بیوتکنولوژی در آیینه اخلاق

1. ! ! " #! $%& '() *+
!"#$%
&
%'()) *+, $ $ - ) ./ 0$120 34$5,67 1 )7 18 )&
#'7 1 )7 18 ) (38 8* 0 93- ) ./ : 3- ) ; ./ 0$12 ) (&
10<$:< / =8 >/ ? < >/ ?1 @A A 7 A AB A@ C
C 0 1@ D B&A E A 1F- A A- , A GA < E ; AH 6)IAJ 1A9 A <
>/ ? 4 K 4:< /C 0 - 1 2&7 L MNA8(? 1) (A* 8
$ OP8)Q AR; A- , )6 A B S.A ) A3@ ) 2 A-< $ T1 )7 U 1 BCA
4 $- - E - / ( $ C V B W1( @ )G (- = ;0< / 6 OM < 4<1 A@ A
C&C / B :< / OM X ,Y 47CA 4 A4 V 1A 7$+A
19 V ) @ Z- 27 0 - 9- @ ?EC 0 - -$ [ +&C J- ) . 6
1F- B 1=A8 4AA -NA AA C AR A $ (- A@ A ) A9-
0 2 7 ) < 1,6 H?4 1 $ 0 *6A < G 14 ? , 4 , 7 )0< / 6
1F-4>/ ? :< /< 1,&4 W ] < [ 8 ^_6Z `A $ )0< A/
a1b :< /A A 1 CA J- ` c *7 A7 A A 1A d A
e1f( * C < 4- A - $ - A / ) 4 A 2 :< A/cCAgA 6 A V [$ `A $
C < O] / CCA :< / 4 $&A AB 7 A ,h19A34$5,i$hj AH
I4$5,id d 7 ;4G E V ba1b*&
7 2 $ O2
! " #$ %&'()
* + , "-N) 1(@0 34$5, ) *+, $ $ - ) $ ./ 0$12
6))6 $( , $ ]%kk'%lmno)7 1 )7 18&
% ./' +0
Archive of SID
www.SID.ir

2. ! ! " #! $%& '()*,
* $1
O VC 1 p1, O V ) 1K [ ; $ - - [ ;&
6D? G < ( $7 19A34$5, A *
- - [ ; 7 1F ?/ ] $0< /A4A B< 1A
C 1 @- * $1 $ - - [ ; 1F- 4 $
< $1A9A A 1K [ A ; 7 @ A- CA
- [ ; I.-0 2 0< / 6 -$ < AA <
[ AA ; 7 1F ?/ AA] 1AAF- AA8q $ C@ AA3 1AA
1K [ ; 4$1 - -=4 1$&05
A K 4 :< /A 1AF- Ab.- $ < A-
r B- -A @ GA @ 1K [ ; 0< /cGA <
A 7OA ; 7 A1A7 A3-
A 7 As 1K$A@Z A 7 A 6A
$ 8@ ; 9 4 44 VCA A A
[<t $ - $ I ) 1K 7 ; $
AA47 AA AA W1AA( @ 1AA9 AA < $ )
A- - 1A A ; E A3 < $ 834$5,E A. .$
CrA B CA +A ) ( < [ ; 4 $
1 2 B 1 - -<0 (A Q $ 4 8A4
[ ; 6 < (/C&(A < [ A ; A@ 7 05 A
OU ?- - C < = .()$ 6 1 A =4
= =4<( 4&6 1O/ @ $ 7 <<
- AA - E AA3OAA/ AA AA( 12 AA8 7 AA <
7 A - A - rA B M d E 3(A $$ CA
= AACAA AA@ CAA8B 7 < ) <(AA < [ AA ; AA4 $
- . 11( @G + <AB -
O A? 7 A C / - - E 3 O/
AA*&< [ AA ; :< AA/ AA $ 6 AA 4 << (AA
$ C 4CA 1 7 L&6AA .6 AH
A4 V A 0 A* ) A ZA t C 4 0 *
G @1F-1 A@ 0 9 B 6 ? )
$1AA 7 AA $ - AA - [ AA ; < 0< AA/ 6AA)7
1F-1 1 2 D d 4
$ ( 12V0< < ( @ 0$A@ 4
Z <A ) - ; 1 @A 1<
C 0 * 0 * 0< / 6 OM&
234* 5 *#
23236 7 8 5
>> ):$1CA A t&ZA t
W$@A K 4 Z t 7 < 7) 1A@ A
1 @ C 7 4)[ ;[ 1f <
@&$ 4 A $1A )CA. ./ A < A t 6
4 AAA ?-C AAAR )CAAA u $ AAA4CAAA $ AAA4$ AAA4
-CC ; 4&Z t)rA $ A AK 4
;7 ZA t 6 1CAU A? - A - A( A A@
= .(AA6AA1AA SAA $ = AAF OAA ( AA tAA
$ 7 A8B A A8- S $ $ 19AV BCA%
!%&"
U ?- =4 13 C 1V X ) K 4 Z tA4
OAA.; 8 1AA3 $AA - =AA4 $ ?4AA 1 d $ AA$ AA4
8 6 1 1 (? $ ?4 8 13CA 0&
W f )r $;0< - 4 @ = ;A4
CAA ^ V AA AAK 4 AA CAA AA&
>/ ?0 , 00< 6 <= 4 A 0 A* A4
1@A ; 1 A@ (A < A :< A/ 05 A @
- $ 1-&
93238 :
tZA t 1A 1AF- ZA , )r $ @ [$$W
C1F- U 1C!#"&L12A A
.b0< @ - $1H4 K 4 $ 4
AA (? AA ZAA 1F- GAA 1AA)= < AADAA d 6 AA
0<1F- - , 4( 4 4&
'6 4t1 ./ [ F- K 4 - , @ C <
1 2&; C. ././< V- - 3 @
( 4 t 6 4&0 * r? < 6%* j B&
Archive of SID
www.SID.ir

3. ! ! " #! $%& '() *,
W P 16ZA 1F- ) - .; 1 $ 1 C
q$12$ 1 _ (- @[<AK 4
0< A C/ 7A@ A* [+A( A A4
4 , ) K (-A 4 1 $ 8 3
* (*&A , : A; 12 W P 1A
q$@ = - : ; 6 (- @2N
hA@ 6A@ A( 7 LA4 A$ 1A 2 1 ) A( 7
* - 8BiA- .; v1 A, 6 ; C 6 1
7)6 L0 A;$ A +A - A8 6 1A OA A
A* (*&1A9 E A?; A)AL12A 1E A 1F-
AV- 1A9 ARVZA 4 A ) (A 4 rA K
6 E 1F-6 A L(A -&A@ A L 1A4A
AA q$(- AA@ AAAA -AA AA-AAK (- AA1AA2
9-A* 2< A 1AF- ZA t&6 AA 1
CAAM 1AA 1F- CAA 6AA - AA /$ AA4AA
ME A 1F- < A @ 4A2< A A
*&6A A A GA 7 G V
< Cq$AK (- A $ (- A@ 12A 12
< A(M 1 1A9 < $ * ? , 9-A/$
A q$ )7 ZAK (- A@ * (*A $ - A /$ A 12
K (-A9- A- A /$A*&7 A v< A
OA.; $ /$A 05 A A :< A/ A 12
C R6*$1C&G =4 O ;C AR
C * 1F- b.- 6 < 7&1A w 1
05 A C - .; 7 L :< / b
$ 7 77 -* @ (J
A C R Z 1F- 1 *$ <1 7<
1@ = 1 7 - /$ - .; > /&
;323<
Z t[)ZA t $ < E$ ( x @ 1F- b.- <
W$19-&y1(3 B$ 12A tW$$$[
0< 7 1 , $ 14 @ * 6+A@1 ( 4
C[ Z t )<1 VH%
A `
AAA1AAA9-$$ - AAA * CAAA 1V 4 AAA9- )rAAA $
V ?b V= ; C @&1 OMA
6 3 , Z t $ 4 E$ 6-E * @
( 4 ; +(-&6A = A @ A; 1A2 A 4 J- e +2
) t6 1IJCA A >&< t zA
0< $ 8*< 7 4u $ ; O ?4)
y0 +A2 {@ $ ]$ OA.; IA.- $ A A4
v$B 4- .; <0<46
1 B 0< /1 2&OA ? < t zA (/
V0 +20< $ 4( 1V v< $ 4
@ C - B 8-[ Z t
V b $ | .( 4 W s3&
93= 4> ! ?"9
AAAA AA =AA ; < AA* AA 1 AA@
*@; A (B 2 A-< Z]1; ; >/ ?
< 1,&>A/ ? 3 1 @GA z$
$ CA 4 OA A 0<$1 ) Z 1F-
; H $1 ZVE)7A U 1 E
0 1@ ,C&A ) >/ ? D 1
1 @0< W 7; 4A
1 K 4 19 E ?; $N
@ : A % B;
@ :C
> -7D
"E
7 L6 } 4 1 @ >/ ? = 4 @
- ,A* 1A9 A ~ 9 $ H1;A A4
*&$ < 6 1 7$+(>/ ? 6 ( 1V
!
"
Archive of SID
www.SID.ir

