SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 14
Download to read offline
BlackwallPartners
How to ride a CAMEL… March 1, 2011
“Banks have more capital as a percentage of assets since anytime since 1934”
- Dick Bove, veteran bank observer
CAMEL Race…
The financial crisis ended some time ago and the
U.S. economy has entered a new “golden age” for
financial equities not unlike the post Savings &
Loan Crisis (“SLC”) two decades ago. As we have
noted in our prior research, the recent financial
crisis was grossly exaggerated via a number of
contributing factors. Factors which have positioned
the current recovery in financials to perhaps be even
more powerful than the recovery experienced in the
nineties. The implementation of new accounting
rules (“mark-to-market”) in 2007-2008 resulted in a
“front-loading” or over-statement of the credit
problems this cycle, which has resulted in record
excess capital and reserve builds. These stores of
excessive capital and liquidity are the largest in
history and will need to be deployed in the coming
years. We anticipate this will usher-in the most
aggressive wave of capital reinvestment that U.S.
financial industry has ever deployed and
investors will be the direct beneficiaries.
Investors should recognize similar dynamics in
financial stocks today to what one would have
witnessed in the sector from 1990 to 1998. This post
SLC period was a time of stabilization,
recapitalization and re-growth in financial industry
net credit revenue as well as in earnings and book
values. This drove a substantial rally in the sector
(See Chart- top right).
The accompanying valuation table (See Chart- page
right) outlines the dramatic discounts in the
valuations of many high profile financial firms. By
our estimates, leading financial firms are priced at
<3x cash flow; 30% below equity plus adjusted loan
loss reserves; and many are currently trading at
below their net cash-on-hand.
Post S&L Crisis - Rally in Financials
0%
100%
200%
300%
400%
500%
600%
700%
800%
900%
November 1990 - April 1998
S&P Financials
S&P 500
Source: Thompson Reuters
Valuations are Absurd!
Price
Book
Value
Adj
Book1
PTPP2
Price/Adj
Book
Price/
PTPP
JP Morgan $42 $41 $51 $13 82% 3.2x
Wells Fargo 31 24 30 8 100 3.7
Citigroup 5 7 8 2 63 2.5
PNC Fin. 61 63 71 17 86 3.6
BankofAmerica 13 27 31 6 42 2.2
Capital One 42 57 66 16 64 2.6
Regions Fin. 7 11 13 3 54 2.8
Average 70% 2.9x
1
Stated book value plus loan loss reserve drawn down to 1% of loans
with excess taxed at 40% tax rate through 2012 estimated earnings
2
Pre-tax, pre-provision net earnings at normalized credit loss
provision rate
Source: Thompson Reuters
2
Anatomy of Under Ownership
SEC filings by large funds indicate that portfolio
managers are grossly under invested in U.S.
financial stocks. In part, we believe this is
attributable to the struggle and hesitancy that
generalists have with the complexities of financial
firm accounting. Naturally, a factor greatly
exacerbated by the financial crisis and reflected in
the ‘jaw-dropping’ valuations previously shown.
Again, this mirrors what we saw coming out of the
SLC.
Extreme under weights in portfolios and
subsequent low valuations now place financials
at their lowest weighting in the S&P 500 in
nearly forty years. The financial sector,
excluding insurers, currently represents only 9%
of the S&P 500, yet is responsible for more than
1/3 of the earnings or economic contribution to
the S&P. It’s simply a blinding fundamental
disconnect.
This marked inefficiency also is evident in
valuations where we calculate the typical larger
U.S. bank trading at 3x free cash flow (“PTPP”),
while the S&P 500 trades closer to 11x cash flow.
This is despite the fact that non- financial firms are
more heavily CapEx intensive and therefore
arguably less “free.” The historic relative multiple
of cash flow for financials relative to the broader
market ranges from 60% to 80% versus today’s
27% [3x / 11x = 27%]. Therefore, both the
absolute values across financials as well as their
relative valuation signal an historic under
valuation opportunity.
A good example of current market disequilibrium
can be found amongst the largest mutual funds. Our
review of SEC filings indicate that a large
(unnamed) Fidelity Investments fund is carrying
twice the S&P 500’s weighting in industrial
materials stocks; less than one-third the weight in
technology; half the weight of consumer services;
and half the already well below normal weight of
financial services. This is astonishing empirically
on several levels. For starters, the U.S. economy is
approximately 85% services related as we are a
services and information technology-driven
economy; not an industrial/manufacturing driven
one. There is nothing wrong with such a fund
weighting per se. In fact, it’s the most common
weighting (by sector) among funds where we
canvassed their regulatory filings. Clearly, the
aforementioned fund’s management team believes
that they see more opportunity in the copiously
heavy industrial and commodity-laden emerging
markets than in any potential recovery in America.
Undoubtedly, this is a sizable bet on a continued
global disequilibrium. However, inferential
statistics and the inevitable reversion to the mean
greatly favor a more dominant domestic services
sector recovery as it has for economic cycles over
the past 40 years. So, the “mechanics” of a
sustained advance in domestic financial and
services economy stocks is in place, in part,
because nobody owns them and Americans have
forgotten what we do best.
Under ownership and subsequent depressed
multiples in the financials are despite tremendous
improvement in credit (the main driver of earnings
recovery) and earnings visibility. This is in addition
to the industry sitting atop record levels of both
liquidity and capital, the driver of earnings
acceleration.
Estimated Earnings Growth
Sector 4Q10 2010 2011
Consumer Discretionary 13% 44% 15%
Consumer Staples 2% 6% 11%
Energy 25% 49% 14%
Financials >200% 158% 37%
Health Care 5% 10% 7%
Industrials 10% 24% 18%
REITs 7% 6% 1%
Technology 13% 41% 10%
Telecom 13% 0% 13%
Utilities -3% 4% -1%
S&P 5003
12% 28% 9%
3
Excludes financials
Source: Thompson Reuters
As we have referenced in recent musings, the table
above illustrates that the financials have the
strongest prospects for earnings growth over the
next several years. In addition to growth, higher
3
“visibility” will be present due to clear credit cost
abatement. This makes the dramatic and ubiquitous
under-weight of the financial sector via fund
managers all the more curious to even the most
casual market observer…disconnects often are.
Credit abatement will drive initial out sized
growth - While securitized loans across all credit
types were mauled by M2M inaccuracies, banks
with more traditional “portfolio” lending or “whole
loan” accounting also were trampled inefficiently as
the credit panic overshot reality.
The accompanying chart courtesy of the Federal
Reserve Bank of St. Louis illustrates the “real” peak
in problem loans. And though potentially
startling to some, this most recent credit cycle
has produced non-performing loans peaking at
70% of the SLC. Thus, it was an unnecessary
panic in 2007-2009. The resulting excessive build-
up of capital and reserves now is a benefit to
financial stock investors.
Nonperforming Loans4
4
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis study of all U.S. commercial
banks; Loans past due 90 days plus nonaccrual loans to total loans.
Source: Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis
The following chart (top right) illustrates the
excessive levels of capital and reserve builds
generated as a function of the traditional capital and
reserve over-builds that typically accompany any
credit crisis.
Common Tier 1 Capital (“CT1”) is
Inordinately High for U.S. Banks
0%
2%
4%
6%
8%
10%
12%
14%
16%
18%
AXP STT NTRS C KEY PNC STI USB RF WFC BAC JPM COF
CT1 less Buybacks CT1
B3M5
= Basel III Minimum risk-based capital standard expected to
be implemented by a global regulators roundtable known as the Basel
Committee on Banking Supervision.
Source: Company reports; Blackwall Partners LLC estimates
US banks hold capital levels that materially exceed
even the future expected higher minimums for “well
capitalized” institutions (See above: B3M5
).
International bank regulators are debating these
levels in the Basel III accords (not expected to be
implemented until at least 2020 BTW).
The perception by many is that U.S. banks are ill-
prepped for B3M and this is patently false. Of
course, we also recently saw a Rasmussen poll that
suggested most Americans were unaware that the
United States was the largest economy in the world,
let alone three times the size of the second largest.
So, it would appear there is plenty of room for folks
that do fundamental research to find market
dislocations.
B3M5
4
1.5%
2.0%
2.5%
3.0%
3.5%
4.0% 1Q09
2Q09
3Q09
4Q09
1Q10
2Q10
3Q10
4Q10e
1Q11e
2Q11e
3Q11e
4Q11e
1Q12e
Net Charge-Offs6
6
Morgan Stanley bank research coverage universe; average net-charge-offs to
average loans
Source: Morgan Stanley & Company
We anticipate material improvement in credit in
2011 and near zero credit costs in 2012 (See-
above). We fully expect to see banks and other
financial firms continue to “release” excess loan
loss reserves back into their earnings at an
accelerated pace in 2011-2014. In addition to
providing significant earnings re-acceleration, this
makes substantial capital available for
dividends, stock buy-backs and acquisitions,
which will help drive-up valuation multiples. The
combination of a strong rise in earnings coupled
with multiple-expansion is the same recipe that
drove the material outperformance for financials in
the post SLC period.
That being noted, how does Blackwall Partners
analyze and value financial firms? What gives
us the “edge” that drives our confidence that we
not only are correct on the fundamentals, but
can move-in early on opportunities? We ride a
slightly different looking horse.
How to ride a CAMEL
Blackwall Partners relies more heavily on financial
regulatory reporting or (RAAP) much more so
than generally accepted accounting principles
known as GAAP. RAAP reports provide to bank
regulators more granular information, which we use
for our proprietary safety and soundness rating
system. This is integral in Blackwall’s selection
process of traditional financial stocks.
$0
$50
$100
$150
$200
$250
Pre-Tax, Pre-Provision
Pre-Tax GAAP
Bank Earnings “Power” v. GAAP
Widest on Record (1980-Present)
Mark-to-Market Accounting
Overstatement
of Losses
Source: Keefe, Bruyette & Woods; Blackwall Partners LLC
In prior writings, we have referenced the chart
above as it speaks volumes relating to this most
recent financial crisis. The chart tracks reported
earnings (GAAP) versus RAAP’s pre-tax, pre-
provision (“PTPP”) or “free cash flow” from 1980-
2010. The dramatic gap in recent years between the
black and blue lines illustrates the reality of the
“non-cash hole” that mark-to-market accounting
(GAAP) blew through the earnings (and capital) of
financial firms during the financial crisis. This also
illustrates the inevitable earnings reacceleration
that we not only can predict, but guarantee. It is
RAAP after-all that the Federal Reserve used to
“stress test” the banks in 2009 under the
Supervisory Capital Assessment Program
(“SCAP”).
This is the very same test the Fed is performing
right now to determine which banks can start
returning excess capital to investors. The “test”
criteria studies five core fundamental factors from
which it gets its acronym – CAMEL
C - Capital Adequacy
A - Asset Quality
M - Management
E - Earnings
L - Liquidity
5
For partners and prospective investors to get a more
thorough understanding of how Blackwall evaluates
potential investments, we illustrate a few examples
of the CAMEL process.
Disclosure: Blackwall Partners LLC chose the
institutions outlined here randomly to show a range
between the controversial to the beloved and how our
use of CAMEL is applied consistently therein. This is
NOT necessarily a representation of the portfolio. The
information is used exclusively for informational
purposes only.
Fifth-Third Bancorp (FITB)
Capital Adequacy
CT1 at 7.5% already exceeds the expected
B3M minimum to rank as “well capitalized”
of 7% and could be as much as 150bp above
this level.
Equally as important, FITB’s CT1 is
steadily growing and will significantly
exceed B3M long before any new standards
are implemented
6.8
7.0
7.2
7.4
1Q10 2Q10 3Q10 4Q10
Common Tier 1 Capital (%)
Source: FITB Corporate Reports
9.4% Tier 1 risk-based capital exceeds
regulatory “well capitalized” by over 50%;
9.7% Tier 1 under B3M tops all regional
bank peers
Capital levels which are strong and rising
are supplemented by high loan loss reserve
levels near 4% which cover current non-
performing loan levels by roughly 1.8x
FITB repaid TARP in full to the U.S.
Treasury in February 2011 and completed a
successful follow-on equity offering
Asset Quality
Severe delinquent loans have fallen by 72%
since 3Q09 and net-charge-offs have fallen
below 2% in 4Q10 for the first time since
before the financial crisis. Early-stage
delinquencies have dropped below 1% for
the first time since 2007. So, we have passed
the peak in problem loans at FITB
Early Stage Delinquency (%)7
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
3Q07 1Q08 3Q08 1Q09 3Q09 1Q10 3Q10
FITB Peers
7
Loans 30-89days past due
Source: FITB Corporate Reports
New nonaccrual loans have fallen by nearly
50% between 1Q09 and 4Q10. They have
steadily declined for five consecutive
quarters and 4Q10 additions represented just
0.6% of total loans
The loan loss reserve (LLR) covers non-
performing loans (NPLs) now by
approximately 200% and PTPP (cash flow)
covers NPLs by 1.6x. So, FITB has returned
to cash flow growth since 1Q10-2Q10 and is
comfortably absorbing remaining loan loss
recognitions
6
0
25
50
75
100
125
150
175
4Q09 1Q10 2Q10 3Q10 4Q10
PTPP/ NCOs (%)
Source: FITB Corporate Reports
Overall, NPLs have declined by 43% since
4Q09
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4Q09 1Q10 2Q10 3Q10 4Q10
NPLs / Loans (%)
Source: FITB Corporate Reports
CT1 plus LLR at 12.3% is the second largest
among FITB’s regional bank peer group
Mortgage repurchase claims represent <1%
of loans and the repo reserve of 63% greatly
exceeds any risk, even if required to buy-in
the loans (assumes all repo claims valid and
home loan-to-value is 63%)
Per regulatory bank exams; the total
regulatory criticized assets (“substandard” or
“doubtful”) are down 16% in 2010 and
represent 6% of existing loans, however
only 0.3% represent a “doubtful” regulatory
classification. This suggests that bank
examiners are just being overly persnickety,
sighting few losses (“doubtful”) but higher
levels of scrutiny (“substandard”); overall
indicative of FITB having been “scrubbed”
Management
The historically stalwart FITB, which once
coveted the highest valuation ratios among
any of the major banks, stumbled in this
recent credit mess
