Sasanka Lenka
lenka57@gmail.com
Indigenous knowledge gained
recognition through
United Nations Conference on Environment and
Education in1992
World Conservation Strategy of International
Union and Conservations of Natural Resources in
1980
Brundtland Commission & World Commission on
Environment and Development, 1987
Which recognized existence of indigenous
knowledge in every country, society, culture
Indigenous technical
knowledge (ITK) is the
accumulated skill and
technology of a locality or a
community that has been
passed on from one generation
to another generation.
Traditional
knowledge
Local knowledge
People’s science
Rural people’s
knowledge
Ethno-ecology
Indigenous Technical
Knowledge
Indigenous knowledge (IK) is,
broadly speaking, the knowledge used by
local people to make a living in particular
environment
It can be defined as
“A body of knowledge built up by a group
of people through generations of living in
close contact with nature”
Grenier (1998) - indigenous knowledge is the traditional
knowledge of the local community existing within and
developed around the specific conditions of women and
men indigenous to a particular geographical area.
Basu(2009) – indigenous knowledge is not confined to tribal
groups or the original inhabitants of an area. It is not
confined to the rural people rather any community
possessing indigenous knowledge- rural or urban, settled or
nomadic, original inhabitants and migrants.
Indigenous knowledge is referred to not only to the
knowledge of indigenous people but also the intellectual
property of other communities.
Adaptive skills of local people usually derived from many years of
experience, that have often been communicated through "oral traditions"
and learned through family members over generations (Thrupp, 1989).
Time-tested agricultural and natural resource management practices, which
pave the way for sustainable agriculture (Venkatratnam, 1990).
Strategies and techniques developed by local people to cope with the
changes in the socio-cultural and environmental conditions.
Practices that are accumulated by farmers due to constant experimentation
and innovation.
Trial-and-error problem-solving approaches by groups of people with an
objective to meet the challenges they face in their local environments
(Roling and Engel, 1988).
Decision-making skills of local people that draw upon the resources they
have at hand.
Indigenous knowledge systems are:
Importance of Indigenous Knowledge
System
Indigenous Knowledge is an integral
part of the development process of local
communities
IKS provides the foundation for their
beliefs and traditional practices
Indigenous knowledge helps to promote
biodiversity conservation
IK learning attitudes and values for a
sustainable future
IK starting locally: From the “Known” to
the “Unknown”
Bio-diversity in India
As many as 167 species of crops, 320 species
of wild crop relatives and several species of
domesticated animals have originated here
And also there are
Rice (50,000 varieties)
Sorghum (5000 varieties)
Mango (1000 varieties)
Pepper (500 varieties)
Cattle (27 breeds)
Goat (22 breeds)
Sheep (40 breeds)
Poultry (18 breeds) and
Buffalo (8 breeds)
Kothari (2001)
More than 1000 species of plants are known to have
insecticidal properties
300 species with repellent properties
30 species possessing insect growth regulatory
(IGR)properties
There is wide scope for use of organic manures which
can be prepared from plant parts as well as animal by
products.
(Jayaraj, 2002)
12/21/2018
12/21/2018
12/21/2018
ITKs are eco-friendly
Sustainable & time tested
Several insect pests have developed
insecticide resistance
Degradation of natural enemies
Secondary pest outbreaks
Environmental pollution has become more
persistent
Input cost on plant protection have increased
enormously
Adaptability is high
Compatible with the ecosystems and social
systems
Why ITK ?
How ITK were developed
Trial and error
Selection
Experiences of the farmers
Living in the eco-systems over generations
But not the freak of nature
Many technologies recommended by the
scientists are developed from the ITKs
Importance of ITK
There is an old African proverb: "When an old
knowledgeable person dies, a whole library dies”
Indigenous technical knowledge has two powerful
advantages over outside
• it has little or no cost
• it is readily available
knowledge (Kothari, 1995)
Changesin
Perspective
Shifting emphasis in Research & Extension
Dominating Discipline Considering farmers
as …
1950 - 1975
Production Stage
1975 - 1985
Economic Stage
1985 - 1995
Ecological Stage
1995 onwards
InstitutionalStage
Plant & Animal Breeding
Genetics
Recipients of external
knowledge
Sources of information
for technology designEconomics & Agronomy
Agro-ecology &
Anthropology
OD, HRD & Training
Full collaborators to Res.
