SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 19
1
Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES
Biopsychosocial Model of Eating Disorders among Female Athletes
Jillian Baillargeon
University of Massachusetts Lowell
2
Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES
Abstract
This literature review paper examines the biological, psychological, and social factors that
contribute to an eating disorder in female athletes. As well as explore female athletes who are
marginalized and stigmatized in their sport environment for having a serious mental disorder.
The many literatures helped support the subtopics within this paper of what female athletes are at
more of a risk that others. The study by Sherman and Thompson, 2001 suggested that eating
disorders only occur in athletes who are predisposed through the combinations of biological,
personality, familial, and sociocultural factors. Hinton and Kubas, 2005 concluded that other
personality characteristics such as excessive control and obsessionality may play roles in the
development of disordered eating. The purpose of this paper was to inform health care providers
on female athletes with eating disorders. While they may well understand most of the medical
complications that result from an eating disorder, the psychological and social factors are areas
they might be unfamiliar with. Therefore, through this paper health care providers can be better
informed on the biological, psychological, social, and even personality factors that accompany
an eating disorder.
3
Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES
Biopsychosocial Model of Eating Disorders among Female Athletes
The prevalence rate of eating disorders is high among female athletes (Sherman and
Thompson, 2001). Female athletes of all levels of sport ability ranging from adolescents in
middle school and high school, to young adults in college, and elite and professional levels
(Greenleaf et al., 2009) develop unhealthful eating behaviors from a multitude of factors
including biological, psychological, and social factors. In addition, it is suggested from across
these literatures (e.g., Blackmer et at, 2011; Greenleaf et al, 2009; Hulley and Hill, 2001;
Scoffier et al, 2010; Skowron and Frielander, 1994) that eating disorders among female athletes
can start at any age. While an eating disorder can be diagnosed at any age, it can also develop
within any sport. This includes but not limited to sports such as basketball, cheerleading, cross
country, dance, field hockey, gymnastics, ice skating, softball, soccer, swimming and diving,
tennis, and track and field (e.g., Holm-Denoma et al, 2009; Karin de Bruin et al, 2011; Scoffier
et al, 2010; and Sherman and Thompson, 2001). Competitive female athletes of all ages, from
middle school to professionals, are more likely to develop an eating disorder, disordered eating
behaviors and unhealthful relationships with food compared to club athletes, independent
exercisers, and non-exercisers (Holm- Denoma et al., 2009). This paper will also discuss eating
disorders such as anorexia nervosa, bulimia nervosa, excessive exercise, binge eating, and eating
disorders not otherwise specified. Before discussing the biological, psychological, and social
factors, consideration needs to be brought to these female athletes that they are marginalized for
their mental illness.
4
Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES
Marginalization
Male athletes are labeled as having a women's problem if they do report their eating
disorder (Sherman and Thompson, 2001). Female athletes are marginalized because of their
eating disorder in their sport. Being body conscious is one of the early signs of developing an
eating disorder (Sherman and Thompson, 2001) and if men become body conscious then they are
perceived as less of a man (Griffiths et al., 2014). Women are already marginalized, but to then
get diagnosed with an eating disorder adds more feelings of feeling abnormality. To marginalize,
from the Merriam Webster Dictionary, 2014 means to put someone in an unimportant position
and feel powerless from a group or society. Female athletes especially college female athletes
have to balance a lot in their lives such as school, work, and other life demands but to then have
an added stressor of feeling rejected by their peers can have a bad impact to their overall well-
being (Skowron and Friedlander, 1994). Churruca, et al, 2014 conducted a study of adults with
eating disorders who participated in a Q methodology study online. The Q methodology used
both qualitative and quantitative techniques. This particular Q methodological study explored
constructions of bulimia. The first step of a Q methodological study to put together a set of items
or statements about the topic, in this particular study it was bulimia. The subtopics of the
statements in this study included: bulimia as a problem, bulimia as a solution, bulimia as a
choice, bulimia as a person, bulimia as normative, and bulimia as marginalized (Churruca et al.,
2014). The participants were mostly women, but consisted of men also. From the subtopics some
of the specific statements were: bulimia as uncontrolled behavior, bulimia is a distressing mental
illness, bulimia is a way to lose weight, self-medicating with food, the pathological pursuit of
thinness, being the best at being thin, and extreme behavior verse mentally ill. There was two
5
Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES
main findings from this study. The findings were that men can in fact develop bulimic behaviors
as well as bulimia being a very serious mental illness.
Despite that results do show that both men and women can develop an eating disorder,
women are still at a higher risk for disordered eating and eating disorders (Holm-Denoma et al.,
2009). Furthermore, there is no evidence suggesting that the prevalence of disordered eating in
athletes is declining (National Collegiate Athletic Association and American College of Sports
Medicine c.f. Sherman and Thompson, 2009). Holm-Denoma et al., (2009) expanded on this
statistic by doing a meta-analysis and found that women in sports are at an increased risk for
developing an eating disorder. One of the implications of the study was that varsity and club
athletes at the university did not represent the different body types in the different sports well
because there was no gymnastics and figure skating teams (Holm-Denoma et al., 2009). This is
an implication because certain sports may be associated with higher levels of eating disorders
than others (Holm-Denoma et al., 2009). In conclusion, there are a multitude of factors as
mentioned previously that can contribute to the development of an eating disorder such as the
type of sport. The psychological and social factors later in this paper will discuss why the type of
sport the female athlete participates in has a strong correlation with eating disorders.
Female athletes who are diagnosed with eating disorders may deal with more
marginalization than non-athletes. This is because of the interpersonal pressure they may place
on themselves along with the biological, psychological, and social factors that contribute.
Interpersonal meaning the type characteristics within the personality the athlete may have in
which this can be determinant factor on whether the athlete is at a greater chance in developing
an eating disorder. Sherman and Thompson, (2001) explained that female athletes may have a
strong drive on pleasing their coaches, parents, as well as accepting nothing less than a perfect
6
Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES
performance. The psychological and social factors will be discussed later in this literature review
in relation to these attributes. In addition to what Churruca et al., (2014) conducted, Hinton and
Kubas , (2005) did a similar study using the ATHLETE questionnaire to also determine what
kind of behaviors may result in an eating disorder. The participants were undergraduate college
female athletes from a Division 1 university. This questionnaire measured six factors such as
drive for thinness and performance, social pressure on eating, performance perfectionism, social
pressure on body shape, and team trust. Given the six psychological and social factors the results
were consistent and valid in which there is a direct association with disordered eating behaviors
and female athletes. The factors mentioned above in the study is what these female athletes deal
with mentally and emotionally. Most of these women are successful not just in their sport, but in
other areas of their life as well (Sherman and Thompson, 2001). Having these constant negative
self perceptions only lowers their self- esteem and overall quality of life (Sherman and
Thompson, 2001).
These female athletes with eating disorders are marginalized and not in the mainstream.
They are stigmatized for their mental illness as being weak physically and mentally, self-
centered, wanting attention, disgusting, and less of a woman (Griffiths et al., 2014). Not being in
the mainstream, meaning they have different behaviors about food so to others this could be
viewed as not being normal. So much is expected from female athletes from doing well in
school, having a job, and to be role models to other female athletes. When these women are
suffering from a severe mental disorder such as an eating disorder it may be harder for them to
balance the other aspects of their life well (Griffiths et al., 2014). Marginalization among female
athletes with eating disorders may imply to their peers that they are physically and mentally
weak. Even when the athlete makes a full recovery from the eating disorder they might always
7
Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES
be labeled as the athlete with the eating disorder. When this label is upon them it may become
their new identity rather than being looked at as a holistic person with other qualities (Griffiths et
al., 2014). The next section of this paper will discuss the biological factors that accompany the
development of an eating disorder.
Biological Factors
While psychological and social factors are a bigger part to contribute to an eating
disorder, biological factors are also a part to contribute to the onset of an eating disorder (e.g.
Blackmer et al, 2011; Churruca et al, 2014; Greenleaf et al, 2009; Griffiths et al, 2014; Skowron
and Friedlander, 1994). The biological aspects include body mass index and body fat. Three
different articles (Churruca et al., 2014; Malinauskas et al, 2007; Reel et al, 2014) discuss the
body mass index and body fat within their studies. In the study done by Malinauskas et al.,
(2007) found that body mass index and body fat contributed to psychological factors. The
psychological factors will be discussed later. If the athlete already struggles with anxiety, low
self-esteem, and or body dissatisfaction then they may have the drive for thinness to lower their
body mass index and body fat (Reel et al, 2013). This implies that if female athletes are not
satisfied with their biological appearance they may use unhealthful eating habits to change their