The company has since re-tooled its risk
appetite and accomplished a great deal in a
relatively short time. All signs pointing
toward a clear recovery are underway
But, they are on notice from investors to
keep moving in its current highly positive
fundamental trajectory or we would
anticipate that FITB would get acquired in
the coming M&A cycle
Earnings
FITB has returned to profitability quite
quickly with three consecutive quarters of
reported profits (though free cash flow has
been positive now for five quarters)
The return on assets (ROA) reached 1.2% in
4Q10. This remains subdued due to
excessive liquidity and remaining loan loss
recognition
The 4Q10 return on equity (ROE) was 10%
or equally unacceptable if the stock should
attain its once high valuation among its
peers again
Increasingly both the ROA and ROE will
require significant redeployment of excess
liquidity and capital into an economic
recovery. The evidence would now suggest
that both are highly likely; PTPP as a
percentage of risk-weighted assets rose to
2.3% in 4Q10. This demonstrates the
improving ROA and ROE to come or to be
monetized by an acquirer
7
Liquidity
FITB is awash in liquidity
The loan-to-deposit ratio has fallen to 94%
meaning the bank is under “lent out”; 88%
of FITB’s deposits are cheap “core” funding
or non-time related; deposit growth is
double digits while loan growth is just
starting to turn up slightly
FITB’s balance sheet now carries more net
cash and cash equivalents than market value
Conclusion – 1 2 3 2 1 / Overall 2
With improving fundamentals across all categories,
we rank FITB with an overall CAMEL rating of 2.
This clearly is not reflected in the stock’s current
depressed valuations including but not limited to a
mere 4x run-rate free cash flow (PTPP); 1x book
value (which assumes no franchise value or
“deposit premium”); and 7.8x our 2012 reported
earnings estimate.
At 1x book (<1x forward book value), FITB trades
with no franchise value. For example, with
approximately $90 billion in core deposits and
applying a reasonable private market value
premium of 15%; FITB is intrinsically worth as
much as $29 per share or 109% above prevailing
market...and this assumes no future growth.
If FITB remains independent, we anticipate $2.50 in
EPS by 2013 and a $38 stock price discounted in
advance.
Recent prevailing market for the shares is $13-$14
per share.
Capital One Financial (COF)
Capital Adequacy
CT1 at 8.8% greatly exceeds the SCAP
minimum and illustrates why COF was
among the first banks to repay TARP in full
in the spring of 2009. COF’s ability to
generate excess capital internally has
facilitated the maintenance of very high
capital ratios throughout the crisis
Strong Capital Generation
Source: COF Corporate Reports
CTI plus LLR is 13.2% or among the
highest of any consumer-heavy bank, while
COF’s ability to “cash flow” credit costs due
to high yield assets differentiates the
company from the ‘garden variety’ bank
8
Asset Quality
Credit improvement continues to ‘front-run’
broader economic indicators as net charge-
offs (NCOs) have rapidly declined
Domestic Credit Card (%)
Source: COF Corporate Reports
International Credit Card (%)
Source: COF Corporate Reports
Earliest stage delinquencies in the highest
risk (unsecured) credit card portfolios also
are declining rapidly, forecasting continued
material lower credit costs for COF in the
coming quarters/years despite perceived
risks to persistent high unemployment
Commercial Real Estate (%)
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
3Q09 4Q09 1Q10 2Q10 3Q10 4Q10
NPAs
NCOs
Source: COF Corporate Reports
As a regional commercial bank, COF is also
seeing steady improvement in commercial
real estate credit
Net Charge-Offs (%)
Source: COF Corporate Reports
COF also is experiencing low credit costs
which have improved and are now stable in
both mortgages and auto lending as well
Management
COF has among the most well respected
management teams in the financial industry;
the firm is a perennial member of
FORTUNE’s best companies to work for
CEO takes all of his compensation in stock
and the senior management team also takes
a substantial portion of their compensation
in company stock
9
Took a fledgling credit card business of a
small Virginia bank (Signet) and created one
of the world’s five largest credit card firms
with global branding
Earnings
COF is among the most profitable banks in
the world due, in large part, to being very
adept at underwriting high yield credit
(credit cards). The bank’s net interest
margin has consistently been twice that of
its regional banking peers
Net Interest Margin (%)
Source: COF Corporate Reports
COF’s strong and consistent PTPP enables it
to absorb credit storms with greater ease
than traditional banks. Also, the bank is
among the first to see earnings re-accelerate
in an economic recovery as a result of its
high, price inelastic earning asset yields
Liquidity
Like most of its peers, COF has more
liquidity than would be normal given the
economic environment we are exiting;
COF’s cash and equivalents represent nearly
30% of the bank’s assets
A consistent shift to lower costs and core
funding also has positioned COF in a
uniquely strong position coming out of this
crisis; the loan-to-deposit ratio is 100%
(unlevered) and COF’s blended cost of
funding has fallen to as low as 1.5% in 4Q10
COF currently has more net cash and
equivalents than market value
Conclusion – 1 1 1 1 1 / Overall 1
Like a slot machine hitting all cherries, we rate COF
an across the board CAMEL 1 with no regulatory
fundamental weaknesses in our view. And COF is
witnessing improved fundamentals across each of
these categories.
The disconnect between the fundamentals and the
current valuation are stark with COF.
In addition to trading below net cash-on-hand, COF
currently trades hands at just 2.5x free cash flow
(PTPP); <70% of book value (which assumes no
franchise value or “deposit premium”); and 7.0x our
2012 reported earnings estimate, which we believe
is quite conservative.
A 15x P/E multiple on 2012-2013 earnings per
share of $8 renders a target price of $120 or 2.5x
prevailing market prices.
Citigroup (C)
Capital Adequacy
CT1 is now the highest among ALL multi-
national banks in the world at 11% or nearly
60% higher than the rumored Basel III
minimum for “well capitalized” and 78%
above the SCAP test level
1
3
5
7
9
11
2007 2008 2009 2010
CT1 (%)
Source: Citigroup Corporate Reports
10
CT1 plus its loan loss reserve (LLR) makes
C the most heavily capitalized large bank in
the world
CT1 plus LLR (%)
Source: Citigroup Corporate Reports
Asset Quality
C has started to “release” reserves as mark-
downs on assets via M2M accounting rules
in 2008-2009 proved to be far too large and
resulted in a loan loss reserve over-build
1.5
2.5
3.5
4.5
5.5
6.5
7.5
2007 2008 2009 1Q10 2Q10 3Q10 4Q10
LLR (%)
Source: Citigroup Corporate Reports
Consequently, the managed loan loss
provision is steadily declining, fueling C’s
(surprising to some) profits recovery
5
10
15
2007 2008 2009 2010
Managed Credit Costs $B
Source: Citigroup Corporate Reports
C’s problem portfolio was in residential
mortgages (of course) and a large part of the
improving credit and falling credit costs
story is the “run-off” in the levered
mortgage portfolio
North America EOP Mortgages $B
Source: Citigroup Corporate Reports
C now has repositioned itself into two
companies – CitiFinancial, which looks like
a levered bond hedge fund (which is in run-
off), and the other entity which is the old
core “Citibank”; both entities are seeing
excessive reserve builds into peak credit
losses, putting the former behind the
company and the latter back into focus for
global “core” banking growth
11
Management
This is likely the most controversial issue at
present. We believe management has done a
very good job of re-tooling itself and has the
right talent to run the old new “Citibank”
Equally critical, we are very impressed with
additions to C’s board of directors which
have taken place post-financial crisis which
nearly crippled the franchise (and should
have); for example, we like the addition of
our old friend Jerry Grundhofer to the
Citibank board; Jerry made us money at
both Cincinnati’s Star Bank as well as thru
his great success at putting together a top
tier franchise in US Bancorp (USB)
Should the current senior management not
deliver on the promise of this franchise, we
believe the right person to step-up already is
in place. This gives us uber confidence in
Citi’s leadership relative to the generally
pessimistic investor perceptions
Earnings
A discussion of C isn’t complete without
acknowledging its unmatched global
presence, a strength of past management and
a focus on the current leadership
Global Banking by Region
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
EEMA
Latin America
Asia
North America
Source: Citigroup Corporate Reports
C’s earnings power across multiple
geographies is incredible and cannot be
easily replicated by any bank globally
International Banking Growth
95
105
115
125
135
145
155
4Q08
1Q09
2Q09
3Q09
4Q09
1Q10
2Q10
3Q10
4Q10
Loans
Deposits
Source: Citigroup Corporate Reports
While C’s international bank continues to
grow rapidly, its U.S. bank has turned the
corner and thus the realization of a very
substantial earnings turnaround is
developing quickly as domestic credit
expenses continue declining
Revenue Stability $B
Source: Citigroup Corporate Reports
5
10
15
2007 2008 2009 2010
Managed Credit Costs $B
Source: Citigroup Corporate Reports
12
-20
-10
0
10
2007 2008 2009 2010
Net Income $B
Source: Citigroup Corporate Reports
With C’s international bank continuing to
grow; overall corporate revenue remains
stable and strong. With credit costs falling
C’s earnings power rises very quickly; the
current run-rate cash flow (PTPP) exceeds
analysts estimates for reported earnings this
coming year by 150%
Liquidity
C too is awash in liquidity
Loans-to-deposits at 72% reflect C being
grossly under loaned. This signals a large
opportunity in C for strong earning asset
growth into an economic recovery
C also has more net cash-on-hand than
market value by almost two-fold
Conclusion – 1 2 2 2 1 / Overall 2
With improving fundamentals across all categories,
we rate C an overall CAMEL 2.
So how this conclusion washes with C’s current
depressed stock price is a question for psychologists
perhaps. This is a stock trading at half its net cash-
on-hand; a mere 2.5x run-rate free cash flow
(PTPP); and half its book value (no franchise value
for this global juggernaut?)
We see this as a $12 stock inside of a few years.
__________________________________________
JP Morgan (JPM)
Capital Adequacy
CT1 of 9.8% is well above the current
regulatory minimum for “well capitalized”
and JPM is already at the pro forma B3M
CT1 “well capitalized” threshold years
before its potential implementation
The addition of a loss coverage ratio of
4.5% (of loans) creates an incredibly strong
double digit “risk buffer” of nearly 15%
JPM carries a global liquidity reserve of
over $260 billion or >22% of total risk-
weighted assets; amazing
Therefore, JPM enjoys enormous capital and
liquidity strength for a large, multi-national
bank; internal CT1 capital generation is near
10% annually
Asset Quality
Loan loss reserve at a strong 190% of
nonperforming loans already has started to
come down as the level of problem loans has
peaked and has begun to decline noticeably
Huge Reserve Coverage $B
Source: JP Morgan Corporate Reports
Early-Stage delinquency also showing clear
signs of “post peak” for this credit cycle and
this bodes well for more of JPM’s excess
LLR to be “released” back into reported
capital (book value). We calculate JPM’s
13
book value to be understated by a
conservative $10 to $12 per share or 20%-
25%
Early-Stage Delinquency $B
Source: JP Morgan Corporate Reports
Management
Known as the “second Federal Reserve”
during the financial crisis (aiding in the
unwinding of rivals Bear Stearns, Lehman
Bros. and Washington Mutual); we believe
JPM’s management team has more than
proven itself
“Scarlet Letters” and “Half Bankers; Half
Lawyers” are the persnickety words of a
very high quality management team just
frustrated with the government and
investors; JPM’s management team has
earned the right to shout loudly at both
Earnings
The acquisition of Washington Mutual alone
adds huge earnings power to JPM as they
acquired the beleaguered bank at “fire sale”
prices including massive discounts on
troubled assets
JPM remained profitable throughout the
crisis and throws-off the largest free cash
flow (PTPP) among any multi-national
bank. The current run-rate (PTPP) represents
almost 30% of the market value of the stock
which also is the book value; astonishing
JPM recorded record revenue in 2010, up
15% from the prior year while expenses rose
only 2%. This illustrates the profit
scalability of this impressive multi-strategy
financial franchise
Reported earnings in core commercial
banking rose nearly 100% in 2010 and the
return on common equity (ROE) already is
back to 16% with huge excess liquidity and
capital which is yet to be redeployed into
higher return investments
Further earnings power is demonstrated in
JPM’s “league table” position in investment
banking - #1 in global investment banking
fees; #1 in global debt and equity
underwriting; and #1 in global loan
syndication. Yet, despite leading the league,
JPM’s average market share is under 10% in
total investment banking globally, thus
significant market share opportunity remains
Liquidity
With a liquidity reserve equal to >20% of
risk-weighted assets and twice common
equity capital, JPM is inordinately liquid
JPM also holds net cash 1.5x that of its
market value and the loan-to-deposit ratio is
a materially under loaned out 66%
JPM’s biggest problem is that it is too
liquid, a classic “high class” problem to
have
Conclusion – 1 1 1 1 1 / Overall 1
With strong fundamentals and excess capacity
across all categories from capital to credit to
earnings power and liquidity, we rate JPM a
CAMEL 1.
How the stock of this impressive franchise trades
hands at approximately 3x run-rate free cash flow
(PTPP); below net cash-on-hand; and at book value
is inexplicable.
14
We expect investors will look back at these
valuations and wonder why they didn’t take more
advantage…
To be conservative, we see at least $8 per share in
EPS by 2013-2014. At 80% of the long-term
market multiple (well deserved), we believe that
this is a $120 stock inside of two years
The untapped historic capital, liquidity and earnings
power of the U.S. financial industry coupled with
near all-time low absolute and relative valuations is
excessive “dry powder” for the sector’s out-
performance.
When considering the recent macro events in the
Middle East, we would anticipate that any tailing-
off of these global headwinds would again be a
“green light” for financials to move aggressively
higher.
It’s all there in the CAMELs. It’s just a matter of
time.
Regards,
Michael P. Durante
Managing Partner
Blackwall Partners LLC

