SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 14
Elegant Caucasians,Amorous Arabs,and Invisible Others Signs and Images of Foreigners in Japanese BL Manga SayakaTsujii AlidaNurSakinah
Boys Love Female fantasies of idealised male homosexual relationships The Development: 1970s24-nen gumi 1980sani-paro; doujinshi 1990sboom of male homosexuality sector in Japanese book market
Ani-paro
Why would female loveBoys Love? Romantic plot Female desires Pain, fear, abandonment, escapism Female subconscious escapist desires
Foreigner Appearances Majority of the characters: Japanese 100 from 140 BL manga magazines (published between November 2004-June 2008) contain stories featuring foreign characters Most of the foreign characters: Caucasian Arab
Stop and Think. Why would female readers prefer Caucasian and Arab characters and effectively erase representations of characters of other races?
Images of Caucasians Positive qualities: elegance, gracefulness, social success/status, etc. Stereotypes Dramatic narrative devices Vividly emphasized Caucasians=Successful men
Caucasian worship/idealization Blonde, blue-eyed Caucasian characters Enhance readers’ romantic, escapist satisfaction!   Superior signs Female BL fans can imaginatively identify with the male homosexual characters in the fantasies
Semeand Uke Seme(literally attack, connoting the male sexual role) Uke(literally receive, connoting the female sexual role) Caucasian BL characters Generally appear as seme Out of 29 cases of Caucasian-Japanese lovers, 22 follow this pattern: Japanese = an ordinary feminine character Caucasian = an elegant, rich Westerner of high social status  Superior others!!
OccidentVS Orient McClintock Relationship between the Caucasian semeand Japanese (Orient) uke Socio/culturally constructed ideology of a strong, masculine West and a weak, feminine Orient is subconsciously inscribed, even in narratives which are only concerned with the depiction of Japanese female fantasies
Arab Characters Arab characters = Seme Japanese characters = Uke Generally portrayed as stereotypical sexual otherswith a vast amount of money Money (fortune) enhances women’s romantic motivations Primary concern: Money Personal characteristics: amorousness and eroticism
Differences between Caucasian and Arab Seme Racial textuality Caucasian seme Superior, masculine subjects Reflect the ideological necessity to reinforce the imperialist voice by feminizing the Orient/Japan Arab seme Symbols of eroticism by means of Orientalistic images of harems and polygamy
Absent Others vs. Constructed Others 1950s American films: No African-Americans lives are represented African-Americans = Invisible, negative sign 透明なマイノリティー (Invisible minority) Signs of Superiority and inferiority Does not signify the liberation of that race, but rather itsinvisibility The negative connotations of specific races are merely repressed, not eliminated!! Constructed others (Caucasians and Arabians) vs. Absent others (invisible race)
BL Movies: Takumikun Series http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z_5JHoI7ipw

More Related Content

What's hot

Mulvey lesson 8
Mulvey   lesson 8Mulvey   lesson 8
Mulvey lesson 8
sezpenfold
 
Gender in Film (TV Y1)
Gender in Film (TV Y1)Gender in Film (TV Y1)
Gender in Film (TV Y1)
Simon Wright
 
Media essay life on mars
Media essay life on marsMedia essay life on mars
Media essay life on mars
SamMedia1
 
Gender In Film (DAPS 6 and 7)
Gender In Film (DAPS 6 and 7)Gender In Film (DAPS 6 and 7)
Gender In Film (DAPS 6 and 7)
Simon Wright
 
Laura Mulvey and Campion's 'The Piano'
Laura Mulvey and Campion's 'The Piano'Laura Mulvey and Campion's 'The Piano'
Laura Mulvey and Campion's 'The Piano'
Rachel Jones
 

What's hot (19)

Laura mulvey male gaze textual analysis media
Laura mulvey male gaze textual analysis mediaLaura mulvey male gaze textual analysis media
Laura mulvey male gaze textual analysis media
 
Male gaze theory
Male gaze theoryMale gaze theory
Male gaze theory
 
Art Spiegelman, Comix, and Maus
Art Spiegelman, Comix, and MausArt Spiegelman, Comix, and Maus
Art Spiegelman, Comix, and Maus
 