& Extn., Develop alliances
between different Org.
Contributors of ITK, Victims
& Cause for Unsustainable
development
Sources of ITK
Farmers
Community leaders
Elders
Forklore
Songs and poetry
Ancient records
NGO’s
Extension agencies
Published materials of different languages.
Difference of Traditional knowledge System and
Scientific system
12/21/2018
Traditional Knowledge system Scientific System
All parts of the natural world are regarded
as animate, all life forms as interdependent
Human life is generally regarded as superior,
with a moral right to control other life forms
Knowledge is transmitted largely through
oral media.
Knowledge is transmitted largely through the
written word
Knowledge is developed and acquired
through observation and practical experience
Knowledge is generally learned in a situation,
which is remote from its applied context
Knowledge is holistic, intuitive, qualitative
and practical
Knowledge is essentially
reductionist, quantitative, analytical and theoretical.
Knowledge is generated by resource users
in a diachronic (long-term) time scale
Knowledge is generated largely by specialist
researchers on a synchronic (short-term) time
scale
The nature and status of particular
knowledge is influenced by socio-cultural
factors such as spiritual beliefs and is
communally held
The nature and status of particular knowledge is
influenced by peer review and is held by
individual specialists
Explanations behind perceived phenomena
are often spiritually based on subjective
The explanation behind perceived phenomena
are essentially rational and objective
Knowledge is used to make suitable
decisions under variable conditions
Knowledge is used to put forward a
hypothesis and to verify underlying laws and
constants
Characteristics of ITK
ITK is not static but dynamic
Exogenous knowledge and endogenous creativity
brings change to ITK
ITK is intuitive in its mode of thinking
ITK is mainly qualitative in nature
ITK study needs a holistic approach
ITK, if properly tapped, can provide valuable
insights into resources, processes, possibilities,
and problems in a particular area
ITK is recorded and transferred through oral
tradition
ITK is learned through observation and hands-on
experience
ITK forms an information base for a variety
ITK reflects local tradition
Classes of ITK in Agriculture
Irrigation & water
management
Agronomic Practices
Post Harvesting
Techn. & Methods
Plant Protection
Soil Fertility
Local Soil &
Taxonomy
Climat
ology
Seed
Bank
Light Trap or
Fire Trap
BorderCrop,
TraporInter
Crop
Integrated Pest
Management
Pure Seeds
Tolerant to
Diseases and Pest
Nutrient
Management
ITKs Wheel
Roles of ITK
12/21/2018
ITK can aid development efforts
ITK can facilitate local people’s
participation
ITK is a valuable source of developing
appropriate technologies
Scope of ITK analysis
12/21/2018
New biological and ecological insight
Resource management
Protected areas and conservation
education
Development planning
Environment assessment
Decisions on Using ITK
in Agricultural R&D
Apply and promote improved ITK
Yes
Can ITK be improved? No
Test appropriate
outside knowledge
Yes Promote ITKIs ITK effective and sustainable?
No
Test appropriate
outside knowledge
Does ITK relating to problem
exist?
No
Yes
Identify Problem
Identification and collection of ITK: methods and techniques
12/21/2018
1. Documentation of oral histories
2. The Delphi method
3. Agro-ecosystem analysis
a) Mapping (ecological, agronomic, seasonal, spatial)
b) Transect
4. Manual discriminative analysis (ask farmers to discriminate practices and find
rationality)
5. Decision tree analysis
6. Use of local resource persons
7. Linguistic and historical analysis of concepts, vocabulary, and keywords
8. Ethno botany
9. Critical incident analysis (farmers’ seed exchanges and new variety introduction)
10. Analysis of peasants’ journals and newspapers
11. Arranging competition
12. Conducting documentation workshops
13. Continuous interactions during on-farm experiments
14. Anthropological methods (investigation into the social, cultural and other aspects of
rural tradition)