More Related Content

What's hot

Michael Durante Western Reserve Blackwall Partners 1Q12
Michael Durante Western Reserve Blackwall Partners  1Q12Michael Durante Western Reserve Blackwall Partners  1Q12
Michael Durante Western Reserve Blackwall Partners 1Q12Michael Durante
 
2010 Financial Markets Outlook_2010_With Cover_2010 vf
2010 Financial Markets Outlook_2010_With Cover_2010 vf2010 Financial Markets Outlook_2010_With Cover_2010 vf
2010 Financial Markets Outlook_2010_With Cover_2010 vfAndrew Kessler
 
Opportunities in adversity
Opportunities in adversityOpportunities in adversity
Opportunities in adversityNicholas Bruneau
 
Outlook For Commodities
Outlook For CommoditiesOutlook For Commodities
Outlook For CommoditiesRusNewton
 
US Capital Trends-The Big Picture
US Capital Trends-The Big PictureUS Capital Trends-The Big Picture
US Capital Trends-The Big PictureLiberty McPartland
 
Baird municipal market update may 2015
Baird municipal market update may 2015Baird municipal market update may 2015
Baird municipal market update may 2015sande833
 
Valuation Insights - Q3 2016
Valuation Insights - Q3 2016Valuation Insights - Q3 2016
Valuation Insights - Q3 2016Duff & Phelps
 
Fritz Meyer Sample Presentation
Fritz Meyer Sample PresentationFritz Meyer Sample Presentation
Fritz Meyer Sample PresentationAdvisors4Advisors
 
Q1 2016-credit third avenue
Q1 2016-credit third avenueQ1 2016-credit third avenue
Q1 2016-credit third avenueFrank Ragol
 
SJP Special Investment Bulletin Feb 2016
SJP Special Investment Bulletin Feb 2016SJP Special Investment Bulletin Feb 2016
SJP Special Investment Bulletin Feb 2016Tyler Stuart
 
Rules of Thumb for a Volatile Market
Rules of Thumb for a Volatile MarketRules of Thumb for a Volatile Market
Rules of Thumb for a Volatile MarketMarqus J Freeman
 
Deloitte Report "Global Powers of Retail 2014"
Deloitte Report "Global Powers of Retail 2014"Deloitte Report "Global Powers of Retail 2014"
Deloitte Report "Global Powers of Retail 2014"Oliver Grave
 
Fritzmeyersamplepresentation 110217102619-phpapp01
Fritzmeyersamplepresentation 110217102619-phpapp01Fritzmeyersamplepresentation 110217102619-phpapp01
Fritzmeyersamplepresentation 110217102619-phpapp01Rod Tyler
 
2018 01-25 hm
2018 01-25 hm2018 01-25 hm
2018 01-25 hmMats Larsson
 
Client Alert: Brexit - The Impact on Cost of Capital
Client Alert: Brexit - The Impact on Cost of CapitalClient Alert: Brexit - The Impact on Cost of Capital
Client Alert: Brexit - The Impact on Cost of CapitalDuff & Phelps
 

What's hot (16)

Michael Durante Western Reserve Blackwall Partners 1Q12
Michael Durante Western Reserve Blackwall Partners  1Q12Michael Durante Western Reserve Blackwall Partners  1Q12
Michael Durante Western Reserve Blackwall Partners 1Q12
 
2010 Financial Markets Outlook_2010_With Cover_2010 vf
2010 Financial Markets Outlook_2010_With Cover_2010 vf2010 Financial Markets Outlook_2010_With Cover_2010 vf
2010 Financial Markets Outlook_2010_With Cover_2010 vf
 
Opportunities in adversity
Opportunities in adversityOpportunities in adversity
Opportunities in adversity
 
Outlook For Commodities
Outlook For CommoditiesOutlook For Commodities
Outlook For Commodities
 
Feeding the Dragon - GMO
Feeding the Dragon - GMO Feeding the Dragon - GMO
Feeding the Dragon - GMO
 
US Capital Trends-The Big Picture
US Capital Trends-The Big PictureUS Capital Trends-The Big Picture
US Capital Trends-The Big Picture
 
Baird municipal market update may 2015
Baird municipal market update may 2015Baird municipal market update may 2015
Baird municipal market update may 2015
 
Valuation Insights - Q3 2016
Valuation Insights - Q3 2016Valuation Insights - Q3 2016
Valuation Insights - Q3 2016
 
Fritz Meyer Sample Presentation
Fritz Meyer Sample PresentationFritz Meyer Sample Presentation
Fritz Meyer Sample Presentation
 
Q1 2016-credit third avenue
Q1 2016-credit third avenueQ1 2016-credit third avenue
Q1 2016-credit third avenue
 