4. ! ! " #! $%& '()*(
A* 19 $ 1 @[ A ; 05 A [ A ; A4
- 1K7C d1A@&$ |A ; A 1 )6 1 A
O Z?- B 41 @)$ |A . A G <
V b*1A9 A < $ 7 2 - 2 4
C *4 $[ ;1A4 A U A 1 A 1K
j H?&
2393" F&
)CA*2 A@ 7 A L ) A ; A A $ 1 @
0<$11(3? B, 1 ; (B 2 -< 4I*
4&1AF- >/ ? 7e1A]A (@
rAH 7 - ; (B 2 -< E ; H )0 1 -
6 A ( $1A - A4ut0A-&• A < A <
0 A* $ 0 A2 6 ] $ 7 ( O ; ( 12
(@$7 A 8( 1( 2 7 b H $ 7 $
7 @ * $7 E ? 9- 9LA$ (A 1, $
1A- ) AB $ 7 } 4 ; H (/!n"A 4
CA A Z A :< A/ E ; AH&)7 A 6A
0 A9 B < A A S? 1 E ; H05A $
A A :< / , - Z(* $ C 1
( < 7 ; C%
,AB$ ]1;(A* 2
C!€"&
;3GG GG - @ GG4 GG GG = GG 4
+AH.9
? B *$ ZV b ( <[ ; 4
( <$ C* 8 $7*&) AV b 6
4 C $ 4 ( )E fS? 1AE A / A
11 2&W A < A@ CA 2 7%l•‚OM A
AA |AA ;:< AA/ZAA- 2 AA (AA < AA
.1A AV B A ; 7 AB$ AB A
C 12&C W f x ; OM 6A B A4 $
0< / ( < [ ;gA (J 4)05 A0< A/A4
#
CA 0 A - A - E A / S? 1&A9- 0 A-< 7 A
AR; A AR; - , 1 6(*)A8B$< 7 A
GAA @ AA $ AA -Z `AA $ $ AA AA B AA8
8 6 $ y @ b • /- -4OM <
$ A*+, [ A ; C 1A3 , @ C 0 1 d d
AA1AAAA ; 7 AAB$ $ AA 7 AA ;
CAAA 0 AAA 1&+AAA - 4 AAA 2 $ - AAA / 0< AAA/
)CA@ CA (A* A F; 4 $
$ O ` O ) 1F- b.-<d dC 6 1&
I 1, 9J , )7 C =d1 ; *+,A4
60< /?-$ C 0CA. ./A*+, A)A
7 A 4 ZAb A $ GA*+, $ A ZbA4 @
7 AA 0< AA/ 19 AA AA AA*< AA $ - AA
A ]A*&A a1Ab 4 A@ $ A4 K 4
- *+,C -9J ,d dA@ * 4
A a1b 6 - OMA A $ A*
*+,CA E$ ( < :< -)14A AL7 A
A < A3J A*+, A(A <A* A
$&AA(AA << CAA8B AA <AA*+, AA
AA AA4 + AA (NW$(AA < AA e AA4 AA@ 7
A; K A $ ( / 4 @ Z x 1]<(A
7 : A ; e A4 A )C - 1 @ $ ; 8 V
OM C $ | ; yO] /A4 $ CA <
C 7&A (A < A @ 7 [$
a1Et z;|A? B A A 1A t $ A4A4
6 1 <E ; H 1< 1,)P/ ?7 } 4N
AA @ AAL AA AA@ 6AA $ 7 AA - [ AA8 )E AA / v<
7 - ƒJ**$$ - - ƒJ* C 4
0< A/ - A - C P / [ 8 $ VA S? 1A A4
AACAA&AA (AA < AA AA@ 6AA [ AA
C U 1 OMA4 0< / ; 2
(A <A A4 CA8B $ W1A( @ 6 A } 4 $
05 $ C ; + - ( < [ ;&CA 8-7A A@
Archive of SID
www.SID.ir

5. ! ! " #! $%& '() *-
?- B$ „ 4Z( O ) ( < @ 1@ f
cC *+,A A@ 1A@ A; 7
0< / ( <-C ; $1 6&
C3F&
D b B4 $ C ( <$
C 1AA3 ,= .(AA AA- , AA AA4&
< 0< A/ 6A W A $ VA )C. ./A7 A41
=A C?A - 1A] V 7 A - A@ CA 4 A $ 4
CAAA $ 8AAA34$5,AAA4 $AAA31:< AAA/
&- 6 1(A CA 7<
E ; H7 ;A ; < 0< / 6 $1
C 1A3 , $ W A A CA 6A ) 1@ 1VA4
W $ V&A 1 A 1 <
A 0 * ; H <1AH / W A/ A@ = A @
:< AA/7 AA AAB AA (AA < AA >AA/ ?
C&
23C3A $
`• A / A >A/ ? < (A* 8 A8(? 1
:< AA/AACAA (AA <&< j AAH 6AA AAL12
E ; HA*+,AA*6 A )
? B4C $ ;M A A B < 7 2
@ C(A <A 1AA @&A? BA4
A./ OM A A ~A 9 - , ` 6 ;
1 131 2&? B6JA ) ` ; 4
(A* 8 $ A*+, [<t A8(? 1 CA 1 |/ <
C&6*$ - < ` C /A4 1A
= A @ AB … AV( A A A@ *&AABA
AA E AA AAM [$+AA $ AA ; E AA- C $ AA
=(A 1 0 2 7 -$18*) - AGA A ){ AJ(-
O ? ORV*&7 (A ^ A<
AA 1AAF-< AAKCAAAA 7 (AA CAAJ AA@
@CA A CA T1 Z- ( rb
6( 1 _-BA A8(? 1 A < A - @ -1A
† 9- W s3 *+,19 E ?;A|A/
7 CA / $ ‡A / ) K (- $ C | b ./ )E /
q$1 d $ Vb.A@ 6A A CA E -
1A A 6 L B E - { L L 8( $
- 0 8;%
†!o"
93C3* I$ $? +' + <J $'0
C 13 ,A8 $ OAP A Z < *+, [ ;
B= ; 6$<(J 4@j AH 6
A / OM A ) (1A(A < A
C 0 1@ a1b&x7 A} 4$#
A*Q+AB
0 AA(AA < AA AA@ AA* M AA 6 1AA6AA
7 C/$1 $CA 0 A*&1A • A / OM A
A? B $ C A B 1 s 7 } 4) ; A (B gA (J A4
- $$+A - $ CA 4 j AH ) K (- $ 7 9 41
E ; H < 6 B ^ B { J(- Z>A
C Z < (* 6!•"&
;3C3* IK$ L
0< B 7- A +A@ 1 † 1
1F- <rAb @ ( 4 < K7 A) A*+,
• A / A ` † 3J C;1 7 1
7 T1n
O * Z 4; AH A B < 7 4
A > 0< / @ C(A <A 1A1A 2&
%'^ 14 7 B!% ! &"V ?* G < 6
a1b$ B$ 7 1 CJ G 8 @ …1 @ @
7<1 , @ ˆ 1 $k‚@ - B 7< 19 $ 8
C -<1CJ 6 @ C 6 W 7 @ ) - 7 < 0 ( < -
v< † * 0 Y f( $ 6 < G [ @ ( - (
$ 1(3 E / 7 $ - B † - E$ =4 $ 6 E /
7 B 7 -<1 9( $† - * a1b B1 7 ; -
† bL V B C @ 1 1 7 1= f 0 2 1$ 1 2
CV @ 4 * 7 }- 2L ) -
z 6 U ? V( E B1 0 2* a1b -&
0 * r? < 6o@ j B&
$ ' ! ()
!
Archive of SID
www.SID.ir

