Enterprise Risk Management Introduction (Part 1) John Glenn, MBCI Enterprise Risk Management practitioner Hollywood/Fort Lauderdale Florida 1-954-961-1674 –  [email_address] http://JohnGlennMBCI.com Copyright 2010, John Glenn MBCI
Overview Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) also is known as Business Continuity Continuation Of Operations (COOP) Enterprise Risk Management is not Information Technology Disaster Recovery (IT D/R) although IT D/R is an integral part of Enterprise Risk Management
What’s in a name? Enterprise Risk Management  (ERM) defined  Enterprise : The entire organization, working from the profit center(s) out; holistic, all-inclusive Risk :  All risks, both external and internal; no risk is overlooked or considered “out-of-scope” Management : Control threats through avoidance or mitigation; plan recovery to “business as usual"
Program or project Success or failure ROI or wasted effort and funds Enterprise Risk Management, to be successful,  must  be an on-going program; while there is a beginning, there is no end The program usually consists of projects, each with specific milestones
Who’s in charge? The ideal candidate to sponsor an Enterprise Risk Management program (best) or project is a very senior manager with fiduciary responsibilities, e.g., CEO,  CFO, COO
Who is NOT in charge Functional unit C*Os and VPs (e.g., VP/MIS, CIO) properly are  function focused  and lack enterprise fiduciary responsibility; they also may be perceived as working primarily for the good of their unit vs. the good of the overall organization
Crossing silos Enterprise Risk Management is concerned  with threats to “business as usual” from all directions Enterprise Risk Management focuses on  PROCESSES  and follows critical processes from initiation to completion
Risk Management Humor Passengers board ABC Airlines Flight 13 Pilot ‘s voice comes over the intercom “ Ladies & gentlemen, welcome to ABC Airlines Flight 13 “ This is ABC’s first fully automated flight; the only ABC personnel on board are the Flight Attendants “ Everything is computer controlled “ Nothing can possibly go wrong, go wrong, go . . .
Abbreviated flow diagram What could possibly go wrong ?
Threats to “business as usual” - 1 Threats to “business as usual” come from external vendors Materials suppliers Utilities suppliers Money suppliers (lenders) Transportation providers “ Ubiquitous others”
Threats to “business as usual” - 2 Threats to “business as usual” come from internal vendors Facilities HR/Personnel Office support (Accounting, Mailroom, etc.) IT “ Ubiquitous others”
Threats to “business as usual” - 3 Threats to “business as usual” come from Government, trade groups, regulators Customers Competition Image (company, product, associations) Neighbors Events (holidays)  “ Ubiquitous others”
Prioritize threats Threats are rated by Probability of occurrence Impact on organization You set the scale Low-Medium-High 1 to 3, 5, 10 Avoidance & mitigation costs are not an issue  at  this  p oint
Avoid, Mitigate, or Absorb Threats can be  Avoided: usually the “high cost” option Mitigated: typically less expensive than avoidance, but with trade-offs Mitigation includes insurance coverage Absorbed: The organization will accept the loss
Threat chart Create a chart to list all threats to “business as usual” This  is best accomplished in groups An amanuensis is a must A white board that can “write” to memory is useful
Decision makers The residents of the Corporate Suite review the recommendations and Confirm or change priorities based on business  plans Determine  w hat measures are to be implemented to deal with each threat Decide when to implement the threat avoidance or mitigation measures Smart management listens to its Subject Matter Experts (SMEs)
About the practitioner More than 13 years experience Certified by the Business Continuity Institute Created complete enterprise, key business unit, and IT-specific plans for Defense, Energy, Financial, Fortune 100, Government, Insurance, International, and Transportation organizations Formerly Manager of Business Continuity for a defense industry leader managing 47 sites in 17 states
Enterprise Risk Management an introduction (Part 2) John Glenn, MBCI Enterprise Risk Management practitioner Hollywood/Fort Lauderdale Florida 1-954-961-1674 –  [email_address] http://JohnGlennMBCI.com Copyright 2010, John Glenn MBCI
Best laid plans of mice & men When the “best laid plans of mice and men” still fail to fully protect the organization, there must be a plan to “restore to business as usual”  Efficiently Economically Expeditiously
Many mini-plans Enterprise Risk Management is at once top down and bottom up Top down since enterprise resources may be utilized to restore to “business as usual” Bottom up since each functional unit  needs its own mini-risk management plan
