16. 11. Control of Outdoor Air in VAV Systems 980-RP: Techniques for Measuring and Controlling Minimum Outdoor Air Intake Rates in VAV Systems September 1997 - January 1999 The Regents of the University of Colorado Principal Investigator, Moncef Krarti TC 1.4 Control Theory and Application “ The objective of this research project is to . . . compare various techniques for measuring and controlling minimum outdoor air intake rates in VAV systems. Based on the results of these analyses, a set of guidelines will be provided to assess . . . each technique.” ASHRAE Research Project
17. 11. Control of Outdoor Air in VAV Systems (Transactions #4369: 2000 Summer Meeting in Mpls.) “ Experimental Analysis of Measurement and Control Techniques of Outside Air Intake Rates in VAV Systems” Abstract: “…control strategies using the direct measurement of the outside airflow from an averaging pitot-tube array or an electronic thermal anemometer provided the best ventilation control.” Discussion: “In cases where there is not sufficient unobstructed OA duct length to ensure uniformity of airflow profiles, … a dedicated minimum OA duct is recommended.” ASHRAE 980-RP
22. 12. Inadequate Filtration: Should I use Antimicrobial Filters? ( ASHRAE Journal , December 2000) “ Efficacy of Antimicrobial Filter Treatments” Three treatments were studied: “…an amine neutralized phosphoric ester, a quaternary ammonium compound, and an iodine compound.” Results: “Little or no difference existed in the numbers of xerophilic fungi eluted from the…treated and untreated filters…” And: “…new filters generally are a hostile environment for microbial growth whether treated with antimicrobial agent or not.” Conclusions: “…two of the three antimicrobials inhibited the growth of the test organisms on new filters at all ERHs tested; the third did not [Table 2].” And: “…all of the filters, except for one, did permit the growth of fungi after dust loading [Table 3].” ASHRAE 909-RP
23. 12. Inadequate Filtration: Should I use Antimicrobial Filters? ( Indoor Environment Connections , November 1999) “ ASHRAE Study Shows Mixed Results for Antimicrobial Filters” Products identified: “Antimicrobial 1 is Sporax …Antimicrobial 2 is Intersept …Antimicrobial 3 is Aegis Microbe Shield …” Per Al Veeck, Chairman of the ASHRAE Project Monitoring Committee: “When you find filters with biological growth, it’s always due to a problem upstream in the system. If that problem were fixed, there would be no need for an antimicrobial filter . ” And: “… in hot, humid climates the use of an antimicrobial filter may prove beneficial as part of a holistic approach to IAQ.” ASHRAE 909-RP
30. IAQ and Ventilating Systems Problems Found with All System Types 1. Previous building codes 2. Energy conservation measures 3. Provision for exhaust/relief overlooked
Review and bring literature on Oxine (SO2?). See article from IE Review. Bring samples of Imcoa, literature on Armaflex, Fosters.
1836 Tredgold: 4 CFM/person to purge CO2 and remove body moisture [jokingly- to keep kerosene lamps lit (forget the canary!)] 1865 Nightingale (misspelled above): during Crimean War, served at Barrack Hospital in Turkey [1854-1856] (England, France and Sardinia come to the aid of Turkey against Russia); similar observations regarding poorly -vs- well-ventilated hospitals during US Civil War 1895 Billings, MD: journal article “Ventilation and Heating”; 60 CFM if primary concern is the spread of disease (specifically, tuberculosis), 30 CFM adequate for comfort; and an ASHVE requirement (founded in 1894) “adopted the view that engineers were ready to accept the ideas of hygienists and physiologists” of 30 CFM/occ as the minimum ventilating rate. 1914 ASHVE: proposed model law called for 30 CFM/occ 1922 Adopted by 22 State bldg codes: 30 CFM/occ 1934 Lehmberg: at Harvard University, under contract from ASHVE; published in ASHVE Transactions 1935; first odor study: acceptable at 20 CFM/occ with lower temps, 30 CFM/occ required for higher temps 1936 Yaglou: Constantin Yaglou continued Lehmberg’s work, also at Harvard, and also sponsored by ASHVE Found that grade school children required more ventilation: 50% more ventilation required if children had gone 6.5 days without a bath and change of underwear; 33% more required for adults one week after a bath ASA 1946: American Standards Association Std A53.1 “Light and Ventilation” required 10 CFM/occ of exhaust for ventilation and removal of heat from lighting fixtures to reduce heating load during the cooling season ASA 1966: assigned responsibility for mechanical ventilation section to ASHRAE; resulting in Std 62 in 1973