Accessibility in Context: Understanding the Truly Mobile Experience of Smartphone Users with Motor Impairments + ASSETS 2014 -Maia Naftali /안현진 x 2014 Fall

1. Accessibility in Context:
Understanding the Truly
Mobile Experience
of Smartphone Users
with Motor Impairments
+ ASSETS 2014
-Maia Naftali
/안현진
x 2014 Fall

2. 'BMM-BCNFFUJOH
DDFTTJCJMJUZJO$POUFYU6OEFSTUBOEJOHUIF5SVMZ.PCJMFYQFSJFODF
PG4NBSUQIPOF6TFSTXJUI.PUPS*NQBJSNFOUT
$.4454
컫칺뫊헣팖힒
컪풆샎묞픃뫊믾쿮샎풞

3. VUIPST
6OJWFSTJUZPG.BSZMBOE$PMMFHF1BSL
*ODMVTJWF%FTJHO-BC*)$*-
TTJTUBOU1SPGFTTPS
-FBI'JOEMBUFS
.BTUFS$PVSTF4UVEFOU
.BJB/BGUBMJ

4. 0WFSWJFX
풂솧핳팮핆 .PUPSJNQBJSNFOU
픦큲잖칺푷펞샎킲킲몋핂팒삚.PCJMFDPOUFYU펞컪4VSWFZ퐎
.VMUJDBTFTUVEZ읊
*OUSPEVDUJPO 3FMBUFEXPSL 0OMJOF4VSWFZ
.VMUJDBTF4UVEZ
$BTF
$BTF
$BTF
$BTF
%JTDVTTJPO -JNJUBUJPO $PODMVTJPO

5. *OUSPEVDUJPO
믾홂풂솧핳팮핆뫎엶졶짢핊헟믊컿펾묺퐎
힎믖밚힎픦졶짢핊펞샎펾묺슲 1%빦큲쿦펔픚
풂솧핳팮핆픒퓒 -BC
TFUUJOH
픦펾묺슲핒
핂얾펾묺슲픎찒핳팮핆쫂삲핳팮핆슲핂섢잜픎핓엳폲윦읊쩢몮
섢쁞읺젾뿒읂쁢킪맒핂섢밆삲쁢멑슿픦멾뫊읊짫
몮핖픚
힎잚팒힏밚힎풂솧핳팮핆핂큲잖뫊
쫆펾묺펞컪쁢졶짢핊잳앋 $POUFYU
캏펞컪풂솧핳팮핆슲픦큲잖칺푷펞샎팚팒쫊멑
솒퐢삲

6. 0OMJOFTVSWFZ
.FUIPE
풂솧핳팮읊팡몮핖쁢졶짢핊퓮헎슲픒%JTUSJCVUJPOMJTU퐎폶않핆엊
힎펻삶퓒
쫂쿦쁢팒잖홂캏뭚픒힎믗
컲줆픎
맪픦컲줆픎맪묻픊옪빦쀦펂핟컿쇦펖힎잚힎펻헏핆
힎
컲줆줆
핊짦헏핆헣쫂슲 빦핂
컿쪒
핳팮퓮
졶짢핊싢짢핂큲
핊짦헏핆
싢짢핂큲칺푷픦찒묞
줊읺헏핆컲

7. 0OMJOFTVSWFZ
1BSUJDJQBOUT
핂푷믾믾
졓픦
팒핂졓
팖슪옪핂슪졓
퓖솒푾졓
졓픎펺컿핂펖픊젾빦핂쁢켆
뾚쪟쪎핳팮
킮몋핳팮
뫎헖핳팮
슿쫃헏픊옪핳팮읊팡몮핖펖픚
졓픎펆펂핳팮읊쿦짦몮핖펖픊젾졓픎슱쁢멑펞줆헪많핖펖삲켆졓픎싢짢핂큲읊칺푷쁢섾킪맏헏핆쭖픒멸픚
풂솧핳팮많큲잖픒칺푷펞캏샇
헟믊컿솒묺펞컪쁢졓핂4QFFDIUP5FYU
졓핂큲