Why mini-plans? Each functional unit – profit center or resource – needs its own “mini” plan  If a threat is isolated to one functional unit, the mini-plan should guide responders to determine if the unit can be recovered before there is impact on other functional units
Recovery “by the numbers” Each mini-plan, and the organization’s overall plan, includes procedures to restore critical processes Procedures are prepared by functional unit Subject Matter Experts (SMEs) Procedures are documented (by SMEs or others) Procedures are validated by  NON -SMEs to assure completeness and clarity
Practice makes perfect Restoration procedures must be practiced So responders understand their tasks So responders’ confidence is enhanced So any plan deficiencies are discovered and eliminated There are various exercise levels Walk-throughs to “pull the switch” Exercises, never “tests”
Who responds? Every response task needs at least two responders, a primary and an alternate People get sick, go on vacation, change jobs, go to courses away from the work place Both primary and alternate must be able to do the task Rank is not a consideration in selecting responders
Planning ahead A few things to consider before an event Press releases, and who will give them Different emphasis for different audiences Policies and procedures  Work periods, family considerations, etc. Furlough of non-essential personnel Relocation options
Training Personnel awareness & safety training Sights, sounds, smells Evacuation & in-place sheltering What to do if someone refuses to Leave the building (evacuation) Stay inside the building (in-place sheltering) The lawyers say . . .
Plan maintenance When to review the plan Depends on organization’s dynamics, but at least annually By trigger word changes, “P” words Personnel  Place (location)  Politics (licensing, regulations, zoning)  Procedure  Process  Product  Providers (vendors)  Purchasers (clients)
Planner’s role An experienced practitioner should be involved in creating the plan and monitoring the program either As in-house staff, to manage the process and mentor functional unit staff contributing to the plan As a consultant and mentor to in-house personnel assigned planning tasks
Plan benefits Potentially lower costs Reduced risk impact through avoidance, mitigation More efficient, expeditious recovery Adjusted insurance coverage PR – “We have a plan, therefore we assure product delivery” Enhanced employee loyalty Employees know management cares about them Possibly enhanced stock and bond ratings
About the practitioner More than 13 years experience Certified by the Business Continuity Institute Created complete enterprise, key business unit, and IT-specific plans for Defense, Energy, Financial, Fortune 100, Government, Insurance, International, and Transportation organizations Formerly Manager of Business Continuity for a defense industry leader managing 47 sites in 17 states

Intro to ERM

  • 1.
    Enterprise Risk ManagementIntroduction (Part 1) John Glenn, MBCI Enterprise Risk Management practitioner Hollywood/Fort Lauderdale Florida 1-954-961-1674 – [email_address] http://JohnGlennMBCI.com Copyright 2010, John Glenn MBCI
  • 2.
    Overview Enterprise RiskManagement (ERM) also is known as Business Continuity Continuation Of Operations (COOP) Enterprise Risk Management is not Information Technology Disaster Recovery (IT D/R) although IT D/R is an integral part of Enterprise Risk Management
  • 3.
    What’s in aname? Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) defined Enterprise : The entire organization, working from the profit center(s) out; holistic, all-inclusive Risk : All risks, both external and internal; no risk is overlooked or considered “out-of-scope” Management : Control threats through avoidance or mitigation; plan recovery to “business as usual"
  • 4.
    Program or projectSuccess or failure ROI or wasted effort and funds Enterprise Risk Management, to be successful, must be an on-going program; while there is a beginning, there is no end The program usually consists of projects, each with specific milestones
  • 5.
    Who’s in charge?The ideal candidate to sponsor an Enterprise Risk Management program (best) or project is a very senior manager with fiduciary responsibilities, e.g., CEO, CFO, COO
  • 6.
    Who is NOTin charge Functional unit C*Os and VPs (e.g., VP/MIS, CIO) properly are function focused and lack enterprise fiduciary responsibility; they also may be perceived as working primarily for the good of their unit vs. the good of the overall organization
  • 7.
    Crossing silos EnterpriseRisk Management is concerned with threats to “business as usual” from all directions Enterprise Risk Management focuses on PROCESSES and follows critical processes from initiation to completion
  • 8.
