SlideShare a Scribd company logo
,e-,-la-44@tsih@14&eSallZ ljkZQ ,DliksVZl~] ljnkj'kgj A
vk;dj vihyh; vf/kdj.k] t;iqj U;k;ihB] t;iqj
INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL, JAIPUR BENCH, JAIPUR
Jh vkj-ih-rksykuh] U;kf;d lnL; ,oa Jh Vh-vkj-ehuk] yscL; ds le{k
(BEFORE SHRI R.P. TOLANI AND SHRI T.R.MEENA)
M.A. No.44/JP/2014
(A/o ITA No.390, 679/JP/13 & C.O. 30,52/JP/13)
Assessment Year : 2009-10
PAN : AATFS 9394N
The Dy.Commissioner of Income Tax, Vs. M/s.Saraf Export,
Jhunjhunu. Sardarshar.
vihykFkhZ@Appellant izR;FkhZ@Respondent
M.A. No.45/JP/2014
(A/o ITA No.739/JP/12)
Assessment Year : 2009-10
The Asstt.Commissioner of Income Tax, Vs. M/s.Saraf Export,
Circle, Jhunjhunu. Sardarshar.
vihykFkhZ@Appellant izR;FkhZ@Respondent
M.A. No.46/JP/2014
(A/o ITA No.819/JP/13)
Assessment Year : 2009-10
The Asstt.Commissioner of Income Tax, Vs. M/s.Saraf Seasoning Udyog,
Circle, Jhunjhunu. Sardarshar.
vihykFkhZ@Appellant izR;FkhZ@Respondent
foHkkx dh vksj ls@Department by : Sh.Kailash Mangal (JCIT)
fu/kkZfjrh dh vksj ls@Assessee by : Sh.Suresh Ojha & D.S.Bohra, (Adv.)
lquokbZ dh frfFk@Date of Hearing : 10.04.2015
?kks"k.kk dh frfFk@Date of Pronouncemtnt: 10.04.2015
,e-,-la-44@tsih@14&eSallZ ljkZQ ,DliksVZl~] ljnkj'kgj
- 2 -
vkns'k
ORDER
PER T.R.MEENA, AM:-
The revenue filed M.A. in all the cases wherein it has been contended that
Hon’ble ITAT, Jaipur Bench in its order ITA No.390/JP/2013, C.O. 13/JP/13 and ITA
679/JP/13, C.O.53/JP/13 dated 27.12.2013 has not considered the Hon’ble
Supreme Court decision in case of Liberty India 317 ITR 218(SC) that duty draw
back income is not part of 80IB deduction & resulted Platently wrong & improper
decision given by the Hon’ble ITAT in all the cases (A/o ITA No. 390, 679/JP/13 &
C.O. 30, 52/JP/13, 739/JP/12, 819/JP/13) which is apparent mistake on the part of
Hon’ble ITAT.
2. The Ld.A.R. for the assessee’s file written submission and argued that
application submitted by the A.O. u/s 254(2) of the IT Act is not at all an
application. The order passed by the Hon’ble Tribunal is a conscious order
therefore the application is not at all application in para 2 of this revenue M.A.
worded the application that Hon’ble ITAT’s order in case of the assessee’s
“patently wrong and improper due to following reasons”. The language of
application itself stated that the view which is in favour of department must
have been taken.
,e-,-la-44@tsih@14&eSallZ ljkZQ ,DliksVZl~] ljnkj'kgj
- 3 -
The department wants to dected his condition for accepting the application in
the moreover in which the department wants. The department had admitted
that matter is debatable which can not be rectify u/s 254(2) of the IT Act by
relying Hon’ble Supreme Court decision in case of Vokard India 82 ITR 50 further
department has admitted as under :-
“Further it is a trite that when any amended provision is not
considered or for that matter any relevant provision of the Act is
not considered while giving a judgment, it is treated as in per
curium……………………”
3. The Hon’ble Tribunal had considered the judgement Liberty India (supra) in
above decision. Therefore he requested to impose cost on AO for not drafting
proper application for rectification with respect to Hon’ble ITAT’s order u/s 254(2)
of the IT Act and same may be dismissed. He further relied upon following cases:-
1. ITA No.22 & 23/Jodh/2012 M/s.Saraf Export,
2. 82 ITR 50 T.S.Balram
3. 237 ITR 165 Keshari Metal Pvt.Ltd.,
4. 192 ITR 252 Indian Steel & Wire Product
5. 247 ITR 274 Prakash Chand Nahta
6. 168 ITR 809 ITO Vs. ITAT
7. M.A.49/Jodh./2008 Choksi Heraeus P.Ltd.,
8. M.A. 10/JU/2009 Hanumangarh Kray Vikray Sah.Sam.
9. 72 Taxmann 43 Kamalakshi Finance Corpn.Ltd.,(SC)
4. We have heard the rival submission of both the parties and perused the
material available on record. This Bench has considered the Hon’ble Supreme
,e-,-la-44@tsih@14&eSallZ ljkZQ ,DliksVZl~] ljnkj'kgj
- 4 -
Court decision in case of Liberty India (supra) in assessee’s case and decided issue
as per the amended provision of 80IB of the IT Act. Therefore we dismiss all the
three M.A.s filed by the revenue.
Order pronounced in the open Court on 10.04.2015
Sd/- Sd/-
(R.P.TOLANI) (T.R.MEENA)
U;kf;d lnL;@Judicial Member ys[kk lnL;@Accountant Member
t;iqj@Jaipur,
fnukad@Date : 10/04/2015
*Basant*
vkns'k dh izfrfyfi vxzsf"kr@Copy of the order forwarded to :-
1- mik;qDr vk;dj] >qa>quwa@The DCIT, Jhunjhunu.
2- eSallZ ljkZQ ,DliksVZ] ljnkj'kgj@M/s.Saraf Export, Sardarshar.
3- foHkkxh; izfrfuf/k] t;iqj@The D.R. ITAT, Jaipur
4- xkMZ QkbZy@The Guard File (in M.A. No.44/JP/2014)
vkns'kkuqlkj
By Order
lgk;d iathdkj@Assistant Registrar

