131
Jon Hall, Human Development Report Office, UNDP
BEYONDGDP
AUNPERSPECTIVE
132
FIVE EXCUSES TO STAY BEHIND GDP
I KNOW THE LIMITATIONS OF GDP BUT….
133
1. GDP correlates with everything that’s important
FIVE EXCUSES TO STAY BEHIND GDP
I KNOW THE LIMITATIONS OF GDP BUT….
134
Growth does not always correlate with other aspects of
development
135
1. GDP correlates with everything that’s important
2. My hands are tied as there’s no political demand
FIVE EXCUSES TO STAY BEHIND GDP
I KNOW THE LIMITATIONS OF GDP BUT….
136
EGYPT GDP & WELL BEING
137
1. GDP correlates with everything that’s important
2. My hands are tied as there’s no political demand
3. My hands are tied as there’s no public demand
FIVE EXCUSES TO STAY BEHIND GDP
I KNOW THE LIMITATIONS OF GDP BUT….
138
PUBLIC DEMAND
139
1. GDP correlates with everything that’s important
2. My hands are tied as there’s no political demand
3. My hands are tied as there’s no public demand
4. Its too political for statisticians
FIVE EXCUSES TO STAY BEHIND GDP
I KNOW THE LIMITATIONS OF GDP BUT….
1310
“What we measure affects what we do. If we have the wrong metrics, we will strive
for the wrong things. In the quest to increase GDP, we may end up with a society
in which most citizens have become worse off.”
Joseph Stiglitz, Nobel Laureate, 2009
STATISTICS ARE POLITICAL
1311
1. GDP correlates with everything that’s important
2. My hands are tied as there’s no political demand
3. My hands are tied as there’s no public demand
4. Its too political for statisticians
5. These new measures aren’t meaningful
FIVE EXCUSES TO STAY BEHIND GDP
I KNOW THE LIMITATIONS OF GDP BUT….
1312
LIFE SATISFACTION VS THE HDI
345678
.2 .4 .6 .8 1
Human Development Index (HDI)
95% CI Fitted values
Overall Life Evaluation
1313
FIVE THINGS TO DO BETTER
1314
1. Go Beyond the Field of Dreams
FIVE THINGS TO DO BETTER
1315
1. Go Beyond the Field of Dreams
2. Habituating Statisticians & Policy People
FIVE THINGS TO DO BETTER
1316
1. Go Beyond the Field of Dreams
2. Habituating Statisticians & Policy People
FIVE THINGS TO DO BETTER
1317
1. Go Beyond the Field of Dreams
2. Habituating Statisticians & Policy People
3. Empowering Statisticians as Reluctant Revolutionaries
FIVE THINGS TO DO BETTER
1318
1. Go Beyond the Field of Dreams
2. Habituating Statisticians & Policy People
3. Empowering Statisticians as Reluctant Revolutionaries
FIVE THINGS TO DO BETTER
1319
1. Go Beyond the Field of Dreams
2. Habituating Statisticians & Policy People
3. Empowering Statisticians as Reluctant Revolutionaries
4. Investigating Impact
FIVE THINGS TO DO BETTER
1320
1. Go Beyond the Field of Dreams
2. Habituating Statisticians & Policy People
3. Empowering Statisticians as Reluctant Revolutionaries
4. Investigating Impact
FIVE THINGS TO DO BETTER
1321
1. Go Beyond the Field of Dreams
2. Habituating Statisticians & Policy People
3. Empowering Statisticians as Reluctant Revolutionaries
4. Investigating Impact
5. Recognise the Importance of the Process: Empathy and Understanding
FIVE THINGS TO DO BETTER
1322
1. Go Beyond the Field of Dreams
2. Habituating Statisticians & Policy People
3. Empowering Statisticians as Reluctant Revolutionaries
4. Investigating Impact
5. Recognise the Importance of the Process: Empathy and Understanding
FIVE THINGS TO DO BETTER
1323
Jonathan.hall@undp.org

BRAINPOoL Workshop 24 March 2014: Jon Hall presentation

  • 1.
    131 Jon Hall, HumanDevelopment Report Office, UNDP BEYONDGDP AUNPERSPECTIVE
  • 2.