SJP Special Investment Bulletin Feb 2016
SJP Special Investment Bulletin Feb 2016SJP Special Investment Bulletin Feb 2016
SJP Special Investment Bulletin Feb 2016
 
Rules of Thumb for a Volatile Market
Rules of Thumb for a Volatile MarketRules of Thumb for a Volatile Market
Rules of Thumb for a Volatile Market
 
Deloitte Report "Global Powers of Retail 2014"
Deloitte Report "Global Powers of Retail 2014"Deloitte Report "Global Powers of Retail 2014"
Deloitte Report "Global Powers of Retail 2014"
 
Fritzmeyersamplepresentation 110217102619-phpapp01
Fritzmeyersamplepresentation 110217102619-phpapp01Fritzmeyersamplepresentation 110217102619-phpapp01
Fritzmeyersamplepresentation 110217102619-phpapp01
 
2018 01-25 hm
2018 01-25 hm2018 01-25 hm
2018 01-25 hm
 
Client Alert: Brexit - The Impact on Cost of Capital
Client Alert: Brexit - The Impact on Cost of CapitalClient Alert: Brexit - The Impact on Cost of Capital
Client Alert: Brexit - The Impact on Cost of Capital
 

Viewers also liked

Stefan baltov-2014eng-1
Stefan baltov-2014eng-1Stefan baltov-2014eng-1
Stefan baltov-2014eng-1Sim Aleksiev
 
"Регулирование технических аспектов присоединения объектов распределенной ген...
"Регулирование технических аспектов присоединения объектов распределенной ген..."Регулирование технических аспектов присоединения объектов распределенной ген...
"Регулирование технических аспектов присоединения объектов распределенной ген...НП "Сообщество потребителей энергии"
 
Actividad 5
Actividad 5Actividad 5
Actividad 5KENYAHF10
 
παρουσίαση1
παρουσίαση1παρουσίαση1
παρουσίαση1georgiapanou10
 
Ivan milushev-2013
Ivan milushev-2013Ivan milushev-2013
Ivan milushev-2013Sim Aleksiev
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve Basel III western reserve- commentary
Michael Durante Western Reserve Basel III   western reserve- commentaryMichael Durante Western Reserve Basel III   western reserve- commentary
Michael Durante Western Reserve Basel III western reserve- commentaryMichael Durante
 
Rein cloud14
Rein cloud14Rein cloud14
Rein cloud14Rhein Strife
 
Presentacion power point
Presentacion power pointPresentacion power point
Presentacion power pointDiego Camara
 
Low power vlsi design workshop 1
Low power vlsi design workshop 1Low power vlsi design workshop 1
Low power vlsi design workshop 1Silicon Mentor
 
Poke tasmanian-shellfish-industry-the-future
Poke tasmanian-shellfish-industry-the-futurePoke tasmanian-shellfish-industry-the-future
Poke tasmanian-shellfish-industry-the-futureprogressive01
 
Foreign Direct Investments FDI in Serbia
Foreign Direct Investments FDI in SerbiaForeign Direct Investments FDI in Serbia
Foreign Direct Investments FDI in SerbiaIvan Pavlovic
 
Ars breast cancer
Ars breast cancerArs breast cancer
Ars breast cancerspa718
 
Good morning
Good morningGood morning
Good morninggabydobo
 
Hong kong case studies
Hong kong case studiesHong kong case studies
Hong kong case studiesspa718
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Stefan baltov-2014eng-1
Stefan baltov-2014eng-1Stefan baltov-2014eng-1
Stefan baltov-2014eng-1
 
"Регулирование технических аспектов присоединения объектов распределенной ген...
"Регулирование технических аспектов присоединения объектов распределенной ген..."Регулирование технических аспектов присоединения объектов распределенной ген...
"Регулирование технических аспектов присоединения объектов распределенной ген...
 
Actividad 5
Actividad 5Actividad 5
Actividad 5
 
παρουσίαση1
παρουσίαση1παρουσίαση1
παρουσίαση1
 
Ivan milushev-2013
Ivan milushev-2013Ivan milushev-2013
Ivan milushev-2013
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve Basel III western reserve- commentary
Michael Durante Western Reserve Basel III   western reserve- commentaryMichael Durante Western Reserve Basel III   western reserve- commentary
Michael Durante Western Reserve Basel III western reserve- commentary
 
Scienza da Cargo Cult
Scienza da Cargo CultScienza da Cargo Cult
Scienza da Cargo Cult
 
Rein cloud14
Rein cloud14Rein cloud14
Rein cloud14
 
Presentacion power point
Presentacion power pointPresentacion power point
Presentacion power point
 
Cuestionario 4
Cuestionario 4Cuestionario 4
Cuestionario 4
 
Ns ufolder utskrift
Ns ufolder utskriftNs ufolder utskrift
Ns ufolder utskrift
 
Low power vlsi design workshop 1
Low power vlsi design workshop 1Low power vlsi design workshop 1
Low power vlsi design workshop 1
 
Poke tasmanian-shellfish-industry-the-future
Poke tasmanian-shellfish-industry-the-futurePoke tasmanian-shellfish-industry-the-future
Poke tasmanian-shellfish-industry-the-future
 
Genesis daniel
Genesis danielGenesis daniel
Genesis daniel
 
Foreign Direct Investments FDI in Serbia
Foreign Direct Investments FDI in SerbiaForeign Direct Investments FDI in Serbia
Foreign Direct Investments FDI in Serbia
 
Ars breast cancer
Ars breast cancerArs breast cancer
Ars breast cancer
 
5
55
5
 
Good morning
Good morningGood morning
Good morning
 
Hong kong case studies
Hong kong case studiesHong kong case studies
Hong kong case studies
 
Who am i
Who am iWho am i
Who am i
 

Similar to Financial Stocks Poised for Major Rally on Record Capital Levels

Michael Durante Western Reserve research compilation
Michael Durante Western Reserve  research compilationMichael Durante Western Reserve  research compilation
Michael Durante Western Reserve research compilationMichael Durante
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve 2009 review and 2010 outlook
Michael Durante Western Reserve  2009 review and 2010 outlookMichael Durante Western Reserve  2009 review and 2010 outlook
Michael Durante Western Reserve 2009 review and 2010 outlookMichael Durante
 
BoyarMiller Breakfast Forum: The Current State of the Capital Markets 2009
BoyarMiller Breakfast Forum: The Current State of the Capital Markets 2009BoyarMiller Breakfast Forum: The Current State of the Capital Markets 2009
BoyarMiller Breakfast Forum: The Current State of the Capital Markets 2009BoyarMiller
 
Capital Markets Industry Insights - Q1 2016
Capital Markets Industry Insights - Q1 2016Capital Markets Industry Insights - Q1 2016
Capital Markets Industry Insights - Q1 2016Duff & Phelps
 
2015 banking outlook: The future is bright, but change your password
2015 banking outlook: The future is bright, but change your password 2015 banking outlook: The future is bright, but change your password
2015 banking outlook: The future is bright, but change your password Grant Thornton LLP
 
Monthly market blueprint - June 2020
Monthly market blueprint - June 2020Monthly market blueprint - June 2020
Monthly market blueprint - June 2020Gail Mullard
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve 4Q07 Letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 4Q07 LetterMichael Durante Western Reserve 4Q07 Letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 4Q07 LetterMichael Durante
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve 4Q07
Michael Durante Western Reserve 4Q07Michael Durante Western Reserve 4Q07
Michael Durante Western Reserve 4Q07Michael Durante
 
Macroresearch
MacroresearchMacroresearch
Macroresearchdza1212
 
Volsung Management - Q3 2013 Investor Letter - China Supplement
Volsung Management - Q3 2013 Investor Letter - China SupplementVolsung Management - Q3 2013 Investor Letter - China Supplement
Volsung Management - Q3 2013 Investor Letter - China SupplementNick Poling
 
The Financial Situation in the World by Wouter van der Stok
The Financial Situation in the World by Wouter van der StokThe Financial Situation in the World by Wouter van der Stok
The Financial Situation in the World by Wouter van der StokFelix Meißner
 
After the storm 27 aug 2010
After the storm  27 aug 2010After the storm  27 aug 2010
After the storm 27 aug 2010Gaurav Sharma
 
Agcapita July 2013 - Central Banking's Scylla and Charybdis
Agcapita July 2013 - Central Banking's Scylla and CharybdisAgcapita July 2013 - Central Banking's Scylla and Charybdis
Agcapita July 2013 - Central Banking's Scylla and CharybdisVeripath Partners
 
FMA of NH: Safeguarding Cash
FMA of NH: Safeguarding CashFMA of NH: Safeguarding Cash
FMA of NH: Safeguarding Cashtravismd
 
Karen Hanover: 2009 NREI Outlook
Karen Hanover: 2009 NREI OutlookKaren Hanover: 2009 NREI Outlook
Karen Hanover: 2009 NREI OutlookKaren Wagner
 
Capital Markets Insights: Credit Availability for the Middle Market Remains R...
Capital Markets Insights: Credit Availability for the Middle Market Remains R...Capital Markets Insights: Credit Availability for the Middle Market Remains R...
Capital Markets Insights: Credit Availability for the Middle Market Remains R...Duff & Phelps
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve Blackwall Partners Basel III
Michael Durante Western Reserve Blackwall Partners Basel IIIMichael Durante Western Reserve Blackwall Partners Basel III
Michael Durante Western Reserve Blackwall Partners Basel IIIMichael Durante
 

Similar to Financial Stocks Poised for Major Rally on Record Capital Levels (20)

Michael Durante Western Reserve research compilation
Michael Durante Western Reserve  research compilationMichael Durante Western Reserve  research compilation
Michael Durante Western Reserve research compilation
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve 2009 review and 2010 outlook
Michael Durante Western Reserve  2009 review and 2010 outlookMichael Durante Western Reserve  2009 review and 2010 outlook
Michael Durante Western Reserve 2009 review and 2010 outlook
 
BoyarMiller Breakfast Forum: The Current State of the Capital Markets 2009
BoyarMiller Breakfast Forum: The Current State of the Capital Markets 2009BoyarMiller Breakfast Forum: The Current State of the Capital Markets 2009
BoyarMiller Breakfast Forum: The Current State of the Capital Markets 2009
 
Come Together
Come TogetherCome Together
Come Together
 
Capital Markets Industry Insights - Q1 2016
Capital Markets Industry Insights - Q1 2016Capital Markets Industry Insights - Q1 2016
Capital Markets Industry Insights - Q1 2016
 
2015 banking outlook: The future is bright, but change your password
2015 banking outlook: The future is bright, but change your password 2015 banking outlook: The future is bright, but change your password
2015 banking outlook: The future is bright, but change your password
 
Monthly market blueprint - June 2020
Monthly market blueprint - June 2020Monthly market blueprint - June 2020
Monthly market blueprint - June 2020
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve 4Q07 Letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 4Q07 LetterMichael Durante Western Reserve 4Q07 Letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 4Q07 Letter
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve 4Q07
Michael Durante Western Reserve 4Q07Michael Durante Western Reserve 4Q07
Michael Durante Western Reserve 4Q07
 