More Related Content

What's hot

Aditya Traders vs. ITO Ward-1, Hanumangarh
Aditya Traders vs. ITO Ward-1, HanumangarhAditya Traders vs. ITO Ward-1, Hanumangarh
Aditya Traders vs. ITO Ward-1, Hanumangarh
suresh ojha
 
Gagandeep Kathuria vs. ITO Ward-1, Sriganganagar
Gagandeep Kathuria vs. ITO Ward-1, SriganganagarGagandeep Kathuria vs. ITO Ward-1, Sriganganagar
Gagandeep Kathuria vs. ITO Ward-1, Sriganganagar
suresh ojha
 
Memo.32708 cfms instructions and clarifications to dd os
Memo.32708 cfms instructions and clarifications to dd osMemo.32708 cfms instructions and clarifications to dd os
Memo.32708 cfms instructions and clarifications to dd os
Rajkumar Kamarsu
 
reply to counter in Crl.O.P.No6002
reply to counter in Crl.O.P.No6002reply to counter in Crl.O.P.No6002
reply to counter in Crl.O.P.No6002
chandira thangavel
 
Online Complaint against MOLAJ dated 16.08.2016
Online Complaint against MOLAJ dated 16.08.2016Online Complaint against MOLAJ dated 16.08.2016
Online Complaint against MOLAJ dated 16.08.2016
Om Prakash Poddar
 
500.32 animal facility license application process
500.32 animal facility license application process500.32 animal facility license application process
500.32 animal facility license application process
No Kill Shelter Alliance
 
Renewal-FCRA Certificate
Renewal-FCRA CertificateRenewal-FCRA Certificate
Renewal-FCRA Certificate
Pradeep Mohapatra
 
139
139139
139
ramu458
 
NCLT order on compounding and annual accounts
NCLT order on compounding and annual accounts NCLT order on compounding and annual accounts
NCLT order on compounding and annual accounts
GAURAV KR SHARMA
 
Manual of patent office practice and procedure in india | How to file a paten...
Manual of patent office practice and procedure in india | How to file a paten...Manual of patent office practice and procedure in india | How to file a paten...
Manual of patent office practice and procedure in india | How to file a paten...
Intepat IP
 
News flash Indirect Tax 260115
News flash   Indirect Tax 260115News flash   Indirect Tax 260115
News flash Indirect Tax 260115
udyog
 
Lokpal 2
Lokpal 2Lokpal 2
Lokpal 2
skbabbar
 
Zakia jafri sc 34207 2018 3_1_31354_order_17-nov-2021
Zakia jafri sc 34207 2018 3_1_31354_order_17-nov-2021Zakia jafri sc 34207 2018 3_1_31354_order_17-nov-2021
Zakia jafri sc 34207 2018 3_1_31354_order_17-nov-2021
sabrangsabrang
 
Zakia jafri 34207 2018 3_1_31133_order_11-nov-2021
Zakia jafri 34207 2018 3_1_31133_order_11-nov-2021Zakia jafri 34207 2018 3_1_31133_order_11-nov-2021
Zakia jafri 34207 2018 3_1_31133_order_11-nov-2021
sabrangsabrang
 
Zakia jafri34207 2018 3_2_31132_order_10-nov-2021
Zakia jafri34207 2018 3_2_31132_order_10-nov-2021Zakia jafri34207 2018 3_2_31132_order_10-nov-2021
Zakia jafri34207 2018 3_2_31132_order_10-nov-2021
sabrangsabrang
 
B-411489_1__LATVIAN_CONNECTION__LLC__ ( OFFICIAL GPE IS FBO )
B-411489_1__LATVIAN_CONNECTION__LLC__   ( OFFICIAL GPE IS FBO )B-411489_1__LATVIAN_CONNECTION__LLC__   ( OFFICIAL GPE IS FBO )
B-411489_1__LATVIAN_CONNECTION__LLC__ ( OFFICIAL GPE IS FBO )
Keven Barnes
 
Chimes DGCA Approved Academy - DGCA Licence Renewal
Chimes DGCA Approved Academy - DGCA Licence RenewalChimes DGCA Approved Academy - DGCA Licence Renewal
Chimes DGCA Approved Academy - DGCA Licence Renewal
Saurav Mishra
 
Indian bio chemic act-2009, rules-2009
Indian bio chemic act-2009, rules-2009Indian bio chemic act-2009, rules-2009
Indian bio chemic act-2009, rules-2009
Indo-Socio Welfare-Foundation
 
Gencircular 042014
Gencircular 042014Gencircular 042014
Gencircular 042014
Mumbaikar Le
 

What's hot (19)

