This is presentation for Journal

1. Praptono Nugroho
NIM : 03120062
Implementation of Design and Build on Development
Bali Maritime Tourism Hub (BMTH) in Port of Benoa
Ronny Durrotun Nasihien, ST.,MT
NIDN : 0720127002

2. “Research steps to analyze technically about choosing the right type
contract of work according to the perception of the owner of the job
using Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) method”
Why this is
important…?
This project is one of the efforts to support government programs related to
economic equality, reducing development gaps and inequality in Indonesia,
and increasing trade in Eastern Indonesia
1
2 Choosing the right type of contract is one of the most important managerial
decisions because it has a direct impact on the success of project as it affects
performance indicators such as cost, quality, times and job safety
To find out what the main factors to choose the type of contract
3

3. Over View
ZONA
PERIKANAN
ZONA YACHT
TERMINAL
ZONA
PARIWISAT
A
ZONA CURAH
CAIR DAN
PETIKEMAS
DUMPING I PELABUHAN
BENOA EKSISTING
BALI
TENTEN
MELASTI
TAMAN DANU
KERTHI
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aVNMBbe-xZ0&t=7s

4. What the best type of contract for
deliver oof developed Bali
Maritime Touris Hub (BMTH)
project according to the
perception of the owner?
Research Variable
Variabel bebas (Independent
Variable)
1. Compleks of project
2. Urgent of project
3. The major criteria
influencing
Time
Cost
Quality
Desain Bid
Build
Desain And
Build
Desain And
Managemnet
Variabel terikat ( Dependent
Variable)
Choosing the right type of
contract is one of the most
important managerial decisions
because it has a direct impact on the
success of project as it affects
performance indicators such as cost,
quality, times and job safety

5. Methodology
Contract type selection
Problems
Determination of Criteria
Presentation of calculation
results and discussion
Begin
Study of literature
Criteria Assessment AHP Method
Expert
Finished
Data collection:
1. Primary Data : 2. Secondary Data :
- Interview result - Port master plan data
- Questionnaire result - Development plan data

6. Selecting Criteria
Resume criteria for selecting the type of contract
according to the reference : Grouping the results of previous research :
“These criteria will be used as a
questionnaire to experts”
Cost
uncertainty
Technical
uncertainty
Scope
uncertainty
Process
Uncertainty
Budget
availability
Backup
Availability
Resource
Long
Term
Goals
Critical
schedule
Performance
Claim
Contractor
Difficulty
Technology
Risk
Allocation
Political
factor
Hosseini et al., (2016) X X X X X X X
Kardila & Ranggadara,
(2020)
X X X X
Antoniou et al., (2012) X X X X X X X X X
Antoniou et al., (2013) X X X X X X X X X
Moon et al., (2011) X X X X X
Mahdi & Alreshaid, (2005) X X X X X X X X X X X
Barati et al., (2015) X X X X X X X X X X X
Setiawan, (2005) X X X X X X
Abed, (2015) X X X X X X X X X X X X X X
Ahmed & El-Sayegh,
(2021)
X X X X X X X X X
Bhakti et al., (2013) X X X X
Fauziyah et al., (2016) X X X X X X
Suryadinata Hartono,
(2016)
X X X X X X
DBIA, (2015) X X X X X X X X
Group Scope
Technical
Aspects
Technical uncertainty, Scope uncertainty,
Process Uncertainty, Performance,
Technology.
Financial
Aspects
Cost uncertainty , Budget availability ,
Backup Availability Resource
Legal
Aspects
Political factor
Project
Schedule
Long Term Goals , Critical schedule ,
Contractor Difficulty
Risk Claim, Risk Allocation
Criteria
Reference

7. AHP Processes
1
Make hierarchy
tree
Pairwise Comparison
2 3
Eigen vector (Ev)
4
Consistency
1. Maksimun Eigen
Value (MEV)
2. Consistency Index
(CI)
3. Consistency Ratio
(CR)
5
Global
Priority
CR < 0,1
Yes
No CR > 0,1
Expert profile (25 expert)
Experiences
Expert

8. Contract type selection
Technical
Aspect
23.34 %
Financial
Aspect
15.79 %
Legal
Aspect
26.90 %
Project
schedule
13.83 %
Desain – Bid – Build
Contract
26.42 %
Desain and Build Contract
50.12 %
Risk
Aspect
20.14 %
Desain and Management
Contract
23.45 %
Result
The results are then compared with the data
from interviews where most of the expert
explained that the biggest issues that often
occur at project sites are social, political,
legal and technical Issues. From this it can
be concluded that the assessment or
research carried out can describe the
owner’s perception regarding the
implementation of work at that location
Consistensi Ratio (CR)
CR =
CI , RI =1.12 (of Satty table)
RI
CR = 0.091
CR < 0,1
Yes

9. Thank You