Bocconi251113

cittadini
lobby e
trasparenza
@guidoromeo
Wired - Diritto Di Sapere - Ahref
Università Bocconi - 25.11.2013
lunedì 25 novembre 13

opengovpartnership.org

The goal of the Open Government
Partnership is to get governments
to make (and carry out) concrete
commitments that promote
transparency, empower citizens,
fight corruption,
and harness new technologies
to strengthen governance
opengovpartnership.org

http://www.theguardian.com/media/media-blog/2013/oct/20/journalists-open-government-partnership

a cosa
serve?

www.martingrandjean.ch

opencorporates.com/

http://www.ipaidabribe.com/

http://video.seattletimes.com/1311237892001/

http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/news/nation/lead-poisoning

bello...
ma funziona?


http://www.webfoundation.org/2013/11/statement-of-concern-on-disproportionate-surveillance/?utm_source=hootsuite&utm_campaign=hootsuite

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uBBofPElJXk

e l’Italia
dov’è?

deﬁnizione accesso
deﬁnizione Foia


www.dirittodisapere.it

http://blogs.wsj.com/eurocrisis/2013/04/26/italians-knock-on-transparencys-door-but-get-few-answers/

primo monitoraggio dell’accesso in Italia
www.dirittodisapere.it

LO STATO NON RISPONDE


LE RISPOSTE NEL DETTAGLIO


COSA ABBIAMO CHIESTO


LE RICHIESTE PER AMMINISTRAZIONE


LE RISPOSTE PER AMMINISTRAZIONE


I TEMPI DI RISPOSTA


COME ABBIAMO CHIESTO


CASTA SENZA PRIVILEGI


CIVIL SOCIETY’S REPORT ON
FIRST ITALIAN OPEN GOVERNEMENT ACTION PLAN
IMPLEMENTATION

June 2013

www.opengovernmentforum.it

PROMOTERS


FOREWORD
• In 2011 the Italian governement joined the Open
Government Partnership (OGP), an international
initiative aimed at promoting transparency of
governements through the active participation of
stakeholders, from citizens to professional
associations and companies.
• In April 2012, Italy published an action plan followed
by a public consultation and presented it at the ﬁrst
OGP meeting in Brasilia on April 17 and 18.


FOREWORD
• This report summarizes the analysis conducted by an
independent group of experts and engaged some of
the most relevant civil society organizations active
in Italy on open gov areas.
• The working group deﬁned a common methodology
and framework and divided the Italian 2012 action
plan for the Open Government Partnership in
thematic areas. The group then assessed the plan’s
clarity and its level of implementation.


METHODOLOGY
The action plan’s evaluation
• To evaluate Italy’s OGP action plan - in line with what has been done by Global
Integrity - we adopted the S.M.A.R.T. model based on Specific, Measurable, Actionable,
Relevant and Time-bound indicators. We applied the five indicators to the action plan’s
individual points and checked them against the following questions:
– Specific: is the goal clearly described?
– Measurable: are the elements necessary for measuring implementation or
advancement of that action clearly identified?
– Attainable: are the means for attaining the goal clearly described?
– Relevant: is the goal relevant in the overall framework of the OGP policies
defined by the country?
– Time-bound: have deadlines or timeframes been defined for attaining the
identified goals?
• A YES/NO answer has been given to each element of the model.


THE GOALS’ S.M.A.R.T. ANALYTICS
18'
16'
14'
12'
10'
8'
6'
4'
2'
0'

Measurable'

A0ainable'

Relevant'

Time'Bound'

OK'

9'

8'

7'

12'

2'

KO'


Speciﬁc'
9'

10'

11'

6'

16'

IMPLEMENTATION OF GOALS

Implemented

Partially
implemented
Not implemented


Riepilogo(di(obie+vi(e(stato(di(a0uazione(
delle(a+vità(connesse(
Portale"della"trasparenza"
Approvazione"quadro"norma8vo"contro"la"corruzione"
Sistema"informa8vo"stato"avanzamento"programmazione"
Misurazione"e"riduzione"dei"cos8"a<raverso"Consultazioni"Pubbliche"
Come"fare"per…"
Impulso"all’a<uazione"del"150"
Facilitazione"alla"pubblicazione"e"riuso"dei"da8"pubblici"
Potenziamento"da8.gov.it"
Promozione"standard"nazionali"dei"da8"aper8"
Contest"nazionale"per"il"riuso"
Piano"nazionale"Smart"Communi8es"
Metodi"di"consultazione"con"i"ci<adini"
Raﬀorzamento"della"partecipazione"nei"territori"
Nuovi"ambi8"di"sviluppo"ed"erogazione"dei"servizi"pubblici"
Implementazione"del"CAD"
Diﬀusione"di"strumen8"per"l’eKGOV""verso"imprese"e"professionis8"
Infrastru<ure"
Cloud"Compu8ng"e"datacenter"per"la"PA"


Chiarezza(degli(obie+vi(dichiara9(

S"

M"

A"

R"

T"

Stato(di(
a0uazione(

http://www.opengovpartnership.org/independent-reporting-mechanism

Anticipazione
i problemi dell’action plan italiano
1. fatto senza consultazione pubblica
2. l'Italia non ha identificato un forum della società civile con cui avrebbe dovuto
fare consultazioni specifiche e regolari su action plan e implementazione.
3. mancanza di committment specifici. Solo dove c’erano già azioni fatte (es.io
OpenCoesione).
Di fatto emerge:

A. la mancanza di una vera e propria agenda sull'OpenGov in Italia
B. OpenGov è interpretato come una policy marginale degli open data
http://www.opengovpartnership.org/independent-reporting-mechanism

https://index.okfn.org/

http://theodi.github.io/open-data-barometer-viz/

laboratorio

Italia

http://www.cittadinireattivi.it/

www.openricostruzione.it

www.appelloperlaquila.org

http://www.transparency.it/

blog.wired.it/soldiaipartiti/infograﬁca

http://daily.wired.it/mappa_migliori_ospedali

http://app.wizehive.com/voting/view/dja2013/14511/1244526/0

http://vimeo.com/63394788

http://daily.wired.it/news/politica/2012/11/09/scuole-sicurezza-terremoto-143678.html

http://daily.wired.it/news/2013/07/02/italia-slot-machine.html

http://daily.wired.it/news/2013/07/02/inchiesta-wired-italia-slot-machine-56738.html
http://daily.wired.it/news/2013/07/02/italia-slot-machine.html

le tecnologie
opportunità e vincoli


https://votinginfoproject.org/projects

http://www.fixmystreet.com/

http://www.decorourbano.org/

http://www.epart.it/

http://www.theyworkforyou.com/

http://liquidfeedback.org/

http://www.airesis.it/

www.parlamento5stelle.com

http://www.twitantonio.it/

http://apps.spaghettiopendata.org/tweetyourmep/

http://www.riparteilfuturo.it/

http://parlamento17.openpolis.it/

http://www.openmunicipio.it/

http://criticalcity.org/home/landing

cosa manca
in Italia?

1. riconoscimento CSO
2. obbiettivi misurabili
3. cultura politica

Grazie
@guidoromeo


Bocconi251113

More Related Content

Similar to Bocconi251113

More from Guido Romeo

Bocconi251113