3. Legislation Around Organics
in the United States
State-Wide Organics Diversion Mandate
and/or Disposal Ban1,2,3
Local Residential Waste Collection Program4
Both
1,2 Sources: BioCycle 2014a survey from 39
states that responded; 2014b
Rhode Island legislation
effective 2016.
3 Source: MSW Management, 2015
4 Source: BioCycle 2015, denotes states
that have 1 or more communities
with residential SSO program; are
not state-wide.
3
4. Our Mission
To provide cost-effective and sustainable collection and processing
solutions that recover organic waste, recycle it to highest-value use
and return it to our community value chain.
5. 5
About Organix Solutions
Organic Waste Consultancy
• Support activities to increase organics recycling and cooperate
with local haulers, industry and government.
• Assist with technical expertise to carry out trials and verify the
feasibility of organics recycling.
• Work with corporations, food producers and organic waste
generators on waste reduction planning and implementation
of collection programs.
10. Layer 1
10
Source Separated Organics (SSO)
Municipalities are addressing the impacts of organic
waste (food scraps and food soiled papers) by
implementing curbside SSO programs.
Challenge – do it affordably and design it to be
convenient for the end user
• Haulers are under pressure to provide organics collection
• There is a cost for collection of organics; containers,
collection, processing
• Route density efficiency - rural, seasonal yard waste,
voluntary participation
The Green Bag Organix™ Collection Program addresses all of
these issues through an opt-in program designed for
municipalities and haulers. Recovered Material from
Waste Stream
Waste
Characterization
11. 11
Hennepin County - Organics Diversion
• 2 interested parties: City of Wayzata and Randy’s
Environmental Services
• How to launch an organics pilot as part of recycling
• What evolved over a decade to the present system
Blue Bag Organics® co-collection in MN
• Amount of time and dedicated research invested for a
solution
Wayzata Pilot Results
• Co-collection (organics and MSW) eliminated 1 truck per week
• Residential participation was good, very little contamination
(non-organics)
• 3rd party tested for liner integrity during residential use and
being hauled in/out of the truck
• Good puncture resistance, durable
• Composted completely at the composting facility
City of Wayzata in Hennepin County, Minnesota
How the Program Started - Organics Pilot 2002
* Randy’s is the parent company of Organix Solutions.
12. 12
Blue Bag Organics Co-Collection
Program Launched 2012
Residents collect their food scraps and food soiled papers in the 13-
gallon Extreme Duty Compostable Bag, tie a knot and place the
compostable bag in the same cart with their trash.
• On the regular trash collection day, the hauler empties the cart
• Compostable bags are then sorted at a transfer station or MRF
where they are diverted to a composting facility
• Co-collects organics with trash, no additional cart or truck is
necessary
• Eliminates the need for a dedicated organics route
Blue Bag Organics® is patent pending.
13. 13
Today over 32 cities in Minnesota have implemented the Blue Bag Organics® program and more communities are signing on.
Outside of Minnesota the program is marketed as the Green Bag Organix™.
• Organix Solutions manufactures its own proprietary 100% compostable liners branded as Blue Bag Organics and Green Bag Organix
• Certified by the Biodegradable Products Institute (BPI) to meet the industry standard test methods of ASTM D6400 for
compostability at an industrial composting facility
• Same durable, compostable liner – just a different color
Green Bag Organix Collection Program
Green Bag Organix™ is patent pending.
14. Green Bag Organix Collection Program
14
The organics collection program eliminates the need for
private haulers or municipalities to add routes, trucks and
containers to collect organics, saving enormous costs.
• Organic waste is co-collected with other MSW where it is then
sorted and diverted to compost facilities to become nutrient rich
compost
• Single container, single route by single truck
• BPI® certified 100% Compostable Extreme Duty Liner
(13 gallon and 33 gallon)
• Durable and tear resistant; withstands cold, rain, humidity and UV
• Biodegrades within 45 days at an industrial composting facility
• Helps reduce contamination (our data shows rate <3%)
We will assist in the design of next generation MRF for
processing organics.
15. Monthly Processing for Green Bag Organix Program
15
Prepared for a city in Massachusetts
Number of Households 7,549
Inbound MSW Tons Per Month 456
Tons Per Hour Capacity* 15
Monthly Sort Hours 30.4
Sort Labor $15.00
Staff Labor $35.00
2
1
$912.00
$1,064.00
$1,976.00Labor Subtotal
Portable Sort Line Conveyor (per month**)
Total Monthly Sorting Expense (labor and sort line)
$1,250.00
$3,226.00
$38,712.00Annual Sorting Expense
Processing Headcount
Revenue
Tons per month $/ton Total
456 $9.00 $4,104.00Processing Fee
$49,248.00Annual Fee
$10,536.00Gross Profit (for hauler or Processor) 21.4%
Monthly Processing Fee Charged Per Household $0.54
Cost of Green Bag Organix (GBO) Program @ $59.95 Per Year Per Household
10% Participation
20% Participation
30% Participation
40% Participation
755
1,510
2,265
3,020
$59.95
$59.95
$59.95
$59.95
$45,256.26
$90,512.51
$135,768.77
$181,025.02
Each Household paying $2.00 per month for GBO Program 7,549 $2.00 $181,176.00
Total Monthly Cost Per Household for GBO Program
with Processing fee
7,549 $2.54 $230,424.00
An Example for Comparison
Community in Minnesota: Monthly Costs for
Dedicated Organics
Truck Collection Hours 13
Truck Rate per Hour $90.00
Number of Customers 344
Amortized Cost of Cart $1.05
Disposal Tons 1.3
Tip Fee $45.00
Truck Rate per Month $5,066.10
Cost per Resident $14.73
Cost per Resident w/Dedicated Organics Cart $15.78
Tip Fee per Customer $0.17
Total Monthly Cost Per Household for
Dedicated Organics Including disposal
$15.95
*Portable Sort Line Conveyor has a 15 tons per hour operating capability.