8. 0OMJOFTVSWFZ
'JOEJOHT
졶짢핊싢짢핂큲읊펂싢컪칺푷쁢많
힟펞컪칺푷
킲뺂춞잚팒삖않킲푆펞컪솒칺푷찖솒뽠픚
킲킲푆멎흫핂푢
!
픦줊읺헏핆퓒
힟팖
짢밳줂읜퓒펞숮
힟팖뫊짢밳픦멾뫊많짦헒쇶
!
힟팖뫊퍊푆펞컪픦펂읺
핂젢핊핂빦
4.4
멚핒
폶않핆쿊믆읺몮맪핆헣쫂뫎읺솒묺슲슿펞컪찒킅칺푷
삶
뻲찒멚핂켦뫊맪핆헣쫂뫎읺팿픎퍊푆캏펞컪섢잜핂칺푷 힟WT짤

9. 0OMJOFTVSWFZ
'JOEJOHT
핊짦헏핆핆줆헪펞샎힖줆 젎헪큲
졓훟졓핂젎삲몮픟샃
믾쫆헏핆핓엳펞샎힟뫊퍊푆펞컪픦캏뫎뫎몒
먾픦샎쭎쭒찒킅몋픒쫂핂힎잚
픎픚컿핓엳픒찒옽펺삲읆핟펓슲펞샎펺
힟쫂삲짤핂섢펂옃삲몮픟샃삲
풂솧핳팮핆슲핂픒칺푷쁢멑핂헞헞흫많몮핖삲
핂헒펾묺펞컪핆섦멑
핂젎

10. .VMUJDBTFTUVEZ
1BSUJDJQBOU3FDSVJUNFOU
풂솧핳팮읊팡몮핖쁢졓픦
큲잖픒핦칺푷삲쁢멑픒핓흫믾퓒컪맪풢핂캏픦큲잖칺푷몋핂핖쁢칺푷핞읊졶힟
핊훊핊펞숞쩖핂캏칺푷
졶슮
1SPDFEVSF
졓픦큲잖칺푷핞슲픒샎캏픊옪젎켆켦
픒힒삲

11. .VMUJDBTFTUVEZ
*OJUJBMJOUFSWJFX
쭒맒묺혾쇪핆쫂혾믾묺읊푷몮
핖쁢힎줊픚
핆
%JBSZFOUSJFT
샎컪쫂몮
푢묺칺픊옪쁢맪픦픒핓엳쁢멑핂몮,맏맏픦멑슲픎핓엳쁢섾펞쭒헣솒콚푢쇶
삲핂펂읺펞쁢맫뫎킫훊뫎킫핂컬펺핖펖삲
폲쁦큲잖픒핂푷컪펂썲뫊펓픒힒빦푢
폲쁦퍊푆펞컪펂썲솧픒빦푢
힟팖픎퍊푆펞컪큲잖픦펂썲믾쁳핂솒풎핂쇞빦푢
폲쁦큲잖뫊뫎엶펺많핳팖홙픎몋픎줂펕핆많푢
큲잖뫊뫎엶펔핂짪캫섦헟믊컿핂큖많핖펖빦푢
큲잖몋펞샎팒핂싢펂많핖픊졂잞훊켆푢

12. .VMUJDBTFTUVEZ
$POUFYUVBMTFTTJPO
EJBSZ켆켦뫊삲읂멚JOTJUV몋펞컪핆
켆켦픎뫃뫃핳콚
믾쫆헏핆큲잖솧핟 NJOVUFT
맏
핒픦짷큲퐎핂
퓒팒앦큲퐎핂
!
짦묺혾핆
핊짦헏핆칺푷픒핂믾퓒힖줆픊옪묺컿
EJBSZ핓엳픊옪쭎
!
뻲핂쫂슪팯찒 VQUPIPVS
EJBSZ핓엳픒
폖뮪

13. %BUBOBMZTJT
핂삖켪
퓒뫊헣픊옪쭎삲
몒
졶짢핊핆
QFSTPOBMJ[BUJPO DVTUPNJ[BUJPO
QSFGFSFODFT
믆읺몮XJTIFT NPCJMFFOIBODFNFOUT
QIZTJDBMXPSMEDPOUSPM
읺컪
맪훟펞맪픦
믆읺몮많핳푾
읺펾묺줆헪퐎뫎엶핖쁢켆맪픦

14. .VMUJDBTFTUVEZOEJOHT
$BTF1
1픎빶핞
캂핂삲믊퓯핳팮읊팡몮핖픊젾퍋맒픦킪맏핳팮읊많힎몮핖삲
몋푾펞싾않컪
핊솧팖맪픦삲핂펂읺읊핓엳삲
$POUFYUTFTTJPO펞컪쁢슪앛짣큲옪핊픒뫃퓮쁢멑
큲픚컿핓엳픊옪줆핞
핂큲쭏
믾읊섾졶삲
/FJHICPSIPPEBDUJWJUJFT쁢퍋묻펞많쁢멑뫊힎
큲잖팖슪옪핂슪뻳컪큲

