Elizabeth J Shpall is a professor of medicine and director of several programs at MD Anderson Cancer Center including the Cord Blood Transplant Program and Cord Blood Bank. She is a nationally recognized expert in stem cell transplantation whose research focuses on applications of stem cell transplantation for treating cancers like leukemia and lymphoma. She has held leadership roles in professional organizations related to hematopoietic cell therapy and stem cell transplantation.
1. ELIZABETH J SHPALL, MD
Houston, USA
• Professor of Medicine and Chair of Cord Blood Transplant
Program, UT MD Anderson Cancer Center
• As a nationally recognized expert in stem cell
transplantation, Medical Director of the GMP Cell Therapy
Laboratory since 2002, and the Director of the Cord Blood
Bank (CBB) at M. D. Anderson Cancer Center since 2004,
Dr. Shpall's research covers a range of applications, among
them: leukemia, lymphoma treatment, anti-tumor
immunity enhancement, and tissue repair. Dr. Shpall’s
influence is felt beyond the Texas Medical Center. She is
the current vice-president of FACT Netcord, having chaired
their Cord Blood Standards Committee since 1999, and she
was the founding president and has been a board member
of the Foundation Accreditation of Hematopoietic Cell
Therapy since 1995.
2. Cellular Therapy for ALL with
Chimeric Antigen Receptors
Elizabeth J. Shpall MD
•
3. Roadblocks to Successful Cellular
Immunotherapy for ALL
PROBLEM
•Targeting
•Expansion ex vivo
•Proliferation in the host
•Persistence
•Effector:Target ratio – create
sufficient effector cells for
clinical success
SOLUTION
•CAR or TCR
•GMP cell culture
•?Young T cells
•?Memory T cells
•Ideally, there would be an
efficacy signal, not just
safety, in phase 1
Abbreviations: CAR, chimeric antigen receptor; GMP, good manufacturing practice; TCR, T-cell receptor
4. Gene Transfer of CARs
Eshhar et al; PNAS 1993
Intracytoplasmic
vscFv v
Spacer
Linker
vLvLvLvH
abTcR complex
ge edzz
Monoclonal
antibody
Monoclonal
antibody
T or NK
Cell
TumorTumor
Antigen
CARCAR
CARs combine an antibody binding domain (scFv) that recognizes a desired tumor associated antigen
with one or more T-cell receptor signaling endodomains. Forced expression of CAR on the T-cell surface
leads to activation of T cells through CD3ζ CD28 and/or CD137.
5. Chimeric Antigen Receptors Possess
Advantages Over Endogenous
Receptors
• Intact
molecule
recognized
(including
non-protein)
• HLA-
independent
• Costimulation
not needed
CAR T Cells
Endogenous T cells
• Recognition of
peptides processed
through MHC
• Need
• costimulation
Chimeric Antigen Receptors Possess
6. Redirecting the Specificity of T cells
• Gene transfer technology is used
to stably express CARs on T cells,
conferring novel antigen specificity
• Transduction:
– Many retroviral
– Some now using lentiviral
– Non-viral Sleeping Beauty system
• Temporary modification with RNA
transfection
• Suicide systems
Viral or
nonviral
vector
T cell
CD19
Native
TCR
Tumor cell
CTL019 cell
Dead tumor cell
Anti-CD19
CAR construct
7. Evolution of CARs with additional
costimulatory domains
Dotti et al. 2009
th
this is
hhh
ext tt
e
x
t
Classic CARs Sports CARs Muscle CARs
Sadelain, et al. Cancer Discov. 2013
9. • Clinical scale up: no feeder
cells required
• Expansion >106
-fold
• Repertoire preserved
• T cells persist after infusion
• Maintains function and homing
of T cells
• Induction of telomerase:
minimizing replicative
senescence
Levine et al J Immunol 1997; Carroll et al Science 1997; Weng et al Imm Rev 1997; Humeau et al Mol Ther 2004
Properties of Anti-CD3/CD28
Costimulated Expansion System
10. Sleeping Beauty system to genetically
modify T cells to target CD19 via CAR
Transposon (Donor)
sequences flanked by
inverted repeats are
integrated into genome
Transposase
(Helper) expression
is transient
Plasterk RH, Cell 74(5):781, 1993
Ivics Z, et al, Cell 91 (4):501, 1997
Nucleus
Transposase
Transposon
CAR
Cytoplasm
Laurence Cooper Laboratory
11. Schematic of T-cell manufacture
Methods available at:
Huls MH, et al. Clinical application of
Sleeping Beauty and artificial
antigen presenting cells to
genetically modify T cells from
peripheral and umbilical cord blood.
