SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 11
Download to read offline
Financial Inclusion in Africa
AFFORD UK - The African Foundation for Development
Chatham House – July 1st
2016
Jack Van Cooten
1 Policy Brief July 2016 – Financial Inclusion in Africa
Overview
There is direct relationship between rates of poverty and financial exclusion. Globally, approximately two billion
people, or 38% of working-age adults do not have access to regulated banking or financial services. For those
who live in poverty, the proportion who are unbanked almost doubles, with 73% financial excluded, showing the
disproportionate impact that financial inclusion has on the poor (IFAD, 2015).
Despite the impressive growth rates witnessed in many African countries over the past decade, for growth to be
sustainable and for development to be inclusive, it is imperative that all sections of society are financially
included. The data shows that Africa is falling behind other continents when it comes to inclusive financing, with
only 34% of adults having a bank account and 16% of adults having formal savings; the second lowest of any
region in the world, with only the Middle East having lower rates (World Bank, 2014). Of course, there are
disparities within Africa too, with lower rates of financial inclusion among the continents’ women, youth and
poor. Expanding financial services to these groups in particular will enable communities to be resilient against
shocks, allow them to both save and invest in their families, and will help grow a class of entrepreneurs who in
turn will drive development. The continents’ diaspora and their remittances can and will play a role in this process;
they represent a significant economic force that if properly organised can play a key role in the continent’s
development.
This policy brief first outlines how financial inclusion is both defined and measured, before looking at rates of
financial inclusion in Africa. It then looks at who and where in Africa is financially included and indeed, excluded,
and what the opportunities are to broaden financial systems across the continent. The role of the diaspora in
financial inclusion is then explored, with a focus on the tens of billions of dollars per year that are sent to African
countries from abroad. Finally, best practices from Women’s World Banking and Rwanda’s Umurenge SACCO
programme are highlighted, before a number of policy recommendations to key stakeholders are put forward.
What is Financial Inclusion?
Interest in understanding and broadening financial inclusion has grown in recent years, as exemplified by multi-
country commitments such as the G-20 Financial Inclusion Action Plan (G20, 2014), and the number of individual
countries who have established their own policies in the area. Financial Inclusion ‘refers to a state in which all
working age adults, including those currently excluded by the financial system, have effective access to the
following financial services provided by formal institutions: credit, savings (defined broadly to include current
accounts), payments, and insurance’ (GPFI, 2016).
Explanations and metrics of financial inclusion have progressed away from categorising people according to a
binary separation of being either included or excluded, to seeing financial inclusion as multi-dimensional. The
below table summarises how aspects such as access, usage and quality are being considered as part of a more
encompassing and accurate definition of inclusive financing (Table 1).
Table 1 – The dimensions of financial inclusion. Adapted from the Financial Inclusion Data Working Group (2011) in AfDB (2013)
It is important also to understand the distinction between voluntary and involuntary financial exclusion (Young-
Park & Mercado 2015). People who are voluntarily financially excluded are individuals that choose not to use
financial products and services, either because they do not feel they need them or due to cultural factors that
discourage usage. Conversely, involuntarily exclusion relates to people who cannot access financial services, even
though they may want or need to. This could be down to a number of factors, such as discrimination, lack of
income, being perceived as too risky or unprofitable by financial institutions, or due to lack of proximity, for
example those living in rural areas.
Information on financial inclusion has usually been
broken down into supply and demand-side data.
A simple way to understand this distinction is that
supply-side data is measured from the top-down,
by central banks and governments for instance. An
example of the type of information that supply-
side stakeholders produce is the number of ATMs
or bank accounts in a country or region. However,
using this information to convey levels of usage
and access to financial services is inaccurate, as it
does not show how regional, social or economic
disparities have an impact on financial inclusion.
Demand-side financial inclusion however, is
measured from the bottom-up, and attempts to capture the levels of usage based on perspectives from the
poorest households and low-income, often informal businesses (BIS 2012).
Financial Inclusion in Africa
Whilst financial inclusion in Africa is growing rapidly, increasing from 24% of the population in 2011 to 34% in
2014, Sub-Saharan Africa remains the second least financially included region in the world, with only the Middle
East having a lower proportion unbanked. The World Bank’s Findex Database defines being banked as those
who have an account with either a financial institution, such as a bank or credit union, or alternatively with a
mobile money provider, which can be used to transact money to and from a mobile phone account (Global
Findex Database 2014). It is interesting that whereas globally, only 2% of adults have a mobile money account,
in Sub-Saharan Africa this figure climbs to 12% of the population.
In Africa, when it comes to financial inclusion, there are sharp disparities, both between and within countries. We
will come to how disparities manifest within countries below, but in the countries for which data is available
(Figure 1, above), it is those in Southern Africa that tend to have the highest levels of account ownership – South
Access Usage Quality
Availability of formal, regulated
financial services:
 Physical Proximity
 Affordability
Actual Usage of formal financial
services and products:
 Regularity
 Frequency
 Duration of time used
Products that are well tailored to
client needs:
 With appropriate
segmentation to develop
products for all income levels
Figure 1 – Account Penetration across the World
(Global Findex Database 2014)
3 Policy Brief July 2016 – Financial Inclusion in Africa
Africa is the highest with 70% coverage, closely followed by Namibia (59%) and Botswana (52%). East Africa also
shows relatively high rates compared to the rest of the continent, but this is largely down to the region being
the global hub of mobile money. 75% of Kenyans have an account at some form of financial or mobile money
institution, along with 44% of Ugandans, 40% of Tanzanians, and even 39% of those in Somalia. The rise and
subsequent prevalence of mobile money will also be discussed in greater detail below. The picture is more mixed,
but generally lower in West Africa, ranging from regional highs in Nigeria (44%) and Ghana (41%), to a regional
low of 7% in Guinea. The Sahel and Central African countries also have low percentages of their populations
who are financially included, with almost every country under 20% (Global Findex Database 2014).
Who is Financially Excluded in Africa?
But percentages at the national level do not tell the complete story. For example, if 44% of the 186 million people
in Nigeria do have an account at a financial or mobile money institution, it means that over 100 million people
in Nigeria do not. Who are these people, and why is it important that efforts are made to include them financially?
African Women
African women are an extremely diverse cohort, coming from different
cultural settings, income levels, societies, marital statuses etc. (MFW4A
2013). Throughout Africa, women are less likely to hold an account at a
financial institution than men (figure 2). However, it is widely
acknowledged that the positive effects of broadening financial inclusion
among women go far beyond benefiting the individual, but subsequently
benefits their households, the wider community and ultimately, men too.
Financial products should be tailored so that they are appropriate for
women’s needs and allow more flexibility. Focus also needs to be targeted
towards building knowledge on financial services, so that they can be fully
taken advantage of by women (ibid.).
African Youth
Of all of the demographic groups in Africa, African youth are some of the most marginalised. According to a
report by the UN, for African youth, that is those that are aged between 15 and 24, only 12% have a formal bank
account (UN 2013). Much of this is down to negative stereotypes of youth, legal restrictions and non-inclusive
financial policies and therefore, there is much work to be done. As the continent with highest proportion and
fastest growing population of young people, it is imperative that the financial exclusion of African youth is
addressed. In doing so, the youth should be provided with the knowledge, skills and financial products that will
allow them to build a sustainable livelihood (Braga 2009).
African Poor
Financial inclusion has been broadly recognised as critical in reducing poverty and achieving inclusive economic
growth; however, in every country in Africa, it is the poorest that are the most financially excluded. With the
wealthiest 20% of adults twice as likely to have a bank account as the poorest 20%, financial inclusion is strongly
related to wealth. Financial exclusion also perpetuates poverty, as financially excluded individuals and SMEs are
Figure 2: % Sub-Saharan Africans who
are Financial Included (Global Findex
Database 2014)
28%
30%
32%
34%
36%
38%
40%
Men Women
more likely to seek financial services such as loans through riskier, higher-interest sources (AfDB 2013). Ultimately,
for both individuals and their businesses at the poorer end of African societies, being able to access financial
services can contribute to investment in education, management of risks and a boost in economic growth (Bruhn
& Love 2014).
Opportunities to Broaden Financial Inclusion
For all of the groups listed above, and indeed for other marginalised sections of society in Africa, not having the
financial infrastructure means to also not have a place to securely save or invest money, not having the ability
to insure oneself or one’s business, and thus not having as much ability to build resilience against shocks (IFC
2013). However, impressive progress has been made across the continent in recent years. For example, whereas
in 2011, 76% of the continent was unbanked, only three years later that figure dropped to 66% (and as you are
reading this, that figure is lower still). But quick gains should not mask the fact that there is immense scope by
both governments and the private sector to broaden financial inclusion, particularly among these marginalised
groups.
Broadening Financial Inclusion at the Local Level
At the local level, broadening financial inclusion needs to take a tailored approach, depending on the target
group. For example, African women tend to be in a weaker position for accessing finances than African men,
partly due to discriminatory gendered land rights, meaning they lack the collateral when attempting to obtain
funding (OECD 2011). Their higher vulnerability and higher levels of poverty – particularly among rural women -
