SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Complex Forms Of Deduction
A complex form or pattern of deduction involves a combination
of forms or pattern of deduction such as modus ponens, modus
tollens, disjunctive syllogism, etc., to arrive at a final
conclusion or deduction. Therefore, you must know the four
basic forms of deduction to do complex forms of deduction.
Example # 1:
1. If P, then Q.
2.Not Q.
3. P or K.
Final deduction or Conclusion: ?????
In this complex form of deduction, we arrive at the final
conclusion or deduction as follows:
1. If P, then Q.
2. Not Q
-------------------------
3. Not P (from 1 & 2 using Modus Tollens)
4. P or K
------------------------------------
Final Deduction or conclusion: K. (from 3 & 4 using
Disjunctive syllogism)
Example # 2:
1. P or K
2. If M, then N.
3. If N, then Not K.
4. M.
Final deduction or conclusion:??????
In this complex form of deduction, we arrive at the final
conclusion or deduction as follows. We need to write the correct
sequence of steps to make the deductions clear and easy:
1. If M, then N.
2. If N, then Not K.
-----------------------------
3. If M, then Not K. (from 1 & 2 using hypothetical syllogism)
4. M.
--------------------------------------
5. Not K (from 3 & 4 using modus ponens)
6. P or K
-------------------------------
Final Deduction or conclusion: P. (from 5 & 6 using disjunctive
syllogism)
A Scandal In Bohemia: Study Questions
CSN, Phil 102, Critical Thinking Instructor: Dr. Raghu
A Scandal in Bohemia
Study Questions
Note: These questions are your own reading comprehension
exercise. You are not required to submit your answers.
1. Explain how Holmes deduced that, a) Watson was active in
medical practice, b) Watson had been out in vile weather, and c)
Watson had a clumsy and careless servant girl.
2. What is the distinction Holmes makes between seeing and
observing? How does he illustrate his distinction?
3. Holmes says “It is a capital mistake to theorize before one
has data.” (p. 189) Explain and identify his reason for this
statement.
4. How did Holmes deduce that the paper on which the note was
written was made in Bohemia?
5. How did Holmes deduce that the writer of the note is a
German?
6. “There’s money in this case, Watson, if nothing else.” (p.
190) How did Holmes deduce that?
7. Why does Holmes say that if Irene Adler was Godfrey
Norton’s client, then it is likely that she would have left the
photograph in his keeping, but not likely to have done so if she
was his friend or mistress?
8. Why does Holmes say that as a result of her marriage to
Godfrey Norton, Irene Adler would be averse to the possibility
of the photograph being seen by her new husband?
9. Why does Holmes say that it is unlikely that Irene Adler
carries the photograph with her?
10. Why does Holmes rule out the possibility that the
photograph would be with her lawyer or banker?
11. Why does Holmes think that the photograph must be in her
own house?
12. What does “marm” mean? ( p. 200)
13. What was Holmes’s plan to get Irene Adler to inadvertently
show him the location of the photograph? Why does he think
that his plan will succeed?
14. “Good night, Mister Sherlock Holmes.” “I’ve heard that
voice before,” said Holmes, staring down the dimly lit street.
“Now, I wonder who the deuce that could have been.” (pp. 202)
Supposing Holmes had recognized that voice, what would he
have deduced?
15. “If the lady loves her husband, she does not love your
Majesty. If she does not love your Majesty, there is no reason
why she should interfere with your Majesty’s (marital) plans.”
(p. 203) Complete this argument. What type of argument is it?
16. How did Irene Adler figure out that she had succumbed to
Holmes’ trick?
17. Why did Holmes ask for Irene Adler’s photograph when the
King offered him a reward?
18. What did Holmes mean when he said to the King “From
what I have seen of the lady she seems indeed to be on a very
different level to your Majesty.” ( p. 204)
The Vampire's Third Story
The Parrot and the Thrush.
Which are worse, men or women?
Then the king went back to the sissoo tree to fetch the vampire.
When he got there, he took the body with the goblin in it on his
shoulder, and started off in silence. And as he walked along, the
vampire said to him again: "O King, you must be very tired,
coming and going in the night. So to amuse you I will tell
another story. Listen."
There is a city called Patna, the gem of the earth. And long ago
a king lived there whose name was Lion-of-Victory. Fate had
made him the owner of all virtues and all wealth. And he had a
parrot called Jewel-of-Wisdom, that had divine intelligence and
knew all the sciences, but lived as a parrot because of a curse.
This king had a son called Moon, and by the advice of the
parrot this prince married the daughter of the king of the
Magadha country; and her name was Moonlight. Now this
princess had a thrush named Moony, who was like the parrot,
because she had learning and intelligence. And the parrot and
the thrush lived in one cage in the palace.
One day the parrot eagerly said to the thrush: "My darling, love
me, and share my bed and my chair and my food and my
amusements."
But the thrush said: "I will have nothing to do with men. Men
are bad and ungrateful."
Then the parrot said: "Men are not bad. It is only women who
are bad and cruel-hearted." And they quarrelled.
Then the two birds wagered their freedom with each other and
went to the prince to have their quarrel decided. And the prince
mounted his father's judgment throne, and when he had heard
the cause of the quarrel, he asked the thrush: "How are men
ungrateful? Tell the truth." Then she said, "Listen, O Prince,"
and to prove her point she started to tell this story illustrating
the faults of men.
There is a famous city called Kamandaki, where a wealthy
merchant lived named Fortune. And in time a son was born to
him and named Treasure. Then when the father went to heaven,
the young man became very unruly because of gambling and
other vices. And the rascals came together, and ruined him.
Association with scoundrels is the root from which springs the
tree of calamity.
So in no long time he lost all he had through his vices, and
being ashamed of his poverty, he left his own country and went
to wander in other places. And during his travels he came to a
city called Sandal City, and entered the house of a merchant,
seeking something to eat. When the merchant saw the youth, he
asked him about his family, and finding that he was a
gentleman, he entertained him. And thinking that Gate had sent
the young man, he gave him his own daughter Pearl, together
with some money. And when Treasure was married, he lived in
his father-in-law's house.
As time passed, he forgot his former miseries in the comforts of
his life, and longed for the old vices, and wanted to go home.
So the rascal managed to persuade his father-in-law, who had no
other children, took his wife Pearl with her beautiful ornaments,
and an old woman, and started for his own country. Presently he
came to a wood where he said he was afraid of thieves, so he
took all his wife's ornaments. Perceive, O Prince, how cruel and
hard are the ungrateful hearts of those who indulge in gambling
and other vices. And the scoundrel was ready, just for money, to
kill his good wife. He threw her and the old woman into a pit.
Then the rascal went away and the old woman perished there.
But Pearl, with the little life she had left, managed to get out by
clinging to the grass and bushes, and weeping bitterly, and
bleeding, she asked the way step by step, and painfully reached
her father's house by the way she had come. And her mother and
father were surprised and asked her: "Why did you come back
so soon, and in this condition?"
And that good wife said: "On the road we were robbed, and my
husband was forcibly carried off. And the old woman fell into a
pit and died, but I escaped. And a kind-hearted traveller pulled
me from the pit." Then her father and mother were saddened,
but they comforted her, and Pearl stayed there, true to her
husband.
Then in time Treasure lost all his money in gambling, and he
reflected: "I will get more money from the house of my father-
in-law. I will go there and tell my father-in-law that his
daughter is well and is at my house."
So he went again to his father-in-law. And as he went, his ever-
faithful wife saw him afar off. She ran and fell at the rascal's
feet and told him all the story that she had invented for her
parents. For the heart of a faithful wife does not change even
when she learns that her husband is a rogue.
Then that rascal went without fear into the house of his father-
in-law and bowed low before his feet. And his father-in-law
rejoiced when he saw him and made a great feast with his
relatives, for he said: "My son is delivered alive from the
robbers. Heaven be praised!" Then Treasure enjoyed the wealth
of his father-in-law and lived with his wife Pearl.
Now one night this worst of scoundrels did what I ought not to
repeat, but I will tell it, or my story would be spoiled. Listen, O
Prince. While Pearl lay asleep trusting him, that wretch killed
her in the night, stole all her jewels, and escaped to his own
country. This shows how bad and ungrateful men are.
When the thrush had told her story, the prince smiled and said
to the parrot: "It is your turn now."
Then the parrot said: "Your Majesty, women are cruel and
reckless and bad. To prove it, I will tell you a story. Listen."
There is a city called Joyful, where lived a prince of merchants
named Virtue, who owned millions of money. He had a daughter
named Fortune, peerless in beauty, dearer to him than life. And
she was given in marriage to a merchant's son from Copper
City, whose name was Ocean. He was her equal in wealth,
beauty, and family; a delight to the eyes of men.
One day when her husband was away from home, she saw from
the window a handsome young man. And the moment she saw
him, the fickle girl went mad with love, and secretly sent a
messenger to invite him in, and made love to him in secret.
