SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Individual Criminal Liability in
       International Law



The Rome Statute and the International
          Criminal Court
Agenda
 Overview
     –     What are the history and mission of the ICC?
 Jurisdiction
     –     What crimes are under the jurisdiction of the
           ICC?
 Exercise of Jurisdiction
     –     How are cases brought to the ICC, not domestic
           courts?
 Issues
     –     Does the ICC infringe on state sovereignty?
International Criminal Tribunals and
               the ICC
 Ad hoc courts of limited jurisdiction
        −   Nuremberg and Tokyo tribunals
        −   International Criminal Tribunal on Rwanda
        −   International Criminal Tribunal on the Former
            Yugoslavia
        −   Sierra Leone, Timor-Leste, Cambodia...
 ICC
        −   Expansion in time: A permanent court
        −   Expansion in space: Not limited to regions
Overview of the ICC
 Entered into force July 1, 2002
 121 parties
 Court of last resort
Crimes
Crimes




 Serious
 Crimes
Crimes

Serious
Crimes




           International
              Crimes
Crimes

Serious
Crimes
                         Inter-
                        national
                        Crimes
             Genocide
Crimes

Serious
Crimes
                               Inter-
                              national
                   Crimes     Crimes
                   Against
                   Humanity
Crimes

Serious
Crimes
                        Inter-
                       national
                       Crimes




          War Crimes
Crimes

Serious
Crimes
                                  Inter-
                                 national
                                 Crimes




          Crimes of Aggression
Crimes

Serious
Crimes
                                    Inter-
                                   national
      The             Crimes       Crimes
  Crime of            Against
 Genocide             Humanity

                      Crimes of
War Crimes            Aggression
Genocide
 Objective element
  – Action: Killing, etc. (Art. 6 (a) to (e))
 Subjective element
  – Intention: Intent to destroy national, ethnical,
    racial, religious group
Crimes Against Humanity
 Objective element
  – Action: Murder, etc. (Art. 7 (a) to (k))
  – Condition: Part of widespread/systematic attack
 Subjective element
  – Knowledge of the attack
War Crimes
 Objective element
  – Action: Grave Geneva breaches, etc. (Art. 8 (2))
  – Condition: In particular when part of
    policy/plan
 Subjective element
Crime of Aggression
 Stay tuned! (Art. 5 (2))
Other Limits on Jurisdiction
 Temporal jurisdiction
  – Crimes committed after entry into force (11 (1))
 Admissibility (Art. 17)
  – Investigation or prosecution by a state
    • Unless unable or unwilling
    • Last resort
Exercise of Jurisdiction
ICC Case Checklist
         Is the crime under ICC jurisdiction?             Art. 5



                                                          Art. 11
            Is there temporal jurisdiction?



                                                          Art. 13
           Was the case properly referred?



                                                          Art. 17
Is the domestic court unable or unwilling to prosecute?



                       ICC trial
Exercise of Jurisdiction
         and State Sovereignty
 Of the 3 forms of case referral, which is least
  problematic when it comes to sovereignty?
 Is it justifiable for the Security Council to refer
  cases to the ICC, even situations in non-ICC
  states?
 Is it justifiable for the ICC prosecutor to initiate
  cases? Why or why not?
Criticism of the ICC
 Lack of oversight, checks & balances
 Selectivity
 Sovereignty concerns
 Makes peace process more difficult
Thinking about the ICC
 What checks are there on the ICC’s power?
 Is the ICC biased against Africa?
 Does the ICC infringe on sovereignty?
 Is the ICC doing its job deterring int’l crimes?

