SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 16
The Effect of Equal Access to Capital Income through Equity Markets on Income Inequality
DarienLeblanc
Econ 231
ProfessorFrankLewis
November25,2016
As changesinsocial andeconomicpolicyattempttoclose the income gapit isof use to examine
the historical progressioninthe income of individuals asa resultof accessto capital income.
Investmentsinmanufacturingandotherlarge scale projectswere notfeasibleformajorityof citizens
duringthe Industrial revolution,due tosizable investmentrequirementsorlackof collateral neededto
access debtmarkets.The emergence of equitiesmarketsallowedforinvestmentopportunitieswithless
initial monetary outlay.Itisworthaskinghow equal accessto capital income,throughequitymarkets,
affectedincome inequality. Manyhistoriansandeconomistshave done soandrecordeddatarelative to
Income overmanyyears.Thisessaywill analyze thatdatainorder to come to an independentprognosis
regardingthe emergence of acceleratedincome inequality inrelationtocapital income changes.
I
It isimportantto firstrecognize the components of incomeif understandingitsinequalityisof
interest. Income iscomprisedof earningswhichone wouldgrossthroughthe sale of theirlabour
services,capital income whichisderivedfrominvestmentinanynumberof marketsandopportunities,
and governmenttransfersorthe redistributionof wealthperformedbythe governmentusingtaxation
and subsidies.Forthe purpose of simplicitygovernmenttransferswill be omitted fromall the following
calculation.Thusthe income equationwill become;I= E + K. It isuseful toobserve income inequality
withoutgovernmentintervention foranumberof reasons. Of greatestsignificance isthatthis essayis
not designedtounderstandorcritique how social policyeffectsincomeinequalitybutraterhow the
basicsof economicscanbe appliedtounderstandhow individualchoices andmarketcharacteristicscan
leadto an income gap betweenclasses.
It isabundantlyclearthatboth earningsandcapital have a directrelationshipwithIncome.This
meansthat the rate of appreciationordepreciationof bothearningsandcapital will directly affect
income bythe same rate. Examiningthe literature thatexistsregardingthissubjectone particular
conclusionfromthe prominenteconomistThomas Pikettycomestolight.Afterscrutinizingmanyyears
of income dataovera broad spectrumof countries Pikettycame tothe conclusionthat;“the private rate
of returnoncapital,r, can be significantlyhigherforlongperiodsof time thanthe rate of growthof
income or output”(Piketty, 2014, 571)8
. He exemplifiesthisusingthe historical averagereturn oncapital
(r) and trackingearningsgrowthoveran extensive timeperiod. Since capital income will appreciate ata
much fasterrate than earningsone canconclude capital income will have amuchgreatereffectonthe
change in income of individuals1
overthe longterm,oras Piketty callsitthe principal destabilizingforce.
To exemplifythisIwill show howaone dollarinvestmentinthe Britishequitiesmarketwould
appreciate overthe period1825-1870 if the investorwere toreceive the average returnforthe year.I
will alsoinvestinatheoretical earningsmarketwhere the returnisthe appreciationinthe wage forthat
year.Both investmentswill be fullyinvestedatall timestakingadvantage of compoundinginterest. The
data usedforreturn onBritishequitiesisatotal returnwhichfactorsin capital appreciationand
dividendyield.Itissafe toassume any rational individual withanaverage riskprofile whoinvestsinthe
marketwill strive fordiversificationandthustheirportfoliowill be ablendof equitiesfromall sectors
and dividendyieldingshares. The reasonforusingthisspecificdatasetwasnot onlydue to its
availabilityanditspreferredorganizationbutalsothatit addsperspective tohow aboomingequities
marketcan affectthe uninvested. The wage datausedare average nominal earningsinBritainforthe
respective year.
Figure 1: Investment appreciationof $1 in the British equitymarkets and the theoreticallabour market during the period 1825-
1870. Core Data for equitymarkets from Graeme G. Acheson, Charles R. Hickson, John D. Turner and Qing Ye (2009). Core
Labour market data from Gregory Clarke (2016). Calculation data listed in table 1.
Figure 2: Capitaland wage return fluctuation over the period 1825-1870. Core Data for equity markets from Graeme G.
Acheson, Charles R. Hickson, John D. Turner and Qing Ye (2009). Core La bour market data from Gregory Clarke (2016).
Calculation data listed in table 1.
The value of the dollarinvestedinthe theoretical earningsmarketoverthe 45 yearperiod
appreciatedto$1.75, a 75% increase over45 years. While the dollarinvestedinthe Britishequities
$0.00
$20.00
$40.00
$60.00
$80.00
$100.00
$120.00
$140.00
$160.00
1825
1828
1831
1834
1837
1840
1843
1846
1849
1852
1855
1858
1861
1864
1867
1870
Value
Investment in K and L Markets
Apreciation of Wage
Investment
Appreciation of Capital
Investment
-20
-10
0
10
20
30
40
1825
1827
1829
1831
1833
1835
1837
1839
1841
1843
1845
1847
1849
1851
1853
1855
1857
1859
1861
1863
1865
1867
1869
Return(%)
Change in Wage and Capital
Wage Rates
Capital
marketappreciatedto$169 overthe same period,a 16,800% increase. ThisExample hasproventhe
truth of Piketty’sconclusion.Hisproposal isquite profound,inthatitexemplifiesthatthose whodonot
or cannot investtheirearningswill fall substantiallybehindintermsof income comparedtothose who
do. It is because of this conclusionthatonlyone variable overtime will have aprofoundeffecton
income inequality,thatvariable beingcapital income2
. Thisallowsustofocusour studyon capital
income its emergence andtransitions, andtheirimpactondifferentincome classes.
II
If capital is the driverof income inequalityitisimportanttolook forinstanceswhere inequalityin
capital availabilityemerge betweenclasses.One instance of suchadisparitybetweenclasseswouldbe
the industrial revolution.Itisnowacceptedthatthe growthduringthisperiodwasnotas great as
previouslythought.Thiseconomicchange of heartdoesn’t alterthe factthat barriersof investment
neededtoaccessthisgrowth existed duringthisperiod.The inabilityforsome totake part inthe growth
howevermediocre itmayhave beencreates income separation betweenclasses.
The industrial revolutionischaracterizedbyinnovation drivinggrowth.Changesintechnology
that created,improvedanddrove industrylike hadneverbeenseenbefore.A suitable example would
be the textileindustry. Withinventionslikethe spinningjenny,carding engine andthe waterframe,
textile productioncouldnowbe mechanized.Thisledtofactorieswhere amultitudeof machinescould
be housedandproductionstandardized. The large productionandstandardizationof labourtasks
allowedforeconomiesof scale previouslyunexperienced.Byleveragingof these economiesof scale the
factorycouldcreate unheardof profitmarginsraisingsubstantialwealthfor theirowners andlenders.
To participate inthiswealth,one wouldhave toinvestinall the necessarycapital required.The
average cost of a 24 spindle spinningjennywasaround 70 shillings (Allen,2007, pg.5).Whichadjusted
to the current poundvalue3
wouldbe around £1,4724
(Lawrence H.OfficerandSamuel H.Williamson,
2016). By comparisonthe yearlyearnings of farmlabourer,middlegroupindividuals,andartisansin
1755, incurrent pounds3
,were 19.01,25.17, and 42.30 pounds respectively(Lindert,Williams,1983,
pg.12 figure 1). Asthe Investmentincapital necessaryforentryfarexceeded thananyof these income
groups’ yearlyearningsandbyextensiontheirabilitytoaccessdebtmarkets,itwouldhave been
impossible forthemtoenterthe boomingtextile manufacturing industry.Considering, onlythe rich
couldaccess thisfromof capital income theyheldanalmostcomplete monopolyoverit.Creating
unequal capital income andtherebyacceleratingincome inequality.
Usingdata collectedbyPikettywe canexemplifythischange.Firstlyhe allowsustostudythis
change by analysingthe makeupof capital income duringthisperiod.Ashe explainsamajor
transformationof capital tookplace. More specifically, thatfinancialcapital andindustrialcapital
emerged asthe mainsource of investmentratherthanthe previouslydominantlandcapital (farmland)
(Piketty, 2014, pg.342). Thisstatementisprovenbythe data he compiledrepresentedin figure 3.
Figure 3: Capital split in Britain. Source: Piketty (2014)
There isan obviousdownwardtrendinthe value of national capital comprisedof agricultural land
withotherdomesticcapital (financial andindustrial),makingupthe majorityof itslossforthe period
underquestion. The importance of thisisthatwe can now assume all wealthandcapital data is
primarily made upof increases infinancial andindustrial capital. Inotherwords,allowingus examineto
hisdata seton wealthinequalityinBritain,underthe pretence that changesare mostlydrivenby
increasesinfinancial andindustrial capital.Duringthe laterstage of the industrial revolution the share
of wealthof the top10% increasesfrom 80% to almost90% (Piketty,2014, figure.10.3).Thisbolsters the
presumption thatonly the wealthy wereable toinvestincapital duringthisperiodandthereby
benefitedtremendouslyfromit.
Figure 4: Wealth inequality Britain 1810-2010. Source: Piketty (2014)
