SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 18
Download to read offline
Making Leaders Successful Every Day
January 20, 2009
Business Performance Solutions:
Clash Of The Titans
by Paul D. Hamerman
for Business Process & Applications Professionals
© 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. All rights reserved. Unauthorized reproduction is strictly prohibited. Information is based on best available
resources. Opinions reflect judgment at the time and are subject to change. Forrester®, Technographics®, Forrester Wave, RoleView, TechRadar,
and Total Economic Impact are trademarks of Forrester Research, Inc. All other trademarks are the property of their respective companies. To
purchase reprints of this document, please email clientsupport@forrester.com. For additional information, go to www.forrester.com.
For Business Process & Applications Professionals
Includes a market sizing forecast
Executive Summary
Business performance solutions (BPS) — a software category consisting of applications for budgeting,
forecasting, financial reporting, profitability analysis, and performance measurement — has seen dramatic
growth and vendor consolidation over the past two years. The growth prospects for this space remain
bright, despite the near-term impact of the recession, driven by strong interest in strategy and performance
measurement. Forrester expects BPS software revenues to grow by 12.7% through 2012, growing from its
current size of $2 billion to $3.2 billion during this timeframe. Six large vendors — IBM, Infor, Microsoft,
Oracle, SAP, and SAS Institute — dominate this market, while a number of business intelligence (BI),
enterprise resource planning (ERP), specialists, and BPS pure plays offer a variety of interesting alternatives.
table of Contents
Business Performance Solutions Monitor The
Pulse Of An Organization
The Recession Will Only Temporarily Slow BPS
Growth
BPS Vendors Come In All Shapes And Sizes
recommendations
Learn From Best Practices To Avoid
Implementation Risks
WHAT IT MEANS
Market Consolidation Leaves The Door Open
For Innovation
Supplemental Material
NOTES & RESOURCES
This research is based on numerous client
inquiries, as well as ongoing briefings and
discussions with BPS vendors, including Actuate,
Adaptive Planning, Board International, Clarity
Systems, Host Analytics, IBM Cognos, Infor,
Lawson Software, Longview Solutions, Microsoft,
Oracle, SAP, SAS Institute, and Tagetik.
Related Research Documents
“Measuring And Aligning Business Performance”
April 2, 2008
“The Forrester Wave™: Business Performance
Solutions, Q4, 2007”
October 10, 2007
“Business Performance Solutions: The
Competition Heats Up”
February 7, 2007
January 20, 2009
Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans
The Market Remains Vibrant Following Vendor Consolidation
by Paul D. Hamerman
with Kyle McNabb and Meghan Donnelly
2
5
9
14
15
15
© 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction ProhibitedJanuary 20, 2009
Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans
For Business Process & Applications Professionals
2
BUsiness Performance Solutions Monitor The Pulse Of An Organization
Business performance management consists of a set of processes, frameworks, and systems for
activities such as planning, measuring, communicating, and monitoring business results (see
Figure 1). Enterprises typically link these activities to corporate strategies and objectives and might
drive them down to many individuals within the organization to encourage accountability and
control. Forrester defines business performance solutions as a category of purpose-built software
applications that support these activities.1
The major BPS functional elements include:
·	Strategy and performance measurement address goals, objectives, and accountability. A
strategy management application supports formal strategy management philosophies (e.g., the
Balanced Scorecard) but might be adapted to a business’ specific needs. Applications often display
the strategy definition in visual strategy maps. Scorecards measure progress against the goals and
objectives set forth in the strategy framework. Performance dashboards display more detailed
information and allow drilling down to root-cause detail. Dashboards typically include a variety
of key performance indicators (KPIs) that might include strategic scorecards as well as relevant
comparisons against plans, budgets, forecasts, prior performance, and industry benchmark data.
·	Planning, budgeting, and forecasting solutions support multiple forward-looking processes.
Although used almost universally as a control on spending, budgeting often falls short in
supporting performance initiatives — often the result of a rigorous and inflexible process, not
due to a software shortcoming per se. Fortunately, in addition to budgeting, the planning
solutions support a variety of scenario-based planning activities as well as forecasting processes
that add value beyond that provided by traditional budgeting processes.
·	Cost and profitability management provides detailed analysis to improve margins. This
complex modeling activity helps organizations analyze development, production, and operating
costs against revenues by product, customers, and lines of business. Cost and profitability
management applications often use activity-based costing as the methodology to develop
sophisticated cost and profitability analytical models.
·	Financial reporting and consolidation produce financial statements. Financial reporting and
consolidation applications produce reports focused on delivering financial statements based
on accounting results. Statutory consolidations support regulatory compliance and generally
accepted accounting principles (GAAP) requirements. These applications also support internal
reporting of financial information.
Although the functional elements described above align primarily with finance processes,
enterprises can use strategy and performance measurement, as well as forecasting, to support
all areas of the business. Many BPS product portfolios often include purpose-built performance
management applications for nonfinance areas including human resources (HR), operations,
supply chain, sales, and IT. All types of businesses and government organizations use BPS products,
although considerable extension and adaptation to business requirements is often required.
© 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction Prohibited January 20, 2009
Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans
For Business Process & Applications Professionals
3
Figure 1 Business Performance Solutions Footprint
Organizations Face An Uphill Battle With Business Performance Process Execution
Adopting a strategically aligned and performance-driven culture is easier said than done. Performance-
driven enterprises need more timely support than traditional management processes — including
budgeting and accounting — often provide. Similarly, planning and measurement processes based
on labor-intensive methods (e.g., spreadsheets) are not responsive enough to run the business.
Business performance initiatives suffer from implementation and execution challenges ranging from
culture and organizational alignment to technology integration and project execution. Typical BPS
implementation challenges include the following:
·	Strategies and execution processes are misaligned. All reasonably successful businesses have
a strategy, but often do not support their strategies with processes for communicating, aligning,
and executing them. When business units and departments lack a formalized performance
measurement system aligned with strategy, they develop their own performance measurements
and reporting mechanisms. The result: a great deal of effort expended, but company goals and
objectives are under-realized.
·	Financial accounting and budgeting processes move more slowly than the business.
Financial information, a critical component of business performance information, enables the
visibility of revenues, expenses, profitability, and assets across various organizational dimensions.
Source: Forrester Research, Inc.46571
User experience
Dashboards Scorecards Spreadsheets
BPS application components
Business intelligence
platforms and
integration tools
ERP systems
Configuration tools for processes and business models
Financial reporting
and consolidation
Strategy and
performance measurement
Planning, budgeting,
and forecasting
Cost and profitability
management
© 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction ProhibitedJanuary 20, 2009
Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans
For Business Process & Applications Professionals
4
Yet problems with the complex procedures and batch interfaces required to close the books
along with lengthy budget preparation cycles diminish the actionable value of the information.
·	Improvement initiatives face cultural resistance and unanticipated behaviors. Any initiative
to drive change in an organization, even if mandated from the top, faces natural resistance. The
phrase “you are what you measure” highlights the profound impact of measurements on human
behavior.2
To gauge their true behavioral impact, organizations must put measurements into
play, requiring trial-and-error tweaking. Measurement systems present challenges, particularly
when they affect compensation and, potentially, job security.
·	Business performance questions go unanswered, even with the best technology. A multitude
of technology challenges hinder delivering performance information. One of the biggest
challenges, data integration, must collect information residing in a number of transactional
systems. Even when the systems can successfully assemble information on a BI platform, the
daunting task of effective information delivery remains. Business stakeholders must willingly
engage in the process of shaping the business models and frameworks that drive the delivery of
results. Therefore, IT-led initiatives to build and deliver performance management solutions are
doomed to fail without strong business-driven alignment.
BPS Packages Often Replace Homegrown Solutions
An organization with a strong internal BI IT talent pool and a robust BI infrastructure will likely
have developed customized business performance systems, particularly to address business
performance measurement and forecasting requirements. Companies with very limited resources
still rely primarily on spreadsheets and basic tools for business performance reporting and analysis.
These approaches have worked well for some organizations, but frequently require labor-intensive
maintenance and lack desired levels of flexibility.
BPS packages offer a level of configurability that puts control more squarely into the hands of
the business stakeholders. These solutions typically provide more business process control and
accountability than homegrown solutions, as well as starter kits containing best practices and
prebuilt functionality. Despite these user-driven advantages, IT’s role remains critical for integrating
and managing the underlying information. Enterprises seeking BPS support should look for:
·	Compelling graphics and user interface features. While some products rely heavily on a
signature graphical paradigm, such as fuel gauges, customers need a selection of graphical looks
to suit the information context. End users should have the ability to personalize the presentation
of the graphical content by selecting the visualizations (e.g., symbols, colors, and charts) that
bring the information to life.
·	Breadth of information. The extent to which a BPS vendor embeds a comprehensive analytical
data model differentiates many products. The data model should represent the full breadth of
© 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction Prohibited January 20, 2009
Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans
For Business Process & Applications Professionals
5
the business, from finance to sales and operations, as well as supporting a variety of business
types. The solution should also enable organizations to compare certain KPIs to industry
metrics via connections to external content publishers.
·	Flexibility and extensibility. Every enterprise has a combination of needs ranging from
common to unique, so the flexibility of the product to be configured (not customized) with
nonstandard measurements is essential. The business problems to support, from budgets, to
forecasts, to profitability analysis, depend on the business users’ abilities to model attributes
such as hierarchical structures, mathematical formulas, and timeframes.
·	Openness for integrating multiple data sources. The product needs to be open at the data level
to analyze information from multiple systems. Vendors typically embed or work with leading
data integration and extract, transform, and load tools to manage the diversity of data inputs
to the system. The measurement applications ideally should allow access to underlying details
within the data through drilling into the source data.
·	Support for measurement frameworks. Enterprises often find best practice measurement
frameworks useful as predefined structures within the BPS tools. For example, several tools
provide support for Balanced Scorecard frameworks and may be certified as compliant by the
Balanced Scorecard Collaborative organization.
The Recession Will Only Temporarily Slow BPS Growth
BPS has strong long-term growth prospects, but this software category is not immune to the
recession that we expect to continue well into 2009. Total software revenues (licenses, maintenance,
and subscriptions) will grow by 12.7% compound annual growth rate (CAGR) through 2012
from $2 billion in 2008 to $3.2 billion in 2012 (see Figure 2). We based our market size estimate
on our analysis of individual vendor product revenues and momentum. In analyzing the revenue
components, we find:
·	License revenue will see a slight decline in 2009, followed by a strong recovery. The
recessionary impact is manifested primarily in license revenues, due to reductions in IT
spending. Ironically, software for managing budgets and forecasts, mission-critical in times
of intense economic pressure, make up a significant portion of this market. Enterprises
will struggle to justify upgrading planning and analysis software in the middle of the crisis.
Following a slight 2009 decline, licensing will return to strong levels for 2010 and beyond.
·	Maintenance is substantial and sustainable. Due to the maturity of the BPS market,
particularly for planning and financial consolidation applications, application maintenance
fees provide a strong recurring revenue base. Maintenance revenues will continue to grow as
new licenses and automatic contractual increases are added to the base. Since maintenance
© 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction ProhibitedJanuary 20, 2009
Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans
For Business Process & Applications Professionals
6
represents more than half of the total BPS product revenues (54%), it will sustain overall growth
for the segment even in this challenging macroeconomic climate.
·	Subscriptions will grow as the market gravitates toward software-as-a-service (SaaS).
Software subscription revenue, including SaaS, currently makes up a relatively small component
(8%) of total BPS revenues. But subscription revenue will grow at a 15.7% CAGR during the next
few years. SAS Institute currently generates the bulk of the subscription revenue in this space
today, although enterprises deploy its applications on-premise. SaaS vendors in this space —
including relatively small companies like Adaptive Planning and Host Analytics — will see good
uptake as this deployment model moves toward becoming the mainstream in BPS. Within three
years, customer demand for the SaaS consumption model will compel larger BPS vendors to
introduce SaaS offerings.
Figure 2 Forecast: Global BPS Market Growth 2008 To 2012
Source: Forrester Research, Inc.46571
The spreadsheet detailing this forecast is available online.
$0
$500
$1,000
$1,500
$2,000
$2,500
$3,000
$3,500
Revenue
(US$ millions)
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
Total revenue (millions)
$139
$974
$670
$1,783
$155
$1,082
$744
$1,981
$183
$1,223
$737
$2,142
$222
$1,407
$840
$2,468
$266
$1,632
$940
$2,838
$289
$1,893
$1,053
$3,235
Subscription revenue
Maintenance revenue
License revenue
15.7%
14.2%
9.5%
12.7%
(numbers have been rounded)
CAGR
Subscription
revenue
Maintenance
revenue
License
revenue
Actual Forecast
Sources: Company reports, Hoover’s, and Forrester estimates.
© 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction Prohibited January 20, 2009
Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans
For Business Process & Applications Professionals
7
Strategy And Performance Measurement Solutions Lead BPS Component Growth
The traditional finance components — planning, budgeting, and forecasting and financial reporting
— make up 39% and 28%, respectively, of BPS product revenues. Strategy and performance
measurement (25%), however, has the highest growth rate at 18%, as companies move toward more
comprehensive enterprise performance initiatives (see Figure 3). Considering each of the four
component categories individually, we find:
·	Forecasting has moved to the forefront as a growth driver for the planning category.
Demand remains strong (11% growth through 2012) for planning, budgeting, and forecasting
solutions, which enable companies to support a range of planning processes. Forecasting is a
more nimble planning vehicle than either budgeting or structured financial planning models
(e.g., for mergers and acquisitions). In fact, flexible forecasting models, which organizations
can build for various aspects of the business, drive many deals to help companies cope with
economic uncertainty and market volatility.
·	Financial reporting and consolidation is largely a replacement market. Public companies
