SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 12
Chapter 10 
Community-Based 
Participatory Research or 
Participatory Action 
Research (with Krista 
Harper)
What Is CBPR? 
• CBPR breaks with the logic of the 
detached, objective observer in two ways: 
– (1) The researcher is trying to bring about 
change, and 
– (2) the researcher interacts & cooperates with 
the researched to bring changes the: 
• Researched themselves identified as desirable 
© 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.
What Is CBPR? 
• A Brief History (or Rather, “Herstory”) 
– The Researcher As An Agent Of Change 
– The Community As The “Expert” 
– The Researcher Facilitates & Doesn’t Dictate 
• What Is the Meaning of “Community?” 
• Problem-Solving? Whose Problems, 
Whose Solutions? 
© 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.
Par In Action: Environmental Justice 
In A Hungarian Village 
• Starting with Justice 
• Getting to Know the Roma 
• A Key Informant Emerges 
• Jointly Designing the Project 
– Photo-voice 
© 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.
An Overview Of CBPR As A Design 
Choice 
• The researcher works with community 
leaders and the research is interactive; 
– In accord with egalitarian ideals 
• It is effective to use methods readily 
understood by community members and: 
– That are inherently engaging and participatory 
© 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.
An Overview Of CBPR As A Design 
Choice 
• The production of information in a visual or 
physical form may be a more: 
– Meaningful product than peer-reviewed article 
published in a scholarly journal 
• The researchers must be willing to 
assume new roles as facilitators of: 
– Interaction within the community 
© 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.
An Overview Of CBPR As A Design 
Choice 
• Interaction between the community 
members and the outsider is seen: 
– Explicitly not only as a way of beginning to 
address specific problems but, above all: 
• As a method of breaking isolation 
© 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.
Practical Tips 
• CBPR and PAR require background 
knowledge of the community; 
– And contacts with community leaders 
• Try to establish multiple contacts and 
relationships in the community 
© 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.
Practical Tips 
• Be patient 
• Develop methods of research and 
dissemination of the findings that will be: 
– Comprehensible and of interest to the 
community 
© 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.
Par As Method And Object Of 
Teaching: Critical Perspectives 
• Careful preparation and a self-reflective 
approach to the limits of this design; 
– And the ethical and political concerns 
associated with it 
• A Retelling of PAR’s History 
• Revising the Definition of PAR 
© 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.
Par and Pedagogy: The Politics Of 
Teaching & Learning Through CBPR 
• Beware the Backfire Effect: When CBPR 
Becomes the “Cure That Kills” 
– Objectification 
– Blaming The Victim 
– Paternalism 
• Often manifests in researchers’ and students’ 
verbal and nonverbal expressions 
© 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.
Par and Pedagogy: The Politics Of 
Teaching & Learning Through CBPR 
– Identifying And Overidentifying With “The 
Other” 
– Disillusionment With CBOs 
• Community-based organizations 
– Pressure To Misrepresent 
© 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.

More Related Content

What's hot

"New Research Shows" - or does it? Using ‘Junk Science’ in Information Litera...
"New Research Shows" - or does it? Using ‘Junk Science’ in Information Litera..."New Research Shows" - or does it? Using ‘Junk Science’ in Information Litera...
"New Research Shows" - or does it? Using ‘Junk Science’ in Information Litera...
Rosalind Tedford
 
Chapter 4 class version(1)
Chapter 4 class version(1)Chapter 4 class version(1)
Chapter 4 class version(1)
jbnx
 
Research methidology
Research methidologyResearch methidology
Research methidology
madhuvardhan
 
Qualitative Research Proposal
Qualitative Research ProposalQualitative Research Proposal
Qualitative Research Proposal
madelyne23
 

What's hot (20)

Garner c18
Garner c18Garner c18
Garner c18
 
Garner c20
Garner c20Garner c20
Garner c20
 
Garner c16
Garner c16Garner c16
Garner c16
 
Astrosociology in the Classroom - 100 Year Starship Symposium 2013 - Jim Pass...
Astrosociology in the Classroom - 100 Year Starship Symposium 2013 - Jim Pass...Astrosociology in the Classroom - 100 Year Starship Symposium 2013 - Jim Pass...
Astrosociology in the Classroom - 100 Year Starship Symposium 2013 - Jim Pass...
 
Creative research methods: Research using technology
Creative research methods: Research using technologyCreative research methods: Research using technology
Creative research methods: Research using technology
 
Kud ppt2.05.03.2018 Ethics in Research-Dr.Omprakash H M
Kud ppt2.05.03.2018 Ethics in Research-Dr.Omprakash H MKud ppt2.05.03.2018 Ethics in Research-Dr.Omprakash H M
Kud ppt2.05.03.2018 Ethics in Research-Dr.Omprakash H M
 
Nepotism on Employees Job Satisfaction
Nepotism on Employees Job SatisfactionNepotism on Employees Job Satisfaction
Nepotism on Employees Job Satisfaction
 
Research ethics
Research ethicsResearch ethics
Research ethics
 
"New Research Shows" - or does it? Using ‘Junk Science’ in Information Litera...
"New Research Shows" - or does it? Using ‘Junk Science’ in Information Litera..."New Research Shows" - or does it? Using ‘Junk Science’ in Information Litera...
"New Research Shows" - or does it? Using ‘Junk Science’ in Information Litera...
 
