SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 44
Download to read offline
Too Soon to Turn Away
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need
in the Central African Republic
International Rescue Committee | JULY 2015
FRONT COVER: A boy with a homemade toy gun near Kaga Bandoro, Central African Republic.
OPPOSITE PAGE: An elderly Muslim woman, displaced by sectarian violence, sheltering
at Bangui’s main mosque.
©2015 International Rescue Committee | 122 East 42ND Street, New York, NY 10168 | Rescue.org
Too Soon to Turn Away
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need
in the Central African Republic
International Rescue Committee | JULY 2015
Table of Contents
2	 Executive Summary
4	Introduction
8	Insecurity
11	Governance
15	 Humanitarian Need
21	Risk
25	 Roadmap Forward
27	Conclusion
29	Recommendations
33	Appendices
	 IRC Report Caveats
	 From the Field: Messages to the International Community
	 IRC-SAIS Research Methodology & Limitations
	 The IRC in CAR
38	Endnotes
40	Acknowledgments
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic2
Progress toward stability in the country was made between
2008 and 2012, but hope for a long-lasting peace was
dashed in March 2013 when the Séléka Muslim rebel
alliance overthrew the government of President François
Bozizé and subsequently fractured into militias that
exacted terror on Christian communities. Anti-balaka
Christian self-defense groups sought retribution on Muslim
communities and the country descended into ethnic and
sectarian violence, with thousands fleeing their homes
and the United Nations warning of a high risk of genocide.
Only the intervention of French troops and an expanded
UN peacekeeping force—and the efforts of international
humanitarian aid agencies—prevented CAR from further
descending into anarchy and humanitarian catastrophe.
By May 2015, the worst of the crisis seemed to be over.
Indeed, the Inter-Agency Standing Committee (IASC),
which comprises all major humanitarian agencies inside
and outside the UN system, removed CAR from its list
of “Level 3 Emergencies”—the UN’s highest designation
for a humanitarian crisis. However, the UN humanitarian
appeal for CAR is dangerously underfunded. As of May, only
$129.6 million of the $613 million proposed for humanitarian
aid for 2015—just 21 percent—has been met.1
Once again,
CAR seems destined to fade from the news and the focused
attention of policymakers, meaning that it may never emerge
from its decades-long cycle of failed governance, insecurity
and human suffering. As the UN’s humanitarian coordinator,
Claire Bourgeois, stated, “We must prevent the Central
African Republic from becoming a forgotten crisis… The
current funding for the strategic humanitarian response does
not allow us to ensure the protection of all these displaced
persons or to provide the minimum of what is needed to meet
the huge humanitarian needs.”2
It would be a critical mistake for the international community
to be lulled into thinking that stability has returned to the
country. Conflict and insecurity continue to be the defining
feature of life in CAR. The state has collapsed and armed
groups rule the countryside, challenging each other and
the shaky Transitional Government (TG) based in Bangui,
the capital. The national army and police force are under-
equipped, lack training and cannot ensure the population’s
safety or security.
The International Rescue Committee (IRC) is issuing this
report with the intention of refocusing attention on the needs
of the Central African people as well as on the obstacles
the IRC and other humanitarian agencies are experiencing
in trying to aid the population. The report is based on field
research in CAR and draws on surveys and interviews with
85 conflict-affected Central Africans.3
Additionally, the IRC,
with support provided by a research team from the Johns
Hopkins University School of Advanced International
Studies (SAIS), has projected what humanitarian need in
CAR could look like in two key areas—food security and
shelter—if insecurity persists and funding requirements are
not met. The combination of field research and this analysis
has led to the following key findings:
	 Chronic insecurity, misrule and failed governance are
the biggest obstacles to meeting the humanitarian
needs of Central Africans. Central Africans themselves
cite these problems as reason for skepticism that the
country will manage peaceful elections and transition
to a new government.
	 The impact of humanitarian assistance is muted by
the lack of comprehensive investment designed to bring
stability to the country and support long-term institution
building. Humanitarian assistance is desperately needed
and blunts the impact of the crisis on Central Africans,
but it is only palliative.
	 For the international community to make a difference
it must employ everything in its tool kit to ensure stability
—diplomacy, peacekeeping, and humanitarian and
development assistance.
The international community cannot afford to wait for
ideal conditions to lay the groundwork for CAR’s future.
It must take an approach that allows for security and
good-governance to take root while significantly increasing
investment to meet humanitarian needs. The international
community should seize a superb opportunity right now. In
May 2015, parties to the conflict, religious and traditional
leaders, and members of civil society adopted The
Republican Pact for Peace, National Reconciliation and
Reconstruction, at the close of a long-awaited national peace
dialogue, the Bangui Forum. Donors, humanitarian agencies
and the International Contact Group on the Central African
Republic, in tandem with CAR’s Transitional Government,
The Central African Republic (CAR) has been unstable since its independence from
France in 1960 and is one of the least-developed countries in the world. It has endured
a succession of coups and decades of misrule and lawlessness.
Executive Summary
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 3
can meet humanitarian needs and stabilize the country by
lending their full diplomatic and financial support to this pact,
an investment in the rebirth of a stable nation governed
by effective, inclusive and accountable institutions. Failing
to support it will inevitably lead to new and expensive
chapters for both Central Africans and those who endeavor
to assist them.
Summary of Recommendations
Invest in efforts to reduce insecurity,
impunity and violence
Insecurity continues to shape life in the Central African
Republic. This instability disrupts markets, destroys
communities and causes people to flee their homes.
Every effort must be made to create a secure environment
where citizens do not live in fear and can lead productive
lives. The UN peacekeeping mission in CAR (MINUSCA)
must be fully staffed and resourced. State authority should
be extended across the country by establishing public
security infrastructure such as courts, prisons and police
services that respect the rights of civilians. Significant efforts
must be made to swiftly disarm, demobilize and reintegrate
combatants from all sides of the conflict to prevent ongoing
violence in communities. As efforts are being made to
create basic security, international humanitarian donors
should prioritize funding for conflict-sensitive programs
that prevent and respond to violence against civilians,
particularly women and children.
Create conditions that facilitate the delivery
of humanitarian assistance
Even with a reduction in violence from the peak of the recent
crisis in CAR, a humanitarian catastrophe continues to
unfold. Despite the deactivation of the “Level 3” emergency
status, humanitarian assistance is still desperately needed
and nearly 900,000 people remain displaced. Every effort
must be made to extend life-saving assistance and basic
services to conflict-affected Central Africans, including
to those in areas far outside Bangui. Donor governments
should not turn away from humanitarian needs prematurely
and should fully fund humanitarian appeals. The Transitional
Government of CAR in turn should remove unnecessary
obstacles to humanitarian operations. It should not delay
humanitarian materials in customs and should restore
the tax-exempt status of international non-governmental
organizations (INGOs).
Support the establishment of
effective, inclusive and accountable
government institutions
Prior to the conflict, the ability of the state to provide basic
services like education and health to its population was
weak. Central Africans had very little direct ability to hold
their government accountable or shape the decisions it
made. Donors and international financial institutions should
work with the Transitional and future governments in CAR
to overcome these challenges by strengthening the ability
of the state to manage public resources and provide basic
services. The social contract between citizens and their
government should also be strengthened through increased
information sharing, expanded spaces for dialogue between
people and the state, and new opportunities for participatory
decision-making.
Set CAR on a path toward sustained recovery
and development
Without lasting peace, it will be impossible to move beyond
the humanitarian crisis in CAR. Sustained diplomatic
engagement with the Transitional Government and parties
to the conflict is critical to breaking out of an endless
cycle of violence and poverty. The international community
must seize upon the Republican Pact for Peace, National
Reconciliation and Reconstruction. Funding should be
aligned to areas of the Pact that are critical to resolving the
crisis and establishing a path to a better future: governance,
economic and social development, justice and reconciliation,
and peace and security. The Transitional Government should
continue to consult with an ever-widening array of civil-
society representatives to develop, implement and evaluate
plans that emerge from the Pact.
A Central African woman, Kaga Bandoro.
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic4
The Central African Republic (CAR) has been marred by
corruption, poor governance and chronic instability, all of
which have contributed to the country’s cyclical violence
and stagnation.4
The latest conflict, triggered by a coup
d’état in late 2012—the country’s fifth since independence
in 1960—plunged CAR deeper into crisis and increased
the need for humanitarian aid. The state, already dubbed a
phantom state,5
failed. One of the world’s worst humanitarian
emergencies unfolded, with 6,000 people dead and nearly
one million displaced.6
The already fragile health system
collapsed, with 42 percent of facilities damaged, 50 percent
looted and 68 percent experiencing a shortage of medicine.7
Significant declines in harvests and livestock8
have impacted
the income of over three-fourths of CAR’s agricultural
workers, as well as the food security of the entire population.
The international community, from diplomatic corps to
militaries to humanitarian aid agencies, has mobilized
to halt the violence, create the conditions for dialogue
between armed rivals, and deliver lifesaving assistance
to Central Africans. Starting in 2013, French, European
Union (EU) and African Union (AU) troops, as well as
UN peacekeepers, deployed to CAR to protect civilians.
In July 2014, international mediators facilitated a ceasefire
agreement, known as the Brazzaville Accord. Donors
and their partners have delivered at least $493 million
in humanitarian assistance.9
By early 2015, the crisis appeared to be abating; EU troops
withdrew and the French began to draw down their military
presence. In April 2015, the Transitional Government (TG)
held grassroots consultations to query the general public
on their views on reconciliation. This culminated in May
in a national peace dialogue dubbed the Bangui Forum,
which adopted “The Republican Pact for Peace, National
Reconciliation and Reconstruction,” a roadmap for peace
and sustainable development. As a result of these positive
developments, CAR could be in a position to hold national
and legislative elections by the close of 2015.
These events indicate progress toward peace. Yet stability
remains elusive. The Brazzaville Accord was not recognized
by factions of armed groups and thus not fully implemented.
Despite the deployment of international forces and the
installment of a transitional government, insurgent groups
continue to burn, loot and murder, creating new chaos
throughout the country. Nearly 900,000 people—20 percent
of the total population—remain displaced. Until a strategy
and concomitant funding are in place for the realization of
the new Republican Pact for Peace, National Reconciliation
Introduction
Conflict background
In March 2013, a coalition of predominantly Muslim
rebels, the Séléka alliance, ousted President
Bozizé, bringing Michel Djotodia to power. Djotodia
subsequently lost control of the alliance as it fractured
into multiple militias that embarked on a campaign
of terror against Christian communities. Due to the
complete breakdown in law and order, Christian
self-defense groups, known as the Anti-balaka
(AB), sought retribution against Muslim communities,
going on a “campaign of ethnic cleansing,” as
described by the International Commission of Inquiry.
At the apex of the crisis (late 2013/early 2014), the
French launched Operation Sangaris, deploying
1,600 troops to support the 3,700 MISCA (the AU’s
International Support Mission to CAR) troops on
the ground. President Djotodia resigned and current
interim-president Samba-Panza was elected. By
September 2014, power was transferred from MISCA
to MINUSCA, a multidimensional UN peacekeeping
operation with a mandate to protect civilians.
In July 2014, Séléka and Anti-balaka signed
a ceasefire agreement, the Brazzaville Accord, eliciting
international support for CAR’s transition toward
durable political, security and humanitarian solutions
(via the International Contact Group on the Central
African Republic).
In May 2015, the Bangui Forum was held, bringing all
national stakeholders to the table to set forth a plan
for reconciliation and sustainable peace. Elections are
due to take place by the end of 2015.
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 5
An IRC survey conducted shortly after the grassroots
consultations found that many displaced and conflict-
affected Central Africans strongly questioned whether
the country is undergoing a positive transition.11
(The
consultations were carried out in all 16 of CAR’s prefectures,
but the effort elicited only 4,000 interviews, or a mere
.08 percent of the population.) Central Africans, at least
those responding to interviews, felt that their participation
in CAR’s peace process has been nearly nonexistent; they
did not view the Bangui Forum as a harbinger of peace when
large-scale disarmament, demobilization and reintegration
(DDR) of combatants had yet to take place—a process
they gave top priority. The Central Africans interviewed
overwhelmingly said they desire security first, then a political
process toward peace. In fact, despite assertions to the
contrary from members of the international community, there
is little indication that Central Africans are returning home
from refugee and internally displaced persons (IDP) camps12
and it remains a question whether the country is truly on a
path to sustainable recovery.
Sadly, the conditions that gave rise to the conflict continue
to exist. A hollow state created discontent among
the disenfranchised, resulting in cyclical violence and
and Reconstruction (hereafter referred to as the Pact),
CAR’s political direction may remain uncertain, causing
continued instability.
Despite this prognosis, humanitarian funding has dropped
well below what is required to meet the immense and
growing needs of those affected by the crisis. As of May, only
$129.6 million of the $613 million proposed for humanitarian
aid for 2015—just 21 percent—has been funded.10
The
drop in humanitarian funding reflects a lack of international
attention to CAR and could signal a growing complacency
with regard to humanitarian needs facing the country.
The International Rescue Committee (IRC) is issuing this
report with the intention of refocusing attention on the needs
of the Central African people and on the efforts to stabilize
the country by strategically investing in the Pact. The IRC
sought answers to the following questions:
	 Is CAR emerging from crisis and moving toward stability?
	 Are the needs of people affected by crisis in CAR
being met?
	 What are the main challenges to meeting
humanitarian needs?
Elderly men and women participate in a meeting held by a local women’s association, Bocaranga, Ouham Pendé.
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic6
humanitarian crises. The TG currently lacks authority:
warring parties continue to vie for control, weapons freely
circulate and banditry is rampant. Not only does the
population remain at risk, but the humanitarian community
faces tremendous obstacles to deliver basic aid because
of the country’s lawlessness.
Despite the skepticism of many Central Africans, the Pact
that emerged from the Bangui Forum offers an opportunity
for dialogue and for the international community to ramp
up its efforts at a critical moment—while understanding
that aid is not a long-term solution. A coherent approach
to CAR must include:
	 Robust investment in efforts to reduce insecurity,
impunity and violence.
	 Concerted action to create conditions that facilitate
the delivery of humanitarian assistance.
	 Resolute support for the establishment of effective,
inclusive and accountable government institutions.
	 Prolonged commitment to set CAR on a path toward
long-term recovery and development.
A holistic approach to the crisis in CAR must address
the obstacles that humanitarian agencies face in meeting
the needs of conflict-affected people while working toward
long-term stability.
Displacement Figures, May 2015
58,700
Bangui
48,400
OMBELLA-M’POKO
6,500
KEMO
35,200
LOBAYE
22,200
MAMBÉRÉ-KADEI
18,700
NANA-MAMBÉRÉ
7,300
OUHAM-PENDÉ
82,500
OUHAM
64,800
OUAKA
15,100
HAUTE-KOTTO
2,700
BAMINGUI BANGORAN
1,300
VAKAGA
6,700
BASSE-
KOTTO
11,000
MBOMOU
15,700
HAUT-
MBOMOU
2,900
SANGHA-
MBAÉRÉ
97,195
DEMOCRATIC
REPUBLIC OF
THE CONGO
26,704
CONGO
247,245
CAMEROON
94,024
CHAD
SUDAN
SOUTH SUDAN
26,300
NANA-GRIBIZI
Source: IDMC and OCHA
Introduction (continued)
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 7
A Sample of Central African Voices
The war is not over, as one can see in Kaga
Bandoro. There is a lethargy vis-à-vis the CAR.
The international community is mobilizing for
Boko Haram, but what about us?
—LOCAL AUTHORITY
Security Council Resolution 2127 has not
resulted in anything! There are still killings.
Why isn’t MINUSCA doing its job? I was a
refugee in Cameroon and I have only been back
in Bocaranga for 44 days. I want to see 2127
applied here.
– MUSLIM RETURNEE
We came here because we were scared;
when DDR happens in all the neighborhoods
and the situation gets better, each and every
one of us will be ready to go home … I have
no desire to be here; I want to go home but
I can’t because there is no DDR.
– IDP IN BANGUI
I have no faith in the Bangui Forum; this is not
our first dialogue … the recommendations were
never applied.
– COMMUNITY LEADER
Will our vote count? No one in Cameroon
talked to us about elections. We felt totally
excluded from everything—the election process,
the peace process. People are sensitized here
but no one is going to refugee camps [to get
our opinions].
– MUSLIM RETURNEE
I am a bit confused by the elections calendar.
The census is not yet done and the people
are not yet disarmed. … This is critical. Recall
that the current crisis was set off by the 2011
elections. There was trickery. … So we need
a process, a real and coherent way to organize
the new elections so we don’t descend into
crisis again with accusations of trickery or
nonparticipation.
– LOCAL AUTHORITY
We said we are happy with the consultation
but this is not the case. We could have another
conflict right away. Our representatives lied.
– IRC STAFF MEMBER
Zianabu Djoguel. President of the Hand in Hand Women’s Association of
Koui, Koui, Ouaham Pendé.
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic8
According to humanitarian agencies, as well as Central
Africans themselves (the IRC interviewed program
beneficiaries), CAR remains plagued by:
	 Border insecurity: Militia groups, including armed
Chadians, continue to launch cross-border raids;
there have been multiple reports of elements of the
Chadian National Army attacking villages in CAR.
	 Transhumance-related battles:16
Pastoralists and
farmers continue to clash over local resources such
as pasturelands.
	 Ongoing conflicts: Authorities are trying to
reestablish presence over ex-Séléka and other
armed elements; violence continues between existing
and new non-state actors.
	 Banditry and criminality: Individuals and former militia
members continue to capitalize on the security vacuum
and absence of rule of law to attack and pillage villages,
service-center points (health posts, religious sites,
charitable organizations, etc.) and transport vehicles.
	 Lack of a functioning police service: Absence of a
police force whose mission and purpose is to provide
rule of law and protect citizens.
For Central Africans, the breakdown of law and order in the
country is a matter of life and death and fuels displacement.
Recent displacement trends underscore that violence in
CAR has not subsided. Conflict-related incidents have gone
down drastically in comparison to 2014, but the overall
displacement figure still hovers just below 900,000, roughly
84 percent of what it was at the peak of the violence in
January 2014. While the number of IDPs has decreased
significantly (to 436,119) since the height of the conflict, the
number of new refugees flowing into neighboring countries
has increased (to 460,542 as of mid-May 2015).17, 18
Overlaying IDP displacement figures with data on the
number of conflict-related incidents shows a notable trend:
displacement levels rose sharply on the heels of increased
conflict and decreased sharply when conflict-related
incidents dropped after January 2014. Several factors
influence IDP numbers. While it is unknown if the reduction
in IDPs is due to individuals either going home or becoming
refugees, the trend shows a positive correlation between
conflict and IDP numbers, meaning that conflict will need
to be staunched in order to prevent further displacement.
Insecurity
Conflict in CAR has decreased since 2013, due in part
to the deployment of international forces. The current
peacekeeping operation, the UN’s Multidimensional
Integrated Stabilization Mission in the Central African
Republic (MINUSCA), has played an important role in civilian
security, from proactive efforts to dislodge armed elements
from government buildings, to passive protection offered by
the mere presence of police and military staff. The mission,
however, faces significant challenges, including a slow scale-
up,13
limited logistical resources, and a lack of government
counterparts, all of which have had direct repercussions on
MINUSCA’s ability to implement its protection-of-civilians
strategy—particularly in regard to DDR. MINUSCA and its
military predecessors (MISCA, Operation Sangaris, EUFOR)
have encountered resistance and violent attacks during
disarmament attempts. A new DDR agreement was only
signed in May 2015; its viability is yet to be determined.
Conflict Incident Trends
Year Monthly Average
2014 88
2013 42
2012 7
2011 1.2
2010 13
MINUSCA’s actions have improved security in the country,
but the number of conflict-related incidents (as tracked
by the Armed Conflict Location and Event Data Project,
or ACLED), remains too high to describe conditions as
stabilizing. The number of incidents in 2015 (through
end of April)14
stands at 123, an average of 31 per month,15
far exceeding the level of conflict prior to the onset of this
crisis in 2013.
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 9
Graph 1: IDP Numbers in Relation to
Number of Conflict-Related Incidents
0
200,000
400,000
600,000
800,000
900,000
700,000
500,000
300,000
NumberofCentralAfricanIDPs
NumberofConflict-RelatedIncidents
100,000
250
200
150
100
50
0
APR2015
MAR2015
FEB2015
JAN2015
DEC2014
NOV2014
OCT2014
SEP2014
AUG2014
JUL2014
JUN2014
MAY2014
APR2014
MAR2014
FEB2014
JAN2014
DEC2013
IDPs Conflict-Related Incidents
GRAPH 1 This graph overlays ACLED’S conflict-related incident numbers
with OCHA IDP figures
Since the height of the conflict in January 2014, over
300,000 more refugees have sought safety in countries
neighboring CAR. Continued lawlessness in the country,
and refugee outflows, could have adverse security
implications in a region already plagued by conflict and
violence. It has long been feared that the current security
vacuum, coupled with a near total absence of law and order,
might lead to fertile terrain for terrorist groups such as Boko
Haram. While this has not materialized, the humanitarian
community has seen a worrying encroachment of the Lord’s
Resistance Army (LRA) into CAR. In 2014, LRA attacks and
abductions in CAR increased compared to 2012 and 2013.
As the Uganda People’s Defense Force, with backing from
the United States, has pursued the LRA in southeastern CAR,
the insurgents have moved further north and west. In the
first three months of 2015, tracked incidents decreased;
however, this may be a short-lived trend.19
It may be partially
attributable to the fact that the LRA has moved into areas
where LRA crisis watchers are not active, and civilians may
not be able to identify which armed group is attacking them.20
Insecurity in Numbers
436,119 The number of people
displaced within the country, living in fear of violence
and human-rights violations.21
More than 36,000
The number of people trapped in seven enclaves with limited
access to basic services and at risk of violence and abuse.22
1,455 The number of security incidents recorded
since January 2014, of which 166 (or 11 percent) were direct
violence against humanitarians. In April 2015, 127 security
incidents were recorded, with 17 percent against aid workers
(specifically, humanitarian worker kidnappings).23
18 The number of aid workers killed between
January 2014 and January 2015.24
12,000 The estimated number of armed
ex-Séléka currently making up the three factions of
the former coalition.25
75,000 The estimated number of anti-Balaka
members distributed across the country, according to
their leaders, though some sources put the figure as
low as 20,000.26
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic10
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 11
mentioned the need for more INGOs in CAR. These beliefs
are reinforced by the fact that in some places INGOs are
subsidizing the salaries of health workers. The absence of a
functioning state and good governance has led some Central
Africans to fundamentally misunderstand the role of the
state in regard to basic services for citizens.
The roads haven’t been fixed in over 50 years.
—WOMEN’S GROUP LEADER
The lack of investment in infrastructure is also quite evident.
Roads and bridges are so dilapidated that their condition
severely impedes the delivery of humanitarian assistance.
World Food Programme (WFP) and IRC staff members note
that in some areas it takes up to four hours to travel
120 kilometers,27
and the WFP has had to pay to repair
bridges to facilitate the transport of food aid.
Loss of control of territory: Both INGO staff and Central
Africans spoke of rebel groups providing security rather
than the state. In the northwest, the rebel group Révolution
et Justice has established checkpoints. IRC staff members
in Kaga Bandoro spoke of ex-Séléka as the only authority
recognized by locals. Even in places where government
authorities and/or MINUSCA are present, some Central
Africans still see armed groups as holding de facto power.
Erosion of legitimate authority, inability to provide services
and loss of control of territory, coupled with widespread
corruption and criminality, involuntary movement of
populations, and sharp economic decline, are markers
of a failed state.28, 29
When the communities have issues, they take
their complaints to Séléka and not the sous-
préfet, because he has no authority. Séléka is
truly the one in power. In fact, Séléka occupies
all buildings (in Kaga Bandoro). The sous-Préfet
is sitting at home while his office is occupied by
Séléka.
—NGO STAFF MEMBER
CAR arguably has suffered a governance crisis since the
country’s independence in 1960. Indeed, as far back as
2007, the International Crisis Group (ICG) labeled CAR
a “phantom state…lacking any meaningful institutional
capacity at least since the fall of Emperor Bokassa in 1979.”
This underscores that the current crisis is not new, but
embedded in decades of governance failure. The governance
crisis has become more acute and is manifesting itself in
the following ways:
We don’t feel the efforts of the government
here in Ouham Pendé. It feels as if we are
abandoned. We have no resources to do
our work, no police, no office, nothing.
—PUBLIC SERVANT, BOCARANGA
Erosion of legitimate authority: Central Africans spoke
of feeling “abandoned by the government.” Despite the
strides made by the TG with the support of MINUSCA,
authorities have not been deployed to many of the country’s
prefectures. In addition, armed groups have threatened or
engaged in battle with foreign security actors to impede
the establishment of a government presence. Where
authorities have been deployed, many serve as figureheads.
For example, in Bocaranga, the sous-préfet (the equivalent
of a local governor) has no resources or mechanisms to
carry out his work. The gendarmerie (military police station)
remains burnt and pillaged.
We were assigned here in 2013 but we have
just gotten to our posts because of serious
financial difficulties. We had no transport,
so we had to hitchhike to get here; the last
time we had access to vehicles was during
Bokassa’s tenure.
—GENDARMES
Inability to provide public services: From beneficiaries
to community leaders to other key informants, the
overwhelming majority of Central Africans interviewed
described a near total absence of public services. When
queried on quality education, health, legal services and
management of natural resources, interviewees referenced
INGOs as the expected provider of those services, and
Governance
OPPOSITE PAGE: A destroyed house sits abandoned by its owners who
cannot return to their neighbourhood due to insecurity, Bangui.
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic12
Governance (continued)
Spotlight on MINUSCA
“Concerned with the security, humanitarian, human rights
and political crisis in the Central African Republic and its
regional implications, the Security Council authorized on
10 April 2014 the deployment of a multidimensional United
Nations peacekeeping operation—MINUSCA, with the
protection of civilians as its utmost priority. Its other
initial tasks included support for the transition process;
facilitating humanitarian assistance; promotion and
protection of human rights; support for justice and the rule
of law; and disarmament, demobilization, reintegration and
repatriation processes.” 30
In recognition of the complete
breakdown of the state, the Security Council endowed
the mission with ’urgent temporary measures’31
to accord
MINUSCA the possibility of taking on some basic law
and order functions of the state.
MINUSCA was meant to help the TG establish authority.
Yet CAR’s continuing instability, nearly one year into
the mission, begs the question: why do insecurity and
governance failure continue to be the biggest obstacles
to both Central Africans and aid agencies in meeting
needs? Particular constraints surrounding both the
CAR crisis and the MINUSCA mandate pose significant
challenges to real gains in stability.
Mission Mandate: The protection of civilians is an
ambitious goal in an environment where multiple actors
are perpetrating widespread violence against civilians
and the TG does not have the capacity to contribute
significantly to the protection of civilians within its
borders. As such, MINUSCA must determine how
to prioritize its scarce resources between its various
mandated objectives and tasks. The UN Security Council
(UNSC) helped MINUSCA to prioritize protection by
sequencing its mandate, directing the mission to first
implement primarily protection-related tasks and to delay
many other activities until resources and conditions
permit. Unfortunately, the UNSC did not go far enough
in its efforts to narrow initial mandated activities,
leaving room for the dilution of resources away from
protection activities.32
Mission Strategy: MINUSCA must also determine
which threats and vulnerable populations it will address
and which are beyond its limited capabilities. All
peacekeeping operations mandated to protect must
develop a mission-wide strategy to determine which