with multiple subsidiaries and lines of business use these applications primarily for external
reporting and statutory compliance. As a mature category, maintenance sustains its 10% growth
rate, but legacy product replacement and stopgap solutions fuel licensing. Regulatory filing
requirements, adoption of eXtensible Business Reporting Language (XBRL) as an open standard
for rendering financial statements, and adoption of international accounting standards (i.e.,
International Financial Reporting Standards) drive growth for this mature segment of BPS.
·	Strategy and performance measurement systems have the highest growth potential in
BPS. Many organizations already measure business performance across the enterprise using a
variety of metrics and KPIs, but technology capabilities often lag management’s need for this
information. The desire to formalize measurement processes, supported by incentive rewards,
contributes greatly to our forecasted 17% growth for this segment, a trend that parallels the
rapid uptake of human capital management applications for employee performance.3
The
incorporation of risk management measurement frameworks (key risk indicators [KRIs]) to
help companies anticipate the negative consequences of unusual events will also drive growth.4
·	Cost and profitability management is making a comeback. Current economic conditions
inspire renewed interest in closely managing costs and profitability. Though relatively small (8%
of BPS), this category has a healthy growth trajectory of 13% through 2012. Companies will
demand these tools to help them understand their most profitable products and customers, and
which water down profit margins. Adopters of these tools may benefit from expert guidance in
constructing the models, which software suppliers often provide.
© 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction ProhibitedJanuary 20, 2009
Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans
For Business Process & Applications Professionals
8
Figure 3 BPS Segment Analysis
Source: Forrester Research, Inc.46571
2008 BPS segmentation by product category3-1
2008 BPS segment growth3-2
Planning, budgeting,
and forecasting
39%
Financial reporting
28%
Strategy and
measurement
25%
Cost and
profitability
8%
(numbers have been rounded)
Source: Company reports, Hoover’s, and Forrester estimates.
18%
13%
11%
10%
Strategy and
measurement
Cost and
profitability
Planning, budgeting,
and forecasting
Financial reporting
© 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction Prohibited January 20, 2009
Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans
For Business Process & Applications Professionals
9
BPS Vendors Come In All Shapes And Sizes
Four of the largest information technology vendors in the world dominate the current BPS market —
IBM, Microsoft, Oracle, and SAP. A stunning market consolidation took place in 2007, when SAP,
IBM, and Oracle acquired three major BI and BPS vendors — Business Objects, Cognos, and
Hyperion, respectively. These BI vendors were also among the leaders in BPS at the time they were
acquired, and BPS assets factored heavily in these multibillion dollar acquisition transactions.
Microsoft’s entry into this market occurred in the same timeframe, largely through internal
development efforts of Microsoft Office PerformancePoint Server 2007. Two additional major BPS
players — Infor and SAS Institute — have annual revenues exceeding $2 billion, putting them
among the largest software vendors. These top six vendors currently account for approximately 70%
of the overall BPS market in terms of software revenues (licenses, maintenance, and subscriptions).
Expect More Of The Same: Market Consolidation Is Familiar Territory Within BPS
Prior to the large BI acquisitions, the BPS market had been consolidating for several years. Many
enterprise users of BPS still use the former brand names of the products they use, making a
genealogy chart useful for those trying to identify what they’ve licensed (see Figure 4).
Figure 4 Business Performance Solutions Vendor Genealogy, 2002 To 2008
Source: Forrester Research, Inc.46571
Oracle SAP IBM Microsoft Infor SAS Institute
Hyperion
Siebel
PeopleSoft
Interlace
Systems
UpStream
Software
Razza
Solutions
Decisioneering
(Crystal Ball)
Geac/
Extensity
Systems
Union
Comshare
Cognos
Applix
Adaytum
Frango
OutlookSoft
Pilot
Software
Business
Objects
ProClarity ABC
Technologies
FRx Software
Stratature
Dundas Data
Visualization
Cartesis
ALG
Software
SRC
Software
© 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction ProhibitedJanuary 20, 2009
Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans
For Business Process & Applications Professionals
10
Earlier transactions included in this roll-up include SAS Institute’s acquisition of cost and profitability
specialist ABC Technologies in 2002, and Cognos’ acquisition of budgeting and planning vendor
Adaytum in 2003. Several deals occurred just months prior to the larger BI acquisitions, including
SAP’s acquisitions of OutlookSoft and Pilot Software in 2007, and Cognos’ acquisition of Applix just
two months prior to the IBM-Cognos deal announcement in November 2007.
Whereas IBM had no pre-existing BPS assets to rationalize with Cognos, SAP and Oracle had more
overlaps to resolve. Each had to decide which products to lead with and which to put on life support.
Oracle’s clear choice was to lead with the Hyperion BPS products, while SAP chose a mix of assets
between its portfolio (e.g., OutlookSoft and Pilot Software) and those of Business Objects (e.g., ALG
Software and Cartesis).5
While vendors have well-defined road maps at this stage, the integration
and harmonization work continues.
BPS Offerings Fall Into Four Types Of Vendor Buckets
The types of vendors offering BPS products range from the technology giants to small, specialized
vendors (see Figure 5). Breadth of coverage of the four main BPS functional components varies
widely, and has no correlation to overall vendor size, as shown in the more detailed vendor guide
(see Figure 6). These categories and key vendors are described below.
·	Diversified technology leaders battle for supremacy. The four technology giants in this
category, as mentioned previously, control the lion’s share of this market. Each of these vendors
can provide standalone BPS solutions as individual products or suites, and can also align these
products with their major technology assets in applications and platforms.
·	ERP vendors focus on their applications base. Infor’s Performance Management solution,
formerly a best-of-breed product (Geac/Comshare), has some traction independent of its
diverse ERP applications installed base. However, Infor most often provides it as a cross-
sell or upsell to complement its core applications. Lawson generally sells its budgeting and
dashboarding products to its ERP base. The outlier in this category, Longview Solutions,
operates as an independent unit focusing on larger customers, while its parent company, Exact
Software, focuses on the small and medium-size business (SMB) ERP market.
·	Business intelligence vendors emphasize platforms and tools. SAS Institute is the only
member of this group that offers a comprehensive set of BPS offerings. While the SAS offerings
are well-integrated with one another, it is also the leading player in cost and profitability
solutions as a discrete offering. The other three BI vendors listed — Actuate, Information
Builders, and MicroStrategy — focus their BPS efforts on enterprise performance and strategy
measurement, with less emphasis on the financial domain components.
·	BPS pure plays focus on market niches. Vendors in this category range from comprehensive
BPS to point-solution providers, yet share a common strategy to differentiate themselves from
© 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction Prohibited January 20, 2009
Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans
For Business Process & Applications Professionals
11
the larger market leaders. European-based Board International (Switzerland) and Tagetik
(Italy) now seek growth in other markets, including the US. Clarity Systems has a strong
budgeting and planning solution along with a differentiated external financial statement and
regulatory product, Clarity FSR. Adaptive Planning and Host Analytics provide SaaS solutions
in an historical on-premise market. PROPHIX Software offers a budgeting and performance
management solution for SMBs. Specialist vendors in this bucket include Acorn Systems (cost
and profitability) along with many others.
Figure 5 BPS Vendors By Type
Source: Forrester Research, Inc.46571
Diversified
technology
leaders
ERP Business
intelligence
BPS
pure plays
• IBM Cognos
• Microsoft
• Oracle
• SAP*
• Actuate
• Information Builders
• MicroStrategy
• SAS Institute
• Acorn Systems
• Adaptive Planning
• Board International
• Clarity Systems
• Host Analytics
• PROPHIX Software
• Tagetik
• Infor
• Lawson Software
• Longview Solutions†
*Though primarily an ERP software vendor, SAP has substantial business intelligence (e.g., Business Objects) and
middleware assets
†
Longview Solutions is owned by Exact Software, an ERP software company, but continues to operate as an
independent BPS provider.
© 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction ProhibitedJanuary 20, 2009
Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans
For Business Process & Applications Professionals
12
Figure 6 Guide To BPS Vendors And Products
Source: Forrester Research, Inc.46571
Acorn
Systems
Vendor
• Acorn Performance
• Acorn Price Analyzer
Key product(s)
Planning,
budgeting, and
forecasting
Financial
consolidation
Strategy and
measurement
Actuate
• Actuate Performancesoft
Views
• Actuate Performancesoft
Track
Adaptive
Planning
• Adaptive Planning 5.0
Board
International
• BOARD Management
Intelligence Toolkit
Clarity
Systems
• Clarity 6
• Clarity FSR
Host Analytics
• Host Corporate
Performance Management
(CPM)
IBM Cognos
• IBM Cognos 8 Planning
• IBM Cognos 8 Controller
• IBM Cognos 8 BI
Infor • Infor Performance
Management (PM)
Information
Builders
• WebFOCUS Performance
Metrics Manager (PMM)
• WebFOCUS Performance
Management Framework
(PMF)
Cost and
profitability
management
© 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction Prohibited January 20, 2009
Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans
For Business Process & Applications Professionals
13
Figure 6 Guide To BPS Vendors And Products (Cont.)
Source: Forrester Research, Inc.46571
Lawson
Software
• Lawson EPM (Enterprise
Performance Management)
• Lawson Budgeting &
Planning
Longview
Solutions
• Khalix by Longview
Solutions
• Longview 7 (future release)
Microsoft
• Microsoft Office
PerformancePoint Server
2007
MicroStrategy • MicroStrategy Business
Intelligence Platform
Oracle
• Oracle Hyperion Planning
• Oracle Hyperion Financial
Management (HFM)
• Oracle Business Intelligence
Enterprise Edition (OBIEE)
• Oracle Hyperion Profitability
and Cost Management
• Oracle Crystal Ball
PROPHIX
Software
• PROPHIX Performance
Management
• PROPHIX Budgeting and
Reporting
SAP
• SAP Business Planning and
Consolidation (BPC)
• SAP Strategy Management
• BusinessObjects Profitability
and Cost Management
• BusinessObjects Financial
Consolidation
Vendor Key product(s)
Planning,
budgeting, and
forecasting
Financial
consolidation
Strategy and
measurement
Cost and
profitability
management
© 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction ProhibitedJanuary 20, 2009
Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans
For Business Process & Applications Professionals
14
Figure 6 Guide To BPS Vendors And Products (Cont.)
Reco m m e n dat i o n s
Learn From Best Practices To Avoid Implementation Risks
A large body of knowledge and experience has emerged from other successful performance
management initiatives that can improve success and time to value. Some best practices include:
·	Use a burning platform that accelerates time-to-value. Successful business performance
initiatives occur when a business imperative drives organizational commitment and a sense
of urgency. The current economic climate provides ample impetus to improve planning and
measurement processes and systems. Other types of burning platforms include regulatory
changes, major acquisitions, company restructuring, and so on.
·	Look at the road ahead to drive performance. Running the business with lagging
indicators and historical accounting information leaves too much to chance. Companies
should engineer performance processes that include forecasting and measurement of
leading indicators to stay ahead of the competition.
·	Put monetary rewards behind performance measures at all levels of the organization.
A performance management best practice is to put rewards in place to properly motivate
people. These incentives need to be straightforward and transparent, as well as frequent
enough (e.g., quarterly) to keep people engaged.
·	Begin with pilot projects to tune performance measures for the desired results.
Performance systems need to evolve through internal experience and experimentation to
produce the desired results. You should network with external peers and expert resources to
understand successes and failures.
Source: Forrester Research, Inc.46571
SAS Institute
• SAS Strategic Performance
Management
• SAS Activity-Based
Management
• SAS Profitability
Management
• SAS Financial Management
Tagetik • Tagetik 3.0
Vendor Key product(s)
Planning,
budgeting, and
forecasting
Financial
consolidation
Strategy and
measurement
Cost and
profitability
management
© 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction Prohibited January 20, 2009
Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans
For Business Process & Applications Professionals
15
W H A T I T M E A N S
Market Consolidation Leaves The Door Open For Innovation
The market events of the past few years leave us with four of the largest technology vendors on
the planet — IBM, Microsoft, Oracle, and SAP — in control of market share. While Oracle and SAP
battle for supremacy in this space, Microsoft has the highest potential to gain market share. With
a newer solution set leveraging its Microsoft Office franchise, Microsoft will gain traction among
organizations of various sizes, including large enterprises. IBM Cognos, meanwhile, has embarked
on a road map to refresh some of its aging assets. Yet, among these leading players, none have
built their entire solution set from the ground up and each faces a unique set of challenges to
integrate, innovate, or mature their product sets.
Organizations desire less costly solutions that more closely match their needs. Potentially viable
alternative choices include functional (e.g., planning and costing) and industry-specific point
solutions, SaaS solutions, and simpler products targeted toward smaller organizations. Smaller
BPS vendors that are: 1) technically innovative; 2) less costly to own; 3) quicker to deploy; and 4)
focused on solving specific business problems, will continue to make their mark.
Supplemental MATERIAL
Companies Interviewed For This Document
Actuate
Adaptive Planning
Board International
Clarity Systems
Host Analytics
IBM Cognos
Infor
Information Builders
Lawson Software
Longview Solutions
Microsoft
MicroStrategy
Oracle
SAP
SAS Institute
Tagetik
© 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction ProhibitedJanuary 20, 2009
Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans
For Business Process & Applications Professionals
16
Endnotes
1	
Forrester assessed 10 leading business performance solutions vendors across 83 criteria in a product
evaluation. Additional point-solution vendors not covered in this evaluation might be worth considering
as well, depending on priorities and current capabilities. See the October 10, 2007, “The Forrester Wave™:
Business Performance Solutions, Q4 2007” report.
2	
Metrics influence actions and decisions, whether used explicitly to influence behaviors or simply to report
results. Source: John R. Hauser and Gerald M. Katz, Metrics: You Are What You Measure, MIT Sloan School
of Management, 1998.
3	
Employee performance solutions is the fastest growing product segment within HR and HCM applications,
with a forecasted 17% growth rate through 2011. See the January 7, 2008, “HR/HCM Applications 2008:
Best-Of-Breed Solutions Make A Comeback” report.
4	
Performance management and measurement will top many priority lists, driven in part by a focus of
enterprises to drive risk management into business decisions. See the November 21, 2008, “Trends 2009:
Financial Performance Management” report.
5	
SAP was faced with a rather complicated BPS road map as a result of the Business Objects acquisition. See
the April 1, 2008, “SAP Unveils Its Starting Lineup For Business Performance Solutions” report.
Forrester Research, Inc. (Nasdaq: FORR)
is an independent research company
that provides pragmatic and forward-
thinking advice to global leaders in
business and technology. Forrester
works with professionals in 19 key roles
at major companies providing
proprietary research, consumer insight,
consulting, events, and peer-to-peer
executive programs. For more than 25
years, Forrester has been making IT,
marketing, and technology industry
leaders successful every day. For more
information, visit www.forrester.com.
Australia
Brazil
Canada
Denmark
France
Germany
Hong Kong
India
Israel
Japan
Korea
The Netherlands
Switzerland
United Kingdom
United States
Headquarters
Forrester Research, Inc.
400 Technology Square
Cambridge, MA 02139 USA
Tel: +1 617.613.6000
Fax: +1 617.613.5000
Email: forrester@forrester.com
Nasdaq symbol: FORR
www.forrester.com
M a k i n g L e a d e r s S u c c e s s f u l E v e r y D a y
For a complete list of worldwide locations,
visit www.forrester.com/about.
Research and Sales Offices
46571
For information on hard-copy or electronic reprints, please contact Client Support
at +1 866.367.7378, +1 617.613.5730, or clientsupport@forrester.com.
We offer quantity discounts and special pricing for academic and nonprofit institutions.