body composition.
Furthermore, the kind of sport the female athlete is in may determine whether they are at
a higher risk for developing disordered eating or an eating disorder. Malinauskas et al., (2007)
and Reel et al., (2013) both did studies similar on how body mass index and body fat correlates
with what sport the athlete is in and whether or not they are at a high risk for developing an
eating disorder. On the other hand, Hausenblas and McNally (c.f. Malinauskas et al, 2007)
8
Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES
argued that athletes have less of a chance in developing an eating disorder or disordered eating
symptoms because they have a healthier psychological functioning compared to non-athletes.
Warren et al., (1989) went further with this opposition in their study about disordered eating
patterns in competitive female athletes with a focus on cross country runners and gymnasts. The
participants were 82 female athletes from a Division 1 program, but only 74 volunteered for the
study while the remaining athletes were controls. The Eating Disorders Inventory (EDI) and
Eating Attitudes Test (EAT) were used in the study. The results that were found was that cross
country runners and gymnasts differed from each other. Warren et al, (1989) found that from the
EDI and EAT cross country runners reported less symptoms of disordered eating than female
non-athletes and gymnasts. Because gymnastics is a sport in which the athlete is being judged on
physical appearance, there is a higher chance of these athletes developing disordered eating. One
hypothesis suggested by Warren et al, (1989) is that gymnasts may become preoccupied with
their body mass index and body fat because the nature of the sport requires lean physiques for
optimal performance or at least this is how the gymnast perceives as the only option in being
successful. In conclusion, female cross country runners are at a lower risk for body
dissatisfaction than gymnasts (Warren et al., 1989). This may be because runners do not have to
be judged on physical appearance. This includes other sports such as volleyball that may be at a
lower risk for disordered eating because low body weight is not always an important factor for
achieving athletic success (Rosen et al., 1986 c.f. Warren et al., 1989). On the oppositional side,
(Clark et al, 1988 c.f. Warren et al, 1989) surveyed female elite runners and the results reported a
history of anorexia nervosa and disordered eating. In conclusion, so say that the biological
factors such as body mass index and body fat determine whether the athlete develops an eating
disorder or not is not consistent or valid. While gymnastics may correlate with a higher risk of
9
Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES
developing unhealthful eating behaviors than other sports such as cross country or volleyball
because of the nature of the sport other factors such as psychological and social are factored in.
In conclusion of biological factors, a sport like gymnastics may have athletes with more
muscular build and have a drive to be thin regardless of their biology and the judging criteria of
the sport on appearance. On the other end, a sport such as cross country distance running does
not have an emphasis on appearance to possibly cause distorted body image and eventually over
time the athlete may become thinner than other athletes due to the nature of running. Overall,
athletes with their own biological make up may want to try and change their body composition if
they feel their body mass index or body weight is the reason for a decrease in performance. The
psychological factors are discussed in the next section on why some female athletes are more at
risk of an eating disorder than others.
Psychological Factors
The psychological factors of an eating disorder in female athletes are still unclear
according to Hinton and Kubas, 2005. But rather across these literatures are hypotheses about
what can constitute toward an eating disorder. This may include self-perception of how the
athlete perceives herself out of sport and within her sport as well as the personality of the athlete
such as feelings of inadequacy and anxiety. While Hinton and Kubas, 2005 suggest that
psychological factors are unclear, their ATHLETE Questionnaire as mentioned previously, was
designed to assess psychological factors associated with disordered eating in athletes (Hinton and
Kubas, 2005). Joining sports results in positive outcomes such as higher self esteem and overall
emotional and physical well-being (Hinton and Kubas, 2005). But these female athletes as stated
by previous studies (e.g. Holm-Denoma et al, 2009; Karin de Bruin et al, 2011; Reel et al, 2013;
Skowron and Friedlander, 1994) that there is enough data to support the hypothesis that female
10
Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES
athletes are at a greater risk for developing an eating disorder more so than non-athletes (Hinton
and Kubas, 2005).
The ATHLETE questionnaire tested six different areas within varsity female athletes
from three different Division 1 universities in nine different sports. The athletes ages ranged
from 18-22. The athletic trainers administered the questionnaires to the athletes without the
coaches in the room. The six different areas in the questionnaire that were measured were body
dissatisfaction, drive for thinness, interoceptive awareness, perfectionism, ineffectiveness, and
interpersonal distrust. Three additional areas were tested as well, but they are societal factors that
include social pressure on body shape, social pressure on eating behaviors, and the important of
being an athlete to self-concept (Hinton and Kubas, 2005). While the six different areas were
listed that the questionnaire tested, the Eating disorder inventory was also used in this study
along with other measures. The Eating Disorder Inventory (EDI) included a drive for thinness
construct which is the desire to be leaner to improve performance or appearance and using
excessive and compulsive training above what is require from the athlete (Hinton and Kubas,
2005). The other six constructs' descriptions includes dissatisfaction with body appearance and
body effectiveness related to performance, lack of control and feeling powerless regarding
playing time, training, and performance, excessive personal expectations for superior
achievement and/or avoidance of failure, reluctant to form close relationships with teammates
because of competition for roster positions, playing time, scholarships, and attention from coach,
and the inability to recognize physical hunger and overtraining (Hinton and Kubas, 2005).
Female athletes put a great deal of pressure on themselves by using the fitness level of their
bodies as a way of determining their athletic success. One of the results from this study was the
60% of female athletes reported wanting to lose five pounds, and 30% were trying to lose weight
11
Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES
for their sport (Hinton and Kubas, 2005). This drive to want to lose weight while already being
highly physically active may increase the chances of the athlete to develop an eating disorder.
(Skowron and Friedlander, 1994). The female athletes in literatures previously mentioned still
want to lose weight whether it is to increase sport performance or wanting to become thinner not
related to sport in which this case society has to be blamed for. The desire in wanting to become
thinner among the female athlete will be discussed in the next subtopic. One other factor that
could be included is whether the athlete has been dealing with an eating disorder before joining a
sport. This factor may be out of scope for this paper, but will be taken into consideration.
In continuation of the ATHLETE questionnaire by Hinton and Kubas, 2005 there were
five distinct psychological factors such as drive for thinness, social pressure on eating,
performance perfectionism, social pressure on body shape, and team trust. The athletes had to
decide on how much the statements were true to them or not. Some of the statements that were
included was, I would be more successful in my sport if my body looked better, I train more than
is required by my sport to burn more calories, I feel uncomfortable eating in front of my friends
(non-athletes), coach, family, teammates, No matter how successful I am, I never feel satisfied,
My friends, coach, family, teammates, or society makes me feel fat, Being an athlete is my most
meaningful ability, and lastly, It is hard to get close to my teammates because we are constantly
competing against each other. The end results from this study indicates that five psychological
factors were affirmatively associated with disordered eating behaviors in female athletes (Hinton
and Kubas, 2005). Limitations of this study were that the study relied on self-reported attitudes
and eating behaviors and the truthfulness and accuracy of the self-reported responses are subject
to question (Hinton and Kubas, 2005). For future research the ATHLETE will be used in
studying the etiology of disordered eating in female athletes (Hinton and Kubas, 2005). While
12
Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES
the multitude of the many psychological factors are supported by the research in which how
some female athletes may be at a higher risk than others, societal factors account for last part in
the biopsychosocial model.
Social Factors
The sports culture, explained by Reel et al., 2013 brings greater demands to the
individual female athlete such as body weight, shape, size, sports that emphasize thinness,
muscularity, or a particular build. On the other hand, being a part of a sports team can bring
many positives into the athlete’s life. Making new friends, feeling a sense of belongingness,
camaraderie, and benefits physically are just some of positives an athlete can gain. In fact, sports
can enhance mental well-being as well (Blackmer et al., 2011). While sports have many
advantages, the environment of sports may also increase the risk for disordered eating, distorted
body image, and eating disorders (Reel et al., 2013). Petrie and Greenleaf, 2012 c.f. Reel et al.,
2013 explained that even when the athletes specific sport may require weigh-ins, judging criteria,
fitting into fitted uniforms, the psychological and personality factors of the athlete could be a
strong influence in whether they are at risk. The people in the athlete’s life has a direct
relationship with developing unhealthful eating behaviors. Sherman and Thompson, 2001 further
explain that needing to please the coach, teammates, or the family correlates highly with the
athlete doing so by losing weight to get faster or because they think they are too fat. From these
societal influences, they can bring body concern which can result in anxiety in regards to athletic
performance and start the disordered relationship with food cycle (William et al., 1995 c.f.
Sherman and Thompson, 2001). If the pressures do not come from the sport environment such as