J Vis Exp. 2013 Feb 1;(72):e50070.
SB system with Perry Hackett
aAPC with Carl June
Irradiated aAPC
Derived from K-562 cells and
modified to co-express CD19, CD86,
CD137L, membrane-bound IL-15
(and CD64)
12. Authors Target Disease N Positive
Outcomes
City of Hope
2010
Follicular
lymphoma (FL)
2 --
NCI 2010 FL 1 1 PR
BCM 2011 DLBCL, FL 6 --
U. Penn 2011 CLL 3 2 CR 1 PR
Memorial SK
2011
CLL, ALL 9 1 PR, 1 cCR
CARs Targeting CD19
Initial Results: 2010, 2011
13. Author CD19+
Disease
N infused
Vector/
Activation
Endo-
domain
Chemo CAR+
cell
Response Persist Key Pts
Cruz
BCM
152
Post Allo
9
Retrovirus
EBV/CMV/A
deno
CD28/
CD3z
None Donor T 2/6 DLI bulk
PR->PD
3/3 adult
100% CR
9 wks Novel CAR
Bispecific
Trivirus
Davila
MMSK
69
ALL
13 Adults
Retrovirus
CD3x28 b
CD28/
CD3z
Lympho
depleting
Auto-pbpc
106
/Kg
10/12 MRD-
6 revers CS
83% CR
NR Potent
bridge to
SCT
Grupp
Penn
67
ALL
16 Peds
4 Adults
Lentivirus
CD3x28 b
41BB/
CD3z
Lymph-
depleting
Auto-PB
11
Post Allo
107
-108
/Kg
14/17
82% CR
CS in
responders
1-15+
Mos
respon
Potent
No GVH with
hx
Kalos
Penn
163
CLL -24
ALL-14ped
3 adults
Lentivirus
CD3x28 b
41BB/
CD3z
Lymph-
depleting
Auto-PB 5CR 7PR
50%
CR 8/17 47%
Max5%
All resp
and SD
Deep seq
CRs
Lee
NCI,
Peds
614
CD19+
ALL 7
NHL1
Retrovirus
CD3x28 b.
CD28/
CD3z
Flu-Cy Auto-PB
Pre/Post
Allo 4/4
ALL CR5/7
71%
All pts
1-38%
55days
Active
Fresh
Infusion
ASH 2013 CAR Clinical Abstracts
14. • Disease Target: CD19+ B ALL
• Subjects: 16 adults
• Vector: Retrovirus
• Manufacturing: CD3/28 Beads
• Signaling Endodomains: CD28 and CD3 zeta
• Pre T Cell Prep: Cyclophosphamide
• Overall 14 CR (88%) – higher than salvage chemo
(44%)
• CAR T cells associated with CRS
Chimeric Antigen Receptor (CAR)Memorial Sloan Kettering Experience
(Davila et al 2014)
15. U. Penn Experience (Maude et al 2014)
• Disease Target: CD19+ B ALL
• Subjects: 25 between 5-22, and 5 older adults
• Vector: Lentivirus
• Manufacturing: CD3/28 beads
• Signaling Endodomains: 41BB and CD3 zeta
• Pre T Cell Prep: None, Cy/VP, Flu/Cy, Etoposide/Cytarabine,
Cyclophosphamide, CVAD-B, CVAD-A, or clofarabine
• 27 CR (90%), 6 month EFS 67%, overall survival 78%
• T cells detectable in blood, bone marrow, and CSF of patients
who responded
• All patients had CRS (mild to moderate in 22/30, severe in 8)
