M&A Culture Clashes:  Diagnosing and Dealing with themPhilip H. MirvisFortune magazine “merger maven”with Mitchell Marks @DenisonCulture.com
M&A Culture Clashes:  Diagnosing and Dealing with themPhilip H. MirvisFortune magazine “merger maven”with Mitchell Marks @DenisonCulture.com
Merger hit rate65-85 % of Mergers and Acquisitions FailVs. precombination earnings of 2 cos.Vs. promised returns by executivesVs. costs of capital								WHY?
Combination Phases
Define the End Stateacquired
Company AEngineering & MarketingQualityMatrixPlanningProfessionalCollegialTeamworkOur WayCompany BR&DSpeedFunctionalReady, Fire, AimEntrepreneurialPoliticalStar SystemMy WayTheoretic SynergiesLeading Edge TechnologyBroader User BaseFaster Time to MarketProduct ReliabilityTechnology Transfer
ThinkOrganization & Culture
How and where to Integrate?
Degree of Integration
What’s happening in this picture?Company ACompany B
Physical Signs and Public BehaviorsNorms and Values Private BehaviorsBeliefs on ‘Human Nature and Reality’“Layers” of Culture
Culture Clash:  StagesPerceive DifferencesMagnify DifferencesStereotypeDenigrateSame or Different?Very Different!They are all that wayWe are good; they are not.
PerceiveDifferencesEconomic ConsultingBusiness Consulting
Magnify DifferencesStereotype
We vs. They
Win vs. Lose
Diligent Due DiligenceSynergies: Strategic and Financial “Fit” Organizational and Cultural FitComplementary organization structures/systemsDepth of management talentUnderstandings of the marketCultural norms and valuesHR relations, stakeholder issuesDo your homework- Internet, reporters, academics, retirees, former employees, etc.Culture Surveys!
The Denison Organizational Culture ModelMissionDefining a meaningful long-term direction for the organization“Do we know where we are going?”AdaptabilityTranslating the demands of the business environment into action“Are we listeningto the marketplace?”ConsistencyDefining the valuesand systems that are the basis of a strong culture“Does our system create leverage?”InvolvementBuilding human capability, ownership, and responsibility“Are our people alignedand engaged?“
Software AcquisitionOverall strong profileKey areas for leverage: Teamwork, Empowerment, Creating Change, Agreement and Coordination & IntegrationNeed for Strategic Direction & Goal AlignmentIntegrated IT CompanyStronger Internal FocusKey areas for leverage: Teamwork, Empowerment, Core Values, Agreement and Goals & ObjectivesNeed for Strategic Direction, Capability Development & ADAPTABILITY
Software AcquisitionIntegrated IT Company
Culture & IntegrationHighCombineCarefullyCombineQuicklyCoordinate, CombineSlowlyIntegration:How importantto Strategy? Savings? Synergy?Combine as NeededSeparateLowHardEasyCulture Clash:  Ease of Integration?
Post merger culturesMulticulturalIntegrated: Distinct but all part of the familyPluralistic:  Many tribes, in confederationSegregated:  Superiors and inferiorsMonoculturalMelting Pot: One “happy” familyPressure Cooker: One family or elseEthnocide:  Kill ‘em off
Mergers and Acquisitions Culture Clashes - Diagnosing and Dealing with Them

Mergers and Acquisitions Culture Clashes - Diagnosing and Dealing with Them

  • 1.
    M&A Culture Clashes: Diagnosing and Dealing with themPhilip H. MirvisFortune magazine “merger maven”with Mitchell Marks @DenisonCulture.com
  • 2.
    M&A Culture Clashes: Diagnosing and Dealing with themPhilip H. MirvisFortune magazine “merger maven”with Mitchell Marks @DenisonCulture.com
  • 4.
    Merger hit rate65-85% of Mergers and Acquisitions FailVs. precombination earnings of 2 cos.Vs. promised returns by executivesVs. costs of capital WHY?
  • 5.
  • 6.
    Define the EndStateacquired
  • 7.
    Company AEngineering &MarketingQualityMatrixPlanningProfessionalCollegialTeamworkOur WayCompany BR&DSpeedFunctionalReady, Fire, AimEntrepreneurialPoliticalStar SystemMy WayTheoretic SynergiesLeading Edge TechnologyBroader User BaseFaster Time to MarketProduct ReliabilityTechnology Transfer
  • 10.
  • 11.
    How and whereto Integrate?
  • 12.
  • 13.
    What’s happening inthis picture?Company ACompany B
  • 14.
    Physical Signs andPublic BehaviorsNorms and Values Private BehaviorsBeliefs on ‘Human Nature and Reality’“Layers” of Culture
  • 15.
    Culture Clash: StagesPerceive DifferencesMagnify DifferencesStereotypeDenigrateSame or Different?Very Different!They are all that wayWe are good; they are not.
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20.
    Diligent Due DiligenceSynergies:Strategic and Financial “Fit” Organizational and Cultural FitComplementary organization structures/systemsDepth of management talentUnderstandings of the marketCultural norms and valuesHR relations, stakeholder issuesDo your homework- Internet, reporters, academics, retirees, former employees, etc.Culture Surveys!
  • 21.
    The Denison OrganizationalCulture ModelMissionDefining a meaningful long-term direction for the organization“Do we know where we are going?”AdaptabilityTranslating the demands of the business environment into action“Are we listeningto the marketplace?”ConsistencyDefining the valuesand systems that are the basis of a strong culture“Does our system create leverage?”InvolvementBuilding human capability, ownership, and responsibility“Are our people alignedand engaged?“
  • 22.
    Software AcquisitionOverall strongprofileKey areas for leverage: Teamwork, Empowerment, Creating Change, Agreement and Coordination & IntegrationNeed for Strategic Direction & Goal AlignmentIntegrated IT CompanyStronger Internal FocusKey areas for leverage: Teamwork, Empowerment, Core Values, Agreement and Goals & ObjectivesNeed for Strategic Direction, Capability Development & ADAPTABILITY
  • 23.
  • 24.
    Culture & IntegrationHighCombineCarefullyCombineQuicklyCoordinate,CombineSlowlyIntegration:How importantto Strategy? Savings? Synergy?Combine as NeededSeparateLowHardEasyCulture Clash: Ease of Integration?
  • 25.
    Post merger culturesMulticulturalIntegrated:Distinct but all part of the familyPluralistic: Many tribes, in confederationSegregated: Superiors and inferiorsMonoculturalMelting Pot: One “happy” familyPressure Cooker: One family or elseEthnocide: Kill ‘em off