to lose weight or body fat to perform better than it can come from the athlete (Sherman and
Thompson, 2001) The societal pressures in sport might always exist due to the nature of sports
13
Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES
being competitive and with the athletes in these sports usually having the drive to achieve
excellence it again refers back to the biological and psychological factors. This implies that some
athletes may not feel any of these social pressures whereas others may be affected entirely.
Eating disorders and disordered eating not only affects the athlete mentally, but also physically
by resulting in long term health effects from inadequate nutrition. This last section in the
literature review discusses the long term health effects from eating disorders such as anorexia
nervosa, bulimia nervosa, eating disorders not otherwise specified, and disordered eating
patterns.
Long Term Health Effects
Being an athlete is physically demanding on the body, but to then have an eating disorder
in which the body is not getting proper nutrients is an even greater demand from the body. Jill
Thein-Nissenbaum, 2013 did a study on the long-term consequences of the female athlete triad.
The Female Athlete Triad (FAT) is comprised of three components, disordered eating,
amenorrhea, and osteoporosis (Thein-Nissenbaum, 2013). These three components is what health
care providers and athletic trainers should examine the athlete for. The female athlete triad may
not always result in an eating disorder or vice verse. Morgenthal, 2002 explains that because of
the hard physical training the athlete puts her body through, the body responds by making these
regular systems irregular. This means the loss of the menstrual cycle, hormones like estrogen and
progesterone decrease, constant fatigue, depression, decreased performance, and other endocrine
abnormalities (Morgenthal, 2002). Moreover, Williams et al. 1995 c.f. Morgenthal, 2002
concluded that the athletes training might not be enough to produce these irregular systems
unless low caloric intake is present.
14
Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES
The female athlete triad may not be the only result from inadequate nutrients, fertility and
cardiovascular problems are also at risk. Female athlete triad effects athletes in the high school,
collegiate, and elite levels (Thein-Nissenbaum, 2013). In conclusion to the female athlete triad
both the reproductive and skeletal (osteoporosis) systems are severely affected. Cardiovascular
disease osteoporosis, and fertility and pregnancy problems are just a few of the many health
outcomes from anorexia nervosa in the female athlete (Meczekalski et al., 2013). Meczekalski et
al., 2013 found that 80% of patients with eating disorders reported cardiac complications and
osteoporosis was commonly diagnosed in teenagers before achieving their peak bone mineral
density. In conclusion to these findings across these studies when the athlete restores her weight
to a normal range she might always deal with cardiovascular problems and may never gain full
bone density back. As previously mentioned, the result from osteoporosis is bone mineral density
never being restored again, (Morgenthal, 2002) therefore these women may always have a higher
risk for stress fractures along with other chronic irregularities.
As studies have shown that eating disorders can affect the female athlete at any age, the
female athlete triad can be diagnosed at any age. In an article by Sherman and Thompson, 2006
on the International Olympic Committee Medical Commission Position Stand on the Female
Athlete Triad: A Case Example explores the female athlete triad in elite and professional female
athletes. This study explored the three components of the triad just as previous studies have
done, but the results of this particular study stand out. Other results from previous studies found
correlations between female athletes and whether they were at risk or not in developing
disordered eating or an eating disorder from the biological, psychological, and social factors. But
the results from this study by Sherman and Thompson, 2006 was that the Olympic Committee
15
Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES
Medical Position stand found strategies for managing the issues and problems regarding the
referral, evaluation, and treatment of the female athlete triad.
Conclusion
The biological, psychological, and social factors among female athletes and eating
disorders all have a significant role in whether the athlete develops unhealthful relationships with
food. Each of the different literatures explored not only the biopsychosocial model, but other
factors related. Some opposing viewpoints throughout this literature review was that female
cross country runners may show symptoms and the developments of an eating disorder, but other
articles argued that because cross country runners are not in an judging criteria sport such as
gymnastics they are at a less risk. But what if an athlete doesn't meet full criteria for a clinical or
subclinical eating disorder then what category in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental
Disorders, Fifth Edition would this athlete fall into? The implications of this literature review
paper is the lack of comparison throughout the paper between varsity athletes, club, athletes,
independent exercisers, and non- athletes there was. As well as going not further in depth on
specific areas within the subtopics. Because this literature review has a length requirement,
expanding on other possible factors that could contribute to an eating disorder could not be done.
Not always being able to arrive at a conclusion was difficult because of the complexity of the
topic. For the future, more research should be done on female athletes with anxiety, depression,
obsessive compulsive disorder, and addictive behaviors to determine if they are at a higher,
lower, or the same risk of developing an eating disorder compared to female athletes without
other mental disorders. Moreover, future research should also be done on female athletes and
marginalization.
16
Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES
References
Abood, D., Black, D., & Birnbaum, R. (2004). Nutrition Education Intervention For College
Female Athletes. Journal of Nutrition Education and Behavior, 36(3), 135-139.
Blackmer, V., Searight, H., & Ratwik, S. (2011). The Relationship between Eating Attitudes,
Body Image and Perceived Family- of Origin Climate among College Athletes. North
American Journal of Psychology, 13(3), 435-446.
Bruin, A., Oudejans, R., Bakker, F., & Woertman, L. (2011). Contextual body image and
athletes' disordered eating: The contribution of athletic body image to disordered eating
in high performance women athletes. European Eating Disorders Review, 201-215.
Churruca, K., Perz, J., & Ussher, J. (2014). Uncontrollable behaviors or mental illness?
Exploring constructions of bulimia using Q methodology. Journal of Eating
Disorders,2(22), 1-14.
Greenleaf, C., Petrie, T., Carter, J., & Reel, J. (2009). Female Collegiate Athletes: Prevalence Of
Eating Disorders And Disordered Eating Behaviors. Journal of American College
Health, 57(5), 489-496.
Griffiths, S., Mond, J., Murray, S., & Touyz, S. (2014). The Prevalence and Adverse
Associations of Stigmatization in People with Eating Disorders. International Journal of
Eating Disorders, 1-8.
Hinton PhD, P., & Kubas MS, RD, K. (2005). Psychosocial Correlates of Disordered Eating in
Female Collegiate Athletes: Validation of the ATHLETE Questionnaire. Journal of
American College Health, 54(3), 149-156.
17
Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES
Holm-Denoma, J., Scaringi, V., Gordon, K., Orden, K., & Joiner, T. (2008). Eating disorder
symptoms among undergraduate varsity athletes, club athletes, independent exercisers,
and non-exercisers. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 47-53.
Hulley, A., & Hill, A. (2001). Eating disorders and health in elite women distance
runners.International Journal of Eating Disorders, 312-317.
Krentz, E., & Warschburger, P. (2011). Sports-Related Correlates of Disordered Eating in
Aesthetic Sports. Psychology of Sports and Exercise, 375-382
Malinauskas, B., Cucchiara, A., Aeby, V., & Bruening, C. (2007). Physical activity, disordered
eating risk, and anthropometric measurement: A comparison of college of college female
athletes and non athletes. College Student Journal, 41(1), 217-222.
Meczekalski, B., Podfigurna-Stopa, A., & Katulski, K. (2013). Long-term consequences of
anorexia nervosa. Maturitas, 215-220.
Morgenthal, A. (2002). Female Athlete Triad. Journal of Chiropractic Medicine, 1(3), 97-106.
National Eating Disorders Association- Athletes and Eating Disorders - 2006 -
http://www.nationaleatingdisorders.org
Nieves, J., Melsop, K., Curtis, M., Kelsey, J., Bachrach, L., Greendale, G., ... Sainani, K. (2010).
Nutritional Factors That Influence Change in Bone Density and Stress Fracture Risk
Among Young Female Cross-Country Runners. PM&R, 2(8), 740-750.
Reel, J., Petrie, T., Soohoo, S., & Anderson, C. (2013). Weight pressures in sport: Examining the
factor structure and incremental validity of the weight pressures in sport —
Females. Eating Behaviors, 137-144.
18
Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES
Scoffier, S., Maiano, C., & D' Arripe-Longueville, F. (2010). The Effects of Social Relationships
and Acceptance on Disturbed Eating Attitudes in Elite Adolescent Female Athletes:
The Mediating Role of Physical Self-perceptions. International Journal of Eating
Disorders, 65-71.
Skowron, E., & Friedlander, M. (1994). Psychological Separation, Self-Control, and Weight
Preoccupation Among Elite Women Athletes. Journal of Counseling & Development, 72,
310-315.
Sherman, R., Thompson, R., Dehass, D., & Wilfert, M. (2005). NCAA Coaches Survey: The
Role of the Coach in Identifying and Managing Athletes with Disordered Eating. Eating
Disorders, 447-466.
Sherman, R., & Thompson, R. (2001a). Athletes And Disordered Eating: Four Major Issues For
The Professional Psychologist. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, 32(1),
27-33.
Sherman, R., & Thompson, R. (2006b). Practical use of the International Olympic Committee
Medical Commission position stand on the female athlete triad: A case
example. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 193-201.
Stewart, T., Plasencia, M., Han, H., Jackson, H., & Becker, C. (2014). Moderators and predictors
of response to eating disorder risk factor reduction programs in collegiate female
athletes. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 713-720.
Thein-Nissenbaum, J. (2013). Long term consequences of the female athlete
triad.Maturitas, 107- 112.
19
Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES
Warlick, D. (2000, October 29). Create your APA journal citation. Retrieved December 3, 2014,
from http://www.citationmachine.net/apa/cite-a-journal/create
Warren, B., Stanton, A., & Blessing, D. (1990). Disordered eating patterns in competitive female
athletes. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 9(5), 565-569.