15. 샎

16. 훊칺푷
큲잖픦퓒
줊읺헏쁳엳픒휞몮슲펂폺잂쿦핖힎잚젎헪큲
힟짤펞컪픦칺푷솧뻲훊쪎픊옪

17. .VMUJDBTFTUVEZOEJOHT
$BTF1
!
OBCMFNFOU 혾힏
묞
큲잖픒핂푷쁢멑픎킫몒핂빦켆
ˑ빦쁢핳팮읊많힎몮핖믾쌚줆펞빦쁢힟픦줊읺헏핆핊픒힎팘팒푢빦픦핊픎푢읺힎잚푢읺몒
펞몵핳헎핳쁢
멑핂펞푢핂펔픊졂핂얾멑슲핂섢펂엲풮픒먾펞푢˒
!
1픎핂퍋믾쌚줆펞줊읺헏픊옪튾쁢멑핂펂엲풮삲
뽆읊믾퓒
큲잖픎
1픎읾쇦펂핖쁢
ˑ빦쁢읾쇊펂핖쁢멑픒핋쁢멑펞핂짆뻖줂뻖줂힎믾쌚줆핂횮
힎믖픎헒
핂멑픎삶쿪헟믊컿픦

18. .VMUJDBTFTUVEZOEJOHT
$BTF1
!
4JUVBUJPOBMJNQBJSNFOUT 캏핂빦잳앋쌚줆펞핳팮많짪캫쁢몋푾
픒많힎몮많쁢멑뫊헎핳쁢멑펞캏샇뽆엳쌚줆펞믆쁢폲앦묞삲
ˑ싾씉빮펞쁢헎쁢켢쁢믆멑픒썶펂
쓶잂밚쫞멏빦푢
믆읺몮핞
않핂쩒킪솒핂큖많쇪삲
!
0UIFSBDDFTTJCJMJUZDIBMMFOHFT
1픎7PJDFUP5FYU믾쁳픒큲잖펞컪쌚믆삲힎퓮푷힎팘삲

19. .VMUJDBTFTUVEZOEJOHT
$BTF1
1쁢켆
풂솧쁳엳뫊잞쁢멑핂슲삲

핊솧팖핊
$POUFYUVBMTFTTJPO힒펞컪믆쁢맪핆헣쫂뫎읺
4/4
픚킫헞

/FJHICPSIPPEBDUJWJUJFT펞컪쁢졾픒멅먾빦퍋묻픒짷줆쁢멑
큲잖캊컿맲얻킪4 헟믊컿솒묺칺푷9
훊칺푷
큲잖픦퓒
줊읺헏쁳엳콞젎
힟짤펞컪픦칺푷쿊
잖픒훊쪎

20. .VMUJDBTFTUVEZOEJOHT
$BTF1
!
OBCMFNFOU 혾힏
묞
1쁢팒줂뫃맒
팒줂킪맒펞컪풞멷픊옪핊픒몮핖펂큲잖픒퓮푷삲몮캫맏삲
ˑ빦쁢큲
!
큲잖픎펂썲칺멂핂짪캫픒쌚믆멑펞샎샎
ˑ헎쁢킺힎펂
!
1읊칺푷쿦핖멚
폎삲
믆쁢큲잖픒믾믾읊삲퍟멚칺푷삲폖읊슲졂
믆쁢믆많잖펞핳픒쫂얺맖쌚
힟펞핖쁢J1BE읊핂푷펺뽆컪
맒삲믆멑픒큲잖펞쫂뺂펂핆삲
ˑ헎쁢핦튾힎좉푢몮슿묞쌚쭎
삖삲믆멑슲픎헒쭎솧믾쇦펂핖킃삖삲˒