also means that they are more risk averse than their male counterparts. Additionally, cultural norms placing the
responsibility of raising children in the hands of women and also a lack of financial literacy creates obstacles that
for men are less likely to exist. On the other hand, convenience and the geographic proximity of financial services
have been found to be a greater driver of usage for African women than men (MFW4A 2013). Similarly, African
women generally make smaller transactions than men, and are more reliant on cash. Therefore, gender sensitive
financial products are essential, particularly for women that face multiple-barriers, such as poor or rural women.
One such example is the utilisation of a mobile delivery van in Malawi that brings a range of financial services to
women who would otherwise not have access (Stuart, Ferguson and Cohen 2011).
Measures have been taken to increase the financial inclusion of youth too. Through a joint study of financial
inclusion programmes and accompanying financial management lessons in Togo and Ethiopia (FUCEC in Togo
and ACSI in Ethiopia), participants in both countries doubled their net average incomes (after average expenses),
compared to their respective control groups. This was in part due to their participation in financial education
sessions which taught money management strategies. In addition, participants in both groups tended to save
more and for longer periods of time following the programme’s emphasis on each participant making a financial
plan (UNCDF 2016a). This highlights the importance of financial education accompanying efforts to broaden
access.
Broadening Financial Inclusion at the National Level
Some national governments are taking steps to digitalise the payment of staff wages. By providing their public
sector staff with bank accounts and paying wages into them, rather than in cash, they hope to quicken the pace
of financial inclusivity (World Bank 2015). However, we need to be careful to ensure that we do not assume that
simply providing a person with a bank account automatically means that they are financially included. For
example, a case study in a 2016 UNCDF report describes the situation of a Mozambican school teacher who was
5 Policy Brief July 2016 – Financial Inclusion in Africa
provided with a bank account into which her monthly wages were transferred. However, this was detrimental to
both her overall income and also to her students as she would have to miss one day of teaching per month to
take the long journey to collect her wages, and in doing so, incurring the additional cost of travel (UNCDF 2016b).
This is just one factor among many (such as high bank account fees) in which broadening financial inclusion
through simply providing access to financial services is insufficient. Need and usage are equally important. It is
essential therefore, to provide concrete national regulatory frameworks that are beneficial to account ownership.
This can include measures such as requiring banks to provide low or no-fee accounts, incorporating innovative
technologies such as mobile money, and introducing tiered documentation requirements. Barriers to financial
inclusion are multi-dimensional, and favourable policies implemented at the national level are essential for
removing them.
A Focus on…Mobile Money
The tool that has extended access to financial services at the fastest rates is undoubtedly mobile money, which
in many African countries, is revolutionising how people and businesses send and receive money. Cheap to set
up, branchless, and with deposit/ withdrawal agents located ubiquitously, particularly in East Africa, the
proliferation of mobile money has allowed tens of millions of Africans to make financial transactions relatively
inexpensively. Though more limited in the variety of financial products offered, and arguably less secure than
the formal banking sector, mobile money accounts still provide a platform through which transactions can be
made digitally, from one mobile telephone to another.
Sub-Saharan African mobile money users constitute 52% of all mobile money users worldwide (GSMA 2015). In
2014, 18 of the 19 countries that have more mobile money accounts than bank accounts were located in Africa
(ibid.). Mobile money is also transforming the way that remittances are transferred. Using Burundi as an example
- a country where only 7% of the adult population has a bank account - mobile money organisations are acting
as a ‘game changer’ for those wanting to send money home (The Guardian 2015). Organisations such as
WorldRemit let remitters to quickly send money to a mobile money account, allowing them to avoid having to
use informal channels and meaning that receivers can store their money for later use. With the number of mobile
money accounts continuing to increase across Africa, mobile remittance transactions are sure to play a big role
in the future.
Financial Inclusion and the African Diaspora
The diaspora of Africa play a key part in African development. If combined, the remittances of the diaspora make
up the second largest source of money flowing into Africa from outside the continent (after Foreign Direct
Investment), far eclipsing official development assistance (African Economic Outlook 2015). In macroeconomic
terms, remittances constitute a powerful force. The Consultative Group to Assist the Poor (2014), argue that “a
well-functioning payment and remittance ecosystem” performs a central role in boosting financial inclusion and
reducing or mitigating poverty at the national level. At the household level, what this looks like in practice varies
from providing a safety net to vulnerable families and/or individuals, to lifting families out of poverty and allowing
them to access essential services that they may otherwise be excluded from due to lack of money, such as health
and education.
There is even a positive link between remittance receivers and financial inclusion, with areas that have a higher
percentage of remittance-receiving households having more bank branches, bank accounts and savings
accounts per capita (Demirgüç-Kunt et al. 2011). Remittances and financial inclusion are linked in other ways. For
example, whilst 14% of bank account holders globally use their account to receive remittances, in Africa, that
figure almost triples, to 41% (AfDB 2013). With remittances being named as the world’s largest poverty-reduction
programme (IFAD 2015), and the UN 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development acknowledging their
importance, it is essential that we explore how diaspora and their remittances can be leveraged through financial
inclusion frameworks to meet development objectives (Foote et al. 2015).
However, whilst the remittance market is important, for Africa, the high cost of sending money back home means
that both the African diaspora who send the money and those who receive it can be considered as financially
excluded. With an average cost of 12.5% of the money remitted – among the highest rates in the world – it
means that the poorest continent is effectively paying an additional tax (Foote et al. 2015). A further reason is
related to exclusivity clauses, whereby agreements are signed between banks in order to decrease competition
and ultimately, maintain higher prices (Central Bank of Nigeria, 2008). However, measures are being taken to
tackle these challenges. In 2009, the G20 adopted ‘The General Principles for International Remittance Services’
which aimed to lower costs of remittances to 5%. More recently, during the summit of 2015, Addis Ababa Action
Agenda looked at how the new UN Sustainable Development Goals would be financed and included a target to
reduce the costs of remittances to 3% by 2030 (Foote et al. 2015). Lowering costs would unlock billions of dollars
for individuals, families and businesses in Africa. New technologies and methods - some of which are outlined
in the box left - can go some way in addressing high transaction costs. But for them to be truly effective on a
regional scale, they must be accompanied by international measures and governance that address the lack of
transparency and competition that shroud these flows of money
A Focus on…Digitalisation in Development
Digital technologies and platforms are being widely utilised across the continent to increase financial inclusion,
overcome the high transaction costs of sending money and promote inclusive development. Some of these include:
eTransform Africa
Launched in 2012, eTransform Africa is a collaboration between the African Development Bank, the World Bank and the
African Union. Their publication highlights the role of ICTs in enhancing African regional trade and integration as well
as the need to build a competitive ICT industry to promote innovation, job creation and the export potential of African
companies. Through a focus on six sectors, they hope to shed light upon and drive ICT innovations that deliver home-
grown solutions in Africa, transforming businesses, whilst driving entrepreneurship and economic growth.
MasterCard
The MasterCard Foundation works with financial service providers and users alike to expand access to financial services
for people living in poverty, particularly those in rural and remote areas. Their aim is to deepen the industry’s ability to
serve those people who are too poor or remote to receive financial services by providing insights into client needs and
cost saving delivery channels. At the World Humanitarian Summit, May 2016, MasterCard announced that it plans to
expand its aid distribution services with the launch of MasterCard Humanitarian Aid Solutions. The initiative will provide
an open and flexible network to make complex digital requirements simple for partners to implement.
Better Than Cash
Better Than Cash is a partnership of governments, companies, and international organisations that accelerate the
transition from cash to digital payments in order to reduce poverty and drive inclusive growth. Based on their research,
the Better Than Cash Alliance partners with governments, companies, and international organisations that are the key
drivers behind the transition to make digital payments widely available. They do this by advocating for the transition
from cash to digital payments in a way that advances financial inclusion and catalysing the development of inclusive
digital payments ecosystems in member countries to reduce costs.
7 Policy Brief July 2016 – Financial Inclusion in Africa
What are some of the Best Practices?
Underpinned by an ever-growing foundation of research, experiences and knowledge - governments,
multilateral organisations and policy makers are beginning to prioritise financial inclusion in their national and
international development agendas. There is an emphasis that both inclusive growth and inclusive financing
should be focussed on simultaneously. There is also recognition that in practice, financial inclusion policies and
mechanisms should be focussed on the most marginalised groups, such as women, youth, the poor and the
diaspora. This section highlights a couple of best practices from across the continent that can be used to inform
future policies.
Women’s World Banking
An international NGO focussed on low-income countries, Women’s World Banking (WWB) works closely with a
global network of 40 financial institutions from 29 countries to create new credit, savings, and insurance products
specifically designed for the unique needs of women. Institutions in their network are committed to serving
women as clients, innovators and leaders. Through both research and the design of innovative products, the