Thus her heart was fixed on him alone, and she was happy with
him.
But at last her husband came home and delighted the hearts of
his parents-in-law. And when the day had been spent in
feasting, Fortune was adorned by her mother, and sent to her
husband's room. But she was cold toward him and pretended to
sleep. And her husband went to sleep, too, for he was weary
with his journey, and had been drinking wine.
When everyone in the house had gone to sleep after their
dinner, a thief made a hole in the wall and came into that very
room. And just then the merchant's daughter got up without
seeing him, and went out secretly to a meeting with her lover.
And the thief was disappointed, and thought: "She has gone out
into the night wearing the very jewels that I came to steal. I
must see where she goes." So the thief went out and followed
her.
But she met a woman friend who had flowers in her hand, and
went to a park not very far away. And there she saw the man
whom she came to meet hanging on a tree. For the policeman
had thought he was a thief, had put a rope around his neck and
hanged him.
And at the sight she went distracted, and lamented pitifully:
"Oh, oh! I am undone," and fell on the ground and wept. Then
she took her lover down from the tree and made him sit up,
though he was dead, and adorned him with perfumes and jewels
and flowers.
But when in her love-madness she lifted his face and kissed
him, a goblin who had come to live in her dead lover, bit off her
nose. And she was startled and ran in pain from the spot. But
then she came back to see if perhaps he was alive after all. But
the goblin had gone, and she saw that he was motionless and
dead. So she slowly went back home, frightened and disgraced
and weeping.
And the concealed thief saw it all and thought: "What has the
wicked woman done? Alas! Can women be so dreadful as this?
What might she not do next?" So out of curiosity the thief still
followed her from afar.
And the wretched woman entered the house and cried aloud, and
said: "Save me from my cruel enemy, my own husband. He cut
off my nose and I had done nothing." And her servants heard
her cries and all arose in excitement. Her husband too awoke.
Then her father came and saw that her nose was cut off, and in
his anger he had his son-in-law arrested.
And the poor man did not know what to do. Even when he was
being bound, he remained silent and said nothing. Then they all
woke up and heard the story, but the thief who knew the whole
truth, ran away. And when day came, the merchant's son was
haled before the king by his father-in-law. And Fortune went
there without her nose, and the king heard the whole story and
condemned the merchant's son to death for mistreating his wife.
So the innocent, bewildered man was led to the place of
execution and the drums were beaten. Just then the thief came
up and said to the king's men: "Why do you kill this man
without any good reason? I know how the whole thing
happened. Take me to the king, and I will tell all."
So all the king's men took him to the king. And the thief told
the king all the adventures of the night, and said: "Your
Majesty, if you cannot trust my word, you may find the nose at
this moment between the teeth of the dead body."
Then the king sent men to investigate, and when he found it was
true, he released the merchant's son from the punishment of
death. As for wretched Fortune, he cut off her ears, too, and
banished her from the country. And he took from her father, the
merchant, all his money, and made the thief the chief of police.
He was pleased with him.
O Prince, this shows how cruel and false women are by nature.
As he spoke these words, the parrot changed into a god, for the
curse was fulfilled, and went to heaven like a god. And the
thrush suddenly became a goddess, for her curse was at an end,
and flew up likewise to heaven. So their dispute was never
settled at that court.
When the vampire had told this story, he asked the king: "O
King, tell me. Are men bad, or women? If you know and do not
tell, your head will fly to pieces."
King Vikram's Answer:
Here and there, now and then, there is an occasional bad man
like that. But women are usually bad. We hear about many of
them.
1. King Vikram & the Vampire: Story # 3: "The Parrot and the
Thrush: Which are worse, men or women?"
"As he spoke these words, the parrot changed into a god, for
the curse was fulfilled, and went to heaven like a god. And the
thrush suddenly became a goddess, for her curse was at an end,
and flew up likewise to heaven. So their dispute was never
settled at that court."
When the vampire had told this story, he asked the king: "O
King, tell me. Are men bad, or women? If you know and do not
tell, your head will fly to pieces."
King Vikram's Answer:
Here and there, now and then, there is an occasional bad man
like that. But women are usually bad. We hear about many of
them.
Task:
Probe Vikram's answer with essential questions. Don't forget to
ask essential questions on his assumptions! Note that
"assumption" is used in a specific sense in critical thinking
module # 3. It is an unstated reason. So, neither Vikram's stated
reasons nor his conclusion or answer is an "assumption" in this
technical sense in critical thinking.
You must identify Vikram's answer and reasons before you can
identify his unstated reasons or assumptions. Quote relevant
details from the story in your answers.
2. In the story "A Scandal in Bohemia", identify an important
clue and a deduction based on it by Sherlock Holmes. State the
clue and the deduction each in one concise and clear sentence.
Formulate Holmes' reasoning in terms of Modus
ponens or Modus tollens or Disjunctive orHypothetical forms of
deduction.
Clarification:
Make sure not to switch your clue and deduction when you
analyze Holmes' reasoning.Remember, the clue is the premise or
reason or the observation and the deduction is the conclusion
Holmes draws from the premise, reason, or observation.
Modus Ponens (proving mode):
If you do modus ponens for Holmes' deductions, then the clue
must go into the "if..." part and the deduction or conclusion
must go into the "then..." part. You then affirm the clue in the
second premise and then affirm the deduction in the conclusion.
For example, "If Helen Stoner had a railway return ticket in her
hand (clue), then she arrived by train (deduction or conlusion)."
Helen Stoner had a railway return ticket in her hand. So, she
arrived by train.
Modus Tollens (disproving mode):
If you do modus tollens for Holmes' deductions, then the
deduction or conclusion which is disproved goes into the "if..."
part and the clue which would support that deduction or
conclusion goes into the "then...." part. You then deny the clue
in the second premise and then deny the deduction in the
conclusion.
For example, "If the gypsies had killed Julia Stoner (deduction
or conlcusion to be disproved), then they would have been able
to enter her room through the window or the door (clue which
would support the deduction or conclusion)." They could not
have entered her room through the window or the door. So, the
gypsies had not killed Julia Stoner.
Disjunctive syllogism format:
1) Either Drebber died voluntarily or he was murdered.
2) Drebber did not die voluntarily.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
C: Drebber was murdered.
Hypothetical syllogism format:
1. If the US launches attacks in Libya and Somalia (X), it will
increase the risk of terrorist retaliation against US citizens (Y).
2. If the risk of terrorist retaliation against US citizens
increases (Y), their security is undermined (Z).
Therefore, if the US launches attacks in Libya and Somalia (X),
it will undermine the security of US citizens (Z).
3. Complex Form of Deduction: 1. If P, then not Q, 2. R or P, 3.
Q, 4. If R, then S, 5. If S, then M; What is the final conclusion
or deduction from these statements? Use the reading on
"Complex Forms of Deduction" in module # 5 on forms of
deduction. Follow the format of the steps of deduction and
explanations in parentheses given in this reading.
4. Watch the two video clips
"Zinn(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6klXXLQmmwU&x-
yt-ts=1421914688&x-yt-cl=84503534
)(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AuLLUFXQKEY ): The
Misguided Notion of Patriotism" featuring Howard Zinn in
"Howard Zinn: The Misguided Notion of Patriotism" in module
# 12 "Critical Thinking and Mass Media Propaganda". Identify
one main claim made by Howard Zinn in each of these twovideo
clips and his supporting reason for the claim. Compare his
views to those of Noam Chomsky in the clip "Anti-
Americanism" in the same module page. Probe their claims and
reasons with essential questions and justify your agreement or
disagreement with them.
5. Module 12: Critical Thinking And Mass Media Propaganda:
Watch the full video on "Propaganda and Manipulation"
by Prof. Jerry Kroth.
(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JOgIjSI0FrM )
Identify three techniques of propaganda explained by Prof.
Kroth. How does he illustrate each of these three techniques?
Clarify his examples and show how they illustrate the
propaganda techniques. Did his examples help you to
understand the propaganda function of the mass media? Ask
some essential questions on these propaganda techniques.
6. Revisiting the topic of immigration in the US, watch the
video clips on Chinese immigration and the Chinese Exclusion
Act in the module 13 page on "Immigration in a Global
World"(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=akC_XNlYeec)
How does the information presented in these video clips support
Aviva Chomsky's claims on US immigration policy and anti-
immigrant culture in the history of the US? (You have seen her
video clip and read her articles in the context of DA 2). Watch
also the video clips on Iris Chang's presentation on the
contributions of Chinese immigrants to the US. What are her
main claims and supporting reasons? What essential questions
do you have on these issues?

