SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 5
Download to read offline
International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention 
ISSN (Online): 2319 – 7722, ISSN (Print): 2319 – 7714 
www.ijhssi.org Volume 3 Issue 9 ǁ September. 2014ǁ PP.63-67 
www.ijhssi.org 63 | P a g e 
Nexus Between Inflation And Economic Development In India Dr. Renu Tanwar Assistant Professor Dyal Singh College Karnal (India 
I. INTRODUCTION 
There is a great controversy over the question whether inflation promotes economic development or not. The relationship between inflation and growth remains a controversial one in both theory and empirical findings. A group of economists including Keynes is of the opinion that inflation is a factor which helps economic growth. It is argued that inflation tends to redistribute income and wealth. Keynes favours mild inflation on the ground that it tends to stimulate business optimism through rising prices, resulting in high profit expectation which stimulates further investments, employment, output and income. A majority of economists hold that inflation is a child of growth process. Some degree of inflation is probably unavoidable in the process of economic development. Another group of economists is of the view that inflation does not stimulate economic development but on the contrary, works as an inhibitory factor. Milton Friedman, for instance, totally disagrees with the policy of "development through inflation. The objective of this study is to find out the trade off between inflation and economic development in India and also discuss the measurement of Inflation in India. 
II. OBJECTIVES 
To discuss the measurement of inflation in India To study the trade off between inflation and economic development in India 
III. METHODOLOGY 
This study has been based on secondary data. All the sources were subject related and the sources used were books, journals, newspapers and websites. The paper will be divided in following sections Section 1 Introduction Section 2 Review of literature Section 3 Measurement of inflation in India Section 4 Nexus between inflation and economic development in India Section 5 Conclusions 
IV. REVIEW OF LITERATURE 
Review of literature is very important in case of any study because we can find out what others have done on these lines and what we are going to do. Understanding the relationship between inflation and real growth has all along been a key concern in macro-economic research. Earlier works (for example, Tun Wai, 1959) failed to establish any meaningful relationship between inflation and economic growth. Some cross- country studies, found that inflation affecting economic growth negatively, includes Fischer (1993), Barro (1996) and Bruno and Easterly (1998). Fischer (1993) and Barro (1996) found a very small negative impact of inflation on growth. Yet Fischer (1993: 281) concluded ―however weak the evidence, one strong conclusion can be drawn: inflation is not good for longer-term growth. Barro (1996) also preferred price stability because he believed it to be good for economic growth.De Gregorio (1993) presents evidence from 12 Latin American countries over the period 1950–85. He finds a significant negative correlation between inflation and growth. Though both inflation and its variance have negative effects on growth, since they are highly correlated in cross- 11 country evidence, the results cannot discriminate whether it is the level or the variability that negatively affects growth. Even when high inflation countries were eliminated from the regression, the impact of inflation was both negative and significant Another study by Paul, Kearney and Chowdhury (1997) involving 70 countries (of which 48 are developing economies) for the period 1960-1989 found no causal relationship between inflation and economic growth in 40 % of the countries.Malik and Chowdhury (2001) observed the relationship between inflation and GDP growth for four South Asian countries which is Bangladesh, India, Pakistan and Sri Lanka. They established two results that inflation and economic growth are positively and statistically significantly related for all four countries and the sensitivity of growth to changes in inflation rates is smaller than that of inflation to changes in growth rates. Another study by Faria and Carneiro (2001) claimed
Nexus Between Inflation And Economic... 
www.ijhssi.org 64 | P a g e 
a divergent view from Malik and Chowdhurry (2001). They have measure the relationship between inflation and economic growth in the context of Brazil which has been undergone severe inflation until recently. They took the annual data for the period between 1980 and 1995, they argued that although there is a negative relationship between inflation and economic growth in the short run, but in the long run, economic growth does not affected by inflation. Girija and Anis (2001) use co integration and error correction models to empirically test the long run and short run dynamics of the inflation-economic growth relationship for the four South Asian Countries viz., Bangladesh, India, Pakistan and Srilanka. Using the Annual Data, this study finds that there is long run positive relationship between growth and inflation.Prasanna V Salian, Gopakumar seeks to examine the relationship between inflation and GDP growth in India. An empirical evidence is obtained from the cointegration and error correction models using annual data collected from the Reserve Bank of India. The result shows that there is a long-run negative relationship between inflation and GDP growth rate in India. Inflation is harmful rather than helpful to growth. These results have important policy implications. Cross-country evidence appears to support a cross-country negative relationship. In general, countries with higher growth are those with lower inflation rates. A World Bank study finds that the high-performing East Asian countries, that have had sustained high growth for the last three decades, have each had a stable macroeconomic environment that fostered high rates of investment and economic growth (World Bank 1993). Macroeconomic stability has been defined as inflation being kept under control, internal and external debt remaining manageable, and resolving the macroeconomic crisis that emerged within a year or two. 
MEASUREMENT OF INFLATION IN INDIA : Inflation is usually measured based on certain indices. Broadly, there are two categories of indices for measuring inflation i.e. Wholesale Prices and Consumer Prices. There are certain sub-categories for these indices. An Index number is a single figure that shows how the whole set of related variables has changed over time or from one place to another. Many developing countries use changes in the Consumer Price Index (CPI) as their central measure of inflation. However, this method is unsuitable for use in India, for structural and demographic reasons. CPI numbers are typically measured monthly, and with a significant lag, making them unsuitable for policy use.In India we use five major national indices for measuring inflation or price levels. The Wholesale Price Index is usually considered as the headline inflation indicator in India. In addition to Whole Price Index there are four different consumer price indices which are used to assess the inflation for different sections of the labour force. In addition to above five indices, the GDP deflator as an indicator of inflation is available for the economy as a whole and its different sectors, on a quarterly basis. Wholesale Price Index (WPI) : This index is the most widely used inflation indicator in India. This is published by the Office of Economic Adviser, Ministry of Commerce and Industry. WPI captures price movements in a most comprehensive way. It is widely used by Government, banks, industry and business circles. Important monetary and fiscal policy changes are linked to WPI movements. It is in use since 1939 and is being published since 1947 regularly. The base year of WPI has been revised on number of occasions. The current series of Wholesale Price Index has 2004-05 as the base year. Latest revision of WPI has been done by shifting base year from 1993-94 to 2004-05 on the recommendations of the Working Group set up with Prof Abhijit Sen, Member, Planning Commission as Chairman for revision of WPI series. This new series with base year 2004-05 has been launched on 14th September, 2010. A brief on the historical development of this WPI is given below: -
Nexus Between Inflation And Economic... 
www.ijhssi.org 65 | P a g e 
Table 1: Historical development of this WPI 
Base Year 
Year of Introduction 
No of Items in Index 
No of Price Quotations 
Week ended 19th August 1939 
1942 
23 
23 
End August 1939 
1947 
78 
215 
1952-53 (1948-49 as weight base) 
1952 
112 
555 
1961-62 
July 1969 
139 
774 
1970-71 
January 1977 
350 
1295 
1981-82 
July 1989 
447 
2371 
1993-94 
April 2000 
435 
1918 
2004-05 
September 2010 
676 
5482 
Methodology, Basket and Weights Adopted for Revised Index Numbers of Wholesale Prices in India with Base Year 2004-05 = 100. WPI and Inflation Data up to 2010 based on new series with base year 2004-05 Thus the latest WPI has a basket of 676 items with 5482 quotations. There are three major categories which have different weights. Table 2: Weights of different categories under WPI 
Category 
Weight 
Primary Articles 
20.12% 
Fuel & Power 
14.91% 
Manufactured Products 
64.97% 