More Related Content

What's hot

Peaceful settlement of international dispute
Peaceful settlement of international disputePeaceful settlement of international dispute
Peaceful settlement of international dispute
Mahesh Patil
 
Subjects of international law
Subjects of international lawSubjects of international law
Subjects of international law
Shivani Sharma
 
THE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT (ICC) AND MYANMAR-BANGLADESH
THE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT (ICC) AND MYANMAR-BANGLADESHTHE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT (ICC) AND MYANMAR-BANGLADESH
THE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT (ICC) AND MYANMAR-BANGLADESH
MYO AUNG Myanmar
 
The ICJ
The ICJThe ICJ
The ICJ
mrjust88
 
International criminal law
International criminal lawInternational criminal law
International criminal law
Rittika Dattana
 
The International Court of Justice
The International Court of JusticeThe International Court of Justice
The International Court of Justice
Vanessa Rae Baculio
 
International Humanitarian Law
International Humanitarian LawInternational Humanitarian Law
International Humanitarian Law
maria martha manette madrid
 
International Court of Justice
International Court of JusticeInternational Court of Justice
International Court of Justice
Math_Noortmann
 
Is international law a true law.vvvvvvvvvi
Is international law a true law.vvvvvvvvviIs international law a true law.vvvvvvvvvi
Is international law a true law.vvvvvvvvvi
A K DAS's | Law
 
Criminal jurisdiction
Criminal jurisdictionCriminal jurisdiction
Criminal jurisdiction
Kathmandu University School of Law
 
International law notes
International law notesInternational law notes
International law notes
junaidliaqatjunaid
 
Settlement of international disputes (International Law) Amicable(Rajat Vaish...
Settlement of international disputes (International Law) Amicable(Rajat Vaish...Settlement of international disputes (International Law) Amicable(Rajat Vaish...
Settlement of international disputes (International Law) Amicable(Rajat Vaish...
R V
 
Genocide and crime against humanity final
Genocide and crime against humanity finalGenocide and crime against humanity final
Genocide and crime against humanity final
Palak Agrawal
 
The International Criminal Court (ICC) presentation added-
The International Criminal Court (ICC)  presentation added-The International Criminal Court (ICC)  presentation added-
The International Criminal Court (ICC) presentation added-
Nancy Yanira Munoz Martinez
 
Defences under International Criminal Law
Defences under International Criminal LawDefences under International Criminal Law
Defences under International Criminal Law
University of Rajshahi
 
International humanitarian law (ihl)
International humanitarian law  (ihl)International humanitarian law  (ihl)
International humanitarian law (ihl)
bhagya913
 
Genocide
GenocideGenocide
Genocide
SocProf
 
International Law Short Study Notes
International Law Short Study Notes International Law Short Study Notes
International Law Short Study Notes
zahinch
 
State jurisdiction under PUBLIC INTERNATIONAL LAW
State  jurisdiction under PUBLIC INTERNATIONAL LAWState  jurisdiction under PUBLIC INTERNATIONAL LAW
State jurisdiction under PUBLIC INTERNATIONAL LAW
ovro rakib
 
state responsibility
state responsibilitystate responsibility
state responsibility
Hafizul Mukhlis
 

What's hot (20)

Peaceful settlement of international dispute
Peaceful settlement of international disputePeaceful settlement of international dispute
Peaceful settlement of international dispute
 
Subjects of international law
Subjects of international lawSubjects of international law
Subjects of international law
 
THE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT (ICC) AND MYANMAR-BANGLADESH
THE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT (ICC) AND MYANMAR-BANGLADESHTHE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT (ICC) AND MYANMAR-BANGLADESH
THE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT (ICC) AND MYANMAR-BANGLADESH
 
The ICJ
The ICJThe ICJ
The ICJ
 
International criminal law
International criminal lawInternational criminal law
International criminal law
 
The International Court of Justice
The International Court of JusticeThe International Court of Justice
The International Court of Justice
 
International Humanitarian Law
International Humanitarian LawInternational Humanitarian Law
International Humanitarian Law
 
International Court of Justice
International Court of JusticeInternational Court of Justice
International Court of Justice
 
Is international law a true law.vvvvvvvvvi
Is international law a true law.vvvvvvvvviIs international law a true law.vvvvvvvvvi
Is international law a true law.vvvvvvvvvi
 
Criminal jurisdiction
Criminal jurisdictionCriminal jurisdiction
Criminal jurisdiction
 
International law notes
International law notesInternational law notes
International law notes
 
Settlement of international disputes (International Law) Amicable(Rajat Vaish...
Settlement of international disputes (International Law) Amicable(Rajat Vaish...Settlement of international disputes (International Law) Amicable(Rajat Vaish...
Settlement of international disputes (International Law) Amicable(Rajat Vaish...
 
