SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 12
Download to read offline
50 California Street
34th Floor
San Francisco, CA 94111
T 415.398.3600
F 415.398.2438
Martin A. Mattes
D 415.438.7273
mmattes@nossaman.com
Refer To File #: 190640-0005
56053276.v2
May 10, 2017
Raminder S. Kahlon, Director
Water Division
California Public Utilities Commission
505 Van Ness Avenue
San Francisco, CA 94102
Re: Request of San Jose Water Company for Commission Review
of Water Division’s Rejection of Its Advice Letter No. 501
Dear Mr. Kahlon:
San Jose Water Company (“SJWC”) filed its Advice Letter No. (“AL”) 501 on
January 9, 2017, as a Tier 2 advice letter requesting authorization, pursuant to the
Commission’s Decision (“D.”) 16-12-026, Ordering Paragraph 3, to implement a Sales
Reconciliation Mechanism (“SRM”) to conform water forecasts authorized in its last General
Rate Case (“GRC”) to recorded consumption for the period October 2015 through September
2016. AL 501 requested that the submitted rate changes become effective March 15, 2017.
Water Division suspended AL 501 prior to its effective date, stating that the AL was
not in compliance with a Commission decision but also that “D.16-12-026 has to be
modified.” On April 6, 2017, the Commission adopted D.17-04-002, correcting errors in
D.16-12-026. The Commission noted in D.17-04-002 that Water Division’s review of AL 501
had identified an error in D.16-12-026’s description of the SRM by the use of the word
“revenue” rather than “sales,” and so the April decision replaced references to “revenues” in
the context of the SRM with references to “sales” at several points in the text and also in
Ordering Paragraph 3. By your letter of May 3, 2017, Water Division now rejects AL 501,
based on a reading of D.16-12-026 as “specifically requir[ing] that there exist a declared
drought.”
A. SJWC Requests Commission Review of Water Division’s Rejection of AL 501.
By this letter, submitted in accordance with Section 7.7.1 of General Order No. (“GO”)
96-B, SJWC respectfully requests Commission review of Water Division’s disposition of AL
501. In the paragraphs below, SJWC sets forth the specific grounds on which SJWC
contends that Water Division’s action is unlawful and erroneous. Those grounds may be
summarized as follows:
VIA ELECTRONIC MAIL & U.S. MAIL
Raminder S. Kahlon, Director
May 10, 2017
Page 2
56053276.v2
 Water Division engaged in an unlawful discretionary review of AL 501.
To provide such a review, Water Division should have prepared a
resolution for the Commission’s consideration.
 Water Division fails to apply the clear wording of D.16-12-026, Ordering
Paragraph 3, which unambiguously authorizes SJWC to request an SRM
by Tier 2 advice letter under the circumstances on which SJWC’s request
was based.
 Water Division erroneously relies on the text of D.16-12-026, which is
completely consistent with Ordering Paragraph 3, to reach a conclusion
inconsistent with the clear wording of that ordering paragraph.
 Water Division fails to consider the Commission’s policy discussion in
D.16-12-026, which supports authorization of an SRM to mitigate a
mismatch between authorized and actual sales during a drought year
regardless of whether the drought has ended.
 Water Division fails to consider the various state policies and initiatives
intended to make water conservation a California way of life, or the
complementary local conservation requirements, which can be expected
to prolong the mismatch between SJWC’s authorized and actual sales
absent allowance of an SRM.
B. AL 501 Anticipated the Corrected Requirements of D.16-12-026.
In drafting AL 501, SJWC anticipated the correction to D.16-12-026 that the
Commission made by D.17-04-002. Thus, AL 501 compared the sales forecast of 49,861
Kccf1 authorized in its most recent GRC decision, D.16-06-004, with SJWC’s total actual
sales of 40,173 Kccf during the 12-month period of October 1, 2015 through September 30,
2016, noting that this total divergence of 19.4% exceeded the five percent trigger authorized
in D.16-06-004. Per the authorized SRM, SJWC recalculated rates to account for 50% of the
divergence between authorized and actual sales, resulting in increased quantity rates and a
3.65% increase in the typical residential customer bill.
Water Division found no fault with any aspect of AL 501 except the alleged
dependence of Ordering Paragraph 3 of D.16-12-026 on the existence of a “declared
drought.” As noted above, Water Division’s reading of D.16-12-026 and especially of
Ordering Paragraph 3 is incorrect. This letter will explain why.
1 “Kccf” stands for one thousand one-hundred cubic feet.
Raminder S. Kahlon, Director
May 10, 2017
Page 3
56053276.v2
C. AL 501 Meets the Requirements of Ordering Paragraph 3 but Water Division
Invents an Additional Requirement to Deny the Requested SRM.
Ordering Paragraph 3 of D.16-12-026, as corrected by D.17-04-002, reads as follows:
Class A and B Water Investor-Owned Utilities that have a five percent or greater
divergence (higher or lower) between authorized and actual sales during a
drought period in their current General Rate Case cycle, shall consider filing for
an individual district or several districts a Tier 2 Advice Letter requesting a Sales
Reconciliation Mechanism to conform water forecasts authorized in the current
General Rate Case to actual consumption, in light of the drought and
circumstances faced in their district(s).
Based on the clear wording of Ordering Paragraph 3, SJWC was authorized to file AL
501. SJWC, a Class A water utility, had a divergence greater than five percent (actually
19.4%) between authorized and actual sales during the 12-month period from October 2015
through September 2016.2 That 12-month period occurred during the Drought State of
Emergency declared by Governor Brown on January 17, 2014, which was subsequently
terminated for all except four counties in the state by the Governor’s Executive Order B-40-
17, issued April 7, 2017. Accordingly, SJWC properly filed AL 501 as a Tier 2 advice letter to
implement an SRM “in light of the drought and circumstances faced in [its district].”
Despite identifying no ambiguity in Ordering Paragraph 3, Water Division finds that it
must “interpret” the ordering paragraph by consulting the text of D.16-12-026. Water Division
discovers that page 6 of the decision authorizes an SRM advice letter to be filed only “during
a drought period.” That is the same phrase used in Ordering Paragraph 3, so it does not
help to “interpret” it. Water Division then refers to page 33 of the decision, which states that
an SRM filing may be made “during declared drought years” – which seems entirely
consistent with the “during a drought period” reference and leads Water Division to conclude
that “there must exist a drought in order to make an SRM advice letter filing.” And so there
was when SJWC filed the SRM request on January 9, 2017 – the very same drought that
Governor Brown declared in 2014 and did not declare terminated (in 48 of 52 counties) until
April 7, 2017.
Having exhausted its references to the text of D.16-12-026, Water Division goes on to
state the obvious – that the drought was declared over before AL 501 was, belatedly, acted
upon. Noting that Santa Clara Valley Water District continues to call for 20% water
conservation (which Water Division inaccurately describes as “voluntary”), Water Division
dismisses this “call for conservation” as not relevant to the “intent or plain language of D.16-
12-026 requiring “that there exist a declared drought.” Water Division then notes that SJWC
has requested authority to suspend the drought allocations and surcharges in its Schedule
14.1 (but not the Schedule itself) and on that basis concludes that “SJWC neither has the
drought conditions, nor the need to implement drought allocations that would require an SRM
adjustment for 2017.”
2 As SJWC explained in AL 501, rate changes due to triggering an SRM are typically made
concurrently with escalation rate increases, so usage for the prior 12-month period through
September is applied to determine divergence from authorized sales.
Raminder S. Kahlon, Director
May 10, 2017
Page 4
56053276.v2
D. Water Division’s Rejection of AL 501 Based on a Convoluted Interpretation of
D.16-12-026 Amounts to an Improper Discretionary Review.
Water Division’s conclusion that an SRM cannot be required absent drought
conditions and drought allocations, and the consequent rejection of AL 501, are based on
misinterpretation of D.16-12-026 and an incomplete and inaccurate understanding of the
relevant facts. SJWC will correct these errors in the paragraphs that follow, but first must
state emphatically that Water Division has no authority or discretion to reject a Tier 2 advice
letter based on the sort of analysis your letter presents. Water Division is authorized to reject
a Tier 2 advice letter only when such action is ministerial in nature.3 Whenever a more
discretionary determination is required, the appropriate procedure is for Water Division to
prepare and place on the Commission’s meeting agenda a resolution approving, rejecting, or
modifying the advice letter as submitted – giving affected parties opportunity to comment on
the proposed disposition in advance.4 Water Division’s rejection of AL 401 based on a
convoluted interpretation of the plain language of D.16-12-026, Ordering Paragraph 3, is
certainly more than a ministerial act. Water Division should have prepared a resolution to
permit the Commission to interpret, for itself, whether use of the SRM mechanism, which it
had so recently authorized should now, suddenly, be forbidden.
E. Not Only the Express Terms of Ordering Paragraph 3 but Also the Relevant
Policy Discussion in D.16-12-026 Justify Approving SJWC’s Request for an
SRM.
SJWC was justified in filing AL 501 to establish an SRM not only by the express terms
of D.16-12-026, Ordering Paragraph 3, but also by the policy considerations on which that
ordering paragraph was based. Despite the subsequent official end to the drought, those
policy considerations continue to justify approving AL 501 and allowing SJWC to implement
an SRM.
D.16-12-026 prominently recognized not only the Governor’s declaration of a Drought
State of Emergency in 2014 but also his then most recent Executive Order B-37-16, issued
May 9, 2016, which aimed “to make conservation a way of life in California,” and went on to
describe the actions of the Commission and also the State Water Resources Control Board
(“Water Board”) intending to “build on the 25 percent water reduction levels imposed by
previous Executive Orders, and reflect lessons learned during the drought.”5 D.16-12-016
also prominently featured the Commission’s concern about inaccurate sales forecasts,
emphasizing that “[i]naccurate forecasts provide the air that balloons the WRAM and
surcharges,” and providing for utilities to request SRMs “to conform water forecasts
authorized in the GRC to actual consumption in light of the circumstances faced in their
districts.”6
3 See, GO 96-B, §7.6.1.
4 Id., §7.6.2; see also, Rule 14.5 of the Commission’s Rules of Practice and Procedure.
5 D.16-12-026, at 4-5.
6 Id. at 6.
Raminder S. Kahlon, Director
May 10, 2017
Page 5
56053276.v2
Looking beyond these summary declarations to the details of D.16-12-026’s analysis,
we find confirmation that this “Decision Providing Guidance” was intended to set a path
forward not just for the duration of the current drought but for the longer-term future. The
Decision’s discussion of “Forecasting and SRM” recognized that traditional forecasting