Thus we can say that the WPI measures the price of a representative basket of wholesale goods. In India, this basket is composed of three groups: Primary Articles, Fuel and Power and Manufactured Products. Food Articles from the Primary Articles Group account for 14.3% of the total weight. The most important components of the Manufactured Products Group are Chemicals and Chemical products (12%); Basic Metals, Alloys and Metal Products (10.8%); Machinery and Machine Tools (8.9%); Textiles (7.3%) and Transport, Equipment and Parts (5.2%). WPI numbers are typically measured weekly by the Ministry of Commerce and Industry. The general criticism of WPI is that it considers the wholesale price which is not relevant for consumers because they purchase on retail prices. In this context, a major problem identified by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) is the measurement of inflation in India: ―Which inflation index do we target? Our headline inflation index is the WPI and that does not, by definition, reflect the consumer price situation." (Subbarao (2010a) Secondly WPI has been criticised due to non exclusion of services. The multiplicity of inflation indices available in India has often been described as problematic and has been used as an argument for not adopting a full fledged inflation targeting framework. NEXUS BETWEEN INFLATION AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT IN INDIA : 
To attain sustainable economic growth with price stability continues to be the central objective of macroeconomic policies for most countries in the world today.In the outcome of the global financial crisis in 2008, as growth gradually recovered, inflation gained momentum in India. Inflation remained higher and persisted at above the comfort level of the Reserve Bank of India. The debate of growth-inflation trade-off and the role of monetary policy reappeared and have once again acquired centre stage of recent policy debate. High output growth and low inflation are among the most important objectives of macroeconomic policy. But there are perceived trade-offs between lowering inflation and achieving high growth. Empirical evidence emphasizes that the growth-inflation relationship depends on the level of inflation—at some low levels, inflation may be positively correlated with growth, but at higher levels inflation is likely to be harmful to growth. In other words, the relationship between inflation and output growth is non-linear. If such a non-linear relationship exists, then it should be possible to estimate the inflexion point, or threshold, beyond which output growth becomes costly. In this context, several studies have examined the relationship between inflation and long-run growth in a non- linear framework. There are different economic theories which ascertain consensus on the inflation – growth
Nexus Between Inflation And Economic... 
www.ijhssi.org 66 | P a g e 
relationship. Classical economics recalls supply-side theories, which emphasise the need for incentives to save and invest if the nation's economy is to grow. Keynesian theory provided the AD-AS framework, a more comprehensive model for linking inflation to growth. Monetarism reemphasised the critical role of monetary growth in determining inflation, while Neoclassical and Endogenous Growth theories sought to account for the effects of inflation on growth through its impact on investment and capital accumulation. A plethora of research has extensively examined all the dimensions and aspects of the relationship between inflation and growth including the nature of their interaction and the direction of causality. Bruno and Easterly (1996) also found using different panels, that episodes of high inflation corresponded with negative growth in output. Ghosh and Phillips (1998) interestingly noticed that during low inflation period, there is a significant positive impact on growth, but beyond a certain limit (2 to 3 percent per year), inflation however negatively affects growth in output. Furthermore, they have found that decline is inflation positively influences growth. While there is a consensus suggesting that in the long run, high inflation is correlated with a lower level of economic growth, several other studies have examined this finding for a single country over time. Rangarajan (1997) analyzed data for India and established the range of 5-7 percent which has been further confirmed by Samantaraya and Prasad (2001) who suggested that 6.5 percent is the estimated threshold. Mubarik (2005) studied data for Pakistan for a wide sample period of 1973-2005 and concluded that beyond 9 percent, inflation affects growth adversely, while at a moderately low level of 5 percent, inflation positively influences growth.Krishna Veni and Pradeep Kumar Choudhury concluded on the basis of their study , Based on data of Indian economy during 1981-2004, that the two variables inflation and growth are not co integrated. Therefore, it is evident that there is no long run relationship between these two variables in India. It is also clear from this study that since the growth of the economy is not related to inflation, acceleration of growth should be focused forever as one of the foremost economic objectives of the nation. Similarly, inflation may take place due to supply side and demand side factors. Apart from these, the monetary factors and the international factors also may lead to inflation. Based on the circumstances, the government has to take the timely measures to control the inflation in order to maintain economic stability in the economy. In her paper Saumitra N Bhaduri concluded the negative correlation between the inflation and growth for India, the original series is small and weak. However, after decomposing the data and extracting the long run and short run components, a stronger and persistent negative relationship emerges between the growth and inflation while it is insignificant for the longer term.Using the monthly wholesale price index and index of industrial production as the proxies of inflation and output growth respectively Bipradas Rit have constructed a bivariate GARCH model of inflation and growth to find the relationship between inflation, inflation uncertainty and output growth of India. They find strong evidence of positive relationship between inflation and inflation uncertainty and between growth and growth uncertainty. But no statistically significant relationship between inflation uncertainty and output growth rate has been empirically observed. This analysis suggests that price stability must not be the main focus of policy prescription. .Deepak Mohanty, A B Chakraborty, Abhiman Das and Joice John examine the issue of the existence of threshold effects in the relationship between inflation rate and real GDP growth in India using 3 different approaches. Their empirical analysis uses data for the period of Q1:1996-97 to Q3:2010-11 in order to capture the more recent picture of the growth inflation nexus and results suggest that there exists statistically significant structural break in the relation between output growth and inflation in between 4.0 and 5.5 per cent of inflation above which inflation retards growth rate of GDP and below the threshold level, there is a statistically significant positive relationship between inflation rate and growth. Thus substantial gains can be achieved if inflation is kept below the threshold.
Nexus Between Inflation And Economic... 
www.ijhssi.org 67 | P a g e 
Fig. 1: Recent Trend of Real GDP Growth and Inflation in India Source:Inflation Threshold in India: An Empirical investigation* If we talk about threshold inflation in India, there a number of studies in Indian context which provided different views on inflation threshold. Chakarvarty Committee (1985) referred to it as the acceptable rise in prices at 4 per cent. Rangarajan (1998), who pioneered the concept of threshold inflation, brought central bank focus on inflation rate at 6–7 per cent known as ―acceptable level‖ of inflation. 
V. CONCLUSION 
High output growth and low inflation are among the most important objectives of macroeconomic policy. If we take the case of Indian Economy there are a number of studies which did not find any significant relationship between inflation and economic development. Low level of inflation is beneficial for development but above a certain level it retards economic development. In Indian context this is also true. Considering the relationship between inflation and economic development in India, Inflation targeting should be done which suggest an acceptable level of inflation. REFERENCES 
[1] Barro, R. (1990), Comment on R. Dornbusch, F. Sturzenegger, H. Wolf, Extreme Inflation: Dynamics and Stabilization. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity 2, 68-75. 
[2] Biswal, P.C., Kamiah.B. and Panigrahi, P.K. (2004), Wavelet Analysis of the Bombay Stock Exchange Index‖. Journal of Quantitative Economics, New series2 (1), 133-146. 
[3] Bruno, M., and W.Easterly (1996), Inflation and Growth: In Search of a Stable Relationship, The Federal Reserve Bank of Saint Louis Review, Vol.78, pp.139-146. 
[4] Burdekin, R.C.K, A.T.Denzau, M.W.Keil, T.Sitthiyot, and T.D.Willett (2004), When Does inflation Hurt Economic Growth? Different Nonlinearities for Different Economies, Journal of Macroeconomics, Vol 26, pp. 519-532. 
[5] Fischer, S. (1993), The Role of Macroeconomic Factors in Economic Growth, Journal of Monetary Economics, Vol.32, pp.485-512. 
[6] Ghosh, A., and S.Phillips (1998), Warning: Inflation May be Harmful to Your Growth, IMF Staff Papers, Vol.32, pp.672-710. 
[7] Bipradas Rit(2012) The Relationship between Inflation, Inflation Uncertainty and Output Growth in India Working Paper . 
[8] Bhaduri N Saumitra (2013) Revisiting the Growth-Inflation Nexus: A Wavelet Analysis working paper 77/2013 
(9) * Deepak Mohanty, A B Chakraborty, Abhiman Das and Joice John: Inflation threshold in India: An Empirical Investigation,RBI (10) L Krishna Veni and Pradeep Kumar Choudhary:Inflation and Growth Dilemma: An Econometric Analysis of the Indian Economy,The IUP Journal of Financial Economics.