Genocide and crime against humanity final
Genocide and crime against humanity finalGenocide and crime against humanity final
Genocide and crime against humanity final
 
The International Criminal Court (ICC) presentation added-
The International Criminal Court (ICC)  presentation added-The International Criminal Court (ICC)  presentation added-
The International Criminal Court (ICC) presentation added-
 
Defences under International Criminal Law
Defences under International Criminal LawDefences under International Criminal Law
Defences under International Criminal Law
 
International humanitarian law (ihl)
International humanitarian law  (ihl)International humanitarian law  (ihl)
International humanitarian law (ihl)
 
Genocide
GenocideGenocide
Genocide
 
International Law Short Study Notes
International Law Short Study Notes International Law Short Study Notes
International Law Short Study Notes
 
State jurisdiction under PUBLIC INTERNATIONAL LAW
State  jurisdiction under PUBLIC INTERNATIONAL LAWState  jurisdiction under PUBLIC INTERNATIONAL LAW
State jurisdiction under PUBLIC INTERNATIONAL LAW
 
state responsibility
state responsibilitystate responsibility
state responsibility
 

Viewers also liked

International criminal court
International criminal courtInternational criminal court
International criminal court
Abdirizak Hagi
 
International Criminal Court
International Criminal CourtInternational Criminal Court
International Criminal Court
VI UVMMUN
 
International criminal law
International criminal lawInternational criminal law
International criminal law
Shijirmaa Shijree
 
international court of jurisdiction
international court of jurisdictioninternational court of jurisdiction
international court of jurisdiction
Amulya Nigam
 
International Court of Justice
International Court of JusticeInternational Court of Justice
International Court of Justice
Andi Belegu
 
INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE
INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICEINTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE
INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE
Alyna Adyl
 
Public International Law Vs. Private International Law
Public International Law Vs. Private International LawPublic International Law Vs. Private International Law
Public International Law Vs. Private International Law
Raveesha Gupta
 
LAW5ICL International Criminal Law
LAW5ICL International Criminal LawLAW5ICL International Criminal Law
LAW5ICL International Criminal Law
La Trobe University Library- College of ASSC
 
Universal Jurisdiction Under the Rome Statute- GC (2)
Universal Jurisdiction Under the Rome Statute- GC (2)Universal Jurisdiction Under the Rome Statute- GC (2)
Universal Jurisdiction Under the Rome Statute- GC (2)
Ovo Imoedemhe
 
Criminal jurisdiction
Criminal jurisdictionCriminal jurisdiction
Criminal jurisdiction
James King
 
State jurisdiction
State jurisdictionState jurisdiction
State jurisdiction
pranjal joshi
 
law of the sea
law of the sealaw of the sea
law of the sea
Hafizul Mukhlis
 
What is International Law?
What is International Law?What is International Law?
What is International Law?
Arundathie Abeysinghe
 
International law notes by asmatullah
International law notes by asmatullahInternational law notes by asmatullah
International law notes by asmatullah
Asmatullah Kakar
 
State of the Word 2011
State of the Word 2011State of the Word 2011
State of the Word 2011
photomatt
 
Lwn158 seminar 10
Lwn158 seminar 10 Lwn158 seminar 10
Lwn158 seminar 10
hollyranae
 

Viewers also liked (16)

International criminal court
International criminal courtInternational criminal court
International criminal court
 
