The document summarizes the key discussions and best practices for managing cross-border M&A deals that were shared at the 2015 Lex Mundi Summit. General counsel face many challenges in cross-border M&A including navigating complex regulations, cultural and regulatory asymmetries between jurisdictions, and ensuring successful post-merger integration. The Summit participants identified four important disciplines for general counsel: 1) effective relationship management with regulators and internal stakeholders; 2) clear communication and influence across the organization; 3) prudent process and project management; and 4) relentless focus on post-merger implementation. While much legal advice focuses on closing the deal, participants agreed that the hardest work begins after closing in integrating the two companies and ensuring promised
Eversheds Report - Streamlining for success: M&A Divestment and Separation Tr...Rafal Wasyluk
Sieć Eversheds opublikowała globalny raport pt. „Streamlining for success: M&A Divestment and Separation Trends". Raport koncentruje się na trendach w zakresie wyjść z inwestycji. Za koordynację polskich prac nad raportem odpowiedzialna była Ewa Szlachetka, partner kierujący praktyką fuzji i przejęć w kancelarii Wierzbowski Eversheds.
Na potrzeby raportu przeprowadzone zostało globalne badanie, również wśród klientów Eversheds. Jego celem było uzyskanie odpowiedzi m.in. na poniższe pytania:
Jakie aspekty separacji lub dezinwestycji oraz ogólnego procesu planowania są największym wyzwaniem?
Jakie są przykłady najlepszych praktyk i rozwiązań w zakresie radzenia sobie z tymi wyzwaniami?
Gdzie poszukiwać obszarów, w których można uzyskać wzrost wartości oraz gdzie można najwięcej stracić w procesie separacji?
Które kwestie prawne są krytyczne dla sukcesu transakcji?
Kiedy prawnicy wewnętrzni będą najbardziej skuteczni w swojej roli?
Jakie są najważniejsze zagadnienia dotyczące różnych grup interesariuszy, w tym zarządu, dyrektorów, zespołu zajmującego się rozwojem korporacyjnym i doradców prawnych?
W jaki sposób w trakcie zbycia chronić wartości zarówno w spółce dominującej, jak i zależnej?
Więcej (ENG): http://www.eversheds.com/global/en/what/services/m-and-a/report-2015.page
Institutional investors are highly dissatisfied with the quality of information that they receive about corporate governance policies and practices in the annual proxy. Across the board, they want proxies to be shorter, more concise, more candid, and less legal.
The largest complaint involves executive compensation and the inability of investors to determine whether senior management is paid appropriately. Based on recent survey data from major institutional investors, we describe the information that shareholders would like to see in the “ideal” proxy statement.
We ask:
• What changes can companies make to proxies contain the information that investors want in a format that is easy to read and navigate?
• Would shareholder understanding of corporate governance practices improve if companies provided clearer and more succinct data?
• How might the debate about executive compensation change?
Eversheds Report - Streamlining for success: M&A Divestment and Separation Tr...Rafal Wasyluk
Sieć Eversheds opublikowała globalny raport pt. „Streamlining for success: M&A Divestment and Separation Trends". Raport koncentruje się na trendach w zakresie wyjść z inwestycji. Za koordynację polskich prac nad raportem odpowiedzialna była Ewa Szlachetka, partner kierujący praktyką fuzji i przejęć w kancelarii Wierzbowski Eversheds.
Na potrzeby raportu przeprowadzone zostało globalne badanie, również wśród klientów Eversheds. Jego celem było uzyskanie odpowiedzi m.in. na poniższe pytania:
Jakie aspekty separacji lub dezinwestycji oraz ogólnego procesu planowania są największym wyzwaniem?
Jakie są przykłady najlepszych praktyk i rozwiązań w zakresie radzenia sobie z tymi wyzwaniami?
Gdzie poszukiwać obszarów, w których można uzyskać wzrost wartości oraz gdzie można najwięcej stracić w procesie separacji?
Które kwestie prawne są krytyczne dla sukcesu transakcji?
Kiedy prawnicy wewnętrzni będą najbardziej skuteczni w swojej roli?