organisation looks for new ways to help women build financial safety nets, by showing a broader range of
financial institutions how to move beyond traditional microfinance to provide financial products that include
savings and insurance.
One such research paper looking at how to close the financial inclusion gender gap argued that policy measures
to increase financial inclusion need to be country-specific, and based on each country’s gender gap, unique
challenges and opportunities (Women’s World Banking 2016). When it comes to boosting women’s financial
inclusion globally, there can be no one-size-fits-all approach. An initiative of WWB, which focusses on women-
led small and medium sized enterprises - and more specifically, how to close the gender-gap of these enterprises
in accessing finances - uses Diamond Bank, Nigeria as an example. The challenge was how to offer financial
services that are appropriate for women entrepreneurs working at a market in Lagos, and at a low cost. Named
the ‘BETA savings account’, it was rolled out across 21 Diamond Bank branches, is easy to set up, and has no
minimum balance requirement or fees and was directly tailored towards the needs of the women who work in
the market (Women’s World Banking 2014).
Looking to Rwanda – The Umurenge SACCO Programme
Though Rwanda is one of Africa’s smallest nations, it faces the same problems as many other African countries
when it comes to the challenge of financial inclusion. A World Bank survey conducted in 2008 revealed that only
21% of Rwandans were financially included. The following year, the government decided to take action. The
challenge in Rwanda is acute because the majority of the population live in rural areas, which traditionally have
been underserved by the African financial sector. The answer to this was the Vision 2020 Umurenge programme,
which aims to boost financial inclusion through Umurenge SACCOs, which are savings and credit cooperatives
that are supervised and subsidised by the National Bank of Rwanda. The strategy also identified six main pillars
that had to be in place for this initiative to work: security, low minimum balance, liquidity, government support,
tailored products that meet client needs, public education and capacity building through training (AFI 2014).
Whilst there is certainly room for the scheme to better embrace technology, Umurenge SACCOs are seen as a
good way to bridge the financial inclusion gap, and offer a chance for Rwandans to save money and access
finance. Where access to finance was once scarce, now 90% of Rwandans live within 5km proximity to one of
the 416 Umurenge SACCOs in the country and this has led to a doubling of the proportion of Rwandan adults
who are financially included in just three years. (21% to 42%). A further success is that in 2014, more than 85% of
SACCOs broke even without taking government subsidies into account, and they are increasingly being used as
funding source for state social programmes (ibid.).
Recommendations
If policymakers want to reduce rates of poverty in Africa, it is essential that policies are implemented that remove
barriers to financial inclusion. Inclusive and sustainable growth will only be realised if it is complemented by
financial inclusion, and in practice, this means addressing the challenges of those who are most financially
excluded. This section outlines some policy recommendations directed towards a range of stakeholders involved
in the financial inclusion agenda.
Recommendations to National Governments and Multilateral Organisations:
 National Governments and Multilateral Organisations need to capture the potential of both the individuals
and enterprises that are excluded from the formalised financial sector.
 Those who are most excluded, the women, the youth and the poorest, should be brought into the
conversation so that their needs are met.
 Legal and regulatory frameworks should be revised and adapted so that the barriers that create financial
exclusion and discrimination are lifted, and that there is space for financial products and services that will
promote financial inclusion among marginalised groups.
 There are a number of best practices which can be used as starting points by African Governments and
Multilateral Organisation in their endeavours to increase financial inclusion.
 Successful policies such as those from around the continent and indeed others from further afield should be
drawn upon to create country-specific finance policies that take the needs of the most marginalised into
account.
Recommendations to Banks and Other Financial Institutions:
 For banks and other financial institutions involved in low-income countries, a reconsideration of pricing
models needs to be undertaken. This should acknowledge and be tailored towards the varied and often
quite specific needs of certain groups such as women, youth and low-income consumers.
 New ways of banking should be adopted and harmonised. It is essential that a favourable technological
environment is created around mobile banking, which has spread rapidly and continues to grow in Africa.
There should also be a prioritisation for rural areas, which are much more likely to be unbanked.
 There is a lack of financial knowledge and capacity of financial products and services among many sections
of African society, and much of this is down to a lack of awareness and a lack of trust. Trust must be built by
banks, who need to create and maintain a good reputation; one that protects consumers and caters towards
their needs.
Recommendations to or in regard to the Diaspora:
 Both the African diaspora and organisations that work with the diaspora should raise awareness of issues
around sending and receiving money in Africa, with a particular focus on the high fees and exclusionary
agreements which unfairly penalise people in some of the poorest countries in the world.
 Further research should be conducted into the users and the logistics of current remittance channels, and
should also explore potential innovations that may benefit both senders and receivers. This should contribute
to a growing body of research that places remittances and financial inclusion at the centre of the sustainable
development agenda.
 Further embrace the use of technology as a way to transfer remittances, particularly via mobile technology.
9 Policy Brief July 2016 – Financial Inclusion in Africa
And Finally, a Recommendation for All:
 In order to truly boost financial inclusion in a manner that is sustainable and equitable, stakeholders involved
- whether they are diaspora networks or national governments, banks or policymakers – should continue to
engage in dialogue with one another, but also with the end users, particularly those who are most
marginalised.
References
AfDB –African Development Bank. (2013). Financial Inclusion in Africa. African
Development Bank Publications. 23 May 2016.
AFI - Alliance for Financial Inclusion. (2014). Rwanda's Financial Inclusion Success Story:
Umurenge SACCOS. AFI Case Studies. 1-12.
African Economic Outlook. (2015). African Economic Outlook 2015. AfDB, OECD, UNDP
2015. 1 (1), 1-38.
Beck, T. and Martinez Peria, M. S. (2009). What Explains The Cost Of Remittances ? An
Examination Across 119 Country Corridors. Policy Research Working Papers . 1-31.
BIS - Bank for International Settlements. (2012). IFC Workshop on Financial Inclusion
Indicators. Available: http://www.bis.org/ifc/publ/ifcb38i.pdf. Last accessed 30th May
2016
Braga, Michela (2009). When the Manna Comes from Abroad — Remittances and Youth
Labor Market Behavior in Albania. University of Milan — DEAS.
Bruhn, M., and I. Love. (2014). The Real Impact of Improved Access to Finance: Evidence
from Mexico. Journal of Finance, 69 (3): 1347–76.
Central Bank of Nigeria. (2008). Exclusivity Clauses in the Agreements Signed by
Nigerian Banks with International Money Transfer Operators. Cenbank Circulars.
CGAP - Consultaitive Group to Assist the Poor. (2014). Payments/Remittances. Available:
http://www.cgap.org/topics/paymentsremittances. Last accessed 30th May 2016.
Demirgüç-Kunt, A., López Córdova, E., Martínez Pería, M. and Woodruff, C. (2011).
Remittances and banking sector breadth and depth: Evidence from Mexico. Journal of
Development Economics, 95(2), 229–241.
Financial Inclusion Data Working Group. (2011). Measuring Financial Inclusion Core Set of
Financial Inclusion Indicators. Available: http://www.afi-
global.org/sites/default/files/afi%20fidwg%20report.pdf. Last accessed 23 May 2016.
Foote, M. P. and F. Ngom, M. Passas, A. Kasongo, F. Knoote, M. Lombe, D. F. Terry.
(2015). African Diaspora and Remittances. CFLP Policy Report. 1 (11), 1-16.
G20. (2014). 2014 Financial Inclusion Action Plan . Available:
http://www.g20australia.org/sites/default/files/g20_resources/library/2014_g20_financial_
inclusion_action_plan.pdf. Last accessed 23 May 2016.
Global Findex Database. (2014). The Global Findex Database 2014: Measuring Financial
Inclusion around the World. Policy Research Working Paper. 7255 (1), 23 May 2016.
GPFI. (2016). Global Standard-Setting Bodies and Financial Inclusion: The Evolving
Landscape. Available: http://www.gpfi.org/publications/global-standard-setting-bodies-
and-financial-inclusion-evolving-landscape. Last accessed 23 May 2016.
GSMA. (2015). 2015 State of the Industry Report on Mobile Money. Policy Paper. 1 (1), 1-
73.
FAD. (2015). The use of remittances and financial inclusion. Report by the International
Fund for Agricultural Development and the World Bank Group to the G20 Global
Partnership for Financial Inclusion. 1-62.
IFC - International Finance Corporation. (2013). Access to Finance - Sub-Saharan
Africa. Policy Paper. 1-12.
MFW4A - Making Finance Work for Africa. (2013). Advancing African Women's Financial
Inclusion. Policy Brief. 1-40.
OECD. MENA-OECD Investment Programme. (2011). Women’s Access to Finance in the
Middle East and the North Africa (MENA) Region: Draft Issues Paper. Paris: OECD.
Park, C & Mercado, R. V. (2015). Financial Inclusion, Poverty, and Income Inequality in
Developing Asia. ADB Economics Working Paper Series. 426 (1), 1-25.
Stuart, G., Ferguson, M. & Cohen, M. (2011). Microfinance & Gender: Some Findings
From The Financial Diaries In Malawi. May 2011. Washington, DC: Microfinance
Opportunities.
The Guardian. (2015). Sending cash home: mobile money is a gamechanger. Available:
http://www.theguardian.com/global-development-professionals-
network/2015/sep/29/mobile-money-gamechanger-for-diaspora-sending-remittances.
Last accessed 30th May 2016.
UN. (2013). Financial Inclusion of Youth. Fact Sheet. 1-5.
UNCDF. (2016a). New Research Study Outlines Benefits of Savings Accounts for Young
People in Africa. Available: http://www.uncdf.org/en/new-research-study-outlines-
benefits-savings-accounts-young-people-africa. Last accessed 30th May 2016.
UNCDF. (2016b). Lost in the mail: Why bank account access is not translating into usage.
MAP Global Insights Series. 4 (1), 1-20.
Women's World Banking. (2014). Diamond Bank Storms the Market: A BETA Way to
Save. Policy Paper. 1-20.
Women's World Banking and The Alliance for Financial Inclusion. (2016). Policy
Frameworks to Support Women’s Financial Inclusion.Policy Paper. 1-24.
World Bank. (2014). Financial Inclusion Data / Global Findex - Sub-Saharan
Africa. Available: http://datatopics.worldbank.org/financialinclusion/region/sub-saharan-
africa. Last accessed 23 May 2016.
World Bank 2015. (2015). The Global Findex Database 2014 Measuring Financial Inclusion
around the World. Policy Research Working Paper. 7255 (1), 1-97.
Young-Park, C. and Mercado, R. V. (2015). Financial Inclusion, Poverty, and Income
Inequality in Developing Asia. Asian Development Bank Economics Working Paper
Series. 426 (1), 1-25.