Aditya Traders vs. ITO Ward-1, Hanumangarh
Aditya Traders vs. ITO Ward-1, HanumangarhAditya Traders vs. ITO Ward-1, Hanumangarh
Aditya Traders vs. ITO Ward-1, Hanumangarh
 
Gagandeep Kathuria vs. ITO Ward-1, Sriganganagar
Gagandeep Kathuria vs. ITO Ward-1, SriganganagarGagandeep Kathuria vs. ITO Ward-1, Sriganganagar
Gagandeep Kathuria vs. ITO Ward-1, Sriganganagar
 
Memo.32708 cfms instructions and clarifications to dd os
Memo.32708 cfms instructions and clarifications to dd osMemo.32708 cfms instructions and clarifications to dd os
Memo.32708 cfms instructions and clarifications to dd os
 
reply to counter in Crl.O.P.No6002
reply to counter in Crl.O.P.No6002reply to counter in Crl.O.P.No6002
reply to counter in Crl.O.P.No6002
 
Online Complaint against MOLAJ dated 16.08.2016
Online Complaint against MOLAJ dated 16.08.2016Online Complaint against MOLAJ dated 16.08.2016
Online Complaint against MOLAJ dated 16.08.2016
 
500.32 animal facility license application process
500.32 animal facility license application process500.32 animal facility license application process
500.32 animal facility license application process
 
Renewal-FCRA Certificate
Renewal-FCRA CertificateRenewal-FCRA Certificate
Renewal-FCRA Certificate
 
139
139139
139
 
NCLT order on compounding and annual accounts
NCLT order on compounding and annual accounts NCLT order on compounding and annual accounts
NCLT order on compounding and annual accounts
 
Manual of patent office practice and procedure in india | How to file a paten...
Manual of patent office practice and procedure in india | How to file a paten...Manual of patent office practice and procedure in india | How to file a paten...
Manual of patent office practice and procedure in india | How to file a paten...
 
News flash Indirect Tax 260115
News flash   Indirect Tax 260115News flash   Indirect Tax 260115
News flash Indirect Tax 260115
 
Lokpal 2
Lokpal 2Lokpal 2
Lokpal 2
 
Zakia jafri sc 34207 2018 3_1_31354_order_17-nov-2021
Zakia jafri sc 34207 2018 3_1_31354_order_17-nov-2021Zakia jafri sc 34207 2018 3_1_31354_order_17-nov-2021
Zakia jafri sc 34207 2018 3_1_31354_order_17-nov-2021
 
Zakia jafri 34207 2018 3_1_31133_order_11-nov-2021
Zakia jafri 34207 2018 3_1_31133_order_11-nov-2021Zakia jafri 34207 2018 3_1_31133_order_11-nov-2021
Zakia jafri 34207 2018 3_1_31133_order_11-nov-2021
 
Zakia jafri34207 2018 3_2_31132_order_10-nov-2021
Zakia jafri34207 2018 3_2_31132_order_10-nov-2021Zakia jafri34207 2018 3_2_31132_order_10-nov-2021
Zakia jafri34207 2018 3_2_31132_order_10-nov-2021
 
B-411489_1__LATVIAN_CONNECTION__LLC__ ( OFFICIAL GPE IS FBO )
B-411489_1__LATVIAN_CONNECTION__LLC__   ( OFFICIAL GPE IS FBO )B-411489_1__LATVIAN_CONNECTION__LLC__   ( OFFICIAL GPE IS FBO )
B-411489_1__LATVIAN_CONNECTION__LLC__ ( OFFICIAL GPE IS FBO )
 
Chimes DGCA Approved Academy - DGCA Licence Renewal
Chimes DGCA Approved Academy - DGCA Licence RenewalChimes DGCA Approved Academy - DGCA Licence Renewal
Chimes DGCA Approved Academy - DGCA Licence Renewal
 
Indian bio chemic act-2009, rules-2009
Indian bio chemic act-2009, rules-2009Indian bio chemic act-2009, rules-2009
Indian bio chemic act-2009, rules-2009
 
Gencircular 042014
Gencircular 042014Gencircular 042014
Gencircular 042014
 

Viewers also liked

CSR Project at Support Foundation PPT
CSR Project at Support Foundation PPTCSR Project at Support Foundation PPT
CSR Project at Support Foundation PPT
Abhay Banthia
 
Amarchand Borad vs. ITO, Ward-1, Sriganganagar
Amarchand Borad vs. ITO, Ward-1, SriganganagarAmarchand Borad vs. ITO, Ward-1, Sriganganagar
Amarchand Borad vs. ITO, Ward-1, Sriganganagar
suresh ojha
 
Ganesh Builders vs CIT, Bikaner
Ganesh Builders vs CIT, BikanerGanesh Builders vs CIT, Bikaner
Ganesh Builders vs CIT, Bikaner
suresh ojha
 
Anoopgarh K.V.Sah Samiti vs. ACIT, Sriganganagar
Anoopgarh K.V.Sah Samiti vs. ACIT, SriganganagarAnoopgarh K.V.Sah Samiti vs. ACIT, Sriganganagar
Anoopgarh K.V.Sah Samiti vs. ACIT, Sriganganagar
suresh ojha
 
Ms J.R. Tantia Charitable Trust
Ms J.R. Tantia Charitable TrustMs J.R. Tantia Charitable Trust
Ms J.R. Tantia Charitable Trust
suresh ojha
 
ms classic profile1
ms classic profile1ms classic profile1
ms classic profile1
Bongiwe Msomi
 