21. .VMUJDBTFTUVEZOEJOHT
$BTF1
!
4JUVBUJPOBMJNQBJSNFOUT 캏핂빦잳앋쌚줆펞핳팮많짪캫쁢몋푾
빮틶쁢1펞멚폏픒짆
믆엕힎잚찒많폲먾빦
ˑ푾짣핂폲쁢빮빦쁢봊힫쿦펔펖펂푢빦쁢큋멚훊젆삖읊칺푷쿦펔펖몮
빦쁢뺂픒헤힎팘멚펂싢펞숞펖쁢힎혾
많펂엲풮펂푢˒
!
0UIFSBDDFTTJCJMJUZDIBMMFOHFT
1쁢믎틶읊쿦헣쁢멑
쫃칺쭧펺뻱믾
젎
ˑ빦픦찮슽큲
!
줆핞읊쿦헣쁢멑펻킪솒잲푾펂엲풂핊핂삲줆핞읊쿦헣쁢멑픎잲푾핟믾쌚줆핂삲핂얾멑픒멾믾퓒1쁢삲
읆싢짢핂큲칺푷픒섢컮삲
ˑ큲잖펞컪잜픎핓엳픒퍊몋푾펞쁢뻖줂펂엲풚컪많쁳앷

22. .VMUJDBTFTUVEZOEJOHT
$BTF1
1쁢켆
핊솧팖맪픦삲핂펂읺읊핟컿픊젾핞킮픦팒핂읊많힎몮핖삲
$POUFYUVBMTFTTJPO펞컪쁢믆픦풚
컿픎퍊푆펞컪픦콚
쿦픦졕많힎솧잚픒쁢섾
퐪뺞졂1쁢킪몶펞캂믾쌚줆핂삲믆앦컪켆켦픎풂헒캏픒몮(14뻲찒멚핂켦픒
/FJHICPSIPPEBDUJWJUJFT샎킮펞폎삲
!
큲잖팮팒핂 헟믊컿솒묺칺푷9
훊칺푷펢
큲잖픦퓒
줊읺헏쁳엳
힟짤펞컪픦칺푷많혿짷줆
%JOJOHSPPN

23. .VMUJDBTFTUVEZOEJOHT
$BTF1
!
OBCMFNFOU 혾힏
묞
1펞멚짦쫃헏핆뫊펓뫊맪핆헣쫂뫎읺읊힟펞컪핂푷쿦핖멚삲
ˑ큲잖픒많힎믾헒펞헎쁢핳킲펞맖쌚펞솒뽆쭏픒슲몮맢펖펂푢핆삲섦많쁢
멑졶숞큲잖핂샎
!
4JUVBUJPOBMJNQBJSNFOUT 캏핂빦잳앋쌚줆펞핳팮많짪캫쁢몋푾
1많퍊푆펞빦많핖픒쌚
홓홓많짷팖펞핖쁢큲잖픒
핂엂몋푾헒읊짩쁢삲섦많쁢솧펞밚힎짷쇪삲
!
0UIFSBDDFTTJCJMJUZDIBMMFOHFT
1많퍊푆펞빦많핖픒쌚
홓홓많짷팖펞핖쁢큲잖픒
핂엂몋푾헒읊짩쁢삲섦많쁢솧밚힎짷쇪삲

24. .VMUJDBTFTUVEZOEJOHT
$BTF1
1쁢켆
뾚쪟쪎핳팮읊팡몮핖삲
핊솧팖맪픦삲핂펂읺읊핟컿픊젾핞킮픦팒핂읊많힎몮핖삲
$POUFYUVBMTFTTJPO펞컪쁢
/FJHICPSIPPE핳콚쁢캏헞펞짷줆먾빦퍋묻
큲잖팮팒핂

25. 킪읺
훊칺푷헣쫂헟믊 빮틶
퓇
쁂큲
큲잖픦퓒
줊읺헏쁳엳졶슮5BTL컿뫃헏픊옪쿦
힟짤펞컪픦칺푷잖픒훊쪎솚팒삲삖믾

26. .VMUJDBTFTUVEZOEJOHT
$BTF1
!
OBCMFNFOU 혾힏
묞
1펞멚큲잖픎줊읺헏핆줆헪읊믇쫃쿦핖멚훎삲
ˑ큲잖픒많힎몮핖쁢멑잚픊옪솒줊읺헏핆뽆엳핂묗핳잜핂훒펂슲펖펂푢˒
핂솧캏펞컪1쁢힎
ˑ펦읺쩮핂
1쁢쏞큲잖픒픚컿핓엳펺핂푷펺57퐎큲
!
4JUVBUJPOBMJNQBJSNFOUT 캏핂빦잳앋쌚줆펞핳팮많짪캫쁢몋푾
캏핂빦잳앋펞뫎엶쇪캏핂먾픦핊펂빦힎팘팦삲
빦폏픒짆
!
0UIFSBDDFTTJCJMJUZDIBMMFOHFT
1쁢삲

