A man has traveled across the country to New York City to meet his childhood best friend Jimmy Wells exactly twenty years after they last met. He arrives at the location they agreed upon, the site of their old favorite restaurant. While waiting, he tells his story to a passing police officer. Shortly before 10pm, the agreed upon meeting time, a tall man arrives who appears to be Jimmy Wells. However, upon walking together under bright lights, the man realizes it is not his old friend. The imposter reveals he is a police officer who was tipped off that the man was wanted by Chicago police and had come to arrest him. He shares a note from the real Jimmy Wells explaining that he saw the man was wanted and didn't