Narrative Theorist Genre
Narrative Theorist Genre Narrative Theorist Genre
Narrative Theorist Genre
 
Mulvey lesson 8
Mulvey   lesson 8Mulvey   lesson 8
Mulvey lesson 8
 
Gender in Film (TV Y1)
Gender in Film (TV Y1)Gender in Film (TV Y1)
Gender in Film (TV Y1)
 
Laura Mulvey - Male Gaze Theory Research
Laura Mulvey - Male Gaze Theory ResearchLaura Mulvey - Male Gaze Theory Research
Laura Mulvey - Male Gaze Theory Research
 
Codes and Conventions of Horror Film
Codes and Conventions of Horror FilmCodes and Conventions of Horror Film
Codes and Conventions of Horror Film
 
Mulvey Theory on gender representation
Mulvey Theory on gender representationMulvey Theory on gender representation
Mulvey Theory on gender representation
 
2. meaning (lf)
2. meaning (lf)2. meaning (lf)
2. meaning (lf)
 
Media essay life on mars
Media essay life on marsMedia essay life on mars
Media essay life on mars
 
Laura Mulvey - The Male Gaze
Laura Mulvey - The Male Gaze Laura Mulvey - The Male Gaze
Laura Mulvey - The Male Gaze
 
TV Drama Sexuality
TV Drama SexualityTV Drama Sexuality
TV Drama Sexuality
 
NYCC 2015 Educational Panels by Comic Book School
NYCC 2015 Educational Panels by Comic Book SchoolNYCC 2015 Educational Panels by Comic Book School
NYCC 2015 Educational Panels by Comic Book School
 
Types of Characters
Types of CharactersTypes of Characters
Types of Characters
 
Gender In Film (DAPS 6 and 7)
Gender In Film (DAPS 6 and 7)Gender In Film (DAPS 6 and 7)
Gender In Film (DAPS 6 and 7)
 
Ready for Romance Award Winning Titles
Ready for Romance Award Winning TitlesReady for Romance Award Winning Titles
Ready for Romance Award Winning Titles
 
The male gaze theory - media
The male gaze theory - mediaThe male gaze theory - media
The male gaze theory - media
 
Laura Mulvey and Campion's 'The Piano'
Laura Mulvey and Campion's 'The Piano'Laura Mulvey and Campion's 'The Piano'
Laura Mulvey and Campion's 'The Piano'
 

Similar to Elegant caucasians, amorous arabs, and invisible

Oriental pp media
Oriental pp mediaOriental pp media
Oriental pp media
Cat Davies
 
Jmk 315 -_lecture_3_armah_
Jmk 315 -_lecture_3_armah_Jmk 315 -_lecture_3_armah_
Jmk 315 -_lecture_3_armah_
abe we
 
Running head FICTION ANALYSIS-BATTLE ROYAL .docx
Running head FICTION ANALYSIS-BATTLE ROYAL                       .docxRunning head FICTION ANALYSIS-BATTLE ROYAL                       .docx
Running head FICTION ANALYSIS-BATTLE ROYAL .docx
wlynn1
 
Representation of race & ethnicity
Representation of race & ethnicityRepresentation of race & ethnicity
Representation of race & ethnicity
Craig Osborne
 
Gift of the Magi William Sydney Porter or better known as O. H
Gift of the Magi William Sydney Porter or better known as O. HGift of the Magi William Sydney Porter or better known as O. H
Gift of the Magi William Sydney Porter or better known as O. H
MatthewTennant613
 

Similar to Elegant caucasians, amorous arabs, and invisible (20)

Things fall apart slides
Things fall apart slidesThings fall apart slides
Things fall apart slides
 
Things fall apart slides
Things fall apart slidesThings fall apart slides
Things fall apart slides
 
Things fall apart slides
Things fall apart slidesThings fall apart slides
Things fall apart slides
 
Oriental pp media
Oriental pp mediaOriental pp media
Oriental pp media
 
Jmk 315 -_lecture_3_armah_
Jmk 315 -_lecture_3_armah_Jmk 315 -_lecture_3_armah_
Jmk 315 -_lecture_3_armah_
 
