SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
Author: Martin Milkov Malakov
/Date of Birth: 11.10.1992/
PBA of International Sales and Marketing Management
Tutor: Torben Ibsen Uldall Sorensen
Final Bachelor’s Project
PBA of International Sales and Marketing Management
Business Academy Aarhus
2nd of January 2017
Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
Number of characters: 96490
Sales Strategy for the Bulgarian Market
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
Contents
List of Appendences ......................................................................................................................-1
Executive Summary.........................................................................................................................0
1. Introduction ................................................................................................................................1
1.1. Problem Formulation.......................................................................................................1
1.2. Report Structure...............................................................................................................1
2. Methodology ........................................................................................................................1
2.1. Research Objectives.........................................................................................................2
2.2. Research Paradigm ..........................................................................................................2
2.3. Approach ..........................................................................................................................2
2.4. Method..............................................................................................................................2
2.5. Strategy.............................................................................................................................2
2.6. Time horizon....................................................................................................................2
2.7. Theory and models..........................................................................................................2
2.8. Sources .............................................................................................................................3
2.9. Quality assessment..........................................................................................................4
3. Literature Review .................................................................................................................5
3.1. Market Definition .............................................................................................................5
3.2. Growth Matrix – H. Igor Ansoff.......................................................................................5
3.3. International Growth – why do businesses choose to pursue it?.................................6
3.4. Entry Strategies – how do businesses expand internationally?....................................6
3.5. Export – Direct and Indirect ............................................................................................7
3.6. Distribution Channels......................................................................................................7
3.7. Developing a sales strategy ............................................................................................8
3.8. Cultural Dimensions, affects and considerations .......................................................13
4. Innovation Living’s Business Model .................................................................................16
4.1. Customer Segments ......................................................................................................17
4.2. Value Proposition...........................................................................................................17
4.3. Channels.........................................................................................................................18
4.3.1. Distribution Channels............................................................................................18
4.4. Customer relationships .................................................................................................18
4.5. Revenue Streams............................................................................................................18
4.6. Key Resources ................................................................................................................19
4.6.1. Human resources ...................................................................................................19
4.6.2. Intellectual resources.............................................................................................19
4.6.3. Physical resources..................................................................................................19
4.6.4. Financial resources ................................................................................................19
4.7. Key Activities..................................................................................................................19
4.8. Key Partnerships ............................................................................................................19
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
4.9. Cost Structure ................................................................................................................20
5. External Analysis ...............................................................................................................20
5.1. PESTLE.............................................................................................................................20
5.1.1 Economic factors..............................................................................................................20
5.1.2 Social factors: ..................................................................................................................22
5.1.3 Legal factors: ...................................................................................................................22
5.2. Porter's Five Forces........................................................................................................23
5.2.1. Supplier Bargaining Power - Moderate 5/10 ........................................................23
5.2.2. Buyer Bargaining Power - High 8/10 ....................................................................24
5.2.3. Threat of Substitution 1/10 ..................................................................................24
5.2.4. Threat of New Entry 8/10......................................................................................24
5.2.5. Competitive Rivalry - High 9/10............................................................................25
5.2.6. Attractiveness of the furniture Industry 4/10......................................................25
5.3. ADL Matrix......................................................................................................................26
5.4. Analysis of the Competitors in Bulgaria.......................................................................26
5.4.1 Local Competition ........................................................................................................27
5.4.2 Foreign competition on the Bulgarian furniture market ...........................................27
5.5. Organizational Customer’s Analysis ............................................................................29
5.6 Market Trends and Demand for Design Danish Furniture in Bulgaria............................30
5.7. Bulgarian Culture according to Hofstede’s Six Cultural Dimensions ............................30
6. Insights Based on the Conducted Semi-structured Interviews.......................................32
7. SWOT – is market penetration the way to go?.................................................................33
8. Segmentation, Targeting and Positioning ..............................................................................33
8.1 Segmentation ......................................................................................................................33
8.2 Targeting .............................................................................................................................34
8.3 Positioning...........................................................................................................................35
9. Market Penetration Strategy for the Bulgarian Market - Balanced Scorecard.......................36
9.1 Learning and Growth Perspective ......................................................................................37
9.1.1 Hire a Sales Representative .........................................................................................37
9.1.2 Training Skills and Development ................................................................................38
9.2 Internal Perspective.............................................................................................................38
9.2.1 Develop a sales strategy..............................................................................................38
9.2.2 Improve work efficiency...............................................................................................39
9.3 Customer perspective.........................................................................................................39
9.3.1 Acquire new retailers to act as authorized dealers in Bulgaria; ...............................39
9.3.2 Build long-term relationships......................................................................................39
9.4 Financial perspective ..........................................................................................................39
10. Conclusion ..............................................................................................................................40
Bibliography.....................................................................................................................................1
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
List of Appendences
Appendix 1 – Project Description;
Appendix 2 – Questions for Semi-Structured Interviews;
Appendix 3 – Essence of the Held Interviews Relevant to the Assignment;
Appendix 4 – Contact Details of the Interviewees;
Appendix 5 – Sales Figures Table from Innovation Living;
Appendix 6 – Innovation Living’ Sales Prices for Retailers;
Appendix 7 – Strategy Map & Balanced Score Card;
*Appendences are uploaded as separate documents and are not included in this document.
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
Executive Summary
Innovation Living is a Danish Design Furniture Manufacturer since 1972. Innovation
specializes in producing compact, functional and comfortable sofa/beds for small living
spaces. It has production facilities in Denmark and China and sells its products globally.
However, most of the revenue in Europe comes from Western Europe. Even Though
Innovation operates in some parts of Eastern Europe, the markets there are considered new
and are yet to be developed and the full potential of them to be reached. This report will
combine market research with the best sales theories from modern academic literature and
will suggest how to increase the sales in the Bulgarian market in the future.
The report first presents a Literature review. In the literature review there are different
relevant for the research definitions included. Moreover, concepts and models supporting
the later on given recommendations are described, so that the researcher’s knowledge base
is supported.
Further, an internal analysis of Innovation Living is made through the business model canvas
in order to receive a better understanding of the company’s structure and current situation.
The business model shows that the company is financially healthy and that it has the
necessary structure, experience and current activities that will support a penetration of the
Bulgarian market.
The external analysis made examines the country profile of Bulgaria, the competitive
landscape and consumer behaviour. It also looks at the cultural considerations. Even though
the social and economic situation in Bulgaria is not that “pink” at the moment, the outlooks
for the near future are positive and also there are other pluses like low taxes and cheap
labour that makes the market attractive. The poverty in Bulgaria might be high, but as
Innovation Living is targeting a niche of people with higher income, it is not a factor that
matters, as there are still many affluent people in the Bulgarian society. In terms of
competition, it is highly saturated market in general, but there are still not that many
resembling offerings and room to grow.
The field research indicated that retailers have interest to and do work with foreign
importers, but that they would prefer to communicate with a native representative.
Overall the analysis point out that there is market for Innovation Living, but the company
will have to do more aggressive sales. The cultural differences between Bulgaria and
Denmark are quite big that is why it is proposed for the company to enter the market
directly with its own sales force. Innovation Living will have to search for and hire a
Bulgarian sales rep that will be responsible for the company activities in Bulgaria. The
company has this practice for its UK and Benelux markets. It will also take advantage of its
newly built production facilities in Ukraine.
In the long-term the experience in the Bulgarian market can be further used to enter or
enhance current activities in other similar Eastern European markets.
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
1
1. Introduction
Innovation Living is a Danish Design Furniture Manufacturer since 1972. Innovation
specializes in producing compact, functional and comfortable sofa/beds for small living
spaces. It has production facilities in Denmark and China and sells its products globally.
However, most of the revenue in Europe comes from Western Europe. Even Though
Innovation operates in some parts of Eastern Europe, the markets there are considered new
and are yet to be developed and the full potential of them to be reached. This report will
combine market research with the best sales theories from modern academic literature and
will suggest how to increase the sales in the Bulgarian market.
1.1. Problem Formulation
 How can Innovation A/S improve its sales in Bulgaria?
1.2. Report Structure
The report will be following the structure below: (See figure 1.1);
Figure 1.1: Structure of the report
Source: Own Production;
2. Methodology
This chapter follows Richard Brook’s eleven step model of research design to plan and
present the methodological background of the research. (Brooks, 2013); (See figure 2.1);
Figure 2.1: The eleven step model of research;
Source: Brooks;
Methodology
Literature
Review
Situation
Analysis
Strategy Conclusion
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
2
2.1. Research Objectives
 What is the current situation of Innovation Living both from internal perspective in
the organisation, and from external perspective assessing the furniture industry and
the Bulgarian furniture market?
 How Innovation Living can improve its overall competitiveness in Bulgaria?
 Who are the most attractive potential customers of Innovation Living in the Bulgarian
market?
 How the distanced Bulgarian market could be managed most effectively and by
whom?
 What strategic objectives Innovation Living could implement in order to improve its
market position in Bulgaria?
 How Innovation Living can measure the performance on the Bulgarian market?
2.2. Research Paradigm
The report will follow a critical realism paradigm. It is about observing the cause and effect.
The sales at EEU are low, what would happen if a new sales strategy is implemented? This
question is followed from the paradigm and related to the case of this report. How can the
ongoing business process to be improved? The Critical Realism paradigm will help to get
better insight of what has to be improved.
2.3. Approach
The approach that the research follows is a deductive approach. (Brooks, 2013) A set of
assumptions are made based on the researcher’s inside information from Innovation Living
and the company experience with the Bulgarian market and other markets the company is
operating in. They will be proven throughout the report, either right or wrong, and will be
considered when recommendations are given.
A1: Having direct presence in the market will increase the company’s success in the market
in terms of attracting more partners
A2: Expanding the number of distribution channels in the market will result in bigger reach,
thus attracting new customers and overall increase in sales.
A3: Having a native sales representative will help the company to overcome the culture
barriers and will also contribute with inside knowledge of the market and consumers.
2.4. Method
The choice of data method gathering is through a multimethod qualitative study, as semi-
structured interviews will be conducted both in person and phone.
2.5. Strategy
The strategy of the research is chosen to be a case study as the goal is to receive a rich
understanding of the research topic. (Brooks, 2013);
2.6. Time horizon
The time horizon of the research is a cross-sectional as it was conducted in the range of few
consecutive months – three months in Denmark.
2.7.Theory and models
An internal analysis of the company and its operations will be made using the canvas
business model. The strategy will be analysed based using Porter’s Genic Strategy Matrix,
The Anssoff Grow strategy matrix, the Value Strategy, Degree of Internationalization
For conducting a meaningful external analysis a PESTLE will analyse the market environment
in Bulgaria. Implementation of the Porter's Five Forces Industry analysis will be define the
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
3
attractiveness of the industry and be a solid base to assess the level of competition within
the furniture industry. Gather relevant data through desk research to collect valuable
insights of the Bulgarian furniture market such as market indicators, trends, consumers.
Competitor Analysis will be made to find out the direct competitors, benchmark Innovation
Livings competences and product features with firms from the competition. Evaluate the
competitive advantages of the domestic competitors and the international firms penetrating
the market. Focus on delivering more customer satisfaction than the competitors and gain
market share.
ADL Matrix is applied to determine the current place of Innovation Living in its relatively new
Bulgarian market.
The Hofstede 6 Cultural dimensions analysis is used to evaluate the both the Danish and
Bulgarian culture and to compare them, pointing the essential cultural differences that have
to be considered when doing business;
B2B Customer Analysis is critical for Innovation Living success on the market. Identifying
well established retailers with reputation and strong position on the market, also
understand their buying behaviour, the buying process and also the preferences when
relating to a new supplier.
Essential part of the report is devoted to sales. Theory and models related to sales
techniques, sales planning, and consultative sellers vs transactional sellers. The Spin Model
is also included. The process of salesmen recruitment is explained. A competence profile of
a sale agent, aligned to fulfil a demanding role at Innovation Living as a foreign sales agent.
The strategy map framework is used to create a workable market penetration strategy of
Innovation Living for penetrating the Bulgarian market. All the four perspectives are of a the
strategy are developed and aligned to the specifics of the market and the company
operations in order Innovation Living to reach its potential in Bulgaria.
The Balanced Score Card is used for measuring the performance of the company while
implementing the new strategy. In order the strategy to deliver the desired outcome, the
targets specified in the balance score card has to be fulfilled.
2.8.Sources
The sources used in this research are both primary and secondary sources. The secondary
sources consist of academic journal articles, international publications and academic books.
The primary sources used are the public company information, the information acquired
during the 3 month internship within the sales department. Field research in Bulgaria was
executed, during which a sufficient amount of data was collected. Activities undertaken
during the field research are company and showrooms visits, observing both the businesses
and consumers shaping the industry and the supply of furniture, more precisely sofa/beds.
Taking into account the price/quality, customization and functionality;
Five semi-structured interviews with individuals involved in companies operating as resellers
in Bulgaria were performed. The goal was to get valuable information from companies which
are potential customers of Innovation Living In Bulgaria and are part of its target group. (See
Appendices 2,3,4);
The research could have been more extensive by conducting more interviews, but due to the
time frame and the nature of the contacts, it was not possible to gather more.
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
4
2.9. Quality assessment
The reliability and validity of the research is assured by using mainly five star academic
journal articles, reliable online sources and research conducted by verified institutions. The
primary data gathered also adds up to the reliability of the outcome of the research.
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
5
3. Literature Review
Validating the potential of a specific foreign market is one of the elements when expanding
to foreign markets. Introducing a product to a new market also comes with the need of
taking difficult decision - how should the company market their product. (Erin Anderson).
First to start more broadly by defining the word “market” will be given.
3.1. Market Definition
Market: “Markets include mechanisms or means for (1) determining price of the traded item,
(2) communicating the price information, (3) facilitating deals and transactions, and (4)
effecting distribution. The market for a particular item is made up of existing and potential
customers who need it and have the ability and willingness to pay for it.” (Business
Dictionary, 2013);
The four points that are outlined in the above definition of market should be taken into
account in the forming of a strategy not only when a new business is developed, but also
when a company wants to enter a new market or penetrate the one that is already operating
in.
To make it more specific a definition of a business market will be given:
Business markets: “Markets for products and services, local to international, bought by
businesses, government bodies, and institutions for incorporation, for use or for resale. The
main differences between business marketing and consumer marketing are the nature of the
customers and how they use the product. “(Hutt Speh, 2014)
Having defined what markets and business markets are it is relevant to take a look how an
already operating company within a B2B market can grow.
3.2. Growth Matrix – H. Igor Ansoff
According to the Ansoff Matrix developed by H. Igor Ansoff, found in the article “Strategies
for Diversification”, there are four strategies that companies can use to grow and each on
carries a higher risk.(See figure 3.1);
Figure 3.1: Ansoff Growth Matrix;
Source: Mind Tools, 2016;
Market penetration carries the lowest risk, making it the safes of all the options. The growth
here consists of expansion of the sales in a market that the company already operates in.
Product development is a bit more risky as it involves the introduction of a new product in
an already penetrated market.
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
6
Market development consists of introducing an existing product to a new market, which
increases the risk.
Last but not least, Diversification is the riskiest one as it consists of introducing a untested
product to a completely new market the knowledge for which is not sufficient.
It will depend on the company goals and current capabilities to choose the best fitting
growth strategy. As many of the barriers in the last 20th
century related to international trade
fell, many business began to pursue global strategies in order to gain competitive
advantage. Magdalea Kakol);
3.3. International Growth – why do businesses choose to pursue it?
The most common reasons for companies going international are growth or expansion.
International strategies may benefit the business by helping to diversify it and expand it.
(Katarzyna Twarowska). Going global also reduces the uncertainty of the local and national
markets (demand upturns and downturns for example.) Hence, the company does not need
to rely only on the current market that it is in. (Elmuti D., Kathawala Y.2001);
There are two main approaches to going international – through an international strategy or
a global strategy. (Yip G. 2002);
International strategy is basically working through international subsidiaries that act as they
were local companies and have minimum coordination from the parent company. Global
strategy on the other hand, consists of a wide variety of business strategies that have a high
level of adaptation to local business environment,(Ktarzyna Twarowska) It is basically a
general strategy that can be easily manipulated to fit different local environments when
necessary.
3.4. Entry Strategies – how do businesses expand internationally?
To go back to the beginning of the literature review, when expanding a business to a
foreign market, one of the biggest challenges and decisions to be taken is how to enter the
market. There are several types of entry strategies that are summarized under two major
types and differ by the level of risk involved: (Terpstra V., Sarathy R. 2001);
1) Non-equity mode – includes export and contractual agreements;
2) Equity mode – includes joint venture and wholly owned subsidiaries
(Terpstra V., Sarathy R. 2001);
Figure 3.2: Entry Strategies
Source: Hutt Speh, 2014;
The entry technique that is the least risky and has the least market control is Import and
Export. (See figure 3.2) On the other side of the spectrum are the Direct Investments that
usually constitute of acquisitions (also referred as Brownfield) or to build its own facilities
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
7
(known as Greenfield investment). Direct investments carry the highest risk, but also the
highest market control and expected ROI (return on investment) (Terpstra V., Sarathy R.
2001);
There are six types of entry strategies on the spectrum that all differ in risk, market
involvement, resources required, legal complications, competitive aspect, access to market
knowledge and potential ROI. The entry strategies are as follows: (Terpstra V., Sarathy R.
2001).
 Exporting and importing
 Licensing
 Franchising
 Joint Ventures
 Strategic alliances
 Direct Investments
For the purpose of the report and to stay relevant, only the Exporting entry strategy will be
further discussed.
3.5. Export – Direct and Indirect
As clarified earlier, this strategy is the least risky and the most commonly used one. It is the
process of selling goods or services produced in one market to other markets. ,(Ktarzyna
Twarowska,2013). Two types of exporting exist – direct and indirect.
Indirect export involves other agents to market the products to the foreign market, while in
direct export the company becomes directly involved in marketing its products to the
foreign market. (Hutt Speh, 2014);
Exporting is a good strategy when a company doesn’t have sufficient amount of resources
to make a significant commitment to the market, wants to minimize the risks related to
politics and economy and also is not that familiar with the requirements of the market and
the culture. (Hutt Speh, 2014);
The question that a company can ask at this point is, should the product be distributed
through a company-owned distribution channel or it would be more efficient to outsource
distribution to an independent organization?
3.6. Distribution Channels
Channel of distribution, also referred to as a marketing channel, is:
“A group of individuals and organizations that direct the flow of products from
producers to customers.” (Hutt Speh, 2014);
Most of these marketing channels have the so called marketing intermediaries (or middle
man) that are divided into two types – agents and brokers. (Hutt Speh, 2014)
In the case of this report, the company already collaborates with middleman to sell its
products.(Innovation Living, 2016) Therefore the report will not focus on discussing this
aspect of the distribution channels, but it will look further how the company can more
adequately approach and attract more middleman to collaborate with.
Back to the question – owned salesforce or independent organization?
The former option, an integrated channel, gives the business more control than the latter,
the independent organization. Having an ownership over the salesforce provides the entrant
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
8
with full control, but it also brings responsibility, commitment and attendant risks. (Ahmed
1977).
There are several factors that would influence the choice, as each one of them depending on
the situation would weigh the scale to one side or the other: (Erin Anderson, Anne T.
Coughlan, 1987);
 Service requirements
 Government pressure – using local agents when available
 Product category age
 Task-specialized knowledge and relationships
 Transactional Costs
 Market knowledge
 Strength of patents
 Competitive behaviour
 The country in question
It is more likely a business to choose an integration of the distribution when:
- There is a greater level of transaction-specific assets in the sales force
- The less mature the product category
- The higher the service level associated with the product
- The less prevalent legal restrictions
- When there is an integrated distribution channel already in place
- The importance of the product is high – is it the core one for the business?
- The more important the trade secrets
- The more competitors have integrated distribution channels in the foreign market
- The more similar the culture of the home market is to the culture of country being
entered. (Erin Anderson, Anne T. Coughlan, 1987)
When the company decides to operate through an integrated salesforce, even if that involves
hiring a local sales representative, it will need to create a sales strategy that will be in line
with its marketing plan, will be complied with the business plan and will support the overall
strategic plan of the company. (JWPM Consulting, 2013)
3.7. Developing a sales strategy
A sales strategy has to be very detailed and specific otherwise it is simply a marketing plan.