Researchdone by PeterLindertoveranexpansive time period,1610 - 1910, yieldedthe
conclusionthat“wealthotherthanreal estate,orgross ‘personal estate’,became more unequallyheld
duringthe industrial revolutionera”(Lindert,1986, 1130). Withall fingerspointingatan increase in
capital inequalityitissafe tosay that the industrial revolutionandthe income inequalitythatemerged
was due to barriersof entryintocapital investmentforthe lesswell off.If the inability of some toinvest
couldcreate such inequalityone wouldexpectthatthe emergence of equal accesstocapital income
wouldhelptoclose thiswideninggap.
III
Aroundthe same time periodthe equitymarketsinBrittanhadgone throughdevastationafter
devastation. Chief amongthemthe SouthSeaandBengal bubblesof 1720 and 1769 respectfully. Both
had a considerablyadverseeffectonthe economyasa whole andseverely damagedinvestor
confidence.Thisperiod incapital marketshoused the earliestversionof jointcharteredstock
companies.Withsuspectregulationand alack of honestybetweenthe companieslistedand investors,
speculationandfraudranwild. The eventual crashof these bubbleshurtall income classes andseverely
affectedthe Britisheconomy.Itwouldbe dubious tocall thisan equitymarket.Withall mostno
regulationand rampedfrauditcouldbe bettercharacterizedasa financing ploy benefitingfroman
unobservantinvestorbase.
Many provincial exchangesexistedupuntil 1845. The original expectationwasthattheywouldbe
more informedaboutthe local listingsandthusbe transparent.The rail roadspeculationwashedaway
all but the mostfinancial soundexchanges.This episode representedthe needforacentral exchange
governedbystandardsandprincipalsthatcouldinformthe publicandavoidthe massspeculation.
The London StockExchange whichwasoriginallyformedin1801 and represented precisely what
Britainrequired.Creatingthe LSEallowedfornew rulesandregulationtobe enforced.Theserules
forcedthe exchangesmembertobe transparentand workinthe interestof theircustomersratherthan
theirownself-interest.The LSErepresentedthe largestandmostfinanciallysoundof all the exchanges
and wasable to navigate manyfinancial stormsandemerge steadied.The LSEinauguratedaticker
systemtoallowforequal knowledgeof equityprice fluctuationsin1830. Thenaround the rail road
speculationera,officiallyin1846, theyassuredthe publicabouttheirpricingsystemby havingeach
publishedprice markedbyanofficial of the LSE to assure that all quotes inflotation were legitimate.By
1853 the dominance of the LSE in Britainwasall but assuredas over70% of all rail road equity,the most
tradedand abundantduringthistime period, waslistedonthe LSE (RanaldMichie, 2001, chp.2).The
lastpiece of the puzzle,forgingfull transparency,isthe InvestorsMonthlyManual, whichwasfirst
publishedin18695
(YSM, 2016). The importance of the IMM cannot be understated. Thispublication
allowedforall investorstopeerintothe financialsof all listedcompanies. The IMMpostedchangesin
the equityanddebtof each companylistedonthe LSE and reviledpotentialthreatsoropportunities
each listingpossessed. WhichIbelieve isthe mostimportantstepincreatinganequal exchange asit
garnerstrust and transparency betweeninvestorandthe equity theyare purchasing.
Callingthe Britishequitymarketsup to1869 unjustwould seemcounterintuitive basedon the
example I gave inpart one. Duringthe period1825-1870, as I have alreadyshown,investmentinBritish
equity wouldhave beenextremely lucrative, seemingly counteringmyproposition.The problemisthat
variance inreturn was extremelyhigh duringthisperiod,representing adisparity inreturn between
investors.The standarddeviation7
intotal returnduringthisperiodwas11.73, witha max return of
53.23 and a minimumreturnof -16.93 (Acheson,Hickson, Turner,Ye,2009, Table 5).By comparisonthe
currentstandard deviation of the NYSEis0.6307 (macro axis,marketclose Nov23).The 1825-1870
variancescould be explained asknowledge gapbetweeninvestorsof differentincome classes. More
specificallythatthe higherincome classes makinggainsthroughathoroughunderstandingof the
companiesandthe poorfailingtomake the same return bynot fullyunderstandingthe company, more
oftenfallingintofraudulent traps. Once againturningto the data on wealthaccumulatedbythe top
10% from1825-1870 providedbyPiketty,itisevidentthatthe top10% increasedtheirshare.Since we
alreadyknowthischange wasdrivenby financial andindustrial wealthwe canassume the wealthydrew
mostof the gainsfrom this45 yearbull market.
The disseminationof companyinformationthroughthe investormanual would thenprove tobe
the keyto endunequal returnsinthe equitymarket. Thisisnottoobolda propositionas the variance in
returnpost 1870 pre WW1, droppedto constrained 3.89 whenforeignandBritishexpected return(on
equity) are setequal6
.(AndreyD.Ukhov andWilliamN.Goetzmann,2005, Table 8).
Some may findthe reliance on variance databeingthe lynchpininthisassumption suspect. To
furthersolidify myinference Iwill appraise the risksinvolvedwithinvestinginindustrial andfinancial
capital pre/post1869. In orderto do this one mustconsiderthe fieldof modernportfoliotheory more
specifically,the expectedvaluetheoremand applyingittothe twoinvestmenttype’spre/post1869.
Assumingthatinvestorsare riskadverse,theywill strive toreceive returnsthatwill payforexcess
risk. The expectedvalue isequal tothe value of aninvestmentmultipliedbythe probabilityof that
outcome.Withoutgoingtoomuch intothe actuarial side of finance andinvestmenttheorywe can
observe thatthe probabilitywill becomelessandlessaccurate asthe unknownsincrease orare harder
to quantify.From thisqualitative assumptionitiseasytosee thatcapital investmentsexpectedvalue is
much easiertoquantifyforthe pre 1869 period.Thinkingof capital investmentaspurchasingamachine
where one can examine itsproperfunctioning before the investmentismade.Thusthe onlyrisksare
businessspecifictothe industry the machine will applyto. Converselyinvestmentinequityduringthis
periodwasobviouslylesstangible,butalsoclose toimpossible toobserve the risks asthe company
financialswere not readily available.Withoutknowingthe financial healthof the companyorthe
external factorsitmaybe exposedtothere islimitedabilityto assess risk. Afterthe introductionof the
Investors MonthlyManual itbecomesmucheasierforthe investortoquantifyriskandmake informed
choices. Atthispointthe expectedvalue of investmentincapital andequityof the same outlay will
become similarlyappraisable.Nowthatthe expectedvaluesof financial andindustrial capital couldbe
calculatedinvestorswouldbe able toselectinvestmentforeithersectorwithsimilarexpectedreturns.
Provingthatafter1869 investorsof all incomescouldreceiveasimilarcapital income relativetotheir
investmentoutlay.
It isbecause of the progressive changesendinginthe introductionof the Investors Monthly
Manual that I wouldconsiderthe Londonstockexchange tobe fullyequal andtrustedforall in the year
1869. Allowingforall income classestoparticipate,investandreceive capital incomewithoutthe huge
monetary outlayrequiredbyinvestments inindustrial capital. One wouldthenexpectaquickand
deliberatedecreaseinwealthinequalityaround1869.
IV
Interestinglyenoughthe datacollectedbyPikettyactuallyshowedacceleration inthe capital
share ownedbythe rich from1870 to 1910. Thus increasedcapital income receivedbythe top10%,
increased income andthereby heightened income inequality.Runningcontrarytowhatwas expected,
whichbegsthe question,why?Howis itpossible thatall incomes classeshavingthe opportunityto
receive capital income widenedincome inequality? The simplestanswerwouldbe thatthe lower
income individualsdidn’ttake advantage of the newlyjustequitymarket. Toexamine the possible
explanations one mustconsultthe fieldof behavioural finance.
As previously explaineditissafe toassume that the lowerincome individualswere more often
caught infraudulent investmentsorinthe bubblesthatensnaredmuchof the workingclass.These dark
daysin the marketnegativelyaffectedinvestorconfidence makingitlesslikelyforinvestorstoreturnto
the market.The war storiesof lostfortunesinthe markettoldto childrenenshrinedthe market
fraudulence inthe mindof generationsof low andmiddle classcitizens.Thiswouldbe anexample of
anchoring,the tendencytothinkfroma reference point, usually illogical,inthe decision makingprocess.
For example, the childof afailedinvestormayforeversweartoavoidthe equitymarketdue totheir
familiespastmonetary loss.Theirdecisiondoesn’treflect the realitiesof the currentequitiesmarket
and wouldcause themtolose possible capital income. A second behavioural finance principle that
couldexplainthe situationisoverreaction.Inasingle securitythiswouldbe explainedbyinvestors
reactingto bad newsandpushingthe share price downtoa new low,whichshouldthennotchange
until newinformationisprovided.Thisissimilartothe reactionobservedduring bubblesandother
negative marketphenomena.Investorsseemedtodiscountthe marketasa whole decidingtowarda
waitand see approach,where onlyconstantgoodnewswouldchange theirmindsallowingthemto
investonce again. Lastlyprospecttheorymayexplainthe more emotionalside of low participation. The