**Portable Sort Line Conveyer cost to purchase is $75,000. ($1,250 per month amortized over 60 months.)
16. Organics Collection Carbon Emissions Baseline Study
16
Elk River, Minnesota
Organics Collection GHG Analysis Table 1: Metric tons (MT) of greenhouse gases (GHG) emitted per ton for SSOM-only,
MSW-only and Blue Bag Organics collection. Measured in metric ton GHG equivalents per ton (MTCO2e/ton).
SSOM-only
Diesel Fuel 0.343
MSW-only Blue Bag Organics®
0.025 0.026
Data Results Key Findings:
• GHG emissions per ton for SSOM-only are over 100 times that of MSW-only or Blue Bag Organics.
• Blue Bag Organics emits far less GHGs than SSOM-only collection.
• Notable contributing factor is the low quantity of organics collected per route through SSOM-only (1.07 – 1.46 tons)
compared to MSW-only (11.77 – 23.56 tons) and Blue Bag Organics (11.77 – 23.53 tons).
• Ratio of waste collected to fuel consumed greatly reduces GHG emissions per ton.
Our goal is to increase recovery rates for organics processing. Our work is focused on assisting communities, haulers and industry to meet their diversion goals— keep them ahead of the curve with state, county and city diversion mandates and legislation. We aim to ensure any program our customers implement is repeatable, measurable and manageable.
Residents collect their food scraps and food soiled papers in the 13-gallon Extreme Duty Green Bag, tie a knot and place the compostable bag in the same cart with their trash. On the regular trash collection day, the hauler empties the cart and the compostable bags are then sorted at a transfer station or MRF where they are diverted to a composting facility. Because this program co-collects with trash, no additional cart or truck is necessary. This eliminates the need for a dedicated organics route.
We are currently operating the Blue Bag Organics® collection program in 32 Minnesota communities and several national commercial accounts. We are also actively involved in pilot programming in Massachusetts, California and Vermont, where legislation for organics diversion is gaining traction. We believe our organics co-collection with MSW on a single truck to be the most cost-effective solution for communities and haulers.
We are also actively involved in pilot programming in Massachusetts, California and Vermont, where legislation for organics diversion is gaining traction. We believe our organics co-collection with MSW on a single truck to be the most cost-effective solution for communities and haulers.
We manufacture our own proprietary 100% compostable liners branded as Green Bag Organix™ and Blue Bag Organics. Our Extreme Duty compostable bags are designed for durability to withstand truck compaction and are fully compostable - certified by the Biodegradable Products Institute (BPI) to meet the industry standard test methods of ASTM D 6400 for compostability at an industrial composting facility. Cedar Grove Composting in Everett, Washington, one of the largest commercial composters, performed tests on Organix Solutions’ compostable bags and affirmed the compostability of the 13-gallon extreme duty bag
The program developed by Organix Solutions takes in to account the additional cost of a sort line and labor involved with organics. We can provide cost examples based on your current labor rates and tonnage, as well as assist with planning and implementation of an efficient portable sort line. We are involved with several North Shore communities who are attempting to implement a pilot program. For the purpose of the pilot we can make available a new portable sort line for a 90-day trial.
An example of a single community serves to illustrate the economic feasibility of the Green Bag Organix collection program. This particular example was an exploratory completed for a City in Massachusetts. In this example the cost of the Green Bag program was compared to the known cost of a dedicated organics route. In the Green Bag model, the cost is shared among all households regardless of participation which remains voluntary. The cost per household is $2.54 per month for curbside organics collections on the same truck as the MSW. This compares to a cost of $15.95 per household for a dedicated organics route.
Communities sometimes are missing the goal of reducing carbon missions by failing to consider the environmental impact of added trucks.
Organix Solutions provided data to Wenck Engineering in Minnesota to conduct a carbon emissions study. Data provided included figures on collection costs, miles, fuel and man-hours. The City of Elk River, Minnesota recently changed from a dedicate organics route to the Blue Bag Organics program. Wenck’s analysis provided an approximate and relative baseline for the current Blue Bag collection program. The numbers represent a snapshot of GHGs associated with different waste collection systems.