protection risks it will prioritize. MINUSCA’s mission-
wide protection strategy is one of the most advanced
of any peacekeeping operation, drawing on the latest
UN policies and best practices.33
In order to respond to
a dynamic environment, protection risks are prioritized
in a “flashpoint matrix,” developed in consultation with
other protection stakeholders. However, the success of
the strategy depends on MINUSCA’s ability to respond
flexibly and rapidly to evolving threats on the ground,
which is something peacekeepers struggle with for many
reasons, including, but not limited to, a lack of situational
awareness, poor information and communication
mechanisms and protocols, inadequate logistics and
assets and a lack of political will of some troops to act.
Mission Authority: In recognition of the absence of
governance structures throughout the country, including
those that contribute to the rule of law, the TG invited the
UN to accept temporary authority and maintain law and
order by arresting and detaining criminals.34
The Security
Council refused, but did give MINUSCA the authority to
We [INGO] have been in the CAR for eight years, through different stages of crisis
and calm. I keep hearing from the population that they want us to stay for years and
years, but this exposes a bigger problem—that there is an expectation that NGOs run
the country. I understand that with such limited service delivery, communities feel that
the government has not served them well, but NGOs, whether international or national,
are not the long-term solution to providing services. The expectation and dependency
factor concern me, and it affects meetings and messaging because we seem to
return to this perception.
—IRC STAFF MEMBER
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 13
operate under “urgent temporary measures” which allow
UN police to detain and arrest, “but only when national
forces were not present or operational, on a temporary
and exceptional basis, without creating a precedent,
and without prejudice to the established principles of
peace operations.”35
MINUSCA has been implementing
this aspect of its mandate by arresting “high-value”
targets.36
However, MINUSCA has to turn over arrested
persons to the TG, which has limited capacity to protect
prisoners, ensure they stay in prison and are tried in
courts according to international standards.37
Mission Guidance: The UN Department of
Peacekeeping Operations and Department of Field
Support have recently released a formal policy on
the protection of civilians in peacekeeping38
as well
as protection of civilian’s guidelines for the military
components of peacekeeping operations. However,
given that this formal guidance was issued in 2015, the
extent to which peacekeeping personnel in MINUSCA,
or any mission, are aware of it and/or trained in its
implementation is unknown at this time.
Mission Strength: MINUSCA is currently authorized
to deploy 12,870 total uniformed personnel, including
10,750 military personnel and 2,120 police. As of 31
March 2015, only 9,902 total uniformed personnel were
deployed (8,305 military personnel and 1,466 police).
Even at full strength, troops will continue to be spread
thinly across the vast country, and will be largely limited
to the main axes. MINUSCA does not have the numbers
to establish a protection presence in all areas, much
less in remote rural areas where civilians are under
threat. Further, the lack of available Formed Police
Units (FPUs)39
means that MINUSCA FPUs are limited
to focusing on Bangui. Beyond numbers, troops and
police may not have the adequate training or assets that
would allow them to project themselves beyond limited
areas of operation.
Collectively, these challenges leave MINUSCA in a
difficult situation. The conditions do not allow for the
mission to fully carry out its stabilization mandate or
implement its protection strategy. With a long list of
resource-heavy priority tasks, a lack of state security
forces, an absence of a justice system, and an insufficient
number of personnel, assets and equipment, MINUSCA’s
hands are often tied.40
The mandate listed seven priority tasks
with at least 20 subtasks that the mission
should focus on in the initial phase. The
mandate rightfully included tasks related to
the physical protection of civilians, human
rights monitoring, good offices and political
support for efforts to address root causes
of the conflict, and support to reconciliation
and mediation at the national and local levels
in this initial phase. However, it also included
tasks to extend state authority. Furthermore,
the mandate decided that MINUSCA should
undertake approximately 10 additional tasks
as resources and conditions permit, but did
not identify what conditions were necessary
to trigger the additional activities.41
Members of the Seleka rebel militia, Central African Republic.
South Sudan’s Displacement Crisis14
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 15
Rampant insecurity and the government’s inability to
provide basic services in large areas of the country have
exacerbated the humanitarian situation. Despite reduced
violence and an international humanitarian response, needs
far outstrip the level of assistance being channeled toward
CAR. The number of people requiring emergency assistance
has increased since 2014 and stands to get worse if
significant efforts are not made to address the causes
and consequences of the crisis. A relative comparison of
humanitarian appeal funding levels shows the Strategic
Response Plan (SRP) funded at 21 percent in May 2015
versus 32 percent in May 2014. In actual terms nearly
$50 million more was given to the SRP in CAR by this
time in 2014.42
Funding Levels for SRP to CAR:
2014 versus 2015
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
450 100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
DECNOVOCTSEPAUGJULJUNMAYAPRMARFEBJAN
Fundinginabsoluteamount–millionsofUSD
PercentageofSRPtoCARfunded
Amount given to SRP in USD millions 2014
Amount given to SRP in USD millions 2015
Percentage of SRP funded in 2014
Percentage of SRP funded in 2015
GRAPH 2 Funding levels for the Strategic Response Plan, data based on
the UN OCHA Financial Tracking Service
OCHA identified 2.7 million in need of emergency
humanitarian assistance in 2015, an increase from
2.5 million43
in 2014. Among those, 1.5 million are suffering
from food insecurity, and the entire 2.7 million require
protection assistance.44
The humanitarian appeals likely
underestimate the full scope of need given the inaccessibility
of remote and insecure regions. Moreover, despite the strong
focus on IDPs in various appeals, there is very little data on
the specific needs of IDPs outside of Bangui.45
The following
represents just a snapshot of the challenges faced by
Central Africans:
Women and Girls
Women and girls face significant threats to their personal
safety. They risk rape and other forms of gender-based
violence (GBV), particularly when they collect firewood
and go to fields to farm. IRC assessments in Kaga Bandoro
revealed that some women and girls have had to turn to
negative coping strategies, including transactional sex,
to offset the impact of their loss of livelihoods. No formal
protection structures function outside Bangui to facilitate
assistance to suvivors.
	 Women face GBV, specifically sexual violence, at
shocking rates. In 2014, women and girls reported
over 1,500 incidents of violence to the IRC: 71 percent
were acts of rape, 23 percent physical assault, three
percent sexual assault, two percent psychological and/
or emotional abuse, and one percent denial of resources,
opportunities or services.46
In the bush and forest, women and girls are
exposed to terrible things. But with the crisis,
they continue to go to the bush, looking for
what they can to subsist—firewood, caterpillars,
mushroom, fish—since their livelihoods have
been ravaged. Things happen to them when
they go to the forest.
—IRC STAFF MEMBER
	 There has been no cessation in sexual and other forms
of gender-based violence since the peak of the crisis
in CAR. The IRC continues to see high numbers of
reported incidents. Yet, as of May 2015, the Protection
Cluster has not received any funding specifically to
address GBV.
Before we had a referral system with the police
and justice personnel. Now, there is no justice.
There is 100 percent impunity for rape
perpetrators in Bocaranga.
—IRC STAFF MEMBER
Humanitarian Need
OPPOSITE PAGE: Kaga Bandoro has the region’s only hospital. Last year, advancing rebels ransacked the wards, stealing generators, mattresses, medicines,
and even bed frames. In one of the damaged wards, severely malnourished toddlers receive milk and peanut paste.
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic16
	 The Guidelines for GBV Prevention and Response in
Humanitarian Settings call for access to safety, security,
health and legal services, but given the limited access
to basic services—including safe spaces and health
structures, the absence of authorities and existing
impunity—these guidelines are difficult to apply.
Without police and courts, alleged perpetrators cannot
be detained and survivors are vulnerable to reprisals.
	 Both increased poverty and the threat of sexual
violence are cited as main reasons for early and forced
marriage. The IRC has noted a decrease in the average
age of marriage for girls, some as early as age 12.
Child Protection
Children are most vulnerable to conflict, and an estimated
2.3 million children in CAR have been affected by the crisis in
2014.47
The impact is devastating; children may lose contact
with family members and they may be victims of, witness
or even be forced to carry out acts of horrific violence.
Even prior to the crisis, children had been associated
with armed groups, including self-defense militias allied
to President Bozizé,48
and two out of every three children
had never attended primary school. With the advent of the
crisis, children were forcibly conscripted into armed forces;
Save the Children staff also report that some joined under
pressure from family or peers, or to avenge acts of violence
perpetrated against them or their families.49
	 An estimated 10,000 children are associated with
armed forces.50
UNICEF has requested $73.9 million
in 2015 for child soldier reintegration and rehabilitation
efforts in CAR, but as of April 30, only $17 million
has been funded.
	 As of July 2014, 59 percent of schools remained
closed due to the absence of teachers, school buildings
being occupied by armed groups, and continuing
insecurity. While this figure has surely changed with
the reduction in the intensity of the conflict, children
in many areas have now missed two full school years
or more. OCHA reported in May 2015 that constant
population movements and the volatile security situation
in central and eastern provinces, especially in Nana-
Gribizi Province, still hinder the provision of structured
education and the timely delivery and distribution of
school supplies.
	 Save the Children recently found that over 60 percent
of school-aged children CAR suffer from post-traumatic
stress disorder (PTSD), having either witnessed or
experienced extreme violence during the conflict.51
These children require case management services and
psychosocial support to help them recover and heal.
While some services are available, the demand far
exceeds the current capacity.
	 Children have allegedly been abused by those
designated to protect them. In April 2015, an internal
report commissioned by the UN Office of the High
Commissioner for Human Rights revealed allegations
of sexual abuse of young boys at an IDP site in Bangui
at the hands of French, Chadian and Equatorial Guinean
troops. Children interviewed for the report state that they
were exploited in exchange for food and money.
Health
The crisis has had a profound impact on morbidity and
mortality in CAR, a country that already had one of the
world’s shortest life expectancies, and the highest under-five
and maternal mortality rates.52
Central Africans have long
suffered from a near-total absence of government-sponsored
health services, a situation made worse by the flight of the
limited pool of health professionals, including those who
had benefited from years of INGO-led training and support.
Village health posts53
are now staffed by unskilled personnel.
Many health centers and posts have been looted, burnt or
otherwise abandoned. Meanwhile, as of April 2015, only
three percent of health needs are met through the CAR
humanitarian appeal, while 80 percent of functional health
facilities depend on support from the humanitarian sector.54
	 IRC health program staff have witnessed an increased
prevalence in the rates of malaria, diarrhea, acute
respiratory infections (ARIs) and acute emergency
cases. They also cite gender-based violence and
malnutrition as major public health issues.
	 A six-to-12-month gap in public health services during
the height of the conflict led to an interruption in the
vaccination of children, treatment for chronic diseases
such as HIV/AIDS, and other essential medical services.
	 Essential medicines such as paracetamol, antibiotics,
antidiarrheals and antimalarials are difficult to procure
locally, and if brought abroad or from the capital,
their transport is complicated by poor infrastructure
and insecurity. Similarly, mobile clinics such as those
operated by the IRC suffer service interruptions
intermittently due to insecurity.
Humanitarian Need (continued)
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 17
Spotlight on Health
Given the near-total absence of government-sponsored
health services, CAR’s village health posts were
governed by a grassroots system called COGES (Comité
de la Gestion de la Santé), committees composed of
community-elected members. COGES sets costs for
consultations and medications and pays staff salaries.
Prior to the crisis, the IRC and other INGOs dedicated
significant resources to training COGES members and
health staff on diagnosis and treatment of STDs, malaria,
diarrhea and respiratory infections as well as neonatal,
obstetric and ante/postnatal care. This grassroots system
has all but collapsed with the crisis.
	 Many of the displaced health workers and COGES
members cannot, or chose not, to return to the
country or their health post due to continuing
insecurity or fear of retribution. INGOs thus have
fewer partners with whom to work and less access
to people whose needs have increased.
	 The Ministry of Health has not been able to
implement an alternative plan to compensate for the
nearly defunct COGES system. Instead, in August
2014, the ministry published a directive requiring
humanitarian organizations to support health facilities
comprehensively—in everything from rehabilitation,
to training, to the provision of drugs and payment
of salaries. The humanitarian presence on the
ground does not have the resources to provide this
blanket assistance, despite the ministry’s directive.
The plan does not promote sustainable recovery of
CAR’s health system and relies on the humanitarian
community to assume a role that should be covered
by the government.
	 COGES members have disclosed to IRC staff that
they are reluctant to exercise their duties (such as
oversight and corrective action of staff) given the
wide availability and circulation of arms. Some have
said that they fear “for their lives” should they upset
someone at one of the health posts.
An IRC-trained nurse weighs a baby at a hospital in Kaga Bandoro.
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic18
There are moments when you can’t even move
a truck because of gunfire. You may be meant
to give food in one zone, and when en route,
you are stopped by armed persons and pillaged.
Or you arrive at your target village, and the
village is attacked after you have completed
the distribution and left.
– WFP STAFF MEMBER
	 In 2014, WFP lost 454,634 tons of food to pillaging
en route or at points of distribution. WFP employees
report the consistent looting of food, leading some
partners, from health centers to church sites, to decline
distributing food on WFP’s behalf.
The roads are so poor that we must program
even four hours to travel 120 kilometers.
The bridges are in terrible condition and we
frequently have to unload tons of goods before
crossing and then reload.
– WFP STAFF MEMBER
	 The poor state of roads and bridges, together with
insecurity, slows down aid workers delivering food
and prevents Central Africans from reaching markets.
Food Security and Livelihoods
If nothing changes in CAR, insecurity will
continue to increase and the population will
no longer work in the fields out of fear of being
attacked. Famine will overcome families and
there will be a humanitarian catastrophe.
– IRC STAFF MEMBER
The ability of Central Africans to feed and support
themselves has been dramatically altered by the conflict.
Market linkages have been broken, fields lay fallow and
inflation is rampant. The slaughter of livestock and the
flight of pastoralists also have reduced the food supply.
The inability of Central Africans to harvest crops makes
it difficult for them to pay for education, purchase medicines
and satisfy other important needs. Further, if insecurity
disrupts the 2015 planting season, CAR will absorb another
negative shock in food security and malnutrition rates.
As recently as May 2015, OCHA projected that an estimated
32,000 children may experience severe acute malnutrition
(SAM) and approximately 78,000 will exhibit moderate acute
malnutrition (MAM).55
	 Harvests have decreased nearly 58 percent from
pre-crisis levels,56
while the fish supply and livestock
levels have declined nearly 40 percent and
77 percent respectively.57
Today we are in the dry season, so we don’t
cultivate. But we are going to have some serious
problems if we can’t access the fields come
May and June. We won’t have money to pay
for education, to eat. It causes marital problems.
The fields are our source for everything.
– FEMALE FARMER
	 The consumer price index for goods and services
increased 15 percent in 2014, eroding the purchasing
power of families.58
Staple foods experienced a
shocking inflation of 30 to 70 percent from March
to August 2014.59
Humanitarian Need (continued)
A family in a makeshift camp set up for displaced people
in Kaga Bandoro.
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 19
Spotlight on Delivery of Humanitarian Aid
Insecurity and the absence of governance or strong
institutions allow for the deliberate targeting of
humanitarian workers and have negative ramifications
for delivering goods and services to people in need,
even where humanitarian access is permissible:
	 Aid agencies have difficulty finding commercial
vendors and transporters, as commerce was largely
monopolized by Central African Muslims, 80 percent
of whom reportedly have fled the country. Existing
entrepreneurs are fearful of traveling due to
ongoing attacks and pillaging of trucks.
	 Insecurity-related blockages at the Cameroon-CAR
border lead to pipeline breaks, slowing down the
import of goods.
	 Delivery is often delayed in-country as aid workers
and transporters wait for other providers to travel in
convoys for enhanced protection.
	 The TG has reversed the NGO import tax exoneration
policy, adding to financial difficulties for INGOs
(neither donors nor NGOs had foreseen these costs)
and creating significant delays at customs.
We can’t travel with significant amounts
of cash. It is too much of a security risk.
– INGO STAFF MEMBER
It is difficult to get work done due to the
state of roads plus insecurity. By the time
you get to a village where you are to distribute
goods, you only have two hours before you
have to leave because of sundown, and
return to base.
– IRC STAFF MEMBER
We have to react to the presence of armed
groups to avoid harm to our staff and
beneficiaries, and sometimes this means
we must postpone our services. One day
makes a lot of difference to someone
who is expecting food, seeds, a dignity kit,
or mobile clinic health care.
– IRC STAFF MEMBER
Humanitarian Access Constraints
by Category
Violence against
personnel and/or
assets
Limitations in physical
environment
Active hostilities
Interference in
implementation
Obstacles in accessing
population
Restriction of
movement within
the country
80%
2% 5% 7%
4%
2%
GRAPH 3 Data taken from OCHA’s March 2015 Humanitarian
Access Snapshot
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic20
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 21
Ongoing conflict-related insecurity, governance failure,
and displacement outpace the efforts of aid agencies
that seek to meet humanitarian needs. Add to the mix the
unpredictability of humanitarian funding commitments, and
the situation could prove catastrophic for a country that is
already a failed state by many measures, and lead to more
costly interventions for the international community in the
future. There is a risk to not investing holistically in CAR
now—to address simultaneously humanitarian need, the
root causes of conflict, long-term recovery, peace dividends
and sustainable development.
The IRC, with support provided by a research team
from the Johns Hopkins University School of Advanced
International Studies (SAIS), has projected what humanitarian
need in CAR could look like in two key areas—food security
and shelter—if insecurity persists and funding requirements
are not met. This risk model analyzes how these needs could
change as a result of various levels of humanitarian funding
and levels of conflict to the end of 2015.60
(See appendix:
IRC-SAIS Research Methodology  Limitations for the
methodology behind the model, including the baseline used,
assumptions, calculations and caveats.) Specifically, low,
medium and high levels of funding are compared alongside
improving, status quo and worsening levels of crisis (defined
on the next page). The IRC also conducted an analysis of
no funding to estimate the effect of the crisis in absence of
humanitarian aid.
After evaluating both ACLED’s conflict data and the UN
Financial Tracking Service (FTS) database, and looking at
historic trends in CAR’s conflict and funding, the following
parameters (defined on the next page) were established
to forecast various scenarios (calculations are described in
appendix: IRC-SAIS Research Methodology  Limitations):
N.B. For context, as of May 2015, CAR’s parameters are as
follows: below low funding threshold (21 percent of the SRP)
and lessening conflict (31 conflict-related incidents/mo.).
Risk
OPPOSITE PAGE: A Seleka soldier in the central Nana-Gribizi province. The group, accused of rape, killings and extended looting, overtook Bangui, the
capital of Central African Republic, and overthrew the government of President François Bozize on March 24, 2013.
A severely malnourished toddler is fed at Kaga Bandoro’s only hospital.
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic22
Tables: Scenario Projections of People in Need
All scenarios are given in terms of a probable interval of ± 10 percent to account for variation in the model’s prediction.
All output is in terms of people affected.
Food Insecurity (in terms of people)
No Funding Low Funding Mid Funding High Funding
Lessening conflict
1,038,594
to
1,269,392
844,931
to
1,032,693
669,157
to
817,857
499,318
to
612,720
Status quo conflict
1,612,700
to
1,971,000
1,317,400
to
1,610,200
1,106,200
to
1,352,000
910,800
to
1,113,200
Increasing conflict
2,824,600
to
3,452,200
2,520,700
to
3,080,800
2,348,000
to
2,869,188
2,070,000
to
2,530,000
Risk (continued)
The following parameters were used to forecast various scenarios
Funding Level Parameters:
	Low Funding (30 percent of SRP  previous
bilateral funds) = food security: $58,134,222,
shelter: $7,331,947
	Mid Funding (60 percent of SRP 
previous bilateral funds) = food security:
$116,268,644, shelter: $14,663,894
	High Funding (90 percent of SRP 
previous bilateral funds) = food security:
$174,402,966, shelter: $21,995,84161
Conflict Level Parameters:
	Lessening Conflict: Average 55 conflict-
related incidents/mo. (late 2014/early 2015
average)
	Status Quo Conflict: Average 85 conflict-
related incidents/mo. (2014 average)
	Increasing Conflict: Average 125 conflict-
related incidents/mo. (early 2014 average,
heightened conflict)62
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 23
Shelter Needs (in terms of people)
No Funding Low Funding Mid Funding High Funding
Lessening
conflict
257,000
to
314,200
197,700
to
241,600
131,400
to
160, 600
74,900
to
91,600
196,200
to
239,800
227,900
to
278,500
268,400
to
328,000
338,400
to
413,600
Status quo
conflict
350,400
to
428,300
291,000
to
355,600
220,000
to
269,000
163,700
to
200,000
180,000
to
220,000
226,300
to
276,500
266,800
to
326,100
336,800
to
411,700
Increasing
conflict
474,800
to
580,300
415,400
to
507,700
356,000
to
435,100
296,700
to
362,500
162,700
to
198,900
225,100
to
274,500
279,000
to
341,000
353,100
to
431,600
Emergency Shelter Assistance Rebuilding / Returning
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic24
Food Security Analysis
The model allows us to observe that without any
humanitarian aid, needs would be greater. For example,
according to the model, approximately 400,000 fewer people
would suffer from food insecurity at high versus low levels
of funding, at every level of conflict. Yet currently, funding
is not keeping up with the growing need. Despite spending
over $130 million on food security in 2014, which the model
shows to have the caloric purchasing power to meet the
needs of 500,000 people, actual food insecurity numbers
decreased only by 80,000. The analysis sheds light on the
barriers to meeting humanitarian need. Various scenarios
can be assessed to evaluate the interplay of aid and conflict.
If conflict is reduced significantly and domestic food
production restored, the number of people suffering from
food insecurity falls drastically. The largest possible reduction
could be envisaged through a low-conflict/high-aid scenario:
fewer than 55 incidents per month coupled with SRP funding
in excess of 90 percent would reduce food insecurity levels
to approximately 600,000 people. However, this scenario
demands high humanitarian aid levels, which is uncommon
when conflict subsides.
Alternatively, if the conflict reignites to levels seen in early
2014, more people will suffer from food insecurity at all
levels of aid. Conflict has a higher negative effect on
domestic food production, the import of agricultural goods
and food prices than the positive effect of food aid. If conflict
causes a further 10 percent deterioration of harvesting,
fishing and livestock levels, CAR would suffer a loss of
over 270 billion calories annually. Food aid would have to
total approximately $127 million just to purchase the same
amount of calories lost. In order to have any improvement in
food security there would need to be a combination of lower
conflict and increased funding.
Shelter Analysis
On average in 2014, every conflict-related incident
displaced 640 Central Africans.63
If security is not
established, and the number of conflict-related incidents in
2015 mirrors 2014 averages, the humanitarian community
can expect nearly 500,000 new displacements. Providing
500,000 newly displaced people with emergency shelter
and non-food items (NFIs) could cost upward of $40 million,
based on the reach of 2014 aid.
In a scenario of significantly decreased conflict, new
displacements ostensibly would also drop. Further, with
aid levels and interventions equivalent to 2014, CAR would
see a decreased need for emergency shelter. However, this
reduction must be assessed against an increased need for
permanent shelter in a more stable environment. Permanent
housing needs (assistance returning and rebuilding) will
likely increase as the conflict subsides, as there will be an
increase in returnees from within and neighboring countries.
Consequently, even in a scenario of decreased conflict,
the need for shelter solutions will grow nearly two-fold—
from 178,304 to upward of 320,000 persons—from those
identified in the 2015 SRP.
A worst-case scenario (no funding and increasing conflict)
results in total shelter needs for 800,000 persons, whereas
best-case scenario (high funding and decreasing conflict)
results in shelter needs for 500,000. In short, shelter needs
will remain high throughout 2015.
What this tells us
By comparing food security and shelter needs in a
range of conflict scenarios and at various aid levels, the
international community can gain a sense of the tremendous
importance of establishing security while providing
humanitarian assistance.
The aid provided by the international community has been
invaluable in reducing conflict-related food insecurity and
providing emergency shelter during the current crisis in CAR.
However the reality is that humanitarian aid simply cannot
keep up with the needs created by insecurity.
The estimate of the number of people in need in a low-
funding/lessening conflict scenario is almost on par
with the number of people in need in a high-funding/status
quo-conflict scenario. That is, humanitarian aid without
addressing security provides only partial benefits
to people in need.
Food insecurity is only effectively addressed at high levels
of humanitarian funding and by increasing domestic food
production by tackling insecurity. This is not possible if
displaced citizens do not feel secure enough to return
home, or if people do not feel safe enough to leave their
homes to pursue livelihoods. The risks to the people of CAR
underscore the vital importance of a fruitful peace dialogue.
Risk (continued)
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 25
governance. In sum, they represent the building blocks of a
potential stable nation.
Considering the vast scope of challenges on the table for
Central Africans, the outcomes of this high-stakes forum
are clear and comprehensive. They provide a roadmap
forward to address the most vexing challenges faced by
CAR. It should be noted, however, that this is the country’s
fifth national debate on peace and reconciliation since
1980. The forum, in fact, ended on an ominous note
with some Anti-balaka representatives walking out in
protest during the closing ceremony, and gunfire erupting
outside. The success of the Bangui Forum therefore, will
hinge greatly on implementation of the Pact, including
ongoing consultations among all key actors to make
sure their concerns are adequately represented, and
an international commitment to supporting CAR’s new
roadmap to the future.
Over 700 participants, key stakeholders of
national institutions and entities, against all
expectations, took part in this conference,
considered in everyone’s opinion to be the
last chance for the future of Central African
Republic.
– THE NATIONAL FORUM OF BANGUI REPORT
SYNTHESIS
The national peace dialogue, the Bangui Forum, took place
in May 2015. Nearly 700 political, religious and traditional
leaders as well as parties to the conflict, the private sector,
and civil society, gathered to propose a vision for a post-
conflict CAR. Others attending included leaders from donor
and neighboring countries, regional bodies, multilateral
institutions, and a host of international organizations
(including the International Conference on the Great Lakes
Region and the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation).
Participants were grouped into thematic commissions
with the objective of planning a way forward in four
categories: governance, economic and social development,
justice and reconciliation, and peace and security. The
governance commission addressed aspects of the
constitution, law and policy, and ways to ensure the Forum’s
outcomes will be accountable to the people. The economic
and social development commission deliberated on the
decentralization of the state, budget management, and
the application of an integrated recovery and economic
development strategy, targeting the most disadvantaged
areas of the country. The justice and reconciliation
commission dealt with impunity and national and local
reconciliation mechanisms. The peace and security
commission considered peace accords, disarmament, and
measures to assure the security of the population. In a
plenary session, the commissions proposed a range of steps,
which were subsequently adopted.
This (crisis) is a page in world history that is
being rewritten.
– M. Abdoulaye Bathily
SPECIAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE UN SECRETARY-
GENERAL FOR CENTRAL AFRICA, AND PRESIDENT OF
THE BANGUI FORUM PRESIDIUM
Two groundbreaking outcomes received particular attention.
First, the Anti-balaka and 10 factions of the Séléka reached
a new DDR agreement. Combatants are to give up their
weapons prior to national elections and demilitarized parties
will be integrated into state security sectors or benefit from
income-generating activities. Immunity will not be granted to
perpetrators of war crimes. Second, Séléka and Anti-balaka
representatives agreed to release all children in their ranks,