More Related Content

What's hot

20170203 DW Debate:Apresentação do Relatório do Indice de Sustentabilidade da...
20170203 DW Debate:Apresentação do Relatório do Indice de Sustentabilidade da...20170203 DW Debate:Apresentação do Relatório do Indice de Sustentabilidade da...
20170203 DW Debate:Apresentação do Relatório do Indice de Sustentabilidade da...Development Workshop Angola
 
Banking on Change - Breaking the Barriers to Financial Inclusion
Banking on Change - Breaking the Barriers to Financial InclusionBanking on Change - Breaking the Barriers to Financial Inclusion
Banking on Change - Breaking the Barriers to Financial InclusionDr Lendy Spires
 
Configuring the world peer assignment
Configuring the world   peer assignmentConfiguring the world   peer assignment
Configuring the world peer assignmentFábio Castro
 
Taxation for Domestic Resource Mobilization (DRM in Kenya
Taxation for Domestic Resource Mobilization (DRM in KenyaTaxation for Domestic Resource Mobilization (DRM in Kenya
Taxation for Domestic Resource Mobilization (DRM in KenyaSally A.
 
Reframing and representing african affairs (1)
Reframing and representing african affairs (1)Reframing and representing african affairs (1)
Reframing and representing african affairs (1)Thapelo
 
PEOPLE AND CORRUPTION: ASIA PACIFIC – GLOBAL CORRUPTION BAROMETER
PEOPLE AND CORRUPTION: ASIA PACIFIC – GLOBAL CORRUPTION BAROMETERPEOPLE AND CORRUPTION: ASIA PACIFIC – GLOBAL CORRUPTION BAROMETER
PEOPLE AND CORRUPTION: ASIA PACIFIC – GLOBAL CORRUPTION BAROMETERMYO AUNG Myanmar
 
People and Corruption Asia Pacific – Global Corruption Barometer
People and Corruption Asia Pacific – Global Corruption BarometerPeople and Corruption Asia Pacific – Global Corruption Barometer
People and Corruption Asia Pacific – Global Corruption BarometerMYO AUNG Myanmar
 
Sustainable Development
Sustainable DevelopmentSustainable Development
Sustainable Developmentandreafrei
 
Measuring Financial Inclusion
Measuring Financial InclusionMeasuring Financial Inclusion
Measuring Financial InclusionDr Lendy Spires
 
Youth Active Citizenship Context Analysis 2013
Youth Active Citizenship Context Analysis 2013Youth Active Citizenship Context Analysis 2013
Youth Active Citizenship Context Analysis 2013Geoff Hazell
 
Civic Space Legal framework in the Horn of Africa
Civic Space   Legal framework in the Horn of AfricaCivic Space   Legal framework in the Horn of Africa
Civic Space Legal framework in the Horn of AfricaDésiré Assogbavi
 
Corruption and Good Governance in Nigeria
Corruption and Good Governance in NigeriaCorruption and Good Governance in Nigeria
Corruption and Good Governance in Nigeriatchykita
 

What's hot (17)

20170203 DW Debate:Apresentação do Relatório do Indice de Sustentabilidade da...
20170203 DW Debate:Apresentação do Relatório do Indice de Sustentabilidade da...20170203 DW Debate:Apresentação do Relatório do Indice de Sustentabilidade da...
20170203 DW Debate:Apresentação do Relatório do Indice de Sustentabilidade da...
 
Banking on Change - Breaking the Barriers to Financial Inclusion
Banking on Change - Breaking the Barriers to Financial InclusionBanking on Change - Breaking the Barriers to Financial Inclusion
Banking on Change - Breaking the Barriers to Financial Inclusion
 
Configuring the world peer assignment
Configuring the world   peer assignmentConfiguring the world   peer assignment
Configuring the world peer assignment
 
Taxation for Domestic Resource Mobilization (DRM in Kenya
Taxation for Domestic Resource Mobilization (DRM in KenyaTaxation for Domestic Resource Mobilization (DRM in Kenya
Taxation for Domestic Resource Mobilization (DRM in Kenya
 
1 Pradhan Strengthening March32007
1 Pradhan Strengthening March320071 Pradhan Strengthening March32007
1 Pradhan Strengthening March32007
 
Reframing and representing african affairs (1)
Reframing and representing african affairs (1)Reframing and representing african affairs (1)
Reframing and representing african affairs (1)
 
Geography
GeographyGeography
Geography
 
PEOPLE AND CORRUPTION: ASIA PACIFIC – GLOBAL CORRUPTION BAROMETER
PEOPLE AND CORRUPTION: ASIA PACIFIC – GLOBAL CORRUPTION BAROMETERPEOPLE AND CORRUPTION: ASIA PACIFIC – GLOBAL CORRUPTION BAROMETER
PEOPLE AND CORRUPTION: ASIA PACIFIC – GLOBAL CORRUPTION BAROMETER
 
People and Corruption Asia Pacific – Global Corruption Barometer
People and Corruption Asia Pacific – Global Corruption BarometerPeople and Corruption Asia Pacific – Global Corruption Barometer
People and Corruption Asia Pacific – Global Corruption Barometer
 
Sustainable Development
Sustainable DevelopmentSustainable Development
Sustainable Development
 
carreport
carreportcarreport
carreport
 
Reaching out to the unreached
Reaching out to the unreachedReaching out to the unreached
Reaching out to the unreached
 
Measuring Financial Inclusion
Measuring Financial InclusionMeasuring Financial Inclusion
Measuring Financial Inclusion
 
Youth Active Citizenship Context Analysis 2013
Youth Active Citizenship Context Analysis 2013Youth Active Citizenship Context Analysis 2013
Youth Active Citizenship Context Analysis 2013
 
Mssrf presentation
Mssrf presentation Mssrf presentation
Mssrf presentation
 
Civic Space Legal framework in the Horn of Africa
Civic Space   Legal framework in the Horn of AfricaCivic Space   Legal framework in the Horn of Africa
Civic Space Legal framework in the Horn of Africa
 
Corruption and Good Governance in Nigeria
Corruption and Good Governance in NigeriaCorruption and Good Governance in Nigeria
Corruption and Good Governance in Nigeria
 

Viewers also liked

seeing around corners | technology trends in africa | 2016
seeing around corners | technology trends in africa | 2016seeing around corners | technology trends in africa | 2016
seeing around corners | technology trends in africa | 2016justin spratt
 
Africa FinTech Investment Trends
Africa FinTech Investment TrendsAfrica FinTech Investment Trends
Africa FinTech Investment TrendsDevie Mohan
 
Impact of mobile money in west africa
Impact of mobile money in west africaImpact of mobile money in west africa
Impact of mobile money in west africaYasmine Missinhoun
 
How Digital Has Changed These 7 Banking Roles
How Digital Has Changed These 7 Banking RolesHow Digital Has Changed These 7 Banking Roles
How Digital Has Changed These 7 Banking RolesMX
 
The next 10 years in Fintech
The next 10 years in Fintech The next 10 years in Fintech
The next 10 years in Fintech Kantox
 
FinTech Industry Report 2016
FinTech Industry Report 2016FinTech Industry Report 2016
FinTech Industry Report 2016Bernard Moon
 
Bank: Trends, Tech and Future
Bank: Trends, Tech and FutureBank: Trends, Tech and Future
Bank: Trends, Tech and FutureIvano Digital
 
Disruption in Digital Banking
Disruption in Digital BankingDisruption in Digital Banking
Disruption in Digital BankingBackbase
 
2016 Banking Trends
2016 Banking Trends2016 Banking Trends
2016 Banking TrendsMX
 
Fintech and Transformation of the Financial Services Industry
Fintech and Transformation of the Financial Services IndustryFintech and Transformation of the Financial Services Industry
Fintech and Transformation of the Financial Services IndustryRobin Teigland
 

Viewers also liked (10)

seeing around corners | technology trends in africa | 2016
seeing around corners | technology trends in africa | 2016seeing around corners | technology trends in africa | 2016
seeing around corners | technology trends in africa | 2016
 
Africa FinTech Investment Trends
Africa FinTech Investment TrendsAfrica FinTech Investment Trends
Africa FinTech Investment Trends
 
