LEED CASE STUDY
&
LEED GA EXAM PREP
4 hours total
AIA: 2 CEU’s Sustainable Design
ASID and IIDA: .2 CEU’s
USGBC Green Associate qualified
WHAT TO EXPECT TODAY
1. Share the LEED for Homes Experience – 2007 – THE
START OF A LEED EDUCATION
2. CASE STUDY: Describe the LEED process, including lessons
learned, rating system comparisons, green by LEED
definition, trade-offs of material selection, recycling, the
project costs, energy analysis, and tax benefits.
3. Explain the NAHB Green Rating System and the utilization
of it. And, the Top 10 lists
4. LEED GA PREP: Define LEED and the USGBC and share the
overview of the rating system
COMING UP > Myths | Why did I remodel a LEED house? | MRED | Existing home – no tear down | Preserve exterior walls
TODAY’S OVERVIEW
Mesa Verde, Colorado
Settled 1400 years ago
Continuously occupied for 700 years
THE LEED
FOR HOMES
EXPERINCE
myths I heard
GREEN MYTHS
GREEN IS TOO EXPENSIVE
GREEN MYTHS
GREEN IS UGLY
GREEN MYTHS
GREEN IS CONFUSING
GREEN MYTHS
GREEN IS POLITICAL
challenging finding a
team – became the GC
LEED EXPERIENCE BEGINS
MEDLOCK BEFORE
naïve, first time
What Medlock is, and isn’t
MEDLOCK IS NOT
Overview of LEED
An Architectural Award Winner The Perfect Green Home
MEDLOCK IS
The first LEED certified
single-family remodel in
Arizona
The second LEED Gold
certified single-family
remodel in the U.S.
• A good case study for green remodeling
• Well Planned Remodel
• A project that preserved all exterior walls
• An improvement to traditional building code and practice
MEDLOCK IS
1 = 1 pt - High albedo materials installed
for at least 50% of the site’s hardscape
POINT SYSTEM
Inspiration, asu, etc
Conclusions: Remodel existing home, in the urban core & make it green. What is green? Need a rating system.
So, the LEED education begins…..
Single-Family Building Permits:
Phoenix and Maricopa County
Jan Feb Mar Apr May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec
2005 897 851 1239 1229 972 867 783 934 1028 754 774
1108
Maricopa
42727
2006 837 1239 925 632 1218 862 793 710 590 400 512
513
Maricopa
27812
2007 562 813 859 638 693 632 391 352 173 164 155
201
Maricopa
20183
2008 174 204 244 240 213 292 285 108 135 116 72 93 Maricopa
9643
2009 71 39 70 113 138 200
149
Maricopa
3728
131 107 128 100 90
2010 104 135
Jan Feb Mar Apr May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec
2005 76 193 253 207 208 226 198 206 207 175 156 156
Pima
11166
2006 148 148 190 147 196 186 136 140 113 103 96
93
Pima
8132
2007 107 104 140 163 170 159 136 125 88 96 70
64
Pima
4698
2008 62 64 72 62 64 65 54 46 42 37 24
23
Pima
2743
2009 20 21 28 37 40
48
Pima
384
Single-Family Building Permits:
Tucson and Pima County
RESIDENTIAL PERMIT ACTIVITY
ANNUAL RESIDENTIAL PERMIT ACTIVITY
PHOENIX-MESA-SCOTTSDALE, AZ MSA
SEPTEMBER 2009
0
10,000
20,000
30,000
40,000
50,000
60,000
70,000
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009est
2010prj
2011prj
2012prj
2013prj
2014prj
Single Family Multi-Family
5-Year Forecast
Annual Residential Permit Activity
Phoenix – Mesa – Scottsdale, AZ MSA
September 2009
SEPTEMBER 2005
Lessons learned
JULY 2009
1. Share the LEED for Homes Experience – 2007 – THE START
OF A LEED EDUCATION
2. CASE STUDY: Describe the LEED process, including
lessons learned, rating system comparisons, green by
LEED definition, trade-offs of material selection, recycling,
the project costs, energy analysis, and tax benefits.
3. Explain the NAHB Green Rating System and the utilization
of it. And, the Top 10 lists
4. LEED GA PREP: Define LEED and the USGBC and share the
overview of the rating system
COMING UP > Myths | Why did I remodel a LEED house? | MRED | Existing home – no tear down | Preserve exterior walls
TODAY’S OVERVIEW
Decisions Were Made with the
Best Available Information at
the Given Time
LEED EXPERIENCE
WHAT I HAVE TO DO
WHAT I WANT TO DO
WHAT I CAN DO
DECISION MAKING PROCESS
LEEDPREREQUISITES Innovation and Design (ID) 1.1 Preliminary Rating
Innovation and Design (ID) 2.1 and
2.2
Durability Planning
Durability Management
Sustainable Sites (SS) 1.1 and 2.1 Erosion controls
No invasive Plants
Energy and Atmosphere (EA) 2.1, 3.1,
5.1, 6.1, 8.1, 11.1
Basic Insulation, Reduced Envelope
Leakage, Good Windows, Reduced
Distribution Losses, Good HVAC
design, Energy Star Lights,
Refrigerant Charge Test
Materials and Resources (MR) 1.1,
2.1, 3.1
Framing Waste Factor, FSC Wood for
EPP, Construction Waste
Management
Indoor Environmental Quality (EQ)
2.1, 4.1, 5.1, 6.1, 7.1, 9.1, 10.1
Basic Combusting Measures, Outdoor
Air Ventilation, Local Exhaust,
Manual J, Good filters, Radon-
resistant, No HVAC in Garage
Awareness and Education (AE) 1.1 Basic Operations Training
WHAT I HAVE TO DO
What I HAVE to do NAHB
WHAT I WANT TO DO
WHAT I WANT TO DO
TANKLESS ELECTRIC
Budget
Time
Durability
WHAT I WANT TO DO
REFLECTIVE ROOF
Resale
Aesthetics
WHAT I WANT TO DO
RAIN CAPTURE
Budget
Practicality
The water heater is responsible for 12% of the home’s energy
consumption. If 10% of Arizona’s homes had solar hot water heaters, it
would save enough energy to power more than 36,000 homes.
aps.com
WHAT I WANT TO DO
SOLAR HOT WATER HEATER
Budget
Installation
WHAT I WANT TO DO
PV SYSTEM
Budget
Existing design
HOA
WHAT I WANT TO DO
KITCHEN GARDEN
Dual flush toilets can save up to 67% of water compared to
traditional toilets, which use 1.6 gallons per flush.
WHAT I WANT TO DO
LOW FLUSH TOILETS
1WE 3.1 =
WHAT I WANT TO DO
NO VOC PAINTS
WHAT I WANT TO DO
FOAM INSULATION
Budget
Installation
WHAT I WANT TO DO
NEW HVAC
Budget
WHAT I WANT TO DO
NEW WINDOWS
Budget
City Codes
WHAT I WANT TO DO
WIND ENERGY
Budget
Time
HOA
WHAT I WANT TO DO
ALL DEPENDS ON:
In this lies… “what does green
mean? –importance of rating system
Who is the occupant? What is the budget? What is the time frame? Aesthetics?
Environmental impact? Installation? Durability? Cool factor? City codes?
New information or better knowledge Policy or government incentives
1. Share the LEED for Homes Experience – 2007 – THE START
OF A LEED EDUCATION
2. CASE STUDY: Describe the LEED process, including lessons
learned, rating system comparisons, green by LEED
definition, trade-offs of material selection, recycling, the
project costs, energy analysis, and tax benefits.
3. Explain the NAHB Green Rating System and the utilization
of it. And, the Top 10 lists
4. LEED GA PREP: Define LEED and the USGBC and share the
overview of the rating system
COMING UP > Myths | Why did I remodel a LEED house? | MRED | Existing home – no tear down | Preserve exterior walls
TODAY’S OVERVIEW
WHAT DOES IT
MEAN TO GO
GREEN?
100 people = 100 answers I LEED & NAHB I Define LEED
IN SIMPLE TERMS:
GREEN =
REDUCING
ENVIRONMENTAL
IMPACT
LEED
NAHB
Scottsdale Green Building
Energy Star
Tucson: Regional Green Building
TEP: Guarantee Home
GREEN RATING SYSTEMS
Agency Cost Level Rating Type Tradeoffs Verify Medlock Provider
LEED
$525
$375 USGBC
Members
$4000 Consultation
Certified
Silver
Gold
Platinum
Point System
Organized by
Environmental
Impact Areas
•Hi costs
•Documentat
ion
•Not regional
•Third-party
inspected
Blower Door
Duct Test
HERS
Third-party
LEED Gold
Rich Franz-
Ünder
520-740-6490
NAHB
$500
$200 Members
Consultation $450
*National Green
Building Standard
Bronze
Silver
Gold
Morphing
into ICC-
700, will
include
Emerald
Point System
Organized by
Environmental
Impact Areas
•Less
expensive
than LEED
•Code-able
Third-party
HERS
Gold
Hank Kryzsik
520.327.4846
Or
Mick Dalrymple
GREEN RATING SYSTEMS
Means to an end
ANSI approved ICC-700 2008 National Green Building Standard for residential construction.  The ICC-700 standard was developed by
the National Association of Home Builders in partnership with the International Code Council
Agency Cost Level Rating Type Tradeoffs Verify Medlock Provider
Scottsdale 0
Entry
Advanced
Point System
Organized by
Construction
Categories
•Regional
•Expedite
•Plan Review
Plan Review
Verified by
Building
Inspectors
Advanced 480.312.4202
Energy Star Consultation
$600
Energy Star
Energy Star
+
IAP
RESNET
Standards
•Limited HERS
Rater
HERS 55
602.532.2976
ext 3
Azhomeperforma
nce.com
Pima 0
Up to
Emerald
Launches August
5th
Rich Franz- Ünder
520-740-6490
TEP
No cost to the
Builder – plan
review to TEP
specs
Guaranteed
Home
Guaranteed
•Only new
construction
Multiple
inspections No
remodels
520-623-7211
GREEN RATING SYSTEMS
Since medlock is LEED lets talk in more detail
HIGHLIGHTS
•Cut energy consumption by over 50%
•Improved air quality by using low or no VOC materials
•Located within close proximity of many local amenities
•Minimum construction waste and preservation of all exterior walls
•Designed to maximize livable area
•Increased water efficiency using fixtures and native landscaping
LEED
What I walked away from the LEED-H remodel experience
3313 E MEDLOCK
Water Reuse: LEED as A Design Tool
vs.
LEED EXPERIENCE
1 4
• Most recognized green rating system
• The Team Charette
• An Improved Project Team
• An excellent guide for a first timer
• Management Plan
• An improvement of traditional codes and practices
WHY I’m Glad I Chose LEED
2
How does LEED define green? Environmental impact areas
LEED EXPERIENCE
1. Share the LEED for Homes Experience – 2007 – THE START
OF A LEED EDUCATION
2. CASE STUDY: Describe the LEED process, including lessons
learned, rating system comparisons, green by LEED
definition, trade-offs of material selection, recycling, the
project costs, energy analysis, and tax benefits.
3. Explain the NAHB Green Rating System and the utilization
of it. And, the Top 10 lists
4. LEED GA PREP: Define LEED and the USGBC and share the
overview of the rating system
COMING UP > Myths | Why did I remodel a LEED house? | MRED | Existing home – no tear down | Preserve exterior walls
TODAY’S OVERVIEW
Medlock’s Design:
Defining a GREEN home
• Efficiency: Water and Energy
• IEQ
• Location
• Design – who is the Occupant?
