2. Credit Seminar on :
MILK PROTEINS
INDUCED SATIETY
Shamim Hossain
M.Tech (Dairy Technology))
ICAR-National Dairy Research Institute
Dairy Technology division
3. Outline :
▹ Introduction
▹ Feeding Cycle And It`s Stages
▹ Mechanisms Regarding Protein-induced Satiety
▹ Milk Protein In Satiety
▹ Application
▹ Adverse Effect of High Protein Diet
▹ Conclusion
3
4. Introduction :
Proteins are known to induce Satiety, increase secretion of
GI Hormones, and increase Diet-induced Thermogenesis
Milk protein contributes in short and long-term regulation
of Food Intake and Satiety
Protein is the most Effective in prolonging feelings of
fullness, followed by carbohydrates and then lipids
(Bellissimo et al., 2015)
(Bendtsen et al., 2013)
4
6. Appetite :
Our Psychosocial drive to eat
Mainly controlled by External Influence
Eating behavior is determined Biologically,
Psychologically and Socially
Why we eat ?
What we eat ?
How much we eat ?
When we eat ?
Where we eat ?
(Vendrame et al., 2014)
6
7. Hunger :
Our Biological drive to eat
Orexigenic neuropeptides includes Agouti-gene-related
protein (AgRP) and Neuropeptide Y (NPY) promotes the
intake of food
(Vendrame et al., 2014)
7
8. Satiation :
▹Perception of Fullness which develops during a meal
▹Short term “End of Meal” signal
▸Psychological: Perception of the Amount of eaten food
▸Mechanical: Stomach and intestinal Walls Distension
▸Hormonal: CCK and PYY released in proportion to fat, protein
▸Nutritional : Glucose and Fatty acid acts directly on brain
(Stefano et al., 2014)
8
9. Satiety :
▹Continuation of fullness and suppression of hunger
between meals
▹Determines the time interval between meals
▹Long term fullness signal
(Amin et al., 2015)
9
10. Dietary factors that modulate satiety :
▹ High Protein in diet stimulates PYY secretion
▹ High fiber, high fat food decrease ghrelin secretion
▹ Taking small meals frequently and avoiding fasting
results secretion of insulin
(Chambers et al., 2015)
10
11. Effects of nutrients on satiation/satiety :
Short term effect
(Satiation)
Long term effect
(Satiety)
Lipids + +++
Carbohydrates
-Fiber
++
+++
+
+
Proteins
-Casein
-Whey protein
+
+++
+++
+
(Chambers et al., 2015)
11
18. Milk protein in satiety :
Casein
(Slow protein)
Whey protein
(Fast protein)
(Boirie et al., 1997)
Ingestion
40min 2 hour up to 7 hour
18
19. Casein Vs. whey protein in satiety :
Casein Whey protein
Coagulates in the acidic
environment in the stomach
Delays its gastric emptying
Induces a slow postprandial
increase in plasma amino
acids
Remain soluble in the
stomach
Fast gastric emptying
Induces a fast, high, and
transient increase in plasma
amino acids
(Boirie et al., 1997)
19
20. Casein Vs. whey protein in satiety :
Casein Whey protein
Slowly recovered in the
jejunum
Recovered mainly in the
form of degraded peptides
Absorbed in the upper part
of the intestine
Rapidly recovered in the
upper intestine
Recovered mostly in the
form of intact protein
Further degraded to be
absorbed more distally
(Mahé et al., 2000)
20
21. Casein in satiety :
▹Caseins produce numerous BAPs like β-casomorphins
▹Regulates various physiological processes :
▸food intake regulation
▸gastrointestinal motility
▸plasma insulin concentrations (Froetschel et al., 1996)
21
22. Whey protein in satiety :
▹Contains the highest concentration of the branched-chain
amino acids compared to other food proteins, especially L-
leucine (Sweet dry whey -10.3% ; acid dry whey- 10.5%)
▹Leucine enters the brain from the blood more rapidly than
any other amino acid
▹Maintains a stable level of glucose and low insulin during
energy restriction
(Glass et al., 1976)
(Yudkoff et al., 2005)
(Layman et al., 2006)
22
23. GMP in satiety :
κ- Casein Caseinomacropeptide
Glycomacropeptide
Cholecystokinin (CCK)
SecrationSatiety
chymosin
(Beucher et al. 1994)
23
24. Dairy induces satiety :
▹Over 500 ml of dairy products significantly increases
satiety
▹“You get more feelings of fullness, and less hunger,
consuming a dairy product than consuming a soft drink or
some other product”
▹Protein ↑ ≈ Hunger ↓ ≈Body weight control ↑
(Onvani et al., 2016)
(Anderson et al., 2004)
(Abargouei et al., 2011)
24
25. Protein enriched dairy products :
Greek Yoghurt
Protein : 13 to 18 g per 6 oz
Cottage Cheese
14 g of Protein & 1.3 g of Leucine per 1/2 cup
Core Power
Low-Fat, Lactose-free Milk
26 g of Protein per 11.5oz
(Smith et al., 2013)
25
26. ▹α-Lactalbumin-Enriched Yoghurt Drink
▸More satiating than the whey-enriched yoghurt drink
▸α-Lac is a complete protein
