom as a source of law
Kartik Gupta
 
Pleadings and its essentials
Pleadings and its essentialsPleadings and its essentials
Pleadings and its essentials
Wajid Ali Kharal
 
Specific relief act.ppt
Specific relief act.pptSpecific relief act.ppt
Specific relief act.ppt
Amaresh Patel
 
Discharge Of Tort
Discharge Of TortDischarge Of Tort
Discharge Of Tortjayvant1
 
Vicarious liability of state and sovereign immunity
Vicarious liability of state and sovereign immunityVicarious liability of state and sovereign immunity
Vicarious liability of state and sovereign immunity
Reshma Suresh
 
Code of civil procedure 1908 pleading plaint written statement
Code of civil procedure 1908 pleading plaint written statementCode of civil procedure 1908 pleading plaint written statement
Code of civil procedure 1908 pleading plaint written statement
Dr. Vikas Khakare
 
Trespass to the person
Trespass to the personTrespass to the person
Trespass to the person
Suayni Biggs
 
LLB LAW NOTES ON PROPERTY LAW
LLB LAW NOTES ON PROPERTY LAWLLB LAW NOTES ON PROPERTY LAW
LLB LAW NOTES ON PROPERTY LAW
Kanoon Ke Rakhwale India
 
Law of Torts
Law of TortsLaw of Torts
Law of Torts
Aishwarya Gupta
 
Res gestae
Res gestaeRes gestae
Res gestae
Ikram Abdul Sattar
 
General Exception under Indian Penal Code
General Exception under Indian Penal Code General Exception under Indian Penal Code
General Exception under Indian Penal Code
Law Laboratory
 
Tort nuisance
Tort nuisanceTort nuisance
Tort nuisance
Dr. Vikas Khakare
 
RES JUDICATA
RES JUDICATARES JUDICATA
RES JUDICATA
Mudit Jain
 
Gifts under the transfer of property act.
Gifts under the transfer of property act.Gifts under the transfer of property act.
Gifts under the transfer of property act.
Muskan Sanghi
 
Strict Liability
Strict LiabilityStrict Liability
Strict Liabilityjayvant1
 
LAW OF TORTS
LAW OF TORTSLAW OF TORTS
LAW OF TORTS
cpjcollege
 

What's hot (20)

Ubi jus ibi remedium
Ubi jus ibi remediumUbi jus ibi remedium
Ubi jus ibi remedium
 
Tort strict absolute liability
Tort  strict absolute liabilityTort  strict absolute liability
Tort strict absolute liability
 
Torts against property by Architha Suresh
Torts against property by Architha SureshTorts against property by Architha Suresh
Torts against property by Architha Suresh
 
Judgment and decree
Judgment and decreeJudgment and decree
Judgment and decree
 
custom as a source of law
custom as a source of lawcustom as a source of law
custom as a source of law
 
Pleadings and its essentials
Pleadings and its essentialsPleadings and its essentials
Pleadings and its essentials
 
Specific relief act.ppt
Specific relief act.pptSpecific relief act.ppt
Specific relief act.ppt
 
Discharge Of Tort
Discharge Of TortDischarge Of Tort
Discharge Of Tort
 
Vicarious liability of state and sovereign immunity
Vicarious liability of state and sovereign immunityVicarious liability of state and sovereign immunity
Vicarious liability of state and sovereign immunity
 
Code of civil procedure 1908 pleading plaint written statement
Code of civil procedure 1908 pleading plaint written statementCode of civil procedure 1908 pleading plaint written statement
Code of civil procedure 1908 pleading plaint written statement
 
Trespass to the person
Trespass to the personTrespass to the person
Trespass to the person
 
LLB LAW NOTES ON PROPERTY LAW
LLB LAW NOTES ON PROPERTY LAWLLB LAW NOTES ON PROPERTY LAW
LLB LAW NOTES ON PROPERTY LAW
 
Law of Torts
Law of TortsLaw of Torts
Law of Torts
 
Res gestae
Res gestaeRes gestae
Res gestae
 
General Exception under Indian Penal Code
General Exception under Indian Penal Code General Exception under Indian Penal Code
General Exception under Indian Penal Code
 
Tort nuisance
Tort nuisanceTort nuisance
Tort nuisance
 
RES JUDICATA
RES JUDICATARES JUDICATA
RES JUDICATA
 
Gifts under the transfer of property act.
Gifts under the transfer of property act.Gifts under the transfer of property act.
Gifts under the transfer of property act.
 