Impact of mobile money in west africa
Impact of mobile money in west africaImpact of mobile money in west africa
Impact of mobile money in west africa
 
How Digital Has Changed These 7 Banking Roles
How Digital Has Changed These 7 Banking RolesHow Digital Has Changed These 7 Banking Roles
How Digital Has Changed These 7 Banking Roles
 
The next 10 years in Fintech
The next 10 years in Fintech The next 10 years in Fintech
The next 10 years in Fintech
 
FinTech Industry Report 2016
FinTech Industry Report 2016FinTech Industry Report 2016
FinTech Industry Report 2016
 
Bank: Trends, Tech and Future
Bank: Trends, Tech and FutureBank: Trends, Tech and Future
Bank: Trends, Tech and Future
 
Disruption in Digital Banking
Disruption in Digital BankingDisruption in Digital Banking
Disruption in Digital Banking
 
2016 Banking Trends
2016 Banking Trends2016 Banking Trends
2016 Banking Trends
 
Fintech and Transformation of the Financial Services Industry
Fintech and Transformation of the Financial Services IndustryFintech and Transformation of the Financial Services Industry
Fintech and Transformation of the Financial Services Industry
 

Similar to Financial Inclusion Briefing paper 07072016

Megacommunities and The African Diaspora
Megacommunities and The African DiasporaMegacommunities and The African Diaspora
Megacommunities and The African DiasporaMo Richards MSIPM
 
Promoting Financial Inclusion for Inclusive Growth in Africa
Promoting Financial Inclusion for Inclusive Growth in AfricaPromoting Financial Inclusion for Inclusive Growth in Africa
Promoting Financial Inclusion for Inclusive Growth in AfricaDr Lendy Spires
 
Youth Financial Inclusion
Youth Financial InclusionYouth Financial Inclusion
Youth Financial InclusionDr Lendy Spires
 
Youth financial-inclusion
Youth financial-inclusionYouth financial-inclusion
Youth financial-inclusionDr Lendy Spires
 
Youth financial-inclusion
Youth financial-inclusionYouth financial-inclusion
Youth financial-inclusionDr Lendy Spires
 
Unsgsa annual report september 2014 financial inclusion a path to empowerment...
Unsgsa annual report september 2014 financial inclusion a path to empowerment...Unsgsa annual report september 2014 financial inclusion a path to empowerment...
Unsgsa annual report september 2014 financial inclusion a path to empowerment...Dr Lendy Spires
 
Working paper 181 determining the correlates of poverty for inclusive growt...
Working paper 181   determining the correlates of poverty for inclusive growt...Working paper 181   determining the correlates of poverty for inclusive growt...
Working paper 181 determining the correlates of poverty for inclusive growt...Dr Lendy Spires
 
Determining the correlates of poverty for inclusive growth in africa
Determining the correlates of poverty for inclusive growth in africaDetermining the correlates of poverty for inclusive growth in africa
Determining the correlates of poverty for inclusive growth in africaDr Lendy Spires
 
Working paper 181 determining the correlates of poverty for inclusive growt...
Working paper 181   determining the correlates of poverty for inclusive growt...Working paper 181   determining the correlates of poverty for inclusive growt...
Working paper 181 determining the correlates of poverty for inclusive growt...Dr Lendy Spires
 
Measuring Financial Inclusion the Global Findex
Measuring Financial Inclusion the Global FindexMeasuring Financial Inclusion the Global Findex
Measuring Financial Inclusion the Global FindexDr Lendy Spires
 
I Houghton Post2015 Paper V200812
I Houghton Post2015 Paper V200812I Houghton Post2015 Paper V200812
I Houghton Post2015 Paper V200812irunguh
 
Governor's speech rev 10122013
Governor's speech rev 10122013Governor's speech rev 10122013
Governor's speech rev 10122013Dr Lendy Spires
 
OFFICIAL LAUNCH OF THE NATIONAL FINANCIAL INCLUSION FRAMEWORK
 OFFICIAL LAUNCH OF THE NATIONAL FINANCIAL INCLUSION FRAMEWORK OFFICIAL LAUNCH OF THE NATIONAL FINANCIAL INCLUSION FRAMEWORK
OFFICIAL LAUNCH OF THE NATIONAL FINANCIAL INCLUSION FRAMEWORKDr Lendy Spires
 
Investing in Africa successfully & sustainably
Investing in Africa successfully & sustainablyInvesting in Africa successfully & sustainably
Investing in Africa successfully & sustainablyJames Mwangi
 
Contribution of mobile money in financial system inclussion to rural and poor...
Contribution of mobile money in financial system inclussion to rural and poor...Contribution of mobile money in financial system inclussion to rural and poor...
Contribution of mobile money in financial system inclussion to rural and poor...Abdalla Amour
 
Women and-financial-inclusion-results fromfindex-wb-gatesfndn
Women and-financial-inclusion-results fromfindex-wb-gatesfndnWomen and-financial-inclusion-results fromfindex-wb-gatesfndn
Women and-financial-inclusion-results fromfindex-wb-gatesfndnDr Lendy Spires
 

Similar to Financial Inclusion Briefing paper 07072016 (20)

Megacommunities and The African Diaspora
Megacommunities and The African DiasporaMegacommunities and The African Diaspora
Megacommunities and The African Diaspora
 
Banking on-change
Banking on-changeBanking on-change
Banking on-change
 
Promoting Financial Inclusion for Inclusive Growth in Africa
Promoting Financial Inclusion for Inclusive Growth in AfricaPromoting Financial Inclusion for Inclusive Growth in Africa
Promoting Financial Inclusion for Inclusive Growth in Africa
 
Youth Financial Inclusion
Youth Financial InclusionYouth Financial Inclusion
Youth Financial Inclusion
 
Youth financial-inclusion
Youth financial-inclusionYouth financial-inclusion
Youth financial-inclusion
 
Youth financial-inclusion
Youth financial-inclusionYouth financial-inclusion
Youth financial-inclusion
 
Unsgsa annual report september 2014 financial inclusion a path to empowerment...
Unsgsa annual report september 2014 financial inclusion a path to empowerment...Unsgsa annual report september 2014 financial inclusion a path to empowerment...
Unsgsa annual report september 2014 financial inclusion a path to empowerment...
 
Working paper 181 determining the correlates of poverty for inclusive growt...
Working paper 181   determining the correlates of poverty for inclusive growt...Working paper 181   determining the correlates of poverty for inclusive growt...
Working paper 181 determining the correlates of poverty for inclusive growt...
 
Determining the correlates of poverty for inclusive growth in africa
Determining the correlates of poverty for inclusive growth in africaDetermining the correlates of poverty for inclusive growth in africa
Determining the correlates of poverty for inclusive growth in africa
 
Working paper 181 determining the correlates of poverty for inclusive growt...
Working paper 181   determining the correlates of poverty for inclusive growt...Working paper 181   determining the correlates of poverty for inclusive growt...
Working paper 181 determining the correlates of poverty for inclusive growt...
 
2013a klapper
2013a klapper2013a klapper
2013a klapper
 
Measuring Financial Inclusion the Global Findex
Measuring Financial Inclusion the Global FindexMeasuring Financial Inclusion the Global Findex
Measuring Financial Inclusion the Global Findex
 
I Houghton Post2015 Paper V200812
I Houghton Post2015 Paper V200812I Houghton Post2015 Paper V200812
I Houghton Post2015 Paper V200812
 
Governor's speech rev 10122013
Governor's speech rev 10122013Governor's speech rev 10122013
Governor's speech rev 10122013
 
OFFICIAL LAUNCH OF THE NATIONAL FINANCIAL INCLUSION FRAMEWORK
 OFFICIAL LAUNCH OF THE NATIONAL FINANCIAL INCLUSION FRAMEWORK OFFICIAL LAUNCH OF THE NATIONAL FINANCIAL INCLUSION FRAMEWORK
OFFICIAL LAUNCH OF THE NATIONAL FINANCIAL INCLUSION FRAMEWORK
 
Investing in Africa successfully & sustainably
Investing in Africa successfully & sustainablyInvesting in Africa successfully & sustainably
Investing in Africa successfully & sustainably
 
Contribution of mobile money in financial system inclussion to rural and poor...
Contribution of mobile money in financial system inclussion to rural and poor...Contribution of mobile money in financial system inclussion to rural and poor...
Contribution of mobile money in financial system inclussion to rural and poor...
 