theorystatesthat investorstendto have ahigheremotional response tolossesthantoa proportional
gain.Since the majorityof thisincome classreceivedlow ornegativereturnsprospecttheorywould
state these losseswouldprovide anextreme negative response, possiblycreatinganinvestorwhocould
no longerhandle the marketasa whole causingthemtoremove funds.Inall casesa psychological
tendencywouldhave compelled the marketparticipants’ actiontoremove fundsandall togetheravoid
the marketforgoingfuture capital income. Needlesstosaythose whohave lowerearningswillfind
capital lossesmore painful totheirbottomline thanthose of higherearnings.
The age oldphrase, time isthe healerof all wounds, seemstobe especiallytrue inthe case of
equitymarkets.As representedbyPikettyschartthe capital share receivedbythe top10% significantly
decreasesafterWW1 and WW2 decreasingbyabout20%. Pikettyexplainsthe final decrease in
accumulatedcapital bythe rich as due to the inaugurationof a tax on capital income duringWW1 and
the emergence of athickermiddle class,amongothers.The taxationdoesn’tseemlike areputable
answeras itwouldaffectall incomessimilarlyandforgoinganimportantsource of income simplydue to
small taxationanddoesn’tseemlikethe actionsof utilitymaximizingandrational consumer.The
increase inthe middle classdoeshoweverrepresentanincrease inthe numberof citizenswhocould
affordto investinequitymarkets. Workdone byMartinalsoindicatesthatduring1920 real wages
increasedrepresenting asurge indisposable income(Martin,2007, Tbl.12.3). Meaningthere wasan
increase inthe amountof Britishworkerswhocouldnow affordto investaportionof theirearnings
than inpreviousyears. Withthe tragedy’s’ of the warfirmlyplantedaheadof the fortuneslostinpost
marketfailures,one couldassume the psychological traitsthatwere previouslyhinderingmarketentry
were all butremoved.The inaugurationof the oldage pension in1908 may have also contributedto
increase investment.Withthislandmarksocial welfare reformcitizensbegantothinklongertermand
realizedthe needtoinvesttoreceiveenoughincome tolastthroughretirement,anew concept. With
an increase inthe middle classinvestorbase,theirability andthe willingnesstoenterthe equitymarket,
wealthwasswiftlyapprehended fromthe handsof the rich, as seeninfigure 4.
Figure 5: Income Share Over time. Source: The Equity Trust
V
Althoughthere wasasignificantlagbetween the decreaseinthe toptenpercents’ wealth
accumulationandthe emergence of ajustequitiesmarketitisassuredthatequities marketsandmore
specifically,the London StockExchange did trulyrepresentequal opportunityforall toreceive capital
income hence closingthe gapinincome inequality. Asshownin figure 5,income inequality did
significantlydecreasedfromthe 1930s up to 1979. One explanationforthisdecrease couldbe the
emergence toequal accesstoequitiesmarketsandamore inclinedandactive middle classinvestor
group.The precipitousincrease ininequalityfrom1979 to the present,formingmuchof today’spolitical
foddermayderive itssolutionfromthe pasttriumphsof capital income amongthe middleclassinvestor
from1910-1970’s.
Notes
1) It isassumedthat individuals ineachincome classare workingfulltime atthe average rate
appliedtotheirincome class. Historically,withthe exceptionof the 1990’s-2000’s, inequality
hasn’tbeendrivenbya polarizationinearnings.Bysimplyexaminingthe rate of change in
earnings,overaspecifiedperiod,thisbecomesenormouslyevident.The Earningdifferential
that tookplace in the1990’s- 2000’s can mainlybe attributedtothe lossof manufacturingand
otherlowskill middleclassworkandthe increase indemand andhoursworkedof more skilled
labour(Stewart,2016, lecture 5).
2) It isworth notingthatan increase inthe yearlyearningwill change the income of anindividual
by an equivalentratio,butoverthisperiodthere wasnosubstantial change inearningsandover
the longview, wage disparityisextremelylow.Thus itisall but assured thatonlycapital will
fluctuate andthere byalterthe individualsincome.
3) It isunderstoodthe currentpoundvalue isnotthe value in2016 but in1983. Thiswas necessary
due to the timingof the release of Lindert’spaperandthere byhis“current”Values.Thusto
properlycompare the pricesIusedthe current value duringthe same period.The measuring
wealthsite usingLawrence H.OfficerandSamuel H.Williamson formulasallowingme to
provide thisvalue in1983 terms.
4) Under the pretence itseemedmostappropriatetouse the labourvalue associatedwithcost.
Thisvalue isthe cost associatedwiththe earningsaworkerwouldneedtopurchase abasketof
itemsduringthistime thenindexedandvariedforvalue of purchase.
5) Note that itonlylasteduntil 1929 butat thispointthere were significantotheroptionsto
receive newsandinformationaboutthe companyone wasinvestingin.Thatiswhyits death
wouldn’tchange the levelof opennessinthe market.
6) Settingthe expectedvalue equalallowsinvestmenttoflow througheachona level thatwould
have beenseenduringthe industrial revolutionwhenaccesstoforeignequitywastoa lesser
extentavailable
7) Variance = square root of the standarddeviation.Variance andstandarddeviationare closely
relatedandessentiallybothmeasurevariability,orthe spreadof data points.Ileftthe standard
deviationnumberforthe sake of keepingdataraw,but speakingof variance andusingstandard
deviationnumbersshouldbe understood.
8) Pikettyreferstoincome here butitisunderstoodhe istalkingaboutall non-capital income,as
he laterstates“the inequalityr > g impliesthatwealthaccumulatedinthe pastgrowsmore
rapidlythanoutputand wages” (Piketty,2014, pg.571)
References
1) Vogel,H.L. (2010). Financial MarketBubblesandCrashes.New York:Cambridge University
Press.
2) Olsen,R.A.(2010). Toward a Theoryof Behavioral Finance:Implicationsfromthe Natural
Sciences.QualitativeResearchinFinancialMarkets,2(2),100–128.
3) Gazeley,I.(2003). PovertyinBritain,1900-1965. Palgrave Macmillan.
4) How Has InequalityChanged?The EqualityTrust. https://www.equalitytrust.org.uk/how-has-
inequality-changed.Accessed23November2016
5) GregoryClark,"What Were the BritishEarningsandPricesThen?(New Series)"Measuring
Worth, 2016. http://www.measuringworth.com/ukearncpi/
6) De Long,J. B., & Grossman,R. S. (1993). “ExcessVolatility”onthe LondonStockMarket, 1870-
1990*. Volatilityonthe LondonMarket.
7) Deane,P.The Role of Capital inthe Industrial Revolution.ExplorationsinEconomicHistory.
8) WilliamN.Goetzmann,&AndreyD.Ukhov.BritishInvestmentOverseas1870-1913: A Modern
PortfolioTheoryApproach.Cornell University School of Hotel Administration, The Scholarly
Commons.
9) Graeme G. Acheson,CharlesR.Hickson,JohnD.Turner,& QingYe.Rule Britannia!:BritishStock
Market Returns,1825-1870 . Queen’sUniversityManagementSchool,Queen'sUniversity
Belfast.
10) NYSE StandardDeviation.Macroaxis.
https://www.macroaxis.com/invest/technicalIndicator/^NYA--Standard-Deviation.Accessed23
November2016
11) LondonStock Exchange InvestorMonthlyManual 1869-1929. Yale School Of Management,
International CenterOf Finance. http://som.yale.edu/faculty-research/our-centers-
initiatives/international-center-finance/data/historical-financial-research-data/london-stock-
exchange
12) RanaldMichie.(2003). The LondonStockExchange:A History.OxfordScholarshipOnline.
13) RICHARDS. GROSSMAN.(2015). Bloodyforeigners!Overseasequityonthe LondonStock
Exchange,1869–19291. EconomicHistoryReview,471–521.
14) RobertC. Allen.(2007).The Industrial RevolutioninMiniature:The SpinningJennyinBritain,
France,and India.OxfordUniversity,Departmentof EconomicsWorkingPaper375.
15) Textile Industry.ENGLISHHERITAGE TEACHER’SKIT.
16) RonaldMax I-Iartwell.TAXATION IN ENGLANDDURINGTHE INDUSTRIAL REVOLUTION.CATO
JOURNAL.
17) GregoryClark.(2011). Average EarningsandRetail Prices,UK,1209-2010. Universityof
California,Davis.
18) PeterH. Lindert.(1986). Unequal EnglishWealthsince 1670. The Journal of Political Economy,
94(6), 1127–1162.
19) PHILIPT. HOFFMAN,DAVIDJACKS,PATRICIA A.LEVIN,&PeterH. Lindert.Real Inequalityin
Europe since 1500, 322–355.
20) ThomasPiketty.Technical appendixof the bookCapital inthe 21st Century.Harvard University
Press.
21) Atkinson,A.B.,Piketty,T.,&Saez , E. (2011). Top Incomesinthe Long Run of History.Journal of
EconomicLiterature,49(1),3–71.
22) Piketty,T.,& Zucman,G. (2014). Capital isBack: Wealth-IncomeRatiosinRichCountries1700-
2010. The QuarterlyJournal of Economics,129(3), 1255–1310.
23) Lindert,P.(2000). Whendidinequalityrise inBritainandAmerica?Journal of Income
Distribution,9(1), 11–25.
24) Piketty,T.,& Goldhammer,A.(2014).Capital inthe twenty-firstcentury.Cambridge
Massachusetts:The BelknapPressof Harvard UniversityPress.
25) Lindert,P.H., & Williamson,J.G.(1983). EnglishWorkers'LivingStandardsduringthe Industrial
Revolution:A NewLook.The EconomicHistoryReview,36(1),1.
26) Crafts,N. The Industrial Revolution.EconomicHistoryof Britainsince 1700.
27) Lawrence H. OfficerandSamuel H.Williamson,"Five WaystoCompute the Relative Value of a
UK PoundAmount,1270 to Present,"MeasuringWorth,2016 .
28) DauntonMartin. Wealthandwelfare :an economicandsocial historyof Britain,1851-1951.
OxfordUniversityPress,UK.
29) Steward,Art."Economicsof Social Policy."Lecture,QueensUniversity,Kingston.