University of Pennsylvania Experience
(Maude et al 2014)
16. Modified T cells detectable at high levels
by flow cytometry with longer peristence
Grupp, et al. NEJM 2013
17. NCI Experience (Kochenderfer et al 2014)
• Disease Target: CD19+ B cell malignancies (DLBCL, indolent
lymphomas, CLL)
• Subjects: 15 adults
• Vector: Retrovirus
• Manufacturing: 10-Day Culture
• Signaling Endodomains: CD28 and CD3 zeta
• Pre T Cell Prep: Cyclophosphamide and fludarabine
• 8 CR, 4 PR, 1 SD, 2 not evaluable
• Acute toxicities (fever, hypotension, delirium, neurotoxicity)
resolved within 3 weeks; 1 patient died 16 days post infusion
• 1st
successful treatment of DLBCL with anti CD19 CAR T cells
NCI Experience
(Kochenderfer et al 2014)
18. Pediatrics NCI Experience (Lee et al 2014)
• Disease Target: CD19+ ALL or Non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma
• Subjects: 21 children and young adults (1-30 years of age)
• Vector: Retrovirus
• Manufacturing: Bead Stimulated 11 Day Culture
• Signaling Endodomains: CD28 and CD3 zeta
• Pre T Cell Prep: Cyclophosphamide and fludarabine
• 12 CR (MRD Neg), 1 CR, 1 Cri, 3 SD, 4 PD
• All toxicities fully reversible
Peds NCI Experience
(Lee et al 2014)
19. MD Anderson Kebriaei et al. 2014: Lymphodepletion and Sleeping Beauty
Autologous CAR+
T Cells for Active Disease
Age Dx Stage CAR-T
source
Dose
Level
(%) CAR
expression
Ds. Status
post CAR
Toxicity
33 ALL Refractory relapse MSD 106
/m2
94.0 Progressed, 1 mo. None
25 ALL s/p haploHCT,Refractory Haplo 106
/m2
95.0 Progressed, 6 mo. None
53 NHL Recurrent MSD 106
/m2
58.3 Cru, 6 mo. None
21* ALL s/p alloHCT, Rel 3 MSD 107
/m2
96.8 Progressed, 9 mo. None
31* ALL s/p alloHCT, Rel 2 MSD 107
/m2
93.4 CR, 1 mo. VOD/
GVHD
23* ALL s/p alloHCT, Rel 2 MSD 5x107
/m2
96.5 Progressed, 1 mo. None
58 ALL s/p alloHCT, CR2, MRDpos
alloSelf 5x108
/m2
76.7 CR, 6 mo. None
52 NHL s/p autoHCT, refractory Self 5x108
/m2
89.7 Progressed, 1 mo. None
29 ALL s/p alloHCT, CR3, MRDpos
alloSelf 5x108
/m2
90.1 CR, 3 mo. GVHD
76 CLL Refractory relapse Self 5x108
/m2
31.5 Stable, 12 mo. None
63 CLL Refractory relapse Self 5x108
/m2
57.3 Progressed, 1 mo. None
76 CLL Refractory relapse Self 5x108
/m2
32.9 Progressed, 2 mo. None
31 ALL s/p alloHCT, refractory
CNS
alloSelf 5x109
/m2
88.9 CNS progressed,
1 mo.