It has to be clear who is doing what, when and where and most importantly, it must have
targets. A sales plan is:
“An operational plan that identifies how the annual sales revenue budget will be achieved by
aggregating sales budgets by customer, territory, and sales representative and listing the
week to week activity required to achieve the sales budgets.”
The sales plan is organized around a list of revenues sources and the customers should be
grouped the following way: (See Table 3.3);
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
9
Table 3.3: Customer Grouping;
Existing customers The 80/20 rule usually applies that is
80% of revenue is derived from 20% of
customers. The sales representative
should be able to make a judgement
about how much each customer is
expected to buy in over a year.
Identified new customers Create a list of the sales target for a year
from which 25% might become customers.
As yet not identified new customers Allocate an allowance in for growth as yet
not identified future customers
Major projects Depending on the type of company, make
an allowance for major project revenue.
Source: Own Production;
Setting up a sales plan serves as a great management tool to help forecast the annual sales
revenue, to achieve face-to-face visits, to identify how many sales reps are needed and what
the purpose of each sales visit would be. (JWPM Consulting, 2013);
The content of good sales plan content should contain the following aspects:
- Sales strategy
The company needs to create a general statement for the sales strategy that will reflect the
strategic direction of the organisation.
- Sales Model
There are many ways to structure the sales departments. One of the most common models
used is “every man for himself”. On the selling spectrum there are two types of sales
approaches - transactional or collaborative (William Walker, 2016) Depending on the type of
business, customers and goals, the sales model can be transactional oriented or relationship
oriented (collaborative) which will influence the level of sophistication, the number of
employees involved and the amount of time in the sales process.
Transactional selling approach
Simply put, a transactional sale is a short-term sale in which the buyer knows already exactly
what he needs. (John Tabita, 2012)The main decision criteria are price, features and
availability and the significance of the sales person very often diminishes. The person selling
will know the product and its price, but it won’t be required to convince the purchaser.
(William Walker, 2016);
Consultative selling approach
Consultative selling approach is also referred to as strategic, solution, complex, relationship
and even enterprise selling. (Ed Warner, 2009) It is long-term oriented, usually more than
one decision maker is involved and the focus is put on the value. The questions is not what
the customer is buying, but why. Not like in transactional selling, here the salesperson will
need to be very well educated about the product or service in question. Moreover, to know
more about the customer, what are the goals of the customer’s business and the results that
need to be achieved. When the customer is not very certain about exactly what he/she
needs, the salesperson becomes a coach that helps the customer to establish goals and
objectives and create an action plan that will deliver results. (William Walker, 2016);
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
10
The table below presents an overview of the differences between transactional selling and
consultative selling: (See table 3.4);
Table 3.4: Transactional vs. Consultative Selling;
Source: John Tabita, 2012
As consultative selling requires higher level of knowledge about the customer and what
he/she are aiming for, there are models that can be used to enhance the sales person’s
techniques.
The SPIN selling model was developed by Neil Rackham in 1998, after conducting a vast
research for 12 years about how large sales were made. One of the biggest findings is that
in sales calls it is the buyer who does most of the talking, which on its hand happens by
asking the buyer questions. But it is not about asking any kind of questions, the sales
person should ask certain type of questions and follow a certain flow. (See Figure 3.5);
Figure 3.5: SPIN Selling Model
Source: Strategic Learning, 2013;
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
11
SPIN stands for:
-Situation (questions) - to find out facts about the existing situation of the customer.
-Problem (questions) – to find about what problem the buyer is experiencing in this
current situation.
-Implication (questions) – to make the customer think about the consequences and
effects of the current problems.
-Need-payoff (questions) – to make the buyer focus on the solutions and the value of
the proposed solution.
What the creator of the SPIN selling model himself recommends is that a sales person
should always stay flexible and adapt the speech and the questions according to the specific
situation. It is not always necessary to follow the order of the SPIN questions in a strict
order. (Hutt Speh, 2014);
Another article introduces a concept that serves as an enhancement to the SPIN selling
model, called Social Style model. The model enhances SPIN in three main ways – the sales
person applying a certain style to the selling situation, recognizing and managing the
buyer’s style behaviours and practicing versatility.
Practicing style awareness improves sales people abilities to ask the right questions thus
achieve better success rate and versatility supports all aspects of client management and
selling situations. (Hutt Speh, 2014);
- Territory plan
It is important to segment the sales territory so that the resources and time are allocated
effectively to maximise the sales outcome. The sales territories can be segmented by
geography, industry, customer type, product type and customer size. The choice made can
have a huge impact over sales outcomes.
Figure 3.6: Sales Opportunities Grid
Source: LaForge and Carvens, 1982
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
12
Figure 3.7: 7 step process
- Significant sales opportunities
Each sales plan for the year should have identified and contain the so called “largest”
opportunities for the business and a more detailed plan should be prepared to capture
them. The matrix on the previous page gives an overview on how to allocate the sales
resource depending on the PCU opportunity. (See figure 3.6);
- Sales Budget
The sales budget should contain considerations for at least 12 months and sales targets for
sources of sales growth.
- Sales Activity Plan
A plan for the activity of each sales rep should be prepared that will match the goal of
achieving the targets in the Sales Budget.
- Sales Tactics
Sales tactics may include different considerations such as new initiatives designed to
increase the effectiveness of the sales activity. As well, cultural considerations, which are
very important when conducting sales in foreign markets?
- Resource plan
This plan provides a detailed month over month budget of the sales department expenses:
number of sales reps needed, support staff, equipment purchases, etc. Under this section an
outline of the recruitment plan can also be included, if new sales reps need to be employed.
The recruitment process consists of 7 Steps: (See Figure 3.7);
Determine the number of
sales employees needed
Identify the unique skills,
knowledge and personality
required for the job
Attract a sufficient number
of candidates
Produce one interview
process that accurately
reveals qualifications
Provide employment for
one or more candidates
Introduction of new
employee for the job
Follow-up on performance
in the job
What should be taken into consideration for sales force composition and number?
What preparations should the company make?
How does a company get sufficiently applications?
What sources are there for a company to make use of in order to find possible
candidates?
What tools can a company use?
Considerations about the interview process
How can interview process look like?
What the company must take into consideration when a candidate is offered a job?
What the company must take into consideration when a new employee to be
introduced in the job?
What needs to be followed up? Source: Own Production
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
13
- Sales incentives
Create a scheme of incentives for the sales representatives and the costs should be
considered in the resource plan.
Incentives can take different forms. Apart from the fixed salary and pension, the company
can also offer a variable salary such as: provision, bonuses, paid company car, EBIDA or
stock options.
There can also be other benefits like free phone, health insurance, massage/fitness or it can
be reverences related to the work like parental leave or care taking days. (Jobber &
Lancaster) Also career development aspects such as company paid courses, coaching,
teambuilding and etc.
Related to the compensation, for the sales reps it is very common practice to receive a form
of a variable salary next to the fixed one. It is also referred to as performance based
remuneration. When developing a plan about performance based remuneration, it has to be
decided upon the period, goals, measurements, information access, the size of the bonus,
when it is paid and termination details. The periods can be monthly, quarterly, yearly or
individual for a very specific target. (Jobber & Lancaster)
- Training plan
The training plan in general should be ongoing for any sales department. It will contain all
the training activities planned, participants, cost of the training, schedule and impact on
other related activities.
- Operations plan
This plan contains everything related to working space, equipment needed to conduct the
tasks, software etc. This plan also can contain expenses and other capital discussions.
- Selling expense summary
The total costs for each month are summarized and listed.
Having discussed how to organize a salesforce, it is also very important to take a look at the
cultural factors and considerations that the new sales reps will need to take into account if
expanding to a foreign market.
3.8. Cultural Dimensions, affects and considerations
Culture, cultural differences and the influence of national cultures play an important role in
International Business (IB) field and over the last three decades have been widely studied.
The research paper by Reis, Ferreira, Santos and Serra (2013) examine different cultural
models and present the definition of culture given by Hofstede (1980):
“[t]he collective programming of the mind which distinguishes the members of one human
group from another, … the interactive aggregate of common characteristics that influence a
human group’s response to its environment”.
As well, Gould and Grein (2009) state that:
“[c]ulture consists of explicit and implicit patterns of historically derived and selected ideas
and their embodiment in institutions, practices and artefacts; cultural patterns may, on one
hand, be considered as products of action, and on the other as conditioning elements of
further action”.
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
14
Companies are not in isolation, and they operate in a physical, technological, economic,
social and cultural space to which they must adapt. (Scott, 2002);
According to Guusinger, (2001) one of the factors that culture can influence are the
international strategic options when operating abroad and can have a strong impact on the
choice of entry mode in foreign markets. (Kogut and Singh, 1988; Tihanyi et al., 2005) From
the research, some companies seem to prefer joint ventures and acquisitions rather than
Greenfield investments when entering culturally distant countries. (Shane, 1993);
Three main cultural models exist:
 Edward Hall’s high and low context of culture (1976);
 Trompenaar’s seven dimensions of culture (1993);
 Hofstede’s Cultural dimensions (1980);
Hofstede’s model analyses the different variables of national culture while Trompenaar’s
model focuses on how culture is created. (Hampden-Turner and Trompenaars, 1997) Hall’s
(1976) model did not advance to an internationally comparable measurement and it analyses
only one single variable (context) in a binary output. (Reis, Ferreira, Santos and Serra, 2013)
All of the models have received certain critique regarding peer review, depth of the model
and simplicity. However, the most commonly used model by academia and professionals
today when trying to analyse the culture of a certain market is Hofstede’s model, thus the
literature review will further focus only on this model. (Reis, Ferreira, Santos and Serra,
2013);
Hofstede’s Cultural dimensions
In his book, “Culture’s consequences: International differences in work-related values”,
Hofstede (1986) presents the results of his empirical study through which he managed to
identify four basic cultural dimensions that are able to explain the variance in the countries’
scores of cultural values. The four dimensions are:
Power distance: the degree to which individuals in a culture accept unequal
distribution of power. (Hofstede, 1980);
Uncertainty avoidance: the tolerance of members of the group to unstructured,
ambiguous situations and whether the members of the group accept or try to avoid such
situations. (Hofstede, 1980);
Individualism – collectivism: defined as the extent to which individuals in a national
cultural setting “prefer to act as individuals rather than as members of groups”. (Hofstede,
1994)
Masculinity-femininity: the degree to which traditionally ‘masculine’ values (e.g.,
performance, competition, success and assertiveness) prevail over stereotypically ‘feminine’
values (e.g., solidarity, care for the weak, cooperation, quality of life, personal relationships
and friendship. (Hofstede, 1994) ;
Together with Bond (1988), in later work, a fifth dimension was included:
Confucian dynamism (also known as long term orientation), which relates to the
culture’s time horizon, and the importance ascribed to the future or the past.
The latest cultural dimension added to the model or the sixth one is:
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
15
Indulgence the extent to which people try to control their desires and impulses,
based on the way they were raised. (Hofstede, 2016);
The following limitations when applying Hofstede’s framework should be kept in mind. One
of the obvious weaknesses is that the data is relatively old and doesn’t capture the effect of
recent political, economic and technological changes. Moreover, that the creation of the
model is based on data from only one company – IBM. (Pankaj Ghemawat and Sebastian
Reiche, 2011);
As outlined earlier, national culture differences have a reflection in business decisions like
foreign entry modes. But the understanding of national culture can also improve
management practises and Pankaj Ghemawat and Sebastian Reiche (2011) provided the
following findings:
 Participative management can improve profitability in low power distance cultures
but worsen it in high power distance cultures
 Quick fixes can improve profitability in more short-term oriented cultures but worsen
it in more long-term oriented cultures
 Merit-based pay and promotion policies can improve profitability in more masculine
cultures and reduce it in more feminine cultures
 Emphasizing individual contributions can improve profitability in more individualistic
cultures and worsen it in more collectivistic cultures
The findings can be used when deciding how to manage a sales rep for a foreign market
(tasks allocations, incentive strategies, etc.) after having made an analysis of the cultural
dimensions of the country in question.
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
16
4. Innovation Living’s Business Model
Innovation Living is an international furniture enterprise that has established production
facilities in three countries, on three continents, and has employees all over the world. The
company has full ownership over its supply chain until the distribution to the B2C - the
middle man or the retailers, thus it does not deal with the business to consumer aspect. One
of the biggest pluses for the company image are the “Danish design” and “Danish quality
stamp”.
Before an analysis of the Business models is made, it is relevant to take a look what growth
strategies the company is currently employing:
As shown on the figure below there are four types of generic strategy depending on the
Target Market Scope, the cost and the uniqueness of the product or service. Innovation
Living specializes in a niche market, more specifically the sofa/bed segment and serves
mostly customers who live in small living spaces. (Innovation Living, 2016) Based on this,
the generic strategic is determined to be a Differentiation Focus. (See figure 4.1);
Figure 4.1: Generic Strategies
Source: Hollensen, 2010;
As the main discussion of the report is related to the Bulgarian market and there is enough
data to determine the growth strategy according to the Ansoff Matrix. Innovation Living is
already present in Bulgaria with one authorized dealer in Sofia. The company sells products
from its usual product portfolio without any changes. Meaning that Innovation Living is
using the Market Penetration Growth Strategy;
Now, to receive a better understanding of the company’s concept and to see if it has the
necessary resources and capabilities internally to pursue a new strategy, an analysis of the
business model is made.
An overview of the company’s business model is presented on the next page (See figure
4.2);
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
17
Figure 4.2: Osterwalder Nine Block Business Model
Key partners All major suppliers of parts and materials, logistic partners, dealers and
chains, exhibition/fair executives, Danske Bank, External legal advisor
Key activities Design, production, sales & marketing activities
Key resources Human: Skilled management, Inspired well-known designer, Skilled
experienced experts in all processes of the production
Physical: production facilities/machinery, the building (warehouse,
showroom, offices)
Intellectual: XAL Information user friendly platform, containing data about
customers, procurement, financial data, inventory and transportation
Financial: Liquid/Financially stable company
Value
propositions
Functionality, Quality, Scandinavian Design, Brand Image, Customization,
Comfortability, Flexibility, (In some cases recycled or handmade)
Customer
segments
People of all ages living in small/one room spaces
In BG market: People with high standard of living (with greater disposable
income)passion for imported/ Scandinavian design furniture, High-
end/premium segment/luxury product
Customer
relationships
Personal focused customer relationships mostly aiming to retain existing
customers and less focused on new customer acquisition
Channels Own: Sales force, sales agents partner: dealers, wholesalers
Cost structure Costs related to KA: design, production, marketing & sales
Revenue
streams
Main: sales of furniture
Secondary: Sales of point - sale materials to Dealers
Source: Own production;
4.1. Customer Segments
The product in question is a niche product, with high level of innovation and diversification,
hence it holds a premium price. Therefore, Innovation Living is targeting furniture retailers
that are only distributing furniture in the same price-intervals. It is also important, that the
retailers are picking products that are unconventional and innovative and will attract end
consumers who seek to find unique design and functionality, and are willing to pay a higher
price.
In the Bulgarian market, the company currently operates only through one middle man –
Home Selection. Home Selection focuses exactly on three key aspects: Quality, Functionality
and Innovation. (Home Selection, 2016) It places emphasis on beautiful, functional and
proven quality furniture. The prices in their product range is medium to high.
In order to choose the right B2B customers, Innovation Living has defined a business to
consumer target group – people of all ages living in small/one room spaces, with a higher
disposable income. The company defines these people as young and extremely demanding,
having a dynamic lifestyle that the company’s products can be up to date with.
4.2. Value Proposition
The value proposition constitutes of products that are functional, with high quality, high
degree of customization, flexibility and Scandinavian design.
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
18
Value Strategy - Customer Intimacy;
According to the Harvard Business Review, Customer Intimacy is one of the three value
disciplines. The other two are operational excellence and product leadership. Customer
intimacy observed as a value strategy refers to companies who continuously tailor solutions
(products or services towards the needs of their customers). This approach could be
expensive but it is the right one when the goal is improving the customer loyalty in the long
term. The focus is on the customer lifetime value, not on a single transaction. The idea is
that employees of Innovation Living strive to fulfil every customer desire, even it doesn't
seem important from their perspective.
The most special about Innovation Living’s products is their functionality. The different
sofas are designed to fit rooms of different sizes and to be adjustable depending on the
customer’s need at that current moment – to sit and read a book, to take a nap, etc.
Customers can also customize and give ideas for sofa’s to specifically fit their needs
through the D.I.Y. – Design It Yourself idea and slogan.
4.3. Channels
Innovation living’s marketing communications consist of both push and pull strategies –
they employ online and traditional marketing.
The company has its own website accessible from everywhere, as well as, it is present on
different social media channels – Facebook, Instagram, YouTube. Through these channels,
Innovation living manages to create brand awareness, also to educate and inspire its end
customers and to support its products through descriptions and video demonstrations.
The traditional marketing of the company consists of attending industry trade fairs that play
a very important role in their brand promotion in the B2B world. It is also creating its own
promotional materials such as product catalogues and brochures.
4.3.1. Distribution Channels
The distribution process flow is conducted through sales agents sourcing potential
wholesalers and retailers.
As mentioned earlier, the company operates through middle man, wholesalers and retailers,
and does not have its own brick and mortar stores. It has built its own salesforce and each
sales rep specializes for a different market. Hence, the company’s entry mode in foreign
markets is through direct export, collaborating with native sales representatives.
4.4. Customer relationships
The company conducts relationship based marketing or in other words, it follows the
diamond relationship model, where it has a personal approach to each B2B customers it
collaborates with. The sales reps act as key-account managers to their established partners.
They have constant communication with them and provide all the necessary information
support and information.
4.5. Revenue Streams
Innovation Living has two revenue streams:
 Main: Sales of furniture
 Secondary: Sales of promotional materials to Dealers
The company works with fixed pricing. When negotiating with the middle man, Innovation
Living directly sells its product to the distributor and then the distributor earns a percentage
of the final sale to the B2C customer. Here the risk falls on the middle man, as they stack up
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
19
inventory that needs to be sold. Nevertheless, Innovation Living needs to have certain
activities that support the middleman’s sales activities, so that is a win-win situation.
¨Innovation Living offer not the cheapest, nor the most expensive products.¨ - Quoted from
Jesper Frelund, Chief Executive Assistant;
However, the Innovation Living product prices compared to the price level of similar
products from the same sofa/bed segment in Bulgaria is quite high. Hence, the company
has a premium pricing strategy. Lowering the price of Innovation Products is not an option,
so the Innovation Living products are classified as luxury/premium and the pricing strategy
of the firm will be observed as premium pricing and it targets end consumers with high
disposable income.
4.6. Key Resources
4.6.1. Human resources
The company consists of 25 full time employees in the administration and one intern. The
team consists of CEO, Designers, Product Managers, Logistic Manager, International and
Area Sales Managers, Marketing Coordinators, Customer Service Team, It-Manager and a
Financial Specialist. It also has its own employees in the production facilities.
4.6.2. Intellectual resources
The company has created and poses a database called XAL that contains information about
their customers, procurement, financial data, inventory and transportation.
4.6.3. Physical resources
The company owns three production facilities and special machinery. It also has an
inventory storage space (warehouse), showrooms, offices and different equipment.
4.6.4. Financial resources
A detailed financial analysis of the company through ratios and financial report analysis
couldn’t be made, because of a lack of information from Innovation Living.
However, according to the company, it currently doesn’t have any liabilities. The flow of
revenue has slightly declined after the world’s financial crisis in 2007, but the company still
earns enough to be profitable and to re-invest back into the business. It recently started
building its own production facilities in Ukraine in order to support its activities in both
Eastern/Southern Europe and some parts of Asia. This will reduce the time to market in
certain countries as well as lower the costs for Innovation living in both production and
distribution.
4.7. Key Activities
The key activities of Innovation Living are as follows:
o Production and Design;
o Marketing and Sales;
o Distribution and Support;
4.8. Key Partnerships
The Key partner for Innovation Living are all the major suppliers of parts and materials that
make the production of the sofa’s possible and the dealers and wholesalers through which
the products are distributed to the end customers.
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
20
4.9.Cost Structure
The costs of Innovation Living are compounded of both fixed and variable costs. The fixed
costs include salaries, administration costs, operating costs and equipment depreciation.
The variable costs include marketing activities and sales incentives and bonuses.
5. External Analysis
This section of the report includes relevant parts from PESTLE analysis of Bulgaria, Industry
analysis based on Porter’s 5 forces framework, in-depth analysis of the competition on the
Bulgarian Market, both domestic and foreign firms. Competitive benchmarking based on
select criteria. Analysis of organisational customers relevant to Innovation Living;
5.1. PESTLE
Most relevant to the project are considered to be the economic, social and legal factors and
accurate summarized information is provided.
5.1.1 Economic factors
● Bulgaria is the poorest country in the EU;
● Bulgaria has the lowest wages in EU; Based on recent data published by the Bulgarian
Government, the average salary is app.400 EUR, the minimum salary is app. 200 Euros, high
salaries are app. 800-1000 EUR; However the salary rates are higher in Sofia and the high
salaries account for app. 1500-2500 Euros (BG Govern Stats);
● The manufacturing industry accounts for 20.0% of GDP and 20.3% of the workforce is
working in it.
● Disposable income per capita totalled BGN 6,912 in 2015. The real value of disposable
income per capita is expected to rise by 4.0% in 2016.
● Bulgaria’s economic performance was good in 2015. The economic growth is expected to
keep moderate rates and higher wages will continue to boost household spending, thereby
supporting output growth. The country continued to benefit from a modest increase in
foreign investment inflows and a relatively stronger fiscal stance.
● High rates of unemployment;
● Sofia has the most favourable economic climate and provides excellent conditions for
start-up and growing business;
Source: Bulgarian Country Profile, Euromonitor, 2016;
Figure 5.1: Key Economic Indicators of the Bulgarian Economy
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Inflation (% change) 2.4 4.2 3.0 0.9 -1.4 -0.1
Exchange rate (per US$) 1.48 1.41 1.52 1.47 1.47 1.76
GDP (% real growth) 1.3 1.9 0.0 0.9 1.3 3.6
GDP (national currency millions)
74,771
.3
80,759
.0
82,040
.4
82,166
.1
83,634
.3
88,571
.3
Birth rate (per '000) 10.2 9.6 9.5 9.2 9.4 9.2
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
21
Death rate (per '000) 14.9 14.7 15.0 14.4 15.1 15.3
No. of households ('000)
2,996.
1
3,005.
6
3,011.
6
3,017.
2
3,023.
5
3,026.
9
Total exports (US$ millions)
20,570
.9
28,221
.7
26,666
.9
29,579
.4
29,327
.3
25,715
.2
Total imports (US$ millions)
25,472
.8
32,578
.8
32,708
.7
34,308
.3
34,660
.9
29,225
.8
Urban population ('000)
5,337.
0
5,314.
9
5,324.
9
5,307.
9
5,291.
7
5,267.
5
Urban population (%) 71.9 72.1 72.7 72.9 73.0 73.1
Population aged 0-14 (%) 13.2 13.3 13.4 13.6 13.7 13.9
Population aged 15-64 (%) 68.8 68.3 67.8 67.3 66.7 66.1
Population aged 65+ (%) 18.0 18.3 18.8 19.2 19.6 20.0
Infant mortality (deaths per '000
live births)
9.4 8.5 7.8 7.3 7.6 6.6
Adult literacy (%) 98.3 98.4 98.4 98.4 98.4 98.4
Source: Euromonitor, 2015;
Figure 5.2: Real GDP Growth and GDP per capital development in the period of 2010-2016;
Source: Bulgaria - Economy, Finance and Trade, Euromonitor, 2015;
Income and expenditure in Bulgaria
Bulgaria’s per capita gross income and expenditure levels are the lowest amongst
economies in the European Union (EU).In 2015, consumer expenditure per capita amounted
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
22
to BGN 7,802 (US$4,425). The real value of consumer expenditure per is expected to raise
with 3.4%. Disposable income per capita totalled BGN 6,912 (US$3,921) in 2015. The real
value of disposable income per capita is expected to rise by 4.0% in 2016.
During the period 2015-2030, total disposable income will increase by a cumulative value of
89.8% in real terms – growing at an average annual rate of 4.4%.
As Bulgaria’s political, economic and cultural centre, Sofia gains most of the investment
(public and private) in the country (which results in higher employment rates compared to
the rest of the regions). The city also has the highest concentration of wealthy households in
Bulgaria. This delights the broader South-West region the largest consumer market in the
country, while the region also ranks top in terms of per household average spending;
Source: Euromonitor, 2015;
5.1.2 Social factors:
 The country is experiencing a long-term decline in the population of all ages less than 60.
Total population was 7.2 million in 2015, a drop of almost 800,000 since 2000.
● Bulgaria is losing thousands of qualified workers each year through emigration