Jakie są najważniejsze zagadnienia dotyczące różnych grup interesariuszy, w tym zarządu, dyrektorów, zespołu zajmującego się rozwojem korporacyjnym i doradców prawnych?
W jaki sposób w trakcie zbycia chronić wartości zarówno w spółce dominującej, jak i zależnej?
Więcej (ENG): http://www.eversheds.com/global/en/what/services/m-and-a/report-2015.page
Institutional investors are highly dissatisfied with the quality of information that they receive about corporate governance policies and practices in the annual proxy. Across the board, they want proxies to be shorter, more concise, more candid, and less legal.
The largest complaint involves executive compensation and the inability of investors to determine whether senior management is paid appropriately. Based on recent survey data from major institutional investors, we describe the information that shareholders would like to see in the “ideal” proxy statement.
We ask:
• What changes can companies make to proxies contain the information that investors want in a format that is easy to read and navigate?
• Would shareholder understanding of corporate governance practices improve if companies provided clearer and more succinct data?
• How might the debate about executive compensation change?
The sixth annual Blakes Canadian Public M&A Deal Study focuses on some recurring and emerging issues in the structuring and negotiation of Target-supported public company acquisitions in Canada. The topics covered in the Study range from overall transaction structure and timing, such as the strategic review process and alternatives for dealing with management and significant shareholders, to specific contractual provisions, such as material adverse effect clauses, break and reciprocal break fees and non-solicitation provisions.
Cost vs. Risk: Finding the right balance for hedge fund administrationGrant Thornton LLP
Hedge Funds—Taking a fresh look at operations: How hedge fund managers can engage the right mix of internal, outside and shadow administration. Read the full paper at http://gt-us.co/1rjV3Se
Law and Regulations for Private and Retail Banking (Asia-Pacific, Hong Kong),...Raul A. Lujan Anaya
Notes on Certificate Course (Postgrad.) in Banking, Corporate and Finance Law: Law and Regulations for Private and Retail Banking (Hong Kong, Asia-Pacific), in the University of Hong Kong, First Semester of 2014.
Our endeavour upheld group has more than 50 years of experience working with systematic investment management, and software development. By utilizing machine learning, data science and automation, we enable advisors to manage portfolio risk in near real-time.
The following report by the Credit Suisse
Research Institute explores several important
aspects of the connection between sound governance
and improved business performance. It provides
new data to support the growing investor
interest in governance-related rules and practices
and introduces innovative ways to assess corporate
performance, such as the HOLT governance scorecard,
to support more effective governance-oriented
decision making. Moreover, our experts identify specific
company types and sectors, in which governance
can serve as a particularly robust investment
strategy instrument. Corporate governance is further
likely to contribute to investment decisions in
emerging economies, for instance when firm-level
structures actively compensate for the possible
absence of country-level governance provisions.
Cultural Issues In Asia Private Equity and Venture Capital TransactionsPamir Law Group
This presentation applies ancient Chinese wisdom to 21st century cross-border Venture Capital & Private Equity transactions.
For more information about our Private Equity and Venture Capital services, please visit http://www.pamirlaw.com/en/services/legal/private_equity_venture_capital
Increasingly, law firms have used the device of merger as a road to quick growth. Without comprehensive planning the merger route is a hazardous undertaking.
A Menu of Products for Investors and Lawyers (Series: Commercial Litigation F...Financial Poise
Litigation funding is an increasingly-popular tool for attorneys and clients to share the risk and reward of litigation with third-party investors, and for investors to capitalize on the uncorrelated returns generated by legal-driven revenue. However, the term "litigation-" or "legal-" funding actually encompasses a handful of products, which vary based on borrower profile, stage and sector of litigation, use of proceeds, and ultimately, cost of capital and risk-reward profile. This webinar examines three funding products -- case fundings, law firm loans, and portfolio fundings -- and aims to inform attorneys on best solutions for their firms and clients, and provide an overview for institutional investors looking to allocate capital to litigations.
To view the accompanying webinar, go to: https://www.financialpoise.com/financial-poise-webinars/a-menu-of-products-for-investors-and-lawyers-2021/
Una actividad/taller para elaborar un plan de acción para la construcción de un entorno propicio a la innovación genuina en nuestra organización.