More Related Content

What's hot

Single digit inflation targeting does it promote economic growth
Single digit inflation targeting does it promote economic growthSingle digit inflation targeting does it promote economic growth
Single digit inflation targeting does it promote economic growthAlexander Decker
 
Heritage Foods ltd
Heritage Foods ltdHeritage Foods ltd
Heritage Foods ltdAditya Mehta
 
Impact of political stability on the reserves of pakistan
Impact of political stability on the reserves of pakistanImpact of political stability on the reserves of pakistan
Impact of political stability on the reserves of pakistanKamran Arshad
 
Effect of nigerian macro economic and macro-environment related factors on a...
 Effect of nigerian macro economic and macro-environment related factors on a... Effect of nigerian macro economic and macro-environment related factors on a...
Effect of nigerian macro economic and macro-environment related factors on a...Alexander Decker
 
C431017
C431017C431017
C431017aijbm
 
INDIA’S GDP IN PRE AND POST GLOBALISED ERA: AN APPRAISAL
INDIA’S GDP IN PRE AND POST GLOBALISED ERA: AN APPRAISALINDIA’S GDP IN PRE AND POST GLOBALISED ERA: AN APPRAISAL
INDIA’S GDP IN PRE AND POST GLOBALISED ERA: AN APPRAISALIAEME Publication
 
International Trade and Economic Growth: A Cointegration Analysis for Uganda
International Trade and Economic Growth: A Cointegration Analysis for UgandaInternational Trade and Economic Growth: A Cointegration Analysis for Uganda
International Trade and Economic Growth: A Cointegration Analysis for UgandaPremier Publishers
 
132 article text-185-1-10-20210523
132 article text-185-1-10-20210523132 article text-185-1-10-20210523
132 article text-185-1-10-20210523Arslan Ishaq
 
DETERMINANTS OF INFLATION IN INDIA: AN ECONOMETRIC ANALYSIS
DETERMINANTS OF INFLATION IN INDIA: AN ECONOMETRIC ANALYSISDETERMINANTS OF INFLATION IN INDIA: AN ECONOMETRIC ANALYSIS
DETERMINANTS OF INFLATION IN INDIA: AN ECONOMETRIC ANALYSISSCHOLEDGE R&D CENTER
 
The impact of inflation, policy rate and government consumption expenditure o...
The impact of inflation, policy rate and government consumption expenditure o...The impact of inflation, policy rate and government consumption expenditure o...
The impact of inflation, policy rate and government consumption expenditure o...Alexander Decker
 
21 amassoma ditimi -219-237
21 amassoma ditimi -219-23721 amassoma ditimi -219-237
21 amassoma ditimi -219-237Alexander Decker
 
Choudhri et-al-2015-working-paper-1
Choudhri et-al-2015-working-paper-1Choudhri et-al-2015-working-paper-1
Choudhri et-al-2015-working-paper-1Arslan Ishaq
 
Abstract for the annual acedemic sessions 2014 s m irshad - economics-1
Abstract for the annual acedemic sessions 2014    s m irshad - economics-1Abstract for the annual acedemic sessions 2014    s m irshad - economics-1
Abstract for the annual acedemic sessions 2014 s m irshad - economics-1Sheikh irshad Sahabuddeen
 
indonesia macroeconomics condition
indonesia macroeconomics conditionindonesia macroeconomics condition
indonesia macroeconomics conditionRustan Amarullah
 

What's hot (20)

Single digit inflation targeting does it promote economic growth
Single digit inflation targeting does it promote economic growthSingle digit inflation targeting does it promote economic growth
Single digit inflation targeting does it promote economic growth
 
Heritage Foods ltd
Heritage Foods ltdHeritage Foods ltd
Heritage Foods ltd
 
Inflation
InflationInflation
Inflation
 
Impact of political stability on the reserves of pakistan
Impact of political stability on the reserves of pakistanImpact of political stability on the reserves of pakistan
Impact of political stability on the reserves of pakistan
 
Effect of nigerian macro economic and macro-environment related factors on a...
 Effect of nigerian macro economic and macro-environment related factors on a... Effect of nigerian macro economic and macro-environment related factors on a...
Effect of nigerian macro economic and macro-environment related factors on a...
 
Dp12197
Dp12197Dp12197
Dp12197
 
C431017
C431017C431017
C431017
 
Final Paper
Final PaperFinal Paper
Final Paper
 
INDIA’S GDP IN PRE AND POST GLOBALISED ERA: AN APPRAISAL
INDIA’S GDP IN PRE AND POST GLOBALISED ERA: AN APPRAISALINDIA’S GDP IN PRE AND POST GLOBALISED ERA: AN APPRAISAL
INDIA’S GDP IN PRE AND POST GLOBALISED ERA: AN APPRAISAL
 
International Trade and Economic Growth: A Cointegration Analysis for Uganda
International Trade and Economic Growth: A Cointegration Analysis for UgandaInternational Trade and Economic Growth: A Cointegration Analysis for Uganda
International Trade and Economic Growth: A Cointegration Analysis for Uganda
 
132 article text-185-1-10-20210523
132 article text-185-1-10-20210523132 article text-185-1-10-20210523
132 article text-185-1-10-20210523
 
Paper (2)
Paper (2)Paper (2)
Paper (2)
 
DETERMINANTS OF INFLATION IN INDIA: AN ECONOMETRIC ANALYSIS
DETERMINANTS OF INFLATION IN INDIA: AN ECONOMETRIC ANALYSISDETERMINANTS OF INFLATION IN INDIA: AN ECONOMETRIC ANALYSIS
DETERMINANTS OF INFLATION IN INDIA: AN ECONOMETRIC ANALYSIS
 
The impact of inflation, policy rate and government consumption expenditure o...
The impact of inflation, policy rate and government consumption expenditure o...The impact of inflation, policy rate and government consumption expenditure o...
The impact of inflation, policy rate and government consumption expenditure o...
 
Vol7no2 6
Vol7no2 6Vol7no2 6
Vol7no2 6
 
21 amassoma ditimi -219-237
21 amassoma ditimi -219-23721 amassoma ditimi -219-237
21 amassoma ditimi -219-237
 
Effect of Aggregated and Disaggregated Public Spending On the Nigerian Econom...
Effect of Aggregated and Disaggregated Public Spending On the Nigerian Econom...Effect of Aggregated and Disaggregated Public Spending On the Nigerian Econom...
Effect of Aggregated and Disaggregated Public Spending On the Nigerian Econom...
 
Choudhri et-al-2015-working-paper-1
Choudhri et-al-2015-working-paper-1Choudhri et-al-2015-working-paper-1
Choudhri et-al-2015-working-paper-1
 
Abstract for the annual acedemic sessions 2014 s m irshad - economics-1
Abstract for the annual acedemic sessions 2014    s m irshad - economics-1Abstract for the annual acedemic sessions 2014    s m irshad - economics-1
Abstract for the annual acedemic sessions 2014 s m irshad - economics-1
 
indonesia macroeconomics condition
indonesia macroeconomics conditionindonesia macroeconomics condition
indonesia macroeconomics condition
 

Viewers also liked

201 2-b intro-invention_management
201 2-b intro-invention_management201 2-b intro-invention_management
201 2-b intro-invention_managementAllan Espineli
 
Tarakin Ltd: Strategic Communications Mentoring Presentation
Tarakin Ltd: Strategic Communications Mentoring PresentationTarakin Ltd: Strategic Communications Mentoring Presentation
Tarakin Ltd: Strategic Communications Mentoring PresentationTarakin Ltd
 
The weaknesses of the muslims
The  weaknesses of the muslimsThe  weaknesses of the muslims
The weaknesses of the muslimsSUN&FZ Associates
 
Successful Basketball Inventions
Successful Basketball InventionsSuccessful Basketball Inventions
Successful Basketball Inventionsdavisondesign
 
Why Status Quo Always Defeats Change in Pakistan?
Why Status Quo Always Defeats Change in Pakistan?Why Status Quo Always Defeats Change in Pakistan?
Why Status Quo Always Defeats Change in Pakistan?SUN&FZ Associates
 