15. Local taxonomy
16. Hear-say method
17. Crop histories
18. Survey method
19. In-depth interview of farmers.
Methods of ITK collection
Interaction with leaders and elders
Rural appraisals
Case study
History
Interview method
Brain storming
Group discussions
Field observation
Surveys
SWOT analysis
Notes
Photos
Audio-
recordings
Video-
recordings
Methods
Surveys / RRA / PRA
Observations
Documentary evidences
Survey
Laboratory Analysis
On-farm testing
Input to Research
On Farm Research Farmer
Participatory Research
Laboratory Studies
Guard & Legalize the ITKs
Ensure Ow nership to Local
Communities
Use Media Mix
Integrate Indigenous Netw orks
Publicize & Reward
Promote the Use of
validated and refined ITKs
Protect the Valid and
Refined ITKs
Refine the ITKs for
increasing its applicability
on w ider scale
Validate the ITKs / Assess
the ITKs for Scientific
Logic
Document the ITKs
Testing and Validation: method and techniques
Continuum Weightage
Very rational 5
Rational 4
Undecided 3
Irrational 2
Very irrational 1
1. Prepare a list of all the collected ITK practices
2. Decide the continuum for rating the rationality of ITK
with specific weightages
3. Send the list of ITK practices to experts for their opinion
and judgment on each practice.
4.Calculate the weighted mean score of individual
practices.
5. Select practices above mean score as rational.
Steps involved for developing the ----
Extension Programme
Selecting "research minded"
village extension workers
Identifying "research
minded" farmers who are
already involved in farmer
experiments; and
Establishing programs for
validating farmer experiments
Validation of Farmer’s
Experiment
Understand experiments in the
socio-cultural and agro-
ecological environments
Determine the impact of
the experiments on
productivity, profitability, and
sustainability of the agricultural
system
Understand the rationale behind
farmer experimentation
Recording the mode of
conducting experiments
Identifying farmers' evaluation
criteria
Strategies for Agricultural Research
Strengthening the capacities of regional research and extension organizations;
Building upon local people's knowledge that is acquired through various
processes such as farmer-to-farmer communication, and farmer
experimentation;
Identifying the need for an extension scientist/ social scientist in an interdisciplinary
regional research team;
Formation of a sustainable technology development consortium to bring farmers,
researchers, NGOs, and extension workers together well ahead of the process of
technology development;
Generating technological options rather than fixed technical packages;
Working with the existing organization and management of research and public
sector extension;
Bringing research-extension-farmer together at all stages is practically difficult
considering the existing bureaucracies and spatial as well as academic distances
among the personnel belonging to these organizations.
Outlining areas that research and extension organizations need to concentrate on
during the process of working with farmers.
Understanding that it is impractical to depend entirely on research stations for
innovations considering the inadequate human resource capacity of the regional
research system.
Training on Indigenous Knowledge Systems
Stage-I: Training/workshop for the state
level trainers of TTCs, ICAR Institutes and
agricultural universities from various regions
of the country.
Stage-II: The trainers will then provide
similar training for district-level extension
workers, subject matter specialists of KVKs
etc.
Inter-Disciplinary and Multi-Disciplinary Approach
Identifying the problems
Problem prioritization with the active participation of the
farmers, local people etc.
Formulating research project incorporating the identified ITK as
a major component
Conducting Participatory On-Station Research (POSR) or On-
Farm Farmers Oriented Research (OFFOR)
Evaluating the effectiveness of the ITK including additional
benefits
Testing the research output in farmers’ fields
Technology validation
Technology refinement (if necessary)
Technology demonstration / popularization
Formation of sustainable technology development consortium is to bring
farmers, researchers, extension workers, KVKs and NGOs representatives
Indigenous Technology Map
Blending of indigenous knowledge with modern
scientific technologies is the need of the day to
support the sustainable development of agriculture
and allied sector in our country.
Challenges-----
Protect property rights and
facilitate the process
Raw Materials
Agri products
Industrial
products
Knowledge
products
Information
products
Innovation
Networks
Technology
Industrial
Society
Agricultural
Society
Information
Society
Knowledge
Society
Societal Transformation
36
Go to the people,
Live with them,
Learn from them,
Love them,
Start with what they know,
Build with what they have,
But with the best leaders.