● 22 % of the population are poor people below the poverty line;
● The availability of skilled labour will continue to be a constraint despite the large pool of
unemployed.
● Aging population is a disturbing factor;
● Productivity growth is critical for accelerating income convergence. Productivity must grow
by at least 4% per year if Bulgaria is to reach average EU income levels. Growth prospects
could also be limited by significant population decline owing to emigration and ageing.
Source: (Euromonitor, Bulgaria Country Profile, 2015);
5.1.3 Legal factors:
● High corruption rates in Bulgaria;
● Competitive tax rate of 10%, the lowest in the EU;
● Member of the EU, EU free trade policies apply;
● No additional regulations regarding the import of furniture;
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
23
5.2. Porter's Five Forces
Figure 5.3: Porter's Five Forces Industry Analysis Chart
Source: Based on Michael Porter’s 5 Forces model;
5.2.1. Supplier Bargaining Power - Moderate 5/10
In general, there are plenty of suppliers worldwide providing similar materials (wood/iron
frames, textile covers, mattresses and fillings). Definitely, offered products/materials from
various suppliers may differentiate in terms of price, quality, delivery time, order size, origin
of materials, certification and much more. Firms who has better agreements with a supplier
or partner with suppliers, providing them with superior materials gain competitive
advantage and become the preferred choice of the end consumers. The supplier bargaining
power is determined to be moderate. The suppliers can charge as much as they decide for
their products and services as far as their customers agree to pay. In a free market there are
no general limitations to accessing and cooperating with a certain supplier, it all comes to
negotiating more favourable conditions of cooperation. The suppliers might feel pressured
to lower their price, to win a client. Furniture manufacturers who are able to find and
cooperate with suppliers, offering superior products and services on better terms in the long
term compared to the competition gain sustainable competitive advantage, leading to
increased perceived value for the customer, more sales and bigger profits.
Table 5.4: Indicators of the supplier’s bargaining power;
Number of suppliers High
Size of suppliers Vary
Uniqueness of service Not unique
Your ability to substitute Great
Cost of changing Small
Source: Own Production;
0
2
4
6
8
10
Supplier's
Bargaining
Power
Buyer's
Bargaining
Power
Threat of
Substitution
Threat of New
Entrants
Rivalry among
Existing
Competitors
Porter's 5 Forces Shaping the Furniture
Industry
Porter's 5 Forces Shaping
the Furniture Industry
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
24
5.2.2. Buyer Bargaining Power - High 8/10
The customer is always first, he is the decision maker. Fierce competition between
manufacturers provides the customer with wide range of products to choose from. The
buyer has the power to determine from whom to buy and to decide which offer suits his
needs best.
Table 5.5: Indicators of the buyer’s bargaining power’
Number of customers Medium
Size of each order Vary
Differences between competitors Low, might vary
Price sensibility High
Ability to substitute High
Cost of changing Low
Source: Own production;
5.2.3. Threat of Substitution 1/10
Thinking logically, there is no substitute to furniture. All the substituting products or
products with similar purpose/designation are also categorized as furniture products. So the
furniture is unique and irreplaceable concept. In other words, the furniture products can be
substituted only with other furniture products. Of course there is a wide range of functions
and model varieties which may have similar usage qualities and one product can replace
another. (Example: Sofa/Bed have the properties and applications both of a couch and a bed
and could substitute both. Also decreases the quantity of occupied space (measured in
sq.m), which makes it. in some cases, a preferred product for small living spaces).
Table 5.6: Indicators for threat of substitution
Substitute performance No substitution to furniture
Cost of change -
Source: Own Production;
5.2.4. Threat of New Entry 8/10
In the furniture Industry, the threat of new entry is high. A lot of new firms continuously are
being opened. Small investments of capital are required to buy wood and textile processing
machinery. It is not a necessity to operate complex technologically advanced machinery in
the process of furniture manufacturing. Old machinery, even a manual tools are used to
reduce costs. The administration also processes documentation smoothly without need of a
complex software. Rarely sophisticated CRM systems are used, only by large organisations
who can afford. Furniture manufacturing business can be launched with relatively small
capital. Most of the new entrants are local small firms. Economy of scale is determined to be
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
25
medium to high, mainly because materials are cheaper when purchased in bigger volumes;
also the efficiency of the logistics is increased, leading to lowering of the transportation
costs per unit.
Table 5.7: Indicators of threat of new entry
Time and cost of entry Small
Specialist knowledge Small to medium
Economies of scale Medium to high
Cost advantages Medium to high
Technology protections Small
Barriers of entry Small
Source: Own Production;
5.2.5. Competitive Rivalry - High 9/10
There is high degree of competition within the furniture industry. Huge number of
competitors. The market is very price sensitive, meaning that a change of price, causes a
drastic change in the demand for products. The quality of materials and assembly can vary
depending on suppliers and the expertise of the work force. The furniture industry is not
characterized with high customer loyalty, often the customers are purchasing furniture from
different retailers and manufacturers. A firm which is able to provide a product with the
same perceived benefits cheaper, most likely is the preferred choice of the customer. The
industry is characterized with fierce price competition and could be described as Red Ocean.
Table 5.8: Indicators of the rivalry among competitors;
Number of competitors High
Quality differences High
Other differences High
Switching costs Medium
Customer Loyalty Low
Source: Own Production;
5.2.6. Attractiveness of the furniture Industry 4/10
Overall the furniture manufacturing industry is not very attractive scoring overall rating of
4/10, because of the high level of competition among opponents, the price sensitivity
influencing the demand. On the other hand it is safe industry because there are no
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
26
substitutions and companies with skilled salesforce can achieve high results being able to
satisfy the customer´s demands.
5.3. ADL Matrix
Using the ADL Framework are considered two main factors: the competitive position of
Innovation Living in the Bulgarian Furniture Market and the stage of industry life cycle. The
Industry is considered as mature. The meaning of mature in this case is that the industry is
already grown and it has well established customer base, the market and the market share
are stable, there are a lot of competitors and are focused to differentiate one from another -
exactly what it is happening within the furniture industry. However the Innovation Living
competitive position on the Bulgarian market is tangible, meaning that the company has
small insignificant market share, also it is present only in Sofia. The firm strives to
differentiate its products from the others and retain on the market. In order Innovation
Living to keep its market share and to pursue growth, it has to improve its competitive
advantage and to put more effort on sales and acquire new customers. Based on internal
information from the company, at this moment there are not enough people in the sales
department, which results in inability to acquire new customers. The currently hired sales
people at Innovation only manage to serve existing customer and are unable to negotiate
with potential customers.
Unfortunately, this is a weakness and could have a negative effect to the company
performance and sales figures, it can even result in withdrawal of the market. Further in the
report this problem is to be solved. Innovation Living needs to be active and to stabilize its
position on the market. (See figure 5.9);
Figure 5.9: ADL matrix
Source: Wilson, Richard M.S and Gilligan, Colin, 2005;
5.4. Analysis of the Competitors in Bulgaria
Competitor intelligence acquired based on the analysis will contribute to developing a new
strategy for Innovation Living by identifying the competitive advantages of the competition
and how Innovation Living can steal market share.
The competition of Innovation Living consists of other furniture manufactures supplying
directly or indirectly sofa/beds to the end consumers in Bulgaria. They are divided in two
categories: Local Competition and Foreign Entrants.
¨Market sources of furniture for Bulgaria are dominated by foreign, mainly of European
origin firms. Share of national production out of total consumption is 25%. Share of imports
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
27
out of total consumption is 75%, which means Bulgaria depends on imports.¨ (Furniture
Manufacturing, 2015);
5.4.1 Local Competition
¨There are more than 2300 wood processing and furniture manufacturers in Bulgaria,
which sell both on the domestic market and export internationally. 77.5% of them are micro
firms with 1 to 9 employees. There are only 10 macro enterprises accounting for 0.4% and
they employ more than 250 people. The rest are small and medium firms with 10 to 250
employed personnel.¨
The competition faced by Innovation Living consists of all companies selling sofa/beds as
part of their portfolio on the Internal Market.
In general the products produced by local firms are not homogeneous from customer
perspective. They have similar product ranges. Most local firms do not specialize in a niche
market like Innovation Living, but have broader product portfolios. A usual Bulgarian
manufacturer of commercial furniture offers all types of furniture to be used in all the
rooms, excluding bathroom and restroom furniture. These competitors are mainly B2C
oriented, but the larger ones sell both B2B (sales through retailers and resellers) and B2C.
Ergodesign, Videnov and Irim are well established companies owing a big part of the market
share of the domestic production.
Competitive advantages of the local firms over Innovation Living
● Lower Costs of manufacturing;
● Lower costs of transportation;
● Cultural similarity with the Bulgarian consumers;
● Shorter time to market;
5.4.2 Foreign competition on the Bulgarian furniture market
Companies from Denmark, Sweden, Germany, Italy, Poland, Ukraine and more countries are
already present in Bulgaria, distinguishing from the local competition. Due to the lack of
design, bad quality and similarity of products offered from the local competition, the
consumers seek alternative, especially from customers with higher income and the demand
for imported furniture is growing. The number of foreign companies on the Bulgarian
furniture market is growing. Ikea, Jysk, Cotta, Boconcept are only few market entrants.
Owned Showrooms, Distributors and resellers are commonly used to reach the consumers.
The table below illustrates the customer perceived benefits categorized as order winners
and order qualifiers.
Table 5.10: Order Winners and Order Qualifiers for Sofa/bed Purchase from end consumer
perspective;
Order Winners: Order Qualifiers:
Quality; Comfort;
Design; Customization;
Functionality; Time to market;
Uniqueness;
Source: Own Production, based on primary and secondary data;
In the table below are shown companies which are competing with Innovation Living in the
Bulgarian Market. All companies involved in it, produce and sell products under the category
of sofa/beds. The table provides competitive benchmarking. All criteria are ranked on the
scale from 1 to 10. (See Table 5.11);
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
28
Table 5.11: Competitive Benchmarking of firms in the Bulgarian Furniture Market
Innovation
Living
BO
Concept
IKEA Irim Ergo
Design
Cotta
Headquart
ers:
Denmark Denmark Sweden Bulgaria Bulgaria Germany
Product
range on
the BG
Market:
Sofa/Beds
only
Furniture
for home -
for the
living,
dining
room,
bedroom
Everything
for home
not limited
to furniture
All types of
furniture
for home,
office and
gardens,
hotels
Beds,
Furniture
for
bedroom,
sofa/beds,
mattresses
Furniture
for the
living and
dining
room
Point of
sales:
1 partner
showroom
(Home
Selection
showroom
in Sofia)
1 Owned
Showroom
in Sofia
only
(Boutique);
One brand
store in
Sofia
100 +( in a
lot of
stores
across the
country)
Available in
most cities,
also online
7 (Only can
be
purchased
in AIKO
stores)
Sales
Volume of
Sofa Beds
1 2 3 8 7 8
Time to
market:
7 (app. 3
weeks for
ORL)
7 (4 weeks
in not in
stock)
1(only
products
in stock are
for
purchase)
5 (2 weeks) 6 (3-4
weeks)
1 (only
products
in stock are
for
purchase)
Price of
Sofa/Beds
Sofa/Beds:
8 10 5 3 8 7
Degree of
customizat
ion:
6 4 3 10 7 2
Quality: 8 8 6 6 8
Functionali
ty of
sofa/beds:
9 7 6 10 7 8
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
29
Uniquenes
s of the
design of
the
product on
the
Bulgarian
market:
10 8 7 2 9 6
Brand
Recognitio
n in
Bulgaria:
1 4 9 9 6 5
Level of
Customer
Awareness
in Bulgaria:
2 4 9 9 6 5
Source: Own production, based on field research and company websites;
Results show that Innovation Living performance is satisfying and in some measurements
are superior compared to companies with longer presence and greater market share. The
Innovation Living product lines are competitive and have the potential to sell well in
Bulgaria. The product features such as design, quality customisation and uniqueness make
them attractive to consumers and stand out from competition.
Investing in marketing campaign, will improve the low level of customer awareness and
brand recognition; the existing concept offered by Innovation Living - Shop in Shop is a
good marketing tool but not enough.
Acquiring of new B2B customers is a must and more points of sale on strategic locations
across the country will enable the sales growth and improve the accessibility and consumer
awareness. The fact that Innovation Living is only accessible only in one showroom of a
private design store in Sofia is the main obstacle of weak sales. The company has to act
more offensive, gain market share and strengthen its presence on the market.
The outsourcing of Innovation Living production in the new facility in Ukraine will decrease
the time to market.
Innovation Living has to invest in marketing and business development activities to develop
the market and attract resellers with credible image and reputation.
5.5. Organizational Customer’s Analysis
This section of the report deals with analysis of the organizational buyers. Main area of
focus is B2B Customers of Innovation Living in the Bulgarian market and their characteristics
including assessment of their buying behaviour, involved individuals, and the buying
situation.
Briefly, Innovation Living only works with B2B customers. The goal of the management is to
develop long-term relationship with small number of customers in a specific market, in
order to keep its status of design brand, which cannot be purchased everywhere. Innovation
Livings selectively acquires new customers and does not sell to anyone.
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
30
All customers of Innovation are only companies who resell Innovation Living products for
profit. They don’t use the products in any other aspect in the business.
Most important factors influencing the buying decision for resellers are profit margins of
selling third party products, sales volume, payment options, delivery terms, volume of order
quantities.
In most cases a moderate rebuy situation will occur. As the orders will differ in models
ordered and quantity, depending on season, time of the year, end consumer needs and etc.;
Direct procurement is the main method, because it is common for small firms and the
decision is made individually in the organisation.
In Bulgaria, currently Innovation Living the only customer is Home Selection a designer
furniture store in Sofia, which is an authorized dealer of Innovation Living's products. The
customer has the following characteristics:
 Company size: Small (1 to 9 employees);
 Order Size: Small (Total revenue for 2016 of 55 130 DKK ); (See Appendix 5);
 Position of the decision maker within the organization: CEO/Owner;
 Buying situation: Moderate rebuy;
 Communication: Direct (with the sales coordinator based in Denmark);
Associated resellers are Interior design studios and designer stores. Wholesalers
specializing in furniture sales in Bulgaria are: Videnov, Mondo and AIKO.
5.6 Market Trends and Demand for Design Danish Furniture in Bulgaria
¨A recent survey conducted by Alpha Research for the Bulgarian Chamber of Commerce
concluded that price had been a decisive factor driving furniture consumer preferences in
Bulgaria. Logically the competition on the Bulgarian market for furniture and design was
mainly focusing on price rather than quality of the products. Nevertheless, the survey
identified a new trend; the group of consumers buying new and expensive furniture is
growing, the group predominantly consists of young professionals with a high social and
economic status who are residents of Sofia or other larger cities.¨ - Source: Furniture and
Design Sector in Bulgaria, 2015;
Retailers selling imported design furniture accounted for essential growth with dynamic
rates. The import of design furniture has increased by 300%. Due to increase of disposable
income, more innovative products, matching customers’ expectations and the better leasing
schemes. A lot of foreign brands producing exclusive, designed furniture expanded in
Bulgaria. The most revenue comes from Sofia and the big cities. Great demand comes from
young enthusiastic people with a high social status and disposable income above the
average. Additional demand for quality designer furniture is created by the tourist industry,
which intensively grows. The growing demand for furniture and design in Bulgaria makes
Danish Furniture Design Brands even more popular for the customer and the fact that
Danish producers have the image and reputation for great designers for ages together with
the expertise of furniture manufacturing and the high quality materials used, create
excellent opportunities for the Danish companies to achieve sustainable, sizable growth in
the Bulgarian furniture market; (Furniture and Design Sector in Bulgaria, 2015)
5.7. Bulgarian Culture according to Hofstede’s Six Cultural Dimensions
For this analysis, Hofstede’s website (https://geert-hofstede.com/bulgaria.html) was used as
a source of information. (See figure 5.12);
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
31
Figure 5.12: Bulgaria Cultural Profile
Source: Own Production;
Power distance
As Bulgaria scores very high (70) it means that people in that country accept a hierarchical
order in which everyone has a pre-defined place and it doesn’t need to be further justified.
Centralization is normal and subordinates are told what to do.
Individualism
With a score of 30, Bulgarian society is regarded as collectivistic where close long-term
commitment to the member group is very important. Loyalty is paramount and it goes above
most other social rules and regulations. In this type of societies, offence often leads to
shame and loss of face. Relationships between employees and employer can often turn as a
family link like.
Masculinity
Bulgarian society with a score of 40 is considered more a feminine one rather than
masculine. In this societies the focus is on “working in order to live”, strive for consensus
from the management, valuing equality, solidarity and quality in the working live. Conflicts
are resolved by negotiation and compromising, and incentives such as free time and
flexibility are favoured.
Uncertainty Avoidance
The score of for uncertainty avoidance is very high (85) thus people in Bulgaria prefer to
avoid uncertainty. This constitutes in being intolerant to unorthodox behaviour or ideas.
Time is money in this society, there is inner urge to be busy and work hard, precision and
punctuality are the norm and security is an important element in individual motivation.
Long Term Orientation
The score of 69 for Bulgaria makes it a pragmatic culture, where people believe that truth
will vary based on situation, context and time. There is ability to adapt traditions easily to
changes, tendency to save and invest and perseverance to achieve results.
Indulgence
Bulgarian society has the tendency to cynicism and pessimism or a Restrained culture (low
score of 16). There is no much focus on leisure time and gratification control on the desires.
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
32
Figure 5.13: Bulgarian culture vs. Danish culture
Source: Hofstede, 2016;
The figure above compares the cultural dimensions of the Bulgarian and Danish society and
it can be seen there are almost the total opposite of each other. Hence, Innovation Living
will have to consider adding a native sales representative to the team, as he/she will possess
the necessary understanding of the market and the skills to communicate effectively with
Bulgarian business partners. (see figure 5.13);
6. Insights Based on the Conducted Semi-structured Interviews
Generally 5 retailers from the Bulgarian Market were interviewed. 4 of them are small to
medium size and only AIKO is a whole seller. 2 of them (Acherno and Trinex Design) are
Design Studios, meaning that they are not only retailers but also consult and digitally
visualize interior design concepts.
Language preferences: Eventough some of the participants use English, it is recommended
to have someone speaking the local language and has knowledge of the culture. This makes
a lot easier the negotiation with new customers especially.
Order sizes, excluding the wholesaler are small to medium and the kept inventory is low.
Those boutique and design specialized firms offer customization and allow the end
consumer to order a product which is not in stock and they take it over to supplier.
All firms are present online, but not all sell online, especially those with premium pricing
offer personal selling.
The product range is wide but as Innovation Living carefully selects new dealers and
requires certain level of price/quality to be met, the same is with those specialized retailers,
they carefully select they partners.
For more extensive information gathered from the interviews see Appendix 2, 3 and 4;
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
33
7. SWOT – is market penetration the way to go?
The Information in the table is based on the internal and the external analysis conducted in
the project until this stage. It illustrates the Strengths and the Weaknesses originating from
the company internally. The Opportunities and Threats are external factors related to the
Bulgarian Furniture Market and the Industry that Innovation Living has to assess before
planning further actions.
Table 7.1: SWOT Matrix
S W
O T
Source: Own Production;
8. Segmentation, Targeting and Positioning
8.1 Segmentation
The Industry Innovation Living is targeting are Home and Garden Retailers industry and
more specifically, the Homewares and home furnishing stores. In Bulgaria, the Homewares
and home furnishing stores performs the best in 2015, growing by 4% in value terms.
(http://portal.euromonitor.com.ez-eaa.statsbiblioteket.dk:2048/portal/analysis/tab)
Between the two industries there have been differences in price positioning. While the Home
and Garden Retailers are firmly entrenched at the low-end of the price spectrum, Homeware
and home furnishing stores fall under three distinct price groups:
 Very high Quality – Danish stamp
 Scandinavian Designer
 New production facilities in
Ukraine – shorter time to market
and lower costs
 Wide product range
 Customization of products
 Brand Image
 Price level – high for the
Bulgarian Market
 Only one point of sale in BG
 No actions towards raising
customer awareness
 Not much experience in the
market
 No knowledge of the culture and
the behaviour of the consumers
 Lack of human capital, needed to
research, aquire and serve new
customers
 More and more Bulgarian
customer look for innovative
solutions and Danish design
 Still a decent percentage of the
people have a higher income
 The economic and social factors
are having positive outlooks
 Retailers look to work with
foreign importers
 The costs of expansion and
operations in the country are low
 The market is highly saturated
and there are a lot of indirect
offerings
 Cultural differences – the cultural
barriers are very high between the
two countries
 A large part of the population is
within the range of low to medium
income
 Opportunities can be found only
in large cities, which limits the
potential of the market
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
34
- Low-end
- Mid-end
- High-end
The big furniture retailers in Bulgaria, both foreign and domestic, tend to fall in the broader
category, Home and Garden, making them more in-direct competitors. Moreover, most of
them are operating in the low-end, mid- end price ranges, as their product ranges are quite
extensive and have different “collections” targeting different customer groups.
Hence, Innovation Living will be looking for smaller, more niche furniture retailers that work
with carefully picked suppliers and have a certain vision that will fit the company’s products.
In the Bulgarian market there are currently 80 medium and 450 small retailers of furniture.
The density of furniture shops and showrooms is high, due to relatively low costs related to
showrooms (such as rent, electricity, staff salaries)
However, it is also relevant if they are working with imported furniture and not a very large
percentage of them sells imported furniture. The retailers who do, are usually located in the
big cities and import high-end products. (Innovation Living, 2016)
The company’s aim for the Bulgarian market is to become a premium dealer and expose
Innovation Collection, thus the company wants to target Interior Design Consultancies and
Boutique Furniture Importers in the following cities: Sofia, Varna, Plovdiv, Burgas and
Turnovo.
The smaller retailers usually have a small purchasing team or the decision maker is directly
the Owner of the store. As the products are more expensive and the order volumes are
small, communication plays an important role in keeping relationships, thus the buyer-seller
relationships will not be transactional.
8.2 Targeting
In the Bulgarian market there are currently 80 medium and 450 small retailers of furniture.
The density of furniture shops and showrooms is high, due to relatively low costs related to
showrooms (such as rent, electricity, staff salaries).
However, not a very large percentage of them sell imported furniture. The retailers who do,
are usually located in the big cities and import high-end products. (Innovation Living, 2016)
The company’s aim for the Bulgarian market is to become a premium dealer and expose
Innovation Collection, thus the company wants to target Interior Design Consultancies and
Botique Furniture Importers in the following cities: Sofia, Varna, Plovdiv, Burgas and
Turnovo.
Below a list of companies in Bulgaria from the chosen segment is presented. They are
selected as possible customers with high potential: (See Figure 8.1);
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
35
Figure 8.1: Targeting
Sofia ● Acherno
● Grandecor
● Casadecor
● Mirookki
● Jelanie
● Mebelipro
● Furnish Furnish.bg, also in city of Varna
● Perfecta mebeli /СБС Скандинавия/ - Only Representative of
Stressless and Ekornes in BG
Varna ● La Cassa lacasa.bg Interior Design Solutions- main
partners from Italy, but possible cooperation with
Innovation Living
● Best-furniture.bg - Design Imported Furniture
● Keys // Improter possible only for a small range of the
products offered by Innovation Living
● Bulmarket
● mebelibg
Burgas ● Mebeliverona
● Valdo
● Trinexdesign
● harlexmarket
Source: Own production;
The procurement is usually direct. The larger chains have a procurement team that is
responsible for the whole correspondence. In the smaller companies often the owner or the
CEO is the decision maker and it is easier to conduct negotiations for future cooperation.
8.3 Positioning
Figure 8.2: Positioning Map
Source: Own Production;
Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market
Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III
Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017
36
The positioning map above shows how Innovation Living are currently positioned in the
Bulgarian market compared to their competition. The two factors chosen for comparison are
Price level and Functionality, as these are assumed to be two of the closest related factors
that are looked at by end customers.
The only competitor outperforming Innovation Living in these two criteria is Irim.
Nevertheless, Innovation Living still has the two perceived advantages – Scandinavian design
and quality. The company shouldn’t try to reposition, but it should increase the awareness
of the brand and strengthen its current position. The current obstacles for Innovation in the
market are its low customer awareness and brand recognition, thus this is what the
company should focus on improving.
9. Market Penetration Strategy for the Bulgarian Market - Balanced Scorecard
The main goal for Innovation Living is to expand its presence in Bulgaria and to increase its
sales in the market. Hence, the company will adopt a market penetration strategy. (See
Literature review) As described in the literature review, this strategy is the least risky of all
four Ansoff growth strategies. Innovation Living is going to achieve this increase through
hiring a sales representative for this market.
The strategy is formed as a balanced scorecard that will serve as a tool for Innovation Living
to apply the strategy and to be able to track and measure the performance thus reaches its
overall goal. (See table 9.1) (Hutt and Speh, 2014) All of the objectives set in the balanced
scorecard are based on the S.M.A.R.T. goals model - Specific, Measurable, Attainable,
Realistic and Timely. (Hutt and Speh, 2014) Depending on the objective the targets are set
to be monthly, yearly or one-time based. The strategy is created for one year period.
Figure 9.1: The Balanced Scorecard
Source: Own Production;
*** In case the picture is hard to read, look at it in Appendix 7;
Bachelor Thesis - Sales Strategy, Innovation Living
Bachelor Thesis - Sales Strategy, Innovation Living
Bachelor Thesis - Sales Strategy, Innovation Living
Bachelor Thesis - Sales Strategy, Innovation Living
Bachelor Thesis - Sales Strategy, Innovation Living
Bachelor Thesis - Sales Strategy, Innovation Living
Bachelor Thesis - Sales Strategy, Innovation Living

