PORTFOLIO AND FUND MANAGEMENT




Cougar Takes on the Bear
Dr. James Breech, President and CEO, CIO
Cougar Global Investments LP




    Bear markets arrive and depart                                                colleagues. Kurz had demonstrated
    by stealth. No one rings a bell                                               the crucial role of investors' beliefs
as a bear market gets under way, nor                                              (and mistakes) in capital market
when it has ended. Failure to adjust                                              behaviour. (2) Once the global capital
one’s asset mix during a bear market                                              outlook has been developed, Cougar
can have an enormously adverse                                                    Global Investments uses Downside
impact on the health of an invest-                                                Risk Management software for
ment portfolio. Currently, investors                                              optimizing asset allocation for
who stayed the course have lost the                                               individual client portfolios. The
previous year and a half ’s gains. At                                             research underpinning the superior-
Cougar Global Investments, we                                                     ity of downside risk management
cannot direct the winds, but we can                                               over mean-variance optimization was
adjust our sails.                                                                 conducted at the Pension Fund
    The current crisis in financial                                               Research Institute by Dr. Frank
markets originated in the summer of                                               Sortino and his associates. The basic
2007, taking most investors by                                                    concept recognizes that investors
surprise.    After all, the global      We cannot direct the winds but we         have asymmetric attitudes toward
                                        can adjust our sails
economy for several years had been                                                risk. That is, investors do not view
growing at a rate almost double its                                               large positive returns as risky. Only
average for 1960-2000. Despite this       Rather, the crisis originated           returns that fail to meet their finan-
strong growth, global inflation had     because       investors    collectively   cial objectives are truly risky.
been trending downward for many         realized that they had mis-priced the     Downside Risk Management seeks to
years.                                  true risk on various securities tied to   control only the variance below a
                                        mortgages. In other words, they had       target rate of return, but does not put
Failure to adjust one’s                 made a mistake. The important             a ceiling on the upside. In practice,
                                        thing to learn from this experience is    this approach involves “making hay
    asset mix during a                  that endogenous risk (investors’          when the sun shines” and hunkering
bear market can have                    beliefs, particularly their mistaken
                                        beliefs) is as important as exogenous
                                                                                  down when bad weather sets in.

        an enormously                   risk (GDP, interest rates, inflation
                                        rates, etc.) to the behaviour of global
   adverse impact on                    capital markets.                              Make hay when the
       the health of an                   For the past fifteen years, Cougar
                                        Global Investments has utilized and
                                                                                             sun shines
  investment portfolio                  perfected a proprietary methodology
                                        for making global asset allocation
  The U.S. mortgage-backed security     decisions.        This methodology          Since 2004, the Fed had been
crisis seemed to come out of nowhere.   combines the results of advanced          raising the Fed funds rate, conduct-
There was no big news event. The        research in two areas. (1) To model       ing a “controlled burn” in order to
U.S. Fed had been gradually tighten-    the behaviour of global capital           eliminate excesses caused by finan-
ing, but there was no interest rate     markets, Cougar Global Investments        cial market developments that
shock, nor an inflation shock. War      uses the Theory of Rational Beliefs       depended on ever increasing U.S.
did not break out, and there were no    developed at Stanford University by       house prices. When strains began to
terrorist attacks.                      Dr. Mordecai Kurz and his                 appear last summer, the Fed did act,


54 WEALTH MANAGEMENT REVIEW
PORTFOLIO AND FUND MANAGEMENT




but acted slowly and started playing         Japan is already in recession, and     emerging markets ETFs) and moved
a game of chicken with financial           the economy of the euro area is decel-   80% of our clients’ assets into the
markets. Unfortunately, the Fed got        erating rapidly. However, China and      money market. In February, our
behind the curve and now we have a         the rest of the emerging world are       models called for further reducing
full-blown financial crisis. And the       growing strongly, albeit at a less       emerging markets exposure to only
contagion has spread to Main Street.       robust pace than in the past few         11%. Cougar Global’s models will
  The U.S. economy is teetering on         years. The global economy should         almost certainly stay very defensive
the brink of its most severe recession     stay afloat because of the growth        until there is light at the end of the
in over 25 years. It will take time for    contributed by the developing world.     tunnel for the U.S. economy. ■
the crisis to resolve itself. The fiscal     Cougar Global Investments is an
stimulus and further monetary              expert in active global asset alloca-
easing (the Fed will probably need to      tion. The emergence of Exchange
ease another 2% by August) will            Traded Funds (ETFs) that precisely       Contact Information:
eventually slow the slide in U.S.          track the performance of major asset
house prices. Once the U.S. housing        classes has provided us with tools       Cougar Global Investments LP
market stops plummeting, some              that we did not possess when the         357 Bay Street, Suite 1001
stability should return to financial       company was founded in 1993. On          Toronto, ON M5H 2T7
markets      and     eventually      the   January 14th, 2008, the last day that    (416) 368-5255
extremely resilient U.S. economy           markets held up, we sold all but 20%     Fax: (416) 368-7738
should begin to grow again.                of our equity ETFs (holding only         Web: www.cougarglobal.com




