AN INTRODUCTION TO IMPACT INVESTINGUpdate, v.1.2Slideshare VersionJanuary 2011
SUMMARYWHAT IS IMPACT INVESTING?GLOBAL MARKETPLACELOCAL MARKETPLACEMARKET POTENTIAL
What is impact investing?
WHAT IS IMPACT INVESTING?Impact investments aim to solve social or environmental challenges while generating financial return. Impact investing includes investments that range from producing a return of principal capital to offering market-rate or even market-beating financial returns.
WHAT IS IMPACT INVESTING?Related terms/synonyms: community investing, program-related investments and mission-related investments (MRIs and PRIs are a sub-class of impact investments); not necessarily “new”Demonstrable social and/or environmental impactNot SRI (socially responsible investing) or negative screening“Although impact investing could be categorized as a type of "socially responsible investing," it contrasts with negative screening, which focuses primarily on avoiding investments in "bad" or "harmful" companies - impact investors actively seek to place capital in businesses and funds that can harness the positive power of enterprise.”
WHAT IS IMPACT INVESTING?
What is the global marketplace for impact investing?
GLOBAL MARKETPLACEPotential market sizeprojected that this asset class will grow to $500 billion globally by 2019 (Monitor)
is currently a $120 billion market opportunity for impact investing amongst high net worth individuals (Hope Consulting)Current market sizecommunity investing (PRIs, MRIs, CDFIs, community development banks, and community venture funds) has total assets of $25.77 Billion (US) in 2007 (Rockefeller)
Global estimate: $50 billion (2009)GLOBAL MARKETPLACEINDUSTRY PLAYERSFUNDS (targeting MFIs, BoP ventures and SMEs)INVESTORSINVESTMENT FIRMSPeople like you.™
GLOBAL MARKETPLACENew York City Acquisition Fund (Debt)Purpose: support the development of 30,000 low income housing units in New York CityTarget ventures: for-profit and non-profit affordable housing developersFund size: $230 millionInvestment size and term (ventures): Up to $7.5 mil (new build) or $15 mil (acquisition); lending period of up to three yearsPartners/Investors: Collaboration with the City of New York, major foundations (ie. Ford Foundation, Rockefeller Foundation), and private/community investment groups (ie. JP Morgan Chase Bank)Financial return (investor): variable interest rate currently indexed to prime (minus 40 – 60 basis points)
Serviam Gardens: $3.6 million loan an 83-unit complex for low-income seniors in the Bronx.
GLOBAL MARKETPLACECalvert Community Investment Notes (Debt)Purpose: make loans to highly effective organizations that: develop or rehabilitate affordable homes, Finance small businesses, provide essential community services, and/or create jobs.Fund size: $200 million portfolioTarget ventures: community development intermediaries, affordable housing, social enterprises and micro enterprises in US and around the world.Investment size and term (ventures): $50k to $2.5 mil; lending period of one to five yearsInvestors: retail investors (min. of $20 online or $1,000 in-person)Financial return: variable (0.5 – 2 per cent)
Wood Street Urban Farm: $250k loan through Chicago Community Loan Fund for facility construction.
GLOBAL MARKETPLACEIgnia Fund I, LP (Equity)Purpose: empowers entrepreneurship and generates social impact at the base of the socioeconomic pyramid (BoP) in Latin AmericaTarget ventures: sectors that have a disproportionate impact on the lives of the poor, such as health care, nutrition, housing, education, and basic utilities.Fund size: $102 million (USD)Investment size and term (ventures): $2 – 10 mil per venture; 12 year term for exitInvestors: global and multilateral institutions and high net worth individuals (accredited investors)Financial return: target rate of return (IRR) is 25 – 30 per cent
Finestrella: $4 mil equity investment in regional mobile phone company focused on low-income customers.
What does the impact investingmarketplace look like in Canada?
LOCAL MARKETPLACELOCAL MARKETPLACECurrent market size estimated at ~$2 billion (including community investment, foundations, etc.)Potential market size: unknownFunds: Over $250 million in funds (and foundation investments) with proven track record; 30 funds operating or in developmentDeals: There is measurable (private) impact deal activity in Ontario mostly focused on debt instruments.  In total, there are over 200 “living” deals in place across the country.
LOCAL MARKETPLACEGRAPH: DEAL SIZE FOR COMMUNITY/ MISSION-RELATED INVESTMENTS FOR SELECTED CANADIAN FOUNDATIONS, 2010FoundationsRecent study reported that nine Can. foundations had $32 million community/mission investing assets in their endowments, representing four (4) per cent of their total assets.