• Photo Tour
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
GREEN: WATER EFFICIENCY & LANDSCAPE DESIGN
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
Site Stewardship At least 40% of lot
undisturbed. 1pt
Landscaping Drought tolerant
turf. Turf less
than 20% of lot.
Drought tolerant
plants. 7pts
Shading High-albedo used
for at least 50% of
site’s hardscape.
1pt
Surface Water
Management
Professional
design for erosion
control. 6pts
Irrigation Designed by
licensed
Professional. 4pts
Central shut off.
Time control for
zones. Valves in
heads inspected.
3pts
Ar
22
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
SITE STEWARDSHIP
Landscaping
A front loading washer uses 22 gallons of water; a
top loading washer uses 45 gallons.
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
WATER CONSERVATION
2EA 9.2 =
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
ENERGY EFFICIENCY
Acoustics
Thermal Comfort
1
2
2
Air Infiltration
MR 2.2 Emission EPP
Enhanced Insulation
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
ENERGY EFFICIENCY
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
ENERGY EFFICIENCY
4
3rd
Party Verified
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
ENERGY EFFICIENCY
Thermal imagery: MEDLOCK
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
GREEN DESIGN
The average single family home in the
U.S. is 40% larger today than it was 30
years ago.
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
GREEN DESIGN
5
4 bedrooms, 2140 sq ft
10Site Selection Existing lot. 2 pts
Preferred Location Infill and Previously
Developed. 3pts
Infrastructure Within ½ Mile of Water and
Sewer
Community Resources and
Transit
Within ½ mile of 14
Community Services. 3pts
Access to Open Space Within ½ mile of Green
Space. 1pt
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
LOCATION & LINKAGES
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
GREEN DESIGN
VISTANCIA TO
DOWNTOWN PHX
= 38 MILES
($40 RT)
Preserve all exterior walls
Orientation
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
GREEN DESIGN
ORIGINAL
FLYER
FROM
1959
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
Making the old new,
photo tour
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
GREEN DESIGN
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
GREEN DESIGN
NEW SEWER LINE | DURABILITY
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
GREEN DESIGN
Healthy Home
Replaced
Galvanized Line
1
•Exterior wall shear non-wood
•Joists spaced greater than 16”
•Headers sized for actual loads
•2-stud corners
•Waste factor no more than 10%
3
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
GREEN DESIGN
Where to put the kitchen? Support beam? Daylighting?
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
GREEN DESIGN
2
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
GREEN DESIGN
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
GREEN DESIGN
4
1. Share the LEED for Homes Experience – 2007 – THE START
OF A LEED EDUCATION
2. CASE STUDY: Describe the LEED process, including lessons
learned, rating system comparisons, green by LEED
definition, trade-offs of material selection, recycling, the
project costs, energy analysis, and tax benefits.
3. Explain the NAHB Green Rating System and the utilization
of it. And, the Top 10 lists
4. LEED GA PREP: Define LEED and the USGBC and share the
overview of the rating system
COMING UP > Myths | Why did I remodel a LEED house? | MRED | Existing home – no tear down | Preserve exterior walls
TODAY’S OVERVIEW
LEED EXPERIENCE
RECYCLING
3
LEED EXPERIENCE
RECYCLING
LEED EXPERIENCE
RECYCLING
3
LEED EXPERIENCE
REUSE & RECYCLING - Phoenix
LEED EXPERIENCE
REUSE & RECYCLING - Tucson
1. Share the LEED for Homes Experience – 2007 – THE START
OF A LEED EDUCATION
2. CASE STUDY: Describe the LEED process, including lessons
learned, rating system comparisons, green by LEED
definition, trade-offs of material selection, recycling, the
project costs, energy analysis, and tax benefits.
3. Explain the NAHB Green Rating System and the utilization
of it. And, the Top 10 lists
4. LEED GA PREP: Define LEED and the USGBC and share the
overview of the rating system
COMING UP > Myths | Why did I remodel a LEED house? | MRED | Existing home – no tear down | Preserve exterior walls
TODAY’S OVERVIEW
Decisions Were Made with the
Best Available Information at
the Given Time
LEED EXPERIENCE
MATERIAL SOURCING: STRATEGIES & DECISION MAKING
Credit Item Points Cost for Medlock Tradeoffs Payback
EA 2.1 Basic Insulation Preq $3000 Less expensive
Less efficient
No additional points
EA 2.2 Enhanced Insulation 2 $8500 Additional LEED
points
Efficiency
Health
acoustic
2 – 4 years
EA 3.1
3.2
3,3
Air Infiltration
Reduced Leakage
Greatly Reduced
Minimum
2 Planning +efficiency
EA 5 Heating & Cooling 3 Planning +efficiency
MR 2.2 EPP
&
Emissions
.5
.5
no additional health
8
LEED EXPERIENCE
EA 2: INSULATION
Credit Item Points Cost for Medlock Tradeoffs Payback
Traditional
EA 4.1 Good Windows <.40 Preq $4500 - $6500
EA 4.2 Enhanced Windows
<.35
2 $5,500 - $7,500
2009 - $2500 vinyl, $4500
Premium Wood, $6,000
Custom Wood
18 months
EA 4.3 Exceptional
Windows <.30
3 $8,500 - $12,500
EA 6 Space Heating &
Cooling
3 Design and Planning +efficiency
2+3
LEED EXPERIENCE
EA 4: WINDOWS
LEED EXPERIENCE
Credit Item Points Cost for
Medlock
Tradeoffs Payback Medlock
Traditional HVAC – no design - $18000 Less efficiency
EA 5.3
Minimal
Distribution
Losses
Duct Tightness: Min
Dist Losses <1 CFM
per 100sf
3 Planning and
Design
+efficiency US Air
Conditioning
EA 6.1
EA 6.2
EA 6.3
GOOD – 13 SEER
HIGH EFF – 14 SEER
VERY HIGH 15 SEER
Preq
2 points
4 points
$10500
Manual J
Programmable
Thermostat
Comfort
Air quality
18 months 16 SEER
US Air Cond
EA 11 HVAC Refrigerant 1 Design and
Planning
environment US Air
Conditioning
8
EA 5: DUCT TIGHTNESS / EA 6: SPACE HEATING & COOLING
Credit Item Points Cost for
Medlock
Tradeoffs Payback Medlock
EA 10
(in 2007)
Renewable
Energy System
1-10 $60,000 (2007) 0 Points
EA 10
(in 2009)
Renewable
Energy System
2009
10 $19,000 (2009
with rebates and
credits)
+ Environmental:
less CO
emissions
+ value of home
+ LEED Platinum
6 years REC Solar
LEED EXPERIENCE
EA 5: DUCT TIGHTNESS / EA 6: SPACE HEATING & COOLING
LEED EXPERIENCE
ENVIRONMENTALLY PREFERRED PRODUCTS
MR 2.1 & 2.2
6-8
EPP .5 POINTS EMISSION SPECS .5 POINTS LOCAL PRODUCTION .5 POINTS
Recycled, FSC certified, or
Reclaimed.
No added formaldehyde
•Green Label +
•100% hard flooring = auto .5 points
•Paints and coatings = GS 11
•Finishes = SCAQM
Manufactured within 500 miles of
home
COMPONENT MAX POINTS
Flooring 2 pts
Paints and coatings 1 pt
Decking or patio 1 point
Cabinets 1 point
Counters 1 point
Doors 1 point
Trim 1 point
LEED EXPERIENCE
ENVIRONMENTALLY PREFERRED PRODUCTS (EPP)
MR 2.1 & 2.2
South coast air quality management
Credit Item Points Cost for
Medlock
Tradeoffs Payback
Traditional Carpet Padding
and
Carpet
- .50 cents sf or
$250
$2 sf or $1000
MR 2.2 Carpet Padding
CRI +
and Carpet
.5 Emissions $1.20 sf or $600
$4 sf or $2000
health Health
Traditional Traditional
Bamboo
- $1.95 sf or $3000
MR 2.2 Flooring:
Bamboo
.5 EPP $4.00 or $6000 More expensive
Health
LEED EXPERIENCE
MR 2.2 SELECT ENVIRONMENTALLY PREFERABLE PRODUCTS
FLOORING
1
Credit Item Points Cost for
Medlock
Tradeoffs Payback
Traditional Paints and
Coatings
- $1080
(27 gallons)
MR 2.2 Paints and
Coatings
.5 EPP –meets
GS 43
.5 Emissions –
GS 11
$1080
(27 gallons)
Health Health
LEED EXPERIENCE
MR 2.2 SELECT ENVIRONMENTALLY PREFERABLE PRODUCTS
PAINTS
1
Cost? Green more expensive? First review of MR 2.2
EPP .5 POINTS EMISSION SPECS .5 POINTS LOCAL PRODUCTION .5 POINTS
Recycled, FSC certified, or
Reclaimed.
No added formaldehyde
•Green Label +
•100% hard flooring = auto .5 points
•Paints and coatings = GS 11
•Finishes = SCAQM
Manufactured within 500 miles of
home
COMPONENT MAX POINTS
Flooring 2 pts
Paints and coatings 1 pt
Decking or patio 1 point
Cabinets 1 point
Counters 1 point
Doors 1 point
Trim 1 point
LEED EXPERIENCE
ENVIRONMENTALLY PREFERRED PRODUCTS (EPP)
MR 2.1 & 2.2
Does it all make sense? Save energy?
1. Share the LEED for Homes Experience – 2007 – THE START
OF A LEED EDUCATION
2. CASE STUDY: Describe the LEED process, including lessons
learned, rating system comparisons, green by LEED
definition, trade-offs of material selection, recycling, the
project costs, energy analysis, and tax benefits.
3. Explain the NAHB Green Rating System and the utilization
of it. And, the Top 10 lists
4. LEED GA PREP: Define LEED and the USGBC and share the
overview of the rating system
COMING UP > Myths | Why did I remodel a LEED house? | MRED | Existing home – no tear down | Preserve exterior walls
TODAY’S OVERVIEW
Traditional Green Tradeoffs Payback !0-year return
Insulation $2,500 $8,500 3 years *
Windows $4,500 $8,500 3-5 years *
Framing $25,000 $22,000
HVAC $15,000 $8,500 immed *
Landscape w/
hardscape
$20,000 $45,000
LEED Landscape
Design
$1,000 $8,500
Recessed
Lighting
$100 $1500 *
Bamboo
Flooring
$4,000 $8,000 health
Countertops $13,000 $13,000
Cabinets $18,000 $22,000
Backsplash $1,800 $2,800
Toilets $900 $900 1 year
LEED EXPERIENCE
PRO FORMA
ITEMS COMBINE FOR $30,000 ENERGY SAVINGS OVER 15 YEARS
Traditional Green Tradeoffs Payback !0-year return
Third Party
Test
- $400
Electrical
Upgrade
$7,200 $7,200
New Plumbing
and Sewer
$10,500 $10,500
LEED
Certification
- $4,600
Fixtures $2,500 $2,500 *
Sub-Total $190,000 $218,000
2009 Tax
Credits
-$5,575
15-year energy
savings
-$30,000
TOTAL $190,000 $182,425
PROVE $30,000 IN ENERGY SAVINGS
LEED EXPERIENCE
PRO FORMA
1. Share the LEED for Homes Experience – 2007 – THE START
OF A LEED EDUCATION
2. CASE STUDY: Describe the LEED process, including lessons
learned, rating system comparisons, green by LEED
definition, trade-offs of material selection, recycling, the
project costs, energy analysis, and tax benefits.