Es un taller que usa la metodología de las Simulaciones de Negocio. Es una actividad que dura entre 4 y 8 horas.
The sixth annual Blakes Canadian Public M&A Deal Study focuses on some recurring and emerging issues in the structuring and negotiation of Target-supported public company acquisitions in Canada. The topics covered in the Study range from overall transaction structure and timing, such as the strategic review process and alternatives for dealing with management and significant shareholders, to specific contractual provisions, such as material adverse effect clauses, break and reciprocal break fees and non-solicitation provisions.
Cost vs. Risk: Finding the right balance for hedge fund administrationGrant Thornton LLP
Hedge Funds—Taking a fresh look at operations: How hedge fund managers can engage the right mix of internal, outside and shadow administration. Read the full paper at http://gt-us.co/1rjV3Se
Law and Regulations for Private and Retail Banking (Asia-Pacific, Hong Kong),...Raul A. Lujan Anaya
Notes on Certificate Course (Postgrad.) in Banking, Corporate and Finance Law: Law and Regulations for Private and Retail Banking (Hong Kong, Asia-Pacific), in the University of Hong Kong, First Semester of 2014.
Our endeavour upheld group has more than 50 years of experience working with systematic investment management, and software development. By utilizing machine learning, data science and automation, we enable advisors to manage portfolio risk in near real-time.
The following report by the Credit Suisse
Research Institute explores several important
aspects of the connection between sound governance
and improved business performance. It provides
new data to support the growing investor
interest in governance-related rules and practices
and introduces innovative ways to assess corporate
performance, such as the HOLT governance scorecard,
to support more effective governance-oriented
decision making. Moreover, our experts identify specific
company types and sectors, in which governance
can serve as a particularly robust investment
strategy instrument. Corporate governance is further
likely to contribute to investment decisions in
emerging economies, for instance when firm-level
structures actively compensate for the possible
absence of country-level governance provisions.
Cultural Issues In Asia Private Equity and Venture Capital TransactionsPamir Law Group
This presentation applies ancient Chinese wisdom to 21st century cross-border Venture Capital & Private Equity transactions.
For more information about our Private Equity and Venture Capital services, please visit http://www.pamirlaw.com/en/services/legal/private_equity_venture_capital
Increasingly, law firms have used the device of merger as a road to quick growth. Without comprehensive planning the merger route is a hazardous undertaking.
A Menu of Products for Investors and Lawyers (Series: Commercial Litigation F...Financial Poise
Litigation funding is an increasingly-popular tool for attorneys and clients to share the risk and reward of litigation with third-party investors, and for investors to capitalize on the uncorrelated returns generated by legal-driven revenue. However, the term "litigation-" or "legal-" funding actually encompasses a handful of products, which vary based on borrower profile, stage and sector of litigation, use of proceeds, and ultimately, cost of capital and risk-reward profile. This webinar examines three funding products -- case fundings, law firm loans, and portfolio fundings -- and aims to inform attorneys on best solutions for their firms and clients, and provide an overview for institutional investors looking to allocate capital to litigations.
To view the accompanying webinar, go to: https://www.financialpoise.com/financial-poise-webinars/a-menu-of-products-for-investors-and-lawyers-2021/
Una actividad/taller para elaborar un plan de acción para la construcción de un entorno propicio a la innovación genuina en nuestra organización.
Es un taller que usa la metodología de las Simulaciones de Negocio. Es una actividad que dura entre 4 y 8 horas.
The Devastating Effects of Mismanaged Subsidiary Governance: How You Can Lear...Athennian
This webinar, hosted by Adrian Camara (Co-founder & CEO of Athennian) and Paul Sutton (Founder of LCN Legal), will dive into a causal analysis of corporate scandals and oversights that have led to severe financial and criminal penalties. Discover tangible ways to prevent the mismanagement of corporate data that befell companies like BlackRock & Holcim.
Presentation by Jill Cuthbert, Senior Employee Relations Specialist, Citi (formerly Citibank) at CMP's 'Aiming for excellence' conference, 5 December 2008, London.