More Related Content

What's hot

Au psy492 m1_a2_thompson_d.doc
Au psy492 m1_a2_thompson_d.docAu psy492 m1_a2_thompson_d.doc
Au psy492 m1_a2_thompson_d.docashli1
 
Mens health seminar fall 2014
Mens health seminar fall 2014Mens health seminar fall 2014
Mens health seminar fall 2014Brian Witkov
 
Young teens turning to protein powders, steroids to bulk up: Survey
Young teens turning to protein powders, steroids to bulk up: SurveyYoung teens turning to protein powders, steroids to bulk up: Survey
Young teens turning to protein powders, steroids to bulk up: Surveycoldfascism4997
 
Underdiagnosed male eating disorders are becoming recognized
Underdiagnosed male eating disorders are becoming recognizedUnderdiagnosed male eating disorders are becoming recognized
Underdiagnosed male eating disorders are becoming recognizedDaniel_Klem
 
Health-physical activity
Health-physical activityHealth-physical activity
Health-physical activityAnder050
 
Aging & frailty
Aging & frailtyAging & frailty
Aging & frailtyhodmedicine
 
Dieting and body image in aesthetic based sports presentation
Dieting and body image in aesthetic based sports  presentationDieting and body image in aesthetic based sports  presentation
Dieting and body image in aesthetic based sports presentationcassiemuir
 
Stigmatization of anorexia nervosa and muscle dysmorphia
Stigmatization of anorexia nervosa and muscle dysmorphiaStigmatization of anorexia nervosa and muscle dysmorphia
Stigmatization of anorexia nervosa and muscle dysmorphiaScoti Riff
 
Physical Exercise And Test Taking Anxiety
Physical Exercise And Test Taking AnxietyPhysical Exercise And Test Taking Anxiety
Physical Exercise And Test Taking Anxietynbraccia
 
Review of Anorexia Nervosa and Bulimia Nervosa for Mankind
Review of Anorexia Nervosa and Bulimia Nervosa for MankindReview of Anorexia Nervosa and Bulimia Nervosa for Mankind
Review of Anorexia Nervosa and Bulimia Nervosa for Mankindijsrd.com
 
Presentation3
Presentation3Presentation3
Presentation3bibi A
 
Presentation2
Presentation2Presentation2
Presentation2bibi A
 
Exercise and sports in women srimanti
Exercise and sports in women srimantiExercise and sports in women srimanti
Exercise and sports in women srimantiWbuhs
 
Senior Physical Fitness Test
Senior Physical Fitness TestSenior Physical Fitness Test
Senior Physical Fitness TestMarisa Schuller
 
Breakfast of champions: Steroids and the men who use them
Breakfast of champions: Steroids and the men who use themBreakfast of champions: Steroids and the men who use them
Breakfast of champions: Steroids and the men who use themScoti Riff
 
2016: Frailty-Thomas
2016: Frailty-Thomas2016: Frailty-Thomas
2016: Frailty-ThomasSDGWEP
 

What's hot (18)

Au psy492 m1_a2_thompson_d.doc
Au psy492 m1_a2_thompson_d.docAu psy492 m1_a2_thompson_d.doc
Au psy492 m1_a2_thompson_d.doc
 
HS 1 essay, college anxiety
HS 1 essay, college anxietyHS 1 essay, college anxiety
HS 1 essay, college anxiety
 
Mens health seminar fall 2014
Mens health seminar fall 2014Mens health seminar fall 2014
Mens health seminar fall 2014
 
Young teens turning to protein powders, steroids to bulk up: Survey
Young teens turning to protein powders, steroids to bulk up: SurveyYoung teens turning to protein powders, steroids to bulk up: Survey
Young teens turning to protein powders, steroids to bulk up: Survey
 
Underdiagnosed male eating disorders are becoming recognized
Underdiagnosed male eating disorders are becoming recognizedUnderdiagnosed male eating disorders are becoming recognized
Underdiagnosed male eating disorders are becoming recognized
 
Dissertation
DissertationDissertation
Dissertation
 
Health-physical activity
Health-physical activityHealth-physical activity
Health-physical activity
 
Aging & frailty
Aging & frailtyAging & frailty
Aging & frailty
 
Dieting and body image in aesthetic based sports presentation
Dieting and body image in aesthetic based sports  presentationDieting and body image in aesthetic based sports  presentation
Dieting and body image in aesthetic based sports presentation
 
Stigmatization of anorexia nervosa and muscle dysmorphia
Stigmatization of anorexia nervosa and muscle dysmorphiaStigmatization of anorexia nervosa and muscle dysmorphia
Stigmatization of anorexia nervosa and muscle dysmorphia
 
Physical Exercise And Test Taking Anxiety
Physical Exercise And Test Taking AnxietyPhysical Exercise And Test Taking Anxiety
Physical Exercise And Test Taking Anxiety
 
Review of Anorexia Nervosa and Bulimia Nervosa for Mankind
Review of Anorexia Nervosa and Bulimia Nervosa for MankindReview of Anorexia Nervosa and Bulimia Nervosa for Mankind
Review of Anorexia Nervosa and Bulimia Nervosa for Mankind
 
Presentation3
Presentation3Presentation3
Presentation3
 
Presentation2
Presentation2Presentation2
Presentation2
 
Exercise and sports in women srimanti
Exercise and sports in women srimantiExercise and sports in women srimanti
Exercise and sports in women srimanti
 
Senior Physical Fitness Test
Senior Physical Fitness TestSenior Physical Fitness Test
Senior Physical Fitness Test
 
Breakfast of champions: Steroids and the men who use them
Breakfast of champions: Steroids and the men who use themBreakfast of champions: Steroids and the men who use them
Breakfast of champions: Steroids and the men who use them
 
2016: Frailty-Thomas
2016: Frailty-Thomas2016: Frailty-Thomas
2016: Frailty-Thomas
 

Viewers also liked

Globe group company profile
Globe group company profileGlobe group company profile
Globe group company profileDanila Micheli
 
туристский паспорт тлондода
туристский паспорт тлондодатуристский паспорт тлондода
туристский паспорт тлондодаmotsumada
 
Cowen Group Final 2016
Cowen Group Final 2016Cowen Group Final 2016
Cowen Group Final 2016Ricardo Campos
 
Le cabinet Taj et l’AMAFI décryptent l’actualité fiscale et lois de finances ...
Le cabinet Taj et l’AMAFI décryptent l’actualité fiscale et lois de finances ...Le cabinet Taj et l’AMAFI décryptent l’actualité fiscale et lois de finances ...
Le cabinet Taj et l’AMAFI décryptent l’actualité fiscale et lois de finances ...Deloitte Société d'Avocats
 