When the work is done,
The task accomplished
The people will say
“We have done this ourselves”
-Laotsu-700 B.C.
Think Globally, but Act Locally------

Indigenous Technological Knowledge (ITK) or IKP/ITK

  • 1.
  • 2.
    Indigenous knowledge gained recognitionthrough United Nations Conference on Environment and Education in1992 World Conservation Strategy of International Union and Conservations of Natural Resources in 1980 Brundtland Commission & World Commission on Environment and Development, 1987 Which recognized existence of indigenous knowledge in every country, society, culture
  • 3.
    Indigenous technical knowledge (ITK)is the accumulated skill and technology of a locality or a community that has been passed on from one generation to another generation. Traditional knowledge Local knowledge People’s science Rural people’s knowledge Ethno-ecology Indigenous Technical Knowledge
  • 4.
    Indigenous knowledge (IK)is, broadly speaking, the knowledge used by local people to make a living in particular environment It can be defined as “A body of knowledge built up by a group of people through generations of living in close contact with nature”
  • 5.
    Grenier (1998) -indigenous knowledge is the traditional knowledge of the local community existing within and developed around the specific conditions of women and men indigenous to a particular geographical area. Basu(2009) – indigenous knowledge is not confined to tribal groups or the original inhabitants of an area. It is not confined to the rural people rather any community possessing indigenous knowledge- rural or urban, settled or nomadic, original inhabitants and migrants. Indigenous knowledge is referred to not only to the knowledge of indigenous people but also the intellectual property of other communities.
  • 6.
    Adaptive skills oflocal people usually derived from many years of experience, that have often been communicated through "oral traditions" and learned through family members over generations (Thrupp, 1989). Time-tested agricultural and natural resource management practices, which pave the way for sustainable agriculture (Venkatratnam, 1990). Strategies and techniques developed by local people to cope with the changes in the socio-cultural and environmental conditions. Practices that are accumulated by farmers due to constant experimentation and innovation. Trial-and-error problem-solving approaches by groups of people with an objective to meet the challenges they face in their local environments (Roling and Engel, 1988). Decision-making skills of local people that draw upon the resources they have at hand. Indigenous knowledge systems are:
  • 7.
    Importance of IndigenousKnowledge System Indigenous Knowledge is an integral part of the development process of local communities IKS provides the foundation for their beliefs and traditional practices Indigenous knowledge helps to promote biodiversity conservation IK learning attitudes and values for a sustainable future IK starting locally: From the “Known” to the “Unknown”
  • 8.
    Bio-diversity in India Asmany as 167 species of crops, 320 species of wild crop relatives and several species of domesticated animals have originated here And also there are Rice (50,000 varieties) Sorghum (5000 varieties) Mango (1000 varieties) Pepper (500 varieties) Cattle (27 breeds) Goat (22 breeds) Sheep (40 breeds) Poultry (18 breeds) and Buffalo (8 breeds) Kothari (2001)
  • 9.
    More than 1000species of plants are known to have insecticidal properties 300 species with repellent properties 30 species possessing insect growth regulatory (IGR)properties There is wide scope for use of organic manures which can be prepared from plant parts as well as animal by products. (Jayaraj, 2002)
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
    ITKs are eco-friendly Sustainable& time tested Several insect pests have developed insecticide resistance Degradation of natural enemies Secondary pest outbreaks Environmental pollution has become more persistent Input cost on plant protection have increased enormously Adaptability is high Compatible with the ecosystems and social systems Why ITK ?
  • 14.
    How ITK weredeveloped Trial and error Selection Experiences of the farmers Living in the eco-systems over generations But not the freak of nature Many technologies recommended by the scientists are developed from the ITKs
  • 15.
    Importance of ITK Thereis an old African proverb: "When an old knowledgeable person dies, a whole library dies” Indigenous technical knowledge has two powerful advantages over outside • it has little or no cost • it is readily available knowledge (Kothari, 1995)
  • 16.