Samuel pipim the transformed mind
Samuel pipim   the transformed mindSamuel pipim   the transformed mind
Samuel pipim the transformed mindSamuel Pipim
 

Viewers also liked (10)

D039029030
D039029030D039029030
D039029030
 
201 2-b intro-invention_management
201 2-b intro-invention_management201 2-b intro-invention_management
201 2-b intro-invention_management
 
Tarakin Ltd: Strategic Communications Mentoring Presentation
Tarakin Ltd: Strategic Communications Mentoring PresentationTarakin Ltd: Strategic Communications Mentoring Presentation
Tarakin Ltd: Strategic Communications Mentoring Presentation
 
The weaknesses of the muslims
The  weaknesses of the muslimsThe  weaknesses of the muslims
The weaknesses of the muslims
 
The 6 stages for business advantage
The 6 stages for business advantage The 6 stages for business advantage
The 6 stages for business advantage
 
Successful Basketball Inventions
Successful Basketball InventionsSuccessful Basketball Inventions
Successful Basketball Inventions
 
Personnel security
Personnel securityPersonnel security
Personnel security
 
2011 edge innovation
2011 edge innovation2011 edge innovation
2011 edge innovation
 
Why Status Quo Always Defeats Change in Pakistan?
Why Status Quo Always Defeats Change in Pakistan?Why Status Quo Always Defeats Change in Pakistan?
Why Status Quo Always Defeats Change in Pakistan?
 
Samuel pipim the transformed mind
Samuel pipim   the transformed mindSamuel pipim   the transformed mind
Samuel pipim the transformed mind
 

Similar to J0391063067

Examine the long run relationship between financial development and economic ...
Examine the long run relationship between financial development and economic ...Examine the long run relationship between financial development and economic ...
Examine the long run relationship between financial development and economic ...Alexander Decker
 
Testing for fisher’s hypothesis in nigeria (1970 2012)
Testing for fisher’s hypothesis in nigeria (1970 2012)Testing for fisher’s hypothesis in nigeria (1970 2012)
Testing for fisher’s hypothesis in nigeria (1970 2012)Alexander Decker
 
A280109
A280109A280109
A280109aijbm
 
An empirical test of the relationship between private savings
An empirical test of the relationship between private savingsAn empirical test of the relationship between private savings
An empirical test of the relationship between private savingsAlexander Decker
 
Comparative Longitudinal Analysis on Global Inflation with a special emphasis...
Comparative Longitudinal Analysis on Global Inflation with a special emphasis...Comparative Longitudinal Analysis on Global Inflation with a special emphasis...
Comparative Longitudinal Analysis on Global Inflation with a special emphasis...Ram Sharma
 
11.economic growth and its determinants a longitudinal and a cross regional a...
11.economic growth and its determinants a longitudinal and a cross regional a...11.economic growth and its determinants a longitudinal and a cross regional a...
11.economic growth and its determinants a longitudinal and a cross regional a...Alexander Decker
 
Economic growth and its determinants a longitudinal and a cross regional anal...
Economic growth and its determinants a longitudinal and a cross regional anal...Economic growth and its determinants a longitudinal and a cross regional anal...
Economic growth and its determinants a longitudinal and a cross regional anal...Alexander Decker
 
Effect of inflation and unemployment on economic growth in pakistan
Effect of inflation and unemployment on economic growth in pakistanEffect of inflation and unemployment on economic growth in pakistan
Effect of inflation and unemployment on economic growth in pakistanAlexander Decker
 
Political Instability & Economic Development: Pakistan time-series Analysis
Political Instability & Economic Development: Pakistan time-series AnalysisPolitical Instability & Economic Development: Pakistan time-series Analysis
Political Instability & Economic Development: Pakistan time-series Analysisbc080200109
 
THE CHALLENGE OF INFLATION AND ITS CONSUMPTION RELATION
THE CHALLENGE OF INFLATION AND ITS CONSUMPTION RELATIONTHE CHALLENGE OF INFLATION AND ITS CONSUMPTION RELATION
THE CHALLENGE OF INFLATION AND ITS CONSUMPTION RELATIONpaperpublications3
 
THE CHALLENGE OF INFLATION AND ITS CONSUMPTION RELATION
THE CHALLENGE OF INFLATION AND ITS CONSUMPTION RELATIONTHE CHALLENGE OF INFLATION AND ITS CONSUMPTION RELATION
THE CHALLENGE OF INFLATION AND ITS CONSUMPTION RELATIONpaperpublications3
 
Relationship between economic growth and public expenditure
Relationship between economic growth and public expenditureRelationship between economic growth and public expenditure
Relationship between economic growth and public expenditureMarwadi University Rajkot
 
Qasrim Masheed M.Phil Economics Defence Presentation.ppt
Qasrim Masheed M.Phil Economics Defence Presentation.pptQasrim Masheed M.Phil Economics Defence Presentation.ppt
Qasrim Masheed M.Phil Economics Defence Presentation.pptFazalHayat12
 
Inflation and Trends in India
Inflation and Trends in IndiaInflation and Trends in India
Inflation and Trends in Indiaakashbalram
 
Savings-Growth-Inflation nexus in Asia: Panel Data Approach
Savings-Growth-Inflation nexus in Asia: Panel Data ApproachSavings-Growth-Inflation nexus in Asia: Panel Data Approach
Savings-Growth-Inflation nexus in Asia: Panel Data Approachiosrjce
 
Dynamics of monetary policy and output nexus in nigeria
Dynamics of monetary policy and output nexus in nigeriaDynamics of monetary policy and output nexus in nigeria
Dynamics of monetary policy and output nexus in nigeriaAlexander Decker
 
Fiscal deficit & inflation gaurav tripathi jamia millia islamia, new delhi
Fiscal deficit & inflation gaurav tripathi jamia millia islamia, new delhiFiscal deficit & inflation gaurav tripathi jamia millia islamia, new delhi
Fiscal deficit & inflation gaurav tripathi jamia millia islamia, new delhiJamia Millia Islamia, delhi
 

Similar to J0391063067 (20)

Examine the long run relationship between financial development and economic ...
Examine the long run relationship between financial development and economic ...Examine the long run relationship between financial development and economic ...
Examine the long run relationship between financial development and economic ...
 
Testing for fisher’s hypothesis in nigeria (1970 2012)
Testing for fisher’s hypothesis in nigeria (1970 2012)Testing for fisher’s hypothesis in nigeria (1970 2012)
Testing for fisher’s hypothesis in nigeria (1970 2012)
 
A280109
A280109A280109
A280109
 
An empirical test of the relationship between private savings
An empirical test of the relationship between private savingsAn empirical test of the relationship between private savings
An empirical test of the relationship between private savings
 
Comparative Longitudinal Analysis on Global Inflation with a special emphasis...
Comparative Longitudinal Analysis on Global Inflation with a special emphasis...Comparative Longitudinal Analysis on Global Inflation with a special emphasis...
Comparative Longitudinal Analysis on Global Inflation with a special emphasis...
 
Exam Assignmen5t
Exam Assignmen5tExam Assignmen5t
Exam Assignmen5t
 
11.economic growth and its determinants a longitudinal and a cross regional a...
11.economic growth and its determinants a longitudinal and a cross regional a...11.economic growth and its determinants a longitudinal and a cross regional a...
11.economic growth and its determinants a longitudinal and a cross regional a...
 
Economic growth and its determinants a longitudinal and a cross regional anal...
Economic growth and its determinants a longitudinal and a cross regional anal...Economic growth and its determinants a longitudinal and a cross regional anal...
Economic growth and its determinants a longitudinal and a cross regional anal...
 