More Related Content

Similar to Complex Forms Of DeductionA complex form or pattern of deduction.docx

Summary of the story king grisly beard
Summary of the story king grisly beardSummary of the story king grisly beard
Summary of the story king grisly beardPusang Panboon
 
A town-like-alice by navil shute
A town-like-alice by navil shuteA town-like-alice by navil shute
A town-like-alice by navil shute
Bhim Upadhyaya
 
32 BEAUTY AND THE BEAST completely at home. Like Tannhàuse.docx
32 BEAUTY AND THE BEAST completely at home. Like Tannhàuse.docx32 BEAUTY AND THE BEAST completely at home. Like Tannhàuse.docx
32 BEAUTY AND THE BEAST completely at home. Like Tannhàuse.docx
tamicawaysmith
 
Sir Francis Bacon's Cipher Story - Free Ebook
Sir Francis Bacon's Cipher Story - Free EbookSir Francis Bacon's Cipher Story - Free Ebook
Sir Francis Bacon's Cipher Story - Free Ebook
Chuck Thompson
 
The miller
The millerThe miller
The miller
vivianbonfanti
 
The project gutenberg e book of grimms' fairy tales, by the brothers grimm ...
The project gutenberg e book of grimms' fairy tales, by the brothers grimm   ...The project gutenberg e book of grimms' fairy tales, by the brothers grimm   ...
The project gutenberg e book of grimms' fairy tales, by the brothers grimm ...Andrei Hortúa
 
As you Like it by Dipu (DIU)
As you Like  it by Dipu (DIU)As you Like  it by Dipu (DIU)
As you Like it by Dipu (DIU)
Student
 
Sleeping beauty
Sleeping beautySleeping beauty
Sleeping beauty
Yansi Keim
 
Engl311
Engl311 Engl311
Dracula - Brom Stoker
Dracula - Brom StokerDracula - Brom Stoker
Dracula - Brom Stoker
Vishnu Prasad
 
The sleeping beauty in the wood
The sleeping beauty in the woodThe sleeping beauty in the wood
The sleeping beauty in the wood
judyhubbard
 
Cymbeline - william shakespeare
Cymbeline - william shakespeareCymbeline - william shakespeare
Cymbeline - william shakespeare
Libripass
 
Alls well that ends well - william shakespeare
Alls well that ends well  - william shakespeareAlls well that ends well  - william shakespeare
Alls well that ends well - william shakespeare
Libripass
 

Similar to Complex Forms Of DeductionA complex form or pattern of deduction.docx (20)

The man who would be king
The man who would be kingThe man who would be king
The man who would be king
 
Summary of the story king grisly beard
Summary of the story king grisly beardSummary of the story king grisly beard
Summary of the story king grisly beard
 
A town-like-alice by navil shute
A town-like-alice by navil shuteA town-like-alice by navil shute
A town-like-alice by navil shute
 
32 BEAUTY AND THE BEAST completely at home. Like Tannhàuse.docx
32 BEAUTY AND THE BEAST completely at home. Like Tannhàuse.docx32 BEAUTY AND THE BEAST completely at home. Like Tannhàuse.docx
32 BEAUTY AND THE BEAST completely at home. Like Tannhàuse.docx
 
Sir Francis Bacon's Cipher Story - Free Ebook
Sir Francis Bacon's Cipher Story - Free EbookSir Francis Bacon's Cipher Story - Free Ebook
Sir Francis Bacon's Cipher Story - Free Ebook
 
Shakespeare
ShakespeareShakespeare
Shakespeare
 
The miller
The millerThe miller
The miller
 
Dracula
DraculaDracula
Dracula
 
The project gutenberg e book of grimms' fairy tales, by the brothers grimm ...
The project gutenberg e book of grimms' fairy tales, by the brothers grimm   ...The project gutenberg e book of grimms' fairy tales, by the brothers grimm   ...
The project gutenberg e book of grimms' fairy tales, by the brothers grimm ...
 
As you Like it by Dipu (DIU)
As you Like  it by Dipu (DIU)As you Like  it by Dipu (DIU)
As you Like it by Dipu (DIU)
 
Sleeping beauty
Sleeping beautySleeping beauty
Sleeping beauty
 
Engl311
Engl311 Engl311
Engl311
 
Shakespeare
ShakespeareShakespeare
Shakespeare
 
Dracula - Brom Stoker
Dracula - Brom StokerDracula - Brom Stoker
Dracula - Brom Stoker
 
The sleeping beauty in the wood
The sleeping beauty in the woodThe sleeping beauty in the wood
The sleeping beauty in the wood
 
Cymbeline - william shakespeare
Cymbeline - william shakespeareCymbeline - william shakespeare
Cymbeline - william shakespeare
 
Alls well that ends well - william shakespeare
Alls well that ends well  - william shakespeareAlls well that ends well  - william shakespeare
Alls well that ends well - william shakespeare
 
Hodgson night land
Hodgson night landHodgson night land
Hodgson night land
 
Rupel
RupelRupel
Rupel
 
Liber xcv (waked world)
Liber xcv (waked world)Liber xcv (waked world)
Liber xcv (waked world)
 

More from donnajames55

KATIES POST The crisis case I chose to discuss this week is th.docx
KATIES POST The crisis case I chose to discuss this week is th.docxKATIES POST The crisis case I chose to discuss this week is th.docx
KATIES POST The crisis case I chose to discuss this week is th.docx
donnajames55
 