methods did not adequately capture either recent drought conservation effects or expected
changes in water consumption resulting from the Governor’s Executive Orders and the
Commission’s actions. The Decision especially noted the Governor’s direction to the
Department of Water Resources (“DWR”) to develop new water use targets as part of a
permanent framework for water agencies, and “the steps that many California water
agencies are taking to promote and mandate conservation.”7 Noting concern about
“mismatches” between authorized revenue and actual sales, the Decision saw need for
action “to better align” forecasted and recorded sales.” That action was to order water
utilities with a five percent or greater divergence between authorized and actual revenue
(later corrected to refer to “sales”) during declared drought years in their current GRC cycle
to consider filing for an SRM, which would recalculate rates “through the remainder of the
GRC cycle.”8
Conclusion of Law 3 summarized the Commission’s reasoning:
3. Authorizing Class A and B utilities to consider filing a Tier 2 Advice letter to
implement a drought SRM is consistent with this Commission’s resolution to
promote conservation, our policies to communicate transparent cost-signals to
ratepayers, and Pub. Util. Code §701.10.9
In summary, D.16-12-026 did not envision the SRM solely as a response to the
drought. First and foremost, the Commission saw the SRM as a means of addressing the
mismatch between authorized revenue and sales that resulted from inaccurate sales
forecasts in the context of continuing success in water conservation. Those policy
considerations justified SJWC’s filing of AL 501 to establish an SRM and they continue to
justify approving AL 501 today, whether or not the drought continues. Given the
Commission’s evident interest in the SRM as a means of addressing “mismatches between
authorized revenue and sales,” continuation of the drought is not necessary to justify
implementing an SRM, where the mandated five percent “divergence” already has occurred.
F. Many Factors of Statewide and Local Policy and Practice Support an
Expectation of a Continuing Mismatch Between SJWC’s Adopted and Actual
Sales.
In SJWC’s case, the “mismatch between authorized revenue and sales” was not just
five percent, but 19.4% in the drought year on which AL 501’s SRM request was based.
Absent the requested SRM, that 19.4% “mismatch” may increase or decrease through the
last two years of SJWC’s current GRC cycle, but it certainly will not disappear. Several
7 Id. at 28-30.
8 Id. at 33-34.
9 Id. at 83.
Raminder S. Kahlon, Director
May 10, 2017
Page 6
56053276.v2
relevant factors suggest that SJWC’s sales will remain substantially below the level forecast
in its most recent GRC:
 Governor Brown’s most recent Executive Order B-40-17, while rescinding his
2014 Drought Proclamation, also ordered that “the orders and provisions of
Executive Order B-37-16, Making Water Conservation a California Way of
Life, remain in full force and effect except as modified by this Executive Order.”
 Executive Order B-40-17 expressly directed the Water Board to “continue
development of permanent prohibitions on wasteful water use and requirements
for reporting water use by urban water agencies.”
 Executive Order B-40-17 also directed DWR to continue work with the Water
Board to develop standard for urban water suppliers to use in setting new urban
water use efficiency targets and to direct actions to minimize water system leaks
that waste large amounts of water.
 On April 7, 2017, the same day the Governor rescinded his Drought Proclamation,
th Commission, DWR, the Water Board, and two other California executive
agencies issued their final report, Making Water Conservation a California Way of
Life, implementing Executive Order B-37-16, providing an array of
“recommendations for how to implement long-term improvements to water supply
management that support water conservation.”
 Santa Clara Valley Water District has maintained its call for a water use reduction
target equal to 20% of 2013 water use, for restriction of outdoor watering of
ornamental landscapes or lawns with potable water, and for local enforcement of
the Water Board’s prohibitions of wasteful water use.10 Contrary to Water
Division’s assertion, the District has not described these restrictions as
“voluntary.”
 SJWC’s Rule 14.1 and Schedule 14.1, providing for water shortage contingency
plans, remain in effect. Rule 14.1 continues to prohibit wasteful water use
practices. As Water Division notes, SJWC filed its AL 505 in January 2017 to
suspend Schedule 14.1’s drought allocations and drought surcharges, but
Schedule 14.1 and all of the water use restrictions defined therein remain in
effect.
Based on all these factors, it would be inconsistent and unwise for the Commission
now to disown and abandon the procedure that it so recently adopted in D.16-12-026 for
allowing utilities that have experienced a significant mismatch between authorized and actual
sales during a drought year, based on their most recent GRC decisions, to implement an
SRM that will ameliorate that mismatch and help to achieve more appropriate price signals to
customers. Official termination of the drought does not justify reversing that policy, since
such a reversal would run counter to local and state conservation objectives.
10 See, Santa Clara Valley Water District Resolution No. 17-08, adopted January 31, 2017.
Raminder S. Kahlon, Director
May 10, 2017
Page 7
56053276.v2
G. Conclusion
D.16-12-026, as corrected by D.17-04-002, included as a condition for requesting an
SRM that a water utility have a divergence of five percent or more between authorized and
actual sales “during a drought period” in its current GRC cycle. As discussed above, SJWC
met that condition during the relevant 12-month period and also when it filed AL 501. None
of Water Division’s “interpretations” of Ordering Paragraph 3 justify transforming that
condition into a requirement that the drought continue into the “remainder of the GRC cycle”
when the SRM would be in effect. To the contrary, the policies the Commission articulated in
D.16-12-026 as its reasons for authorizing the SRM argue strongly against imposing such an
added requirement.
For all the reasons stated in this letter, SJWC respectfully urges the Commission,
upon review, to reverse Water Division’s rejection of AL 501 and, instead, to approve the
advice letter as proposed.
Respectfully submitted,
Martin A. Mattes
of Nossaman LLP
Attorneys for SAN JOSE WATER
COMPANY
MAM:mt
cc: Protesting Parties (see attached Service List)
Page 1 of 5
SERVICE LIST BY ELECTRONIC MAIL
rosemary.c.adamson@gmail.com; juliaschan@comcast.net; schatterj@hotmail.com; seawolve44@yahoo.com;
shazzashops@yahoo.com; dhkalmus@gmail.com; lweelee@hotmail.com; jlindsay_us@yahoo.com;
vikrammodak@gmail.com; moriarty95070@gmail.com; samroza@gmail.com; jshank@theshanks.net;
keith_wald@yahoo.com; qulizhou@gmail.com; j-segall@sbcglobal.net; mg_1146@att.net;
pewskinner@yahoo.com; miketutor@comcast.net; mgong1@gmail.com; silvana.panunzio@gmail.com;
vnayak_us@yahoo.com; camconv68@sbcglobal.net; 1250man@gmail.com; djayramasubban@yahoo.com;
jvelas@comcast.net; this.coly@gmail.com; shellieg1@gmail.com; oskinghuang@gmail.com;
elizabeth.g.doros@gmail.com; b4massey@yahoo.com; eriktakaoka@gmail.com; sl951@yahoo.com;
amalia.gomez6@gmail.com; vivekrashmi@hotmail.com; meddevicepro@gmail.com; bsmith1231@yahoo.com;
gschoet@sbcglobal.net; sujatar27@yahoo.com; wesfergy@cyberdude.com; bobrayl@icloud.com;
gtacn@yahoo.com; theponcianos@gmail.com; ldalbert@comcast.net; lauraventura66@yahoo.com;
heng742@live.com; ltaillie@yahoo.com; yqsony@gmail.com; chtliang@yahoo.com; heidari.amir@gmail.com;
hamdjm63@gmail.com; charlieg@sjtoolstore.com; phillipslaura84@gmail.com; levashov_yurii@hotmail.com;
chuckbrassfield@yahoo.com; focused-one@sbcglobal.net; john@marymonte.com;
harold_horimoto@yahoo.com; ackalloor@yahoo.com; ducao60@gmail.com; rchwong6@gmail.com;
suekh@pacbell.net; digital@megainfo.com; cchamrah10@gmail.com; mikeo@sbcglobal.net;
weavus135@yahoo.com; jeanlamarca@sbcglobal.net; austin.bock@intel.com; subraji@att.net;
greglynn@gmail.com; svraley@gmail.com; steve.crimi@outlook.com; davidlai9988@gmail.com;
mtndeb@earthlink.net; mpub@gizmology.com; mikeniday@hotmail.com; tf3328@gmail.com;
jburkhart@sbcglobal.net; frank.seto@gmail.com; larrywangsj@gmail.com; domenico@embertec.com;
fsamadani@comcast.net; jody@refugeesrock.com; angelicruiz@yahoo.com; crows@netzero.net;
bencolombeau@gmail.com; rick.panian@gmail.com; Nayanatara.Rao@kp.org; jas5266@yahoo.com;
jwpalmer@gmail.com; gfiremedic@comcast.net; msbhat@pacbell.net; a.v.goldberg@gmail.com;
jwnielson@gmail.com; bonmueller@comcast.net; dshade14@att.net; txqchen@yahoo.com;
lesliepeluso@yahoo.com; michele_c_lee@yahoo.com; kchen1@gmail.com; vicpaul@sbcglobal.net;
chapsk@gmail.com; chip.maloney@comcast.net; hoser1@pacbell.net; domnjen@comcast.net;
bill_bradley_ca@yahoo.com; ruchijoshi@yahoo.com; kibbish@gmail.com; tom.weldon@sbcglobal.net;
dgingerelli@comcast.net; hauttdo@gmail.com; danielonn2002@yahoo.com; tkbk@mac.com;
tammywan0315@yahoo.com; kthjand@yahoo.com; knrheidi@earthlink.net; J_F_Boyer@hotmail.com;
normmargie@gmail.com; mishra_anurag@yahoo.com; lisa@aa2r.com; bobrayl@icloud.com;
czabarte@yahoo.com; skdwoody0@gmail.com; joshuarichard02@gmail.com; ambidex11@yahoo.com;
vipin.k.jain@gmail.com; michelledong8@yahoo.com; Danh_Van@symantec.com;
christianmastrodonato1977@gmail.com; davidwclin@gmail.com; nommn@aol.com; cchatterj@hotmail.com;
phuong.macleod@gmail.com; tmeskell@hotmail.com; mengqin@gmail.com; sscccharrell@yahoo.com;
biagina2002@icloud.com; leshen@visa.com; rgellman@gmail.com; jooley8@aol.com;
jay11west11@gmail.com; smb.cochran@gmail.com; dickb2@pacbell.net; dognelson95128@yahoo.com;
4anandgrover@gmail.com; karlebaat@gmail.com; neal.jack@gmail.com; azimpetro@yahoo.com;
derrick.nguyen@gmail.com; nnguyenhuy@att.net; chuckvanderwege@gmail.com; bobtemm@gmail.com;
U.GoGirl@hotmail.com; mail4steven@yahoo.com; pkampp@hotmail.com; wbus97@gmail.com;
susanquillinan@gmail.com; mbhaska@hotmail.com; tseng2@gmail.com; sunderraj@ymail.com;
rampitec@gmail.com; johnmaecondie@att.net; sfong6@yahoo.com; bonnasue@yahoo.com; teenyt@me.com;
john.stankus@gmail.com; bobmd@aol.com; biglaurie@aol.com; danifel@gmail.com; ravis2@yahoo.com;
gtom@live.com; fennywongso@gmail.com; vshwen@gmail.com; shyama777@gmail.com;
sameerpradhan@gmail.com; timandkristine@sbcglobal.net; amalarasan@yahoo.com;
boriram3081@gmail.com; ritesh.trivedi@gmail.com; rwaits1@icloud.com; rajwww@yahoo.com;
mpejcic@yahoo.com; robinmagovern@icloud.com; linus.aranha@gmail.com; chiachialu@yahoo.com;
russianvegan@yahoo.com; dmoessinger@comcast.net; jaimebatiz@yahoo.com; yiping@comcast.net;
kiranmayi@rocketmail.com; yanzhang1998@hotmail.com; Elwyn_Cabebe@hotmail.com;
ronghuazhang@gmail.com; vinnysj@pacbell.net; sorisho@gmail.com; debbiejdsy@yahoo.com;
Nidhi.lalit@gmail.com; RLee@rlallp.com; DTDuffy@msn.com; avivgr@gmail.com; aidascott@msn.com;
bronco60@comcast.net; wce@eister.com; jceyip@hotmail.com; kiascu2003@gmail.com;
pigasus821@gmail.com; Robert.Masleid@comcast.net; cnkurzke@gmail.com; heather.palmer@ymail.com;
tom.mcavoy@lmco.com; zhfzhh@yahoo.com; skygem@gmail.com; laurabright59@yahoo.com;
Page 2 of 5
khiem.ho@gmail.com; jkmaniaci@verizon.net; faithtio@yahoo.com; scaplan42@gmail.com; krzyjny@aol.com;
dnsargis@gmail.com; wjmeyer09@att.net; lloydo101@sbcglobal.net; jimgreer1071@gmail.com;
captal44@aol.com; mohsen_tadjvar@yahoo.com; jjko888@hotmail.com; fl@quadbase.com;
chadmitch00@gmail.com; chutani@gmail.com; smachado@yahoo.com; avneet007@gmail.com;