LOCAL MARKETPLACEDEBT					EQUITYCHANTIER TRUST($50k to $1.5 mil)VANCITY CAPITAL CORPORATION($50k to $10 mil)CAIC: MORT.(Up to $500k)CLEANTECH VCsTAF($25 k - $750k)SCP (Up to $300k)INVESTECOCAIC: ENTERPRISE(Up to $50k)RENEWAL2TMX GROUP INC. (NEX, Cleantech Cluster, etc)($2 - $100+ mil Deals)ACCESS COMMUNITYCAPITAL (Up to $5k)CAPE FUND($1 - 7.5 million)OTTAWA COMMUNITY LOAN FUND(Up to $15k)$0		$500,000		$1 million				$10 million			                   $100 million
LOCAL MARKETPLACECanadian Alternative Investment Cooperative (CAIC)Purpose: building alternative economic structures that are supportive of worker cooperatives, disadvantaged peoples, and the environment.Target ventures: non-profits or charitable organizations, affordable housing initiatives, worker cooperatives, and social enterprises.  They target these focus areas through the provision of mortgages and loan financing.Fund size: $7 millionInvestment size and term: up to $50k loans & $500k mortgagesInvestors: 48 co-op members, including organizations across the country such as Montreal City Mission (Quebec), Catholic Health Association (Ontario) and Sisters of Service (Ontario).Financial return: mortgages (5 per cent) and loans (8-9 per cent)
LOCAL MARKETPLACEFIGURE: CASE STUDIES OF IMPACT INVESTING DEALS IN CANADAPRIVATE EQUITYRowe Farms (~$4 mil)DEBT VIA LOANSPlanet Bean Coffee ($250k)Atira Property Management ($150k)DEBT VIA BONDSCSI Bond ($1.8 mil)TCHC Bond ($450 mil)Skydragon Centre Bond  ($100k)$0		$500,000		$1 million				$10 million			                   $100 million+
What is the local potential for impact investing?
MARKET POTENTIALGRAPH: DEFINED CAPITAL NEED FOR TARGET SOCIAL VENTURES IN ONTARIO50 per cent of capital needTotal capital need amongst the cohort is estimated at ~$170 million.
MARKET POTENTIALKEY FACTS: VENTURESCapital demand: Capital demand for sampled social ventures equals $170 millionAccess to capital: Social ventures reported that access to capital was their primary resource need: social enterprises (78%) and social purpose businesses (80%)Impact of capital: 81 per cent of respondents stated that they could more effectively achieve their mission with improved access to capital for growth, infrastructure or working capitalCapital demand type: 54 per cent of social purpose businesses stated that they would be willing to issue public/private equity. 70 per cent of social purpose businesses would be interested in taking on debt, whereas 48 per cent of social enterprises were interested in taking on debt.
MARKET POTENTIALFIGURE: SAMPLE VENTURES WITH CAPITAL DEMAND
MARKET POTENTIALKEY FACTS: INVESTORSTarget: institutional and accredited investors (foundations, asset managers, and wealth managers)Interest in impact investing: 75 per cent would consider impact investments with market return, and 31 per cent would consider investments with modest or below market returnBarriers: 75 per cent of asset owners reported the lack of internal expertise to drive investments in impact investing as the most important barrier. 80 per cent of asset owners report that perceived viability of investees is a barrier to investing.Lack of knowledge about impact investing and lack of internal resources to identify such investments also represent a challenge for 58 per cent of the asset owners.
MARKET POTENTIALGRAPH: INSTITUTIONAL INVESTOR INTEREST IN SELECTED IMPACT INVESTING PRODUCTS
MARKET POTENTIALSUMMARY: SUPPLY & DEMANDSocial ventures have demand for capital.Non-profit and for-profit social ventures are interested in debt and equity investments.Social ventures have limited access to capital.There is an available supply of capital for social ventures.There is a strong base of existing impact investing activity.
MARKET POTENTIALGAPSIntermediation: There is no trusted, structured marketplace to facilitate private deals for funds or individual ventures. Capital demand does not align with existing supply: There is significant demand for capital amongst social ventures resulting in a regional gap in supply in Ontario.Deal design: Social ventures and investors are unfamiliar with existing and emerging means of structuring impact investing deals.Financial expertise: Ventures do not have efficient and effective access to relevant expertise to increase their ability to acquire capital.

A Primer on Impact Investing

  • 1.
    AN INTRODUCTION TOIMPACT INVESTINGUpdate, v.1.2Slideshare VersionJanuary 2011
  • 2.
    SUMMARYWHAT IS IMPACTINVESTING?GLOBAL MARKETPLACELOCAL MARKETPLACEMARKET POTENTIAL
  • 3.
    What is impactinvesting?
  • 4.
    WHAT IS IMPACTINVESTING?Impact investments aim to solve social or environmental challenges while generating financial return. Impact investing includes investments that range from producing a return of principal capital to offering market-rate or even market-beating financial returns.
  • 5.