Powerpoint.pptx
Powerpoint.pptxPowerpoint.pptx
Powerpoint.pptx
 
Running head FICTION ANALYSIS-BATTLE ROYAL .docx
Running head FICTION ANALYSIS-BATTLE ROYAL                       .docxRunning head FICTION ANALYSIS-BATTLE ROYAL                       .docx
Running head FICTION ANALYSIS-BATTLE ROYAL .docx
 
Characters
CharactersCharacters
Characters
 
ASIAN HORROR CINEMA
ASIAN HORROR CINEMAASIAN HORROR CINEMA
ASIAN HORROR CINEMA
 
Prospectus
ProspectusProspectus
Prospectus
 
Representation of race & ethnicity
Representation of race & ethnicityRepresentation of race & ethnicity
Representation of race & ethnicity
 
AFRICAN-LITERATURE NOTES AND MANUSCRIPT.pdf
AFRICAN-LITERATURE NOTES AND MANUSCRIPT.pdfAFRICAN-LITERATURE NOTES AND MANUSCRIPT.pdf
AFRICAN-LITERATURE NOTES AND MANUSCRIPT.pdf
 
Gift of the Magi William Sydney Porter or better known as O. H
Gift of the Magi William Sydney Porter or better known as O. HGift of the Magi William Sydney Porter or better known as O. H
Gift of the Magi William Sydney Porter or better known as O. H
 
Girl Power! How to create a female-friendly manga collection for your library...
Girl Power! How to create a female-friendly manga collection for your library...Girl Power! How to create a female-friendly manga collection for your library...
Girl Power! How to create a female-friendly manga collection for your library...
 
Recap on section
Recap on sectionRecap on section
Recap on section
 
Argumentative Essay Rubric 7Th Grade. Online assignment writing service.
Argumentative Essay Rubric 7Th Grade. Online assignment writing service.Argumentative Essay Rubric 7Th Grade. Online assignment writing service.
Argumentative Essay Rubric 7Th Grade. Online assignment writing service.
 
Task 4 media
Task 4   mediaTask 4   media
Task 4 media
 
Issues and syntax
Issues and syntaxIssues and syntax
Issues and syntax
 
Week 11 The Proposal.pptx
Week 11 The Proposal.pptxWeek 11 The Proposal.pptx
Week 11 The Proposal.pptx
 
Yusef Komunyakaa
Yusef KomunyakaaYusef Komunyakaa
Yusef Komunyakaa
 

Recently uploaded

Title Unlocking Imagination The Importance of Toca Boca for Kids.pdf
Title Unlocking Imagination The Importance of Toca Boca for Kids.pdfTitle Unlocking Imagination The Importance of Toca Boca for Kids.pdf
Title Unlocking Imagination The Importance of Toca Boca for Kids.pdf
Toca boca
 
week 3 questions and answers.phhhhhhhhhhptx
week 3 questions and answers.phhhhhhhhhhptxweek 3 questions and answers.phhhhhhhhhhptx
week 3 questions and answers.phhhhhhhhhhptx
joshuaclack73
 
8th Global Fashion and Design Week Noida 2024 Sets New Standards in Creative ...
8th Global Fashion and Design Week Noida 2024 Sets New Standards in Creative ...8th Global Fashion and Design Week Noida 2024 Sets New Standards in Creative ...
8th Global Fashion and Design Week Noida 2024 Sets New Standards in Creative ...
Marwah Studios
 
在线办理(concordia学位证书)康考迪亚大学毕业证学历学位证书学费发票原版一模一样
在线办理(concordia学位证书)康考迪亚大学毕业证学历学位证书学费发票原版一模一样在线办理(concordia学位证书)康考迪亚大学毕业证学历学位证书学费发票原版一模一样
在线办理(concordia学位证书)康考迪亚大学毕业证学历学位证书学费发票原版一模一样
ahafux
 
batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01
batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01
batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01
Patricia Pham
 
