By Jane Hou , Partner, and Adam Meng, Associate of the Beijing office, and Taylor Lam, SEM of the Hong Kong office
A new perspective devoted to the “policy on the pilot of fixed broadband market liberalization” in China, that encourages civil capital to enter fixed broadband market in various models, a milestone of state monopolized industries’ opening up
The Evolution of VoIP-A look into how VoIP has proliferated into the global d...Bradley Susser
This paper doesn’t dispute the fact that customers will continue to benefit significantly from VoIP as
quality of service has improved while costs have continued to come down considerably rather our
objective is to focus more on the viability of providers that encompass this sector of the market. We
aim to first describe how VoIP has proliferated into the global dominant platform it is today, the
infrastructure and definition of VoIP, VoIP’s classification schemes, the growth of technologies
leveraging the VoIP platform while disrupting traditional carriers business models, covering the topic of
VoIP security, explaining the different regulatory frameworks around the globe and finally concluding
with an opinion on the competitive landscape.
Verizon Communications Inc, Industry External AnalysisMaximilian Mirra
My team and I conducted an industry analysis for our client, Verizon Communications Inc. Within the report we have used tools such as Porter's 5 forces, Strategic Group Maps, and used Key Performance Indicators (KPI) to asses the overall attractiveness of the industries Wireless Telecommunications and Internet Service Providers (ISP).
Whitepaper: From Resistance to Partnership: Operators shift into monetising OTTtyntec
This tyntec-sponsored survey, based on interviews with over 60 mobile operators across global marketplace conducted by independent research company mobilesquared, shows clear evidence that there has been a significant shift in mobile operator mindset regarding OTT communications. The perception that OTT (Over-the-Top) communications is a threat has been replaced with a revenue-generating opportunity. Mobile operators are now open and receptive to partnering with OTT service providers. The research revealed that 98% of mobile operators will potentially enter into an OTT communications partnership. From the perspective of maturing OTT service providers, operators’ openness to partnership brings forth even greater opportunity as they are moving towards a revenue generation model—as opposed to just focusing on market capitalization—to prove their commercial viability.
The Evolution of VoIP-A look into how VoIP has proliferated into the global d...Bradley Susser
This paper doesn’t dispute the fact that customers will continue to benefit significantly from VoIP as
quality of service has improved while costs have continued to come down considerably rather our
objective is to focus more on the viability of providers that encompass this sector of the market. We
aim to first describe how VoIP has proliferated into the global dominant platform it is today, the
infrastructure and definition of VoIP, VoIP’s classification schemes, the growth of technologies
leveraging the VoIP platform while disrupting traditional carriers business models, covering the topic of
VoIP security, explaining the different regulatory frameworks around the globe and finally concluding
with an opinion on the competitive landscape.
Verizon Communications Inc, Industry External AnalysisMaximilian Mirra
My team and I conducted an industry analysis for our client, Verizon Communications Inc. Within the report we have used tools such as Porter's 5 forces, Strategic Group Maps, and used Key Performance Indicators (KPI) to asses the overall attractiveness of the industries Wireless Telecommunications and Internet Service Providers (ISP).
Whitepaper: From Resistance to Partnership: Operators shift into monetising OTTtyntec
This tyntec-sponsored survey, based on interviews with over 60 mobile operators across global marketplace conducted by independent research company mobilesquared, shows clear evidence that there has been a significant shift in mobile operator mindset regarding OTT communications. The perception that OTT (Over-the-Top) communications is a threat has been replaced with a revenue-generating opportunity. Mobile operators are now open and receptive to partnering with OTT service providers. The research revealed that 98% of mobile operators will potentially enter into an OTT communications partnership. From the perspective of maturing OTT service providers, operators’ openness to partnership brings forth even greater opportunity as they are moving towards a revenue generation model—as opposed to just focusing on market capitalization—to prove their commercial viability.
White paper: Closing the mobile data revenue gap (2010)Corine Suscens
The demand for mobile data is exploding, presenting operators with a unique opportunity to generate new revenue streams and grow their business. However revenue is not growing fast enough to ensure profitability. Not only is the mobile data traffic growing much faster than revenues, but the revenue growth rate also tends to decline over the years.