Zubin Master MedicReS World Congress 2014
Zubin Master MedicReS World Congress 2014Zubin Master MedicReS World Congress 2014
Zubin Master MedicReS World Congress 2014
 
Research ethics
Research ethicsResearch ethics
Research ethics
 
Ethical Issues in Research Writing
Ethical Issues in Research WritingEthical Issues in Research Writing
Ethical Issues in Research Writing
 
Chapter 4 class version(1)
Chapter 4 class version(1)Chapter 4 class version(1)
Chapter 4 class version(1)
 
Doing research in cl or rel ed
Doing research in cl or rel edDoing research in cl or rel ed
Doing research in cl or rel ed
 
Intellectual honesty and research integrity abu saleh
Intellectual honesty and research integrity abu salehIntellectual honesty and research integrity abu saleh
Intellectual honesty and research integrity abu saleh
 
Ethics in research1
Ethics in research1Ethics in research1
Ethics in research1
 
QUALITATIVE RESEARCH
QUALITATIVE RESEARCHQUALITATIVE RESEARCH
QUALITATIVE RESEARCH
 
Research methidology
Research methidologyResearch methidology
Research methidology
 
Qualitative Research Proposal
Qualitative Research ProposalQualitative Research Proposal
Qualitative Research Proposal
 
RoRILaunch 2 PRIORITIES Fransman
RoRILaunch 2 PRIORITIES FransmanRoRILaunch 2 PRIORITIES Fransman
RoRILaunch 2 PRIORITIES Fransman
 

Similar to Garner c10

Similar to Garner c10 (20)

2017 ai foundation-draft
2017 ai foundation-draft2017 ai foundation-draft
2017 ai foundation-draft
 
Giving direction to policies and manuals: high school journalism ethics
Giving direction to policies and manuals: high school journalism ethicsGiving direction to policies and manuals: high school journalism ethics
Giving direction to policies and manuals: high school journalism ethics
 
2018 foundation revision copy
2018 foundation revision copy2018 foundation revision copy
2018 foundation revision copy
 
Dr Margo Greenwood (March 2017) Community- Based Participatory Research: A S...
Dr Margo Greenwood (March 2017) Community- Based Participatory Research:  A S...Dr Margo Greenwood (March 2017) Community- Based Participatory Research:  A S...
Dr Margo Greenwood (March 2017) Community- Based Participatory Research: A S...
 
Engaging Online Through Community-Based Social Marketing
Engaging Online Through Community-Based Social MarketingEngaging Online Through Community-Based Social Marketing
Engaging Online Through Community-Based Social Marketing
 
Introduction to Qualitative Research-Week 1.pptx
Introduction to Qualitative Research-Week 1.pptxIntroduction to Qualitative Research-Week 1.pptx
Introduction to Qualitative Research-Week 1.pptx
 
Decolonising DMU and the PGR Experience
Decolonising DMU and the PGR ExperienceDecolonising DMU and the PGR Experience
Decolonising DMU and the PGR Experience
 
Elps 676
Elps 676Elps 676
Elps 676
 
Pg using reading in your assignments
Pg using reading in your assignmentsPg using reading in your assignments
Pg using reading in your assignments
 
A strategic approach to policy engagement for research organisations
A strategic approach to policy engagement for research organisationsA strategic approach to policy engagement for research organisations
A strategic approach to policy engagement for research organisations
 
Garner c19
Garner c19Garner c19
Garner c19
 
Communication for a Change (1).pptx
Communication for a Change (1).pptxCommunication for a Change (1).pptx
Communication for a Change (1).pptx
 
Innovative Partnerships Shift the Poverty Dynamic
Innovative Partnerships Shift the Poverty DynamicInnovative Partnerships Shift the Poverty Dynamic
Innovative Partnerships Shift the Poverty Dynamic
 
Enriching Policy with Research
Enriching Policy with ResearchEnriching Policy with Research
Enriching Policy with Research
 
Having Real Impact with Research
Having Real Impact with ResearchHaving Real Impact with Research
Having Real Impact with Research
 
Public engagement with postgraduate research june 2013
Public engagement with postgraduate research june 2013Public engagement with postgraduate research june 2013
Public engagement with postgraduate research june 2013
 
Sociology as revision
Sociology as revisionSociology as revision
Sociology as revision
 
2016 editorial policy
2016 editorial policy2016 editorial policy
2016 editorial policy
 
Building Research Partnerships for Public Health Impact
Building Research Partnerships for Public Health ImpactBuilding Research Partnerships for Public Health Impact
Building Research Partnerships for Public Health Impact
 