Vector Methods.pptxjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjj
Vector Methods.pptxjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjVector Methods.pptxjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjj
Vector Methods.pptxjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjj
joshuaclack73
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Title Unlocking Imagination The Importance of Toca Boca for Kids.pdf
Title Unlocking Imagination The Importance of Toca Boca for Kids.pdfTitle Unlocking Imagination The Importance of Toca Boca for Kids.pdf
Title Unlocking Imagination The Importance of Toca Boca for Kids.pdf
 
kiff2
kiff2kiff2
kiff2
 
The Gaming Quiz - 17th April 2024, Quiz Club NITW
The Gaming Quiz - 17th April 2024,  Quiz Club NITWThe Gaming Quiz - 17th April 2024,  Quiz Club NITW
The Gaming Quiz - 17th April 2024, Quiz Club NITW
 
WHO KILLED ALASKA? #17: Mirror Memoria - "OFFICER" TRANSCRIPT.pdf
WHO KILLED ALASKA? #17: Mirror Memoria - "OFFICER" TRANSCRIPT.pdfWHO KILLED ALASKA? #17: Mirror Memoria - "OFFICER" TRANSCRIPT.pdf
WHO KILLED ALASKA? #17: Mirror Memoria - "OFFICER" TRANSCRIPT.pdf
 
C&C Artists' Websites .
C&C Artists' Websites                       .C&C Artists' Websites                       .
C&C Artists' Websites .
 
week 3 questions and answers.phhhhhhhhhhptx
week 3 questions and answers.phhhhhhhhhhptxweek 3 questions and answers.phhhhhhhhhhptx
week 3 questions and answers.phhhhhhhhhhptx
 
Young & Hot ℂall Girls Visakhapatnam 8250077686 WhatsApp Number Best Rates of...
Young & Hot ℂall Girls Visakhapatnam 8250077686 WhatsApp Number Best Rates of...Young & Hot ℂall Girls Visakhapatnam 8250077686 WhatsApp Number Best Rates of...
Young & Hot ℂall Girls Visakhapatnam 8250077686 WhatsApp Number Best Rates of...
 
8th Global Fashion and Design Week Noida 2024 Sets New Standards in Creative ...
8th Global Fashion and Design Week Noida 2024 Sets New Standards in Creative ...8th Global Fashion and Design Week Noida 2024 Sets New Standards in Creative ...
8th Global Fashion and Design Week Noida 2024 Sets New Standards in Creative ...
 
The Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Best HD IPTV Service in 2024.pdf
The Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Best HD IPTV Service in 2024.pdfThe Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Best HD IPTV Service in 2024.pdf
The Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Best HD IPTV Service in 2024.pdf
 
small presentation about Star Wars/.pptx
small presentation about Star Wars/.pptxsmall presentation about Star Wars/.pptx
small presentation about Star Wars/.pptx
 
Vibration Control.pptxjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjj
Vibration Control.pptxjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjVibration Control.pptxjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjj
Vibration Control.pptxjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjj
 
在线办理(concordia学位证书)康考迪亚大学毕业证学历学位证书学费发票原版一模一样
在线办理(concordia学位证书)康考迪亚大学毕业证学历学位证书学费发票原版一模一样在线办理(concordia学位证书)康考迪亚大学毕业证学历学位证书学费发票原版一模一样
在线办理(concordia学位证书)康考迪亚大学毕业证学历学位证书学费发票原版一模一样
 
the red riding girl story fkjgoifdjgijogifdoin
the red riding girl story fkjgoifdjgijogifdointhe red riding girl story fkjgoifdjgijogifdoin
the red riding girl story fkjgoifdjgijogifdoin
 
Khaki-Files-Inside-Stories-of-Police-Missions-Kumar-Neeraj-Z-Library.pdf
Khaki-Files-Inside-Stories-of-Police-Missions-Kumar-Neeraj-Z-Library.pdfKhaki-Files-Inside-Stories-of-Police-Missions-Kumar-Neeraj-Z-Library.pdf
Khaki-Files-Inside-Stories-of-Police-Missions-Kumar-Neeraj-Z-Library.pdf
 
WHO KILLED ALASKA? #15: "5½ STORIES Part Two" Transcript .pdf
WHO KILLED ALASKA? #15: "5½ STORIES Part Two" Transcript .pdfWHO KILLED ALASKA? #15: "5½ STORIES Part Two" Transcript .pdf
WHO KILLED ALASKA? #15: "5½ STORIES Part Two" Transcript .pdf
 