International Criminal Court
International Criminal CourtInternational Criminal Court
International Criminal Court
 
International criminal law
International criminal lawInternational criminal law
International criminal law
 
international court of jurisdiction
international court of jurisdictioninternational court of jurisdiction
international court of jurisdiction
 
International Court of Justice
International Court of JusticeInternational Court of Justice
International Court of Justice
 
INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE
INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICEINTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE
INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE
 
Public International Law Vs. Private International Law
Public International Law Vs. Private International LawPublic International Law Vs. Private International Law
Public International Law Vs. Private International Law
 
LAW5ICL International Criminal Law
LAW5ICL International Criminal LawLAW5ICL International Criminal Law
LAW5ICL International Criminal Law
 
Universal Jurisdiction Under the Rome Statute- GC (2)
Universal Jurisdiction Under the Rome Statute- GC (2)Universal Jurisdiction Under the Rome Statute- GC (2)
Universal Jurisdiction Under the Rome Statute- GC (2)
 
Criminal jurisdiction
Criminal jurisdictionCriminal jurisdiction
Criminal jurisdiction
 
State jurisdiction
State jurisdictionState jurisdiction
State jurisdiction
 
law of the sea
law of the sealaw of the sea
law of the sea
 
What is International Law?
What is International Law?What is International Law?
What is International Law?
 
International law notes by asmatullah
International law notes by asmatullahInternational law notes by asmatullah
International law notes by asmatullah
 
State of the Word 2011
State of the Word 2011State of the Word 2011
State of the Word 2011
 
Lwn158 seminar 10
Lwn158 seminar 10 Lwn158 seminar 10
Lwn158 seminar 10
 

Similar to International Criminal Court: Jurisdiction and Issues

International Crime
International CrimeInternational Crime
International Crime
Mr Shipp
 
Introduction to International Criminal Law
Introduction to International Criminal LawIntroduction to International Criminal Law
Introduction to International Criminal Law
MasoudZamani13
 
Presentation1.pptx
Presentation1.pptxPresentation1.pptx
Presentation1.pptx
Masoud Zamani
 
The ICC
The ICCThe ICC
The ICC
Andrea Quadra
 
6.1 categories of international crime
6.1 categories of international crime6.1 categories of international crime
6.1 categories of international crime
Alisa Stephens
 
Significant development of the role of the International Criminal Court post ...
Significant development of the role of the International Criminal Court post ...Significant development of the role of the International Criminal Court post ...
Significant development of the role of the International Criminal Court post ...
Vilashini Devi
 
1)state jurisdiction
1)state jurisdiction1)state jurisdiction
1)state jurisdiction
ilyana iskandar
 
Assignment.pptx
Assignment.pptxAssignment.pptx
Assignment.pptx
RohitBishnoi15
 
Hukum pidana internasional
Hukum pidana internasionalHukum pidana internasional
Hukum pidana internasional
Kardoman Tumangger
 
Icc 140312-presentation-j-cubbon
Icc 140312-presentation-j-cubbonIcc 140312-presentation-j-cubbon
Icc 140312-presentation-j-cubbon
Nancy Yanira Munoz Martinez
 
Ad hoc Tribunals in International Criminal Law.pptx
Ad hoc Tribunals in International Criminal Law.pptxAd hoc Tribunals in International Criminal Law.pptx
Ad hoc Tribunals in International Criminal Law.pptx
Masoud Zamani
 
State Jurisdiction under International Criminal Law
State Jurisdiction under International Criminal LawState Jurisdiction under International Criminal Law
State Jurisdiction under International Criminal Law
University of Rajshahi
 
International criminal-law
International criminal-lawInternational criminal-law
International criminal-law
Mainan Ray
 
Enhancing the Legal Framework on Male-Directed Sexual Violence Part 2
Enhancing the Legal Framework on Male-Directed Sexual Violence Part 2Enhancing the Legal Framework on Male-Directed Sexual Violence Part 2
Enhancing the Legal Framework on Male-Directed Sexual Violence Part 2
United Nations Office of the Special Representative on Sexual Violence in Conflict
 