Download this whitepaper to find out ways to address this challenge and better capitalize on the mobile data opportunity.
The whitepaper analyses business models and capabilities that will help an operator to optimize its subscriber potential, differentiate itself from the competition, and achieve its mobile data revenue maximization goals.
PLDT Incorporated (TEL) provides Filipinos with telecommunications services, fiber-optic backbones, fixed-line and cellular networks operating in three business groups: fixed-line, wireless and others.
Profitable Growth has fallen to #7 from #3 over the last five years. TEL now only ranks better than 42 of 140 large Telecom companies.
Learn more at: http://becomeabetterinvestor.net/blog/a-telecom-in-tough-waters/
Detecon Workshop - Telco and OTT PartnershipsAdrian Hall
Innovation in the field of ICT products and services is significantly changing human communication behaviour and drives data usage on both fixed and mobile networks.
Pricing trends for communication services in the UK - May 2018Portal Mediatelecom
This report looks at pricing trends for residential phone, broadband and TV services in the UK. It examines the prices of standalone and bundled services currently available, and what consumers actually pay for these services.
It also looks at how consumers engage with the market, including their understanding of usage levels, contract lengths, and promotional prices. It illustrates how the prices paid by engaged consumers (those who shop around and are aware of their contractual status), who are currently within a minimum contract period, differ from prices paid by consumers outside a minimum contractual period.
The report also includes the results of our consumer engagement research, which looked at the reasons why consumers may not engage with the market.
Check out our in-depth country specific research on consumer preferences towards OTT services across local markets covering 9 countries - from Hong Kong, India, Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines, Singapore, Taiwan, Thailand and Vietnam.
BELTUG_competition study with notes_websasvangent32
Danielle Jacobs highlighted the results of BELTUG’s own research into the current situation of the business market, clearly demonstrating there is insufficient competition. “Often, organisations do not get more than one or two responses to their RFPs. There is also limited vendor switching,” she explained. “An important shift is necessary. International and national authorities need to consider businesses as a separate market with its own needs. More and more companies are looking for service providers to help them with increased complexity. Integrators (will) have 'preferred' suppliers. Often Belgacom will be one of these. BELTUG fears that there is an increased risk of dependency on Belgacom."
The indigenous Telecoms, Internet, Media & Edutainment (TIME) sector
has grown its international footprint over the last six years. The continued adoption of high-speed internet (fixed and mobile) as a direct channel opens up a significant revenue opportunity.
India telecom revenues is primarily driven by voice which constitutes to 90% of total revenues leaving only a smaller portion for data. Aegis LeadCap Research & Consulting predicts that in next 5 years share of revenue from voice will reduce down to 60% from its current state of 90%. 40% revenue from data also includes the revenue from BWA service providers like Reliance Infotel, Tikona etc. Most prominent value add services which drives data revenues include mobile internet, mobile broadband, games, location based services, video calls, mobile adverts, music, video and mobile TV.
White paper: Closing the mobile data revenue gap (2010)Corine Suscens
The demand for mobile data is exploding, presenting operators with a unique opportunity to generate new revenue streams and grow their business. However revenue is not growing fast enough to ensure profitability. Not only is the mobile data traffic growing much faster than revenues, but the revenue growth rate also tends to decline over the years.
Download this whitepaper to find out ways to address this challenge and better capitalize on the mobile data opportunity.
The whitepaper analyses business models and capabilities that will help an operator to optimize its subscriber potential, differentiate itself from the competition, and achieve its mobile data revenue maximization goals.
PLDT Incorporated (TEL) provides Filipinos with telecommunications services, fiber-optic backbones, fixed-line and cellular networks operating in three business groups: fixed-line, wireless and others.
Profitable Growth has fallen to #7 from #3 over the last five years. TEL now only ranks better than 42 of 140 large Telecom companies.
Learn more at: http://becomeabetterinvestor.net/blog/a-telecom-in-tough-waters/
Detecon Workshop - Telco and OTT PartnershipsAdrian Hall
Innovation in the field of ICT products and services is significantly changing human communication behaviour and drives data usage on both fixed and mobile networks.
Pricing trends for communication services in the UK - May 2018Portal Mediatelecom
This report looks at pricing trends for residential phone, broadband and TV services in the UK. It examines the prices of standalone and bundled services currently available, and what consumers actually pay for these services.