Strict Liability
Strict LiabilityStrict Liability
Strict Liability
 
LAW OF TORTS
LAW OF TORTSLAW OF TORTS
LAW OF TORTS
 

Viewers also liked

Vicarious liability
Vicarious liabilityVicarious liability
Vicarious liability
Justin Tay
 
Tort Law: Public Policy And Psychiatric Injury
Tort Law: Public Policy And Psychiatric InjuryTort Law: Public Policy And Psychiatric Injury
Tort Law: Public Policy And Psychiatric Injury
Kirsty Allison
 
Psychiatric illness tort law
Psychiatric illness tort lawPsychiatric illness tort law
Psychiatric illness tort law
Justin Tay
 
An Introduction to Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
An Introduction to Motor Vehicles Act, 1988An Introduction to Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
An Introduction to Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
Nilendra Kumar
 
Motor Vehicles Insurance
Motor Vehicles InsuranceMotor Vehicles Insurance
Motor Vehicles InsuranceVarun Vaish
 
LAW OF TORT - caselist
LAW OF TORT - caselistLAW OF TORT - caselist
LAW OF TORT - caselistFAROUQ
 
Trespass
TrespassTrespass
Trespass
zarinaf
 
Consumer protection-act-1986
Consumer protection-act-1986Consumer protection-act-1986
Consumer protection-act-1986suparswa
 
Negligence
Negligence Negligence
Negligence
zarinaf
 
Vicarious liability in tort
Vicarious liability in tortVicarious liability in tort
Vicarious liability in tort
Tuan Syahmi Matter
 
General defence tort law
General defence tort law General defence tort law
General defence tort law
Justin Tay
 
Negligence duty of care
Negligence   duty of careNegligence   duty of care
Negligence duty of careKulshoom
 
Motor vehicle Insurance in India
Motor vehicle Insurance in IndiaMotor vehicle Insurance in India
Motor vehicle Insurance in India
Varun Vaish
 
Law of tort negligence
Law of tort   negligenceLaw of tort   negligence
Law of tort negligenceNasrul Fazmi
 
Law of tort
Law of tortLaw of tort
Neighbour Principle
Neighbour PrincipleNeighbour Principle
Neighbour Principle
Nur Farhana Ana
 

Viewers also liked (17)

Vicarious liability
Vicarious liabilityVicarious liability
Vicarious liability
 
Tort Law: Public Policy And Psychiatric Injury
Tort Law: Public Policy And Psychiatric InjuryTort Law: Public Policy And Psychiatric Injury
Tort Law: Public Policy And Psychiatric Injury
 
Psychiatric illness tort law
Psychiatric illness tort lawPsychiatric illness tort law
Psychiatric illness tort law
 
An Introduction to Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
An Introduction to Motor Vehicles Act, 1988An Introduction to Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
An Introduction to Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
 
Motor Vehicles Insurance
Motor Vehicles InsuranceMotor Vehicles Insurance
Motor Vehicles Insurance
 
LAW OF TORT - caselist
LAW OF TORT - caselistLAW OF TORT - caselist
LAW OF TORT - caselist
 
Trespass
TrespassTrespass
Trespass
 
Consumer protection-act-1986
Consumer protection-act-1986Consumer protection-act-1986
Consumer protection-act-1986
 
Negligence
Negligence Negligence
Negligence
 
Vicarious liability in tort
Vicarious liability in tortVicarious liability in tort
Vicarious liability in tort
 
General defence tort law
General defence tort law General defence tort law
General defence tort law
 
