Floodproofing Methods that Work
in West Virginia
Joe Trimboli, MSc, CFM
Community Planner
Huntington District
17 March 2011




US Army Corps of Engineers
BUILDING STRONG®
NFRMP
 National Flood Risk Management Program
 Corps Program to integrate and
  synchronize USACE flood risk
  management programs and activities, both
  internally and with counterpart activities of
  the Department of Homeland Security,
  Federal Emergency Management Agency
  (FEMA), other Federal agencies, state
  organizations, and regional and local
  agencies.
                                      BUILDING STRONG®
Silver Jackets
 Continuous collaboration between state
  and Federal agencies to reduce flood risk
  and other natural disasters and to
  enhance response and recovery efforts
 State teams lead by State NFIP
  Coordinator (flexible structure)
 West Virginia Flood Risk Communication
  Taskforce

                                    BUILDING STRONG®
NFPC
 National Nonstructural Flood Proofing
  Committee (NFPC)
 Evolved from Floodplain Management
  Services Program (CORPS FPMS)
 Committee on Residential Flood Proofing
  (1978)
 Coordinates and provides direction to
  flood proofing activities

                                  BUILDING STRONG®
Local Flood Proofing Programs
 NFPC Publication (2005)
 Proven approaches to reducing flood
  damage
 Significant flood loss reduction
  ► Financial
  ► Technical
  ► Environmental




                                  BUILDING STRONG®
Government Programs
 FEMA Mitigation Assistance (FMA)
  Program
  ► Planning Grants
  ► Project Grants
  ► Management Cost Grants
 Corps of Engineer Authorities
  ► Flood Plain Management Services (FPMS)
  ► Planning Assistance to States (PAS)
  ► Special Studies (Congressional Add)
  ► Section 202 (Tug Fork / Levisa Fork)
                                    BUILDING STRONG®
Reduction Measures
 Emergency Measures
  ►   Sandbagging, Flood Warning Systems...

 Structural Measures
  ►   Levees, Dams, Channels...

 Relocation Measures
  ►   Move, Purchase, Demolition...

 Modification Measures
  ►   Building Modifications, Lot Enhancements...




                                                    BUILDING STRONG®
WV Example – Wayne County
   Section 202 (Congressional Add)
   33.5 miles of the main stem Tug Fork
   Protection - April 1977 flood reoccurrence
   66 structures
    ► 39 floodproofed structures
    ► 27 voluntary floodplain acquisitions




                                             BUILDING STRONG®
Extended Foundation




                  BUILDING STRONG®
Ring Wall




            BUILDING STRONG®
Ring Wall




            BUILDING STRONG®
Space Replacement




                BUILDING STRONG®
Extended Foundation




                  BUILDING STRONG®
Extended Foundation




                  BUILDING STRONG®
Extended Foundation




                  BUILDING STRONG®
Extended Foundation




                  BUILDING STRONG®
Relocation




             BUILDING STRONG®
Extended Foundation




                  BUILDING STRONG®
Extended Foundation




                  BUILDING STRONG®
Extended Foundation




                  BUILDING STRONG®
Most Used FRM WV
 Elevation / Wet Floodproofing
 Relocation
  ► Acquisition
  ► Move on property
  ► Space Replacement

 Dry Floodproofing
 Ring walls


                                  BUILDING STRONG®
Restrictions
 No improvements
 Work must meet local code
 Porches (no matter material) are replaced
  with Treated Lumber
 No damageable materials below flood
  protection level
 Space replacement only includes “Living
  Space”
                                   BUILDING STRONG®
Opportunities
 Buy Up to Floodproofing
 Home Improvements allowed
  ► Paid   by Homeowner
 Structurally unsound – cost comparison
  ► Leastexpensive
  ► Acquisition vs Comparable New Construction




                                      BUILDING STRONG®
Program Evaluation




Elevation   Relocation   Levees and   Dry Flood    Wet Flood
                         Floodwalls   Proofing     Proofing