Macroresearch
MacroresearchMacroresearch
Macroresearch
 
Volsung Management - Q3 2013 Investor Letter - China Supplement
Volsung Management - Q3 2013 Investor Letter - China SupplementVolsung Management - Q3 2013 Investor Letter - China Supplement
Volsung Management - Q3 2013 Investor Letter - China Supplement
 
The Financial Situation in the World by Wouter van der Stok
The Financial Situation in the World by Wouter van der StokThe Financial Situation in the World by Wouter van der Stok
The Financial Situation in the World by Wouter van der Stok
 
After the storm 27 aug 2010
After the storm  27 aug 2010After the storm  27 aug 2010
After the storm 27 aug 2010
 
Why the Banking Industry Needs $600 Billion Worth of M&A
Why the Banking Industry Needs $600 Billion Worth of M&AWhy the Banking Industry Needs $600 Billion Worth of M&A
Why the Banking Industry Needs $600 Billion Worth of M&A
 
Agcapita July 2013 - Central Banking's Scylla and Charybdis
Agcapita July 2013 - Central Banking's Scylla and CharybdisAgcapita July 2013 - Central Banking's Scylla and Charybdis
Agcapita July 2013 - Central Banking's Scylla and Charybdis
 
FMA of NH: Safeguarding Cash
FMA of NH: Safeguarding CashFMA of NH: Safeguarding Cash
FMA of NH: Safeguarding Cash
 
MTBiz September 2014
MTBiz September 2014MTBiz September 2014
MTBiz September 2014
 
Karen Hanover: 2009 NREI Outlook
Karen Hanover: 2009 NREI OutlookKaren Hanover: 2009 NREI Outlook
Karen Hanover: 2009 NREI Outlook
 
Capital Markets Insights: Credit Availability for the Middle Market Remains R...
Capital Markets Insights: Credit Availability for the Middle Market Remains R...Capital Markets Insights: Credit Availability for the Middle Market Remains R...
Capital Markets Insights: Credit Availability for the Middle Market Remains R...
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve Blackwall Partners Basel III
Michael Durante Western Reserve Blackwall Partners Basel IIIMichael Durante Western Reserve Blackwall Partners Basel III
Michael Durante Western Reserve Blackwall Partners Basel III
 

More from Michael Durante

EBITDA Shortcomings
EBITDA ShortcomingsEBITDA Shortcomings
EBITDA ShortcomingsMichael Durante
 
Michael Durante EBITDA Shortcomings - BlackwallPartners
Michael Durante EBITDA Shortcomings - BlackwallPartnersMichael Durante EBITDA Shortcomings - BlackwallPartners
Michael Durante EBITDA Shortcomings - BlackwallPartnersMichael Durante
 
Valuation Analysis - EBITDA Shortcomings
Valuation Analysis - EBITDA Shortcomings Valuation Analysis - EBITDA Shortcomings
Valuation Analysis - EBITDA Shortcomings Michael Durante
 
Michael Durante EBITDA Shortcomings
Michael Durante EBITDA ShortcomingsMichael Durante EBITDA Shortcomings
Michael Durante EBITDA ShortcomingsMichael Durante
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve 3Q07 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 3Q07 letterMichael Durante Western Reserve 3Q07 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 3Q07 letterMichael Durante
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve 2Q06 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 2Q06 letterMichael Durante Western Reserve 2Q06 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 2Q06 letterMichael Durante
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve 2Q05 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 2Q05 letterMichael Durante Western Reserve 2Q05 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 2Q05 letterMichael Durante
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve WRHE 2Q04 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve WRHE 2Q04 letterMichael Durante Western Reserve WRHE 2Q04 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve WRHE 2Q04 letterMichael Durante
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve spring 2010 review
Michael Durante Western Reserve  spring 2010 reviewMichael Durante Western Reserve  spring 2010 review
Michael Durante Western Reserve spring 2010 reviewMichael Durante
 
Are bean counters to blame
Are bean counters to blameAre bean counters to blame
Are bean counters to blameMichael Durante
 
Study on mark to-market accounting
Study on mark to-market accountingStudy on mark to-market accounting
Study on mark to-market accountingMichael Durante
 
Michael Western Reserve financial reform primer- march 2010
Michael Western Reserve  financial reform primer- march 2010Michael Western Reserve  financial reform primer- march 2010
Michael Western Reserve financial reform primer- march 2010Michael Durante
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve research analysis- camel example
Michael Durante Western Reserve  research analysis- camel exampleMichael Durante Western Reserve  research analysis- camel example
Michael Durante Western Reserve research analysis- camel exampleMichael Durante
 
Michael Western Reserve spring 2010 review
Michael Western Reserve  spring 2010 reviewMichael Western Reserve  spring 2010 review
Michael Western Reserve spring 2010 reviewMichael Durante
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve 1Q029 review
Michael Durante Western Reserve  1Q029 reviewMichael Durante Western Reserve  1Q029 review
Michael Durante Western Reserve 1Q029 reviewMichael Durante
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve Q109 update letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve  Q109 update letterMichael Durante Western Reserve  Q109 update letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve Q109 update letterMichael Durante
 
Western reserve q1 2009 client update letter
Western reserve  q1 2009 client update letterWestern reserve  q1 2009 client update letter
Western reserve q1 2009 client update letterMichael Durante
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve 3Q05 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 3Q05 letterMichael Durante Western Reserve 3Q05 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 3Q05 letterMichael Durante
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve 4Q05 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 4Q05 letterMichael Durante Western Reserve 4Q05 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 4Q05 letterMichael Durante
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve 4Q06 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 4Q06 letterMichael Durante Western Reserve 4Q06 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 4Q06 letterMichael Durante
 

More from Michael Durante (20)

EBITDA Shortcomings
EBITDA ShortcomingsEBITDA Shortcomings
EBITDA Shortcomings
 
Michael Durante EBITDA Shortcomings - BlackwallPartners
Michael Durante EBITDA Shortcomings - BlackwallPartnersMichael Durante EBITDA Shortcomings - BlackwallPartners
Michael Durante EBITDA Shortcomings - BlackwallPartners
 
Valuation Analysis - EBITDA Shortcomings
Valuation Analysis - EBITDA Shortcomings Valuation Analysis - EBITDA Shortcomings
Valuation Analysis - EBITDA Shortcomings
 
Michael Durante EBITDA Shortcomings
Michael Durante EBITDA ShortcomingsMichael Durante EBITDA Shortcomings
Michael Durante EBITDA Shortcomings
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve 3Q07 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 3Q07 letterMichael Durante Western Reserve 3Q07 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 3Q07 letter
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve 2Q06 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 2Q06 letterMichael Durante Western Reserve 2Q06 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 2Q06 letter
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve 2Q05 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 2Q05 letterMichael Durante Western Reserve 2Q05 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 2Q05 letter
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve WRHE 2Q04 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve WRHE 2Q04 letterMichael Durante Western Reserve WRHE 2Q04 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve WRHE 2Q04 letter
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve spring 2010 review
Michael Durante Western Reserve  spring 2010 reviewMichael Durante Western Reserve  spring 2010 review
Michael Durante Western Reserve spring 2010 review
 
Are bean counters to blame
Are bean counters to blameAre bean counters to blame
Are bean counters to blame
 
Study on mark to-market accounting
Study on mark to-market accountingStudy on mark to-market accounting
Study on mark to-market accounting
 
Michael Western Reserve financial reform primer- march 2010
Michael Western Reserve  financial reform primer- march 2010Michael Western Reserve  financial reform primer- march 2010
Michael Western Reserve financial reform primer- march 2010
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve research analysis- camel example
Michael Durante Western Reserve  research analysis- camel exampleMichael Durante Western Reserve  research analysis- camel example
Michael Durante Western Reserve research analysis- camel example
 
Michael Western Reserve spring 2010 review
Michael Western Reserve  spring 2010 reviewMichael Western Reserve  spring 2010 review
Michael Western Reserve spring 2010 review
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve 1Q029 review
Michael Durante Western Reserve  1Q029 reviewMichael Durante Western Reserve  1Q029 review
Michael Durante Western Reserve 1Q029 review
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve Q109 update letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve  Q109 update letterMichael Durante Western Reserve  Q109 update letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve Q109 update letter
 
Western reserve q1 2009 client update letter
Western reserve  q1 2009 client update letterWestern reserve  q1 2009 client update letter
Western reserve q1 2009 client update letter
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve 3Q05 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 3Q05 letterMichael Durante Western Reserve 3Q05 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 3Q05 letter
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve 4Q05 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 4Q05 letterMichael Durante Western Reserve 4Q05 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 4Q05 letter
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve 4Q06 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 4Q06 letterMichael Durante Western Reserve 4Q06 letter
Michael Durante Western Reserve 4Q06 letter
 

Recently uploaded

Bladex Earnings Call Presentation 1Q2024
Bladex Earnings Call Presentation 1Q2024Bladex Earnings Call Presentation 1Q2024
Bladex Earnings Call Presentation 1Q2024Bladex
 
Lundin Gold April 2024 Corporate Presentation v4.pdf
Lundin Gold April 2024 Corporate Presentation v4.pdfLundin Gold April 2024 Corporate Presentation v4.pdf
Lundin Gold April 2024 Corporate Presentation v4.pdfAdnet Communications
 
Andheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot Models
Andheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot ModelsAndheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot Models
Andheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot Modelshematsharma006
 
Log your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaign
Log your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaignLog your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaign
Log your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaignHenry Tapper
 
Vip B Aizawl Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service Aizawl
Vip B Aizawl Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service AizawlVip B Aizawl Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service Aizawl
Vip B Aizawl Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service Aizawlmakika9823
 
call girls in Nand Nagri (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in  Nand Nagri (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️call girls in  Nand Nagri (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in Nand Nagri (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️9953056974 Low Rate Call Girls In Saket, Delhi NCR
 
SBP-Market-Operations and market managment
SBP-Market-Operations and market managmentSBP-Market-Operations and market managment
SBP-Market-Operations and market managmentfactical
 
20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf
20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf
20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdfAdnet Communications
 
Russian Call Girls In Gtb Nagar (Delhi) 9711199012 💋✔💕😘 Naughty Call Girls Se...
Russian Call Girls In Gtb Nagar (Delhi) 9711199012 💋✔💕😘 Naughty Call Girls Se...Russian Call Girls In Gtb Nagar (Delhi) 9711199012 💋✔💕😘 Naughty Call Girls Se...
Russian Call Girls In Gtb Nagar (Delhi) 9711199012 💋✔💕😘 Naughty Call Girls Se...shivangimorya083
 
(办理学位证)加拿大萨省大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
(办理学位证)加拿大萨省大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一(办理学位证)加拿大萨省大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
(办理学位证)加拿大萨省大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一S SDS
 