Kate Chopins concise The Story of an Hour.  What does Joseph.docx
Kate Chopins concise The Story of an Hour.  What does Joseph.docxKate Chopins concise The Story of an Hour.  What does Joseph.docx
Kate Chopins concise The Story of an Hour.  What does Joseph.docx
donnajames55
 
Kadyr AkovaCosc 1437D. KirkEnemy.javaimport java.util..docx
Kadyr AkovaCosc 1437D. KirkEnemy.javaimport java.util..docxKadyr AkovaCosc 1437D. KirkEnemy.javaimport java.util..docx
Kadyr AkovaCosc 1437D. KirkEnemy.javaimport java.util..docx
donnajames55
 
K-2nd Grade3rd-5th Grade6th-8th GradeMajor Concepts,.docx
K-2nd Grade3rd-5th Grade6th-8th GradeMajor Concepts,.docxK-2nd Grade3rd-5th Grade6th-8th GradeMajor Concepts,.docx
K-2nd Grade3rd-5th Grade6th-8th GradeMajor Concepts,.docx
donnajames55
 
JWI 505 Business Communications and Executive Presence Lect.docx
JWI 505 Business Communications and Executive Presence Lect.docxJWI 505 Business Communications and Executive Presence Lect.docx
JWI 505 Business Communications and Executive Presence Lect.docx
donnajames55
 
Just Walk on By by Brent Staples My firs.docx
Just Walk on By by Brent Staples               My firs.docxJust Walk on By by Brent Staples               My firs.docx
Just Walk on By by Brent Staples My firs.docx
donnajames55
 
Just make it simple. and not have to be good, its the first draft. .docx
Just make it simple. and not have to be good, its the first draft. .docxJust make it simple. and not have to be good, its the first draft. .docx
Just make it simple. and not have to be good, its the first draft. .docx
donnajames55
 
JUST 497 Senior Seminar and Internship ExperienceInternationa.docx
JUST 497 Senior Seminar and Internship ExperienceInternationa.docxJUST 497 Senior Seminar and Internship ExperienceInternationa.docx
JUST 497 Senior Seminar and Internship ExperienceInternationa.docx
donnajames55
 
July 2002, Vol 92, No. 7 American Journal of Public Health E.docx
July 2002, Vol 92, No. 7  American Journal of Public Health E.docxJuly 2002, Vol 92, No. 7  American Journal of Public Health E.docx
July 2002, Vol 92, No. 7 American Journal of Public Health E.docx
donnajames55
 
Journals are to be 2 pages long with an introduction, discussion and.docx
Journals are to be 2 pages long with an introduction, discussion and.docxJournals are to be 2 pages long with an introduction, discussion and.docx
Journals are to be 2 pages long with an introduction, discussion and.docx
donnajames55
 
Judgement in Managerial Decision MakingBased on examples fro.docx
Judgement in Managerial Decision MakingBased on examples fro.docxJudgement in Managerial Decision MakingBased on examples fro.docx
Judgement in Managerial Decision MakingBased on examples fro.docx
donnajames55
 
Joyce is a 34-year-old woman who has been married 10 years. She .docx
Joyce is a 34-year-old woman who has been married 10 years. She .docxJoyce is a 34-year-old woman who has been married 10 years. She .docx
Joyce is a 34-year-old woman who has been married 10 years. She .docx
donnajames55
 
Journal Write in 300-500 words about the following topic.After .docx
Journal Write in 300-500 words about the following topic.After .docxJournal Write in 300-500 words about the following topic.After .docx
Journal Write in 300-500 words about the following topic.After .docx
donnajames55
 
Journal Supervision and Management StyleWhen it comes to superv.docx
Journal Supervision and Management StyleWhen it comes to superv.docxJournal Supervision and Management StyleWhen it comes to superv.docx
Journal Supervision and Management StyleWhen it comes to superv.docx
donnajames55
 
Journal of Soc. & Psy. Sci. 2018 Volume 11 (1) 51-55 Ava.docx
Journal of Soc. & Psy. Sci. 2018 Volume 11 (1) 51-55  Ava.docxJournal of Soc. & Psy. Sci. 2018 Volume 11 (1) 51-55  Ava.docx
Journal of Soc. & Psy. Sci. 2018 Volume 11 (1) 51-55 Ava.docx
donnajames55
 
Journal of Social Work Values & Ethics, Fall 2018, Vol. 15, No.docx
Journal of Social Work Values & Ethics, Fall 2018, Vol. 15, No.docxJournal of Social Work Values & Ethics, Fall 2018, Vol. 15, No.docx
Journal of Social Work Values & Ethics, Fall 2018, Vol. 15, No.docx
donnajames55
 
Journal of Policy Practice, 9220–239, 2010 Copyright © Taylor &.docx
Journal of Policy Practice, 9220–239, 2010 Copyright © Taylor &.docxJournal of Policy Practice, 9220–239, 2010 Copyright © Taylor &.docx
Journal of Policy Practice, 9220–239, 2010 Copyright © Taylor &.docx
donnajames55
 
Journal of Personality 862, April 2018VC 2016 Wiley Perio.docx
Journal of Personality 862, April 2018VC 2016 Wiley Perio.docxJournal of Personality 862, April 2018VC 2016 Wiley Perio.docx
Journal of Personality 862, April 2018VC 2016 Wiley Perio.docx
donnajames55
 
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology1977, Vol. 35, N.docx
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology1977, Vol. 35, N.docxJournal of Personality and Social Psychology1977, Vol. 35, N.docx
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology1977, Vol. 35, N.docx
donnajames55
 
Journal of Pcnonaluy and Social Psychology1»M. Vd 47, No 6. .docx
Journal of Pcnonaluy and Social Psychology1»M. Vd 47, No 6. .docxJournal of Pcnonaluy and Social Psychology1»M. Vd 47, No 6. .docx
Journal of Pcnonaluy and Social Psychology1»M. Vd 47, No 6. .docx
donnajames55
 

More from donnajames55 (20)

KATIES POST The crisis case I chose to discuss this week is th.docx
KATIES POST The crisis case I chose to discuss this week is th.docxKATIES POST The crisis case I chose to discuss this week is th.docx
KATIES POST The crisis case I chose to discuss this week is th.docx
 
Kate Chopins concise The Story of an Hour.  What does Joseph.docx
Kate Chopins concise The Story of an Hour.  What does Joseph.docxKate Chopins concise The Story of an Hour.  What does Joseph.docx
Kate Chopins concise The Story of an Hour.  What does Joseph.docx
 
Kadyr AkovaCosc 1437D. KirkEnemy.javaimport java.util..docx
Kadyr AkovaCosc 1437D. KirkEnemy.javaimport java.util..docxKadyr AkovaCosc 1437D. KirkEnemy.javaimport java.util..docx
Kadyr AkovaCosc 1437D. KirkEnemy.javaimport java.util..docx
 
K-2nd Grade3rd-5th Grade6th-8th GradeMajor Concepts,.docx
K-2nd Grade3rd-5th Grade6th-8th GradeMajor Concepts,.docxK-2nd Grade3rd-5th Grade6th-8th GradeMajor Concepts,.docx
K-2nd Grade3rd-5th Grade6th-8th GradeMajor Concepts,.docx
 
JWI 505 Business Communications and Executive Presence Lect.docx
JWI 505 Business Communications and Executive Presence Lect.docxJWI 505 Business Communications and Executive Presence Lect.docx
JWI 505 Business Communications and Executive Presence Lect.docx
 
