1. This work is supported by the National Science Foundation’s
Directorate for Education and Human Resources TUES-1245025, IUSE-
1612248, IUSE-1725347, and IUSE-1914915. Questions, contact education-AT-unavco.org
MEASURING WATER RESOURCES
Unit 4 Water budget assessment
of a California drought
2. OUTLINE
1. CA drought: Spatial extent, timing, and historical perspective
2. California Physiography: Mountains and valley
3. Drought and societal impacts
4. Precipitation record
5. Measuring snow with snow pillows and GPS-IR
3. PALMER DROUGHT SEVERITY INDEX
“The Palmer Drought Severity Index (PDSI),
devised in 1965, was the first drought indicator
to assess moisture status comprehensively. It
uses temperature and precipitation data to
calculate water supply and demand,
incorporates soil moisture, and is considered
most effective for unirrigated cropland”1.
1 https://www.drought.gov/drought/content/products-current-drought-and-monitoring-
drought-indicators/palmer-drought-severity-index.
5. CALIFORNIA DROUGHT: SPATIAL EXTENT
March 31, 2015April 1, 2014
U.S. Drought Monitor Intensity: Multiple indicators of drought conditions
6. CALIFORNIA DROUGHT: TIMING
Time series of U.S. Drought Monitor intensity, from
http://cpo.noaa.gov/ClimatePrograms/ModelingAnalysisPredictionsandProjections/MAPPTaskForces/DroughtTaskForce/Californi
aDrought.aspx
8. CALIFORNIA DROUGHT IMPACTS: SOCIETY
“We are embarked upon an experiment that no one has ever tried,” said Gov. Jerry
Brown in early April, in ordering the first mandatory statewide water rationing for
cities.”
and
“…California, from this drought onward, will be a state transformed…The California
drought of today is mostly nature’s hand, diminishing an Eden created by man. The
Golden State may recover, but it won’t be the same place.
(NY TIMES: http://www.nytimes.com/2015/05/03/opinion/sunday/the-end-of-california.html?_r=0)
9. HUMAN COST OF DROUGHT
USDA personnel talks to farmer about the damage the drought has
caused to a vineyard in the Lamont farming community in
southeastern San Joaquin Valley Feb. 26, 2014.
10. HUMAN COST OF DROUGHT
July 2015 - Grandfather and great-granddaughter stand by the water tank they used for water
after their well went dry. Wells went dry across many communities in California’s southern
Sacramento-San Joaquin Valley as the exceptional drought continued. People became
dependent on water trucks.
11. JUNE 2017 – CALIFORNIA GROUNDWATER STILL
BELOW NORMAL
Although the surface
water had recovered by
spring 2017, the
groundwater remained
very low
12. CALIFORNIA DROUGHT: PHYSIOGRAPHY
See Sacramento-
San Joaquin Valley
Basin Map (pdf)
• Two large
basins:
Sacramento
and San
Joaquin (total
area = 1.55x105
km2)
• Sierra Nevada
Mountains
(granitic rocks)
• Central Valley
(deep
sediments)
17. “WATER YEAR” VERSUS CALENDAR YEAR
What is a Water Year?
“….defined as the 12-month period October 1, for any given year through September 30, of the
following year.
The water year is designated by the calendar year in which it ends and which includes 9 of the
12 months.
Thus, the year ending September 30, 1999 is called the "1999" water year.”
http://water.usgs.gov/nwc/explain_data.html
18. SNOTEL STATIONS
Snow Water Equivalent (SWE) is the
depth of water that would result if all
the snow was melted.
Pressure from the overlying snow is
measured beneath the pillow.
Information is transmitted to data
centers.
20. USING GPS-REFLECTOMETRY FOR TERRESTRIAL HYDROLOGY
STUDIES
Changes in the ground
such as added snow
change the path and
characteristics of the
reflect GPS signal
P101 (Utah)
More information: http://droughtmonitor.unl.edu/AboutUs/ClassificationScheme.aspx
The California drought began in 2012 and persisted through 2016 (Figure 2). By 2013 it was clear that this was a significant drought and by the end of 2014 more than half the state was experiencing an “exceptional” drought. The winter and spring of 2017 had well above normal precipitation and although groundwater aquifers were not recovered, at the surface level, the state was considered to no longer be in drought. The focus of this unit is on characterizing the exceptional period of the drought during water years 2014 and 2015.
Additional information on this image at https://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/IOTD/view.php?id=89110
Droughts cause distinct human and economic consequences.