Law of torts
Law of tortsLaw of torts
Law of torts
 
Negligence duty of care
Negligence   duty of careNegligence   duty of care
Negligence duty of care
 
Motor vehicle Insurance in India
Motor vehicle Insurance in IndiaMotor vehicle Insurance in India
Motor vehicle Insurance in India
 
Law of tort negligence
Law of tort   negligenceLaw of tort   negligence
Law of tort negligence
 
Law of tort
Law of tortLaw of tort
Law of tort
 
Neighbour Principle
Neighbour PrincipleNeighbour Principle
Neighbour Principle
 

Similar to NERVOUS SHOCK

tort.pptx notes for ba llb ccs university
tort.pptx notes for ba llb ccs universitytort.pptx notes for ba llb ccs university
tort.pptx notes for ba llb ccs university
mehultomar73
 
An introduction to law of torts
An introduction to law of tortsAn introduction to law of torts
An introduction to law of torts
Dr. Sandeep Kulshrestha
 
Law-Exchange.co.uk Shared Resource
Law-Exchange.co.uk Shared ResourceLaw-Exchange.co.uk Shared Resource
Law-Exchange.co.uk Shared Resourcelawexchange.co.uk
 
Law of trot
Law of trotLaw of trot
Law of trot
vishnu mohan
 
Page v Smith [1995]
Page v Smith [1995]Page v Smith [1995]
Page v Smith [1995]
Amalia Sulaiman
 
Tort Law-2.pdf
Tort Law-2.pdfTort Law-2.pdf
Tort Law-2.pdf
MarcTittlebaum1
 
The HeartObjectives· Identify the anatomical structures of the.docx
The HeartObjectives· Identify the anatomical structures of the.docxThe HeartObjectives· Identify the anatomical structures of the.docx
The HeartObjectives· Identify the anatomical structures of the.docx
rtodd33
 
general defence
general defencegeneral defence
general defence
priyanshiTiwari32
 
LIABILITY INSURANCE: WHAT YOU MUST KNOW!
 LIABILITY INSURANCE:   WHAT YOU MUST KNOW! LIABILITY INSURANCE:   WHAT YOU MUST KNOW!
LIABILITY INSURANCE: WHAT YOU MUST KNOW!
Newton Bezeng
 
Learning plan week 2 torts
Learning plan week 2 tortsLearning plan week 2 torts
Learning plan week 2 tortssjohnstonnau
 
LLB LAW NOTES ON LAW OF TORTS
LLB LAW NOTES ON LAW OF TORTSLLB LAW NOTES ON LAW OF TORTS
LLB LAW NOTES ON LAW OF TORTS
Kanoon Ke Rakhwale India
 
Lecture 10 law of tort
Lecture 10  law of tort Lecture 10  law of tort
Lecture 10 law of tort fatima d
 
Saylor URL httpwww.saylor.orgbooks Saylor.org 302 .docx
Saylor URL httpwww.saylor.orgbooks  Saylor.org  302 .docxSaylor URL httpwww.saylor.orgbooks  Saylor.org  302 .docx
Saylor URL httpwww.saylor.orgbooks Saylor.org 302 .docx
anhlodge
 
Tort.pptx EXTRA CONTARCTUAL LIABILITY LAWTO
Tort.pptx EXTRA CONTARCTUAL LIABILITY LAWTOTort.pptx EXTRA CONTARCTUAL LIABILITY LAWTO
Tort.pptx EXTRA CONTARCTUAL LIABILITY LAWTO
SaabbaaMan
 
BUSINESS AND COMPANY LAW TUTORIAL.docx
BUSINESS AND COMPANY LAW TUTORIAL.docxBUSINESS AND COMPANY LAW TUTORIAL.docx
BUSINESS AND COMPANY LAW TUTORIAL.docx
SharumathyMathy
 
LAW OF TORTS LAW OF TORTS LAW OF TORTS LAW OF TORTS
LAW OF TORTS LAW OF TORTS LAW OF TORTS LAW OF TORTSLAW OF TORTS LAW OF TORTS LAW OF TORTS LAW OF TORTS
LAW OF TORTS LAW OF TORTS LAW OF TORTS LAW OF TORTS
govasek953
 