More Related Content

What's hot

Quản trị rủi ro (Value at risk)
Quản trị rủi ro (Value at risk)Quản trị rủi ro (Value at risk)
Quản trị rủi ro (Value at risk)
Nghiên Cứu Định Lượng
 
Các nhân tố ảnh hưởng đến chiến dịch GM của các doanh nghiệp F&B - Green Mark...
Các nhân tố ảnh hưởng đến chiến dịch GM của các doanh nghiệp F&B - Green Mark...Các nhân tố ảnh hưởng đến chiến dịch GM của các doanh nghiệp F&B - Green Mark...
Các nhân tố ảnh hưởng đến chiến dịch GM của các doanh nghiệp F&B - Green Mark...
hNgc7
 
Chiến lược Marketing quốc tế : Đưa sản phẩm “Quýt Hồng Lai Vung®” tỉnh Đồng T...
Chiến lược Marketing quốc tế : Đưa sản phẩm “Quýt Hồng Lai Vung®” tỉnh Đồng T...Chiến lược Marketing quốc tế : Đưa sản phẩm “Quýt Hồng Lai Vung®” tỉnh Đồng T...
Chiến lược Marketing quốc tế : Đưa sản phẩm “Quýt Hồng Lai Vung®” tỉnh Đồng T...
luanvantrust
 
Bảng câu-hỏi-khảo-sát-khách-hàng
Bảng câu-hỏi-khảo-sát-khách-hàngBảng câu-hỏi-khảo-sát-khách-hàng
Bảng câu-hỏi-khảo-sát-khách-hàng
Khanh V. Nguyen
 
Đề tài: xây dựng chiến lược markeiting cho sản phẩm bánh mì, 9 điểm!
Đề tài: xây dựng chiến lược markeiting cho sản phẩm bánh mì, 9 điểm!Đề tài: xây dựng chiến lược markeiting cho sản phẩm bánh mì, 9 điểm!
Đề tài: xây dựng chiến lược markeiting cho sản phẩm bánh mì, 9 điểm!
Dịch Vụ Viết Luận Văn Thuê ZALO/TELEGRAM 0934573149
 
Quản lý quan hệ khách hàng tại Ngân hàng TMCP Ngoại Thương Việt Nam – Chi nhá...
Quản lý quan hệ khách hàng tại Ngân hàng TMCP Ngoại Thương Việt Nam – Chi nhá...Quản lý quan hệ khách hàng tại Ngân hàng TMCP Ngoại Thương Việt Nam – Chi nhá...
Quản lý quan hệ khách hàng tại Ngân hàng TMCP Ngoại Thương Việt Nam – Chi nhá...
luanvantrust
 
Luận văn: Nghiên cứu các yếu tố ảnh hưởng đến quyết định mua sắm trực tuyến
Luận văn: Nghiên cứu các yếu tố ảnh hưởng đến quyết định mua sắm trực tuyếnLuận văn: Nghiên cứu các yếu tố ảnh hưởng đến quyết định mua sắm trực tuyến
Luận văn: Nghiên cứu các yếu tố ảnh hưởng đến quyết định mua sắm trực tuyến
Viết Thuê Khóa Luận _ ZALO 0917.193.864 default
 
Đánh giá mức độ hài lòng của khách hàng đối với dịch vụ của hệ thống rạp chiế...
Đánh giá mức độ hài lòng của khách hàng đối với dịch vụ của hệ thống rạp chiế...Đánh giá mức độ hài lòng của khách hàng đối với dịch vụ của hệ thống rạp chiế...
Đánh giá mức độ hài lòng của khách hàng đối với dịch vụ của hệ thống rạp chiế...
Nhận Viết Đề Tài Trọn Gói ZALO 0932091562
 
Ảnh hưởng của thiết kế bao bì đến quyết định mua ngành hàng F&B
Ảnh hưởng của thiết kế bao bì đến quyết định mua ngành hàng F&BẢnh hưởng của thiết kế bao bì đến quyết định mua ngành hàng F&B
Ảnh hưởng của thiết kế bao bì đến quyết định mua ngành hàng F&B
Hai Le
 
Đề tài: Một số giải pháp nhằm hoàn thiện công tác Marketing Online cho Công t...
Đề tài: Một số giải pháp nhằm hoàn thiện công tác Marketing Online cho Công t...Đề tài: Một số giải pháp nhằm hoàn thiện công tác Marketing Online cho Công t...
Đề tài: Một số giải pháp nhằm hoàn thiện công tác Marketing Online cho Công t...
Viết thuê trọn gói ZALO 0934573149
 
Đề tài: Nâng cao hiệu quả hoạt động marketing tại công ty Tâm Chiến
Đề tài: Nâng cao hiệu quả hoạt động marketing tại công ty Tâm ChiếnĐề tài: Nâng cao hiệu quả hoạt động marketing tại công ty Tâm Chiến
Đề tài: Nâng cao hiệu quả hoạt động marketing tại công ty Tâm Chiến
Dịch vụ viết bài trọn gói ZALO: 0909232620
 
Luận văn: Giải pháp thu hút khách hàng tại siêu thị Thuận Thành, HAY
Luận văn: Giải pháp thu hút khách hàng tại siêu thị Thuận Thành, HAYLuận văn: Giải pháp thu hút khách hàng tại siêu thị Thuận Thành, HAY
Luận văn: Giải pháp thu hút khách hàng tại siêu thị Thuận Thành, HAY
Viết thuê trọn gói ZALO 0934573149
 
Chuyên đề quy trình lựa chọn và quản lý nhà cung cấp
Chuyên đề quy trình lựa chọn và quản lý nhà cung cấpChuyên đề quy trình lựa chọn và quản lý nhà cung cấp
Chuyên đề quy trình lựa chọn và quản lý nhà cung cấp
Buu Dang
 
Quản trị quan hệ khách hàng tại công ty Bảo Việt Đà Nẵng
Quản trị quan hệ khách hàng tại công ty Bảo Việt Đà NẵngQuản trị quan hệ khách hàng tại công ty Bảo Việt Đà Nẵng
Quản trị quan hệ khách hàng tại công ty Bảo Việt Đà Nẵng
luanvantrust
 
Hoạt động marketing hỗn hợp của Tổng công ty dịch vụ viễn thông Vinaphone đối...
Hoạt động marketing hỗn hợp của Tổng công ty dịch vụ viễn thông Vinaphone đối...Hoạt động marketing hỗn hợp của Tổng công ty dịch vụ viễn thông Vinaphone đối...
Hoạt động marketing hỗn hợp của Tổng công ty dịch vụ viễn thông Vinaphone đối...
luanvantrust
 
Marketing Của Công Ty Bảo Việt Nhân Thọ Hà Nội
Marketing Của Công Ty Bảo Việt Nhân Thọ Hà NộiMarketing Của Công Ty Bảo Việt Nhân Thọ Hà Nội
Marketing Của Công Ty Bảo Việt Nhân Thọ Hà Nội
luanvantrust
 
Mẫu lập dự án đầu tư và phát triển hệ thống logistics
Mẫu lập dự án đầu tư và phát triển hệ thống logisticsMẫu lập dự án đầu tư và phát triển hệ thống logistics
Mẫu lập dự án đầu tư và phát triển hệ thống logistics
CÔNG TY CỔ PHẦN TƯ VẤN ĐẦU TƯ THẢO NGUYÊN XANH
 
Tiểu luận xây dựng chiến lược kinh doanh của công ty vinamil đến năm 2020_Nhậ...
Tiểu luận xây dựng chiến lược kinh doanh của công ty vinamil đến năm 2020_Nhậ...Tiểu luận xây dựng chiến lược kinh doanh của công ty vinamil đến năm 2020_Nhậ...
Tiểu luận xây dựng chiến lược kinh doanh của công ty vinamil đến năm 2020_Nhậ...
Nguyễn Thị Thanh Tươi
 
Luận văn: Thực trạng hoạt động marketing công ty thuốc thú y, HAY
Luận văn: Thực trạng hoạt động marketing công ty thuốc thú y, HAYLuận văn: Thực trạng hoạt động marketing công ty thuốc thú y, HAY
Luận văn: Thực trạng hoạt động marketing công ty thuốc thú y, HAY
Viết thuê trọn gói ZALO 0934573149
 
Thuyết minh dự án Khu Trung tâm Logistics Chu Lai tỉnh Quảng Nam 0918755356
Thuyết minh dự án Khu Trung tâm Logistics Chu Lai tỉnh Quảng Nam 0918755356Thuyết minh dự án Khu Trung tâm Logistics Chu Lai tỉnh Quảng Nam 0918755356
Thuyết minh dự án Khu Trung tâm Logistics Chu Lai tỉnh Quảng Nam 0918755356
Công Ty Cổ Phần Tư Vấn Đầu Tư Dự Án Việt
 

What's hot (20)

Quản trị rủi ro (Value at risk)
Quản trị rủi ro (Value at risk)Quản trị rủi ro (Value at risk)
Quản trị rủi ro (Value at risk)
 
Các nhân tố ảnh hưởng đến chiến dịch GM của các doanh nghiệp F&B - Green Mark...
Các nhân tố ảnh hưởng đến chiến dịch GM của các doanh nghiệp F&B - Green Mark...Các nhân tố ảnh hưởng đến chiến dịch GM của các doanh nghiệp F&B - Green Mark...
Các nhân tố ảnh hưởng đến chiến dịch GM của các doanh nghiệp F&B - Green Mark...
 
Chiến lược Marketing quốc tế : Đưa sản phẩm “Quýt Hồng Lai Vung®” tỉnh Đồng T...
Chiến lược Marketing quốc tế : Đưa sản phẩm “Quýt Hồng Lai Vung®” tỉnh Đồng T...Chiến lược Marketing quốc tế : Đưa sản phẩm “Quýt Hồng Lai Vung®” tỉnh Đồng T...
Chiến lược Marketing quốc tế : Đưa sản phẩm “Quýt Hồng Lai Vung®” tỉnh Đồng T...
 
Bảng câu-hỏi-khảo-sát-khách-hàng
Bảng câu-hỏi-khảo-sát-khách-hàngBảng câu-hỏi-khảo-sát-khách-hàng
Bảng câu-hỏi-khảo-sát-khách-hàng
 
Đề tài: xây dựng chiến lược markeiting cho sản phẩm bánh mì, 9 điểm!
Đề tài: xây dựng chiến lược markeiting cho sản phẩm bánh mì, 9 điểm!Đề tài: xây dựng chiến lược markeiting cho sản phẩm bánh mì, 9 điểm!
Đề tài: xây dựng chiến lược markeiting cho sản phẩm bánh mì, 9 điểm!
 
Quản lý quan hệ khách hàng tại Ngân hàng TMCP Ngoại Thương Việt Nam – Chi nhá...
Quản lý quan hệ khách hàng tại Ngân hàng TMCP Ngoại Thương Việt Nam – Chi nhá...Quản lý quan hệ khách hàng tại Ngân hàng TMCP Ngoại Thương Việt Nam – Chi nhá...
Quản lý quan hệ khách hàng tại Ngân hàng TMCP Ngoại Thương Việt Nam – Chi nhá...
 