Eripm wd bgt0000 nbk
Eripm wd bgt0000 nbkEripm wd bgt0000 nbk
Eripm wd bgt0000 nbkSprl Eripm
 
Qu'est-ce qu'un schéma d'aménagement et de développement
Qu'est-ce qu'un schéma d'aménagement et de développementQu'est-ce qu'un schéma d'aménagement et de développement
Qu'est-ce qu'un schéma d'aménagement et de développementVille de Laval
 

Viewers also liked (14)

Globe group company profile
Globe group company profileGlobe group company profile
Globe group company profile
 
MCMAGCOVER-Typo1
MCMAGCOVER-Typo1MCMAGCOVER-Typo1
MCMAGCOVER-Typo1
 
VA_1
 VA_1 VA_1
VA_1
 
CMS UDIs
CMS UDIsCMS UDIs
CMS UDIs
 
Avance del internet en méxico
Avance del internet en méxicoAvance del internet en méxico
Avance del internet en méxico
 
Act1 jenl
Act1 jenlAct1 jenl
Act1 jenl
 
туристский паспорт тлондода
туристский паспорт тлондодатуристский паспорт тлондода
туристский паспорт тлондода
 
Cowen Group Final 2016
Cowen Group Final 2016Cowen Group Final 2016
Cowen Group Final 2016
 
Kimpres
KimpresKimpres
Kimpres
 
Abdelmagid Abdel Aziz
Abdelmagid Abdel AzizAbdelmagid Abdel Aziz
Abdelmagid Abdel Aziz
 
Hahn Bill
Hahn BillHahn Bill
Hahn Bill
 
Le cabinet Taj et l’AMAFI décryptent l’actualité fiscale et lois de finances ...
Le cabinet Taj et l’AMAFI décryptent l’actualité fiscale et lois de finances ...Le cabinet Taj et l’AMAFI décryptent l’actualité fiscale et lois de finances ...
Le cabinet Taj et l’AMAFI décryptent l’actualité fiscale et lois de finances ...
 
Eripm wd bgt0000 nbk
Eripm wd bgt0000 nbkEripm wd bgt0000 nbk
Eripm wd bgt0000 nbk
 
Qu'est-ce qu'un schéma d'aménagement et de développement
Qu'est-ce qu'un schéma d'aménagement et de développementQu'est-ce qu'un schéma d'aménagement et de développement
Qu'est-ce qu'un schéma d'aménagement et de développement
 

Similar to Final LIT REVIEW IN SEMINAR ON ED

Psyc 3050 Final Paper
Psyc 3050 Final PaperPsyc 3050 Final Paper
Psyc 3050 Final PaperAmy Teresa
 
Dimensions of physical and mental health
Dimensions of physical and mental healthDimensions of physical and mental health
Dimensions of physical and mental healthIrfan iftekhar
 
eating disorders sorority life
eating disorders sorority lifeeating disorders sorority life
eating disorders sorority lifeMatthew Greer
 
SULLIVAN TU DOT EBP review 2012
SULLIVAN TU DOT EBP review 2012SULLIVAN TU DOT EBP review 2012
SULLIVAN TU DOT EBP review 2012Allison Sullivan
 
Adolescent athletes
Adolescent athletesAdolescent athletes
Adolescent athletesKatie Egger
 
httpsdoi.org10.11770022146517715671Journal of Health
httpsdoi.org10.11770022146517715671Journal of Health httpsdoi.org10.11770022146517715671Journal of Health
httpsdoi.org10.11770022146517715671Journal of Health LizbethQuinonez813
 
Health, sport and physical activity
Health, sport and physical activityHealth, sport and physical activity
Health, sport and physical activityAllieBarber
 
Running head PHYSICAL ACTIVITY AND SELF-EFFICACY .docx
Running head PHYSICAL ACTIVITY AND SELF-EFFICACY               .docxRunning head PHYSICAL ACTIVITY AND SELF-EFFICACY               .docx
Running head PHYSICAL ACTIVITY AND SELF-EFFICACY .docxcharisellington63520
 
Develop a taxonomy” of DSIA document. A taxonomy is a way of org.docx
Develop a taxonomy” of DSIA document. A taxonomy is a way of org.docxDevelop a taxonomy” of DSIA document. A taxonomy is a way of org.docx
Develop a taxonomy” of DSIA document. A taxonomy is a way of org.docxsimonithomas47935
 
Ysanders Graduate Seminar Presentation Fall 2011
Ysanders Graduate Seminar Presentation Fall 2011Ysanders Graduate Seminar Presentation Fall 2011
Ysanders Graduate Seminar Presentation Fall 2011YoLanda Sanders, MSc, CFLE
 
Research paper sp
Research paper spResearch paper sp
Research paper spjfahrnbauer
 

Similar to Final LIT REVIEW IN SEMINAR ON ED (16)

Psyc 3050 Final Paper
Psyc 3050 Final PaperPsyc 3050 Final Paper
Psyc 3050 Final Paper
 
Dissertation PDF
Dissertation PDFDissertation PDF
Dissertation PDF
 
Dimensions of physical and mental health
Dimensions of physical and mental healthDimensions of physical and mental health
Dimensions of physical and mental health
 
eating disorders sorority life
eating disorders sorority lifeeating disorders sorority life
eating disorders sorority life
 
SULLIVAN TU DOT EBP review 2012
SULLIVAN TU DOT EBP review 2012SULLIVAN TU DOT EBP review 2012
SULLIVAN TU DOT EBP review 2012
 
Adolescent athletes
Adolescent athletesAdolescent athletes
Adolescent athletes
 
httpsdoi.org10.11770022146517715671Journal of Health
httpsdoi.org10.11770022146517715671Journal of Health httpsdoi.org10.11770022146517715671Journal of Health
httpsdoi.org10.11770022146517715671Journal of Health
 
Childhood Obesity
Childhood ObesityChildhood Obesity
Childhood Obesity
 
Health, sport and physical activity
Health, sport and physical activityHealth, sport and physical activity
Health, sport and physical activity
 
Running head PHYSICAL ACTIVITY AND SELF-EFFICACY .docx
Running head PHYSICAL ACTIVITY AND SELF-EFFICACY               .docxRunning head PHYSICAL ACTIVITY AND SELF-EFFICACY               .docx
Running head PHYSICAL ACTIVITY AND SELF-EFFICACY .docx
 
SocietyInfluencingHealth(1)
SocietyInfluencingHealth(1)SocietyInfluencingHealth(1)
SocietyInfluencingHealth(1)
 
Develop a taxonomy” of DSIA document. A taxonomy is a way of org.docx
Develop a taxonomy” of DSIA document. A taxonomy is a way of org.docxDevelop a taxonomy” of DSIA document. A taxonomy is a way of org.docx
Develop a taxonomy” of DSIA document. A taxonomy is a way of org.docx
 
Ysanders Graduate Seminar Presentation Fall 2011
Ysanders Graduate Seminar Presentation Fall 2011Ysanders Graduate Seminar Presentation Fall 2011
Ysanders Graduate Seminar Presentation Fall 2011
 
Research paper sp
Research paper spResearch paper sp
Research paper sp
 
Philosophy paper
Philosophy paperPhilosophy paper
Philosophy paper
 
Eating Disorders Assessment: Part 1
Eating Disorders Assessment: Part 1Eating Disorders Assessment: Part 1
Eating Disorders Assessment: Part 1
 