It also looks at how consumers engage with the market, including their understanding of usage levels, contract lengths, and promotional prices. It illustrates how the prices paid by engaged consumers (those who shop around and are aware of their contractual status), who are currently within a minimum contract period, differ from prices paid by consumers outside a minimum contractual period.
The report also includes the results of our consumer engagement research, which looked at the reasons why consumers may not engage with the market.
Check out our in-depth country specific research on consumer preferences towards OTT services across local markets covering 9 countries - from Hong Kong, India, Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines, Singapore, Taiwan, Thailand and Vietnam.
BELTUG_competition study with notes_websasvangent32
Danielle Jacobs highlighted the results of BELTUG’s own research into the current situation of the business market, clearly demonstrating there is insufficient competition. “Often, organisations do not get more than one or two responses to their RFPs. There is also limited vendor switching,” she explained. “An important shift is necessary. International and national authorities need to consider businesses as a separate market with its own needs. More and more companies are looking for service providers to help them with increased complexity. Integrators (will) have 'preferred' suppliers. Often Belgacom will be one of these. BELTUG fears that there is an increased risk of dependency on Belgacom."
The indigenous Telecoms, Internet, Media & Edutainment (TIME) sector
has grown its international footprint over the last six years. The continued adoption of high-speed internet (fixed and mobile) as a direct channel opens up a significant revenue opportunity.
India telecom revenues is primarily driven by voice which constitutes to 90% of total revenues leaving only a smaller portion for data. Aegis LeadCap Research & Consulting predicts that in next 5 years share of revenue from voice will reduce down to 60% from its current state of 90%. 40% revenue from data also includes the revenue from BWA service providers like Reliance Infotel, Tikona etc. Most prominent value add services which drives data revenues include mobile internet, mobile broadband, games, location based services, video calls, mobile adverts, music, video and mobile TV.
•
Malaysia has made significant progress in basic connectivity, but there is an opportunity to expand access to and use of higher quality broadband.
•
Ubiquitous, high quality, affordable broadband will increasingly be a critical foundation of the digital economy. Better connected economies will do better.
•
Malaysia’s ambitions for the digital economy will only be realized, and its investments (DFTZ, Industry 4.0 etc.) pay off, if fixed broadband services become more affordable and their quality is improved.
•
Malaysia can consider a new strategy, with more ambitious targets, to promote competitive markets, accelerate infrastructure deployments, and attract private capitalto increase broadband network roll out and use.
TIA experts, including featured guest, former FCC Commissioner Harold Furchtgott-Roth, analyze FCC Chairman Julius Genachowski's proposal to reclassify broadband as a Title II service under Telecommunications Act. Watch webinar: http://www.brighttalk.com/webcast/21172
Accelerating enterprise innovation and transformation with 5G and Wi-Fi 6aakash malhotra
We are living in a hyper-connected era where the count of network devices has reached 29.3, three times more than the actual population. The next generation 5G and WiFi 6 are no longer long-lost dreams but are the reality that will transform the ways networks connect machines and people, offering better speed, higher data capacity, and location sensing. Be the part of the change and learn how 5G and WiFi 6 can accelerate enterprise innovation with the following PDF.
Mobile VAS and Multimedia Ecosystem and Value‐Chain over 4G and 4.5G Network ...Ali Saghaeian
The slides cover a broad range of topics, including:
4G and 4.5G as the Next Uplift of Growth
The Evolution of Mobile Operators' Business Model
Possible Changes in the Value Chain
How to take the Smart Pipe VAS Strategy
Data as the key to create Competing Value
Key Drivers and Success Factors in Future Networks
Operators' Strategies in the Value Chain
Digital Economy and the Evolving Ecosystem
Multi system operators - an industry perspectiveAbhinav Mishra
A thought leadership paper on Multiple System Operators (MSO) providing an overview of the Indian cable television industry’s future trends, technologies and challenges faced by them along with a new era of possibilities available in the wake of an increased demand for quality viewer experience.
A thought leadership paper on Multiple System Operators (MSO) providing an overview of the Indian cable television industry’s future trends, technologies and challenges faced by them along with a new era of possibilities available in the wake of an increased demand for quality viewer experience.