Just Walk on By by Brent Staples My firs.docx
Just Walk on By by Brent Staples               My firs.docxJust Walk on By by Brent Staples               My firs.docx
Just Walk on By by Brent Staples My firs.docx
 
Just make it simple. and not have to be good, its the first draft. .docx
Just make it simple. and not have to be good, its the first draft. .docxJust make it simple. and not have to be good, its the first draft. .docx
Just make it simple. and not have to be good, its the first draft. .docx
 
JUST 497 Senior Seminar and Internship ExperienceInternationa.docx
JUST 497 Senior Seminar and Internship ExperienceInternationa.docxJUST 497 Senior Seminar and Internship ExperienceInternationa.docx
JUST 497 Senior Seminar and Internship ExperienceInternationa.docx
 
July 2002, Vol 92, No. 7 American Journal of Public Health E.docx
July 2002, Vol 92, No. 7  American Journal of Public Health E.docxJuly 2002, Vol 92, No. 7  American Journal of Public Health E.docx
July 2002, Vol 92, No. 7 American Journal of Public Health E.docx
 
Journals are to be 2 pages long with an introduction, discussion and.docx
Journals are to be 2 pages long with an introduction, discussion and.docxJournals are to be 2 pages long with an introduction, discussion and.docx
Journals are to be 2 pages long with an introduction, discussion and.docx
 
Judgement in Managerial Decision MakingBased on examples fro.docx
Judgement in Managerial Decision MakingBased on examples fro.docxJudgement in Managerial Decision MakingBased on examples fro.docx
Judgement in Managerial Decision MakingBased on examples fro.docx
 
Joyce is a 34-year-old woman who has been married 10 years. She .docx
Joyce is a 34-year-old woman who has been married 10 years. She .docxJoyce is a 34-year-old woman who has been married 10 years. She .docx
Joyce is a 34-year-old woman who has been married 10 years. She .docx
 
Journal Write in 300-500 words about the following topic.After .docx
Journal Write in 300-500 words about the following topic.After .docxJournal Write in 300-500 words about the following topic.After .docx
Journal Write in 300-500 words about the following topic.After .docx
 
Journal Supervision and Management StyleWhen it comes to superv.docx
Journal Supervision and Management StyleWhen it comes to superv.docxJournal Supervision and Management StyleWhen it comes to superv.docx
Journal Supervision and Management StyleWhen it comes to superv.docx
 
Journal of Soc. & Psy. Sci. 2018 Volume 11 (1) 51-55 Ava.docx
Journal of Soc. & Psy. Sci. 2018 Volume 11 (1) 51-55  Ava.docxJournal of Soc. & Psy. Sci. 2018 Volume 11 (1) 51-55  Ava.docx
Journal of Soc. & Psy. Sci. 2018 Volume 11 (1) 51-55 Ava.docx
 
Journal of Social Work Values & Ethics, Fall 2018, Vol. 15, No.docx
Journal of Social Work Values & Ethics, Fall 2018, Vol. 15, No.docxJournal of Social Work Values & Ethics, Fall 2018, Vol. 15, No.docx
Journal of Social Work Values & Ethics, Fall 2018, Vol. 15, No.docx
 
Journal of Policy Practice, 9220–239, 2010 Copyright © Taylor &.docx
Journal of Policy Practice, 9220–239, 2010 Copyright © Taylor &.docxJournal of Policy Practice, 9220–239, 2010 Copyright © Taylor &.docx
Journal of Policy Practice, 9220–239, 2010 Copyright © Taylor &.docx
 
Journal of Personality 862, April 2018VC 2016 Wiley Perio.docx
Journal of Personality 862, April 2018VC 2016 Wiley Perio.docxJournal of Personality 862, April 2018VC 2016 Wiley Perio.docx
Journal of Personality 862, April 2018VC 2016 Wiley Perio.docx
 
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology1977, Vol. 35, N.docx
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology1977, Vol. 35, N.docxJournal of Personality and Social Psychology1977, Vol. 35, N.docx
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology1977, Vol. 35, N.docx
 
Journal of Pcnonaluy and Social Psychology1»M. Vd 47, No 6. .docx
Journal of Pcnonaluy and Social Psychology1»M. Vd 47, No 6. .docxJournal of Pcnonaluy and Social Psychology1»M. Vd 47, No 6. .docx
Journal of Pcnonaluy and Social Psychology1»M. Vd 47, No 6. .docx
 

Recently uploaded

The French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free download
The French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free downloadThe French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free download
The French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free download
Vivekanand Anglo Vedic Academy
 
TESDA TM1 REVIEWER FOR NATIONAL ASSESSMENT WRITTEN AND ORAL QUESTIONS WITH A...
TESDA TM1 REVIEWER  FOR NATIONAL ASSESSMENT WRITTEN AND ORAL QUESTIONS WITH A...TESDA TM1 REVIEWER  FOR NATIONAL ASSESSMENT WRITTEN AND ORAL QUESTIONS WITH A...
TESDA TM1 REVIEWER FOR NATIONAL ASSESSMENT WRITTEN AND ORAL QUESTIONS WITH A...
EugeneSaldivar
 
Honest Reviews of Tim Han LMA Course Program.pptx
Honest Reviews of Tim Han LMA Course Program.pptxHonest Reviews of Tim Han LMA Course Program.pptx
Honest Reviews of Tim Han LMA Course Program.pptx
timhan337
 
Francesca Gottschalk - How can education support child empowerment.pptx
Francesca Gottschalk - How can education support child empowerment.pptxFrancesca Gottschalk - How can education support child empowerment.pptx
Francesca Gottschalk - How can education support child empowerment.pptx
EduSkills OECD
 
Sha'Carri Richardson Presentation 202345
Sha'Carri Richardson Presentation 202345Sha'Carri Richardson Presentation 202345
Sha'Carri Richardson Presentation 202345
beazzy04
 
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
siemaillard
 
Acetabularia Information For Class 9 .docx
Acetabularia Information For Class 9  .docxAcetabularia Information For Class 9  .docx
Acetabularia Information For Class 9 .docx
vaibhavrinwa19
 
Lapbook sobre os Regimes Totalitários.pdf
Lapbook sobre os Regimes Totalitários.pdfLapbook sobre os Regimes Totalitários.pdf
Lapbook sobre os Regimes Totalitários.pdf
Jean Carlos Nunes Paixão
 
Unit 2- Research Aptitude (UGC NET Paper I).pdf
Unit 2- Research Aptitude (UGC NET Paper I).pdfUnit 2- Research Aptitude (UGC NET Paper I).pdf
Unit 2- Research Aptitude (UGC NET Paper I).pdf
Thiyagu K
 
The approach at University of Liverpool.pptx
The approach at University of Liverpool.pptxThe approach at University of Liverpool.pptx
The approach at University of Liverpool.pptx
Jisc
 
2024.06.01 Introducing a competency framework for languag learning materials ...
2024.06.01 Introducing a competency framework for languag learning materials ...2024.06.01 Introducing a competency framework for languag learning materials ...
2024.06.01 Introducing a competency framework for languag learning materials ...
Sandy Millin
 
How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17
How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17
How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17
Celine George
 
June 3, 2024 Anti-Semitism Letter Sent to MIT President Kornbluth and MIT Cor...
June 3, 2024 Anti-Semitism Letter Sent to MIT President Kornbluth and MIT Cor...June 3, 2024 Anti-Semitism Letter Sent to MIT President Kornbluth and MIT Cor...
June 3, 2024 Anti-Semitism Letter Sent to MIT President Kornbluth and MIT Cor...
Levi Shapiro
 