                                                  BUILDING STRONG®
Selection Factors



                   Site
                   Characteristics
Flood                                Building
Characteristics                      Characteristics
                      Location
                        Soil
    Depth                              Foundation
   Velocity                           Construction
    Flash                               Condition
    Debris


                                           BUILDING STRONG®
Formulation Matrix




                     BUILDING STRONG®
Matrix Highlight




                   BUILDING STRONG®
Community Flood Proofing
           Benefits
   Customer service
   Economics
   Comprehensive planning
   External impact
   The Community Rating System
   Post-flood mitigation funding


                                    BUILDING STRONG®
National Plan




                BUILDING STRONG®
Flood Risk Management Cycle
• Future Mitigation     • Flood Fighting Prep
• Develop & Implement   • State & Local Coord
Improvements            • System Assessments &
• Modify Mitigation     Inspection
Plan                    • Forecasting / Scenario
• Interim Risk          Development
Reduction Measures




                        • Report Impacts
• Repair Damage
                        • Systems Performance
• Assess & Document
                        • Support Flood Fighting
• Identify Mitigation
                        • Emergency
Opportunities
                        Stabilization



                             BUILDING STRONG®
Summary




Organization and Team Work
                             BUILDING STRONG®
References
 National Flood Risk Management Program (NFRMP)
      http://www.nfrmp.us/
 Silver Jackets
      http://www.nfrmp.us/state/
 National Nonstructural Flood Proofing Committee (NFPC)
      http://www.nwo.usace.army.mil/nfpc/
 Local Flood Proofing Measures NFPC 2005
      http://www.nwo.usace.army.mil/nfpc/Local_FP_Programs_Fe
       bruary_2005.pdf
 Flood Damage Reduction Matrix NFPC 2007
      http://www.nwo.usace.army.mil/nfpc/NFPC_Measures_Matrix
       .pdf
 Huntington District
      http://www.lrh.usace.army.mil/

                                                     BUILDING STRONG®
QUESTIONS?