3. Explain the NAHB Green Rating System and the utilization
of it. And, the Top 10 lists
4. LEED GA PREP: Define LEED and the USGBC and share the
overview of the rating system
COMING UP > Myths | Why did I remodel a LEED house? | MRED | Existing home – no tear down | Preserve exterior walls
TODAY’S OVERVIEW
LEED EXPERIENCE
ENERGY ANALYSIS
3313 E MEDLOCK COMPARED TO 3307 & 3319 E MEDLOCK
3 things used for analysis; SRP; Energy 10; Energy Star
LEED EXPERIENCE
THE CLAIM
LEED EXPERIENCE
ENERGY 10: MEDLOCK
Explain Energy 10
Medlock uses
53.09% LESS
energy than
average
Valley home
3319 33073313
LEED EXPERIENCE
COMPARED TO NEIGHBORS
COMPARED TO NEIGHBORS
NEIGHBOR ‘MEDLOCK’ NEIGHBOR
Sq ft 1400
Occupants 2
Remodeled never
NEIGHBOR: 3319 E MEDLOCK
Sq ft 1700
Occupants 1
Remodeled 2007
NEIGHBOR: 3307 E MEDLOCK
Sq ft 2150
Occupants 1
Remodeled 2007
GREEN STREET HOME: 3313 E MEDLOCK
3307 3313 3319
August $158 vs. $308 $195 $132 vs. $302
Medlock 49% less 56% less
Energy 10 53% less
August 2008: Medlock versus 3307 and 3319
3307 and 3319 rate if as efficient as Medlock
LEED EXPERIENCE
ENERGY ANALYSIS
3313 E MEDLOCK COMPARED TO 3307 & 3319 E MEDLOCK
LEED EXPERIENCE
ENERGY ANALYSIS
3313 E MEDLOCK COMPARED TO 3307 & 3319 E MEDLOCK
3319 E MEDLOCK
LEED EXPERIENCE
ENERGY ANALYSIS
3313 E MEDLOCK COMPARED TO 3307 & 3319 E MEDLOCK
3313 E MEDLOCK
Time to test the market - April 2008
LEED EXPERIENCE
MARKET CRASHES IN PHOENIX
APRIL 2008
10 MINUTE
BREAK
Incentives and
NAHB
1. Share the LEED for Homes Experience – 2007 – THE START
OF A LEED EDUCATION
2. CASE STUDY: Describe the LEED process, including lessons
learned, rating system comparisons, green by LEED
definition, trade-offs of material selection, recycling, the
project costs, energy analysis, and tax benefits.
3. Explain the NAHB Green Rating System and the utilization
of it. And, the Top 10 lists
4. LEED GA PREP: Define LEED and the USGBC and share the
overview of the rating system
COMING UP > Myths | Why did I remodel a LEED house? | MRED | Existing home – no tear down | Preserve exterior walls
TODAY’S OVERVIEW
Vendor/
Manufacturer
FEDERAL STATE APS SRP TOTAL
HVAC York
$1500 rebate
Tax credit
30%
Includes labor
- SEER 13 $175
SEER 14 – 16 $425
SEER 17 $525
SEER 15 $200
SEER 16 $300
SEER 17 $400
$3525
INSULATION 30% of cost
Includes Labor
($1500 total home)
$1500
WINDOWS
(skylights)
Manufacturer 30%
Not including labor
Less than .30 U Factor
$2250
DUCTS
TEST
.75 x cost of repair, up
to $75
$75
DUCTS
REPAIR
.75 x cost of repair up
to $175
$175
Water Heaters SW Gas $75 30% tax credit
SOLAR HOT
WATER HEATER
30% tax credit, no
maximum
25% of the
cost up to
$1000
$.75/kWh of estimated
first year savings up to
50% of system cost
Utility Rebate
$.50/kWh of installed
kWh
$3800 -
$4000
HOME SELLER
selling energy
efficient home
Personal
Deduction
5% of sales
price, up to 5k
$5000
LEED EXPERIENCE
TAX CREDITS & REBATES
Discuss handouts I Energy efficient – state stimulus
LEED EXPERIENCE
TAX CREDITS & REBATES
LEED EXPERIENCE
TAX CREDITS & REBATES
1. Share the LEED for Homes Experience – 2007 – THE START
OF A LEED EDUCATION
2. CASE STUDY: Describe the LEED process, including lessons
learned, rating system comparisons, green by LEED
definition, trade-offs of material selection, recycling, the
project costs, energy analysis, and tax benefits.
3. Explain the NAHB Green Rating System and the
utilization of it. And, the Top 10 lists
4. LEED GA PREP: Define LEED and the USGBC and share the
overview of the rating system
COMING UP > Myths | Why did I remodel a LEED house? | MRED | Existing home – no tear down | Preserve exterior walls
TODAY’S OVERVIEW
NAHB RATING SYSTEM
Green Street Homes: Crisis leads to Opportunity
NAHB RATING SYSTEM
•Located within ¼ mile of Light Rail
•The greenest building is the existing one
•Green-certified, verified, recognized
•Affordable- priced at or below market
•Energy Rated
GREEN STREET HOMES
Practical
Simple
Recognized
Non-document intensive
Easy to understand for trades
Third-party verified
NAHB RATING SYSTEM
NEEDED A RATING SYSTEM THAT WAS:
Water Heater not in conditioned space unless in separate
room with outdoor air source
Wall-to-wall carpeting is not installed adjacent to water
closets or bathing fixtures
All bathrooms are vented to outdoors at least 50 cfm
Clothes dryer is vented to the outdoors.
Kitchen exhaust at least 400 cfm
Existing unsealed combustion gas dryer is sealed with
sealed exhaust vent
NAHB RATING SYSTEM
PRE-1980 HAVE-TO’S:
Bronze – 20%
Silver – 34%
Gold – 43%
Emerald – 50%
NAHB RATING SYSTEM
NGBS RATING LEVELS
ANSI approved ICC-700 2008 National Green Building Standard for residential construction.  The ICC-700 standard was developed by
the National Association of Home Builders in partnership with the International Code Council
GREEN STREET
HOMES
150 W ELM
EMERALD
CERTIFIED
BEFORE
AFTER
BEFORE
AFTER
BEFORE
AFTER
BEFORE
AFTER
BEFORE
AFTER
AFTER
AFTER
150 W Elm – Before & After
Pre HERS 208
Post HERS 79
Annual Savings $1200
Water Savings 62%
Purchase Price 90k
Improvement Cost 70k
Sales Price 240k
WORKSHOP OVERVIEW
New HVAC $6500
New Windows and Doors $13500
Foam Insulation $1500
Landscape and Hardscape $11,500
New roof $5500
Paint, interior and exterior $6500
Sub-total $41,500
WORKSHOP OVERVIE
150 W Elm – IMPROVEMENTS & BUDGET
1818 W TURNEY – EMERALD CERTIFIED
WORKSHOP OVERVIEW
BEFOREAFTER
Pre HERS 284
Post HERS 76
Annual Savings $2000
Water Savings 72%
Purchase Price 39k
Improvement Cost 42k
Sales Price 119k
1818 W TURNEY – Before & After
GREEN STREET HOMES
IMPROVEMENTS AND BUDGET
New HVAC $5400
New Windows and Doors $3500
Landscaping $6500
Insulation $1600
Appliances $2500
Sub-total $19,500
GREEN STREET HOMES
1818 W TURNEY – IMPROVEMENTS & BUDGET
5626 N 20TH DRIVE – BRONZE CERTIFIED
GREEN STREET HOMES
BEFOREAFTER
5626 N 20th
Dr – before/after
Pre HERS 195
Post HERS 120
Annual Savings $650
Water Savings 40%
Purchase Price 47k
Improvement Cost 31k
Sales Price 124k
1818 W TURNEY – Before & After
GREEN STREET HOMES
IMPROVEMENTS AND BUDGET
Tune up HVAC and tighten ducts $1300
New appliances $2600
Caulk windows and weather
stripping
$250
New water heater $400
Cellulose Insulation $400
CFL’s $50
Sub-total $5000
GREEN STREET HOMES
IMPROVEMENTS & BUDGET
319 W VIRGINIA – GOLD CERTIFIED
GREEN STREET HOMES
BEFORE
319 W Virginia – before/after
Pre HERS 194
Post HERS 122 (37% improve)
Annual Savings $900
Water Savings 40%
Purchase Price 178k
Improvement Cost 90k
Sales Price 409k
319 W VIRGINIA – Before & After
GREEN STREET HOMES
IMPROVEMENTS AND BUDGET
Foam Insulation $4000
Solar Water Heater $6500 (before incentives)
Caulk windows and weather strip $300
CFL’s $50
Landscape $3700
Water Sense Fixtures and Toilets $1500
Sub-total $16050
GREEN STREET HOMES
319 W VIRGINIA – IMPROVEMENTS & BUDGET
RESIDENTIAL PERMIT ACTIVITY
ANNUAL RESIDENTIAL PERMIT ACTIVITY
PHOENIX-MESA-SCOTTSDALE, AZ MSA
SEPTEMBER 2009
0
10,000
20,000
30,000
40,000
50,000
60,000
70,000
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009est
2010prj
2011prj
2012prj
2013prj
2014prj
Single Family Multi-Family
5-Year Forecast
Annual Residential Permit Activity
Phoenix – Mesa – Scottsdale, AZ MSA
September 2009
1. Share the LEED for Homes Experience – 2007 – A GREEN
REMODEL EDUCATION
2. Lessons learned, the need for a Rating System, Green by
Definition, Material Selection, Recycling, The Cost, A LEED
Case Study
3. Tax Credits, Rebates, and Stimulus Funds
4. Explain the NAHB Green Rating System
5. Putting the NAHB Green Rating System to Practice
6. TOP 10 List – low budget or open budget
7. Q & A: Expert Panel
WORKSHOP OVERVIEW
1. Test ducts for tightness, and sealing of leaks.
2. Professional HVAC service, and install of programmable thermostat
3. Caulking of and leaks in the building envelope, including windows and doors
4. The use of a recycle bin in the kitchen.
5. Replacement of incandescent lighting with cfl’s
6. The use of household cleaners that do not contain toxic chemicals. Homemade
cleaners are best, using items such as vinegar, baking soda, and tea tree oil.
And, the elimination of all chemical air fresheners.
7. The use of shading via plants or screens on walls or windows with high sun
exposure.
8. The installation of daylighting in dark areas of your home to reduce the need for
lights and to improve mental health
9. Upgrade insulation to a higher R value
10. Installation of highly reflective window film
TOP TEN
LOW BUDGET GREEN HOME IMPROVEMENTS:
1. Foam insulation in the lid of the roof
2. New windows
3. New HVAC (always windows before HVAC, and Manual J required before
determining size of unit)
4. Solar Hot water heater (current incentives and rebates results in a $1500 net cost
to homeowner)
5. Front loading clothes washer, will reduce water usage by more than 60%
compared to a top loading washers)
6. Native landscaping along with an irrigation system, and turf reduction
7. Consideration of low environmental impact materials when selecting new
cabinets, flooring, countertops, or paint.
8. A rain capture system, and consideration to low flush toilets and Water Sense
labeled fixtures
9. A Photovoltaic system once doing all the above building envelope improvements,
which will reduce the size of the PV system needed
10. Get your project LEED or NAHB certified
TOP TEN
MEDIUM TO HIGH BUDGET GREEN HOME IMPROVEMENTS:
1. Share the LEED for Homes Experience – 2007 – THE START
OF A LEED EDUCATION
2. CASE STUDY: Describe the LEED process, including lessons
learned, rating system comparisons, green by LEED
definition, trade-offs of material selection, recycling, the
project costs, energy analysis, and tax benefits.