Women and-financial-inclusion-results fromfindex-wb-gatesfndn
Women and-financial-inclusion-results fromfindex-wb-gatesfndnWomen and-financial-inclusion-results fromfindex-wb-gatesfndn
Women and-financial-inclusion-results fromfindex-wb-gatesfndn
 
Hajara Adeola
Hajara AdeolaHajara Adeola
Hajara Adeola
 
Inequality 31
Inequality 31Inequality 31
Inequality 31
 

Financial Inclusion Briefing paper 07072016

  • 1. Financial Inclusion in Africa AFFORD UK - The African Foundation for Development Chatham House – July 1st 2016 Jack Van Cooten
  • 2. 1 Policy Brief July 2016 – Financial Inclusion in Africa Overview There is direct relationship between rates of poverty and financial exclusion. Globally, approximately two billion people, or 38% of working-age adults do not have access to regulated banking or financial services. For those who live in poverty, the proportion who are unbanked almost doubles, with 73% financial excluded, showing the disproportionate impact that financial inclusion has on the poor (IFAD, 2015). Despite the impressive growth rates witnessed in many African countries over the past decade, for growth to be sustainable and for development to be inclusive, it is imperative that all sections of society are financially included. The data shows that Africa is falling behind other continents when it comes to inclusive financing, with only 34% of adults having a bank account and 16% of adults having formal savings; the second lowest of any region in the world, with only the Middle East having lower rates (World Bank, 2014). Of course, there are disparities within Africa too, with lower rates of financial inclusion among the continents’ women, youth and poor. Expanding financial services to these groups in particular will enable communities to be resilient against shocks, allow them to both save and invest in their families, and will help grow a class of entrepreneurs who in turn will drive development. The continents’ diaspora and their remittances can and will play a role in this process; they represent a significant economic force that if properly organised can play a key role in the continent’s development. This policy brief first outlines how financial inclusion is both defined and measured, before looking at rates of financial inclusion in Africa. It then looks at who and where in Africa is financially included and indeed, excluded, and what the opportunities are to broaden financial systems across the continent. The role of the diaspora in financial inclusion is then explored, with a focus on the tens of billions of dollars per year that are sent to African countries from abroad. Finally, best practices from Women’s World Banking and Rwanda’s Umurenge SACCO programme are highlighted, before a number of policy recommendations to key stakeholders are put forward. What is Financial Inclusion? Interest in understanding and broadening financial inclusion has grown in recent years, as exemplified by multi- country commitments such as the G-20 Financial Inclusion Action Plan (G20, 2014), and the number of individual countries who have established their own policies in the area. Financial Inclusion ‘refers to a state in which all working age adults, including those currently excluded by the financial system, have effective access to the following financial services provided by formal institutions: credit, savings (defined broadly to include current accounts), payments, and insurance’ (GPFI, 2016). Explanations and metrics of financial inclusion have progressed away from categorising people according to a binary separation of being either included or excluded, to seeing financial inclusion as multi-dimensional. The below table summarises how aspects such as access, usage and quality are being considered as part of a more encompassing and accurate definition of inclusive financing (Table 1).
  • 3. Table 1 – The dimensions of financial inclusion. Adapted from the Financial Inclusion Data Working Group (2011) in AfDB (2013) It is important also to understand the distinction between voluntary and involuntary financial exclusion (Young- Park & Mercado 2015). People who are voluntarily financially excluded are individuals that choose not to use financial products and services, either because they do not feel they need them or due to cultural factors that discourage usage. Conversely, involuntarily exclusion relates to people who cannot access financial services, even though they may want or need to. This could be down to a number of factors, such as discrimination, lack of income, being perceived as too risky or unprofitable by financial institutions, or due to lack of proximity, for example those living in rural areas. Information on financial inclusion has usually been broken down into supply and demand-side data. A simple way to understand this distinction is that supply-side data is measured from the top-down, by central banks and governments for instance. An example of the type of information that supply- side stakeholders produce is the number of ATMs or bank accounts in a country or region. However, using this information to convey levels of usage and access to financial services is inaccurate, as it does not show how regional, social or economic disparities have an impact on financial inclusion. Demand-side financial inclusion however, is measured from the bottom-up, and attempts to capture the levels of usage based on perspectives from the poorest households and low-income, often informal businesses (BIS 2012). Financial Inclusion in Africa Whilst financial inclusion in Africa is growing rapidly, increasing from 24% of the population in 2011 to 34% in 2014, Sub-Saharan Africa remains the second least financially included region in the world, with only the Middle East having a lower proportion unbanked. The World Bank’s Findex Database defines being banked as those who have an account with either a financial institution, such as a bank or credit union, or alternatively with a mobile money provider, which can be used to transact money to and from a mobile phone account (Global Findex Database 2014). It is interesting that whereas globally, only 2% of adults have a mobile money account, in Sub-Saharan Africa this figure climbs to 12% of the population. In Africa, when it comes to financial inclusion, there are sharp disparities, both between and within countries. We will come to how disparities manifest within countries below, but in the countries for which data is available (Figure 1, above), it is those in Southern Africa that tend to have the highest levels of account ownership – South Access Usage Quality Availability of formal, regulated financial services:  Physical Proximity  Affordability Actual Usage of formal financial services and products:  Regularity  Frequency  Duration of time used Products that are well tailored to client needs:  With appropriate segmentation to develop products for all income levels Figure 1 – Account Penetration across the World (Global Findex Database 2014)
  • 4. 3 Policy Brief July 2016 – Financial Inclusion in Africa Africa is the highest with 70% coverage, closely followed by Namibia (59%) and Botswana (52%). East Africa also shows relatively high rates compared to the rest of the continent, but this is largely down to the region being the global hub of mobile money. 75% of Kenyans have an account at some form of financial or mobile money institution, along with 44% of Ugandans, 40% of Tanzanians, and even 39% of those in Somalia. The rise and subsequent prevalence of mobile money will also be discussed in greater detail below. The picture is more mixed, but generally lower in West Africa, ranging from regional highs in Nigeria (44%) and Ghana (41%), to a regional low of 7% in Guinea. The Sahel and Central African countries also have low percentages of their populations who are financially included, with almost every country under 20% (Global Findex Database 2014). Who is Financially Excluded in Africa? But percentages at the national level do not tell the complete story. For example, if 44% of the 186 million people in Nigeria do have an account at a financial or mobile money institution, it means that over 100 million people in Nigeria do not. Who are these people, and why is it important that efforts are made to include them financially? African Women African women are an extremely diverse cohort, coming from different cultural settings, income levels, societies, marital statuses etc. (MFW4A 2013). Throughout Africa, women are less likely to hold an account at a financial institution than men (figure 2). However, it is widely acknowledged that the positive effects of broadening financial inclusion among women go far beyond benefiting the individual, but subsequently benefits their households, the wider community and ultimately, men too. Financial products should be tailored so that they are appropriate for women’s needs and allow more flexibility. Focus also needs to be targeted towards building knowledge on financial services, so that they can be fully taken advantage of by women (ibid.). African Youth Of all of the demographic groups in Africa, African youth are some of the most marginalised. According to a report by the UN, for African youth, that is those that are aged between 15 and 24, only 12% have a formal bank account (UN 2013). Much of this is down to negative stereotypes of youth, legal restrictions and non-inclusive financial policies and therefore, there is much work to be done. As the continent with highest proportion and fastest growing population of young people, it is imperative that the financial exclusion of African youth is addressed. In doing so, the youth should be provided with the knowledge, skills and financial products that will allow them to build a sustainable livelihood (Braga 2009). African Poor Financial inclusion has been broadly recognised as critical in reducing poverty and achieving inclusive economic growth; however, in every country in Africa, it is the poorest that are the most financially excluded. With the wealthiest 20% of adults twice as likely to have a bank account as the poorest 20%, financial inclusion is strongly related to wealth. Financial exclusion also perpetuates poverty, as financially excluded individuals and SMEs are Figure 2: % Sub-Saharan Africans who are Financial Included (Global Findex Database 2014) 28% 30% 32% 34% 36% 38% 40% Men Women
