A novel technique utilizing supercritical carbon dioxide (scCO2) was used to pre-disperse nanoclays before mixing with polystyrene. This improved the dispersion and interface of clay platelets in the final nanocomposites. The effects of clay modifier, fraction, and scCO2 processing on structure and barrier properties were investigated. Results showed that scCO2 processing led to a more homogeneous dispersion and an 82.7% reduction in oxygen permeation with only 3.3% clay loading, corresponding to an effective aspect ratio increase of 16.7%.