    Risk Management HumorPassengers board ABC Airlines Flight 13 Pilot ‘s voice comes over the intercom “ Ladies & gentlemen, welcome to ABC Airlines Flight 13 “ This is ABC’s first fully automated flight; the only ABC personnel on board are the Flight Attendants “ Everything is computer controlled “ Nothing can possibly go wrong, go wrong, go . . .
  • 9.
    Abbreviated flow diagramWhat could possibly go wrong ?
  • 10.
    Threats to “businessas usual” - 1 Threats to “business as usual” come from external vendors Materials suppliers Utilities suppliers Money suppliers (lenders) Transportation providers “ Ubiquitous others”
  • 11.
    Threats to “businessas usual” - 2 Threats to “business as usual” come from internal vendors Facilities HR/Personnel Office support (Accounting, Mailroom, etc.) IT “ Ubiquitous others”
  • 12.
    Threats to “businessas usual” - 3 Threats to “business as usual” come from Government, trade groups, regulators Customers Competition Image (company, product, associations) Neighbors Events (holidays) “ Ubiquitous others”
  • 13.
    Prioritize threats Threatsare rated by Probability of occurrence Impact on organization You set the scale Low-Medium-High 1 to 3, 5, 10 Avoidance & mitigation costs are not an issue at this p oint
  • 14.
    Avoid, Mitigate, orAbsorb Threats can be Avoided: usually the “high cost” option Mitigated: typically less expensive than avoidance, but with trade-offs Mitigation includes insurance coverage Absorbed: The organization will accept the loss
  • 15.
    Threat chart Createa chart to list all threats to “business as usual” This is best accomplished in groups An amanuensis is a must A white board that can “write” to memory is useful
  • 16.
    Decision makers Theresidents of the Corporate Suite review the recommendations and Confirm or change priorities based on business plans Determine w hat measures are to be implemented to deal with each threat Decide when to implement the threat avoidance or mitigation measures Smart management listens to its Subject Matter Experts (SMEs)
  • 17.
    About the practitionerMore than 13 years experience Certified by the Business Continuity Institute Created complete enterprise, key business unit, and IT-specific plans for Defense, Energy, Financial, Fortune 100, Government, Insurance, International, and Transportation organizations Formerly Manager of Business Continuity for a defense industry leader managing 47 sites in 17 states
  • 18.
    Enterprise Risk Managementan introduction (Part 2) John Glenn, MBCI Enterprise Risk Management practitioner Hollywood/Fort Lauderdale Florida 1-954-961-1674 – [email_address] http://JohnGlennMBCI.com Copyright 2010, John Glenn MBCI
  • 19.
    Best laid plansof mice & men When the “best laid plans of mice and men” still fail to fully protect the organization, there must be a plan to “restore to business as usual” Efficiently Economically Expeditiously
  • 20.
    Many mini-plans EnterpriseRisk Management is at once top down and bottom up Top down since enterprise resources may be utilized to restore to “business as usual” Bottom up since each functional unit needs its own mini-risk management plan
  • 21.
    Why mini-plans? Eachfunctional unit – profit center or resource – needs its own “mini” plan If a threat is isolated to one functional unit, the mini-plan should guide responders to determine if the unit can be recovered before there is impact on other functional units
  • 22.
    Recovery “by thenumbers” Each mini-plan, and the organization’s overall plan, includes procedures to restore critical processes Procedures are prepared by functional unit Subject Matter Experts (SMEs) Procedures are documented (by SMEs or others) Procedures are validated by NON -SMEs to assure completeness and clarity
  • 23.
    Practice makes perfectRestoration procedures must be practiced So responders understand their tasks So responders’ confidence is enhanced So any plan deficiencies are discovered and eliminated There are various exercise levels Walk-throughs to “pull the switch” Exercises, never “tests”
  • 24.
    Who responds? Everyresponse task needs at least two responders, a primary and an alternate People get sick, go on vacation, change jobs, go to courses away from the work place Both primary and alternate must be able to do the task Rank is not a consideration in selecting responders
  • 25.
    Planning ahead Afew things to consider before an event Press releases, and who will give them Different emphasis for different audiences Policies and procedures Work periods, family considerations, etc. Furlough of non-essential personnel Relocation options
  • 26.