27. .VMUJDBTFTUVEZOEJOHT
$SPTTDBTFOBMZTJTBOE4VNNBSZ
!
헒짦헏픊옪큲잖픎킲뺂푆펞컪짪멚칺푷쇦펖삲
킲펞
!
OBCMFNFOU 혾힏
묞
큲잖픎핂솧픒솒퐎훊쁢펻픒삲
힎
풞멷펓줂읊솒퐎훎삲
뭐픎빮틶먾빦쌚쁢
폶않핆쿊펞샎펂읺
POTJUF펞컪픦줊멂픒묺핓쁢줆헪많$POUFYUVBMTFTTJPO펞컪뫃
줊읺헏핆쭎샂픒훒핂졂컪삲읆믾믾읊혾홓쿦핖멚훎삲
풚
졶짢핊싢짢핂큲쁢줊읺헏픊옪믾쁢퓒읊샎
핂읊

28. .VMUJDBTFTUVEZOEJOHT
$SPTTDBTFOBMZTJTBOE4VNNBSZ
!
4JUVBUJPOBMJNQBJSNFOUT 캏핂빦잳앋쌚줆펞핳팮많짪캫쁢몋푾
,BOF픦펾묺읊슅짩
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
:FFUBMˏT픦펾묺읊슅짩
?
삲잚퍊푆펞컪쁢슪켙픒빎삲섦힎쁢짷킫픊옪핊쭎멾몮핖믾솒삲

29. .VMUJDBTFTUVEZOEJOHT
$SPTTDBTFOBMZTJTBOE4VNNBSZ
!
0UIFSBDDFTTJCJMJUZDIBMMFOHFT
.VMUJUPVDI핓엳펞샎핂헒펾묺읊멎흫삲
폲힏졓픦펔픊졂쭖많
쁳삲
졶짢핊픚컿핆킫콢욶켦 FY4JSJ
쁢
!
8JTIFTGPSGVUVSFUFDIOPMPHJFT
켆졓픦
1쁢.VMUJUPVDI펞샎샎팖핂푢삲몮잞삲
믆푆펞솒줂컮슿핂핖펖삲

30. %JTDVTTJPO
1IZTJDBMXPSMEBDDFTTJCJMJUZ
픒훒폎삲
뫃맒싢핞핂뻖슲픎펂쎉멚졶짢핊컪찒큲많줊읺헏헟믊컿픒캏킪
짆앦픦큲잖픦핮핺헏핆핳헞픎졶짢핊싢짢핂큲옪혾홓쿦핖쁢힟팖솒묺슲핂잜삲쁢멑핂삲
!
.PCJMFUFYUJOQVU
졕졕킪펞퓶
헏핂힎팘픎졂솒쫂폎삲
핂줆헪읊멾엲졂읊샎
먾빦쁢슿픦짷팖핂푢삲
!
4JUVBUJPOBMJNQBJSNFOUT
,BOF픦펾묺펞컪킪맏핳팮핆픒훟킺픊옪4JUVBUJPOBMJNQBJSNFOU픦폏픒삲욶몮핖쁢섾
핂멑핂풂솧핳팮핆펞멚솒
샇쇶픒흫졓쿦핖펖삲
푾읺픦핆싷슲픎펂썲잳앋푢콚많풂솧핳팮핆픦졶짢핊헟믊컿펞폏픒짆

31. %JTDVTTJPO
1PUFOUJBMPGXFBSBCMFEFWJDF
졶짢핊핓엳짷쩣픎삲읆싢짢핂큲슲 풶펂얺쯢핳찒
픚컿슿
옪빦쀦펂힖쿦핖삲
핂엕멚캖옻멚슿핳쁢뺂좆뫊캏쭧펂핖픒쿦핖쁢풶펂얺쯢핳찒펞샎
!
-BCUPSFBMXPSME
-JTB픦펾묺읊헪푆졂힎믖밚힎먾픦졶슮펾묺슲핂킲킲켆픊옪힒핂쇦펂퐢삲
킲킲켆솒쭒졓픦짆많핖힎잚킲헪몋펞컪잚

32. 맞칺삖삲

33. situational impairment
!
a difficulty accessing computers due to the context or
situation one is in, as opposed to a physical impairment.
Examples include noise, poor lighting, distractions, other
tasks that require use of hands or eyes, and social
constraints such as the inappropriateness of using devices
with audio when attending a lecture. For instance, users who
are driving are unable to effectively work with complex visual
displays. Users in noisy situations (or quiet ones) may be
unable to use audio or speech interfaces.