More Related Content

What's hot

Information Is King
Information Is KingInformation Is King
Information Is KingManish Desai
 
Ben Chamberlain, UMT360: PPM + Financial Intelligence = Greater ROI
Ben Chamberlain, UMT360: PPM + Financial Intelligence = Greater ROIBen Chamberlain, UMT360: PPM + Financial Intelligence = Greater ROI
Ben Chamberlain, UMT360: PPM + Financial Intelligence = Greater ROIUMT
 
Portfolio Agility– From Elusive Imperative to Practical Reality: Seven Dimens...
Portfolio Agility– From Elusive Imperative to Practical Reality: Seven Dimens...Portfolio Agility– From Elusive Imperative to Practical Reality: Seven Dimens...
Portfolio Agility– From Elusive Imperative to Practical Reality: Seven Dimens...UMT
 
Zd article delivering-erp_success_041812
Zd article delivering-erp_success_041812Zd article delivering-erp_success_041812
Zd article delivering-erp_success_041812Mitch Rushing
 
Leading enterprise-scale big data business outcomes
Leading enterprise-scale big data business outcomesLeading enterprise-scale big data business outcomes
Leading enterprise-scale big data business outcomesGuy Pearce
 
Lecture 6 Strategic Alignment Techniques
Lecture 6   Strategic Alignment TechniquesLecture 6   Strategic Alignment Techniques
Lecture 6 Strategic Alignment TechniquesMatthew Montebello
 
IBM wilhide better insight
IBM wilhide better insightIBM wilhide better insight
IBM wilhide better insightKathleen Wilhide
 
Strategic Business IT alignment
Strategic Business IT alignmentStrategic Business IT alignment
Strategic Business IT alignmentJulen Mohanty
 
Tricks of the Transformation Trade: Disruptive Disintermediation, Agility Age...
Tricks of the Transformation Trade: Disruptive Disintermediation, Agility Age...Tricks of the Transformation Trade: Disruptive Disintermediation, Agility Age...
Tricks of the Transformation Trade: Disruptive Disintermediation, Agility Age...UMT
 
Analytics-Based Enterprise Performance Management
Analytics-Based Enterprise Performance ManagementAnalytics-Based Enterprise Performance Management
Analytics-Based Enterprise Performance ManagementOsvaldo Maldonado
 
process-excellence-2931947
process-excellence-2931947process-excellence-2931947
process-excellence-2931947Mike Metcalf
 