NO1 Pakistan Vashikaran Specialist in Uk Black Magic Specialist in Uk Black M...
NO1 Pakistan Vashikaran Specialist in Uk Black Magic Specialist in Uk Black M...NO1 Pakistan Vashikaran Specialist in Uk Black Magic Specialist in Uk Black M...
NO1 Pakistan Vashikaran Specialist in Uk Black Magic Specialist in Uk Black M...
 
batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01
batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01
batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01
 
Vector Methods.pptxjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjj
Vector Methods.pptxjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjVector Methods.pptxjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjj
Vector Methods.pptxjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjj
 
Online Winbuzz ID Provider in India | Get Your Sports ID
Online Winbuzz ID Provider in India | Get Your Sports IDOnline Winbuzz ID Provider in India | Get Your Sports ID
Online Winbuzz ID Provider in India | Get Your Sports ID
 
Young & Hot ℂall Girls Jaipur 8250077686 WhatsApp Number Best Rates of Jaipur...
Young & Hot ℂall Girls Jaipur 8250077686 WhatsApp Number Best Rates of Jaipur...Young & Hot ℂall Girls Jaipur 8250077686 WhatsApp Number Best Rates of Jaipur...
Young & Hot ℂall Girls Jaipur 8250077686 WhatsApp Number Best Rates of Jaipur...
 

Elegant caucasians, amorous arabs, and invisible

  • 1. Elegant Caucasians,Amorous Arabs,and Invisible Others Signs and Images of Foreigners in Japanese BL Manga SayakaTsujii AlidaNurSakinah
  • 2. Boys Love Female fantasies of idealised male homosexual relationships The Development: 1970s24-nen gumi 1980sani-paro; doujinshi 1990sboom of male homosexuality sector in Japanese book market
  • 4. Why would female loveBoys Love? Romantic plot Female desires Pain, fear, abandonment, escapism Female subconscious escapist desires
  • 5. Foreigner Appearances Majority of the characters: Japanese 100 from 140 BL manga magazines (published between November 2004-June 2008) contain stories featuring foreign characters Most of the foreign characters: Caucasian Arab
  • 6. Stop and Think. Why would female readers prefer Caucasian and Arab characters and effectively erase representations of characters of other races?
  • 7. Images of Caucasians Positive qualities: elegance, gracefulness, social success/status, etc. Stereotypes Dramatic narrative devices Vividly emphasized Caucasians=Successful men
  • 8. Caucasian worship/idealization Blonde, blue-eyed Caucasian characters Enhance readers’ romantic, escapist satisfaction! Superior signs Female BL fans can imaginatively identify with the male homosexual characters in the fantasies
  • 9. Semeand Uke Seme(literally attack, connoting the male sexual role) Uke(literally receive, connoting the female sexual role) Caucasian BL characters Generally appear as seme Out of 29 cases of Caucasian-Japanese lovers, 22 follow this pattern: Japanese = an ordinary feminine character Caucasian = an elegant, rich Westerner of high social status Superior others!!
  • 10. OccidentVS Orient McClintock Relationship between the Caucasian semeand Japanese (Orient) uke Socio/culturally constructed ideology of a strong, masculine West and a weak, feminine Orient is subconsciously inscribed, even in narratives which are only concerned with the depiction of Japanese female fantasies
  • 11. Arab Characters Arab characters = Seme Japanese characters = Uke Generally portrayed as stereotypical sexual otherswith a vast amount of money Money (fortune) enhances women’s romantic motivations Primary concern: Money Personal characteristics: amorousness and eroticism
  • 12. Differences between Caucasian and Arab Seme Racial textuality Caucasian seme Superior, masculine subjects Reflect the ideological necessity to reinforce the imperialist voice by feminizing the Orient/Japan Arab seme Symbols of eroticism by means of Orientalistic images of harems and polygamy
  • 13. Absent Others vs. Constructed Others 1950s American films: No African-Americans lives are represented African-Americans = Invisible, negative sign 透明なマイノリティー (Invisible minority) Signs of Superiority and inferiority Does not signify the liberation of that race, but rather itsinvisibility The negative connotations of specific races are merely repressed, not eliminated!! Constructed others (Caucasians and Arabians) vs. Absent others (invisible race)
  • 14. BL Movies: Takumikun Series http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z_5JHoI7ipw