Final LIT REVIEW IN SEMINAR ON ED

  • 1. 1 Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES Biopsychosocial Model of Eating Disorders among Female Athletes Jillian Baillargeon University of Massachusetts Lowell
  • 2. 2 Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES Abstract This literature review paper examines the biological, psychological, and social factors that contribute to an eating disorder in female athletes. As well as explore female athletes who are marginalized and stigmatized in their sport environment for having a serious mental disorder. The many literatures helped support the subtopics within this paper of what female athletes are at more of a risk that others. The study by Sherman and Thompson, 2001 suggested that eating disorders only occur in athletes who are predisposed through the combinations of biological, personality, familial, and sociocultural factors. Hinton and Kubas, 2005 concluded that other personality characteristics such as excessive control and obsessionality may play roles in the development of disordered eating. The purpose of this paper was to inform health care providers on female athletes with eating disorders. While they may well understand most of the medical complications that result from an eating disorder, the psychological and social factors are areas they might be unfamiliar with. Therefore, through this paper health care providers can be better informed on the biological, psychological, social, and even personality factors that accompany an eating disorder.
  • 3. 3 Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES Biopsychosocial Model of Eating Disorders among Female Athletes The prevalence rate of eating disorders is high among female athletes (Sherman and Thompson, 2001). Female athletes of all levels of sport ability ranging from adolescents in middle school and high school, to young adults in college, and elite and professional levels (Greenleaf et al., 2009) develop unhealthful eating behaviors from a multitude of factors including biological, psychological, and social factors. In addition, it is suggested from across these literatures (e.g., Blackmer et at, 2011; Greenleaf et al, 2009; Hulley and Hill, 2001; Scoffier et al, 2010; Skowron and Frielander, 1994) that eating disorders among female athletes can start at any age. While an eating disorder can be diagnosed at any age, it can also develop within any sport. This includes but not limited to sports such as basketball, cheerleading, cross country, dance, field hockey, gymnastics, ice skating, softball, soccer, swimming and diving, tennis, and track and field (e.g., Holm-Denoma et al, 2009; Karin de Bruin et al, 2011; Scoffier et al, 2010; and Sherman and Thompson, 2001). Competitive female athletes of all ages, from middle school to professionals, are more likely to develop an eating disorder, disordered eating behaviors and unhealthful relationships with food compared to club athletes, independent exercisers, and non-exercisers (Holm- Denoma et al., 2009). This paper will also discuss eating disorders such as anorexia nervosa, bulimia nervosa, excessive exercise, binge eating, and eating disorders not otherwise specified. Before discussing the biological, psychological, and social factors, consideration needs to be brought to these female athletes that they are marginalized for their mental illness.
  • 4. 4 Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES Marginalization Male athletes are labeled as having a women's problem if they do report their eating disorder (Sherman and Thompson, 2001). Female athletes are marginalized because of their eating disorder in their sport. Being body conscious is one of the early signs of developing an eating disorder (Sherman and Thompson, 2001) and if men become body conscious then they are perceived as less of a man (Griffiths et al., 2014). Women are already marginalized, but to then get diagnosed with an eating disorder adds more feelings of feeling abnormality. To marginalize, from the Merriam Webster Dictionary, 2014 means to put someone in an unimportant position and feel powerless from a group or society. Female athletes especially college female athletes have to balance a lot in their lives such as school, work, and other life demands but to then have an added stressor of feeling rejected by their peers can have a bad impact to their overall well- being (Skowron and Friedlander, 1994). Churruca, et al, 2014 conducted a study of adults with eating disorders who participated in a Q methodology study online. The Q methodology used both qualitative and quantitative techniques. This particular Q methodological study explored constructions of bulimia. The first step of a Q methodological study to put together a set of items or statements about the topic, in this particular study it was bulimia. The subtopics of the statements in this study included: bulimia as a problem, bulimia as a solution, bulimia as a choice, bulimia as a person, bulimia as normative, and bulimia as marginalized (Churruca et al., 2014). The participants were mostly women, but consisted of men also. From the subtopics some of the specific statements were: bulimia as uncontrolled behavior, bulimia is a distressing mental illness, bulimia is a way to lose weight, self-medicating with food, the pathological pursuit of thinness, being the best at being thin, and extreme behavior verse mentally ill. There was two
  • 5. 5 Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES main findings from this study. The findings were that men can in fact develop bulimic behaviors as well as bulimia being a very serious mental illness. Despite that results do show that both men and women can develop an eating disorder, women are still at a higher risk for disordered eating and eating disorders (Holm-Denoma et al., 2009). Furthermore, there is no evidence suggesting that the prevalence of disordered eating in athletes is declining (National Collegiate Athletic Association and American College of Sports Medicine c.f. Sherman and Thompson, 2009). Holm-Denoma et al., (2009) expanded on this statistic by doing a meta-analysis and found that women in sports are at an increased risk for developing an eating disorder. One of the implications of the study was that varsity and club athletes at the university did not represent the different body types in the different sports well because there was no gymnastics and figure skating teams (Holm-Denoma et al., 2009). This is an implication because certain sports may be associated with higher levels of eating disorders than others (Holm-Denoma et al., 2009). In conclusion, there are a multitude of factors as mentioned previously that can contribute to the development of an eating disorder such as the type of sport. The psychological and social factors later in this paper will discuss why the type of sport the female athlete participates in has a strong correlation with eating disorders. Female athletes who are diagnosed with eating disorders may deal with more marginalization than non-athletes. This is because of the interpersonal pressure they may place on themselves along with the biological, psychological, and social factors that contribute. Interpersonal meaning the type characteristics within the personality the athlete may have in which this can be determinant factor on whether the athlete is at a greater chance in developing an eating disorder. Sherman and Thompson, (2001) explained that female athletes may have a strong drive on pleasing their coaches, parents, as well as accepting nothing less than a perfect
  • 6. 6 Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES performance. The psychological and social factors will be discussed later in this literature review in relation to these attributes. In addition to what Churruca et al., (2014) conducted, Hinton and Kubas , (2005) did a similar study using the ATHLETE questionnaire to also determine what kind of behaviors may result in an eating disorder. The participants were undergraduate college female athletes from a Division 1 university. This questionnaire measured six factors such as drive for thinness and performance, social pressure on eating, performance perfectionism, social pressure on body shape, and team trust. Given the six psychological and social factors the results were consistent and valid in which there is a direct association with disordered eating behaviors and female athletes. The factors mentioned above in the study is what these female athletes deal with mentally and emotionally. Most of these women are successful not just in their sport, but in other areas of their life as well (Sherman and Thompson, 2001). Having these constant negative self perceptions only lowers their self- esteem and overall quality of life (Sherman and Thompson, 2001). These female athletes with eating disorders are marginalized and not in the mainstream. They are stigmatized for their mental illness as being weak physically and mentally, self- centered, wanting attention, disgusting, and less of a woman (Griffiths et al., 2014). Not being in the mainstream, meaning they have different behaviors about food so to others this could be viewed as not being normal. So much is expected from female athletes from doing well in school, having a job, and to be role models to other female athletes. When these women are suffering from a severe mental disorder such as an eating disorder it may be harder for them to balance the other aspects of their life well (Griffiths et al., 2014). Marginalization among female athletes with eating disorders may imply to their peers that they are physically and mentally weak. Even when the athlete makes a full recovery from the eating disorder they might always
  • 7. 7 Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES be labeled as the athlete with the eating disorder. When this label is upon them it may become their new identity rather than being looked at as a holistic person with other qualities (Griffiths et al., 2014). The next section of this paper will discuss the biological factors that accompany the development of an eating disorder. Biological Factors While psychological and social factors are a bigger part to contribute to an eating disorder, biological factors are also a part to contribute to the onset of an eating disorder (e.g. Blackmer et al, 2011; Churruca et al, 2014; Greenleaf et al, 2009; Griffiths et al, 2014; Skowron and Friedlander, 1994). The biological aspects include body mass index and body fat. Three different articles (Churruca et al., 2014; Malinauskas et al, 2007; Reel et al, 2014) discuss the body mass index and body fat within their studies. In the study done by Malinauskas et al., (2007) found that body mass index and body fat contributed to psychological factors. The psychological factors will be discussed later. If the athlete already struggles with anxiety, low self-esteem, and or body dissatisfaction then they may have the drive for thinness to lower their body mass index and body fat (Reel et al, 2013). This implies that if female athletes are not satisfied with their biological appearance they may use unhealthful eating habits to change their body composition. Furthermore, the kind of sport the female athlete is in may determine whether they are at a higher risk for developing disordered eating or an eating disorder. Malinauskas et al., (2007) and Reel et al., (2013) both did studies similar on how body mass index and body fat correlates with what sport the athlete is in and whether or not they are at a high risk for developing an eating disorder. On the other hand, Hausenblas and McNally (c.f. Malinauskas et al, 2007)
