삼성SDI로 합병된 제일모직에서 2014년 4월 9일 발표한 자료입니다. ^^ 풀 공유!!! 강의신청은 shawn@blte.kr 로 부탁드립니다. 흐흐. 광고. (중소기업, 연구소 특허교,발명교육 전문^^) 비엘티 특허법률사무소 변리사 엄정한 www.fb.com/byunlisa (페이스북) www.blte.kr (홈페이지) www.bltm.kr (커뮤니티) 070-4100-0102

1. BLTBLT
shawn@blte.kr
070-4100
shawn@blte.kr
4100-0102

2. •
•Microsoft Certified Professional
• (2001)
• (2006)
• ETRI (2013)
• ]
• ]
• ]
• ,
• , , , )
2
)
shawn@BLTe.kr

3. 3
. ,
,
.
< LG ) >

4. •
4
(NPE) …
?

5. 5
• (1819 ~ 1867)
•
...
,
• ,
, ...
• 1854 ,
• (1867

6. 1.
2.
. 4400$ )
3.
. (
-
+ (NPE) 160
6
.(I.M. = )
.
.
~ )
160 …

7. !!!!
7

8. !!!!
8

9. • MOP (Management Of Patent)
MOP (Management of Patent)
M.O.P
• Value Chain
•
• Value Chain
• , , , ,
, …
• ,
9
MOP (Management Of Patent)
M.O.P
• , IP
• ,
• Value Chain
• ,
• , (NPE)

10. 10

11. 11

12. 12

13. 13

14. 14

15. 1998
15
1998

16. 16

17. 17

18. 2004
18
2004

19. 2004
19
2004

20. 2009
20
2009

21. 21

22. 22

23. 23

24. 24

25. 1, 2, 3
,
,
13 125
1, 2, 3
.
1 2
, 1
.
25
1, 2, 3
,
,
2 700 ppm ,
, ,
125 ppm ,
,
,
,

26. 26

27. vs
27

28. .
15
.
CMP 'KCS-3100'
7,115,021 USP 7,871,308 .
vs
28
(CMP
6
USP

29. "
"
"
.
CMP
CMP STI
alphag@
vs
29
.
STI .

30. vs
30

31. vs
31

32. vs
32

33. vs
33
• ,
.
• (%) CeO2
.
• , SiO2
Si3N4 .
•
,
.

34. vs
34

35. 1. An abrasive comprising
said particles having a crystal grain boundary
and having a maximum diameter of not large
than 3000 nm.
2. The abrasive of claim 1, wherein a crystallite of
said cerium oxide particles has a maximum
diameter of not larger than 600 nm
3. The abrasive of claim 1, wherein said cerium
oxide particles have pores
4. ~ 20.
vs
35
abrasive comprising cerium oxide particles,
having a crystal grain boundary
having a maximum diameter of not large
The abrasive of claim 1, wherein a crystallite of
said cerium oxide particles has a maximum
diameter of not larger than 600 nm.
The abrasive of claim 1, wherein said cerium
oxide particles have pores.

36. vs
36

37. 7. An abrasive comprising slurry including medium and
cerium oxide particles dispersed in said medium, said
oxide particles constituted of at least two crystallites
having crystal grain boundaries
wherein:
cerium oxide particles with diameter not smaller than
occupies at least 0.1% by weight of the total weight of the
cerium oxide particles; and
said cerium oxide particles having
have characteristic of polishing target member
collapsing.
vs
37
7. An abrasive comprising slurry including medium and
dispersed in said medium, said cerium
at least two crystallites and
crystal grain boundaries,
with diameter not smaller than
occupies at least 0.1% by weight of the total weight of the
having crystal grain boundaries
have characteristic of polishing target member while

38. vs
38
Application/Filing Date: 2006-07-12

39. KC Tech cerium oxide “ceria”) slurry
Hitachi Chemical
1. KCS-3100 ceria (ceria particle)
2. KCS-3100 (dispersant)
3. KCS-3100 ceria
.
4. KCS-3100
5. KCS-3100
vs
39
ceria”) slurry KCS-3100.
.
KCS-3100 .
(ceria particle) .
(dispersant) .
(crystal grain boundaries)
ceria .
ceria
.

40. vs
40

41. vs
41

42. vs
42

43. vs
43

44. 44

45. 45

46. •
•
•
(wilfulness)
.
46
)
,
,
.
,

47. 47

48. 2(Doctrine of
Equivalents)
48
1 (All Element Rule)
2
3 ( File Wrapper
Estoppel)
vs ?

49. 49
.
.

50. •
50
X
.