[Whitepaper] Business Transformation Success Factors
[Whitepaper] Business Transformation Success Factors[Whitepaper] Business Transformation Success Factors
[Whitepaper] Business Transformation Success FactorsFlevy.com Best Practices
 
Information technology and cost optimization
Information technology and cost optimizationInformation technology and cost optimization
Information technology and cost optimizationeSAT Publishing House
 
Strategic Cost Optimization: Driving Business Innovation While Reducing IT Costs
Strategic Cost Optimization: Driving Business Innovation While Reducing IT CostsStrategic Cost Optimization: Driving Business Innovation While Reducing IT Costs
Strategic Cost Optimization: Driving Business Innovation While Reducing IT CostsCognizant
 
Align Information Technology and Business Strategy
Align Information Technology and Business Strategy Align Information Technology and Business Strategy
Align Information Technology and Business Strategy Salman Memon
 
How Gartner Helps Across the Entire IT Cost Optimization Life Cycle
How Gartner Helps Across the Entire IT Cost Optimization Life CycleHow Gartner Helps Across the Entire IT Cost Optimization Life Cycle
How Gartner Helps Across the Entire IT Cost Optimization Life CycleChris Grow
 

What's hot (20)

Beating the ERP Implementation Odds
Beating the ERP Implementation OddsBeating the ERP Implementation Odds
Beating the ERP Implementation Odds
 
Analyst connection sap
Analyst connection sapAnalyst connection sap
Analyst connection sap
 
Information Is King
Information Is KingInformation Is King
Information Is King
 
Ben Chamberlain, UMT360: PPM + Financial Intelligence = Greater ROI
Ben Chamberlain, UMT360: PPM + Financial Intelligence = Greater ROIBen Chamberlain, UMT360: PPM + Financial Intelligence = Greater ROI
Ben Chamberlain, UMT360: PPM + Financial Intelligence = Greater ROI
 
Portfolio Agility– From Elusive Imperative to Practical Reality: Seven Dimens...
Portfolio Agility– From Elusive Imperative to Practical Reality: Seven Dimens...Portfolio Agility– From Elusive Imperative to Practical Reality: Seven Dimens...
Portfolio Agility– From Elusive Imperative to Practical Reality: Seven Dimens...
 
Zd article delivering-erp_success_041812
Zd article delivering-erp_success_041812Zd article delivering-erp_success_041812
Zd article delivering-erp_success_041812
 
Leading enterprise-scale big data business outcomes
Leading enterprise-scale big data business outcomesLeading enterprise-scale big data business outcomes
Leading enterprise-scale big data business outcomes
 
Lecture 6 Strategic Alignment Techniques
Lecture 6   Strategic Alignment TechniquesLecture 6   Strategic Alignment Techniques
Lecture 6 Strategic Alignment Techniques
 
IBM wilhide better insight
IBM wilhide better insightIBM wilhide better insight
IBM wilhide better insight
 
Strategic Business IT alignment
Strategic Business IT alignmentStrategic Business IT alignment
Strategic Business IT alignment
 
Tricks of the Transformation Trade: Disruptive Disintermediation, Agility Age...
Tricks of the Transformation Trade: Disruptive Disintermediation, Agility Age...Tricks of the Transformation Trade: Disruptive Disintermediation, Agility Age...
Tricks of the Transformation Trade: Disruptive Disintermediation, Agility Age...
 
Analytics-Based Enterprise Performance Management
Analytics-Based Enterprise Performance ManagementAnalytics-Based Enterprise Performance Management
Analytics-Based Enterprise Performance Management
 
Law Firms in Business Development Transition
Law Firms in Business Development TransitionLaw Firms in Business Development Transition
Law Firms in Business Development Transition
 
process-excellence-2931947
process-excellence-2931947process-excellence-2931947
process-excellence-2931947
 
[Whitepaper] Business Transformation Success Factors
[Whitepaper] Business Transformation Success Factors[Whitepaper] Business Transformation Success Factors
[Whitepaper] Business Transformation Success Factors
 
Information technology and cost optimization
Information technology and cost optimizationInformation technology and cost optimization
Information technology and cost optimization
 
Gary Cokins Enterprise Performance Management (EPM) Analytics
Gary Cokins Enterprise Performance Management (EPM) AnalyticsGary Cokins Enterprise Performance Management (EPM) Analytics
Gary Cokins Enterprise Performance Management (EPM) Analytics
 
Strategic Cost Optimization: Driving Business Innovation While Reducing IT Costs
Strategic Cost Optimization: Driving Business Innovation While Reducing IT CostsStrategic Cost Optimization: Driving Business Innovation While Reducing IT Costs
Strategic Cost Optimization: Driving Business Innovation While Reducing IT Costs
 
Align Information Technology and Business Strategy
Align Information Technology and Business Strategy Align Information Technology and Business Strategy
Align Information Technology and Business Strategy
 
How Gartner Helps Across the Entire IT Cost Optimization Life Cycle
How Gartner Helps Across the Entire IT Cost Optimization Life CycleHow Gartner Helps Across the Entire IT Cost Optimization Life Cycle
How Gartner Helps Across the Entire IT Cost Optimization Life Cycle
 

Similar to Forrester perf-mgmt-012009[1]

Chap11 Developing Business It Strategies[1]
Chap11 Developing Business It Strategies[1]Chap11 Developing Business It Strategies[1]
Chap11 Developing Business It Strategies[1]sihamy
 
Transforming PMO Success with AI - Discover OnePlan Strategic Portfolio Work ...
Transforming PMO Success with AI - Discover OnePlan Strategic Portfolio Work ...Transforming PMO Success with AI - Discover OnePlan Strategic Portfolio Work ...
Transforming PMO Success with AI - Discover OnePlan Strategic Portfolio Work ...OnePlan Solutions
 
G A InfoMart Cognos TM1 planning budgeting-forecasting solution
G A InfoMart Cognos TM1 planning budgeting-forecasting solutionG A InfoMart Cognos TM1 planning budgeting-forecasting solution
G A InfoMart Cognos TM1 planning budgeting-forecasting solutionGA InfoMart Ltd
 
Fail to prepare - Softworld 2011
Fail to prepare -  Softworld 2011Fail to prepare -  Softworld 2011
Fail to prepare - Softworld 2011Sageukofficial
 
Fail to prepare, prepare to fail: implementing ERP and CRM systems
Fail to prepare, prepare to fail: implementing ERP and CRM systemsFail to prepare, prepare to fail: implementing ERP and CRM systems
Fail to prepare, prepare to fail: implementing ERP and CRM systemsSageukofficial
 
Creating a Business Case for Big Data
Creating a Business Case for Big DataCreating a Business Case for Big Data
Creating a Business Case for Big DataPerficient, Inc.
 
9 Steps to Creating ADM Budgets
9 Steps to Creating ADM Budgets9 Steps to Creating ADM Budgets
9 Steps to Creating ADM BudgetsCAST
 
Enterprise Business Intelligence From Erp Systems V3
Enterprise Business Intelligence From Erp Systems V3Enterprise Business Intelligence From Erp Systems V3
Enterprise Business Intelligence From Erp Systems V3guest3be51a
 
The business case for software analysis & measurement
The business case for software analysis & measurementThe business case for software analysis & measurement
The business case for software analysis & measurementCAST
 
Business it and labor strategy infrastructure enhancements to achieve corpora...
Business it and labor strategy infrastructure enhancements to achieve corpora...Business it and labor strategy infrastructure enhancements to achieve corpora...
Business it and labor strategy infrastructure enhancements to achieve corpora...David Bustin
 
Transform your Corporate Strategy Office - Harness OnePlan’s Strategic Portfo...
Transform your Corporate Strategy Office - Harness OnePlan’s Strategic Portfo...Transform your Corporate Strategy Office - Harness OnePlan’s Strategic Portfo...
Transform your Corporate Strategy Office - Harness OnePlan’s Strategic Portfo...OnePlan Solutions
 
Managing and Using Information Systems A Strategic Approach –.docx
Managing and Using Information Systems A Strategic Approach –.docxManaging and Using Information Systems A Strategic Approach –.docx
Managing and Using Information Systems A Strategic Approach –.docxtienboileau
 
B P G010 Mooney 091907
B P G010  Mooney 091907B P G010  Mooney 091907
B P G010 Mooney 091907Dreamforce07
 
Piloting procter & gamble from decicion cockpits
Piloting procter & gamble from decicion cockpitsPiloting procter & gamble from decicion cockpits
Piloting procter & gamble from decicion cockpitsniz73
 
B P G005 Johnson 091807
B P G005  Johnson 091807B P G005  Johnson 091807
B P G005 Johnson 091807Dreamforce07
 
Embracing Change - The Impact of Generative AI on Strategic Portfolio Management
Embracing Change - The Impact of Generative AI on Strategic Portfolio ManagementEmbracing Change - The Impact of Generative AI on Strategic Portfolio Management
Embracing Change - The Impact of Generative AI on Strategic Portfolio ManagementOnePlan Solutions
 
Establishing a framework for it governance by dave cunningham 2007
Establishing a framework for it governance by dave cunningham 2007Establishing a framework for it governance by dave cunningham 2007
Establishing a framework for it governance by dave cunningham 2007David Cunningham
 
Best Practices for Enterprise Performance Management
Best Practices for Enterprise Performance ManagementBest Practices for Enterprise Performance Management
Best Practices for Enterprise Performance ManagementPerficient, Inc.
 

Similar to Forrester perf-mgmt-012009[1] (20)

Chap11 Developing Business It Strategies[1]
Chap11 Developing Business It Strategies[1]Chap11 Developing Business It Strategies[1]
Chap11 Developing Business It Strategies[1]
 
Transforming PMO Success with AI - Discover OnePlan Strategic Portfolio Work ...
Transforming PMO Success with AI - Discover OnePlan Strategic Portfolio Work ...Transforming PMO Success with AI - Discover OnePlan Strategic Portfolio Work ...
Transforming PMO Success with AI - Discover OnePlan Strategic Portfolio Work ...
 