Kamal Kishore Jhanwar, Classic Marbles, Makrana vs ITO Ward-1, Makrana
Kamal Kishore Jhanwar, Classic Marbles, Makrana vs ITO Ward-1, MakranaKamal Kishore Jhanwar, Classic Marbles, Makrana vs ITO Ward-1, Makrana
Kamal Kishore Jhanwar, Classic Marbles, Makrana vs ITO Ward-1, Makrana
suresh ojha
 
DCIT Vs Saraf Export
DCIT Vs Saraf ExportDCIT Vs Saraf Export
DCIT Vs Saraf Export
suresh ojha
 
Kanoi Charitable Trust vs. CIT-II, Jodhpur
Kanoi Charitable Trust vs. CIT-II, JodhpurKanoi Charitable Trust vs. CIT-II, Jodhpur
Kanoi Charitable Trust vs. CIT-II, Jodhpur
suresh ojha
 
Gagan Deep Kathuria vs. ACIT, Sriganganagar
Gagan Deep Kathuria vs. ACIT, SriganganagarGagan Deep Kathuria vs. ACIT, Sriganganagar
Gagan Deep Kathuria vs. ACIT, Sriganganagar
suresh ojha
 
Gouri Shankar Singhal vs. ITO Ward-1 Sriganganagar
Gouri Shankar Singhal vs. ITO Ward-1 SriganganagarGouri Shankar Singhal vs. ITO Ward-1 Sriganganagar
Gouri Shankar Singhal vs. ITO Ward-1 Sriganganagar
suresh ojha
 
Shilpika creation
Shilpika creationShilpika creation
Shilpika creation
Pravesh Srivastav
 
YB CV
YB CVYB CV
YB CV
yao bankas
 

Viewers also liked (14)

CSR Project at Support Foundation PPT
CSR Project at Support Foundation PPTCSR Project at Support Foundation PPT
CSR Project at Support Foundation PPT
 
Amarchand Borad vs. ITO, Ward-1, Sriganganagar
Amarchand Borad vs. ITO, Ward-1, SriganganagarAmarchand Borad vs. ITO, Ward-1, Sriganganagar
Amarchand Borad vs. ITO, Ward-1, Sriganganagar
 
Ganesh Builders vs CIT, Bikaner
Ganesh Builders vs CIT, BikanerGanesh Builders vs CIT, Bikaner
Ganesh Builders vs CIT, Bikaner
 
Anoopgarh K.V.Sah Samiti vs. ACIT, Sriganganagar
Anoopgarh K.V.Sah Samiti vs. ACIT, SriganganagarAnoopgarh K.V.Sah Samiti vs. ACIT, Sriganganagar
Anoopgarh K.V.Sah Samiti vs. ACIT, Sriganganagar
 
Ms J.R. Tantia Charitable Trust
Ms J.R. Tantia Charitable TrustMs J.R. Tantia Charitable Trust
Ms J.R. Tantia Charitable Trust
 
ms classic profile1
ms classic profile1ms classic profile1
ms classic profile1
 
Kamal Kishore Jhanwar, Classic Marbles, Makrana vs ITO Ward-1, Makrana
Kamal Kishore Jhanwar, Classic Marbles, Makrana vs ITO Ward-1, MakranaKamal Kishore Jhanwar, Classic Marbles, Makrana vs ITO Ward-1, Makrana
Kamal Kishore Jhanwar, Classic Marbles, Makrana vs ITO Ward-1, Makrana
 
DCIT Vs Saraf Export
DCIT Vs Saraf ExportDCIT Vs Saraf Export
DCIT Vs Saraf Export
 
Kanoi Charitable Trust vs. CIT-II, Jodhpur
Kanoi Charitable Trust vs. CIT-II, JodhpurKanoi Charitable Trust vs. CIT-II, Jodhpur
Kanoi Charitable Trust vs. CIT-II, Jodhpur
 
MCDFeaturePagePdf451
MCDFeaturePagePdf451MCDFeaturePagePdf451
MCDFeaturePagePdf451
 
Gagan Deep Kathuria vs. ACIT, Sriganganagar
Gagan Deep Kathuria vs. ACIT, SriganganagarGagan Deep Kathuria vs. ACIT, Sriganganagar
Gagan Deep Kathuria vs. ACIT, Sriganganagar
 
Gouri Shankar Singhal vs. ITO Ward-1 Sriganganagar
Gouri Shankar Singhal vs. ITO Ward-1 SriganganagarGouri Shankar Singhal vs. ITO Ward-1 Sriganganagar
Gouri Shankar Singhal vs. ITO Ward-1 Sriganganagar
 
Shilpika creation
Shilpika creationShilpika creation
Shilpika creation
 
YB CV
YB CVYB CV
YB CV
 

Similar to 2014_DCIT_Vs._Saraf_Export

DRI Aug 2017.pdf
DRI Aug 2017.pdfDRI Aug 2017.pdf
DRI Aug 2017.pdf
Hindenburg Research
 
Case law knit
Case law  knitCase law  knit
Case law knit
mslad
 
Case law knit
Case law  knitCase law  knit
Case law knit
mslad
 
Published patent and design registration information september 19th, 2014
Published patent and design registration information   september 19th, 2014Published patent and design registration information   september 19th, 2014
Published patent and design registration information september 19th, 2014
InvnTree IP Services Pvt. Ltd.
 