Impact of covid 19 on sectors in India - Pinnacle DigitalAnuj Tanwar
Industry: Telecom and Technology
Impact: Low
Recovery Period: Short
Future : Promising
Telcom sector saw a huge spike in data traffic and consumption. The growth rate of traffic since mid March, 2020 is the highest in the last 12 months. Mobile data traffic, too, rebounded after declining for 10 straight months, the data showed.
A comprehensive analysis of the applications, use cases, and business considerations of LTE Broadcast from network operators, industry analysts and enterprise users perspective. To download, please visit: https://www.qualcomm.com/media/documents/files/lte-broadcast-white-paper-by-idc.pdf
Similar to The policy and prospects of China’s fixed broadband Market liberalization (20)
The European Commission’s new rule on credit cards will cut 200 million commissions in Italy: will a subscription fee be introduced? With a contribution by Gabor Friedenthal, Dep. Managing Director, and Daniele Pontecorvo, SEM
Dynamic ticket pricing. Squeezing more juice from half time oranges Value Partners
A new perspective devoted to the benefits of the dynamic ticket pricing (DTP) in the sport industry. It is a pricing strategy according to which companies set flexible (dynamic) prices based on market demands.
Online to offline. What is in for traditional retailers? Value Partners
A new perspective devoted to O2O and the latest approaches adopted by retailers trying to integrate online resources with their offline physical assets
Customer Service: Achieving excellence through a company-wide approachValue Partners
A new perspective devoted to customer satisfaction, a key driver to increase a company’s value. By Alberto Griselli and Charles Monteux of the São Paulo office
Magazine Publishers' Transformation: The Time to Act is Now! Value Partners
By Demetrio Di Martino, Partner of the Singapore office, Charles Monteux, Senior Engagement Manager of the São Paulo office and Mark Weston, Business Analyst of the London office. January
Un nuovo perspective dedicato all'importanza della trasparenza nel settore sanità, con un confronto internazionale - A cura di Daniela Scaramuccia, Partner, e Nunzio Guida, Associate dell'ufficio di Milano Dicembre
A new perspective devoted to forecasting: demand planning is a very challenging job, that is why multinationals manage forecasting poorly. How can they improve it?
A perspective devoted to Private Equity firms: to be successful they should adopt an innovative business model and control the richest parts of the value chain
By Rachel Healy, senior manager, and Kim Chua, manager, at Value Partners London
There has been much discussion about the level and rate of viewing migration from linear to VOD; the general consensus seems to be that the speed of the shift will be slow, and that the proportion of VOD viewing in the medium term (say fi ve years) will remain low at 6 – 8%, compared to c. 2% today. However, do these forecasts take into account step-change shifts in behaviour of Generation Z1, the ‘digital natives’? Value Partners runs an internship programme for aspiring TMT strategy consultants each summer. This year, we asked one of our interns to carry out primary research into their peer group’s current and future TV viewing patterns. We worked with her to design a 26-question survey which she distributed via Facebook. Although this is by no means a ‘representative sample’ of Gen Z – a sample of just 78 respondents, largely Oxbridge and users of Facebook – the results paint an interesting picture of the relationship this highly sought after demographic has with TV and how this will evolve as they leave university and move into the world of work.
Exclusive content cross-carriage obligation in Singapore: an innovative inter...Value Partners
By Ruggero Jenna, director, Dominic Arena, partner, and Cheryl Lim, manager at Value Partners Singapore. Singapore's pay TV industry is experiencing a transformation. The advent of fierce competition and rights bidding, followed by a controversial regulatory development, namely the Media Development Authority of Singapore's (MDA) proposed introduction of an “exclusive content cross-carriage measure”, has captured the attention of pay TV industry groups and other interested parties worldwide. Well-voiced concerns on both sides of the spectrum regarding the formulation, feasibility and impact of such a regulatory measure have been fiercely debated by stakeholders, with the face-off at one stage threatening to snowball into an international incident. However, contrary to some quite negative arguments put forward publicly to date, Value Partners' independent analysis over a 10-year timeframe shows that the MDA measure is not an ill-conceived or hasty retort to a temporary market anomaly which threatens to destroy economic value, but an innovative and well-grounded measure.