51. vs
51

52. cerium oxide particles
having crystal grain boundary
having maximum diameter of not large
than 3000 nm
• KCS-
cerium oxide particles,
having maximum diameter of not large
than 3000 nm
1. An abrasive comprising
particles, said particles
grain boundary and
diameter of not large than 3000 nm.
52
cerium oxide particles
having crystal grain boundary
having maximum diameter of not large
than 3000 nm
?
-3100 US7,871,308
cerium oxide particles, having crystal grain boundary
having maximum diameter of not large
3000nm
.
An abrasive comprising cerium oxide
, said particles having a crystal
and having a maximum
diameter of not large than 3000 nm.

53. (Doctrine of Equivalents)
.
53
Doctrine of Equivalents)
.

54. 2(Doctrine of
Equivalents)
54
1 (All Element Rule)
2
3 ( File Wrapper
Estoppel)
vs ?

55. (File Wrapper Estoppel)
55
Wrapper Estoppel)

56. (File Wrapper Estoppel)
"
,
,
“V"
(700)
,
56
Wrapper Estoppel)
(700)

57. (File Wrapper Estoppel)
95
1
.
. Y
57
Wrapper Estoppel)
95-4971
, 1998. 7. 22.
1
,
.

58. (File Wrapper Estoppel)
58
Wrapper Estoppel)

59. (File Wrapper Estoppel)
"
59
Wrapper Estoppel)
.
{( )
, (
.

60. 60

61. 61

62. 62
10-2003-7005273 (20030415)
10-2000-7006683 (20000617)
10-2006-7024951 (20061127)
PCT/JP1998/005736(1998.12.18)
7,871,308
7,115,021
1997-349240
1998-083042
1998-083043

63. 63
1997-349240

64. 1
2 ,
5 250 nm
2
3 1 , 100
4 3 , 300
5
6 1 , 5 150 nm
7 6 , 10 50 nm
8 4 , 50 200 nm
9 1 ,
10 1 , 600 nm
11 1 ,
12
11 ,
10 30 % .
13
11 , B.J.H.(Barret, Joyner, Halende)
/g .
14
15 1 , (bulk density)
16 15 , 5.0 g/ , 5.9 g/
17 1 , .
10-2000-7006683 (20000617)
64
100 1500 nm ,
.
100 1200 nm .
300 1OOO nm .
150 nm .
50 nm .
200 nm .
3000 nm .
.
.
X
0.02 0.05
(bulk density) 6.5 g/ .
, 5.9 g/ .
7006683 (20000617)

65. 1
2 ,
5 250 nm
2
3 1 , 100
4 3 , 300
5
6 1 , 5 150 nm
7 6 , 10 50 nm
8 4 , 50 200 nm
9 1 ,
10 1 , 600 nm
11 1 ,
12
11 ,
10 30 % .
13
11 , B.J.H.(Barret, Joyner, Halende)
/g .
14
15 1 , (bulk density)
16 15 , 5.0 g/ , 5.9 g/
17 1 , .
10-2000-7006683 (20000617)
65
100 1500 nm ,
.
100 1200 nm .
300 1OOO nm .
150 nm .
50 nm .
200 nm .
3000 nm .
.
.
X
0.02 0.05
(bulk density) 6.5 g/ .
, 5.9 g/ .
?
7006683 (20000617)

66. 1
2
100 1500 nm ,
1
An abrasive comprising cerium oxide particles
having crystal grain boundary
diameter of not large than 3000 nm.
10-2000-7006683 (20000617)
7,871,308
66
,
5 250 nm
.
cerium oxide particles said particles
having crystal grain boundary and having maximum
diameter of not large than 3000 nm.
?

67. 10-2000-7006683 (20000617)
67

68. 68

69. A B
1 2
69
DC E
11 2

70. 1
An abrasive comprising cerium oxide particles
having crystal grain boundary
diameter of not large than 3000 nm.
7,871,308
1
2
100 1500 nm ,
10-2000-7006683 (20000617)
70
cerium oxide particles said particles
having crystal grain boundary and having maximum
diameter of not large than 3000 nm.
?
,
5 250 nm
.

71. 71

72. 72

73. WIPS
Delphion
Total Patents 96 30
Aureka 22
Focust
Russian Academy
of Sciences
73
WINTELIPS
PatentLap
30 Analytics
21 Patentweb

74. •• 100100 (30(30 Full textFull text
74
Full text (30)
Bibliographic(70)
))

75. Application/Filing Date: 2006
75
Application/Filing Date: 2006-07-12

76. 76

77. 77

78. 78

79. 79

80. 80

81. ;
;
,
.
81
;
;
;
;
;
;

82. 82

83. 83
A
C
B ?
B
?

84. 84

85. vs
85

86. B24B 1/04
( (tumbling)
B24B 31/06;
B23B 37/00
C09C 1/68
C01F 17/00
C09K 3/14
H01L 21/304
H01L 21/3105
86
B24B 31/00;
B24B 31/06; (superfinishing)
B24B 35/00)
(
B24B 1/04)
(cutting)

87. 87

88. CONTENTS
I
CONTENTS

89. 1.
2.
3.

