In 1993 the 101st International Olympic Committee met in Monaco to select the 2000 Winter Olympics site. The cities in the running were Beijing (B), Berlin (L), Istanbul (I), Manchester (M), and Sydney (S). Suppose we look at their voting preferences. Find the results of the election using the Hare method. Just after the third vote, one of the committee members voting for Manchester was accused of cheating and was disqualified. Because of that scandal, one member admitted she was voting insincerely, and changed her vote from Manchester to Sydney. What is the result of using the Hare method? Do the results of parts (a) and (b) violate any of the fairness criteria? Yes no if the last answer positive, which fairness criterion is being violated? Monotonicity Criterion Irrelevant Alternatives Criterion Condorcet Criterion None Majority Criterion Solution L no none .

1. In 1993 the 101st International Olympic Committee met in Monaco to select the 2000 Winter
Olympics site. The cities in the running were Beijing (B), Berlin (L), Istanbul (I), Manchester
(M), and Sydney (S). Suppose we look at their voting preferences. Find the results of the election
using the Hare method. Just after the third vote, one of the committee members voting for
Manchester was accused of cheating and was disqualified. Because of that scandal, one member
admitted she was voting insincerely, and changed her vote from Manchester to Sydney. What is
the result of using the Hare method? Do the results of parts (a) and (b) violate any of the fairness
criteria? Yes no if the last answer positive, which fairness criterion is being violated?
Monotonicity Criterion Irrelevant Alternatives Criterion Condorcet Criterion None Majority
Criterion
Solution
L no none