3. perspective The policy and prospects of China’s fixed broadband Market liberalization
OVERVIEW
In December 2014, the Ministry of Industry
and Information Technology of China
(hereinafter referred to as “MIIT” or “the Ministry”)
introduced “policy on the pilot of fixed broadband
market liberalization”, encouraging civil capital
to enter fixed broadband market in various
models, which is considered as another milestone
of state monopolized industries’ opening up.
There’re various types of participants in
fixed broadband market worldwide.
Several distinguished business models have
been outlined.
5. perspective The policy and prospects of China’s fixed broadband Market liberalization
distinguished
business models
From a global perspective, major FBB
players – besides typical ISPs and
network providers – can be divided into
4-5 groups: tier 2 broadband operators,
light tier 2 broadband operators, tier 3
broadband operators/VISPs, light VISPs
and broadband resellers. Due to the
high liberalization level of the market,
tier 2 broadband operators are com-
monly participating in the construction
and operation of the backbone network.
Across the oversea markets, there’re
many non-telecom background com-
panies which operate fixed broadband
business, like internet, media, energy,
financial services and even NGO.
1) The entrance of FTTX, 2) Capability
of high CAPEX investment, 3) Source-
ful OTT contents to bundle formed the
key success basis for the FBB business.
There’re non-telecom background com-
panies (like internet companies Google,
Facebook and Virgin Media), typical
VISP (like British media company Sky),
light VISP (like American IP telephone
services provider Vonage) and some
resellers in the market.
Internet giant Google invested radically
in network infrustratures, including
Google Fiber project, Unity Consortium
project, Titan Aerospace project, O3B
Networks project, Project Loon and
TV Whitespace project. Google Fiber
– Google’s FTTX initiative launched in
2012 - is highly comparable to China’s
potential piloting players. Thus, its
underlyding business logics could be
inspirations to China’s incoming partici-
pants, especially to internet companies.
Google Fiber project is a high-speed
FTTX project which was launched
in 2012 by Google, now is rolling out
in 12 cities in the US as planned (by
December 2014, 3 cities had actually
launched). By possessing ample band-
width through contract with network
providers, relying on high-quality
optical fiber under the support of PON
technology, Google Fiber could provide
unprecedent high speed internet con-
nection – nearly as much as 1000 times
of market average in the US – to the
end users. Both the uplink and downlink
transmission speed are up to 1GBps.
Google has bundled pay TV, cloud
drive, mobile phone business into its
high speed internet service package.
Due to the maturity of America’s pay
TV market, Google Fiber has a very
high ARPU reaching 107 USD / month in
Kansas City. In the mean time, Google
Fiber utilized the model of “Booking
first, building afterward” to devest
unnecessary investments. And the
ultimate cost allocation of FTTX is 1100
USD per household. Therefore, Google
Fiber would be able to achieve the paid-
back in about 1 year.
6. 6 – 7
Exhibit 2
Google Fiber service offers
Sources: Google Fiber webpage, Value Partners Analysis 2015
GIGABIT + TV
$ 120 / mo
$300 waived
construction fee
GIGABIT INTERNET
$ 70 / mo
$300 waived
construction fee
FREE INTERNET
$ 0 / mo
$300 construction fee
(one time or $ 25 / mo for 12 mo)
Google Drive
(1TB storage)
Network Box
HDTV
(TV Set Not Included)
Optional Add-On:
Chromebook
Nexus 7 tabletTV BoxStorage Box
7. perspective The policy and prospects of China’s fixed broadband Market liberalization
Value Partners believes Google’s posse-
sion of network infrastructure is highly
consistent with company’s strategic
demands.
• The wholesale cost control.
By investing in network assets,
Google can significantly downsize
the bandwidth wholesale cost
from telecommunication operators,
also increase the bargaining chip
in the game.
• To improve the user experiences.
Poor internet speed will degrade
the user experience of Youtube
and other OTT services from Google.
• Driving family market product/service.
High-quality network can greatly
promote Google’s products/services
targeting on family and establish
stronger loyalty.
• To hatch things like IOT with high-
quality network. Support projects
of high data consumption such as
Google Driverless Car.
• To raise competition threshold.
The investment in telecom network
will set a high threshold for future
competitors.