Bladex 1Q24 Earning Results Presentation
Bladex 1Q24 Earning Results PresentationBladex 1Q24 Earning Results Presentation
Bladex 1Q24 Earning Results PresentationBladex
 
Attachment Of Assets......................
Attachment Of Assets......................Attachment Of Assets......................
Attachment Of Assets......................AmanBajaj36
 
Instant Issue Debit Cards - High School Spirit
Instant Issue Debit Cards - High School SpiritInstant Issue Debit Cards - High School Spirit
Instant Issue Debit Cards - High School Spiritegoetzinger
 
Independent Lucknow Call Girls 8923113531WhatsApp Lucknow Call Girls make you...
Independent Lucknow Call Girls 8923113531WhatsApp Lucknow Call Girls make you...Independent Lucknow Call Girls 8923113531WhatsApp Lucknow Call Girls make you...
Independent Lucknow Call Girls 8923113531WhatsApp Lucknow Call Girls make you...makika9823
 
Q3 2024 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast Slides
Q3 2024 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast SlidesQ3 2024 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast Slides
Q3 2024 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast SlidesMarketing847413
 
Financial institutions facilitate financing, economic transactions, issue fun...
Financial institutions facilitate financing, economic transactions, issue fun...Financial institutions facilitate financing, economic transactions, issue fun...
Financial institutions facilitate financing, economic transactions, issue fun...Avanish Goel
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Jodhpur Park 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Jodhpur Park 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Jodhpur Park 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Jodhpur Park 👉 8250192130 Available With Roomdivyansh0kumar0
 
BPPG response - Options for Defined Benefit schemes - 19Apr24.pdf
BPPG response - Options for Defined Benefit schemes - 19Apr24.pdfBPPG response - Options for Defined Benefit schemes - 19Apr24.pdf
BPPG response - Options for Defined Benefit schemes - 19Apr24.pdfHenry Tapper
 
How Automation is Driving Efficiency Through the Last Mile of Reporting
How Automation is Driving Efficiency Through the Last Mile of ReportingHow Automation is Driving Efficiency Through the Last Mile of Reporting
How Automation is Driving Efficiency Through the Last Mile of ReportingAggregage
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Bladex Earnings Call Presentation 1Q2024
Bladex Earnings Call Presentation 1Q2024Bladex Earnings Call Presentation 1Q2024
Bladex Earnings Call Presentation 1Q2024
 
Lundin Gold April 2024 Corporate Presentation v4.pdf
Lundin Gold April 2024 Corporate Presentation v4.pdfLundin Gold April 2024 Corporate Presentation v4.pdf
Lundin Gold April 2024 Corporate Presentation v4.pdf
 
Andheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot Models
Andheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot ModelsAndheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot Models
Andheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot Models
 
Log your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaign
Log your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaignLog your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaign
Log your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaign
 
Vip B Aizawl Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service Aizawl
Vip B Aizawl Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service AizawlVip B Aizawl Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service Aizawl
Vip B Aizawl Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service Aizawl
 
call girls in Nand Nagri (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in  Nand Nagri (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️call girls in  Nand Nagri (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in Nand Nagri (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
 
SBP-Market-Operations and market managment
SBP-Market-Operations and market managmentSBP-Market-Operations and market managment
SBP-Market-Operations and market managment
 
20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf
20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf
20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf
 
Russian Call Girls In Gtb Nagar (Delhi) 9711199012 💋✔💕😘 Naughty Call Girls Se...
Russian Call Girls In Gtb Nagar (Delhi) 9711199012 💋✔💕😘 Naughty Call Girls Se...Russian Call Girls In Gtb Nagar (Delhi) 9711199012 💋✔💕😘 Naughty Call Girls Se...
Russian Call Girls In Gtb Nagar (Delhi) 9711199012 💋✔💕😘 Naughty Call Girls Se...
 
(办理学位证)加拿大萨省大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
(办理学位证)加拿大萨省大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一(办理学位证)加拿大萨省大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
(办理学位证)加拿大萨省大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
 
Bladex 1Q24 Earning Results Presentation
Bladex 1Q24 Earning Results PresentationBladex 1Q24 Earning Results Presentation
Bladex 1Q24 Earning Results Presentation
 
Attachment Of Assets......................
Attachment Of Assets......................Attachment Of Assets......................
Attachment Of Assets......................
 
Instant Issue Debit Cards - High School Spirit
Instant Issue Debit Cards - High School SpiritInstant Issue Debit Cards - High School Spirit
Instant Issue Debit Cards - High School Spirit
 
Independent Lucknow Call Girls 8923113531WhatsApp Lucknow Call Girls make you...
Independent Lucknow Call Girls 8923113531WhatsApp Lucknow Call Girls make you...Independent Lucknow Call Girls 8923113531WhatsApp Lucknow Call Girls make you...
Independent Lucknow Call Girls 8923113531WhatsApp Lucknow Call Girls make you...
 
🔝+919953056974 🔝young Delhi Escort service Pusa Road
🔝+919953056974 🔝young Delhi Escort service Pusa Road🔝+919953056974 🔝young Delhi Escort service Pusa Road
🔝+919953056974 🔝young Delhi Escort service Pusa Road
 
Q3 2024 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast Slides
Q3 2024 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast SlidesQ3 2024 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast Slides
Q3 2024 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast Slides
 
Financial institutions facilitate financing, economic transactions, issue fun...
Financial institutions facilitate financing, economic transactions, issue fun...Financial institutions facilitate financing, economic transactions, issue fun...
Financial institutions facilitate financing, economic transactions, issue fun...
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Jodhpur Park 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Jodhpur Park 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Jodhpur Park 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Jodhpur Park 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
 
BPPG response - Options for Defined Benefit schemes - 19Apr24.pdf
BPPG response - Options for Defined Benefit schemes - 19Apr24.pdfBPPG response - Options for Defined Benefit schemes - 19Apr24.pdf
BPPG response - Options for Defined Benefit schemes - 19Apr24.pdf
 
How Automation is Driving Efficiency Through the Last Mile of Reporting
How Automation is Driving Efficiency Through the Last Mile of ReportingHow Automation is Driving Efficiency Through the Last Mile of Reporting
How Automation is Driving Efficiency Through the Last Mile of Reporting
 