90. 90

91. But,
Bell: VS
Dial Bell
.
Bell ,
Dial .
]
;
;
,
.
91
Dial:
)
Bell ,
,
]
;
,
.

92. LED
92
LED

93. 93

94. 94

95. 95

96. 96

97. 97

98. 98

99. 99

100. 100
• 8
•
•
•
•
100
2000
1000
?

101. 101 101

102. 102
813,538 813,537
401,327 881,943
102
813,539 793,413
776,841 734,569

103. 103 103

104. 104 104

105. 105
30
(for every line-ups)
?
105
• 1990
• 10
• 70%
• 10
•

106. 106
US 5,010,646
US 4,813,131
US 4,785,534
106
US 5,027,511
US 5,430,939
US D377,237
US 5,113,585

107. 107 107

108. 108
.

109. 2-KEY
• ‘ ‘
-
109
-

110. 2-KEY
• ‘ ‘
-
110
-

111. 2-KEY
• ‘ ‘
-
111

112. 2-KEY
• ‘ ‘
-
, , R&D
, 6HA
.
112
.
.
.

113. 6HA - OPEN
(Element)
113
(Object)
(Problem)
lement) -
(Needs) -
6HA

114. 6HA - OPEN
(Object)
(Problem)
(Element) -
(Needs) -
114
O
P
E
N
?
?
?
?

115. BLU 1
1
(450) (410)
2
,
(450)
(450)
(450)
3
(450)
4
(430)
(440)
115
?
(410) O
(450)
(420)
O
(430)
O
(450)
(440)
O

116. BLU 1
(450) (410)
, (450)
(450)
(450)
(450)
(420)
(450)
(430)
(430)
(450) (440)
116
???
?
• BLU ?
• BLU ?
• BLU ?
• BLU ?
• ?
• ? LED ?
• BLU ?
• ??
(430)
• ?
• ?
• ? ??
• ?
• ?
• ??

117. •
!!!
117

118. •
!
118

119. 119

120. 120 120

121. 121 121

122. 122 122

123. 123 123

124. 124 124

125. 125 125
!?

126. 126 126

127. 2006.02
CREATIVE
(UI part)
UI
2006.04 ~
2007.06
iPhone
2G
2008.10
127 127
Smart Phone
2011.04
Apple
(UI part)
2008.10 ~

128. ?
,
Copycat(
128 128
, LED)
,

129. •
129 129
,
= .

130. BLT
BLT Business, Law & Technology
130
(1999)
(2005) SS 40” (a-Si TFT)
(2002) SS 2.2”
(1997)
OLED
130
(2009)AMOLED
(2012) LG 55”
(2007) SS AMOLED
(2007) SONY 11”
OLED TV
(2009) LG, OLED

131. 131

132. 132

133. 133
>
•
• /
• (It’s Fun~!!)
•
,
133
•
•
•
?
…

134. 134 134

135. 135
>
•
•
•
•
135
•
•
•
?

136. 136
-
(KR , PCT only)
136

137. 137 137
• IP
• , <
M&A, NORTEL
•
Rockstar Bidco LP

138. •
138
7,812,828
7,669,134
6,493,002
7,469,381
7,844,915
7,853,891
7,863,533
’s IP
138
’s IP

139. 139
>
• + CIPO
• <Value Up>
•
•
139
•
•
•
OA !

140. 140
Reclaim
a Patent
($0)
Star Patent
($100M)
Idea Prosecute
Client
140
• – Value Up
Star Patent
($100M)
Reclaiming,
Claim charting,
Reverse engineering
for sophisticated standard IPs
Value-up Monetize
GDI

141. 141 141
-
(VU, )

142. 142
>
•
• ,
• ,
•
142
•
•
• ,

143. 1.
2.
3.

144. 1]
,
,
.
?
: A+B+C+D :
: A+B+C :
Case 1
Case 2
144
]
,
.

145. 1
2
3
4
5
145

146. 1]
342437 :
1
~
, (1) 9
(3) ;
(1) (3)
(2)
146
.
)
12 1
(2)
11 ,
(3) (1)
, ~
.

147. 1
VS.
147
;

148. ,
148
“
, ”
(Estoppel)

149. 149

150. 150
1.
2.
3.

151. RF /
& SW
SW
151

152. /
152
/
( )
/

153. /
/
/M&A ( /
153
( )
( , ,
,
/ )

154. 1. R&D
2.
3.
4.
5.