Effect of inflation and unemployment on economic growth in pakistan
Effect of inflation and unemployment on economic growth in pakistanEffect of inflation and unemployment on economic growth in pakistan
Effect of inflation and unemployment on economic growth in pakistan
 
Political Instability & Economic Development: Pakistan time-series Analysis
Political Instability & Economic Development: Pakistan time-series AnalysisPolitical Instability & Economic Development: Pakistan time-series Analysis
Political Instability & Economic Development: Pakistan time-series Analysis
 
THE CHALLENGE OF INFLATION AND ITS CONSUMPTION RELATION
THE CHALLENGE OF INFLATION AND ITS CONSUMPTION RELATIONTHE CHALLENGE OF INFLATION AND ITS CONSUMPTION RELATION
THE CHALLENGE OF INFLATION AND ITS CONSUMPTION RELATION
 
THE CHALLENGE OF INFLATION AND ITS CONSUMPTION RELATION
THE CHALLENGE OF INFLATION AND ITS CONSUMPTION RELATIONTHE CHALLENGE OF INFLATION AND ITS CONSUMPTION RELATION
THE CHALLENGE OF INFLATION AND ITS CONSUMPTION RELATION
 
Relationship between economic growth and public expenditure
Relationship between economic growth and public expenditureRelationship between economic growth and public expenditure
Relationship between economic growth and public expenditure
 
Stock Market Development and Economic Growth in Bangladesh: An Empirical Appr...
Stock Market Development and Economic Growth in Bangladesh: An Empirical Appr...Stock Market Development and Economic Growth in Bangladesh: An Empirical Appr...
Stock Market Development and Economic Growth in Bangladesh: An Empirical Appr...
 
Qasrim Masheed M.Phil Economics Defence Presentation.ppt
Qasrim Masheed M.Phil Economics Defence Presentation.pptQasrim Masheed M.Phil Economics Defence Presentation.ppt
Qasrim Masheed M.Phil Economics Defence Presentation.ppt
 
Inflation and Trends in India
Inflation and Trends in IndiaInflation and Trends in India
Inflation and Trends in India
 
Savings-Growth-Inflation nexus in Asia: Panel Data Approach
Savings-Growth-Inflation nexus in Asia: Panel Data ApproachSavings-Growth-Inflation nexus in Asia: Panel Data Approach
Savings-Growth-Inflation nexus in Asia: Panel Data Approach
 
Dynamics of monetary policy and output nexus in nigeria
Dynamics of monetary policy and output nexus in nigeriaDynamics of monetary policy and output nexus in nigeria
Dynamics of monetary policy and output nexus in nigeria
 
Inflation and its impact
Inflation and its impactInflation and its impact
Inflation and its impact
 
Fiscal deficit & inflation gaurav tripathi jamia millia islamia, new delhi
Fiscal deficit & inflation gaurav tripathi jamia millia islamia, new delhiFiscal deficit & inflation gaurav tripathi jamia millia islamia, new delhi
Fiscal deficit & inflation gaurav tripathi jamia millia islamia, new delhi
 

Recently uploaded

FULL ENJOY - 8264348440 Call Girls in Rohini Sector 22 | Delhi
FULL ENJOY - 8264348440 Call Girls in Rohini Sector 22 | DelhiFULL ENJOY - 8264348440 Call Girls in Rohini Sector 22 | Delhi
FULL ENJOY - 8264348440 Call Girls in Rohini Sector 22 | Delhisoniya singh
 
Indira Nagar Lucknow #Call Girls Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payme...
Indira Nagar Lucknow #Call Girls Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payme...Indira Nagar Lucknow #Call Girls Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payme...
Indira Nagar Lucknow #Call Girls Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payme...akbard9823
 
Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow | Whatsapp No 8923113531 VIP Escorts Ser...
Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow | Whatsapp No 8923113531 VIP Escorts Ser...Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow | Whatsapp No 8923113531 VIP Escorts Ser...
Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow | Whatsapp No 8923113531 VIP Escorts Ser...anilsa9823
 
Lucknow 💋 Escort Service in Lucknow (Adult Only) 8923113531 Escort Service 2...
Lucknow 💋 Escort Service in Lucknow  (Adult Only) 8923113531 Escort Service 2...Lucknow 💋 Escort Service in Lucknow  (Adult Only) 8923113531 Escort Service 2...
Lucknow 💋 Escort Service in Lucknow (Adult Only) 8923113531 Escort Service 2...anilsa9823
 
Jeremy Casson - An Architectural and Historical Journey Around Europe
Jeremy Casson - An Architectural and Historical Journey Around EuropeJeremy Casson - An Architectural and Historical Journey Around Europe
Jeremy Casson - An Architectural and Historical Journey Around EuropeJeremy Casson
 
Bridge Fight Board by Daniel Johnson dtjohnsonart.com
Bridge Fight Board by Daniel Johnson dtjohnsonart.comBridge Fight Board by Daniel Johnson dtjohnsonart.com
Bridge Fight Board by Daniel Johnson dtjohnsonart.comthephillipta
 
Lucknow 💋 (Call Girls) in Mahanagar | Service-oriented sexy call girls 892311...
Lucknow 💋 (Call Girls) in Mahanagar | Service-oriented sexy call girls 892311...Lucknow 💋 (Call Girls) in Mahanagar | Service-oriented sexy call girls 892311...
Lucknow 💋 (Call Girls) in Mahanagar | Service-oriented sexy call girls 892311...anilsa9823
 
Gomti Nagar & High Profile Call Girls in Lucknow (Adult Only) 8923113531 Esc...
Gomti Nagar & High Profile Call Girls in Lucknow  (Adult Only) 8923113531 Esc...Gomti Nagar & High Profile Call Girls in Lucknow  (Adult Only) 8923113531 Esc...
Gomti Nagar & High Profile Call Girls in Lucknow (Adult Only) 8923113531 Esc...gurkirankumar98700
 
AaliyahBell_themist_v01.pdf .
AaliyahBell_themist_v01.pdf             .AaliyahBell_themist_v01.pdf             .
AaliyahBell_themist_v01.pdf .AaliyahB2
 
Lucknow 💋 Cheap Call Girls In Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 8923113531 Avail...
Lucknow 💋 Cheap Call Girls In Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 8923113531 Avail...Lucknow 💋 Cheap Call Girls In Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 8923113531 Avail...
Lucknow 💋 Cheap Call Girls In Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 8923113531 Avail...anilsa9823
 
(9711106444 )🫦#Sexy Desi Call Girls Noida Sector 4 Escorts Service Delhi 🫶
(9711106444 )🫦#Sexy Desi Call Girls Noida Sector 4 Escorts Service Delhi 🫶(9711106444 )🫦#Sexy Desi Call Girls Noida Sector 4 Escorts Service Delhi 🫶
(9711106444 )🫦#Sexy Desi Call Girls Noida Sector 4 Escorts Service Delhi 🫶delhimunirka444
 
VIP Ramnagar Call Girls, Ramnagar escorts Girls 📞 8617697112
VIP Ramnagar Call Girls, Ramnagar escorts Girls 📞 8617697112VIP Ramnagar Call Girls, Ramnagar escorts Girls 📞 8617697112
VIP Ramnagar Call Girls, Ramnagar escorts Girls 📞 8617697112Nitya salvi
 
Authentic # 00971556872006 # Hot Call Girls Service in Dubai By International...
Authentic # 00971556872006 # Hot Call Girls Service in Dubai By International...Authentic # 00971556872006 # Hot Call Girls Service in Dubai By International...
Authentic # 00971556872006 # Hot Call Girls Service in Dubai By International...home
 
Lucknow 💋 Call Girls Service Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...
Lucknow 💋 Call Girls Service Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...Lucknow 💋 Call Girls Service Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...
Lucknow 💋 Call Girls Service Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...anilsa9823
 
Lucknow 💋 Call Girl in Lucknow | Whatsapp No 8923113531 VIP Escorts Service A...
Lucknow 💋 Call Girl in Lucknow | Whatsapp No 8923113531 VIP Escorts Service A...Lucknow 💋 Call Girl in Lucknow | Whatsapp No 8923113531 VIP Escorts Service A...
Lucknow 💋 Call Girl in Lucknow | Whatsapp No 8923113531 VIP Escorts Service A...anilsa9823
 