6. ! ! " #! $%& '()+.
7 T1<2 j A- A gA (J E 1AF- b.-7 2 A-
= . OC&A@ 6A A?(;[ AK-CA?P OA ;
1K7 ) ; [ K- < * T1
T17W V%
$OV 7 T1#
= .A @&
6 } 47 T1 |. : I.- ?(;)
- ? $ 7 T1n
$T17A- ? $ 1A d€
.=*&CA E A] $ 1 j -N
g'@)CA - 1F- 8qA -
1 $ y @CA /A @o
{'A) 1A A@
8q $ )C 1F- 8q1F-6A )0 1 -
C 0 1@ e 8q @•
&7 2Z 4A8( / 6
= /- - -&A )W P 1
C <7E A A CA [ ; @
$) K-rb-‰ A A -A
* (* W V 7 T1 3 /&
C3C3M N " * I0
6$ A A 7 =3L < + - j H
0 - -C`A A 7 2 A- 2 $< < 7 - $
0 1F--&< 1 2 B$ 1A 3@E AK-
8 B A AL 1F- b.- < 0 1@ (- 1
1A A † * (* -A|A/ A (A
I C* -1 6 V-[ AAA (-
GA @ M - |/ 7 19 † -E AK- $
1 2 A B O ; 6 < $† A @A@ b- A 4
C 0 * 1@u 19 E V bC* -1 6 V |/
$W .(7 7 - 1CA - ABA@$
E C d G - (k
V7 A -AAA L 1A4
* $A< -&(A* 8 84 9(A
E / < @Z 41A(/A @ 1
' !
' !
* ! ) !
+ ! ' ! ) !
,
" -! ' ! ) !
. !
[ - 4 2C 0 1@ 3@A@ C /
$7 B4 E K- $!k"&
D3C3O' ? P1# * I
j AAH< +AA - 6 AA B S.AA 6 1AA j +AA- $ • AA /
E ; H- 1 ,`T1C 2 -< $&IAJ
O8B<S.A Z `A A A A E A
6 B< 1,&;A 6 A B S. 1 |/ < 0
C* -1 6 V |/ (j7 W A/ ) @
0 ; @OA ; 6A 6 A B E A / |/ ? 1 19
1 d$A , -- A*!k"&`A A
6 B1 9 / @ 05 $ ( - 41Ap
g ; <$ KK*` )• A /CA 1A&
$ A ZA A@ A 6 } 47 ABA
8E A / |A/ … AV 1AF- Ab.- < ` ) @
O E / |/ $a1b* 4!k"&S.;
6 BE * E ; H B <)CA e (
A A@ M B0 1(A 2 gA 7 A84 2 A <
./ )$?4[1AB 0 A9- 7 A A@ CA
7 ZA- |A/ OA $ j AH 6A -
7 -C!m&"
E3C3Q (R $ '. * I
C 13 ,Q AR; A- , 7 A $ *+, = ; 7$+ <$
g (J<A (A < :< / )19 7 -
IA 1,CAA 0 1A@ $1AA $ A AAB A4!l"&
AB *+, = ; @ ]A 1 C 1A3 , <
@+As 7 A} 4 R; - , 7+A -A* 1A
* 4 B + - - - C 4 ` 0 9-&6 } 4
fJ* R; - ,A@$ 0 A* +As T1A AL
A $ CA32< 7 $ - / E / < 4 6
E /- -( *+, 1F- <A 64u )C
0 1@ W s3 7 <C&
S3C3%#"/' T U&R 7" -
Archive of SID
www.SID.ir

7. ! ! " #! $%& '() +)
C4 $- / ) 4 2 :< / G (- = ;
B 4 , ) - - $,CA (*&
I , O 1 d 0 2 4 , $ CV ? e1f $ O
G < 7$,7$+A <$ < A - A A@ XA
A 7 A )1A9 A < - - r B
:< /a A] $ 4 A 2 G (- ` U 1 >/ ?
ORV ) 4 2A$1A $CA ( A&6 A 4
a ] Z < `- /$ A (- OAP A $
CA 0 * a1b + - - - 5- a ] (/&A/W
)1H /A4 $ CA G 5 1(A C 4 B
6A 13 ; 7 )G (- = ;0< A/1A Q+AB
* 4 3@ ;&7 +A 6 4 )W / 6
C <4 $C A / C @ )0 * *
6*$ `<&4 $ C 6<GA
AA ZAA AAAA <7 AA 7 AA} 4 AA4
8$ C V B d 6 ` $7$+A- A -8
0 1@ K• A / 4 A , O 19 < $ )
d d DB )7A4A B0 A* A $1A
C&0 ;$01AK , )7 A $1A G (- = ; 4
E$ (1 8 0< ?A 13 1A32&
=3L< -0 @ $* [ @< - 4
A(/ A < A A A( 12 C7 1A@ 6 +9 AB 7 A
(M 4A A 6A 8 ^ B <1A
1 2&@ = @ B 1 C @ 8
A F; W A AL )7 A ( E ]Z `A
Q R; - ,)* 4 ,=8 >/ ? <$1
C ( <&C05 G (- = ; 4 $
?* 0< /< A- A -%
1A A C A /
(J 9-C#
!%‚)%%"&
/ ! !(
#'1] V 7 < ^ 14 7 B O ` O 0 2 F/ 1
@V .@ @ C p 84 2 1 e 1
?*- <./C P / - $ C 2< - $ … V 13
- - C 1@ $&0 * r?%%* j B&
AAAA AA 6AA AA 1AA 2 AA AA AA-
1AA 0 (AA Q1AA 2&6 AA } 4AABCAA P / AA$
0 A2 A(/ $ A- 7 A - 1 d W A $ - - C 1@
- ( 1, 5-IAJ 6 ZV 84$12 -
* - 19- DB $ @ | 3- AA*
- - - j - C 1@ Zd d @&6 C 8-= ; @
s G (-C ? $&7 Z? GA8 A- A-
3) * (* - O1F- <{ A b
- $ E RV 1 . C8B $* 8 K 4&
7 19 Z?: (A Q A OA $ • /
@ C 1 d7 19- -O 3 $ 0 @6 1
*&* 0 * x ? @ b- 4CA=A ; A4 $
G (-7:< / 7 + E 3@GA +
( 4A - @ ) 1@ ?3+A A A-
6 A < 1 - b *7 1A(A= AF; A4$12 $ A4
* O ? - -&
<E A- A? @ $ 9 A 12 05 A 1A. 1A9
) d<CA A8 K 4 - < A <
@8 V B $ 1@&7 -A 12
AA)1AA9$v AA-<1 AA(/AA< ) AA*$1
A 7 A - ) A @A3@$7 A - CA - 1A2 A(/
&) 7 ; 11A. < * - ( ;$
9 12`7 @ < 2 7 ( @ C -
C*2&01K , 12 6 1<< A 7 - $
O A/ A $ 9 A 12 O A3 OA/ IAJ - @ *
=@7 1@E 1pC 12 0 - 7 ?- * 7&6A
j A- 14 7 2 )W /|A .a A] A
A E $1AH A OA 4 2 :< / (-
† 1@ B
V3C37" - %#" % P'M+' T
C*2 @ 7 LC $ G 8A4 $
G (-C 4 2&A - 9 12 r 87 A
e1AAAf $ OAAA AAA- 214 1AAA 0CAAAV ?$
Archive of SID
www.SID.ir