Left image: USDA photo by David Kosling. (https://www.flickr.com/photos/usdagov/12927295893/in/photolist-kGkLFX-9Ycd5N-aawFBm-eaLJga-8cJWjv-o4V8Wk-Tkbah-aatSn2-oavqZk-aatSrz-kGkLoc-KqmjjF-kGnhiS-aatTat-aawGp5-aawFQA-aawFTA-Pu3rnv-jZcgok-9YFKFr-jZbouP-nY5qet-nRzGht-aatSBX-nUru2C-tV2pMA-Q4NDAs-QpK27y-r69uKY-tCa9f8-ro9MbP-xjFzjA-ygGbKM-xjFYAq-xjChCq-yeoJw1-yhokra-xZ4jg1-xZ2TkJ-yfLCVN-xZ2QnE-yhoPQK-ygDVLn-yfN7VJ-xZ1Aem-xjBsZQ-yemHyo-yfJBzq-xZ37J5-xZ9qQV)
Right image: Quinn Dombrowski; released for reuse (https://www.flickr.com/photos/quinnanya/31166105555/in/photolist-Pu3rnv-jZcgok-9YFKFr-jZbouP-nY5qet-nRzGht-aatSBX-nUru2C-tV2pMA-Q4NDAs-QpK27y-r69uKY-tCa9f8-ro9MbP-xjFzjA-ygGbKM-xjFYAq-xjChCq-yeoJw1-yhokra-xZ4jg1-xZ2TkJ-yfLCVN-xZ2QnE-yhoPQK-ygDVLn-yfN7VJ-xZ1Aem-xjBsZQ-yemHyo-yfJBzq-xZ37J5-xZ9qQV-xZ2roJ-xjKNE4-xZ56q1-xjLvjk-yfNW2Y-xZ2kRu-xZ3rTh-xjDs47-yfLmBf-xZ7Gjo-xZ2YGA-yfMcnw-ygHCB4-yhnkVi-xZ4RSu-yhnAU6-xjGwZo/)
Circle of Blue; Brett Walton, http://www.circleofblue.org/2015/water-climate/california-drought/after-dry-wells-relief-for-some-california-families/
Reused with permission.
Although the reservoirs and streamflow were recovered by spring 2017, the legacy of the drought was strong in the groundwater system – continuing to cause difficulties for effected communities. This image shows groundwater levels as monitored but the USGS.
https://ca.water.usgs.gov/data/drought/drought-impact.html
Left image: http://www.conservation.ca.gov/cgs/information/publications/ms/Documents/MS057.pdf (Courtesy of the California Geological Survey)
Right image: Maps compiled by the GETSI project from publically available data (see data-sources.xlsx in the Unit 4 Instructor Data Files)
The groundwater movement patterns have modified significantly in the course of agricultural development.
Image modified by K. Shevais (UNAVCO) from Faunt, 2009, USGS Professional Paper 1766 (https://pubs.usgs.gov/pp/1766/PP_1766.pdf)
During the worst of the drought the streamflow was drastically reduced at the majority of gaging sites around California.
However streamflow does not give direct data on groundwater and the measurements are at point locations only with many gaps.
Image 1 from https://waterwatch.usgs.gov/index.php?id=pa01d&sid=w__plot_sum&r=ca
Image 2 from: http://ca.water.usgs.gov/data/drought/drought-impact.html
Precipitation is also measured in point locations and gridded in order to develop continuous maps.
http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/monitoring-references/maps/us-climate-divisions.php
source: National Climatic Data Center, Climate Division Monthly Data, ftp://ftp.ncdc.noaa.gov/pub/data/cirs/climdiv
SNOTEL stations are very valuable, but they provide only a point source of information. Snow depth is notoriously variable due to factors such as wind and vegetation. It is not feasible to have the density of these stations that would really help constrain snow mass more comprehensively. Also the measurements are only over an area of a few square meters for each site. Geodetic methods such as reflection GPS can help augment data from SNOTEL stations.
SNOTEL stations contain a variety of equipment.
The primary measurement is determination of snow mass through the pressure sensor within the pillow.
Other equipment collects snow depth (look-down sensor) and a variety of other meteorological equipment.
Image: https://www.nrcs.usda.gov/wps/portal/nrcs/detail/id/snow/?cid=nrcs144p2_047776
American Geophysical Union allows reuse of a figure for educational non-commerical purposes.
Larson, K. M., E. Gutmann, V. Zavorotny, J. Braun, M. Williams, F. G. Nievinski, Can We Measure Snow Depth with GPS Receivers?, Geophysical Research Letters, 36(L17502), doi:10.1029/2009GL039430, 2009
Image also from http://xenon.colorado.edu/spotlight/index.php?action=kb&page=10
GPS stations were originally installed to measure tectonic motions. Position is determined by calculating the distances from satellites using the direct incoming signals. Originally all signals that reflected off surrounding surfaces were considered noise and researchers did their best to filter them out. However, more recently researchers at the University of Colorado Boulder realized that the the reflected signal could be used to determine things such as changes in height or conditions of the surrounding ground.
Image from UNAVCOO.
red = right hand
blue = left hand
antenna is L2 Choke antenna
The reflected signal is useable when the satellites are closer to the horizon.
Image after Larson, K.M., GPS Interferometric Reflectometry: Applications to Surface Soil Moisture, Snow Depth, and Vegetation Water Content in the Western United States, WIREs Water, Vol. 3, 775-787, 10.1002/wat2.1167, 2016.
Unlike a SNOTEL pillow which only measures a few square meters of area, reflected GPS signals integrate snow depth from an around of about 1000 sq meters.
Image from Eric Small.
PBO H2O actually produces three data products from reflection GPS (snow, vegetation, and soil moisture) and one from the vertical signal (water loading – same idea as was done in Unit 3 of the Measuring Water Resources module). All four products are related to different aspects of the water cycle but in this unit we are only using the snow data product.
Not all GPS stations can be used for reflection GPS. The area around the antenna needs to be carefully evaluated. This map shows the stations being used for snow. Initially just stations from the Plate Boundary Observatory were included but the network has grown to include other interested organizations such as the Minnesota Dept of Transportation.
Images from PBO H2O site http://cires1.colorado.edu/portal/index.php; basemap image from Google Maps