Chapter 4.ppt
Chapter 4.pptChapter 4.ppt
Chapter 4.ppt
ketan349068
 
The Impact Of Tort Law Essay
The Impact Of Tort Law EssayThe Impact Of Tort Law Essay
The Impact Of Tort Law Essay
Buy Dissertation Paper Minnetonka
 
Torts and cyber
Torts and cyberTorts and cyber
Torts and cyber
Mayank Sharma
 

Similar to NERVOUS SHOCK (20)

tort.pptx notes for ba llb ccs university
tort.pptx notes for ba llb ccs universitytort.pptx notes for ba llb ccs university
tort.pptx notes for ba llb ccs university
 
An introduction to law of torts
An introduction to law of tortsAn introduction to law of torts
An introduction to law of torts
 
Law-Exchange.co.uk Shared Resource
Law-Exchange.co.uk Shared ResourceLaw-Exchange.co.uk Shared Resource
Law-Exchange.co.uk Shared Resource
 
Law of trot
Law of trotLaw of trot
Law of trot
 
Page v Smith [1995]
Page v Smith [1995]Page v Smith [1995]
Page v Smith [1995]
 
Tort Law-2.pdf
Tort Law-2.pdfTort Law-2.pdf
Tort Law-2.pdf
 
The HeartObjectives· Identify the anatomical structures of the.docx
The HeartObjectives· Identify the anatomical structures of the.docxThe HeartObjectives· Identify the anatomical structures of the.docx
The HeartObjectives· Identify the anatomical structures of the.docx
 
general defence
general defencegeneral defence
general defence
 
LIABILITY INSURANCE: WHAT YOU MUST KNOW!
 LIABILITY INSURANCE:   WHAT YOU MUST KNOW! LIABILITY INSURANCE:   WHAT YOU MUST KNOW!
LIABILITY INSURANCE: WHAT YOU MUST KNOW!
 
Learning plan week 2 torts
Learning plan week 2 tortsLearning plan week 2 torts
Learning plan week 2 torts
 
LLB LAW NOTES ON LAW OF TORTS
LLB LAW NOTES ON LAW OF TORTSLLB LAW NOTES ON LAW OF TORTS
LLB LAW NOTES ON LAW OF TORTS
 
Lecture 10 law of tort
Lecture 10  law of tort Lecture 10  law of tort
Lecture 10 law of tort
 
Saylor URL httpwww.saylor.orgbooks Saylor.org 302 .docx
Saylor URL httpwww.saylor.orgbooks  Saylor.org  302 .docxSaylor URL httpwww.saylor.orgbooks  Saylor.org  302 .docx
Saylor URL httpwww.saylor.orgbooks Saylor.org 302 .docx
 
Tort.pptx EXTRA CONTARCTUAL LIABILITY LAWTO
Tort.pptx EXTRA CONTARCTUAL LIABILITY LAWTOTort.pptx EXTRA CONTARCTUAL LIABILITY LAWTO
Tort.pptx EXTRA CONTARCTUAL LIABILITY LAWTO
 
Torts in law at help withassignment
Torts in law at help withassignmentTorts in law at help withassignment
Torts in law at help withassignment
 
BUSINESS AND COMPANY LAW TUTORIAL.docx
BUSINESS AND COMPANY LAW TUTORIAL.docxBUSINESS AND COMPANY LAW TUTORIAL.docx
BUSINESS AND COMPANY LAW TUTORIAL.docx
 
LAW OF TORTS LAW OF TORTS LAW OF TORTS LAW OF TORTS
LAW OF TORTS LAW OF TORTS LAW OF TORTS LAW OF TORTSLAW OF TORTS LAW OF TORTS LAW OF TORTS LAW OF TORTS
LAW OF TORTS LAW OF TORTS LAW OF TORTS LAW OF TORTS
 