More Related Content

What's hot

Presentation on stock market behaviour
Presentation on stock market behaviourPresentation on stock market behaviour
Presentation on stock market behaviourAbhijit Biswas
 
Trade and Financial Liberalization and Its Effects on Growth, Employment and ...
Trade and Financial Liberalization and Its Effects on Growth, Employment and ...Trade and Financial Liberalization and Its Effects on Growth, Employment and ...
Trade and Financial Liberalization and Its Effects on Growth, Employment and ...Grupo de Economia Política IE-UFRJ
 
Inflation Targeting Needs Re-examination in the Developed Economies
Inflation Targeting Needs Re-examination in the Developed EconomiesInflation Targeting Needs Re-examination in the Developed Economies
Inflation Targeting Needs Re-examination in the Developed EconomiesEconomic Policy Dialogue
 
Product 2905 Pdf Linkchina
Product 2905 Pdf LinkchinaProduct 2905 Pdf Linkchina
Product 2905 Pdf LinkchinaStephen Mcvey
 
Monetary Policy in Canada: Time for Change
Monetary Policy in Canada: Time for ChangeMonetary Policy in Canada: Time for Change
Monetary Policy in Canada: Time for ChangeEconomic Policy Dialogue
 
Meeting 8 - Keynesian model of unemployment (Macroeconomics)
Meeting 8 - Keynesian model of unemployment (Macroeconomics)Meeting 8 - Keynesian model of unemployment (Macroeconomics)
Meeting 8 - Keynesian model of unemployment (Macroeconomics)Albina Gaisina
 
Classical vs keynesian theory
Classical vs keynesian theoryClassical vs keynesian theory
Classical vs keynesian theoryRyan Reardon
 
Time to Rethink "Emerging" Markets
Time to Rethink "Emerging" MarketsTime to Rethink "Emerging" Markets
Time to Rethink "Emerging" MarketsDr. Ping Jiang
 
Q4_2015_2016_Outlook
Q4_2015_2016_OutlookQ4_2015_2016_Outlook
Q4_2015_2016_OutlookDebi Myers
 
Classical Vs Keynesian Economics
Classical Vs Keynesian EconomicsClassical Vs Keynesian Economics
Classical Vs Keynesian Economicskmadeiras
 
Watch newsletter nov2014
Watch newsletter nov2014Watch newsletter nov2014
Watch newsletter nov2014Alan Milligan
 
Lewis model & rastow stages
Lewis model & rastow stagesLewis model & rastow stages
Lewis model & rastow stagesNaseem Ch
 
Uop eco 561 final guide new 2018
Uop eco 561 final guide new 2018Uop eco 561 final guide new 2018
Uop eco 561 final guide new 2018charlesangles123
 

What's hot (20)

Presentation on stock market behaviour
Presentation on stock market behaviourPresentation on stock market behaviour
Presentation on stock market behaviour
 
Presentation on keynesian theory
Presentation on keynesian theoryPresentation on keynesian theory
Presentation on keynesian theory
 
Trade and Financial Liberalization and Its Effects on Growth, Employment and ...
Trade and Financial Liberalization and Its Effects on Growth, Employment and ...Trade and Financial Liberalization and Its Effects on Growth, Employment and ...
Trade and Financial Liberalization and Its Effects on Growth, Employment and ...
 
Inflation Targeting Needs Re-examination in the Developed Economies
Inflation Targeting Needs Re-examination in the Developed EconomiesInflation Targeting Needs Re-examination in the Developed Economies
Inflation Targeting Needs Re-examination in the Developed Economies
 
14 is lm model of ad
14 is lm model of ad14 is lm model of ad
14 is lm model of ad
 
Economics
EconomicsEconomics
Economics
 
Product 2905 Pdf Linkchina
Product 2905 Pdf LinkchinaProduct 2905 Pdf Linkchina
Product 2905 Pdf Linkchina
 
Monetary Policy in Canada: Time for Change
Monetary Policy in Canada: Time for ChangeMonetary Policy in Canada: Time for Change
Monetary Policy in Canada: Time for Change
 
Ppt econ 9e_one_click_ch28
Ppt econ 9e_one_click_ch28Ppt econ 9e_one_click_ch28
Ppt econ 9e_one_click_ch28
 
Meeting 8 - Keynesian model of unemployment (Macroeconomics)
Meeting 8 - Keynesian model of unemployment (Macroeconomics)Meeting 8 - Keynesian model of unemployment (Macroeconomics)
Meeting 8 - Keynesian model of unemployment (Macroeconomics)
 
Classical vs keynesian theory
Classical vs keynesian theoryClassical vs keynesian theory
Classical vs keynesian theory
 
Time to Rethink "Emerging" Markets
Time to Rethink "Emerging" MarketsTime to Rethink "Emerging" Markets
Time to Rethink "Emerging" Markets
 
Q4_2015_2016_Outlook
Q4_2015_2016_OutlookQ4_2015_2016_Outlook
Q4_2015_2016_Outlook
 
Classical Vs Keynesian Economics
Classical Vs Keynesian EconomicsClassical Vs Keynesian Economics
Classical Vs Keynesian Economics
 
Ppt econ 9e_one_click_ch27
Ppt econ 9e_one_click_ch27Ppt econ 9e_one_click_ch27
Ppt econ 9e_one_click_ch27
 
Watch newsletter nov2014
Watch newsletter nov2014Watch newsletter nov2014
Watch newsletter nov2014
 
Lewis model & rastow stages
Lewis model & rastow stagesLewis model & rastow stages
Lewis model & rastow stages
 
Ppt econ 9e_one_click_ch32
Ppt econ 9e_one_click_ch32Ppt econ 9e_one_click_ch32
Ppt econ 9e_one_click_ch32
 
The Day After
The Day AfterThe Day After
The Day After
 
Uop eco 561 final guide new 2018
Uop eco 561 final guide new 2018Uop eco 561 final guide new 2018
Uop eco 561 final guide new 2018
 

Viewers also liked

Group presentation
Group presentation Group presentation
Group presentation guzmanav
 
How to properly develop a garden post design
How to properly develop a garden post designHow to properly develop a garden post design
How to properly develop a garden post designNicola Gammon
 
E broucher india food park
E broucher india food parkE broucher india food park
E broucher india food parkMurali B
 
Venta tradicional vs Venta consultiva. Aprende a trabajar como asesor intelig...
Venta tradicional vs Venta consultiva. Aprende a trabajar como asesor intelig...Venta tradicional vs Venta consultiva. Aprende a trabajar como asesor intelig...
Venta tradicional vs Venta consultiva. Aprende a trabajar como asesor intelig...SDS training
 
Aρχες Συνθεσης 4, Τα Χρωματικά στοιχεία της σύνθεσης
Aρχες Συνθεσης 4, Τα Χρωματικά στοιχεία της σύνθεσηςAρχες Συνθεσης 4, Τα Χρωματικά στοιχεία της σύνθεσης
Aρχες Συνθεσης 4, Τα Χρωματικά στοιχεία της σύνθεσηςΓεωργία Βαλωμένου
 
Creating a successful online horticultural community online
Creating a successful online horticultural community onlineCreating a successful online horticultural community online
Creating a successful online horticultural community onlineNicola Gammon
 
Poses and facial expressions
Poses and facial expressionsPoses and facial expressions
Poses and facial expressionsHannah Ould
 
Same plan different performance
Same plan different performanceSame plan different performance
Same plan different performanceMauro Pagano
 

Viewers also liked (13)

Correccion power point
Correccion power pointCorreccion power point
Correccion power point
 
Sebastián Villalobos
Sebastián VillalobosSebastián Villalobos
Sebastián Villalobos
 
Placa base
Placa basePlaca base
Placa base
 
Group presentation
Group presentation Group presentation
Group presentation
 
Sesión 2
Sesión 2 Sesión 2
Sesión 2
 
How to properly develop a garden post design
How to properly develop a garden post designHow to properly develop a garden post design
How to properly develop a garden post design
 
E broucher india food park
E broucher india food parkE broucher india food park
E broucher india food park
 
Venta tradicional vs Venta consultiva. Aprende a trabajar como asesor intelig...
Venta tradicional vs Venta consultiva. Aprende a trabajar como asesor intelig...Venta tradicional vs Venta consultiva. Aprende a trabajar como asesor intelig...
Venta tradicional vs Venta consultiva. Aprende a trabajar como asesor intelig...
 