and humanitarian agencies will be granted immediate access
to them so family tracing and reunification can begin. While
these two outcomes are certainly notable and inspire hope
for CAR’s immediate future, the Forum’s other outcomes—
proposals adopted via the Pact—are equally important,
as they could serve as a roadmap for stability and good
Roadmap Forward
Pregnant women waiting for vaccinations at Castors
Health Centre, Bangui.
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic26
Key Adopted Proposals
Governance
	Constitutional amendments prohibiting
a rise to executive power by force;
establishment of a national, republican,
and multiethnic Central African army;
establishment of an independent High
Authority for Good Governance and
Anti-Corruption, with prosecutorial powers.
	A series of new laws and policies with a
view to ensure equality for all, with special
provisions for minorities, and protecting
religious liberty, citizenship and voting rights.
	National 10-year plans for increasing
access to education, employment and
health services.
	An emergency plan for extending state
authority throughout the country’s territory.
Justice and Reconciliation
	A special criminal court for conflict-related
crimes, rebellions and coups d’etats.
	Free and universal access to justice.
	Establishment of a truth and justice,
reparation and reconciliation commission.
	Creation of local peace and
reconciliation committees.
Economic and Social Development
	Efforts to secure transhumance corridors
in collaboration with pastoralists and farmers.
	The establishment of basic social services,
specifically education, health and hygiene,
as well as access to water and housing for
all victims of the crisis.
	A health policy including universal
health insurance.
	Rehabilitation and/or construction of
infrastructure in all areas, from transport
to communications to renewable energy.
Peace and Security
	Full implementation of the Brazzaville Accord.
	The establishment in law of a Bangui Forum
monitoring committee.
	Reparations for victims of “politico-
military” crises.
	Establishment of a mechanism
for transitional justice.
Roadmap Forward (continued)
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 27
Central Africans. The current transition, now embodied
through the Pact, requires sustained diplomatic attention
and financial support. Without DDR, the development of
transparent and inclusive governance mechanisms, and
sustained international focus, CAR could face increased
violence and further collapse. A stable security environment
is essential for Central Africans to return home, rebuild their
lives, and participate in a sustainable and inclusive transition.
Likewise, improved security is the building block for aid
agencies to gain humanitarian access and deliver lifesaving
services in a timely and effective manner.
Our problems are many. It is necessary
that the international community see our
problems as their own, because what happens
here will affect the whole region. If CAR isn’t
supported, CAR could disappear. We depend
on international community support for us
not to disappear.
– IRC LOCAL STAFF MEMBER
International donors and diplomats must recognize the need
to promote institution-strengthening activities and robust
humanitarian assistance at this critical time. In this vein, the
IRC encourages a multifaceted approach for short- and long-
term recovery that includes:
	 Investing in efforts to reduce insecurity, impunity and
violence.
	 Creating conditions that facilitate the delivery of
humanitarian assistance.
	 Establishing effective, inclusive and accountable
government institutions, including a police service that
protects civilians.
	 Setting CAR on a path toward sustained recovery and
development.
Despite the skepticism that some Central Africans expressed
in the lead up to the Bangui Forum, the dialogue’s outcomes
represent CAR’s best hope for peace and stability, and an
opportunity to arrest the cyclical violence that has plagued
the country for decades.
There is no doubt that if we maintain the status
quo, CAR will become a Somalia or a Libya.
– IRC LOCAL STAFF MEMBER
The tremendous amount of progress that the international
community, from diplomatic corps to humanitarian aid
agencies, has achieved since crisis newly broke out in
CAR cannot be underestimated. The country is not suffering
a campaign of ethnic cleansing, as the Commission of
Inquiry found to be true in 2014. However, the volatility of
CAR’s security environment cannot be underestimated.
Conflict incidence remains high, the vast majority of IDPs
have not returned home, refugee numbers have increased,
the TG has not established its presence throughout the
country, MINUSCA has not been able to secure the country,
and humanitarian aid agencies are severely restricted
from carrying out their mandates and reaching the most
vulnerable efficiently and effectively.
To determine whether the country is emerging from
crisis and moving toward stability, the IRC listened to
the voices of people whose lives have been impacted
by the conflict. Central Africans interviewed by the IRC
communicated resounding fear of the transition process
and skepticism about the national peace forum. They
identified security as their unmistakable and primary need
and specifically demanded a robust and rapid disarmament
process. The Bangui Forum’s outcomes, which address
many of these concerns, could reverse this fear and
skepticism with the right international support to see
through their implementation.
CAR’s history is one of poor governance, recurring political
violence and failed peace processes. The international
community has too often taken short-term approaches to
the deeply-rooted governance and security challenges facing
Conclusion
A girl from the Peul ethnic group near Ouandago. The Peul are a nomadic
community of herders.
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic28
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 29
	 MINUSCA should invest in civilian-military coordination
mechanisms to ensure its plans are informed by
priorities identified by civilians, local civil-society groups
and INGOs.
Create Conditions That Facilitate the
Delivery of Humanitarian Assistance
Recognize that CAR remains in crisis
	 Despite the deactivation of the Inter-Agency Standing
Committee (IASC) System-Wide Level 3 Emergency
Response for CAR, international support, is still
required.64
	 The 2015 Strategic Response Plan and the forthcoming
2016 appeal should be funded in total.
Expand humanitarian reach
	 Donors should commit to a robust and long-term
humanitarian presence in key locations, especially those
areas that remain underserved due to insecurity. UN
agencies, MINUSCA, and INGOs alike must commit to a
sustained presence in areas where the need is greatest.
	 Donors should resource MINUSCA to ensure they can
fulfill their protection mandate, improve security and, as
a result, increase the delivery of civilian-led humanitarian
assistance.
Facilitate the delivery of aid
	 The TG should restore tax-exempt status to INGOs to
ensure the maximum amount of humanitarian assistance
reaches those in need.
	 The TG should eliminate bureaucratic hurdles to
releasing INGO goods at customs and border control
points in order to facilitate the swift delivery of
assistance to people in need.
	 Donors should recognize the inordinate logistical costs
of operating in CAR and fund agencies appropriately so
that their operations are not compromised and people in
need are reached.
As long as insecurity and failed governance persist, the
international community cannot meet humanitarian needs or
help achieve durable peace in CAR. Furthermore, it must be
understood that humanitarian aid is not a long-term solution.
A holistic approach to the CAR crisis at this critical juncture
should address the obstacles that agencies such as the IRC
face in meeting humanitarian needs, while reducing the root
causes of conflict to ensure lasting peace and stability.
Invest in Efforts to Reduce Insecurity,
Impunity and Violence
Prioritize protection of the vulnerable
	 Donors should institute early-warning systems that
identify signs of potential conflict before it erupts
and prioritize funding of conflict-sensitive programs
that prevent and respond to violence against
civilians, including gender-based violence and child-
protection concerns.
Extend state authority
	 The international community should work with the TG
to support the redeployment of government authorities
in tandem with MINUSCA deployments, and to fund
the rehabilitation and reconstruction of public security
infrastructure such as courts, detention facilities,
prisons and gendarmeries.
Adequately support MINUSCA to protect
civilians
	 Troop-contributing countries should meet their
commitments and immediately deploy the remaining
2,379 uniformed and civilian personnel authorized by the
Security Council. Absent these commitments, MINUSCA
will be less able to fulfill its mandate to protect civilians.
	 Donors should supply MINUSCA with the equipment
necessary to carry out patrols and communicate
effectively internally within its own ranks and externally
with the humanitarian community and the civilians they
are protecting.
	 The international community and MINUSCA should
use their leverage with the TG to ensure the swift
implementation of the new DDR agreement.
Recommendations
OPPOSITE PAGE: Children in Kaga Bandoro, Central African Republic.
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic30
	 Donor governments and international financial
institutions should build state capacity to effectively
plan and manage human resources and public finances
to support service delivery.
	 Donor governments and international financial
institutions should support the creation and
implementation of policies that remove financial barriers
to health and education for impoverished and conflict-
affected people.
Strengthen the social contract between citizens
and the state
	 The TG should facilitate the dissemination of information
about government roles and responsibilities as well as
civic rights and responsibilities to all Central Africans,
particularly women and members of vulnerable and
marginalized groups.
	 The TG should expand spaces for state-society dialogue
and collaboration that are inclusive of the viewpoints of
Central Africans from all groups and geographic areas
of the country. These spaces should bring together
duty bearers (service providers, local authorities, etc.)
and community members and/or their representatives
(service users, civil society organizations, etc.) in settings
such as town hall meetings, and health and school
management committees.
	 The international community should strengthen the
capacity of civil-society organizations to mobilize and
support civic engagement in participatory decision-
making (e.g., inclusive planning and budgeting
processes) regarding government-provided health,
education and other basic services, and to hold the
state accountable for addressing needs.
	 The international community should support state
institutions to recognize civic rights and engage
constructively with the population, and to demonstrate
greater responsiveness to the needs, priorities and
concerns of the people.
Prioritize investments in areas that most
impact people’s lives
	 Prioritize among the areas identified in the 2015
Strategic Response Plan to ensure the most basic
humanitarian needs are addressed throughout the
country.
  	Extend food security programming beyond IDP and
returnee target groups to all conflict-affected Central
Africans in need. Ensure that access to and availability
of nutritious food is prioritized.
	 Dedicate resources to meet the specific needs of
women and girls; address both restoration of livelihoods
and the violence they experience.
	 Redouble efforts to resource the opening of primary and
secondary schools and invest in extended psychosocial
and reintegration programs for former child soldiers and
all children affected by the crisis.
	 Reestablish primary health services, including the
introduction of community-based care. Maintain funding
for mobile outreach services until primary health care is
accessible to all conflict-affected Central Africans.
Support The Establishment of
Effective, Inclusive and Accountable
Government Institutions
Build accountable institutions
	 Donor governments and international financial
institutions should develop and finance comprehensive
strategies for institution building and improved
government service provision. The following should be
implemented and staffed with adequate resources:
–– Investment in “immediate peace dividends” that
support disarmament and build trust between
Central Africans and their institutions, including
employment and livelihood opportunities, and
increased access to basic services for all.
–– Support for rebuilding of core state functions in
order to establish greater legitimacy (including
delivery of health, education, legal, and security
services, among others).
Recommendations (continued)
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 31
	 The TG should continue to consult with an ever-widening
array of civil-society representatives to develop and
implement the commissions’ strategies and to evaluate
their impact on Central Africans’ lives.
Commit to funding recovery
	 Donor governments and international financial
institutions should commit to financing the
implementation of effective strategies that emerge
from the Pact.
	 Bilateral donors should ensure their development
and humanitarian assistance offices are aligned and
coordinated to achieve maximum impact on both short-
and long-term needs.
	 Donors should provide funding that links
reconstruction and development, including support
for mechanisms such as the European Trust Fund
for the Central African Republic.
Set Car on Path Toward Sustained
Recovery and Development
Pursue peace
	 The international community should support the
International Contact Group in its continued pursuit
of a political solution to the CAR crisis through
sustained diplomatic engagement with the TG and
parties to the conflict.
Support the development of the May
2015 Republican Pact for Peace, National
Reconciliation and Reconstruction
	 International donors, organizations and financial
institutions should support the Bangui Forum proposals
by working with the four commissions—Governance,
Economic and Social Development, Justice and
Reconciliation, and Peace and Security—to develop
implementation strategies, including a robust monitoring
and evaluation plan to meet milestones.
Central African women, Kaga Bandoro.
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 33
7.	 “The elections are questionable—will the process
be transparent and will legitimate authorities be put
in place?”
8.	 “The international community must be involved to
establish the rule of law to help the Central African
administration recover—at least until it’s up and
running—and to strengthen security in all of CAR
and the neighboring countries.”
9.	 “What we are asking of the international community
is not food. We are asking the international community
to disarm combatants so that we can go home to the
neighborhoods we abandoned when we came to these
IDP sites. Neither food nor the small income-generating
activities at these sites will allow us to go home.”
10.	 The international community knows that things happen
here, but we only hear silence. The truth is not told
because if it were, people would understand that
stability hasn’t yet returned to the country.”
APPENDIX: IRC-SAIS Research
Methodology  Limitations
The figures given below were used as baseline
measurements, on which the risk model for humanitarian
need in food security and shelter was built.
Baseline
Humanitarian Need
According to the 2015 Strategic Response Plan (SRP)
the following are the current needs in food security and
emergency shelter:
	 1,520,000 people are in need of emergency
food assistance.
	 259,736 people are in need of emergency
shelter assistance.
	 178,301 people are in need of assistance
returning/rebuilding.65
Conflict Levels
The follow represent the level of conflict at the end of 2014
and its effects on hazards:
	 Risk: Level of conflict, which averaged 85 conflict-
related incidents in 2014.66
APPENDIX: IRC Report Caveats
The IRC’s humanitarian character prohibits it from taking
a position on the viability or the timeline of elections; any
reference to elections are intended to communicate the
views of Central Africans interviewed for this report.
The IRC has done its best to ensure that all information
relayed in this report is accurate as of the time of publication
(June 2015). The information presented herein is subject
to change, particularly in light of the volatility of the crisis
in CAR.
APPENDIX: From the Field—Messages
to the International Community
The IRC asked Central Africans who consented to an
interview what they would like to communicate to donors
and policymakers in the international community. Here
is a selection of messages:
1.	 “We need to multiply the number of blue helmets and
patrols along the border. The army is not present and
MINUSCA is trying to fill the gap, but they don’t have
the forces or the resources to do this.”
2.	 “We call on the international community to assist in
the Brazzaville Accord’s implementation. The accord is
in place but not the measures, and the state is too weak.
We need help.”
3.	 “The international community has rallied to take care
of humanitarian needs but not security needs. Security
and demilitarization is required to be able to roll out
humanitarian activities in optimal conditions.”
4.	 “CAR is still in a period of convalescence. It is too soon
for the humanitarian community to depart. We still need
donors, even after the elections. I fear for a catastrophe
if humanitarian assistance is withdrawn.”
5.	 “CAR is not the first country to live through a crisis.
Donors and supporters must change to help us fix the
system —above all, improve education. If people were
more educated, they would think more before engaging
in conflict. Those that are uneducated are manipulated.”
6.	 “In the DDR process, if the first D is missed, then the
second D and the R will never work. The first D is not
happening and we may see another rebellion.”
Appendices
OPPOSITE PAGE: Muslim returnee in front of the ruins of his home,
Bocaranga.
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic34
Humanitarian aid is resulting in an addition of calories
through two means, as per the SRP:
	 Aid spent on direct food assistance (food baskets,
vouchers).
	 Aid spent on indirect food assistance (agricultural
trainings, farming inputs).
The model measures food security in terms of calories,
including both the number of calories provided through
intervention funded by humanitarian aid, as well as the
number of calories lost due to the level of crisis. Caloric
intake was chosen as the measurement of food security,
as numerous sources cite the need for approximately
2,100 daily calories, including the World Food Programme.74
Although it is not a perfect measure of food security,
a Food Security Information Network study found a
significant correlation between the Food Consumption
Score (a measurement of both quality and quantity of diet)
and caloric intake. Furthermore, the measurement of 2,100
calories is cited by the SRP as their measurement for
food security; for the sake of consistency this definition is
maintained.
The model then measures the effect on calories of each one
percent change in funding (based on a calculation of calories
bought per dollar of aid), as well as the caloric effect of each
one percent change in hazards. The effects of both a change
in funding and a change in hazards are then combined to get
the overall effect on calories for an aggregate outcome.
The assumptions underlying the calculation of the effect
of humanitarian aid on food security are based on project
proposals submitted to the United Nations Financial Tracking
Service (FTS),75
as well as the food aid budgets of WFP and
USAID.76
By measuring the amount of calories purchased,
including overhead costs, per dollar, a measurement of the
relationship between aid spending and calories created
reach was calculated. The assumptions for the calculation
of the effect of change in the different hazards was based
on the level of output pre-crisis taken from the Food and
Agriculture Organization (FAO), then the number of calories
of said output was calculated based on calories/ton.
Shelter Security Assumptions and Calculations:
The model assumes that conflict is resulting in an increase
in shelter needs through two main means:
	 Hazards: Impact of conflict on key variables.
–– Harvesting levels: 58 percent reduction from
pre-crisis levels.
–– Fishing: 40 percent reduction from pre-crisis levels.
–– Livestock: 70 percent reduction67
from
pre-crisis levels.
–– Inflation: 10 percent68
from pre-crisis levels.
–– Agricultural imports: 27 percent reduction69
from pre-crisis levels.
–– Number of Displaced: 20 percent of the
population70
from pre-crisis levels.
Humanitarian Aid Levels
2014 Humanitarian aid funding:71
	 SRP: funded at $382.2 million, 69 percent of requested.
	 Additional bilateral and multilateral: $111 million.
–– $106.5 million of this was given to food security
via the SRP, and an additional $30 million
(approximate) was given to food security outside
of the SRP from bilateral and multilateral donors.
–– $9.1 million of this was given to the shelter cluster
via the SRP, while an additional (approximate)
$10 million in aid was given through bilateral
and multilateral donors.
2015 humanitarian aid funding to date:72
	 SRP: funded at $115.2 million, 19 percent of requested.
	 Additional bilateral and multilateral funding:
$51.6 million.
Food Security Assumptions and Calculations:
Based on the current literature, our model assumes
that conflict is resulting in a loss of calories through four
main means:73
	 Reduction in agricultural production.
	 Reduction in agricultural imports.
	 Inflation levels lowering purchasing power.
	 Humanitarian food aid lost (diverted/pillaged/theft).
Appendices (continued)
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 35
to account for all aspects of domestic food production
in CAR. However the model accounts for those which
make up a significant portion of CAR’s production, as
reported by FAO, including cassava, cereals, livestock,
milk products, fish, and bananas. Furthermore, the level
of conflict as reported by ACLED may have limitations,
given the fluid level of conflict in CAR. Despite the above
limitations, the model is based on the most accurate
data available, which are regularly used by numerous
humanitarian and development agencies.
2.	 The population distribution used in the food security
model is a normal distribution and may not fully
represent the distribution of food security in CAR,
however, without a census of caloric intake of the entire
population, it would be impossible to build the true
distribution. Therefore a normal distribution is used as
the most likely representation. There is justification in
that this distribution matches the HNO statement that
30 percent of the population is moderately or severely
food insecure.
3.	 The model looks at the population of CAR as a whole
and therefore assumes somewhat equal access to
citizens in various areas. Given that this is unlikely,
the true need will vary slightly given the access to
different areas.
4.	 The model seeks to predict the need by the end of
2015 and there are limitations with that time frame; a
conflict that is only two years old provides a small pool of
sampling data, and therefore predicting the results of a
one year period, based on statistics from only two prior
years naturally assumes room for error.
5.	 Not all clusters are evaluated and it may be possible that
there are positive spillover effects between clusters, i.e.
assisting the WASH cluster may have a positive effect
on food security. This link is accounted for between
shelter and food security, but the effect of other clusters
on food and shelter are not accounted for.
6.	 There may be an oscillation in violence in CAR. If
violence drops and a large number of Central Africans
return, there may be an increase in tensions and violence
once again. This level of analysis is not conducted, given
the short time frame of this model, however, it would
need to be an important consideration in any model
projecting longer than the end of 2015.
	 Increase in the number of displaced (associated with
an increase in conflict).
	 Increase in the number of returnees (associated with
a decrease in conflict).
Humanitarian aid is resulting in a reduction in shelter needs
through two means:77
	 Aid spent on emergency shelter assistance.
	 Aid spent on permanent housing solutions including
assistance returning and rebuilding.
Shelter security is measured in terms of individuals
displaced. Shelter needs are determined by the number of
displacements due to conflict-related incidents. The Armed
Conflict Location  Event Data Project’s (ACLED) real-time
database,78
which tracks conflict-related incidents, was used
as the measurement of conflict in CAR. OCHA’s statistics79
were used to determine current displacement levels. By
looking at the relationship of these statistics, a correlation
was calculated to estimate the relationship between the level
of conflict-related incidents and the level of displacement.
Specific calculations concerning the reach of shelter aid are
based on project proposals submitted to the FTS, as well
as the previous shelter budgets of the UN by measuring
the cost of providing shelter to one displaced individual, a
per-dollar measurement was calculated of the relationship
between aid spending and shelter reach. The model then
measures the aggregate impact on shelter needs of any one
percent change in funding levels, as well as any one percent
change in conflict-levels.
Caveats
This model is, first and foremost, a statistical estimate, and
the following must be taken in to account when evaluating
the results:
1.	 The model relies on the best available data, but said
databases have their own limitations, including ACLED,
OCHA’s Humanitarian Needs Overview (HNO), SRP
and FTS, FAO, World Bank (WB), and International
Monetary Fund (IMF). There are limitations to each of
these sources including lack of comprehensive data,
and periodic and non-mandatory reporting, all of which
places limitations on gauging the full reach of aid. Said
limitations include the fact that the model is not able
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic36
The IRC intends to continue its activities in
Ouham Pendé, Nana Gribizi and Bangui, and
expand its activities in La Kémo, throughout
2015.
The IRC in CAR: The IRC works in the following
sectors in CAR:
	 Women’s Protection and Empowerment
	 Economic Recovery and Development and
Food Security
	Health
	 Child Protection
WASH activities will phase out in 2015 as environmental
health programming folds into other sectors, such as health
and economic recovery.
The IRC has its main office in Bangui and currently maintains
two field offices (Kaga Bandoro and Bocaranga). The IRC
implements programs in Bangui, Nana Gribizi, Ouham Pendé
and Ouham prefectures.
Staffing: The IRC in CAR operates with 15 expatriate staff
members and 90 national staff members.
Budget: The IRC in CAR has a projected budget of
approximately $9,500,000 for FY15. Funding for the IRC in
CAR is provided by SIDA, UNICEF, WFP, OFDA, EuropeAid,
CHF, Stichting Vluchteling and private donors.
Women’s Protection and Empowerment: The IRC
provides survivors of GBV with timely access to psychosocial
and health services, works with communities to reduce
risks confronting women and girls, and supports women’s
economic and social empowerment. The IRC established
safe spaces in Bangui, Nana Gribizi and Ouham Pendé,
where survivors can receive case management, counseling
and referrals to health care. The IRC also works at the
community level to prevent violence through advocacy
campaigns, focus groups and awareness sessions that
highlight the devastating effects of GBV and the importance
of protecting survivors.
APPENDIX: The IRC in CAR
The IRC began working in Central African Republic in
December 2006, following an eruption of violence that
caused thousands of people to flee their homes. In response
to the more recent power struggle between Ex-Séléka and
Anti-balaka groups in 2013, the IRC shifted to a multisectoral
intervention, and has since been working to help the most
vulnerable populations affected by this ongoing crisis—
especially women and children. The IRC strives to repair
social cohesion by laying the foundation for recovery and
self-reliance, helping displaced populations to return home,
facilitating economic recovery and restoring access to quality
basic services.
Approximately 20 percent of the country’s population has
been displaced by the current crisis, compounding prolonged
preexisting poverty. The situation remains extremely
volatile; while many IDPs started returning home in 2014,
436,119 people remain displaced throughout the country
(as of May 2015), 58,700 of who reside in 34 sites in CAR’s
capital city, Bangui.
The IRC in CAR has restored functionality at targeted health
centers, established mobile clinics in rural Ouham Pendé,
supported food distribution and economic recovery activities
in Nana Gribizi, and led emergency interventions for the
protection of women and children in Bangui.
Violence continues to force mass displacement countrywide,
destroying much of the country’s social fabric. The farming
community has missed a second planting season, and many
markets have ceased to function. Women and girls continue
to be vulnerable to gender-based violence (GBV), with cases
being reported to the IRC at alarmingly high rates. Children
remain at risk of abuse, exploitation and separation from their
families. Infrastructure, such as health points and sanitation
facilities, are not maintained, especially in rural areas, making
access to health care nearly impossible.
Although the IRC and other organizations are working across
these sectors, available funding remains inadequate or short
term in nature. In response, the IRC is seeking to establish
local networks with alert and response mechanisms to
provide information on security issues and threats to early
recovery; such information is intended to trigger appropriate
and timely responses, at first from the international
community, but increasingly from local actors.
Appendices (continued)
Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 37
Economic Recovery and Development: The IRC focuses
primarily on market-systems recovery by increasing
agricultural production and restoring microbusiness activities.
The overarching goal is to help local producers increase crop
and livestock yields. In addition, the IRC distributes seeds,
tools and food to help households restart and build resilience
against future shocks. The IRC also conducts market
analysis, trains producers on new and enhanced agriculture
techniques, provides support to small business enterprises,
and operates Cash-for-Work programs that provide local
people with short-term jobs on infrastructure construction
projects. The IRC also conducts cash transfers and income-
generating activities to allow individuals and women’s groups
to build knowledge and resources to run small businesses.
Environmental Health/WASH: Over the past year and a
half, the IRC built 396 latrines and 328 showers for people
living in displaced camps. The IRC rehabilitated water points
and sanitation infrastructure in 10 villages in Ouham Pendé
One of the key ways to bring stability back to CAR is to help people get back to work. The IRC has programs designed to train both men and women in
useful skills to help them find jobs or create small businesses.
and is also rehabilitating water points in 30 villages across
Nana Gribizi. The IRC also educates communities and
displaced people on the dangers of poor sanitation and the
importance of good hygiene.
Health: As one of few actors in Ouham Pendé prefecture,
the IRC is working to reestablish the health care system in
the region. In 2014, the IRC health program implemented
lifesaving activities for conflict-affected populations in 10
villages and is currently expanding to 15 health facilities in
La Kémo prefecture. The team initiated two mobile clinics
that bring free health care to people in need in four villages.
The IRC is also rehabilitating 15 looted health facilities,
training staff and providing incentives for them and
community health workers, as well as providing essential
medicines and medical devices worth $330,000. From
2014 through March 2015, the IRC mobile clinics and the
supported health facilities provided quality care to conflict-
affected populations through 22,154 curative consultations.
carreport
carreport
carreport
carreport
carreport