3. Explain the NAHB Green Rating System and the utilization
of it. And, the Top 10 lists
4. LEED GA PREP: Define LEED and the USGBC and share
the overview of the rating system
COMING UP > Myths | Why did I remodel a LEED house? | MRED | Existing home – no tear down | Preserve exterior walls
TODAY’S OVERVIEW
greenstreetdev.com
602.466.7444
LEED GA
Why Build Green?
IN SIMPLE TERMS:
GREEN =
REDUCING
ENVIRONMENTAL
IMPACT
Conventional Building Process
vs
Integrative Design Process
To be eligible for the LEED Green Associate credential, you must have
previous experience supporting a project registered for LEED
certification, working in a sustainable field of work, or attending an
education program that addresses green building principles. Only one
of these criteria is required to be met to demonstrate eligibility.
The LEED Green Associate exam is a 2-hour exam. The LEED Green
Associate exam is neither a prerequisite nor an eligibility
requirement for the LEED AP or any other GBCI exam.
To be eligible for the LEED AP credential, you must have previous
experience with a project registered for LEED certification within three
years of your application submittal date. This work experience must be
documented in the form of a letter of attestation from a supervisor,
client, or project manager and must describe your involvement on the
LEED Project as a consultant, contracted worker, member of the LEED
project team, LEED Homes Provider, LEED Reviewer, LEED for Homes
Green Rater, or staff member of a Certifying Body (CB).
The LEED AP is a 4-hour exam comprised of two parts: the LEED Green
Associate and LEED AP specialty exams. (If you are enrolling or
currently hold an active LEED Green Associate or LEED AP credential,
you are exempt from the first part.) If you wish to take the exam in two
2-hour sessions, you may first apply for and earn the LEED Green
Associate and then apply for the LEED AP including demonstrating
eligibility and paying the applicable fees.
USGBC: U.S. Green
Building Council
LEED: Leadership in Energy
and Environmental Design
LEED OVERVIEW
LEED OVERVIEW
Not “LEEDS”
LEED OVERVIEW
LEED CERTIFIED
LEED ACCREDITED
PROFESSIONAL
LEED ACCREDITED PROFFESIONALS
aka LEED APs
go to:
www.gbci.org
www.usgbc.org
LEED OVERVIEW
BEFORE
CI
NC
EB
NOW
ID + C
BD + C
EB & OM
H
ND
NEW: Green Associate
NEW: LEED Fellow
ID – Interior Design
BD – Building Design
C – Construction
OM – Operations and Maintenance
ID – Interior Design
BD – Building Design
C – Construction
OM – Operations and Maintenance
NOW
ID + C
BD + C
EB & OM
H
ND
NEW: Green Associate
NEW: LEED Fellow
Buildings? I Certificate
LEED OVERVIEW
• LEED for New Construction
• LEED for Existing Buildings (O&M)
• LEED for Commercial Interiors
• LEED for Schools
• LEED for Core and Shell
• LEED for Retail
• LEED for Healthcare
• LEED for Neighborhood Development
• LEED for Homes
LEED RATING SYSTEMS
•A “cool roof” system
•Consumes 40% less water
•Geothermal heat pump system
•Heating costs are reduced by between 30-70%
•Local industry and businesses were supported by the use of regional materials
LEED
Charlottesville Transit Center – NC Gold
•Diverting more than 80% of on-site construction wasteDiverting more than 80% of on-site construction waste
•Using green housekeeping productsUsing green housekeeping products
•Making daylight and window views available to more than 90% of occupantsMaking daylight and window views available to more than 90% of occupants
•Providing centrally located recycling collection areasProviding centrally located recycling collection areas
•Retrofitting plumbing fixtures to increase water efficiencyRetrofitting plumbing fixtures to increase water efficiency
LEED
Kimball Office Headquarters – CI Silver
•The process entailed 45 projects, including upgrading building control systems, retrofitting
lighting, and adding motion sensors. 
•The designation culminates a five-year, $1.1 million campaign to maximize the sustainability and
energy efficiency of the building, which opened in 1996. 
•Electricity consumption has been reduced by 35 percent; irrigation water use has decreased by 75
percent.
LEED
Adobe Corporate Offices – EB Platinum
TRENDS IN LEED DEVELOPMENT
10 MINUTE BREAK
Incentives and
NAHB
http://www.greenbuildingpages.com/links/weblinks_LEED.html
GSA
Requires all building projects starting design
in 2003 meet LEED certified level standards
with a target of LEED Silver.
Arizona
Currently requiring LEED Silver on all state-
funded buildings and requires incorporation
of renewable energy.
California
Executive Order #S-20-04 requires all new
and renovated state-owned facilities to be
LEED Silver
Los Angeles
Requires LEED Certification of all public
works construction projects over 7,500 gsf.
Georgia Tech
requires LEED Gold for all new buildings and
renovations
ASU
all new buildings must be LEED
In the District, every new or substantially renovated nonresidential
privately owned building with at least 50,000 square feet of gross floor
area must submit a green building checklist with its application for a
building permit. Beginning Jan. 1, 2012, every new nonresidential
building, regardless of size, must be LEED certified.
In Montgomery County, every new or extensively modified
commercial or multifamily residential building with at least
10,000 square feet of gross floor area must be LEED
certified.
HOME STAR
Green Building: Washington Bill Requires LEED Certification For Sales and Use Tax Deferral
                    
A bill was introduced in the Washington State Legislature yesterday that will require LEED certification for sales and use
tax deferral on select construction projects. If this bill (SB 6598) becomes law, projects will have to achieve a certain
level of LEED certification to qualify for deferral of sales and use tax on materials and other components of the work. The
higher the project's LEED certification, the greater the amount of sales and use tax that's deferred.
This chart identifies the percentage of sales and use tax each level of certification will deliver:
LEED Certification
Level
Percentage of Sales
and Use Tax Deferred
Platinum 100%
Gold 75%
Silver 50%
Less Than Silver 25%
QUESTIONS: USGBC
The installation of low-flow faucet
aerators at hand washing stations
will result in which two of the
following?
a) Reduced hours of occupancy
b) Reduced energy use
c) Reduced water use
d) Increased occupant productivity
e) Reduced storm water runoff
Credit weightings are based on _____?
a) Relative costs and benefits of each
credit
b) Environmental impacts and human
benefits
c) Carbon footprint and embodied
energy
d) Expected environmental
performance
DEFINING GREEN or LEED
Defining a GREEN home
• Efficiency: Water and Energy
• IEQ
• Location
• Design – who is the Occupant?
• Photo Tour
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
• Sustainable Sites
• Water Efficiency
• Energy & Atmosphere
• Materials and Resources
• Indoor Environmental Quality
• Innovation and Design
LEED CATEGORIES
Sustainable Sites
• Transportation
• Site selection
• Site design and management
• Stormwater management
10Site Selection Existing lot. 2 pts
Preferred Location Infill and Previously
Developed. 3pts
Infrastructure Within ½ Mile of Water and
Sewer
Community Resources and
Transit
Within ½ mile of 14
Community Services. 3pts
Access to Open Space Within ½ mile of Green
Space. 1pt
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
LOCATION & LINKAGES
Site Stewardship At least 40% of lot
undisturbed. 1pt
Landscaping Drought tolerant
turf. Turf less
than 20% of lot.
Drought tolerant
plants. 7pts
Shading High-albedo used
for at least 50% of
site’s hardscape.
1pt
Surface Water
Management
Professional
design for erosion
control. 6pts
Irrigation Designed by
licensed
Professional. 4pts
Central shut off.
Time control for
zones. Valves in
heads inspected.
3pts
Ar
22
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
SITE STEWARDSHIP
Landscaping
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
GREEN DESIGN
5
4 bedrooms, 2140 sq ft
QUESTIONS: Sustainable Sites
A project that specifies exterior
surfaces with high solar reflectance
index (SRI) values is contributing to
which environmental benefit?
a) Reduced heat island effect
b) Support for renewable energy
c) Protection of the dark-sky
initiative
d) Improved stormwater quality
Prior to the final selection of the
project site, the owner and the
design team should confirm that
the site is_____?
a) Compliant with the green design
criteria
b) Compliant with the sustainable
building codes
c) Previously undeveloped
d) Removed from other development
Water Efficiency
• Indoor water
• Irrigation water
• Process water
A front loading washer uses 22 gallons of water; a
top loading washer uses 45 gallons.
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
WATER CONSERVATION
2EA 9.2 =
QUESTIONS: Water Efficiency
What is the baseline water use for
water closets?
a) 0.8 gallons per flush
b) 1.0 gallons per flush
c) 1.6 gallons per flush
d) 3.2 gallons per flush
What is the primary standard used
to establish the baseline case for
indoor water use?
a) The Clean Water Act
b) Energy Policy Act of 1992
c) ASHRAE Standard 90.1
d) National Environmental Policy Act
Energy and Atmosphere
• Energy demand
• Energy efficiency
• Renewable energy
• Ongoing energy performance
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
ENERGY EFFICIENCY
DEFINING A GREEN HOME
ENERGY EFFICIENCY
4
QUESTIONS: Energy and Atmosphere
What is the first step a project
team should consider when trying
to save energy?
a) Use on-site renewable energy
b) Reduce energy demand
c) Adopt energy efficient measures
d) Install submetering equipment
One of the most cost-effective
ways to ensure optimal ongoing
energy performance is to _______?
a) Commission building systems
b) Upgrade mechanical systems
c) Install renewable energy systems
d) Maintain trees and landscaping
features
Materials and Resources
• Selection of sustainable materials
(life-cycle impacts)
• Waste management
WHAT I WANT TO DO
NO VOC PAINTS
Credit Item Points Cost for
Medlock
Tradeoffs Payback
Traditional Carpet Padding
and
Carpet
- .50 cents sf or
$250
$2 sf or $1000
MR 2.2 Carpet Padding
CRI +
and Carpet
.5 Emissions $1.20 sf or $600
$4 sf or $2000
health Health
Traditional Traditional
Bamboo
- $1.95 sf or $3000
MR 2.2 Flooring:
Bamboo
.5 EPP $4.00 or $6000 More expensive
Health
LEED EXPERIENCE
MR 2.2 SELECT ENVIRONMENTALLY PREFERABLE PRODUCTS
FLOORING
1
LEED EXPERIENCE
RECYCLING
3
LEED EXPERIENCE
RECYCLING
3
QUESTIONS: Materials and Resources
LEED defines regional materials as
originating within________?
a) 50 miles of the project site
b) 250 miles of the project site
c) 500 miles of the project site
d) 750 miles of the project site
What is the first step in a
successful waste management
policy?
a) Recycle all possible construction
materials
b) Reuse existing materials
c) Reduce the total quantity of waste
d) Specify recyclable materials
e) Determine the embodied energy of
the product
Indoor Environmental Quality
• Indoor air quality
• Thermal comfort
• Lighting
• Acoustics
1
Indoor Environmental Quality: Air Quality
acoustics
Daylighting
QUESTIONS: Indoor Environmental Quality
The abbreviation VOC refers to?
a) Volatile Organic Compounds
b) Volatile Operating Conditions
c) Variable Ozone Contaminants
d) Versatile Organized Composites
According to the Environmental
Protection Agency, what
percentage of time do Americans
spend indoors?
a) 75%
b) 65%
c) 90%
d) 50%
INNOVATION IN DESIGN
•Innovation in Design
•Exemplary Performance
Innovation in Design
WIND ENERGY
TAKING THE LEED GA TEST
GBCI.ORG
greenstreetdev.com
602.466.7444
THANK YOU
April 6th
, Tucson
May 6th
, Jacksonville, FL
May 14th
, Flagstaff
May 17th
, Charlotte, NC
May 20th
, Phoenix
UPCOMING WORKSHOPS
LEED GA Exam Prep

LEED GA Exam Prep

  • 1.