pranab.dhar@gmail.com; vernalee2@yahoo.com; lukluck98@yahoo.com; celestemartino@yahoo.com;
dfarrington311@gmail.com; jaswang2006@gmail.com; rich-sharon@att.net; sherburnes@sbcglobal.net;
lan1truong@yahoo.com; tiffanysp@hotmail.com; lancesp@hotmail.com; peggykendall@comcast.net;
sreimert@gmail.com; kuszikam@aim.com; PrettyPopcorn@aol.com; wei_wu_01@yahoo.com;
martinspicer00@gmail.com; abrigantino@yahoo.com; cjon2008@gmail.com; tempnick@live.com;
bmuniz@baca.org; denver@mediationmasters.com;jerrygao2011@gmail.com; taniajz@gmail.com;
noorm937@yahoo.com; kmasini@me.com; Dean_Sakauye@msn.com; olipkind@gmail.com;
qiawang@cisco.com; btuvey@ht-world.com; tesferd@gmail.com; smith.keyston@gmail.com;
kzobeck@gmail.com; jincyn@gmail.com; wenhendry@comcast.net; dhg2@myway.com;
danny28888@yahoo.com; panzica.linda@gmail.com; tae.kim@gmail.com; phlei@yahoo.com;
good2bus29@yahoo.com; damoresix@comcast.net; c.conrad1@mindspring.com; bentjensen@yahoo.com;
namansonal@gmail.com; Joe.Dutra@ti.com; tsticklinski@apm.com; agulesserian111@gmail.com;
Gayle.Calkins@harker.org; jtakatsuji@shibatec.com; dean.p.giovannetti@nasa.gov; bien.luc@hotmail.com;
lboyzo98@gmail.com; patwood@winterbourne.com; ted_bancroft@yahoo.com; jeankk@gmail.com;
tdoan1991@gmail.com; doupola@aol.com; rongarcia@ymail.com; cadoganlm@gmail.com;
idnanichandru@gmail.com; beckersze@yahoo.com; fraldrete@gmail.com; gene123@sbcglobal.net;
athan2@sbcglobal.net; frany454@yahoo.com; markasikes@gmail.com; shyamvedantam21@gmail.com;
voodooboy@gmail.com; Debgrizzle@comcast.net; beckyolmos@att.net; kedhermanla@yahoo.com;
lmmagall@yahoo.com; praveen@gonugunta.com; nathanballard1171@outlook.com; llopez2196@aol.com;
dcao62@yahoo.com; Matt.Winans@claconnect1.com; avinashpatro@gmail.com; graycd@comcast.net;
p.murots@gmail.com; robertyager@comcast.net; powpowhughes@yahoo.com; josephjrodriguez@gmail.com;
hrklaver@yahoo.com; vincestaub@yahoo.com; matthewalanstevenson@gmail.com; Laurie@rialtowest.com;
abdulrasheed.a@gmail.com; xiaoxiny@hotmail.com; jackiefahrner@gmail.com; tonybayarea@icloud.com;
kmassarat@gmail.com; beasines@pacbell.net; gfhuang@gmail.com; craig.stafford@nelsonirrigation.com;
jackiefahrner@gmail.com; ca.fahrner@comcast.net; sergei_perfilov@yahoo.com; leevon49@yahoo.com;
firatkart@gmail.com; martin1880@sbcglobal.net; luchen26@hotmail.com; SWCHIC@msn.com; jlc20@att.net;
emma.bolich@gmail.com; ray@persico.us; asowda@gmail.com; ltng04@gmail.com;
zypchenfeng@gmail.com; jamieb186@gmail.com; yapkke@gmail.com; zagers@gmail.com;
Mare501@yahoo.com; brian@missionbenefits.com; gstuckert1@juno.com; Timeforme0214@outlook.com;
caroleroth410@gmail.com; perob744@gmail.com; digby.pun@gmail.com; suzettem@wordsanddeeds.com;
ctraeg@gmail.com; tim@PETTITT.US; wolfner89@gmail.com; awakenfive@gmail.com;
pedybiagtan@yahoo.com; lynnemiz123@gmail.com; rloftusjr@yahoo.com; rwoolman58@gmail.com;
ronnie.militante@gmail.com; jwponte@att.net; jeffreynaristide@comcast.net; doria.dy@bayvoice.net;
kskandad@yahoo.com; equal3@att.net; bmattade@pacbell.net; alexandra.rae.frey@gmail.com;
luke_reimer@sbcglobal.net; jpalmer@advanceddiscovery.com; merrywyj@gmail.com; lisali.lyj@gmail.com;
oakleygirvan@gmail.com; hongbud@yahoo.com; junlu_email@yahoo.com; ganjiayan@gmail.com;
luyihuan78@gmail.com; cuiyingsj@hotmail.com; rosapyun@gmail.com; feralwriter1@gmail.com;
m1105chester@yahoo.com; jmg001@mindspring.com; rishida@pacbell.net; yournamehere@sonic.net;
h_sarah_chen@yahoo.com; zypwxl@yahoo.com; alex@clemm.org; casa95129@yahoo.com;
jerrykennedy0021@sbcglobal.net; adel.khouja@gmail.com; c_huang88@yahoo.com; samleelee3@gmail.com;
alexwheeler@gmail.com; dianne.tuleybrown@gmail.com; hannahitbrown@gmail.com; scquinn@sonic.net;
jmolaw@pacbell.net; gstuckert1@juno.com; eddiesweeney@icloud.com; agulesserian111@gmail.com;
mgharding@sbcglobal.net; natalyman2002@yahoo.com; anniexh@gmail.com; tracycl2003@yahoo.com;
williamblabon@comcast.net; liuwei_xd@hotmail.com; bubbibobbi@mymailstation.com; tleipelt@ymail.com;
bladetheslayer@gmail.com; 1davidholland@gmail.com; suzjone@comcast.net; ALevy@hopkinscarley.com;
cynndi.wang@gmail.com; atyrequest@gmail.com; bfs7351@gmail.com; stevenlpalmer@yahoo.com;
olyubynska@gmail.com; jcbeatty21@gmail.com; poonamkravi@yahoo.com; kvrousseau@gmail.com;
bretbeechie@sbcglobal.net; home_and_finance@yahoo.com; skygem@gmail.com;
davidmk@generalmail.com; pjk3@comcast.net; adachan288@yahoo.com; ldornell2@comcast.net;
jdmiller1023@comcast.net; steve@theenlightenedmind.net; patricia_juarez@comcast.net;
hisey@stanford.edu; jengifford@att.net; rajik99@yahoo.com; hawkseer1111@yahoo.com
Page 3 of 5
SERVICE LIST BY U.S. MAIL
Kathy Cleary
20645 Montalvo Heights Drive
Saratoga, CA 95070
Armando Lopez, Jr.
376 Jerome Street
San Jose, CA 95125
Yakoub Bellawala
1440 Harriet Avenue
Campbell, CA 95008
Dolores Cunha
620 Kenneth Avenue
Campbell, CA 95008
W. Higginson
487 Skall Drive
San Jose, CA 95111
Ulysses Sambajon
10587 Franklin Boulevard
Elk Grove, CA 95757
Floyd Okada
14085 Taos Drive
Saratoga, CA 95070
Don and Vera Reed
6067 Pietz Court
San Jose, CA 95123
Cynthia Ryan Francis
1652 Naglee Avenue
San Jose, CA 95126
William Nevis
126 Fox Avenue
San Jose, CA 95110
Thomas Valdez, Jr.
1343 Mich Bluff Drive
San Jose, CA 95131
Laura Schneider
638 Auzerais Avenue
San Jose, CA 95126
Benton Hooper
1881 Ensendada Drive
Campbell, CA 95008
Nellie Jenks
6106 Iowa Drive
San Jose, CA 95123
Mary E. Keifer
1362 Hillcrest Court
San Jose, CA 95120
Dr. Gerald Bittner, Jr.
14309 Chester Avenue
Saratoga, CA 95070
Anita Gable
1363 Winona Drive
San Jose, CA 95125
William and Macy Ip
12921 Brandywine Drive
Saratoga, CA 95070
Laurie Stapleton
10395 Moretti Drive
Cupertino, CA 95014
David Shade
16615 Englewood Avenue
Los Gatos, CA 95032
Kitrick E. Whitney
735 Carlotta Court
San Jose, CA 95136
Michael Jenks
1584 Keesling Avenue
San Jose, CA 95125
Catherine Comer
1494 Cherry Valley Drive
San Jose, CA 95125
Ivan and Jeanette Aladjoff
112 Belwood Lane
Los Gatos, CA 95032
Dolores T. Kloss
20031 Somerset Drive
Cupertino, CA 95014
Beth Keifer
1873 Huxley Court
San Jose, CA 95125
Yelena Yakirina
1200 Valley Quail Circle
San Jose, CA 95120
Dorothy A. Brown
2350 Shade Tree Lane
San Jose, CA 95131
Philip J. Shanker
15949 Cerro Vista Court
Los Gatos, CA 95032
David H. Mowbray
1032 Empey Way
San Jose, CA 95128
Joseph and Deborah Isham
2196 Willester Avenue
San Jose, CA 95124
Seyed M. Sabahi
2205 Corktree Lane
San Jose, CA 95132
William and Mirella Auer
6077 Burnbank Place
San Jose, CA 95120
Larry and Vicky Toder
1858 Gunston Way
San Jose, CA 95124
Samuel A. Moiseff
6262 Paso Los Cerritos
San Jose, CA 95120
Margaret Jasper
20191 Bonnie Brae Way
Saratoga, CA 95070
Muthukumar Mudaliar
1413 Vallejo Drive
San Jose, CA 95130
Darline Lohman
1114 Virgil Place
San Jose, CA 95120
Katherine Jen
19431 San Marcos Road
Saratoga, CA 95070
Ron and Rhondda Leckie
18779 Kosich Drive
Saratoga, CA 95070
F.T. Comstock
15730 Oak Knoll Drive
Los Gatos, CA 95030
Sally and Dave Baum
1484 Pollard Road
Los Gatos, CA 95032
Page 4 of 5
Silvia Malley
5453 Muir Drive
San Jose, CA 95124
Rennis Kauffman
109 Treseder Court
Los Gatos, CA 95032
Pascuala Huerta
103 Loma Vista Court
Los Gatos, CA 95032
Hugh Reynolds
1622 Montrose Way
San Jose, CA 95124
Laura P. Bence
P.O. Box 3697
Los Altos, CA 95024
Kathy J. Smith
David A. Craig
5085 Capistrano Avenue
San Jose, CA 95129
Fred Luk
18021 Rose Court
Monte Sereno, CA 95030
Donna
814 Century Drive
Campbell, CA 95008
Jessie Villicana
716 Harrison Street
San Jose, CA 95125
Larry Fabian
18660 Vista De Almaden
San Jose, CA 95120
Qianfan Xu, Xiaojia Hou,
and Lexi Xu
6021 Calle De Felice
San Jose, CA 95124
Edward M. Pacheco
1426 Mt. Stanley Way
San Jose, CA 95127
Neil Knott
17150 Scott Drive
Monte Sereno, CA 95030
Edith and Blair Gallant
661 Cambrian Drive
Campbell, CA 95008
Christine Brum
1807 Kirklyn Drive
San Jose, CA 95124
Dina Sargis
6564 Northridge Drive
San Jose, CA 95120
Aileen Gulesserian
111 Vallecitos Way
Los Gatos, CA 95032
Bobbie Morrison
2300 Shibley Avenue
San Jose, CA 95125
Steven and Pat Moore
18971 Easton Place
Saratoga, CA 95070
Leigh Haldeman
1730 Santa Lucia Drive
San Jose, CA 95125
Ronald Franken
5304 McKee Road
San Jose, CA 95127
Michael S. Blodgett
70 Decker Way
San Jose, CA 95127
Raymond and Carol Copeland
1202 Chateau Drive
San Jose, CA 95120
Suzanne Regul
4667 Mossbrook Circle
San Jose, CA 95130
Angela Giacalone
1569 Cherry Glen Way
San Jose, CA 95125
Suzette Bromagem
1735 Wickham Court
San Jose, CA 95132
Mickey Starr
5419 Starcrest Drive
San Jose, CA 95123
Wendy Watkins
984 Willow Glen Way
San Jose, CA 95125
Vanessa and Clay Fiske
1524 Monteval Place
San Jose, CA 95120
Stanford and Pamela Atwood
16125 Greenwood Lane
Monte Sereno, CA 95030
Norvelle Benevento
821 Plaza Drive
San Jose, CA 95125
Gary Wiesehahn
1576 Sheffield Avenue
San Jose, CA 95125
Susan Eiguren
2530 Calma Court
San Jose, CA 95128
Linda M. Haro
54 Birch Lane
San Jose, CA 95127
Brad and Michelle Foote
1090 Holmes Avenue
Campbell, CA 95008
Karen Clark
4313 Faraday Drive
San Jose, CA 95124
Robert Antone
1752 El Codo Way
San Jose, CA 95124
Ed Saxon
1484 Elsman Court
San Jose, CA 95120
Nick Lamberti
1656 Sweetbriar Drive
San Jose, CA 95125
Dean R. Kwarta
Kathleen Stenberg
1829 Kirkland Drive
San Jose, CA 95125
George and Barbara Callisch
2929 Kring Drive
San Jose, CA 95125
Sharon and Wayne Wood
4160 Golf Drive
San Jose, CA 95127
Nathan T. Ballard
1171 Utopia Place
San Jose, CA 95127
Anne Zingale
725 Pershing Avenue
San Jose, CA 95126
Page 5 of 5
Scott Levene
125 Dillon Avenue
Campbell, CA 95008
R.A. and W. Guardino
1479 De Tracey Street
San Jose, CA 95128
Steve McArthur
1837 Kirkland Avenue
San Jose, CA 95125
Bea Sines
641 Rebecca Way
San Jose, CA 95117
Mark Warneke
14544 Berry Way
San Jose, CA 95124
Shirley Kong
3476 Ramstad Drive
San Jose, CA 95127
Alma Baillif
5840 Recife Way
San Jose, CA 95120
Khanh Cao
110 Drysdale Drive
Los Gatos, CA 95032
Tom and Cassandra Owen
3859 Via Montalvo
Campbell, CA 95008
David Schulze
1009 Mount Carmel Drive
San Jose, CA 95120
Gurcan and Sumru Aral
1040 November Drive
Cupertino, CA 95014
Nicola McAllister
15612 Kavin Lane
Monte Sereno, CA 95030
Ingrid Oakley-Girvan
260 El Cajon Way
Los Gatos, CA 95032
Josh Palmer
877 Almarida
Campbell, CA 95008
Sergio Villaverde
637 Soni Court
San Jose, CA 95116
Brenda and Thomas Dohmen
7016 Wooded Lake Drive
San Jose, CA 95120
Barbara G. Bacile
1088 Fleetwood Drive
San Jose, CA 95120
Sylvia O. Ortiz
3474 Cherry Avenue
San Jose, CA 95118
Rudy Crespo
3482 Crespo Drive
San Jose, CA 95118
Constantinos Bassias
6140 Cecala Drive
San Jose, CA 95120
Christine Brum
1807 Kirklyn Drive
San Jose, CA 95124
Brenda and Larry Mehringer
18709 Westview Drive
Saratoga, CA 95070
Krishraveni Meka
19170 Monte Vista Drive
Saratoga, CA 95070
Alex and Cherie Wheeler
1665 Cottle Avenue
San Jose, CA 95110
Kay Fontana
2143 Coastland Avenue
San Jose, CA 95125
Judy H. Lomas
19405 Bainter Avenue
Los Gatos, CA 95030
Fred Runco
1444 Cerro Verde
San Jose, CA 95120
Eva Runco
1444 Cerro Verde
San Jose, CA 95120
James Dutkiewicz
1511 Willowdale Drive
San Jose, CA 95118
Aileen Gulesserian
111 Vallecitos Way
Los Gatos, CA 95032
Michele & Gordon van Zuiden
17573 Eaton Lane
Monte Sereno, CA 95030
Rita Benton
18555 Ravenwood Drive
Saratoga, CA 95070
Laurie Lew-McCrigler
2436 Homewood Drive
San Jose, CA 95128
Ronald Moser
1577 Inverness Circle
San Jose, CA 95124
Mr. & Mrs. Joseph Shank
20756 Scenic Vista Drive
San Jose, CA 95120
Janice Hirata
866 Lincoln Court
San Jose, CA 95125
Lainey and Bruce Richardson
14801 Golf Links Drive
Los Gatos, CA 95032
Laura and Scott Kupor
18211 Bancroft Avenue
Monte Sereno, CA 95030
Alex and Carol Hanuska
804 Kenneth Avenue
Campbell, CA 95008