8. ! ! " #! $%& '()+/
| b (- 834$5,$< A U1A* $
1@&8 - 19- $ E 1 JC <Ab=A3L OA
C - * ,&A < AA-$ $ CAV ? 7 A( 1Ab
7 4 2 E / V ?7 19-&-2 A 7
- $ JA W A 7 +A4 1A A@ <A4< -
$ 0 1@ 6 7 -$ OA A- 2 1A4 :< B ) @
e1f&A7 A`AGA @ A Ad 6 `A
v$< S A ‡ / $ 7 4 2 (- a ] 4CA
$ =)1bW V1@ 1 1&A@ A* 6z b
a AA]) AA (-1AA 1AA9 6 1AA 1AAb 4 AA ,
- C < S&<A - 190< AB 7 A
[ 1 $ 4 3@ @1 .a A] E A 0 93 <
- * O ? d 4 3@ 4 2 : *&-CA 2 7 A
7 L1 < 3JA A8- A A- 12 $ 1 . [
1@ 1 + L 14&(6 A <7 1A@ 1 A <
7 @$ O 7$- 2 e1f4 A 2 A4
V ?7 - v0 A*A@ A ; y A A †CA
† B$ ; 6 E ?p 1
1A2 A(/ A@ AB$ IA 1, 6 B W / 6
6 <7$(- e1f $ OA 7 A4 2A
AB - A $ rA 1 O L * 2 X ,
A (- E 1f $ O 7AB$CA. ./ †
A- 2 7 - @ C -t 7 < EA 1
A* V ?7 A4 2A CAA @&2 A-< A(/
A- 2 + - ( < $ 3@A4e1Af $ OA <
C8BEt Af A $ E A A 0< ? ) ?8
„ A4 $ AB$ < $ A3@ B0 A20 A*0 A3-
6A 1 1 @ C)E A… 1A(;0 A* A
*&$ A AL 4 A ‰ @ C 6 W z
$ O 7E 1Af$ 0 A* 1A@uE / A]A (-
B$@$BC$$… 1A(;
1† 1 2
C. ./7C@a ]7 4 2-8
;B -$1 dA)CA -AAABA
=3L< -IJ)7;C1AF- < @A
0 ,$(/)$1HA*&A6A
)W /a ](-7 4 2OH1;$A-) A u
-7 ;;B -.*&A]
@a ]) (-SC <V ?A 8) A -
V ?<1FSC <6 LA ;
B -4$<71 2 B1@&6 A } 4
@6 L- 4 2CB$- $
8- -8@<6- 27 4 2$
r <77e1f7 2 @;!-84 9A3 <
. . +@ 1 $"1 2 A BA*&E ; AHA
AA- - )0 AA*M AA $ >AA/ ? < AA4CAAAA@
C 13 , W ?- 7K [ A ; 4A A 1
0 * $1 $ 7-&OM AAA 1Af (A <
C - E ; H&W1A( @ $ = F 7 } 4 M
` )C V B: *:< A/ +A - E A- / A (
1 > $ B ( < >/ ?( 12-%
!%#)%n")0 - 9- @f- 8- Z 4 6( 1,&
xt AA]< $1AA , AA (AA < AA AA@ AAB 7 <
C 13 ,4S $ ˆ? ) :< /c A
AA -(AA $ r AAB CAA 7 AA<E ; AAH6AA
M 0< /&
D3* : / - 7 'B
17 A ; A A V CA34 1A] V 7 2 A -
AAA8@CAAA @AAA 1F- GAAA AAA@ $AAA
0 1 AA*1AA-&) AA*+, $ (AA < AA $1AA
%'7 } 4 2 + 7 p =4 E - / ( `
OM < 1H / W / =4 $ 0 a1b [ ( $ C- @a1b
C 1 @ 0< /&: * r?%n* j B&
Archive of SID
www.SID.ir

9. ! ! " #! $%& '() +0
1F-A@ A* 0< A/ 6A < - 9J , -
C34 4 V 6 B $* - 2
%
!%€"N
C AA* $ a AAH$#
)[ KAA -2< AA $n
$ W AA @ )
C V B€
A )A2o
E A )A ?•
8 B A E A )k
)
$ 4 < Em
; $7l
&
< 4Az GA A @ C W z 6 B
25 $ @41@) A*AA-
A* A † $ 7 1A@ OA ; 7 1
AAAA(/ CAA 2 7 AA1AA2[ AA AA ZAA 1F- GAA
AA25 $AAK 1AA =4< AA AA* (AA* AA AA4
V B@C&A@ A V )C. ./
A. - A /$ 1 d E 1F- [)CA+A L
7 0 - 9- @ Ch-$ [ +( • /iA -&
hAA-$ [ +AAi$1AA -AA@1hAA 1F- GAA AA@
iC&A 1AF- A $ 6 4 <‰ A A A
7 1@V7 A e$1AV!%o"A- AA 1F
E A 1F- ( 1V O 3 G < @ C C .
?18 7 1%‚
< $ * (* -
* ?- - 9 7 L =4 D d = ; < 19@[ +A E
W+ 1 ] 7 -$&$ v< A 6A CA. ./
8CCA 0 1@ W s3 0 - 9- 64u&
1F-C - .; v1 ,gA A 1,
$C O ; 1 ? - /A- .; A A4 $
$ / - (012* O 3 6 32&
#'76 V 6Š? $ 6 / @ @ a1b
6 $ C 8 6 1 O W ; $ Q *@$ (
6 1 7 < O.( 8@ ( 6 1 ( -
$ <12 1-1&7 3 - 7 j +- 6
C a1b + - 7&$ I ,I 12@ +(V $ 1V*
- 2 =4 7 @e ( < V- )6 4
C 6 `&
/ )
/ ! )
/ ! ! ! ' !
0 )
1 ! ) 2
" % ) 2
. 3 2
4 )
5 ) ' ! !
E3@ :UG7$G '.G -"> GW
<XT + '
23E3*#8 :U
AAE ; AAHAA<AA? BAA4- 2 AA- 2
70 A9-AA&0 A2Z `A(A$A
( -O ;$0 2`AE A]$A8 25 $OA ;
- -a1b*&D((- @$ArA -
9-$7 1BD d^A,<1Af;19 A*$
0 AACAAAA@v1 AA,1AA4GAA<6AA$)0 2 AA
4 ,Y:< /AA4
C*&6 } 4C R@<GAA3
3 -4b$<b.-1F-1A9A3
0<4)A4A41A7 AB0< A
AA( 12CAA&6AA0 9(AAAA+AA -:< AA/
4 ,YA&7$+A1A
61F-$0 9()I.-7$0<A4
$AA4 K 4?4AA:< AA/>AA/ ?(AA <
AA -7 AA0 AA -CAA* 9-&6AAIAAJ1AA4GAA<
84 9-- 2 8LtA2A 1V0 1A@$
4 ,[ +(14G<E A 1F-A$1A
>/ ?$= *&
93E3T + '"8G ' -@ G :GYG4
$22
!%•)%k"
<0 AA9-6AAAA 1F-) AArAA -1(AA31AAAAV
1(3<1) V By<A7 A$
B7O ;C&6 1O ;$- -AB
4@6 1(3rA -(AB6 1(A3AV
1V B@&r -7 9-0$12$O ;%#
$0 ;%n
= .- *&r -B$y1(3
$ 141 $CA&rA -)7 A9-(A$(A -
O ;? 1K (-@<7O ;O] /) *
6 - !
! !
$ !
Archive of SID
www.SID.ir