Financial Stocks Poised for Major Rally on Record Capital Levels

  • 1. BlackwallPartners How to ride a CAMEL… March 1, 2011 “Banks have more capital as a percentage of assets since anytime since 1934” - Dick Bove, veteran bank observer CAMEL Race… The financial crisis ended some time ago and the U.S. economy has entered a new “golden age” for financial equities not unlike the post Savings & Loan Crisis (“SLC”) two decades ago. As we have noted in our prior research, the recent financial crisis was grossly exaggerated via a number of contributing factors. Factors which have positioned the current recovery in financials to perhaps be even more powerful than the recovery experienced in the nineties. The implementation of new accounting rules (“mark-to-market”) in 2007-2008 resulted in a “front-loading” or over-statement of the credit problems this cycle, which has resulted in record excess capital and reserve builds. These stores of excessive capital and liquidity are the largest in history and will need to be deployed in the coming years. We anticipate this will usher-in the most aggressive wave of capital reinvestment that U.S. financial industry has ever deployed and investors will be the direct beneficiaries. Investors should recognize similar dynamics in financial stocks today to what one would have witnessed in the sector from 1990 to 1998. This post SLC period was a time of stabilization, recapitalization and re-growth in financial industry net credit revenue as well as in earnings and book values. This drove a substantial rally in the sector (See Chart- top right). The accompanying valuation table (See Chart- page right) outlines the dramatic discounts in the valuations of many high profile financial firms. By our estimates, leading financial firms are priced at <3x cash flow; 30% below equity plus adjusted loan loss reserves; and many are currently trading at below their net cash-on-hand. Post S&L Crisis - Rally in Financials 0% 100% 200% 300% 400% 500% 600% 700% 800% 900% November 1990 - April 1998 S&P Financials S&P 500 Source: Thompson Reuters Valuations are Absurd! Price Book Value Adj Book1 PTPP2 Price/Adj Book Price/ PTPP JP Morgan $42 $41 $51 $13 82% 3.2x Wells Fargo 31 24 30 8 100 3.7 Citigroup 5 7 8 2 63 2.5 PNC Fin. 61 63 71 17 86 3.6 BankofAmerica 13 27 31 6 42 2.2 Capital One 42 57 66 16 64 2.6 Regions Fin. 7 11 13 3 54 2.8 Average 70% 2.9x 1 Stated book value plus loan loss reserve drawn down to 1% of loans with excess taxed at 40% tax rate through 2012 estimated earnings 2 Pre-tax, pre-provision net earnings at normalized credit loss provision rate Source: Thompson Reuters
  • 2. 2 Anatomy of Under Ownership SEC filings by large funds indicate that portfolio managers are grossly under invested in U.S. financial stocks. In part, we believe this is attributable to the struggle and hesitancy that generalists have with the complexities of financial firm accounting. Naturally, a factor greatly exacerbated by the financial crisis and reflected in the ‘jaw-dropping’ valuations previously shown. Again, this mirrors what we saw coming out of the SLC. Extreme under weights in portfolios and subsequent low valuations now place financials at their lowest weighting in the S&P 500 in nearly forty years. The financial sector, excluding insurers, currently represents only 9% of the S&P 500, yet is responsible for more than 1/3 of the earnings or economic contribution to the S&P. It’s simply a blinding fundamental disconnect. This marked inefficiency also is evident in valuations where we calculate the typical larger U.S. bank trading at 3x free cash flow (“PTPP”), while the S&P 500 trades closer to 11x cash flow. This is despite the fact that non- financial firms are more heavily CapEx intensive and therefore arguably less “free.” The historic relative multiple of cash flow for financials relative to the broader market ranges from 60% to 80% versus today’s 27% [3x / 11x = 27%]. Therefore, both the absolute values across financials as well as their relative valuation signal an historic under valuation opportunity. A good example of current market disequilibrium can be found amongst the largest mutual funds. Our review of SEC filings indicate that a large (unnamed) Fidelity Investments fund is carrying twice the S&P 500’s weighting in industrial materials stocks; less than one-third the weight in technology; half the weight of consumer services; and half the already well below normal weight of financial services. This is astonishing empirically on several levels. For starters, the U.S. economy is approximately 85% services related as we are a services and information technology-driven economy; not an industrial/manufacturing driven one. There is nothing wrong with such a fund weighting per se. In fact, it’s the most common weighting (by sector) among funds where we canvassed their regulatory filings. Clearly, the aforementioned fund’s management team believes that they see more opportunity in the copiously heavy industrial and commodity-laden emerging markets than in any potential recovery in America. Undoubtedly, this is a sizable bet on a continued global disequilibrium. However, inferential statistics and the inevitable reversion to the mean greatly favor a more dominant domestic services sector recovery as it has for economic cycles over the past 40 years. So, the “mechanics” of a sustained advance in domestic financial and services economy stocks is in place, in part, because nobody owns them and Americans have forgotten what we do best. Under ownership and subsequent depressed multiples in the financials are despite tremendous improvement in credit (the main driver of earnings recovery) and earnings visibility. This is in addition to the industry sitting atop record levels of both liquidity and capital, the driver of earnings acceleration. Estimated Earnings Growth Sector 4Q10 2010 2011 Consumer Discretionary 13% 44% 15% Consumer Staples 2% 6% 11% Energy 25% 49% 14% Financials >200% 158% 37% Health Care 5% 10% 7% Industrials 10% 24% 18% REITs 7% 6% 1% Technology 13% 41% 10% Telecom 13% 0% 13% Utilities -3% 4% -1% S&P 5003 12% 28% 9% 3 Excludes financials Source: Thompson Reuters As we have referenced in recent musings, the table above illustrates that the financials have the strongest prospects for earnings growth over the next several years. In addition to growth, higher
  • 3. 3 “visibility” will be present due to clear credit cost abatement. This makes the dramatic and ubiquitous under-weight of the financial sector via fund managers all the more curious to even the most casual market observer…disconnects often are. Credit abatement will drive initial out sized growth - While securitized loans across all credit types were mauled by M2M inaccuracies, banks with more traditional “portfolio” lending or “whole loan” accounting also were trampled inefficiently as the credit panic overshot reality. The accompanying chart courtesy of the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis illustrates the “real” peak in problem loans. And though potentially startling to some, this most recent credit cycle has produced non-performing loans peaking at 70% of the SLC. Thus, it was an unnecessary panic in 2007-2009. The resulting excessive build- up of capital and reserves now is a benefit to financial stock investors. Nonperforming Loans4 4 Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis study of all U.S. commercial banks; Loans past due 90 days plus nonaccrual loans to total loans. Source: Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis The following chart (top right) illustrates the excessive levels of capital and reserve builds generated as a function of the traditional capital and reserve over-builds that typically accompany any credit crisis. Common Tier 1 Capital (“CT1”) is Inordinately High for U.S. Banks 0% 2% 4% 6% 8% 10% 12% 14% 16% 18% AXP STT NTRS C KEY PNC STI USB RF WFC BAC JPM COF CT1 less Buybacks CT1 B3M5 = Basel III Minimum risk-based capital standard expected to be implemented by a global regulators roundtable known as the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision. Source: Company reports; Blackwall Partners LLC estimates US banks hold capital levels that materially exceed even the future expected higher minimums for “well capitalized” institutions (See above: B3M5 ). International bank regulators are debating these levels in the Basel III accords (not expected to be implemented until at least 2020 BTW). The perception by many is that U.S. banks are ill- prepped for B3M and this is patently false. Of course, we also recently saw a Rasmussen poll that suggested most Americans were unaware that the United States was the largest economy in the world, let alone three times the size of the second largest. So, it would appear there is plenty of room for folks that do fundamental research to find market dislocations. B3M5
  • 4. 4 1.5% 2.0% 2.5% 3.0% 3.5% 4.0% 1Q09 2Q09 3Q09 4Q09 1Q10 2Q10 3Q10 4Q10e 1Q11e 2Q11e 3Q11e 4Q11e 1Q12e Net Charge-Offs6 6 Morgan Stanley bank research coverage universe; average net-charge-offs to average loans Source: Morgan Stanley & Company We anticipate material improvement in credit in 2011 and near zero credit costs in 2012 (See- above). We fully expect to see banks and other financial firms continue to “release” excess loan loss reserves back into their earnings at an accelerated pace in 2011-2014. In addition to providing significant earnings re-acceleration, this makes substantial capital available for dividends, stock buy-backs and acquisitions, which will help drive-up valuation multiples. The combination of a strong rise in earnings coupled with multiple-expansion is the same recipe that drove the material outperformance for financials in the post SLC period. That being noted, how does Blackwall Partners analyze and value financial firms? What gives us the “edge” that drives our confidence that we not only are correct on the fundamentals, but can move-in early on opportunities? We ride a slightly different looking horse. How to ride a CAMEL Blackwall Partners relies more heavily on financial regulatory reporting or (RAAP) much more so than generally accepted accounting principles known as GAAP. RAAP reports provide to bank regulators more granular information, which we use for our proprietary safety and soundness rating system. This is integral in Blackwall’s selection process of traditional financial stocks. $0 $50 $100 $150 $200 $250 Pre-Tax, Pre-Provision Pre-Tax GAAP Bank Earnings “Power” v. GAAP Widest on Record (1980-Present) Mark-to-Market Accounting Overstatement of Losses Source: Keefe, Bruyette & Woods; Blackwall Partners LLC In prior writings, we have referenced the chart above as it speaks volumes relating to this most recent financial crisis. The chart tracks reported earnings (GAAP) versus RAAP’s pre-tax, pre- provision (“PTPP”) or “free cash flow” from 1980- 2010. The dramatic gap in recent years between the black and blue lines illustrates the reality of the “non-cash hole” that mark-to-market accounting (GAAP) blew through the earnings (and capital) of financial firms during the financial crisis. This also illustrates the inevitable earnings reacceleration that we not only can predict, but guarantee. It is RAAP after-all that the Federal Reserve used to “stress test” the banks in 2009 under the Supervisory Capital Assessment Program (“SCAP”). This is the very same test the Fed is performing right now to determine which banks can start returning excess capital to investors. The “test” criteria studies five core fundamental factors from which it gets its acronym – CAMEL C - Capital Adequacy A - Asset Quality M - Management E - Earnings L - Liquidity
  • 5. 5 For partners and prospective investors to get a more thorough understanding of how Blackwall evaluates potential investments, we illustrate a few examples of the CAMEL process. Disclosure: Blackwall Partners LLC chose the institutions outlined here randomly to show a range between the controversial to the beloved and how our use of CAMEL is applied consistently therein. This is NOT necessarily a representation of the portfolio. The information is used exclusively for informational purposes only. Fifth-Third Bancorp (FITB) Capital Adequacy CT1 at 7.5% already exceeds the expected B3M minimum to rank as “well capitalized” of 7% and could be as much as 150bp above this level. Equally as important, FITB’s CT1 is steadily growing and will significantly exceed B3M long before any new standards are implemented 6.8 7.0 7.2 7.4 1Q10 2Q10 3Q10 4Q10 Common Tier 1 Capital (%) Source: FITB Corporate Reports 9.4% Tier 1 risk-based capital exceeds regulatory “well capitalized” by over 50%; 9.7% Tier 1 under B3M tops all regional bank peers Capital levels which are strong and rising are supplemented by high loan loss reserve levels near 4% which cover current non- performing loan levels by roughly 1.8x FITB repaid TARP in full to the U.S. Treasury in February 2011 and completed a successful follow-on equity offering Asset Quality Severe delinquent loans have fallen by 72% since 3Q09 and net-charge-offs have fallen below 2% in 4Q10 for the first time since before the financial crisis. Early-stage delinquencies have dropped below 1% for the first time since 2007. So, we have passed the peak in problem loans at FITB Early Stage Delinquency (%)7 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 3Q07 1Q08 3Q08 1Q09 3Q09 1Q10 3Q10 FITB Peers 7 Loans 30-89days past due Source: FITB Corporate Reports New nonaccrual loans have fallen by nearly 50% between 1Q09 and 4Q10. They have steadily declined for five consecutive quarters and 4Q10 additions represented just 0.6% of total loans The loan loss reserve (LLR) covers non- performing loans (NPLs) now by approximately 200% and PTPP (cash flow) covers NPLs by 1.6x. So, FITB has returned to cash flow growth since 1Q10-2Q10 and is comfortably absorbing remaining loan loss recognitions
