3. Introduction
Therapies for autoimmune disease can have
major side effects
Current therapies are not always effective
Biologic therapies have the potential to be
specific and not cause general
immunosuppression
5. IL-6 and disease
↑ IL-6 in synovial fluid of RA patients
↑ IL-6 in pleural effusion cells of TB patients
Produced by cells infiltrating islets of
Langerhans in type 1 diabetes
Produced by cells from patients with UC
Levels correlate with disease activity on
Crohn’s
6. Effects
Mice
IL-6 deficient mice resistant to EAE
Onset and severity of CIA delayed
Partially resistant to colitis
Anti-IL-6
Inhibits type 1 diabetes
Prevents colitis
Suppresses EAE
People
Used in sJIA – 30% improvement
RA-20% improvement in 50% patients
7. TNF-α
TNF-α
TNFR
•acute phase proteins
•mobilises neutrophils from BM
•induces fever
•activates endothelial cells
•migration of dendritic cells to
lymph nodes and their maturation
elevated
elevated
sTNFR
elevated!!
8.
9.
10. IL-15
T cell memory
maintenance
T cell
recruitment and
activation
Neutrophil
activation
Delays
apoptosis in
endothelial
cells and
synoviocytes
TNF-α and
IL-1β
production
13. Effects
Inhibition of collagen synthesis
Stimulating the release of prostaglandin E2 and NO
Inducing fever
Activation of T and B cells
Resorption of bone
Release of enzymes and chemotactic factors from
macrophages
14. IL-1 and RA
Elevated levels found in patients with RA
Correlates with disease activity
IL-1b injected into joints→arthritis
IL-1ra deficient →autoimmune disease
Human trials
Rapid reduction of disease progression
BUT short ½life – daily injections
Combined with anti-TNF-α→serious infection
17. How?
Improves BBB function
Inhibits transmigration of leucocytes
Inhibits the action of H2O2 and TNF-α to alter the tight
junction molecules between endothelial cells
Reduces the ability of inflammatory cells to enter the
CNS.
18. Peptide therapy
Promising results in animals
Altered peptide ligand – T cell antagonist
Protected mice from EAE
No clinical effects in humans
Th2 → hypersensitivity?
19. Mice
(Ac1-9), MBP 68-86 + 87-99 protected against
EAE
Synergistic effects of MBP 68-86 + 87-99
B chain of insulin protected against type 1
diabetes
Humans
Hsp60 maintained islet cell function
dnaJ reduced TNFα and IFNγ in RA
20. How?
Oral tolerance
Stimulation of regulatory
T cells
Active suppression
Mucosal tolerance
Regulatory T cells
Bystander suppression
Immune deviation
22. Therapies to come
IL-23
IL-23 deficient mice resistant to EAE, CIA, IBD
Blockade prevents EAE
Does not affect ongoing EAE
Efalizumab
Blocks LFA-1 + ICAM-1 interaction
Reduced T cell activation + recruitment
LymphoStat-B
Blocks BlyS
Increased expression associated with autoantibodies
Required for B cell maturation
23. Conclusion
Only a small sample of current/possible
biologic therapy
Potential for specific modulation of immune
system
Potential for serious adverse effects
Editor's Notes
IL-6 - produced by macrophages, T cells, endothelial cells
Causes
Causes acute phase protein production e.g. CRP
Causes fever
T & B cell growth + differentiation
Haematopoietic stem cells
RA
Activates osteoclasts – bone resorption
Causes endothelial cells to upregulate adhesive molecules – increased inflammatory infiltration
Activates synoviocytes – thickened synovium in RA
Signalling
STAT3 mediated
SHP-2 mediated
Is IL-6 present in disease?
Increased in synovial fluid of RA
Increased in pleural effusion of pulmonary TB
These patients often have wide range of autoantibodies
Increased in SLE serum
Produced by infiltrating cells in IDDM
Produced by lamina propria mononuclear cells in UC (also TNF & IL-1)
Levels correlate with disease activity in Crohn’s
What happens if its not there?
Deficient mice resistent to EAE (model for MS)
Fewer ICAM-1 and VCAM-1 expressed
No infiltration of inflammatory cells in CNS
Delays CIA and reduces severity
Partially resistant to colitis
Anti-IL-6 in mice
Inhibits IDDM in NOD mice
Reduced severity of CIA
Prevents colitis
NB all these prevented disease form occurring; not acting on current disease
Suppressed EAE
? Due to actual blocking effect or secondary effect of increasing IL-6 production (as increased IL-6 in CNS & blood)
Anti-IL-6 in people
Systematic juvenile idiopathic arthritis
Single dose
Rapid response-48hrs
30% improvement in 11/18
Duration - 4-8 weeks
Initial increase in IL-6 seen then decrease
RA
Single dose
50% had 20% improvement
Duration- - 8 weeks
IL-6 also plays role in anaemia of RA – resolution seen with anti-IL-6 treatment
TNF can be bound by TNFR on cell surface or soluble TNFR
Wide range of actions including
Acute phase proteins
Mobilises neutrophils
Induces fever
Activates endothelial cells
Migration and maturation of dendritic cells
TNF elevated in RA
TNFR elevated in RA
sTNFR elevated
Surprising as increased sTNFR should mop up excess TNF seen
Levels seem to correlate with disease activity
Exclude possibility that pathogenesis of RA is failure to produce inhibitory factors
Cytokine cascade
First suggested by Marc Feldmann in 1996
Shows that both pro-inflammatory and anti-inflammatory factors are regulated by TNF (+IL-1) in RA
Three main types – chimeric (infliximab), human (adaluminab), human fusion protein (etanercept)
Infliximab
Antigen binding site is murine
Rest is human
Clinical and radiological improvement
Synergistic with methotrexate
Etanercept
TNFR + Fc
Radiological and clinical improvement
Effective in early aggressive RA
Adaluminab
Fully human
Fewer side-effects as less antibodies
Efficacy in those with anti-TNf Ab
Maintenance of T cell memory
Interesting as suggests could disrupt maintenance of autoreactive T cells
“Reset” immune system?