Luận văn: Nghiên cứu các yếu tố ảnh hưởng đến quyết định mua sắm trực tuyến
Luận văn: Nghiên cứu các yếu tố ảnh hưởng đến quyết định mua sắm trực tuyếnLuận văn: Nghiên cứu các yếu tố ảnh hưởng đến quyết định mua sắm trực tuyến
Luận văn: Nghiên cứu các yếu tố ảnh hưởng đến quyết định mua sắm trực tuyến
 
Đánh giá mức độ hài lòng của khách hàng đối với dịch vụ của hệ thống rạp chiế...
Đánh giá mức độ hài lòng của khách hàng đối với dịch vụ của hệ thống rạp chiế...Đánh giá mức độ hài lòng của khách hàng đối với dịch vụ của hệ thống rạp chiế...
Đánh giá mức độ hài lòng của khách hàng đối với dịch vụ của hệ thống rạp chiế...
 
Ảnh hưởng của thiết kế bao bì đến quyết định mua ngành hàng F&B
Ảnh hưởng của thiết kế bao bì đến quyết định mua ngành hàng F&BẢnh hưởng của thiết kế bao bì đến quyết định mua ngành hàng F&B
Ảnh hưởng của thiết kế bao bì đến quyết định mua ngành hàng F&B
 
Đề tài: Một số giải pháp nhằm hoàn thiện công tác Marketing Online cho Công t...
Đề tài: Một số giải pháp nhằm hoàn thiện công tác Marketing Online cho Công t...Đề tài: Một số giải pháp nhằm hoàn thiện công tác Marketing Online cho Công t...
Đề tài: Một số giải pháp nhằm hoàn thiện công tác Marketing Online cho Công t...
 
Đề tài: Nâng cao hiệu quả hoạt động marketing tại công ty Tâm Chiến
Đề tài: Nâng cao hiệu quả hoạt động marketing tại công ty Tâm ChiếnĐề tài: Nâng cao hiệu quả hoạt động marketing tại công ty Tâm Chiến
Đề tài: Nâng cao hiệu quả hoạt động marketing tại công ty Tâm Chiến
 
Luận văn: Giải pháp thu hút khách hàng tại siêu thị Thuận Thành, HAY
Luận văn: Giải pháp thu hút khách hàng tại siêu thị Thuận Thành, HAYLuận văn: Giải pháp thu hút khách hàng tại siêu thị Thuận Thành, HAY
Luận văn: Giải pháp thu hút khách hàng tại siêu thị Thuận Thành, HAY
 
Chuyên đề quy trình lựa chọn và quản lý nhà cung cấp
Chuyên đề quy trình lựa chọn và quản lý nhà cung cấpChuyên đề quy trình lựa chọn và quản lý nhà cung cấp
Chuyên đề quy trình lựa chọn và quản lý nhà cung cấp
 
Quản trị quan hệ khách hàng tại công ty Bảo Việt Đà Nẵng
Quản trị quan hệ khách hàng tại công ty Bảo Việt Đà NẵngQuản trị quan hệ khách hàng tại công ty Bảo Việt Đà Nẵng
Quản trị quan hệ khách hàng tại công ty Bảo Việt Đà Nẵng
 
Hoạt động marketing hỗn hợp của Tổng công ty dịch vụ viễn thông Vinaphone đối...
Hoạt động marketing hỗn hợp của Tổng công ty dịch vụ viễn thông Vinaphone đối...Hoạt động marketing hỗn hợp của Tổng công ty dịch vụ viễn thông Vinaphone đối...
Hoạt động marketing hỗn hợp của Tổng công ty dịch vụ viễn thông Vinaphone đối...
 
Marketing Của Công Ty Bảo Việt Nhân Thọ Hà Nội
Marketing Của Công Ty Bảo Việt Nhân Thọ Hà NộiMarketing Của Công Ty Bảo Việt Nhân Thọ Hà Nội
Marketing Của Công Ty Bảo Việt Nhân Thọ Hà Nội
 
Mẫu lập dự án đầu tư và phát triển hệ thống logistics
Mẫu lập dự án đầu tư và phát triển hệ thống logisticsMẫu lập dự án đầu tư và phát triển hệ thống logistics
Mẫu lập dự án đầu tư và phát triển hệ thống logistics
 
Tiểu luận xây dựng chiến lược kinh doanh của công ty vinamil đến năm 2020_Nhậ...
Tiểu luận xây dựng chiến lược kinh doanh của công ty vinamil đến năm 2020_Nhậ...Tiểu luận xây dựng chiến lược kinh doanh của công ty vinamil đến năm 2020_Nhậ...
Tiểu luận xây dựng chiến lược kinh doanh của công ty vinamil đến năm 2020_Nhậ...
 
Luận văn: Thực trạng hoạt động marketing công ty thuốc thú y, HAY
Luận văn: Thực trạng hoạt động marketing công ty thuốc thú y, HAYLuận văn: Thực trạng hoạt động marketing công ty thuốc thú y, HAY
Luận văn: Thực trạng hoạt động marketing công ty thuốc thú y, HAY
 
Thuyết minh dự án Khu Trung tâm Logistics Chu Lai tỉnh Quảng Nam 0918755356
Thuyết minh dự án Khu Trung tâm Logistics Chu Lai tỉnh Quảng Nam 0918755356Thuyết minh dự án Khu Trung tâm Logistics Chu Lai tỉnh Quảng Nam 0918755356
Thuyết minh dự án Khu Trung tâm Logistics Chu Lai tỉnh Quảng Nam 0918755356
 

Similar to Bachelor Thesis - Sales Strategy, Innovation Living

Final COM 440 project
Final COM 440 projectFinal COM 440 project
Final COM 440 project
Westley Casey
 
Us engleski jezik i
Us   engleski jezik iUs   engleski jezik i
Us engleski jezik i
Marija Starcevic
 
Assessment of Juvenile Justice Reform Achievements in Kyrgyzstan
Assessment of Juvenile Justice Reform Achievements in KyrgyzstanAssessment of Juvenile Justice Reform Achievements in Kyrgyzstan
Assessment of Juvenile Justice Reform Achievements in Kyrgyzstan
UNICEF Europe & Central Asia
 
STEM report_ 20 October 2015 (2)
STEM report_ 20 October 2015 (2)STEM report_ 20 October 2015 (2)
STEM report_ 20 October 2015 (2)
Ministeriet for Børn, Undervisning og Ligestilling
 
Identification of Opportunities for Norwegian Businesses in Enhancement of Va...
Identification of Opportunities for Norwegian Businesses in Enhancement of Va...Identification of Opportunities for Norwegian Businesses in Enhancement of Va...
Identification of Opportunities for Norwegian Businesses in Enhancement of Va...
RICHARDBONYO1
 
International innovators business plan
International innovators business planInternational innovators business plan
International innovators business plan
jitharadharmesh
 
FINNISH SPORT SPONSORSHIP AND SPONSORED SOCIAL MEDIA CONTENT
FINNISH SPORT SPONSORSHIP AND SPONSORED SOCIAL MEDIA CONTENTFINNISH SPORT SPONSORSHIP AND SPONSORED SOCIAL MEDIA CONTENT
FINNISH SPORT SPONSORSHIP AND SPONSORED SOCIAL MEDIA CONTENT
Laura Peltonen
 
Luxembourg 18112008 formation_professionnelle_en
Luxembourg 18112008 formation_professionnelle_enLuxembourg 18112008 formation_professionnelle_en
Luxembourg 18112008 formation_professionnelle_en
Dr Lendy Spires
 
Sask. Kindergarten Curriculum
Sask. Kindergarten CurriculumSask. Kindergarten Curriculum
Sask. Kindergarten Curriculum
susan70
 
Internship Report some solutions to attract more customers to come to torino ...
Internship Report some solutions to attract more customers to come to torino ...Internship Report some solutions to attract more customers to come to torino ...
Internship Report some solutions to attract more customers to come to torino ...
Dịch vụ viết thuê đề tài trọn gói 👍👍 Liên hệ Zalo/Tele: 0917.193.864
 
2016 Direct Marketing Team A
2016 Direct Marketing Team A2016 Direct Marketing Team A
2016 Direct Marketing Team A
Skip Spoerke
 
THE DIGITAL TURN Pathways for higher education in the digital age
THE DIGITAL TURN Pathways for higher education in the digital ageTHE DIGITAL TURN Pathways for higher education in the digital age
THE DIGITAL TURN Pathways for higher education in the digital age
eraser Juan José Calderón
 
Universal Studios -Strategic Business Proposal
Universal Studios -Strategic Business ProposalUniversal Studios -Strategic Business Proposal
Universal Studios -Strategic Business Proposal
Doral Peoples
 
Serving Up Justice: How to Design an Emergency Feeding Program and Build Comm...
Serving Up Justice: How to Design an Emergency Feeding Program and Build Comm...Serving Up Justice: How to Design an Emergency Feeding Program and Build Comm...
Serving Up Justice: How to Design an Emergency Feeding Program and Build Comm...
School Vegetable Gardening - Victory Gardens
 
Serving Up Food Justice at School: How to Design an Emergency Feeding Program...
Serving Up Food Justice at School: How to Design an Emergency Feeding Program...Serving Up Food Justice at School: How to Design an Emergency Feeding Program...
Serving Up Food Justice at School: How to Design an Emergency Feeding Program...
School Vegetable Gardening - Victory Gardens
 
Gloabal Panorama on Postal Financial Inclusion: Business Model and Key Issues
Gloabal Panorama on Postal Financial Inclusion: Business Model and Key IssuesGloabal Panorama on Postal Financial Inclusion: Business Model and Key Issues
Gloabal Panorama on Postal Financial Inclusion: Business Model and Key Issues
Dr Lendy Spires
 
Event
EventEvent
Event
rishirai13
 
Advertising Specialties Impressions Study 2014
Advertising Specialties Impressions Study 2014Advertising Specialties Impressions Study 2014
Advertising Specialties Impressions Study 2014
The J Paul Company
 
BIC_Brand Analysis
BIC_Brand AnalysisBIC_Brand Analysis
BIC_Brand Analysis
Eitai Ben-Natan
 
Yellowhead Brewery FINAL (2)
Yellowhead Brewery FINAL (2)Yellowhead Brewery FINAL (2)
Yellowhead Brewery FINAL (2)
Alastair Lillico
 

Similar to Bachelor Thesis - Sales Strategy, Innovation Living (20)

Final COM 440 project
Final COM 440 projectFinal COM 440 project
Final COM 440 project
 
Us engleski jezik i
Us   engleski jezik iUs   engleski jezik i
Us engleski jezik i
 
Assessment of Juvenile Justice Reform Achievements in Kyrgyzstan
Assessment of Juvenile Justice Reform Achievements in KyrgyzstanAssessment of Juvenile Justice Reform Achievements in Kyrgyzstan
Assessment of Juvenile Justice Reform Achievements in Kyrgyzstan
 
STEM report_ 20 October 2015 (2)
STEM report_ 20 October 2015 (2)STEM report_ 20 October 2015 (2)
STEM report_ 20 October 2015 (2)
 
Identification of Opportunities for Norwegian Businesses in Enhancement of Va...
Identification of Opportunities for Norwegian Businesses in Enhancement of Va...Identification of Opportunities for Norwegian Businesses in Enhancement of Va...
Identification of Opportunities for Norwegian Businesses in Enhancement of Va...
 
International innovators business plan
International innovators business planInternational innovators business plan
International innovators business plan
 
FINNISH SPORT SPONSORSHIP AND SPONSORED SOCIAL MEDIA CONTENT
FINNISH SPORT SPONSORSHIP AND SPONSORED SOCIAL MEDIA CONTENTFINNISH SPORT SPONSORSHIP AND SPONSORED SOCIAL MEDIA CONTENT
FINNISH SPORT SPONSORSHIP AND SPONSORED SOCIAL MEDIA CONTENT
 
Luxembourg 18112008 formation_professionnelle_en
Luxembourg 18112008 formation_professionnelle_enLuxembourg 18112008 formation_professionnelle_en
Luxembourg 18112008 formation_professionnelle_en
 
Sask. Kindergarten Curriculum
Sask. Kindergarten CurriculumSask. Kindergarten Curriculum
Sask. Kindergarten Curriculum
 
Internship Report some solutions to attract more customers to come to torino ...
Internship Report some solutions to attract more customers to come to torino ...Internship Report some solutions to attract more customers to come to torino ...
Internship Report some solutions to attract more customers to come to torino ...
 
2016 Direct Marketing Team A
2016 Direct Marketing Team A2016 Direct Marketing Team A
2016 Direct Marketing Team A
 
THE DIGITAL TURN Pathways for higher education in the digital age
THE DIGITAL TURN Pathways for higher education in the digital ageTHE DIGITAL TURN Pathways for higher education in the digital age
THE DIGITAL TURN Pathways for higher education in the digital age
 
Universal Studios -Strategic Business Proposal
Universal Studios -Strategic Business ProposalUniversal Studios -Strategic Business Proposal
Universal Studios -Strategic Business Proposal
 
Serving Up Justice: How to Design an Emergency Feeding Program and Build Comm...
Serving Up Justice: How to Design an Emergency Feeding Program and Build Comm...Serving Up Justice: How to Design an Emergency Feeding Program and Build Comm...
Serving Up Justice: How to Design an Emergency Feeding Program and Build Comm...
 
Serving Up Food Justice at School: How to Design an Emergency Feeding Program...
Serving Up Food Justice at School: How to Design an Emergency Feeding Program...Serving Up Food Justice at School: How to Design an Emergency Feeding Program...
Serving Up Food Justice at School: How to Design an Emergency Feeding Program...
 
Gloabal Panorama on Postal Financial Inclusion: Business Model and Key Issues
Gloabal Panorama on Postal Financial Inclusion: Business Model and Key IssuesGloabal Panorama on Postal Financial Inclusion: Business Model and Key Issues
Gloabal Panorama on Postal Financial Inclusion: Business Model and Key Issues
 
Event
EventEvent
Event
 
Advertising Specialties Impressions Study 2014
Advertising Specialties Impressions Study 2014Advertising Specialties Impressions Study 2014
Advertising Specialties Impressions Study 2014
 
BIC_Brand Analysis
BIC_Brand AnalysisBIC_Brand Analysis
BIC_Brand Analysis
 
Yellowhead Brewery FINAL (2)
Yellowhead Brewery FINAL (2)Yellowhead Brewery FINAL (2)
Yellowhead Brewery FINAL (2)
 