Charbagh ! (Call Girls) in Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 🥗 8923113531 🏊 Avai...
Charbagh ! (Call Girls) in Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 🥗 8923113531 🏊 Avai...Charbagh ! (Call Girls) in Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 🥗 8923113531 🏊 Avai...
Charbagh ! (Call Girls) in Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 🥗 8923113531 🏊 Avai...gurkirankumar98700
 
Hazratganj ] (Call Girls) in Lucknow - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 🧄 89231135...
Hazratganj ] (Call Girls) in Lucknow - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 🧄 89231135...Hazratganj ] (Call Girls) in Lucknow - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 🧄 89231135...
Hazratganj ] (Call Girls) in Lucknow - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 🧄 89231135...akbard9823
 
The First Date by Daniel Johnson (Inspired By True Events)
The First Date by Daniel Johnson (Inspired By True Events)The First Date by Daniel Johnson (Inspired By True Events)
The First Date by Daniel Johnson (Inspired By True Events)thephillipta
 
Lucknow 💋 Call Girl in Lucknow Phone No 8923113531 Elite Escort Service Avail...
Lucknow 💋 Call Girl in Lucknow Phone No 8923113531 Elite Escort Service Avail...Lucknow 💋 Call Girl in Lucknow Phone No 8923113531 Elite Escort Service Avail...
Lucknow 💋 Call Girl in Lucknow Phone No 8923113531 Elite Escort Service Avail...anilsa9823
 
Admirable # 00971529501107 # Call Girls at dubai by Dubai Call Girl
Admirable # 00971529501107 # Call Girls at dubai by Dubai Call GirlAdmirable # 00971529501107 # Call Girls at dubai by Dubai Call Girl
Admirable # 00971529501107 # Call Girls at dubai by Dubai Call Girlhome
 

Recently uploaded (20)

FULL ENJOY - 8264348440 Call Girls in Rohini Sector 22 | Delhi
FULL ENJOY - 8264348440 Call Girls in Rohini Sector 22 | DelhiFULL ENJOY - 8264348440 Call Girls in Rohini Sector 22 | Delhi
FULL ENJOY - 8264348440 Call Girls in Rohini Sector 22 | Delhi
 
Indira Nagar Lucknow #Call Girls Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payme...
Indira Nagar Lucknow #Call Girls Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payme...Indira Nagar Lucknow #Call Girls Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payme...
Indira Nagar Lucknow #Call Girls Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payme...
 
Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow | Whatsapp No 8923113531 VIP Escorts Ser...
Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow | Whatsapp No 8923113531 VIP Escorts Ser...Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow | Whatsapp No 8923113531 VIP Escorts Ser...
Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow | Whatsapp No 8923113531 VIP Escorts Ser...
 
Lucknow 💋 Escort Service in Lucknow (Adult Only) 8923113531 Escort Service 2...
Lucknow 💋 Escort Service in Lucknow  (Adult Only) 8923113531 Escort Service 2...Lucknow 💋 Escort Service in Lucknow  (Adult Only) 8923113531 Escort Service 2...
Lucknow 💋 Escort Service in Lucknow (Adult Only) 8923113531 Escort Service 2...
 
Jeremy Casson - An Architectural and Historical Journey Around Europe
Jeremy Casson - An Architectural and Historical Journey Around EuropeJeremy Casson - An Architectural and Historical Journey Around Europe
Jeremy Casson - An Architectural and Historical Journey Around Europe
 
Bridge Fight Board by Daniel Johnson dtjohnsonart.com
Bridge Fight Board by Daniel Johnson dtjohnsonart.comBridge Fight Board by Daniel Johnson dtjohnsonart.com
Bridge Fight Board by Daniel Johnson dtjohnsonart.com
 
Lucknow 💋 (Call Girls) in Mahanagar | Service-oriented sexy call girls 892311...
Lucknow 💋 (Call Girls) in Mahanagar | Service-oriented sexy call girls 892311...Lucknow 💋 (Call Girls) in Mahanagar | Service-oriented sexy call girls 892311...
Lucknow 💋 (Call Girls) in Mahanagar | Service-oriented sexy call girls 892311...
 
Gomti Nagar & High Profile Call Girls in Lucknow (Adult Only) 8923113531 Esc...
Gomti Nagar & High Profile Call Girls in Lucknow  (Adult Only) 8923113531 Esc...Gomti Nagar & High Profile Call Girls in Lucknow  (Adult Only) 8923113531 Esc...
Gomti Nagar & High Profile Call Girls in Lucknow (Adult Only) 8923113531 Esc...
 
AaliyahBell_themist_v01.pdf .
AaliyahBell_themist_v01.pdf             .AaliyahBell_themist_v01.pdf             .
AaliyahBell_themist_v01.pdf .
 
Lucknow 💋 Cheap Call Girls In Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 8923113531 Avail...
Lucknow 💋 Cheap Call Girls In Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 8923113531 Avail...Lucknow 💋 Cheap Call Girls In Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 8923113531 Avail...
Lucknow 💋 Cheap Call Girls In Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 8923113531 Avail...
 
(9711106444 )🫦#Sexy Desi Call Girls Noida Sector 4 Escorts Service Delhi 🫶
(9711106444 )🫦#Sexy Desi Call Girls Noida Sector 4 Escorts Service Delhi 🫶(9711106444 )🫦#Sexy Desi Call Girls Noida Sector 4 Escorts Service Delhi 🫶
(9711106444 )🫦#Sexy Desi Call Girls Noida Sector 4 Escorts Service Delhi 🫶
 
VIP Ramnagar Call Girls, Ramnagar escorts Girls 📞 8617697112
VIP Ramnagar Call Girls, Ramnagar escorts Girls 📞 8617697112VIP Ramnagar Call Girls, Ramnagar escorts Girls 📞 8617697112
VIP Ramnagar Call Girls, Ramnagar escorts Girls 📞 8617697112
 
Authentic # 00971556872006 # Hot Call Girls Service in Dubai By International...
Authentic # 00971556872006 # Hot Call Girls Service in Dubai By International...Authentic # 00971556872006 # Hot Call Girls Service in Dubai By International...
Authentic # 00971556872006 # Hot Call Girls Service in Dubai By International...
 
Lucknow 💋 Call Girls Service Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...
Lucknow 💋 Call Girls Service Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...Lucknow 💋 Call Girls Service Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...
Lucknow 💋 Call Girls Service Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...
 
Lucknow 💋 Call Girl in Lucknow | Whatsapp No 8923113531 VIP Escorts Service A...
Lucknow 💋 Call Girl in Lucknow | Whatsapp No 8923113531 VIP Escorts Service A...Lucknow 💋 Call Girl in Lucknow | Whatsapp No 8923113531 VIP Escorts Service A...
Lucknow 💋 Call Girl in Lucknow | Whatsapp No 8923113531 VIP Escorts Service A...
 
Charbagh ! (Call Girls) in Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 🥗 8923113531 🏊 Avai...
Charbagh ! (Call Girls) in Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 🥗 8923113531 🏊 Avai...Charbagh ! (Call Girls) in Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 🥗 8923113531 🏊 Avai...
Charbagh ! (Call Girls) in Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 🥗 8923113531 🏊 Avai...
 
Hazratganj ] (Call Girls) in Lucknow - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 🧄 89231135...
Hazratganj ] (Call Girls) in Lucknow - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 🧄 89231135...Hazratganj ] (Call Girls) in Lucknow - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 🧄 89231135...
Hazratganj ] (Call Girls) in Lucknow - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 🧄 89231135...
 
The First Date by Daniel Johnson (Inspired By True Events)
The First Date by Daniel Johnson (Inspired By True Events)The First Date by Daniel Johnson (Inspired By True Events)
The First Date by Daniel Johnson (Inspired By True Events)
 
Lucknow 💋 Call Girl in Lucknow Phone No 8923113531 Elite Escort Service Avail...
Lucknow 💋 Call Girl in Lucknow Phone No 8923113531 Elite Escort Service Avail...Lucknow 💋 Call Girl in Lucknow Phone No 8923113531 Elite Escort Service Avail...
Lucknow 💋 Call Girl in Lucknow Phone No 8923113531 Elite Escort Service Avail...
 