  • 5. more likely to seek financial services such as loans through riskier, higher-interest sources (AfDB 2013). Ultimately, for both individuals and their businesses at the poorer end of African societies, being able to access financial services can contribute to investment in education, management of risks and a boost in economic growth (Bruhn & Love 2014). Opportunities to Broaden Financial Inclusion For all of the groups listed above, and indeed for other marginalised sections of society in Africa, not having the financial infrastructure means to also not have a place to securely save or invest money, not having the ability to insure oneself or one’s business, and thus not having as much ability to build resilience against shocks (IFC 2013). However, impressive progress has been made across the continent in recent years. For example, whereas in 2011, 76% of the continent was unbanked, only three years later that figure dropped to 66% (and as you are reading this, that figure is lower still). But quick gains should not mask the fact that there is immense scope by both governments and the private sector to broaden financial inclusion, particularly among these marginalised groups. Broadening Financial Inclusion at the Local Level At the local level, broadening financial inclusion needs to take a tailored approach, depending on the target group. For example, African women tend to be in a weaker position for accessing finances than African men, partly due to discriminatory gendered land rights, meaning they lack the collateral when attempting to obtain funding (OECD 2011). Their higher vulnerability and higher levels of poverty – particularly among rural women - also means that they are more risk averse than their male counterparts. Additionally, cultural norms placing the responsibility of raising children in the hands of women and also a lack of financial literacy creates obstacles that for men are less likely to exist. On the other hand, convenience and the geographic proximity of financial services have been found to be a greater driver of usage for African women than men (MFW4A 2013). Similarly, African women generally make smaller transactions than men, and are more reliant on cash. Therefore, gender sensitive financial products are essential, particularly for women that face multiple-barriers, such as poor or rural women. One such example is the utilisation of a mobile delivery van in Malawi that brings a range of financial services to women who would otherwise not have access (Stuart, Ferguson and Cohen 2011). Measures have been taken to increase the financial inclusion of youth too. Through a joint study of financial inclusion programmes and accompanying financial management lessons in Togo and Ethiopia (FUCEC in Togo and ACSI in Ethiopia), participants in both countries doubled their net average incomes (after average expenses), compared to their respective control groups. This was in part due to their participation in financial education sessions which taught money management strategies. In addition, participants in both groups tended to save more and for longer periods of time following the programme’s emphasis on each participant making a financial plan (UNCDF 2016a). This highlights the importance of financial education accompanying efforts to broaden access. Broadening Financial Inclusion at the National Level Some national governments are taking steps to digitalise the payment of staff wages. By providing their public sector staff with bank accounts and paying wages into them, rather than in cash, they hope to quicken the pace of financial inclusivity (World Bank 2015). However, we need to be careful to ensure that we do not assume that simply providing a person with a bank account automatically means that they are financially included. For example, a case study in a 2016 UNCDF report describes the situation of a Mozambican school teacher who was
  • 6. 5 Policy Brief July 2016 – Financial Inclusion in Africa provided with a bank account into which her monthly wages were transferred. However, this was detrimental to both her overall income and also to her students as she would have to miss one day of teaching per month to take the long journey to collect her wages, and in doing so, incurring the additional cost of travel (UNCDF 2016b). This is just one factor among many (such as high bank account fees) in which broadening financial inclusion through simply providing access to financial services is insufficient. Need and usage are equally important. It is essential therefore, to provide concrete national regulatory frameworks that are beneficial to account ownership. This can include measures such as requiring banks to provide low or no-fee accounts, incorporating innovative technologies such as mobile money, and introducing tiered documentation requirements. Barriers to financial inclusion are multi-dimensional, and favourable policies implemented at the national level are essential for removing them. A Focus on…Mobile Money The tool that has extended access to financial services at the fastest rates is undoubtedly mobile money, which in many African countries, is revolutionising how people and businesses send and receive money. Cheap to set up, branchless, and with deposit/ withdrawal agents located ubiquitously, particularly in East Africa, the proliferation of mobile money has allowed tens of millions of Africans to make financial transactions relatively inexpensively. Though more limited in the variety of financial products offered, and arguably less secure than the formal banking sector, mobile money accounts still provide a platform through which transactions can be made digitally, from one mobile telephone to another. Sub-Saharan African mobile money users constitute 52% of all mobile money users worldwide (GSMA 2015). In 2014, 18 of the 19 countries that have more mobile money accounts than bank accounts were located in Africa (ibid.). Mobile money is also transforming the way that remittances are transferred. Using Burundi as an example - a country where only 7% of the adult population has a bank account - mobile money organisations are acting as a ‘game changer’ for those wanting to send money home (The Guardian 2015). Organisations such as WorldRemit let remitters to quickly send money to a mobile money account, allowing them to avoid having to use informal channels and meaning that receivers can store their money for later use. With the number of mobile money accounts continuing to increase across Africa, mobile remittance transactions are sure to play a big role in the future. Financial Inclusion and the African Diaspora The diaspora of Africa play a key part in African development. If combined, the remittances of the diaspora make up the second largest source of money flowing into Africa from outside the continent (after Foreign Direct Investment), far eclipsing official development assistance (African Economic Outlook 2015). In macroeconomic terms, remittances constitute a powerful force. The Consultative Group to Assist the Poor (2014), argue that “a well-functioning payment and remittance ecosystem” performs a central role in boosting financial inclusion and reducing or mitigating poverty at the national level. At the household level, what this looks like in practice varies from providing a safety net to vulnerable families and/or individuals, to lifting families out of poverty and allowing them to access essential services that they may otherwise be excluded from due to lack of money, such as health and education.
  • 7. There is even a positive link between remittance receivers and financial inclusion, with areas that have a higher percentage of remittance-receiving households having more bank branches, bank accounts and savings accounts per capita (Demirgüç-Kunt et al. 2011). Remittances and financial inclusion are linked in other ways. For example, whilst 14% of bank account holders globally use their account to receive remittances, in Africa, that figure almost triples, to 41% (AfDB 2013). With remittances being named as the world’s largest poverty-reduction programme (IFAD 2015), and the UN 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development acknowledging their importance, it is essential that we explore how diaspora and their remittances can be leveraged through financial inclusion frameworks to meet development objectives (Foote et al. 2015). However, whilst the remittance market is important, for Africa, the high cost of sending money back home means that both the African diaspora who send the money and those who receive it can be considered as financially excluded. With an average cost of 12.5% of the money remitted – among the highest rates in the world – it means that the poorest continent is effectively paying an additional tax (Foote et al. 2015). A further reason is related to exclusivity clauses, whereby agreements are signed between banks in order to decrease competition and ultimately, maintain higher prices (Central Bank of Nigeria, 2008). However, measures are being taken to tackle these challenges. In 2009, the G20 adopted ‘The General Principles for International Remittance Services’ which aimed to lower costs of remittances to 5%. More recently, during the summit of 2015, Addis Ababa Action Agenda looked at how the new UN Sustainable Development Goals would be financed and included a target to reduce the costs of remittances to 3% by 2030 (Foote et al. 2015). Lowering costs would unlock billions of dollars for individuals, families and businesses in Africa. New technologies and methods - some of which are outlined in the box left - can go some way in addressing high transaction costs. But for them to be truly effective on a regional scale, they must be accompanied by international measures and governance that address the lack of transparency and competition that shroud these flows of money A Focus on…Digitalisation in Development Digital technologies and platforms are being widely utilised across the continent to increase financial inclusion, overcome the high transaction costs of sending money and promote inclusive development. Some of these include: eTransform Africa Launched in 2012, eTransform Africa is a collaboration between the African Development Bank, the World Bank and the African Union. Their publication highlights the role of ICTs in enhancing African regional trade and integration as well as the need to build a competitive ICT industry to promote innovation, job creation and the export potential of African companies. Through a focus on six sectors, they hope to shed light upon and drive ICT innovations that deliver home- grown solutions in Africa, transforming businesses, whilst driving entrepreneurship and economic growth. MasterCard The MasterCard Foundation works with financial service providers and users alike to expand access to financial services for people living in poverty, particularly those in rural and remote areas. Their aim is to deepen the industry’s ability to serve those people who are too poor or remote to receive financial services by providing insights into client needs and cost saving delivery channels. At the World Humanitarian Summit, May 2016, MasterCard announced that it plans to expand its aid distribution services with the launch of MasterCard Humanitarian Aid Solutions. The initiative will provide an open and flexible network to make complex digital requirements simple for partners to implement. Better Than Cash Better Than Cash is a partnership of governments, companies, and international organisations that accelerate the transition from cash to digital payments in order to reduce poverty and drive inclusive growth. Based on their research, the Better Than Cash Alliance partners with governments, companies, and international organisations that are the key drivers behind the transition to make digital payments widely available. They do this by advocating for the transition from cash to digital payments in a way that advances financial inclusion and catalysing the development of inclusive digital payments ecosystems in member countries to reduce costs.