In addition, FBB business model of ICP,
VAS providers such as Virgin Media
(UK), Sky (UK) and Vonage (USA) are
similar to Google. Facebook invested
heavily in the construction of the sub-
marine cable connecting the US West
Coast and for private use, in order to
support the real-time data synchroniza-
tion of different IDCs across continents.
The intention of Google’s 300 million
dollars submarine cable project Unity
Consortium is close to Facebook’s.
8. Exhibit 3
2012-2018 China fixed broadband market size
(unit: million, household)
Sources: OVUM, MIIT, Value Partners Analysis
8 – 9
Household
penetration rate
Year to year
growth rate
2012 2013 2014 E 2015 E 2016 E 2017 E 2018 E
32% 35%
12%
39%
11%
42%
9%
45%
8%
48%
6%
50%
5%
165
185
205
224
241
256
269
9. perspective The policy and prospects of China’s fixed broadband Market liberalization
In recent years, Chinese fixed broadband
user base has been expanding. By the end
of 2013, there were more than 185 million
residentials or business users nationwide.
And this figure would exceed 200 million
in 2014 even by conservative estimates.
Institutions believe that Chinese broad-
band user amount will increase steadily
with not less than 5% of an amplitude in
the next 5 years.
On the other hand, Chinese broadband
household penetration rate is still less
than 40%, especially in the vast under-
developed areas where the broadband
households penetration is only 18%.
China’s fixed broadband market potential
is still very huge.
Chinese fixed broadband
market overview
In addition, the proportion of China
FTTX among all connectivity technolo-
gies is still very low, most broadband
users are still on cable modem, DSL
and other traditional technology rather
than optic fiber.
Therefore, the broadband speed is far
behind the developed markets.
According to Akamai report, China’s
average broadband speed is merely
about 1.7Mbps, whereas Korea’s average
is at 14.2Mbps. Clear opportunities on
optic fiber broadband are set to seize.
The saturation of Chinese fixed
broadband market is deficient,
but its future growth is stable,
and fibre optic broadband has
significant market potential.
10. DSL
10 – 11
Sources: OVUM, MIIT, Value Partners Analysis
Exhibit 4
China’s FBB user bases by connectivity technologies
(unit: million, household)
20120%
100%
2013 2014 E 2015 E 2016 E 2017 E 2018 E
4% 4%
71% 56%
13%
16%
12%
22%
224
241
Cable modem
other
FTTH / B
5% 5% 5% 5% 5%
46% 39% 33% 28% 24%
19%
21%
23%
24%
25%
30%
35%
39%
43%
46%
11. perspective The policy and prospects of China’s fixed broadband Market liberalization
Based on the depth of involvement
along the FBB value chain, China’s
fixed broadband market players can be
categorized into four segments: tier 1
broadband operators (basic telecom
operators), tier 2 broadband operators,
tier 3/residential broadband operators
and broadband resellers/distributors.
• Tier 1 / broadband operators.
Owners of national, provincial and
metro backbone networks, also
involved in the construction of metro
network and CPN. They are eligible to
provide self-branded wire communi-
cations broadband service and value
added services to the end users.
Commonly they tend to collaborate
with tier 3 or residential broadband
operators in the construction and
operations of CPN. Exemplary
enterprises include China Mobile,
China Unicom, China Telecom, as well
as non-telecom enterprises such as
the branch of State Administration
of Press, Publication, Radio, Film and
Television, and CITIC.
• Tier 2 / broadband operators.
Through renting the bandwidth from
tier 1 broadband operators, these
operators construct metro broad-
band network and as well provide
additional services, such as IDC and
enterprise dedicated lines. The main
advantage of these operators is main-
ly high quality-price and enterprise-
level after sales service. Exemplary
companies include The Great Wall
Broadband, Gohoo Broadband, Aipu
Broadband.
• Tier 3 / residential broadband
operators. Usually these enterprises
are involved in the operation of CPN,
and provide resale service from the
upper-tier broadband operators.
These enterprises’ main advantage
are its in-depth involvement into
communities, residential areas and
commercial buildings, as well as
strong social networks. They can also
provide timely and direct response
along with lower and more flexible
pricing to their network services,
so as to capture a major non-
mainstream market share. Most of
these enterprises are real estate and
property management companies.