CESTAT Ruling Power Equipment 2022.pdf
CESTAT Ruling Power Equipment 2022.pdfCESTAT Ruling Power Equipment 2022.pdf
CESTAT Ruling Power Equipment 2022.pdf
Hindenburg Research
 
Sc order freedom of rel act
Sc order freedom of rel actSc order freedom of rel act
Sc order freedom of rel act
sabrangsabrang
 
promotion judgemnet of Revenue department staff_welfare_vs_the_state_of_kerala
promotion judgemnet of Revenue department staff_welfare_vs_the_state_of_keralapromotion judgemnet of Revenue department staff_welfare_vs_the_state_of_kerala
promotion judgemnet of Revenue department staff_welfare_vs_the_state_of_kerala
shanavas chithara
 
Gauti Shankar vs. ITO, Ward-1, Sriganganagar
Gauti Shankar vs. ITO, Ward-1, SriganganagarGauti Shankar vs. ITO, Ward-1, Sriganganagar
Gauti Shankar vs. ITO, Ward-1, Sriganganagar
suresh ojha
 
BEFORE THE HON
BEFORE THE HONBEFORE THE HON
BEFORE THE HON
chandira thangavel
 
Patent registaration
Patent registarationPatent registaration
Patent registaration
aakashmehta1083
 
DRI 2014 (PMC Projects).pdf
DRI 2014 (PMC Projects).pdfDRI 2014 (PMC Projects).pdf
DRI 2014 (PMC Projects).pdf
Hindenburg Research
 
569257821928895310213$5^1 refno1725-_sahaini_social_service_society_
 569257821928895310213$5^1 refno1725-_sahaini_social_service_society_ 569257821928895310213$5^1 refno1725-_sahaini_social_service_society_
569257821928895310213$5^1 refno1725-_sahaini_social_service_society_
Mumbai Ngo
 
s. Hanumangarh Kray
s. Hanumangarh Krays. Hanumangarh Kray
s. Hanumangarh Kray
suresh ojha
 
030 2008-02789 (1)
030 2008-02789 (1)030 2008-02789 (1)
030 2008-02789 (1)
Raj kumar
 
Internal notification.pdf
Internal notification.pdfInternal notification.pdf
Internal notification.pdf
RikuGogoi1
 
Ipab procedures
Ipab proceduresIpab procedures
Ipab procedures
Altacit Global
 
Biocon vs income tax on esop (Discounted ESOPs Are Not Taxable)
Biocon vs income tax on esop (Discounted ESOPs Are Not Taxable)Biocon vs income tax on esop (Discounted ESOPs Are Not Taxable)
Biocon vs income tax on esop (Discounted ESOPs Are Not Taxable)
NextBigWhat
 
Published patent and design registration information september 5th, 2014
Published patent and design registration information   september 5th, 2014Published patent and design registration information   september 5th, 2014
Published patent and design registration information september 5th, 2014
InvnTree IP Services Pvt. Ltd.
 
Embed-3-2.pdfkp[k[odk[odk[d[ok[d[pkdkdkl
Embed-3-2.pdfkp[k[odk[odk[d[ok[d[pkdkdklEmbed-3-2.pdfkp[k[odk[odk[d[ok[d[pkdkdkl
Embed-3-2.pdfkp[k[odk[odk[d[ok[d[pkdkdkl
bhavenpr
 
DRI 2014.pdf
DRI 2014.pdfDRI 2014.pdf
DRI 2014.pdf
Hindenburg Research
 

Similar to 2014_DCIT_Vs._Saraf_Export (20)

DRI Aug 2017.pdf
DRI Aug 2017.pdfDRI Aug 2017.pdf
DRI Aug 2017.pdf
 
Case law knit
Case law  knitCase law  knit
Case law knit
 
Case law knit
Case law  knitCase law  knit
Case law knit
 
Published patent and design registration information september 19th, 2014
Published patent and design registration information   september 19th, 2014Published patent and design registration information   september 19th, 2014
Published patent and design registration information september 19th, 2014
 
CESTAT Ruling Power Equipment 2022.pdf
CESTAT Ruling Power Equipment 2022.pdfCESTAT Ruling Power Equipment 2022.pdf
CESTAT Ruling Power Equipment 2022.pdf
 
Sc order freedom of rel act
Sc order freedom of rel actSc order freedom of rel act
Sc order freedom of rel act
 
promotion judgemnet of Revenue department staff_welfare_vs_the_state_of_kerala
promotion judgemnet of Revenue department staff_welfare_vs_the_state_of_keralapromotion judgemnet of Revenue department staff_welfare_vs_the_state_of_kerala
promotion judgemnet of Revenue department staff_welfare_vs_the_state_of_kerala
 
Gauti Shankar vs. ITO, Ward-1, Sriganganagar
Gauti Shankar vs. ITO, Ward-1, SriganganagarGauti Shankar vs. ITO, Ward-1, Sriganganagar
Gauti Shankar vs. ITO, Ward-1, Sriganganagar
 
BEFORE THE HON
BEFORE THE HONBEFORE THE HON
BEFORE THE HON
 
Patent registaration
Patent registarationPatent registaration
Patent registaration
 
DRI 2014 (PMC Projects).pdf
DRI 2014 (PMC Projects).pdfDRI 2014 (PMC Projects).pdf
DRI 2014 (PMC Projects).pdf
 