    WHAT IS IMPACTINVESTING?Related terms/synonyms: community investing, program-related investments and mission-related investments (MRIs and PRIs are a sub-class of impact investments); not necessarily “new”Demonstrable social and/or environmental impactNot SRI (socially responsible investing) or negative screening“Although impact investing could be categorized as a type of "socially responsible investing," it contrasts with negative screening, which focuses primarily on avoiding investments in "bad" or "harmful" companies - impact investors actively seek to place capital in businesses and funds that can harness the positive power of enterprise.”
  • 6.
    WHAT IS IMPACTINVESTING?
  • 7.
    What is theglobal marketplace for impact investing?
  • 8.
    GLOBAL MARKETPLACEPotential marketsizeprojected that this asset class will grow to $500 billion globally by 2019 (Monitor)
  • 9.
    is currently a$120 billion market opportunity for impact investing amongst high net worth individuals (Hope Consulting)Current market sizecommunity investing (PRIs, MRIs, CDFIs, community development banks, and community venture funds) has total assets of $25.77 Billion (US) in 2007 (Rockefeller)
  • 10.
    Global estimate: $50billion (2009)GLOBAL MARKETPLACEINDUSTRY PLAYERSFUNDS (targeting MFIs, BoP ventures and SMEs)INVESTORSINVESTMENT FIRMSPeople like you.™
  • 11.
    GLOBAL MARKETPLACENew YorkCity Acquisition Fund (Debt)Purpose: support the development of 30,000 low income housing units in New York CityTarget ventures: for-profit and non-profit affordable housing developersFund size: $230 millionInvestment size and term (ventures): Up to $7.5 mil (new build) or $15 mil (acquisition); lending period of up to three yearsPartners/Investors: Collaboration with the City of New York, major foundations (ie. Ford Foundation, Rockefeller Foundation), and private/community investment groups (ie. JP Morgan Chase Bank)Financial return (investor): variable interest rate currently indexed to prime (minus 40 – 60 basis points)
  • 12.
    Serviam Gardens: $3.6million loan an 83-unit complex for low-income seniors in the Bronx.
  • 13.
    GLOBAL MARKETPLACECalvert CommunityInvestment Notes (Debt)Purpose: make loans to highly effective organizations that: develop or rehabilitate affordable homes, Finance small businesses, provide essential community services, and/or create jobs.Fund size: $200 million portfolioTarget ventures: community development intermediaries, affordable housing, social enterprises and micro enterprises in US and around the world.Investment size and term (ventures): $50k to $2.5 mil; lending period of one to five yearsInvestors: retail investors (min. of $20 online or $1,000 in-person)Financial return: variable (0.5 – 2 per cent)
  • 14.
    Wood Street UrbanFarm: $250k loan through Chicago Community Loan Fund for facility construction.
  • 15.
    GLOBAL MARKETPLACEIgnia FundI, LP (Equity)Purpose: empowers entrepreneurship and generates social impact at the base of the socioeconomic pyramid (BoP) in Latin AmericaTarget ventures: sectors that have a disproportionate impact on the lives of the poor, such as health care, nutrition, housing, education, and basic utilities.Fund size: $102 million (USD)Investment size and term (ventures): $2 – 10 mil per venture; 12 year term for exitInvestors: global and multilateral institutions and high net worth individuals (accredited investors)Financial return: target rate of return (IRR) is 25 – 30 per cent
  • 16.
    Finestrella: $4 milequity investment in regional mobile phone company focused on low-income customers.
  • 17.
    What does theimpact investingmarketplace look like in Canada?
  • 18.
    LOCAL MARKETPLACELOCAL MARKETPLACECurrentmarket size estimated at ~$2 billion (including community investment, foundations, etc.)Potential market size: unknownFunds: Over $250 million in funds (and foundation investments) with proven track record; 30 funds operating or in developmentDeals: There is measurable (private) impact deal activity in Ontario mostly focused on debt instruments. In total, there are over 200 “living” deals in place across the country.
  • 19.
    LOCAL MARKETPLACEGRAPH: DEALSIZE FOR COMMUNITY/ MISSION-RELATED INVESTMENTS FOR SELECTED CANADIAN FOUNDATIONS, 2010FoundationsRecent study reported that nine Can. foundations had $32 million community/mission investing assets in their endowments, representing four (4) per cent of their total assets.
  • 20.
    LOCAL MARKETPLACEDEBT EQUITYCHANTIER TRUST($50kto $1.5 mil)VANCITY CAPITAL CORPORATION($50k to $10 mil)CAIC: MORT.(Up to $500k)CLEANTECH VCsTAF($25 k - $750k)SCP (Up to $300k)INVESTECOCAIC: ENTERPRISE(Up to $50k)RENEWAL2TMX GROUP INC. (NEX, Cleantech Cluster, etc)($2 - $100+ mil Deals)ACCESS COMMUNITYCAPITAL (Up to $5k)CAPE FUND($1 - 7.5 million)OTTAWA COMMUNITY LOAN FUND(Up to $15k)$0 $500,000 $1 million $10 million $100 million
  • 21.