Admirable # 00971529501107 # Call Girls at dubai by Dubai Call Girl
Admirable # 00971529501107 # Call Girls at dubai by Dubai Call GirlAdmirable # 00971529501107 # Call Girls at dubai by Dubai Call Girl
Admirable # 00971529501107 # Call Girls at dubai by Dubai Call Girl
 

J0391063067

  • 1. International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention ISSN (Online): 2319 – 7722, ISSN (Print): 2319 – 7714 www.ijhssi.org Volume 3 Issue 9 ǁ September. 2014ǁ PP.63-67 www.ijhssi.org 63 | P a g e Nexus Between Inflation And Economic Development In India Dr. Renu Tanwar Assistant Professor Dyal Singh College Karnal (India I. INTRODUCTION There is a great controversy over the question whether inflation promotes economic development or not. The relationship between inflation and growth remains a controversial one in both theory and empirical findings. A group of economists including Keynes is of the opinion that inflation is a factor which helps economic growth. It is argued that inflation tends to redistribute income and wealth. Keynes favours mild inflation on the ground that it tends to stimulate business optimism through rising prices, resulting in high profit expectation which stimulates further investments, employment, output and income. A majority of economists hold that inflation is a child of growth process. Some degree of inflation is probably unavoidable in the process of economic development. Another group of economists is of the view that inflation does not stimulate economic development but on the contrary, works as an inhibitory factor. Milton Friedman, for instance, totally disagrees with the policy of "development through inflation. The objective of this study is to find out the trade off between inflation and economic development in India and also discuss the measurement of Inflation in India. II. OBJECTIVES To discuss the measurement of inflation in India To study the trade off between inflation and economic development in India III. METHODOLOGY This study has been based on secondary data. All the sources were subject related and the sources used were books, journals, newspapers and websites. The paper will be divided in following sections Section 1 Introduction Section 2 Review of literature Section 3 Measurement of inflation in India Section 4 Nexus between inflation and economic development in India Section 5 Conclusions IV. REVIEW OF LITERATURE Review of literature is very important in case of any study because we can find out what others have done on these lines and what we are going to do. Understanding the relationship between inflation and real growth has all along been a key concern in macro-economic research. Earlier works (for example, Tun Wai, 1959) failed to establish any meaningful relationship between inflation and economic growth. Some cross- country studies, found that inflation affecting economic growth negatively, includes Fischer (1993), Barro (1996) and Bruno and Easterly (1998). Fischer (1993) and Barro (1996) found a very small negative impact of inflation on growth. Yet Fischer (1993: 281) concluded ―however weak the evidence, one strong conclusion can be drawn: inflation is not good for longer-term growth. Barro (1996) also preferred price stability because he believed it to be good for economic growth.De Gregorio (1993) presents evidence from 12 Latin American countries over the period 1950–85. He finds a significant negative correlation between inflation and growth. Though both inflation and its variance have negative effects on growth, since they are highly correlated in cross- 11 country evidence, the results cannot discriminate whether it is the level or the variability that negatively affects growth. Even when high inflation countries were eliminated from the regression, the impact of inflation was both negative and significant Another study by Paul, Kearney and Chowdhury (1997) involving 70 countries (of which 48 are developing economies) for the period 1960-1989 found no causal relationship between inflation and economic growth in 40 % of the countries.Malik and Chowdhury (2001) observed the relationship between inflation and GDP growth for four South Asian countries which is Bangladesh, India, Pakistan and Sri Lanka. They established two results that inflation and economic growth are positively and statistically significantly related for all four countries and the sensitivity of growth to changes in inflation rates is smaller than that of inflation to changes in growth rates. Another study by Faria and Carneiro (2001) claimed
  • 2. Nexus Between Inflation And Economic... www.ijhssi.org 64 | P a g e a divergent view from Malik and Chowdhurry (2001). They have measure the relationship between inflation and economic growth in the context of Brazil which has been undergone severe inflation until recently. They took the annual data for the period between 1980 and 1995, they argued that although there is a negative relationship between inflation and economic growth in the short run, but in the long run, economic growth does not affected by inflation. Girija and Anis (2001) use co integration and error correction models to empirically test the long run and short run dynamics of the inflation-economic growth relationship for the four South Asian Countries viz., Bangladesh, India, Pakistan and Srilanka. Using the Annual Data, this study finds that there is long run positive relationship between growth and inflation.Prasanna V Salian, Gopakumar seeks to examine the relationship between inflation and GDP growth in India. An empirical evidence is obtained from the cointegration and error correction models using annual data collected from the Reserve Bank of India. The result shows that there is a long-run negative relationship between inflation and GDP growth rate in India. Inflation is harmful rather than helpful to growth. These results have important policy implications. Cross-country evidence appears to support a cross-country negative relationship. In general, countries with higher growth are those with lower inflation rates. A World Bank study finds that the high-performing East Asian countries, that have had sustained high growth for the last three decades, have each had a stable macroeconomic environment that fostered high rates of investment and economic growth (World Bank 1993). Macroeconomic stability has been defined as inflation being kept under control, internal and external debt remaining manageable, and resolving the macroeconomic crisis that emerged within a year or two. MEASUREMENT OF INFLATION IN INDIA : Inflation is usually measured based on certain indices. Broadly, there are two categories of indices for measuring inflation i.e. Wholesale Prices and Consumer Prices. There are certain sub-categories for these indices. An Index number is a single figure that shows how the whole set of related variables has changed over time or from one place to another. Many developing countries use changes in the Consumer Price Index (CPI) as their central measure of inflation. However, this method is unsuitable for use in India, for structural and demographic reasons. CPI numbers are typically measured monthly, and with a significant lag, making them unsuitable for policy use.In India we use five major national indices for measuring inflation or price levels. The Wholesale Price Index is usually considered as the headline inflation indicator in India. In addition to Whole Price Index there are four different consumer price indices which are used to assess the inflation for different sections of the labour force. In addition to above five indices, the GDP deflator as an indicator of inflation is available for the economy as a whole and its different sectors, on a quarterly basis. Wholesale Price Index (WPI) : This index is the most widely used inflation indicator in India. This is published by the Office of Economic Adviser, Ministry of Commerce and Industry. WPI captures price movements in a most comprehensive way. It is widely used by Government, banks, industry and business circles. Important monetary and fiscal policy changes are linked to WPI movements. It is in use since 1939 and is being published since 1947 regularly. The base year of WPI has been revised on number of occasions. The current series of Wholesale Price Index has 2004-05 as the base year. Latest revision of WPI has been done by shifting base year from 1993-94 to 2004-05 on the recommendations of the Working Group set up with Prof Abhijit Sen, Member, Planning Commission as Chairman for revision of WPI series. This new series with base year 2004-05 has been launched on 14th September, 2010. A brief on the historical development of this WPI is given below: -