More Related Content

Similar to Sjwc letter to water division 05 10-17

Final Order Amending The Lake Jesup Basin Management Action Plan
Final Order Amending The Lake Jesup Basin Management Action PlanFinal Order Amending The Lake Jesup Basin Management Action Plan
Final Order Amending The Lake Jesup Basin Management Action PlanVictoriaColangelo
 
Tuskawilla Wastewater Treatment Facility
Tuskawilla Wastewater Treatment FacilityTuskawilla Wastewater Treatment Facility
Tuskawilla Wastewater Treatment FacilityVictoriaColangelo
 
Lead Service Line Replacement and Notification Act102-0613.pdf
Lead Service Line Replacement and Notification Act102-0613.pdfLead Service Line Replacement and Notification Act102-0613.pdf
Lead Service Line Replacement and Notification Act102-0613.pdfMeghan Knudson
 
Senate COVID-19 spending bill and more
Senate COVID-19 spending bill and moreSenate COVID-19 spending bill and more
Senate COVID-19 spending bill and moreEducationNC
 
PA DEP Policy for the Replacement or Restoration of Private Water Supplies Im...
PA DEP Policy for the Replacement or Restoration of Private Water Supplies Im...PA DEP Policy for the Replacement or Restoration of Private Water Supplies Im...
PA DEP Policy for the Replacement or Restoration of Private Water Supplies Im...Marcellus Drilling News
 
96753
9675396753
96753mawhitt
 
Senate COVID-19 after chamber passage
Senate COVID-19 after chamber passageSenate COVID-19 after chamber passage
Senate COVID-19 after chamber passageEducationNC
 
Senate spending bill after appropriations committee
Senate spending bill after appropriations committeeSenate spending bill after appropriations committee
Senate spending bill after appropriations committeeEducationNC
 
PA House Bill 2277 - Requires $2M Bond to Drill a Shale Well
PA House Bill 2277 - Requires $2M Bond to Drill a Shale WellPA House Bill 2277 - Requires $2M Bond to Drill a Shale Well
PA House Bill 2277 - Requires $2M Bond to Drill a Shale WellMarcellus Drilling News
 
Item # 4 - Water Restrictions Amendment
Item # 4 - Water Restrictions AmendmentItem # 4 - Water Restrictions Amendment
Item # 4 - Water Restrictions Amendmentahcitycouncil
 

Similar to Sjwc letter to water division 05 10-17 (11)

Final Order Amending The Lake Jesup Basin Management Action Plan
Final Order Amending The Lake Jesup Basin Management Action PlanFinal Order Amending The Lake Jesup Basin Management Action Plan
Final Order Amending The Lake Jesup Basin Management Action Plan
 
Tuskawilla Wastewater Treatment Facility
Tuskawilla Wastewater Treatment FacilityTuskawilla Wastewater Treatment Facility
Tuskawilla Wastewater Treatment Facility
 
Lead Service Line Replacement and Notification Act102-0613.pdf
Lead Service Line Replacement and Notification Act102-0613.pdfLead Service Line Replacement and Notification Act102-0613.pdf
Lead Service Line Replacement and Notification Act102-0613.pdf
 
Senate COVID-19 spending bill and more
Senate COVID-19 spending bill and moreSenate COVID-19 spending bill and more
Senate COVID-19 spending bill and more
 
PA DEP Policy for the Replacement or Restoration of Private Water Supplies Im...
PA DEP Policy for the Replacement or Restoration of Private Water Supplies Im...PA DEP Policy for the Replacement or Restoration of Private Water Supplies Im...
PA DEP Policy for the Replacement or Restoration of Private Water Supplies Im...
 
96753
9675396753
96753
 
April 3, 2012 Agenda packet Part I
April 3, 2012 Agenda packet Part IApril 3, 2012 Agenda packet Part I
April 3, 2012 Agenda packet Part I
 
Senate COVID-19 after chamber passage
Senate COVID-19 after chamber passageSenate COVID-19 after chamber passage
Senate COVID-19 after chamber passage
 
Senate spending bill after appropriations committee
Senate spending bill after appropriations committeeSenate spending bill after appropriations committee
Senate spending bill after appropriations committee
 
PA House Bill 2277 - Requires $2M Bond to Drill a Shale Well
PA House Bill 2277 - Requires $2M Bond to Drill a Shale WellPA House Bill 2277 - Requires $2M Bond to Drill a Shale Well
PA House Bill 2277 - Requires $2M Bond to Drill a Shale Well
 
Item # 4 - Water Restrictions Amendment
Item # 4 - Water Restrictions AmendmentItem # 4 - Water Restrictions Amendment
Item # 4 - Water Restrictions Amendment
 

More from Rishi Kumar

Hindu Temple Terms & Conditions INSTRUCTORS.pdf
Hindu Temple Terms & Conditions INSTRUCTORS.pdfHindu Temple Terms & Conditions INSTRUCTORS.pdf
Hindu Temple Terms & Conditions INSTRUCTORS.pdfRishi Kumar
 
Issues — anna eshoo for congress 2020
Issues — anna eshoo for congress 2020Issues — anna eshoo for congress 2020
Issues — anna eshoo for congress 2020Rishi Kumar
 
Saratoga's 12 14-21 Proposed development projects for housing element
Saratoga's 12 14-21 Proposed development projects for housing elementSaratoga's 12 14-21 Proposed development projects for housing element
Saratoga's 12 14-21 Proposed development projects for housing elementRishi Kumar
 
Encampment cleanup fact sheet final
Encampment cleanup fact sheet finalEncampment cleanup fact sheet final
Encampment cleanup fact sheet finalRishi Kumar
 
Filing an appeal for the RHNA numbers
Filing an appeal for the RHNA numbersFiling an appeal for the RHNA numbers
Filing an appeal for the RHNA numbersRishi Kumar
 
Quito Village summary letter b
Quito Village summary letter bQuito Village summary letter b
Quito Village summary letter bRishi Kumar
 
Additional revenue for Road Repair : 04 27-2021 agenda packet
Additional revenue for Road Repair : 04 27-2021 agenda packetAdditional revenue for Road Repair : 04 27-2021 agenda packet
Additional revenue for Road Repair : 04 27-2021 agenda packetRishi Kumar
 
California 2021 redistricting preview the cook political report
California  2021 redistricting preview   the cook political reportCalifornia  2021 redistricting preview   the cook political report
California 2021 redistricting preview the cook political reportRishi Kumar
 
Saratoga 2020 legislative_summary_1328179.1_
Saratoga 2020 legislative_summary_1328179.1_Saratoga 2020 legislative_summary_1328179.1_
Saratoga 2020 legislative_summary_1328179.1_Rishi Kumar
 
Senate housing package__building_opportunities_for_all___focus
Senate housing package__building_opportunities_for_all___focusSenate housing package__building_opportunities_for_all___focus
Senate housing package__building_opportunities_for_all___focusRishi Kumar
 
Housing legislation
Housing legislationHousing legislation
Housing legislationRishi Kumar
 
2021 01 25_retreat_staff_report_-_housing_element_update_dp
2021 01 25_retreat_staff_report_-_housing_element_update_dp2021 01 25_retreat_staff_report_-_housing_element_update_dp
2021 01 25_retreat_staff_report_-_housing_element_update_dpRishi Kumar
 
Housing element presentation
Housing element presentationHousing element presentation
Housing element presentationRishi Kumar
 
New Flightpath affecting Santa Cruz (and Santa Clara county)
New Flightpath affecting Santa Cruz (and Santa Clara county) New Flightpath affecting Santa Cruz (and Santa Clara county)
New Flightpath affecting Santa Cruz (and Santa Clara county) Rishi Kumar
 
2020 05-20. resignation letter Lucas M. Pastuszka .saratoga planning commissi...
2020 05-20. resignation letter Lucas M. Pastuszka .saratoga planning commissi...2020 05-20. resignation letter Lucas M. Pastuszka .saratoga planning commissi...
2020 05-20. resignation letter Lucas M. Pastuszka .saratoga planning commissi...Rishi Kumar
 
Rishi kumar for Congress 2020. Who is Rishi and context to Rishi's run for Un...
Rishi kumar for Congress 2020. Who is Rishi and context to Rishi's run for Un...Rishi kumar for Congress 2020. Who is Rishi and context to Rishi's run for Un...
Rishi kumar for Congress 2020. Who is Rishi and context to Rishi's run for Un...Rishi Kumar
 
Precinct walking neighborhood team model guide
Precinct walking neighborhood team model guidePrecinct walking neighborhood team model guide
Precinct walking neighborhood team model guideRishi Kumar
 
San jose water company AL 532 - suspension notice
San jose water company   AL 532 - suspension noticeSan jose water company   AL 532 - suspension notice
San jose water company AL 532 - suspension noticeRishi Kumar
 
Councilmember rishi kumar saratoga christmas newsletter 2018 google docs
Councilmember rishi kumar saratoga christmas newsletter 2018   google docsCouncilmember rishi kumar saratoga christmas newsletter 2018   google docs
Councilmember rishi kumar saratoga christmas newsletter 2018 google docsRishi Kumar
 
Councilmember rishi kumar saratoga sept oct newsletter 2018 google docs
Councilmember rishi kumar saratoga sept oct newsletter 2018   google docsCouncilmember rishi kumar saratoga sept oct newsletter 2018   google docs
Councilmember rishi kumar saratoga sept oct newsletter 2018 google docsRishi Kumar
 

More from Rishi Kumar (20)

Hindu Temple Terms & Conditions INSTRUCTORS.pdf
Hindu Temple Terms & Conditions INSTRUCTORS.pdfHindu Temple Terms & Conditions INSTRUCTORS.pdf
Hindu Temple Terms & Conditions INSTRUCTORS.pdf
 
Issues — anna eshoo for congress 2020
Issues — anna eshoo for congress 2020Issues — anna eshoo for congress 2020
Issues — anna eshoo for congress 2020
 
Saratoga's 12 14-21 Proposed development projects for housing element
Saratoga's 12 14-21 Proposed development projects for housing elementSaratoga's 12 14-21 Proposed development projects for housing element
Saratoga's 12 14-21 Proposed development projects for housing element
 
Encampment cleanup fact sheet final
Encampment cleanup fact sheet finalEncampment cleanup fact sheet final
Encampment cleanup fact sheet final
 
Filing an appeal for the RHNA numbers
Filing an appeal for the RHNA numbersFiling an appeal for the RHNA numbers
Filing an appeal for the RHNA numbers
 
Quito Village summary letter b
Quito Village summary letter bQuito Village summary letter b
Quito Village summary letter b
 
Additional revenue for Road Repair : 04 27-2021 agenda packet
Additional revenue for Road Repair : 04 27-2021 agenda packetAdditional revenue for Road Repair : 04 27-2021 agenda packet
Additional revenue for Road Repair : 04 27-2021 agenda packet
 
California 2021 redistricting preview the cook political report
California  2021 redistricting preview   the cook political reportCalifornia  2021 redistricting preview   the cook political report
California 2021 redistricting preview the cook political report
 
Saratoga 2020 legislative_summary_1328179.1_
Saratoga 2020 legislative_summary_1328179.1_Saratoga 2020 legislative_summary_1328179.1_
Saratoga 2020 legislative_summary_1328179.1_
 
Senate housing package__building_opportunities_for_all___focus
Senate housing package__building_opportunities_for_all___focusSenate housing package__building_opportunities_for_all___focus
Senate housing package__building_opportunities_for_all___focus
 
Housing legislation
Housing legislationHousing legislation
Housing legislation
 
2021 01 25_retreat_staff_report_-_housing_element_update_dp
2021 01 25_retreat_staff_report_-_housing_element_update_dp2021 01 25_retreat_staff_report_-_housing_element_update_dp
2021 01 25_retreat_staff_report_-_housing_element_update_dp
 
Housing element presentation
Housing element presentationHousing element presentation
Housing element presentation
 
New Flightpath affecting Santa Cruz (and Santa Clara county)
New Flightpath affecting Santa Cruz (and Santa Clara county) New Flightpath affecting Santa Cruz (and Santa Clara county)
New Flightpath affecting Santa Cruz (and Santa Clara county)
 
2020 05-20. resignation letter Lucas M. Pastuszka .saratoga planning commissi...
2020 05-20. resignation letter Lucas M. Pastuszka .saratoga planning commissi...2020 05-20. resignation letter Lucas M. Pastuszka .saratoga planning commissi...
2020 05-20. resignation letter Lucas M. Pastuszka .saratoga planning commissi...
 