More Related Content

What's hot

National policy conference 2017 strategy and tactics
National policy conference 2017 strategy and tacticsNational policy conference 2017 strategy and tactics
National policy conference 2017 strategy and tacticsSABC News
 
Peace and security in west africa any role for the commonwealth
Peace and security in west africa   any role for the commonwealthPeace and security in west africa   any role for the commonwealth
Peace and security in west africa any role for the commonwealthKayode Fayemi
 
Lwf Dws Rwanda Presentation On Peace Regional Consultation Dsm
Lwf Dws Rwanda Presentation On Peace Regional Consultation DsmLwf Dws Rwanda Presentation On Peace Regional Consultation Dsm
Lwf Dws Rwanda Presentation On Peace Regional Consultation DsmBobby Waddell
 
Good governance module, Bishkek Academy, 2018
Good governance module, Bishkek Academy, 2018Good governance module, Bishkek Academy, 2018
Good governance module, Bishkek Academy, 2018Murod Khusanov
 
05 d increasing-womens-participation
05 d increasing-womens-participation05 d increasing-womens-participation
05 d increasing-womens-participationDr Lendy Spires
 
Poverty Reduction And Good Governance, Nepal
Poverty Reduction And Good Governance, NepalPoverty Reduction And Good Governance, Nepal
Poverty Reduction And Good Governance, Nepaluttamrregmi
 
IRD_Afghan_CaseStudy_29Apr14
IRD_Afghan_CaseStudy_29Apr14IRD_Afghan_CaseStudy_29Apr14
IRD_Afghan_CaseStudy_29Apr14John Engels
 
Women in peace making an AU-IGAD Strategy
Women in peace making an AU-IGAD StrategyWomen in peace making an AU-IGAD Strategy
Women in peace making an AU-IGAD StrategyCosty Costantinos
 
Asia Pacific Beijing20 CSO Forum Statement 16 Nov 2014
Asia Pacific Beijing20 CSO Forum Statement 16 Nov 2014Asia Pacific Beijing20 CSO Forum Statement 16 Nov 2014
Asia Pacific Beijing20 CSO Forum Statement 16 Nov 2014Dr Lendy Spires
 
National policy conference 2017 organisational renewal
National policy conference 2017 organisational renewalNational policy conference 2017 organisational renewal
National policy conference 2017 organisational renewalSABC News
 
Peacebuilding from below The case of Zimbabwe
Peacebuilding from below The case of ZimbabwePeacebuilding from below The case of Zimbabwe
Peacebuilding from below The case of ZimbabweSheunesu Hove
 
National policy conference 2017 communications
National policy conference 2017 communicationsNational policy conference 2017 communications
National policy conference 2017 communicationsSABC News
 
CSOSI Middle East North Africa-2020
CSOSI Middle East North Africa-2020CSOSI Middle East North Africa-2020
CSOSI Middle East North Africa-2020Jamaity
 
National policy conference 2017 social transformation
National policy conference 2017 social transformationNational policy conference 2017 social transformation
National policy conference 2017 social transformationSABC News
 
Geneva NGO Forum Beijing+20 Outcome Document
Geneva NGO Forum Beijing+20 Outcome DocumentGeneva NGO Forum Beijing+20 Outcome Document
Geneva NGO Forum Beijing+20 Outcome DocumentDr Lendy Spires
 
Decentralization in Unitary States
Decentralization in Unitary StatesDecentralization in Unitary States
Decentralization in Unitary StatesJamaity
 
05 c genderandpostconflictgovernance
05 c genderandpostconflictgovernance05 c genderandpostconflictgovernance
05 c genderandpostconflictgovernanceDr Lendy Spires
 

What's hot (19)

National policy conference 2017 strategy and tactics
National policy conference 2017 strategy and tacticsNational policy conference 2017 strategy and tactics
National policy conference 2017 strategy and tactics
 
Peace and security in west africa any role for the commonwealth
Peace and security in west africa   any role for the commonwealthPeace and security in west africa   any role for the commonwealth
Peace and security in west africa any role for the commonwealth
 
Lwf Dws Rwanda Presentation On Peace Regional Consultation Dsm
Lwf Dws Rwanda Presentation On Peace Regional Consultation DsmLwf Dws Rwanda Presentation On Peace Regional Consultation Dsm
Lwf Dws Rwanda Presentation On Peace Regional Consultation Dsm
 
Good governance module, Bishkek Academy, 2018
Good governance module, Bishkek Academy, 2018Good governance module, Bishkek Academy, 2018
Good governance module, Bishkek Academy, 2018
 
05 d increasing-womens-participation
05 d increasing-womens-participation05 d increasing-womens-participation
05 d increasing-womens-participation
 
Ms lina presentation
Ms lina presentationMs lina presentation
Ms lina presentation
 
Poverty Reduction And Good Governance, Nepal
Poverty Reduction And Good Governance, NepalPoverty Reduction And Good Governance, Nepal
Poverty Reduction And Good Governance, Nepal
 
IRD_Afghan_CaseStudy_29Apr14
IRD_Afghan_CaseStudy_29Apr14IRD_Afghan_CaseStudy_29Apr14
IRD_Afghan_CaseStudy_29Apr14
 
Women in peace making an AU-IGAD Strategy
Women in peace making an AU-IGAD StrategyWomen in peace making an AU-IGAD Strategy
Women in peace making an AU-IGAD Strategy
 
Asia Pacific Beijing20 CSO Forum Statement 16 Nov 2014
Asia Pacific Beijing20 CSO Forum Statement 16 Nov 2014Asia Pacific Beijing20 CSO Forum Statement 16 Nov 2014
Asia Pacific Beijing20 CSO Forum Statement 16 Nov 2014
 
National policy conference 2017 organisational renewal
National policy conference 2017 organisational renewalNational policy conference 2017 organisational renewal
National policy conference 2017 organisational renewal
 
Peacebuilding from below The case of Zimbabwe
Peacebuilding from below The case of ZimbabwePeacebuilding from below The case of Zimbabwe
Peacebuilding from below The case of Zimbabwe
 
National policy conference 2017 communications
National policy conference 2017 communicationsNational policy conference 2017 communications
National policy conference 2017 communications
 
CSOSI Middle East North Africa-2020
CSOSI Middle East North Africa-2020CSOSI Middle East North Africa-2020
CSOSI Middle East North Africa-2020
 
National policy conference 2017 social transformation
National policy conference 2017 social transformationNational policy conference 2017 social transformation
National policy conference 2017 social transformation
 
Geneva NGO Forum Beijing+20 Outcome Document
Geneva NGO Forum Beijing+20 Outcome DocumentGeneva NGO Forum Beijing+20 Outcome Document
Geneva NGO Forum Beijing+20 Outcome Document
 
Decentralization in Unitary States
Decentralization in Unitary StatesDecentralization in Unitary States
Decentralization in Unitary States
 
Public Administration as Governance
Public Administration as GovernancePublic Administration as Governance
Public Administration as Governance
 
05 c genderandpostconflictgovernance
05 c genderandpostconflictgovernance05 c genderandpostconflictgovernance
05 c genderandpostconflictgovernance
 

Viewers also liked

Viewers also liked (12)

PPP Slides
PPP SlidesPPP Slides
PPP Slides
 
TalkRite Communications, LLC ORM PowerPoint
TalkRite Communications, LLC  ORM PowerPointTalkRite Communications, LLC  ORM PowerPoint
TalkRite Communications, LLC ORM PowerPoint
 
NWS Alumni Profile
NWS Alumni ProfileNWS Alumni Profile
NWS Alumni Profile
 
Final Report
Final ReportFinal Report
Final Report
 
MS UEE42611 RPL Credit Application V2 copy
MS UEE42611 RPL Credit Application  V2 copyMS UEE42611 RPL Credit Application  V2 copy
MS UEE42611 RPL Credit Application V2 copy
 
CASA FLOORS
CASA FLOORSCASA FLOORS
CASA FLOORS
 
Week 8 portfolio
Week 8 portfolioWeek 8 portfolio
Week 8 portfolio
 
Diabetes
DiabetesDiabetes
Diabetes
 
Justin Beslity -Thesis
Justin Beslity -ThesisJustin Beslity -Thesis
Justin Beslity -Thesis
 
презентация 2013 2015 30.07.15
презентация 2013 2015 30.07.15презентация 2013 2015 30.07.15
презентация 2013 2015 30.07.15
 
MATERIAL SAFETY DATA SHEET FOR HALON.
MATERIAL SAFETY DATA SHEET FOR HALON.MATERIAL SAFETY DATA SHEET FOR HALON.
MATERIAL SAFETY DATA SHEET FOR HALON.
 