  • 2.
    4 hours total AIA:2 CEU’s Sustainable Design ASID and IIDA: .2 CEU’s USGBC Green Associate qualified WHAT TO EXPECT TODAY
  • 3.
    1. Share theLEED for Homes Experience – 2007 – THE START OF A LEED EDUCATION 2. CASE STUDY: Describe the LEED process, including lessons learned, rating system comparisons, green by LEED definition, trade-offs of material selection, recycling, the project costs, energy analysis, and tax benefits. 3. Explain the NAHB Green Rating System and the utilization of it. And, the Top 10 lists 4. LEED GA PREP: Define LEED and the USGBC and share the overview of the rating system COMING UP > Myths | Why did I remodel a LEED house? | MRED | Existing home – no tear down | Preserve exterior walls TODAY’S OVERVIEW
  • 4.
    Mesa Verde, Colorado Settled1400 years ago Continuously occupied for 700 years
  • 5.
  • 6.
    GREEN MYTHS GREEN ISTOO EXPENSIVE
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.
    GREEN MYTHS GREEN ISPOLITICAL challenging finding a team – became the GC
  • 10.
    LEED EXPERIENCE BEGINS MEDLOCKBEFORE naïve, first time
  • 11.
    What Medlock is,and isn’t
  • 12.
    MEDLOCK IS NOT Overviewof LEED An Architectural Award Winner The Perfect Green Home
  • 13.
    MEDLOCK IS The firstLEED certified single-family remodel in Arizona The second LEED Gold certified single-family remodel in the U.S.
  • 14.
    • A goodcase study for green remodeling • Well Planned Remodel • A project that preserved all exterior walls • An improvement to traditional building code and practice MEDLOCK IS
  • 15.
    1 = 1pt - High albedo materials installed for at least 50% of the site’s hardscape POINT SYSTEM Inspiration, asu, etc
  • 17.
    Conclusions: Remodel existinghome, in the urban core & make it green. What is green? Need a rating system.
  • 18.
    So, the LEEDeducation begins…..
  • 19.
    Single-Family Building Permits: Phoenixand Maricopa County Jan Feb Mar Apr May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec 2005 897 851 1239 1229 972 867 783 934 1028 754 774 1108 Maricopa 42727 2006 837 1239 925 632 1218 862 793 710 590 400 512 513 Maricopa 27812 2007 562 813 859 638 693 632 391 352 173 164 155 201 Maricopa 20183 2008 174 204 244 240 213 292 285 108 135 116 72 93 Maricopa 9643 2009 71 39 70 113 138 200 149 Maricopa 3728 131 107 128 100 90 2010 104 135
  • 20.
    Jan Feb MarApr May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec 2005 76 193 253 207 208 226 198 206 207 175 156 156 Pima 11166 2006 148 148 190 147 196 186 136 140 113 103 96 93 Pima 8132 2007 107 104 140 163 170 159 136 125 88 96 70 64 Pima 4698 2008 62 64 72 62 64 65 54 46 42 37 24 23 Pima 2743 2009 20 21 28 37 40 48 Pima 384 Single-Family Building Permits: Tucson and Pima County
  • 21.
    RESIDENTIAL PERMIT ACTIVITY ANNUALRESIDENTIAL PERMIT ACTIVITY PHOENIX-MESA-SCOTTSDALE, AZ MSA SEPTEMBER 2009 0 10,000 20,000 30,000 40,000 50,000 60,000 70,000 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009est 2010prj 2011prj 2012prj 2013prj 2014prj Single Family Multi-Family 5-Year Forecast Annual Residential Permit Activity Phoenix – Mesa – Scottsdale, AZ MSA September 2009
  • 22.
  • 23.
  • 24.
    1. Share theLEED for Homes Experience – 2007 – THE START OF A LEED EDUCATION 2. CASE STUDY: Describe the LEED process, including lessons learned, rating system comparisons, green by LEED definition, trade-offs of material selection, recycling, the project costs, energy analysis, and tax benefits. 3. Explain the NAHB Green Rating System and the utilization of it. And, the Top 10 lists 4. LEED GA PREP: Define LEED and the USGBC and share the overview of the rating system COMING UP > Myths | Why did I remodel a LEED house? | MRED | Existing home – no tear down | Preserve exterior walls TODAY’S OVERVIEW
  • 25.
    Decisions Were Madewith the Best Available Information at the Given Time LEED EXPERIENCE
  • 26.
    WHAT I HAVETO DO WHAT I WANT TO DO WHAT I CAN DO DECISION MAKING PROCESS
  • 27.
    LEEDPREREQUISITES Innovation andDesign (ID) 1.1 Preliminary Rating Innovation and Design (ID) 2.1 and 2.2 Durability Planning Durability Management Sustainable Sites (SS) 1.1 and 2.1 Erosion controls No invasive Plants Energy and Atmosphere (EA) 2.1, 3.1, 5.1, 6.1, 8.1, 11.1 Basic Insulation, Reduced Envelope Leakage, Good Windows, Reduced Distribution Losses, Good HVAC design, Energy Star Lights, Refrigerant Charge Test Materials and Resources (MR) 1.1, 2.1, 3.1 Framing Waste Factor, FSC Wood for EPP, Construction Waste Management Indoor Environmental Quality (EQ) 2.1, 4.1, 5.1, 6.1, 7.1, 9.1, 10.1 Basic Combusting Measures, Outdoor Air Ventilation, Local Exhaust, Manual J, Good filters, Radon- resistant, No HVAC in Garage Awareness and Education (AE) 1.1 Basic Operations Training WHAT I HAVE TO DO What I HAVE to do NAHB
  • 28.
  • 29.
    WHAT I WANTTO DO TANKLESS ELECTRIC Budget Time Durability
  • 30.
    WHAT I WANTTO DO REFLECTIVE ROOF Resale Aesthetics
  • 31.
    WHAT I WANTTO DO RAIN CAPTURE Budget Practicality
  • 32.
    The water heateris responsible for 12% of the home’s energy consumption. If 10% of Arizona’s homes had solar hot water heaters, it would save enough energy to power more than 36,000 homes. aps.com WHAT I WANT TO DO SOLAR HOT WATER HEATER Budget Installation
  • 33.
    WHAT I WANTTO DO PV SYSTEM Budget Existing design HOA
  • 34.
    WHAT I WANTTO DO KITCHEN GARDEN
  • 35.
    Dual flush toiletscan save up to 67% of water compared to traditional toilets, which use 1.6 gallons per flush. WHAT I WANT TO DO LOW FLUSH TOILETS 1WE 3.1 =
  • 36.
    WHAT I WANTTO DO NO VOC PAINTS
  • 37.
    WHAT I WANTTO DO FOAM INSULATION Budget Installation
  • 38.
    WHAT I WANTTO DO NEW HVAC Budget
  • 39.
    WHAT I WANTTO DO NEW WINDOWS Budget City Codes
  • 40.
    WHAT I WANTTO DO WIND ENERGY Budget Time HOA
  • 41.
    WHAT I WANTTO DO ALL DEPENDS ON: In this lies… “what does green mean? –importance of rating system Who is the occupant? What is the budget? What is the time frame? Aesthetics? Environmental impact? Installation? Durability? Cool factor? City codes? New information or better knowledge Policy or government incentives
  • 42.
    1. Share theLEED for Homes Experience – 2007 – THE START OF A LEED EDUCATION 2. CASE STUDY: Describe the LEED process, including lessons learned, rating system comparisons, green by LEED definition, trade-offs of material selection, recycling, the project costs, energy analysis, and tax benefits. 3. Explain the NAHB Green Rating System and the utilization of it. And, the Top 10 lists 4. LEED GA PREP: Define LEED and the USGBC and share the overview of the rating system COMING UP > Myths | Why did I remodel a LEED house? | MRED | Existing home – no tear down | Preserve exterior walls TODAY’S OVERVIEW
  • 43.
    WHAT DOES IT MEANTO GO GREEN? 100 people = 100 answers I LEED & NAHB I Define LEED
  • 44.
    IN SIMPLE TERMS: GREEN= REDUCING ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT
  • 45.
    LEED NAHB Scottsdale Green Building EnergyStar Tucson: Regional Green Building TEP: Guarantee Home GREEN RATING SYSTEMS
  • 46.
    Agency Cost LevelRating Type Tradeoffs Verify Medlock Provider LEED $525 $375 USGBC Members $4000 Consultation Certified Silver Gold Platinum Point System Organized by Environmental Impact Areas •Hi costs •Documentat ion •Not regional •Third-party inspected Blower Door Duct Test HERS Third-party LEED Gold Rich Franz- Ünder 520-740-6490 NAHB $500 $200 Members Consultation $450 *National Green Building Standard Bronze Silver Gold Morphing into ICC- 700, will include Emerald Point System Organized by Environmental Impact Areas •Less expensive than LEED •Code-able Third-party HERS Gold Hank Kryzsik 520.327.4846 Or Mick Dalrymple GREEN RATING SYSTEMS Means to an end ANSI approved ICC-700 2008 National Green Building Standard for residential construction.  The ICC-700 standard was developed by the National Association of Home Builders in partnership with the International Code Council
  • 47.
    Agency Cost LevelRating Type Tradeoffs Verify Medlock Provider Scottsdale 0 Entry Advanced Point System Organized by Construction Categories •Regional •Expedite •Plan Review Plan Review Verified by Building Inspectors Advanced 480.312.4202 Energy Star Consultation $600 Energy Star Energy Star + IAP RESNET Standards •Limited HERS Rater HERS 55 602.532.2976 ext 3 Azhomeperforma nce.com Pima 0 Up to Emerald Launches August 5th Rich Franz- Ünder 520-740-6490 TEP No cost to the Builder – plan review to TEP specs Guaranteed Home Guaranteed •Only new construction Multiple inspections No remodels 520-623-7211 GREEN RATING SYSTEMS Since medlock is LEED lets talk in more detail
  • 48.
    HIGHLIGHTS •Cut energy consumptionby over 50% •Improved air quality by using low or no VOC materials •Located within close proximity of many local amenities •Minimum construction waste and preservation of all exterior walls •Designed to maximize livable area •Increased water efficiency using fixtures and native landscaping LEED What I walked away from the LEED-H remodel experience 3313 E MEDLOCK
  • 49.
    Water Reuse: LEEDas A Design Tool vs. LEED EXPERIENCE 1 4
  • 50.
    • Most recognizedgreen rating system • The Team Charette • An Improved Project Team • An excellent guide for a first timer • Management Plan • An improvement of traditional codes and practices WHY I’m Glad I Chose LEED 2 How does LEED define green? Environmental impact areas LEED EXPERIENCE
  • 51.
    1. Share theLEED for Homes Experience – 2007 – THE START OF A LEED EDUCATION 2. CASE STUDY: Describe the LEED process, including lessons learned, rating system comparisons, green by LEED definition, trade-offs of material selection, recycling, the project costs, energy analysis, and tax benefits. 3. Explain the NAHB Green Rating System and the utilization of it. And, the Top 10 lists 4. LEED GA PREP: Define LEED and the USGBC and share the overview of the rating system COMING UP > Myths | Why did I remodel a LEED house? | MRED | Existing home – no tear down | Preserve exterior walls TODAY’S OVERVIEW
  • 52.
    Medlock’s Design: Defining aGREEN home • Efficiency: Water and Energy • IEQ • Location • Design – who is the Occupant? • Photo Tour DEFINING A GREEN HOME
  • 54.
    GREEN: WATER EFFICIENCY& LANDSCAPE DESIGN DEFINING A GREEN HOME
  • 55.