  • 3. Nexus Between Inflation And Economic... www.ijhssi.org 65 | P a g e Table 1: Historical development of this WPI Base Year Year of Introduction No of Items in Index No of Price Quotations Week ended 19th August 1939 1942 23 23 End August 1939 1947 78 215 1952-53 (1948-49 as weight base) 1952 112 555 1961-62 July 1969 139 774 1970-71 January 1977 350 1295 1981-82 July 1989 447 2371 1993-94 April 2000 435 1918 2004-05 September 2010 676 5482 Methodology, Basket and Weights Adopted for Revised Index Numbers of Wholesale Prices in India with Base Year 2004-05 = 100. WPI and Inflation Data up to 2010 based on new series with base year 2004-05 Thus the latest WPI has a basket of 676 items with 5482 quotations. There are three major categories which have different weights. Table 2: Weights of different categories under WPI Category Weight Primary Articles 20.12% Fuel & Power 14.91% Manufactured Products 64.97% Thus we can say that the WPI measures the price of a representative basket of wholesale goods. In India, this basket is composed of three groups: Primary Articles, Fuel and Power and Manufactured Products. Food Articles from the Primary Articles Group account for 14.3% of the total weight. The most important components of the Manufactured Products Group are Chemicals and Chemical products (12%); Basic Metals, Alloys and Metal Products (10.8%); Machinery and Machine Tools (8.9%); Textiles (7.3%) and Transport, Equipment and Parts (5.2%). WPI numbers are typically measured weekly by the Ministry of Commerce and Industry. The general criticism of WPI is that it considers the wholesale price which is not relevant for consumers because they purchase on retail prices. In this context, a major problem identified by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) is the measurement of inflation in India: ―Which inflation index do we target? Our headline inflation index is the WPI and that does not, by definition, reflect the consumer price situation." (Subbarao (2010a) Secondly WPI has been criticised due to non exclusion of services. The multiplicity of inflation indices available in India has often been described as problematic and has been used as an argument for not adopting a full fledged inflation targeting framework. NEXUS BETWEEN INFLATION AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT IN INDIA : To attain sustainable economic growth with price stability continues to be the central objective of macroeconomic policies for most countries in the world today.In the outcome of the global financial crisis in 2008, as growth gradually recovered, inflation gained momentum in India. Inflation remained higher and persisted at above the comfort level of the Reserve Bank of India. The debate of growth-inflation trade-off and the role of monetary policy reappeared and have once again acquired centre stage of recent policy debate. High output growth and low inflation are among the most important objectives of macroeconomic policy. But there are perceived trade-offs between lowering inflation and achieving high growth. Empirical evidence emphasizes that the growth-inflation relationship depends on the level of inflation—at some low levels, inflation may be positively correlated with growth, but at higher levels inflation is likely to be harmful to growth. In other words, the relationship between inflation and output growth is non-linear. If such a non-linear relationship exists, then it should be possible to estimate the inflexion point, or threshold, beyond which output growth becomes costly. In this context, several studies have examined the relationship between inflation and long-run growth in a non- linear framework. There are different economic theories which ascertain consensus on the inflation – growth
  • 4. Nexus Between Inflation And Economic... www.ijhssi.org 66 | P a g e relationship. Classical economics recalls supply-side theories, which emphasise the need for incentives to save and invest if the nation's economy is to grow. Keynesian theory provided the AD-AS framework, a more comprehensive model for linking inflation to growth. Monetarism reemphasised the critical role of monetary growth in determining inflation, while Neoclassical and Endogenous Growth theories sought to account for the effects of inflation on growth through its impact on investment and capital accumulation. A plethora of research has extensively examined all the dimensions and aspects of the relationship between inflation and growth including the nature of their interaction and the direction of causality. Bruno and Easterly (1996) also found using different panels, that episodes of high inflation corresponded with negative growth in output. Ghosh and Phillips (1998) interestingly noticed that during low inflation period, there is a significant positive impact on growth, but beyond a certain limit (2 to 3 percent per year), inflation however negatively affects growth in output. Furthermore, they have found that decline is inflation positively influences growth. While there is a consensus suggesting that in the long run, high inflation is correlated with a lower level of economic growth, several other studies have examined this finding for a single country over time. Rangarajan (1997) analyzed data for India and established the range of 5-7 percent which has been further confirmed by Samantaraya and Prasad (2001) who suggested that 6.5 percent is the estimated threshold. Mubarik (2005) studied data for Pakistan for a wide sample period of 1973-2005 and concluded that beyond 9 percent, inflation affects growth adversely, while at a moderately low level of 5 percent, inflation positively influences growth.Krishna Veni and Pradeep Kumar Choudhury concluded on the basis of their study , Based on data of Indian economy during 1981-2004, that the two variables inflation and growth are not co integrated. Therefore, it is evident that there is no long run relationship between these two variables in India. It is also clear from this study that since the growth of the economy is not related to inflation, acceleration of growth should be focused forever as one of the foremost economic objectives of the nation. Similarly, inflation may take place due to supply side and demand side factors. Apart from these, the monetary factors and the international factors also may lead to inflation. Based on the circumstances, the government has to take the timely measures to control the inflation in order to maintain economic stability in the economy. In her paper Saumitra N Bhaduri concluded the negative correlation between the inflation and growth for India, the original series is small and weak. However, after decomposing the data and extracting the long run and short run components, a stronger and persistent negative relationship emerges between the growth and inflation while it is insignificant for the longer term.Using the monthly wholesale price index and index of industrial production as the proxies of inflation and output growth respectively Bipradas Rit have constructed a bivariate GARCH model of inflation and growth to find the relationship between inflation, inflation uncertainty and output growth of India. They find strong evidence of positive relationship between inflation and inflation uncertainty and between growth and growth uncertainty. But no statistically significant relationship between inflation uncertainty and output growth rate has been empirically observed. This analysis suggests that price stability must not be the main focus of policy prescription. .Deepak Mohanty, A B Chakraborty, Abhiman Das and Joice John examine the issue of the existence of threshold effects in the relationship between inflation rate and real GDP growth in India using 3 different approaches. Their empirical analysis uses data for the period of Q1:1996-97 to Q3:2010-11 in order to capture the more recent picture of the growth inflation nexus and results suggest that there exists statistically significant structural break in the relation between output growth and inflation in between 4.0 and 5.5 per cent of inflation above which inflation retards growth rate of GDP and below the threshold level, there is a statistically significant positive relationship between inflation rate and growth. Thus substantial gains can be achieved if inflation is kept below the threshold.
  • 5. Nexus Between Inflation And Economic... www.ijhssi.org 67 | P a g e Fig. 1: Recent Trend of Real GDP Growth and Inflation in India Source:Inflation Threshold in India: An Empirical investigation* If we talk about threshold inflation in India, there a number of studies in Indian context which provided different views on inflation threshold. Chakarvarty Committee (1985) referred to it as the acceptable rise in prices at 4 per cent. Rangarajan (1998), who pioneered the concept of threshold inflation, brought central bank focus on inflation rate at 6–7 per cent known as ―acceptable level‖ of inflation. V. CONCLUSION High output growth and low inflation are among the most important objectives of macroeconomic policy. If we take the case of Indian Economy there are a number of studies which did not find any significant relationship between inflation and economic development. Low level of inflation is beneficial for development but above a certain level it retards economic development. In Indian context this is also true. Considering the relationship between inflation and economic development in India, Inflation targeting should be done which suggest an acceptable level of inflation. REFERENCES [1] Barro, R. (1990), Comment on R. Dornbusch, F. Sturzenegger, H. Wolf, Extreme Inflation: Dynamics and Stabilization. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity 2, 68-75. [2] Biswal, P.C., Kamiah.B. and Panigrahi, P.K. (2004), Wavelet Analysis of the Bombay Stock Exchange Index‖. Journal of Quantitative Economics, New series2 (1), 133-146. [3] Bruno, M., and W.Easterly (1996), Inflation and Growth: In Search of a Stable Relationship, The Federal Reserve Bank of Saint Louis Review, Vol.78, pp.139-146. [4] Burdekin, R.C.K, A.T.Denzau, M.W.Keil, T.Sitthiyot, and T.D.Willett (2004), When Does inflation Hurt Economic Growth? Different Nonlinearities for Different Economies, Journal of Macroeconomics, Vol 26, pp. 519-532. [5] Fischer, S. (1993), The Role of Macroeconomic Factors in Economic Growth, Journal of Monetary Economics, Vol.32, pp.485-512. [6] Ghosh, A., and S.Phillips (1998), Warning: Inflation May be Harmful to Your Growth, IMF Staff Papers, Vol.32, pp.672-710. [7] Bipradas Rit(2012) The Relationship between Inflation, Inflation Uncertainty and Output Growth in India Working Paper . [8] Bhaduri N Saumitra (2013) Revisiting the Growth-Inflation Nexus: A Wavelet Analysis working paper 77/2013 (9) * Deepak Mohanty, A B Chakraborty, Abhiman Das and Joice John: Inflation threshold in India: An Empirical Investigation,RBI (10) L Krishna Veni and Pradeep Kumar Choudhary:Inflation and Growth Dilemma: An Econometric Analysis of the Indian Economy,The IUP Journal of Financial Economics.