Unicode Hindi Typing Using Google Input Tool
Unicode Hindi Typing Using Google Input ToolUnicode Hindi Typing Using Google Input Tool
Unicode Hindi Typing Using Google Input Tool
 

Similar to carreport

The Acceptance of Tunisian Returnees from a Social Point of View
The Acceptance of Tunisian Returnees from a Social Point of ViewThe Acceptance of Tunisian Returnees from a Social Point of View
The Acceptance of Tunisian Returnees from a Social Point of ViewMaghreb Economic Forum (MEF)
 
337308-2022-TIP-REPORT-inaccessible.pdf
337308-2022-TIP-REPORT-inaccessible.pdf337308-2022-TIP-REPORT-inaccessible.pdf
337308-2022-TIP-REPORT-inaccessible.pdf中 央社
 
Political Will paper
Political Will paperPolitical Will paper
Political Will paperJoseph Yav
 
Case 4 space 1.2. presentation heike alefsen_undg.pptx
Case 4 space 1.2. presentation heike alefsen_undg.pptxCase 4 space 1.2. presentation heike alefsen_undg.pptx
Case 4 space 1.2. presentation heike alefsen_undg.pptxcase4space
 
BKAK Negros Presentation Flow.pptx
BKAK Negros Presentation Flow.pptxBKAK Negros Presentation Flow.pptx
BKAK Negros Presentation Flow.pptxJoshEusebio
 
Red Cross World Disaster Report- 2018
Red Cross World Disaster Report- 2018Red Cross World Disaster Report- 2018
Red Cross World Disaster Report- 2018Energy for One World
 
Preventing mass-atrocities
Preventing mass-atrocitiesPreventing mass-atrocities
Preventing mass-atrocitiesEhteshamul Hoq
 
Humanitarian imperative - Murtala Muhammed Foundation
Humanitarian imperative - Murtala Muhammed FoundationHumanitarian imperative - Murtala Muhammed Foundation
Humanitarian imperative - Murtala Muhammed FoundationMMFNG
 
Undp country programme doc. 2016 2020-en copy
Undp country programme doc. 2016 2020-en copyUndp country programme doc. 2016 2020-en copy
Undp country programme doc. 2016 2020-en copyAndrewCheatham7
 
Development Cooperation post COVID-19: Calling for a New Type of Global Solid...
Development Cooperation post COVID-19: Calling for a New Type of Global Solid...Development Cooperation post COVID-19: Calling for a New Type of Global Solid...
Development Cooperation post COVID-19: Calling for a New Type of Global Solid...Francois Stepman
 
Popular Participation & Decentralization in Africa
Popular Participation & Decentralization in AfricaPopular Participation & Decentralization in Africa
Popular Participation & Decentralization in AfricaJamaity
 
popular participation-decentralization-in-africa-min
popular participation-decentralization-in-africa-minpopular participation-decentralization-in-africa-min
popular participation-decentralization-in-africa-minJamaity
 
Financial Inclusion Briefing paper 07072016
Financial Inclusion Briefing paper 07072016Financial Inclusion Briefing paper 07072016
Financial Inclusion Briefing paper 07072016Jack Van Cooten
 
Myanmar_Protecting_Minority_Rights - 30 May 2013_FINAL REPORT
Myanmar_Protecting_Minority_Rights - 30 May 2013_FINAL REPORTMyanmar_Protecting_Minority_Rights - 30 May 2013_FINAL REPORT
Myanmar_Protecting_Minority_Rights - 30 May 2013_FINAL REPORTSushetha Gopallawa
 
Civic Space Africa Briefing Nov 2016 Eng
Civic Space Africa Briefing Nov 2016 EngCivic Space Africa Briefing Nov 2016 Eng
Civic Space Africa Briefing Nov 2016 EngDésiré Assogbavi
 
Dialogue policy brief-ilovepdf-compressed
Dialogue policy brief-ilovepdf-compressedDialogue policy brief-ilovepdf-compressed
Dialogue policy brief-ilovepdf-compressedEnayaba Napoleon
 

Similar to carreport (20)

The Acceptance of Tunisian Returnees from a Social Point of View
The Acceptance of Tunisian Returnees from a Social Point of ViewThe Acceptance of Tunisian Returnees from a Social Point of View
The Acceptance of Tunisian Returnees from a Social Point of View
 
2023 UNHCR global appeal.
2023 UNHCR global appeal.2023 UNHCR global appeal.
2023 UNHCR global appeal.
 
337308-2022-TIP-REPORT-inaccessible.pdf
337308-2022-TIP-REPORT-inaccessible.pdf337308-2022-TIP-REPORT-inaccessible.pdf
337308-2022-TIP-REPORT-inaccessible.pdf
 
Political Will paper
Political Will paperPolitical Will paper
Political Will paper
 
Case 4 space 1.2. presentation heike alefsen_undg.pptx
Case 4 space 1.2. presentation heike alefsen_undg.pptxCase 4 space 1.2. presentation heike alefsen_undg.pptx
Case 4 space 1.2. presentation heike alefsen_undg.pptx
 
BKAK Negros Presentation Flow.pptx
BKAK Negros Presentation Flow.pptxBKAK Negros Presentation Flow.pptx
BKAK Negros Presentation Flow.pptx
 
Red Cross World Disaster Report- 2018
Red Cross World Disaster Report- 2018Red Cross World Disaster Report- 2018
Red Cross World Disaster Report- 2018
 
Preventing mass-atrocities
Preventing mass-atrocitiesPreventing mass-atrocities
Preventing mass-atrocities
 
Humanitarian imperative - Murtala Muhammed Foundation
Humanitarian imperative - Murtala Muhammed FoundationHumanitarian imperative - Murtala Muhammed Foundation
Humanitarian imperative - Murtala Muhammed Foundation
 
Undp country programme doc. 2016 2020-en copy
Undp country programme doc. 2016 2020-en copyUndp country programme doc. 2016 2020-en copy
Undp country programme doc. 2016 2020-en copy
 
Development Cooperation post COVID-19: Calling for a New Type of Global Solid...
Development Cooperation post COVID-19: Calling for a New Type of Global Solid...Development Cooperation post COVID-19: Calling for a New Type of Global Solid...
Development Cooperation post COVID-19: Calling for a New Type of Global Solid...
 
Popular Participation & Decentralization in Africa
Popular Participation & Decentralization in AfricaPopular Participation & Decentralization in Africa
Popular Participation & Decentralization in Africa
 
popular participation-decentralization-in-africa-min
popular participation-decentralization-in-africa-minpopular participation-decentralization-in-africa-min
popular participation-decentralization-in-africa-min
 
Financial Inclusion Briefing paper 07072016
Financial Inclusion Briefing paper 07072016Financial Inclusion Briefing paper 07072016
Financial Inclusion Briefing paper 07072016
 
Myanmar_Protecting_Minority_Rights - 30 May 2013_FINAL REPORT
Myanmar_Protecting_Minority_Rights - 30 May 2013_FINAL REPORTMyanmar_Protecting_Minority_Rights - 30 May 2013_FINAL REPORT
Myanmar_Protecting_Minority_Rights - 30 May 2013_FINAL REPORT
 
Civic Space Africa Briefing Nov 2016 Eng
Civic Space Africa Briefing Nov 2016 EngCivic Space Africa Briefing Nov 2016 Eng
Civic Space Africa Briefing Nov 2016 Eng
 
Unchr statement
Unchr statementUnchr statement
Unchr statement
 
Unchr statement
Unchr statementUnchr statement
Unchr statement
 
Chair's Summary
Chair's SummaryChair's Summary
Chair's Summary
 
Dialogue policy brief-ilovepdf-compressed
Dialogue policy brief-ilovepdf-compressedDialogue policy brief-ilovepdf-compressed
Dialogue policy brief-ilovepdf-compressed
 