Seizing the regulatory opportunity: A Deloitte perspective on how financial i...Deloitte Canada
Financial institutions that look for opportunities in compliance rather than resign themselves to it can position themselves ahead of the competition. The energy they put into understanding the impact of new regulations on their businesses, customers and risks can be used to drive operational changes.
The role of audit committees continues to expand to keep pace with the modern business operating environment. In addition to responsibility for a company’s financial reporting and management, audit committees increasingly take an active role in an organization’s risk management strategy.
Audit committees can be instrumental in helping their organizations implement procedures to address the challenges they face. They can also assist with addressing internal and external audit findings or with exploring best practices for addressing areas of operations that may be vulnerable to disruption or extraordinary risks.
A quick review of those issues that confront both public & private companies, C & S Corps, LLC's, Trusts & Partnerships in today's transparency driven business environment.
Shieldpay - Changing Properties (the future of real estate transactions)Peter Janes
Shieldpay - Changing Properties
Shieldpay has published our White Paper on Third Party Managed Accounts (TPMAs). This is an overview of the current regulatory position of using TPMAs such as Shieldpay for property transactions.
Anti-Bribery and Corruption Compliance for Third PartiesDun & Bradstreet
In this white paper, Kelvin Dickenson, Managing Director of D&B Global Compliance Solutions, discusses thoughtful approaches to buidling a scalable, effective and proportionate anti-corruption program for third-party due dilligence.
Main Legal Risk Issues Facing Entrepreneurs | Virginia Suveiu | Lunch & Learn UCICove
About UCI Applied Innovation:
UCI Applied Innovation is a dynamic, innovative central platform for the UCI campus, entrepreneurs, inventors, the business community and investors to collaborate and move UCI research from lab to market.
About the Cove @ UCI:
To accelerate collaboration by better connecting innovation partners in Orange County, UCI Applied Innovation created the Cove, a physical, state-of-the-art hub for entrepreneurs to gather and navigate the resources available both on and off campus. The Cove is headquarters for UCI Applied Innovation, as well as houses several ecosystem partners including incubators, accelerators, angel investors, venture capitalists, mentors and legal experts.
Follow us on social media:
Facebook: @UCICove
Twitter: @UCICove
Instagram: @UCICove
LinkedIn: @UCIAppliedInnovation
For more information:
cove@uci.edu
http://innovation.uci.edu/
2. 2
Table of Contents
About this Report....................................................................................................................3
How General Counsel Can Manage Demand, Deliver Quality and Articulate Value
in Cross-Border M&A: Organizational Challenges and Best Practices.........................................4
Global M&A Landscape – Assessing and Avoiding Anti-Corruption Risk...................................8
Acknowledgements...............................................................................................................10
Additional Resources..............................................................................................................13
Lex Mundi – The law firms that know your markets.
3. 3
About This Report
M&A activity is re-approaching 2007 levels, but the involvement of general counsel and corporate
legal departments in deal activity has changed significantly since the last peak. Much of this
change has been a result of dramatic shifts in the operating environment, which are driving large
scale mergers and shaping new approaches to due diligence, negotiations and realization of post-
merger synergies. Increased political and regulatory scrutiny, rising standards of corporate conduct
and governance, and greater exposure to shareholder activism are all just part of ‘new normal’
conditions. As a consequence, general counsel have had to adapt and innovate in order to manage
increasing demands from a diverse group of stakeholders, deliver quality legal counsel to company
decision makers and boards, and articulate the value they add to M&A.
This report analyzes best-practices shared by general counsel participants during the 2015 Lex Mundi
Summit in Amsterdam. During the interactive panel discussions and break-out sessions, four critical
disciplines came to light that make the difference between more and less successful M&A outcomes:
(i) effective and proactive relationship management with local regulators
and internal stakeholders;
(ii) careful communication and influence across the organization;
(iii) a common sense approach to process and project management to maintain efficiency;
and, not least,
(iv) a relentless focus on post-merger implementation from the onset of the transaction.
The following report elaborates on each discipline and provides examples of how they can be fostered
in the organization.
We extend our thanks and appreciation to the general counsel participants, Lex Mundi member
firm lawyers and our guest speakers for their contributions to the program and their active
Summit participation.