10. ! ! " #! $%& '()+1
<A @&AK (-AM 12%
rA -12A-:< A/
C2$6 .-4 ,. ;(*
AA*&<AA B4 AA ,6 AA L1AA $:< AA/
9- -$CA) A2C AfAM 12CA&
C AAfAA ;#
AA7 AA ;y AAAA1AA
< K 4B11 2&<K-@y
B7 A)OA ;AfCOA ;CA)1A2C Af
;$19 E ?;r -C 1P@AV BAR(
7 -$C](*) *77 - A$
CB4&61A $A -7 A
1C|/4O.(<C AfA ;Af
1@&19 E ?;7C 20 A9-rA -) A-
|/46 A1A) 1AO.(A<rA -)CA 1P@
B$?- -&AK (-7 A 12rA -A
v$1C8B6 ?[ 8r -1A@0A-&7 A L
AA@x ?AA7 AAAA*)<0 2 AA- AA7 AAL[ AA(
6 1( 8`- A -E A?;<A 1K@ A*$
En
$$<‹-$€
CA&A <AB
7GK 4)GO ;GA7 - A7 +ArA -7
AAAAB1AAAA4CAA 12&AA*$AAAA@
7r -7 AL[ A(<76JAAA 2
*$EAA /o
O A*E$1Ap)E A)( A)
(AA $)E18AA*)=AA ;$$‹AA-1AA.$AA--$
)*$C f$- A$•1A1A
1 2&C8B8 1 2K 4)VC24
$7 -24]B4AA@rA -
1P@ /$$‹-O A/- A 1•
&A ,
6 L4 9-A:< A/AŠAH $CA&
]@=A;<[ A- - A$ACA
;- 2/ 1*@C 1P@1AV B
/ ! 7 !
!
! !
!
0 !
1 8 !( ! ! ! 8 !( !
*$7 3 1P@ A/0 A$$‹A-A8-
O .6 L[- -$(AABA4
c(/12r -$./C$A1A$ AV
67-0( 120 **&60 9-AA
$AAK (-[ AAF-AA./<AA|AA/7 AAAA@
01AA8AA<AA./6 AA1AAAA 41AA
8L{ LC /147 A ;
<U .-gVH1 $r -AA /1A
( 12C&r -7B*(1 s
0 9-r -W$?(*c -A- 2A@CA ;
O /4./617 A 46 ARA*
!%m"&6B$AABCA*A@1A $rA -
---:< /0O/A]
1C /$6 R./61A1A 1
rC 1P@=4 1@&
;3E3T + '"8 ' -*G :GGS
!%•)%m"
1F-(- A@A7 AA<6 1 A21 p`
E AA 1F-AA1AA] V:< AA/>AA/ ?AAK 4
C -&7 -(- @DOA]CA d7 A
7 -{ L L- .;$6 ;W A/=KA
(7 9- -$C7 +21AA4
&C- @76 1(2 +e,$Œ$1A
- .;C -&6V@C- @<G
1 1-7 L[ 41) 1 2@4 K 4
+ L+BE /1- -1A- -(A$
K (-1O.;AA8-A- A*$<A
19(?7 -4 K 41O.;)ˆA
12< -6 A ((V 1A*$A/$A
AA@AA4 K 4AAAA* -<6 1AAAA8
-&7 L@>/ ?V+ -4OA]
C d7-7m
7 (E 1A.A 1F-ACA- @
" , ! !
. , !( !
Archive of SID
www.SID.ir

11. ! ! " #! $%& '() +*
C&6O]11 p`19*17 ( 2A./
131] V(*C&<O] /r B6A0< A$
O]h7 -7 A8BW A*i%
)CA- @A$ A0 A- 9-
-0 9(7 -|/AA (
*@L{ LA./)1A3OM A4AK
B1AA4&OA]1A 18- A -$[$+A
[ 1(/C P /8- -]1 1$7=4A8
O7 -7A8-A7 A ( 21A31A] V
CA!%•"&0 A9-|AA/AA4 AA ,
| ;$C8B0 44 1C*&C. ./
= AAFAAAA./1AA3S? 1AAAAAA
7 } 4;- 8B[ -- -$A./1A3#
{ L L6 40 9-|/7 -A BA]
&e 10 9-r -9-@A @`1AC Af
;)@- 4r -CA 1P@CA)0 A,A
ˆ.-./C$1$B) @
0 9-) (- @r -C 1P@$C f;A -A-
Bˆ.-./6CAc A*A(/1A2rA -
C 1P@6 L+ LR(@&1W APA -7 A
17$C HZ- 4 28-7 ;- <
E . .C <( *0181A+A
1&6 } 460 9-)4 ,. ;
E ; HY0< /A 14$1A
) - -- A /$4 A 2A4CA*&
114[ @<6>A/ ?CA]1Y AA
?@1<8-0 **&
C3E3T + '"8 ' -* :G%&'G(
$!%l";
C R<- 9L76JAA 2&6A
@- 9LfJ*$L8 25 $fJ*
7 ;O RA7$AAB†
4 -! ' 2
-! ' ! ! & ! 9 ! !
& ! $ (
*
C RAL:< A/A4 1 $A$
AAL:< AA/AA4 1 $e1AA]AA$AA- .;
7 V<E 1F-a1AbZ AA<1A
7 <a1b0C&6AAO A/J AA
CXZ7 -&$1f;1H /+ -
7 ;?B1 1E 1F-O ;$
051 $|/…1;[ -0 1A@CA
!#‚"&
Z `]C R6ACAA@A- 9L
- AA -AA† AA$1AAAA1AA $
C R-6C@1W P)7 *+,7 ..
$1@- 2AA .AA4A
1) -(<LR1† *
1?6$1AA}- L1A1A 2AOM A
1( ARA*= AfA8 1 2
+ -E f$8B4CA*&O A3
]6 L1 $6C@A- 9LA7 A
7$ AA6(AA*AA8@OAA ;AA$AA4AA4$
E RV)S.A1AhC ARA4i= Af
C 12†
AAAA 1AAC AARAA+AA -1AA1AA$AA4
= f8 1 2O/E RV1 +2 -CAA
7OA ;AA4A*&)GA*+,) (A 1,
|A.$xt A]1AA4OA ;- A -AA@1A 2OM AA
AACAA)1AA4AAL=AA4<C AARt AA
1) *O ;RV$1 $A4A*
@1O/8-< -8@O ;-CA&
1W P1G*+,6W •a1b*@
S.B@- 1f171A]A ;
CC†1
= AA .AAR;AAW AA/AA21AA@AAAA
C32<$)C -917@CC
†1KE 1 s(-7 A4 2$E A- /$
Archive of SID
www.SID.ir