SEAMLESS, CURRENT, and AUTOMATED




                               BUILDING STRONG®

Floodproofing Methods That Work In West Virginia

  • 1.
    Floodproofing Methods thatWork in West Virginia Joe Trimboli, MSc, CFM Community Planner Huntington District 17 March 2011 US Army Corps of Engineers BUILDING STRONG®
  • 2.
    NFRMP  National FloodRisk Management Program  Corps Program to integrate and synchronize USACE flood risk management programs and activities, both internally and with counterpart activities of the Department of Homeland Security, Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), other Federal agencies, state organizations, and regional and local agencies. BUILDING STRONG®
  • 3.
    Silver Jackets  Continuouscollaboration between state and Federal agencies to reduce flood risk and other natural disasters and to enhance response and recovery efforts  State teams lead by State NFIP Coordinator (flexible structure)  West Virginia Flood Risk Communication Taskforce BUILDING STRONG®
  • 4.
    NFPC  National NonstructuralFlood Proofing Committee (NFPC)  Evolved from Floodplain Management Services Program (CORPS FPMS)  Committee on Residential Flood Proofing (1978)  Coordinates and provides direction to flood proofing activities BUILDING STRONG®
  • 5.
    Local Flood ProofingPrograms  NFPC Publication (2005)  Proven approaches to reducing flood damage  Significant flood loss reduction ► Financial ► Technical ► Environmental BUILDING STRONG®
  • 6.
    Government Programs  FEMAMitigation Assistance (FMA) Program ► Planning Grants ► Project Grants ► Management Cost Grants  Corps of Engineer Authorities ► Flood Plain Management Services (FPMS) ► Planning Assistance to States (PAS) ► Special Studies (Congressional Add) ► Section 202 (Tug Fork / Levisa Fork) BUILDING STRONG®
  • 7.
    Reduction Measures  EmergencyMeasures ► Sandbagging, Flood Warning Systems...  Structural Measures ► Levees, Dams, Channels...  Relocation Measures ► Move, Purchase, Demolition...  Modification Measures ► Building Modifications, Lot Enhancements... BUILDING STRONG®
  • 8.
    WV Example –Wayne County  Section 202 (Congressional Add)  33.5 miles of the main stem Tug Fork  Protection - April 1977 flood reoccurrence  66 structures ► 39 floodproofed structures ► 27 voluntary floodplain acquisitions BUILDING STRONG®
  • 9.
    Extended Foundation BUILDING STRONG®
  • 10.
    Ring Wall BUILDING STRONG®
  • 11.
    Ring Wall BUILDING STRONG®
  • 12.
    Space Replacement BUILDING STRONG®
  • 13.
    Extended Foundation BUILDING STRONG®
  • 14.
    Extended Foundation BUILDING STRONG®
  • 15.
    Extended Foundation BUILDING STRONG®
  • 16.
    Extended Foundation BUILDING STRONG®
  • 17.
    Relocation BUILDING STRONG®
  • 18.
    Extended Foundation BUILDING STRONG®
  • 19.
    Extended Foundation BUILDING STRONG®
  • 20.
    Extended Foundation BUILDING STRONG®
  • 21.
    Most Used FRMWV  Elevation / Wet Floodproofing  Relocation ► Acquisition ► Move on property ► Space Replacement  Dry Floodproofing  Ring walls BUILDING STRONG®
  • 22.
    Restrictions  No improvements Work must meet local code  Porches (no matter material) are replaced with Treated Lumber  No damageable materials below flood protection level  Space replacement only includes “Living Space” BUILDING STRONG®
  • 23.
    Opportunities  Buy Upto Floodproofing  Home Improvements allowed ► Paid by Homeowner  Structurally unsound – cost comparison ► Leastexpensive ► Acquisition vs Comparable New Construction BUILDING STRONG®
  • 24.
    Program Evaluation Elevation Relocation Levees and Dry Flood Wet Flood Floodwalls Proofing Proofing BUILDING STRONG®
  • 25.
    Selection Factors Site Characteristics Flood Building Characteristics Characteristics Location Soil Depth Foundation Velocity Construction Flash Condition Debris BUILDING STRONG®
  • 26.
    Formulation Matrix BUILDING STRONG®
  • 27.
    Matrix Highlight BUILDING STRONG®
  • 28.
    Community Flood Proofing Benefits  Customer service  Economics  Comprehensive planning  External impact  The Community Rating System  Post-flood mitigation funding BUILDING STRONG®
  • 29.
    National Plan BUILDING STRONG®
  • 30.
    Flood Risk ManagementCycle • Future Mitigation • Flood Fighting Prep • Develop & Implement • State & Local Coord Improvements • System Assessments & • Modify Mitigation Inspection Plan • Forecasting / Scenario • Interim Risk Development Reduction Measures • Report Impacts • Repair Damage • Systems Performance • Assess & Document • Support Flood Fighting • Identify Mitigation • Emergency Opportunities Stabilization BUILDING STRONG®
  • 31.
    Summary Organization and TeamWork BUILDING STRONG®
  • 32.
    References  National FloodRisk Management Program (NFRMP)  http://www.nfrmp.us/  Silver Jackets  http://www.nfrmp.us/state/  National Nonstructural Flood Proofing Committee (NFPC)  http://www.nwo.usace.army.mil/nfpc/  Local Flood Proofing Measures NFPC 2005  http://www.nwo.usace.army.mil/nfpc/Local_FP_Programs_Fe bruary_2005.pdf  Flood Damage Reduction Matrix NFPC 2007  http://www.nwo.usace.army.mil/nfpc/NFPC_Measures_Matrix .pdf  Huntington District  http://www.lrh.usace.army.mil/ BUILDING STRONG®
  • 33.
    QUESTIONS? SEAMLESS, CURRENT, andAUTOMATED BUILDING STRONG®