Bachelor Thesis - Sales Strategy, Innovation Living

  • 1. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 Author: Martin Milkov Malakov /Date of Birth: 11.10.1992/ PBA of International Sales and Marketing Management Tutor: Torben Ibsen Uldall Sorensen Final Bachelor’s Project PBA of International Sales and Marketing Management Business Academy Aarhus 2nd of January 2017 Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 Number of characters: 96490 Sales Strategy for the Bulgarian Market
  • 2. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 Contents List of Appendences ......................................................................................................................-1 Executive Summary.........................................................................................................................0 1. Introduction ................................................................................................................................1 1.1. Problem Formulation.......................................................................................................1 1.2. Report Structure...............................................................................................................1 2. Methodology ........................................................................................................................1 2.1. Research Objectives.........................................................................................................2 2.2. Research Paradigm ..........................................................................................................2 2.3. Approach ..........................................................................................................................2 2.4. Method..............................................................................................................................2 2.5. Strategy.............................................................................................................................2 2.6. Time horizon....................................................................................................................2 2.7. Theory and models..........................................................................................................2 2.8. Sources .............................................................................................................................3 2.9. Quality assessment..........................................................................................................4 3. Literature Review .................................................................................................................5 3.1. Market Definition .............................................................................................................5 3.2. Growth Matrix – H. Igor Ansoff.......................................................................................5 3.3. International Growth – why do businesses choose to pursue it?.................................6 3.4. Entry Strategies – how do businesses expand internationally?....................................6 3.5. Export – Direct and Indirect ............................................................................................7 3.6. Distribution Channels......................................................................................................7 3.7. Developing a sales strategy ............................................................................................8 3.8. Cultural Dimensions, affects and considerations .......................................................13 4. Innovation Living’s Business Model .................................................................................16 4.1. Customer Segments ......................................................................................................17 4.2. Value Proposition...........................................................................................................17 4.3. Channels.........................................................................................................................18 4.3.1. Distribution Channels............................................................................................18 4.4. Customer relationships .................................................................................................18 4.5. Revenue Streams............................................................................................................18 4.6. Key Resources ................................................................................................................19 4.6.1. Human resources ...................................................................................................19 4.6.2. Intellectual resources.............................................................................................19 4.6.3. Physical resources..................................................................................................19 4.6.4. Financial resources ................................................................................................19 4.7. Key Activities..................................................................................................................19 4.8. Key Partnerships ............................................................................................................19
  • 3. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 4.9. Cost Structure ................................................................................................................20 5. External Analysis ...............................................................................................................20 5.1. PESTLE.............................................................................................................................20 5.1.1 Economic factors..............................................................................................................20 5.1.2 Social factors: ..................................................................................................................22 5.1.3 Legal factors: ...................................................................................................................22 5.2. Porter's Five Forces........................................................................................................23 5.2.1. Supplier Bargaining Power - Moderate 5/10 ........................................................23 5.2.2. Buyer Bargaining Power - High 8/10 ....................................................................24 5.2.3. Threat of Substitution 1/10 ..................................................................................24 5.2.4. Threat of New Entry 8/10......................................................................................24 5.2.5. Competitive Rivalry - High 9/10............................................................................25 5.2.6. Attractiveness of the furniture Industry 4/10......................................................25 5.3. ADL Matrix......................................................................................................................26 5.4. Analysis of the Competitors in Bulgaria.......................................................................26 5.4.1 Local Competition ........................................................................................................27 5.4.2 Foreign competition on the Bulgarian furniture market ...........................................27 5.5. Organizational Customer’s Analysis ............................................................................29 5.6 Market Trends and Demand for Design Danish Furniture in Bulgaria............................30 5.7. Bulgarian Culture according to Hofstede’s Six Cultural Dimensions ............................30 6. Insights Based on the Conducted Semi-structured Interviews.......................................32 7. SWOT – is market penetration the way to go?.................................................................33 8. Segmentation, Targeting and Positioning ..............................................................................33 8.1 Segmentation ......................................................................................................................33 8.2 Targeting .............................................................................................................................34 8.3 Positioning...........................................................................................................................35 9. Market Penetration Strategy for the Bulgarian Market - Balanced Scorecard.......................36 9.1 Learning and Growth Perspective ......................................................................................37 9.1.1 Hire a Sales Representative .........................................................................................37 9.1.2 Training Skills and Development ................................................................................38 9.2 Internal Perspective.............................................................................................................38 9.2.1 Develop a sales strategy..............................................................................................38 9.2.2 Improve work efficiency...............................................................................................39 9.3 Customer perspective.........................................................................................................39 9.3.1 Acquire new retailers to act as authorized dealers in Bulgaria; ...............................39 9.3.2 Build long-term relationships......................................................................................39 9.4 Financial perspective ..........................................................................................................39 10. Conclusion ..............................................................................................................................40 Bibliography.....................................................................................................................................1
  • 4. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 List of Appendences Appendix 1 – Project Description; Appendix 2 – Questions for Semi-Structured Interviews; Appendix 3 – Essence of the Held Interviews Relevant to the Assignment; Appendix 4 – Contact Details of the Interviewees; Appendix 5 – Sales Figures Table from Innovation Living; Appendix 6 – Innovation Living’ Sales Prices for Retailers; Appendix 7 – Strategy Map & Balanced Score Card; *Appendences are uploaded as separate documents and are not included in this document.
  • 5. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 Executive Summary Innovation Living is a Danish Design Furniture Manufacturer since 1972. Innovation specializes in producing compact, functional and comfortable sofa/beds for small living spaces. It has production facilities in Denmark and China and sells its products globally. However, most of the revenue in Europe comes from Western Europe. Even Though Innovation operates in some parts of Eastern Europe, the markets there are considered new and are yet to be developed and the full potential of them to be reached. This report will combine market research with the best sales theories from modern academic literature and will suggest how to increase the sales in the Bulgarian market in the future. The report first presents a Literature review. In the literature review there are different relevant for the research definitions included. Moreover, concepts and models supporting the later on given recommendations are described, so that the researcher’s knowledge base is supported. Further, an internal analysis of Innovation Living is made through the business model canvas in order to receive a better understanding of the company’s structure and current situation. The business model shows that the company is financially healthy and that it has the necessary structure, experience and current activities that will support a penetration of the Bulgarian market. The external analysis made examines the country profile of Bulgaria, the competitive landscape and consumer behaviour. It also looks at the cultural considerations. Even though the social and economic situation in Bulgaria is not that “pink” at the moment, the outlooks for the near future are positive and also there are other pluses like low taxes and cheap labour that makes the market attractive. The poverty in Bulgaria might be high, but as Innovation Living is targeting a niche of people with higher income, it is not a factor that matters, as there are still many affluent people in the Bulgarian society. In terms of competition, it is highly saturated market in general, but there are still not that many resembling offerings and room to grow. The field research indicated that retailers have interest to and do work with foreign importers, but that they would prefer to communicate with a native representative. Overall the analysis point out that there is market for Innovation Living, but the company will have to do more aggressive sales. The cultural differences between Bulgaria and Denmark are quite big that is why it is proposed for the company to enter the market directly with its own sales force. Innovation Living will have to search for and hire a Bulgarian sales rep that will be responsible for the company activities in Bulgaria. The company has this practice for its UK and Benelux markets. It will also take advantage of its newly built production facilities in Ukraine. In the long-term the experience in the Bulgarian market can be further used to enter or enhance current activities in other similar Eastern European markets.
  • 6. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 1 1. Introduction Innovation Living is a Danish Design Furniture Manufacturer since 1972. Innovation specializes in producing compact, functional and comfortable sofa/beds for small living spaces. It has production facilities in Denmark and China and sells its products globally. However, most of the revenue in Europe comes from Western Europe. Even Though Innovation operates in some parts of Eastern Europe, the markets there are considered new and are yet to be developed and the full potential of them to be reached. This report will combine market research with the best sales theories from modern academic literature and will suggest how to increase the sales in the Bulgarian market. 1.1. Problem Formulation  How can Innovation A/S improve its sales in Bulgaria? 1.2. Report Structure The report will be following the structure below: (See figure 1.1); Figure 1.1: Structure of the report Source: Own Production; 2. Methodology This chapter follows Richard Brook’s eleven step model of research design to plan and present the methodological background of the research. (Brooks, 2013); (See figure 2.1); Figure 2.1: The eleven step model of research; Source: Brooks; Methodology Literature Review Situation Analysis Strategy Conclusion
  • 7. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 2 2.1. Research Objectives  What is the current situation of Innovation Living both from internal perspective in the organisation, and from external perspective assessing the furniture industry and the Bulgarian furniture market?  How Innovation Living can improve its overall competitiveness in Bulgaria?  Who are the most attractive potential customers of Innovation Living in the Bulgarian market?  How the distanced Bulgarian market could be managed most effectively and by whom?  What strategic objectives Innovation Living could implement in order to improve its market position in Bulgaria?  How Innovation Living can measure the performance on the Bulgarian market? 2.2. Research Paradigm The report will follow a critical realism paradigm. It is about observing the cause and effect. The sales at EEU are low, what would happen if a new sales strategy is implemented? This question is followed from the paradigm and related to the case of this report. How can the ongoing business process to be improved? The Critical Realism paradigm will help to get better insight of what has to be improved. 2.3. Approach The approach that the research follows is a deductive approach. (Brooks, 2013) A set of assumptions are made based on the researcher’s inside information from Innovation Living and the company experience with the Bulgarian market and other markets the company is operating in. They will be proven throughout the report, either right or wrong, and will be considered when recommendations are given. A1: Having direct presence in the market will increase the company’s success in the market in terms of attracting more partners A2: Expanding the number of distribution channels in the market will result in bigger reach, thus attracting new customers and overall increase in sales. A3: Having a native sales representative will help the company to overcome the culture barriers and will also contribute with inside knowledge of the market and consumers. 2.4. Method The choice of data method gathering is through a multimethod qualitative study, as semi- structured interviews will be conducted both in person and phone. 2.5. Strategy The strategy of the research is chosen to be a case study as the goal is to receive a rich understanding of the research topic. (Brooks, 2013); 2.6. Time horizon The time horizon of the research is a cross-sectional as it was conducted in the range of few consecutive months – three months in Denmark. 2.7.Theory and models An internal analysis of the company and its operations will be made using the canvas business model. The strategy will be analysed based using Porter’s Genic Strategy Matrix, The Anssoff Grow strategy matrix, the Value Strategy, Degree of Internationalization For conducting a meaningful external analysis a PESTLE will analyse the market environment in Bulgaria. Implementation of the Porter's Five Forces Industry analysis will be define the
  • 8. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 3 attractiveness of the industry and be a solid base to assess the level of competition within the furniture industry. Gather relevant data through desk research to collect valuable insights of the Bulgarian furniture market such as market indicators, trends, consumers. Competitor Analysis will be made to find out the direct competitors, benchmark Innovation Livings competences and product features with firms from the competition. Evaluate the competitive advantages of the domestic competitors and the international firms penetrating the market. Focus on delivering more customer satisfaction than the competitors and gain market share. ADL Matrix is applied to determine the current place of Innovation Living in its relatively new Bulgarian market. The Hofstede 6 Cultural dimensions analysis is used to evaluate the both the Danish and Bulgarian culture and to compare them, pointing the essential cultural differences that have to be considered when doing business; B2B Customer Analysis is critical for Innovation Living success on the market. Identifying well established retailers with reputation and strong position on the market, also understand their buying behaviour, the buying process and also the preferences when relating to a new supplier. Essential part of the report is devoted to sales. Theory and models related to sales techniques, sales planning, and consultative sellers vs transactional sellers. The Spin Model is also included. The process of salesmen recruitment is explained. A competence profile of a sale agent, aligned to fulfil a demanding role at Innovation Living as a foreign sales agent. The strategy map framework is used to create a workable market penetration strategy of Innovation Living for penetrating the Bulgarian market. All the four perspectives are of a the strategy are developed and aligned to the specifics of the market and the company operations in order Innovation Living to reach its potential in Bulgaria. The Balanced Score Card is used for measuring the performance of the company while implementing the new strategy. In order the strategy to deliver the desired outcome, the targets specified in the balance score card has to be fulfilled. 2.8.Sources The sources used in this research are both primary and secondary sources. The secondary sources consist of academic journal articles, international publications and academic books. The primary sources used are the public company information, the information acquired during the 3 month internship within the sales department. Field research in Bulgaria was executed, during which a sufficient amount of data was collected. Activities undertaken during the field research are company and showrooms visits, observing both the businesses and consumers shaping the industry and the supply of furniture, more precisely sofa/beds. Taking into account the price/quality, customization and functionality; Five semi-structured interviews with individuals involved in companies operating as resellers in Bulgaria were performed. The goal was to get valuable information from companies which are potential customers of Innovation Living In Bulgaria and are part of its target group. (See Appendices 2,3,4); The research could have been more extensive by conducting more interviews, but due to the time frame and the nature of the contacts, it was not possible to gather more.
  • 9. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 4 2.9. Quality assessment The reliability and validity of the research is assured by using mainly five star academic journal articles, reliable online sources and research conducted by verified institutions. The primary data gathered also adds up to the reliability of the outcome of the research.
  • 10. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 5 3. Literature Review Validating the potential of a specific foreign market is one of the elements when expanding to foreign markets. Introducing a product to a new market also comes with the need of taking difficult decision - how should the company market their product. (Erin Anderson). First to start more broadly by defining the word “market” will be given. 3.1. Market Definition Market: “Markets include mechanisms or means for (1) determining price of the traded item, (2) communicating the price information, (3) facilitating deals and transactions, and (4) effecting distribution. The market for a particular item is made up of existing and potential customers who need it and have the ability and willingness to pay for it.” (Business Dictionary, 2013); The four points that are outlined in the above definition of market should be taken into account in the forming of a strategy not only when a new business is developed, but also when a company wants to enter a new market or penetrate the one that is already operating in. To make it more specific a definition of a business market will be given: Business markets: “Markets for products and services, local to international, bought by businesses, government bodies, and institutions for incorporation, for use or for resale. The main differences between business marketing and consumer marketing are the nature of the customers and how they use the product. “(Hutt Speh, 2014) Having defined what markets and business markets are it is relevant to take a look how an already operating company within a B2B market can grow. 3.2. Growth Matrix – H. Igor Ansoff According to the Ansoff Matrix developed by H. Igor Ansoff, found in the article “Strategies for Diversification”, there are four strategies that companies can use to grow and each on carries a higher risk.(See figure 3.1); Figure 3.1: Ansoff Growth Matrix; Source: Mind Tools, 2016; Market penetration carries the lowest risk, making it the safes of all the options. The growth here consists of expansion of the sales in a market that the company already operates in. Product development is a bit more risky as it involves the introduction of a new product in an already penetrated market.
  • 11. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 6 Market development consists of introducing an existing product to a new market, which increases the risk. Last but not least, Diversification is the riskiest one as it consists of introducing a untested product to a completely new market the knowledge for which is not sufficient. It will depend on the company goals and current capabilities to choose the best fitting growth strategy. As many of the barriers in the last 20th century related to international trade fell, many business began to pursue global strategies in order to gain competitive advantage. Magdalea Kakol); 3.3. International Growth – why do businesses choose to pursue it? The most common reasons for companies going international are growth or expansion. International strategies may benefit the business by helping to diversify it and expand it. (Katarzyna Twarowska). Going global also reduces the uncertainty of the local and national markets (demand upturns and downturns for example.) Hence, the company does not need to rely only on the current market that it is in. (Elmuti D., Kathawala Y.2001); There are two main approaches to going international – through an international strategy or a global strategy. (Yip G. 2002); International strategy is basically working through international subsidiaries that act as they were local companies and have minimum coordination from the parent company. Global strategy on the other hand, consists of a wide variety of business strategies that have a high level of adaptation to local business environment,(Ktarzyna Twarowska) It is basically a general strategy that can be easily manipulated to fit different local environments when necessary. 3.4. Entry Strategies – how do businesses expand internationally? To go back to the beginning of the literature review, when expanding a business to a foreign market, one of the biggest challenges and decisions to be taken is how to enter the market. There are several types of entry strategies that are summarized under two major types and differ by the level of risk involved: (Terpstra V., Sarathy R. 2001); 1) Non-equity mode – includes export and contractual agreements; 2) Equity mode – includes joint venture and wholly owned subsidiaries (Terpstra V., Sarathy R. 2001); Figure 3.2: Entry Strategies Source: Hutt Speh, 2014; The entry technique that is the least risky and has the least market control is Import and Export. (See figure 3.2) On the other side of the spectrum are the Direct Investments that usually constitute of acquisitions (also referred as Brownfield) or to build its own facilities
  • 12. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 7 (known as Greenfield investment). Direct investments carry the highest risk, but also the highest market control and expected ROI (return on investment) (Terpstra V., Sarathy R. 2001); There are six types of entry strategies on the spectrum that all differ in risk, market involvement, resources required, legal complications, competitive aspect, access to market knowledge and potential ROI. The entry strategies are as follows: (Terpstra V., Sarathy R. 2001).  Exporting and importing  Licensing  Franchising  Joint Ventures  Strategic alliances  Direct Investments For the purpose of the report and to stay relevant, only the Exporting entry strategy will be further discussed. 3.5. Export – Direct and Indirect As clarified earlier, this strategy is the least risky and the most commonly used one. It is the process of selling goods or services produced in one market to other markets. ,(Ktarzyna Twarowska,2013). Two types of exporting exist – direct and indirect. Indirect export involves other agents to market the products to the foreign market, while in direct export the company becomes directly involved in marketing its products to the foreign market. (Hutt Speh, 2014); Exporting is a good strategy when a company doesn’t have sufficient amount of resources to make a significant commitment to the market, wants to minimize the risks related to politics and economy and also is not that familiar with the requirements of the market and the culture. (Hutt Speh, 2014); The question that a company can ask at this point is, should the product be distributed through a company-owned distribution channel or it would be more efficient to outsource distribution to an independent organization? 3.6. Distribution Channels Channel of distribution, also referred to as a marketing channel, is: “A group of individuals and organizations that direct the flow of products from producers to customers.” (Hutt Speh, 2014); Most of these marketing channels have the so called marketing intermediaries (or middle man) that are divided into two types – agents and brokers. (Hutt Speh, 2014) In the case of this report, the company already collaborates with middleman to sell its products.(Innovation Living, 2016) Therefore the report will not focus on discussing this aspect of the distribution channels, but it will look further how the company can more adequately approach and attract more middleman to collaborate with. Back to the question – owned salesforce or independent organization? The former option, an integrated channel, gives the business more control than the latter, the independent organization. Having an ownership over the salesforce provides the entrant
  • 13. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 8 with full control, but it also brings responsibility, commitment and attendant risks. (Ahmed 1977). There are several factors that would influence the choice, as each one of them depending on the situation would weigh the scale to one side or the other: (Erin Anderson, Anne T. Coughlan, 1987);  Service requirements  Government pressure – using local agents when available  Product category age  Task-specialized knowledge and relationships  Transactional Costs  Market knowledge  Strength of patents  Competitive behaviour  The country in question It is more likely a business to choose an integration of the distribution when: - There is a greater level of transaction-specific assets in the sales force - The less mature the product category - The higher the service level associated with the product - The less prevalent legal restrictions - When there is an integrated distribution channel already in place - The importance of the product is high – is it the core one for the business? - The more important the trade secrets - The more competitors have integrated distribution channels in the foreign market - The more similar the culture of the home market is to the culture of country being entered. (Erin Anderson, Anne T. Coughlan, 1987) When the company decides to operate through an integrated salesforce, even if that involves hiring a local sales representative, it will need to create a sales strategy that will be in line with its marketing plan, will be complied with the business plan and will support the overall strategic plan of the company. (JWPM Consulting, 2013) 3.7. Developing a sales strategy A sales strategy has to be very detailed and specific otherwise it is simply a marketing plan. It has to be clear who is doing what, when and where and most importantly, it must have targets. A sales plan is: “An operational plan that identifies how the annual sales revenue budget will be achieved by aggregating sales budgets by customer, territory, and sales representative and listing the week to week activity required to achieve the sales budgets.” The sales plan is organized around a list of revenues sources and the customers should be grouped the following way: (See Table 3.3);