Chapter 4.ppt
Chapter 4.pptChapter 4.ppt
Chapter 4.ppt
 
The Impact Of Tort Law Essay
The Impact Of Tort Law EssayThe Impact Of Tort Law Essay
The Impact Of Tort Law Essay
 
Torts and cyber
Torts and cyberTorts and cyber
Torts and cyber
 

NERVOUS SHOCK

  • 1.
  • 2. Tort is a civil wrong arising from an act or failure to act, independently of any contract, for which an action for personal injury or property damages may be brought Definition of tort according to-  Salmond:- Tort is a civil wrong for which the remedy is a common law action for unliquidated damages, and which is not exclusively the breach of contract or the breach of trust or other merely equitable obligation.
  • 3.  Winfield:- Tortuous liability arises from breach of duty primarily fixed by law; this duty is towards persons generally and its breach is redressible by an action for unliquidated damages
  • 4. The word tort is equivalent to- WRONG in English DELICT in Roman JIMHA in Sanskrit When we look at the journey of the word ‘tort’ from France to India we find that it came from to India from England. In 1605, England was conquered by Normandy (a place in France) and French became the spoken language of courts for many years. Thus, it happened The word ‘tort’ is of French origin and has been derived from the Latin word tortum which means to twist.
  • 5. That many technical terms of English law are of French origin. When Britishers ruled over India, during the 18th century British courts were established and use of British legal terms were common. Thus, the word ‘tort’ was introduced in Indian legal system.
  • 6. As per Salmond’s definition, the essentials of a tort are – 1- There must be a civil wrong, 2- The remedy for that wrong, is a common law action for unliquidated damages, 3- and which is not exclusively the reach of a contract or the breach of trust or other merely equitable obligation. According to Dr. Winfield, the essentials of a tort are – 1- Tortuous liability arises from breach of duty primarily fixed by law, 2- This duty is towards person generally, 3- Its breach is redressable by an action for unliquidated damages.
  • 7. It is a shock to the nerve and brain structures of the body It is not a physical injury either by stick, bullet or sword but merely by what has been seen or heard. E.g., injury through agitation caused by a false alarm or unlawful threats may result in a nervous breakdown or a mental shock which may injure the plaintiff for his ordinary activities. It is a shock which arises from a reasonable fear to immediate personal injury to oneself
  • 8. For a case under nervous shock, the plaintiff has to prove the following things: -  Necessary chain of causation between nervous shock and the death or injury of one or more parties caused by the defendant's wrongful act;  Plaintiff is required to prove shock caused to him by seeing or hearing something. Physical injury is not necessary;  His proximity to the accident was sufficiently close in time and space.
  • 9. Thus, a man who came up on a scene of serious accident for acting as a rescuer, when suffered a nervous shock, was allowed to claim the damages
  • 10. In Page v. Smith (1995 ) 2 All ER 736) (House of Lords case), the plaintiff, though directly involved in the motor accident remained physically unhurt but suffered a psychiatric illness. The House of Lords held the defendant liable for damages and laid down the following important propositions: -  in cases involving nervous shock, it is essential to distinguish between the primary victims and secondary victims; in claims of secondary victims, the law insists on certain control mechanisms, to limit the number of potential claimants;
  • 11. Thus, defendant will not be liable unless the psychiatric injury/nervous shock is foreseeable in a person of normal health. The control mechanism has no place where the plaintiff is a primary victim.  in claims of secondary victims, it may be legitimate to use hindsight/observation in order to be able to apply the test of reasonable foreseeability;  subject to the above, whether the defendant can reasonably foresee that his conduct will expose the plaintiff to the risk of personal physical injury or nervous shock? If the answer is YES, then the duty of care is established, even though physical injury does not in fact occur.
  • 12.  the defendant who is under a duty of care to the plaintiff, whether primary or secondary victim, is not liable for damages for nervous shock unless the nervous shock results in some recognized psychiatric illness. The tortfeasor must take his victim as he finds him. A mere bystander not in the vicinity of danger zone and who suffers injury by nervous shock cannot recover damages from the defendant.
  • 13. YOU