569257821928895310213$5^1 refno1725-_sahaini_social_service_society_
 569257821928895310213$5^1 refno1725-_sahaini_social_service_society_ 569257821928895310213$5^1 refno1725-_sahaini_social_service_society_
569257821928895310213$5^1 refno1725-_sahaini_social_service_society_
 
s. Hanumangarh Kray
s. Hanumangarh Krays. Hanumangarh Kray
s. Hanumangarh Kray
 
030 2008-02789 (1)
030 2008-02789 (1)030 2008-02789 (1)
030 2008-02789 (1)
 
Internal notification.pdf
Internal notification.pdfInternal notification.pdf
Internal notification.pdf
 
Ipab procedures
Ipab proceduresIpab procedures
Ipab procedures
 
Biocon vs income tax on esop (Discounted ESOPs Are Not Taxable)
Biocon vs income tax on esop (Discounted ESOPs Are Not Taxable)Biocon vs income tax on esop (Discounted ESOPs Are Not Taxable)
Biocon vs income tax on esop (Discounted ESOPs Are Not Taxable)
 
Published patent and design registration information september 5th, 2014
Published patent and design registration information   september 5th, 2014Published patent and design registration information   september 5th, 2014
Published patent and design registration information september 5th, 2014
 
Embed-3-2.pdfkp[k[odk[odk[d[ok[d[pkdkdkl
Embed-3-2.pdfkp[k[odk[odk[d[ok[d[pkdkdklEmbed-3-2.pdfkp[k[odk[odk[d[ok[d[pkdkdkl
Embed-3-2.pdfkp[k[odk[odk[d[ok[d[pkdkdkl
 
DRI 2014.pdf
DRI 2014.pdfDRI 2014.pdf
DRI 2014.pdf
 

More from suresh ojha

Recording_of_statement
Recording_of_statementRecording_of_statement
Recording_of_statement
suresh ojha
 
The ITO Ward, Bikaner vs. Shree Bhagwan Suthar
The ITO Ward, Bikaner vs. Shree Bhagwan SutharThe ITO Ward, Bikaner vs. Shree Bhagwan Suthar
The ITO Ward, Bikaner vs. Shree Bhagwan Suthar
suresh ojha
 
The ACIT, Sriganganagar vs. Ganesh Builders, Sriganganagar
The ACIT, Sriganganagar vs. Ganesh Builders, SriganganagarThe ACIT, Sriganganagar vs. Ganesh Builders, Sriganganagar
The ACIT, Sriganganagar vs. Ganesh Builders, Sriganganagar
suresh ojha
 
Smt. Shalu Sachdeva vs. The ACIT Circle, Sriganganagar 471-2014
Smt. Shalu Sachdeva vs. The ACIT Circle, Sriganganagar 471-2014Smt. Shalu Sachdeva vs. The ACIT Circle, Sriganganagar 471-2014
Smt. Shalu Sachdeva vs. The ACIT Circle, Sriganganagar 471-2014
suresh ojha
 
Shri Virendra Singh Shekawat
Shri Virendra Singh ShekawatShri Virendra Singh Shekawat
Shri Virendra Singh Shekawat
suresh ojha
 
Shri Mahabir Prasad,
Shri Mahabir Prasad,Shri Mahabir Prasad,
Shri Mahabir Prasad,
suresh ojha
 
SARRAF_EXPORT vs. ITO, Ward -2, Churu JODH-2012
SARRAF_EXPORT  vs. ITO, Ward -2, Churu JODH-2012SARRAF_EXPORT  vs. ITO, Ward -2, Churu JODH-2012
SARRAF_EXPORT vs. ITO, Ward -2, Churu JODH-2012
suresh ojha
 
Radhey Shyam Chugh vs. ITO, Suratgarh
Radhey Shyam Chugh vs. ITO, SuratgarhRadhey Shyam Chugh vs. ITO, Suratgarh
Radhey Shyam Chugh vs. ITO, Suratgarh
suresh ojha
 
Radhey Shyam
Radhey ShyamRadhey Shyam
Radhey Shyam
suresh ojha
 
Pushpa Devi Singla vs. The JCIT Range, Sriganganagar
Pushpa Devi Singla vs. The JCIT Range, SriganganagarPushpa Devi Singla vs. The JCIT Range, Sriganganagar
Pushpa Devi Singla vs. The JCIT Range, Sriganganagar
suresh ojha
 
Patel Educationa & Social Welfare Trust vs. ITO Suratgarh
Patel Educationa & Social Welfare Trust vs. ITO SuratgarhPatel Educationa & Social Welfare Trust vs. ITO Suratgarh
Patel Educationa & Social Welfare Trust vs. ITO Suratgarh
suresh ojha
 
NOSEGAY PUBLIC SCHOOL COMMITTEE
NOSEGAY PUBLIC SCHOOL COMMITTEENOSEGAY PUBLIC SCHOOL COMMITTEE
NOSEGAY PUBLIC SCHOOL COMMITTEE
suresh ojha
 
Nosegay Public School
Nosegay Public SchoolNosegay Public School
Nosegay Public School
suresh ojha
 
Mata Padmawati Shyamdaya Charitable Trust
Mata Padmawati Shyamdaya Charitable TrustMata Padmawati Shyamdaya Charitable Trust
Mata Padmawati Shyamdaya Charitable Trust
suresh ojha
 
