1. Comments on “Real Time Gesture
Learning and Recognition: Towards
Automatic Categorization”
Muhammad Ikhsan Assaat
Scientific Writing Class
Baptiste Caramiaux, Patrick Susini, Tommaso Bianco, Frédéric Bevilacqua, Olivier Houix, Norbert Schnell, Nicolas Misdariis, Gestural Embodiment of
Environmental Sounds : an Experimental Study, Proceedings of the International Conference on New Interfaces for Musical Expression, pp. 144–148, 2011.

2. Structure
• Clear Structure
• Abstract, Introduction, Methods, Results,
Discussions, Conclusion, Future Work

3. Clarity
• Usage of graphs for data visualization
• Technical terms although people in the respected
field should be familiar

4. Content
• Techniques to recognize gestures from
accelerometer sensor (Wii controller)
• Recognize a fixed length gesture with supervised
method
• Recognize various length gesture with
unsupervised method
• Related work around gesture recognition field

5. Understanding
• Conference tend to have specified format
• Structure gives readers familiarity