    Site Stewardship Atleast 40% of lot undisturbed. 1pt Landscaping Drought tolerant turf. Turf less than 20% of lot. Drought tolerant plants. 7pts Shading High-albedo used for at least 50% of site’s hardscape. 1pt Surface Water Management Professional design for erosion control. 6pts Irrigation Designed by licensed Professional. 4pts Central shut off. Time control for zones. Valves in heads inspected. 3pts Ar 22 DEFINING A GREEN HOME SITE STEWARDSHIP Landscaping
  • 56.
    A front loadingwasher uses 22 gallons of water; a top loading washer uses 45 gallons. DEFINING A GREEN HOME WATER CONSERVATION 2EA 9.2 =
  • 57.
    DEFINING A GREENHOME ENERGY EFFICIENCY Acoustics Thermal Comfort 1 2 2 Air Infiltration MR 2.2 Emission EPP Enhanced Insulation
  • 58.
    DEFINING A GREENHOME ENERGY EFFICIENCY
  • 59.
    DEFINING A GREENHOME ENERGY EFFICIENCY 4 3rd Party Verified
  • 60.
    DEFINING A GREENHOME ENERGY EFFICIENCY Thermal imagery: MEDLOCK
  • 61.
    DEFINING A GREENHOME GREEN DESIGN The average single family home in the U.S. is 40% larger today than it was 30 years ago.
  • 62.
    DEFINING A GREENHOME GREEN DESIGN 5 4 bedrooms, 2140 sq ft
  • 63.
    10Site Selection Existinglot. 2 pts Preferred Location Infill and Previously Developed. 3pts Infrastructure Within ½ Mile of Water and Sewer Community Resources and Transit Within ½ mile of 14 Community Services. 3pts Access to Open Space Within ½ mile of Green Space. 1pt DEFINING A GREEN HOME LOCATION & LINKAGES
  • 64.
    DEFINING A GREENHOME GREEN DESIGN VISTANCIA TO DOWNTOWN PHX = 38 MILES ($40 RT)
  • 65.
    Preserve all exteriorwalls Orientation DEFINING A GREEN HOME GREEN DESIGN
  • 66.
    ORIGINAL FLYER FROM 1959 DEFINING A GREENHOME Making the old new, photo tour
  • 67.
    DEFINING A GREENHOME GREEN DESIGN
  • 68.
    DEFINING A GREENHOME GREEN DESIGN NEW SEWER LINE | DURABILITY
  • 70.
    DEFINING A GREENHOME GREEN DESIGN Healthy Home Replaced Galvanized Line
  • 71.
  • 72.
    •Exterior wall shearnon-wood •Joists spaced greater than 16” •Headers sized for actual loads •2-stud corners •Waste factor no more than 10% 3 DEFINING A GREEN HOME GREEN DESIGN
  • 73.
    Where to putthe kitchen? Support beam? Daylighting? DEFINING A GREEN HOME GREEN DESIGN
  • 74.
    2 DEFINING A GREENHOME GREEN DESIGN
  • 75.
    DEFINING A GREENHOME GREEN DESIGN 4
  • 76.
    1. Share theLEED for Homes Experience – 2007 – THE START OF A LEED EDUCATION 2. CASE STUDY: Describe the LEED process, including lessons learned, rating system comparisons, green by LEED definition, trade-offs of material selection, recycling, the project costs, energy analysis, and tax benefits. 3. Explain the NAHB Green Rating System and the utilization of it. And, the Top 10 lists 4. LEED GA PREP: Define LEED and the USGBC and share the overview of the rating system COMING UP > Myths | Why did I remodel a LEED house? | MRED | Existing home – no tear down | Preserve exterior walls TODAY’S OVERVIEW
  • 77.
  • 78.
  • 79.
  • 80.
    LEED EXPERIENCE REUSE &RECYCLING - Phoenix
  • 81.
    LEED EXPERIENCE REUSE &RECYCLING - Tucson
  • 82.
    1. Share theLEED for Homes Experience – 2007 – THE START OF A LEED EDUCATION 2. CASE STUDY: Describe the LEED process, including lessons learned, rating system comparisons, green by LEED definition, trade-offs of material selection, recycling, the project costs, energy analysis, and tax benefits. 3. Explain the NAHB Green Rating System and the utilization of it. And, the Top 10 lists 4. LEED GA PREP: Define LEED and the USGBC and share the overview of the rating system COMING UP > Myths | Why did I remodel a LEED house? | MRED | Existing home – no tear down | Preserve exterior walls TODAY’S OVERVIEW
  • 83.
    Decisions Were Madewith the Best Available Information at the Given Time LEED EXPERIENCE MATERIAL SOURCING: STRATEGIES & DECISION MAKING
  • 84.
    Credit Item PointsCost for Medlock Tradeoffs Payback EA 2.1 Basic Insulation Preq $3000 Less expensive Less efficient No additional points EA 2.2 Enhanced Insulation 2 $8500 Additional LEED points Efficiency Health acoustic 2 – 4 years EA 3.1 3.2 3,3 Air Infiltration Reduced Leakage Greatly Reduced Minimum 2 Planning +efficiency EA 5 Heating & Cooling 3 Planning +efficiency MR 2.2 EPP & Emissions .5 .5 no additional health 8 LEED EXPERIENCE EA 2: INSULATION
  • 85.
    Credit Item PointsCost for Medlock Tradeoffs Payback Traditional EA 4.1 Good Windows <.40 Preq $4500 - $6500 EA 4.2 Enhanced Windows <.35 2 $5,500 - $7,500 2009 - $2500 vinyl, $4500 Premium Wood, $6,000 Custom Wood 18 months EA 4.3 Exceptional Windows <.30 3 $8,500 - $12,500 EA 6 Space Heating & Cooling 3 Design and Planning +efficiency 2+3 LEED EXPERIENCE EA 4: WINDOWS
  • 86.
    LEED EXPERIENCE Credit ItemPoints Cost for Medlock Tradeoffs Payback Medlock Traditional HVAC – no design - $18000 Less efficiency EA 5.3 Minimal Distribution Losses Duct Tightness: Min Dist Losses <1 CFM per 100sf 3 Planning and Design +efficiency US Air Conditioning EA 6.1 EA 6.2 EA 6.3 GOOD – 13 SEER HIGH EFF – 14 SEER VERY HIGH 15 SEER Preq 2 points 4 points $10500 Manual J Programmable Thermostat Comfort Air quality 18 months 16 SEER US Air Cond EA 11 HVAC Refrigerant 1 Design and Planning environment US Air Conditioning 8 EA 5: DUCT TIGHTNESS / EA 6: SPACE HEATING & COOLING
  • 87.
    Credit Item PointsCost for Medlock Tradeoffs Payback Medlock EA 10 (in 2007) Renewable Energy System 1-10 $60,000 (2007) 0 Points EA 10 (in 2009) Renewable Energy System 2009 10 $19,000 (2009 with rebates and credits) + Environmental: less CO emissions + value of home + LEED Platinum 6 years REC Solar LEED EXPERIENCE EA 5: DUCT TIGHTNESS / EA 6: SPACE HEATING & COOLING
  • 88.
  • 89.
    EPP .5 POINTSEMISSION SPECS .5 POINTS LOCAL PRODUCTION .5 POINTS Recycled, FSC certified, or Reclaimed. No added formaldehyde •Green Label + •100% hard flooring = auto .5 points •Paints and coatings = GS 11 •Finishes = SCAQM Manufactured within 500 miles of home COMPONENT MAX POINTS Flooring 2 pts Paints and coatings 1 pt Decking or patio 1 point Cabinets 1 point Counters 1 point Doors 1 point Trim 1 point LEED EXPERIENCE ENVIRONMENTALLY PREFERRED PRODUCTS (EPP) MR 2.1 & 2.2 South coast air quality management
  • 90.
    Credit Item PointsCost for Medlock Tradeoffs Payback Traditional Carpet Padding and Carpet - .50 cents sf or $250 $2 sf or $1000 MR 2.2 Carpet Padding CRI + and Carpet .5 Emissions $1.20 sf or $600 $4 sf or $2000 health Health Traditional Traditional Bamboo - $1.95 sf or $3000 MR 2.2 Flooring: Bamboo .5 EPP $4.00 or $6000 More expensive Health LEED EXPERIENCE MR 2.2 SELECT ENVIRONMENTALLY PREFERABLE PRODUCTS FLOORING 1
  • 91.
    Credit Item PointsCost for Medlock Tradeoffs Payback Traditional Paints and Coatings - $1080 (27 gallons) MR 2.2 Paints and Coatings .5 EPP –meets GS 43 .5 Emissions – GS 11 $1080 (27 gallons) Health Health LEED EXPERIENCE MR 2.2 SELECT ENVIRONMENTALLY PREFERABLE PRODUCTS PAINTS 1 Cost? Green more expensive? First review of MR 2.2
  • 92.
    EPP .5 POINTSEMISSION SPECS .5 POINTS LOCAL PRODUCTION .5 POINTS Recycled, FSC certified, or Reclaimed. No added formaldehyde •Green Label + •100% hard flooring = auto .5 points •Paints and coatings = GS 11 •Finishes = SCAQM Manufactured within 500 miles of home COMPONENT MAX POINTS Flooring 2 pts Paints and coatings 1 pt Decking or patio 1 point Cabinets 1 point Counters 1 point Doors 1 point Trim 1 point LEED EXPERIENCE ENVIRONMENTALLY PREFERRED PRODUCTS (EPP) MR 2.1 & 2.2 Does it all make sense? Save energy?
  • 93.
    1. Share theLEED for Homes Experience – 2007 – THE START OF A LEED EDUCATION 2. CASE STUDY: Describe the LEED process, including lessons learned, rating system comparisons, green by LEED definition, trade-offs of material selection, recycling, the project costs, energy analysis, and tax benefits. 3. Explain the NAHB Green Rating System and the utilization of it. And, the Top 10 lists 4. LEED GA PREP: Define LEED and the USGBC and share the overview of the rating system COMING UP > Myths | Why did I remodel a LEED house? | MRED | Existing home – no tear down | Preserve exterior walls TODAY’S OVERVIEW
  • 94.
    Traditional Green TradeoffsPayback !0-year return Insulation $2,500 $8,500 3 years * Windows $4,500 $8,500 3-5 years * Framing $25,000 $22,000 HVAC $15,000 $8,500 immed * Landscape w/ hardscape $20,000 $45,000 LEED Landscape Design $1,000 $8,500 Recessed Lighting $100 $1500 * Bamboo Flooring $4,000 $8,000 health Countertops $13,000 $13,000 Cabinets $18,000 $22,000 Backsplash $1,800 $2,800 Toilets $900 $900 1 year LEED EXPERIENCE PRO FORMA ITEMS COMBINE FOR $30,000 ENERGY SAVINGS OVER 15 YEARS
  • 95.
    Traditional Green TradeoffsPayback !0-year return Third Party Test - $400 Electrical Upgrade $7,200 $7,200 New Plumbing and Sewer $10,500 $10,500 LEED Certification - $4,600 Fixtures $2,500 $2,500 * Sub-Total $190,000 $218,000 2009 Tax Credits -$5,575 15-year energy savings -$30,000 TOTAL $190,000 $182,425 PROVE $30,000 IN ENERGY SAVINGS LEED EXPERIENCE PRO FORMA
  • 96.
    1. Share theLEED for Homes Experience – 2007 – THE START OF A LEED EDUCATION 2. CASE STUDY: Describe the LEED process, including lessons learned, rating system comparisons, green by LEED definition, trade-offs of material selection, recycling, the project costs, energy analysis, and tax benefits. 3. Explain the NAHB Green Rating System and the utilization of it. And, the Top 10 lists 4. LEED GA PREP: Define LEED and the USGBC and share the overview of the rating system COMING UP > Myths | Why did I remodel a LEED house? | MRED | Existing home – no tear down | Preserve exterior walls TODAY’S OVERVIEW
  • 98.