• Broadband resellers / distributors.
Through cooperating with primary
and secondary broadband opera-
tors, distributors act as sales agents
to resell the broadband services.
These enterprises include 3C/home
appliance retailers such as Gome and
Suning.
12. 12 – 13
Exhibit 5
Policy Decoding
(FBB Value Chain)
Sources: MIIT, Expert interview, Value Partners Analysis
backbone network
liberalized
intra-city
network
cpn
brand /
marketing
offering /
tariff
distribution /
retail
customer
service /
caring
1
2
3
model 1
Certificate of Network
Construction
Certificate of ISP
model 2
model 3
13. perspective The policy and prospects of China’s fixed broadband Market liberalization
Value Partners believes the liberalization
of broadband market is driven by three
main levers. Predominantly, MIIT is aiming
to better regulating the fixed broadband
market, tier 2 and tier 3 FBB operators,
in order to eliminate the ‘gray broad-
band’ services commonly available in the
Chinese market. Also, the accumulated
CAPEX on backbone network (core
network) by basic telecom operators has
been considerable, whereas the acces-
sible residential area and commercial
buildings are limited to them, largely
restricting the service expansion.
Therefore, integrating civil enterprises’
resources and service capacities can ef-
fectively promote the FTTX deployment,
and hence retrieve the return from state-
owned investment into the core networks.
Additionally, such policies are aligned
with the Central Government’s essential
statement on liberalization to civil capitals
among nationally monopolistic industries,
and to optimize the flexibility and innova-
tive advantages of civil enterprises.
MIIT encourages three service models
amongst civil capital investment to par-
ticipate in the broadband service provi-
sion, including two types of qualifications
(see Exhibit 5).
MIIT Policy Decoding
Primarily, MIIT allows civil enterprises
to construct fully or partially
the infrastructures and network equip-
ment necessary for household users’
wire communications, and the scale
shall be from user end to the Network
Access Server, i.e. FTTX (Fiber to the X).
Enterprises are also eligible to rent and
resale relevant network elements.
Enterprises acquiring the ISP qualification
are also eligible to provide self-branded
services to the end users for their broad-
band internet usage.
Currently MIIT has only opened the ‘last-
mile network’ – FTTX – resources for civil
enterprises, namely the construction and
operation of non-core / non-backbone
broadband infrustratures. After the pilot
period, MIIT may also liberalize the back-
bone network to civil enterprises.
14. 14 – 15
Immediately after the introduction
of this policy, multiple enterprises started
to pay close attention to the license;
we expect that enterprises from various
industries will participate in license ap-
plications.
Since the introduction of the policy,
a number of enterprises from different
industries have been closely following
the detailed instruction and progression
from MIIT, with some clearly stating
to apply for the license. Value Partners
believes the qualification to FBB license
application shall be much stricter than
the MVNO license issued by MIIT in 2013.
From our benchmarking with the overall
industrial data, the capital expenditure
(CAPEX) is around 1,000 RMB if investing
only the CPN to reach each household in
the residential area. If the network con-
struction is extended to metro network
scale, the CAPEX would be hard to esti-
mate considering the complexity of con-
struction conditions. The post-sale service
of broadband, moreover, requires staffing
to enter each household for network
maintenance and debugging, the service
cost (part of the operation expenditure)
would therefore be also substantial.
We presume enterprises intending to
obtain the license are most likely from
the following industries/backgrounds:
• Secondary broadband operators.
Undeniably the most competitive and
pertinent players in obtaining the li-
cense, given their business operation
advantage and the key focus of MIIT.
• Real estate / Property management
companies (third-level broadband
operator). Real estate and property
enterprises are intrinsically advan-
tageous in undertaking the fixed-
broadband service to households,
provided the ownership and manage-
ment of the residences and com-
mercial buildings, complimentary to
basic telecom operators’ resources.
The collaboration between telecom
operators and these companies
would be therefore highly prioritized.
• Internet and digital media
enterprises. Internet companies
including Baidu, Alibaba and Ten-
cent can promptly try obtaining
the license, and achieving different
objectives, such as promoting more
value added internet-based service,
assisting IDCs’ fiber connection cross
regions, and further enriching big
data accumulation.