carreport

  • 1. Too Soon to Turn Away Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic International Rescue Committee | JULY 2015
  • 2.
  • 3. FRONT COVER: A boy with a homemade toy gun near Kaga Bandoro, Central African Republic. OPPOSITE PAGE: An elderly Muslim woman, displaced by sectarian violence, sheltering at Bangui’s main mosque. ©2015 International Rescue Committee | 122 East 42ND Street, New York, NY 10168 | Rescue.org Too Soon to Turn Away Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic International Rescue Committee | JULY 2015 Table of Contents 2 Executive Summary 4 Introduction 8 Insecurity 11 Governance 15 Humanitarian Need 21 Risk 25 Roadmap Forward 27 Conclusion 29 Recommendations 33 Appendices IRC Report Caveats From the Field: Messages to the International Community IRC-SAIS Research Methodology & Limitations The IRC in CAR 38 Endnotes 40 Acknowledgments
  • 4. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic2 Progress toward stability in the country was made between 2008 and 2012, but hope for a long-lasting peace was dashed in March 2013 when the Séléka Muslim rebel alliance overthrew the government of President François Bozizé and subsequently fractured into militias that exacted terror on Christian communities. Anti-balaka Christian self-defense groups sought retribution on Muslim communities and the country descended into ethnic and sectarian violence, with thousands fleeing their homes and the United Nations warning of a high risk of genocide. Only the intervention of French troops and an expanded UN peacekeeping force—and the efforts of international humanitarian aid agencies—prevented CAR from further descending into anarchy and humanitarian catastrophe. By May 2015, the worst of the crisis seemed to be over. Indeed, the Inter-Agency Standing Committee (IASC), which comprises all major humanitarian agencies inside and outside the UN system, removed CAR from its list of “Level 3 Emergencies”—the UN’s highest designation for a humanitarian crisis. However, the UN humanitarian appeal for CAR is dangerously underfunded. As of May, only $129.6 million of the $613 million proposed for humanitarian aid for 2015—just 21 percent—has been met.1 Once again, CAR seems destined to fade from the news and the focused attention of policymakers, meaning that it may never emerge from its decades-long cycle of failed governance, insecurity and human suffering. As the UN’s humanitarian coordinator, Claire Bourgeois, stated, “We must prevent the Central African Republic from becoming a forgotten crisis… The current funding for the strategic humanitarian response does not allow us to ensure the protection of all these displaced persons or to provide the minimum of what is needed to meet the huge humanitarian needs.”2 It would be a critical mistake for the international community to be lulled into thinking that stability has returned to the country. Conflict and insecurity continue to be the defining feature of life in CAR. The state has collapsed and armed groups rule the countryside, challenging each other and the shaky Transitional Government (TG) based in Bangui, the capital. The national army and police force are under- equipped, lack training and cannot ensure the population’s safety or security. The International Rescue Committee (IRC) is issuing this report with the intention of refocusing attention on the needs of the Central African people as well as on the obstacles the IRC and other humanitarian agencies are experiencing in trying to aid the population. The report is based on field research in CAR and draws on surveys and interviews with 85 conflict-affected Central Africans.3 Additionally, the IRC, with support provided by a research team from the Johns Hopkins University School of Advanced International Studies (SAIS), has projected what humanitarian need in CAR could look like in two key areas—food security and shelter—if insecurity persists and funding requirements are not met. The combination of field research and this analysis has led to the following key findings: Chronic insecurity, misrule and failed governance are the biggest obstacles to meeting the humanitarian needs of Central Africans. Central Africans themselves cite these problems as reason for skepticism that the country will manage peaceful elections and transition to a new government. The impact of humanitarian assistance is muted by the lack of comprehensive investment designed to bring stability to the country and support long-term institution building. Humanitarian assistance is desperately needed and blunts the impact of the crisis on Central Africans, but it is only palliative. For the international community to make a difference it must employ everything in its tool kit to ensure stability —diplomacy, peacekeeping, and humanitarian and development assistance. The international community cannot afford to wait for ideal conditions to lay the groundwork for CAR’s future. It must take an approach that allows for security and good-governance to take root while significantly increasing investment to meet humanitarian needs. The international community should seize a superb opportunity right now. In May 2015, parties to the conflict, religious and traditional leaders, and members of civil society adopted The Republican Pact for Peace, National Reconciliation and Reconstruction, at the close of a long-awaited national peace dialogue, the Bangui Forum. Donors, humanitarian agencies and the International Contact Group on the Central African Republic, in tandem with CAR’s Transitional Government, The Central African Republic (CAR) has been unstable since its independence from France in 1960 and is one of the least-developed countries in the world. It has endured a succession of coups and decades of misrule and lawlessness. Executive Summary
  • 5. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 3 can meet humanitarian needs and stabilize the country by lending their full diplomatic and financial support to this pact, an investment in the rebirth of a stable nation governed by effective, inclusive and accountable institutions. Failing to support it will inevitably lead to new and expensive chapters for both Central Africans and those who endeavor to assist them. Summary of Recommendations Invest in efforts to reduce insecurity, impunity and violence Insecurity continues to shape life in the Central African Republic. This instability disrupts markets, destroys communities and causes people to flee their homes. Every effort must be made to create a secure environment where citizens do not live in fear and can lead productive lives. The UN peacekeeping mission in CAR (MINUSCA) must be fully staffed and resourced. State authority should be extended across the country by establishing public security infrastructure such as courts, prisons and police services that respect the rights of civilians. Significant efforts must be made to swiftly disarm, demobilize and reintegrate combatants from all sides of the conflict to prevent ongoing violence in communities. As efforts are being made to create basic security, international humanitarian donors should prioritize funding for conflict-sensitive programs that prevent and respond to violence against civilians, particularly women and children. Create conditions that facilitate the delivery of humanitarian assistance Even with a reduction in violence from the peak of the recent crisis in CAR, a humanitarian catastrophe continues to unfold. Despite the deactivation of the “Level 3” emergency status, humanitarian assistance is still desperately needed and nearly 900,000 people remain displaced. Every effort must be made to extend life-saving assistance and basic services to conflict-affected Central Africans, including to those in areas far outside Bangui. Donor governments should not turn away from humanitarian needs prematurely and should fully fund humanitarian appeals. The Transitional Government of CAR in turn should remove unnecessary obstacles to humanitarian operations. It should not delay humanitarian materials in customs and should restore the tax-exempt status of international non-governmental organizations (INGOs). Support the establishment of effective, inclusive and accountable government institutions Prior to the conflict, the ability of the state to provide basic services like education and health to its population was weak. Central Africans had very little direct ability to hold their government accountable or shape the decisions it made. Donors and international financial institutions should work with the Transitional and future governments in CAR to overcome these challenges by strengthening the ability of the state to manage public resources and provide basic services. The social contract between citizens and their government should also be strengthened through increased information sharing, expanded spaces for dialogue between people and the state, and new opportunities for participatory decision-making. Set CAR on a path toward sustained recovery and development Without lasting peace, it will be impossible to move beyond the humanitarian crisis in CAR. Sustained diplomatic engagement with the Transitional Government and parties to the conflict is critical to breaking out of an endless cycle of violence and poverty. The international community must seize upon the Republican Pact for Peace, National Reconciliation and Reconstruction. Funding should be aligned to areas of the Pact that are critical to resolving the crisis and establishing a path to a better future: governance, economic and social development, justice and reconciliation, and peace and security. The Transitional Government should continue to consult with an ever-widening array of civil- society representatives to develop, implement and evaluate plans that emerge from the Pact. A Central African woman, Kaga Bandoro.
  • 6. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic4 The Central African Republic (CAR) has been marred by corruption, poor governance and chronic instability, all of which have contributed to the country’s cyclical violence and stagnation.4 The latest conflict, triggered by a coup d’état in late 2012—the country’s fifth since independence in 1960—plunged CAR deeper into crisis and increased the need for humanitarian aid. The state, already dubbed a phantom state,5 failed. One of the world’s worst humanitarian emergencies unfolded, with 6,000 people dead and nearly one million displaced.6 The already fragile health system collapsed, with 42 percent of facilities damaged, 50 percent looted and 68 percent experiencing a shortage of medicine.7 Significant declines in harvests and livestock8 have impacted the income of over three-fourths of CAR’s agricultural workers, as well as the food security of the entire population. The international community, from diplomatic corps to militaries to humanitarian aid agencies, has mobilized to halt the violence, create the conditions for dialogue between armed rivals, and deliver lifesaving assistance to Central Africans. Starting in 2013, French, European Union (EU) and African Union (AU) troops, as well as UN peacekeepers, deployed to CAR to protect civilians. In July 2014, international mediators facilitated a ceasefire agreement, known as the Brazzaville Accord. Donors and their partners have delivered at least $493 million in humanitarian assistance.9 By early 2015, the crisis appeared to be abating; EU troops withdrew and the French began to draw down their military presence. In April 2015, the Transitional Government (TG) held grassroots consultations to query the general public on their views on reconciliation. This culminated in May in a national peace dialogue dubbed the Bangui Forum, which adopted “The Republican Pact for Peace, National Reconciliation and Reconstruction,” a roadmap for peace and sustainable development. As a result of these positive developments, CAR could be in a position to hold national and legislative elections by the close of 2015. These events indicate progress toward peace. Yet stability remains elusive. The Brazzaville Accord was not recognized by factions of armed groups and thus not fully implemented. Despite the deployment of international forces and the installment of a transitional government, insurgent groups continue to burn, loot and murder, creating new chaos throughout the country. Nearly 900,000 people—20 percent of the total population—remain displaced. Until a strategy and concomitant funding are in place for the realization of the new Republican Pact for Peace, National Reconciliation Introduction Conflict background In March 2013, a coalition of predominantly Muslim rebels, the Séléka alliance, ousted President Bozizé, bringing Michel Djotodia to power. Djotodia subsequently lost control of the alliance as it fractured into multiple militias that embarked on a campaign of terror against Christian communities. Due to the complete breakdown in law and order, Christian self-defense groups, known as the Anti-balaka (AB), sought retribution against Muslim communities, going on a “campaign of ethnic cleansing,” as described by the International Commission of Inquiry. At the apex of the crisis (late 2013/early 2014), the French launched Operation Sangaris, deploying 1,600 troops to support the 3,700 MISCA (the AU’s International Support Mission to CAR) troops on the ground. President Djotodia resigned and current interim-president Samba-Panza was elected. By September 2014, power was transferred from MISCA to MINUSCA, a multidimensional UN peacekeeping operation with a mandate to protect civilians. In July 2014, Séléka and Anti-balaka signed a ceasefire agreement, the Brazzaville Accord, eliciting international support for CAR’s transition toward durable political, security and humanitarian solutions (via the International Contact Group on the Central African Republic). In May 2015, the Bangui Forum was held, bringing all national stakeholders to the table to set forth a plan for reconciliation and sustainable peace. Elections are due to take place by the end of 2015.
  • 7. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 5 An IRC survey conducted shortly after the grassroots consultations found that many displaced and conflict- affected Central Africans strongly questioned whether the country is undergoing a positive transition.11 (The consultations were carried out in all 16 of CAR’s prefectures, but the effort elicited only 4,000 interviews, or a mere .08 percent of the population.) Central Africans, at least those responding to interviews, felt that their participation in CAR’s peace process has been nearly nonexistent; they did not view the Bangui Forum as a harbinger of peace when large-scale disarmament, demobilization and reintegration (DDR) of combatants had yet to take place—a process they gave top priority. The Central Africans interviewed overwhelmingly said they desire security first, then a political process toward peace. In fact, despite assertions to the contrary from members of the international community, there is little indication that Central Africans are returning home from refugee and internally displaced persons (IDP) camps12 and it remains a question whether the country is truly on a path to sustainable recovery. Sadly, the conditions that gave rise to the conflict continue to exist. A hollow state created discontent among the disenfranchised, resulting in cyclical violence and and Reconstruction (hereafter referred to as the Pact), CAR’s political direction may remain uncertain, causing continued instability. Despite this prognosis, humanitarian funding has dropped well below what is required to meet the immense and growing needs of those affected by the crisis. As of May, only $129.6 million of the $613 million proposed for humanitarian aid for 2015—just 21 percent—has been funded.10 The drop in humanitarian funding reflects a lack of international attention to CAR and could signal a growing complacency with regard to humanitarian needs facing the country. The International Rescue Committee (IRC) is issuing this report with the intention of refocusing attention on the needs of the Central African people and on the efforts to stabilize the country by strategically investing in the Pact. The IRC sought answers to the following questions: Is CAR emerging from crisis and moving toward stability? Are the needs of people affected by crisis in CAR being met? What are the main challenges to meeting humanitarian needs? Elderly men and women participate in a meeting held by a local women’s association, Bocaranga, Ouham Pendé.
  • 8. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic6 humanitarian crises. The TG currently lacks authority: warring parties continue to vie for control, weapons freely circulate and banditry is rampant. Not only does the population remain at risk, but the humanitarian community faces tremendous obstacles to deliver basic aid because of the country’s lawlessness. Despite the skepticism of many Central Africans, the Pact that emerged from the Bangui Forum offers an opportunity for dialogue and for the international community to ramp up its efforts at a critical moment—while understanding that aid is not a long-term solution. A coherent approach to CAR must include: Robust investment in efforts to reduce insecurity, impunity and violence. Concerted action to create conditions that facilitate the delivery of humanitarian assistance. Resolute support for the establishment of effective, inclusive and accountable government institutions. Prolonged commitment to set CAR on a path toward long-term recovery and development. A holistic approach to the crisis in CAR must address the obstacles that humanitarian agencies face in meeting the needs of conflict-affected people while working toward long-term stability. Displacement Figures, May 2015 58,700 Bangui 48,400 OMBELLA-M’POKO 6,500 KEMO 35,200 LOBAYE 22,200 MAMBÉRÉ-KADEI 18,700 NANA-MAMBÉRÉ 7,300 OUHAM-PENDÉ 82,500 OUHAM 64,800 OUAKA 15,100 HAUTE-KOTTO 2,700 BAMINGUI BANGORAN 1,300 VAKAGA 6,700 BASSE- KOTTO 11,000 MBOMOU 15,700 HAUT- MBOMOU 2,900 SANGHA- MBAÉRÉ 97,195 DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC OF THE CONGO 26,704 CONGO 247,245 CAMEROON 94,024 CHAD SUDAN SOUTH SUDAN 26,300 NANA-GRIBIZI Source: IDMC and OCHA Introduction (continued)
  • 9. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 7 A Sample of Central African Voices The war is not over, as one can see in Kaga Bandoro. There is a lethargy vis-à-vis the CAR. The international community is mobilizing for Boko Haram, but what about us? —LOCAL AUTHORITY Security Council Resolution 2127 has not resulted in anything! There are still killings. Why isn’t MINUSCA doing its job? I was a refugee in Cameroon and I have only been back in Bocaranga for 44 days. I want to see 2127 applied here. – MUSLIM RETURNEE We came here because we were scared; when DDR happens in all the neighborhoods and the situation gets better, each and every one of us will be ready to go home … I have no desire to be here; I want to go home but I can’t because there is no DDR. – IDP IN BANGUI I have no faith in the Bangui Forum; this is not our first dialogue … the recommendations were never applied. – COMMUNITY LEADER Will our vote count? No one in Cameroon talked to us about elections. We felt totally excluded from everything—the election process, the peace process. People are sensitized here but no one is going to refugee camps [to get our opinions]. – MUSLIM RETURNEE I am a bit confused by the elections calendar. The census is not yet done and the people are not yet disarmed. … This is critical. Recall that the current crisis was set off by the 2011 elections. There was trickery. … So we need a process, a real and coherent way to organize the new elections so we don’t descend into crisis again with accusations of trickery or nonparticipation. – LOCAL AUTHORITY We said we are happy with the consultation but this is not the case. We could have another conflict right away. Our representatives lied. – IRC STAFF MEMBER Zianabu Djoguel. President of the Hand in Hand Women’s Association of Koui, Koui, Ouaham Pendé.
  • 10. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic8 According to humanitarian agencies, as well as Central Africans themselves (the IRC interviewed program beneficiaries), CAR remains plagued by: Border insecurity: Militia groups, including armed Chadians, continue to launch cross-border raids; there have been multiple reports of elements of the Chadian National Army attacking villages in CAR. Transhumance-related battles:16 Pastoralists and farmers continue to clash over local resources such as pasturelands. Ongoing conflicts: Authorities are trying to reestablish presence over ex-Séléka and other armed elements; violence continues between existing and new non-state actors. Banditry and criminality: Individuals and former militia members continue to capitalize on the security vacuum and absence of rule of law to attack and pillage villages, service-center points (health posts, religious sites, charitable organizations, etc.) and transport vehicles. Lack of a functioning police service: Absence of a police force whose mission and purpose is to provide rule of law and protect citizens. For Central Africans, the breakdown of law and order in the country is a matter of life and death and fuels displacement. Recent displacement trends underscore that violence in CAR has not subsided. Conflict-related incidents have gone down drastically in comparison to 2014, but the overall displacement figure still hovers just below 900,000, roughly 84 percent of what it was at the peak of the violence in January 2014. While the number of IDPs has decreased significantly (to 436,119) since the height of the conflict, the number of new refugees flowing into neighboring countries has increased (to 460,542 as of mid-May 2015).17, 18 Overlaying IDP displacement figures with data on the number of conflict-related incidents shows a notable trend: displacement levels rose sharply on the heels of increased conflict and decreased sharply when conflict-related incidents dropped after January 2014. Several factors influence IDP numbers. While it is unknown if the reduction in IDPs is due to individuals either going home or becoming refugees, the trend shows a positive correlation between conflict and IDP numbers, meaning that conflict will need to be staunched in order to prevent further displacement. Insecurity Conflict in CAR has decreased since 2013, due in part to the deployment of international forces. The current peacekeeping operation, the UN’s Multidimensional Integrated Stabilization Mission in the Central African Republic (MINUSCA), has played an important role in civilian security, from proactive efforts to dislodge armed elements from government buildings, to passive protection offered by the mere presence of police and military staff. The mission, however, faces significant challenges, including a slow scale- up,13 limited logistical resources, and a lack of government counterparts, all of which have had direct repercussions on MINUSCA’s ability to implement its protection-of-civilians strategy—particularly in regard to DDR. MINUSCA and its military predecessors (MISCA, Operation Sangaris, EUFOR) have encountered resistance and violent attacks during disarmament attempts. A new DDR agreement was only signed in May 2015; its viability is yet to be determined. Conflict Incident Trends Year Monthly Average 2014 88 2013 42 2012 7 2011 1.2 2010 13 MINUSCA’s actions have improved security in the country, but the number of conflict-related incidents (as tracked by the Armed Conflict Location and Event Data Project, or ACLED), remains too high to describe conditions as stabilizing. The number of incidents in 2015 (through end of April)14 stands at 123, an average of 31 per month,15 far exceeding the level of conflict prior to the onset of this crisis in 2013.
  • 11. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 9 Graph 1: IDP Numbers in Relation to Number of Conflict-Related Incidents 0 200,000 400,000 600,000 800,000 900,000 700,000 500,000 300,000 NumberofCentralAfricanIDPs NumberofConflict-RelatedIncidents 100,000 250 200 150 100 50 0 APR2015 MAR2015 FEB2015 JAN2015 DEC2014 NOV2014 OCT2014 SEP2014 AUG2014 JUL2014 JUN2014 MAY2014 APR2014 MAR2014 FEB2014 JAN2014 DEC2013 IDPs Conflict-Related Incidents GRAPH 1 This graph overlays ACLED’S conflict-related incident numbers with OCHA IDP figures Since the height of the conflict in January 2014, over 300,000 more refugees have sought safety in countries neighboring CAR. Continued lawlessness in the country, and refugee outflows, could have adverse security implications in a region already plagued by conflict and violence. It has long been feared that the current security vacuum, coupled with a near total absence of law and order, might lead to fertile terrain for terrorist groups such as Boko Haram. While this has not materialized, the humanitarian community has seen a worrying encroachment of the Lord’s Resistance Army (LRA) into CAR. In 2014, LRA attacks and abductions in CAR increased compared to 2012 and 2013. As the Uganda People’s Defense Force, with backing from the United States, has pursued the LRA in southeastern CAR, the insurgents have moved further north and west. In the first three months of 2015, tracked incidents decreased; however, this may be a short-lived trend.19 It may be partially attributable to the fact that the LRA has moved into areas where LRA crisis watchers are not active, and civilians may not be able to identify which armed group is attacking them.20 Insecurity in Numbers 436,119 The number of people displaced within the country, living in fear of violence and human-rights violations.21 More than 36,000 The number of people trapped in seven enclaves with limited access to basic services and at risk of violence and abuse.22 1,455 The number of security incidents recorded since January 2014, of which 166 (or 11 percent) were direct violence against humanitarians. In April 2015, 127 security incidents were recorded, with 17 percent against aid workers (specifically, humanitarian worker kidnappings).23 18 The number of aid workers killed between January 2014 and January 2015.24 12,000 The estimated number of armed ex-Séléka currently making up the three factions of the former coalition.25 75,000 The estimated number of anti-Balaka members distributed across the country, according to their leaders, though some sources put the figure as low as 20,000.26
  • 12. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic10
  • 13. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 11 mentioned the need for more INGOs in CAR. These beliefs are reinforced by the fact that in some places INGOs are subsidizing the salaries of health workers. The absence of a functioning state and good governance has led some Central Africans to fundamentally misunderstand the role of the state in regard to basic services for citizens. The roads haven’t been fixed in over 50 years. —WOMEN’S GROUP LEADER The lack of investment in infrastructure is also quite evident. Roads and bridges are so dilapidated that their condition severely impedes the delivery of humanitarian assistance. World Food Programme (WFP) and IRC staff members note that in some areas it takes up to four hours to travel 120 kilometers,27 and the WFP has had to pay to repair bridges to facilitate the transport of food aid. Loss of control of territory: Both INGO staff and Central Africans spoke of rebel groups providing security rather than the state. In the northwest, the rebel group Révolution et Justice has established checkpoints. IRC staff members in Kaga Bandoro spoke of ex-Séléka as the only authority recognized by locals. Even in places where government authorities and/or MINUSCA are present, some Central Africans still see armed groups as holding de facto power. Erosion of legitimate authority, inability to provide services and loss of control of territory, coupled with widespread corruption and criminality, involuntary movement of populations, and sharp economic decline, are markers of a failed state.28, 29 When the communities have issues, they take their complaints to Séléka and not the sous- préfet, because he has no authority. Séléka is truly the one in power. In fact, Séléka occupies all buildings (in Kaga Bandoro). The sous-Préfet is sitting at home while his office is occupied by Séléka. —NGO STAFF MEMBER CAR arguably has suffered a governance crisis since the country’s independence in 1960. Indeed, as far back as 2007, the International Crisis Group (ICG) labeled CAR a “phantom state…lacking any meaningful institutional capacity at least since the fall of Emperor Bokassa in 1979.” This underscores that the current crisis is not new, but embedded in decades of governance failure. The governance crisis has become more acute and is manifesting itself in the following ways: We don’t feel the efforts of the government here in Ouham Pendé. It feels as if we are abandoned. We have no resources to do our work, no police, no office, nothing. —PUBLIC SERVANT, BOCARANGA Erosion of legitimate authority: Central Africans spoke of feeling “abandoned by the government.” Despite the strides made by the TG with the support of MINUSCA, authorities have not been deployed to many of the country’s prefectures. In addition, armed groups have threatened or engaged in battle with foreign security actors to impede the establishment of a government presence. Where authorities have been deployed, many serve as figureheads. For example, in Bocaranga, the sous-préfet (the equivalent of a local governor) has no resources or mechanisms to carry out his work. The gendarmerie (military police station) remains burnt and pillaged. We were assigned here in 2013 but we have just gotten to our posts because of serious financial difficulties. We had no transport, so we had to hitchhike to get here; the last time we had access to vehicles was during Bokassa’s tenure. —GENDARMES Inability to provide public services: From beneficiaries to community leaders to other key informants, the overwhelming majority of Central Africans interviewed described a near total absence of public services. When queried on quality education, health, legal services and management of natural resources, interviewees referenced INGOs as the expected provider of those services, and Governance OPPOSITE PAGE: A destroyed house sits abandoned by its owners who cannot return to their neighbourhood due to insecurity, Bangui.
  • 14. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic12 Governance (continued) Spotlight on MINUSCA “Concerned with the security, humanitarian, human rights and political crisis in the Central African Republic and its regional implications, the Security Council authorized on 10 April 2014 the deployment of a multidimensional United Nations peacekeeping operation—MINUSCA, with the protection of civilians as its utmost priority. Its other initial tasks included support for the transition process; facilitating humanitarian assistance; promotion and protection of human rights; support for justice and the rule of law; and disarmament, demobilization, reintegration and repatriation processes.” 30 In recognition of the complete breakdown of the state, the Security Council endowed the mission with ’urgent temporary measures’31 to accord MINUSCA the possibility of taking on some basic law and order functions of the state. MINUSCA was meant to help the TG establish authority. Yet CAR’s continuing instability, nearly one year into the mission, begs the question: why do insecurity and governance failure continue to be the biggest obstacles to both Central Africans and aid agencies in meeting needs? Particular constraints surrounding both the CAR crisis and the MINUSCA mandate pose significant challenges to real gains in stability. Mission Mandate: The protection of civilians is an ambitious goal in an environment where multiple actors are perpetrating widespread violence against civilians and the TG does not have the capacity to contribute significantly to the protection of civilians within its borders. As such, MINUSCA must determine how to prioritize its scarce resources between its various mandated objectives and tasks. The UN Security Council (UNSC) helped MINUSCA to prioritize protection by sequencing its mandate, directing the mission to first implement primarily protection-related tasks and to delay many other activities until resources and conditions permit. Unfortunately, the UNSC did not go far enough in its efforts to narrow initial mandated activities, leaving room for the dilution of resources away from protection activities.32 Mission Strategy: MINUSCA must also determine which threats and vulnerable populations it will address and which are beyond its limited capabilities. All peacekeeping operations mandated to protect must develop a mission-wide strategy to determine which protection risks it will prioritize. MINUSCA’s mission- wide protection strategy is one of the most advanced of any peacekeeping operation, drawing on the latest UN policies and best practices.33 In order to respond to a dynamic environment, protection risks are prioritized in a “flashpoint matrix,” developed in consultation with other protection stakeholders. However, the success of the strategy depends on MINUSCA’s ability to respond flexibly and rapidly to evolving threats on the ground, which is something peacekeepers struggle with for many reasons, including, but not limited to, a lack of situational awareness, poor information and communication mechanisms and protocols, inadequate logistics and assets and a lack of political will of some troops to act. Mission Authority: In recognition of the absence of governance structures throughout the country, including those that contribute to the rule of law, the TG invited the UN to accept temporary authority and maintain law and order by arresting and detaining criminals.34 The Security Council refused, but did give MINUSCA the authority to We [INGO] have been in the CAR for eight years, through different stages of crisis and calm. I keep hearing from the population that they want us to stay for years and years, but this exposes a bigger problem—that there is an expectation that NGOs run the country. I understand that with such limited service delivery, communities feel that the government has not served them well, but NGOs, whether international or national, are not the long-term solution to providing services. The expectation and dependency factor concern me, and it affects meetings and messaging because we seem to return to this perception. —IRC STAFF MEMBER