Jurisdiction active and passive personality, protective principle and
Jurisdiction active and passive personality, protective principle andJurisdiction active and passive personality, protective principle and
Jurisdiction active and passive personality, protective principle and
Absar Aftab Absar
 
United Nations Convention Against Transnational Organized Crime.
United Nations Convention Against Transnational Organized Crime.United Nations Convention Against Transnational Organized Crime.
United Nations Convention Against Transnational Organized Crime.
Minakshi Das
 
International criminal court against child kidnapping
  International criminal court against child kidnapping  International criminal court against child kidnapping
International criminal court against child kidnapping
International Criminal Court Against Child Kidnapping
 
International Criminal Court
International Criminal CourtInternational Criminal Court
International Criminal Court
Jessica Cannella
 
Ch 6. Understanding Our Criminal Justice System 3 Criminal Law.ppt.ppt
Ch 6. Understanding Our Criminal Justice System 3 Criminal Law.ppt.pptCh 6. Understanding Our Criminal Justice System 3 Criminal Law.ppt.ppt
Ch 6. Understanding Our Criminal Justice System 3 Criminal Law.ppt.ppt
NamitaPatra3
 
Principle of complementarity
Principle of complementarityPrinciple of complementarity
Principle of complementarity
gagan deep
 

Similar to International Criminal Court: Jurisdiction and Issues (20)

International Crime
International CrimeInternational Crime
International Crime
 
Introduction to International Criminal Law
Introduction to International Criminal LawIntroduction to International Criminal Law
Introduction to International Criminal Law
 
Presentation1.pptx
Presentation1.pptxPresentation1.pptx
Presentation1.pptx
 
The ICC
The ICCThe ICC
The ICC
 
6.1 categories of international crime
6.1 categories of international crime6.1 categories of international crime
6.1 categories of international crime
 
Significant development of the role of the International Criminal Court post ...
Significant development of the role of the International Criminal Court post ...Significant development of the role of the International Criminal Court post ...
Significant development of the role of the International Criminal Court post ...
 
1)state jurisdiction
1)state jurisdiction1)state jurisdiction
1)state jurisdiction
 
Assignment.pptx
Assignment.pptxAssignment.pptx
Assignment.pptx
 
Hukum pidana internasional
Hukum pidana internasionalHukum pidana internasional
Hukum pidana internasional
 
Icc 140312-presentation-j-cubbon
Icc 140312-presentation-j-cubbonIcc 140312-presentation-j-cubbon
Icc 140312-presentation-j-cubbon
 
Ad hoc Tribunals in International Criminal Law.pptx
Ad hoc Tribunals in International Criminal Law.pptxAd hoc Tribunals in International Criminal Law.pptx
Ad hoc Tribunals in International Criminal Law.pptx
 
State Jurisdiction under International Criminal Law
State Jurisdiction under International Criminal LawState Jurisdiction under International Criminal Law
State Jurisdiction under International Criminal Law
 
International criminal-law
International criminal-lawInternational criminal-law
International criminal-law
 
Enhancing the Legal Framework on Male-Directed Sexual Violence Part 2
Enhancing the Legal Framework on Male-Directed Sexual Violence Part 2Enhancing the Legal Framework on Male-Directed Sexual Violence Part 2
Enhancing the Legal Framework on Male-Directed Sexual Violence Part 2
 
Jurisdiction active and passive personality, protective principle and
Jurisdiction active and passive personality, protective principle andJurisdiction active and passive personality, protective principle and
Jurisdiction active and passive personality, protective principle and
 
United Nations Convention Against Transnational Organized Crime.
United Nations Convention Against Transnational Organized Crime.United Nations Convention Against Transnational Organized Crime.
United Nations Convention Against Transnational Organized Crime.
 