  • 8. 8 Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES argued that athletes have less of a chance in developing an eating disorder or disordered eating symptoms because they have a healthier psychological functioning compared to non-athletes. Warren et al., (1989) went further with this opposition in their study about disordered eating patterns in competitive female athletes with a focus on cross country runners and gymnasts. The participants were 82 female athletes from a Division 1 program, but only 74 volunteered for the study while the remaining athletes were controls. The Eating Disorders Inventory (EDI) and Eating Attitudes Test (EAT) were used in the study. The results that were found was that cross country runners and gymnasts differed from each other. Warren et al, (1989) found that from the EDI and EAT cross country runners reported less symptoms of disordered eating than female non-athletes and gymnasts. Because gymnastics is a sport in which the athlete is being judged on physical appearance, there is a higher chance of these athletes developing disordered eating. One hypothesis suggested by Warren et al, (1989) is that gymnasts may become preoccupied with their body mass index and body fat because the nature of the sport requires lean physiques for optimal performance or at least this is how the gymnast perceives as the only option in being successful. In conclusion, female cross country runners are at a lower risk for body dissatisfaction than gymnasts (Warren et al., 1989). This may be because runners do not have to be judged on physical appearance. This includes other sports such as volleyball that may be at a lower risk for disordered eating because low body weight is not always an important factor for achieving athletic success (Rosen et al., 1986 c.f. Warren et al., 1989). On the oppositional side, (Clark et al, 1988 c.f. Warren et al, 1989) surveyed female elite runners and the results reported a history of anorexia nervosa and disordered eating. In conclusion, so say that the biological factors such as body mass index and body fat determine whether the athlete develops an eating disorder or not is not consistent or valid. While gymnastics may correlate with a higher risk of
  • 9. 9 Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES developing unhealthful eating behaviors than other sports such as cross country or volleyball because of the nature of the sport other factors such as psychological and social are factored in. In conclusion of biological factors, a sport like gymnastics may have athletes with more muscular build and have a drive to be thin regardless of their biology and the judging criteria of the sport on appearance. On the other end, a sport such as cross country distance running does not have an emphasis on appearance to possibly cause distorted body image and eventually over time the athlete may become thinner than other athletes due to the nature of running. Overall, athletes with their own biological make up may want to try and change their body composition if they feel their body mass index or body weight is the reason for a decrease in performance. The psychological factors are discussed in the next section on why some female athletes are more at risk of an eating disorder than others. Psychological Factors The psychological factors of an eating disorder in female athletes are still unclear according to Hinton and Kubas, 2005. But rather across these literatures are hypotheses about what can constitute toward an eating disorder. This may include self-perception of how the athlete perceives herself out of sport and within her sport as well as the personality of the athlete such as feelings of inadequacy and anxiety. While Hinton and Kubas, 2005 suggest that psychological factors are unclear, their ATHLETE Questionnaire as mentioned previously, was designed to assess psychological factors associated with disordered eating in athletes (Hinton and Kubas, 2005). Joining sports results in positive outcomes such as higher self esteem and overall emotional and physical well-being (Hinton and Kubas, 2005). But these female athletes as stated by previous studies (e.g. Holm-Denoma et al, 2009; Karin de Bruin et al, 2011; Reel et al, 2013; Skowron and Friedlander, 1994) that there is enough data to support the hypothesis that female
  • 10. 10 Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES athletes are at a greater risk for developing an eating disorder more so than non-athletes (Hinton and Kubas, 2005). The ATHLETE questionnaire tested six different areas within varsity female athletes from three different Division 1 universities in nine different sports. The athletes ages ranged from 18-22. The athletic trainers administered the questionnaires to the athletes without the coaches in the room. The six different areas in the questionnaire that were measured were body dissatisfaction, drive for thinness, interoceptive awareness, perfectionism, ineffectiveness, and interpersonal distrust. Three additional areas were tested as well, but they are societal factors that include social pressure on body shape, social pressure on eating behaviors, and the important of being an athlete to self-concept (Hinton and Kubas, 2005). While the six different areas were listed that the questionnaire tested, the Eating disorder inventory was also used in this study along with other measures. The Eating Disorder Inventory (EDI) included a drive for thinness construct which is the desire to be leaner to improve performance or appearance and using excessive and compulsive training above what is require from the athlete (Hinton and Kubas, 2005). The other six constructs' descriptions includes dissatisfaction with body appearance and body effectiveness related to performance, lack of control and feeling powerless regarding playing time, training, and performance, excessive personal expectations for superior achievement and/or avoidance of failure, reluctant to form close relationships with teammates because of competition for roster positions, playing time, scholarships, and attention from coach, and the inability to recognize physical hunger and overtraining (Hinton and Kubas, 2005). Female athletes put a great deal of pressure on themselves by using the fitness level of their bodies as a way of determining their athletic success. One of the results from this study was the 60% of female athletes reported wanting to lose five pounds, and 30% were trying to lose weight
  • 11. 11 Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES for their sport (Hinton and Kubas, 2005). This drive to want to lose weight while already being highly physically active may increase the chances of the athlete to develop an eating disorder. (Skowron and Friedlander, 1994). The female athletes in literatures previously mentioned still want to lose weight whether it is to increase sport performance or wanting to become thinner not related to sport in which this case society has to be blamed for. The desire in wanting to become thinner among the female athlete will be discussed in the next subtopic. One other factor that could be included is whether the athlete has been dealing with an eating disorder before joining a sport. This factor may be out of scope for this paper, but will be taken into consideration. In continuation of the ATHLETE questionnaire by Hinton and Kubas, 2005 there were five distinct psychological factors such as drive for thinness, social pressure on eating, performance perfectionism, social pressure on body shape, and team trust. The athletes had to decide on how much the statements were true to them or not. Some of the statements that were included was, I would be more successful in my sport if my body looked better, I train more than is required by my sport to burn more calories, I feel uncomfortable eating in front of my friends (non-athletes), coach, family, teammates, No matter how successful I am, I never feel satisfied, My friends, coach, family, teammates, or society makes me feel fat, Being an athlete is my most meaningful ability, and lastly, It is hard to get close to my teammates because we are constantly competing against each other. The end results from this study indicates that five psychological factors were affirmatively associated with disordered eating behaviors in female athletes (Hinton and Kubas, 2005). Limitations of this study were that the study relied on self-reported attitudes and eating behaviors and the truthfulness and accuracy of the self-reported responses are subject to question (Hinton and Kubas, 2005). For future research the ATHLETE will be used in studying the etiology of disordered eating in female athletes (Hinton and Kubas, 2005). While
  • 12. 12 Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES the multitude of the many psychological factors are supported by the research in which how some female athletes may be at a higher risk than others, societal factors account for last part in the biopsychosocial model. Social Factors The sports culture, explained by Reel et al., 2013 brings greater demands to the individual female athlete such as body weight, shape, size, sports that emphasize thinness, muscularity, or a particular build. On the other hand, being a part of a sports team can bring many positives into the athlete’s life. Making new friends, feeling a sense of belongingness, camaraderie, and benefits physically are just some of positives an athlete can gain. In fact, sports can enhance mental well-being as well (Blackmer et al., 2011). While sports have many advantages, the environment of sports may also increase the risk for disordered eating, distorted body image, and eating disorders (Reel et al., 2013). Petrie and Greenleaf, 2012 c.f. Reel et al., 2013 explained that even when the athletes specific sport may require weigh-ins, judging criteria, fitting into fitted uniforms, the psychological and personality factors of the athlete could be a strong influence in whether they are at risk. The people in the athlete’s life has a direct relationship with developing unhealthful eating behaviors. Sherman and Thompson, 2001 further explain that needing to please the coach, teammates, or the family correlates highly with the athlete doing so by losing weight to get faster or because they think they are too fat. From these societal influences, they can bring body concern which can result in anxiety in regards to athletic performance and start the disordered relationship with food cycle (William et al., 1995 c.f. Sherman and Thompson, 2001). If the pressures do not come from the sport environment such as to lose weight or body fat to perform better than it can come from the athlete (Sherman and Thompson, 2001) The societal pressures in sport might always exist due to the nature of sports