  • 15. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 13 operate under “urgent temporary measures” which allow UN police to detain and arrest, “but only when national forces were not present or operational, on a temporary and exceptional basis, without creating a precedent, and without prejudice to the established principles of peace operations.”35 MINUSCA has been implementing this aspect of its mandate by arresting “high-value” targets.36 However, MINUSCA has to turn over arrested persons to the TG, which has limited capacity to protect prisoners, ensure they stay in prison and are tried in courts according to international standards.37 Mission Guidance: The UN Department of Peacekeeping Operations and Department of Field Support have recently released a formal policy on the protection of civilians in peacekeeping38 as well as protection of civilian’s guidelines for the military components of peacekeeping operations. However, given that this formal guidance was issued in 2015, the extent to which peacekeeping personnel in MINUSCA, or any mission, are aware of it and/or trained in its implementation is unknown at this time. Mission Strength: MINUSCA is currently authorized to deploy 12,870 total uniformed personnel, including 10,750 military personnel and 2,120 police. As of 31 March 2015, only 9,902 total uniformed personnel were deployed (8,305 military personnel and 1,466 police). Even at full strength, troops will continue to be spread thinly across the vast country, and will be largely limited to the main axes. MINUSCA does not have the numbers to establish a protection presence in all areas, much less in remote rural areas where civilians are under threat. Further, the lack of available Formed Police Units (FPUs)39 means that MINUSCA FPUs are limited to focusing on Bangui. Beyond numbers, troops and police may not have the adequate training or assets that would allow them to project themselves beyond limited areas of operation. Collectively, these challenges leave MINUSCA in a difficult situation. The conditions do not allow for the mission to fully carry out its stabilization mandate or implement its protection strategy. With a long list of resource-heavy priority tasks, a lack of state security forces, an absence of a justice system, and an insufficient number of personnel, assets and equipment, MINUSCA’s hands are often tied.40 The mandate listed seven priority tasks with at least 20 subtasks that the mission should focus on in the initial phase. The mandate rightfully included tasks related to the physical protection of civilians, human rights monitoring, good offices and political support for efforts to address root causes of the conflict, and support to reconciliation and mediation at the national and local levels in this initial phase. However, it also included tasks to extend state authority. Furthermore, the mandate decided that MINUSCA should undertake approximately 10 additional tasks as resources and conditions permit, but did not identify what conditions were necessary to trigger the additional activities.41 Members of the Seleka rebel militia, Central African Republic.
  • 17. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 15 Rampant insecurity and the government’s inability to provide basic services in large areas of the country have exacerbated the humanitarian situation. Despite reduced violence and an international humanitarian response, needs far outstrip the level of assistance being channeled toward CAR. The number of people requiring emergency assistance has increased since 2014 and stands to get worse if significant efforts are not made to address the causes and consequences of the crisis. A relative comparison of humanitarian appeal funding levels shows the Strategic Response Plan (SRP) funded at 21 percent in May 2015 versus 32 percent in May 2014. In actual terms nearly $50 million more was given to the SRP in CAR by this time in 2014.42 Funding Levels for SRP to CAR: 2014 versus 2015 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 DECNOVOCTSEPAUGJULJUNMAYAPRMARFEBJAN Fundinginabsoluteamount–millionsofUSD PercentageofSRPtoCARfunded Amount given to SRP in USD millions 2014 Amount given to SRP in USD millions 2015 Percentage of SRP funded in 2014 Percentage of SRP funded in 2015 GRAPH 2 Funding levels for the Strategic Response Plan, data based on the UN OCHA Financial Tracking Service OCHA identified 2.7 million in need of emergency humanitarian assistance in 2015, an increase from 2.5 million43 in 2014. Among those, 1.5 million are suffering from food insecurity, and the entire 2.7 million require protection assistance.44 The humanitarian appeals likely underestimate the full scope of need given the inaccessibility of remote and insecure regions. Moreover, despite the strong focus on IDPs in various appeals, there is very little data on the specific needs of IDPs outside of Bangui.45 The following represents just a snapshot of the challenges faced by Central Africans: Women and Girls Women and girls face significant threats to their personal safety. They risk rape and other forms of gender-based violence (GBV), particularly when they collect firewood and go to fields to farm. IRC assessments in Kaga Bandoro revealed that some women and girls have had to turn to negative coping strategies, including transactional sex, to offset the impact of their loss of livelihoods. No formal protection structures function outside Bangui to facilitate assistance to suvivors. Women face GBV, specifically sexual violence, at shocking rates. In 2014, women and girls reported over 1,500 incidents of violence to the IRC: 71 percent were acts of rape, 23 percent physical assault, three percent sexual assault, two percent psychological and/ or emotional abuse, and one percent denial of resources, opportunities or services.46 In the bush and forest, women and girls are exposed to terrible things. But with the crisis, they continue to go to the bush, looking for what they can to subsist—firewood, caterpillars, mushroom, fish—since their livelihoods have been ravaged. Things happen to them when they go to the forest. —IRC STAFF MEMBER There has been no cessation in sexual and other forms of gender-based violence since the peak of the crisis in CAR. The IRC continues to see high numbers of reported incidents. Yet, as of May 2015, the Protection Cluster has not received any funding specifically to address GBV. Before we had a referral system with the police and justice personnel. Now, there is no justice. There is 100 percent impunity for rape perpetrators in Bocaranga. —IRC STAFF MEMBER Humanitarian Need OPPOSITE PAGE: Kaga Bandoro has the region’s only hospital. Last year, advancing rebels ransacked the wards, stealing generators, mattresses, medicines, and even bed frames. In one of the damaged wards, severely malnourished toddlers receive milk and peanut paste.
  • 18. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic16 The Guidelines for GBV Prevention and Response in Humanitarian Settings call for access to safety, security, health and legal services, but given the limited access to basic services—including safe spaces and health structures, the absence of authorities and existing impunity—these guidelines are difficult to apply. Without police and courts, alleged perpetrators cannot be detained and survivors are vulnerable to reprisals. Both increased poverty and the threat of sexual violence are cited as main reasons for early and forced marriage. The IRC has noted a decrease in the average age of marriage for girls, some as early as age 12. Child Protection Children are most vulnerable to conflict, and an estimated 2.3 million children in CAR have been affected by the crisis in 2014.47 The impact is devastating; children may lose contact with family members and they may be victims of, witness or even be forced to carry out acts of horrific violence. Even prior to the crisis, children had been associated with armed groups, including self-defense militias allied to President Bozizé,48 and two out of every three children had never attended primary school. With the advent of the crisis, children were forcibly conscripted into armed forces; Save the Children staff also report that some joined under pressure from family or peers, or to avenge acts of violence perpetrated against them or their families.49 An estimated 10,000 children are associated with armed forces.50 UNICEF has requested $73.9 million in 2015 for child soldier reintegration and rehabilitation efforts in CAR, but as of April 30, only $17 million has been funded. As of July 2014, 59 percent of schools remained closed due to the absence of teachers, school buildings being occupied by armed groups, and continuing insecurity. While this figure has surely changed with the reduction in the intensity of the conflict, children in many areas have now missed two full school years or more. OCHA reported in May 2015 that constant population movements and the volatile security situation in central and eastern provinces, especially in Nana- Gribizi Province, still hinder the provision of structured education and the timely delivery and distribution of school supplies. Save the Children recently found that over 60 percent of school-aged children CAR suffer from post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), having either witnessed or experienced extreme violence during the conflict.51 These children require case management services and psychosocial support to help them recover and heal. While some services are available, the demand far exceeds the current capacity. Children have allegedly been abused by those designated to protect them. In April 2015, an internal report commissioned by the UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights revealed allegations of sexual abuse of young boys at an IDP site in Bangui at the hands of French, Chadian and Equatorial Guinean troops. Children interviewed for the report state that they were exploited in exchange for food and money. Health The crisis has had a profound impact on morbidity and mortality in CAR, a country that already had one of the world’s shortest life expectancies, and the highest under-five and maternal mortality rates.52 Central Africans have long suffered from a near-total absence of government-sponsored health services, a situation made worse by the flight of the limited pool of health professionals, including those who had benefited from years of INGO-led training and support. Village health posts53 are now staffed by unskilled personnel. Many health centers and posts have been looted, burnt or otherwise abandoned. Meanwhile, as of April 2015, only three percent of health needs are met through the CAR humanitarian appeal, while 80 percent of functional health facilities depend on support from the humanitarian sector.54 IRC health program staff have witnessed an increased prevalence in the rates of malaria, diarrhea, acute respiratory infections (ARIs) and acute emergency cases. They also cite gender-based violence and malnutrition as major public health issues. A six-to-12-month gap in public health services during the height of the conflict led to an interruption in the vaccination of children, treatment for chronic diseases such as HIV/AIDS, and other essential medical services. Essential medicines such as paracetamol, antibiotics, antidiarrheals and antimalarials are difficult to procure locally, and if brought abroad or from the capital, their transport is complicated by poor infrastructure and insecurity. Similarly, mobile clinics such as those operated by the IRC suffer service interruptions intermittently due to insecurity. Humanitarian Need (continued)
  • 19. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 17 Spotlight on Health Given the near-total absence of government-sponsored health services, CAR’s village health posts were governed by a grassroots system called COGES (Comité de la Gestion de la Santé), committees composed of community-elected members. COGES sets costs for consultations and medications and pays staff salaries. Prior to the crisis, the IRC and other INGOs dedicated significant resources to training COGES members and health staff on diagnosis and treatment of STDs, malaria, diarrhea and respiratory infections as well as neonatal, obstetric and ante/postnatal care. This grassroots system has all but collapsed with the crisis. Many of the displaced health workers and COGES members cannot, or chose not, to return to the country or their health post due to continuing insecurity or fear of retribution. INGOs thus have fewer partners with whom to work and less access to people whose needs have increased. The Ministry of Health has not been able to implement an alternative plan to compensate for the nearly defunct COGES system. Instead, in August 2014, the ministry published a directive requiring humanitarian organizations to support health facilities comprehensively—in everything from rehabilitation, to training, to the provision of drugs and payment of salaries. The humanitarian presence on the ground does not have the resources to provide this blanket assistance, despite the ministry’s directive. The plan does not promote sustainable recovery of CAR’s health system and relies on the humanitarian community to assume a role that should be covered by the government. COGES members have disclosed to IRC staff that they are reluctant to exercise their duties (such as oversight and corrective action of staff) given the wide availability and circulation of arms. Some have said that they fear “for their lives” should they upset someone at one of the health posts. An IRC-trained nurse weighs a baby at a hospital in Kaga Bandoro.
  • 20. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic18 There are moments when you can’t even move a truck because of gunfire. You may be meant to give food in one zone, and when en route, you are stopped by armed persons and pillaged. Or you arrive at your target village, and the village is attacked after you have completed the distribution and left. – WFP STAFF MEMBER In 2014, WFP lost 454,634 tons of food to pillaging en route or at points of distribution. WFP employees report the consistent looting of food, leading some partners, from health centers to church sites, to decline distributing food on WFP’s behalf. The roads are so poor that we must program even four hours to travel 120 kilometers. The bridges are in terrible condition and we frequently have to unload tons of goods before crossing and then reload. – WFP STAFF MEMBER The poor state of roads and bridges, together with insecurity, slows down aid workers delivering food and prevents Central Africans from reaching markets. Food Security and Livelihoods If nothing changes in CAR, insecurity will continue to increase and the population will no longer work in the fields out of fear of being attacked. Famine will overcome families and there will be a humanitarian catastrophe. – IRC STAFF MEMBER The ability of Central Africans to feed and support themselves has been dramatically altered by the conflict. Market linkages have been broken, fields lay fallow and inflation is rampant. The slaughter of livestock and the flight of pastoralists also have reduced the food supply. The inability of Central Africans to harvest crops makes it difficult for them to pay for education, purchase medicines and satisfy other important needs. Further, if insecurity disrupts the 2015 planting season, CAR will absorb another negative shock in food security and malnutrition rates. As recently as May 2015, OCHA projected that an estimated 32,000 children may experience severe acute malnutrition (SAM) and approximately 78,000 will exhibit moderate acute malnutrition (MAM).55 Harvests have decreased nearly 58 percent from pre-crisis levels,56 while the fish supply and livestock levels have declined nearly 40 percent and 77 percent respectively.57 Today we are in the dry season, so we don’t cultivate. But we are going to have some serious problems if we can’t access the fields come May and June. We won’t have money to pay for education, to eat. It causes marital problems. The fields are our source for everything. – FEMALE FARMER The consumer price index for goods and services increased 15 percent in 2014, eroding the purchasing power of families.58 Staple foods experienced a shocking inflation of 30 to 70 percent from March to August 2014.59 Humanitarian Need (continued) A family in a makeshift camp set up for displaced people in Kaga Bandoro.
  • 21. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 19 Spotlight on Delivery of Humanitarian Aid Insecurity and the absence of governance or strong institutions allow for the deliberate targeting of humanitarian workers and have negative ramifications for delivering goods and services to people in need, even where humanitarian access is permissible: Aid agencies have difficulty finding commercial vendors and transporters, as commerce was largely monopolized by Central African Muslims, 80 percent of whom reportedly have fled the country. Existing entrepreneurs are fearful of traveling due to ongoing attacks and pillaging of trucks. Insecurity-related blockages at the Cameroon-CAR border lead to pipeline breaks, slowing down the import of goods. Delivery is often delayed in-country as aid workers and transporters wait for other providers to travel in convoys for enhanced protection. The TG has reversed the NGO import tax exoneration policy, adding to financial difficulties for INGOs (neither donors nor NGOs had foreseen these costs) and creating significant delays at customs. We can’t travel with significant amounts of cash. It is too much of a security risk. – INGO STAFF MEMBER It is difficult to get work done due to the state of roads plus insecurity. By the time you get to a village where you are to distribute goods, you only have two hours before you have to leave because of sundown, and return to base. – IRC STAFF MEMBER We have to react to the presence of armed groups to avoid harm to our staff and beneficiaries, and sometimes this means we must postpone our services. One day makes a lot of difference to someone who is expecting food, seeds, a dignity kit, or mobile clinic health care. – IRC STAFF MEMBER Humanitarian Access Constraints by Category Violence against personnel and/or assets Limitations in physical environment Active hostilities Interference in implementation Obstacles in accessing population Restriction of movement within the country 80% 2% 5% 7% 4% 2% GRAPH 3 Data taken from OCHA’s March 2015 Humanitarian Access Snapshot
  • 22. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic20
  • 23. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 21 Ongoing conflict-related insecurity, governance failure, and displacement outpace the efforts of aid agencies that seek to meet humanitarian needs. Add to the mix the unpredictability of humanitarian funding commitments, and the situation could prove catastrophic for a country that is already a failed state by many measures, and lead to more costly interventions for the international community in the future. There is a risk to not investing holistically in CAR now—to address simultaneously humanitarian need, the root causes of conflict, long-term recovery, peace dividends and sustainable development. The IRC, with support provided by a research team from the Johns Hopkins University School of Advanced International Studies (SAIS), has projected what humanitarian need in CAR could look like in two key areas—food security and shelter—if insecurity persists and funding requirements are not met. This risk model analyzes how these needs could change as a result of various levels of humanitarian funding and levels of conflict to the end of 2015.60 (See appendix: IRC-SAIS Research Methodology Limitations for the methodology behind the model, including the baseline used, assumptions, calculations and caveats.) Specifically, low, medium and high levels of funding are compared alongside improving, status quo and worsening levels of crisis (defined on the next page). The IRC also conducted an analysis of no funding to estimate the effect of the crisis in absence of humanitarian aid. After evaluating both ACLED’s conflict data and the UN Financial Tracking Service (FTS) database, and looking at historic trends in CAR’s conflict and funding, the following parameters (defined on the next page) were established to forecast various scenarios (calculations are described in appendix: IRC-SAIS Research Methodology Limitations): N.B. For context, as of May 2015, CAR’s parameters are as follows: below low funding threshold (21 percent of the SRP) and lessening conflict (31 conflict-related incidents/mo.). Risk OPPOSITE PAGE: A Seleka soldier in the central Nana-Gribizi province. The group, accused of rape, killings and extended looting, overtook Bangui, the capital of Central African Republic, and overthrew the government of President François Bozize on March 24, 2013. A severely malnourished toddler is fed at Kaga Bandoro’s only hospital.
  • 24. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic22 Tables: Scenario Projections of People in Need All scenarios are given in terms of a probable interval of ± 10 percent to account for variation in the model’s prediction. All output is in terms of people affected. Food Insecurity (in terms of people) No Funding Low Funding Mid Funding High Funding Lessening conflict 1,038,594 to 1,269,392 844,931 to 1,032,693 669,157 to 817,857 499,318 to 612,720 Status quo conflict 1,612,700 to 1,971,000 1,317,400 to 1,610,200 1,106,200 to 1,352,000 910,800 to 1,113,200 Increasing conflict 2,824,600 to 3,452,200 2,520,700 to 3,080,800 2,348,000 to 2,869,188 2,070,000 to 2,530,000 Risk (continued) The following parameters were used to forecast various scenarios Funding Level Parameters: Low Funding (30 percent of SRP previous bilateral funds) = food security: $58,134,222, shelter: $7,331,947 Mid Funding (60 percent of SRP previous bilateral funds) = food security: $116,268,644, shelter: $14,663,894 High Funding (90 percent of SRP previous bilateral funds) = food security: $174,402,966, shelter: $21,995,84161 Conflict Level Parameters: Lessening Conflict: Average 55 conflict- related incidents/mo. (late 2014/early 2015 average) Status Quo Conflict: Average 85 conflict- related incidents/mo. (2014 average) Increasing Conflict: Average 125 conflict- related incidents/mo. (early 2014 average, heightened conflict)62
  • 25. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 23 Shelter Needs (in terms of people) No Funding Low Funding Mid Funding High Funding Lessening conflict 257,000 to 314,200 197,700 to 241,600 131,400 to 160, 600 74,900 to 91,600 196,200 to 239,800 227,900 to 278,500 268,400 to 328,000 338,400 to 413,600 Status quo conflict 350,400 to 428,300 291,000 to 355,600 220,000 to 269,000 163,700 to 200,000 180,000 to 220,000 226,300 to 276,500 266,800 to 326,100 336,800 to 411,700 Increasing conflict 474,800 to 580,300 415,400 to 507,700 356,000 to 435,100 296,700 to 362,500 162,700 to 198,900 225,100 to 274,500 279,000 to 341,000 353,100 to 431,600 Emergency Shelter Assistance Rebuilding / Returning
  • 26. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic24 Food Security Analysis The model allows us to observe that without any humanitarian aid, needs would be greater. For example, according to the model, approximately 400,000 fewer people would suffer from food insecurity at high versus low levels of funding, at every level of conflict. Yet currently, funding is not keeping up with the growing need. Despite spending over $130 million on food security in 2014, which the model shows to have the caloric purchasing power to meet the needs of 500,000 people, actual food insecurity numbers decreased only by 80,000. The analysis sheds light on the barriers to meeting humanitarian need. Various scenarios can be assessed to evaluate the interplay of aid and conflict. If conflict is reduced significantly and domestic food production restored, the number of people suffering from food insecurity falls drastically. The largest possible reduction could be envisaged through a low-conflict/high-aid scenario: fewer than 55 incidents per month coupled with SRP funding in excess of 90 percent would reduce food insecurity levels to approximately 600,000 people. However, this scenario demands high humanitarian aid levels, which is uncommon when conflict subsides. Alternatively, if the conflict reignites to levels seen in early 2014, more people will suffer from food insecurity at all levels of aid. Conflict has a higher negative effect on domestic food production, the import of agricultural goods and food prices than the positive effect of food aid. If conflict causes a further 10 percent deterioration of harvesting, fishing and livestock levels, CAR would suffer a loss of over 270 billion calories annually. Food aid would have to total approximately $127 million just to purchase the same amount of calories lost. In order to have any improvement in food security there would need to be a combination of lower conflict and increased funding. Shelter Analysis On average in 2014, every conflict-related incident displaced 640 Central Africans.63 If security is not established, and the number of conflict-related incidents in 2015 mirrors 2014 averages, the humanitarian community can expect nearly 500,000 new displacements. Providing 500,000 newly displaced people with emergency shelter and non-food items (NFIs) could cost upward of $40 million, based on the reach of 2014 aid. In a scenario of significantly decreased conflict, new displacements ostensibly would also drop. Further, with aid levels and interventions equivalent to 2014, CAR would see a decreased need for emergency shelter. However, this reduction must be assessed against an increased need for permanent shelter in a more stable environment. Permanent housing needs (assistance returning and rebuilding) will likely increase as the conflict subsides, as there will be an increase in returnees from within and neighboring countries. Consequently, even in a scenario of decreased conflict, the need for shelter solutions will grow nearly two-fold— from 178,304 to upward of 320,000 persons—from those identified in the 2015 SRP. A worst-case scenario (no funding and increasing conflict) results in total shelter needs for 800,000 persons, whereas best-case scenario (high funding and decreasing conflict) results in shelter needs for 500,000. In short, shelter needs will remain high throughout 2015. What this tells us By comparing food security and shelter needs in a range of conflict scenarios and at various aid levels, the international community can gain a sense of the tremendous importance of establishing security while providing humanitarian assistance. The aid provided by the international community has been invaluable in reducing conflict-related food insecurity and providing emergency shelter during the current crisis in CAR. However the reality is that humanitarian aid simply cannot keep up with the needs created by insecurity. The estimate of the number of people in need in a low- funding/lessening conflict scenario is almost on par with the number of people in need in a high-funding/status quo-conflict scenario. That is, humanitarian aid without addressing security provides only partial benefits to people in need. Food insecurity is only effectively addressed at high levels of humanitarian funding and by increasing domestic food production by tackling insecurity. This is not possible if displaced citizens do not feel secure enough to return home, or if people do not feel safe enough to leave their homes to pursue livelihoods. The risks to the people of CAR underscore the vital importance of a fruitful peace dialogue. Risk (continued)
  • 27. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 25 governance. In sum, they represent the building blocks of a potential stable nation. Considering the vast scope of challenges on the table for Central Africans, the outcomes of this high-stakes forum are clear and comprehensive. They provide a roadmap forward to address the most vexing challenges faced by CAR. It should be noted, however, that this is the country’s fifth national debate on peace and reconciliation since 1980. The forum, in fact, ended on an ominous note with some Anti-balaka representatives walking out in protest during the closing ceremony, and gunfire erupting outside. The success of the Bangui Forum therefore, will hinge greatly on implementation of the Pact, including ongoing consultations among all key actors to make sure their concerns are adequately represented, and an international commitment to supporting CAR’s new roadmap to the future. Over 700 participants, key stakeholders of national institutions and entities, against all expectations, took part in this conference, considered in everyone’s opinion to be the last chance for the future of Central African Republic. – THE NATIONAL FORUM OF BANGUI REPORT SYNTHESIS The national peace dialogue, the Bangui Forum, took place in May 2015. Nearly 700 political, religious and traditional leaders as well as parties to the conflict, the private sector, and civil society, gathered to propose a vision for a post- conflict CAR. Others attending included leaders from donor and neighboring countries, regional bodies, multilateral institutions, and a host of international organizations (including the International Conference on the Great Lakes Region and the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation). Participants were grouped into thematic commissions with the objective of planning a way forward in four categories: governance, economic and social development, justice and reconciliation, and peace and security. The governance commission addressed aspects of the constitution, law and policy, and ways to ensure the Forum’s outcomes will be accountable to the people. The economic and social development commission deliberated on the decentralization of the state, budget management, and the application of an integrated recovery and economic development strategy, targeting the most disadvantaged areas of the country. The justice and reconciliation commission dealt with impunity and national and local reconciliation mechanisms. The peace and security commission considered peace accords, disarmament, and measures to assure the security of the population. In a plenary session, the commissions proposed a range of steps, which were subsequently adopted. This (crisis) is a page in world history that is being rewritten. – M. Abdoulaye Bathily SPECIAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE UN SECRETARY- GENERAL FOR CENTRAL AFRICA, AND PRESIDENT OF THE BANGUI FORUM PRESIDIUM Two groundbreaking outcomes received particular attention. First, the Anti-balaka and 10 factions of the Séléka reached a new DDR agreement. Combatants are to give up their weapons prior to national elections and demilitarized parties will be integrated into state security sectors or benefit from income-generating activities. Immunity will not be granted to perpetrators of war crimes. Second, Séléka and Anti-balaka representatives agreed to release all children in their ranks, and humanitarian agencies will be granted immediate access to them so family tracing and reunification can begin. While these two outcomes are certainly notable and inspire hope for CAR’s immediate future, the Forum’s other outcomes— proposals adopted via the Pact—are equally important, as they could serve as a roadmap for stability and good Roadmap Forward Pregnant women waiting for vaccinations at Castors Health Centre, Bangui.