International criminal court against child kidnapping
  International criminal court against child kidnapping  International criminal court against child kidnapping
International criminal court against child kidnapping
 
International Criminal Court
International Criminal CourtInternational Criminal Court
International Criminal Court
 
Ch 6. Understanding Our Criminal Justice System 3 Criminal Law.ppt.ppt
Ch 6. Understanding Our Criminal Justice System 3 Criminal Law.ppt.pptCh 6. Understanding Our Criminal Justice System 3 Criminal Law.ppt.ppt
Ch 6. Understanding Our Criminal Justice System 3 Criminal Law.ppt.ppt
 
Principle of complementarity
Principle of complementarityPrinciple of complementarity
Principle of complementarity
 

International Criminal Court: Jurisdiction and Issues

  • 1. Individual Criminal Liability in International Law The Rome Statute and the International Criminal Court
  • 2. Agenda  Overview – What are the history and mission of the ICC?  Jurisdiction – What crimes are under the jurisdiction of the ICC?  Exercise of Jurisdiction – How are cases brought to the ICC, not domestic courts?  Issues – Does the ICC infringe on state sovereignty?
  • 3. International Criminal Tribunals and the ICC  Ad hoc courts of limited jurisdiction − Nuremberg and Tokyo tribunals − International Criminal Tribunal on Rwanda − International Criminal Tribunal on the Former Yugoslavia − Sierra Leone, Timor-Leste, Cambodia...  ICC − Expansion in time: A permanent court − Expansion in space: Not limited to regions
  • 4. Overview of the ICC  Entered into force July 1, 2002  121 parties  Court of last resort
  • 7. Crimes Serious Crimes International Crimes
  • 8. Crimes Serious Crimes Inter- national Crimes Genocide
  • 9. Crimes Serious Crimes Inter- national Crimes Crimes Against Humanity
  • 10. Crimes Serious Crimes Inter- national Crimes War Crimes
  • 11. Crimes Serious Crimes Inter- national Crimes Crimes of Aggression
  • 12. Crimes Serious Crimes Inter- national The Crimes Crimes Crime of Against Genocide Humanity Crimes of War Crimes Aggression
  • 13. Genocide  Objective element – Action: Killing, etc. (Art. 6 (a) to (e))  Subjective element – Intention: Intent to destroy national, ethnical, racial, religious group
  • 14. Crimes Against Humanity  Objective element – Action: Murder, etc. (Art. 7 (a) to (k)) – Condition: Part of widespread/systematic attack  Subjective element – Knowledge of the attack
  • 15. War Crimes  Objective element – Action: Grave Geneva breaches, etc. (Art. 8 (2)) – Condition: In particular when part of policy/plan  Subjective element
  • 16. Crime of Aggression  Stay tuned! (Art. 5 (2))
  • 17. Other Limits on Jurisdiction  Temporal jurisdiction – Crimes committed after entry into force (11 (1))  Admissibility (Art. 17) – Investigation or prosecution by a state • Unless unable or unwilling • Last resort
  • 19. ICC Case Checklist Is the crime under ICC jurisdiction? Art. 5 Art. 11 Is there temporal jurisdiction? Art. 13 Was the case properly referred? Art. 17 Is the domestic court unable or unwilling to prosecute? ICC trial
  • 20. Exercise of Jurisdiction and State Sovereignty  Of the 3 forms of case referral, which is least problematic when it comes to sovereignty?  Is it justifiable for the Security Council to refer cases to the ICC, even situations in non-ICC states?  Is it justifiable for the ICC prosecutor to initiate cases? Why or why not?
  • 21. Criticism of the ICC  Lack of oversight, checks & balances  Selectivity  Sovereignty concerns  Makes peace process more difficult
  • 22. Thinking about the ICC  What checks are there on the ICC’s power?  Is the ICC biased against Africa?  Does the ICC infringe on sovereignty?  Is the ICC doing its job deterring int’l crimes?