Aρχες Συνθεσης 4, Τα Χρωματικά στοιχεία της σύνθεσης
Aρχες Συνθεσης 4, Τα Χρωματικά στοιχεία της σύνθεσηςAρχες Συνθεσης 4, Τα Χρωματικά στοιχεία της σύνθεσης
Aρχες Συνθεσης 4, Τα Χρωματικά στοιχεία της σύνθεσης
 
Creating a successful online horticultural community online
Creating a successful online horticultural community onlineCreating a successful online horticultural community online
Creating a successful online horticultural community online
 
B2G
B2GB2G
B2G
 
Poses and facial expressions
Poses and facial expressionsPoses and facial expressions
Poses and facial expressions
 
Same plan different performance
Same plan different performanceSame plan different performance
Same plan different performance
 

Similar to Econ 231 Essay

Global Economic And Financial Crisis
Global Economic And Financial CrisisGlobal Economic And Financial Crisis
Global Economic And Financial CrisisCrystal Williams
 
Hirschman theory.pdf
Hirschman theory.pdfHirschman theory.pdf
Hirschman theory.pdfssuser2a4bff
 
Equity analaysi on macro economics factor of selectied security
Equity analaysi on macro economics factor of selectied securityEquity analaysi on macro economics factor of selectied security
Equity analaysi on macro economics factor of selectied securityMohitAgarwal312
 
International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)
International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)
International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)inventionjournals
 
Funding our future_ns5
Funding our future_ns5Funding our future_ns5
Funding our future_ns5Andrew Power
 
An alternative perspective to EM investing: The case for an industry allocati...
An alternative perspective to EM investing: The case for an industry allocati...An alternative perspective to EM investing: The case for an industry allocati...
An alternative perspective to EM investing: The case for an industry allocati...Jean Meilhoc Ricaume
 
Economics Mr Thompsons Notes
Economics Mr Thompsons NotesEconomics Mr Thompsons Notes
Economics Mr Thompsons NotesAndre Bauhofer
 
As current growth rates reach a new low, competition for the future is on the...
As current growth rates reach a new low, competition for the future is on the...As current growth rates reach a new low, competition for the future is on the...
As current growth rates reach a new low, competition for the future is on the...SimCorp
 
FINANCIAL ANALYSISHow Fast Should Your CompanyGrowb
FINANCIAL ANALYSISHow Fast Should Your CompanyGrowbFINANCIAL ANALYSISHow Fast Should Your CompanyGrowb
FINANCIAL ANALYSISHow Fast Should Your CompanyGrowbAlysonDuongtw
 
Outlook For Commodities
Outlook For CommoditiesOutlook For Commodities
Outlook For CommoditiesRusNewton
 
Foreign direct investment good cholesterol
Foreign direct investment  good cholesterol Foreign direct investment  good cholesterol
Foreign direct investment good cholesterol Gignacio1
 
Rentier incomes and financial crises (2003) Gerald Epstein, Dorothy Power
Rentier incomes and financial crises (2003) Gerald Epstein, Dorothy PowerRentier incomes and financial crises (2003) Gerald Epstein, Dorothy Power
Rentier incomes and financial crises (2003) Gerald Epstein, Dorothy PowerConor McCabe
 
Life Settlement Industry Report - Magna Life Settlements
Life Settlement Industry Report - Magna Life SettlementsLife Settlement Industry Report - Magna Life Settlements
Life Settlement Industry Report - Magna Life SettlementsMagna Life Settlements
 
Forecast of Top Index Funds for Investing in the Stock Market
Forecast of Top Index Funds for Investing in the Stock MarketForecast of Top Index Funds for Investing in the Stock Market
Forecast of Top Index Funds for Investing in the Stock MarketMintKit Institute
 
Macroeconomics Policies
Macroeconomics PoliciesMacroeconomics Policies
Macroeconomics Policiescrrcaz
 
CAUSES AND CONSEQUENCESOF THE TRADE DEFICITAN OVERVIEW.docx
CAUSES AND CONSEQUENCESOF THE TRADE DEFICITAN OVERVIEW.docxCAUSES AND CONSEQUENCESOF THE TRADE DEFICITAN OVERVIEW.docx
CAUSES AND CONSEQUENCESOF THE TRADE DEFICITAN OVERVIEW.docxcravennichole326
 
Capital Inflows and Economic Growth A Comperative Study
Capital Inflows and Economic Growth A Comperative StudyCapital Inflows and Economic Growth A Comperative Study
Capital Inflows and Economic Growth A Comperative Studyiosrjce
 

Similar to Econ 231 Essay (20)

Global Economic And Financial Crisis
Global Economic And Financial CrisisGlobal Economic And Financial Crisis
Global Economic And Financial Crisis
 
U.S. Real Rates
U.S. Real RatesU.S. Real Rates
U.S. Real Rates
 
Hirschman theory.pdf
Hirschman theory.pdfHirschman theory.pdf
Hirschman theory.pdf
 
Equity analaysi on macro economics factor of selectied security
Equity analaysi on macro economics factor of selectied securityEquity analaysi on macro economics factor of selectied security
Equity analaysi on macro economics factor of selectied security
 
International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)
International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)
International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)
 
Funding our future_ns5
Funding our future_ns5Funding our future_ns5
Funding our future_ns5
 
An alternative perspective to EM investing: The case for an industry allocati...
An alternative perspective to EM investing: The case for an industry allocati...An alternative perspective to EM investing: The case for an industry allocati...
An alternative perspective to EM investing: The case for an industry allocati...
 
Economics Mr Thompsons Notes
Economics Mr Thompsons NotesEconomics Mr Thompsons Notes
Economics Mr Thompsons Notes
 
How can competition contribute to fairer societies? – JENNY – November 2018 O...
How can competition contribute to fairer societies? – JENNY – November 2018 O...How can competition contribute to fairer societies? – JENNY – November 2018 O...
How can competition contribute to fairer societies? – JENNY – November 2018 O...
 
As current growth rates reach a new low, competition for the future is on the...
As current growth rates reach a new low, competition for the future is on the...As current growth rates reach a new low, competition for the future is on the...
As current growth rates reach a new low, competition for the future is on the...
 
FINANCIAL ANALYSISHow Fast Should Your CompanyGrowb
FINANCIAL ANALYSISHow Fast Should Your CompanyGrowbFINANCIAL ANALYSISHow Fast Should Your CompanyGrowb
FINANCIAL ANALYSISHow Fast Should Your CompanyGrowb
 
Outlook For Commodities
Outlook For CommoditiesOutlook For Commodities
Outlook For Commodities
 
Foreign direct investment good cholesterol
Foreign direct investment  good cholesterol Foreign direct investment  good cholesterol
Foreign direct investment good cholesterol
 
Rentier incomes and financial crises (2003) Gerald Epstein, Dorothy Power
Rentier incomes and financial crises (2003) Gerald Epstein, Dorothy PowerRentier incomes and financial crises (2003) Gerald Epstein, Dorothy Power
Rentier incomes and financial crises (2003) Gerald Epstein, Dorothy Power
 
Life Settlement Industry Report - Magna Life Settlements
Life Settlement Industry Report - Magna Life SettlementsLife Settlement Industry Report - Magna Life Settlements
Life Settlement Industry Report - Magna Life Settlements
 
Forecast of Top Index Funds for Investing in the Stock Market
Forecast of Top Index Funds for Investing in the Stock MarketForecast of Top Index Funds for Investing in the Stock Market
Forecast of Top Index Funds for Investing in the Stock Market
 
Macroeconomics Policies
Macroeconomics PoliciesMacroeconomics Policies
Macroeconomics Policies
 
CAUSES AND CONSEQUENCESOF THE TRADE DEFICITAN OVERVIEW.docx
CAUSES AND CONSEQUENCESOF THE TRADE DEFICITAN OVERVIEW.docxCAUSES AND CONSEQUENCESOF THE TRADE DEFICITAN OVERVIEW.docx
CAUSES AND CONSEQUENCESOF THE TRADE DEFICITAN OVERVIEW.docx
 
International Capital Flows and Inclusive Growth in Nigeria
International Capital Flows and Inclusive Growth in NigeriaInternational Capital Flows and Inclusive Growth in Nigeria
International Capital Flows and Inclusive Growth in Nigeria
 
Capital Inflows and Economic Growth A Comperative Study
Capital Inflows and Economic Growth A Comperative StudyCapital Inflows and Economic Growth A Comperative Study
Capital Inflows and Economic Growth A Comperative Study
 