  • 14. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 9 Table 3.3: Customer Grouping; Existing customers The 80/20 rule usually applies that is 80% of revenue is derived from 20% of customers. The sales representative should be able to make a judgement about how much each customer is expected to buy in over a year. Identified new customers Create a list of the sales target for a year from which 25% might become customers. As yet not identified new customers Allocate an allowance in for growth as yet not identified future customers Major projects Depending on the type of company, make an allowance for major project revenue. Source: Own Production; Setting up a sales plan serves as a great management tool to help forecast the annual sales revenue, to achieve face-to-face visits, to identify how many sales reps are needed and what the purpose of each sales visit would be. (JWPM Consulting, 2013); The content of good sales plan content should contain the following aspects: - Sales strategy The company needs to create a general statement for the sales strategy that will reflect the strategic direction of the organisation. - Sales Model There are many ways to structure the sales departments. One of the most common models used is “every man for himself”. On the selling spectrum there are two types of sales approaches - transactional or collaborative (William Walker, 2016) Depending on the type of business, customers and goals, the sales model can be transactional oriented or relationship oriented (collaborative) which will influence the level of sophistication, the number of employees involved and the amount of time in the sales process. Transactional selling approach Simply put, a transactional sale is a short-term sale in which the buyer knows already exactly what he needs. (John Tabita, 2012)The main decision criteria are price, features and availability and the significance of the sales person very often diminishes. The person selling will know the product and its price, but it won’t be required to convince the purchaser. (William Walker, 2016); Consultative selling approach Consultative selling approach is also referred to as strategic, solution, complex, relationship and even enterprise selling. (Ed Warner, 2009) It is long-term oriented, usually more than one decision maker is involved and the focus is put on the value. The questions is not what the customer is buying, but why. Not like in transactional selling, here the salesperson will need to be very well educated about the product or service in question. Moreover, to know more about the customer, what are the goals of the customer’s business and the results that need to be achieved. When the customer is not very certain about exactly what he/she needs, the salesperson becomes a coach that helps the customer to establish goals and objectives and create an action plan that will deliver results. (William Walker, 2016);
  • 15. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 10 The table below presents an overview of the differences between transactional selling and consultative selling: (See table 3.4); Table 3.4: Transactional vs. Consultative Selling; Source: John Tabita, 2012 As consultative selling requires higher level of knowledge about the customer and what he/she are aiming for, there are models that can be used to enhance the sales person’s techniques. The SPIN selling model was developed by Neil Rackham in 1998, after conducting a vast research for 12 years about how large sales were made. One of the biggest findings is that in sales calls it is the buyer who does most of the talking, which on its hand happens by asking the buyer questions. But it is not about asking any kind of questions, the sales person should ask certain type of questions and follow a certain flow. (See Figure 3.5); Figure 3.5: SPIN Selling Model Source: Strategic Learning, 2013;
  • 16. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 11 SPIN stands for: -Situation (questions) - to find out facts about the existing situation of the customer. -Problem (questions) – to find about what problem the buyer is experiencing in this current situation. -Implication (questions) – to make the customer think about the consequences and effects of the current problems. -Need-payoff (questions) – to make the buyer focus on the solutions and the value of the proposed solution. What the creator of the SPIN selling model himself recommends is that a sales person should always stay flexible and adapt the speech and the questions according to the specific situation. It is not always necessary to follow the order of the SPIN questions in a strict order. (Hutt Speh, 2014); Another article introduces a concept that serves as an enhancement to the SPIN selling model, called Social Style model. The model enhances SPIN in three main ways – the sales person applying a certain style to the selling situation, recognizing and managing the buyer’s style behaviours and practicing versatility. Practicing style awareness improves sales people abilities to ask the right questions thus achieve better success rate and versatility supports all aspects of client management and selling situations. (Hutt Speh, 2014); - Territory plan It is important to segment the sales territory so that the resources and time are allocated effectively to maximise the sales outcome. The sales territories can be segmented by geography, industry, customer type, product type and customer size. The choice made can have a huge impact over sales outcomes. Figure 3.6: Sales Opportunities Grid Source: LaForge and Carvens, 1982
  • 17. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 12 Figure 3.7: 7 step process - Significant sales opportunities Each sales plan for the year should have identified and contain the so called “largest” opportunities for the business and a more detailed plan should be prepared to capture them. The matrix on the previous page gives an overview on how to allocate the sales resource depending on the PCU opportunity. (See figure 3.6); - Sales Budget The sales budget should contain considerations for at least 12 months and sales targets for sources of sales growth. - Sales Activity Plan A plan for the activity of each sales rep should be prepared that will match the goal of achieving the targets in the Sales Budget. - Sales Tactics Sales tactics may include different considerations such as new initiatives designed to increase the effectiveness of the sales activity. As well, cultural considerations, which are very important when conducting sales in foreign markets? - Resource plan This plan provides a detailed month over month budget of the sales department expenses: number of sales reps needed, support staff, equipment purchases, etc. Under this section an outline of the recruitment plan can also be included, if new sales reps need to be employed. The recruitment process consists of 7 Steps: (See Figure 3.7); Determine the number of sales employees needed Identify the unique skills, knowledge and personality required for the job Attract a sufficient number of candidates Produce one interview process that accurately reveals qualifications Provide employment for one or more candidates Introduction of new employee for the job Follow-up on performance in the job What should be taken into consideration for sales force composition and number? What preparations should the company make? How does a company get sufficiently applications? What sources are there for a company to make use of in order to find possible candidates? What tools can a company use? Considerations about the interview process How can interview process look like? What the company must take into consideration when a candidate is offered a job? What the company must take into consideration when a new employee to be introduced in the job? What needs to be followed up? Source: Own Production
  • 18. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 13 - Sales incentives Create a scheme of incentives for the sales representatives and the costs should be considered in the resource plan. Incentives can take different forms. Apart from the fixed salary and pension, the company can also offer a variable salary such as: provision, bonuses, paid company car, EBIDA or stock options. There can also be other benefits like free phone, health insurance, massage/fitness or it can be reverences related to the work like parental leave or care taking days. (Jobber & Lancaster) Also career development aspects such as company paid courses, coaching, teambuilding and etc. Related to the compensation, for the sales reps it is very common practice to receive a form of a variable salary next to the fixed one. It is also referred to as performance based remuneration. When developing a plan about performance based remuneration, it has to be decided upon the period, goals, measurements, information access, the size of the bonus, when it is paid and termination details. The periods can be monthly, quarterly, yearly or individual for a very specific target. (Jobber & Lancaster) - Training plan The training plan in general should be ongoing for any sales department. It will contain all the training activities planned, participants, cost of the training, schedule and impact on other related activities. - Operations plan This plan contains everything related to working space, equipment needed to conduct the tasks, software etc. This plan also can contain expenses and other capital discussions. - Selling expense summary The total costs for each month are summarized and listed. Having discussed how to organize a salesforce, it is also very important to take a look at the cultural factors and considerations that the new sales reps will need to take into account if expanding to a foreign market. 3.8. Cultural Dimensions, affects and considerations Culture, cultural differences and the influence of national cultures play an important role in International Business (IB) field and over the last three decades have been widely studied. The research paper by Reis, Ferreira, Santos and Serra (2013) examine different cultural models and present the definition of culture given by Hofstede (1980): “[t]he collective programming of the mind which distinguishes the members of one human group from another, … the interactive aggregate of common characteristics that influence a human group’s response to its environment”. As well, Gould and Grein (2009) state that: “[c]ulture consists of explicit and implicit patterns of historically derived and selected ideas and their embodiment in institutions, practices and artefacts; cultural patterns may, on one hand, be considered as products of action, and on the other as conditioning elements of further action”.
  • 19. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 14 Companies are not in isolation, and they operate in a physical, technological, economic, social and cultural space to which they must adapt. (Scott, 2002); According to Guusinger, (2001) one of the factors that culture can influence are the international strategic options when operating abroad and can have a strong impact on the choice of entry mode in foreign markets. (Kogut and Singh, 1988; Tihanyi et al., 2005) From the research, some companies seem to prefer joint ventures and acquisitions rather than Greenfield investments when entering culturally distant countries. (Shane, 1993); Three main cultural models exist:  Edward Hall’s high and low context of culture (1976);  Trompenaar’s seven dimensions of culture (1993);  Hofstede’s Cultural dimensions (1980); Hofstede’s model analyses the different variables of national culture while Trompenaar’s model focuses on how culture is created. (Hampden-Turner and Trompenaars, 1997) Hall’s (1976) model did not advance to an internationally comparable measurement and it analyses only one single variable (context) in a binary output. (Reis, Ferreira, Santos and Serra, 2013) All of the models have received certain critique regarding peer review, depth of the model and simplicity. However, the most commonly used model by academia and professionals today when trying to analyse the culture of a certain market is Hofstede’s model, thus the literature review will further focus only on this model. (Reis, Ferreira, Santos and Serra, 2013); Hofstede’s Cultural dimensions In his book, “Culture’s consequences: International differences in work-related values”, Hofstede (1986) presents the results of his empirical study through which he managed to identify four basic cultural dimensions that are able to explain the variance in the countries’ scores of cultural values. The four dimensions are: Power distance: the degree to which individuals in a culture accept unequal distribution of power. (Hofstede, 1980); Uncertainty avoidance: the tolerance of members of the group to unstructured, ambiguous situations and whether the members of the group accept or try to avoid such situations. (Hofstede, 1980); Individualism – collectivism: defined as the extent to which individuals in a national cultural setting “prefer to act as individuals rather than as members of groups”. (Hofstede, 1994) Masculinity-femininity: the degree to which traditionally ‘masculine’ values (e.g., performance, competition, success and assertiveness) prevail over stereotypically ‘feminine’ values (e.g., solidarity, care for the weak, cooperation, quality of life, personal relationships and friendship. (Hofstede, 1994) ; Together with Bond (1988), in later work, a fifth dimension was included: Confucian dynamism (also known as long term orientation), which relates to the culture’s time horizon, and the importance ascribed to the future or the past. The latest cultural dimension added to the model or the sixth one is:
  • 20. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 15 Indulgence the extent to which people try to control their desires and impulses, based on the way they were raised. (Hofstede, 2016); The following limitations when applying Hofstede’s framework should be kept in mind. One of the obvious weaknesses is that the data is relatively old and doesn’t capture the effect of recent political, economic and technological changes. Moreover, that the creation of the model is based on data from only one company – IBM. (Pankaj Ghemawat and Sebastian Reiche, 2011); As outlined earlier, national culture differences have a reflection in business decisions like foreign entry modes. But the understanding of national culture can also improve management practises and Pankaj Ghemawat and Sebastian Reiche (2011) provided the following findings:  Participative management can improve profitability in low power distance cultures but worsen it in high power distance cultures  Quick fixes can improve profitability in more short-term oriented cultures but worsen it in more long-term oriented cultures  Merit-based pay and promotion policies can improve profitability in more masculine cultures and reduce it in more feminine cultures  Emphasizing individual contributions can improve profitability in more individualistic cultures and worsen it in more collectivistic cultures The findings can be used when deciding how to manage a sales rep for a foreign market (tasks allocations, incentive strategies, etc.) after having made an analysis of the cultural dimensions of the country in question.
  • 21. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 16 4. Innovation Living’s Business Model Innovation Living is an international furniture enterprise that has established production facilities in three countries, on three continents, and has employees all over the world. The company has full ownership over its supply chain until the distribution to the B2C - the middle man or the retailers, thus it does not deal with the business to consumer aspect. One of the biggest pluses for the company image are the “Danish design” and “Danish quality stamp”. Before an analysis of the Business models is made, it is relevant to take a look what growth strategies the company is currently employing: As shown on the figure below there are four types of generic strategy depending on the Target Market Scope, the cost and the uniqueness of the product or service. Innovation Living specializes in a niche market, more specifically the sofa/bed segment and serves mostly customers who live in small living spaces. (Innovation Living, 2016) Based on this, the generic strategic is determined to be a Differentiation Focus. (See figure 4.1); Figure 4.1: Generic Strategies Source: Hollensen, 2010; As the main discussion of the report is related to the Bulgarian market and there is enough data to determine the growth strategy according to the Ansoff Matrix. Innovation Living is already present in Bulgaria with one authorized dealer in Sofia. The company sells products from its usual product portfolio without any changes. Meaning that Innovation Living is using the Market Penetration Growth Strategy; Now, to receive a better understanding of the company’s concept and to see if it has the necessary resources and capabilities internally to pursue a new strategy, an analysis of the business model is made. An overview of the company’s business model is presented on the next page (See figure 4.2);
  • 22. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 17 Figure 4.2: Osterwalder Nine Block Business Model Key partners All major suppliers of parts and materials, logistic partners, dealers and chains, exhibition/fair executives, Danske Bank, External legal advisor Key activities Design, production, sales & marketing activities Key resources Human: Skilled management, Inspired well-known designer, Skilled experienced experts in all processes of the production Physical: production facilities/machinery, the building (warehouse, showroom, offices) Intellectual: XAL Information user friendly platform, containing data about customers, procurement, financial data, inventory and transportation Financial: Liquid/Financially stable company Value propositions Functionality, Quality, Scandinavian Design, Brand Image, Customization, Comfortability, Flexibility, (In some cases recycled or handmade) Customer segments People of all ages living in small/one room spaces In BG market: People with high standard of living (with greater disposable income)passion for imported/ Scandinavian design furniture, High- end/premium segment/luxury product Customer relationships Personal focused customer relationships mostly aiming to retain existing customers and less focused on new customer acquisition Channels Own: Sales force, sales agents partner: dealers, wholesalers Cost structure Costs related to KA: design, production, marketing & sales Revenue streams Main: sales of furniture Secondary: Sales of point - sale materials to Dealers Source: Own production; 4.1. Customer Segments The product in question is a niche product, with high level of innovation and diversification, hence it holds a premium price. Therefore, Innovation Living is targeting furniture retailers that are only distributing furniture in the same price-intervals. It is also important, that the retailers are picking products that are unconventional and innovative and will attract end consumers who seek to find unique design and functionality, and are willing to pay a higher price. In the Bulgarian market, the company currently operates only through one middle man – Home Selection. Home Selection focuses exactly on three key aspects: Quality, Functionality and Innovation. (Home Selection, 2016) It places emphasis on beautiful, functional and proven quality furniture. The prices in their product range is medium to high. In order to choose the right B2B customers, Innovation Living has defined a business to consumer target group – people of all ages living in small/one room spaces, with a higher disposable income. The company defines these people as young and extremely demanding, having a dynamic lifestyle that the company’s products can be up to date with. 4.2. Value Proposition The value proposition constitutes of products that are functional, with high quality, high degree of customization, flexibility and Scandinavian design.
  • 23. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 18 Value Strategy - Customer Intimacy; According to the Harvard Business Review, Customer Intimacy is one of the three value disciplines. The other two are operational excellence and product leadership. Customer intimacy observed as a value strategy refers to companies who continuously tailor solutions (products or services towards the needs of their customers). This approach could be expensive but it is the right one when the goal is improving the customer loyalty in the long term. The focus is on the customer lifetime value, not on a single transaction. The idea is that employees of Innovation Living strive to fulfil every customer desire, even it doesn't seem important from their perspective. The most special about Innovation Living’s products is their functionality. The different sofas are designed to fit rooms of different sizes and to be adjustable depending on the customer’s need at that current moment – to sit and read a book, to take a nap, etc. Customers can also customize and give ideas for sofa’s to specifically fit their needs through the D.I.Y. – Design It Yourself idea and slogan. 4.3. Channels Innovation living’s marketing communications consist of both push and pull strategies – they employ online and traditional marketing. The company has its own website accessible from everywhere, as well as, it is present on different social media channels – Facebook, Instagram, YouTube. Through these channels, Innovation living manages to create brand awareness, also to educate and inspire its end customers and to support its products through descriptions and video demonstrations. The traditional marketing of the company consists of attending industry trade fairs that play a very important role in their brand promotion in the B2B world. It is also creating its own promotional materials such as product catalogues and brochures. 4.3.1. Distribution Channels The distribution process flow is conducted through sales agents sourcing potential wholesalers and retailers. As mentioned earlier, the company operates through middle man, wholesalers and retailers, and does not have its own brick and mortar stores. It has built its own salesforce and each sales rep specializes for a different market. Hence, the company’s entry mode in foreign markets is through direct export, collaborating with native sales representatives. 4.4. Customer relationships The company conducts relationship based marketing or in other words, it follows the diamond relationship model, where it has a personal approach to each B2B customers it collaborates with. The sales reps act as key-account managers to their established partners. They have constant communication with them and provide all the necessary information support and information. 4.5. Revenue Streams Innovation Living has two revenue streams:  Main: Sales of furniture  Secondary: Sales of promotional materials to Dealers The company works with fixed pricing. When negotiating with the middle man, Innovation Living directly sells its product to the distributor and then the distributor earns a percentage of the final sale to the B2C customer. Here the risk falls on the middle man, as they stack up
  • 24. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 19 inventory that needs to be sold. Nevertheless, Innovation Living needs to have certain activities that support the middleman’s sales activities, so that is a win-win situation. ¨Innovation Living offer not the cheapest, nor the most expensive products.¨ - Quoted from Jesper Frelund, Chief Executive Assistant; However, the Innovation Living product prices compared to the price level of similar products from the same sofa/bed segment in Bulgaria is quite high. Hence, the company has a premium pricing strategy. Lowering the price of Innovation Products is not an option, so the Innovation Living products are classified as luxury/premium and the pricing strategy of the firm will be observed as premium pricing and it targets end consumers with high disposable income. 4.6. Key Resources 4.6.1. Human resources The company consists of 25 full time employees in the administration and one intern. The team consists of CEO, Designers, Product Managers, Logistic Manager, International and Area Sales Managers, Marketing Coordinators, Customer Service Team, It-Manager and a Financial Specialist. It also has its own employees in the production facilities. 4.6.2. Intellectual resources The company has created and poses a database called XAL that contains information about their customers, procurement, financial data, inventory and transportation. 4.6.3. Physical resources The company owns three production facilities and special machinery. It also has an inventory storage space (warehouse), showrooms, offices and different equipment. 4.6.4. Financial resources A detailed financial analysis of the company through ratios and financial report analysis couldn’t be made, because of a lack of information from Innovation Living. However, according to the company, it currently doesn’t have any liabilities. The flow of revenue has slightly declined after the world’s financial crisis in 2007, but the company still earns enough to be profitable and to re-invest back into the business. It recently started building its own production facilities in Ukraine in order to support its activities in both Eastern/Southern Europe and some parts of Asia. This will reduce the time to market in certain countries as well as lower the costs for Innovation living in both production and distribution. 4.7. Key Activities The key activities of Innovation Living are as follows: o Production and Design; o Marketing and Sales; o Distribution and Support; 4.8. Key Partnerships The Key partner for Innovation Living are all the major suppliers of parts and materials that make the production of the sofa’s possible and the dealers and wholesalers through which the products are distributed to the end customers.
  • 25. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 20 4.9.Cost Structure The costs of Innovation Living are compounded of both fixed and variable costs. The fixed costs include salaries, administration costs, operating costs and equipment depreciation. The variable costs include marketing activities and sales incentives and bonuses. 5. External Analysis This section of the report includes relevant parts from PESTLE analysis of Bulgaria, Industry analysis based on Porter’s 5 forces framework, in-depth analysis of the competition on the Bulgarian Market, both domestic and foreign firms. Competitive benchmarking based on select criteria. Analysis of organisational customers relevant to Innovation Living; 5.1. PESTLE Most relevant to the project are considered to be the economic, social and legal factors and accurate summarized information is provided. 5.1.1 Economic factors ● Bulgaria is the poorest country in the EU; ● Bulgaria has the lowest wages in EU; Based on recent data published by the Bulgarian Government, the average salary is app.400 EUR, the minimum salary is app. 200 Euros, high salaries are app. 800-1000 EUR; However the salary rates are higher in Sofia and the high salaries account for app. 1500-2500 Euros (BG Govern Stats); ● The manufacturing industry accounts for 20.0% of GDP and 20.3% of the workforce is working in it. ● Disposable income per capita totalled BGN 6,912 in 2015. The real value of disposable income per capita is expected to rise by 4.0% in 2016. ● Bulgaria’s economic performance was good in 2015. The economic growth is expected to keep moderate rates and higher wages will continue to boost household spending, thereby supporting output growth. The country continued to benefit from a modest increase in foreign investment inflows and a relatively stronger fiscal stance. ● High rates of unemployment; ● Sofia has the most favourable economic climate and provides excellent conditions for start-up and growing business; Source: Bulgarian Country Profile, Euromonitor, 2016; Figure 5.1: Key Economic Indicators of the Bulgarian Economy 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Inflation (% change) 2.4 4.2 3.0 0.9 -1.4 -0.1 Exchange rate (per US$) 1.48 1.41 1.52 1.47 1.47 1.76 GDP (% real growth) 1.3 1.9 0.0 0.9 1.3 3.6 GDP (national currency millions) 74,771 .3 80,759 .0 82,040 .4 82,166 .1 83,634 .3 88,571 .3 Birth rate (per '000) 10.2 9.6 9.5 9.2 9.4 9.2
  • 26. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 21 Death rate (per '000) 14.9 14.7 15.0 14.4 15.1 15.3 No. of households ('000) 2,996. 1 3,005. 6 3,011. 6 3,017. 2 3,023. 5 3,026. 9 Total exports (US$ millions) 20,570 .9 28,221 .7 26,666 .9 29,579 .4 29,327 .3 25,715 .2 Total imports (US$ millions) 25,472 .8 32,578 .8 32,708 .7 34,308 .3 34,660 .9 29,225 .8 Urban population ('000) 5,337. 0 5,314. 9 5,324. 9 5,307. 9 5,291. 7 5,267. 5 Urban population (%) 71.9 72.1 72.7 72.9 73.0 73.1 Population aged 0-14 (%) 13.2 13.3 13.4 13.6 13.7 13.9 Population aged 15-64 (%) 68.8 68.3 67.8 67.3 66.7 66.1 Population aged 65+ (%) 18.0 18.3 18.8 19.2 19.6 20.0 Infant mortality (deaths per '000 live births) 9.4 8.5 7.8 7.3 7.6 6.6 Adult literacy (%) 98.3 98.4 98.4 98.4 98.4 98.4 Source: Euromonitor, 2015; Figure 5.2: Real GDP Growth and GDP per capital development in the period of 2010-2016; Source: Bulgaria - Economy, Finance and Trade, Euromonitor, 2015; Income and expenditure in Bulgaria Bulgaria’s per capita gross income and expenditure levels are the lowest amongst economies in the European Union (EU).In 2015, consumer expenditure per capita amounted