Recruitment and activation of T cells
Activation of neutrophils
Delay apoptosis of fibroblast-like synoviocytes and endothelial cells
TNF and IL-1 production
Il-15 and IL-2 (receptors v. similar) appear to have opposite effects
IL-15 maintains CD8+ T cells, IL-2 inhibits
IL-2 is involved in activation-induced cell death, IL-15 inhibits it
Increased expression of IL-15 in
RA
MS
UC
Coeliac
Psoriasis
Allograft rejection
Anti-IL-15
Prevented development of CIA + reduced inflammation & destruction
Resolution of psoriasis in mouse model
Allowed engraftment of minor histocompatibility mismatched grafts + prolonged survival of MHc mismatched
Response rates similar to that of TNf in RA
Cytokine cascade
Suggested that IL-15 precedes TNF
Ability to induce TNF and IL-1
Abnormalities of IL-15 seen in RA
IL-1 has an interesting family tree
Two forms of receptor – IL-1R I + IL-1R II
Two forms of cytokines – IL-1a + IL-1b
Natural receptor antagonist – IL-1Ra
IL-1R II
Short cytoplasmic tail
Non-functional
Competes with IL-1R I
Lower binding affinity for IL-1a
IL-1R I
Stimulated by Il-1a + Il-1b
Inhibited by Il-1Ra
Affects transcription by P50/65
Soluble receptors
Mainly produced by activated macrophages
Inhibition of collagen synthesis
Stimulating the release of prostaglandin E2 and NO
Fever
Activation of T and B cells
Osteoclast activation - resorption of bone
Release of matrix metalloproteinases (destroy cartilege) and chemotactic factors from macrophages
Elevated levels in serum and synovial fluid of RA
Disease activity correlates with synovial and serum levels of IL-1
Injecting Il-1b into joints caused arthritis + bone and cartilege resorption
IL-1ra deficient mice have spontaneous autoimmune disease
Human
Anakinra (huIL-1ra)
Reduced inflammation and destruction in CIA
Rapid effect in humans
Half life of 6 hrs means daily injections
Not as effective as anti-TNF
? Increased serious infection
Combination
Animal models showed potent effect of IL-1ra + anti-TNF combination
Human trial halted due to high incidence of serious infection
Physioloigcal actions
Increases cell resistance to viral replication
Activates NK cells
Increased MHC class I presentation
Increased antigen presentation
STAT mediated gene transcription
MS
MS lymphocytes produce less IFN
?virus persistance – trigger
Lymphocyte hyporeactivity associated with HLA-DR2 ( as is MS)
Treatment reduces new lesions seen on MRI
Reduces relapse number and severity
Delays conversion to CDMS
Early Ms may be more susceptible
Dose effect seen
IFN improves BBB function
Inhibits transendothelial migration of leukocytes
H2O2 and TNF affect tight junction molecules and make them leaky
IFN stops this
Reduces ability of inflammatory cells to enter CNS
Altered peptide ligand acts as a T cell antagonist
APL derived from MBP protected from and reversed EAE
No clinical response in human trial
Th2 cytokines seen
Systemic hypersensitivity seen in 13 of 142 patients led to halting of trial
Due to Th2 response?
Mice
Various parts of MBP administered nasally or subcutaneously protected from MBP
Parts chosen as antigens most commonly seen for autoreactive T cells in EAE
MBP 68-86 and MBP 87-99 could not protect completely alone, but had synergistic effect together
Suggests both present as antigens in EAE
B(9-23) – part of the B chain of insulin protected NOD mice from IDDM
Another antigen found on A chain but minority in proportion both in individual and population
Humans
dnaJ reduced TNF and IFN in RA
Safety trial
Clinical efficacy not evaluated
Hsp60 maintained islet cell function in newly diagnosed type 1 diabetics
Cytokines showed Th2 type response
Different methods depending on route of adminstration
Oral tolerance
Stimulates regulatory T cells
Active suppression
Clonal deletion + anergy
Mucosal tolerance
Regulatory t cells
Bystander suppression
Il-10 mediated
Non-sepcific
Immune deviation
To anti-inflammatory type
Increased expression of FoxP3 (regulatory T cell marker)
Deletion/anergy not seen
But controversial
Infection
URTI + TB with anti-TNF
Opportunistic infections (Pneumocystis and histoplasmosis) with infliximab
Malignancy
Anti-TNF = increased risk of lymphoma
But RA = increased risk of lymphoma
Autoantibodies
Anti-TNF
More likely in patients with side effects
Occasionally lupus-like sydrome seen
Treatment antibodies
Anti-TNF
Generally less improvement
But not huge difference if responder
Demyelinating disease
Optic neuritis, Guillain-Barré syndrome and chronic inflammtory demyelinating polyradiculoneuropathy
The unexpected
Nataluzimab and progressive multifocal leukoencephalopathy
CD28 and cytokine storm