We hope you find this analysis beneficial and look forward to the 2016 Lex Mundi Summit in Amsterdam
(May 19 – 20), where we will continue our focus on best practices for general counsel – this time on the
topic of The Expanding Role of the General Counsel in Protecting Corporate Reputation.
Carl Anduri Eric R. Staal
President Director of Business Development
Lex Mundi Lex Mundi
Lex Mundi – The law firms that know your markets.
4. 4
This report is a summary of the proceedings of the
2015 Lex Mundi Summit which focused on how
general counsel can manage demand, deliver quality
and articulate value in cross-border MA. Cross-border
transactions involve general counsel in a myriad of
challenges, among which are regulatory risks and
pressures, asymmetries between the acquirer and
target, greater shareholder activism and post-merger
integration.
In recent years there has been an increase not only in
regulatory breaches, but in the number of companies
held liable for violations that take place prior to
acquisition. In the U.S., for example, ninety-nine percent
of the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA) enforcement
fines have occurred in the last ten years (out of the
previous forty years) with the size of these penalties
becoming significantly larger. Despite a plethora of rules,
regulations and guidance globally, corporate scandals
are becoming more prominent. Compounded with
time-consuming involvement by competition authorities,
who have extensive powers and tools to review mergers,
getting it wrong, or acquiring a company without
fully understanding all of its liabilities, can lead to
significant claims. In one case, a 2015 Lex Mundi Summit
participant discussed a merger being reviewed long
after closing and integration was underway, despite the
acquiring company having taken all appropriate steps
with the antitrust authorities.
Asymmetries between the acquiring company and
jurisdiction or the target company and jurisdiction
provide for another set of obstacles. For example, the
acquirer may be dealing with a target or a jurisdiction
that does not have sophisticated management or
experienced regulators. However, the lack of experience
or sophistication does not temper the ambitions and
activism of regulators, which confounds negotiations and
the necessary approvals. One lesson shared by a Summit
participant cautioned not to overwhelm counterparties
in developing countries with requests for information or
demands for compliance with company procedures and
policies. These expectations are often unrealistic and can
result in an immobilization of the transaction.
Furthermore, shareholder activism continues to rise.
Management should be wary of being on the receiving
end of a claim as well as aware of schemes to gain
influence over the board or extracting value from
proposed takeovers. A well-constructed legal firewall
and strategy can help mitigate any adverse impact
these contingencies may have on the bottom line.
In addition, the general counsel can serve as arbiter
between shareholders and management, an “honest
broker” pre- and post-transaction to facilitate the deal.
Summit participants were not surprisingly
unanimous that the real – and perhaps the
most difficult – work begins on day one of the
new combined entity.
Last, but not least, is the task of bringing the two
organizational cultures together to ensure the
promised synergies of the transaction are delivered.
Much of the legal advice focuses on putting the deal
together. However, Summit participants were not
surprisingly unanimous that the real – and perhaps
the most difficult – work begins on day one of the
new combined entity. This time is crucial for extending
policies across the organization and refocusing the
approaches taken by the legal teams to serve the new
business. Sound policies and processes are essential,
but it is ultimately the attitudes and behavior of
individuals that determine whether there is adherence.
In response to the above interrelated challenges,
Summit discussions brought to light four disciplines that
general counsel and their legal teams should skillfully
apply in order to deliver value to their company’s cross-
border MA deals: 1) relationship management; 2)
communication and influence; 3) process and project
management; and 4) post-merger implementation.
These disciplines are mutually reinforcing in that
effectiveness in one area can help advance the others.
I. Relationship Management
Relationship building within the organization and
with external stakeholders is a task that must be
undertaken prior to the onset of any MA transaction.
Strong relationships between senior management
and in-house counsel, in-house counsel and their
external counterparts, and between companies and
regulators are essential for cross-border mergers to run
smoothly. The lack of these strong relationships can
lead to breakdowns and delays in the process because
How General Counsel Can Manage
Demand, Deliver Quality and Articulate
Value in Cross-Border MA:
Organizational Challenges and Best Practices
5. 5
the foundation that allows the company to address
problems and steer through solutions is missing.