  • 28. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic26 Key Adopted Proposals Governance Constitutional amendments prohibiting a rise to executive power by force; establishment of a national, republican, and multiethnic Central African army; establishment of an independent High Authority for Good Governance and Anti-Corruption, with prosecutorial powers. A series of new laws and policies with a view to ensure equality for all, with special provisions for minorities, and protecting religious liberty, citizenship and voting rights. National 10-year plans for increasing access to education, employment and health services. An emergency plan for extending state authority throughout the country’s territory. Justice and Reconciliation A special criminal court for conflict-related crimes, rebellions and coups d’etats. Free and universal access to justice. Establishment of a truth and justice, reparation and reconciliation commission. Creation of local peace and reconciliation committees. Economic and Social Development Efforts to secure transhumance corridors in collaboration with pastoralists and farmers. The establishment of basic social services, specifically education, health and hygiene, as well as access to water and housing for all victims of the crisis. A health policy including universal health insurance. Rehabilitation and/or construction of infrastructure in all areas, from transport to communications to renewable energy. Peace and Security Full implementation of the Brazzaville Accord. The establishment in law of a Bangui Forum monitoring committee. Reparations for victims of “politico- military” crises. Establishment of a mechanism for transitional justice. Roadmap Forward (continued)
  • 29. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 27 Central Africans. The current transition, now embodied through the Pact, requires sustained diplomatic attention and financial support. Without DDR, the development of transparent and inclusive governance mechanisms, and sustained international focus, CAR could face increased violence and further collapse. A stable security environment is essential for Central Africans to return home, rebuild their lives, and participate in a sustainable and inclusive transition. Likewise, improved security is the building block for aid agencies to gain humanitarian access and deliver lifesaving services in a timely and effective manner. Our problems are many. It is necessary that the international community see our problems as their own, because what happens here will affect the whole region. If CAR isn’t supported, CAR could disappear. We depend on international community support for us not to disappear. – IRC LOCAL STAFF MEMBER International donors and diplomats must recognize the need to promote institution-strengthening activities and robust humanitarian assistance at this critical time. In this vein, the IRC encourages a multifaceted approach for short- and long- term recovery that includes: Investing in efforts to reduce insecurity, impunity and violence. Creating conditions that facilitate the delivery of humanitarian assistance. Establishing effective, inclusive and accountable government institutions, including a police service that protects civilians. Setting CAR on a path toward sustained recovery and development. Despite the skepticism that some Central Africans expressed in the lead up to the Bangui Forum, the dialogue’s outcomes represent CAR’s best hope for peace and stability, and an opportunity to arrest the cyclical violence that has plagued the country for decades. There is no doubt that if we maintain the status quo, CAR will become a Somalia or a Libya. – IRC LOCAL STAFF MEMBER The tremendous amount of progress that the international community, from diplomatic corps to humanitarian aid agencies, has achieved since crisis newly broke out in CAR cannot be underestimated. The country is not suffering a campaign of ethnic cleansing, as the Commission of Inquiry found to be true in 2014. However, the volatility of CAR’s security environment cannot be underestimated. Conflict incidence remains high, the vast majority of IDPs have not returned home, refugee numbers have increased, the TG has not established its presence throughout the country, MINUSCA has not been able to secure the country, and humanitarian aid agencies are severely restricted from carrying out their mandates and reaching the most vulnerable efficiently and effectively. To determine whether the country is emerging from crisis and moving toward stability, the IRC listened to the voices of people whose lives have been impacted by the conflict. Central Africans interviewed by the IRC communicated resounding fear of the transition process and skepticism about the national peace forum. They identified security as their unmistakable and primary need and specifically demanded a robust and rapid disarmament process. The Bangui Forum’s outcomes, which address many of these concerns, could reverse this fear and skepticism with the right international support to see through their implementation. CAR’s history is one of poor governance, recurring political violence and failed peace processes. The international community has too often taken short-term approaches to the deeply-rooted governance and security challenges facing Conclusion A girl from the Peul ethnic group near Ouandago. The Peul are a nomadic community of herders.
  • 30. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic28
  • 31. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 29 MINUSCA should invest in civilian-military coordination mechanisms to ensure its plans are informed by priorities identified by civilians, local civil-society groups and INGOs. Create Conditions That Facilitate the Delivery of Humanitarian Assistance Recognize that CAR remains in crisis Despite the deactivation of the Inter-Agency Standing Committee (IASC) System-Wide Level 3 Emergency Response for CAR, international support, is still required.64 The 2015 Strategic Response Plan and the forthcoming 2016 appeal should be funded in total. Expand humanitarian reach Donors should commit to a robust and long-term humanitarian presence in key locations, especially those areas that remain underserved due to insecurity. UN agencies, MINUSCA, and INGOs alike must commit to a sustained presence in areas where the need is greatest. Donors should resource MINUSCA to ensure they can fulfill their protection mandate, improve security and, as a result, increase the delivery of civilian-led humanitarian assistance. Facilitate the delivery of aid The TG should restore tax-exempt status to INGOs to ensure the maximum amount of humanitarian assistance reaches those in need. The TG should eliminate bureaucratic hurdles to releasing INGO goods at customs and border control points in order to facilitate the swift delivery of assistance to people in need. Donors should recognize the inordinate logistical costs of operating in CAR and fund agencies appropriately so that their operations are not compromised and people in need are reached. As long as insecurity and failed governance persist, the international community cannot meet humanitarian needs or help achieve durable peace in CAR. Furthermore, it must be understood that humanitarian aid is not a long-term solution. A holistic approach to the CAR crisis at this critical juncture should address the obstacles that agencies such as the IRC face in meeting humanitarian needs, while reducing the root causes of conflict to ensure lasting peace and stability. Invest in Efforts to Reduce Insecurity, Impunity and Violence Prioritize protection of the vulnerable Donors should institute early-warning systems that identify signs of potential conflict before it erupts and prioritize funding of conflict-sensitive programs that prevent and respond to violence against civilians, including gender-based violence and child- protection concerns. Extend state authority The international community should work with the TG to support the redeployment of government authorities in tandem with MINUSCA deployments, and to fund the rehabilitation and reconstruction of public security infrastructure such as courts, detention facilities, prisons and gendarmeries. Adequately support MINUSCA to protect civilians Troop-contributing countries should meet their commitments and immediately deploy the remaining 2,379 uniformed and civilian personnel authorized by the Security Council. Absent these commitments, MINUSCA will be less able to fulfill its mandate to protect civilians. Donors should supply MINUSCA with the equipment necessary to carry out patrols and communicate effectively internally within its own ranks and externally with the humanitarian community and the civilians they are protecting. The international community and MINUSCA should use their leverage with the TG to ensure the swift implementation of the new DDR agreement. Recommendations OPPOSITE PAGE: Children in Kaga Bandoro, Central African Republic.
  • 32. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic30 Donor governments and international financial institutions should build state capacity to effectively plan and manage human resources and public finances to support service delivery. Donor governments and international financial institutions should support the creation and implementation of policies that remove financial barriers to health and education for impoverished and conflict- affected people. Strengthen the social contract between citizens and the state The TG should facilitate the dissemination of information about government roles and responsibilities as well as civic rights and responsibilities to all Central Africans, particularly women and members of vulnerable and marginalized groups. The TG should expand spaces for state-society dialogue and collaboration that are inclusive of the viewpoints of Central Africans from all groups and geographic areas of the country. These spaces should bring together duty bearers (service providers, local authorities, etc.) and community members and/or their representatives (service users, civil society organizations, etc.) in settings such as town hall meetings, and health and school management committees. The international community should strengthen the capacity of civil-society organizations to mobilize and support civic engagement in participatory decision- making (e.g., inclusive planning and budgeting processes) regarding government-provided health, education and other basic services, and to hold the state accountable for addressing needs. The international community should support state institutions to recognize civic rights and engage constructively with the population, and to demonstrate greater responsiveness to the needs, priorities and concerns of the people. Prioritize investments in areas that most impact people’s lives Prioritize among the areas identified in the 2015 Strategic Response Plan to ensure the most basic humanitarian needs are addressed throughout the country.   Extend food security programming beyond IDP and returnee target groups to all conflict-affected Central Africans in need. Ensure that access to and availability of nutritious food is prioritized. Dedicate resources to meet the specific needs of women and girls; address both restoration of livelihoods and the violence they experience. Redouble efforts to resource the opening of primary and secondary schools and invest in extended psychosocial and reintegration programs for former child soldiers and all children affected by the crisis. Reestablish primary health services, including the introduction of community-based care. Maintain funding for mobile outreach services until primary health care is accessible to all conflict-affected Central Africans. Support The Establishment of Effective, Inclusive and Accountable Government Institutions Build accountable institutions Donor governments and international financial institutions should develop and finance comprehensive strategies for institution building and improved government service provision. The following should be implemented and staffed with adequate resources: –– Investment in “immediate peace dividends” that support disarmament and build trust between Central Africans and their institutions, including employment and livelihood opportunities, and increased access to basic services for all. –– Support for rebuilding of core state functions in order to establish greater legitimacy (including delivery of health, education, legal, and security services, among others). Recommendations (continued)
  • 33. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 31 The TG should continue to consult with an ever-widening array of civil-society representatives to develop and implement the commissions’ strategies and to evaluate their impact on Central Africans’ lives. Commit to funding recovery Donor governments and international financial institutions should commit to financing the implementation of effective strategies that emerge from the Pact. Bilateral donors should ensure their development and humanitarian assistance offices are aligned and coordinated to achieve maximum impact on both short- and long-term needs. Donors should provide funding that links reconstruction and development, including support for mechanisms such as the European Trust Fund for the Central African Republic. Set Car on Path Toward Sustained Recovery and Development Pursue peace The international community should support the International Contact Group in its continued pursuit of a political solution to the CAR crisis through sustained diplomatic engagement with the TG and parties to the conflict. Support the development of the May 2015 Republican Pact for Peace, National Reconciliation and Reconstruction International donors, organizations and financial institutions should support the Bangui Forum proposals by working with the four commissions—Governance, Economic and Social Development, Justice and Reconciliation, and Peace and Security—to develop implementation strategies, including a robust monitoring and evaluation plan to meet milestones. Central African women, Kaga Bandoro.
  • 34.
  • 35. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 33 7. “The elections are questionable—will the process be transparent and will legitimate authorities be put in place?” 8. “The international community must be involved to establish the rule of law to help the Central African administration recover—at least until it’s up and running—and to strengthen security in all of CAR and the neighboring countries.” 9. “What we are asking of the international community is not food. We are asking the international community to disarm combatants so that we can go home to the neighborhoods we abandoned when we came to these IDP sites. Neither food nor the small income-generating activities at these sites will allow us to go home.” 10. The international community knows that things happen here, but we only hear silence. The truth is not told because if it were, people would understand that stability hasn’t yet returned to the country.” APPENDIX: IRC-SAIS Research Methodology Limitations The figures given below were used as baseline measurements, on which the risk model for humanitarian need in food security and shelter was built. Baseline Humanitarian Need According to the 2015 Strategic Response Plan (SRP) the following are the current needs in food security and emergency shelter: 1,520,000 people are in need of emergency food assistance. 259,736 people are in need of emergency shelter assistance. 178,301 people are in need of assistance returning/rebuilding.65 Conflict Levels The follow represent the level of conflict at the end of 2014 and its effects on hazards: Risk: Level of conflict, which averaged 85 conflict- related incidents in 2014.66 APPENDIX: IRC Report Caveats The IRC’s humanitarian character prohibits it from taking a position on the viability or the timeline of elections; any reference to elections are intended to communicate the views of Central Africans interviewed for this report. The IRC has done its best to ensure that all information relayed in this report is accurate as of the time of publication (June 2015). The information presented herein is subject to change, particularly in light of the volatility of the crisis in CAR. APPENDIX: From the Field—Messages to the International Community The IRC asked Central Africans who consented to an interview what they would like to communicate to donors and policymakers in the international community. Here is a selection of messages: 1. “We need to multiply the number of blue helmets and patrols along the border. The army is not present and MINUSCA is trying to fill the gap, but they don’t have the forces or the resources to do this.” 2. “We call on the international community to assist in the Brazzaville Accord’s implementation. The accord is in place but not the measures, and the state is too weak. We need help.” 3. “The international community has rallied to take care of humanitarian needs but not security needs. Security and demilitarization is required to be able to roll out humanitarian activities in optimal conditions.” 4. “CAR is still in a period of convalescence. It is too soon for the humanitarian community to depart. We still need donors, even after the elections. I fear for a catastrophe if humanitarian assistance is withdrawn.” 5. “CAR is not the first country to live through a crisis. Donors and supporters must change to help us fix the system —above all, improve education. If people were more educated, they would think more before engaging in conflict. Those that are uneducated are manipulated.” 6. “In the DDR process, if the first D is missed, then the second D and the R will never work. The first D is not happening and we may see another rebellion.” Appendices OPPOSITE PAGE: Muslim returnee in front of the ruins of his home, Bocaranga.
  • 36. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic34 Humanitarian aid is resulting in an addition of calories through two means, as per the SRP: Aid spent on direct food assistance (food baskets, vouchers). Aid spent on indirect food assistance (agricultural trainings, farming inputs). The model measures food security in terms of calories, including both the number of calories provided through intervention funded by humanitarian aid, as well as the number of calories lost due to the level of crisis. Caloric intake was chosen as the measurement of food security, as numerous sources cite the need for approximately 2,100 daily calories, including the World Food Programme.74 Although it is not a perfect measure of food security, a Food Security Information Network study found a significant correlation between the Food Consumption Score (a measurement of both quality and quantity of diet) and caloric intake. Furthermore, the measurement of 2,100 calories is cited by the SRP as their measurement for food security; for the sake of consistency this definition is maintained. The model then measures the effect on calories of each one percent change in funding (based on a calculation of calories bought per dollar of aid), as well as the caloric effect of each one percent change in hazards. The effects of both a change in funding and a change in hazards are then combined to get the overall effect on calories for an aggregate outcome. The assumptions underlying the calculation of the effect of humanitarian aid on food security are based on project proposals submitted to the United Nations Financial Tracking Service (FTS),75 as well as the food aid budgets of WFP and USAID.76 By measuring the amount of calories purchased, including overhead costs, per dollar, a measurement of the relationship between aid spending and calories created reach was calculated. The assumptions for the calculation of the effect of change in the different hazards was based on the level of output pre-crisis taken from the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), then the number of calories of said output was calculated based on calories/ton. Shelter Security Assumptions and Calculations: The model assumes that conflict is resulting in an increase in shelter needs through two main means: Hazards: Impact of conflict on key variables. –– Harvesting levels: 58 percent reduction from pre-crisis levels. –– Fishing: 40 percent reduction from pre-crisis levels. –– Livestock: 70 percent reduction67 from pre-crisis levels. –– Inflation: 10 percent68 from pre-crisis levels. –– Agricultural imports: 27 percent reduction69 from pre-crisis levels. –– Number of Displaced: 20 percent of the population70 from pre-crisis levels. Humanitarian Aid Levels 2014 Humanitarian aid funding:71 SRP: funded at $382.2 million, 69 percent of requested. Additional bilateral and multilateral: $111 million. –– $106.5 million of this was given to food security via the SRP, and an additional $30 million (approximate) was given to food security outside of the SRP from bilateral and multilateral donors. –– $9.1 million of this was given to the shelter cluster via the SRP, while an additional (approximate) $10 million in aid was given through bilateral and multilateral donors. 2015 humanitarian aid funding to date:72 SRP: funded at $115.2 million, 19 percent of requested. Additional bilateral and multilateral funding: $51.6 million. Food Security Assumptions and Calculations: Based on the current literature, our model assumes that conflict is resulting in a loss of calories through four main means:73 Reduction in agricultural production. Reduction in agricultural imports. Inflation levels lowering purchasing power. Humanitarian food aid lost (diverted/pillaged/theft). Appendices (continued)
  • 37. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 35 to account for all aspects of domestic food production in CAR. However the model accounts for those which make up a significant portion of CAR’s production, as reported by FAO, including cassava, cereals, livestock, milk products, fish, and bananas. Furthermore, the level of conflict as reported by ACLED may have limitations, given the fluid level of conflict in CAR. Despite the above limitations, the model is based on the most accurate data available, which are regularly used by numerous humanitarian and development agencies. 2. The population distribution used in the food security model is a normal distribution and may not fully represent the distribution of food security in CAR, however, without a census of caloric intake of the entire population, it would be impossible to build the true distribution. Therefore a normal distribution is used as the most likely representation. There is justification in that this distribution matches the HNO statement that 30 percent of the population is moderately or severely food insecure. 3. The model looks at the population of CAR as a whole and therefore assumes somewhat equal access to citizens in various areas. Given that this is unlikely, the true need will vary slightly given the access to different areas. 4. The model seeks to predict the need by the end of 2015 and there are limitations with that time frame; a conflict that is only two years old provides a small pool of sampling data, and therefore predicting the results of a one year period, based on statistics from only two prior years naturally assumes room for error. 5. Not all clusters are evaluated and it may be possible that there are positive spillover effects between clusters, i.e. assisting the WASH cluster may have a positive effect on food security. This link is accounted for between shelter and food security, but the effect of other clusters on food and shelter are not accounted for. 6. There may be an oscillation in violence in CAR. If violence drops and a large number of Central Africans return, there may be an increase in tensions and violence once again. This level of analysis is not conducted, given the short time frame of this model, however, it would need to be an important consideration in any model projecting longer than the end of 2015. Increase in the number of displaced (associated with an increase in conflict). Increase in the number of returnees (associated with a decrease in conflict). Humanitarian aid is resulting in a reduction in shelter needs through two means:77 Aid spent on emergency shelter assistance. Aid spent on permanent housing solutions including assistance returning and rebuilding. Shelter security is measured in terms of individuals displaced. Shelter needs are determined by the number of displacements due to conflict-related incidents. The Armed Conflict Location Event Data Project’s (ACLED) real-time database,78 which tracks conflict-related incidents, was used as the measurement of conflict in CAR. OCHA’s statistics79 were used to determine current displacement levels. By looking at the relationship of these statistics, a correlation was calculated to estimate the relationship between the level of conflict-related incidents and the level of displacement. Specific calculations concerning the reach of shelter aid are based on project proposals submitted to the FTS, as well as the previous shelter budgets of the UN by measuring the cost of providing shelter to one displaced individual, a per-dollar measurement was calculated of the relationship between aid spending and shelter reach. The model then measures the aggregate impact on shelter needs of any one percent change in funding levels, as well as any one percent change in conflict-levels. Caveats This model is, first and foremost, a statistical estimate, and the following must be taken in to account when evaluating the results: 1. The model relies on the best available data, but said databases have their own limitations, including ACLED, OCHA’s Humanitarian Needs Overview (HNO), SRP and FTS, FAO, World Bank (WB), and International Monetary Fund (IMF). There are limitations to each of these sources including lack of comprehensive data, and periodic and non-mandatory reporting, all of which places limitations on gauging the full reach of aid. Said limitations include the fact that the model is not able
  • 38. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic36 The IRC intends to continue its activities in Ouham Pendé, Nana Gribizi and Bangui, and expand its activities in La Kémo, throughout 2015. The IRC in CAR: The IRC works in the following sectors in CAR: Women’s Protection and Empowerment Economic Recovery and Development and Food Security Health Child Protection WASH activities will phase out in 2015 as environmental health programming folds into other sectors, such as health and economic recovery. The IRC has its main office in Bangui and currently maintains two field offices (Kaga Bandoro and Bocaranga). The IRC implements programs in Bangui, Nana Gribizi, Ouham Pendé and Ouham prefectures. Staffing: The IRC in CAR operates with 15 expatriate staff members and 90 national staff members. Budget: The IRC in CAR has a projected budget of approximately $9,500,000 for FY15. Funding for the IRC in CAR is provided by SIDA, UNICEF, WFP, OFDA, EuropeAid, CHF, Stichting Vluchteling and private donors. Women’s Protection and Empowerment: The IRC provides survivors of GBV with timely access to psychosocial and health services, works with communities to reduce risks confronting women and girls, and supports women’s economic and social empowerment. The IRC established safe spaces in Bangui, Nana Gribizi and Ouham Pendé, where survivors can receive case management, counseling and referrals to health care. The IRC also works at the community level to prevent violence through advocacy campaigns, focus groups and awareness sessions that highlight the devastating effects of GBV and the importance of protecting survivors. APPENDIX: The IRC in CAR The IRC began working in Central African Republic in December 2006, following an eruption of violence that caused thousands of people to flee their homes. In response to the more recent power struggle between Ex-Séléka and Anti-balaka groups in 2013, the IRC shifted to a multisectoral intervention, and has since been working to help the most vulnerable populations affected by this ongoing crisis— especially women and children. The IRC strives to repair social cohesion by laying the foundation for recovery and self-reliance, helping displaced populations to return home, facilitating economic recovery and restoring access to quality basic services. Approximately 20 percent of the country’s population has been displaced by the current crisis, compounding prolonged preexisting poverty. The situation remains extremely volatile; while many IDPs started returning home in 2014, 436,119 people remain displaced throughout the country (as of May 2015), 58,700 of who reside in 34 sites in CAR’s capital city, Bangui. The IRC in CAR has restored functionality at targeted health centers, established mobile clinics in rural Ouham Pendé, supported food distribution and economic recovery activities in Nana Gribizi, and led emergency interventions for the protection of women and children in Bangui. Violence continues to force mass displacement countrywide, destroying much of the country’s social fabric. The farming community has missed a second planting season, and many markets have ceased to function. Women and girls continue to be vulnerable to gender-based violence (GBV), with cases being reported to the IRC at alarmingly high rates. Children remain at risk of abuse, exploitation and separation from their families. Infrastructure, such as health points and sanitation facilities, are not maintained, especially in rural areas, making access to health care nearly impossible. Although the IRC and other organizations are working across these sectors, available funding remains inadequate or short term in nature. In response, the IRC is seeking to establish local networks with alert and response mechanisms to provide information on security issues and threats to early recovery; such information is intended to trigger appropriate and timely responses, at first from the international community, but increasingly from local actors. Appendices (continued)
  • 39. Security, Governance and Humanitarian Need in the Central African Republic 37 Economic Recovery and Development: The IRC focuses primarily on market-systems recovery by increasing agricultural production and restoring microbusiness activities. The overarching goal is to help local producers increase crop and livestock yields. In addition, the IRC distributes seeds, tools and food to help households restart and build resilience against future shocks. The IRC also conducts market analysis, trains producers on new and enhanced agriculture techniques, provides support to small business enterprises, and operates Cash-for-Work programs that provide local people with short-term jobs on infrastructure construction projects. The IRC also conducts cash transfers and income- generating activities to allow individuals and women’s groups to build knowledge and resources to run small businesses. Environmental Health/WASH: Over the past year and a half, the IRC built 396 latrines and 328 showers for people living in displaced camps. The IRC rehabilitated water points and sanitation infrastructure in 10 villages in Ouham Pendé One of the key ways to bring stability back to CAR is to help people get back to work. The IRC has programs designed to train both men and women in useful skills to help them find jobs or create small businesses. and is also rehabilitating water points in 30 villages across Nana Gribizi. The IRC also educates communities and displaced people on the dangers of poor sanitation and the importance of good hygiene. Health: As one of few actors in Ouham Pendé prefecture, the IRC is working to reestablish the health care system in the region. In 2014, the IRC health program implemented lifesaving activities for conflict-affected populations in 10 villages and is currently expanding to 15 health facilities in La Kémo prefecture. The team initiated two mobile clinics that bring free health care to people in need in four villages. The IRC is also rehabilitating 15 looted health facilities, training staff and providing incentives for them and community health workers, as well as providing essential medicines and medical devices worth $330,000. From 2014 through March 2015, the IRC mobile clinics and the supported health facilities provided quality care to conflict- affected populations through 22,154 curative consultations.