Additional Benefits for Employee Website.pdf
Additional Benefits for Employee Website.pdfAdditional Benefits for Employee Website.pdf
Additional Benefits for Employee Website.pdf
joachimlavalley1
 
Thesis Statement for students diagnonsed withADHD.ppt
Thesis Statement for students diagnonsed withADHD.pptThesis Statement for students diagnonsed withADHD.ppt
Thesis Statement for students diagnonsed withADHD.ppt
EverAndrsGuerraGuerr
 
A Strategic Approach: GenAI in Education
A Strategic Approach: GenAI in EducationA Strategic Approach: GenAI in Education
A Strategic Approach: GenAI in Education
Peter Windle
 
How libraries can support authors with open access requirements for UKRI fund...
How libraries can support authors with open access requirements for UKRI fund...How libraries can support authors with open access requirements for UKRI fund...
How libraries can support authors with open access requirements for UKRI fund...
Jisc
 
Supporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptx
Supporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptxSupporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptx
Supporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptx
Jisc
 
The Accursed House by Émile Gaboriau.pptx
The Accursed House by Émile Gaboriau.pptxThe Accursed House by Émile Gaboriau.pptx
The Accursed House by Émile Gaboriau.pptx
DhatriParmar
 
Operation Blue Star - Saka Neela Tara
Operation Blue Star   -  Saka Neela TaraOperation Blue Star   -  Saka Neela Tara
Operation Blue Star - Saka Neela Tara
Balvir Singh
 

Recently uploaded (20)

The French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free download
The French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free downloadThe French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free download
The French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free download
 
TESDA TM1 REVIEWER FOR NATIONAL ASSESSMENT WRITTEN AND ORAL QUESTIONS WITH A...
TESDA TM1 REVIEWER  FOR NATIONAL ASSESSMENT WRITTEN AND ORAL QUESTIONS WITH A...TESDA TM1 REVIEWER  FOR NATIONAL ASSESSMENT WRITTEN AND ORAL QUESTIONS WITH A...
TESDA TM1 REVIEWER FOR NATIONAL ASSESSMENT WRITTEN AND ORAL QUESTIONS WITH A...
 
Honest Reviews of Tim Han LMA Course Program.pptx
Honest Reviews of Tim Han LMA Course Program.pptxHonest Reviews of Tim Han LMA Course Program.pptx
Honest Reviews of Tim Han LMA Course Program.pptx
 
Francesca Gottschalk - How can education support child empowerment.pptx
Francesca Gottschalk - How can education support child empowerment.pptxFrancesca Gottschalk - How can education support child empowerment.pptx
Francesca Gottschalk - How can education support child empowerment.pptx
 
Sha'Carri Richardson Presentation 202345
Sha'Carri Richardson Presentation 202345Sha'Carri Richardson Presentation 202345
Sha'Carri Richardson Presentation 202345
 
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
 
Acetabularia Information For Class 9 .docx
Acetabularia Information For Class 9  .docxAcetabularia Information For Class 9  .docx
Acetabularia Information For Class 9 .docx
 
Lapbook sobre os Regimes Totalitários.pdf
Lapbook sobre os Regimes Totalitários.pdfLapbook sobre os Regimes Totalitários.pdf
Lapbook sobre os Regimes Totalitários.pdf
 
Unit 2- Research Aptitude (UGC NET Paper I).pdf
Unit 2- Research Aptitude (UGC NET Paper I).pdfUnit 2- Research Aptitude (UGC NET Paper I).pdf
Unit 2- Research Aptitude (UGC NET Paper I).pdf
 
The approach at University of Liverpool.pptx
The approach at University of Liverpool.pptxThe approach at University of Liverpool.pptx
The approach at University of Liverpool.pptx
 
2024.06.01 Introducing a competency framework for languag learning materials ...
2024.06.01 Introducing a competency framework for languag learning materials ...2024.06.01 Introducing a competency framework for languag learning materials ...
2024.06.01 Introducing a competency framework for languag learning materials ...
 
How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17
How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17
How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17
 
June 3, 2024 Anti-Semitism Letter Sent to MIT President Kornbluth and MIT Cor...
June 3, 2024 Anti-Semitism Letter Sent to MIT President Kornbluth and MIT Cor...June 3, 2024 Anti-Semitism Letter Sent to MIT President Kornbluth and MIT Cor...
June 3, 2024 Anti-Semitism Letter Sent to MIT President Kornbluth and MIT Cor...
 
Additional Benefits for Employee Website.pdf
Additional Benefits for Employee Website.pdfAdditional Benefits for Employee Website.pdf
Additional Benefits for Employee Website.pdf
 
Thesis Statement for students diagnonsed withADHD.ppt
Thesis Statement for students diagnonsed withADHD.pptThesis Statement for students diagnonsed withADHD.ppt
Thesis Statement for students diagnonsed withADHD.ppt
 
A Strategic Approach: GenAI in Education
A Strategic Approach: GenAI in EducationA Strategic Approach: GenAI in Education
A Strategic Approach: GenAI in Education
 
How libraries can support authors with open access requirements for UKRI fund...
How libraries can support authors with open access requirements for UKRI fund...How libraries can support authors with open access requirements for UKRI fund...
How libraries can support authors with open access requirements for UKRI fund...
 
Supporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptx
Supporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptxSupporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptx
Supporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptx
 
The Accursed House by Émile Gaboriau.pptx
The Accursed House by Émile Gaboriau.pptxThe Accursed House by Émile Gaboriau.pptx
The Accursed House by Émile Gaboriau.pptx
 
Operation Blue Star - Saka Neela Tara
Operation Blue Star   -  Saka Neela TaraOperation Blue Star   -  Saka Neela Tara
Operation Blue Star - Saka Neela Tara
 