    Changesin Perspective Shifting emphasis inResearch & Extension Dominating Discipline Considering farmers as … 1950 - 1975 Production Stage 1975 - 1985 Economic Stage 1985 - 1995 Ecological Stage 1995 onwards InstitutionalStage Plant & Animal Breeding Genetics Recipients of external knowledge Sources of information for technology designEconomics & Agronomy Agro-ecology & Anthropology OD, HRD & Training Full collaborators to Res. & Extn., Develop alliances between different Org. Contributors of ITK, Victims & Cause for Unsustainable development
  • 17.
    Sources of ITK Farmers Communityleaders Elders Forklore Songs and poetry Ancient records NGO’s Extension agencies Published materials of different languages.
  • 18.
    Difference of Traditionalknowledge System and Scientific system 12/21/2018 Traditional Knowledge system Scientific System All parts of the natural world are regarded as animate, all life forms as interdependent Human life is generally regarded as superior, with a moral right to control other life forms Knowledge is transmitted largely through oral media. Knowledge is transmitted largely through the written word Knowledge is developed and acquired through observation and practical experience Knowledge is generally learned in a situation, which is remote from its applied context Knowledge is holistic, intuitive, qualitative and practical Knowledge is essentially reductionist, quantitative, analytical and theoretical. Knowledge is generated by resource users in a diachronic (long-term) time scale Knowledge is generated largely by specialist researchers on a synchronic (short-term) time scale The nature and status of particular knowledge is influenced by socio-cultural factors such as spiritual beliefs and is communally held The nature and status of particular knowledge is influenced by peer review and is held by individual specialists Explanations behind perceived phenomena are often spiritually based on subjective The explanation behind perceived phenomena are essentially rational and objective Knowledge is used to make suitable decisions under variable conditions Knowledge is used to put forward a hypothesis and to verify underlying laws and constants
  • 19.
    Characteristics of ITK ITKis not static but dynamic Exogenous knowledge and endogenous creativity brings change to ITK ITK is intuitive in its mode of thinking ITK is mainly qualitative in nature ITK study needs a holistic approach ITK, if properly tapped, can provide valuable insights into resources, processes, possibilities, and problems in a particular area ITK is recorded and transferred through oral tradition ITK is learned through observation and hands-on experience ITK forms an information base for a variety ITK reflects local tradition
  • 20.
    Classes of ITKin Agriculture Irrigation & water management Agronomic Practices Post Harvesting Techn. & Methods Plant Protection Soil Fertility Local Soil & Taxonomy Climat ology
  • 21.
    Seed Bank Light Trap or FireTrap BorderCrop, TraporInter Crop Integrated Pest Management Pure Seeds Tolerant to Diseases and Pest Nutrient Management ITKs Wheel
  • 22.
    Roles of ITK 12/21/2018 ITKcan aid development efforts ITK can facilitate local people’s participation ITK is a valuable source of developing appropriate technologies
  • 23.
    Scope of ITKanalysis 12/21/2018 New biological and ecological insight Resource management Protected areas and conservation education Development planning Environment assessment
  • 24.
    Decisions on UsingITK in Agricultural R&D Apply and promote improved ITK Yes Can ITK be improved? No Test appropriate outside knowledge Yes Promote ITKIs ITK effective and sustainable? No Test appropriate outside knowledge Does ITK relating to problem exist? No Yes Identify Problem
  • 25.
    Identification and collectionof ITK: methods and techniques 12/21/2018 1. Documentation of oral histories 2. The Delphi method 3. Agro-ecosystem analysis a) Mapping (ecological, agronomic, seasonal, spatial) b) Transect 4. Manual discriminative analysis (ask farmers to discriminate practices and find rationality) 5. Decision tree analysis 6. Use of local resource persons 7. Linguistic and historical analysis of concepts, vocabulary, and keywords 8. Ethno botany 9. Critical incident analysis (farmers’ seed exchanges and new variety introduction) 10. Analysis of peasants’ journals and newspapers 11. Arranging competition 12. Conducting documentation workshops 13. Continuous interactions during on-farm experiments 14. Anthropological methods (investigation into the social, cultural and other aspects of rural tradition) 15. Local taxonomy 16. Hear-say method 17. Crop histories 18. Survey method 19. In-depth interview of farmers.