None
63 CLL s/p alloHCT, refractory alloSelf 5x109
/m2
92.2 Too early None
N=14 pts treated, 5 with disease regression med. 6 mo follow-up
20. • Extraordinarily high ferritin levels after highly active CAR
infusion suggest MAS/HLH/CRS
• 16,000 to 415,000 in Penn studies
• Mild coagulopathy, transaminitis
• Elevated D-dimer and low fibrinogen
• High fevers, hypotension
• Moderate marrow hematophagocytosis
Macrophage Activation Syndrome (MAS)
Hemophagocytic Lymphohistiocytosis (HLH)
Cytokine Release Syndrom (CRS) “Storm”
21. Cytokine Release Syndrome (CRS)
• Can be significant, but highly variable across patients
and studies
• May or may not scale with dose, may scale with
disease burden
• ? Different with different diseases
• Different in the era of highly active CAR cell therapy
• IL-6 is an important driver of toxicity
• Entirely reversible with cytokine blockade
– IL-6R blocking agent tocilizumab
22. Tocilizumab (Actemra)
• IL-6 receptor antagonist
• Blocks IL-6 mediated effects
• Indicated in:
– juvenile idiopathic arthritis (JIA)
– Rheumatoid arthritis (RA)
– In Japan, indication for Castleman’s Disease
• Typically given monthly
• Rare side effects of transaminitis and neutropenia
• Penn uses 8 mg/kg
24. Neurotoxicity issues
• Seen in several CD19 trials:
– NCI
– CHOP/U. Penn
– CD19-CAR-T and Blinatumomab
• Self-limited, generally untreated, fully
resolves
• ? Related to CRS
• Not prevented by tocilizumab
25. • CD19-directed CAR T cells
• Adverse events related to cytokine release syndrome
occur --- but most are manageable
• Partnerships with industry bring technology closer to
being part of clinical care
• In July 2014, FDA designated CTL019 CAR T cells
with “breakthrough therapy” status
• Improvements in CAR therapies underway
CAR Therapy: Summary Recent Trials
26. • Persistence: Correlates with Outcome
• Vector
• sCFv or Endodomain Construction
• Bulk of Disease
• Cell Type Modified (auto vs allo)
CAR Therapy: Outstanding Issues
27. CAR Therapy: Outstanding Issues
• Ex Vivo Expansion
• CD3x28 Beads
• OKT3/IL2
• Antigen Presenting Cells
• Cytokines
• Duration of Ex Vivo Culture
• Pre-Infusion Therapy: Lymphopenia? Treg Decrease?
• No Therapy
• Lymphodepleting Chemotherapy
• Stem Cell Transplant
CAR Therapy: Oustanding Issues
28. CAR Therapy: Outstanding Issues
• Homing
• CNS
• Other Sanctuarial Sites
• On Target Toxicity: B Cell Aplasia, Cytokine Storm
Syndrome
• Tocilizumab
• Conditional Ablation: Caspase, HSV-TK
CAR Therapy: Oustanding Issues
29. • Consolidate patients with MRD
What is the Potential for CAR Therapy in ALL?
• Reinduce remission
• Produce MRD(-) state prior to SCT (Bridge to SCT)
• Multicenter trial/s in pediatric ALL are enrolling
Potential Roles for CAR Therapy in ALL
30. Acknowledgements
Richard Champlin Katy Rezvani Ian McNiece
Laurence Cooper Marcos de Lima Amin Alousi
Simrit Parmar Chitra Hosing Nina Shah
Borje Andersson Michael Andreeff Simon Robinson
Steven Kornblau Yago Nieto Hong Yang
Roy Jones Mark Munsell Xiaoying Liu
Martin Korbling Paolo Anderlini Qaiser Bashir
Jeffrey Molldrem Patrick Zweidler-McKay Michael Thomas
Partow Kebriaei Sue Armitage Tara Sadeghi
Laura Worth Demetri Petropoulos Indreshpal Kaur
Mark Munsell Sairah Ahmed Muzaffar Qazilbash
Qing Ma Issa Khouri Jared Burks
Lisa St John Beatriz Martin-Antonio Gabriela Rondon
Doyle Bosque Lori Griffin Kai Cao
Rima Saliba Peter Thall Betul Oran
Funding
NCI R01- CA061508
NCI PO1- CA148600
CPRIT RP100469
CPRIT RP 100430
CLL Global Research Fund
HRSA 234200737
Funding
NCI R01- CA061508
NCI PO1- CA148600
CPRIT RP100469
CPRIT RP 100430
CLL Global Research Fund
HRSA 234200737
Catherine Bollard
Michael Keating
William Wierda
Genetically modify T-cells to express an antigen recognition domain of a specific antibody, in this case CD-19. Traditionally did not lead to in vivo expansion. The newest generation of CAR T-cells were enhanced by adding a co-stimulatory domain. In our model the co-stimulatory domain is 4-1BB (CD137) CARs are not all the same.
The co-stimulatory domains were murine but now humanized to try to further minimize rejection.