G A InfoMart Cognos TM1 planning budgeting-forecasting solution
G A InfoMart Cognos TM1 planning budgeting-forecasting solutionG A InfoMart Cognos TM1 planning budgeting-forecasting solution
G A InfoMart Cognos TM1 planning budgeting-forecasting solution
 
Fail to prepare - Softworld 2011
Fail to prepare -  Softworld 2011Fail to prepare -  Softworld 2011
Fail to prepare - Softworld 2011
 
Fail to prepare, prepare to fail: implementing ERP and CRM systems
Fail to prepare, prepare to fail: implementing ERP and CRM systemsFail to prepare, prepare to fail: implementing ERP and CRM systems
Fail to prepare, prepare to fail: implementing ERP and CRM systems
 
Creating a Business Case for Big Data
Creating a Business Case for Big DataCreating a Business Case for Big Data
Creating a Business Case for Big Data
 
9 Steps to Creating ADM Budgets
9 Steps to Creating ADM Budgets9 Steps to Creating ADM Budgets
9 Steps to Creating ADM Budgets
 
Enterprise Business Intelligence From Erp Systems V3
Enterprise Business Intelligence From Erp Systems V3Enterprise Business Intelligence From Erp Systems V3
Enterprise Business Intelligence From Erp Systems V3
 
The business case for software analysis & measurement
The business case for software analysis & measurementThe business case for software analysis & measurement
The business case for software analysis & measurement
 
Unit-5.docx
Unit-5.docxUnit-5.docx
Unit-5.docx
 
Business it and labor strategy infrastructure enhancements to achieve corpora...
Business it and labor strategy infrastructure enhancements to achieve corpora...Business it and labor strategy infrastructure enhancements to achieve corpora...
Business it and labor strategy infrastructure enhancements to achieve corpora...
 
Transform your Corporate Strategy Office - Harness OnePlan’s Strategic Portfo...
Transform your Corporate Strategy Office - Harness OnePlan’s Strategic Portfo...Transform your Corporate Strategy Office - Harness OnePlan’s Strategic Portfo...
Transform your Corporate Strategy Office - Harness OnePlan’s Strategic Portfo...
 
Managing and Using Information Systems A Strategic Approach –.docx
Managing and Using Information Systems A Strategic Approach –.docxManaging and Using Information Systems A Strategic Approach –.docx
Managing and Using Information Systems A Strategic Approach –.docx
 
B P G010 Mooney 091907
B P G010  Mooney 091907B P G010  Mooney 091907
B P G010 Mooney 091907
 
Piloting procter & gamble from decicion cockpits
Piloting procter & gamble from decicion cockpitsPiloting procter & gamble from decicion cockpits
Piloting procter & gamble from decicion cockpits
 
B P G005 Johnson 091807
B P G005  Johnson 091807B P G005  Johnson 091807
B P G005 Johnson 091807
 
Embracing Change - The Impact of Generative AI on Strategic Portfolio Management
Embracing Change - The Impact of Generative AI on Strategic Portfolio ManagementEmbracing Change - The Impact of Generative AI on Strategic Portfolio Management
Embracing Change - The Impact of Generative AI on Strategic Portfolio Management
 
Zhameir
ZhameirZhameir
Zhameir
 
Establishing a framework for it governance by dave cunningham 2007
Establishing a framework for it governance by dave cunningham 2007Establishing a framework for it governance by dave cunningham 2007
Establishing a framework for it governance by dave cunningham 2007
 
Best Practices for Enterprise Performance Management
Best Practices for Enterprise Performance ManagementBest Practices for Enterprise Performance Management
Best Practices for Enterprise Performance Management
 

Recently uploaded

Building a General PDE Solving Framework with Symbolic-Numeric Scientific Mac...
Building a General PDE Solving Framework with Symbolic-Numeric Scientific Mac...Building a General PDE Solving Framework with Symbolic-Numeric Scientific Mac...
Building a General PDE Solving Framework with Symbolic-Numeric Scientific Mac...stazi3110
 
Der Spagat zwischen BIAS und FAIRNESS (2024)
Der Spagat zwischen BIAS und FAIRNESS (2024)Der Spagat zwischen BIAS und FAIRNESS (2024)
Der Spagat zwischen BIAS und FAIRNESS (2024)OPEN KNOWLEDGE GmbH
 
Project Based Learning (A.I).pptx detail explanation
Project Based Learning (A.I).pptx detail explanationProject Based Learning (A.I).pptx detail explanation
Project Based Learning (A.I).pptx detail explanationkaushalgiri8080
 
Building Real-Time Data Pipelines: Stream & Batch Processing workshop Slide
Building Real-Time Data Pipelines: Stream & Batch Processing workshop SlideBuilding Real-Time Data Pipelines: Stream & Batch Processing workshop Slide
Building Real-Time Data Pipelines: Stream & Batch Processing workshop SlideChristina Lin
 
Asset Management Software - Infographic
Asset Management Software - InfographicAsset Management Software - Infographic
Asset Management Software - InfographicHr365.us smith
 
What is Fashion PLM and Why Do You Need It
What is Fashion PLM and Why Do You Need ItWhat is Fashion PLM and Why Do You Need It
What is Fashion PLM and Why Do You Need ItWave PLM
 
(Genuine) Escort Service Lucknow | Starting ₹,5K To @25k with A/C 🧑🏽‍❤️‍🧑🏻 89...
(Genuine) Escort Service Lucknow | Starting ₹,5K To @25k with A/C 🧑🏽‍❤️‍🧑🏻 89...(Genuine) Escort Service Lucknow | Starting ₹,5K To @25k with A/C 🧑🏽‍❤️‍🧑🏻 89...
(Genuine) Escort Service Lucknow | Starting ₹,5K To @25k with A/C 🧑🏽‍❤️‍🧑🏻 89...gurkirankumar98700
 
chapter--4-software-project-planning.ppt
chapter--4-software-project-planning.pptchapter--4-software-project-planning.ppt
chapter--4-software-project-planning.pptkotipi9215
 
why an Opensea Clone Script might be your perfect match.pdf
why an Opensea Clone Script might be your perfect match.pdfwhy an Opensea Clone Script might be your perfect match.pdf
why an Opensea Clone Script might be your perfect match.pdfjoe51371421
 
Advancing Engineering with AI through the Next Generation of Strategic Projec...
Advancing Engineering with AI through the Next Generation of Strategic Projec...Advancing Engineering with AI through the Next Generation of Strategic Projec...
Advancing Engineering with AI through the Next Generation of Strategic Projec...OnePlan Solutions
 
KnowAPIs-UnknownPerf-jaxMainz-2024 (1).pptx
KnowAPIs-UnknownPerf-jaxMainz-2024 (1).pptxKnowAPIs-UnknownPerf-jaxMainz-2024 (1).pptx
KnowAPIs-UnknownPerf-jaxMainz-2024 (1).pptxTier1 app
 
Professional Resume Template for Software Developers
Professional Resume Template for Software DevelopersProfessional Resume Template for Software Developers
Professional Resume Template for Software DevelopersVinodh Ram
 
Short Story: Unveiling the Reasoning Abilities of Large Language Models by Ke...
Short Story: Unveiling the Reasoning Abilities of Large Language Models by Ke...Short Story: Unveiling the Reasoning Abilities of Large Language Models by Ke...
Short Story: Unveiling the Reasoning Abilities of Large Language Models by Ke...kellynguyen01
 
Learn the Fundamentals of XCUITest Framework_ A Beginner's Guide.pdf
Learn the Fundamentals of XCUITest Framework_ A Beginner's Guide.pdfLearn the Fundamentals of XCUITest Framework_ A Beginner's Guide.pdf
Learn the Fundamentals of XCUITest Framework_ A Beginner's Guide.pdfkalichargn70th171
 
The Evolution of Karaoke From Analog to App.pdf
The Evolution of Karaoke From Analog to App.pdfThe Evolution of Karaoke From Analog to App.pdf
The Evolution of Karaoke From Analog to App.pdfPower Karaoke
 
Adobe Marketo Engage Deep Dives: Using Webhooks to Transfer Data
Adobe Marketo Engage Deep Dives: Using Webhooks to Transfer DataAdobe Marketo Engage Deep Dives: Using Webhooks to Transfer Data
Adobe Marketo Engage Deep Dives: Using Webhooks to Transfer DataBradBedford3
 
EY_Graph Database Powered Sustainability
EY_Graph Database Powered SustainabilityEY_Graph Database Powered Sustainability
EY_Graph Database Powered SustainabilityNeo4j
 
XpertSolvers: Your Partner in Building Innovative Software Solutions
XpertSolvers: Your Partner in Building Innovative Software SolutionsXpertSolvers: Your Partner in Building Innovative Software Solutions
XpertSolvers: Your Partner in Building Innovative Software SolutionsMehedi Hasan Shohan
 
The Essentials of Digital Experience Monitoring_ A Comprehensive Guide.pdf
The Essentials of Digital Experience Monitoring_ A Comprehensive Guide.pdfThe Essentials of Digital Experience Monitoring_ A Comprehensive Guide.pdf
The Essentials of Digital Experience Monitoring_ A Comprehensive Guide.pdfkalichargn70th171
 
5 Signs You Need a Fashion PLM Software.pdf
5 Signs You Need a Fashion PLM Software.pdf5 Signs You Need a Fashion PLM Software.pdf
5 Signs You Need a Fashion PLM Software.pdfWave PLM
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Building a General PDE Solving Framework with Symbolic-Numeric Scientific Mac...
Building a General PDE Solving Framework with Symbolic-Numeric Scientific Mac...Building a General PDE Solving Framework with Symbolic-Numeric Scientific Mac...
Building a General PDE Solving Framework with Symbolic-Numeric Scientific Mac...
 
Der Spagat zwischen BIAS und FAIRNESS (2024)
Der Spagat zwischen BIAS und FAIRNESS (2024)Der Spagat zwischen BIAS und FAIRNESS (2024)
Der Spagat zwischen BIAS und FAIRNESS (2024)
 
Project Based Learning (A.I).pptx detail explanation
Project Based Learning (A.I).pptx detail explanationProject Based Learning (A.I).pptx detail explanation
Project Based Learning (A.I).pptx detail explanation
 
Building Real-Time Data Pipelines: Stream & Batch Processing workshop Slide
Building Real-Time Data Pipelines: Stream & Batch Processing workshop SlideBuilding Real-Time Data Pipelines: Stream & Batch Processing workshop Slide
Building Real-Time Data Pipelines: Stream & Batch Processing workshop Slide
 
Asset Management Software - Infographic
Asset Management Software - InfographicAsset Management Software - Infographic
Asset Management Software - Infographic
 
What is Fashion PLM and Why Do You Need It
What is Fashion PLM and Why Do You Need ItWhat is Fashion PLM and Why Do You Need It
What is Fashion PLM and Why Do You Need It
 
(Genuine) Escort Service Lucknow | Starting ₹,5K To @25k with A/C 🧑🏽‍❤️‍🧑🏻 89...
(Genuine) Escort Service Lucknow | Starting ₹,5K To @25k with A/C 🧑🏽‍❤️‍🧑🏻 89...(Genuine) Escort Service Lucknow | Starting ₹,5K To @25k with A/C 🧑🏽‍❤️‍🧑🏻 89...
(Genuine) Escort Service Lucknow | Starting ₹,5K To @25k with A/C 🧑🏽‍❤️‍🧑🏻 89...
 
chapter--4-software-project-planning.ppt
chapter--4-software-project-planning.pptchapter--4-software-project-planning.ppt
chapter--4-software-project-planning.ppt
 
why an Opensea Clone Script might be your perfect match.pdf
why an Opensea Clone Script might be your perfect match.pdfwhy an Opensea Clone Script might be your perfect match.pdf
why an Opensea Clone Script might be your perfect match.pdf
 
Advancing Engineering with AI through the Next Generation of Strategic Projec...
Advancing Engineering with AI through the Next Generation of Strategic Projec...Advancing Engineering with AI through the Next Generation of Strategic Projec...
Advancing Engineering with AI through the Next Generation of Strategic Projec...
 
