Both Cate and Colton's costumes are designed to portray different personas - Cate's black dress and red lipstick convey conventional attractiveness for a party, while Colton's band t-shirt and ripped jeans depict a rock fan. Their costumes will be ordered online or borrowed, with backups prepared in case of issues. The locations of the girls' and boys' rooms will use props and decor to represent stereotypical teenage spaces, while the boys' room additionally includes disturbing elements relating to Colton's obsession with Cate.