12. ! ! " #! $%& '()++
7 -A 1F- <A ;A( 1 ,CAA†1A
C R<X ,6Et zBA
g$A9-A@0< A/C ARA4)7 A-
C$1 +2 -O ;O (*&
S3" 8 ' - " T + '!#%"
0 1(AA 2AA2:< AA/>AA/ ?AA$j AA
E ; H8-<GA$W A$ZVAe19A*
C4 $60< /4<A1A90< AA4
OM)j (B$6 ;W /A ,$
W /v1( 2$1 $0 1@C&AMA@7 A <
7 9-7@a1b0 A?-$AA 1
AAA6A0< AA-a1Ab0 AA3-CA&1AAW AAP
E . .C4 $= ;GA (-1A4A:< A/
) 4 2- -$- /MC@A ;0
441a1b0 *C&> ? 6018
21<= .Z t0<47 AAZA t
0< AAAA47 AA9-AA $!7 1? AA ,")AA t1 AA
6 1<60<4$01 tO ;)7 •6A
( -0 *12@E ; HAA B
0 A ; A AA tW$7 A!A V7 A(AAK
0 -@19-0< AA47 A9-7 A0 A
C")0 *1( 19--&A6A7 AA V
C -@7(6- 2E ; HC /
$d d1$(/rHr(* -A-&7 A } 4
AA@AA1 AAE AA 1F-AA+AA -CAA. ./
4 ,W ]$;6ACAA@1Ap
AA0< AA/E ; AAHAA7 AA3-
4)7+ -7C 2W A]A
>V?<0<4tW$7AA-:< A/
E ; H( <B11 2&6W /<
6( -?-O d@}-7 A VA 1F-A
M*CA. ./+A LCA -+ABZA t
[$D4@- 4C* 1$16 1A<ZA t
W$C&C. ./Z tW$D7 (J AA
7 $1 ,7H1;0 *C&U ? (W ]A
<Z tW$$1 270< /4BC. ./
- 21F<77 (C@1B
8( 13 ,) ;4 $${ L L41F-
7CAA&A.(;AA4 K 4A*<$
( 1<6 1) 8B$y1(3)
(?-4)7 $1 ,7 ACA&Š AH7A@7 A
7$7 1GAv<) AZA <
.b$B-&1 <6C16 ;$
| ;0<4(+6):< /A*<$
4 K 4O.;A6AA4 K 4A.(V
*&Ve$1V7@h}-{CA
-$=47C $†}-A-$CA $
{†CAi4 AV7 $1A ,7 A+A -A$
0$12O.;$O.-A0< A/AA&
1W P7 -$I 120 ;W +A(;$1VA*
,- 1@&7 1V*a160A@A$A
+AAB<DAAAA/$CAA( AACAA -)AAAA- 2
O.-121O,c - 1@e 17 +(V@
7C 2A; A-OA.;A 12:< A/v<A4
$0 $-&7 8BC+ -760 A9-
8 @$8- (A $1,AA4 K 4AGA
OAAMAA*&7 AA LAA@AA(/7 AA 8+AA -AA$0$1AA2
^@$7= .0 *-&< e 476.
@`16( -C@A2 AA -7 A<GA
rHƒJ37 ;rAHA6A7 $ A
1@&6 101A4j AHA](A
rAAH7 2 AA- 2AABAA 1AA -&j AA$
- 2 - 2rH1 ,1 stW$6@A- 4
7 AA(AA $CAA$+AA -I AA,8AAH11AA< AA
12&:< /E ; AH+A -j AQ7 A
Archive of SID
www.SID.ir

13. ! ! " #! $%& '() +,
7$7 LC&<}-C*26A*$AA*
@0 9-O.;AA-{ L AL
E 1F-19a1bA*&6 1 AA7 A<
)7$8(- @$rA -A9-$A
C R6J)C 26V@1 $A
$AA=AAd) AA{ L AALAA<E AA 1F-
OO*&
V3"8 IM"Z WT + '
U ?ACAA4 $OA$e1AfCA <
( *14:< /) 4 2/- A$- A -$
W z6a1bC@1Et z
O u8-Oa1CN
23V3*'?[
I 1,0 * a1b6C@[ K-6- 2O
$E 1f1AF- <AAB†CAt zA<
O ?L7 +)AALb 1A*)AL$1A<
I 1,4;16W z]( 4&
93V3%GG'+GG B% GG*GG7" GG#"
T + '
C4 $1F- <A-
W 3|/C*0$<O ?CA4A V
*†1A9 E A?;A6ACAA4 $
- 4C4 $1(*4A ;$(V A]
W 38( /CAA VA- A*A†1A
`36)W zE$4 A6ACAA4 $A
1 AAACAAAAAA4 $AAA ;$(V AAA]CAAA&
C4 $60< /- 2U ?Z `
C7 -$S)C6 H6@r1AA
S<018<A8-O A|A/CAA V
D/ ]< (0 26ACAA0 A -6( 1A2|A/
( AAA1AAA91AAA1AAAKAAA*&1AAAW AAAP
CA4 $A ;ZA <A $AA 1A
C4 $(V ]A <OA /$OA.-E$ A (
C&1F- <7a1:|/C
) V$W1( @1@$<C7
A8-1 2 A B† 1A@A6 A 4y AA7 AA
C4 $= ;G (-0< /4 20 A*1A@&
X ,A$W •AA$OAA8->A A < A -
0 1( 2&
3+ ' Z W " F 7T
(1F-AA)v1 A,W A]A
4Z]1;AE$ A (CA&A6A
) B$1@u0 ,<W ]1 < C $1H
0<$1-- 2A 4OA ;1AA-1 2&
6W ]Ž<A 1F-AAQ A(A
B1-1 2&AV ?CA>A=/ +A6A
W ]Y>AfCAA@<
Z ] /6A1Af(JΠACA&)7 2 A -A8L
O]1A <W A]6 A:< A/A(A <
( --!##"N
g'1Ht%
{'O]#
Œ'C ; O]n
'1 W .( O]€
)W / 6- 4 ]hC ;i=4~ A =A4 $ 7<$
h1Hti$hO]i7 A?(; A cC -
1, )O] $O]C B O C ;&6 } 4
1A W .( O]'7 A CA d OA] 7 A B1 A@
7 -C'W ] 7 7<$ =4 O] G -
E 1F- 1 O / @ - 2)$ ?
C - - O V&A - A( - 6 < B$ 67 A
O dA 1A d A $ A W1A( @ 1 @
! ! ! !
! ! !
! :
! ! )
Archive of SID
www.SID.ir