    132 FIVE EXCUSES TOSTAY BEHIND GDP I KNOW THE LIMITATIONS OF GDP BUT….
  • 3.
    133 1. GDP correlateswith everything that’s important FIVE EXCUSES TO STAY BEHIND GDP I KNOW THE LIMITATIONS OF GDP BUT….
  • 4.
    134 Growth does notalways correlate with other aspects of development
  • 5.
    135 1. GDP correlateswith everything that’s important 2. My hands are tied as there’s no political demand FIVE EXCUSES TO STAY BEHIND GDP I KNOW THE LIMITATIONS OF GDP BUT….
  • 6.
    136 EGYPT GDP &WELL BEING
  • 7.
    137 1. GDP correlateswith everything that’s important 2. My hands are tied as there’s no political demand 3. My hands are tied as there’s no public demand FIVE EXCUSES TO STAY BEHIND GDP I KNOW THE LIMITATIONS OF GDP BUT….
  • 8.
  • 9.
    139 1. GDP correlateswith everything that’s important 2. My hands are tied as there’s no political demand 3. My hands are tied as there’s no public demand 4. Its too political for statisticians FIVE EXCUSES TO STAY BEHIND GDP I KNOW THE LIMITATIONS OF GDP BUT….
  • 10.
    1310 “What we measureaffects what we do. If we have the wrong metrics, we will strive for the wrong things. In the quest to increase GDP, we may end up with a society in which most citizens have become worse off.” Joseph Stiglitz, Nobel Laureate, 2009 STATISTICS ARE POLITICAL
  • 11.
    1311 1. GDP correlateswith everything that’s important 2. My hands are tied as there’s no political demand 3. My hands are tied as there’s no public demand 4. Its too political for statisticians 5. These new measures aren’t meaningful FIVE EXCUSES TO STAY BEHIND GDP I KNOW THE LIMITATIONS OF GDP BUT….
  • 12.
    1312 LIFE SATISFACTION VSTHE HDI 345678 .2 .4 .6 .8 1 Human Development Index (HDI) 95% CI Fitted values Overall Life Evaluation
  • 13.
  • 14.
    1314 1. Go Beyondthe Field of Dreams FIVE THINGS TO DO BETTER
  • 15.
    1315 1. Go Beyondthe Field of Dreams 2. Habituating Statisticians & Policy People FIVE THINGS TO DO BETTER
  • 16.
    1316 1. Go Beyondthe Field of Dreams 2. Habituating Statisticians & Policy People FIVE THINGS TO DO BETTER
  • 17.
    1317 1. Go Beyondthe Field of Dreams 2. Habituating Statisticians & Policy People 3. Empowering Statisticians as Reluctant Revolutionaries FIVE THINGS TO DO BETTER
  • 18.
    1318 1. Go Beyondthe Field of Dreams 2. Habituating Statisticians & Policy People 3. Empowering Statisticians as Reluctant Revolutionaries FIVE THINGS TO DO BETTER
  • 19.
    1319 1. Go Beyondthe Field of Dreams 2. Habituating Statisticians & Policy People 3. Empowering Statisticians as Reluctant Revolutionaries 4. Investigating Impact FIVE THINGS TO DO BETTER
  • 20.
    1320 1. Go Beyondthe Field of Dreams 2. Habituating Statisticians & Policy People 3. Empowering Statisticians as Reluctant Revolutionaries 4. Investigating Impact FIVE THINGS TO DO BETTER
  • 21.
    1321 1. Go Beyondthe Field of Dreams 2. Habituating Statisticians & Policy People 3. Empowering Statisticians as Reluctant Revolutionaries 4. Investigating Impact 5. Recognise the Importance of the Process: Empathy and Understanding FIVE THINGS TO DO BETTER
  • 22.
    1322 1. Go Beyondthe Field of Dreams 2. Habituating Statisticians & Policy People 3. Empowering Statisticians as Reluctant Revolutionaries 4. Investigating Impact 5. Recognise the Importance of the Process: Empathy and Understanding FIVE THINGS TO DO BETTER
  • 23.