  • 6. 6 0 25 50 75 100 125 150 175 4Q09 1Q10 2Q10 3Q10 4Q10 PTPP/ NCOs (%) Source: FITB Corporate Reports Overall, NPLs have declined by 43% since 4Q09 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 4Q09 1Q10 2Q10 3Q10 4Q10 NPLs / Loans (%) Source: FITB Corporate Reports CT1 plus LLR at 12.3% is the second largest among FITB’s regional bank peer group Mortgage repurchase claims represent <1% of loans and the repo reserve of 63% greatly exceeds any risk, even if required to buy-in the loans (assumes all repo claims valid and home loan-to-value is 63%) Per regulatory bank exams; the total regulatory criticized assets (“substandard” or “doubtful”) are down 16% in 2010 and represent 6% of existing loans, however only 0.3% represent a “doubtful” regulatory classification. This suggests that bank examiners are just being overly persnickety, sighting few losses (“doubtful”) but higher levels of scrutiny (“substandard”); overall indicative of FITB having been “scrubbed” Management The historically stalwart FITB, which once coveted the highest valuation ratios among any of the major banks, stumbled in this recent credit mess The company has since re-tooled its risk appetite and accomplished a great deal in a relatively short time. All signs pointing toward a clear recovery are underway But, they are on notice from investors to keep moving in its current highly positive fundamental trajectory or we would anticipate that FITB would get acquired in the coming M&A cycle Earnings FITB has returned to profitability quite quickly with three consecutive quarters of reported profits (though free cash flow has been positive now for five quarters) The return on assets (ROA) reached 1.2% in 4Q10. This remains subdued due to excessive liquidity and remaining loan loss recognition The 4Q10 return on equity (ROE) was 10% or equally unacceptable if the stock should attain its once high valuation among its peers again Increasingly both the ROA and ROE will require significant redeployment of excess liquidity and capital into an economic recovery. The evidence would now suggest that both are highly likely; PTPP as a percentage of risk-weighted assets rose to 2.3% in 4Q10. This demonstrates the improving ROA and ROE to come or to be monetized by an acquirer
  • 7. 7 Liquidity FITB is awash in liquidity The loan-to-deposit ratio has fallen to 94% meaning the bank is under “lent out”; 88% of FITB’s deposits are cheap “core” funding or non-time related; deposit growth is double digits while loan growth is just starting to turn up slightly FITB’s balance sheet now carries more net cash and cash equivalents than market value Conclusion – 1 2 3 2 1 / Overall 2 With improving fundamentals across all categories, we rank FITB with an overall CAMEL rating of 2. This clearly is not reflected in the stock’s current depressed valuations including but not limited to a mere 4x run-rate free cash flow (PTPP); 1x book value (which assumes no franchise value or “deposit premium”); and 7.8x our 2012 reported earnings estimate. At 1x book (<1x forward book value), FITB trades with no franchise value. For example, with approximately $90 billion in core deposits and applying a reasonable private market value premium of 15%; FITB is intrinsically worth as much as $29 per share or 109% above prevailing market...and this assumes no future growth. If FITB remains independent, we anticipate $2.50 in EPS by 2013 and a $38 stock price discounted in advance. Recent prevailing market for the shares is $13-$14 per share. Capital One Financial (COF) Capital Adequacy CT1 at 8.8% greatly exceeds the SCAP minimum and illustrates why COF was among the first banks to repay TARP in full in the spring of 2009. COF’s ability to generate excess capital internally has facilitated the maintenance of very high capital ratios throughout the crisis Strong Capital Generation Source: COF Corporate Reports CTI plus LLR is 13.2% or among the highest of any consumer-heavy bank, while COF’s ability to “cash flow” credit costs due to high yield assets differentiates the company from the ‘garden variety’ bank
  • 8. 8 Asset Quality Credit improvement continues to ‘front-run’ broader economic indicators as net charge- offs (NCOs) have rapidly declined Domestic Credit Card (%) Source: COF Corporate Reports International Credit Card (%) Source: COF Corporate Reports Earliest stage delinquencies in the highest risk (unsecured) credit card portfolios also are declining rapidly, forecasting continued material lower credit costs for COF in the coming quarters/years despite perceived risks to persistent high unemployment Commercial Real Estate (%) 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 3Q09 4Q09 1Q10 2Q10 3Q10 4Q10 NPAs NCOs Source: COF Corporate Reports As a regional commercial bank, COF is also seeing steady improvement in commercial real estate credit Net Charge-Offs (%) Source: COF Corporate Reports COF also is experiencing low credit costs which have improved and are now stable in both mortgages and auto lending as well Management COF has among the most well respected management teams in the financial industry; the firm is a perennial member of FORTUNE’s best companies to work for CEO takes all of his compensation in stock and the senior management team also takes a substantial portion of their compensation in company stock
  • 9. 9 Took a fledgling credit card business of a small Virginia bank (Signet) and created one of the world’s five largest credit card firms with global branding Earnings COF is among the most profitable banks in the world due, in large part, to being very adept at underwriting high yield credit (credit cards). The bank’s net interest margin has consistently been twice that of its regional banking peers Net Interest Margin (%) Source: COF Corporate Reports COF’s strong and consistent PTPP enables it to absorb credit storms with greater ease than traditional banks. Also, the bank is among the first to see earnings re-accelerate in an economic recovery as a result of its high, price inelastic earning asset yields Liquidity Like most of its peers, COF has more liquidity than would be normal given the economic environment we are exiting; COF’s cash and equivalents represent nearly 30% of the bank’s assets A consistent shift to lower costs and core funding also has positioned COF in a uniquely strong position coming out of this crisis; the loan-to-deposit ratio is 100% (unlevered) and COF’s blended cost of funding has fallen to as low as 1.5% in 4Q10 COF currently has more net cash and equivalents than market value Conclusion – 1 1 1 1 1 / Overall 1 Like a slot machine hitting all cherries, we rate COF an across the board CAMEL 1 with no regulatory fundamental weaknesses in our view. And COF is witnessing improved fundamentals across each of these categories. The disconnect between the fundamentals and the current valuation are stark with COF. In addition to trading below net cash-on-hand, COF currently trades hands at just 2.5x free cash flow (PTPP); <70% of book value (which assumes no franchise value or “deposit premium”); and 7.0x our 2012 reported earnings estimate, which we believe is quite conservative. A 15x P/E multiple on 2012-2013 earnings per share of $8 renders a target price of $120 or 2.5x prevailing market prices. Citigroup (C) Capital Adequacy CT1 is now the highest among ALL multi- national banks in the world at 11% or nearly 60% higher than the rumored Basel III minimum for “well capitalized” and 78% above the SCAP test level 1 3 5 7 9 11 2007 2008 2009 2010 CT1 (%) Source: Citigroup Corporate Reports
  • 10. 10 CT1 plus its loan loss reserve (LLR) makes C the most heavily capitalized large bank in the world CT1 plus LLR (%) Source: Citigroup Corporate Reports Asset Quality C has started to “release” reserves as mark- downs on assets via M2M accounting rules in 2008-2009 proved to be far too large and resulted in a loan loss reserve over-build 1.5 2.5 3.5 4.5 5.5 6.5 7.5 2007 2008 2009 1Q10 2Q10 3Q10 4Q10 LLR (%) Source: Citigroup Corporate Reports Consequently, the managed loan loss provision is steadily declining, fueling C’s (surprising to some) profits recovery 5 10 15 2007 2008 2009 2010 Managed Credit Costs $B Source: Citigroup Corporate Reports C’s problem portfolio was in residential mortgages (of course) and a large part of the improving credit and falling credit costs story is the “run-off” in the levered mortgage portfolio North America EOP Mortgages $B Source: Citigroup Corporate Reports C now has repositioned itself into two companies – CitiFinancial, which looks like a levered bond hedge fund (which is in run- off), and the other entity which is the old core “Citibank”; both entities are seeing excessive reserve builds into peak credit losses, putting the former behind the company and the latter back into focus for global “core” banking growth
  • 11. 11 Management This is likely the most controversial issue at present. We believe management has done a very good job of re-tooling itself and has the right talent to run the old new “Citibank” Equally critical, we are very impressed with additions to C’s board of directors which have taken place post-financial crisis which nearly crippled the franchise (and should have); for example, we like the addition of our old friend Jerry Grundhofer to the Citibank board; Jerry made us money at both Cincinnati’s Star Bank as well as thru his great success at putting together a top tier franchise in US Bancorp (USB) Should the current senior management not deliver on the promise of this franchise, we believe the right person to step-up already is in place. This gives us uber confidence in Citi’s leadership relative to the generally pessimistic investor perceptions Earnings A discussion of C isn’t complete without acknowledging its unmatched global presence, a strength of past management and a focus on the current leadership Global Banking by Region 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% EEMA Latin America Asia North America Source: Citigroup Corporate Reports C’s earnings power across multiple geographies is incredible and cannot be easily replicated by any bank globally International Banking Growth 95 105 115 125 135 145 155 4Q08 1Q09 2Q09 3Q09 4Q09 1Q10 2Q10 3Q10 4Q10 Loans Deposits Source: Citigroup Corporate Reports While C’s international bank continues to grow rapidly, its U.S. bank has turned the corner and thus the realization of a very substantial earnings turnaround is developing quickly as domestic credit expenses continue declining Revenue Stability $B Source: Citigroup Corporate Reports 5 10 15 2007 2008 2009 2010 Managed Credit Costs $B Source: Citigroup Corporate Reports
  • 12. 12 -20 -10 0 10 2007 2008 2009 2010 Net Income $B Source: Citigroup Corporate Reports With C’s international bank continuing to grow; overall corporate revenue remains stable and strong. With credit costs falling C’s earnings power rises very quickly; the current run-rate cash flow (PTPP) exceeds analysts estimates for reported earnings this coming year by 150% Liquidity C too is awash in liquidity Loans-to-deposits at 72% reflect C being grossly under loaned. This signals a large opportunity in C for strong earning asset growth into an economic recovery C also has more net cash-on-hand than market value by almost two-fold Conclusion – 1 2 2 2 1 / Overall 2 With improving fundamentals across all categories, we rate C an overall CAMEL 2. So how this conclusion washes with C’s current depressed stock price is a question for psychologists perhaps. This is a stock trading at half its net cash- on-hand; a mere 2.5x run-rate free cash flow (PTPP); and half its book value (no franchise value for this global juggernaut?) We see this as a $12 stock inside of a few years. __________________________________________ JP Morgan (JPM) Capital Adequacy CT1 of 9.8% is well above the current regulatory minimum for “well capitalized” and JPM is already at the pro forma B3M CT1 “well capitalized” threshold years before its potential implementation The addition of a loss coverage ratio of 4.5% (of loans) creates an incredibly strong double digit “risk buffer” of nearly 15% JPM carries a global liquidity reserve of over $260 billion or >22% of total risk- weighted assets; amazing Therefore, JPM enjoys enormous capital and liquidity strength for a large, multi-national bank; internal CT1 capital generation is near 10% annually Asset Quality Loan loss reserve at a strong 190% of nonperforming loans already has started to come down as the level of problem loans has peaked and has begun to decline noticeably Huge Reserve Coverage $B Source: JP Morgan Corporate Reports Early-Stage delinquency also showing clear signs of “post peak” for this credit cycle and this bodes well for more of JPM’s excess LLR to be “released” back into reported capital (book value). We calculate JPM’s
  • 13. 13 book value to be understated by a conservative $10 to $12 per share or 20%- 25% Early-Stage Delinquency $B Source: JP Morgan Corporate Reports Management Known as the “second Federal Reserve” during the financial crisis (aiding in the unwinding of rivals Bear Stearns, Lehman Bros. and Washington Mutual); we believe JPM’s management team has more than proven itself “Scarlet Letters” and “Half Bankers; Half Lawyers” are the persnickety words of a very high quality management team just frustrated with the government and investors; JPM’s management team has earned the right to shout loudly at both Earnings The acquisition of Washington Mutual alone adds huge earnings power to JPM as they acquired the beleaguered bank at “fire sale” prices including massive discounts on troubled assets JPM remained profitable throughout the crisis and throws-off the largest free cash flow (PTPP) among any multi-national bank. The current run-rate (PTPP) represents almost 30% of the market value of the stock which also is the book value; astonishing JPM recorded record revenue in 2010, up 15% from the prior year while expenses rose only 2%. This illustrates the profit scalability of this impressive multi-strategy financial franchise Reported earnings in core commercial banking rose nearly 100% in 2010 and the return on common equity (ROE) already is back to 16% with huge excess liquidity and capital which is yet to be redeployed into higher return investments Further earnings power is demonstrated in JPM’s “league table” position in investment banking - #1 in global investment banking fees; #1 in global debt and equity underwriting; and #1 in global loan syndication. Yet, despite leading the league, JPM’s average market share is under 10% in total investment banking globally, thus significant market share opportunity remains Liquidity With a liquidity reserve equal to >20% of risk-weighted assets and twice common equity capital, JPM is inordinately liquid JPM also holds net cash 1.5x that of its market value and the loan-to-deposit ratio is a materially under loaned out 66% JPM’s biggest problem is that it is too liquid, a classic “high class” problem to have Conclusion – 1 1 1 1 1 / Overall 1 With strong fundamentals and excess capacity across all categories from capital to credit to earnings power and liquidity, we rate JPM a CAMEL 1. How the stock of this impressive franchise trades hands at approximately 3x run-rate free cash flow (PTPP); below net cash-on-hand; and at book value is inexplicable.
  • 14. 14 We expect investors will look back at these valuations and wonder why they didn’t take more advantage… To be conservative, we see at least $8 per share in EPS by 2013-2014. At 80% of the long-term market multiple (well deserved), we believe that this is a $120 stock inside of two years The untapped historic capital, liquidity and earnings power of the U.S. financial industry coupled with near all-time low absolute and relative valuations is excessive “dry powder” for the sector’s out- performance. When considering the recent macro events in the Middle East, we would anticipate that any tailing- off of these global headwinds would again be a “green light” for financials to move aggressively higher. It’s all there in the CAMELs. It’s just a matter of time. Regards, Michael P. Durante Managing Partner Blackwall Partners LLC