  • 26.
    Methods of ITKcollection Interaction with leaders and elders Rural appraisals Case study History Interview method Brain storming Group discussions Field observation Surveys SWOT analysis Notes Photos Audio- recordings Video- recordings
  • 27.
    Methods Surveys / RRA/ PRA Observations Documentary evidences Survey Laboratory Analysis On-farm testing Input to Research On Farm Research Farmer Participatory Research Laboratory Studies Guard & Legalize the ITKs Ensure Ow nership to Local Communities Use Media Mix Integrate Indigenous Netw orks Publicize & Reward Promote the Use of validated and refined ITKs Protect the Valid and Refined ITKs Refine the ITKs for increasing its applicability on w ider scale Validate the ITKs / Assess the ITKs for Scientific Logic Document the ITKs
  • 28.
    Testing and Validation:method and techniques Continuum Weightage Very rational 5 Rational 4 Undecided 3 Irrational 2 Very irrational 1 1. Prepare a list of all the collected ITK practices 2. Decide the continuum for rating the rationality of ITK with specific weightages 3. Send the list of ITK practices to experts for their opinion and judgment on each practice. 4.Calculate the weighted mean score of individual practices. 5. Select practices above mean score as rational.
  • 29.
    Steps involved fordeveloping the ---- Extension Programme Selecting "research minded" village extension workers Identifying "research minded" farmers who are already involved in farmer experiments; and Establishing programs for validating farmer experiments Validation of Farmer’s Experiment Understand experiments in the socio-cultural and agro- ecological environments Determine the impact of the experiments on productivity, profitability, and sustainability of the agricultural system Understand the rationale behind farmer experimentation Recording the mode of conducting experiments Identifying farmers' evaluation criteria
  • 30.
    Strategies for AgriculturalResearch Strengthening the capacities of regional research and extension organizations; Building upon local people's knowledge that is acquired through various processes such as farmer-to-farmer communication, and farmer experimentation; Identifying the need for an extension scientist/ social scientist in an interdisciplinary regional research team; Formation of a sustainable technology development consortium to bring farmers, researchers, NGOs, and extension workers together well ahead of the process of technology development; Generating technological options rather than fixed technical packages; Working with the existing organization and management of research and public sector extension; Bringing research-extension-farmer together at all stages is practically difficult considering the existing bureaucracies and spatial as well as academic distances among the personnel belonging to these organizations. Outlining areas that research and extension organizations need to concentrate on during the process of working with farmers. Understanding that it is impractical to depend entirely on research stations for innovations considering the inadequate human resource capacity of the regional research system.
  • 31.
    Training on IndigenousKnowledge Systems Stage-I: Training/workshop for the state level trainers of TTCs, ICAR Institutes and agricultural universities from various regions of the country. Stage-II: The trainers will then provide similar training for district-level extension workers, subject matter specialists of KVKs etc.
  • 32.
    Inter-Disciplinary and Multi-DisciplinaryApproach Identifying the problems Problem prioritization with the active participation of the farmers, local people etc. Formulating research project incorporating the identified ITK as a major component Conducting Participatory On-Station Research (POSR) or On- Farm Farmers Oriented Research (OFFOR) Evaluating the effectiveness of the ITK including additional benefits Testing the research output in farmers’ fields Technology validation Technology refinement (if necessary) Technology demonstration / popularization Formation of sustainable technology development consortium is to bring farmers, researchers, extension workers, KVKs and NGOs representatives
  • 33.
  • 35.
    Blending of indigenousknowledge with modern scientific technologies is the need of the day to support the sustainable development of agriculture and allied sector in our country. Challenges----- Protect property rights and facilitate the process Raw Materials Agri products Industrial products Knowledge products Information products Innovation Networks Technology Industrial Society Agricultural Society Information Society Knowledge Society Societal Transformation
  • 36.
    36 Go to thepeople, Live with them, Learn from them, Love them, Start with what they know, Build with what they have, But with the best leaders. When the work is done, The task accomplished The people will say “We have done this ourselves” -Laotsu-700 B.C. Think Globally, but Act Locally------