In this context, the 2015 Lex Mundi Summit participants
focused on the need to manage the expectations of
the acquirer’s senior decision makers, especially when
regulatory sophistication in a foreign jurisdiction is in
question. Most general counsel recognized a certain
tension between the company’s “enablers” (corporate
dealmakers) and its “gatekeepers” (lawyers), with some
emphasizing the struggle to persuade management of
the need for patience. Protecting the company from
avoidable risk can test even the best relationships with
internal decision makers.
Relationship building takes a consistent investment of
time and a demonstrated interest in the role others
play in the MA process. While it may be easy to
overlook the importance of this discipline, relationship
management is a core component to the success and
effectiveness of the in-house counsel role.
Participants discussed the following best practices for
managing relationships:
1. At the outset of the deal, take a general
inventory of the quality of key relationships to
detect areas of potential difficulty and identify
proactive steps.
2. Cultivate local relationships with regulators
and/or legal counsel on the ground in order to
anticipate the behavior of counterparties and
regulators as well as appropriately allocate time
and resources. One in-house counsel recounted
a time when his company wasted twelve months
of management time and money by fighting
the wrong battle instead of addressing the
appropriate regulatory concerns.
3. Designate a main point of contact either within
the legal department or elsewhere in the
organization to be responsible for the overall
relationship with regulators. For those companies
with a government relations function traditionally
responsible for this role, participants thought
it best to integrate this function with the legal
function. If the government relations function
sits elsewhere in the organization, it must be
carefully determined who is responsible for the
relationship with regulators.
4. Proactively communicate the deal rationale and
the steps taken to ensure success to (institutional)
shareholders. This practice will head off any
suspicions of being out of the information loop
and will help cultivate advocates for the deal who
can argue its merits.
5. Instill in the in-house team a sense of being
part of the business and an integral means of
providing objective input. As an extension, the
in-house team should see themselves first and
foremost as business people with legal expertise.
For example, members of the in-house team can
be seconded to business functions or units to
familiarize themselves with business dynamics.
II. Communication and Influence
Across the Organization
Closely allied to the discipline of relationship
management is the importance of strong
communication skills on the part of internal and
external counsel. Lawyers often act as the lynchpin
between shareholders, management, regulators,
employees and business partners. They are stewards of
the company’s message and brand identity, simplifying
technical issues so those issues can be acted upon in
an efficient and effective manner.
Most major transactions will need a mix of in-house
corporate counsel who know the business and the
personalities as well as external expertise based on
sector or jurisdictional knowledge. Establishing a
system of strong communication policies will...
• Cross Border MA:
How General Counsel Can
Manage Demand, Deliver
Quality and Articulate Value
This full report provides best
practices, critical disciplines and
examples how these disciplines can
be fostered in an organization.
• MA Legal Services
Integration Checklist
This checklist is designed to assist
you in streamlining the integration
process with a target company
that has operations in multiple
jurisdictions.
Contact:
Kim Bradell
kbradell@lexmundi.com
Requestyourcomplimentary
copiesof:
6. 6
About Lex Mundi
Lex Mundi is the world’s leading network of independent law firms with in-depth experience in 100+ countries.
Lex Mundi member firms offer clients preferred access to more than 21,000 lawyers worldwide – a global
resource of unmatched breadth and depth. Each member firm is selected on the basis of its leadership in –
and continued commitment to – its local market. The Lex Mundi principle is one independent firm for each
jurisdiction. Firms must maintain their level of excellence to retain membership within Lex Mundi.
Through close collaboration, information-sharing, training and inter-firm initiatives, the Lex Mundi network is an
assurance of connected, on-the-ground expertise in every market in which a client needs to operate. Working
together, Lex Mundi member firms are able to seamlessly handle their clients’ most challenging cross-border
transactions and disputes.
Lex Mundi member firms are located throughout Europe, the Middle East, Africa, Asia and the Pacific,
Latin America and the Caribbean, and North America. Through our nonprofit affiliate, the Lex Mundi Pro Bono
Foundation, members also provide pro bono legal assistance to social entrepreneurs around the globe.
Lex Mundi
The World’s Leading Network of Independent Law Firms
2100 West Loop South, Suite 1000
Houston, Texas USA 77027
1.713.626.9393
www.lexmundi.com
Lex Mundi – The law firms that know your markets.