Kangiri Contractors
Kangiri ContractorsKangiri Contractors
Kangiri Contractors
suresh ojha
 
ITO Ward-1, Churu vs. Gunjan Enterprises
ITO Ward-1, Churu vs. Gunjan EnterprisesITO Ward-1, Churu vs. Gunjan Enterprises
ITO Ward-1, Churu vs. Gunjan Enterprises
suresh ojha
 
DCIT, Central Circle, BikanerAnil Kumar Tantia
DCIT, Central Circle, BikanerAnil Kumar TantiaDCIT, Central Circle, BikanerAnil Kumar Tantia
DCIT, Central Circle, BikanerAnil Kumar Tantia
suresh ojha
 

More from suresh ojha (18)

Copy of AIFTP
Copy of AIFTP Copy of AIFTP
Copy of AIFTP
 
Recording_of_statement
Recording_of_statementRecording_of_statement
Recording_of_statement
 
The ITO Ward, Bikaner vs. Shree Bhagwan Suthar
The ITO Ward, Bikaner vs. Shree Bhagwan SutharThe ITO Ward, Bikaner vs. Shree Bhagwan Suthar
The ITO Ward, Bikaner vs. Shree Bhagwan Suthar
 
The ACIT, Sriganganagar vs. Ganesh Builders, Sriganganagar
The ACIT, Sriganganagar vs. Ganesh Builders, SriganganagarThe ACIT, Sriganganagar vs. Ganesh Builders, Sriganganagar
The ACIT, Sriganganagar vs. Ganesh Builders, Sriganganagar
 
Smt. Shalu Sachdeva vs. The ACIT Circle, Sriganganagar 471-2014
Smt. Shalu Sachdeva vs. The ACIT Circle, Sriganganagar 471-2014Smt. Shalu Sachdeva vs. The ACIT Circle, Sriganganagar 471-2014
Smt. Shalu Sachdeva vs. The ACIT Circle, Sriganganagar 471-2014
 
Shri Virendra Singh Shekawat
Shri Virendra Singh ShekawatShri Virendra Singh Shekawat
Shri Virendra Singh Shekawat
 
Shri Mahabir Prasad,
Shri Mahabir Prasad,Shri Mahabir Prasad,
Shri Mahabir Prasad,
 
SARRAF_EXPORT vs. ITO, Ward -2, Churu JODH-2012
SARRAF_EXPORT  vs. ITO, Ward -2, Churu JODH-2012SARRAF_EXPORT  vs. ITO, Ward -2, Churu JODH-2012
SARRAF_EXPORT vs. ITO, Ward -2, Churu JODH-2012
 
Radhey Shyam Chugh vs. ITO, Suratgarh
Radhey Shyam Chugh vs. ITO, SuratgarhRadhey Shyam Chugh vs. ITO, Suratgarh
Radhey Shyam Chugh vs. ITO, Suratgarh
 
Radhey Shyam
Radhey ShyamRadhey Shyam
Radhey Shyam
 
Pushpa Devi Singla vs. The JCIT Range, Sriganganagar
Pushpa Devi Singla vs. The JCIT Range, SriganganagarPushpa Devi Singla vs. The JCIT Range, Sriganganagar
Pushpa Devi Singla vs. The JCIT Range, Sriganganagar
 
Patel Educationa & Social Welfare Trust vs. ITO Suratgarh
Patel Educationa & Social Welfare Trust vs. ITO SuratgarhPatel Educationa & Social Welfare Trust vs. ITO Suratgarh
Patel Educationa & Social Welfare Trust vs. ITO Suratgarh
 
NOSEGAY PUBLIC SCHOOL COMMITTEE
NOSEGAY PUBLIC SCHOOL COMMITTEENOSEGAY PUBLIC SCHOOL COMMITTEE
NOSEGAY PUBLIC SCHOOL COMMITTEE
 
Nosegay Public School
Nosegay Public SchoolNosegay Public School
Nosegay Public School
 
Mata Padmawati Shyamdaya Charitable Trust
Mata Padmawati Shyamdaya Charitable TrustMata Padmawati Shyamdaya Charitable Trust
Mata Padmawati Shyamdaya Charitable Trust
 
Kangiri Contractors
Kangiri ContractorsKangiri Contractors
Kangiri Contractors
 
ITO Ward-1, Churu vs. Gunjan Enterprises
ITO Ward-1, Churu vs. Gunjan EnterprisesITO Ward-1, Churu vs. Gunjan Enterprises
ITO Ward-1, Churu vs. Gunjan Enterprises
 
DCIT, Central Circle, BikanerAnil Kumar Tantia
DCIT, Central Circle, BikanerAnil Kumar TantiaDCIT, Central Circle, BikanerAnil Kumar Tantia
DCIT, Central Circle, BikanerAnil Kumar Tantia
 