    Training Personnel awareness& safety training Sights, sounds, smells Evacuation & in-place sheltering What to do if someone refuses to Leave the building (evacuation) Stay inside the building (in-place sheltering) The lawyers say . . .
  • 27.
    Plan maintenance Whento review the plan Depends on organization’s dynamics, but at least annually By trigger word changes, “P” words Personnel Place (location) Politics (licensing, regulations, zoning) Procedure Process Product Providers (vendors) Purchasers (clients)
  • 28.
    Planner’s role Anexperienced practitioner should be involved in creating the plan and monitoring the program either As in-house staff, to manage the process and mentor functional unit staff contributing to the plan As a consultant and mentor to in-house personnel assigned planning tasks
  • 29.
    Plan benefits Potentiallylower costs Reduced risk impact through avoidance, mitigation More efficient, expeditious recovery Adjusted insurance coverage PR – “We have a plan, therefore we assure product delivery” Enhanced employee loyalty Employees know management cares about them Possibly enhanced stock and bond ratings
  • 30.
    About the practitionerMore than 13 years experience Certified by the Business Continuity Institute Created complete enterprise, key business unit, and IT-specific plans for Defense, Energy, Financial, Fortune 100, Government, Insurance, International, and Transportation organizations Formerly Manager of Business Continuity for a defense industry leader managing 47 sites in 17 states

Editor's Notes

  • #3 Explain ERM is the evolution of D/R to protect the profit centers and all profit center resources, including internal and external vendors (internal=Accounting, Facilities, HR, IT, Purchasing, Shipping, etc.; external=all vendors [product, raw materials, money], customers, transportation, etc.)
  • #5 Explain ROI
  • #6 CIOs and VPs of MIS or IT often are tasked with Enterprise Risk Management sponsorship because they have Disaster Recovery experience and because other managers fail to understand what Enterprise Risk Management is about more than IT
  • #8 Define processes – the need for granularity; ERM is done at ground level to follow a process from origination to completion (e.g., sale to money-in-bank). Practitioners need to “follow the trail” – e.g., if there is an IT dependency, what applications and what do the applications require (other apps, hardware, connectivity, etc.)
  • #9 The seriousness behind the joke - If anything can go wrong, it will; risks will be missed, people will panic
  • #10 Discussion. This diagram has a lot on it but it is not “all-inclusive.” What can be added?
  • #11 Get input from class – what are some of the “Ubiquitous others” “ Ubiquitous others” are things that normally are not identified (but one of the reasons plans are NOT created in a vacuum – the more people involved, generally the better.
  • #12 Get input from class – what are some of the “Ubiquitous others”
  • #13 Get input from class – what are some of the “Ubiquitous others”; why “neighbors”?
  • #15 What type insurance coverage might be considered? (Business interruption – with paperwork) Explain “absorption” – technology not worth replacing
  • #16 Why groups (dynamics), aman·u·en·sis Have someone look up “amanuensis”
  • #17 Explain why “second” prioritization (mgt’s biz plan); Smart SMEs don’t ask for the Sun when the Moon will do If implementation is >6 months away, exclude it from recovery planning; too many things can happen to cancel the implementation.
  • #18 End of first day
  • #20 Explain some of the consequences of failing any of the three Costs, competition, loss of personnel
  • #21 See http://johnglennmbci.com/MiniOne.html and http://johnglennmbci.com/PlnVPln.html
  • #22 Ask for other examples – troops called to active duty, traffic congestion
  • #23 Why non-SMEs? Documentation must be complete and clear so that a person can be brought in, read the procedure(s) and accomplish the task. RECOVERY IS NOT NECESSARILY THE SAME AS “BUSINESS AS USUAL.”
  • #24 Tests are pass/fail; they intimidate and are counterproductive; how often to exercise plans – unit, enterprise
  • #25 Risk of multi-tasking (simultaneous jobs); boss may report to one of own reports; how to find out who is suitable
  • #26 Press – honesty is critical; Relo – immediate, shot, long term, employee proximity
  • #27 One reason why plaanning must be enterprise – lawyers are involved in evac and in-place sheltering and in other areas
  • #28 Minimum once-a-year
  • #30 #1 priority is to protect the #1 resource: personnel
  • #31 End Day 2/End presentation