    LEED EXPERIENCE ENERGY ANALYSIS 3313E MEDLOCK COMPARED TO 3307 & 3319 E MEDLOCK 3 things used for analysis; SRP; Energy 10; Energy Star
  • 99.
  • 100.
    LEED EXPERIENCE ENERGY 10:MEDLOCK Explain Energy 10 Medlock uses 53.09% LESS energy than average Valley home
  • 101.
    3319 33073313 LEED EXPERIENCE COMPAREDTO NEIGHBORS COMPARED TO NEIGHBORS NEIGHBOR ‘MEDLOCK’ NEIGHBOR
  • 102.
    Sq ft 1400 Occupants2 Remodeled never NEIGHBOR: 3319 E MEDLOCK
  • 103.
    Sq ft 1700 Occupants1 Remodeled 2007 NEIGHBOR: 3307 E MEDLOCK
  • 104.
    Sq ft 2150 Occupants1 Remodeled 2007 GREEN STREET HOME: 3313 E MEDLOCK
  • 105.
    3307 3313 3319 August$158 vs. $308 $195 $132 vs. $302 Medlock 49% less 56% less Energy 10 53% less August 2008: Medlock versus 3307 and 3319 3307 and 3319 rate if as efficient as Medlock LEED EXPERIENCE ENERGY ANALYSIS 3313 E MEDLOCK COMPARED TO 3307 & 3319 E MEDLOCK
  • 106.
    LEED EXPERIENCE ENERGY ANALYSIS 3313E MEDLOCK COMPARED TO 3307 & 3319 E MEDLOCK 3319 E MEDLOCK
  • 107.
    LEED EXPERIENCE ENERGY ANALYSIS 3313E MEDLOCK COMPARED TO 3307 & 3319 E MEDLOCK 3313 E MEDLOCK
  • 108.
    Time to testthe market - April 2008
  • 109.
    LEED EXPERIENCE MARKET CRASHESIN PHOENIX APRIL 2008
  • 110.
  • 111.
    1. Share theLEED for Homes Experience – 2007 – THE START OF A LEED EDUCATION 2. CASE STUDY: Describe the LEED process, including lessons learned, rating system comparisons, green by LEED definition, trade-offs of material selection, recycling, the project costs, energy analysis, and tax benefits. 3. Explain the NAHB Green Rating System and the utilization of it. And, the Top 10 lists 4. LEED GA PREP: Define LEED and the USGBC and share the overview of the rating system COMING UP > Myths | Why did I remodel a LEED house? | MRED | Existing home – no tear down | Preserve exterior walls TODAY’S OVERVIEW
  • 112.
    Vendor/ Manufacturer FEDERAL STATE APSSRP TOTAL HVAC York $1500 rebate Tax credit 30% Includes labor - SEER 13 $175 SEER 14 – 16 $425 SEER 17 $525 SEER 15 $200 SEER 16 $300 SEER 17 $400 $3525 INSULATION 30% of cost Includes Labor ($1500 total home) $1500 WINDOWS (skylights) Manufacturer 30% Not including labor Less than .30 U Factor $2250 DUCTS TEST .75 x cost of repair, up to $75 $75 DUCTS REPAIR .75 x cost of repair up to $175 $175 Water Heaters SW Gas $75 30% tax credit SOLAR HOT WATER HEATER 30% tax credit, no maximum 25% of the cost up to $1000 $.75/kWh of estimated first year savings up to 50% of system cost Utility Rebate $.50/kWh of installed kWh $3800 - $4000 HOME SELLER selling energy efficient home Personal Deduction 5% of sales price, up to 5k $5000 LEED EXPERIENCE TAX CREDITS & REBATES Discuss handouts I Energy efficient – state stimulus
  • 113.
  • 114.
  • 116.
    1. Share theLEED for Homes Experience – 2007 – THE START OF A LEED EDUCATION 2. CASE STUDY: Describe the LEED process, including lessons learned, rating system comparisons, green by LEED definition, trade-offs of material selection, recycling, the project costs, energy analysis, and tax benefits. 3. Explain the NAHB Green Rating System and the utilization of it. And, the Top 10 lists 4. LEED GA PREP: Define LEED and the USGBC and share the overview of the rating system COMING UP > Myths | Why did I remodel a LEED house? | MRED | Existing home – no tear down | Preserve exterior walls TODAY’S OVERVIEW
  • 118.
    NAHB RATING SYSTEM GreenStreet Homes: Crisis leads to Opportunity
  • 120.
    NAHB RATING SYSTEM •Locatedwithin ¼ mile of Light Rail •The greenest building is the existing one •Green-certified, verified, recognized •Affordable- priced at or below market •Energy Rated GREEN STREET HOMES
  • 121.
    Practical Simple Recognized Non-document intensive Easy tounderstand for trades Third-party verified NAHB RATING SYSTEM NEEDED A RATING SYSTEM THAT WAS:
  • 124.
    Water Heater notin conditioned space unless in separate room with outdoor air source Wall-to-wall carpeting is not installed adjacent to water closets or bathing fixtures All bathrooms are vented to outdoors at least 50 cfm Clothes dryer is vented to the outdoors. Kitchen exhaust at least 400 cfm Existing unsealed combustion gas dryer is sealed with sealed exhaust vent NAHB RATING SYSTEM PRE-1980 HAVE-TO’S:
  • 125.
    Bronze – 20% Silver– 34% Gold – 43% Emerald – 50% NAHB RATING SYSTEM NGBS RATING LEVELS ANSI approved ICC-700 2008 National Green Building Standard for residential construction.  The ICC-700 standard was developed by the National Association of Home Builders in partnership with the International Code Council
  • 126.
  • 127.
  • 128.
  • 129.
  • 130.
  • 131.
  • 132.
  • 133.
  • 134.
  • 135.
  • 136.
  • 137.
  • 138.
  • 139.
  • 140.
    150 W Elm– Before & After Pre HERS 208 Post HERS 79 Annual Savings $1200 Water Savings 62% Purchase Price 90k Improvement Cost 70k Sales Price 240k WORKSHOP OVERVIEW
  • 141.
    New HVAC $6500 NewWindows and Doors $13500 Foam Insulation $1500 Landscape and Hardscape $11,500 New roof $5500 Paint, interior and exterior $6500 Sub-total $41,500 WORKSHOP OVERVIE 150 W Elm – IMPROVEMENTS & BUDGET
  • 144.
    1818 W TURNEY– EMERALD CERTIFIED WORKSHOP OVERVIEW BEFOREAFTER
  • 145.
    Pre HERS 284 PostHERS 76 Annual Savings $2000 Water Savings 72% Purchase Price 39k Improvement Cost 42k Sales Price 119k 1818 W TURNEY – Before & After GREEN STREET HOMES
  • 146.
    IMPROVEMENTS AND BUDGET NewHVAC $5400 New Windows and Doors $3500 Landscaping $6500 Insulation $1600 Appliances $2500 Sub-total $19,500 GREEN STREET HOMES 1818 W TURNEY – IMPROVEMENTS & BUDGET
  • 147.
    5626 N 20THDRIVE – BRONZE CERTIFIED GREEN STREET HOMES BEFOREAFTER
  • 148.
    5626 N 20th Dr– before/after Pre HERS 195 Post HERS 120 Annual Savings $650 Water Savings 40% Purchase Price 47k Improvement Cost 31k Sales Price 124k 1818 W TURNEY – Before & After GREEN STREET HOMES
  • 149.
    IMPROVEMENTS AND BUDGET Tuneup HVAC and tighten ducts $1300 New appliances $2600 Caulk windows and weather stripping $250 New water heater $400 Cellulose Insulation $400 CFL’s $50 Sub-total $5000 GREEN STREET HOMES IMPROVEMENTS & BUDGET
  • 150.
    319 W VIRGINIA– GOLD CERTIFIED GREEN STREET HOMES BEFORE
  • 160.
    319 W Virginia– before/after Pre HERS 194 Post HERS 122 (37% improve) Annual Savings $900 Water Savings 40% Purchase Price 178k Improvement Cost 90k Sales Price 409k 319 W VIRGINIA – Before & After GREEN STREET HOMES
  • 161.
    IMPROVEMENTS AND BUDGET FoamInsulation $4000 Solar Water Heater $6500 (before incentives) Caulk windows and weather strip $300 CFL’s $50 Landscape $3700 Water Sense Fixtures and Toilets $1500 Sub-total $16050 GREEN STREET HOMES 319 W VIRGINIA – IMPROVEMENTS & BUDGET
  • 163.
    RESIDENTIAL PERMIT ACTIVITY ANNUALRESIDENTIAL PERMIT ACTIVITY PHOENIX-MESA-SCOTTSDALE, AZ MSA SEPTEMBER 2009 0 10,000 20,000 30,000 40,000 50,000 60,000 70,000 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009est 2010prj 2011prj 2012prj 2013prj 2014prj Single Family Multi-Family 5-Year Forecast Annual Residential Permit Activity Phoenix – Mesa – Scottsdale, AZ MSA September 2009
  • 165.
    1. Share theLEED for Homes Experience – 2007 – A GREEN REMODEL EDUCATION 2. Lessons learned, the need for a Rating System, Green by Definition, Material Selection, Recycling, The Cost, A LEED Case Study 3. Tax Credits, Rebates, and Stimulus Funds 4. Explain the NAHB Green Rating System 5. Putting the NAHB Green Rating System to Practice 6. TOP 10 List – low budget or open budget 7. Q & A: Expert Panel WORKSHOP OVERVIEW
  • 166.
    1. Test ductsfor tightness, and sealing of leaks. 2. Professional HVAC service, and install of programmable thermostat 3. Caulking of and leaks in the building envelope, including windows and doors 4. The use of a recycle bin in the kitchen. 5. Replacement of incandescent lighting with cfl’s 6. The use of household cleaners that do not contain toxic chemicals. Homemade cleaners are best, using items such as vinegar, baking soda, and tea tree oil. And, the elimination of all chemical air fresheners. 7. The use of shading via plants or screens on walls or windows with high sun exposure. 8. The installation of daylighting in dark areas of your home to reduce the need for lights and to improve mental health 9. Upgrade insulation to a higher R value 10. Installation of highly reflective window film TOP TEN LOW BUDGET GREEN HOME IMPROVEMENTS:
  • 167.
    1. Foam insulationin the lid of the roof 2. New windows 3. New HVAC (always windows before HVAC, and Manual J required before determining size of unit) 4. Solar Hot water heater (current incentives and rebates results in a $1500 net cost to homeowner) 5. Front loading clothes washer, will reduce water usage by more than 60% compared to a top loading washers) 6. Native landscaping along with an irrigation system, and turf reduction 7. Consideration of low environmental impact materials when selecting new cabinets, flooring, countertops, or paint. 8. A rain capture system, and consideration to low flush toilets and Water Sense labeled fixtures 9. A Photovoltaic system once doing all the above building envelope improvements, which will reduce the size of the PV system needed 10. Get your project LEED or NAHB certified TOP TEN MEDIUM TO HIGH BUDGET GREEN HOME IMPROVEMENTS:
  • 168.