Rishi kumar for Congress 2020. Who is Rishi and context to Rishi's run for Un...
Rishi kumar for Congress 2020. Who is Rishi and context to Rishi's run for Un...Rishi kumar for Congress 2020. Who is Rishi and context to Rishi's run for Un...
Rishi kumar for Congress 2020. Who is Rishi and context to Rishi's run for Un...
 
Precinct walking neighborhood team model guide
Precinct walking neighborhood team model guidePrecinct walking neighborhood team model guide
Precinct walking neighborhood team model guide
 
San jose water company AL 532 - suspension notice
San jose water company   AL 532 - suspension noticeSan jose water company   AL 532 - suspension notice
San jose water company AL 532 - suspension notice
 
Councilmember rishi kumar saratoga christmas newsletter 2018 google docs
Councilmember rishi kumar saratoga christmas newsletter 2018   google docsCouncilmember rishi kumar saratoga christmas newsletter 2018   google docs
Councilmember rishi kumar saratoga christmas newsletter 2018 google docs
 
Councilmember rishi kumar saratoga sept oct newsletter 2018 google docs
Councilmember rishi kumar saratoga sept oct newsletter 2018   google docsCouncilmember rishi kumar saratoga sept oct newsletter 2018   google docs
Councilmember rishi kumar saratoga sept oct newsletter 2018 google docs
 

Recently uploaded

(TARA) Call Girls Chakan ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(TARA) Call Girls Chakan ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(TARA) Call Girls Chakan ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(TARA) Call Girls Chakan ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Serviceranjana rawat
 
Greater Noida Call Girls 9711199012 WhatsApp No 24x7 Vip Escorts in Greater N...
Greater Noida Call Girls 9711199012 WhatsApp No 24x7 Vip Escorts in Greater N...Greater Noida Call Girls 9711199012 WhatsApp No 24x7 Vip Escorts in Greater N...
Greater Noida Call Girls 9711199012 WhatsApp No 24x7 Vip Escorts in Greater N...ankitnayak356677
 
Precarious profits? Why firms use insecure contracts, and what would change t...
Precarious profits? Why firms use insecure contracts, and what would change t...Precarious profits? Why firms use insecure contracts, and what would change t...
Precarious profits? Why firms use insecure contracts, and what would change t...ResolutionFoundation
 
VIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Ishita 💚😋 9256729539 🚀 Indore Escorts
VIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Ishita 💚😋  9256729539 🚀 Indore EscortsVIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Ishita 💚😋  9256729539 🚀 Indore Escorts
VIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Ishita 💚😋 9256729539 🚀 Indore Escortsaditipandeya
 
##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas Whats Up Number
##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas  Whats Up Number##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas  Whats Up Number
##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas Whats Up NumberMs Riya
 
Fair Trash Reduction - West Hartford, CT
Fair Trash Reduction - West Hartford, CTFair Trash Reduction - West Hartford, CT
Fair Trash Reduction - West Hartford, CTaccounts329278
 
(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Serviceranjana rawat
 
(SHINA) Call Girls Khed ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(SHINA) Call Girls Khed ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(SHINA) Call Girls Khed ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(SHINA) Call Girls Khed ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Serviceranjana rawat
 
VIP High Profile Call Girls Gorakhpur Aarushi 8250192130 Independent Escort S...
VIP High Profile Call Girls Gorakhpur Aarushi 8250192130 Independent Escort S...VIP High Profile Call Girls Gorakhpur Aarushi 8250192130 Independent Escort S...
VIP High Profile Call Girls Gorakhpur Aarushi 8250192130 Independent Escort S...Suhani Kapoor
 
2024 Zoom Reinstein Legacy Asbestos Webinar
2024 Zoom Reinstein Legacy Asbestos Webinar2024 Zoom Reinstein Legacy Asbestos Webinar
2024 Zoom Reinstein Legacy Asbestos WebinarLinda Reinstein
 
(NEHA) Bhosari Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts
(NEHA) Bhosari Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts(NEHA) Bhosari Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts
(NEHA) Bhosari Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escortsranjana rawat
 
(ANIKA) Call Girls Wadki ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(ANIKA) Call Girls Wadki ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(ANIKA) Call Girls Wadki ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(ANIKA) Call Girls Wadki ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Serviceranjana rawat
 
VIP High Class Call Girls Amravati Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...
VIP High Class Call Girls Amravati Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...VIP High Class Call Girls Amravati Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...
VIP High Class Call Girls Amravati Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...Suhani Kapoor
 
DNV publication: China Energy Transition Outlook 2024
DNV publication: China Energy Transition Outlook 2024DNV publication: China Energy Transition Outlook 2024
DNV publication: China Energy Transition Outlook 2024Energy for One World
 
Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...
Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...
Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...anilsa9823
 
WIPO magazine issue -1 - 2024 World Intellectual Property organization.
WIPO magazine issue -1 - 2024 World Intellectual Property organization.WIPO magazine issue -1 - 2024 World Intellectual Property organization.
WIPO magazine issue -1 - 2024 World Intellectual Property organization.Christina Parmionova
 
How the Congressional Budget Office Assists Lawmakers
How the Congressional Budget Office Assists LawmakersHow the Congressional Budget Office Assists Lawmakers
How the Congressional Budget Office Assists LawmakersCongressional Budget Office
 
VIP Call Girls Pune Vani 8617697112 Independent Escort Service Pune
VIP Call Girls Pune Vani 8617697112 Independent Escort Service PuneVIP Call Girls Pune Vani 8617697112 Independent Escort Service Pune
VIP Call Girls Pune Vani 8617697112 Independent Escort Service PuneCall girls in Ahmedabad High profile
 
(VASUDHA) Call Girls Balaji Nagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(VASUDHA) Call Girls Balaji Nagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(VASUDHA) Call Girls Balaji Nagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(VASUDHA) Call Girls Balaji Nagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Serviceranjana rawat
 

Recently uploaded (20)

(TARA) Call Girls Chakan ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(TARA) Call Girls Chakan ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(TARA) Call Girls Chakan ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(TARA) Call Girls Chakan ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
 
Greater Noida Call Girls 9711199012 WhatsApp No 24x7 Vip Escorts in Greater N...
Greater Noida Call Girls 9711199012 WhatsApp No 24x7 Vip Escorts in Greater N...Greater Noida Call Girls 9711199012 WhatsApp No 24x7 Vip Escorts in Greater N...
Greater Noida Call Girls 9711199012 WhatsApp No 24x7 Vip Escorts in Greater N...
 
Precarious profits? Why firms use insecure contracts, and what would change t...
Precarious profits? Why firms use insecure contracts, and what would change t...Precarious profits? Why firms use insecure contracts, and what would change t...
Precarious profits? Why firms use insecure contracts, and what would change t...
 
VIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Ishita 💚😋 9256729539 🚀 Indore Escorts
VIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Ishita 💚😋  9256729539 🚀 Indore EscortsVIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Ishita 💚😋  9256729539 🚀 Indore Escorts
VIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Ishita 💚😋 9256729539 🚀 Indore Escorts
 
##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas Whats Up Number
##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas  Whats Up Number##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas  Whats Up Number
##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas Whats Up Number
 
Fair Trash Reduction - West Hartford, CT
Fair Trash Reduction - West Hartford, CTFair Trash Reduction - West Hartford, CT
Fair Trash Reduction - West Hartford, CT
 
(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
 
(SHINA) Call Girls Khed ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(SHINA) Call Girls Khed ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(SHINA) Call Girls Khed ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(SHINA) Call Girls Khed ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
 
VIP High Profile Call Girls Gorakhpur Aarushi 8250192130 Independent Escort S...
VIP High Profile Call Girls Gorakhpur Aarushi 8250192130 Independent Escort S...VIP High Profile Call Girls Gorakhpur Aarushi 8250192130 Independent Escort S...
VIP High Profile Call Girls Gorakhpur Aarushi 8250192130 Independent Escort S...
 
2024 Zoom Reinstein Legacy Asbestos Webinar
2024 Zoom Reinstein Legacy Asbestos Webinar2024 Zoom Reinstein Legacy Asbestos Webinar
2024 Zoom Reinstein Legacy Asbestos Webinar
 
(NEHA) Bhosari Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts
(NEHA) Bhosari Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts(NEHA) Bhosari Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts
(NEHA) Bhosari Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts
 
(ANIKA) Call Girls Wadki ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(ANIKA) Call Girls Wadki ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(ANIKA) Call Girls Wadki ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(ANIKA) Call Girls Wadki ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
 
VIP High Class Call Girls Amravati Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...
VIP High Class Call Girls Amravati Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...VIP High Class Call Girls Amravati Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...
VIP High Class Call Girls Amravati Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...
 
Delhi Russian Call Girls In Connaught Place ➡️9999965857 India's Finest Model...
Delhi Russian Call Girls In Connaught Place ➡️9999965857 India's Finest Model...Delhi Russian Call Girls In Connaught Place ➡️9999965857 India's Finest Model...
Delhi Russian Call Girls In Connaught Place ➡️9999965857 India's Finest Model...
 
DNV publication: China Energy Transition Outlook 2024
DNV publication: China Energy Transition Outlook 2024DNV publication: China Energy Transition Outlook 2024
DNV publication: China Energy Transition Outlook 2024
 
Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...
Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...
Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...
 
WIPO magazine issue -1 - 2024 World Intellectual Property organization.
WIPO magazine issue -1 - 2024 World Intellectual Property organization.WIPO magazine issue -1 - 2024 World Intellectual Property organization.
WIPO magazine issue -1 - 2024 World Intellectual Property organization.
 