  • 8. 7 Policy Brief July 2016 – Financial Inclusion in Africa What are some of the Best Practices? Underpinned by an ever-growing foundation of research, experiences and knowledge - governments, multilateral organisations and policy makers are beginning to prioritise financial inclusion in their national and international development agendas. There is an emphasis that both inclusive growth and inclusive financing should be focussed on simultaneously. There is also recognition that in practice, financial inclusion policies and mechanisms should be focussed on the most marginalised groups, such as women, youth, the poor and the diaspora. This section highlights a couple of best practices from across the continent that can be used to inform future policies. Women’s World Banking An international NGO focussed on low-income countries, Women’s World Banking (WWB) works closely with a global network of 40 financial institutions from 29 countries to create new credit, savings, and insurance products specifically designed for the unique needs of women. Institutions in their network are committed to serving women as clients, innovators and leaders. Through both research and the design of innovative products, the organisation looks for new ways to help women build financial safety nets, by showing a broader range of financial institutions how to move beyond traditional microfinance to provide financial products that include savings and insurance. One such research paper looking at how to close the financial inclusion gender gap argued that policy measures to increase financial inclusion need to be country-specific, and based on each country’s gender gap, unique challenges and opportunities (Women’s World Banking 2016). When it comes to boosting women’s financial inclusion globally, there can be no one-size-fits-all approach. An initiative of WWB, which focusses on women- led small and medium sized enterprises - and more specifically, how to close the gender-gap of these enterprises in accessing finances - uses Diamond Bank, Nigeria as an example. The challenge was how to offer financial services that are appropriate for women entrepreneurs working at a market in Lagos, and at a low cost. Named the ‘BETA savings account’, it was rolled out across 21 Diamond Bank branches, is easy to set up, and has no minimum balance requirement or fees and was directly tailored towards the needs of the women who work in the market (Women’s World Banking 2014). Looking to Rwanda – The Umurenge SACCO Programme Though Rwanda is one of Africa’s smallest nations, it faces the same problems as many other African countries when it comes to the challenge of financial inclusion. A World Bank survey conducted in 2008 revealed that only 21% of Rwandans were financially included. The following year, the government decided to take action. The challenge in Rwanda is acute because the majority of the population live in rural areas, which traditionally have been underserved by the African financial sector. The answer to this was the Vision 2020 Umurenge programme, which aims to boost financial inclusion through Umurenge SACCOs, which are savings and credit cooperatives that are supervised and subsidised by the National Bank of Rwanda. The strategy also identified six main pillars that had to be in place for this initiative to work: security, low minimum balance, liquidity, government support, tailored products that meet client needs, public education and capacity building through training (AFI 2014). Whilst there is certainly room for the scheme to better embrace technology, Umurenge SACCOs are seen as a good way to bridge the financial inclusion gap, and offer a chance for Rwandans to save money and access finance. Where access to finance was once scarce, now 90% of Rwandans live within 5km proximity to one of the 416 Umurenge SACCOs in the country and this has led to a doubling of the proportion of Rwandan adults who are financially included in just three years. (21% to 42%). A further success is that in 2014, more than 85% of SACCOs broke even without taking government subsidies into account, and they are increasingly being used as funding source for state social programmes (ibid.).
  • 9. Recommendations If policymakers want to reduce rates of poverty in Africa, it is essential that policies are implemented that remove barriers to financial inclusion. Inclusive and sustainable growth will only be realised if it is complemented by financial inclusion, and in practice, this means addressing the challenges of those who are most financially excluded. This section outlines some policy recommendations directed towards a range of stakeholders involved in the financial inclusion agenda. Recommendations to National Governments and Multilateral Organisations:  National Governments and Multilateral Organisations need to capture the potential of both the individuals and enterprises that are excluded from the formalised financial sector.  Those who are most excluded, the women, the youth and the poorest, should be brought into the conversation so that their needs are met.  Legal and regulatory frameworks should be revised and adapted so that the barriers that create financial exclusion and discrimination are lifted, and that there is space for financial products and services that will promote financial inclusion among marginalised groups.  There are a number of best practices which can be used as starting points by African Governments and Multilateral Organisation in their endeavours to increase financial inclusion.  Successful policies such as those from around the continent and indeed others from further afield should be drawn upon to create country-specific finance policies that take the needs of the most marginalised into account. Recommendations to Banks and Other Financial Institutions:  For banks and other financial institutions involved in low-income countries, a reconsideration of pricing models needs to be undertaken. This should acknowledge and be tailored towards the varied and often quite specific needs of certain groups such as women, youth and low-income consumers.  New ways of banking should be adopted and harmonised. It is essential that a favourable technological environment is created around mobile banking, which has spread rapidly and continues to grow in Africa. There should also be a prioritisation for rural areas, which are much more likely to be unbanked.  There is a lack of financial knowledge and capacity of financial products and services among many sections of African society, and much of this is down to a lack of awareness and a lack of trust. Trust must be built by banks, who need to create and maintain a good reputation; one that protects consumers and caters towards their needs. Recommendations to or in regard to the Diaspora:  Both the African diaspora and organisations that work with the diaspora should raise awareness of issues around sending and receiving money in Africa, with a particular focus on the high fees and exclusionary agreements which unfairly penalise people in some of the poorest countries in the world.  Further research should be conducted into the users and the logistics of current remittance channels, and should also explore potential innovations that may benefit both senders and receivers. This should contribute to a growing body of research that places remittances and financial inclusion at the centre of the sustainable development agenda.  Further embrace the use of technology as a way to transfer remittances, particularly via mobile technology.
  • 10. 9 Policy Brief July 2016 – Financial Inclusion in Africa And Finally, a Recommendation for All:  In order to truly boost financial inclusion in a manner that is sustainable and equitable, stakeholders involved - whether they are diaspora networks or national governments, banks or policymakers – should continue to engage in dialogue with one another, but also with the end users, particularly those who are most marginalised.
  • 11. References AfDB –African Development Bank. (2013). Financial Inclusion in Africa. African Development Bank Publications. 23 May 2016. AFI - Alliance for Financial Inclusion. (2014). Rwanda's Financial Inclusion Success Story: Umurenge SACCOS. AFI Case Studies. 1-12. African Economic Outlook. (2015). African Economic Outlook 2015. AfDB, OECD, UNDP 2015. 1 (1), 1-38. Beck, T. and Martinez Peria, M. S. (2009). What Explains The Cost Of Remittances ? An Examination Across 119 Country Corridors. Policy Research Working Papers . 1-31. BIS - Bank for International Settlements. (2012). IFC Workshop on Financial Inclusion Indicators. Available: http://www.bis.org/ifc/publ/ifcb38i.pdf. Last accessed 30th May 2016 Braga, Michela (2009). When the Manna Comes from Abroad — Remittances and Youth Labor Market Behavior in Albania. University of Milan — DEAS. Bruhn, M., and I. Love. (2014). The Real Impact of Improved Access to Finance: Evidence from Mexico. Journal of Finance, 69 (3): 1347–76. Central Bank of Nigeria. (2008). Exclusivity Clauses in the Agreements Signed by Nigerian Banks with International Money Transfer Operators. Cenbank Circulars. CGAP - Consultaitive Group to Assist the Poor. (2014). Payments/Remittances. Available: http://www.cgap.org/topics/paymentsremittances. Last accessed 30th May 2016. Demirgüç-Kunt, A., López Córdova, E., Martínez Pería, M. and Woodruff, C. (2011). Remittances and banking sector breadth and depth: Evidence from Mexico. Journal of Development Economics, 95(2), 229–241. Financial Inclusion Data Working Group. (2011). Measuring Financial Inclusion Core Set of Financial Inclusion Indicators. Available: http://www.afi- global.org/sites/default/files/afi%20fidwg%20report.pdf. Last accessed 23 May 2016. Foote, M. P. and F. Ngom, M. Passas, A. Kasongo, F. Knoote, M. Lombe, D. F. Terry. (2015). African Diaspora and Remittances. CFLP Policy Report. 1 (11), 1-16. G20. (2014). 2014 Financial Inclusion Action Plan . Available: http://www.g20australia.org/sites/default/files/g20_resources/library/2014_g20_financial_ inclusion_action_plan.pdf. Last accessed 23 May 2016. Global Findex Database. (2014). The Global Findex Database 2014: Measuring Financial Inclusion around the World. Policy Research Working Paper. 7255 (1), 23 May 2016. GPFI. (2016). Global Standard-Setting Bodies and Financial Inclusion: The Evolving Landscape. Available: http://www.gpfi.org/publications/global-standard-setting-bodies- and-financial-inclusion-evolving-landscape. Last accessed 23 May 2016. GSMA. (2015). 2015 State of the Industry Report on Mobile Money. Policy Paper. 1 (1), 1- 73. FAD. (2015). The use of remittances and financial inclusion. Report by the International Fund for Agricultural Development and the World Bank Group to the G20 Global Partnership for Financial Inclusion. 1-62. IFC - International Finance Corporation. (2013). Access to Finance - Sub-Saharan Africa. Policy Paper. 1-12. MFW4A - Making Finance Work for Africa. (2013). Advancing African Women's Financial Inclusion. Policy Brief. 1-40. OECD. MENA-OECD Investment Programme. (2011). Women’s Access to Finance in the Middle East and the North Africa (MENA) Region: Draft Issues Paper. Paris: OECD. Park, C & Mercado, R. V. (2015). Financial Inclusion, Poverty, and Income Inequality in Developing Asia. ADB Economics Working Paper Series. 426 (1), 1-25. Stuart, G., Ferguson, M. & Cohen, M. (2011). Microfinance & Gender: Some Findings From The Financial Diaries In Malawi. May 2011. Washington, DC: Microfinance Opportunities. The Guardian. (2015). Sending cash home: mobile money is a gamechanger. Available: http://www.theguardian.com/global-development-professionals- network/2015/sep/29/mobile-money-gamechanger-for-diaspora-sending-remittances. Last accessed 30th May 2016. UN. (2013). Financial Inclusion of Youth. Fact Sheet. 1-5. UNCDF. (2016a). New Research Study Outlines Benefits of Savings Accounts for Young People in Africa. Available: http://www.uncdf.org/en/new-research-study-outlines- benefits-savings-accounts-young-people-africa. Last accessed 30th May 2016. UNCDF. (2016b). Lost in the mail: Why bank account access is not translating into usage. MAP Global Insights Series. 4 (1), 1-20. Women's World Banking. (2014). Diamond Bank Storms the Market: A BETA Way to Save. Policy Paper. 1-20. Women's World Banking and The Alliance for Financial Inclusion. (2016). Policy Frameworks to Support Women’s Financial Inclusion.Policy Paper. 1-24. World Bank. (2014). Financial Inclusion Data / Global Findex - Sub-Saharan Africa. Available: http://datatopics.worldbank.org/financialinclusion/region/sub-saharan- africa. Last accessed 23 May 2016. World Bank 2015. (2015). The Global Findex Database 2014 Measuring Financial Inclusion around the World. Policy Research Working Paper. 7255 (1), 1-97. Young-Park, C. and Mercado, R. V. (2015). Financial Inclusion, Poverty, and Income Inequality in Developing Asia. Asian Development Bank Economics Working Paper Series. 426 (1), 1-25.