KnowAPIs-UnknownPerf-jaxMainz-2024 (1).pptx
KnowAPIs-UnknownPerf-jaxMainz-2024 (1).pptxKnowAPIs-UnknownPerf-jaxMainz-2024 (1).pptx
KnowAPIs-UnknownPerf-jaxMainz-2024 (1).pptx
 
Professional Resume Template for Software Developers
Professional Resume Template for Software DevelopersProfessional Resume Template for Software Developers
Professional Resume Template for Software Developers
 
Short Story: Unveiling the Reasoning Abilities of Large Language Models by Ke...
Short Story: Unveiling the Reasoning Abilities of Large Language Models by Ke...Short Story: Unveiling the Reasoning Abilities of Large Language Models by Ke...
Short Story: Unveiling the Reasoning Abilities of Large Language Models by Ke...
 
Learn the Fundamentals of XCUITest Framework_ A Beginner's Guide.pdf
Learn the Fundamentals of XCUITest Framework_ A Beginner's Guide.pdfLearn the Fundamentals of XCUITest Framework_ A Beginner's Guide.pdf
Learn the Fundamentals of XCUITest Framework_ A Beginner's Guide.pdf
 
The Evolution of Karaoke From Analog to App.pdf
The Evolution of Karaoke From Analog to App.pdfThe Evolution of Karaoke From Analog to App.pdf
The Evolution of Karaoke From Analog to App.pdf
 
Adobe Marketo Engage Deep Dives: Using Webhooks to Transfer Data
Adobe Marketo Engage Deep Dives: Using Webhooks to Transfer DataAdobe Marketo Engage Deep Dives: Using Webhooks to Transfer Data
Adobe Marketo Engage Deep Dives: Using Webhooks to Transfer Data
 
EY_Graph Database Powered Sustainability
EY_Graph Database Powered SustainabilityEY_Graph Database Powered Sustainability
EY_Graph Database Powered Sustainability
 
XpertSolvers: Your Partner in Building Innovative Software Solutions
XpertSolvers: Your Partner in Building Innovative Software SolutionsXpertSolvers: Your Partner in Building Innovative Software Solutions
XpertSolvers: Your Partner in Building Innovative Software Solutions
 
The Essentials of Digital Experience Monitoring_ A Comprehensive Guide.pdf
The Essentials of Digital Experience Monitoring_ A Comprehensive Guide.pdfThe Essentials of Digital Experience Monitoring_ A Comprehensive Guide.pdf
The Essentials of Digital Experience Monitoring_ A Comprehensive Guide.pdf
 
5 Signs You Need a Fashion PLM Software.pdf
5 Signs You Need a Fashion PLM Software.pdf5 Signs You Need a Fashion PLM Software.pdf
5 Signs You Need a Fashion PLM Software.pdf
 

Forrester perf-mgmt-012009[1]