▸More thermogenic
▸High concentrations of leucine and lysine (ketogenic AA)
(Johnstone et al., 2008)
(Milgen et al., 2002)
(Heine et al., 1991)
(Hursel et al., 2009)
26
27. ▹High-protein yoghurt (73%) > Low-protein yoghurt (34%)
▹Same calorie
▹Greater suppression of hunger
(Vandewa et al.,1994)
27
28. Application in Areas of Health and
Disease :
(Preedy et al., 2011)
Binge Eating
Disorder
Bulimia
Nervosa
Anorexia
Nervosa
28
29. Adverse effect of high protein diet :
▹RDA for protein : Adults - 0.8 g protein/kg BW/day
Children - 1.5 g protein/kg BW/day
Adolescents - 1.0 g protein/kg BW/day
▹ Long-term high protein intake in humans :
(a) Disorders of Bone and Calcium Homeostasis
(b) Disorders of Renal Function
(c) Increased Cancer Risk
(d) Disorders of Liver Function
(e) Progression of Coronary Artery Disease
(Kafatos et al., 2008)
(Dioguardi et al., 2013)
29
30. High intake of
protein
High intake of
purines
Hyperuricosuria
Uric acid kidney stones
Acid load is buffered in
part by bone which
releases calcium to be
excreted by the kidney
Hypercalciuria
Calcium kidney
stones
High acidogenic
content
Decrease of urinary pH
Decreased solubility of
uric acid
Weak bone
(Barzel et al., 1998)
30
31. Conclusion :
▹Consumption of protein under RDA level have a very
good effect on satiety thus leads to body weight control
and reduces obesity and its comorbidities
▹Milk protein has a complete effect on satiety and by
modifying its protein level we can increase its hunger
suppressing efficiency
▹Protein enrichment and measures of appetite and energy
expenditure, seem to be key elements in the design of
future studies
31
Editor's Notes
This pre covers
Proteins have a great impact on satiety. they induce satiety by increasing GI hormone secretion, diet induced thermogenesis and decreasing hunger.
protein generally increases satiety to a greater extent than carbohydrate or fat and may facilitate a reduction in energy consumption under ad libitum dietary conditions. Whey protein contributes in short-term and casein in long-term regulation of satiety
Here is the feeding cycle. We are undergone this cycle through out the day. There are mainly 4 stages they are appetite and hunger which tells us to eat and satiation and satiety which tells us to stop eating. Hunger and satiation are the feeling just before and after eating. Satiety and appetite are the interphase in between meals
Apppetite is Our Psychosocial drive to eat which is Mainly controlled by External Influence like Why we eat ?What we eat ?How much we eat ?When we eat Where we eat ? This all together called eating behavior which is determined by Biologically, Psychologically and Socially
Hunger is the biological drive to eat. When our stomach is empty & body`s energy and nutrient level decreased then ghrelin is released by stomach which induce the release of orxigenic neuropeptides like AgRP and NPY in hypothalamus causes hunger
Satiation is the development of fullness and reduction of hunger during a meal. Satiation occurs during an eating episode and brings it to an end. It is a short term signal mainly driven by this 4 factors- Psychological : that is perception of how much food we have eaten . Mechanical : by taking meal mechanical stretching of the stomach takes place and sensed by the stretch receptor of the stomach wall. Hormonal : CKK and PYY released in proportion of the fat and protein content of our meal. Nutritional : the glucose and fatty acid present in food have a direct effect in the hypothalamus of brain
the continuation of fullness and suppression of hunger between meals. Satiety starts after the end of eating and prevents further eating before the return of hunger so it determines the time interval between meals
Presence of food in stomach continues satiation signals -Absence of food initiates ghrelin signal
-Foods which delay stomach emptying
Blood glucose levels determines insulin levels
Protein in diet stimulates PYY secretion
Here are the hormones which are the main controller of satiety and hunger. The cholecystokinin and GIP from small intestine, GLP-1, PYY from large intestine are mainly induced by protein ingestion results satiety. insulin and amyline from pancreas and leptin from adipose tissue aslo have satiating effect but they asr mainly induced by carbohydrate and fat. the only appetizing hormone is ghrelin which is secrated by empty stomach .all signal goes to the appetite center of hypothalamus which control the whole system of hunger and satiety.