Complex Forms Of DeductionA complex form or pattern of deduction.docx

  • 1. Complex Forms Of Deduction A complex form or pattern of deduction involves a combination of forms or pattern of deduction such as modus ponens, modus tollens, disjunctive syllogism, etc., to arrive at a final conclusion or deduction. Therefore, you must know the four basic forms of deduction to do complex forms of deduction. Example # 1: 1. If P, then Q. 2.Not Q. 3. P or K. Final deduction or Conclusion: ????? In this complex form of deduction, we arrive at the final conclusion or deduction as follows: 1. If P, then Q. 2. Not Q ------------------------- 3. Not P (from 1 & 2 using Modus Tollens) 4. P or K
  • 2. ------------------------------------ Final Deduction or conclusion: K. (from 3 & 4 using Disjunctive syllogism) Example # 2: 1. P or K 2. If M, then N. 3. If N, then Not K. 4. M. Final deduction or conclusion:?????? In this complex form of deduction, we arrive at the final conclusion or deduction as follows. We need to write the correct sequence of steps to make the deductions clear and easy: 1. If M, then N. 2. If N, then Not K. ----------------------------- 3. If M, then Not K. (from 1 & 2 using hypothetical syllogism) 4. M. -------------------------------------- 5. Not K (from 3 & 4 using modus ponens)
  • 3. 6. P or K ------------------------------- Final Deduction or conclusion: P. (from 5 & 6 using disjunctive syllogism) A Scandal In Bohemia: Study Questions CSN, Phil 102, Critical Thinking Instructor: Dr. Raghu A Scandal in Bohemia Study Questions Note: These questions are your own reading comprehension exercise. You are not required to submit your answers. 1. Explain how Holmes deduced that, a) Watson was active in medical practice, b) Watson had been out in vile weather, and c) Watson had a clumsy and careless servant girl. 2. What is the distinction Holmes makes between seeing and observing? How does he illustrate his distinction? 3. Holmes says “It is a capital mistake to theorize before one has data.” (p. 189) Explain and identify his reason for this statement. 4. How did Holmes deduce that the paper on which the note was written was made in Bohemia?
  • 4. 5. How did Holmes deduce that the writer of the note is a German? 6. “There’s money in this case, Watson, if nothing else.” (p. 190) How did Holmes deduce that? 7. Why does Holmes say that if Irene Adler was Godfrey Norton’s client, then it is likely that she would have left the photograph in his keeping, but not likely to have done so if she was his friend or mistress? 8. Why does Holmes say that as a result of her marriage to Godfrey Norton, Irene Adler would be averse to the possibility of the photograph being seen by her new husband? 9. Why does Holmes say that it is unlikely that Irene Adler carries the photograph with her? 10. Why does Holmes rule out the possibility that the photograph would be with her lawyer or banker? 11. Why does Holmes think that the photograph must be in her own house? 12. What does “marm” mean? ( p. 200)
  • 5. 13. What was Holmes’s plan to get Irene Adler to inadvertently show him the location of the photograph? Why does he think that his plan will succeed? 14. “Good night, Mister Sherlock Holmes.” “I’ve heard that voice before,” said Holmes, staring down the dimly lit street. “Now, I wonder who the deuce that could have been.” (pp. 202) Supposing Holmes had recognized that voice, what would he have deduced? 15. “If the lady loves her husband, she does not love your Majesty. If she does not love your Majesty, there is no reason why she should interfere with your Majesty’s (marital) plans.” (p. 203) Complete this argument. What type of argument is it? 16. How did Irene Adler figure out that she had succumbed to Holmes’ trick? 17. Why did Holmes ask for Irene Adler’s photograph when the King offered him a reward? 18. What did Holmes mean when he said to the King “From what I have seen of the lady she seems indeed to be on a very different level to your Majesty.” ( p. 204) The Vampire's Third Story The Parrot and the Thrush. Which are worse, men or women?
  • 6. Then the king went back to the sissoo tree to fetch the vampire. When he got there, he took the body with the goblin in it on his shoulder, and started off in silence. And as he walked along, the vampire said to him again: "O King, you must be very tired, coming and going in the night. So to amuse you I will tell another story. Listen." There is a city called Patna, the gem of the earth. And long ago a king lived there whose name was Lion-of-Victory. Fate had made him the owner of all virtues and all wealth. And he had a parrot called Jewel-of-Wisdom, that had divine intelligence and knew all the sciences, but lived as a parrot because of a curse. This king had a son called Moon, and by the advice of the parrot this prince married the daughter of the king of the Magadha country; and her name was Moonlight. Now this princess had a thrush named Moony, who was like the parrot, because she had learning and intelligence. And the parrot and the thrush lived in one cage in the palace. One day the parrot eagerly said to the thrush: "My darling, love me, and share my bed and my chair and my food and my amusements." But the thrush said: "I will have nothing to do with men. Men are bad and ungrateful."
  • 7. Then the parrot said: "Men are not bad. It is only women who are bad and cruel-hearted." And they quarrelled. Then the two birds wagered their freedom with each other and went to the prince to have their quarrel decided. And the prince mounted his father's judgment throne, and when he had heard the cause of the quarrel, he asked the thrush: "How are men ungrateful? Tell the truth." Then she said, "Listen, O Prince," and to prove her point she started to tell this story illustrating the faults of men. There is a famous city called Kamandaki, where a wealthy merchant lived named Fortune. And in time a son was born to him and named Treasure. Then when the father went to heaven, the young man became very unruly because of gambling and other vices. And the rascals came together, and ruined him. Association with scoundrels is the root from which springs the tree of calamity. So in no long time he lost all he had through his vices, and being ashamed of his poverty, he left his own country and went to wander in other places. And during his travels he came to a city called Sandal City, and entered the house of a merchant, seeking something to eat. When the merchant saw the youth, he asked him about his family, and finding that he was a gentleman, he entertained him. And thinking that Gate had sent the young man, he gave him his own daughter Pearl, together with some money. And when Treasure was married, he lived in his father-in-law's house.
  • 8. As time passed, he forgot his former miseries in the comforts of his life, and longed for the old vices, and wanted to go home. So the rascal managed to persuade his father-in-law, who had no other children, took his wife Pearl with her beautiful ornaments, and an old woman, and started for his own country. Presently he came to a wood where he said he was afraid of thieves, so he took all his wife's ornaments. Perceive, O Prince, how cruel and hard are the ungrateful hearts of those who indulge in gambling and other vices. And the scoundrel was ready, just for money, to kill his good wife. He threw her and the old woman into a pit. Then the rascal went away and the old woman perished there. But Pearl, with the little life she had left, managed to get out by clinging to the grass and bushes, and weeping bitterly, and bleeding, she asked the way step by step, and painfully reached her father's house by the way she had come. And her mother and father were surprised and asked her: "Why did you come back so soon, and in this condition?" And that good wife said: "On the road we were robbed, and my husband was forcibly carried off. And the old woman fell into a pit and died, but I escaped. And a kind-hearted traveller pulled me from the pit." Then her father and mother were saddened, but they comforted her, and Pearl stayed there, true to her husband. Then in time Treasure lost all his money in gambling, and he
  • 9. reflected: "I will get more money from the house of my father- in-law. I will go there and tell my father-in-law that his daughter is well and is at my house." So he went again to his father-in-law. And as he went, his ever- faithful wife saw him afar off. She ran and fell at the rascal's feet and told him all the story that she had invented for her parents. For the heart of a faithful wife does not change even when she learns that her husband is a rogue. Then that rascal went without fear into the house of his father- in-law and bowed low before his feet. And his father-in-law rejoiced when he saw him and made a great feast with his relatives, for he said: "My son is delivered alive from the robbers. Heaven be praised!" Then Treasure enjoyed the wealth of his father-in-law and lived with his wife Pearl. Now one night this worst of scoundrels did what I ought not to repeat, but I will tell it, or my story would be spoiled. Listen, O Prince. While Pearl lay asleep trusting him, that wretch killed her in the night, stole all her jewels, and escaped to his own country. This shows how bad and ungrateful men are. When the thrush had told her story, the prince smiled and said to the parrot: "It is your turn now."
  • 10. Then the parrot said: "Your Majesty, women are cruel and reckless and bad. To prove it, I will tell you a story. Listen." There is a city called Joyful, where lived a prince of merchants named Virtue, who owned millions of money. He had a daughter named Fortune, peerless in beauty, dearer to him than life. And she was given in marriage to a merchant's son from Copper City, whose name was Ocean. He was her equal in wealth, beauty, and family; a delight to the eyes of men. One day when her husband was away from home, she saw from the window a handsome young man. And the moment she saw him, the fickle girl went mad with love, and secretly sent a messenger to invite him in, and made love to him in secret. Thus her heart was fixed on him alone, and she was happy with him. But at last her husband came home and delighted the hearts of his parents-in-law. And when the day had been spent in feasting, Fortune was adorned by her mother, and sent to her husband's room. But she was cold toward him and pretended to sleep. And her husband went to sleep, too, for he was weary with his journey, and had been drinking wine. When everyone in the house had gone to sleep after their dinner, a thief made a hole in the wall and came into that very room. And just then the merchant's daughter got up without seeing him, and went out secretly to a meeting with her lover.