  • 13. 13 Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES being competitive and with the athletes in these sports usually having the drive to achieve excellence it again refers back to the biological and psychological factors. This implies that some athletes may not feel any of these social pressures whereas others may be affected entirely. Eating disorders and disordered eating not only affects the athlete mentally, but also physically by resulting in long term health effects from inadequate nutrition. This last section in the literature review discusses the long term health effects from eating disorders such as anorexia nervosa, bulimia nervosa, eating disorders not otherwise specified, and disordered eating patterns. Long Term Health Effects Being an athlete is physically demanding on the body, but to then have an eating disorder in which the body is not getting proper nutrients is an even greater demand from the body. Jill Thein-Nissenbaum, 2013 did a study on the long-term consequences of the female athlete triad. The Female Athlete Triad (FAT) is comprised of three components, disordered eating, amenorrhea, and osteoporosis (Thein-Nissenbaum, 2013). These three components is what health care providers and athletic trainers should examine the athlete for. The female athlete triad may not always result in an eating disorder or vice verse. Morgenthal, 2002 explains that because of the hard physical training the athlete puts her body through, the body responds by making these regular systems irregular. This means the loss of the menstrual cycle, hormones like estrogen and progesterone decrease, constant fatigue, depression, decreased performance, and other endocrine abnormalities (Morgenthal, 2002). Moreover, Williams et al. 1995 c.f. Morgenthal, 2002 concluded that the athletes training might not be enough to produce these irregular systems unless low caloric intake is present.
  • 14. 14 Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES The female athlete triad may not be the only result from inadequate nutrients, fertility and cardiovascular problems are also at risk. Female athlete triad effects athletes in the high school, collegiate, and elite levels (Thein-Nissenbaum, 2013). In conclusion to the female athlete triad both the reproductive and skeletal (osteoporosis) systems are severely affected. Cardiovascular disease osteoporosis, and fertility and pregnancy problems are just a few of the many health outcomes from anorexia nervosa in the female athlete (Meczekalski et al., 2013). Meczekalski et al., 2013 found that 80% of patients with eating disorders reported cardiac complications and osteoporosis was commonly diagnosed in teenagers before achieving their peak bone mineral density. In conclusion to these findings across these studies when the athlete restores her weight to a normal range she might always deal with cardiovascular problems and may never gain full bone density back. As previously mentioned, the result from osteoporosis is bone mineral density never being restored again, (Morgenthal, 2002) therefore these women may always have a higher risk for stress fractures along with other chronic irregularities. As studies have shown that eating disorders can affect the female athlete at any age, the female athlete triad can be diagnosed at any age. In an article by Sherman and Thompson, 2006 on the International Olympic Committee Medical Commission Position Stand on the Female Athlete Triad: A Case Example explores the female athlete triad in elite and professional female athletes. This study explored the three components of the triad just as previous studies have done, but the results of this particular study stand out. Other results from previous studies found correlations between female athletes and whether they were at risk or not in developing disordered eating or an eating disorder from the biological, psychological, and social factors. But the results from this study by Sherman and Thompson, 2006 was that the Olympic Committee
  • 15. 15 Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES Medical Position stand found strategies for managing the issues and problems regarding the referral, evaluation, and treatment of the female athlete triad. Conclusion The biological, psychological, and social factors among female athletes and eating disorders all have a significant role in whether the athlete develops unhealthful relationships with food. Each of the different literatures explored not only the biopsychosocial model, but other factors related. Some opposing viewpoints throughout this literature review was that female cross country runners may show symptoms and the developments of an eating disorder, but other articles argued that because cross country runners are not in an judging criteria sport such as gymnastics they are at a less risk. But what if an athlete doesn't meet full criteria for a clinical or subclinical eating disorder then what category in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition would this athlete fall into? The implications of this literature review paper is the lack of comparison throughout the paper between varsity athletes, club, athletes, independent exercisers, and non- athletes there was. As well as going not further in depth on specific areas within the subtopics. Because this literature review has a length requirement, expanding on other possible factors that could contribute to an eating disorder could not be done. Not always being able to arrive at a conclusion was difficult because of the complexity of the topic. For the future, more research should be done on female athletes with anxiety, depression, obsessive compulsive disorder, and addictive behaviors to determine if they are at a higher, lower, or the same risk of developing an eating disorder compared to female athletes without other mental disorders. Moreover, future research should also be done on female athletes and marginalization.
  • 16. 16 Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES References Abood, D., Black, D., & Birnbaum, R. (2004). Nutrition Education Intervention For College Female Athletes. Journal of Nutrition Education and Behavior, 36(3), 135-139. Blackmer, V., Searight, H., & Ratwik, S. (2011). The Relationship between Eating Attitudes, Body Image and Perceived Family- of Origin Climate among College Athletes. North American Journal of Psychology, 13(3), 435-446. Bruin, A., Oudejans, R., Bakker, F., & Woertman, L. (2011). Contextual body image and athletes' disordered eating: The contribution of athletic body image to disordered eating in high performance women athletes. European Eating Disorders Review, 201-215. Churruca, K., Perz, J., & Ussher, J. (2014). Uncontrollable behaviors or mental illness? Exploring constructions of bulimia using Q methodology. Journal of Eating Disorders,2(22), 1-14. Greenleaf, C., Petrie, T., Carter, J., & Reel, J. (2009). Female Collegiate Athletes: Prevalence Of Eating Disorders And Disordered Eating Behaviors. Journal of American College Health, 57(5), 489-496. Griffiths, S., Mond, J., Murray, S., & Touyz, S. (2014). The Prevalence and Adverse Associations of Stigmatization in People with Eating Disorders. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 1-8. Hinton PhD, P., & Kubas MS, RD, K. (2005). Psychosocial Correlates of Disordered Eating in Female Collegiate Athletes: Validation of the ATHLETE Questionnaire. Journal of American College Health, 54(3), 149-156.
  • 17. 17 Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES Holm-Denoma, J., Scaringi, V., Gordon, K., Orden, K., & Joiner, T. (2008). Eating disorder symptoms among undergraduate varsity athletes, club athletes, independent exercisers, and non-exercisers. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 47-53. Hulley, A., & Hill, A. (2001). Eating disorders and health in elite women distance runners.International Journal of Eating Disorders, 312-317. Krentz, E., & Warschburger, P. (2011). Sports-Related Correlates of Disordered Eating in Aesthetic Sports. Psychology of Sports and Exercise, 375-382 Malinauskas, B., Cucchiara, A., Aeby, V., & Bruening, C. (2007). Physical activity, disordered eating risk, and anthropometric measurement: A comparison of college of college female athletes and non athletes. College Student Journal, 41(1), 217-222. Meczekalski, B., Podfigurna-Stopa, A., & Katulski, K. (2013). Long-term consequences of anorexia nervosa. Maturitas, 215-220. Morgenthal, A. (2002). Female Athlete Triad. Journal of Chiropractic Medicine, 1(3), 97-106. National Eating Disorders Association- Athletes and Eating Disorders - 2006 - http://www.nationaleatingdisorders.org Nieves, J., Melsop, K., Curtis, M., Kelsey, J., Bachrach, L., Greendale, G., ... Sainani, K. (2010). Nutritional Factors That Influence Change in Bone Density and Stress Fracture Risk Among Young Female Cross-Country Runners. PM&R, 2(8), 740-750. Reel, J., Petrie, T., Soohoo, S., & Anderson, C. (2013). Weight pressures in sport: Examining the factor structure and incremental validity of the weight pressures in sport — Females. Eating Behaviors, 137-144.
  • 18. 18 Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES Scoffier, S., Maiano, C., & D' Arripe-Longueville, F. (2010). The Effects of Social Relationships and Acceptance on Disturbed Eating Attitudes in Elite Adolescent Female Athletes: The Mediating Role of Physical Self-perceptions. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 65-71. Skowron, E., & Friedlander, M. (1994). Psychological Separation, Self-Control, and Weight Preoccupation Among Elite Women Athletes. Journal of Counseling & Development, 72, 310-315. Sherman, R., Thompson, R., Dehass, D., & Wilfert, M. (2005). NCAA Coaches Survey: The Role of the Coach in Identifying and Managing Athletes with Disordered Eating. Eating Disorders, 447-466. Sherman, R., & Thompson, R. (2001a). Athletes And Disordered Eating: Four Major Issues For The Professional Psychologist. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, 32(1), 27-33. Sherman, R., & Thompson, R. (2006b). Practical use of the International Olympic Committee Medical Commission position stand on the female athlete triad: A case example. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 193-201. Stewart, T., Plasencia, M., Han, H., Jackson, H., & Becker, C. (2014). Moderators and predictors of response to eating disorder risk factor reduction programs in collegiate female athletes. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 713-720. Thein-Nissenbaum, J. (2013). Long term consequences of the female athlete triad.Maturitas, 107- 112.
  • 19. 19 Running head: EATING DISORDERS AND FEMALE ATHLETES Warlick, D. (2000, October 29). Create your APA journal citation. Retrieved December 3, 2014, from http://www.citationmachine.net/apa/cite-a-journal/create Warren, B., Stanton, A., & Blessing, D. (1990). Disordered eating patterns in competitive female athletes. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 9(5), 565-569.