How the Congressional Budget Office Assists Lawmakers
How the Congressional Budget Office Assists LawmakersHow the Congressional Budget Office Assists Lawmakers
How the Congressional Budget Office Assists Lawmakers
 
VIP Call Girls Pune Vani 8617697112 Independent Escort Service Pune
VIP Call Girls Pune Vani 8617697112 Independent Escort Service PuneVIP Call Girls Pune Vani 8617697112 Independent Escort Service Pune
VIP Call Girls Pune Vani 8617697112 Independent Escort Service Pune
 
(VASUDHA) Call Girls Balaji Nagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(VASUDHA) Call Girls Balaji Nagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(VASUDHA) Call Girls Balaji Nagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(VASUDHA) Call Girls Balaji Nagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
 

Sjwc letter to water division 05 10-17

  • 1. 50 California Street 34th Floor San Francisco, CA 94111 T 415.398.3600 F 415.398.2438 Martin A. Mattes D 415.438.7273 mmattes@nossaman.com Refer To File #: 190640-0005 56053276.v2 May 10, 2017 Raminder S. Kahlon, Director Water Division California Public Utilities Commission 505 Van Ness Avenue San Francisco, CA 94102 Re: Request of San Jose Water Company for Commission Review of Water Division’s Rejection of Its Advice Letter No. 501 Dear Mr. Kahlon: San Jose Water Company (“SJWC”) filed its Advice Letter No. (“AL”) 501 on January 9, 2017, as a Tier 2 advice letter requesting authorization, pursuant to the Commission’s Decision (“D.”) 16-12-026, Ordering Paragraph 3, to implement a Sales Reconciliation Mechanism (“SRM”) to conform water forecasts authorized in its last General Rate Case (“GRC”) to recorded consumption for the period October 2015 through September 2016. AL 501 requested that the submitted rate changes become effective March 15, 2017. Water Division suspended AL 501 prior to its effective date, stating that the AL was not in compliance with a Commission decision but also that “D.16-12-026 has to be modified.” On April 6, 2017, the Commission adopted D.17-04-002, correcting errors in D.16-12-026. The Commission noted in D.17-04-002 that Water Division’s review of AL 501 had identified an error in D.16-12-026’s description of the SRM by the use of the word “revenue” rather than “sales,” and so the April decision replaced references to “revenues” in the context of the SRM with references to “sales” at several points in the text and also in Ordering Paragraph 3. By your letter of May 3, 2017, Water Division now rejects AL 501, based on a reading of D.16-12-026 as “specifically requir[ing] that there exist a declared drought.” A. SJWC Requests Commission Review of Water Division’s Rejection of AL 501. By this letter, submitted in accordance with Section 7.7.1 of General Order No. (“GO”) 96-B, SJWC respectfully requests Commission review of Water Division’s disposition of AL 501. In the paragraphs below, SJWC sets forth the specific grounds on which SJWC contends that Water Division’s action is unlawful and erroneous. Those grounds may be summarized as follows: VIA ELECTRONIC MAIL & U.S. MAIL
  • 2. Raminder S. Kahlon, Director May 10, 2017 Page 2 56053276.v2  Water Division engaged in an unlawful discretionary review of AL 501. To provide such a review, Water Division should have prepared a resolution for the Commission’s consideration.  Water Division fails to apply the clear wording of D.16-12-026, Ordering Paragraph 3, which unambiguously authorizes SJWC to request an SRM by Tier 2 advice letter under the circumstances on which SJWC’s request was based.  Water Division erroneously relies on the text of D.16-12-026, which is completely consistent with Ordering Paragraph 3, to reach a conclusion inconsistent with the clear wording of that ordering paragraph.  Water Division fails to consider the Commission’s policy discussion in D.16-12-026, which supports authorization of an SRM to mitigate a mismatch between authorized and actual sales during a drought year regardless of whether the drought has ended.  Water Division fails to consider the various state policies and initiatives intended to make water conservation a California way of life, or the complementary local conservation requirements, which can be expected to prolong the mismatch between SJWC’s authorized and actual sales absent allowance of an SRM. B. AL 501 Anticipated the Corrected Requirements of D.16-12-026. In drafting AL 501, SJWC anticipated the correction to D.16-12-026 that the Commission made by D.17-04-002. Thus, AL 501 compared the sales forecast of 49,861 Kccf1 authorized in its most recent GRC decision, D.16-06-004, with SJWC’s total actual sales of 40,173 Kccf during the 12-month period of October 1, 2015 through September 30, 2016, noting that this total divergence of 19.4% exceeded the five percent trigger authorized in D.16-06-004. Per the authorized SRM, SJWC recalculated rates to account for 50% of the divergence between authorized and actual sales, resulting in increased quantity rates and a 3.65% increase in the typical residential customer bill. Water Division found no fault with any aspect of AL 501 except the alleged dependence of Ordering Paragraph 3 of D.16-12-026 on the existence of a “declared drought.” As noted above, Water Division’s reading of D.16-12-026 and especially of Ordering Paragraph 3 is incorrect. This letter will explain why. 1 “Kccf” stands for one thousand one-hundred cubic feet.
  • 3. Raminder S. Kahlon, Director May 10, 2017 Page 3 56053276.v2 C. AL 501 Meets the Requirements of Ordering Paragraph 3 but Water Division Invents an Additional Requirement to Deny the Requested SRM. Ordering Paragraph 3 of D.16-12-026, as corrected by D.17-04-002, reads as follows: Class A and B Water Investor-Owned Utilities that have a five percent or greater divergence (higher or lower) between authorized and actual sales during a drought period in their current General Rate Case cycle, shall consider filing for an individual district or several districts a Tier 2 Advice Letter requesting a Sales Reconciliation Mechanism to conform water forecasts authorized in the current General Rate Case to actual consumption, in light of the drought and circumstances faced in their district(s). Based on the clear wording of Ordering Paragraph 3, SJWC was authorized to file AL 501. SJWC, a Class A water utility, had a divergence greater than five percent (actually 19.4%) between authorized and actual sales during the 12-month period from October 2015 through September 2016.2 That 12-month period occurred during the Drought State of Emergency declared by Governor Brown on January 17, 2014, which was subsequently terminated for all except four counties in the state by the Governor’s Executive Order B-40- 17, issued April 7, 2017. Accordingly, SJWC properly filed AL 501 as a Tier 2 advice letter to implement an SRM “in light of the drought and circumstances faced in [its district].” Despite identifying no ambiguity in Ordering Paragraph 3, Water Division finds that it must “interpret” the ordering paragraph by consulting the text of D.16-12-026. Water Division discovers that page 6 of the decision authorizes an SRM advice letter to be filed only “during a drought period.” That is the same phrase used in Ordering Paragraph 3, so it does not help to “interpret” it. Water Division then refers to page 33 of the decision, which states that an SRM filing may be made “during declared drought years” – which seems entirely consistent with the “during a drought period” reference and leads Water Division to conclude that “there must exist a drought in order to make an SRM advice letter filing.” And so there was when SJWC filed the SRM request on January 9, 2017 – the very same drought that Governor Brown declared in 2014 and did not declare terminated (in 48 of 52 counties) until April 7, 2017. Having exhausted its references to the text of D.16-12-026, Water Division goes on to state the obvious – that the drought was declared over before AL 501 was, belatedly, acted upon. Noting that Santa Clara Valley Water District continues to call for 20% water conservation (which Water Division inaccurately describes as “voluntary”), Water Division dismisses this “call for conservation” as not relevant to the “intent or plain language of D.16- 12-026 requiring “that there exist a declared drought.” Water Division then notes that SJWC has requested authority to suspend the drought allocations and surcharges in its Schedule 14.1 (but not the Schedule itself) and on that basis concludes that “SJWC neither has the drought conditions, nor the need to implement drought allocations that would require an SRM adjustment for 2017.” 2 As SJWC explained in AL 501, rate changes due to triggering an SRM are typically made concurrently with escalation rate increases, so usage for the prior 12-month period through September is applied to determine divergence from authorized sales.
  • 4. Raminder S. Kahlon, Director May 10, 2017 Page 4 56053276.v2 D. Water Division’s Rejection of AL 501 Based on a Convoluted Interpretation of D.16-12-026 Amounts to an Improper Discretionary Review. Water Division’s conclusion that an SRM cannot be required absent drought conditions and drought allocations, and the consequent rejection of AL 501, are based on misinterpretation of D.16-12-026 and an incomplete and inaccurate understanding of the relevant facts. SJWC will correct these errors in the paragraphs that follow, but first must state emphatically that Water Division has no authority or discretion to reject a Tier 2 advice letter based on the sort of analysis your letter presents. Water Division is authorized to reject a Tier 2 advice letter only when such action is ministerial in nature.3 Whenever a more discretionary determination is required, the appropriate procedure is for Water Division to prepare and place on the Commission’s meeting agenda a resolution approving, rejecting, or modifying the advice letter as submitted – giving affected parties opportunity to comment on the proposed disposition in advance.4 Water Division’s rejection of AL 401 based on a convoluted interpretation of the plain language of D.16-12-026, Ordering Paragraph 3, is certainly more than a ministerial act. Water Division should have prepared a resolution to permit the Commission to interpret, for itself, whether use of the SRM mechanism, which it had so recently authorized should now, suddenly, be forbidden. E. Not Only the Express Terms of Ordering Paragraph 3 but Also the Relevant Policy Discussion in D.16-12-026 Justify Approving SJWC’s Request for an SRM. SJWC was justified in filing AL 501 to establish an SRM not only by the express terms of D.16-12-026, Ordering Paragraph 3, but also by the policy considerations on which that ordering paragraph was based. Despite the subsequent official end to the drought, those policy considerations continue to justify approving AL 501 and allowing SJWC to implement an SRM. D.16-12-026 prominently recognized not only the Governor’s declaration of a Drought State of Emergency in 2014 but also his then most recent Executive Order B-37-16, issued May 9, 2016, which aimed “to make conservation a way of life in California,” and went on to describe the actions of the Commission and also the State Water Resources Control Board (“Water Board”) intending to “build on the 25 percent water reduction levels imposed by previous Executive Orders, and reflect lessons learned during the drought.”5 D.16-12-016 also prominently featured the Commission’s concern about inaccurate sales forecasts, emphasizing that “[i]naccurate forecasts provide the air that balloons the WRAM and surcharges,” and providing for utilities to request SRMs “to conform water forecasts authorized in the GRC to actual consumption in light of the circumstances faced in their districts.”6 3 See, GO 96-B, §7.6.1. 4 Id., §7.6.2; see also, Rule 14.5 of the Commission’s Rules of Practice and Procedure. 5 D.16-12-026, at 4-5. 6 Id. at 6.