Asking Anthropological Questions
Asking Anthropological QuestionsAsking Anthropological Questions
Asking Anthropological Questions
 

More from Beulah Heights University (20)

Kotler mm 14e_22_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_22_ipptKotler mm 14e_22_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_22_ippt
 
Kotler mm 14e_21_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_21_ipptKotler mm 14e_21_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_21_ippt
 
Kotler mm 14e_20_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_20_ipptKotler mm 14e_20_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_20_ippt
 
Kotler mm 14e_19_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_19_ipptKotler mm 14e_19_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_19_ippt
 
Kotler mm 14e_18_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_18_ipptKotler mm 14e_18_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_18_ippt
 
Kotler mm 14e_17_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_17_ipptKotler mm 14e_17_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_17_ippt
 
Kotler mm 14e_16_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_16_ipptKotler mm 14e_16_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_16_ippt
 
Kotler mm 14e_15_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_15_ipptKotler mm 14e_15_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_15_ippt
 
Kotler mm 14e_14_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_14_ipptKotler mm 14e_14_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_14_ippt
 
Kotler mm 14e_13_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_13_ipptKotler mm 14e_13_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_13_ippt
 
Kotler mm 14e_12_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_12_ipptKotler mm 14e_12_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_12_ippt
 
Kotler mm 14e_11_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_11_ipptKotler mm 14e_11_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_11_ippt
 
Kotler mm 14e_10_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_10_ipptKotler mm 14e_10_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_10_ippt
 
Kotler mm 14e_09_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_09_ipptKotler mm 14e_09_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_09_ippt
 
Kotler mm 14e_08_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_08_ipptKotler mm 14e_08_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_08_ippt
 
Kotler mm 14e_07_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_07_ipptKotler mm 14e_07_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_07_ippt
 
Kotler mm 14e_04_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_04_ipptKotler mm 14e_04_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_04_ippt
 
Kotler mm 14e_03_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_03_ipptKotler mm 14e_03_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_03_ippt
 
Kotler mm 14e_01_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_01_ipptKotler mm 14e_01_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_01_ippt
 
Kotler mm 14e_02_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_02_ipptKotler mm 14e_02_ippt
Kotler mm 14e_02_ippt
 

Garner c10

  • 1. Chapter 10 Community-Based Participatory Research or Participatory Action Research (with Krista Harper)
  • 2. What Is CBPR? • CBPR breaks with the logic of the detached, objective observer in two ways: – (1) The researcher is trying to bring about change, and – (2) the researcher interacts & cooperates with the researched to bring changes the: • Researched themselves identified as desirable © 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.
  • 3. What Is CBPR? • A Brief History (or Rather, “Herstory”) – The Researcher As An Agent Of Change – The Community As The “Expert” – The Researcher Facilitates & Doesn’t Dictate • What Is the Meaning of “Community?” • Problem-Solving? Whose Problems, Whose Solutions? © 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.
  • 4. Par In Action: Environmental Justice In A Hungarian Village • Starting with Justice • Getting to Know the Roma • A Key Informant Emerges • Jointly Designing the Project – Photo-voice © 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.
  • 5. An Overview Of CBPR As A Design Choice • The researcher works with community leaders and the research is interactive; – In accord with egalitarian ideals • It is effective to use methods readily understood by community members and: – That are inherently engaging and participatory © 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.
  • 6. An Overview Of CBPR As A Design Choice • The production of information in a visual or physical form may be a more: – Meaningful product than peer-reviewed article published in a scholarly journal • The researchers must be willing to assume new roles as facilitators of: – Interaction within the community © 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.
  • 7. An Overview Of CBPR As A Design Choice • Interaction between the community members and the outsider is seen: – Explicitly not only as a way of beginning to address specific problems but, above all: • As a method of breaking isolation © 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.
  • 8. Practical Tips • CBPR and PAR require background knowledge of the community; – And contacts with community leaders • Try to establish multiple contacts and relationships in the community © 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.
  • 9. Practical Tips • Be patient • Develop methods of research and dissemination of the findings that will be: – Comprehensible and of interest to the community © 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.
  • 10. Par As Method And Object Of Teaching: Critical Perspectives • Careful preparation and a self-reflective approach to the limits of this design; – And the ethical and political concerns associated with it • A Retelling of PAR’s History • Revising the Definition of PAR © 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.
  • 11. Par and Pedagogy: The Politics Of Teaching & Learning Through CBPR • Beware the Backfire Effect: When CBPR Becomes the “Cure That Kills” – Objectification – Blaming The Victim – Paternalism • Often manifests in researchers’ and students’ verbal and nonverbal expressions © 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.
  • 12. Par and Pedagogy: The Politics Of Teaching & Learning Through CBPR – Identifying And Overidentifying With “The Other” – Disillusionment With CBOs • Community-based organizations – Pressure To Misrepresent © 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.