The theoretical basis of this relationship may be that increased energy expenditure at rest implies increased oxygen consumption and an increase in body temperature that may lead to feeling deprived of oxygen and thus promote satiety
The theory is termed the aminostatic hypothesis. Whether induced by feeding of protein or amino acids, or by infusing amino acid mixtures, a rise in the serum amino acid concentration appeared to be accompanied by a waning of appetite. The subsequent increase in appetite was accompanied by a fall in the amino acid concentration
The satiating effect of high protein feeding could be related to the improvement of glucose homeostasis through the modulation of hepatic gluconeogenesis and subsequent glucose metabolism
A main reason for the difference in the thermic effects of food may be due to the fact that the body has no storage capacity for protein and thus it needs to be metabolically processed immediately. The synthesis of protein, the high ATP cost of peptide bond synthesis as well as the high cost of urea production and gluconeogenesis are often cited reasons for the higher thermic effect of protein.
In humans, consumption of whey resulted in a fast, but short and transient, increase in plasma amino acids that peaked in 40 min to 2 h after its ingestion and returned to baseline values after 3–4 h. Casein, in contrast, and consistent with its slow gastric emptying, results in plasma amino acid concentrations that rose more slowly and are lower, but had sustained a plateau lasting for 7 h.
Casein, unlike whey, coagulates in the acidic environment in the stomach, which delays its gastric emptying and induces a slow postprandial increase in plasma amino acids. Whey proteins, on the other side are soluble and remain soluble in the stomach, which is why they reach the upper intestine more rapidly than casein & induces a fast, high, and transient increase in plasma amino acids
b-lactoglobulin, a main component of whey, was rapidly recovered in the upper intestine mostly in the form of intact protein that needs to be further degraded to be absorbed more distally. In contrast, casein was slowly recovered in the jejunum, mainly in the form of degraded peptides efficiently absorbed in the upper part of the intestine
Opioid peptides known as -casomorphins are BAP derived from casein and are involved in the regulation of various physiological processes, including food intake regulation, gastrointestinal motility, and plasma insulin concentrations
Whey proteins, compared to other food proteins contain the highest concentration of the branched-chain amino acids, especially L-leucine. Sweet and acid dry whey contain 10.3 and 10.5% of leucine, respectively . Leucine acts as the stimulator of the downstream signal control of protein synthesis in the insulin signaling pathway that contributes to the economy of lean tissue proteins (e.g. muscles) as well as maintains a stable level of glucose and low insulin during energy restriction. Leucine enters the brain from the blood more rapidly than any other amino acid that cause a fast satiating effect of whey
caseinomacropeptide, a polypeptide of 64 amino acid residues, formed from the action of the enzyme chymosin on k-casein. Glycomacropeptide (GMP), the glycosylated fragment of caseinomacropeptide has been shown to stimulate the secretion of the gut hormone cholecystokinin (CCK) which may induce satiety
Among Satiating foods and drinks milk and milk products shows a better satiating effect and depression of hunger. According to some researchers consumption of over 500 ml of dairy products significantly increases satiety.as milk has high quality proteins it reduces hunger and improve control over body weight
Beside the WPC, WPI, WP, casein there are some other protein enriched dairy products which have a very good effect on satiety.
Consumption of a high-protein breakfast with added a-lac is more thermogenic than consumption of a normal-protein breakfast containing milk protein. An explanation for the thermogenic effect of a-lac may be that it is a complete protein. a-lac contains high concentrations of leucine and lysine, which
are ketogenic amino acids. It is known that hunger is suppressed by ketogenic amino acids
Among the protein enriched yoghurts high protein yoghurts having a greater hunger supressioin ability than low protein yoghurt at isocaloric diet.
Binge eating disorder is a eating disorder that implies the consumption of a very large amount of food until the person feels uncomfortably full
Bulimia nervosa is the latter stage of binge eating disorder. People with this condition binge eat. They then take steps to avoid weightgain. Most commonly, this means vomiting
Anorexia nervosa is a disorder to try to maintain a below-normal weight through starvation or too much exercise.
We all know that overdose of anything is not good for health. Same in the case of protein also. The RDA for protein is .8 ,1.5 and 1 g /kg BW/day for adults, children and adolescents. But long time consumption of more than this can cause several problems like :Disorders of Bone and Calcium Homeostasis, Disorders of Renal Function, Disorders of Liver Function, Increased Cancer Risk & progression of CVD
Low fluid intake and excessive intake of protein are important risk factors for kidney stones. Protein ingestion increases renal acid excretion, and acid loads, in turn, may be buffered in part by bone, which releases calcium to be excreted by the kidney. This protein-induced hypercalciuria could lead to the formation of calcium kidney stones and on the other side reduces bone calcium which causes bone weakness. Furthermore, animal protein is also the major dietary source of purines, the precursors of uric acid. Excessive intake of animal protein is therefore associated with hyperuricosuria, leads to uric acid kidney stone.