  • 5. Raminder S. Kahlon, Director May 10, 2017 Page 5 56053276.v2 Looking beyond these summary declarations to the details of D.16-12-026’s analysis, we find confirmation that this “Decision Providing Guidance” was intended to set a path forward not just for the duration of the current drought but for the longer-term future. The Decision’s discussion of “Forecasting and SRM” recognized that traditional forecasting methods did not adequately capture either recent drought conservation effects or expected changes in water consumption resulting from the Governor’s Executive Orders and the Commission’s actions. The Decision especially noted the Governor’s direction to the Department of Water Resources (“DWR”) to develop new water use targets as part of a permanent framework for water agencies, and “the steps that many California water agencies are taking to promote and mandate conservation.”7 Noting concern about “mismatches” between authorized revenue and actual sales, the Decision saw need for action “to better align” forecasted and recorded sales.” That action was to order water utilities with a five percent or greater divergence between authorized and actual revenue (later corrected to refer to “sales”) during declared drought years in their current GRC cycle to consider filing for an SRM, which would recalculate rates “through the remainder of the GRC cycle.”8 Conclusion of Law 3 summarized the Commission’s reasoning: 3. Authorizing Class A and B utilities to consider filing a Tier 2 Advice letter to implement a drought SRM is consistent with this Commission’s resolution to promote conservation, our policies to communicate transparent cost-signals to ratepayers, and Pub. Util. Code §701.10.9 In summary, D.16-12-026 did not envision the SRM solely as a response to the drought. First and foremost, the Commission saw the SRM as a means of addressing the mismatch between authorized revenue and sales that resulted from inaccurate sales forecasts in the context of continuing success in water conservation. Those policy considerations justified SJWC’s filing of AL 501 to establish an SRM and they continue to justify approving AL 501 today, whether or not the drought continues. Given the Commission’s evident interest in the SRM as a means of addressing “mismatches between authorized revenue and sales,” continuation of the drought is not necessary to justify implementing an SRM, where the mandated five percent “divergence” already has occurred. F. Many Factors of Statewide and Local Policy and Practice Support an Expectation of a Continuing Mismatch Between SJWC’s Adopted and Actual Sales. In SJWC’s case, the “mismatch between authorized revenue and sales” was not just five percent, but 19.4% in the drought year on which AL 501’s SRM request was based. Absent the requested SRM, that 19.4% “mismatch” may increase or decrease through the last two years of SJWC’s current GRC cycle, but it certainly will not disappear. Several 7 Id. at 28-30. 8 Id. at 33-34. 9 Id. at 83.
  • 6. Raminder S. Kahlon, Director May 10, 2017 Page 6 56053276.v2 relevant factors suggest that SJWC’s sales will remain substantially below the level forecast in its most recent GRC:  Governor Brown’s most recent Executive Order B-40-17, while rescinding his 2014 Drought Proclamation, also ordered that “the orders and provisions of Executive Order B-37-16, Making Water Conservation a California Way of Life, remain in full force and effect except as modified by this Executive Order.”  Executive Order B-40-17 expressly directed the Water Board to “continue development of permanent prohibitions on wasteful water use and requirements for reporting water use by urban water agencies.”  Executive Order B-40-17 also directed DWR to continue work with the Water Board to develop standard for urban water suppliers to use in setting new urban water use efficiency targets and to direct actions to minimize water system leaks that waste large amounts of water.  On April 7, 2017, the same day the Governor rescinded his Drought Proclamation, th Commission, DWR, the Water Board, and two other California executive agencies issued their final report, Making Water Conservation a California Way of Life, implementing Executive Order B-37-16, providing an array of “recommendations for how to implement long-term improvements to water supply management that support water conservation.”  Santa Clara Valley Water District has maintained its call for a water use reduction target equal to 20% of 2013 water use, for restriction of outdoor watering of ornamental landscapes or lawns with potable water, and for local enforcement of the Water Board’s prohibitions of wasteful water use.10 Contrary to Water Division’s assertion, the District has not described these restrictions as “voluntary.”  SJWC’s Rule 14.1 and Schedule 14.1, providing for water shortage contingency plans, remain in effect. Rule 14.1 continues to prohibit wasteful water use practices. As Water Division notes, SJWC filed its AL 505 in January 2017 to suspend Schedule 14.1’s drought allocations and drought surcharges, but Schedule 14.1 and all of the water use restrictions defined therein remain in effect. Based on all these factors, it would be inconsistent and unwise for the Commission now to disown and abandon the procedure that it so recently adopted in D.16-12-026 for allowing utilities that have experienced a significant mismatch between authorized and actual sales during a drought year, based on their most recent GRC decisions, to implement an SRM that will ameliorate that mismatch and help to achieve more appropriate price signals to customers. Official termination of the drought does not justify reversing that policy, since such a reversal would run counter to local and state conservation objectives. 10 See, Santa Clara Valley Water District Resolution No. 17-08, adopted January 31, 2017.
  • 7. Raminder S. Kahlon, Director May 10, 2017 Page 7 56053276.v2 G. Conclusion D.16-12-026, as corrected by D.17-04-002, included as a condition for requesting an SRM that a water utility have a divergence of five percent or more between authorized and actual sales “during a drought period” in its current GRC cycle. As discussed above, SJWC met that condition during the relevant 12-month period and also when it filed AL 501. None of Water Division’s “interpretations” of Ordering Paragraph 3 justify transforming that condition into a requirement that the drought continue into the “remainder of the GRC cycle” when the SRM would be in effect. To the contrary, the policies the Commission articulated in D.16-12-026 as its reasons for authorizing the SRM argue strongly against imposing such an added requirement. For all the reasons stated in this letter, SJWC respectfully urges the Commission, upon review, to reverse Water Division’s rejection of AL 501 and, instead, to approve the advice letter as proposed. Respectfully submitted, Martin A. Mattes of Nossaman LLP Attorneys for SAN JOSE WATER COMPANY MAM:mt cc: Protesting Parties (see attached Service List)
  • 8. Page 1 of 5 SERVICE LIST BY ELECTRONIC MAIL rosemary.c.adamson@gmail.com; juliaschan@comcast.net; schatterj@hotmail.com; seawolve44@yahoo.com; shazzashops@yahoo.com; dhkalmus@gmail.com; lweelee@hotmail.com; jlindsay_us@yahoo.com; vikrammodak@gmail.com; moriarty95070@gmail.com; samroza@gmail.com; jshank@theshanks.net; keith_wald@yahoo.com; qulizhou@gmail.com; j-segall@sbcglobal.net; mg_1146@att.net; pewskinner@yahoo.com; miketutor@comcast.net; mgong1@gmail.com; silvana.panunzio@gmail.com; vnayak_us@yahoo.com; camconv68@sbcglobal.net; 1250man@gmail.com; djayramasubban@yahoo.com; jvelas@comcast.net; this.coly@gmail.com; shellieg1@gmail.com; oskinghuang@gmail.com; elizabeth.g.doros@gmail.com; b4massey@yahoo.com; eriktakaoka@gmail.com; sl951@yahoo.com; amalia.gomez6@gmail.com; vivekrashmi@hotmail.com; meddevicepro@gmail.com; bsmith1231@yahoo.com; gschoet@sbcglobal.net; sujatar27@yahoo.com; wesfergy@cyberdude.com; bobrayl@icloud.com; gtacn@yahoo.com; theponcianos@gmail.com; ldalbert@comcast.net; lauraventura66@yahoo.com; heng742@live.com; ltaillie@yahoo.com; yqsony@gmail.com; chtliang@yahoo.com; heidari.amir@gmail.com; hamdjm63@gmail.com; charlieg@sjtoolstore.com; phillipslaura84@gmail.com; levashov_yurii@hotmail.com; chuckbrassfield@yahoo.com; focused-one@sbcglobal.net; john@marymonte.com; harold_horimoto@yahoo.com; ackalloor@yahoo.com; ducao60@gmail.com; rchwong6@gmail.com; suekh@pacbell.net; digital@megainfo.com; cchamrah10@gmail.com; mikeo@sbcglobal.net; weavus135@yahoo.com; jeanlamarca@sbcglobal.net; austin.bock@intel.com; subraji@att.net; greglynn@gmail.com; svraley@gmail.com; steve.crimi@outlook.com; davidlai9988@gmail.com; mtndeb@earthlink.net; mpub@gizmology.com; mikeniday@hotmail.com; tf3328@gmail.com; jburkhart@sbcglobal.net; frank.seto@gmail.com; larrywangsj@gmail.com; domenico@embertec.com; fsamadani@comcast.net; jody@refugeesrock.com; angelicruiz@yahoo.com; crows@netzero.net; bencolombeau@gmail.com; rick.panian@gmail.com; Nayanatara.Rao@kp.org; jas5266@yahoo.com; jwpalmer@gmail.com; gfiremedic@comcast.net; msbhat@pacbell.net; a.v.goldberg@gmail.com; jwnielson@gmail.com; bonmueller@comcast.net; dshade14@att.net; txqchen@yahoo.com; lesliepeluso@yahoo.com; michele_c_lee@yahoo.com; kchen1@gmail.com; vicpaul@sbcglobal.net; chapsk@gmail.com; chip.maloney@comcast.net; hoser1@pacbell.net; domnjen@comcast.net; bill_bradley_ca@yahoo.com; ruchijoshi@yahoo.com; kibbish@gmail.com; tom.weldon@sbcglobal.net; dgingerelli@comcast.net; hauttdo@gmail.com; danielonn2002@yahoo.com; tkbk@mac.com; tammywan0315@yahoo.com; kthjand@yahoo.com; knrheidi@earthlink.net; J_F_Boyer@hotmail.com; normmargie@gmail.com; mishra_anurag@yahoo.com; lisa@aa2r.com; bobrayl@icloud.com; czabarte@yahoo.com; skdwoody0@gmail.com; joshuarichard02@gmail.com; ambidex11@yahoo.com; vipin.k.jain@gmail.com; michelledong8@yahoo.com; Danh_Van@symantec.com; christianmastrodonato1977@gmail.com; davidwclin@gmail.com; nommn@aol.com; cchatterj@hotmail.com; phuong.macleod@gmail.com; tmeskell@hotmail.com; mengqin@gmail.com; sscccharrell@yahoo.com; biagina2002@icloud.com; leshen@visa.com; rgellman@gmail.com; jooley8@aol.com; jay11west11@gmail.com; smb.cochran@gmail.com; dickb2@pacbell.net; dognelson95128@yahoo.com; 4anandgrover@gmail.com; karlebaat@gmail.com; neal.jack@gmail.com; azimpetro@yahoo.com; derrick.nguyen@gmail.com; nnguyenhuy@att.net; chuckvanderwege@gmail.com; bobtemm@gmail.com; U.GoGirl@hotmail.com; mail4steven@yahoo.com; pkampp@hotmail.com; wbus97@gmail.com; susanquillinan@gmail.com; mbhaska@hotmail.com; tseng2@gmail.com; sunderraj@ymail.com; rampitec@gmail.com; johnmaecondie@att.net; sfong6@yahoo.com; bonnasue@yahoo.com; teenyt@me.com; john.stankus@gmail.com; bobmd@aol.com; biglaurie@aol.com; danifel@gmail.com; ravis2@yahoo.com; gtom@live.com; fennywongso@gmail.com; vshwen@gmail.com; shyama777@gmail.com; sameerpradhan@gmail.com; timandkristine@sbcglobal.net; amalarasan@yahoo.com; boriram3081@gmail.com; ritesh.trivedi@gmail.com; rwaits1@icloud.com; rajwww@yahoo.com; mpejcic@yahoo.com; robinmagovern@icloud.com; linus.aranha@gmail.com; chiachialu@yahoo.com; russianvegan@yahoo.com; dmoessinger@comcast.net; jaimebatiz@yahoo.com; yiping@comcast.net; kiranmayi@rocketmail.com; yanzhang1998@hotmail.com; Elwyn_Cabebe@hotmail.com; ronghuazhang@gmail.com; vinnysj@pacbell.net; sorisho@gmail.com; debbiejdsy@yahoo.com; Nidhi.lalit@gmail.com; RLee@rlallp.com; DTDuffy@msn.com; avivgr@gmail.com; aidascott@msn.com; bronco60@comcast.net; wce@eister.com; jceyip@hotmail.com; kiascu2003@gmail.com; pigasus821@gmail.com; Robert.Masleid@comcast.net; cnkurzke@gmail.com; heather.palmer@ymail.com; tom.mcavoy@lmco.com; zhfzhh@yahoo.com; skygem@gmail.com; laurabright59@yahoo.com;