14. ! ! " #! $%& '()+(
$ W AA] a1AA AA 1 +2 AA- AA( 7 AAAA4 K 4
:< AA/ 7 @ AA- CA OAA ; A 4 AA@ = (A 4
*&<6$0 A, C $1H
] <6 W0 *= * (* 2@
SA $ < 0< / 6- A -1(A3 1 A@&
-0W .(A $ CA V B A; C 6 Z
AA-&AA@ CAA 6AA W .(AA [ AA; 7 AA < AAF
7CA @$1 19 W ] 6 < 1&
@ K- < W / 6 ;W ] 6S.A- A 4 A? B
C - 0 < 8- V $ G&
233<]5
6O]05= FS $; (B@7 $ 1
&? 16O]„ 4^@|/-7$B
1H7 19$@&B(*= A*
@1HtGO]| bCA -&A6AA VA@
16C1AHA1A dABA*&
6 17C 21HtGAOA]A8-CA -&
1AAHtAA 1,1 AAW AA]$8AA*<AA
(1*&1W P`… V$1H
<8POBh1AHtiCA&
]@1 93 ,$ArA1AH<1A9$A
V BW @1H1 dA*< A=A4) 1AH
B -$1 dC&<6 4$0 A- 9-6 1A
$C@1Ht12LGAOA]A 4A @
1W ])C<?(;| b1CA -&
6O]05@O]h1A 1$rAˆ AV?i
1 AAAA1AA$AA./1AA31AAAA4CAA&
1$1O( <+ -1AHtGAOA]
4C&6Š AHA@1AH1A dABA
7 191F- <, -C$<7{ A (B
1@&6B$6I 1,AAA-A@y A
G1HB<1H1A dABCA L†
X ,6AIA 1,7$+A1Ah1AHtiAW A]
1A9= A < -A@A4<1AB7 A
7 3-4&
933<$ " #
AA 17 AA6AAOAA]$OAA]1AAHtOAA]
A/ $AAA*0 $AA-&<1AF-AA 17 AA
)O]8L0<$A8VA ;
O= .C!#n"&
%'7 -?-1H$A1A*A1A9OA
@)#'7 -(<$ $1H$1A*C?A -A
7 191 2 B@)n'7 -A1AHAB
r 1@)€'7 -A-A8-A ?1AH$1A*A
7 19O@)A<$ $1AH$1A*A
7 191 2 B$1*$1HBr 1$
(Q .$VA1A$A -[ A21A&
7 L@F/A) A*6 A $OA]<6AW A]
- 2 8L7 4OA]h1AHtiAA V| AR7
C&
;33<% ^"Y>" 4 #HG
O]C d77 -A7 AA6 1AOA]
K 4[ F-7 -*$&6
O]057 (E 1.Z 1F-C- @C&rA
0 (+<7 -r $$19CA&
0 (+A<7 A -AA VA -CA d7 A
7 -C&? 16)O]8- -4C dE
0$<C P /- -7- 1&6AOA]
AA0< AA/AA47 2 AA- 2AAK 44 AA ,
AA. ;AA,&|AA/6 AA VCAA* -10< AA/
C$) ./V-<6O]C&:< A/
+ -6O]R(@@8- A -A
7 AA ;CAA d)AAAAB1AAAA-1 2&rAAAA- 214
Archive of SID
www.SID.ir

15. ! ! " #! $%& '() +-
E ;*+,$. .7$C AH1Aj1A (
1C d77 -C&6 } 41?6)OA]
< K= 4 J-16 `] .. .
:< AA/AA)1AAAA/Q AA*$AA(/
E - /W•+)= 4$7$B7 3(8-
j HE . .1= 4&
C33<1 #
<j$1O]C d77 -6C@7 A -
O ;$•= f1 2A4U A 1AA<
C&6B*CA@6AOA]AE A]
ŠAAH $1AA$1 AA@1AA:< AA/AA
-4O ;*&6O]- 214=‘
C?AA -AA1AA• AAAA -AAAA @&AA(?AA- 2
( 1,1$=7 AC?A -AW A$A6 - AK
AAAA-1AAF- <AAAAB) AA*$1AAW AA ;
,1(AA 1AA6AAAA84$12+AA -AA 1,OAA]
6C ;hC fi4&
D33> .! "F 7
7$+AA1AAW AA]AA 4) AAW AA]1AA9+AA -
-:< /4O ;A
1 d7O ;*@1<A8-0 A*
= 41@<W A]A 46ACAA@A@
C--K (-G@C -c *E ?;
19)O ;1F- <O ;{W A?-A-&
O]Z VO .(+ -<W ]4C&A
6O]27 197 L(6@@A
7- 2(*&60<<B0< AA4
C@747 2 - 2@`7+ -1
( 12C&7<77 ;O]AM%
A
@&1? A , 6 1A +A - 7 - A!Y"[ A $
;!j"0<4A- A < 6 ?&DA B
- O] @ 77B7 8A@ CA- @ 1A 2 1 $ W A*
9 ! !
6 A L +A - A* 0 A* 7 A C- @ Z 1F- >
0<1A&CA d OA] )CA. ./7 A
A* O] 6 - , 7 -CAA A@A-
4 7 (- @ K 4 [ F-&< 1A9 A
)W ]OA][$+ACA ;U A (/1(A3OM A
S? 1AAAAT1AA$2 AA-<CAA&6AAOAA]05 AA
A ; 1 @ T1 $ 2 -< U 1 >/ ?&
+AA - OAA] 6AA AAAA] AA = AAVAA4
B$ + @`&<1A9W A]) A 4OA]
C 4C -E$ RC&1Z ,6A)OA]
O ;)9-0+AA(J 9-A- ,= .(A&
O][$+BV ?7$1 dAV ?7 A
)O ;$+ -O]B‹ (-A ;GAOA ;+A -<
W ]4*A&OA]1AAOA
1$O]O u4NgAO]+A 41,<
;@‹ (-A 1 d)AL127OA ;< AK
*c{AO]r;@1F- << KCc
6+ K7-ZA <Q A0 (A=4 1A
@&<O]C ]$CM 1+ -7:< A/
OM018A*$E A]AB$
S 1*[<t7@C&
2_37 *^$^"T + ' @ B ` "
232_3Z K*^$^"7
E V bC <bAL<1AF-j AH$AL<
1F-1934$5,AB$CA ;7 AA
1AA&- AA <0 AA27 AA -$0 AA27 AA /$0 AA2
7 4 2C&407 -$7 /$0 27 A4 2+A -
7 V; K@O$Œ<S4 93 <#
$0 28<8-S4 9A3 <A
V b1A-1 2; ! ' ' <&0 A2+A -E AV bA
E ]? @1[ K-1 2&E V bA? @105 A
=! '
Archive of SID
www.SID.ir

16. ! ! " #! $%& '(),.
S0 93 <1 @1(3&E AV b
CAAA <( AAA*|AAA +7- AAA -AAA7 AAA /
4 93 <11^ ;OA VA41Ax A@
W VCA&E AV b) - A -7 A) A
C 1@$C P /- -6 1y AA <
7O ;-&E V bC <( *1A
$E AA- /+AA -<C AA /AA4Y AAAA
1cC05A]A@E A- /u
|AA/= AA3&AA(?AA(/1AA2E AA- /u|AA/
= 3-<=4d dA47 A -A-: A
: *(E A- /a1AbCA&E AV b1A
$E - /0 2d d4C <b+ -a1Ab
*&E V b1$7 4 2+ -,4$
E 1 p`6E V b1$SC <<G$
K (-E . .7 -<19d d4
B( 4@-7A2 A<7CA*2&
7 ,1@u0 ,<d d4$(a1Ab
E V bC <( *b[ A ;$e1A]1AF-<
j HY.0 *= @&@`A= A @A@
6Et z-14- 2| .C <A *
a1b*&A 11A4I4$5A,A](AA
AABAA)CAA 4AAV4 AA ,$7$< 1AA
4 K 4E ]1 2&
932_3*^$^"7= R'K
Et •A[ A;AB (1A4A- 2A34$5,Aj AAH
I4$5,$ 1A7 A -!- A <"W A/AA
]+@1 (CN
gA- <c{A1934$5,cŒAe1[&
AgA7 A LA@= A‡A /$CA /<
C P /$C 1@) - -<A4A
7 -C&0 B4g (JO]rA0 (A
+<7 -@-<C 1@$CA P /- A -
C6- 2I4$5,4B11 2&
Z `C H- 4 21@j HI4$5,1A
) 1A 20 A B<CA ;CA 1@$CA P /- A -
C&6ACA6 A LAfA*A@OA]rA
: (+<7 -HjI4$5,1A7
1… V*c$C V $6CA@e1A]
j HI4$5,1A6( 1A21AAA V: (A
+<$C -&)CA. ./1AAI4$5A,A
[ ;C H)1C* -1IW ;C @ /
@&C d<O]r: (+$C
-06( 12|/{ J(-1$|/6 VCA* -1
$&196J0 9-A@) 1AA= Af0 A-1 2
CAA -$7 1AA91AA$= AAfAAAA-1 2AA1AA
7 } 4+$-7 ;7 -(0 *CA&
6 LC@h1i- 4h’*if0 A*
$/+W+00 *C&AA@
C H- 4 21B$): (+<1A
E AA]AA( 19-CAA&AA(?AAF<AAfAA- 4 2)
E ?;C<4 2O /O uN
gA6@6I4$5,7 A ;- A <A
0 (11 2&
{A6AA@e A4$CAA4 $6A|A .A
AA 1y$4 AA2AA41AAAA$j AA0
*&
ŒA6@LE 1Ab$Ar AA (/|A .
B ($4†
A6@L81.6E 8u J
0 *†C6)W /(/C H- 4 2-A-
< K14- 2$5,341$1AA*&A
]1<A4 (x AAB -A4) A
(/121C? -[ K-7C AH(A*A*&
6 } 41I4$5,4-O: (A+A<
1OA t1A96ACAx AAB -
*&Z( -19Z <834$5,CA <( A*
Archive of SID
www.SID.ir