• Cloud service / telecom value
added service provider (especially
for business clients). The fixed
broadband service can be naturally
bundled with information system ser-
vices and cloud services, considering
the strong coupling nature of the two
businesses.
15. perspective The policy and prospects of China’s fixed broadband Market liberalization
• Smart home products / smart TV
manufacturers. The target market of
smart TV and smart home appliances
manufacturers is highly overlapping
with that of fixed broadband market.
Smart home appliances companies
can integrate the broadband business
with their core business and upgrade
the service experiences through
enhanced network service, hence
augment associated user values and
user stickiness.
• Mobile virtual network operators
(3C and home appliance retailers).
Similar to the MVNO qualification
issued by MIIT in 2013, this is another
opportune business for most Chinese
3C / electronic appliance retailers on
their ongoing strategic transforma-
tion. Fixed broadband service can
enhance the users’ relationship by
diversifying the service/product
portfolio. The physical stores of these
companies are, in fact, already critical
distribution channels for primary and
secondary broadband operators.
• Additionally, private network opera-
tors (such as financial service institu-
tions, and airline companies) and
network equipment provider (such
as Huawei and ZTE) may also extend
their service realm to commercial
broadband.
Given the initiation of this pilot and the
limited resources liberalized to civil
capital, apart from secondary broad-
band operators, real estate enterprises
and other enterprises with real property
resources would become the most
prioritized partners for the telecom
operators. These enterprises are also
presumably more capable of accumu-
lating large user base within the 3-year
timeframe of pilot period.
16. 16 – 17
Currently China’s fixed broadband pen-
etration rate is still at a comparatively low
level, with low broadband access speed
and hence large profitability opportunity
to be filled. The overall development of
Chinese high-speed broadband network
has been slow, consequent to the insuf-
ficient investment in infrastructures and
basic equipment. According to the ‘China
Broadband Strategic Plan’, the number
of fixed broadband users in China is
expected to reach 0.4bn in 2020, and
the growth of households of high-speed
broadband access must be supported by
large capital investment.
On the other hand, companies in the
capital-intensive industries, such as
energy & utility and telecommunications
industry, are gradually transforming from
the long-existing monopolistic / oligopo-
listic status to more mixed ownership with
capital injections from civil enterprises.
Further, despite large investment into
the backbone network by the telecom
operators, these enterprises suffer
limited business diversity and scalability,
especially when the market demand is in-
creasingly diverse. In sum, the MIIT policy
on the introduction of civil capital into
fixed broadband service market is highly
aligned with the overall Chinese macro-
and micro-economic scenario.
Value Partners
Perspectives
Although only the peripheral resources
related to FBB is open to civil capital at
the pilot stage, we expect MIIT to deepen
the market liberalization further in the
future. Considering the complexity in
construction and difficulty in operation
of the FBB service, MIIT would strictly
ensure the qualification of licensed enter-
prises and control the number of license
issued. Therefore, we highly recommend
enterprises with particular economic and
operational strength, such as internet
companies, media, and real estate com-
panies, to proactively obtain this valuable
license.
In the meantime, from the perspective
of market opportunity and basic tel-
ecom operators’ current obstacles, civil
enterprises applying for the license shall
be particularly focusing on integrating
residential or office buildings. We believe
sufficient acess to FTTX entrances would
be the key success factor for the license
applicants.
17. perspective The policy and prospects of China’s fixed broadband Market liberalization
Such policies are aligned with
the Central Government’s
essential statement on
liberalization to civil capitals
among nationally monopolistic
industries, and to optimize
the flexibility and innovative
advantages of civil enterprises.
18. 18 – 19
AUTHORS
JANE HOU
Principal, Beijing office
jane.hou@valuepartners.com
ADAM MENG
Associate, Beijing office
adam.meng@valuepartners.com
TAYlor Lam
Associate, Hong Kong office
taylor.lam@valuepartners.com
19. perspective The policy and prospects of China’s fixed broadband Market liberalization
Currently MIIT has only opened
the ‘last-mile network’ – FTTX –
resources for civil enterprises,
namely the construction and operation
of non-core / non-backbone broadband
infrustratures. After the pilot period,
MIIT may also liberalize the backbone
network to civil enterprises.