155. Patent Map
Power Patenting

156. Needs
Value Chain Analysis
Data Gathering /
Application Survey
Application
Market Status
- Size, Growth rate,
Competitor,
Market Research Co.
Application
Work Shop
Cowork
Process
Cowork
PRM TRM
Phase I -
D/Around
Phase II
- Phase I
Phase III -
- New Concept Tech.
Tech Trend ( / /
)
Work Shop
Cowork / Review
Work Shop
Cowork / Review
Application
gap
(Make, Buy,
Collaboration)

157. /
Tech tree
OOOO
OOOO
OOOO
OOOO
D
C
B
A
Needs
Background
157
IP-R&D
Spec

158. PLC Position
)
= + +
158
(PLC Position)
, ,
- ?? (?? , ??), ?? (?? ),
, , )
, , )
+ Risk

159. A B
A B
2001----44 60 100 1 8
2000-29---
2000-18-- 60-75 500 1 7
2008-04-5 60 100~2000 1 7
2001-16---1 50% 100 1 8
2001-26-- 55~65 420~2000 1 4
1998-15-- 75 12 4 9
1997-34-- 70~80% 100~2000 4 7
1996-26-- 70~80% 100~2000 4 7
2007-08--- 80 100~900 4 7
159
9 8 8 8 24
8 7 3 7 17
8 7 3 7 17
9 8 8 8 24
5 7 5 7 19
13 8 6 7 21
11 8 8 8 24
11 8 8 8 24
11 7 5 7 19

160. D
OOO
C , D
X : , Y :
,
160
D
C
B
A
C
)

161. ( PRM-TRM )
,
->
-> )
/
161
TRM )
/ / Parameter
Parameter

162. Matrix
)
(P1)
(P3)
(P2)
28
29
(P4)
(P15
(00 )
00 000 P21
000 P21
000 000 P16
(
E1 00
E10
E15
E32
E33
E49
E50
E62
E64
E71
E74
162
)
Check(-> 20% ).
[ ]
00
(00 )
00 (000mm )
000
/

163. Catch Up
)
163
/
=> R&D

164. ( , ?? , , )
-->
164

165. ???
??
salt
OO
=> OOOO
=> OOOO( )
165
OOO
, .

166. (
( )
=>
)
OOO
00
(00 00 000
00 00 00
0000
000
OOO OOO
O - 0.04
OOO
0.13 ~ 10 (OOO
OO
166
)
000 +
00
OO
.)
8

167. ??
( : )
=> 000
00
167
,

168. Idea
R&D
IdeaIdea
168
Idea

169. 1990
Copyright 2011 Jung-Ho Kim
//
169
)
1991 ••• 2009 2010
//

170. --- )
)
--- )
USD 70.00
USD 58.75
)
.
Copyright 2011 Jung-Ho Kim
170
---
)
)
)
USD 52.50
)
170

171. ,
100
a
b
c
d
e
f
g
h
A B C D E
171
a
b
c
d
e
f
g
h
A B C D E

172. 172
Mix-Up
)
, )

173. Positives
Objections
What else
Enhancements
Remedies
: “THINK BETTER’ Tim Hurson, PP231-241)
173
?
bjections ?
hat else
?
?
?
nhancements
?
?

174. STEP QUESTIONS
Positive
?
?
Objection
?
?
What else
Value Chain ?
?
?
?
?
Enhancement
Remedy
?
?
Idea Seed
Work Sheet for IdeationWork Sheet for Ideation
174
METHOD
?
/
) / )
/
?
5 Whys
.

175. •
Idea
)
NewRoadmap
175
Idea
Idea
R&D
R&D
Seed

176. •
Idea
)
NewRoadmap
176
Idea
Idea
R&D
R&D
Seed

177. Code
Silk S-1
S-2
S-3
S-4
S-5
S-6
S-7
S-8
S-9
S-10
Portfolio
-
-
177
( / )/
5 1
9 9
Know How Filtering
- R&D

178. 178

179. (Literal Infringement)
(Doctrine of Equivalents )
(File Wrapper Estoppel)
•
•
(All Elements Rule)
•
•
•
179
97 )
(elements)
,

180. JP2000-000000
1
,
.
JP2000
,
2 , JP2000
3 Yb Er JP2000
Er
4 JP2000
4 JP2000
5 JP2000
6
,
JP2000
(11)
(52)
JP2000-000000 1-6
000000, JP2000-000000
,
180
JP2000-000000
.
JP2000-000000 JP00-000000
.
JP2000-000000 JP00-000000
.
JP2000-000000
.
JP2000-000000
.
JP2000-000000
.
JP2000-000000
(51, 54) WDM
(55) .
JP2000-000000, JP00-
, , JP2000-000000
1-6 ,
.
IP-R&D

181. 181

182. BLT Business, Law & Technology www.BLT
The only FIRM who cares your SUCCESS
BLT
www.fb.com/byunlisa
070-4100-0102, 0
shawn@BLTe.kr
BLT
BLTe.kr 182
The only FIRM who cares your SUCCESS
BLT
www.fb.com/byunlisa
010-2393-5709
shawn@BLTe.kr