    LOCAL MARKETPLACECanadian AlternativeInvestment Cooperative (CAIC)Purpose: building alternative economic structures that are supportive of worker cooperatives, disadvantaged peoples, and the environment.Target ventures: non-profits or charitable organizations, affordable housing initiatives, worker cooperatives, and social enterprises. They target these focus areas through the provision of mortgages and loan financing.Fund size: $7 millionInvestment size and term: up to $50k loans & $500k mortgagesInvestors: 48 co-op members, including organizations across the country such as Montreal City Mission (Quebec), Catholic Health Association (Ontario) and Sisters of Service (Ontario).Financial return: mortgages (5 per cent) and loans (8-9 per cent)
  • 22.
    LOCAL MARKETPLACEFIGURE: CASESTUDIES OF IMPACT INVESTING DEALS IN CANADAPRIVATE EQUITYRowe Farms (~$4 mil)DEBT VIA LOANSPlanet Bean Coffee ($250k)Atira Property Management ($150k)DEBT VIA BONDSCSI Bond ($1.8 mil)TCHC Bond ($450 mil)Skydragon Centre Bond ($100k)$0 $500,000 $1 million $10 million $100 million+
  • 23.
    What is thelocal potential for impact investing?
  • 24.
    MARKET POTENTIALGRAPH: DEFINEDCAPITAL NEED FOR TARGET SOCIAL VENTURES IN ONTARIO50 per cent of capital needTotal capital need amongst the cohort is estimated at ~$170 million.
  • 25.
    MARKET POTENTIALKEY FACTS:VENTURESCapital demand: Capital demand for sampled social ventures equals $170 millionAccess to capital: Social ventures reported that access to capital was their primary resource need: social enterprises (78%) and social purpose businesses (80%)Impact of capital: 81 per cent of respondents stated that they could more effectively achieve their mission with improved access to capital for growth, infrastructure or working capitalCapital demand type: 54 per cent of social purpose businesses stated that they would be willing to issue public/private equity. 70 per cent of social purpose businesses would be interested in taking on debt, whereas 48 per cent of social enterprises were interested in taking on debt.
  • 26.
    MARKET POTENTIALFIGURE: SAMPLEVENTURES WITH CAPITAL DEMAND
  • 27.
    MARKET POTENTIALKEY FACTS:INVESTORSTarget: institutional and accredited investors (foundations, asset managers, and wealth managers)Interest in impact investing: 75 per cent would consider impact investments with market return, and 31 per cent would consider investments with modest or below market returnBarriers: 75 per cent of asset owners reported the lack of internal expertise to drive investments in impact investing as the most important barrier. 80 per cent of asset owners report that perceived viability of investees is a barrier to investing.Lack of knowledge about impact investing and lack of internal resources to identify such investments also represent a challenge for 58 per cent of the asset owners.
  • 28.
    MARKET POTENTIALGRAPH: INSTITUTIONALINVESTOR INTEREST IN SELECTED IMPACT INVESTING PRODUCTS
  • 29.
    MARKET POTENTIALSUMMARY: SUPPLY& DEMANDSocial ventures have demand for capital.Non-profit and for-profit social ventures are interested in debt and equity investments.Social ventures have limited access to capital.There is an available supply of capital for social ventures.There is a strong base of existing impact investing activity.
  • 30.
    MARKET POTENTIALGAPSIntermediation: Thereis no trusted, structured marketplace to facilitate private deals for funds or individual ventures. Capital demand does not align with existing supply: There is significant demand for capital amongst social ventures resulting in a regional gap in supply in Ontario.Deal design: Social ventures and investors are unfamiliar with existing and emerging means of structuring impact investing deals.Financial expertise: Ventures do not have efficient and effective access to relevant expertise to increase their ability to acquire capital.

Editor's Notes

  • #5 - people, planet and profits
  • #11 GBF's mission is to build and support high-impact enterprises that provide sustainable economic opportunities to thousands of people at the base of the economic pyramid. GBF actively supports enterprises throughout Latin America, Africa, India, and Southeast Asia. RSF Social Investment Fund: diversified, direct loan fund comprised of over 75 leading non-profit organizations and for-profit social enterprises. Root Capital: nonprofit social investment fund that is pioneering finance for grassroots businesses in rural areas of developing countries in central america, latin america, and east and west africa. Root Capital provides capital, financial education, and market connections to small and growing businesses
  • #15 Facility operates a transitional employment program for residents who have been incarcerated or were homeless. Over 150 individuals have benefited from the job training program, which has also provided local families with access to local, organic produce.