2014_DCIT_Vs._Saraf_Export

  • 1. ,e-,-la-44@tsih@14&eSallZ ljkZQ ,DliksVZl~] ljnkj'kgj A vk;dj vihyh; vf/kdj.k] t;iqj U;k;ihB] t;iqj INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL, JAIPUR BENCH, JAIPUR Jh vkj-ih-rksykuh] U;kf;d lnL; ,oa Jh Vh-vkj-ehuk] yscL; ds le{k (BEFORE SHRI R.P. TOLANI AND SHRI T.R.MEENA) M.A. No.44/JP/2014 (A/o ITA No.390, 679/JP/13 & C.O. 30,52/JP/13) Assessment Year : 2009-10 PAN : AATFS 9394N The Dy.Commissioner of Income Tax, Vs. M/s.Saraf Export, Jhunjhunu. Sardarshar. vihykFkhZ@Appellant izR;FkhZ@Respondent M.A. No.45/JP/2014 (A/o ITA No.739/JP/12) Assessment Year : 2009-10 The Asstt.Commissioner of Income Tax, Vs. M/s.Saraf Export, Circle, Jhunjhunu. Sardarshar. vihykFkhZ@Appellant izR;FkhZ@Respondent M.A. No.46/JP/2014 (A/o ITA No.819/JP/13) Assessment Year : 2009-10 The Asstt.Commissioner of Income Tax, Vs. M/s.Saraf Seasoning Udyog, Circle, Jhunjhunu. Sardarshar. vihykFkhZ@Appellant izR;FkhZ@Respondent foHkkx dh vksj ls@Department by : Sh.Kailash Mangal (JCIT) fu/kkZfjrh dh vksj ls@Assessee by : Sh.Suresh Ojha & D.S.Bohra, (Adv.) lquokbZ dh frfFk@Date of Hearing : 10.04.2015 ?kks"k.kk dh frfFk@Date of Pronouncemtnt: 10.04.2015
  • 2. ,e-,-la-44@tsih@14&eSallZ ljkZQ ,DliksVZl~] ljnkj'kgj - 2 - vkns'k ORDER PER T.R.MEENA, AM:- The revenue filed M.A. in all the cases wherein it has been contended that Hon’ble ITAT, Jaipur Bench in its order ITA No.390/JP/2013, C.O. 13/JP/13 and ITA 679/JP/13, C.O.53/JP/13 dated 27.12.2013 has not considered the Hon’ble Supreme Court decision in case of Liberty India 317 ITR 218(SC) that duty draw back income is not part of 80IB deduction & resulted Platently wrong & improper decision given by the Hon’ble ITAT in all the cases (A/o ITA No. 390, 679/JP/13 & C.O. 30, 52/JP/13, 739/JP/12, 819/JP/13) which is apparent mistake on the part of Hon’ble ITAT. 2. The Ld.A.R. for the assessee’s file written submission and argued that application submitted by the A.O. u/s 254(2) of the IT Act is not at all an application. The order passed by the Hon’ble Tribunal is a conscious order therefore the application is not at all application in para 2 of this revenue M.A. worded the application that Hon’ble ITAT’s order in case of the assessee’s “patently wrong and improper due to following reasons”. The language of application itself stated that the view which is in favour of department must have been taken.
  • 3. ,e-,-la-44@tsih@14&eSallZ ljkZQ ,DliksVZl~] ljnkj'kgj - 3 - The department wants to dected his condition for accepting the application in the moreover in which the department wants. The department had admitted that matter is debatable which can not be rectify u/s 254(2) of the IT Act by relying Hon’ble Supreme Court decision in case of Vokard India 82 ITR 50 further department has admitted as under :- “Further it is a trite that when any amended provision is not considered or for that matter any relevant provision of the Act is not considered while giving a judgment, it is treated as in per curium……………………” 3. The Hon’ble Tribunal had considered the judgement Liberty India (supra) in above decision. Therefore he requested to impose cost on AO for not drafting proper application for rectification with respect to Hon’ble ITAT’s order u/s 254(2) of the IT Act and same may be dismissed. He further relied upon following cases:- 1. ITA No.22 & 23/Jodh/2012 M/s.Saraf Export, 2. 82 ITR 50 T.S.Balram 3. 237 ITR 165 Keshari Metal Pvt.Ltd., 4. 192 ITR 252 Indian Steel & Wire Product 5. 247 ITR 274 Prakash Chand Nahta 6. 168 ITR 809 ITO Vs. ITAT 7. M.A.49/Jodh./2008 Choksi Heraeus P.Ltd., 8. M.A. 10/JU/2009 Hanumangarh Kray Vikray Sah.Sam. 9. 72 Taxmann 43 Kamalakshi Finance Corpn.Ltd.,(SC) 4. We have heard the rival submission of both the parties and perused the material available on record. This Bench has considered the Hon’ble Supreme
  • 4. ,e-,-la-44@tsih@14&eSallZ ljkZQ ,DliksVZl~] ljnkj'kgj - 4 - Court decision in case of Liberty India (supra) in assessee’s case and decided issue as per the amended provision of 80IB of the IT Act. Therefore we dismiss all the three M.A.s filed by the revenue. Order pronounced in the open Court on 10.04.2015 Sd/- Sd/- (R.P.TOLANI) (T.R.MEENA) U;kf;d lnL;@Judicial Member ys[kk lnL;@Accountant Member t;iqj@Jaipur, fnukad@Date : 10/04/2015 *Basant* vkns'k dh izfrfyfi vxzsf"kr@Copy of the order forwarded to :- 1- mik;qDr vk;dj] >qa>quwa@The DCIT, Jhunjhunu. 2- eSallZ ljkZQ ,DliksVZ] ljnkj'kgj@M/s.Saraf Export, Sardarshar. 3- foHkkxh; izfrfuf/k] t;iqj@The D.R. ITAT, Jaipur 4- xkMZ QkbZy@The Guard File (in M.A. No.44/JP/2014) vkns'kkuqlkj By Order lgk;d iathdkj@Assistant Registrar