    1. Share theLEED for Homes Experience – 2007 – THE START OF A LEED EDUCATION 2. CASE STUDY: Describe the LEED process, including lessons learned, rating system comparisons, green by LEED definition, trade-offs of material selection, recycling, the project costs, energy analysis, and tax benefits. 3. Explain the NAHB Green Rating System and the utilization of it. And, the Top 10 lists 4. LEED GA PREP: Define LEED and the USGBC and share the overview of the rating system COMING UP > Myths | Why did I remodel a LEED house? | MRED | Existing home – no tear down | Preserve exterior walls TODAY’S OVERVIEW
  • 169.
  • 170.
  • 171.
    IN SIMPLE TERMS: GREEN= REDUCING ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT
  • 172.
  • 174.
    To be eligiblefor the LEED Green Associate credential, you must have previous experience supporting a project registered for LEED certification, working in a sustainable field of work, or attending an education program that addresses green building principles. Only one of these criteria is required to be met to demonstrate eligibility. The LEED Green Associate exam is a 2-hour exam. The LEED Green Associate exam is neither a prerequisite nor an eligibility requirement for the LEED AP or any other GBCI exam.
  • 175.
    To be eligiblefor the LEED AP credential, you must have previous experience with a project registered for LEED certification within three years of your application submittal date. This work experience must be documented in the form of a letter of attestation from a supervisor, client, or project manager and must describe your involvement on the LEED Project as a consultant, contracted worker, member of the LEED project team, LEED Homes Provider, LEED Reviewer, LEED for Homes Green Rater, or staff member of a Certifying Body (CB). The LEED AP is a 4-hour exam comprised of two parts: the LEED Green Associate and LEED AP specialty exams. (If you are enrolling or currently hold an active LEED Green Associate or LEED AP credential, you are exempt from the first part.) If you wish to take the exam in two 2-hour sessions, you may first apply for and earn the LEED Green Associate and then apply for the LEED AP including demonstrating eligibility and paying the applicable fees.
  • 176.
    USGBC: U.S. Green BuildingCouncil LEED: Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design LEED OVERVIEW
  • 177.
  • 178.
    Not “LEEDS” LEED OVERVIEW LEEDCERTIFIED LEED ACCREDITED PROFESSIONAL
  • 179.
    LEED ACCREDITED PROFFESIONALS akaLEED APs go to: www.gbci.org www.usgbc.org LEED OVERVIEW BEFORE CI NC EB NOW ID + C BD + C EB & OM H ND NEW: Green Associate NEW: LEED Fellow ID – Interior Design BD – Building Design C – Construction OM – Operations and Maintenance
  • 180.
    ID – InteriorDesign BD – Building Design C – Construction OM – Operations and Maintenance NOW ID + C BD + C EB & OM H ND NEW: Green Associate NEW: LEED Fellow Buildings? I Certificate LEED OVERVIEW
  • 181.
    • LEED forNew Construction • LEED for Existing Buildings (O&M) • LEED for Commercial Interiors • LEED for Schools • LEED for Core and Shell • LEED for Retail • LEED for Healthcare • LEED for Neighborhood Development • LEED for Homes LEED RATING SYSTEMS
  • 182.
    •A “cool roof”system •Consumes 40% less water •Geothermal heat pump system •Heating costs are reduced by between 30-70% •Local industry and businesses were supported by the use of regional materials LEED Charlottesville Transit Center – NC Gold
  • 183.
    •Diverting more than80% of on-site construction wasteDiverting more than 80% of on-site construction waste •Using green housekeeping productsUsing green housekeeping products •Making daylight and window views available to more than 90% of occupantsMaking daylight and window views available to more than 90% of occupants •Providing centrally located recycling collection areasProviding centrally located recycling collection areas •Retrofitting plumbing fixtures to increase water efficiencyRetrofitting plumbing fixtures to increase water efficiency LEED Kimball Office Headquarters – CI Silver
  • 184.
    •The process entailed45 projects, including upgrading building control systems, retrofitting lighting, and adding motion sensors.  •The designation culminates a five-year, $1.1 million campaign to maximize the sustainability and energy efficiency of the building, which opened in 1996.  •Electricity consumption has been reduced by 35 percent; irrigation water use has decreased by 75 percent. LEED Adobe Corporate Offices – EB Platinum
  • 185.
    TRENDS IN LEEDDEVELOPMENT
  • 186.
  • 189.
    http://www.greenbuildingpages.com/links/weblinks_LEED.html GSA Requires all buildingprojects starting design in 2003 meet LEED certified level standards with a target of LEED Silver. Arizona Currently requiring LEED Silver on all state- funded buildings and requires incorporation of renewable energy. California Executive Order #S-20-04 requires all new and renovated state-owned facilities to be LEED Silver Los Angeles Requires LEED Certification of all public works construction projects over 7,500 gsf. Georgia Tech requires LEED Gold for all new buildings and renovations ASU all new buildings must be LEED
  • 190.
    In the District,every new or substantially renovated nonresidential privately owned building with at least 50,000 square feet of gross floor area must submit a green building checklist with its application for a building permit. Beginning Jan. 1, 2012, every new nonresidential building, regardless of size, must be LEED certified. In Montgomery County, every new or extensively modified commercial or multifamily residential building with at least 10,000 square feet of gross floor area must be LEED certified.
  • 191.
  • 192.
    Green Building: WashingtonBill Requires LEED Certification For Sales and Use Tax Deferral                      A bill was introduced in the Washington State Legislature yesterday that will require LEED certification for sales and use tax deferral on select construction projects. If this bill (SB 6598) becomes law, projects will have to achieve a certain level of LEED certification to qualify for deferral of sales and use tax on materials and other components of the work. The higher the project's LEED certification, the greater the amount of sales and use tax that's deferred. This chart identifies the percentage of sales and use tax each level of certification will deliver: LEED Certification Level Percentage of Sales and Use Tax Deferred Platinum 100% Gold 75% Silver 50% Less Than Silver 25%
  • 193.
    QUESTIONS: USGBC The installationof low-flow faucet aerators at hand washing stations will result in which two of the following? a) Reduced hours of occupancy b) Reduced energy use c) Reduced water use d) Increased occupant productivity e) Reduced storm water runoff Credit weightings are based on _____? a) Relative costs and benefits of each credit b) Environmental impacts and human benefits c) Carbon footprint and embodied energy d) Expected environmental performance
  • 194.
  • 195.
    Defining a GREENhome • Efficiency: Water and Energy • IEQ • Location • Design – who is the Occupant? • Photo Tour DEFINING A GREEN HOME
  • 196.
    • Sustainable Sites •Water Efficiency • Energy & Atmosphere • Materials and Resources • Indoor Environmental Quality • Innovation and Design LEED CATEGORIES
  • 197.
    Sustainable Sites • Transportation •Site selection • Site design and management • Stormwater management
  • 200.
    10Site Selection Existinglot. 2 pts Preferred Location Infill and Previously Developed. 3pts Infrastructure Within ½ Mile of Water and Sewer Community Resources and Transit Within ½ mile of 14 Community Services. 3pts Access to Open Space Within ½ mile of Green Space. 1pt DEFINING A GREEN HOME LOCATION & LINKAGES
  • 201.
    Site Stewardship Atleast 40% of lot undisturbed. 1pt Landscaping Drought tolerant turf. Turf less than 20% of lot. Drought tolerant plants. 7pts Shading High-albedo used for at least 50% of site’s hardscape. 1pt Surface Water Management Professional design for erosion control. 6pts Irrigation Designed by licensed Professional. 4pts Central shut off. Time control for zones. Valves in heads inspected. 3pts Ar 22 DEFINING A GREEN HOME SITE STEWARDSHIP Landscaping
  • 202.
    DEFINING A GREENHOME GREEN DESIGN 5 4 bedrooms, 2140 sq ft
  • 204.
    QUESTIONS: Sustainable Sites Aproject that specifies exterior surfaces with high solar reflectance index (SRI) values is contributing to which environmental benefit? a) Reduced heat island effect b) Support for renewable energy c) Protection of the dark-sky initiative d) Improved stormwater quality Prior to the final selection of the project site, the owner and the design team should confirm that the site is_____? a) Compliant with the green design criteria b) Compliant with the sustainable building codes c) Previously undeveloped d) Removed from other development
  • 205.
    Water Efficiency • Indoorwater • Irrigation water • Process water
  • 206.
    A front loadingwasher uses 22 gallons of water; a top loading washer uses 45 gallons. DEFINING A GREEN HOME WATER CONSERVATION 2EA 9.2 =
  • 209.
    QUESTIONS: Water Efficiency Whatis the baseline water use for water closets? a) 0.8 gallons per flush b) 1.0 gallons per flush c) 1.6 gallons per flush d) 3.2 gallons per flush What is the primary standard used to establish the baseline case for indoor water use? a) The Clean Water Act b) Energy Policy Act of 1992 c) ASHRAE Standard 90.1 d) National Environmental Policy Act
  • 210.
    Energy and Atmosphere •Energy demand • Energy efficiency • Renewable energy • Ongoing energy performance
  • 211.
    DEFINING A GREENHOME ENERGY EFFICIENCY
  • 212.
    DEFINING A GREENHOME ENERGY EFFICIENCY 4
  • 217.
    QUESTIONS: Energy andAtmosphere What is the first step a project team should consider when trying to save energy? a) Use on-site renewable energy b) Reduce energy demand c) Adopt energy efficient measures d) Install submetering equipment One of the most cost-effective ways to ensure optimal ongoing energy performance is to _______? a) Commission building systems b) Upgrade mechanical systems c) Install renewable energy systems d) Maintain trees and landscaping features
  • 218.
    Materials and Resources •Selection of sustainable materials (life-cycle impacts) • Waste management
  • 220.
    WHAT I WANTTO DO NO VOC PAINTS
  • 221.
    Credit Item PointsCost for Medlock Tradeoffs Payback Traditional Carpet Padding and Carpet - .50 cents sf or $250 $2 sf or $1000 MR 2.2 Carpet Padding CRI + and Carpet .5 Emissions $1.20 sf or $600 $4 sf or $2000 health Health Traditional Traditional Bamboo - $1.95 sf or $3000 MR 2.2 Flooring: Bamboo .5 EPP $4.00 or $6000 More expensive Health LEED EXPERIENCE MR 2.2 SELECT ENVIRONMENTALLY PREFERABLE PRODUCTS FLOORING 1
  • 222.
  • 223.
  • 226.
    QUESTIONS: Materials andResources LEED defines regional materials as originating within________? a) 50 miles of the project site b) 250 miles of the project site c) 500 miles of the project site d) 750 miles of the project site What is the first step in a successful waste management policy? a) Recycle all possible construction materials b) Reuse existing materials c) Reduce the total quantity of waste d) Specify recyclable materials e) Determine the embodied energy of the product
  • 227.
    Indoor Environmental Quality •Indoor air quality • Thermal comfort • Lighting • Acoustics
  • 228.
  • 229.
  • 230.
  • 231.
  • 232.
    QUESTIONS: Indoor EnvironmentalQuality The abbreviation VOC refers to? a) Volatile Organic Compounds b) Volatile Operating Conditions c) Variable Ozone Contaminants d) Versatile Organized Composites According to the Environmental Protection Agency, what percentage of time do Americans spend indoors? a) 75% b) 65% c) 90% d) 50%
  • 233.
    INNOVATION IN DESIGN •Innovationin Design •Exemplary Performance
  • 234.
  • 236.
    TAKING THE LEEDGA TEST GBCI.ORG
  • 238.
  • 239.
    April 6th , Tucson May6th , Jacksonville, FL May 14th , Flagstaff May 17th , Charlotte, NC May 20th , Phoenix UPCOMING WORKSHOPS

Editor's Notes

  • #42 Occupants Budget Timeframe Aesthetics Impact on environment Installation Durability Cool factor City codes and laws
  • #82 Demo., Excavation, Asbestos Test, Environmental Svc.