Econ 231 Essay

  • 1. The Effect of Equal Access to Capital Income through Equity Markets on Income Inequality DarienLeblanc Econ 231 ProfessorFrankLewis November25,2016
  • 2. As changesinsocial andeconomicpolicyattempttoclose the income gapit isof use to examine the historical progressioninthe income of individuals asa resultof accessto capital income. Investmentsinmanufacturingandotherlarge scale projectswere notfeasibleformajorityof citizens duringthe Industrial revolution,due tosizable investmentrequirementsorlackof collateral neededto access debtmarkets.The emergence of equitiesmarketsallowedforinvestmentopportunitieswithless initial monetary outlay.Itisworthaskinghow equal accessto capital income,throughequitymarkets, affectedincome inequality. Manyhistoriansandeconomistshave done soandrecordeddatarelative to Income overmanyyears.Thisessaywill analyze thatdatainorder to come to an independentprognosis regardingthe emergence of acceleratedincome inequality inrelationtocapital income changes. I It isimportantto firstrecognize the components of incomeif understandingitsinequalityisof interest. Income iscomprisedof earningswhichone wouldgrossthroughthe sale of theirlabour services,capital income whichisderivedfrominvestmentinanynumberof marketsandopportunities, and governmenttransfersorthe redistributionof wealthperformedbythe governmentusingtaxation and subsidies.Forthe purpose of simplicitygovernmenttransferswill be omitted fromall the following calculation.Thusthe income equationwill become;I= E + K. It isuseful toobserve income inequality withoutgovernmentintervention foranumberof reasons. Of greatestsignificance isthatthis essayis not designedtounderstandorcritique how social policyeffectsincomeinequalitybutraterhow the basicsof economicscanbe appliedtounderstandhow individualchoices andmarketcharacteristicscan leadto an income gap betweenclasses. It isabundantlyclearthatboth earningsandcapital have a directrelationshipwithIncome.This meansthat the rate of appreciationordepreciationof bothearningsandcapital will directly affect
  • 3. income bythe same rate. Examiningthe literature thatexistsregardingthissubjectone particular conclusionfromthe prominenteconomistThomas Pikettycomestolight.Afterscrutinizingmanyyears of income dataovera broad spectrumof countries Pikettycame tothe conclusionthat;“the private rate of returnoncapital,r, can be significantlyhigherforlongperiodsof time thanthe rate of growthof income or output”(Piketty, 2014, 571)8 . He exemplifiesthisusingthe historical averagereturn oncapital (r) and trackingearningsgrowthoveran extensive timeperiod. Since capital income will appreciate ata much fasterrate than earningsone canconclude capital income will have amuchgreatereffectonthe change in income of individuals1 overthe longterm,oras Piketty callsitthe principal destabilizingforce. To exemplifythisIwill show howaone dollarinvestmentinthe Britishequitiesmarketwould appreciate overthe period1825-1870 if the investorwere toreceive the average returnforthe year.I will alsoinvestinatheoretical earningsmarketwhere the returnisthe appreciationinthe wage forthat year.Both investmentswill be fullyinvestedatall timestakingadvantage of compoundinginterest. The data usedforreturn onBritishequitiesisatotal returnwhichfactorsin capital appreciationand dividendyield.Itissafe toassume any rational individual withanaverage riskprofile whoinvestsinthe marketwill strive fordiversificationandthustheirportfoliowill be ablendof equitiesfromall sectors and dividendyieldingshares. The reasonforusingthisspecificdatasetwasnot onlydue to its availabilityanditspreferredorganizationbutalsothatit addsperspective tohow aboomingequities marketcan affectthe uninvested. The wage datausedare average nominal earningsinBritainforthe respective year.
  • 4. Figure 1: Investment appreciationof $1 in the British equitymarkets and the theoreticallabour market during the period 1825- 1870. Core Data for equitymarkets from Graeme G. Acheson, Charles R. Hickson, John D. Turner and Qing Ye (2009). Core Labour market data from Gregory Clarke (2016). Calculation data listed in table 1. Figure 2: Capitaland wage return fluctuation over the period 1825-1870. Core Data for equity markets from Graeme G. Acheson, Charles R. Hickson, John D. Turner and Qing Ye (2009). Core La bour market data from Gregory Clarke (2016). Calculation data listed in table 1. The value of the dollarinvestedinthe theoretical earningsmarketoverthe 45 yearperiod appreciatedto$1.75, a 75% increase over45 years. While the dollarinvestedinthe Britishequities $0.00 $20.00 $40.00 $60.00 $80.00 $100.00 $120.00 $140.00 $160.00 1825 1828 1831 1834 1837 1840 1843 1846 1849 1852 1855 1858 1861 1864 1867 1870 Value Investment in K and L Markets Apreciation of Wage Investment Appreciation of Capital Investment -20 -10 0 10 20 30 40 1825 1827 1829 1831 1833 1835 1837 1839 1841 1843 1845 1847 1849 1851 1853 1855 1857 1859 1861 1863 1865 1867 1869 Return(%) Change in Wage and Capital Wage Rates Capital
  • 5. marketappreciatedto$169 overthe same period,a 16,800% increase. ThisExample hasproventhe truth of Piketty’sconclusion.Hisproposal isquite profound,inthatitexemplifiesthatthose whodonot or cannot investtheirearningswill fall substantiallybehindintermsof income comparedtothose who do. It is because of this conclusionthatonlyone variable overtime will have aprofoundeffecton income inequality,thatvariable beingcapital income2 . Thisallowsustofocusour studyon capital income its emergence andtransitions, andtheirimpactondifferentincome classes. II If capital is the driverof income inequalityitisimportanttolook forinstanceswhere inequalityin capital availabilityemerge betweenclasses.One instance of suchadisparitybetweenclasseswouldbe the industrial revolution.Itisnowacceptedthatthe growthduringthisperiodwasnotas great as previouslythought.Thiseconomicchange of heartdoesn’t alterthe factthat barriersof investment neededtoaccessthisgrowth existed duringthisperiod.The inabilityforsome totake part inthe growth howevermediocre itmayhave beencreates income separation betweenclasses. The industrial revolutionischaracterizedbyinnovation drivinggrowth.Changesintechnology that created,improvedanddrove industrylike hadneverbeenseenbefore.A suitable example would be the textileindustry. Withinventionslikethe spinningjenny,carding engine andthe waterframe, textile productioncouldnowbe mechanized.Thisledtofactorieswhere amultitudeof machinescould be housedandproductionstandardized. The large productionandstandardizationof labourtasks allowedforeconomiesof scale previouslyunexperienced.Byleveragingof these economiesof scale the factorycouldcreate unheardof profitmarginsraisingsubstantialwealthfor theirowners andlenders.
  • 6. To participate inthiswealth,one wouldhave toinvestinall the necessarycapital required.The average cost of a 24 spindle spinningjennywasaround 70 shillings (Allen,2007, pg.5).Whichadjusted to the current poundvalue3 wouldbe around £1,4724 (Lawrence H.OfficerandSamuel H.Williamson, 2016). By comparisonthe yearlyearnings of farmlabourer,middlegroupindividuals,andartisansin 1755, incurrent pounds3 ,were 19.01,25.17, and 42.30 pounds respectively(Lindert,Williams,1983, pg.12 figure 1). Asthe Investmentincapital necessaryforentryfarexceeded thananyof these income groups’ yearlyearningsandbyextensiontheirabilitytoaccessdebtmarkets,itwouldhave been impossible forthemtoenterthe boomingtextile manufacturing industry.Considering, onlythe rich couldaccess thisfromof capital income theyheldanalmostcomplete monopolyoverit.Creating unequal capital income andtherebyacceleratingincome inequality. Usingdata collectedbyPikettywe canexemplifythischange.Firstlyhe allowsustostudythis change by analysingthe makeupof capital income duringthisperiod.Ashe explainsamajor transformationof capital tookplace. More specifically, thatfinancialcapital andindustrialcapital emerged asthe mainsource of investmentratherthanthe previouslydominantlandcapital (farmland) (Piketty, 2014, pg.342). Thisstatementisprovenbythe data he compiledrepresentedin figure 3. Figure 3: Capital split in Britain. Source: Piketty (2014)
  • 7. There isan obviousdownwardtrendinthe value of national capital comprisedof agricultural land withotherdomesticcapital (financial andindustrial),makingupthe majorityof itslossforthe period underquestion. The importance of thisisthatwe can now assume all wealthandcapital data is primarily made upof increases infinancial andindustrial capital. Inotherwords,allowingus examineto hisdata seton wealthinequalityinBritain,underthe pretence that changesare mostlydrivenby increasesinfinancial andindustrial capital.Duringthe laterstage of the industrial revolution the share of wealthof the top10% increasesfrom 80% to almost90% (Piketty,2014, figure.10.3).Thisbolsters the presumption thatonly the wealthy wereable toinvestincapital duringthisperiodandthereby benefitedtremendouslyfromit. Figure 4: Wealth inequality Britain 1810-2010. Source: Piketty (2014) Researchdone by PeterLindertoveranexpansive time period,1610 - 1910, yieldedthe conclusionthat“wealthotherthanreal estate,orgross ‘personal estate’,became more unequallyheld duringthe industrial revolutionera”(Lindert,1986, 1130). Withall fingerspointingatan increase in capital inequalityitissafe tosay that the industrial revolutionandthe income inequalitythatemerged was due to barriersof entryintocapital investmentforthe lesswell off.If the inability of some toinvest couldcreate such inequalityone wouldexpectthatthe emergence of equal accesstocapital income wouldhelptoclose thiswideninggap.