  • 1. Making Leaders Successful Every Day January 20, 2009 Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans by Paul D. Hamerman for Business Process & Applications Professionals
  • 2. © 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. All rights reserved. Unauthorized reproduction is strictly prohibited. Information is based on best available resources. Opinions reflect judgment at the time and are subject to change. Forrester®, Technographics®, Forrester Wave, RoleView, TechRadar, and Total Economic Impact are trademarks of Forrester Research, Inc. All other trademarks are the property of their respective companies. To purchase reprints of this document, please email clientsupport@forrester.com. For additional information, go to www.forrester.com. For Business Process & Applications Professionals Includes a market sizing forecast Executive Summary Business performance solutions (BPS) — a software category consisting of applications for budgeting, forecasting, financial reporting, profitability analysis, and performance measurement — has seen dramatic growth and vendor consolidation over the past two years. The growth prospects for this space remain bright, despite the near-term impact of the recession, driven by strong interest in strategy and performance measurement. Forrester expects BPS software revenues to grow by 12.7% through 2012, growing from its current size of $2 billion to $3.2 billion during this timeframe. Six large vendors — IBM, Infor, Microsoft, Oracle, SAP, and SAS Institute — dominate this market, while a number of business intelligence (BI), enterprise resource planning (ERP), specialists, and BPS pure plays offer a variety of interesting alternatives. table of Contents Business Performance Solutions Monitor The Pulse Of An Organization The Recession Will Only Temporarily Slow BPS Growth BPS Vendors Come In All Shapes And Sizes recommendations Learn From Best Practices To Avoid Implementation Risks WHAT IT MEANS Market Consolidation Leaves The Door Open For Innovation Supplemental Material NOTES & RESOURCES This research is based on numerous client inquiries, as well as ongoing briefings and discussions with BPS vendors, including Actuate, Adaptive Planning, Board International, Clarity Systems, Host Analytics, IBM Cognos, Infor, Lawson Software, Longview Solutions, Microsoft, Oracle, SAP, SAS Institute, and Tagetik. Related Research Documents “Measuring And Aligning Business Performance” April 2, 2008 “The Forrester Wave™: Business Performance Solutions, Q4, 2007” October 10, 2007 “Business Performance Solutions: The Competition Heats Up” February 7, 2007 January 20, 2009 Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans The Market Remains Vibrant Following Vendor Consolidation by Paul D. Hamerman with Kyle McNabb and Meghan Donnelly 2 5 9 14 15 15
  • 3. © 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction ProhibitedJanuary 20, 2009 Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans For Business Process & Applications Professionals 2 BUsiness Performance Solutions Monitor The Pulse Of An Organization Business performance management consists of a set of processes, frameworks, and systems for activities such as planning, measuring, communicating, and monitoring business results (see Figure 1). Enterprises typically link these activities to corporate strategies and objectives and might drive them down to many individuals within the organization to encourage accountability and control. Forrester defines business performance solutions as a category of purpose-built software applications that support these activities.1 The major BPS functional elements include: · Strategy and performance measurement address goals, objectives, and accountability. A strategy management application supports formal strategy management philosophies (e.g., the Balanced Scorecard) but might be adapted to a business’ specific needs. Applications often display the strategy definition in visual strategy maps. Scorecards measure progress against the goals and objectives set forth in the strategy framework. Performance dashboards display more detailed information and allow drilling down to root-cause detail. Dashboards typically include a variety of key performance indicators (KPIs) that might include strategic scorecards as well as relevant comparisons against plans, budgets, forecasts, prior performance, and industry benchmark data. · Planning, budgeting, and forecasting solutions support multiple forward-looking processes. Although used almost universally as a control on spending, budgeting often falls short in supporting performance initiatives — often the result of a rigorous and inflexible process, not due to a software shortcoming per se. Fortunately, in addition to budgeting, the planning solutions support a variety of scenario-based planning activities as well as forecasting processes that add value beyond that provided by traditional budgeting processes. · Cost and profitability management provides detailed analysis to improve margins. This complex modeling activity helps organizations analyze development, production, and operating costs against revenues by product, customers, and lines of business. Cost and profitability management applications often use activity-based costing as the methodology to develop sophisticated cost and profitability analytical models. · Financial reporting and consolidation produce financial statements. Financial reporting and consolidation applications produce reports focused on delivering financial statements based on accounting results. Statutory consolidations support regulatory compliance and generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) requirements. These applications also support internal reporting of financial information. Although the functional elements described above align primarily with finance processes, enterprises can use strategy and performance measurement, as well as forecasting, to support all areas of the business. Many BPS product portfolios often include purpose-built performance management applications for nonfinance areas including human resources (HR), operations, supply chain, sales, and IT. All types of businesses and government organizations use BPS products, although considerable extension and adaptation to business requirements is often required.
  • 4. © 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction Prohibited January 20, 2009 Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans For Business Process & Applications Professionals 3 Figure 1 Business Performance Solutions Footprint Organizations Face An Uphill Battle With Business Performance Process Execution Adopting a strategically aligned and performance-driven culture is easier said than done. Performance- driven enterprises need more timely support than traditional management processes — including budgeting and accounting — often provide. Similarly, planning and measurement processes based on labor-intensive methods (e.g., spreadsheets) are not responsive enough to run the business. Business performance initiatives suffer from implementation and execution challenges ranging from culture and organizational alignment to technology integration and project execution. Typical BPS implementation challenges include the following: · Strategies and execution processes are misaligned. All reasonably successful businesses have a strategy, but often do not support their strategies with processes for communicating, aligning, and executing them. When business units and departments lack a formalized performance measurement system aligned with strategy, they develop their own performance measurements and reporting mechanisms. The result: a great deal of effort expended, but company goals and objectives are under-realized. · Financial accounting and budgeting processes move more slowly than the business. Financial information, a critical component of business performance information, enables the visibility of revenues, expenses, profitability, and assets across various organizational dimensions. Source: Forrester Research, Inc.46571 User experience Dashboards Scorecards Spreadsheets BPS application components Business intelligence platforms and integration tools ERP systems Configuration tools for processes and business models Financial reporting and consolidation Strategy and performance measurement Planning, budgeting, and forecasting Cost and profitability management
  • 5. © 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction ProhibitedJanuary 20, 2009 Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans For Business Process & Applications Professionals 4 Yet problems with the complex procedures and batch interfaces required to close the books along with lengthy budget preparation cycles diminish the actionable value of the information. · Improvement initiatives face cultural resistance and unanticipated behaviors. Any initiative to drive change in an organization, even if mandated from the top, faces natural resistance. The phrase “you are what you measure” highlights the profound impact of measurements on human behavior.2 To gauge their true behavioral impact, organizations must put measurements into play, requiring trial-and-error tweaking. Measurement systems present challenges, particularly when they affect compensation and, potentially, job security. · Business performance questions go unanswered, even with the best technology. A multitude of technology challenges hinder delivering performance information. One of the biggest challenges, data integration, must collect information residing in a number of transactional systems. Even when the systems can successfully assemble information on a BI platform, the daunting task of effective information delivery remains. Business stakeholders must willingly engage in the process of shaping the business models and frameworks that drive the delivery of results. Therefore, IT-led initiatives to build and deliver performance management solutions are doomed to fail without strong business-driven alignment. BPS Packages Often Replace Homegrown Solutions An organization with a strong internal BI IT talent pool and a robust BI infrastructure will likely have developed customized business performance systems, particularly to address business performance measurement and forecasting requirements. Companies with very limited resources still rely primarily on spreadsheets and basic tools for business performance reporting and analysis. These approaches have worked well for some organizations, but frequently require labor-intensive maintenance and lack desired levels of flexibility. BPS packages offer a level of configurability that puts control more squarely into the hands of the business stakeholders. These solutions typically provide more business process control and accountability than homegrown solutions, as well as starter kits containing best practices and prebuilt functionality. Despite these user-driven advantages, IT’s role remains critical for integrating and managing the underlying information. Enterprises seeking BPS support should look for: · Compelling graphics and user interface features. While some products rely heavily on a signature graphical paradigm, such as fuel gauges, customers need a selection of graphical looks to suit the information context. End users should have the ability to personalize the presentation of the graphical content by selecting the visualizations (e.g., symbols, colors, and charts) that bring the information to life. · Breadth of information. The extent to which a BPS vendor embeds a comprehensive analytical data model differentiates many products. The data model should represent the full breadth of
  • 6. © 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction Prohibited January 20, 2009 Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans For Business Process & Applications Professionals 5 the business, from finance to sales and operations, as well as supporting a variety of business types. The solution should also enable organizations to compare certain KPIs to industry metrics via connections to external content publishers. · Flexibility and extensibility. Every enterprise has a combination of needs ranging from common to unique, so the flexibility of the product to be configured (not customized) with nonstandard measurements is essential. The business problems to support, from budgets, to forecasts, to profitability analysis, depend on the business users’ abilities to model attributes such as hierarchical structures, mathematical formulas, and timeframes. · Openness for integrating multiple data sources. The product needs to be open at the data level to analyze information from multiple systems. Vendors typically embed or work with leading data integration and extract, transform, and load tools to manage the diversity of data inputs to the system. The measurement applications ideally should allow access to underlying details within the data through drilling into the source data. · Support for measurement frameworks. Enterprises often find best practice measurement frameworks useful as predefined structures within the BPS tools. For example, several tools provide support for Balanced Scorecard frameworks and may be certified as compliant by the Balanced Scorecard Collaborative organization. The Recession Will Only Temporarily Slow BPS Growth BPS has strong long-term growth prospects, but this software category is not immune to the recession that we expect to continue well into 2009. Total software revenues (licenses, maintenance, and subscriptions) will grow by 12.7% compound annual growth rate (CAGR) through 2012 from $2 billion in 2008 to $3.2 billion in 2012 (see Figure 2). We based our market size estimate on our analysis of individual vendor product revenues and momentum. In analyzing the revenue components, we find: · License revenue will see a slight decline in 2009, followed by a strong recovery. The recessionary impact is manifested primarily in license revenues, due to reductions in IT spending. Ironically, software for managing budgets and forecasts, mission-critical in times of intense economic pressure, make up a significant portion of this market. Enterprises will struggle to justify upgrading planning and analysis software in the middle of the crisis. Following a slight 2009 decline, licensing will return to strong levels for 2010 and beyond. · Maintenance is substantial and sustainable. Due to the maturity of the BPS market, particularly for planning and financial consolidation applications, application maintenance fees provide a strong recurring revenue base. Maintenance revenues will continue to grow as new licenses and automatic contractual increases are added to the base. Since maintenance
  • 7. © 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction ProhibitedJanuary 20, 2009 Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans For Business Process & Applications Professionals 6 represents more than half of the total BPS product revenues (54%), it will sustain overall growth for the segment even in this challenging macroeconomic climate. · Subscriptions will grow as the market gravitates toward software-as-a-service (SaaS). Software subscription revenue, including SaaS, currently makes up a relatively small component (8%) of total BPS revenues. But subscription revenue will grow at a 15.7% CAGR during the next few years. SAS Institute currently generates the bulk of the subscription revenue in this space today, although enterprises deploy its applications on-premise. SaaS vendors in this space — including relatively small companies like Adaptive Planning and Host Analytics — will see good uptake as this deployment model moves toward becoming the mainstream in BPS. Within three years, customer demand for the SaaS consumption model will compel larger BPS vendors to introduce SaaS offerings. Figure 2 Forecast: Global BPS Market Growth 2008 To 2012 Source: Forrester Research, Inc.46571 The spreadsheet detailing this forecast is available online. $0 $500 $1,000 $1,500 $2,000 $2,500 $3,000 $3,500 Revenue (US$ millions) 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Total revenue (millions) $139 $974 $670 $1,783 $155 $1,082 $744 $1,981 $183 $1,223 $737 $2,142 $222 $1,407 $840 $2,468 $266 $1,632 $940 $2,838 $289 $1,893 $1,053 $3,235 Subscription revenue Maintenance revenue License revenue 15.7% 14.2% 9.5% 12.7% (numbers have been rounded) CAGR Subscription revenue Maintenance revenue License revenue Actual Forecast Sources: Company reports, Hoover’s, and Forrester estimates.