  • 11. And the thief was disappointed, and thought: "She has gone out into the night wearing the very jewels that I came to steal. I must see where she goes." So the thief went out and followed her. But she met a woman friend who had flowers in her hand, and went to a park not very far away. And there she saw the man whom she came to meet hanging on a tree. For the policeman had thought he was a thief, had put a rope around his neck and hanged him. And at the sight she went distracted, and lamented pitifully: "Oh, oh! I am undone," and fell on the ground and wept. Then she took her lover down from the tree and made him sit up, though he was dead, and adorned him with perfumes and jewels and flowers. But when in her love-madness she lifted his face and kissed him, a goblin who had come to live in her dead lover, bit off her nose. And she was startled and ran in pain from the spot. But then she came back to see if perhaps he was alive after all. But the goblin had gone, and she saw that he was motionless and dead. So she slowly went back home, frightened and disgraced and weeping. And the concealed thief saw it all and thought: "What has the wicked woman done? Alas! Can women be so dreadful as this? What might she not do next?" So out of curiosity the thief still
  • 12. followed her from afar. And the wretched woman entered the house and cried aloud, and said: "Save me from my cruel enemy, my own husband. He cut off my nose and I had done nothing." And her servants heard her cries and all arose in excitement. Her husband too awoke. Then her father came and saw that her nose was cut off, and in his anger he had his son-in-law arrested. And the poor man did not know what to do. Even when he was being bound, he remained silent and said nothing. Then they all woke up and heard the story, but the thief who knew the whole truth, ran away. And when day came, the merchant's son was haled before the king by his father-in-law. And Fortune went there without her nose, and the king heard the whole story and condemned the merchant's son to death for mistreating his wife. So the innocent, bewildered man was led to the place of execution and the drums were beaten. Just then the thief came up and said to the king's men: "Why do you kill this man without any good reason? I know how the whole thing happened. Take me to the king, and I will tell all." So all the king's men took him to the king. And the thief told the king all the adventures of the night, and said: "Your Majesty, if you cannot trust my word, you may find the nose at this moment between the teeth of the dead body."
  • 13. Then the king sent men to investigate, and when he found it was true, he released the merchant's son from the punishment of death. As for wretched Fortune, he cut off her ears, too, and banished her from the country. And he took from her father, the merchant, all his money, and made the thief the chief of police. He was pleased with him. O Prince, this shows how cruel and false women are by nature. As he spoke these words, the parrot changed into a god, for the curse was fulfilled, and went to heaven like a god. And the thrush suddenly became a goddess, for her curse was at an end, and flew up likewise to heaven. So their dispute was never settled at that court. When the vampire had told this story, he asked the king: "O King, tell me. Are men bad, or women? If you know and do not tell, your head will fly to pieces." King Vikram's Answer: Here and there, now and then, there is an occasional bad man like that. But women are usually bad. We hear about many of them. 1. King Vikram & the Vampire: Story # 3: "The Parrot and the Thrush: Which are worse, men or women?" "As he spoke these words, the parrot changed into a god, for
  • 14. the curse was fulfilled, and went to heaven like a god. And the thrush suddenly became a goddess, for her curse was at an end, and flew up likewise to heaven. So their dispute was never settled at that court." When the vampire had told this story, he asked the king: "O King, tell me. Are men bad, or women? If you know and do not tell, your head will fly to pieces." King Vikram's Answer: Here and there, now and then, there is an occasional bad man like that. But women are usually bad. We hear about many of them. Task: Probe Vikram's answer with essential questions. Don't forget to ask essential questions on his assumptions! Note that "assumption" is used in a specific sense in critical thinking module # 3. It is an unstated reason. So, neither Vikram's stated reasons nor his conclusion or answer is an "assumption" in this technical sense in critical thinking. You must identify Vikram's answer and reasons before you can identify his unstated reasons or assumptions. Quote relevant details from the story in your answers. 2. In the story "A Scandal in Bohemia", identify an important clue and a deduction based on it by Sherlock Holmes. State the clue and the deduction each in one concise and clear sentence. Formulate Holmes' reasoning in terms of Modus ponens or Modus tollens or Disjunctive orHypothetical forms of deduction. Clarification: Make sure not to switch your clue and deduction when you analyze Holmes' reasoning.Remember, the clue is the premise or reason or the observation and the deduction is the conclusion Holmes draws from the premise, reason, or observation. Modus Ponens (proving mode): If you do modus ponens for Holmes' deductions, then the clue must go into the "if..." part and the deduction or conclusion
  • 15. must go into the "then..." part. You then affirm the clue in the second premise and then affirm the deduction in the conclusion. For example, "If Helen Stoner had a railway return ticket in her hand (clue), then she arrived by train (deduction or conlusion)." Helen Stoner had a railway return ticket in her hand. So, she arrived by train. Modus Tollens (disproving mode): If you do modus tollens for Holmes' deductions, then the deduction or conclusion which is disproved goes into the "if..." part and the clue which would support that deduction or conclusion goes into the "then...." part. You then deny the clue in the second premise and then deny the deduction in the conclusion. For example, "If the gypsies had killed Julia Stoner (deduction or conlcusion to be disproved), then they would have been able to enter her room through the window or the door (clue which would support the deduction or conclusion)." They could not have entered her room through the window or the door. So, the gypsies had not killed Julia Stoner. Disjunctive syllogism format: 1) Either Drebber died voluntarily or he was murdered. 2) Drebber did not die voluntarily. ----------------------------------------------------------------- C: Drebber was murdered. Hypothetical syllogism format: 1. If the US launches attacks in Libya and Somalia (X), it will increase the risk of terrorist retaliation against US citizens (Y). 2. If the risk of terrorist retaliation against US citizens increases (Y), their security is undermined (Z). Therefore, if the US launches attacks in Libya and Somalia (X), it will undermine the security of US citizens (Z). 3. Complex Form of Deduction: 1. If P, then not Q, 2. R or P, 3.
  • 16. Q, 4. If R, then S, 5. If S, then M; What is the final conclusion or deduction from these statements? Use the reading on "Complex Forms of Deduction" in module # 5 on forms of deduction. Follow the format of the steps of deduction and explanations in parentheses given in this reading. 4. Watch the two video clips "Zinn(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6klXXLQmmwU&x- yt-ts=1421914688&x-yt-cl=84503534 )(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AuLLUFXQKEY ): The Misguided Notion of Patriotism" featuring Howard Zinn in "Howard Zinn: The Misguided Notion of Patriotism" in module # 12 "Critical Thinking and Mass Media Propaganda". Identify one main claim made by Howard Zinn in each of these twovideo clips and his supporting reason for the claim. Compare his views to those of Noam Chomsky in the clip "Anti- Americanism" in the same module page. Probe their claims and reasons with essential questions and justify your agreement or disagreement with them. 5. Module 12: Critical Thinking And Mass Media Propaganda: Watch the full video on "Propaganda and Manipulation" by Prof. Jerry Kroth. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JOgIjSI0FrM ) Identify three techniques of propaganda explained by Prof. Kroth. How does he illustrate each of these three techniques? Clarify his examples and show how they illustrate the propaganda techniques. Did his examples help you to understand the propaganda function of the mass media? Ask some essential questions on these propaganda techniques. 6. Revisiting the topic of immigration in the US, watch the video clips on Chinese immigration and the Chinese Exclusion Act in the module 13 page on "Immigration in a Global World"(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=akC_XNlYeec) How does the information presented in these video clips support Aviva Chomsky's claims on US immigration policy and anti-
  • 17. immigrant culture in the history of the US? (You have seen her video clip and read her articles in the context of DA 2). Watch also the video clips on Iris Chang's presentation on the contributions of Chinese immigrants to the US. What are her main claims and supporting reasons? What essential questions do you have on these issues?