                                                                                            WEALTH MANAGEMENT REVIEW 55

Cougar Global Investments Article

  • 1.
    PORTFOLIO AND FUNDMANAGEMENT Cougar Takes on the Bear Dr. James Breech, President and CEO, CIO Cougar Global Investments LP Bear markets arrive and depart colleagues. Kurz had demonstrated by stealth. No one rings a bell the crucial role of investors' beliefs as a bear market gets under way, nor (and mistakes) in capital market when it has ended. Failure to adjust behaviour. (2) Once the global capital one’s asset mix during a bear market outlook has been developed, Cougar can have an enormously adverse Global Investments uses Downside impact on the health of an invest- Risk Management software for ment portfolio. Currently, investors optimizing asset allocation for who stayed the course have lost the individual client portfolios. The previous year and a half ’s gains. At research underpinning the superior- Cougar Global Investments, we ity of downside risk management cannot direct the winds, but we can over mean-variance optimization was adjust our sails. conducted at the Pension Fund The current crisis in financial Research Institute by Dr. Frank markets originated in the summer of Sortino and his associates. The basic 2007, taking most investors by concept recognizes that investors surprise. After all, the global We cannot direct the winds but we have asymmetric attitudes toward can adjust our sails economy for several years had been risk. That is, investors do not view growing at a rate almost double its large positive returns as risky. Only average for 1960-2000. Despite this Rather, the crisis originated returns that fail to meet their finan- strong growth, global inflation had because investors collectively cial objectives are truly risky. been trending downward for many realized that they had mis-priced the Downside Risk Management seeks to years. true risk on various securities tied to control only the variance below a mortgages. In other words, they had target rate of return, but does not put Failure to adjust one’s made a mistake. The important a ceiling on the upside. In practice, thing to learn from this experience is this approach involves “making hay asset mix during a that endogenous risk (investors’ when the sun shines” and hunkering bear market can have beliefs, particularly their mistaken beliefs) is as important as exogenous down when bad weather sets in. an enormously risk (GDP, interest rates, inflation rates, etc.) to the behaviour of global adverse impact on capital markets. Make hay when the the health of an For the past fifteen years, Cougar Global Investments has utilized and sun shines investment portfolio perfected a proprietary methodology for making global asset allocation The U.S. mortgage-backed security decisions. This methodology Since 2004, the Fed had been crisis seemed to come out of nowhere. combines the results of advanced raising the Fed funds rate, conduct- There was no big news event. The research in two areas. (1) To model ing a “controlled burn” in order to U.S. Fed had been gradually tighten- the behaviour of global capital eliminate excesses caused by finan- ing, but there was no interest rate markets, Cougar Global Investments cial market developments that shock, nor an inflation shock. War uses the Theory of Rational Beliefs depended on ever increasing U.S. did not break out, and there were no developed at Stanford University by house prices. When strains began to terrorist attacks. Dr. Mordecai Kurz and his appear last summer, the Fed did act, 54 WEALTH MANAGEMENT REVIEW
  • 2.
    PORTFOLIO AND FUNDMANAGEMENT but acted slowly and started playing Japan is already in recession, and emerging markets ETFs) and moved a game of chicken with financial the economy of the euro area is decel- 80% of our clients’ assets into the markets. Unfortunately, the Fed got erating rapidly. However, China and money market. In February, our behind the curve and now we have a the rest of the emerging world are models called for further reducing full-blown financial crisis. And the growing strongly, albeit at a less emerging markets exposure to only contagion has spread to Main Street. robust pace than in the past few 11%. Cougar Global’s models will The U.S. economy is teetering on years. The global economy should almost certainly stay very defensive the brink of its most severe recession stay afloat because of the growth until there is light at the end of the in over 25 years. It will take time for contributed by the developing world. tunnel for the U.S. economy. ■ the crisis to resolve itself. The fiscal Cougar Global Investments is an stimulus and further monetary expert in active global asset alloca- easing (the Fed will probably need to tion. The emergence of Exchange ease another 2% by August) will Traded Funds (ETFs) that precisely Contact Information: eventually slow the slide in U.S. track the performance of major asset house prices. Once the U.S. housing classes has provided us with tools Cougar Global Investments LP market stops plummeting, some that we did not possess when the 357 Bay Street, Suite 1001 stability should return to financial company was founded in 1993. On Toronto, ON M5H 2T7 markets and eventually the January 14th, 2008, the last day that (416) 368-5255 extremely resilient U.S. economy markets held up, we sold all but 20% Fax: (416) 368-7738 should begin to grow again. of our equity ETFs (holding only Web: www.cougarglobal.com WEALTH MANAGEMENT REVIEW 55