  • 8. © 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction Prohibited January 20, 2009 Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans For Business Process & Applications Professionals 7 Strategy And Performance Measurement Solutions Lead BPS Component Growth The traditional finance components — planning, budgeting, and forecasting and financial reporting — make up 39% and 28%, respectively, of BPS product revenues. Strategy and performance measurement (25%), however, has the highest growth rate at 18%, as companies move toward more comprehensive enterprise performance initiatives (see Figure 3). Considering each of the four component categories individually, we find: · Forecasting has moved to the forefront as a growth driver for the planning category. Demand remains strong (11% growth through 2012) for planning, budgeting, and forecasting solutions, which enable companies to support a range of planning processes. Forecasting is a more nimble planning vehicle than either budgeting or structured financial planning models (e.g., for mergers and acquisitions). In fact, flexible forecasting models, which organizations can build for various aspects of the business, drive many deals to help companies cope with economic uncertainty and market volatility. · Financial reporting and consolidation is largely a replacement market. Public companies with multiple subsidiaries and lines of business use these applications primarily for external reporting and statutory compliance. As a mature category, maintenance sustains its 10% growth rate, but legacy product replacement and stopgap solutions fuel licensing. Regulatory filing requirements, adoption of eXtensible Business Reporting Language (XBRL) as an open standard for rendering financial statements, and adoption of international accounting standards (i.e., International Financial Reporting Standards) drive growth for this mature segment of BPS. · Strategy and performance measurement systems have the highest growth potential in BPS. Many organizations already measure business performance across the enterprise using a variety of metrics and KPIs, but technology capabilities often lag management’s need for this information. The desire to formalize measurement processes, supported by incentive rewards, contributes greatly to our forecasted 17% growth for this segment, a trend that parallels the rapid uptake of human capital management applications for employee performance.3 The incorporation of risk management measurement frameworks (key risk indicators [KRIs]) to help companies anticipate the negative consequences of unusual events will also drive growth.4 · Cost and profitability management is making a comeback. Current economic conditions inspire renewed interest in closely managing costs and profitability. Though relatively small (8% of BPS), this category has a healthy growth trajectory of 13% through 2012. Companies will demand these tools to help them understand their most profitable products and customers, and which water down profit margins. Adopters of these tools may benefit from expert guidance in constructing the models, which software suppliers often provide.
  • 9. © 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction ProhibitedJanuary 20, 2009 Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans For Business Process & Applications Professionals 8 Figure 3 BPS Segment Analysis Source: Forrester Research, Inc.46571 2008 BPS segmentation by product category3-1 2008 BPS segment growth3-2 Planning, budgeting, and forecasting 39% Financial reporting 28% Strategy and measurement 25% Cost and profitability 8% (numbers have been rounded) Source: Company reports, Hoover’s, and Forrester estimates. 18% 13% 11% 10% Strategy and measurement Cost and profitability Planning, budgeting, and forecasting Financial reporting
  • 10. © 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction Prohibited January 20, 2009 Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans For Business Process & Applications Professionals 9 BPS Vendors Come In All Shapes And Sizes Four of the largest information technology vendors in the world dominate the current BPS market — IBM, Microsoft, Oracle, and SAP. A stunning market consolidation took place in 2007, when SAP, IBM, and Oracle acquired three major BI and BPS vendors — Business Objects, Cognos, and Hyperion, respectively. These BI vendors were also among the leaders in BPS at the time they were acquired, and BPS assets factored heavily in these multibillion dollar acquisition transactions. Microsoft’s entry into this market occurred in the same timeframe, largely through internal development efforts of Microsoft Office PerformancePoint Server 2007. Two additional major BPS players — Infor and SAS Institute — have annual revenues exceeding $2 billion, putting them among the largest software vendors. These top six vendors currently account for approximately 70% of the overall BPS market in terms of software revenues (licenses, maintenance, and subscriptions). Expect More Of The Same: Market Consolidation Is Familiar Territory Within BPS Prior to the large BI acquisitions, the BPS market had been consolidating for several years. Many enterprise users of BPS still use the former brand names of the products they use, making a genealogy chart useful for those trying to identify what they’ve licensed (see Figure 4). Figure 4 Business Performance Solutions Vendor Genealogy, 2002 To 2008 Source: Forrester Research, Inc.46571 Oracle SAP IBM Microsoft Infor SAS Institute Hyperion Siebel PeopleSoft Interlace Systems UpStream Software Razza Solutions Decisioneering (Crystal Ball) Geac/ Extensity Systems Union Comshare Cognos Applix Adaytum Frango OutlookSoft Pilot Software Business Objects ProClarity ABC Technologies FRx Software Stratature Dundas Data Visualization Cartesis ALG Software SRC Software
  • 11. © 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction ProhibitedJanuary 20, 2009 Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans For Business Process & Applications Professionals 10 Earlier transactions included in this roll-up include SAS Institute’s acquisition of cost and profitability specialist ABC Technologies in 2002, and Cognos’ acquisition of budgeting and planning vendor Adaytum in 2003. Several deals occurred just months prior to the larger BI acquisitions, including SAP’s acquisitions of OutlookSoft and Pilot Software in 2007, and Cognos’ acquisition of Applix just two months prior to the IBM-Cognos deal announcement in November 2007. Whereas IBM had no pre-existing BPS assets to rationalize with Cognos, SAP and Oracle had more overlaps to resolve. Each had to decide which products to lead with and which to put on life support. Oracle’s clear choice was to lead with the Hyperion BPS products, while SAP chose a mix of assets between its portfolio (e.g., OutlookSoft and Pilot Software) and those of Business Objects (e.g., ALG Software and Cartesis).5 While vendors have well-defined road maps at this stage, the integration and harmonization work continues. BPS Offerings Fall Into Four Types Of Vendor Buckets The types of vendors offering BPS products range from the technology giants to small, specialized vendors (see Figure 5). Breadth of coverage of the four main BPS functional components varies widely, and has no correlation to overall vendor size, as shown in the more detailed vendor guide (see Figure 6). These categories and key vendors are described below. · Diversified technology leaders battle for supremacy. The four technology giants in this category, as mentioned previously, control the lion’s share of this market. Each of these vendors can provide standalone BPS solutions as individual products or suites, and can also align these products with their major technology assets in applications and platforms. · ERP vendors focus on their applications base. Infor’s Performance Management solution, formerly a best-of-breed product (Geac/Comshare), has some traction independent of its diverse ERP applications installed base. However, Infor most often provides it as a cross- sell or upsell to complement its core applications. Lawson generally sells its budgeting and dashboarding products to its ERP base. The outlier in this category, Longview Solutions, operates as an independent unit focusing on larger customers, while its parent company, Exact Software, focuses on the small and medium-size business (SMB) ERP market. · Business intelligence vendors emphasize platforms and tools. SAS Institute is the only member of this group that offers a comprehensive set of BPS offerings. While the SAS offerings are well-integrated with one another, it is also the leading player in cost and profitability solutions as a discrete offering. The other three BI vendors listed — Actuate, Information Builders, and MicroStrategy — focus their BPS efforts on enterprise performance and strategy measurement, with less emphasis on the financial domain components. · BPS pure plays focus on market niches. Vendors in this category range from comprehensive BPS to point-solution providers, yet share a common strategy to differentiate themselves from
  • 12. © 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction Prohibited January 20, 2009 Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans For Business Process & Applications Professionals 11 the larger market leaders. European-based Board International (Switzerland) and Tagetik (Italy) now seek growth in other markets, including the US. Clarity Systems has a strong budgeting and planning solution along with a differentiated external financial statement and regulatory product, Clarity FSR. Adaptive Planning and Host Analytics provide SaaS solutions in an historical on-premise market. PROPHIX Software offers a budgeting and performance management solution for SMBs. Specialist vendors in this bucket include Acorn Systems (cost and profitability) along with many others. Figure 5 BPS Vendors By Type Source: Forrester Research, Inc.46571 Diversified technology leaders ERP Business intelligence BPS pure plays • IBM Cognos • Microsoft • Oracle • SAP* • Actuate • Information Builders • MicroStrategy • SAS Institute • Acorn Systems • Adaptive Planning • Board International • Clarity Systems • Host Analytics • PROPHIX Software • Tagetik • Infor • Lawson Software • Longview Solutions† *Though primarily an ERP software vendor, SAP has substantial business intelligence (e.g., Business Objects) and middleware assets † Longview Solutions is owned by Exact Software, an ERP software company, but continues to operate as an independent BPS provider.
  • 13. © 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction ProhibitedJanuary 20, 2009 Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans For Business Process & Applications Professionals 12 Figure 6 Guide To BPS Vendors And Products Source: Forrester Research, Inc.46571 Acorn Systems Vendor • Acorn Performance • Acorn Price Analyzer Key product(s) Planning, budgeting, and forecasting Financial consolidation Strategy and measurement Actuate • Actuate Performancesoft Views • Actuate Performancesoft Track Adaptive Planning • Adaptive Planning 5.0 Board International • BOARD Management Intelligence Toolkit Clarity Systems • Clarity 6 • Clarity FSR Host Analytics • Host Corporate Performance Management (CPM) IBM Cognos • IBM Cognos 8 Planning • IBM Cognos 8 Controller • IBM Cognos 8 BI Infor • Infor Performance Management (PM) Information Builders • WebFOCUS Performance Metrics Manager (PMM) • WebFOCUS Performance Management Framework (PMF) Cost and profitability management
  • 14. © 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction Prohibited January 20, 2009 Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans For Business Process & Applications Professionals 13 Figure 6 Guide To BPS Vendors And Products (Cont.) Source: Forrester Research, Inc.46571 Lawson Software • Lawson EPM (Enterprise Performance Management) • Lawson Budgeting & Planning Longview Solutions • Khalix by Longview Solutions • Longview 7 (future release) Microsoft • Microsoft Office PerformancePoint Server 2007 MicroStrategy • MicroStrategy Business Intelligence Platform Oracle • Oracle Hyperion Planning • Oracle Hyperion Financial Management (HFM) • Oracle Business Intelligence Enterprise Edition (OBIEE) • Oracle Hyperion Profitability and Cost Management • Oracle Crystal Ball PROPHIX Software • PROPHIX Performance Management • PROPHIX Budgeting and Reporting SAP • SAP Business Planning and Consolidation (BPC) • SAP Strategy Management • BusinessObjects Profitability and Cost Management • BusinessObjects Financial Consolidation Vendor Key product(s) Planning, budgeting, and forecasting Financial consolidation Strategy and measurement Cost and profitability management
  • 15. © 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction ProhibitedJanuary 20, 2009 Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans For Business Process & Applications Professionals 14 Figure 6 Guide To BPS Vendors And Products (Cont.) Reco m m e n dat i o n s Learn From Best Practices To Avoid Implementation Risks A large body of knowledge and experience has emerged from other successful performance management initiatives that can improve success and time to value. Some best practices include: · Use a burning platform that accelerates time-to-value. Successful business performance initiatives occur when a business imperative drives organizational commitment and a sense of urgency. The current economic climate provides ample impetus to improve planning and measurement processes and systems. Other types of burning platforms include regulatory changes, major acquisitions, company restructuring, and so on. · Look at the road ahead to drive performance. Running the business with lagging indicators and historical accounting information leaves too much to chance. Companies should engineer performance processes that include forecasting and measurement of leading indicators to stay ahead of the competition. · Put monetary rewards behind performance measures at all levels of the organization. A performance management best practice is to put rewards in place to properly motivate people. These incentives need to be straightforward and transparent, as well as frequent enough (e.g., quarterly) to keep people engaged. · Begin with pilot projects to tune performance measures for the desired results. Performance systems need to evolve through internal experience and experimentation to produce the desired results. You should network with external peers and expert resources to understand successes and failures. Source: Forrester Research, Inc.46571 SAS Institute • SAS Strategic Performance Management • SAS Activity-Based Management • SAS Profitability Management • SAS Financial Management Tagetik • Tagetik 3.0 Vendor Key product(s) Planning, budgeting, and forecasting Financial consolidation Strategy and measurement Cost and profitability management
  • 16. © 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction Prohibited January 20, 2009 Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans For Business Process & Applications Professionals 15 W H A T I T M E A N S Market Consolidation Leaves The Door Open For Innovation The market events of the past few years leave us with four of the largest technology vendors on the planet — IBM, Microsoft, Oracle, and SAP — in control of market share. While Oracle and SAP battle for supremacy in this space, Microsoft has the highest potential to gain market share. With a newer solution set leveraging its Microsoft Office franchise, Microsoft will gain traction among organizations of various sizes, including large enterprises. IBM Cognos, meanwhile, has embarked on a road map to refresh some of its aging assets. Yet, among these leading players, none have built their entire solution set from the ground up and each faces a unique set of challenges to integrate, innovate, or mature their product sets. Organizations desire less costly solutions that more closely match their needs. Potentially viable alternative choices include functional (e.g., planning and costing) and industry-specific point solutions, SaaS solutions, and simpler products targeted toward smaller organizations. Smaller BPS vendors that are: 1) technically innovative; 2) less costly to own; 3) quicker to deploy; and 4) focused on solving specific business problems, will continue to make their mark. Supplemental MATERIAL Companies Interviewed For This Document Actuate Adaptive Planning Board International Clarity Systems Host Analytics IBM Cognos Infor Information Builders Lawson Software Longview Solutions Microsoft MicroStrategy Oracle SAP SAS Institute Tagetik
  • 17. © 2009, Forrester Research, Inc. Reproduction ProhibitedJanuary 20, 2009 Business Performance Solutions: Clash Of The Titans For Business Process & Applications Professionals 16 Endnotes 1 Forrester assessed 10 leading business performance solutions vendors across 83 criteria in a product evaluation. Additional point-solution vendors not covered in this evaluation might be worth considering as well, depending on priorities and current capabilities. See the October 10, 2007, “The Forrester Wave™: Business Performance Solutions, Q4 2007” report. 2 Metrics influence actions and decisions, whether used explicitly to influence behaviors or simply to report results. Source: John R. Hauser and Gerald M. Katz, Metrics: You Are What You Measure, MIT Sloan School of Management, 1998. 3 Employee performance solutions is the fastest growing product segment within HR and HCM applications, with a forecasted 17% growth rate through 2011. See the January 7, 2008, “HR/HCM Applications 2008: Best-Of-Breed Solutions Make A Comeback” report. 4 Performance management and measurement will top many priority lists, driven in part by a focus of enterprises to drive risk management into business decisions. See the November 21, 2008, “Trends 2009: Financial Performance Management” report. 5 SAP was faced with a rather complicated BPS road map as a result of the Business Objects acquisition. See the April 1, 2008, “SAP Unveils Its Starting Lineup For Business Performance Solutions” report.
  • 18. Forrester Research, Inc. (Nasdaq: FORR) is an independent research company that provides pragmatic and forward- thinking advice to global leaders in business and technology. Forrester works with professionals in 19 key roles at major companies providing proprietary research, consumer insight, consulting, events, and peer-to-peer executive programs. For more than 25 years, Forrester has been making IT, marketing, and technology industry leaders successful every day. For more information, visit www.forrester.com. Australia Brazil Canada Denmark France Germany Hong Kong India Israel Japan Korea The Netherlands Switzerland United Kingdom United States Headquarters Forrester Research, Inc. 400 Technology Square Cambridge, MA 02139 USA Tel: +1 617.613.6000 Fax: +1 617.613.5000 Email: forrester@forrester.com Nasdaq symbol: FORR www.forrester.com M a k i n g L e a d e r s S u c c e s s f u l E v e r y D a y For a complete list of worldwide locations, visit www.forrester.com/about. Research and Sales Offices 46571 For information on hard-copy or electronic reprints, please contact Client Support at +1 866.367.7378, +1 617.613.5730, or clientsupport@forrester.com. We offer quantity discounts and special pricing for academic and nonprofit institutions.