17. ! ! " #! $%& '() ,)
1$7 -6C@0 A26A8 A- A -
C@j HI4$5,1( 12CA&A6A
+ -C HD/ ]7WU1*†CXA ,
6W •(?CA1A6AA@Ab7 A -A
8AB0 A*<$AbCAAA*
= $-&2-7<6 LAbj A
B1@&1x PG[1_A$7<
GG JCA†AA- 1AA@IAJ
0 * B<7A1AI A <A(A 1
G7IJC0 - 9-6( 1 A,ZAbCA
1B&2-7C 2@1AC?A -
83JB0 *<7ZbCA(A*
*&126 LA*6AE A]I A,<7A@
C H1834$5,yO ;1) 1 2(A
Š f; (BB1@&(?67VC -
@IJB0 *<77 -7 (14A(
1@&^,7 *+,1AF- <A< AK(A -7$ A
C AAHD/ AA][1_AAAAD/ AA]GAA JC?AA -
01AA81AA<7$v $1AA,6 AA B[ AAAA -&
C. ./<7B@Z `Zb16 A B$y A@
)0Z `8)C[ 9 40 (<[1_A$A
G J) 1O fAH$$1AHCA&
AA19AA34$5,AAAAAA(AA*= AA*AA@
834$5,C <) ( *- <87 -CA -
@C ;C <( A*1AcA
1934$5,+ -?-v 11@&E 1b(/@
6CC A$7 AB19A34$5,A 8) A -
Z `8C@BB1A1A 2&
6 11934$5,+ -C?A -AE 1AbA (/
xt$0 2*$x - pI ,4[<t‡A /
($E A]1A 2&0$ A;1A`AE 1Ab
) (/C 1@$C P /- -1934$5,+ -<A B
OM8C@BY11 2&
6 1 AA: (AA+AA<19AA34$5,AA@AAAA-
E AAf- 2 AA- 28AA34$5,AA ;$05 AA
E AA. .AAE AA]1AA 21AAF- <AA
jCA&7$+A1A- A <$)19A34$5,e1A
+ -E A. .AAA-a1Ab
*&1W PM<O ??*) <W A.(-
6 B$xt ]OMU 1A:< A/$7 9(A
CAA A@ A 1 7 AA ; A +A - AA A $ - A <
4 $I <A I4$5, $C VAH$ 1A A-
A * 1p• 8-A-1 2 1A AB A&x A
CAA 48AA34$5,$E AA3 <AA$CAA
4 $6(*<GA1A$S ACA <
) - -- A /$4 A 21 p`AAA2$<A
19-2 -<; (B7 -|A ; A A
C1 p`1A4&<6 A 4$A(/1A2) - A <
C H- 4 21;(**$6@x
- <7 -* ?-)- A -A*A@ACA ;
[ AADAA- B(q AA /$AA- 4 2I4$5AA,C@1AA*
0 AA -) AA*7 AA<AA7 AA6AA$6AA@
)I4$5,U1*[<tA$-U1A*A@'1AA
7O ;C&
*6''K
8( 13 ,;13:< /7 -
1] V7 }--40CAA@=A3L< A-
6 1$6 ;W /=<1A$$1A
4&16CA@1/= AF;) A ;7 A -<
G< -W1A( @ACA$<A1A9
Π(I/$&1 2 @4 K 4
]@A (?1AZA 1F-A)e A*) A@
)=K)O @)0;$E) ?8 B$
6 ;W /7[ +(-$*A-<
G7 -7 ;CA dE AA@1A4A- 2
Archive of SID
www.SID.ir

18. ! ! " #! $%& '(),/
0 (+<$xjCAACA /
14$<19[ F-V ?7 8B$C 8-
E /- -<1bj -469-&
6 L1F-=A4ZAW1A( @$A8A41b
AA* -<C 1AA3 ,AA ;AAAA*$=AA4AA1AA
4 ($834$5,GA7 A1 A$
I4&<6$< -A[ AF-A
@:< /[ A9 4$0 1A 4AEt A
;VA$A @)7 19A34$5,)7 +2 A@
C)7 2= F0 @$W V(: @60< /<
C V- -*-8GE $1H; (BC
@G< -/$17 -*&
" $ +N
A 4 < A 1 A3 $ • _AA3-
$ A . 6 - < 1 8 - = / { B
- ; E 1@7 *< 1[&
0 ! > $ ? 2 ! )> ! !>
! ! ) 2 ! (
) # @2 555A " 5
? > & ) # @2
555
n'- $ = ; E 7 @&
: *)B 66“" B&
0 !( > > , & CD E
! !C ! / ! !
# # @2 66 A
& % ' $ ( > ? ! !
54 A 4.
" ) !! D ! 0 1 ! =! '
!> ! , > &> 0 !(
# > ! ! () # @2
555A .
k')&E / |/&E . . K
./(38 8* 0 93-)0 *n#'n%$ + , )
7 ( <%nm‚'%nkl&
m')&[1B |/ 6 B S.&
6(0 * ) 6 : 34$5, < - $ OPo%)
0 u%nm%
5 $ $ 3 ( ! ! ! !> ! , >
& > 0 !( ! ! # # @ !
66 A 5 6
6 / ! !( & ! # !( > $ !
$ ! ! + ! #
' ) / !> 55.
& % 9 ) )E !
! !( % ! 55.A >
"6
# !> ! > ! ,
& > 0 !( / ! ! #
# @2 66 A 5 "
, ! = 2 ! > ! ? !
> ! ) ? =! + 2 F @>
& ! $ 2> 5" A 5
# > / !
# 31 -! ' ) >
31 55 A .
G !! & > ' ! ! )> !
& ( ? ) 66 A .
%•')&M E 1F-
- ) ./: *#l8 )%nm%&
. & $ ! > !
, > & > 0 !( / ! ! #
# @2 666A 46 4"
4 # ) % ! $ > !
66 A . .5
5 0 > ! ? & *
666A
6 ! ) * > -! ' )
> * 0 54
# ) # $ ( ! ! # > ! , >
& > 0 !(( # @2 66 A
5
# > / 55 A 6 5"
H !@ ! D > !( 2 / + % >
! & 5. A .
Archive of SID
www.SID.ir