  • 8. III Aroundthe same time periodthe equitymarketsinBrittanhadgone throughdevastationafter devastation. Chief amongthemthe SouthSeaandBengal bubblesof 1720 and 1769 respectfully. Both had a considerablyadverseeffectonthe economyasa whole andseverely damagedinvestor confidence.Thisperiod incapital marketshoused the earliestversionof jointcharteredstock companies.Withsuspectregulationand alack of honestybetweenthe companieslistedand investors, speculationandfraudranwild. The eventual crashof these bubbleshurtall income classes andseverely affectedthe Britisheconomy.Itwouldbe dubious tocall thisan equitymarket.Withall mostno regulationand rampedfrauditcouldbe bettercharacterizedasa financing ploy benefitingfroman unobservantinvestorbase. Many provincial exchangesexistedupuntil 1845. The original expectationwasthattheywouldbe more informedaboutthe local listingsandthusbe transparent.The rail roadspeculationwashedaway all but the mostfinancial soundexchanges.This episode representedthe needforacentral exchange governedbystandardsandprincipalsthatcouldinformthe publicandavoidthe massspeculation. The London StockExchange whichwasoriginallyformedin1801 and represented precisely what Britainrequired.Creatingthe LSEallowedfornew rulesandregulationtobe enforced.Theserules forcedthe exchangesmembertobe transparentand workinthe interestof theircustomersratherthan theirownself-interest.The LSErepresentedthe largestandmostfinanciallysoundof all the exchanges and wasable to navigate manyfinancial stormsandemerge steadied.The LSEinauguratedaticker systemtoallowforequal knowledgeof equityprice fluctuationsin1830. Thenaround the rail road speculationera,officiallyin1846, theyassuredthe publicabouttheirpricingsystemby havingeach publishedprice markedbyanofficial of the LSE to assure that all quotes inflotation were legitimate.By
  • 9. 1853 the dominance of the LSE in Britainwasall but assuredas over70% of all rail road equity,the most tradedand abundantduringthistime period, waslistedonthe LSE (RanaldMichie, 2001, chp.2).The lastpiece of the puzzle,forgingfull transparency,isthe InvestorsMonthlyManual, whichwasfirst publishedin18695 (YSM, 2016). The importance of the IMM cannot be understated. Thispublication allowedforall investorstopeerintothe financialsof all listedcompanies. The IMMpostedchangesin the equityanddebtof each companylistedonthe LSE and reviledpotentialthreatsoropportunities each listingpossessed. WhichIbelieve isthe mostimportantstepincreatinganequal exchange asit garnerstrust and transparency betweeninvestorandthe equity theyare purchasing. Callingthe Britishequitymarketsup to1869 unjustwould seemcounterintuitive basedon the example I gave inpart one. Duringthe period1825-1870, as I have alreadyshown,investmentinBritish equity wouldhave beenextremely lucrative, seemingly counteringmyproposition.The problemisthat variance inreturn was extremelyhigh duringthisperiod,representing adisparity inreturn between investors.The standarddeviation7 intotal returnduringthisperiodwas11.73, witha max return of 53.23 and a minimumreturnof -16.93 (Acheson,Hickson, Turner,Ye,2009, Table 5).By comparisonthe currentstandard deviation of the NYSEis0.6307 (macro axis,marketclose Nov23).The 1825-1870 variancescould be explained asknowledge gapbetweeninvestorsof differentincome classes. More specificallythatthe higherincome classes makinggainsthroughathoroughunderstandingof the companiesandthe poorfailingtomake the same return bynot fullyunderstandingthe company, more oftenfallingintofraudulent traps. Once againturningto the data on wealthaccumulatedbythe top 10% from1825-1870 providedbyPiketty,itisevidentthatthe top10% increasedtheirshare.Since we alreadyknowthischange wasdrivenby financial andindustrial wealthwe canassume the wealthydrew mostof the gainsfrom this45 yearbull market.
  • 10. The disseminationof companyinformationthroughthe investormanual would thenprove tobe the keyto endunequal returnsinthe equitymarket. Thisisnottoobolda propositionas the variance in returnpost 1870 pre WW1, droppedto constrained 3.89 whenforeignandBritishexpected return(on equity) are setequal6 .(AndreyD.Ukhov andWilliamN.Goetzmann,2005, Table 8). Some may findthe reliance on variance databeingthe lynchpininthisassumption suspect. To furthersolidify myinference Iwill appraise the risksinvolvedwithinvestinginindustrial andfinancial capital pre/post1869. In orderto do this one mustconsiderthe fieldof modernportfoliotheory more specifically,the expectedvaluetheoremand applyingittothe twoinvestmenttype’spre/post1869. Assumingthatinvestorsare riskadverse,theywill strive toreceive returnsthatwill payforexcess risk. The expectedvalue isequal tothe value of aninvestmentmultipliedbythe probabilityof that outcome.Withoutgoingtoomuch intothe actuarial side of finance andinvestmenttheorywe can observe thatthe probabilitywill becomelessandlessaccurate asthe unknownsincrease orare harder to quantify.From thisqualitative assumptionitiseasytosee thatcapital investmentsexpectedvalue is much easiertoquantifyforthe pre 1869 period.Thinkingof capital investmentaspurchasingamachine where one can examine itsproperfunctioning before the investmentismade.Thusthe onlyrisksare businessspecifictothe industry the machine will applyto. Converselyinvestmentinequityduringthis periodwasobviouslylesstangible,butalsoclose toimpossible toobserve the risks asthe company financialswere not readily available.Withoutknowingthe financial healthof the companyorthe external factorsitmaybe exposedtothere islimitedabilityto assess risk. Afterthe introductionof the Investors MonthlyManual itbecomesmucheasierforthe investortoquantifyriskandmake informed choices. Atthispointthe expectedvalue of investmentincapital andequityof the same outlay will become similarlyappraisable.Nowthatthe expectedvaluesof financial andindustrial capital couldbe calculatedinvestorswouldbe able toselectinvestmentforeithersectorwithsimilarexpectedreturns.
  • 11. Provingthatafter1869 investorsof all incomescouldreceiveasimilarcapital income relativetotheir investmentoutlay. It isbecause of the progressive changesendinginthe introductionof the Investors Monthly Manual that I wouldconsiderthe Londonstockexchange tobe fullyequal andtrustedforall in the year 1869. Allowingforall income classestoparticipate,investandreceive capital incomewithoutthe huge monetary outlayrequiredbyinvestments inindustrial capital. One wouldthenexpectaquickand deliberatedecreaseinwealthinequalityaround1869. IV Interestinglyenoughthe datacollectedbyPikettyactuallyshowedacceleration inthe capital share ownedbythe rich from1870 to 1910. Thus increasedcapital income receivedbythe top10%, increased income andthereby heightened income inequality.Runningcontrarytowhatwas expected, whichbegsthe question,why?Howis itpossible thatall incomes classeshavingthe opportunityto receive capital income widenedincome inequality? The simplestanswerwouldbe thatthe lower income individualsdidn’ttake advantage of the newlyjustequitymarket. Toexamine the possible explanations one mustconsultthe fieldof behavioural finance. As previously explaineditissafe toassume that the lowerincome individualswere more often caught infraudulent investmentsorinthe bubblesthatensnaredmuchof the workingclass.These dark daysin the marketnegativelyaffectedinvestorconfidence makingitlesslikelyforinvestorstoreturnto the market.The war storiesof lostfortunesinthe markettoldto childrenenshrinedthe market fraudulence inthe mindof generationsof low andmiddle classcitizens.Thiswouldbe anexample of