  • 9. Page 2 of 5 khiem.ho@gmail.com; jkmaniaci@verizon.net; faithtio@yahoo.com; scaplan42@gmail.com; krzyjny@aol.com; dnsargis@gmail.com; wjmeyer09@att.net; lloydo101@sbcglobal.net; jimgreer1071@gmail.com; captal44@aol.com; mohsen_tadjvar@yahoo.com; jjko888@hotmail.com; fl@quadbase.com; chadmitch00@gmail.com; chutani@gmail.com; smachado@yahoo.com; avneet007@gmail.com; pranab.dhar@gmail.com; vernalee2@yahoo.com; lukluck98@yahoo.com; celestemartino@yahoo.com; dfarrington311@gmail.com; jaswang2006@gmail.com; rich-sharon@att.net; sherburnes@sbcglobal.net; lan1truong@yahoo.com; tiffanysp@hotmail.com; lancesp@hotmail.com; peggykendall@comcast.net; sreimert@gmail.com; kuszikam@aim.com; PrettyPopcorn@aol.com; wei_wu_01@yahoo.com; martinspicer00@gmail.com; abrigantino@yahoo.com; cjon2008@gmail.com; tempnick@live.com; bmuniz@baca.org; denver@mediationmasters.com;jerrygao2011@gmail.com; taniajz@gmail.com; noorm937@yahoo.com; kmasini@me.com; Dean_Sakauye@msn.com; olipkind@gmail.com; qiawang@cisco.com; btuvey@ht-world.com; tesferd@gmail.com; smith.keyston@gmail.com; kzobeck@gmail.com; jincyn@gmail.com; wenhendry@comcast.net; dhg2@myway.com; danny28888@yahoo.com; panzica.linda@gmail.com; tae.kim@gmail.com; phlei@yahoo.com; good2bus29@yahoo.com; damoresix@comcast.net; c.conrad1@mindspring.com; bentjensen@yahoo.com; namansonal@gmail.com; Joe.Dutra@ti.com; tsticklinski@apm.com; agulesserian111@gmail.com; Gayle.Calkins@harker.org; jtakatsuji@shibatec.com; dean.p.giovannetti@nasa.gov; bien.luc@hotmail.com; lboyzo98@gmail.com; patwood@winterbourne.com; ted_bancroft@yahoo.com; jeankk@gmail.com; tdoan1991@gmail.com; doupola@aol.com; rongarcia@ymail.com; cadoganlm@gmail.com; idnanichandru@gmail.com; beckersze@yahoo.com; fraldrete@gmail.com; gene123@sbcglobal.net; athan2@sbcglobal.net; frany454@yahoo.com; markasikes@gmail.com; shyamvedantam21@gmail.com; voodooboy@gmail.com; Debgrizzle@comcast.net; beckyolmos@att.net; kedhermanla@yahoo.com; lmmagall@yahoo.com; praveen@gonugunta.com; nathanballard1171@outlook.com; llopez2196@aol.com; dcao62@yahoo.com; Matt.Winans@claconnect1.com; avinashpatro@gmail.com; graycd@comcast.net; p.murots@gmail.com; robertyager@comcast.net; powpowhughes@yahoo.com; josephjrodriguez@gmail.com; hrklaver@yahoo.com; vincestaub@yahoo.com; matthewalanstevenson@gmail.com; Laurie@rialtowest.com; abdulrasheed.a@gmail.com; xiaoxiny@hotmail.com; jackiefahrner@gmail.com; tonybayarea@icloud.com; kmassarat@gmail.com; beasines@pacbell.net; gfhuang@gmail.com; craig.stafford@nelsonirrigation.com; jackiefahrner@gmail.com; ca.fahrner@comcast.net; sergei_perfilov@yahoo.com; leevon49@yahoo.com; firatkart@gmail.com; martin1880@sbcglobal.net; luchen26@hotmail.com; SWCHIC@msn.com; jlc20@att.net; emma.bolich@gmail.com; ray@persico.us; asowda@gmail.com; ltng04@gmail.com; zypchenfeng@gmail.com; jamieb186@gmail.com; yapkke@gmail.com; zagers@gmail.com; Mare501@yahoo.com; brian@missionbenefits.com; gstuckert1@juno.com; Timeforme0214@outlook.com; caroleroth410@gmail.com; perob744@gmail.com; digby.pun@gmail.com; suzettem@wordsanddeeds.com; ctraeg@gmail.com; tim@PETTITT.US; wolfner89@gmail.com; awakenfive@gmail.com; pedybiagtan@yahoo.com; lynnemiz123@gmail.com; rloftusjr@yahoo.com; rwoolman58@gmail.com; ronnie.militante@gmail.com; jwponte@att.net; jeffreynaristide@comcast.net; doria.dy@bayvoice.net; kskandad@yahoo.com; equal3@att.net; bmattade@pacbell.net; alexandra.rae.frey@gmail.com; luke_reimer@sbcglobal.net; jpalmer@advanceddiscovery.com; merrywyj@gmail.com; lisali.lyj@gmail.com; oakleygirvan@gmail.com; hongbud@yahoo.com; junlu_email@yahoo.com; ganjiayan@gmail.com; luyihuan78@gmail.com; cuiyingsj@hotmail.com; rosapyun@gmail.com; feralwriter1@gmail.com; m1105chester@yahoo.com; jmg001@mindspring.com; rishida@pacbell.net; yournamehere@sonic.net; h_sarah_chen@yahoo.com; zypwxl@yahoo.com; alex@clemm.org; casa95129@yahoo.com; jerrykennedy0021@sbcglobal.net; adel.khouja@gmail.com; c_huang88@yahoo.com; samleelee3@gmail.com; alexwheeler@gmail.com; dianne.tuleybrown@gmail.com; hannahitbrown@gmail.com; scquinn@sonic.net; jmolaw@pacbell.net; gstuckert1@juno.com; eddiesweeney@icloud.com; agulesserian111@gmail.com; mgharding@sbcglobal.net; natalyman2002@yahoo.com; anniexh@gmail.com; tracycl2003@yahoo.com; williamblabon@comcast.net; liuwei_xd@hotmail.com; bubbibobbi@mymailstation.com; tleipelt@ymail.com; bladetheslayer@gmail.com; 1davidholland@gmail.com; suzjone@comcast.net; ALevy@hopkinscarley.com; cynndi.wang@gmail.com; atyrequest@gmail.com; bfs7351@gmail.com; stevenlpalmer@yahoo.com; olyubynska@gmail.com; jcbeatty21@gmail.com; poonamkravi@yahoo.com; kvrousseau@gmail.com; bretbeechie@sbcglobal.net; home_and_finance@yahoo.com; skygem@gmail.com; davidmk@generalmail.com; pjk3@comcast.net; adachan288@yahoo.com; ldornell2@comcast.net; jdmiller1023@comcast.net; steve@theenlightenedmind.net; patricia_juarez@comcast.net; hisey@stanford.edu; jengifford@att.net; rajik99@yahoo.com; hawkseer1111@yahoo.com
  • 10. Page 3 of 5 SERVICE LIST BY U.S. MAIL Kathy Cleary 20645 Montalvo Heights Drive Saratoga, CA 95070 Armando Lopez, Jr. 376 Jerome Street San Jose, CA 95125 Yakoub Bellawala 1440 Harriet Avenue Campbell, CA 95008 Dolores Cunha 620 Kenneth Avenue Campbell, CA 95008 W. Higginson 487 Skall Drive San Jose, CA 95111 Ulysses Sambajon 10587 Franklin Boulevard Elk Grove, CA 95757 Floyd Okada 14085 Taos Drive Saratoga, CA 95070 Don and Vera Reed 6067 Pietz Court San Jose, CA 95123 Cynthia Ryan Francis 1652 Naglee Avenue San Jose, CA 95126 William Nevis 126 Fox Avenue San Jose, CA 95110 Thomas Valdez, Jr. 1343 Mich Bluff Drive San Jose, CA 95131 Laura Schneider 638 Auzerais Avenue San Jose, CA 95126 Benton Hooper 1881 Ensendada Drive Campbell, CA 95008 Nellie Jenks 6106 Iowa Drive San Jose, CA 95123 Mary E. Keifer 1362 Hillcrest Court San Jose, CA 95120 Dr. Gerald Bittner, Jr. 14309 Chester Avenue Saratoga, CA 95070 Anita Gable 1363 Winona Drive San Jose, CA 95125 William and Macy Ip 12921 Brandywine Drive Saratoga, CA 95070 Laurie Stapleton 10395 Moretti Drive Cupertino, CA 95014 David Shade 16615 Englewood Avenue Los Gatos, CA 95032 Kitrick E. Whitney 735 Carlotta Court San Jose, CA 95136 Michael Jenks 1584 Keesling Avenue San Jose, CA 95125 Catherine Comer 1494 Cherry Valley Drive San Jose, CA 95125 Ivan and Jeanette Aladjoff 112 Belwood Lane Los Gatos, CA 95032 Dolores T. Kloss 20031 Somerset Drive Cupertino, CA 95014 Beth Keifer 1873 Huxley Court San Jose, CA 95125 Yelena Yakirina 1200 Valley Quail Circle San Jose, CA 95120 Dorothy A. Brown 2350 Shade Tree Lane San Jose, CA 95131 Philip J. Shanker 15949 Cerro Vista Court Los Gatos, CA 95032 David H. Mowbray 1032 Empey Way San Jose, CA 95128 Joseph and Deborah Isham 2196 Willester Avenue San Jose, CA 95124 Seyed M. Sabahi 2205 Corktree Lane San Jose, CA 95132 William and Mirella Auer 6077 Burnbank Place San Jose, CA 95120 Larry and Vicky Toder 1858 Gunston Way San Jose, CA 95124 Samuel A. Moiseff 6262 Paso Los Cerritos San Jose, CA 95120 Margaret Jasper 20191 Bonnie Brae Way Saratoga, CA 95070 Muthukumar Mudaliar 1413 Vallejo Drive San Jose, CA 95130 Darline Lohman 1114 Virgil Place San Jose, CA 95120 Katherine Jen 19431 San Marcos Road Saratoga, CA 95070 Ron and Rhondda Leckie 18779 Kosich Drive Saratoga, CA 95070 F.T. Comstock 15730 Oak Knoll Drive Los Gatos, CA 95030 Sally and Dave Baum 1484 Pollard Road Los Gatos, CA 95032
  • 11. Page 4 of 5 Silvia Malley 5453 Muir Drive San Jose, CA 95124 Rennis Kauffman 109 Treseder Court Los Gatos, CA 95032 Pascuala Huerta 103 Loma Vista Court Los Gatos, CA 95032 Hugh Reynolds 1622 Montrose Way San Jose, CA 95124 Laura P. Bence P.O. Box 3697 Los Altos, CA 95024 Kathy J. Smith David A. Craig 5085 Capistrano Avenue San Jose, CA 95129 Fred Luk 18021 Rose Court Monte Sereno, CA 95030 Donna 814 Century Drive Campbell, CA 95008 Jessie Villicana 716 Harrison Street San Jose, CA 95125 Larry Fabian 18660 Vista De Almaden San Jose, CA 95120 Qianfan Xu, Xiaojia Hou, and Lexi Xu 6021 Calle De Felice San Jose, CA 95124 Edward M. Pacheco 1426 Mt. Stanley Way San Jose, CA 95127 Neil Knott 17150 Scott Drive Monte Sereno, CA 95030 Edith and Blair Gallant 661 Cambrian Drive Campbell, CA 95008 Christine Brum 1807 Kirklyn Drive San Jose, CA 95124 Dina Sargis 6564 Northridge Drive San Jose, CA 95120 Aileen Gulesserian 111 Vallecitos Way Los Gatos, CA 95032 Bobbie Morrison 2300 Shibley Avenue San Jose, CA 95125 Steven and Pat Moore 18971 Easton Place Saratoga, CA 95070 Leigh Haldeman 1730 Santa Lucia Drive San Jose, CA 95125 Ronald Franken 5304 McKee Road San Jose, CA 95127 Michael S. Blodgett 70 Decker Way San Jose, CA 95127 Raymond and Carol Copeland 1202 Chateau Drive San Jose, CA 95120 Suzanne Regul 4667 Mossbrook Circle San Jose, CA 95130 Angela Giacalone 1569 Cherry Glen Way San Jose, CA 95125 Suzette Bromagem 1735 Wickham Court San Jose, CA 95132 Mickey Starr 5419 Starcrest Drive San Jose, CA 95123 Wendy Watkins 984 Willow Glen Way San Jose, CA 95125 Vanessa and Clay Fiske 1524 Monteval Place San Jose, CA 95120 Stanford and Pamela Atwood 16125 Greenwood Lane Monte Sereno, CA 95030 Norvelle Benevento 821 Plaza Drive San Jose, CA 95125 Gary Wiesehahn 1576 Sheffield Avenue San Jose, CA 95125 Susan Eiguren 2530 Calma Court San Jose, CA 95128 Linda M. Haro 54 Birch Lane San Jose, CA 95127 Brad and Michelle Foote 1090 Holmes Avenue Campbell, CA 95008 Karen Clark 4313 Faraday Drive San Jose, CA 95124 Robert Antone 1752 El Codo Way San Jose, CA 95124 Ed Saxon 1484 Elsman Court San Jose, CA 95120 Nick Lamberti 1656 Sweetbriar Drive San Jose, CA 95125 Dean R. Kwarta Kathleen Stenberg 1829 Kirkland Drive San Jose, CA 95125 George and Barbara Callisch 2929 Kring Drive San Jose, CA 95125 Sharon and Wayne Wood 4160 Golf Drive San Jose, CA 95127 Nathan T. Ballard 1171 Utopia Place San Jose, CA 95127 Anne Zingale 725 Pershing Avenue San Jose, CA 95126
  • 12. Page 5 of 5 Scott Levene 125 Dillon Avenue Campbell, CA 95008 R.A. and W. Guardino 1479 De Tracey Street San Jose, CA 95128 Steve McArthur 1837 Kirkland Avenue San Jose, CA 95125 Bea Sines 641 Rebecca Way San Jose, CA 95117 Mark Warneke 14544 Berry Way San Jose, CA 95124 Shirley Kong 3476 Ramstad Drive San Jose, CA 95127 Alma Baillif 5840 Recife Way San Jose, CA 95120 Khanh Cao 110 Drysdale Drive Los Gatos, CA 95032 Tom and Cassandra Owen 3859 Via Montalvo Campbell, CA 95008 David Schulze 1009 Mount Carmel Drive San Jose, CA 95120 Gurcan and Sumru Aral 1040 November Drive Cupertino, CA 95014 Nicola McAllister 15612 Kavin Lane Monte Sereno, CA 95030 Ingrid Oakley-Girvan 260 El Cajon Way Los Gatos, CA 95032 Josh Palmer 877 Almarida Campbell, CA 95008 Sergio Villaverde 637 Soni Court San Jose, CA 95116 Brenda and Thomas Dohmen 7016 Wooded Lake Drive San Jose, CA 95120 Barbara G. Bacile 1088 Fleetwood Drive San Jose, CA 95120 Sylvia O. Ortiz 3474 Cherry Avenue San Jose, CA 95118 Rudy Crespo 3482 Crespo Drive San Jose, CA 95118 Constantinos Bassias 6140 Cecala Drive San Jose, CA 95120 Christine Brum 1807 Kirklyn Drive San Jose, CA 95124 Brenda and Larry Mehringer 18709 Westview Drive Saratoga, CA 95070 Krishraveni Meka 19170 Monte Vista Drive Saratoga, CA 95070 Alex and Cherie Wheeler 1665 Cottle Avenue San Jose, CA 95110 Kay Fontana 2143 Coastland Avenue San Jose, CA 95125 Judy H. Lomas 19405 Bainter Avenue Los Gatos, CA 95030 Fred Runco 1444 Cerro Verde San Jose, CA 95120 Eva Runco 1444 Cerro Verde San Jose, CA 95120 James Dutkiewicz 1511 Willowdale Drive San Jose, CA 95118 Aileen Gulesserian 111 Vallecitos Way Los Gatos, CA 95032 Michele & Gordon van Zuiden 17573 Eaton Lane Monte Sereno, CA 95030 Rita Benton 18555 Ravenwood Drive Saratoga, CA 95070 Laurie Lew-McCrigler 2436 Homewood Drive San Jose, CA 95128 Ronald Moser 1577 Inverness Circle San Jose, CA 95124 Mr. & Mrs. Joseph Shank 20756 Scenic Vista Drive San Jose, CA 95120 Janice Hirata 866 Lincoln Court San Jose, CA 95125 Lainey and Bruce Richardson 14801 Golf Links Drive Los Gatos, CA 95032 Laura and Scott Kupor 18211 Bancroft Avenue Monte Sereno, CA 95030 Alex and Carol Hanuska 804 Kenneth Avenue Campbell, CA 95008