  • 27. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 22 to BGN 7,802 (US$4,425). The real value of consumer expenditure per is expected to raise with 3.4%. Disposable income per capita totalled BGN 6,912 (US$3,921) in 2015. The real value of disposable income per capita is expected to rise by 4.0% in 2016. During the period 2015-2030, total disposable income will increase by a cumulative value of 89.8% in real terms – growing at an average annual rate of 4.4%. As Bulgaria’s political, economic and cultural centre, Sofia gains most of the investment (public and private) in the country (which results in higher employment rates compared to the rest of the regions). The city also has the highest concentration of wealthy households in Bulgaria. This delights the broader South-West region the largest consumer market in the country, while the region also ranks top in terms of per household average spending; Source: Euromonitor, 2015; 5.1.2 Social factors:  The country is experiencing a long-term decline in the population of all ages less than 60. Total population was 7.2 million in 2015, a drop of almost 800,000 since 2000. ● Bulgaria is losing thousands of qualified workers each year through emigration ● 22 % of the population are poor people below the poverty line; ● The availability of skilled labour will continue to be a constraint despite the large pool of unemployed. ● Aging population is a disturbing factor; ● Productivity growth is critical for accelerating income convergence. Productivity must grow by at least 4% per year if Bulgaria is to reach average EU income levels. Growth prospects could also be limited by significant population decline owing to emigration and ageing. Source: (Euromonitor, Bulgaria Country Profile, 2015); 5.1.3 Legal factors: ● High corruption rates in Bulgaria; ● Competitive tax rate of 10%, the lowest in the EU; ● Member of the EU, EU free trade policies apply; ● No additional regulations regarding the import of furniture;
  • 28. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 23 5.2. Porter's Five Forces Figure 5.3: Porter's Five Forces Industry Analysis Chart Source: Based on Michael Porter’s 5 Forces model; 5.2.1. Supplier Bargaining Power - Moderate 5/10 In general, there are plenty of suppliers worldwide providing similar materials (wood/iron frames, textile covers, mattresses and fillings). Definitely, offered products/materials from various suppliers may differentiate in terms of price, quality, delivery time, order size, origin of materials, certification and much more. Firms who has better agreements with a supplier or partner with suppliers, providing them with superior materials gain competitive advantage and become the preferred choice of the end consumers. The supplier bargaining power is determined to be moderate. The suppliers can charge as much as they decide for their products and services as far as their customers agree to pay. In a free market there are no general limitations to accessing and cooperating with a certain supplier, it all comes to negotiating more favourable conditions of cooperation. The suppliers might feel pressured to lower their price, to win a client. Furniture manufacturers who are able to find and cooperate with suppliers, offering superior products and services on better terms in the long term compared to the competition gain sustainable competitive advantage, leading to increased perceived value for the customer, more sales and bigger profits. Table 5.4: Indicators of the supplier’s bargaining power; Number of suppliers High Size of suppliers Vary Uniqueness of service Not unique Your ability to substitute Great Cost of changing Small Source: Own Production; 0 2 4 6 8 10 Supplier's Bargaining Power Buyer's Bargaining Power Threat of Substitution Threat of New Entrants Rivalry among Existing Competitors Porter's 5 Forces Shaping the Furniture Industry Porter's 5 Forces Shaping the Furniture Industry
  • 29. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 24 5.2.2. Buyer Bargaining Power - High 8/10 The customer is always first, he is the decision maker. Fierce competition between manufacturers provides the customer with wide range of products to choose from. The buyer has the power to determine from whom to buy and to decide which offer suits his needs best. Table 5.5: Indicators of the buyer’s bargaining power’ Number of customers Medium Size of each order Vary Differences between competitors Low, might vary Price sensibility High Ability to substitute High Cost of changing Low Source: Own production; 5.2.3. Threat of Substitution 1/10 Thinking logically, there is no substitute to furniture. All the substituting products or products with similar purpose/designation are also categorized as furniture products. So the furniture is unique and irreplaceable concept. In other words, the furniture products can be substituted only with other furniture products. Of course there is a wide range of functions and model varieties which may have similar usage qualities and one product can replace another. (Example: Sofa/Bed have the properties and applications both of a couch and a bed and could substitute both. Also decreases the quantity of occupied space (measured in sq.m), which makes it. in some cases, a preferred product for small living spaces). Table 5.6: Indicators for threat of substitution Substitute performance No substitution to furniture Cost of change - Source: Own Production; 5.2.4. Threat of New Entry 8/10 In the furniture Industry, the threat of new entry is high. A lot of new firms continuously are being opened. Small investments of capital are required to buy wood and textile processing machinery. It is not a necessity to operate complex technologically advanced machinery in the process of furniture manufacturing. Old machinery, even a manual tools are used to reduce costs. The administration also processes documentation smoothly without need of a complex software. Rarely sophisticated CRM systems are used, only by large organisations who can afford. Furniture manufacturing business can be launched with relatively small capital. Most of the new entrants are local small firms. Economy of scale is determined to be
  • 30. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 25 medium to high, mainly because materials are cheaper when purchased in bigger volumes; also the efficiency of the logistics is increased, leading to lowering of the transportation costs per unit. Table 5.7: Indicators of threat of new entry Time and cost of entry Small Specialist knowledge Small to medium Economies of scale Medium to high Cost advantages Medium to high Technology protections Small Barriers of entry Small Source: Own Production; 5.2.5. Competitive Rivalry - High 9/10 There is high degree of competition within the furniture industry. Huge number of competitors. The market is very price sensitive, meaning that a change of price, causes a drastic change in the demand for products. The quality of materials and assembly can vary depending on suppliers and the expertise of the work force. The furniture industry is not characterized with high customer loyalty, often the customers are purchasing furniture from different retailers and manufacturers. A firm which is able to provide a product with the same perceived benefits cheaper, most likely is the preferred choice of the customer. The industry is characterized with fierce price competition and could be described as Red Ocean. Table 5.8: Indicators of the rivalry among competitors; Number of competitors High Quality differences High Other differences High Switching costs Medium Customer Loyalty Low Source: Own Production; 5.2.6. Attractiveness of the furniture Industry 4/10 Overall the furniture manufacturing industry is not very attractive scoring overall rating of 4/10, because of the high level of competition among opponents, the price sensitivity influencing the demand. On the other hand it is safe industry because there are no
  • 31. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 26 substitutions and companies with skilled salesforce can achieve high results being able to satisfy the customer´s demands. 5.3. ADL Matrix Using the ADL Framework are considered two main factors: the competitive position of Innovation Living in the Bulgarian Furniture Market and the stage of industry life cycle. The Industry is considered as mature. The meaning of mature in this case is that the industry is already grown and it has well established customer base, the market and the market share are stable, there are a lot of competitors and are focused to differentiate one from another - exactly what it is happening within the furniture industry. However the Innovation Living competitive position on the Bulgarian market is tangible, meaning that the company has small insignificant market share, also it is present only in Sofia. The firm strives to differentiate its products from the others and retain on the market. In order Innovation Living to keep its market share and to pursue growth, it has to improve its competitive advantage and to put more effort on sales and acquire new customers. Based on internal information from the company, at this moment there are not enough people in the sales department, which results in inability to acquire new customers. The currently hired sales people at Innovation only manage to serve existing customer and are unable to negotiate with potential customers. Unfortunately, this is a weakness and could have a negative effect to the company performance and sales figures, it can even result in withdrawal of the market. Further in the report this problem is to be solved. Innovation Living needs to be active and to stabilize its position on the market. (See figure 5.9); Figure 5.9: ADL matrix Source: Wilson, Richard M.S and Gilligan, Colin, 2005; 5.4. Analysis of the Competitors in Bulgaria Competitor intelligence acquired based on the analysis will contribute to developing a new strategy for Innovation Living by identifying the competitive advantages of the competition and how Innovation Living can steal market share. The competition of Innovation Living consists of other furniture manufactures supplying directly or indirectly sofa/beds to the end consumers in Bulgaria. They are divided in two categories: Local Competition and Foreign Entrants. ¨Market sources of furniture for Bulgaria are dominated by foreign, mainly of European origin firms. Share of national production out of total consumption is 25%. Share of imports
  • 32. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 27 out of total consumption is 75%, which means Bulgaria depends on imports.¨ (Furniture Manufacturing, 2015); 5.4.1 Local Competition ¨There are more than 2300 wood processing and furniture manufacturers in Bulgaria, which sell both on the domestic market and export internationally. 77.5% of them are micro firms with 1 to 9 employees. There are only 10 macro enterprises accounting for 0.4% and they employ more than 250 people. The rest are small and medium firms with 10 to 250 employed personnel.¨ The competition faced by Innovation Living consists of all companies selling sofa/beds as part of their portfolio on the Internal Market. In general the products produced by local firms are not homogeneous from customer perspective. They have similar product ranges. Most local firms do not specialize in a niche market like Innovation Living, but have broader product portfolios. A usual Bulgarian manufacturer of commercial furniture offers all types of furniture to be used in all the rooms, excluding bathroom and restroom furniture. These competitors are mainly B2C oriented, but the larger ones sell both B2B (sales through retailers and resellers) and B2C. Ergodesign, Videnov and Irim are well established companies owing a big part of the market share of the domestic production. Competitive advantages of the local firms over Innovation Living ● Lower Costs of manufacturing; ● Lower costs of transportation; ● Cultural similarity with the Bulgarian consumers; ● Shorter time to market; 5.4.2 Foreign competition on the Bulgarian furniture market Companies from Denmark, Sweden, Germany, Italy, Poland, Ukraine and more countries are already present in Bulgaria, distinguishing from the local competition. Due to the lack of design, bad quality and similarity of products offered from the local competition, the consumers seek alternative, especially from customers with higher income and the demand for imported furniture is growing. The number of foreign companies on the Bulgarian furniture market is growing. Ikea, Jysk, Cotta, Boconcept are only few market entrants. Owned Showrooms, Distributors and resellers are commonly used to reach the consumers. The table below illustrates the customer perceived benefits categorized as order winners and order qualifiers. Table 5.10: Order Winners and Order Qualifiers for Sofa/bed Purchase from end consumer perspective; Order Winners: Order Qualifiers: Quality; Comfort; Design; Customization; Functionality; Time to market; Uniqueness; Source: Own Production, based on primary and secondary data; In the table below are shown companies which are competing with Innovation Living in the Bulgarian Market. All companies involved in it, produce and sell products under the category of sofa/beds. The table provides competitive benchmarking. All criteria are ranked on the scale from 1 to 10. (See Table 5.11);
  • 33. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 28 Table 5.11: Competitive Benchmarking of firms in the Bulgarian Furniture Market Innovation Living BO Concept IKEA Irim Ergo Design Cotta Headquart ers: Denmark Denmark Sweden Bulgaria Bulgaria Germany Product range on the BG Market: Sofa/Beds only Furniture for home - for the living, dining room, bedroom Everything for home not limited to furniture All types of furniture for home, office and gardens, hotels Beds, Furniture for bedroom, sofa/beds, mattresses Furniture for the living and dining room Point of sales: 1 partner showroom (Home Selection showroom in Sofia) 1 Owned Showroom in Sofia only (Boutique); One brand store in Sofia 100 +( in a lot of stores across the country) Available in most cities, also online 7 (Only can be purchased in AIKO stores) Sales Volume of Sofa Beds 1 2 3 8 7 8 Time to market: 7 (app. 3 weeks for ORL) 7 (4 weeks in not in stock) 1(only products in stock are for purchase) 5 (2 weeks) 6 (3-4 weeks) 1 (only products in stock are for purchase) Price of Sofa/Beds Sofa/Beds: 8 10 5 3 8 7 Degree of customizat ion: 6 4 3 10 7 2 Quality: 8 8 6 6 8 Functionali ty of sofa/beds: 9 7 6 10 7 8
  • 34. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 29 Uniquenes s of the design of the product on the Bulgarian market: 10 8 7 2 9 6 Brand Recognitio n in Bulgaria: 1 4 9 9 6 5 Level of Customer Awareness in Bulgaria: 2 4 9 9 6 5 Source: Own production, based on field research and company websites; Results show that Innovation Living performance is satisfying and in some measurements are superior compared to companies with longer presence and greater market share. The Innovation Living product lines are competitive and have the potential to sell well in Bulgaria. The product features such as design, quality customisation and uniqueness make them attractive to consumers and stand out from competition. Investing in marketing campaign, will improve the low level of customer awareness and brand recognition; the existing concept offered by Innovation Living - Shop in Shop is a good marketing tool but not enough. Acquiring of new B2B customers is a must and more points of sale on strategic locations across the country will enable the sales growth and improve the accessibility and consumer awareness. The fact that Innovation Living is only accessible only in one showroom of a private design store in Sofia is the main obstacle of weak sales. The company has to act more offensive, gain market share and strengthen its presence on the market. The outsourcing of Innovation Living production in the new facility in Ukraine will decrease the time to market. Innovation Living has to invest in marketing and business development activities to develop the market and attract resellers with credible image and reputation. 5.5. Organizational Customer’s Analysis This section of the report deals with analysis of the organizational buyers. Main area of focus is B2B Customers of Innovation Living in the Bulgarian market and their characteristics including assessment of their buying behaviour, involved individuals, and the buying situation. Briefly, Innovation Living only works with B2B customers. The goal of the management is to develop long-term relationship with small number of customers in a specific market, in order to keep its status of design brand, which cannot be purchased everywhere. Innovation Livings selectively acquires new customers and does not sell to anyone.
  • 35. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 30 All customers of Innovation are only companies who resell Innovation Living products for profit. They don’t use the products in any other aspect in the business. Most important factors influencing the buying decision for resellers are profit margins of selling third party products, sales volume, payment options, delivery terms, volume of order quantities. In most cases a moderate rebuy situation will occur. As the orders will differ in models ordered and quantity, depending on season, time of the year, end consumer needs and etc.; Direct procurement is the main method, because it is common for small firms and the decision is made individually in the organisation. In Bulgaria, currently Innovation Living the only customer is Home Selection a designer furniture store in Sofia, which is an authorized dealer of Innovation Living's products. The customer has the following characteristics:  Company size: Small (1 to 9 employees);  Order Size: Small (Total revenue for 2016 of 55 130 DKK ); (See Appendix 5);  Position of the decision maker within the organization: CEO/Owner;  Buying situation: Moderate rebuy;  Communication: Direct (with the sales coordinator based in Denmark); Associated resellers are Interior design studios and designer stores. Wholesalers specializing in furniture sales in Bulgaria are: Videnov, Mondo and AIKO. 5.6 Market Trends and Demand for Design Danish Furniture in Bulgaria ¨A recent survey conducted by Alpha Research for the Bulgarian Chamber of Commerce concluded that price had been a decisive factor driving furniture consumer preferences in Bulgaria. Logically the competition on the Bulgarian market for furniture and design was mainly focusing on price rather than quality of the products. Nevertheless, the survey identified a new trend; the group of consumers buying new and expensive furniture is growing, the group predominantly consists of young professionals with a high social and economic status who are residents of Sofia or other larger cities.¨ - Source: Furniture and Design Sector in Bulgaria, 2015; Retailers selling imported design furniture accounted for essential growth with dynamic rates. The import of design furniture has increased by 300%. Due to increase of disposable income, more innovative products, matching customers’ expectations and the better leasing schemes. A lot of foreign brands producing exclusive, designed furniture expanded in Bulgaria. The most revenue comes from Sofia and the big cities. Great demand comes from young enthusiastic people with a high social status and disposable income above the average. Additional demand for quality designer furniture is created by the tourist industry, which intensively grows. The growing demand for furniture and design in Bulgaria makes Danish Furniture Design Brands even more popular for the customer and the fact that Danish producers have the image and reputation for great designers for ages together with the expertise of furniture manufacturing and the high quality materials used, create excellent opportunities for the Danish companies to achieve sustainable, sizable growth in the Bulgarian furniture market; (Furniture and Design Sector in Bulgaria, 2015) 5.7. Bulgarian Culture according to Hofstede’s Six Cultural Dimensions For this analysis, Hofstede’s website (https://geert-hofstede.com/bulgaria.html) was used as a source of information. (See figure 5.12);
  • 36. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 31 Figure 5.12: Bulgaria Cultural Profile Source: Own Production; Power distance As Bulgaria scores very high (70) it means that people in that country accept a hierarchical order in which everyone has a pre-defined place and it doesn’t need to be further justified. Centralization is normal and subordinates are told what to do. Individualism With a score of 30, Bulgarian society is regarded as collectivistic where close long-term commitment to the member group is very important. Loyalty is paramount and it goes above most other social rules and regulations. In this type of societies, offence often leads to shame and loss of face. Relationships between employees and employer can often turn as a family link like. Masculinity Bulgarian society with a score of 40 is considered more a feminine one rather than masculine. In this societies the focus is on “working in order to live”, strive for consensus from the management, valuing equality, solidarity and quality in the working live. Conflicts are resolved by negotiation and compromising, and incentives such as free time and flexibility are favoured. Uncertainty Avoidance The score of for uncertainty avoidance is very high (85) thus people in Bulgaria prefer to avoid uncertainty. This constitutes in being intolerant to unorthodox behaviour or ideas. Time is money in this society, there is inner urge to be busy and work hard, precision and punctuality are the norm and security is an important element in individual motivation. Long Term Orientation The score of 69 for Bulgaria makes it a pragmatic culture, where people believe that truth will vary based on situation, context and time. There is ability to adapt traditions easily to changes, tendency to save and invest and perseverance to achieve results. Indulgence Bulgarian society has the tendency to cynicism and pessimism or a Restrained culture (low score of 16). There is no much focus on leisure time and gratification control on the desires.
  • 37. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 32 Figure 5.13: Bulgarian culture vs. Danish culture Source: Hofstede, 2016; The figure above compares the cultural dimensions of the Bulgarian and Danish society and it can be seen there are almost the total opposite of each other. Hence, Innovation Living will have to consider adding a native sales representative to the team, as he/she will possess the necessary understanding of the market and the skills to communicate effectively with Bulgarian business partners. (see figure 5.13); 6. Insights Based on the Conducted Semi-structured Interviews Generally 5 retailers from the Bulgarian Market were interviewed. 4 of them are small to medium size and only AIKO is a whole seller. 2 of them (Acherno and Trinex Design) are Design Studios, meaning that they are not only retailers but also consult and digitally visualize interior design concepts. Language preferences: Eventough some of the participants use English, it is recommended to have someone speaking the local language and has knowledge of the culture. This makes a lot easier the negotiation with new customers especially. Order sizes, excluding the wholesaler are small to medium and the kept inventory is low. Those boutique and design specialized firms offer customization and allow the end consumer to order a product which is not in stock and they take it over to supplier. All firms are present online, but not all sell online, especially those with premium pricing offer personal selling. The product range is wide but as Innovation Living carefully selects new dealers and requires certain level of price/quality to be met, the same is with those specialized retailers, they carefully select they partners. For more extensive information gathered from the interviews see Appendix 2, 3 and 4;
  • 38. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 33 7. SWOT – is market penetration the way to go? The Information in the table is based on the internal and the external analysis conducted in the project until this stage. It illustrates the Strengths and the Weaknesses originating from the company internally. The Opportunities and Threats are external factors related to the Bulgarian Furniture Market and the Industry that Innovation Living has to assess before planning further actions. Table 7.1: SWOT Matrix S W O T Source: Own Production; 8. Segmentation, Targeting and Positioning 8.1 Segmentation The Industry Innovation Living is targeting are Home and Garden Retailers industry and more specifically, the Homewares and home furnishing stores. In Bulgaria, the Homewares and home furnishing stores performs the best in 2015, growing by 4% in value terms. (http://portal.euromonitor.com.ez-eaa.statsbiblioteket.dk:2048/portal/analysis/tab) Between the two industries there have been differences in price positioning. While the Home and Garden Retailers are firmly entrenched at the low-end of the price spectrum, Homeware and home furnishing stores fall under three distinct price groups:  Very high Quality – Danish stamp  Scandinavian Designer  New production facilities in Ukraine – shorter time to market and lower costs  Wide product range  Customization of products  Brand Image  Price level – high for the Bulgarian Market  Only one point of sale in BG  No actions towards raising customer awareness  Not much experience in the market  No knowledge of the culture and the behaviour of the consumers  Lack of human capital, needed to research, aquire and serve new customers  More and more Bulgarian customer look for innovative solutions and Danish design  Still a decent percentage of the people have a higher income  The economic and social factors are having positive outlooks  Retailers look to work with foreign importers  The costs of expansion and operations in the country are low  The market is highly saturated and there are a lot of indirect offerings  Cultural differences – the cultural barriers are very high between the two countries  A large part of the population is within the range of low to medium income  Opportunities can be found only in large cities, which limits the potential of the market
  • 39. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 34 - Low-end - Mid-end - High-end The big furniture retailers in Bulgaria, both foreign and domestic, tend to fall in the broader category, Home and Garden, making them more in-direct competitors. Moreover, most of them are operating in the low-end, mid- end price ranges, as their product ranges are quite extensive and have different “collections” targeting different customer groups. Hence, Innovation Living will be looking for smaller, more niche furniture retailers that work with carefully picked suppliers and have a certain vision that will fit the company’s products. In the Bulgarian market there are currently 80 medium and 450 small retailers of furniture. The density of furniture shops and showrooms is high, due to relatively low costs related to showrooms (such as rent, electricity, staff salaries) However, it is also relevant if they are working with imported furniture and not a very large percentage of them sells imported furniture. The retailers who do, are usually located in the big cities and import high-end products. (Innovation Living, 2016) The company’s aim for the Bulgarian market is to become a premium dealer and expose Innovation Collection, thus the company wants to target Interior Design Consultancies and Boutique Furniture Importers in the following cities: Sofia, Varna, Plovdiv, Burgas and Turnovo. The smaller retailers usually have a small purchasing team or the decision maker is directly the Owner of the store. As the products are more expensive and the order volumes are small, communication plays an important role in keeping relationships, thus the buyer-seller relationships will not be transactional. 8.2 Targeting In the Bulgarian market there are currently 80 medium and 450 small retailers of furniture. The density of furniture shops and showrooms is high, due to relatively low costs related to showrooms (such as rent, electricity, staff salaries). However, not a very large percentage of them sell imported furniture. The retailers who do, are usually located in the big cities and import high-end products. (Innovation Living, 2016) The company’s aim for the Bulgarian market is to become a premium dealer and expose Innovation Collection, thus the company wants to target Interior Design Consultancies and Botique Furniture Importers in the following cities: Sofia, Varna, Plovdiv, Burgas and Turnovo. Below a list of companies in Bulgaria from the chosen segment is presented. They are selected as possible customers with high potential: (See Figure 8.1);
  • 40. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 35 Figure 8.1: Targeting Sofia ● Acherno ● Grandecor ● Casadecor ● Mirookki ● Jelanie ● Mebelipro ● Furnish Furnish.bg, also in city of Varna ● Perfecta mebeli /СБС Скандинавия/ - Only Representative of Stressless and Ekornes in BG Varna ● La Cassa lacasa.bg Interior Design Solutions- main partners from Italy, but possible cooperation with Innovation Living ● Best-furniture.bg - Design Imported Furniture ● Keys // Improter possible only for a small range of the products offered by Innovation Living ● Bulmarket ● mebelibg Burgas ● Mebeliverona ● Valdo ● Trinexdesign ● harlexmarket Source: Own production; The procurement is usually direct. The larger chains have a procurement team that is responsible for the whole correspondence. In the smaller companies often the owner or the CEO is the decision maker and it is easier to conduct negotiations for future cooperation. 8.3 Positioning Figure 8.2: Positioning Map Source: Own Production;
  • 41. Final Bachelor Project - Sales Strategy of Innovation Living for the Bulgarian Market Martin Malakov, CPR: 1110923003, Program: ISM, Team: Z, Semester: III Tutor: Torben Sorensen, Hand-in Date: 09.01.2017 36 The positioning map above shows how Innovation Living are currently positioned in the Bulgarian market compared to their competition. The two factors chosen for comparison are Price level and Functionality, as these are assumed to be two of the closest related factors that are looked at by end customers. The only competitor outperforming Innovation Living in these two criteria is Irim. Nevertheless, Innovation Living still has the two perceived advantages – Scandinavian design and quality. The company shouldn’t try to reposition, but it should increase the awareness of the brand and strengthen its current position. The current obstacles for Innovation in the market are its low customer awareness and brand recognition, thus this is what the company should focus on improving. 9. Market Penetration Strategy for the Bulgarian Market - Balanced Scorecard The main goal for Innovation Living is to expand its presence in Bulgaria and to increase its sales in the market. Hence, the company will adopt a market penetration strategy. (See Literature review) As described in the literature review, this strategy is the least risky of all four Ansoff growth strategies. Innovation Living is going to achieve this increase through hiring a sales representative for this market. The strategy is formed as a balanced scorecard that will serve as a tool for Innovation Living to apply the strategy and to be able to track and measure the performance thus reaches its overall goal. (See table 9.1) (Hutt and Speh, 2014) All of the objectives set in the balanced scorecard are based on the S.M.A.R.T. goals model - Specific, Measurable, Attainable, Realistic and Timely. (Hutt and Speh, 2014) Depending on the objective the targets are set to be monthly, yearly or one-time based. The strategy is created for one year period. Figure 9.1: The Balanced Scorecard Source: Own Production; *** In case the picture is hard to read, look at it in Appendix 7;