  • 12. anchoring,the tendencytothinkfroma reference point, usually illogical,inthe decision makingprocess. For example, the childof afailedinvestormayforeversweartoavoidthe equitymarketdue totheir familiespastmonetary loss.Theirdecisiondoesn’treflect the realitiesof the currentequitiesmarket and wouldcause themtolose possible capital income. A second behavioural finance principle that couldexplainthe situationisoverreaction.Inasingle securitythiswouldbe explainedbyinvestors reactingto bad newsandpushingthe share price downtoa new low,whichshouldthennotchange until newinformationisprovided.Thisissimilartothe reactionobservedduring bubblesandother negative marketphenomena.Investorsseemedtodiscountthe marketasa whole decidingtowarda waitand see approach,where onlyconstantgoodnewswouldchange theirmindsallowingthemto investonce again. Lastlyprospecttheorymayexplainthe more emotionalside of low participation. The theorystatesthat investorstendto have ahigheremotional response tolossesthantoa proportional gain.Since the majorityof thisincome classreceivedlow ornegativereturnsprospecttheorywould state these losseswouldprovide anextreme negative response, possiblycreatinganinvestorwhocould no longerhandle the marketasa whole causingthemtoremove funds.Inall casesa psychological tendencywouldhave compelled the marketparticipants’ actiontoremove fundsandall togetheravoid the marketforgoingfuture capital income. Needlesstosaythose whohave lowerearningswillfind capital lossesmore painful totheirbottomline thanthose of higherearnings. The age oldphrase, time isthe healerof all wounds, seemstobe especiallytrue inthe case of equitymarkets.As representedbyPikettyschartthe capital share receivedbythe top10% significantly decreasesafterWW1 and WW2 decreasingbyabout20%. Pikettyexplainsthe final decrease in accumulatedcapital bythe rich as due to the inaugurationof a tax on capital income duringWW1 and the emergence of athickermiddle class,amongothers.The taxationdoesn’tseemlike areputable answeras itwouldaffectall incomessimilarlyandforgoinganimportantsource of income simplydue to small taxationanddoesn’tseemlikethe actionsof utilitymaximizingandrational consumer.The
  • 13. increase inthe middle classdoeshoweverrepresentanincrease inthe numberof citizenswhocould affordto investinequitymarkets. Workdone byMartinalsoindicatesthatduring1920 real wages increasedrepresenting asurge indisposable income(Martin,2007, Tbl.12.3). Meaningthere wasan increase inthe amountof Britishworkerswhocouldnow affordto investaportionof theirearnings than inpreviousyears. Withthe tragedy’s’ of the warfirmlyplantedaheadof the fortuneslostinpost marketfailures,one couldassume the psychological traitsthatwere previouslyhinderingmarketentry were all butremoved.The inaugurationof the oldage pension in1908 may have also contributedto increase investment.Withthislandmarksocial welfare reformcitizensbegantothinklongertermand realizedthe needtoinvesttoreceiveenoughincome tolastthroughretirement,anew concept. With an increase inthe middle classinvestorbase,theirability andthe willingnesstoenterthe equitymarket, wealthwasswiftlyapprehended fromthe handsof the rich, as seeninfigure 4. Figure 5: Income Share Over time. Source: The Equity Trust
  • 14. V Althoughthere wasasignificantlagbetween the decreaseinthe toptenpercents’ wealth accumulationandthe emergence of ajustequitiesmarketitisassuredthatequities marketsandmore specifically,the London StockExchange did trulyrepresentequal opportunityforall toreceive capital income hence closingthe gapinincome inequality. Asshownin figure 5,income inequality did significantlydecreasedfromthe 1930s up to 1979. One explanationforthisdecrease couldbe the emergence toequal accesstoequitiesmarketsandamore inclinedandactive middle classinvestor group.The precipitousincrease ininequalityfrom1979 to the present,formingmuchof today’spolitical foddermayderive itssolutionfromthe pasttriumphsof capital income amongthe middleclassinvestor from1910-1970’s. Notes 1) It isassumedthat individuals ineachincome classare workingfulltime atthe average rate appliedtotheirincome class. Historically,withthe exceptionof the 1990’s-2000’s, inequality hasn’tbeendrivenbya polarizationinearnings.Bysimplyexaminingthe rate of change in earnings,overaspecifiedperiod,thisbecomesenormouslyevident.The Earningdifferential that tookplace in the1990’s- 2000’s can mainlybe attributedtothe lossof manufacturingand otherlowskill middleclassworkandthe increase indemand andhoursworkedof more skilled labour(Stewart,2016, lecture 5). 2) It isworth notingthatan increase inthe yearlyearningwill change the income of anindividual by an equivalentratio,butoverthisperiodthere wasnosubstantial change inearningsandover the longview, wage disparityisextremelylow.Thus itisall but assured thatonlycapital will fluctuate andthere byalterthe individualsincome.
  • 15. 3) It isunderstoodthe currentpoundvalue isnotthe value in2016 but in1983. Thiswas necessary due to the timingof the release of Lindert’spaperandthere byhis“current”Values.Thusto properlycompare the pricesIusedthe current value duringthe same period.The measuring wealthsite usingLawrence H.OfficerandSamuel H.Williamson formulasallowingme to provide thisvalue in1983 terms. 4) Under the pretence itseemedmostappropriatetouse the labourvalue associatedwithcost. Thisvalue isthe cost associatedwiththe earningsaworkerwouldneedtopurchase abasketof itemsduringthistime thenindexedandvariedforvalue of purchase. 5) Note that itonlylasteduntil 1929 butat thispointthere were significantotheroptionsto receive newsandinformationaboutthe companyone wasinvestingin.Thatiswhyits death wouldn’tchange the levelof opennessinthe market. 6) Settingthe expectedvalue equalallowsinvestmenttoflow througheachona level thatwould have beenseenduringthe industrial revolutionwhenaccesstoforeignequitywastoa lesser extentavailable 7) Variance = square root of the standarddeviation.Variance andstandarddeviationare closely relatedandessentiallybothmeasurevariability,orthe spreadof data points.Ileftthe standard deviationnumberforthe sake of keepingdataraw,but speakingof variance andusingstandard deviationnumbersshouldbe understood. 8) Pikettyreferstoincome here butitisunderstoodhe istalkingaboutall non-capital income,as he laterstates“the inequalityr > g impliesthatwealthaccumulatedinthe pastgrowsmore rapidlythanoutputand wages” (Piketty,2014, pg.571) References 1) Vogel,H.L. (2010). Financial MarketBubblesandCrashes.New York:Cambridge University Press. 2) Olsen,R.A.(2010). Toward a Theoryof Behavioral Finance:Implicationsfromthe Natural Sciences.QualitativeResearchinFinancialMarkets,2(2),100–128. 3) Gazeley,I.(2003). PovertyinBritain,1900-1965. Palgrave Macmillan. 4) How Has InequalityChanged?The EqualityTrust. https://www.equalitytrust.org.uk/how-has- inequality-changed.Accessed23November2016 5) GregoryClark,"What Were the BritishEarningsandPricesThen?(New Series)"Measuring Worth, 2016. http://www.measuringworth.com/ukearncpi/ 6) De Long,J. B., & Grossman,R. S. (1993). “ExcessVolatility”onthe LondonStockMarket, 1870- 1990*. Volatilityonthe LondonMarket. 7) Deane,P.The Role of Capital inthe Industrial Revolution.ExplorationsinEconomicHistory. 8) WilliamN.Goetzmann,&AndreyD.Ukhov.BritishInvestmentOverseas1870-1913: A Modern PortfolioTheoryApproach.Cornell University School of Hotel Administration, The Scholarly Commons. 9) Graeme G. Acheson,CharlesR.Hickson,JohnD.Turner,& QingYe.Rule Britannia!:BritishStock Market Returns,1825-1870 . Queen’sUniversityManagementSchool,Queen'sUniversity Belfast.
  • 16. 10) NYSE StandardDeviation.Macroaxis. https://www.macroaxis.com/invest/technicalIndicator/^NYA--Standard-Deviation.Accessed23 November2016 11) LondonStock Exchange InvestorMonthlyManual 1869-1929. Yale School Of Management, International CenterOf Finance. http://som.yale.edu/faculty-research/our-centers- initiatives/international-center-finance/data/historical-financial-research-data/london-stock- exchange 12) RanaldMichie.(2003). The LondonStockExchange:A History.OxfordScholarshipOnline. 13) RICHARDS. GROSSMAN.(2015). Bloodyforeigners!Overseasequityonthe LondonStock Exchange,1869–19291. EconomicHistoryReview,471–521. 14) RobertC. Allen.(2007).The Industrial RevolutioninMiniature:The SpinningJennyinBritain, France,and India.OxfordUniversity,Departmentof EconomicsWorkingPaper375. 15) Textile Industry.ENGLISHHERITAGE TEACHER’SKIT. 16) RonaldMax I-Iartwell.TAXATION IN ENGLANDDURINGTHE INDUSTRIAL REVOLUTION.CATO JOURNAL. 17) GregoryClark.(2011). Average EarningsandRetail Prices,UK,1209-2010. Universityof California,Davis. 18) PeterH. Lindert.(1986). Unequal EnglishWealthsince 1670. The Journal of Political Economy, 94(6), 1127–1162. 19) PHILIPT. HOFFMAN,DAVIDJACKS,PATRICIA A.LEVIN,&PeterH. Lindert.Real Inequalityin Europe since 1500, 322–355. 20) ThomasPiketty.Technical appendixof the bookCapital inthe 21st Century.Harvard University Press. 21) Atkinson,A.B.,Piketty,T.,&Saez , E. (2011). Top Incomesinthe Long Run of History.Journal of EconomicLiterature,49(1),3–71. 22) Piketty,T.,& Zucman,G. (2014). Capital isBack: Wealth-IncomeRatiosinRichCountries1700- 2010. The QuarterlyJournal of Economics,129(3), 1255–1310. 23) Lindert,P.(2000). Whendidinequalityrise inBritainandAmerica?Journal of Income Distribution,9(1), 11–25. 24) Piketty,T.,& Goldhammer,A.(2014).Capital inthe twenty-firstcentury.Cambridge Massachusetts:The BelknapPressof Harvard UniversityPress. 25) Lindert,P.H., & Williamson,J.G.(1983). EnglishWorkers'LivingStandardsduringthe Industrial Revolution:A NewLook.The EconomicHistoryReview,36(1),1. 26) Crafts,N. The Industrial Revolution.EconomicHistoryof Britainsince 1700. 27) Lawrence H. OfficerandSamuel H.Williamson,"Five WaystoCompute the Relative Value of a UK PoundAmount,1270 to Present,"MeasuringWorth,2016 . 28) DauntonMartin. Wealthandwelfare :an economicandsocial historyof Britain,1851-1951. OxfordUniversityPress,UK. 29) Steward,Art."Economicsof Social Policy."Lecture,QueensUniversity,Kingston.